Origins of the Somali civil war
Вставка
- Опубліковано 3 кві 2017
- Support CaspianReport through Patreon:
/ caspianreport
BAKU - In recent decades Somalia has become analogous to a failed state. It is known as a sanctuary for warlords, jihadist and even pirates. For this reason, the country poses a security risk in the Horn of Africa. However, it wasn’t always like this. In fact, in the mid-20th century, the country was a powerful force in the region. So, in this report, we will explore the decline of Somalia, the origins of its long-standing crisis and what issues the country faces today.
Soundtrack:
Decisions Kevin MacLeod (incompetech.com)
Licensed under Creative Commons: By Attribution 3.0
creativecommons.org/licenses/b...
Follow CaspianReport on social media.
Facebook: / caspianreport
Twitter: / caspianreport
One of the sad things is that beneath these issues, it appears to be a really beautiful country
James Harrison
It really is
I went to the coast and bro it was empty
Nice white sand and blue Indian Ocean
But it was just absolutely empty
Nobody there lol
James Harrison it was beautiful well modernized country before 1991, it was known as the Switzerland of Africa and the capital Mogadishu was known as the white pearl of the Indian Ocean.
Somalia has the longest coastline in mainland Africa with the most beautiful beaches.
If it was peaceful right now it would’ve been a tourist heaven like old days but sadly none of the regional countries wants that to never happen again.
But we will finally win against our geopolitical enemies.
Horumarka Dalka
Yh but that's the thing
If you look through history
It was somalis who built Mogadishu
It was somali people who traded as far as medievalist Ming china
It was somali people who established trade with Indians, Persians, Arabs etc
the Ajuran somali Empire was the only hydraulic empire in Africa.
Somali people were the first people to defeat a European power in Africa
Somali vs Portuguese empire
Somali navy defeated Portuguese empire who were known for their extreme naval strength
Look at all of this
And you know that right now somalia is just suffering because of mistakes made by stupid people
We can make it great again but we have to seriously get rid of tribalism
Horumarka Dalka fuck off
James Harrison Yes, Somalia is beautiful with the long Indian Ocean coastline, we have the potential to be a major tourist destination.
Our neighbours Somalia. I pray for this country with very beautiful beaches and hardworking people to gain peace. And stand on their feet as one. I know they will one day. I have hopes. Lots of love from Kenya
THANK U SO MUCH FOR BEING RESPECTFUL.
Glad you guys are getting. Love from Haiti.
Thank you
@@MarioLopez-si8jb thank you very much
@@khadkaon1259 you welcome my beloved sister.
I love somalia from sudan
Fuck u
Thank you
@@salihalash4111 where are you from
We love Brothers of Sudanese
I'm from Sudan
I pray one day somalia can go back to its original borders and have peace, Love from Morocco 🇲🇦 🇸🇴
Still supporting Somali irredentism? 🤣
We’ve made big progress so far check out our latest videos and history on UA-cam, you’ll be amazed. Sending love back 🇸🇴🇲🇦
@@kiuk_kiks shut up
@@farhiyamohamed___
Somalia became forever destabilised because of the irredentist Ogaden war. So you shut up instead.
@@kiuk_kiks u stfu u twat
Wow. I didn't know how powerful Somalia was
We was powerful in Africa and still we are. Thank you
@Razor Ramone there is no civil war anymore just a divide among Somalia due to the civil war. Apart from that there is the terrorist group al shabaab which kill alot of people every year and that's only in the south and they are solely there because of the Somalia govt allowing them but the north Somaliland is much better place than the south which terror ridden
@@rackojama You dumb ass. You sad there is no civil war but then said there is civil war. Al shabaab don't exist coz government allows them but because government are too weak to defeat them even with AU helping them. Why would shabaab bother with Somaliland when south somalia is the important part, once they take Mogadishu they can go for hargesia.
@@totallyfrozen Where did you get that information? If you mean the Christians of Amisom then you are right but there no open Somali Christians in Somalia, only a few secret ones. There is a church in the north tho even though there are no Christians there either.
@@rackojama Lol you deleted your comment. I speak facts, I don't support Al Shabaab. You need to stop lying to the people or just admit you're a dumb ass and get some education. So responding to your bullshit is "projecting"? Clearly you can't handle the truth.
love you Somali from Turkey. 🙋 ❤
Love you guy and we will always thankful for what you guys did in our country.our only brother we have in this world. Thanks God.🙏🏽🙏🏽
çok tesekkur ederız bızde turkıye sıvıyoruz
We love you too turkey 🥰🥰🥰🥰🥰🥰🥰
Somalia LOVES TURKEY. Thank you guys SOOO much.
Too we Turkey Brothers love you♥️🇸🇴♥️🇹🇷♥️
So Barre was the Somali Saddam Hussein, and Ethiopia was his Iran?
Somalia was Sudie Arabia and Ethiopia is Iran.
I never thought of it like that...😂😂😂
Smart analogy!
Ibrahim Abdile but he bombed them
Yep
I was born in the wrong time. I can only Tear down (BC I'm Somali ) I miss my county being peacefull and having Name 😢😢😢
barna bas you didn't have to do Somalia like that. I felt that and I'm Ghanaian
barna bas Assumpations?
Yu Somalians do have a lot of problems you cant lie about that
dark night dummo Problems caused by neighbouring countries/western nations so they profit of the chaos, Somalia has alot of natural untapped resources and Turkey even China are in the process of helping reach that, once that happens the whole region will be different and become the strong nation it once was. Time heals everything.
MK Dons so basically you cant do it yourselves you need Chinese and turkish to do it for you and they'll reap most of the benefits
When you spoke about 'greater Somalia' at 2:00 you should've mentioned that greater Somalia is what Somalia's flag represents( the five sided star represents the 5 Somali regions).
im somali and didn't even know that
Such a gorgeous flag honestly. I didn't know that either, but it sounds amazing. I can only imagine the light blue represents the water off the coast of the Indian Ocean and the white symbolic of what he said being the "Pearl of the Indian Ocean." Looking at a design like that makes one hopeful for the potential in such a nation.
@@cloin6 the sky blue color represents the Clear somali sky(due to Somalia having clear beautiful blue skies all year round). In the national flag anthem= Qolabaa Alankeed (every nation has its own flag), it states that Somalia's one is like the clear blue sky without the clouds and we love it.
* inagaa keynu waa
* cirkoo kala ee
* aan caadna Laheyn
* ee caashaqayee
And did you know African people or the most beautifulest people in the world :>
@@mahmudshiil135 it sounds truly beautiful there, I hope your nation finds peace one day 🙏
I love Somalia and I really hope that stability can happen permanently in the region. The county has the potential to be one of the greatest in Africa thanks to it's resources.
Wishing you all the best from Sudan.
Shirvan, your videos are great. Obviously no one is completely without bias, but it's so refreshing to come across such level-headed analysis in the face of all the noise and mudslinging going on everywhere else - keep it up.
love somalia from turkey
from somalia ilove my brothers turkey
True. We Love Somalia from Turkey :))
We love u too ours brothers and sister we are one family bro thnks from Somali G boy✌❤
love you too
Am a somali in turkey....appreciate the love bruh
*_4:54_**_ before I die i want to see the great Somalia back Insha'Allah_*
𝙎𝙊𝙈𝘼𝙇𝙄𝘼 𝙃𝘼𝙉𝙊𝙊𝙇𝘼𝘼𝙏𝙊🇸🇴💪🏿🦁
Ahmed haji Burco it's not impossible but very unlikely, especially in the modern world. Crazier things have happened.
Same
Back? It never existed in history
@Tennesee Testostreone
𝓐𝓻𝓮 𝔂𝓸𝓾 𝓼𝓽𝓾𝓹𝓲𝓭 𝓸𝓻 𝓭𝓻𝓾𝓷𝓴 𝓮𝓽𝓱𝓲𝓸𝓹𝓲𝓪𝓷 𝓽𝓱𝓮𝔂'𝓻𝓮 𝓷𝓸𝓽 𝓒𝓱𝓻𝓲𝓼𝓽𝓲𝓪𝓷𝓼 𝓶𝓪𝓳𝓸𝓻𝓲𝓽𝔂 𝓸𝓯 𝓔𝓽𝓱𝓲𝓸𝓹𝓲𝓪 𝓪𝓻𝓮 𝓞𝓻𝓸𝓶𝓸 𝓪𝓷 80% 𝓸𝓯 𝓞𝓻𝓸𝓶𝓸 𝓪𝓻𝓮 𝓜𝓾𝓼𝓵𝓲𝓶 20% 𝓔𝓽𝓱𝓲𝓸𝓹𝓲𝓪𝓷𝓼 𝓪𝓻𝓮 𝓒𝓱𝓻𝓲𝓼𝓽𝓲𝓪𝓷𝓼 𝓶𝓪𝓳𝓸𝓻𝓲𝓽𝓲𝓮𝓼 𝓪𝓻𝓮 𝓜𝓾𝓼𝓵𝓲𝓶 s𝓸𝓶𝓪𝓵𝓲𝓪 𝓲𝓼 𝓽𝓱𝓮 𝓴𝓲𝓷𝓰 𝓸𝓯 𝓔𝓪𝓼𝓽 𝓐𝓯𝓻𝓲𝓬𝓪
@@Last_King2023 you can google it about 65%-70% of Ethiopian population is christian the rest is muslim don't talk about what you want talk about tge truth
Our dads always tell us and speak nothing but positivity of the Somalians. That even carried over when we emigrated to Europe and America in the 80’s. All love to Somalia
✌🏾🇪🇷
Love you Eritrean❤
Love to Eritrea. We both know the fake nation of 'ethiopia' and its creation by colonisers via menelik
Am from Djibouti 🇩🇯 the former French Somaliland and I love my brothers from Somalia. Odds are against Somalia returning to its former glory but I believe that they'll overcome.
In your Dream IctirafLand you're just a stupide jaleous Somalilander. Djibouti were independant country from Somalia always You're not from Djibouti return in your Ictirafland, dumarland, etc.
@@engineer2010mad I am Djiboutian and I believe deep inside me that we are stronger only if Somalia is strong. I am Somali before being djiboutian. This is what the reality is
@@leomandchourian5460 Sorry guys you've made a big mistake, we speak Somalie language but the Djiboutian ppl are not from Somalia Country. It's a huge difference Djibouti is a independant country since always, if you're from Somalia it's up to you and it's your reality not the reality of the Djiboutian ppl. Stop your propaganda and your irrational delusious. You said what????? You're Djiboutian ??? I'm sure 100% you're not from Djibouti cause we know who we are and your kind of virus ppl it seems you are looking for a place to identify because you don't exist anywhere in this world and everyone knows you're not from Djibouti....
@@engineer2010mad you are Afar, I understood. I am Djiboutian in at least 100 generation , pure autochtone of Djibouti. And we don't believe in borders made by colonial power who came 170 years ago. Djiboutian people believe in greater Somalia and are somalis. Somali power 💪
@@leomandchourian5460 lol Pure Djiboutian you are reached another level of delusious in your Dream if i'm Issa or Afar it doesn't maner who cares about that I'm not from Somalia but it seems you're a simple visiter in Djibouti. I'm sure you're from the haters from Somalilanders... We're stronger than your hate and your propaganda... You can't change the history give me one part of Djibouti or region that other ppl lived other than Issa or Afar ? Adeer Haa igu dhajiin magaca Cusbayaan hadad tahey iska nolow o iska bashal lakin haa ilowin wadanka you're just a visiter.... We'll be so happy of our neighbour Somalia is back again but we're brave country who take our destiny alone not like your Somaliland. You know my friend we support you even with your hate...
I have a friend that wants to take the African media by storm. Just waiting on me to partner with him. God bless my brothers and sisters in Somalia I love you very much.
we love you very much too
Thank u brother we love u too
tell me the meaning storm in here your sentence
Can i be a part of it?
Love you Somalia from Somalia 🤦🏾♀️🤦🏾♀️
An army somali hi
Clan system has to go! There’s Only one clan Somalia! A united Somalia
tbh no it shouldn't
@@chvrry6468 why
@@buzzlightyear1010 clans give somalis an identity. A better one. Than just single handedly being called "somali"
There the best.
Howevwr the clans must be under one..with equality
Did you mean "clean" Somalia?
@@SherKhan-rd9uw Id there are just going to be clans anyway, why even have a Somalia? If all the groups want to go their own way, couldn’t they just all declare independence for themselves?
The most factual representation I have come across thus far of the Somalis history... I salute you #CasbianReport for not being biased as many news reporters are. InshaAllah Somali will rise from the chaos to well productive country soon🙏🏼🙏🏼
How can someone give a 12 minutes summary of Somali Crisis without mentioning General Mohamed Farrah Aidid???
Yeah,that's what I was thinking about. He was a legend. Somalia will never ever forget that guy. What he did to his country. True legend.RIP rest in paradise.😞😔 I wish we have another General aidid.
Dadka dagaal oogeyaasha ah taariikhda ma xusto
Somalia should focus on rebuilding itself rather than living in the past, of colonial borders and clan representation. All the people want is a better future, the somalis in kenya and ethiopia are living much better and safer life there, so claiming land is not the solution. They should as well abolish clanism and adopt a federal system of governance as a substitute to accelerate their country's economic growth. Make peace, not war.
Arasky I agree with you 21%. most African nations are poor largely due to colonialism and weak democracies. I know Somalia will surely rise again...but with the geopolitical technicalities that come along with a greater Somalia, I can say with confidence that a greater somalia is a pipe-dream. It's wise to build what you have first, then seek greatness later.
again I know that kenya and ethiopia want a stable and peaceful region(which works for everybody's interests). Thats why they gave their soldiers (even despite having many casualties in the ensuing war) to somalia to help fight al shabaab. Otherwise they could just have protected their own borders from intrusion. Give credit where it is deserved brother.
Could not have said it better myself .
Daniel K lol u do know Ethiopia is highly suspected of funding alshabab hahaha which is not a suprise considering it's In their interest along with Kenya to have a destabilised Somalia since a strong Somalia like the one in the 70s means irrendentist policies and somalis wanting to retake their territory in both countries inhabited by ethnic somalis which was the cause of the 1977 ogadem war..and not to mention Ethiopia being landlocked, a weak Somalia means easy access to their numerous ports btw Somalia has the longest coastline on mainland Africa ..so there are many reasons for these countries to have a weak Somalia ..Their involvement in Somalia is merely a charade as they have their own geopolitical interests at heart..One thing is certain..at one point Somalia will stabilise and return to pre-civil war levels ..Once they do that they have the resources to develop at a fast rate and catch up to other regional economies. .with such prosperity they will undoubtedly reassume their irrendentist policies of wanting to retake their territories in Ethiopia and Kenya either diplomatically or militarily. .that's inevitable..as long as somalis exist and the country is stable and they aren't dealing with other problems like terrorism,foreign interference,disunity amongst themselves..They will always end up wanting their lands back and at one point it will lead to another war believe me..I hope I'm alive so I can support it by joining the army or govt amiin ya rabbal alamiin
Stupid and ignorant do uknow how somalis in north eastern and in ogaden are suffering never comment in what u have no knowledge
Somalia will rise again and stronger then before insha allah
Somalia is dead and burried for good!!!
Mesfin Gondar Serqe Berhan then wht is your point 🤔🤔
So sure
Somali has always been strong even today with so many war Somali is steel stronger then south Sudan,Congo and central Africa.
One thing Somali must do is not to go to war with Ethiopia instead build relationship and business deal. War will keep both nation poor and undeveloped.
No it won't, it will eventually collapse into smaller portions then the smaller portions would fight amongst themselves and eventually it would all collapse into anarchy and go back to stone age.
wow am Eritrean and I have to say very impressed by depth knowledge you got about Somalia. until I watched this video I didn't know the full cause of Somalia devastating cive war. thank you for the report
Oh Allah make my country come together and live peacefully
@muslim police is banning accounts on youtube you are demon tufu nacaltula caleyk bedey baa thy noloshisi ü bdly gaalnimo
hanad gigis amuus garaco bila diinta nacalatulah caleyk waar yaa ku baray somaliga ma oramadii uraysay bAd tahay
Ameen
@Homunkulus lmao Islam is about peace so what's your point
Our country is peaceful now babes
This guy is well inform in the geopolitical situation in Somalia, great work
Somalia 🇸🇴 4 million
1977 war Vs
Ethiopian 🇪🇹66 million
Cuba 🇨🇺 16.000
Russia 🇷🇺 4.000
somalia france america artria tplf vs ethiopia and russia
@@baligamingethiopia france and America was against Somalia 🇸🇴 go check the history
Even pakistan and all arab nations was behind Ethiopia
Tplf start 1991 lol
And Yamen 🇾🇪
Love you somaila from Pakistan
Moha Amip love Turkey also brothers
I from somalia u welcome somaliya Mogadisho
Huzaifa Tanveer Somalia Turkey and Pakistan❤️😍🇸🇴🇵🇰🇹🇷
we like our muslims Pakistan zindabad
Homosexuall?
A very decent, informative and well paced presentation. Well done.
Ogadenya And NFD And D Jabuti That is my country Somalia😍
Somali children use to be so beautiful-just goes to show you how having a place to call home gives you inner and outer beauty. Inshaallah things will turn up for us.
I see that Shirvan is forming his own team of reporters... Hopefully those mid-term and long-term goals are on their way to be achieved.
May the somalis be united under one.
🇦🇫🇸🇴
🇦🇫❤️🇸🇴
Oh look another failed state!
No free Somali land
FREE SOMALILAND!!!! greater Somalia 👎
I love you my country Somalia 4ever 🇸🇴
Laakin waxay tahay Garxajis?
@@ogolow570 hhhh waa qabiil isaaq ka mid ah
Greatings from Eritrea ❤
I just want to say the obvious again because the humble should never tire of it... I very much appreciate your reports. From the content to the maps and graphics i absolutely love and very much look forward to them. So thanks. And thanks to your financial supporters too, extra special thanks to them from me because when i give, it goes to my church so i don't have the room. So yeah, thanks to them too. Great videos.
Caspian report is great in its info and video editing. Love it
I wonder what Beijing's plan for the region is.
Cypher Caliban they want the trade route which leads to the suez canal secured.
anything else?
find out on the next thrilling episode of Dragon Ball Z...
They are putting their first military base in Jubadi. One mile away from the American base.
Beijing has built lots nice road and infrastructure , much better than the two superpowers
+themaster100 Chinese "investments" in Africa are building roads for them and in exchange they take most natural resources (iron, gold, etc.) African countries should do something with those valuables, themselves instead of letting the Chinese rob them of it
I really hope that this country recovers! It's really sad to see the world has turned it's back against it!
Yeah British white peolle made borders that divided the ethnic Somalis and this went to war with its neighbors and became a failed state
I agree. I fully hope that it can stabilize itself and return a sense of normalcy before the civil war.
That was a well presented documentary.Thanks for educating me about the region.
the most truthful news i have ever come across keep continue bro
could you make a video on the Ethiopia-Eritrea dispute also? That is a very touchy but interesting topic. Also Ethiopia's blossoming relationship with China and Eritrea's blacklisting from the global economy being labelled 'the North Korea of Africa'.
great work
How ever I Love my country Somalia ❤🇸🇴🇸🇴
Thank you Caspianreport, Nice work
It took me years to get here. Thanks for your work.
Somalia have only one friend at the moment to be honest, Turkey.
And Kenya😁
@@rudboy8459 nah, Kenya are melding in our election and They have rightful somali clay
@@rudboy8459 Kenya is a client..you are not a friend in our list but recently, you have been demanding our full attention...you know us better than anyone..we are perplexed of your audacity to even look us in the eyes...but keep it up..keep what 4 European powers failed to succeed in the 20th century
Attempt to steal our shit..just a friend advice
@@geletoz libaax hadlay 🦁 🇸🇴
Long Live Greater Somalia
yeah, keep killing each other like sheep. Idiots.
Its a hope that can never die. Rome died but Greater Somalia will never die
Kooshin Diini you are mareexaan too waaw walaale
@@kasoco4746 " ... we say we do something we f do it." You mean building stable government, having a national currency... you couldn't even do the basics to have a country.
Thank you bro
Great job on the video! I learn something new every time i come to your channel!
One of the best history channel. Thanks for your good work
Never thought Somalia would be interesting
It is a a a beautiful country. Blessed one
I think most are interesting once you dig into their histories, it's a major reading project of mine in the future.
I'm British so I'm first of all trying to connect with my own nation's history (the history taught to me in school was severely lacking), but once I've done enough of that I want to explore the history of the world, firstly by looking at the British Empire and then by looking at the histories of the places that became part of the British Empire, specifically India and the British parts of Africa.
It's so obvious that it never gets said and so no-one remembers it but while your country was having its history other places were having their histories, everywhere in the world has a history, but because you can never teach it all most people will only learn about the history of wherever they're from because that's what their school system prioritises. Although some school systems don't even do that very well.
@@Generalscorpio good luck, U.K has a long history
The history and culture of somalis are even more interesting
*The Somali people are people who speak the language of the Pharaohs, a Cushitic language; and who still share many of those cultural traits and articles (Was scepter = hangool...). They were the first Africans, to make contact with China in trade as well as skirmishes. They were also able to defeat the Portuguese Navy at the height of its power, in an area where they were especially interested in, looking for that ancient Saint Prester John. They were also the first to be attacked with airplanes in all of Africa; after dislodging the British colonialists*
*They have been trading for many generations as far as China. Along the coast there are grave sites with Chinese porcelain dishware inlaid into the grave headstones.*
*There were even trading expeditions from ancient Egypt and queen Hatshepsut.into this land which was then called the land of Punt - some 5,000 years ago. Being second only to ancient Egypt in the age of cities in all of Africa predating many European cities such as London (or ancient londinium) by as much as a 1000 years. Never very populous, but very ancient.*
Today our problem is with some few resentful shortsighted separatists, who are sureptitiously supporting extremist groups and terrorists.
I would 100% donate to Caspian report for the great quality videos being made. But at the moment Im a poor student in college. :(
You're right.Can't believe someone is watching a document about Somalia and at the same time writing on his laptop "I'm a poor college student".
Maybe want to drop out
I don't know if you are like me, but it was not until the third year when i figured out the lie of college or university.
So I would call to gain information on my loans for instance right and the person on the other end told me that interest on the loans increased every year.
I was already looking at 3 to 4 % interest rate, which is high enough. That is how they get everyone in debt and trap them. The biggest scam in American History, if you ask me, but they don't warn nor tell you about any of this.
You grow up to realize that it might have been better to have never step foot onto a college or university campus and just began work.
But easy mathematics can solve a lot of that problem. Just lower the interest rate(s).
And as for a work is concerned. A lot of the jobs anyone applies to or for do not even require a college or university degree. I have read many of the requirements from several numerous employers.
So why not just say this to students who are in high school ? And not push the envelope of pursuing a college degree ?
Because then, people would not feel as if they have been deceived in any way by the same principals, teachers and administrators who are and were supposed to be properly advising them in the first place ?
Also they also never or do not tell you that you will be harrassed to make monthly payments. Thanks...
And on the topic of the medical world. A magnetic resonance image or scanning is no more than $500. I mean, just think about. The medical facilities are supposed to be providing a service.
But I was away at James Madison University for a minimum of two years and from experience, it is not worth it. All I got out of it was a psychological disorder, which I needed to go to therapy for.
And going back to the cost of an MRI. At that affordable price. No one would need these insurance cards and the insurance companies will be out of business. That is just an analysis.
Beautiful and summarised history. love this channel.
Brilliantly informative. Essential and understandable. Bravo zulu. Thank you.
Don't forget that certain Western countries supported piracy in Somalia to make profits from shipping insurance, etc.
Until Turkey showed up in the scene to ruin their savage game that is.
Turkey is neo colony of the Somalian Peninsula
for almost 2000 years Ethiopia gets defeated by Somalia but there is always foreign power helping them out.
hahahahaha you are ridiculous. "Somalia" was fabricated in 1960 by England and Italy. There was nothing called "Somalia" before 1960.
Eyob I. He meant somali states
Eyob I. Yeah we became a country the but we are ancient we lived on are lands for a long time
@Razor Ramone what are i saying are u okey
Etihiopia was not colonized and somalia was colonized different !!!
Great info. It really saved my history day project
Thanks Caspianreport. Im a Somali and I like your research and quality videos.
Love Somalia from India...
To my brothers Somali; beware of the gift bearer. Foreign intervention is a poisonous assistance.
Foreign intervention CAN be good if well executed and if the removal of the leader will actually improve the country. The US invasion of Grenada was a good intervention, as were some of the Soviet liberation of Eastern Europe (the soviets were bad but better than Hitler in areas like Poland), and the interventions by the Allies in Western Europe during WW2 as well. Japan was improved by the invasion in WW2. Afghanistan was a shit show but it did improve their country since the Taliban were terrible. The first invasion of Iraq was necessary in preventing Saddams wars of aggression in places like Kuwait and Iran, but the second war was a mixed bag. Many of the Soviet and American interventions in South America were a mess though.
The key is you have to have a necessary reason to intervene, the intervention has to be carried out to improve the country, you need clear goals before hand, you have to follow up any intervention (rebuild infrastructure, help establish a fair government, etc.), the locals need to oppose the leadership, and you cant just carry out the war for your own reasons.
@Max Smith It's not like America has been doing anything anyway. Also, what the hell is this "we" as if you've done anything.
Very informative video!! Keep up the good work!!
I REALLY LOVE CaspianReport!
The best analysis of the origins of the Somali civil war, I have ever encountered. The Ogaden region was never conquered by the Ethiopians, except for Harar. Great Britain handed over the Ogaden in 1948 and Haud and Reserved area in 1954 without the consent of the Somali people to Ethiopia.
I always wondered why there was a "Somaliland" and a "Somalia" country on recent world maps. Thanks for all this great information and great video as always! :)
Mike Dawson really??!! I haven't noticed
I guess it depends on which world maps we use!
Mike Dawson could you send me an example of one?? Please??
mapmaker[dot]nationalgeographic[dot]org/ that's the one I use
Mike Dawson thanks
Great video! Very detailed and very informative.
very informative video. Thank you!
well remember that the Pilot Ahmed Mohamed Hassan has refused to bombard hargeysa, he called it a madness and refused the order, a real brave pilot!!!! A shame others didnt follow his steps
Most of the pilots that bombed hargeysa were mercenaries hired from apartheid South Africa.
@Bruno Lito what do you mean evil im darood and my people rebelled against barre they were killed by his soldiers so its not darood its that stupid barre
@@coon_award437 trying so hard to hide the history of isaaq people everything is on record to bad for you and your followers you guy's can't do that believe me we know our history our suffering so we don't learn about you anything about our people faced because of this so called simalinimo f**ck that sh**t
My grandfather who's sheekhal refused his brother was killed and property in xamar and farm in afgooye was confiscated...
They should make this into a movie/tv show interesting AF
Great analysis as always, just love your videos
This was WELL done..!! It was clear and chronologically accurate. I am a Suscriber. Thumbs up
what do you think will happen if Khamenei has died ?
plz a vid on that
Berenspelen his successor will be appointed just like he was appointed when his predecessor died is very simple really!
Shia arent muslims they are khawariij and soon the iranians will be back their originaly religion muslim (sunni)
I see a lot of foreigners angry that Somalis still want a greater Somalia after all that has happened we don’t care greater Somalia will one day happen inshallah 💪🏿
Lol and then there will be no more somalia😂 there will be only absolute devastation,if somalia just trying to occupy ogaden made this much effect on ur country I can't imagine what going up against a modern Ethiopian army would do to ur country I can assure u you will loose the land u even have now and instead of greater Somalia it will be greater Ethiopia with the biggest costline in Africa😂
@@SAVAGE-py2fp Ethiopians can't withstand a united and strong somali offensive you know that, and history tells that but you can take advantage of our division but if we have the same strength and no foreign intervention you will get destroyed.
Greater somalia is a fiction and it will never happen. Stick to reality people
@@SAVAGE-py2fp I'm 100% sure he is a Daarood clan because he have their mentality 😂.
@Mm Mmnugaal 😂😂😂😂. Just keep dreaming, my dear friend 😂😂😂😂.
This is very interesting. Great job!
Good information, thanks Shirvan.
United great of Somalia
I hope one day Somalia will become a stable country ...love and respect to Somalia and its common peoples 💙❤️
Keen for AU, keep the Africa material coming +CaspianReport
Really love your videos on how elaborated you explain everything easily to understand
It's like Lebanon the politics. But over there it's more religious representation.
Very informative, thanks. This is a tragedy for the somalis. I was stationed in Mogadishu 6 months in 1993. Mogadishu could be a really nice city
with Italian influences if there would be peace in this region.
The influences of colonialism are one of our biggest problems.
Eew no Italian or white influence needed
Much of the Italian influences are destroyed now since 1993
Never knew about the Isaaq massacre until I watched this video. Well done, sire.
You can find goooogle British somaliland
An excellent report. Thank you.
Very informative. Thanks for sharing
even meles zenawi (current president of ethiopia) confessed that Ethiopians are naive people. ethiopia down kenya down . Long live the big Somali
patek phillipe meles died in 2012 and was a prime minister not a president
@@kingr0bel 😂😂😂
Am somalian we have much respect to the kenya and ethiopian people this politicean in the region were mess and still goin on that shitttttt
Shut up and leave with ignorance.
Fucking tremendous mate, in 12 min you changed my view on a entire geo-political region. Keep up the good work, this is much more fascinating journalism instead of reporting what Trump tweeted!
Rokiriko changed how? If i may ask
Please explain your comment, you have an interesting conclusion. Did you think another issue was more at fault or something lacking.
When the journalist is a insider. I mean he is related to the country he is reporting the information he give is completely differ from other sources. Example I am Somali, and I m not journalist but I have all these information.
Thanks for this video!
great content as always shirvan
i hope to see a video explaining somaliland in particular as it has developed into a democracy in this unstable region.
I don't know why I can't hold back my tears 😭 , we lost people, culture, peace, the country's name , powerful and everything but not the hope , however we will be great again .🇸🇴❤
i can't wait for the next report. as an Ethiopian American you hear a lot of stories about the AU and its difficult to tell what is and isn't true
Lemme tell you something that is true.
the AU, being largely funded by non African countries, became a tool for neo colonialism a while back.
Anyone telling you something else is shitting you
Very educational. You gave a lot of info in short time.
another awesome video
Interesting I am 38yrs old and have never heard this history before. I'm sure there is more to the story. I always thought the structures that I saw in films etc in Somalia were grand and related to a greater time in the past.
Things are getting better now in Somalia ! The country is recovering and making significant progress
Excellent analysis. I must say it was detailed and objective. As a native of Ethiopia I must say that you have a great grasp on the dynamics of the horn region.
Thank you for doing a video on Africa! Looking forward to more
Thanks for your work!
Bring back the afro's, Somalia!
We naturally either have afros or short hair.
Ayanami Rei I can't even grow an Afro. Somalis have different hair textures some curly some Afro textured
And if we do grow an Afro, it's a pain to comb.
Somalis also naturally have wavy and curly hair
@frimz What are saying we are not arabs and we are somali and Africans and.we are more then 25.millions we are like 60_millions or more then
10:40 So it's like Lebanon but based on clans rather than religions. A pretty tricky situation, because the confessional system is at the same time the thing keeping the country together and the thing keeping the state weak.
+db exactly
No its actually the white peoples fault they took our lands and gave it to ethiopian and kenya none of this bs would happen if we had all of our land
Who the hell is "we", though? This is blatant nonsense being espoused by Somalis who are ignorant about their own history to put together any informed and constructive reasons for why the Somali nation should exist.
Firstly, Somalia is an inherently colonial project, even the name comes from the colonial name given to it by the Italians: Italia Somalia.
Secondly, the notion of a unified Somali state that encompasses all Somalis, regardless of where they live, is, again, an idea that was imported from Europe and has no intellectual roots, as far as I am aware, in Somali history. Somalis have always been separated into small groups mainly on the grounds of clan allegiances. Very rarely would you see empires and sultanates that extended beyond the realm of its own clans. However, even in such instances the empire or sultanate would have been ruled by a specific clan and never was there anything remotely comparable to any such notions of a unified Somali state.
Thirdly, the destruction of Somalia is an inherent consequence of its narrow-minded desire to pursue the policy of Somaliweyn (greater Somalia). If anything, European imperialism was great for Somalia - as opposed to other African states - because it set in place the intellectual roots that would eventually allow for the tree of Somalia to grow. Thanks to Somali backwardness, it evolved into a corrupt, diseased and deformed tree; giving birth to equally corrupt, diseased and deformed fruits.
Lastly, though my analysis of what you say is harsh, and that of Somalia, I only do it because I am a firm believer in establishing progress through a robust framework of self-criticism. Blatant historical falsehoods and self-pity leave no room for the robust structure of self-criticism that Somalia, and Somalis, need if they wish to create a healthy tree that shades all our people.
@@johnwayne8297 Somali is not name that was given to somalia by a clonist !!!
@@johnwayne8297 thank you bruh
Finally THANK YOU
This is well researched video ... Good job 👍👍
AMISON is the reason why its not at peace and also Ethopia and Kenya and Clan warfare.
Khadar Knowledge islam is the reason with Islam no peace
Guulane death to islam
Dino Morea Islam the religion of pieces LMAO
Gulane islam is haram and is the reason zoomalia is a shithole
Grey Owl you’re so obsessed with islam, good to know, mr.donkey.
As a Somali people "we are all at the middle of a lot of hyenas/enemies who want our resources,land,oil,gold,our beautiful ocean with all types of fish. And can't see Somalia as one. And those are some arab countries (UAE,Saudi Arabia,Qatar,and Kuwait),most European countries,America,Kenya,isreal and even Russia and lastly and the most painful one is Ethiopia.
Ethiopia is always an arch enemy.
Hopefully we got one brother and that's Turkey
🇹🇷 may God bless you guys and we can't thank you enough.
In addition, I'm missing legend in this video (General Mohamed farah Aidid) he was legend and we will never ever forget that guy.(ethiopia affair that guy very much)And theirs bad view that the world have a Somali(pirate,terrorist,and,etc).pirates are small people who live in a coasts and want to save/defense their oceans/fish.some illegal ships want to take our fish,oil,and etc. So these population are defending their country,is that what the whole world called pirate?
I wish my future kid will see Somalia have their power back,identity,and stand its own legs. I don't have a chance to see that my kid will INSHA ALLAH
God bless y'all ✌🏽👍🏾
So true wallahi, inshallah generations ahead of me will get to see something better🇸🇴
long live Ethiopia the greatest country in the continent
Funny how you consider countries like Kenya your enemy. A people who hosted your displaced citizens, helped you get a president and even sent their own military to die in your country for the sake of greater peace and prosperity of the region. Indeed the only way a donkey says thank you is by kicking you. But it is God who blessess and curses and so your acknowledgement is pointless.
BLA BLA BLA,,YOU TEND TO BLAME EVERYONE ELSE FOR YOUR OWN MISTAKES,,YOU THOUGHT YOU WOULD BE THE SOVIET UNION OF AFRICA AND THAT BACKFIRED ON YOU TERRIBLY LEADING TO THE COLLAPSE OF YOUR NATION,,HOPE THOSE LEADERS FOCUSED ON WHAT THEY HAD AND SOMALI WOULD HAVE NEVER COLLAPSED,,YOU WANTED EVERYTHING AND INSTEAD LOST EVERYTHING
If there is any one Somalia should blame it's Clans. No one wants your resources what we want is a peaceful border. How does the oil you are speaking about helping you out in the war? Change that perspective bro, oil comes from fossils by killing each other you are making more oil than you need don't you think?
great video thank you fore the superb content
Caspian report is my source of info when news doesn't make sense as they are influenced by political bias . keep up with updates on geopolitics on nations Caspian report!