What I love about Noel Gallagher is that, regardless of who wrote it, performed it or sang it, he always makes it his own, and that's exactly what happens here. I love the way he changes the last line of the chorus from "Heaven Help You Catch Me If I Fall," to "Come On Out, Yeah, Make My World Stand Tall." I also love the high note at the end, he hits that far better than the way his brother does. He also sings the whole song and does it very well too. Job well done there, Noel.
ijohnno32 I doubt he changed it to that, this is a demo so it was probably that originally then he changed it later on before they recorded it in the studio with Liam
Damn this shows why we need a reunion. Noel’s genius songwriting with Liam’s voice that carried the songs perfectly. A match made in heaven. As good as this is and appreciating it’s just a demo, he definitely wrote this one for his brother!
+blitzcraig For me Liam sings "Roll it over" better, he got that power in the voice that Noel does not have, but Noel is an awesome songwritter, no one can deny it !
he is definitely Not a bad guitarist. he can play any song by ear. he can write amazing guitar solos such as live forever and shout it out loud. and he can improvise, as he usually does when he's playing champagne supernova live, especially on the be here now tour.
As much as I love Noel and think he has a good voice, Liam really owns this song. The aggressiveness and vigor with which he sings is perfect for these types of songs. This isn't too bad though. That being said, Noel is truly the only one who can sing Don't Look Back in Anger. It's perfect for his voice.
I just marvel at how much of the finished song is here. I read the story is that Sony said "you don't have a lead single" and decided at the 11th hour that this was their best shot at a lead single from the rejected demos. Noel didn't like the song, thought it was fairly weak. Dave Sardy took Liam and Zak Starkey in for a recording session to redo the vocals and drums, re-engineered it and here it is. Considering so many Oasis demos are different or flat or much more skeletal than the end product, it's quite a marvel that this banger - probably the best lead single since Some Might Say - was essentially 80% finished.
Liam's voice in the early days was bettered by no one but as of age and abuse it's deteriorated over the years and Noel's the much more accomplished singer. But Liam can still blow you away. Ala beady eye at live at abbey road
I definitely agree with you about Lyla. I partially agree about Supersonic and Wonderwall. What I mean is that I prefer listening to Liam's voice when these songs are sung like the album versions, but I love listening to the Noel's exclusive versions (generally calmer and more sentimental). I personally love this version of Supersonic (watch?v=VsnXz4P4TKY) and this version of Wonderwall (watch?v=bg-Q0oduvfA). Same goes to Live Forever (check this version: watch?v=9TJhl7PqW70)
So, that's how this song's supposed to be sung. Noel should release a demo of all his songs with himself on lead vocals. Having said that, I do like the way Liam interprets Noel's songs and sings them in his own voice.
If it were to be sung by Noel and we never heard the Liam version, it would definitely sound like something off Be Here Now or Heathen Chem that Noel usually sings.. I was thinking it's a bit like 'Force Of Nature' to be honest!
Spot on! But there were the odd songs that Noel will write and not know whether or not they were suitable for him or Liam. A prime example of that would be Wonderwall
@JohnKulo ´Still, Liam did some things to take care of his voice. He changed the way to sing and it´s not the same junkie he used to be. IMO he is still a great singer and i really can´t understand don´t like songs like Four Letter Word, Millionaire, Roller, Beat Goes On, Morning Sun, Bubble in a bullet. I really can´t and i´m sorry for you. The main point is that i don´t think he shloud have any regrets. But you can think whatever you want. And i´m not saying in a agressive way.Cheers
@Sgtpepper212 It wasn't that, Liam joined Bonehead's band 'The Rain' with Guigsy and Tony McCarroll. Liam thought that if he joined, Noel would, and they'd use his songs. It's known that Bonehead brought Liam in to get Noel as well.
@JohnKulo imagine Liam "saving" his voice in Maine ROad, Finbury Park and Wembley. You would´nt have some of the best vocal performances ever. So stop crying your heart out.
amazing!! noels version is amazing! eeeeey lyla!! but liams version is amazing too! noel can sing her song if he want to do it hH he wrote the songs! haha come on guys!
wuppi do, president of the first oasis fanclub austria. it was on dvd but then you would know such things like that wouldn't you? they where raised not far from me guess you knew that to eh. lol
Can't really feel the same energy in this one as the album version with Liam. Noel is too gentle, doesn't really give it all. But it is actually comfortable to listen to this, but when you're used to the album version... it just won't do, y'know?
@JohnKulo i do agree he could do something to keep the voice better but it wouldn´t matter too much. The voice is worse now, mainly, because it´s a natural thing of age. The man is fourty now. And about being useless in Beady Eye it makes no sense. If you understand something about rock n roll´and check some videos live, like Isle of Wight or Rio de janeiro(that i went). That band is on fire, kept the Oasis level, one of the best at the moment. And prepare for the secnd album.
I personally think that Liam is a better singer and he's voice is so fucking nice. I don't like Noels voice. But Noel is one of the best guitarists with such a feeling! It's simple as that.
now, why are you twiting on me? the main problem is, that i´m from austria! this dvd wasn´t realesd in my f***ing country! so,i try my best, to know everything...and, that they were raised near you, is clear to me. who doesn´t know? they once told me:"heya, we were raised near julie2009ish, thats awsome, innit?" :-D
i don´t think so. on my single there is lyla, eyeball tickler and won´t let you down. maybe there are other realeses in other countries, but i would know that :-) as president of the first oasis fanclub austria i have to know such things :-D
Liams voice is way more unique an better than Noels. Noels voice is suited for some songs but not really this one. He is a far far superior songwriter though!
Don't judge Noel's vocals on this. This wasn't intended for the public to hear, he's just laying down the tune.
Nothing wrong with it😊
What I love about Noel Gallagher is that, regardless of who wrote it, performed it or sang it, he always makes it his own, and that's exactly what happens here. I love the way he changes the last line of the chorus from "Heaven Help You Catch Me If I Fall," to "Come On Out, Yeah, Make My World Stand Tall." I also love the high note at the end, he hits that far better than the way his brother does. He also sings the whole song and does it very well too. Job well done there, Noel.
ijohnno32 I doubt he changed it to that, this is a demo so it was probably that originally then he changed it later on before they recorded it in the studio with Liam
Damn this shows why we need a reunion. Noel’s genius songwriting with Liam’s voice that carried the songs perfectly. A match made in heaven. As good as this is and appreciating it’s just a demo, he definitely wrote this one for his brother!
Alan is playing drums on this demo, best Oasis drummer
LIAM for this bad boy
I love Noel a lot. He's my favourite musician, but Liam sings it so much better.
***** Jesus, mate, you alright?
***** you make no sence
*****
Haven't seen a 'comment' as stupid as yours here on YT for a _long, long_ time...
+blitzcraig For me Liam sings "Roll it over" better, he got that power in the voice that Noel does not have, but Noel is an awesome songwritter, no one can deny it !
Let's face it, they're both amazing in different ways! I absolutely love when Liam sings backup to Noel on the fade away warchild version
he is definitely Not a bad guitarist. he can play any song by ear. he can write amazing guitar solos such as live forever and shout it out loud. and he can improvise, as he usually does when he's playing champagne supernova live, especially on the be here now tour.
As much as I love Noel and think he has a good voice, Liam really owns this song. The aggressiveness and vigor with which he sings is perfect for these types of songs. This isn't too bad though.
That being said, Noel is truly the only one who can sing Don't Look Back in Anger. It's perfect for his voice.
Everything Noel touches is GOLD! God Head!
Me encanta esta versión!!
SHES THE QUEEN OF ALL I'VE SEEN!
its just a demo!! relax!!stop comparing these guys for every fuckkin reason.
I just marvel at how much of the finished song is here. I read the story is that Sony said "you don't have a lead single" and decided at the 11th hour that this was their best shot at a lead single from the rejected demos. Noel didn't like the song, thought it was fairly weak. Dave Sardy took Liam and Zak Starkey in for a recording session to redo the vocals and drums, re-engineered it and here it is. Considering so many Oasis demos are different or flat or much more skeletal than the end product, it's quite a marvel that this banger - probably the best lead single since Some Might Say - was essentially 80% finished.
This suits Liam's voice far more.
Pra mim os dois são muito fodas!
Não tem melhor,é apenas diferente.
amazing
Noels a talented songwriter but some of the songs (well majority of them) just suit's Liam's uniquely powerful voice this is definitely one of them.
That's like saying Roger Daltry voice suits songs better than Pete's did... Thanks captain obvious!
the chorus sounds great!!
Liam's voice in the early days was bettered by no one but as of age and abuse it's deteriorated over the years and Noel's the much more accomplished singer. But Liam can still blow you away. Ala beady eye at live at abbey road
This is Liam's song, yes...but Noel's voice has something of charming!
this song needs a raspy voice
+Muhammad Siregar I think that Noel could've done this a lot better if he sang it with some more balls, like how he does the backup vocals live.
Nobody can sing a chorus quite like Noel Gallagher though
I like Noel on vocals :D
I definitely agree with you about Lyla. I partially agree about Supersonic and Wonderwall. What I mean is that I prefer listening to Liam's voice when these songs are sung like the album versions, but I love listening to the Noel's exclusive versions (generally calmer and more sentimental).
I personally love this version of Supersonic (watch?v=VsnXz4P4TKY) and this version of Wonderwall (watch?v=bg-Q0oduvfA). Same goes to Live Forever (check this version: watch?v=9TJhl7PqW70)
Everyone quit bitching about who does better lead singing. Noel is different but still fits well and does a great job, too.
Great
So, that's how this song's supposed to be sung. Noel should release a demo of all his songs with himself on lead vocals. Having said that, I do like the way Liam interprets Noel's songs and sings them in his own voice.
I only listen to the Noel acoustic of Slide Away and Cast no Shadow now.
wow , so glad Liam sung this one
Interesting version, sounds good also, but Liam's version is better I think.
Is there DLBIA version sang by Liam ?
That would be awesome!
It would be weird?
it exists, but none of them actually published it... they should do it though
actually, it doesnt exist. and there's no evidence to say otherwise
It exists but they havent release it
a voz do Liam eternizou essa canção... mas ficou legal com o Noel também,
by the lyrics you can see that this is the demo version. Noel usually sings the demo version of his songs.
I always prefer Noel's versions but Liam's also an awesome singer!
heyyyyy lyla.
노엘 사랑해!!!!
this is infinitely better than the version that was released, especially with the cool jam at the end.
I think he sings them in the demos cause he wrote them, and he later shows them to the band and here's when Liam comes up
Noel sei un genio ❤
noel's got a better voice...but this songs is liam's...hands down
***** fact based on nothing.
KAZZisti I agree totally there mate
truth dude
"better", Liam got the better voice/talent, but noel sings better, much different
anybody that thinks noel has a better voice knows fuck all about music or singing.
LIAM LIAM LIAM!
1:00 sounds like he was anticipating a classic elongated Liam snarl but it didn't really happen on the record
id go to a noel show and scream this at the top of my lungs with him, i dont care who sings it. liam, noel, whatever it's oasis .
If it were to be sung by Noel and we never heard the Liam version, it would definitely sound like something off Be Here Now or Heathen Chem that Noel usually sings.. I was thinking it's a bit like 'Force Of Nature' to be honest!
Крутая песня
Agreed. Its a good example of why having two choices of lead singer worked for Oasis though.
Spot on! But there were the odd songs that Noel will write and not know whether or not they were suitable for him or Liam. A prime example of that would be Wonderwall
Best
Lino, definitely owns this one Noel.
This song needs some heavy balls
Angelo Reyes you saying Noel haven't got one 😒
@JohnKulo ´Still, Liam did some things to take care of his voice. He changed the way to sing and it´s not the same junkie he used to be. IMO he is still a great singer and i really can´t understand don´t like songs like Four Letter Word, Millionaire, Roller, Beat Goes On, Morning Sun, Bubble in a bullet. I really can´t and i´m sorry for you. The main point is that i don´t think he shloud have any regrets. But you can think whatever you want. And i´m not saying in a agressive way.Cheers
Get this band back together!!!!!
Not bad Noel.. but you can see why it was Liam who led vocals.
@Sgtpepper212 It wasn't that, Liam joined Bonehead's band 'The Rain' with Guigsy and Tony McCarroll. Liam thought that if he joined, Noel would, and they'd use his songs. It's known that Bonehead brought Liam in to get Noel as well.
he is just laying down the tune
@JohnKulo imagine Liam "saving" his voice in Maine ROad, Finbury Park and Wembley. You would´nt have some of the best vocal performances ever. So stop crying your heart out.
amazing!! noels version is amazing! eeeeey lyla!! but liams version is amazing too! noel can sing her song if he want to do it hH he wrote the songs! haha come on guys!
@LordEizen according to one interview, star wars is one of the favorites movies of Noel
awww he sounds cute here
FIFA 06 has just changed your life.
wuppi do, president of the first oasis fanclub austria. it was on dvd but then you would know such things like that wouldn't you? they where raised not far from me guess you knew that to eh. lol
Me gusto, al fin al cabo es creacion de Noel 👍
Yea Noel is by far the better singer. Better musician all around. Liam does add to the band tho.. hes a cool front man.
even if he isnt a guitar god he is still rather good very simple but good
I like noel's voice . To me, this version is too much better than original :)
I named my daughter Lyla because of this song :)
he wakes up with them
no one knows
not even him
노래 최고된다
Can't really feel the same energy in this one as the album version with Liam. Noel is too gentle, doesn't really give it all. But it is actually comfortable to listen to this, but when you're used to the album version... it just won't do, y'know?
It's probably a song that could be edited to an acoustic tune...but with the electric guitars, it needs liam! Fucking decent though
I quite like Noels version but maybe i prefer Liams one co its the offical song but Noel made a good job of this
Come on back and make my world stand tall? Huh?
@JohnKulo i do agree he could do something to keep the voice better but it wouldn´t matter too much. The voice is worse now, mainly, because it´s a natural thing of age. The man is fourty now. And about being useless in Beady Eye it makes no sense. If you understand something about rock n roll´and check some videos live, like Isle of Wight or Rio de janeiro(that i went). That band is on fire, kept the Oasis level, one of the best at the moment. And prepare for the secnd album.
Even Noel admit that this is 'Liam's song' but that doesn't mean he's not allowed to sing it. and very well he does it too.
Noel is GodHead!
I personally think that Liam is a better singer and he's voice is so fucking nice. I don't like Noels voice. But Noel is one of the best guitarists with such a feeling! It's simple as that.
I think everytime Liam pissess off Noel, Noel sings the songs that Liam sings just to show he's better.
lol how goes there 'cuz of FIFA 06 and discover this group :)
A real rock song like this needs a gritty voice which Noel ain't got and Liam has but Noel's still a better singer!! Just Liam suits this more!!
Actually a lot better than what Liam did with the song in Helsinki this weekend
same
Noel's voice is sooo much better than Liam's u.u
I think Noel's voice is good in this, not bad
love noel but yes this is liam's song.
Force of Nature.
@WPPDuke Its a demo they just recorded somewhere! ha
now, why are you twiting on me? the main problem is, that i´m from austria! this dvd wasn´t realesd in my f***ing country! so,i try my best, to know everything...and, that they were raised near you, is clear to me. who doesn´t know? they once told me:"heya, we were raised near julie2009ish, thats awsome, innit?" :-D
Ouch myyyy eeeeaaarrrssss
Noel sings some killer tunes but this one Liam wins!! Liam sounds better singing Lord Don't Slow Me Down too.
the ending of the song sounds like the ending of "its getting better" by the beatles
I think you might find its the rolling stones with Brian Jones
Brian Jones made the stones a great taliented person dont forget him
whoops!
anybody who thinks noel can pull this song off better than liam is kidding themselves on
hahahah good song!!!
@greciasoleble good to know :D
I think this song is great and just hearing it by the man who wrote it makes it different
i don´t think so. on my single there is lyla, eyeball tickler and won´t let you down. maybe there are other realeses in other countries, but i would know that :-) as president of the first oasis fanclub austria i have to know such things :-D
Liams voice is way more unique an better than Noels. Noels voice is suited for some songs but not really this one. He is a far far superior songwriter though!
I think you took the last part of my statement as my own personal opinion. :P
i think noel has the most beautiful voice. but for rock n roll.. liam all the way :)
we are due at least 3 remix albums then
I like Liam's voice better for this song... except IMO Noel's voice is the better one of the two live nowadays..
I'd say a Bieber one. Blur fans had already admitted Noel's a genius
If Noel sung this like he sings Cum On Feel The Noize it would sound fantastic
It's cool, but although I love Noel and prefer his voice, this for me is one of those songs that should be sung by Liam.