What’s changed in Iran? | Start Here

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 12 гру 2022
  • The protests in Iran haven’t let up since Mahsa Amini died in police custody back in September. Why have they lasted this long? And have they changed anything? #AJStartHere with Sandra Gathmann explains.
    #mahsaamini
    #iranprotests
    Check out our other Start Here episodes bit.ly/3o0BEIW
    Subscribe to our channel bit.ly/AJSubscribe
    Follow us on Twitter / ajenglish
    Find us on Facebook / aljazeera
    Check our website: www.aljazeera.com/
    And let us know in the comments if there’s a topic you find confusing and would like Start Here to cover ⤵️

КОМЕНТАРІ • 946

  • @oscopin74
    @oscopin74 Рік тому +361

    I don't care who you are or where you're from. The Iranian women and men who support them, I have 100% respect for.

    • @yusfmuralsgraffititv1051
      @yusfmuralsgraffititv1051 Рік тому

      THEIR IS ALOT WILL SHOCK YOU. FROM OUR HISTORY AND PRESENT. FROM EAST ASIA TO THE WEST. ALOT IS GOING. ALOT IS CHANGING.
      JUST LISTEN TO OUR PAST STORIES AND PRESENT. YOU WILL GET HEADECH

    • @yusfmuralsgraffititv1051
      @yusfmuralsgraffititv1051 Рік тому +1

      OTHERS GREW IN THE HANDS OF ISLAMIC STATE, OTHER GREW IN THE HANDS OF ATHEIST COMMUNITY, OTHER CHRISTIANITY OTHER GREW IN THE HANDS OF GANGS. OTHERS ETCETRA. WE ARE IN TURMOIL....

    • @yusfmuralsgraffititv1051
      @yusfmuralsgraffititv1051 Рік тому

      WE WILL FIGHT TO DOMINATE. WHAT'S YOUR SOLUTION?

    • @Crashed131963
      @Crashed131963 Рік тому +3

      I remember the 1979 protest with female students wearing jeans with nice long hair demanding the return of religion nut Ruhollah Khomeini from France.
      He is the guy who removed women's right in Iran.

    • @fubytv731
      @fubytv731 Рік тому +2

      I don't care, as long as you love me.

  • @Kapplerartbloomingdale
    @Kapplerartbloomingdale Рік тому +223

    Freedom to the Iran people. blessings to the brave who stand up to unjust cruelty by the ruling party.

    • @namakdoon1155
      @namakdoon1155 Рік тому

      @ Kevin Michael Kappler ! How many estimate of Iranian people all together in all those videos that you have seen regarding this so called protest would you say are ? 10000 , 100000 , 1 million !!!? Have you seen videos of pro government that come out on street of cities of iran ? If you are not a bios person by seeing pro government videos you can tell at least who represents absolute majority! Never mind the ballet box results in past 20-40 years ! And yet you still think few people from all sort of reasons are Iranian people!!! Body Iran has 85-90 million population! At least 70 million of them are above age of 15 ! What gives you right to assume these few in pro western mainstream corporate media are “ All Iranian People “ !? The truth can’t be changed by propaganda! Whether we are pro government in Tehran or anti government in Iran ! I myself am anti government policies in Iran that doesn’t mean l blindly except any lies and propaganda spread by western corporate mainstream media and their social media ! By the way Kevin ! Iran isn’t either Yugoslavia or Syria ! Your calculations are wrong thinking you can turn Iran to Syria or Balkanize Iran just like Yugoslavia and Libya because of few simple unrest at best with pretty slogans such as ; women , life and freedom! You don’t speak the language of Iranian perhaps hence you don’t know what they are saying in Iranian language amongst themselves! I Do and definitely they aren’t Pro all Women’s right other wise they wouldn’t attack a women minister of Iran in Denmark or attacked those women who have different opinions in many cases ! They also don’t look for life ! They haven’t even overthrown the government in Iran and yet they are talking about hanging their opposition from lamps’ post and trees!!! And when you asked them would you do it even if the opposition numbers would be as high as 10-20 millions ! And they say without any doubt! who cares how many of them there are ! We hang them all ! As for freedom! Asked them what do they mean by freedom!!!? Would they respect individual freedom and freedom of religious! Most of them would say only those who agree with them ! In my personal experience! I find them fascist raciest arrogant ignorant groups out side of Iran that don’t represent our values! Such as democracy, freedom and human’s right never mind women’s rights! One of their popular slogans in Farsi is “ Ma hame Ariaee hastim Arab nemiparastim “ which translate in English to “ we all are Arian and we don’t pray and like Arabs ethnicity “ even though maybe if I am not mistaken we “ Iran “ has 5% Arab ethnicity in south western of Iran ! So don’t tell me firstly they represent all Iranian people and don’t tell me they fight for righteousness such as ; Women life and freedom!

    • @shahlaalizadeh1039
      @shahlaalizadeh1039 Рік тому +1

      Please, if you want to do something for the people of Iran, ask your government to expel the Iranian ambassador and also expel the relatives of the Iranian officials who are in the West and confiscate the property that they stole from the people of Iran.

    • @Hify732
      @Hify732 Рік тому +2

      😂. How do you know they are cruel. How do you know this is Iran?

    • @dollarchange2917
      @dollarchange2917 Рік тому +2

      Freedom to the people of your country. Blessing to the brave that stand up to unjust cruelty by the ruling party of your country

    • @baganthekerannaghor8161
      @baganthekerannaghor8161 Рік тому

      What about Palestinian??

  • @anitavelieves
    @anitavelieves Рік тому +334

    My heart goes out to the suffering of people and salute to the brave citizens in Iran

    • @shahlaalizadeh1039
      @shahlaalizadeh1039 Рік тому +16

      Please, if you want to do something for the people of Iran, ask your government to expel the Iranian ambassador and also expel the relatives of the Iranian officials who are in the West and confiscate the property that they stole from the people of Iran.

    • @zatoichiable
      @zatoichiable Рік тому +4

      What about the people palestine did you felt the same?

    • @ihsanamsal2947
      @ihsanamsal2947 Рік тому +2

      I admire their bravery to ignore about what happened on the record of cctv 😏🙏

    • @a.d8509
      @a.d8509 Рік тому +1

      @@zatoichiable
      Whataboutism?

    • @thomervin7450
      @thomervin7450 Рік тому

      @@a.d8509 Reductionism?

  • @Art-qy6gd
    @Art-qy6gd Рік тому +181

    I’m so proud of everyone they’re still protesting!!! Keep going please.

    • @salampakistan3691
      @salampakistan3691 Рік тому +3

      Forever wwaring my burka

    • @shahlaalizadeh1039
      @shahlaalizadeh1039 Рік тому +6

      Please, if you want to do something for the people of Iran, ask your government to expel the Iranian ambassador and also expel the relatives of the Iranian officials who are in the West and confiscate the property that they stole from the people of Iran.

    • @sisygambis.
      @sisygambis. Рік тому +6

      @@salampakistan3691 lmao the same account under another video about iran. ماشالله فاطی کماندو سایبری🤣🤣🤣

    • @followersofyeshuahamashiac462
      @followersofyeshuahamashiac462 Рік тому +1

      @@shahlaalizadeh1039 Our government officials are as corrupt as yours, WE Americans just don’t have the balls to step up against them. Prayers from Americans who love humanity… this is breaking our heart.
      May YHWH protect
      ❤🛐❤🛐❤✝️

    • @KnockingONwood1111
      @KnockingONwood1111 Рік тому +3

      @@salampakistan3691 awesome, but irrelevant. You do you. ✌️

  • @pwnage1337
    @pwnage1337 Рік тому +51

    Support every protester from Iran
    Much love and support from Poland
    🇵🇱❤️🇮🇷

    • @based-iranian
      @based-iranian Рік тому +4

      Thanks for your support 💖

    • @pwnage1337
      @pwnage1337 Рік тому +3

      @@based-iranian no problem 👌
      We were also fighting for our freedom, nearly for 200 years, but we've managed to surpass the censorship and dictatorship!
      ❤️ Much love ❤️

  • @bakhtovarmansurov7784
    @bakhtovarmansurov7784 Рік тому +54

    Start here is the best that AlJazeera has put out. No excessive talking right amount. wish to see more of Start Here

  • @sidali2590
    @sidali2590 Рік тому +55

    Stand with these Iranian protesters. Shame on the Iranian government

  • @filipepedro8272
    @filipepedro8272 Рік тому +88

    i was in Iran this past September. met some of the warmest and kindest people ever. they really deserve a better leadership. this oppressively system is just the death of a society.

    • @namakdoon1155
      @namakdoon1155 Рік тому

      Did you say anything about Shireen Abu Akleh? If there are questions about death of Mahsa Amini, there is no doubt about a American Palestinian woman shot in a day light in front of a live show ! Yet I didn’t see any comments from people like you which claim are supporter of human’s rights and women rights! That is the question! Not that whether the government of Iran has legitimacy or not ! It’s up to the people of Iran to decide of their government legitimacy at ballet boxes not you or your kind which obviously have a certain political agenda! By the way! If any individual or group use violence and brute force to achieve a certain political agenda according to Webster dictionary or any other dictionary called terrorism! So stop your double standard in case of Charlie Hebdo! You call them terrorist and your enforcement kill them like dogs on street of Paris and in case of Iran you called them protestors!!!

    • @keyboardwarrior6786
      @keyboardwarrior6786 Рік тому +1

      Western r weirdos, racists.they r always agenda driven people

    • @fightthepower4648
      @fightthepower4648 Рік тому

      Universal problem: ALL ideologies are plagued by corruption and directly responsible for global division.
      Universal solution: A pure and permanent global democracy driven by a secure and transparent technology.
      "The time is upon us when the wretched of the earth unite to scream in revolt!"
      "Nothing is more powerful than an idea whose time has come."
      Global Online Democracy Systems (GODS) is an APP and idea whose time has come; it can permanently place power in the hands of the majority of the people and not just the Global Power Elites!
      "Fight the Power - Global Declaration of Independence" (UA-cam video) offers a unique and viable global solution to global problems. Share this concept with everyone and be the spark that ignites a global revolution for all people for all time!

    • @krystofk.2279
      @krystofk.2279 Рік тому +12

      I've had one of the best interactions with Iranis expats in Prague, when they organised protest against government/showing solidarity for Irani people. Even though it was below 0 degrees and I almost froze to death it was an amazing experience. They really do deserve better.
      Women, life, freedom!

    • @behiran2252
      @behiran2252 Рік тому +3

      ❤️🤝🙏🇮🇷

  • @persepolisclubhouse2277
    @persepolisclubhouse2277 Рік тому +57

    Kudos to brave Iranian women
    The whole world is watching you and supports you ❤❤❤❤👏👏👏

    • @fightthepower4648
      @fightthepower4648 Рік тому

      Universal problem: ALL ideologies are plagued by corruption and directly responsible for global division.
      Universal solution: A pure and permanent global democracy driven by a secure and transparent technology.
      "The time is upon us when the wretched of the earth unite to scream in revolt!"
      "Nothing is more powerful than an idea whose time has come."
      Global Online Democracy Systems (GODS) is an APP and idea whose time has come; it can permanently place power in the hands of the majority of the people and not just the Global Power Elites!
      "Fight the Power - Global Declaration of Independence" (UA-cam video) offers a unique and viable global solution to global problems. Share this concept with everyone and be the spark that ignites a global revolution for all people for all time!

  • @MHN212
    @MHN212 Рік тому +96

    A nice summary of the whole situation. Thank you for putting this together.

    • @namakdoon1155
      @namakdoon1155 Рік тому

      @ Mark Noble !? Would tell me how do you feel about perpetrators of Charlie Hebdo incident?

  • @mahisaghi
    @mahisaghi Рік тому +35

    Thanks for the news coverage and being Iranian's voice.

  • @jasperangel
    @jasperangel Рік тому +34

    Fan here in the Philippines 🌴 and I'm supporting women life and freedom in Iran..

    • @ihsanamsal2947
      @ihsanamsal2947 Рік тому +2

      Gay

    • @mukundsingh3799
      @mukundsingh3799 Рік тому +2

      @@ihsanamsal2947 life your father 🤣🤣😂

    • @antonio-do9ff
      @antonio-do9ff 4 місяці тому

      @@ihsanamsal2947 bro you don't know what is woman 💀💀

    • @ihsanamsal2947
      @ihsanamsal2947 4 місяці тому

      adult human female. answered😊@@antonio-do9ff

  • @adithyadushyanth4653
    @adithyadushyanth4653 Рік тому +29

    Full support and mad respect for the brave people of Iran. We are with you.
    Zan Zendegi Azadi!

  • @yunusseedat3213
    @yunusseedat3213 Рік тому +22

    Very good News presenter, well done

  • @sosostrar5887
    @sosostrar5887 Рік тому +57

    We support you all iranian people from palestine

    • @fightthepower4648
      @fightthepower4648 Рік тому

      Universal problem: ALL ideologies are plagued by corruption and directly responsible for global division.
      Universal solution: A pure and permanent global democracy driven by a secure and transparent technology.
      "The time is upon us when the wretched of the earth unite to scream in revolt!"
      "Nothing is more powerful than an idea whose time has come."
      Global Online Democracy Systems (GODS) is an APP and idea whose time has come; it can permanently place power in the hands of the majority of the people and not just the Global Power Elites!
      "Fight the Power - Global Declaration of Independence" (UA-cam video) offers a unique and viable global solution to global problems. Share this concept with everyone and be the spark that ignites a global revolution for all people for all time!

    • @marina12345678911000
      @marina12345678911000 Рік тому +8

      Could you be more specific? By all iranian people do you mean both the protestors and the people that send you money and weapons? Do you support the women that fight for their civil rights or do you support the Islamic regime that sponsors HAMAS and Hezbollah?

    • @krystofk.2279
      @krystofk.2279 Рік тому +4

      ​@@marina12345678911000 people of Iran (or any country) is a phrase (or let's say shortened phrase) that indicates all the common people of Iran. Usually meaning low and middle class, although a lot of times meaning just the low and lower middle class.
      Languages work differently with words i. e. if you wish someone "happy evening" it's (again) shortened version of "I hope that you enjoy this evening".
      Find better excuse to attack someone than you not understanding basics in the language you're using. That said, especially to attack Palestinians which suffered enough during the past 50 years and which situation is looking even more grim lately.
      Also if this person is from Palestine it doesn't necessarily means he/she supports Hamas. It's like if you said Iranians support Irani government. Gosh.

    • @marina12345678911000
      @marina12345678911000 Рік тому +1

      @@krystofk.2279 People under every Islamic regime and/or dictatorship are suffering and have no civil rights. What is so special about suffering of Arabs in Gaza strip under Hamas or suffering of Arabs in the west bank ruled by corrupted and rich KGB agent Abu Mazen and Islamic Jihad terrorists group that It is not ok with you to ask them if they support people that paying for their weapons for 75 years : Islamic regime of Iran?!

    • @krystofk.2279
      @krystofk.2279 Рік тому +1

      @@marina12345678911000 I'm not saying that other people (not only arabs) don't suffer. It wasn't the subject of your comment from my understanding if it was Egyptian, Syrian, Saudi, or Yemeni, but also Chinese, Peruvians, Russians and many more I would say the same.
      Yes it is ok to ask them if they support the people. Yet your comment was (from my understanding) more of an attack on the people than genuine question. associating them with the terrorist group/government based on their nationality and thus I had the need to defend them. Not everyone is on board with their government and that is important to understand.
      Anyway I guess I misunderstood your comment and am sorry for that. Have a nice day.

  • @aqmorisny
    @aqmorisny Рік тому +30

    Thank you for reporting about the Iran protests. 🙏🏽 Women, Life, Freedom ✊🏽

    • @fightthepower4648
      @fightthepower4648 Рік тому

      Universal problem: ALL ideologies are plagued by corruption and directly responsible for global division.
      Universal solution: A pure and permanent global democracy driven by a secure and transparent technology.
      "The time is upon us when the wretched of the earth unite to scream in revolt!"
      "Nothing is more powerful than an idea whose time has come."
      Global Online Democracy Systems (GODS) is an APP and idea whose time has come; it can permanently place power in the hands of the majority of the people and not just the Global Power Elites!
      "Fight the Power - Global Declaration of Independence" (UA-cam video) offers a unique and viable global solution to global problems. Share this concept with everyone and be the spark that ignites a global revolution for all people for all time!

  • @armaan_maurya
    @armaan_maurya Рік тому +44

    Iranians are beyond brave..!!
    My love, respect and full support to them!
    ❤🙏❤

    • @ihsanamsal2947
      @ihsanamsal2947 Рік тому

      Brave enough to ignore about what actually happened on Mahsa Amini's cause of death 😏

    • @brendonfernandes2877
      @brendonfernandes2877 Рік тому +1

      ​@@ihsanamsal2947 Her death was just a spark. The main reason is people are fed up of living under a dictatorship. They want to live free. There is a reason people run away from Iran rather than people trying to live in Iran from elsewhere. No one wants to live under a dictatorship.

  • @SoLongMarianne_
    @SoLongMarianne_ Рік тому +5

    Much love from Norway, I'm here rooting for you brave people of Iran!! 🩷

  • @Brad-gk9jd
    @Brad-gk9jd Рік тому +6

    Stand firm in unity! The world is with you!

  • @puregold05
    @puregold05 Рік тому +30

    We’ve never been closer to freedom. We’re on the brink of a free iran. ZAN ZENDGI AZADI

    • @hillaryh.5197
      @hillaryh.5197 Рік тому

      American and Israeli secret intelligence say that the regime is not shaken. They say the regime is simply humoring” the people of Iran.

  • @MrFariso
    @MrFariso Рік тому +9

    Thanks, please show more to the world. People need help and have no voice.

  • @jizza7173
    @jizza7173 Рік тому +7

    Been waiting a min for this, thanks and nice one Sandy.

  • @beakhammer2638
    @beakhammer2638 Рік тому +5

    Great journalism. Thank you. From Ireland.

  • @sabtaingopinath9652
    @sabtaingopinath9652 Рік тому +12

    It's called social engineering.
    A strategic re alignment.
    The Iranian state did a 40 year experiment on their own people.

    • @keyboardwarrior6786
      @keyboardwarrior6786 Рік тому

      Whats about indias hindutava

    • @fightthepower4648
      @fightthepower4648 Рік тому

      Universal problem: ALL ideologies are plagued by corruption and directly responsible for global division.
      Universal solution: A pure and permanent global democracy driven by a secure and transparent technology.
      "The time is upon us when the wretched of the earth unite to scream in revolt!"
      "Nothing is more powerful than an idea whose time has come."
      Global Online Democracy Systems (GODS) is an APP and idea whose time has come; it can permanently place power in the hands of the majority of the people and not just the Global Power Elites!
      "Fight the Power - Global Declaration of Independence" (UA-cam video) offers a unique and viable global solution to global problems. Share this concept with everyone and be the spark that ignites a global revolution for all people for all time!

  • @Lizard_King177
    @Lizard_King177 Рік тому +7

    Great coverage! Women life freedom! ✌️

  • @ajay_pn
    @ajay_pn Рік тому +5

    Great program,thanks Sandra.

  • @itsqazaleh
    @itsqazaleh Рік тому +16

    Thank you for being Iranian's voice .

  • @jeffseng6385
    @jeffseng6385 Рік тому +5

    This was very well put together. I hope all their bravery pays off.

  • @nassermj7671
    @nassermj7671 Рік тому +8

    As always great topics. Katie you rock!

  • @maryamnataj8193
    @maryamnataj8193 Рік тому +13

    Our situation in Iran could not have been explained any better. BTW shervin's song (Baraye )includes almost everything we are fighting for.

    • @ramathanabdallah6493
      @ramathanabdallah6493 Рік тому +2

      WHAT ARE YOU FIGHTING FOR ??? ARE YOU FIGHTING TO DENOUNCE ALLAH'S ORDER FOR WEARING HIJAB OR YOU WANT REGIME CHANGE ?? CAN YOU PLEASE EXPLAIN

    • @glennwatson3313
      @glennwatson3313 Рік тому

      A mention of the Iranian Hostage Crisis in 1979 would be appropriate. Americans have not forgotten what you did.

    • @mahtabn.b5230
      @mahtabn.b5230 Рік тому +2

      @@ramathanabdallah6493 chill, we wanna change the system. jeez.

    • @snowpenguin2266
      @snowpenguin2266 Рік тому +3

      @@ramathanabdallah6493 not everyone cares about allah. Stop forcing your beliefs on others and thinking yours is the only correct belief lol

  • @mmdyari3328
    @mmdyari3328 Рік тому +3

    Please share it more♥️

  • @mashallzaheer4446
    @mashallzaheer4446 Рік тому +4

    Very well summarized!

    • @akmaljaved9609
      @akmaljaved9609 Рік тому

      Let me tell you one thing…….. start here is becoming more and more popular in students comradery in Pakistan….. so please don’t Stop this program ……

  • @elyesafozer
    @elyesafozer Рік тому +7

    My bless is with the protester of Iran! Please get rid of the brutal dictator and do not be afraid do it give up! The west need to help with weapon to the uprising immediately

  • @karz12
    @karz12 Рік тому +4

    To fight for your freedom with your bare hands against one of the most brutal dictatorships in the world is the most awe inspiring thing. Don't ever give up for your freedom, till the last person ! Fight !

  • @theindieindian_
    @theindieindian_ 6 місяців тому +1

    Respect, love & support for Iranians.

  • @kasforai
    @kasforai Рік тому

    Keep coverage up please

  • @thedadadaraindejavu8622
    @thedadadaraindejavu8622 Рік тому +4

    I’m an Iranian living in Iran and despite of the heavy oppressions of this terrorist regime, we’re not backing off this time, even if they did, I’ll solely go on the streets and protest, we’ve had enough, please don’t forget about us world

    • @carlosjuan831
      @carlosjuan831 Рік тому

      Iranians are more than capable of handling their own issues, unless they want their country to end up like Syria which also begged for the world to intervene. Stand for reform but don't destruct your country in the process. And read a history book.

    • @biscotte3201
      @biscotte3201 Рік тому

      Hello, bonjour from France. I have a small question for you: recently in the press it is said that israel with the support of france(macron meets netanyahu) and of course the support od usa, plans to intervene militarily in iran to bomb a few targets (related to the nuclear subject) or even to invade your country to bring the democracy. do you support this solution?

  • @VaibhavSharma-zj4gk
    @VaibhavSharma-zj4gk Рік тому +8

    They are so peaceful that they directly put protesters to Rest in Peace.

  • @ashkan_1339
    @ashkan_1339 Рік тому +5

    As an Iranian I just cried when I saw the 23 year old being sentenced to death

  • @rawthentictruth
    @rawthentictruth Рік тому +17

    My only prayer for these brave Iranian women and men is that after all the sacrifices they’ve made with their blood 🩸 something much change for their good and the generations after them. 🙏🙏🙏🙏

  • @100saltanhayee
    @100saltanhayee Рік тому +24

    Very well documented. Thanks !

  • @roystonds9465
    @roystonds9465 Рік тому +6

    This happened when religion is involved in administration instead of individual faith. This apply to all religion not only for Islam.

    • @SmackDabCola
      @SmackDabCola Рік тому

      Whatever government the Iranian people elect, there will be bloodshed on all sides, with bombings similar to those seen in Syria.

  • @jossefjossikajit4169
    @jossefjossikajit4169 Рік тому +2

    THANKS FOR REPORTING THE TRUTH

  • @NathanTamaja
    @NathanTamaja Рік тому +32

    Great video, thanks for your hard work! G(o)od bless the people in Iran and may he bring them peace and justice.

    • @namakdoon1155
      @namakdoon1155 Рік тому +1

      They are all sorts of Iranian people with all sorts of political and personal beliefs, opinions and ethnicity in Iran and it’s 85 millions population of their society which Iranian people are you talking about exactly?

    • @NathanTamaja
      @NathanTamaja Рік тому

      @@namakdoon1155 The people who fight for freedom who don't kill people because of their appearances. Further questions?

    • @namakdoon1155
      @namakdoon1155 Рік тому

      @@NathanTamaja have you watched the Video of Mahsa Amini when she was walking to the courthouse and collapsed? If you haven’t I suggest you watch it ! It is available on UA-cam! Also research “ Sammy Yatim “ and “ Ashley Smith “ and compare these with videos of Mahsa Amini ! Then tell me who killed who ! Perhaps people like you still think the earth is flat no matter the evidence and facts contrary to it !

    • @NathanTamaja
      @NathanTamaja Рік тому

      @@namakdoon1155 It's Not about this Single woman, it's Not only about Iran. It's about our whole life together and dictators don't belong in this World anymore if they are blinded by money and Power.
      Love in your life for Jesus is love and love is life in the grace of our savior ❤️🧡💛💚💙💜❤️ stay strong, never give up. In sanity and honesty for eternity. ~

    • @namakdoon1155
      @namakdoon1155 Рік тому

      @@NathanTamaja if it’s not about this single woman from a certain background and certain Geographical location! And as you say it’s about oppressed and oppressor and dictatorship! Why didn’t you say anything about the case of Rachel Corrie or Shireen Abu Akleh! The problem with your claim is you only see the sins of others ( at best case scenario that we assume that Iranian government is a dictatorship which is a whole other topic ) but you don’t see your own sins ! I am not a Christian but I clearly remember the proverb about Jesus that tells a crowd only those who haven’t sin dare pick up the stone! Yet you are a Christian ( well just in name and because you born in a society that the major beliefs is base on Christianity) and yet don’t practice the most simple commandment of Jesus ! As a atheist I don’t have a problem with people of faith actually I respect them if they act base on what their preach but I have a enormous disagreement with those who under pretext of any ideology just blindly promoting ignorance and arrogance! So again look into mirror first before judging a nation of 85 million! No one claim any government or any society is perfect but compare to your hypocrisy and history Iranian government is much more legitimate than yours ! And if you really believe in Justice, equality and freedom! You should try to open your mind and engage in dialogue instead of spreading false narrative and lies and deceit! Remember what happened in Iraq base on false Few western narrative mostly NATO’s countries when they lied about WMD in Iraq ! A million innocent Iraqis died ! Including Christian Iraqis! So think and research your claims before jumping into conclusions because it’s more easier to listen to your corporate global imperialist mainstream media’s propaganda instead of fact searching or researching the facts and evidence! I know thinking is hard ! But even a man of faith can prove there is no contradiction between logic and beliefs!

  • @aaronchen8604
    @aaronchen8604 Рік тому +3

    Sending my support

  • @mansoor7334
    @mansoor7334 Рік тому +18

    Shame on irani religious leader

    • @ritamedina-molina8550
      @ritamedina-molina8550 Рік тому

      What I don't understand the Iranians had the same protest to get rid of the Shah...they wanted the Ayatolla....now they repeat the whole process. To replace what they fought for with what.plse x plain...

  • @essyaboii
    @essyaboii Рік тому +1

    Thank you to everyone showing us Iranians support

  • @mahmoodmohammadi4828
    @mahmoodmohammadi4828 Рік тому +1

    💚💚🤍🦁🤍❤️❤️ From Toronto Canada, we are with you. MY PEOPLE

  • @rajbthapar1880
    @rajbthapar1880 Рік тому +25

    Best of luck to all freedom fighters of Iran.

  • @Sparrowcrow-qc4pp
    @Sparrowcrow-qc4pp Рік тому +6

    I pray for you Iran I am so sorry you are going through this. I am so proud of you for standing up for what you believe in.

  • @brogrow7038
    @brogrow7038 Рік тому

    we are with you

  • @Tinman1380
    @Tinman1380 6 місяців тому

    Good report.

  • @RPRosen-ki2fk
    @RPRosen-ki2fk Рік тому +4

    WOMEN ... LIFE ... FREEDOM! May the Iranian people be STRONG & VICTORIOUS in their fight against tyranny. May the latest, Majidreza Rahnavard & Mohsen Shekari along with all the COUNTLESS OTHERS the government slaughters ... RIP.

  • @jayque
    @jayque Рік тому +7

    I can't believe the singer died.

  • @moonlitSapphire3691
    @moonlitSapphire3691 Рік тому +2

    Keep fighting dear Iranians! You got this! Our blessings are with you!❤

  • @karmatenzin1643
    @karmatenzin1643 Рік тому +8

    RIP i hope u will find freedom one day!

  • @mike798859
    @mike798859 Рік тому +14

    Thank you for the documentary Sandra

  • @quranchannel4622
    @quranchannel4622 Рік тому +20

    In the video, the claim is Iranian want Regime change not hijab change, but in the comment sections you see opposite of the video content and make it all about hijab

  • @stellarmelody2784
    @stellarmelody2784 Рік тому +1

    I am a Christian from Indonesia and is sad to see this to the Muslim and to Iran people i hope that this 2023 and from the future that the law will change and work well without suffer and killing as a leadership you must listen to your people whats they say and i wish you all well

  • @nigelwiseman8644
    @nigelwiseman8644 Рік тому

    Keep it up.

  • @jazz3ferzz865
    @jazz3ferzz865 Рік тому +6

    Finally you muster the courage to speak... Up... Some one in AL jazeera.. Is realizing the importance of supporting bravery....

  • @geess007
    @geess007 Рік тому +8

    Help all women all over the world. There are many countries not just Iran where women are forced to submit “morality” laws.

    • @nibsvkh
      @nibsvkh Рік тому

      Almost all are governed by religion and especially islam the motherlode of bad ideas!
      Religion poisons everything!

  • @nafeekarim2780
    @nafeekarim2780 5 місяців тому

    ❤Sandra Gathmann.

  • @thomasanders1314
    @thomasanders1314 Рік тому +3

    Freedom of choice for Iranian Women 🇮🇷❤!

  • @nuwanthilina9
    @nuwanthilina9 Рік тому +6

    May the Percians get their true freedom.!

  • @mimbele
    @mimbele Рік тому

    Short and accurate. 👍

  • @mieliav
    @mieliav Рік тому +1

    respect for the women who led the way, for the men who joined them, for the brave people of Iran.
    a segment on how the revolution in Iran is seen in the moslem world would be interesting.

  • @christianpage1445
    @christianpage1445 Рік тому +21

    Thr regime should change for the wellbeing of the citizens.

    • @namakdoon1155
      @namakdoon1155 Рік тому

      Whenever you could changed your regime for well being of humanity never mind just their own citizens then and maybe then we have something to talk about ! LMAO

  • @hpersian1980
    @hpersian1980 Рік тому +9

    ✋✋To all People of the free countries!✋✋
    Please do us a very important favor and contact and ask your politicians, representatives or senators to recall your ambassadors from Iran, expel the terrorist-ambassadors of this illegal regime, and cut any connections with them! This is what we need! They are not our representatives! Don’t deal with our murderers!

    • @marina12345678911000
      @marina12345678911000 Рік тому +3

      I would add “And ask them to stop making “deals” and sending money to Islamic regime.”

    • @glennwatson3313
      @glennwatson3313 Рік тому

      America has already done that after what Iran did in 1979 Hostage Crisis. We have not forgotten.

    • @hpersian1980
      @hpersian1980 Рік тому

      @@glennwatson3313 yes, thanks, but during the past 44 years, US could stand stronger against the Ayatollahs. Like the atomic deal through which US gave 150 billions dollars to them. Although that money was our wealth, but it was given to these corrupt terrorists and nothing was spent on our people but to expand the regime’s terrors. US still can stand much stronger and more demanding. Believe me, mullahs fear the US like a raccoon fear the lion. Whenever US acted tough, they backed off and whenever US got loose they got bold. US can politically and effectively support the people in Iran so that we can get rid of this mafia regime sooner. We don’t need a war or military movement but just avoid doing business and dealing with this corrupt murdering regime who has no morals and doesn’t care about Iranians at all. We have nothing in common with them. They’ll be gone soon. Remember that our revolution has just started and the idea of removing this regime is this much widespread just since 5 years ago. Before that, we thought we could have reforms. But we got to know that there is no reforms possible within this regime. So don’t get deceived that we wanted this regime. From the day one, this regime was never chosen and never liked and got and remained in power just by bloodshed. They are a black point in our 7000 years history nothing more. They’re Evils sent upon us.

  • @Lucinda666
    @Lucinda666 9 місяців тому

    For Freedom ❤❤❤

  • @joblakelisbon
    @joblakelisbon 6 місяців тому

    These women are so elegant and articulate.

  • @alihaider6537
    @alihaider6537 Рік тому +16

    Good job Iran

  • @pedroaguilardesousa3437
    @pedroaguilardesousa3437 Рік тому +4

    It's a disgrace when the dogma it's superb, instead of loving and respect mother and sisters... Power in the wrong hands carrys only disgrace...

  • @gmasookie7841
    @gmasookie7841 3 місяці тому +1

    Iran is a good reminder of the importance of the separation of church and state.

  • @ilkertas
    @ilkertas Рік тому

    good job

  • @bigsky7599
    @bigsky7599 Рік тому +4

    Do Not Ask Monster's for Mercy ... Learn how to Use a Staff / Stick .!

  • @aadilhussein466
    @aadilhussein466 Рік тому +5

    Iran is not Libya Iraq or Sudan

    • @ufukci
      @ufukci Рік тому +1

      İt could be even worse!

  • @mathewroy3
    @mathewroy3 Рік тому +2

    Our respects to the courageous women, children and men for standing up against the brutal dictatorial regime, for the sake of freedom and respect for human rights and values. May their struggle bring genuine freedom to the people of Iran.

    • @jeffpliskin
      @jeffpliskin Рік тому

      They don't have that kind of culture based on secular humanism. I suggest whatever replaces their theorcracy wont be any better actually be something like Iraqs baathists, Syria's Al asad or look how long Hamid Khazi lasted? It's best the USA, Isreal stop meddling in cultures and lands they don't understand creating more frankensteins.

  • @yapiridebbarma4000
    @yapiridebbarma4000 Рік тому +1

    Keep fighting for the up coming generations. One day u will succeed and the up coming generations will b grateful of ur actions. May God bless you all. Amen.

  • @judykinsman3258
    @judykinsman3258 Рік тому +14

    Why aren’t men required to have self discipline & restraint?

    • @mrssomeone2143
      @mrssomeone2143 Рік тому +4

      They are. You just don't know

    • @Sarah-xw2sv
      @Sarah-xw2sv Рік тому

      the media just covering and sharing women protesters more. 2 men got executed in 2 days because defending protesters. 400 men got killed in protest

    • @judykinsman3258
      @judykinsman3258 Рік тому +1

      @@mrssomeone2143 neither do the women they control.

    • @oscopin74
      @oscopin74 Рік тому +1

      @@mrssomeone2143 no they aren't. They seem lawless when it comes to womens rights.

  • @edamameedamame1202
    @edamameedamame1202 6 місяців тому +1

    Morality + Police : two words should never be used together, let alone given power over another human being.

  • @nzs316
    @nzs316 Рік тому

    Is there a specific time (day) period that Sandra makes her presentations? It seems to be random!

  • @lastChang
    @lastChang Рік тому +32

    Iranian 🇮🇷 fight for freedom should inspire all Chinese.

    • @ricfermi5886
      @ricfermi5886 Рік тому +5

      The Chinese people have chosen and fought for their regime.
      The Chinese people are in charge of their beautiful country!

    • @prinznoir7371
      @prinznoir7371 Рік тому +2

      @@ricfermi5886 in your dreams lmao

    • @ricfermi5886
      @ricfermi5886 Рік тому +1

      @منى احمد Mah Shah Allah beautiful Muhammad bin Salman 🇸🇦🙏🏻 The most generous and democratic man on earth 🙏🏻

    • @carlosjuan831
      @carlosjuan831 Рік тому

      What do you mean Chinese? I think you meant to say Americans

  • @quippy8402
    @quippy8402 Рік тому +11

    Usually I look for description more than just "people vs gov". I wish there was more description of the opposition parties/groups/factions/etc. and how the protests are organized; and what the protestors did (likely many peaceful, some not). Otherwise, it is very difficult to ascertain what actually happened there. Typically, many political forces take leverage in cases like this one and the reality is usually more complicated. Wrongful death happens in a lot of places on Earth and all of them should be prosecuted to the fullest extent. But it is a big jump from a wrongful death to riots that could easily get many more people killed. Every action will be a forced move in a riot; and you would know why when you had been in one. People who too casually push an already marginal society beyond its safety redline also deserve serious examinations. There are usually many different undercurrents and that's what I would look for from news. Lives are not cheap and one shouldn't value one live way more than hundred others who might not want to be dragged into the abyss in the first place. We should respect lives in all cases and be really careful of the way and the method we use to shape the world.

    • @AFara-wg9fz
      @AFara-wg9fz Рік тому +6

      It grassroot movement not run or coordinated by parties. There is only one party of the gov.

    • @chirravurisaichaitanya5765
      @chirravurisaichaitanya5765 Рік тому +4

      Iran is not a democratic nation to have multiple political parties.
      So its people of Iran vs government of Iran

    • @nibsvkh
      @nibsvkh Рік тому

      Blah blah blah…you’d know the why and how if you really wanted to and were following the news from the beginning of the murder of an innocent woman and subsequent protests!

    • @worldwithoutwar8622
      @worldwithoutwar8622 Рік тому

      People are not robots!!! Ultimately they choose freely . . . you cannot blame "higher forces" for 'manipulating' people's minds. The issues are as clear as crystal . . . people are murdered by the government for the most stupid petty reasons!!!

  • @momadevali5231
    @momadevali5231 20 днів тому +1

    What Iran needs is change of policy .

  • @Gwoks
    @Gwoks Рік тому +2

    to the women of iran 👏👏👏👏👏👏

  • @alikuthoo
    @alikuthoo Рік тому +3

    Hail IR IRAN
    Allah bless you 🖤🖤🖤🖤

    • @robertosborne7542
      @robertosborne7542 Рік тому +1

      Your point is?just shouting from what I can see.Btw where is your god when innocent children are being killed?68 I believe the number was,perhaps you think they were working for foriegn powers ?

    • @carlosjuan831
      @carlosjuan831 Рік тому

      Iran Iraq war
      Vietnam
      Libya
      Iraq
      Millions dead due to US interference. Handle your own genocidal policies before commenting on other countries. And read a history book before as well.

  • @mohdmalik6569
    @mohdmalik6569 Рік тому +13

    Make a story about absolute Monarchy in Qatar ......

    • @TheLegendsOfRock1001
      @TheLegendsOfRock1001 Рік тому +1

      Why cant u just watch one from the countless other news media? U do realise AJ's channel have the choice to delete comments if they wanted but choose not to?

    • @peaceprosperity3951
      @peaceprosperity3951 Рік тому

      Do you hate Qatar just because they refused to allow Alcohol, Drugs and Homosexuality into their country? What about other murderous monarchies in the Middle East?

  • @adkh5826
    @adkh5826 Рік тому +1

    What happened to the chair transitions?

  • @officer_miller
    @officer_miller Рік тому

    a very easy answer is that protests are getting more frequent and people are finaly getting to a point of slowly slowly going for another revolution

  • @peterwilliamson8721
    @peterwilliamson8721 Рік тому +3

    The govt of Iran has been given a pass by western govts because this barbaric form of monotheism, is in compliance with the rest, for some reason our western govts are ok with this

  • @vishalmeghwal1403
    @vishalmeghwal1403 Рік тому +4

    Taliban with strict Hijab laws and Iran with Change in Hijab laws ,living side by side would be amazing to see.

    • @nibsvkh
      @nibsvkh Рік тому

      Amazing to see the continuing of Taliban strict hijab laws?
      Another YT WTF comment!!!

  • @eileengarcia7923
    @eileengarcia7923 Рік тому +1

    The World is supporting this protest!!!!

  • @doncbenny
    @doncbenny Рік тому +9

    When it comes to palestine :-
    Islamic world - 🤬👿👺
    When it comes to Iran :-
    Islamic world - 🤐😴🙈🙉🙊

    • @lonelyboy1977
      @lonelyboy1977 Рік тому

      Iran is a non-Muslim land; less than 15% of the population is Muslim. Most Iranians (80%) are Rafidah aka the worst enemies of Islam.

    • @onmygoldenwings
      @onmygoldenwings Рік тому +1

      Didn’t get your meaning.

  • @alborz2485
    @alborz2485 Рік тому +1

    You know, Al Jazeera didn't say anything about Iran for 3 months , or they had to work with Iranian regime, now they make a rapport. Shame on Al Jazeera

  • @liorab9753
    @liorab9753 Рік тому

    I wish you - good people, good Women, good youth, loving people - much success! you are the inspiration of courage and real love to Life

  • @Geo-politic
    @Geo-politic Рік тому +9

    Iran has installed despotic leadership on the society and the death of the woman is a beginning or latent stage of the conflict and the conflict broke out as manifestation and conflict manifestation.The theocrat is a bourgeoise in Tehran and the government has become one of the toughest where there is no social contract.Those who have experience of suppression may support the Iranian regime.Never forget peoples power always wins!!!

    • @SuperErikRoss
      @SuperErikRoss Рік тому

      If anybody " installed " the current leadership and it's policies, It is the people of Iran being as the revolution to remove the corrupt shah from power was a popular uprising. What you are seeing now is unrest fomented by foriegn intervention and upon the youth of Iran cuz that's how they work through the easily influenced minds of children this too will soon pass just as it did in Syria and Iraq.

    • @Geo-politic
      @Geo-politic Рік тому

      @@SuperErikRoss did you read the book by George Orwell?

    • @SuperErikRoss
      @SuperErikRoss Рік тому

      @@Geo-politic yup endless war in the middle east digging holes and filling em back up yea i'm familiar

  • @shawnyousafi622
    @shawnyousafi622 Рік тому +3

    We Iranian want change we had enough of lies and killing but we ask leaders of world doing business with Regime and give them money otherwise Regime will bring problem to your country.
    One solution revolution.

  • @emilioong72
    @emilioong72 Рік тому

    Prayer to the people in iran

  • @1_jahwarrior
    @1_jahwarrior Рік тому

    Fight! 🙏🏽