Here’s THE TRUTH About the Israeli-Palestinian Conflict (A Comprehensive History)
Вставка
- Опубліковано 4 чер 2021
- Go to expressVPN.com/Ben and find out how you can get 3 months of ExpressVPN free!
From biblical times to today, Ben takes us through time to explore the long history of Israel and explains the many conflicts along the way.
Other videos you might enjoy:
Ben Shapiro Explains Why He Wears A Yarmulke - • Ben Shapiro Explains W...
IDF Spokesman Explains How The Iron Dome Actually Works - • IDF Spokesman Explains...
BITCOIN: The Future of Finance or Fool’s Gold? - • BITCOIN: The Future of...
#History #Politics #Religion #Israel #Judaism #Islam #Jordan #Gaza #Hamas
It's crazy being here 2 years later and having the exact same thing happen all over again. Especially profound to hear Ben specifically say this same cycle repeats every couple of years
I just watched this for the first time. The history is very informative - I’ll be interested to see if there’s a version from the Palestinian perspective. Main reason I’m here is because I want to hear what Ben has to say about the current situation. Again, I’ll listen to both sides but I can’t see how the terrorists can possibly justify themselves. Not long ago the world had so much empathy for the plight of the Palestinian people. But, if they’re being programmed to hate Israel and think it should be wiped off the map and all Jews should be killed, from a young age, then there’s not much that can be done. It does go both ways. Many Isrealis think that all Palestinians are terrible when that simply isn’t the case. So, I do feel bad for ordinary people on both sides who don’t support the violence… Hamas don’t care that they’re setting their own people up for slaughter. They’ll happily use kids as human shields as they think it’s great marketing.
I think the truth is somewhere in the middle. It baffles me why Israel is allowing the settlements, because there is much more to lose than to gain with that. They could have the complete moral high ground if they didn’t defy the UN for the last 60 years. What Hamas did the last few days is completely wrong, but Israel seems to be set on giving them all kinds of excuses.
Also I don’t understand the complete blockade of Gaza (“no food, no water, no electricity”), because there are innocent people and children there. You can’t punish all of them. By doing that people will say “how is that different than the Warsaw ghetto?”
I don’t understand…
they are happy and celebrating in london.@@PhilT81
I've been waiting on his updated explanation of the current events happening over there.
@@PhilT81 how do you decide to give some land with ppl living in it ! Oh they claimed it was empty.
The most fought over land in history as he claims it was empty so the British decided to give it away. I get it now thanks .
If Ben didn't talk so fast, this video would be two days long.
A discussion between Shapiro and Tim Pool is so fast that it ends before it even starts.
I listen to Ben at 1.5x, just because I like the challenge. 2x is a bit too fast for me.
At normal pace Israel could have won another defensive war in the time taken to go through the history.
🤣🤣
🤣🤣🤣
I honestly thought he made this video recently until I looked and realized it was 2 years old. That says a lot about this conflict.
I did the same this is how Ben needs to act today
Same.
For information only, what this man has said is wrong on so many statements he made. he is without a doubt on an agenda - what that may be is unknown. I will write this man has made so many false/fake misstatement of fact it is pathetic that people believe him. I was on this earth before WWII and I have lived all that he has spoken about and I have a very great grasp of the history of the Middle East. I was deeply angered by his lies and falsehoods - to the place where I could no longer listen to his lies and false words - he is part of the cause of the continuing problems in the Middle East. Let those who speak truth speak for the Middle East - let them gather all peoples together and solve the problems once and forever. What most people do not understand is that all Jewish people still live in their minds the days of Germany and the Holocaust. As a Christian we were killed, beaten, banished centuries ago - remember Jesus was hung from the cross because he was a "teacher with a following" the Romans did not like. I say this final word about this fake "he knows not what he speaks". Please people do not accept this mans words blindly - please at a minimum fact check him - and for that matter fact check me. I strongly suggest you view the You Tube interview between Ben Shapiro and Piers Morgan shortly after October 7th.
This occupation goes back 75 years ago
He has just recently made another similar video that is available here on You Tube other than the interview with Piers Morgan - he is classified as a "radical" and cares not one bit what people think or say about him and his opinions. He is, and I want to be careful here because I am not Jewish, he is very far right is his positions on Israel and the Jewish people, because he is in fact Jewish. One thing he did say in the Piers Morgan interview that did not surprise me was that he still harbored a deep hatred because of the Holocaust and that seems to be a theme with many people of the Jewish faith - they can not get over (nor should they forget) what happened back in the 1930-45 time period by a crazed man who wanted only power and the death of the Jewish people - and Shapiro seems to forget that this is an entirely different time period. He also seems to forget that more than 50 million other people died during that same time period from all nations involved in that war - we live on - we remember and honor but we don't live as though that period has never ended. It does not give an explanation to what is going on now. If you read my entire piece I explain all that I took exception to his statements which were complete lies and he himself says he doesn't care if he tells lies and misstates facts - and that is what I object to. If he had told the truth in his followup interviews with Morgan and in a group round table discussion I would not have spent time and energy correcting him but I am the type of person who does place a very high degree in people telling the truth - especially those who are earning money from lies and misstatements.
I am a Christian and my husband was dying of cancer. I found out that because a friend of mine told me that my husband was added to the Tree Of Life for the year. My husband was far gone and died that year. The Jewish people will always be close to my heart. What is going on in the US is awful. I will always stand up for that generous gift that they presented to me. God bless you all.
What about Palestinian Muslims and Christians, women and children who are mass murdered by Israel in Gaza?
@@aniawarner9909 Blame hamas for that
@@aniawarner9909 Islam never takes accountability for anything : it always provokes others and when they finally react it plays the eternal victim. Such a disgusting culture.
@@aniawarner9909 I had a scating comment to tell you what a disgrace the culture of ' the religion of peace ' really is , but the hypocritical you tube police deleted it. Of course.
@@aniawarner9909 shouldnt have started a war you couldnt finish.
So Ben is talking so fast that youtube offers vietnamese subtitles
Holy shit
😂😂😂😂
Bwahahahahaa. I just noticed it!!😂😂😂😂
lmao
I wish there was a slow down function!
"Gets attacked from all sides"
Poland: First time?
😂☹️😂
Im Polish.... i LMFAO
@@dhswatcher5259 poor Poland vanished from the surface of the earth like 3 times, but recovered every time so Poland stronk 💪
@@hydraulicfacechannel2147 well you should read the history of India, it's the most invaded country in the world.
@@loranttoth5897 yes
That was a fantastic condensed version of this whole conflict. When I was in a government class in high school, I chose to represent the country of Israel. It required A LOT of study on the different conflicts in order to represent Israel correctly, because our government teacher was no slouch....let me tell you! I learned a lot then, and this taught me even more. Well done!
No, it's really not. Christians controlled the area, Muslims controlled the area, jewish people controlled the area. You had canaanites, Egyptians, Greeks, Romans and of course Jewish people running that area.
The whole idea that the land is jewish is ridiculous. They were kicked out 2000 years ago by the romans.
You obviously did not do enough study of the Middle East history! I suggest you view the You Tube interview between Ben Shapiro and Piers Morgan shortly after October 7th.
@@rhh3582 haha.
Again, for the millionth time:
Settlers decided to settle in a place that was populated. So they stole the land. They are still stealing land.
Bad call.
@@nosuchthing8 Are you really that ignorant?
@@nosuchthing8 I said it once and I say it again, your ignorance only is preceded by you hate of non-Jews and the constant memories of the Holocaust that was caused by the Germans and not the Arabs or any other group. You ignorance is only preceded by you arrogance.
Hello ben It's me 2 years later, this vídeo should be updated with the events of the last 2 years!
View the You Tube interview between Ben Sharpiro and Piers Morgan made shortly after October 7th.
Just realized this needs to be updated. 😅
Especially about the part where he says Israel cares about innocent human lives. 😂
@@cheese32ifmore importantly - all the untruths and misstatements need to be corrected - but that's right Shapiro doesn't care what any people say, I almost forgot how he does not relate with people
Ben flipping a whiteboard might be my new favorite thing. He should do more whiteboard explanations.
I think Ben gave some whiteboard lectures in the space laser.
I uploaded a video titled, "Jewish Space Laser DESTROYS Communism with Facts and Logic".
Here's a link if interested: ua-cam.com/video/WWsSzXJJtzU/v-deo.html
Definitely!
ua-cam.com/video/wSfmWkKrjNk/v-deo.html
Lol
@Be Rational ua-cam.com/video/wSfmWkKrjNk/v-deo.html
The press getting this wrong isn't coming from ignorance, the motivation is a lot darker.
I think largely the press is reporting the conflict quite fairly. At least in Europe. Ben got a little triggered by some fringe press reports.
what have they got wrong exactly?
Reality is ua-cam.com/video/wSfmWkKrjNk/v-deo.html
who started without right continues without right to prove his right. "Zionism" Is a sick Ideology, I think Christians shall own that land also cause jesus was there. I think Islam shall take back some parts of spain cause they were there a once. It's not history its as the wise people who commented here it's a kid stories.
Ur not wrong there very sinister agendas at work
Not a single word about Arabian oil vs Iranian oil and the fact that one of those nations doesn't use the dollar to sell it.
A friend said that this war is about oil. We weren't even touching that possibility 6 months ago.
Is that what you're saying in your comment? Just curious.
Please elaborate. Israel, unlike most of the area, has no oil. Right? You are talking about currency value? Gold vs oil?
@@elypearl826 Iran and the US are enemies because the first one doesn't want to exchange their oil for dollars, and this has led to conflict since the Islamic revolution happened.
Before the revolution, Iran was under a US-approved government, and they sold oil for dollars. After that ended in 1979, the US started wars against Iran (the Iran-Irak war, where they supported Saddam against them). Their only objective is to obtain their oil. They don't really care about it being a theocracy (if they did, they'd be enemies with Arabia too, and they wouldn't have supported a dictator like Saddam).
All of this has made the Iranian government very anti-America. Israel is the US' best friend in the region, and the US uses that friendship to destabilize the Middle East. This time, the terrorist attack of Hamas has given an excuse to Israel-US to start a war there, and I think they wanted to see how Iran would react against something like this (that's why, in the context of war, they bombed the Iranian embassy in Damascus).
The Israel-Palestinian conflict is used by the US to destabilize the region, as a way to control their influence over there.
@@elypearl826 it doesn't matter if Israel herself has oil. The American dollar, the worlds reserve currency, is propped up artificially by the global oil market because 99% of oil sales are made in American dollars. I believe that's the point they're making: the countries that try to deviate from the American oil hegemony are conveniently always the countries America and her allies decide to paint as enemies, almost as if its the only way for America to maintain its global dominance of the economy.
@@RustyCarbomb This is an important point. Thanks for sharing. The Iranian government now has access to $6 billion of their funds to be used for humanitarian purposes as a part of a wider deal that allowed five Americans who had been imprisoned in Iran to go free. So the Biden administration is keeping afloat the american dollar there in the middle East Correct Rusty?
Part of the Potsham agreement between Churchill, Stalin and Roosevelt, was that Great Brittan was to liberate its colonies in the middle east, near east and asia, to local rule. This is how India, was liberated and why Israel was created in 1947
This is the best 'Fun with Flags with Sheldon Cooper' episode ever.
Thanks for making my day better
First thing that popped on my head
@Dan S cool story bro
Who has?
Dr Sheldon Cooper
Nothing destroys the last 50 years of American public school education more than historical fact.
true fact
ua-cam.com/video/ufqvz3xycBs/v-deo.html
ua-cam.com/video/ufqvz3xycBs/v-deo.html
Which doesnt care about your feelings
You can lead an American to history, but you cannot make him think!
Some people are allergic to history... but thank you.
He’s misrepresenting several key events, learn history from a more accurate source, don’t stay in his echo chamber
Sure. Which other accurate sources do you recommend?
@@grayonthewaterwhat more accurate source?
@@grayonthewater says the man with no source. what key events are being misrepresented? Literally no one knows who you are yet you jump in here telling everyone to just belief you on faith. How do you think you just debunked this whole video with a "nut-uh!" ?
Kinda gloss over the "they enter the land of Canaan" part Ben. There were people there during their first invasion who wound up a lot like the people of the second and current invasion.
Which country are you from?
@@alabisilas5915 The Great White North - Canada
This is why history is not taught. The devil is always in the details. Remove the details its easy to propagate false narratives. Love Ben & Dinesh.
Ben leaves some things out, especially about how the war started. The war started because Egypt wouldn't let Israeli shipping through the Straits of Tiran. Israel attacked Egypt over it. It was economic mostly.
@@inquisitorofkek2472 Blockade of the strait of Tiran is considered an act of war. Israel fired the first shot after that.
I just don't understand THIS:
If literally the ONLY ONE good thing happening to Jews in the last 2 thousand years was DONE BY TRUMP, than why the hell did they support BIDEN?
@@shreddedmetal2526 Not according to international law. They had absolutely zero claim to the Straits. They have no right to anything. In other words, they have about as much right to bomb Egypt as Japan had to bomb Pearl Harbor and for much the same reasons.
So why is ben against teaching of Americas Racist history
I imagine Ben helping his kids with their homework, white board at ready, and " These are the facts " lol!!
ua-cam.com/video/wSfmWkKrjNk/v-deo.html
Except they arent the facts, just one sided propaganda.
@@susiex6669 he is Zionist.. Bro😅 how do u expect a truth. Just watch his old videos.
@@lojainshawmi5801 you sound Muslim, how do I expect truth, just one sided propaganda
@@jackmccoy7435 ua-cam.com/video/wSfmWkKrjNk/v-deo.html
i feel like im being sold a used car or a vcr
lol
A side of me “Listen carefully to what he is explaining”
The other side “ I have never realised he was such an handsome…”
The Romans renamed the area "Syria Palaestina" as an insult to the Jews. It refers to the Philistines, past enemies of the Jewish people. Emperor Hadrian really hated Jews.
and for good reason, read about the jewish history at the time
Basically, it was an ancient flex against the Jews
Well, if YOU had to send 12 Roman legions to conquer them, you'd hate the Jews too - it took 4 legions to subdue the entire british isle FFS.
@@roylahav3283 dude the Brits were a bunch of divided tribes with no fortifications also they do battle they get defeated and surrender.
But if u are talking about the Jewish revolt the whole Jews revolted the legions needed to go to every village and town to subdue them not to talk about the fortifications like Jerusalem and they did a hit and run tactics never give a big battle except for a few, also have you heard about the City of Masada it is a small city in a MOUNTAIN.
@@TheGodfather441 I would love to know more about that, can you give me a good source.
Didn't realize this was from 2 years ago until Ben explicitly said "that brings us to were we are right now in 2021". Video could not have that line and still be the exact same thing for 2023.
Watch the Tantura documentary
Nor has it aged particularly well.
@@theresawestfall5949
Why please?
I know!
That’s how history works
This aged well.
This is fascinating. My history classes in high school had a lot of this wrong, or not mentioned at all.
Free Palestine 🇵🇸
@@just_a_turtle_chad yes, free Palestinians from the terrorist organization Hamas
You can't argue against the fact that the Tanakh (Old Testament) dates way further back then the Quran.
I was thinking the same thing
ua-cam.com/video/ufqvz3xycBs/v-deo.html
Ben Shapiro is standing in front of a map. You have my attention now
Awesome stuff. Hey Ben. Can you recommend a book that gets into all if this? Really would like to know.
if only my school took the time to teach as well as this
This has to be translated in every language
@@swanita9568 Palestine didnt exist
@@swanita9568
ua-cam.com/video/B1yFjib3wug/v-deo.html
@@swanita9568 WAR CRIME. One side wants to completely kill every single Jew in the Middle East while other is stealing land . Is it morally equivalent ❔❔❔❔can you tell me which law Hamas violates , let me guess CRIMES AGAINST AGAINST HUMANITY, or genocide ...
@@swanita9568 there was no settlements before 1967.
20 years in which the arabs tried to destroy israel, from the decesion of UN about 2 states in 1947 until the six days war in 1967.
They never wanted 2 states and they are still dont support that solution, even thou israel tried to offer them the same solution over and over again they rejected all of them.
@@swanita9568 If there can be something known as Palestinian land, Why cant there be Isreali land? Palestinians have no historical existence, they are simply Arab immigrants, On the other hand you have a race of people with HISTORICALLY MIDDLE EASTERN DESCENT with no country to call their own at all. Do you not see the hypocrisy ??
But I guess terrorism and blatant racism and persecution for centuries doesn't count as "war crimes" typical Arab move, Ignore the UN when they rule against you for funding terrorism, BUT SUDDENLY THE UN IS GREAT AND AMAZING when they rule in your favor. suddenly the Geneva convention matters OMG HOW CONVENIENT
It is horrible that you have to explain this history. I applaud you for explaining this to confront the left.
Tom...people don't really know because it's not taught, properly, in school.
@@swanita9568 listen to what he is saying.
Well, of course someone has to explain history? Unless you were alive and present for it, someone always has to explain history to you.
@@trevorsmith6035 I think that he is referring to the fact that everyone just jumps to the conclusion that Palestinians are in the right and Israel is in the wrong(no matter how many signs point to the opposite)...their doesn't seem to be any effort to research history and check into pro-Palestine people's claims so he has had to do the work for us
@@swanita9568 True Americans will stand and fight with Israel. This is just getting started
Ben, you say Gaza started Gaza War 2008 but it was Israel that preemptively struck...
Bravo, now I need to watch this 1200 more times to be able to speak truth to the idiots around me in Portland Oregon
American broken public school system won't touch this... Thank God, I was fortunate enough to go to a Catholic school that did teach this.
@Karl Quetzacoatl much harder, if not impossible, to control a critical thinker.
My 8 year old childs school does but it is a christian school
Did you school also teach you about the rhineland massacre?
It depends on the teacher. Some history teachers do go rogue and teach actual history as well as the School District requirements. I had a history teacher that brought his classes together to the schools back field and had us reenact many battles from throughout history to give us an idea (miniscule though it was) of the odds some of these people faced. He even brought Veterans in to talk from WWII, KOREA, VIETNAM, etc.
Yikes catholic school, imagine entrusting your education and religions faith to a bunch of old people who thought the world was flat.
if only Ben had taught history at my high school... instead I got a teacher who told me that the holocaust had come from no where and could never happen again.
That's really interesting actually. In Israel we learned that the Holocaust wasn't a unique phenomenon, maybe the largest in scale, but there have been many pogroms and persecution. Where are you from?
@@ravila2910 Australia and I should mention although the rest of them where rather left wing, it was only one teacher who told us this. She also thought that it was all beacuse of Hitler (he convinced everyone to be anti-Semitic
)
@Saad Malik is he pushing Israel above America in this video?
Why is he not living in Israel running his business for Israelies?
Does he believe that Israel is a better place to live and raise his kids?
@@Bauernade I did mine..and ben is totally right about it!!!
@@Bauernade could you give a few examples where he was completely inaccurate or misrepresenting something in this presentation?
14:17 How they came to an accord with Sadat wearing this tie is a miracle
Just FYI: You might assume that most people already know this, but you left out the fact that Christianity also pre-dates Islam. I think a lot of people think of Islam as "exotic" and therefore "old" or "ancient" compared to the West, but it's really the newest religion on the scene when it comes to the three big "Abrahamic" faiths.
He mentioned the foundation of Islam, but it's really not relevant to the peace of modern-day Israel.
Exactly, Muslims just like Mormons believe their prophet was the last prophet of the Abraham lineage. The difference of course is that Mormons for the most part are productive and peaceful.
What are those?
@@Seekingthefacts4 , What are what/who?
@@Tryingtofindmyway Nice one. But hold on. Let me learn you something. Invention of Islamic Civilization: Coffee, Algebra, the Astrolabe, mass production of paper books,
I'm a simple man, I see Ben at a whiteboard ready to give a history lesson -- I click.
Yessir
Because the news does a better job?🙄
@@mtcoorscan they really dont
ua-cam.com/video/6VixqvOcK8E/v-deo.html
It’s really the small things in life..
the only reason arabs came to Israel from Saudi Arabia was and still is to interrupt the Jews. they just hate the fact Isaac inherit Abraham and not Ishmael
it was the land of canan first though right?
It's so crazy that there is that much HATE in the world.
might as well wake up to it now... human beings ARE sinners, we are all hateful and have the propensity to do evil, but also good. The left tries to leave out the first part though in ignorance that were all just happy with rainbows, that's why ppl like Biden and Obama show sympathy to terrorist groups and we all get fucked later on. It's willfull ignorance.
ua-cam.com/video/wSfmWkKrjNk/v-deo.html
It’s life man...get used to it
the Palestinian are same ancient people and even in Jericho before the Judaism and no one left it, they r same people, this guy is Zionism propagandist.. Its a History crime, it doesn't relate to hate you but taking other people land by the name of god rather if u weren't same people 3000 years ago is mistake, Zionism is crime.. There is no such thing everyone are expelled even in Germany.. They're about 116,000 to 225,000 after Nazi there is nothing worse than Nazi.
@@sultansultan5529 your wrong. Completely wrong. He's not lying about anything he told the TRUTH about it. The Jews were there over a thousand years before Islam was even created. The Jews would live there in peace with all of them, but all of them have wanted to drive out or totally wipe the Jews out. Period. End of story. It's that simple. If Your on the side of Hamas then your on the wrong fuckin side. It doesn't take a rocket scientist to figure that out
" UN a garbage organization" I knew this the very second I started thinking for myself.
You say for likes in a echo chamber...........
@@danielcollins7515 as if you don’t reaffirm your beliefs on other videos that agree with your agenda. It’s only human to affirm things. You’re just butthurt because you disagree. And you’re wrong, there’s a reason why Brexit happened. EU sucks.
@@SerenityScratch lol, thanks for proving my point.
@@SerenityScratch Brexit did not happen because of UN. Why would you write something like this? It's just factually wrong.
@@duggme I think she’s making a wider point about multinational organisations.
Canaanite ancestry is a mix of indigenous populations who settled the Levant (the region encompassing much of modern Syria, Lebanon, Jordan, and the Palestinian territories) around 10,000 years ago, and migrants who arrived from the east between 6,600 and 3,550.
Others migrate d later from Egypt.
Hi Ben, Great video.. have you ever looked into the patterns of evidence? the research behind it? It is really amazing, wonder about how you look at it
This teaching by Ben is long overdue.
Hasbara lesson of the day with Ben Shapiro. 1) Lets learn to distort facts. 2) The art of omitting pertinent information in order to give a slanted view on history. 3) Get agitated so people think youre serious. 😂
@@susiex6669 fortunately we live in a time when access to information is easier than ever, so it is going to be increasingly difficult for your sort to cope. :/
@@theformerlife I think you have that backwards Sunshine. Corporate media is dead and Zionists no longer control the narrative, they know it, which is why the latest attack on Gaza was a complete media disaster internationally for Israel, and its only going to get worse for the apartheid state.
Kind of you to call this a teaching
@@susiex6669 Well, your latent anti-Semitic prejudice aside, I don't think it was a 'media disaster', media was as usual divided along ideological lines; perspective followed accordingly. Israel is not an apartheid state; it however, identifies your ideological source.
I got a free history lesson the schools couldn’t take the time to teach
they have to time to teach cancel culture and white supremacy 😂
@@almog1910 or teaching u that ur racist for being born white 😂 absolutely outrageous
ua-cam.com/video/Ns13VjwUGd4/v-deo.html
This video has so much propaganda its insane, so much information purposefully left out and blatant lies. Even my Israeli friends agree with me.
@@leb5550 Everything he said was a fact .
I'm disappointed, in the first 10 seconds of this video he said we're going to Go Back In Time. I watched this whole video and not once did I see Marty McFly or Doc Brown!
Why you skipped the history of the canaanites, which were in that land before the children of Isreal(Jacob) that migrated from egypt to the holy land.
You don't know shit about our history
Take it to the God of the universe. He invited them...
Bud there was tons of tribes there at that time theu were all war lords when the jews went there they created the country the Canaanties were of Greek who lived on the coast which in the bible when u read that was the first contact the jews had with them was war they were Greek war lords there was no Arabs there Arabs come from the Arab pensiula plz look that up don't be a clown
Yes. But they were same people, Jews.
@@bujarberisha5834 that's false. Canaanites were pagan.
I'm Israeli, I study at Ort in Tel Aviv.
Half of the students are Muslims.
We get along very well. And the media won't show you this truth.
They sure won’t
ua-cam.com/video/ufqvz3xycBs/v-deo.html
ua-cam.com/video/ufqvz3xycBs/v-deo.html
Stop the apartheid state in Israel
And they don't tell people that there are quite a few Christian Palestinians who support Israel.
I appreciate someone explaining this instead saying its "too complicated"
he is lying to you
@@luijay007 you are lying .
@@luijay007 ironic coming from the roaming liar
This video just barely scratches the surface. Involved(but not mentioned here) is one of the reasons Hitler and the Germans in general were against the Jews was the large persecuted Jewish population Germany took in from Russia in the 1800's and very generously set up with farms, tools, livestock, etc.
Now, WWI was fought basically to a stalemate with all parties involved bled white and ready to go home with the map of Europe largely unchanged. Along comes a Zionist (Rothschild?) who traded the promise of a fresh allie(the US) to Britain for British creation of a Jewish homeland in Israel after the war.(The Balfour declaration) Instead of all the combatants going home to lick their wounds without much of a surrender, the US's Jewish population caused the US to enter the war which resulted in the defeat of Germany which resulted in the disastrous Treaty Of Versailles which stripped Germany of industrial productivity infrastructure and contributed greatly to the VERY ruinous depression in Germany in the 1930's. So Germans weren't very charitably disposed toward Jews after a Jew(s) repaid German kindness with the geo-political treachery that resulted in Germany losing WWI. Along came the immigrant Jewish pawn brokers and land buyers who refused to pay more than fractions of a cent on the Mark for anything the economic depression starved Germans had to sell. These Jewish opportunists had access to capital from outside of Germany and, when a German in the '30's got so hungry and so desperate they were willing to part with their family heirloom gold watch or jewelry or farm, the Jews always had ready cash and bought up large swaths of prime German real estate and farms as well as tons of family gold and jewelry. Pretty much anything of value, the Jews bought and paid nearly nothing. So instead of repaying the German kindness for taking them in and setting them up, the Jews took gross advantage of the Germans and basically plundered what was left by the treaty of Versailles. I'm not saying that Hitler and the Germans were right in carrying out the Holocaust, far from it........but I kind of understand.
@@jonnygranville281 open your eyes. Read on the ethnic cleansing in sheikh jarrah
I'm waiting for Finkelstein's reply-with maps.
Although I don't agree with a lot of Ben's politics, this is a super important video for my generation to watch. We love to act like we know what we're talking about 24/7, when we don't.
Ben's Biden impression is miles ahead of his Bernie Sanders impression.
@@TheEverCuriousJen and I disagree with your calorie intake, I'd bet your heart and the rest of your body probably agrees with me.
that biden impersonation was pure GOLD
ua-cam.com/video/wSfmWkKrjNk/v-deo.html
OMG.....best example of Biden speaking ever!! In the words of Jim Rome, EPICCC......
the time stamp for this golden nugger is 30:03 if anyone's intersted
ua-cam.com/video/lY6DQt2aGI0/v-deo.html
Is there a slower version of this? I learned a lot, but had to rewind a few times.
Tap your screen. You’ll see a “gear” in the top right corner of the video. Tap that to open playback settings. Set the speed to .75.
What I don't understand is why the Jews didn't leave altogether? All the surrounding countries obviously did not want them there for centuries but they continued to force themselves upon ppl and areas that clearly wanted nothing to do with them.
1. It's not easy to leave your livelyhood.
2. Other people not wanting you in your own place, is other people's evilness. They have to be rebuked. Not you, for not leaving.
3. They were commanded not to leave by God, since the whole earth is God's and He has given them Israel.
Thats definitly not gonna get Controvertial.
Free Palestine 🇵🇸
@@just_a_turtle_chad no
@@just_a_turtle_chad from
@@just_a_turtle_chad from hamas yes, from the reason I’m assuming your meaning by that comment, no
@@just_a_turtle_chad history doesn’t lie #istandwithisrael
Ben doesn't fear controversy, controversy fears him.
Facts
I like to think of Ben as the Chuck Norris of facts.
@@crackerjack6454 u win the comment of the year
@junkid29 lol who’s worshiping him?
ua-cam.com/video/ufqvz3xycBs/v-deo.html
This is their government. Not the thousands innocent people living there. The children are innocent. They are dying on both sides.
Nope, that's exactly how the size is. You 'fabrucated' not just the size, but also the word fabricated.
When are you going to debate Norman Filkenstein? 😂
Sad. This is reality. This is history. "They" won't even look at it. They won't teach it.
Because it is fake.
Shapiro dont whant to learn geography also 🤷🏻
They won't teach it because it will destroy all their propaganda narratives. Every child will see through their fake wokeism and call them out.
@@naserel-zebdeh7359 You've said that on almost ALL comments. Just send your link so we can know your pov. 🙄
@@mystique5113 Watch this video and see the "propaganda" for yourself.
ua-cam.com/video/CUZaR3op1qw/v-deo.html
There's sooooo many more videos, informational and actions, just showing all the lies made by Zionists to get the west on their side, and how IDF soldiers treat Palestinians. If you want to check these videos out let me know.
This all needs to be explained more often.
Word!
Anybody who sees this and didn't notice Ben hasn't condemned Israel at all should re-evaluate the validity of what he said. This wasn't an accurate representation of a situation from both sides. If you think all Ben said clarifies the situation then I got news for ya. The biggest red flag when someone is telling you something like this and has nothing to say that is negative to the side they support (Israel is the world leader in killing children- Average life expectancy in Palestine is less than 21 which is crazy). It says a lot when people don't immediately question that information that is clearly one sided.
Remember that the Palestinians are a mixture of Jewish, Christians, and Muslims- All are a Semetic people by origin in that area. It's just so happened three major religions originated in the Middle-East. As expected, many people converted. Palestine is the oldest Muslim and Christian nation in history. Ben is saying Jewish people were always present. That is correct. They are the Palestinians. There was mass immigration into Palestine from Europe. They no longer have a right to the land. It makes no sense that they are considered "indigenous". No one here would even amuse the thought of the indigenous people in America taking it back- they would be put down real fast. They've been distinct this whole time and none have needed to immigrate after hundreds of years which is a much more powerful connection that any Jewish person in the world automatically having a right to the land of Israel. Think about that. Israel as a state is what matters. There were documents that defined the land and borders of Palestine and Israel. The UN did a terrible job of dividing this land in a reasonable way. It looks like a jigsaw puzzle. By international law, Israel is illegally occupying Palestinian land- this is a fact. Israel is known to consistently encroach beyond the Palestinian border. When they built a wall to prevent conflicts between Israelis and Palestinians except they built the wall well into Palestine instead of on the border. Imagine your neighbor is building a fence between your home for privacy and builds it two feet into your backyard- that would be quite the piss off and I am sure you respond in a way you feel is appropriate.
The six-day war was a surprise attack from perception of war. I can't say I know for sure if a war was imminent. It is conjecture. However, Ben's education would likely gloss over that since he went to Jewish school. What is true is that tensions were high and there was a lot of hate. The Yom Kippur War was won by the Egypt and got their land back.
Bill Clinton was actually the closest person to ever to achieving peace between Palestine and Israel. Palestine should have negotiated and given access to all religious sites with pertinence to Jewish people. However, the reason that negotiations fell through is for a couple reasons likely that Israel would continue to control water supply and imports and exports. Who on earth would say yes to that? Saying that every concession was given is factually incorrect- more "generous than usual" seems great but it needs context as what that means. Wording is important.
The fact that Israel has by definition created an apartheid that great minds like Malcom X, Nelson Mandela, and Albert Einstein all condemn strongly everything that Israel has done the last 70 years of its existence. The videos the "prove" that building managers in Palestine would let everyone in a building die for news is really ridiculous- any amount of critical thinking would immediately send doubt through the entire narrative. What do they gain? How did Israel even get this building managers number? Why did they attack a residential building? Now, there are much more Israeli soldiers who have openly come out and confessed their crimes and the weight of guilt they feel. Palestinians aren't allowed to rest. Every night soldiers go through their homes to ensure that they never feel safe. Videos of Israeli citizens smiling while taking pictures of Palestinians mobbed in the street. The hate is strong on both sides and Palestinians have also mobbed Israelis at times when found in their territory. Israel and Zionist schools have a strong propaganda which must be addressed. This propaganda is likely present in the warring Arab countries as well. This results in a lack of human consideration on all sides but Arab countries have stopped attacking Israel. The problem now is the power dynamic- A fully funded, US supported military (3.6 billion) with a world renowned defense system vs. people with rocks, faulty rockets, and extreme poverty. It makes no sense that Israel is unable to target the one group that is actually attacking them (as well as the Palestinian people). Hamas's existence was started (allegedly) and supported (overtly) by Israel. As they rose to power, they cut their ties to Israel for reasons I do not know from everything I've seen.
Abbas and Netanyahu have both used propaganda against an enemy to retain power prior to an election or when needing support. It truly disgusts me. Their corruptness and greed is simply abhorrent.
I hate that anti-semetic attacks have risen when many Jewish people support Palestine and are against the actions in Israel. Jewish people don't deserve any hate any violence or ill will. Some people look for excuses to support their internal biases against a people- confirmation bias- and will use any excuse to act on it. If you have read this far, thank you for reading.
True
@@Bauernade but people who defend Palestine and condemn Israel are not biased or misrepresenting facts? Hmmmmmmm
@@Bauernade unless you specify exactly what is represented wrong, your message is futile.
All I can say is Thank You for explaining the history to one ignorant American (me). Whenever i run into one of your videos, i watch and listen to educate myself and my children. As an American and a professional, i get wrapped up in my own bubble and do not always understand what my government is doing. Today’s media certainly doesn’t help.
Ben, you are wrong. Judea and Samaria shall never be seperated from Israel again. Israel rejects any attempts to leave Holy Jewish Land.
Careful Ben, Truth is offensive, ya know!
@@eeerrr3371 where in the video is there any lie? Please correct the history i would love to be enlightened
@@eeerrr3371 His Yarmulke? Wtf are you talking about? Lmfao. How is that evidence?
@@eeerrr3371 It just sounds like you disagree. Ben thoroughly went over the conflict between Israel and Palestine. Can’t argue with facts.
@@michaelmouawad3575 isn't terrorism about targets and motivations rather than numbers? Targeting civilians who aren't firing at you isn't acceptable regardless of how many people you manage to kill, and doing so while hiding behind your own civilians is even worse.
In any case, what exactly is the context he left out, besides this part about Israel having killed more Arabs than vice versa?
@@eeerrr3371 k but I don't see "The Bible says Israel is for the Jews" anywhere in his argument. If you see it, point to where.
It deserves 100 million views . UA-cam has ghosted this video .
of course it is ghosted. So is everything from ben. youtube's definition of 'videos on politics' is antifa and socialism
@@kvzhdist This video is extremely biased. BEN IS JEWISH AND A ZIONIST! He didn’t say one good thing about Palestine and made Israel seem innocent. 😂
@@grumpyoldpotatoes7203 That is quite easy. In fact, there are many already out there. You can convince anyone anything if you are a good talker and only prioritize the facts that you want the outcome to be. Both these countries are at fault. Both have done horrible things but for Ben to act like Israel was innocent all along is simply a lie.
@@grumpyoldpotatoes7203 “ You can only guess who he’s going to side with” That’s the point I’m trying to make. This whole video is biased and is not a good educational video for beginners learning about this conflict. That’s all. There are much better non biased videos out there about this conflict. Watch those.
@@reviewhead An ideal video on this conflict would be one where they show a history of both sides rights and wrongs. It leaves the viewer to decide. Telling only one story leads to misinformation
I find it strange that he feels the need to talk so fast that it's actually hard to comprehend the info and let it sink in. It's important info, why make it inaccessible?
You can change the settings on the video play speed. I get bored at normal speed for most podcasters so I put it at 1.25 or 1.5 but if you want to do the opposite just click the settings button on the video and put it at 75%.
It's fine.
Yeah, I normally like Ben, but when it became apparent that he was going to say “ BCE” instead of “BC” every time, I’m out. He even acknowledges Christ exists, but still can’t use the easier and less distracting “Before Christ.” I thought that was something only obnoxious atheists did.
Good thing Ben can speak fast or else this would’ve taken a couple of hours to go through...lol
Lol!!
If you play his clips at 0.75 speed it's a _tad_ too slow; he sounds like he's been drinking and slurs his speech. We need a "0.85 Shapiro Speed" in the settings for people who want to listen to a more regular speech pace. ;o)
Bawhahaha true
@@danh5150 he sounds like he’s high on 0.75 speed
Got speak fast to get in all those hasbara talking points.
@@Sara-9865 The anti-Semitism line is getting really tired, its like milk past its due date, especially when its thrown by people who arent even Semitic. You know who are Semitic? Palestinians. The irony.
Wow. 2 years later, you have this as a receipt that you knew how this would play out with incredible accuracy
Ask Benny if the current government in the US should concede its power to Native Americans and that all none native Americans should leave the country, I bet he would say no and we're talking about something that is way closer to our current timeline than a 4000-year-old claim.
@asundersweet absolutely not. . .this country is for Whites ONLY. I'm all for a Jewish and White European state.
Do you listen to anything he said?
Am yisrael chai! Shalom and G'day from Australia 🇦🇺. One for Israel 🇮🇱 OSEH SHALOM
Israel was offering Yassa Arafat all the rooms to the mansion, but no access to the hallways. What good is the land if you are completely in prison in it?
Ben: **gives facts**
Demo logic: “We all know it’s Donald trumps fault!”
I hope you weren't fooled by this... there weren't many facts lol and he still made so many mistakes lololol. Also this conflict isn't a Democrat vs Republican, but an occupier vs the occupied. Pick the right side!
@@naserel-zebdeh7359 Looking forward too your debunk response video since you know better..
@@waunbudd2665 happy just responding to UA-cam comments for now 😀. Maybe later!
ua-cam.com/video/Ns13VjwUGd4/v-deo.html
@@naserel-zebdeh7359 You are a fool. Israel is "occupied" , yet Jews and Arabs can practice religion freely and participate in government. Try being a Jew and wander over to the West Bank.......fool. Tell me whats "occupied" now?
As someone from the UAE 🇦🇪 , I believe that Trump's Abraham Accord was truly a miracle.
Our decision to normalize relations with Israel was not solely due to a common threat, but also because we recognize Israel's sincere desire for a resolution, which stands in stark contrast to the PLO and Iran's long-arm, Hamas.
How wonderful it would be if there was peace between the countries. I believe that it would make them both most powerful in everything.
ما زادوكم الا خذاله . 😊
@@donewheny8526
هذه رَحمَة جَعلَها الله تعالى في قُلُوب عِباده.
It's not what I'm discussing, but thanks for the hadith exchange.
Ks 2mak 3la 2m al emarat 😊
@a.n.k3339 Go home kiddo, ad hominem doesn't work on me.
White paper allowed for 75,000 Jewish immigrants over a period of 5 years, not per year, dude.
30:02 Not a good time to be taking a drink. 😂
Soooo glad Ben’s committed to truth and chose this career.
Ben Shapiro is always beside Israel.. He is sponsored by AIPAC he is the Israeli Propagandist in U.S like Hanaya Nafatalie in Middle East so we can't hear history from both of them it should be neutral not..Someone Positive to any side rather Palestine or Israel.
@@Nada-bh3gz Enlighten us, please, as to what we’re missing in this presentation.
@@Teal_Seal you ever read what bens wrote about this issue and about Palestine in general? He is an extremely biased source here, he says as much and you're gullible to think otherwise. No not even gullible, I guess ignorant fits better bc its laid out plainly.
@@Teal_Seal you can go as far back in history as you want but you cannot ignore the fact that Palestinian children are being killed at unprecedented rates in empoverished areas of gaza
@@Teal_Seal Zionism doesn't represent Judaism you can't mix this into history in all cases I've notice that the Palestinian side is missing... He repeat jews rights in different ways.. You feel that he wants to convince us of the legitimacy and right of Zionism, which doesn't represent Judaism for many jewish
The fact that the video is 2 years old in 2024 but still fit the current situation almost perfectely is quite unsettling
101st like.
this man is an utter liar, it is actually infuriating how much he has lied through his teeth in this video and we are expected to just believe him...
@@Aldaker_
Why?
@@nicbentulangews have been the reason why white nations fall every single time. Ben isn’t a real conservative he’s milking our benefits
@@Aldaker_Please explain why he’s a liar? There’s a reason, right?
Unfortunately, it’s not about history it’s about present day
My 13 year old son will watch this tonight. Everyone should understand this history.
@Spongebob Squarepants Come on Spongebob.
The First Settlement was in 3500 BC. Jerusalem was conquered by Canaanites in 1200 BC. King David Conquered Jerusalem and declared it the City Capital of the “Jewish Kingdom” in 1000 BC. The Canaanites weren't there until the late Bronze and Iron age, 2000 years after the first settlers came.
@@Bauernade How many times are you going to copy and paste that.😂
@Spongebob Squarepants
They didn't arrive in the land known as Israel until the late bronze and Iron age. Many tribes were inhabiting that area until 2500 BC when the first pagan tribe conquered the land, the Jebusites were the last Canaan tribe to conquer the land before King David.
@Spongebob Squarepants
No need to be a strawman. I never claim that whoever was there first has more or less “claim” to the land. Logically speaking the people who have “claim” to a land are the inhabitants of said land, all land has been conquered for centuries, just because someone was there doesn't give them any more credibility. All natives conquered each other and committed countless genocides and attempts.
@@blessingmansallay4559 A one state solution should do the trick, right? We should ask all those dozens of jews in the arabic world and north africa how's that working out for them. "They say we must be dead and we say we want to be alive. Between life and death, I do not know of a compromise, and that is why we have no choice". Prime minister Meir was sadly not ahead of her time, rather, she knew her history and it's painful lessons
The truth is my taxes are going up
Because those folks think that some ugly plot of land is magical.
I've always found humor in a Roman overlord naming a land Palestine then the name kinda stuck. Philistines
“ it’s called we do a little trolling”
It's called "FREE PALESTINE"
ua-cam.com/video/ufqvz3xycBs/v-deo.html
ua-cam.com/video/ufqvz3xycBs/v-deo.html
@@just_a_turtle_chad From the river to the sea, leave Isreal be.
i heard him say it…” every criticism of israel is not antisemitism “. that’s good to hear and should be truth.
The Candace supporters don’t want to hear that though.
There is a difference between criticizing like French President Macron, for example, who said that Israel should stop killing women and children, and criticizing "Israel is an Afraid state that commits genocide and is racist towards Palestinians"
As an Indian I will always stand with Israel
I watched this whole thing and I couldn’t believe it was 40 minutes long 😳
Sign of a good lecturer
I was thinking, " no it wasn't". Then I looked back. .....damn. 😆
Dude this guy is fucking awsome it makes me really fear for his life...
That passed by so quick
It would have been funnier if this was sponsored by Birch Gold.
Too true
*rubs hands vigorously
@@tomasschuman6576 bruhh
Maybe by birchstein Goldberg?
ua-cam.com/video/ufqvz3xycBs/v-deo.html
It's a good video but he neglects to mention settlements! Settlements in the west bank didn't stop after Oslo or the other peace accords and is one of the reasons that they failed.
arabs don't want peace
23:07 USA gave them the Patriot Rocket technology.
lol ben shapiro should do more lectures, this was actually interesting
It was wrong and misleading.
@@naserel-zebdeh7359 well, agree to disagree
@@nextgenfootball69420 fair enough. I would recommend you to try some other lectures and videos to get other perspectives. Crash course Israel and Palestinian history video is a pretty sanitised summary of the recent history of Israel and Palestine.
I died when he imitated Joe Biden lol
@@mtngwane2066 you should watch trump imitating biden in the debates, man's a comedy genius
30:01 Joe Biden takes over, and Joe Biden decides: "Udebbabmama mudubabada", I lost it. My neighbours didn't understand what the roar from my house was coming from.
xD
Same here.....
🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣 same here!!!
I couldn’t help it either he did it with such a straight face!
@Carissa Wu Biden is nothing but a puppet. He’s not the one in control.
Perspective given here by Ben S is so important in avoiding the trend toward fussing over the lost Palestinian villages, whilst avoiding any consideration of all the other lost territories one can see around the world.
Was the first Aliyah illegal?
Right on the money Ben. Too bad the people who need to see this, won’t
Isn't that the truth! Great point.
Who are the people who need to see this?
@@duggme there has been more Palestinians casualties compared to Israelis
@@mohamedsaid9416 I know. May they rest in peace.
@Central Intelligence Agency through out the major peace talks the two major blocs of settlements which are right on the border and contain 80+% of settlers in the land (unlike what the Palestinians who claim for land grab by Israeli gov will lead you to believe)
is and will be part of israel the rest is Palestinian land + land swap for the major settlement blocs
"The Six-Day War"! Of course! They HAD to do it in six days, because the seventh day is a day of rest!
I hope you are joking, since the six day war started on June 5th, 1967, which was a Monday, and ended on Saturday, June 10th, 1967. Mind that the holy day for Jews is Saturday...
@@liorp23 It is clearly a joke
@@benjaminandrews956 to be fair i did say i hope he is joking
Hahaha
@@liorp23 😌
Glad to hear that Ben mentioned Theodor Herzl. However, Ben fails to mention that Herzl was a Hungarian Jew who was a journalist and his pamphlet “The Stare of the Jews”, which proposed either Israel OR VENEZUELA as a home state for the Jews was rejected by many Ashkenazi Jews as they did not want to bring more attention to themselves as antisemitism was on the rise in Europe.
If should be noted that Herzl claimed Jewish ancestry from both Ashkenazi and Sephardic origins. As a journalist, his pamphlet was more of an opinion piece and NOT a call to action.
Again, Ben fails to mention this and in so doing, promulgates dangerous propaganda that has proven itself harmful to not only the Jews living in the area, but to Jews and non-Jews living in the United States.
i thought i was using 2x speed💀
Honestly why isn't this getting taught in highschool? Just a few years ago I was taught about native Americans and what not, and although that's important I feel like this should have been in there too. And so many other important historical events!
be honest 99% of high schoolers would say "come on why do I have to know this? This is dumb who cares"
I learned about this in High school back in 2014-2015.
Because almost nothing said here is true or complete. Highschool should teach science, not Jewish perspective of things.
@@duggme you know people have a good arguemnt when the only thing they can say is "you're wrong"
You know how vast the history of the entire world is? You cannot expect high schools to teach you everything within the span of the few years that you are there. They will obviously prioritise anything related to the US first and then cover major things like WWI/WWII/cold war/vietnam/korea?.
My biggest question: Why the hell don't they teach this stuff in universities?
Because they hate Israel too.
That’s a silly question
Because it's not true, fabricated history by Ben Shapiro. He doesn't mention how the crusaders killed all the Jews in Jerusalem, he also doesn't mention how the Mamluke conquest of Palestine from the Crusaders allowed Jews to enter the region again.
They don’t communism either. It’s because they like communist.
Simple, anti-Semitism is deeply entrenched in this country, too.
Is this official story, or your side of the story? Would the Arab surrounding countries portrait the history the same way?
You didn't talk about British plan of giving Israel land in east Africa modern day (Kenya) .
Few people know it
thought that was Uganda
9:40 I love that he doesn't want to mention that Israel started the conflict with a better army. They forced hunreds of thousands of arabs to leave their land. So yeah I would be pissed too and revolt.
I wish schools taught history. I've known this stuff for 50 years, the young have no clue.
@Goolag Tube which generation hasn't done that? The difference in education between now and 50 years ago is postmodern thought has crept into the education sector. Truth and history has become subject to one's own opinion. Nobody ends up knowing anything except how to deconstruct, ask questions with no real answers and highlight 'tension'.
This isnt history, its one sided propaganda. The Old Testament isnt a history book nd a lot is missing from his narrative. Why no mention of the Irgun, Stern Gang, Hagganah and other Zionist terrorist groups? How the Swedish diplomat Folke Bernadotte, who was a UN representative, a man who saved Jewish lives during WW2, was shot dead in cold blood by Zionist thugs because he pushed for Palestinian right of return to the land they were ethnically cleansed from to create Israel. He may have been murdered but his Resolution 194 was still passed in 1948 but has never been applied. Its the stumbling block in every "peace" process. Funny how Ben just conveniently skipped over that one.
@@susiex6669 I’m just gonna say that the “history” from the bible has time and again been proven true through archaeological findings. Idk about the rest of your comments but this I know your wrong
@@klazyman579 like genesis? Yah 6000 thousand year old earth bud
@Goolag Tube you failed yourself and people like you who blame others for your shortcomings is the problem with the world.