This is fucking heavy. I mean, not just for an oasis song but this is ear-ringing stuff. Haunting and dripping with attitude. This version is one of their greatest tunes.
@@LukasOfTheLight but you literally listen to Coldplay? They were originally a guitar band. Guitar bands don’t get signed anymore and that’s why there are none in the charts and it’s not the bands fault it’s record company’s fault
Never thought of that, but you're spot on mate...I never stopped loving the early records, but around that time period I had kinda been sleeping on Oasis for a while, then late one night caught the video for "Shock of the Lightning" and it sucked me right back in again, couldn't figure out why...but it's because, like this demo, it took the Oasis sound and put it through a heavy shoegaze-style filter, which had become one of my favorite styles in the intervening years
@@LucasAlvesMusic The psychedelia of this demo is much more in line with the 'sharp', bright-sounding vibes of the tracks on DOYS--"Shock of the Lightning", etc. The finished "Shoulders", especially most of the 'trippy' tracks, just had a kind of flat, drab sound...in my opinion, of course
@@mywhychromosome that's true. But the heavy drums and overall dark sound reminded me of SOTSOG and gas panic especially. Drums almost sound like a loop
you fall in, we fall down there's no love in this shotgun town what you believe is not fair when you leave, yeah the world won't care the ghost that is your soul it leaves me cold, babe the ghost that is your soul it leaves me cold, babe cos you get so high you just don't feel it yeah you get so high you just can't feel it in and out your brain running through your veins you've got no sunshine you've got rain you fall in, we fall down there's no love in your shotgun town what you believe is not fair when you leave, yeah the world won't care the ghost that is your soul it leaves me cold, babe the ghost that is your soul it leaves me cold, babe cos you get so high you just don't feel it yeah you get so high you just won't feel it in and out your brain runnin' through your veins you've got no sunshine you've got rain why'd you get so high? cos you just can't feel it why'd you get so high? so you just can't feel it yeah you get so high you just can't feel it cos you get so high you just can't feel it in and out your brain runnin' through your veins you've got no sunshine you've got rain
Was going to reply, yes! But then I saw this is a 15 year old comment and paused at how this song is so great, a demo of it is still getting comments 15 years later.
Noel Gallagher A MUSICIAN WITHOUT STUDIES IN MUSICAL THEORY BUT A GENIUS WHEN COMPOSING AND A BRILLIANT MAKING MUSIC WITH HIS PERFECTION IS WHERE HE IS
me chupo siempre un huevo el estudio de la musica ....cuantos genios sin escuela hicieron hermosas canciones ...odio a los bobitos q se saben todas las escalas aguante OASIS
@@adriandiaz9120 Has intentado componer algo alguna vez? Xd Sin siquiera saber algo de teoría, aprendas donde la aprendas, no vas a poder juntar 2 acordes...
interesting how the original lyrics are very melancholic (like most oasis post 90s) but he changed them into a classic positive 90s oasis meaning, it's like he was trying to recapture smth
i don't remember where i heard this but i think gem urged noel to do the best oasis song he could do and i think that was the kickoff for the actual hindu times
Amazing!! This has so much more attitude than the studio version!!! What I love so much about Oasis is the quality of the B-sides and Demos. Cant imagine many people having such interest in Bloc Party and Kaiser Chief B-sides!!! Dont care what people say, Oasis still have it!
Favourite Noel and Liam photo at 1:29! I love both the demo and album version. I like the lyrics of this one but there's just something about Liam's voice
I wonder if it was intentional, but the specific sound of the drum programming on this makes it sound like one of the dance-influenced bands that preceded Oasis in early-'90s U.K., like coming full circle...
I agree , discovered it years ago ,I have sent it to all my mates ,we followed oasis all the time when we was in our 20s ! They all said same , amazing version
@@thelad789 his live voice between 01-09 was mangled, in the studio he was generally tip top (studio magic obviously helped) - these days his voice has improved vastly. He's about as good now as he was in 2000-2002
wo!!!'w this version is absolutly much better!! (i feel the island in this version....imagine in the trafalgare square with the phones) amazing versión!
if a recall correctly I heard this when it was actually still just a demo. Noel had sent it to Death in Vegas as he wanted them to be the potential album producers. Such a shame nothing ever came of it.
Already commented on this, but I tend to notice something new every few times I listen to an Oasis b-side/single/alt-version, etc...Although I'm amongst those who've actually found some worthwhile songs amongst the "Be Here Now", "Giants", "Heathen" eras and so on (rather than writing them off totally as so many have), the more I dig deeper, especially into those 3 records, the more I've realized...If they'd simply taken Noel's demos (this one is a good example; there are even better ones), taken them into the proper studio, recorded Liam's vocals over them, percussion--although some of the tracks actually sound find with the drum machine IMO--Bonehead's guitar where needed...they would've ended up with something a lot more clean, emotional, less overblown, and actually with a kind of sound that pushed them forward a bit, into new territory, but not in a drastic or alienating way and without ever losing that crucial 'Oasis' element that's hard to quantify but always there in their best stuff. ESPECIALLY with "Be Here Now", if you've ever heard those demos, it really could've made it more clear how strong some of those songs are instead of that record becoming some kind of black sheep. When I found an article with the producer who worked on all their best albums discussing the possibility of exactly that, I just thought...holy shit. Lol
The ghost that is your soul, it keeps me cold. Been listening to this demo for over a decade and still come back to it. Amazing demo and better than the actual release in my opinion. Noel’s and excellent and talented writer, a bit overlooked if you ask me
Holy fuck this is brilliant. Sounds so much better than the album version. Noel's vocals are stronger, the guitar solo sounds brilliant and the lyrics are some of Noel's finest. This should've been the one, maybe Oasis fans might've liked Heathen Chemistry more if THIS was the lead single.
Yeah and Noel is like 2 inches shorter than Liam aswell lol. Liam was actually quite big though when I met him, about 5'11" and Noel looked maybe 5'7.5 - 5'8?! Liam is such a nice guy!
the official release should've sounded just like this
100%
Obviously changed it because it was about his ex 😂
This was added to UA-cam whilst they were still together, They split for 15 years and now they are back together. Crazy!
Anyone still here in 2024 🫡
YUP.
Shoegaze-style Oasis
Yes they were the best band in the world in my eyes never to be beaten
@@fionnmcnessaagree 100%
Lucky enough to see them live 25 times 👏🏼👏🏼
@stephenwilson2793 Jesus that's some feat I seen them once in slane in ireland ill never forget it
This is fucking heavy. I mean, not just for an oasis song but this is ear-ringing stuff. Haunting and dripping with attitude. This version is one of their greatest tunes.
A 1000 times better than anything we will ever here in the charts today. What an amazing sounding demo!
@@LukasOfTheLight it’s kinda true
@@LukasOfTheLight yeah and guitar bands used to be in the top of mainstream charts and there not anymore. That’s what people mean
@@LukasOfTheLight but you literally listen to Coldplay? They were originally a guitar band. Guitar bands don’t get signed anymore and that’s why there are none in the charts and it’s not the bands fault it’s record company’s fault
Also applies in 2023 ✌🏻
Absolutely. Probably the top two rock bands that started in the 1990s and lived on for over two decades.
This demo sounds like it should be in Dig Out Your Soul!
Never thought of that, but you're spot on mate...I never stopped loving the early records, but around that time period I had kinda been sleeping on Oasis for a while, then late one night caught the video for "Shock of the Lightning" and it sucked me right back in again, couldn't figure out why...but it's because, like this demo, it took the Oasis sound and put it through a heavy shoegaze-style filter, which had become one of my favorite styles in the intervening years
Or in standing on the shoulder of giants
@@LucasAlvesMusic The psychedelia of this demo is much more in line with the 'sharp', bright-sounding vibes of the tracks on DOYS--"Shock of the Lightning", etc. The finished "Shoulders", especially most of the 'trippy' tracks, just had a kind of flat, drab sound...in my opinion, of course
@@mywhychromosome that's true. But the heavy drums and overall dark sound reminded me of SOTSOG and gas panic especially. Drums almost sound like a loop
@@LucasAlvesMusic Oh man...I DO love "Gas Panic". One of my overall favorites of theirs, actually. I do see where you're coming from
you fall in, we fall down
there's no love in this shotgun town
what you believe is not fair
when you leave, yeah the world won't care
the ghost that is your soul it leaves me cold, babe
the ghost that is your soul it leaves me cold, babe
cos you get so high you just don't feel it
yeah you get so high you just can't feel it
in and out your brain
running through your veins
you've got no sunshine
you've got rain
you fall in, we fall down
there's no love in your shotgun town
what you believe is not fair
when you leave, yeah the world won't care
the ghost that is your soul it leaves me cold, babe
the ghost that is your soul it leaves me cold, babe
cos you get so high you just don't feel it
yeah you get so high you just won't feel it
in and out your brain
runnin' through your veins
you've got no sunshine
you've got rain
why'd you get so high? cos you just can't feel it
why'd you get so high? so you just can't feel it
yeah you get so high you just can't feel it
cos you get so high you just can't feel it
in and out your brain
runnin' through your veins
you've got no sunshine
you've got rain
I love the words of the Nasty demo version. Mean as fuck.
Thank you for posting the lyrics
gotta love the raw almost smashing pumpkins sounding guitar. just for that this is better than the completed version.
'The ghost that is your soul, it leaves me cold, babe'
What a great lyric?
Apart from ‘babe’
Ah. Absolute quality. First touch.
no idea why they changed it
Was going to reply, yes! But then I saw this is a 15 year old comment and paused at how this song is so great, a demo of it is still getting comments 15 years later.
Yes I much better lyric in my view
This version with Liam on vocals would probably be their best song ever
Probably one of the best songs they ever did and I mean this version. Superb
It fuckin' rocks
@@tonyhewitt9440 yep always loved this version much more than the rewritten released version. Much darker really rock’s prefer the lyrics
@@tonyhewitt9440 the demo version of rock and roll star says it all for me a band destined for fame it sounds fresh
Noel Gallagher A MUSICIAN WITHOUT STUDIES IN MUSICAL THEORY BUT A GENIUS WHEN COMPOSING AND A BRILLIANT MAKING MUSIC WITH HIS PERFECTION IS WHERE HE IS
But sucks when choosing which version should be on the album and what should be put on B side.
me chupo siempre un huevo el estudio de la musica ....cuantos genios sin escuela hicieron hermosas canciones ...odio a los bobitos q se saben todas las escalas aguante OASIS
@@adriandiaz9120 Has intentado componer algo alguna vez? Xd
Sin siquiera saber algo de teoría, aprendas donde la aprendas, no vas a poder juntar 2 acordes...
It's all about having a good ear, think Kurt knew about music theory?
I really wish this was on spotify.
Since leaving Spotify for UA-cam premium I've never looked back. Problem solved ^
Wish they would do 20 year anniversary heathen chemistry deluxe edition like with DM, WTSMG and BHN
Fuck Spotify.
interesting how the original lyrics are very melancholic (like most oasis post 90s) but he changed them into a classic positive 90s oasis meaning, it's like he was trying to recapture smth
Good point that is
i don't remember where i heard this but i think gem urged noel to do the best oasis song he could do and i think that was the kickoff for the actual hindu times
(because noel referred to that anecdote while talking about how he wrote the song)
An avalanche of sound! The ghost that is your soul is leaves me cold babe.
That fact that replying to a 6 year old comment is completely mute leaves me cold babe.
I love The Hindu Times but I love this demo version more. This should be the song. Wow what strong lyrics.
ladymay30 the lyrics are nonsense
fede018 that makes it so great for me :-) I love the song and the sound.
+fede018 better than the final version. This is proper shoe gazing
+fede018 actually have a meaning
DerkY
oh, yeah? what is it then?
"What you believe is not fair, when you leave, the world won't care" Great lyric
Amazing!! This has so much more attitude than the studio version!!! What I love so much about Oasis is the quality of the B-sides and Demos. Cant imagine many people having such interest in Bloc Party and Kaiser Chief B-sides!!! Dont care what people say, Oasis still have it!
Such a good tune. Noel is by far one of my biggest influences.
Wow, its amazing to rummage through the back catalog and realize what a songwriting legend Noel is!
He's got brains
I play this over and over
Favourite Noel and Liam photo at 1:29! I love both the demo and album version. I like the lyrics of this one but there's just something about Liam's voice
There's a general consense that this version is way better than the original! it's true, it's better, and this song is fucking great.
Tomás Orellana deffo! This version is biblical
This is the origional, coconut.
Original as in album version, apricot
Its 1,000,000,000 times better.. the vibe is fucking awesome
i love the fucking drums in this version
Much appreciated for your time and effort to upload this
It’s a filthy grind. I love it.
This version has got more balls
I wonder if it was intentional, but the specific sound of the drum programming on this makes it sound like one of the dance-influenced bands that preceded Oasis in early-'90s U.K., like coming full circle...
This song is fooking mega !!! I love Oasis forever !!!
Unbelievable version
I agree , discovered it years ago ,I have sent it to all my mates ,we followed oasis all the time when we was in our 20s ! They all said same , amazing version
So raw and with amazing attitude. Gotta love NG.
This is better than the single!
This version is much better. Would be even more so if Liam's singing it.
The released version felt like oldies??
Amazing version this
I'd love to hear this version with Liam singing it.
He fors....you mong
Not sure Liam could of sang it in his later years as the words probably wouldn't sound clear enough.
Voice Note King What?
@@badgasaurus4211 His throat was mangled from cocaine.
@@thelad789 his live voice between 01-09 was mangled, in the studio he was generally tip top (studio magic obviously helped) - these days his voice has improved vastly. He's about as good now as he was in 2000-2002
Much better than the other version!
Yeah I'm with you this much better not over produced sounds like a one take song
Imagine liam on vox. Stunning
wo!!!'w this version is absolutly much better!!
(i feel the island in this version....imagine in the trafalgare square with the phones)
amazing versión!
Better than the other version...1000 times better :)))
Rebecca Bradley how so?
Esta version es mucho mejor que del producto final👌😳escuchando este temazoo en Asuncion Paraguay
GOOD!!! I CANT EXPLAIN HOW I LOVE THIS BAND!!!
me tooooooooo
That drummings sick
Love the sound of the guitars
this is my favorite version. diggin the drums on this
Biblical 🤘🎶🤘
i heard about this didnt know what to expect WOW!!!
Amazing!! Big fan of Oasis though I've never heard this version before!!
These these lyrics are far superior to the ones we ended with.
Absolutely not but still great demo
if a recall correctly I heard this when it was actually still just a demo. Noel had sent it to Death in Vegas as he wanted them to be the potential album producers. Such a shame nothing ever came of it.
Got my tickets for summer ‘25 😎
I love this.
It’s the only version I’ve heard
It sounds like Jesus and the Mary Chain!
how come this is a demo and not a single?
What happened? This is better than the released version. Check out the early Liverpool sessions. Amazing
Yo nunca había oído esta versión, I love it!
for this version, i like the distortion sound effect
Wonder what would've happened to Oasis if they went down this road...
They did
Mngwa Dodds not that much
Brilliant version...Even better than the album version!!!
Already commented on this, but I tend to notice something new every few times I listen to an Oasis b-side/single/alt-version, etc...Although I'm amongst those who've actually found some worthwhile songs amongst the "Be Here Now", "Giants", "Heathen" eras and so on (rather than writing them off totally as so many have), the more I dig deeper, especially into those 3 records, the more I've realized...If they'd simply taken Noel's demos (this one is a good example; there are even better ones), taken them into the proper studio, recorded Liam's vocals over them, percussion--although some of the tracks actually sound find with the drum machine IMO--Bonehead's guitar where needed...they would've ended up with something a lot more clean, emotional, less overblown, and actually with a kind of sound that pushed them forward a bit, into new territory, but not in a drastic or alienating way and without ever losing that crucial 'Oasis' element that's hard to quantify but always there in their best stuff. ESPECIALLY with "Be Here Now", if you've ever heard those demos, it really could've made it more clear how strong some of those songs are instead of that record becoming some kind of black sheep. When I found an article with the producer who worked on all their best albums discussing the possibility of exactly that, I just thought...holy shit. Lol
Fuck !!!!!! What an intro with the drums !!!!!! Love it
Can't stop listening to this!
AMAZING!!! the lyrics are perfect! love it so much!!!
The ghost that is your soul, it keeps me cold. Been listening to this demo for over a decade and still come back to it. Amazing demo and better than the actual release in my opinion. Noel’s and excellent and talented writer, a bit overlooked if you ask me
better version ever
The drums 😍
much better. so much better.
Click on settings, put the speed at x1.25, it sounds rad
So much better at 1.25
Where's settings? :/
+Thom Lennon mouse over the video window and you'll see it there
UP!
Only works on the demo version xD doing 1.25 on the regular Hindu Times is just bland, but this is fucking BIBLICAL
I think this version is much better and I do love Noels voice but imagine if Liam did the vocal, would be insanely good!
Yep, Live Forever.
Why this didn't make the album I do not know. Noel Gallagher is a legend.
Yitzchok Nussbaum not very good at choosing songs or versions of songs though
Cuz’ they want a radio friendly song for the charts
@@BrunoHuerta24 probably why gas panic did not make it either..
Thank you so so much for uploading this 💗
Is this version in C standard on guitar? This would've sounded insane in a stadium.
DeathFromAbove1981 The original is in A and this is a semitone higher than the original so it is probably in B flat, could be wrong though
@@TheBiologyking the Cd version is in B
Cd version in B for sure
Já ouvi essa música incontáveis vezes. Boa demais! Muito boa mesmo!
This version is much better
AWESOME drums!
Best Song Noel himself has ever sang albeit Little By Little and Don't Look Back In Anger.
way way way way way better than the final version - actual musical filth !!!!
"You Get So High" woulda been a proper title for this tune imo
absolutely briliant
so much more dark this version
this song is THICK with atmosphere.
Sounds mint, gives off loads of different vibes, cool lyrics, the whole thing sound like a Columbia version two.
This is better than the release version. Jesus, so much better.
The Pre Chorus is obviously inspired by Street Fighting Man............
the riff is inspired/taken from Same Size Feet by Stereophonics. Both good tunes..
38Highbury i think they took it from an abba tune. As Noel said everything comes from somewhere, nothing is original.
theselector Abba - "does your mother know"
ua-cam.com/video/lk1CLm0FsuM/v-deo.html
First time I heard this liked it more than released version. Darker lyrics and rocking
Versão muito melhor que de estúdio!! This version is better than studio!
top class
this version are so F great! and the of 0:43, woo the same face, haha xD live 4eva gallaghers,
Loki, Ernie, Nike, Jack, and Andromeda fell. Happy Holidays!🎄🎉
Holy fuck this is brilliant. Sounds so much better than the album version. Noel's vocals are stronger, the guitar solo sounds brilliant and the lyrics are some of Noel's finest. This should've been the one, maybe Oasis fans might've liked Heathen Chemistry more if THIS was the lead single.
what
True
Agreed, sounds so much better
I like both versions of this song... but the demo is just something very special
偉大的歌曲！偉大的天才！
The guitars on this are off the scale!
these lyrics are so much better! 'theres no love, in this shotgun town' magic!
Fuck me that's better than the album version...love the lyrics.
That sonic vibe.😍
I am speechless because of how good this is. Maybe we should start spray painting Noel is God on some walls.
Why'd didnt Noel just use this version & sing it himself? I completely love it!!
Yeah and Noel is like 2 inches shorter than Liam aswell lol. Liam was actually quite big though when I met him, about 5'11" and Noel looked maybe 5'7.5 - 5'8?! Liam is such a nice guy!