Lebanon's confusing civil war
Вставка
- Опубліковано 26 вер 2024
- By the mid-1970s, #Lebanon's power vacuum reached its tipping point. Disenfranchised #minorities took up arms and plunged the country into total conflict.
✔ GET NORDVPN ► nordvpn.com/ca...
✔ USE COUPON CODE ► caspianreport
✔ USE THE CODE SO YOU CAN GET 70% off 3-year plan + 4 months free
Support CaspianReport
✔ UA-cam membership ► / @caspianreport
✔ Patreon ► / caspianreport
✔ PayPal ► www.paypal.me/...
✔ Merchandise ►teespring.com/...
Crypto endorsement
✔ Bitcoin ► 1MwRNXWWqzbmsHova7FMW11zPftVZVUfbU
✔ Ether ► 0xfE4c310ccb6f52f9D220F25Ce76Dec0493dF9aA0
✔ Bitcoin Cash ► 1BKLti4Wq4EK9fsBnYWC91caK7NZfUhNw9
Join us on Facebook or Twitter
✔ Twitter ► / caspianreport
✔ Facebook ► / caspianreport
✔ My equipment and editing software ► www.amazon.com...
✔ GET NORDVPN ► nordvpn.com/caspianreport
✔ USE COUPON CODE ► caspianreport
✔ USE THE CODE SO YOU CAN GET 70% off 3-year plan + 4 months free
Do a report on a possible American Civil War 2
Can you plz make a video on pakistan and its fight against terrorism .
What cluster f"""""
Hello I am watching your videos for so long now waiting to watch one day a video about Cyprus. You are getting closer. I would like to see your opinion and the information you will find about how people and other nations are thinking about if Turkey came in peace in Cyprus or they made up the situation and took advantage of it to occupy half of this beautiful island occurring 200000 refugees
I wanna hear Caspian Report talk about the situation in Hong Kong. The Chinese are really exploiting the pandemic to fully takeover there. Found a great analysis on what's happening there and whether we're headed for a new Cold War: ua-cam.com/video/uMm67LHxR7M/v-deo.html
"If you understand Lebanon, someone's done a bad job explaining it to you."
I heard it's a country, that's about it. Great job.
It’s a county in Tennessee
Lebanon is a lesbian country, duh
Xxleo promanxXmaster buy my on nvm
It's fairly easy to understand provided someone is willing to A) distance themselves from their biases and B) are willing to seek out and listen to/read information from the myriad groups involved. For instance, if you really want to understand the conflict you must be willing to understand why the Lebanese Shi'a who joined and supported Hezbollah. Likewise, you also need to understand why the Maronite Christian's inside of Lebanon were and still are afraid of losing the political power that their group possesses.
Balkans: "We're brothers but we're killing each other. It's complicated."
Lebanon: "Hold my hummus..."
HOLD MY HUMMUS LMAOOOOOOO
Typical Anglo-Saxon propaganda about the Balkans like if the Westerners didn't commit a bunch of genocide against minorities or each other on a much, much larger scale.
@Hoàng Nguyên Whatever poor country like Myanmar did it has the aftermath though.Soon,it will face friendship crisis+More ethnic fighters crisis.Just like it is still fighting.Rohingyas aren't only muslims it has Muslim,Hindu & Christian. All are Bengali speakers. Cause rakhine was part of Bengal empire.
Hold my Arak
Hold my kombucha
"When God created Lebanon with the beautiful mountains and sunny beaches, the angels asked why are you so generous to this spot of land? God replied, wait until you see the neighbors I'm going to give them."
Shit XD
Hilarious.. I literally "laughed out loud" in my room...
As for your saying, "There's always a catch.."
Best comment
*cries in Sidon, Tyre, and Byblos*
@@Hmongboi228 me too!! I may have awaken all the house with my laughter 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
In all this mayhem the ordinary Lebanese citizen gains nothing, he is the victim and no one is held accountable.
True. But again must see which religious faction got benefited
This is your country on identity politics
as if that is ever not the case.
The old, rich and powerful get the young, poor and weak to fight for them by promising them dreams of a perfect society, if only the young, poor and weak agree to give up just a little more of their lives, money and freedom.
@@gilgameschvonuruk4982 true, and on open borders for refugees.
Hope Europe doesn't turn to lebanon.
and till now as lebanese we still suffer
I'm Lebanese and I don't understand what the heck happened to my country 30 years ago.
As a fellow Lebanese, no one does
@@imadnemeir9455 Now fight
Ok guys, then you really need to watch this video a second time ! 😅
Well I do 😂
As a Lebanese, I still have no idea, too confusing and no matter how much I read about it, it's still complicated with always new things to learn and discover.
The more I try to understand the middle east the less I understand the middle east
You must Thank israel for that
I Hate Furries And Sionists Allegui everyone hates Israel lol why doesn’t the all of the Middle East just team up and kaboom the damn country
@@george4111 Nice, i hate all arab countries. Whats your point? (:
SOG my point was so many middle eastern people absolutely hate Israel so I said why don’t they team up and do a little bit of allahuakbar. Wasn’t even talking to you so idk why you even wasted your time to respond my comment was pretty straight forward.
@@ihatefurriesandsionistsall3102 Because there was peace in the Middle East before Israel was established right?
History is often sad. Lebanon is no exception.
History is tragedies merged together
Things may be bad in Lebanon, but its even worse in Yemen with the civil war going on there. To make matters worse, separatists in the South have just declared independence there. There’s an interesting video analysing the Yemen secession crisis as well as a background explainer of Yemen's Civil War and US involvement in it: ua-cam.com/video/oqpHV3xBCBE/v-deo.html
I used to think history was a tragedy, but now I realize, it's a comedy.
Edit: please don't take me seriously. it's just a random joker reference
@@tokevarvaspolvi8999 you can be taken seriously after what is happening in Gotham.. I mean Minneapolis
The majority of humans care the most about sustenance. They concentrate on survival and nothing above, especially at critical moments. Are we that much above other animals? Not really.
Doing this in 20 minutes is really impressive.
I can do it in less!
The Killer for example?
Mike Dallor I would recommend a Documentary of the civil war it consists of 15 segments where each segment is about 50 mins long that I found to be very thorough and Way more interesting than many popular Netflix series lol ua-cam.com/video/9raBZZzcqqY/v-deo.html
There's a lot of things that are missing although till nowadays people will still think this is biased no matter what's the content, the conflict was ultimately complicated
Stewie Griffin thanks bro.
Lebanon was one of the beautiful countries I have seen. Met with a few Arab Lebanese. They were good to me. Well mannered and soft spoken.
Yes. And if Lebanon rufuses to unite, they'll be their own fall.
@@sm3675 Geo politics at play with a hint of religion.
I’m Lebanese and I started watching this video to see what you get wrong and comment, but you’ve really done a great job. (And I can honestly say, as Lebanese people, we’re also still confused about what really happened).
Hi :)
Can you talk me a little about Lebanese society ?
Are you all united as Lebanese (regardless the religion ,each one of you belong to) ?
Do you all get along with each other , are very common intermarriages between Lebanese people of different religion Cathólics - suni - Shia - Orthodox ?
@@Unknown-vl4hl It depends on the person honestly as far as tolerance. But intermarriage is illegal unfortunately.
@@ryuugureen4969
Ohhh really ?
So sad .
I like Lebanon a lot and I plan to visit it soon .
You should take example from Albania .
The percentage of religions are similar to Lebanon ( half of people declared to have Mūslim background and other half Christian background (both Orthodox and Catholic)).
We never had a problem because of religion.
Simply because , more than 80% of people are Athèists or Agnostic in practice ( they don't practice any religion).
Intermarriages are extremely common, we don't care what religion background the other person have .
In Albania it's a TABOO to ask the other person , what his religion is .
It's sad that foreign powers try to destabilize Lebanon and divide Lebanese people
@@Unknown-vl4hl no. There is a lack to trust between everyone.
@@ryuugureen4969 what? It is not illegal, but it is not viewed in a good way by society. My cousin is actually married to a woman from a different religion
Just when you think you have it all figured out, geopolitics throws another curveball.
But I haven't even figured out anything :D
Then you haven't seen Yemen which has been hit by a triple whammy of a separatist crisis, civil war AND CORONVIRUS.Theres an interesting a video analysing the Yemen secession crisis, it's impact on the PANDEMIC as well as a background explainer of Yemen's Civil War and US involvement in it: ua-cam.com/video/oqpHV3xBCBE/v-deo.html
You mean keep the chaos going not only in Lebonon but the whole region!
Lebanon is the Bosnia & Herzegovina equivalent of the Middle East.
It's completely different Bosnia didn't have a civil war,she was attack by serbs and croatians inside and outside from Bosnia.
way worse...
Lebanon alone was rather the entire Balkans.
@@faridbang9432 How exactly three ethnic groups/nations living and fighting in the same country is not a civil war? Croatia and Serbia were heavily involved but were not in direct war with Bosnia, they had there proxies but so were the others countries.
I believe the analogy is meant to convey a tendency to shatter or “Balkanize” within Lebanon, and similarly based on religious lines.
Lebanon would be best off if it could manage a strong central government to A keel militias in check and B keep foreign powers, which support these various groups at times, out. That’s a major problem they have is everyone around Lebanon want to keep messing with them.
Lived in Lebanon for 11 years, saw the scars of that conflict every day but never understood the jumbled mess of the history. Thank you Sirvan for the clarity and conciseness but it's still hardly any clearer.
Do not be stupid, all conflict on the planet is either ethinicly based, finacially based or relgiously based!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! Lebanon is no different!!!!!!!
@@tomstaples144
or any combination of the three.
@@tomstaples144 Religious based includes "For spreading Liberalism and secular human rights like democracy"
This video leaves a lot of stuff out. The fighting in Lebanon started AFTER the Palestinian Liberation Organization moved there and brought their weapons from Jordan . FYI, the PLO was kicked out of Jordan in 1970 because they started a revolt there and tried to over throw the Jordanian government. 26,000 Palestinians died in that rebellion. THAT should also have been mentioned in this video, but was not.
This video should have also mentioned that the reason the Christians were given more seats in the government was because they had the bigger population. But it was not mentioned here. It makes it seem as though the problems started because of the division of power. It did not. Lebanon was a beautiful and thriving place in the 1950s and 1960s, until the Palestinian Liberation Organization moved there after they were kicked out of Jordan for starting a war there as well.
That, too, should have been mentioned in this video
Americans: God, the Syrian civil war is so confusing!
Lebanon: Am I a joke to you?
Libya: Hello there
The balkan: Amateurs
For all of you "woke" people out there. All of these conflicts including the Lebanese and Syrian Civil wars were created and planned by USA and NATO. To weaken these countries and protect "Israel". Coming from a Lebanese.
Syrian also more confusing because there are multinational terrorist named ISIS and many vilubteer join ISIS or other militias (ypg etc)
@@pogchamp2897 Not even close. I don't know about Balkan people emmigrating to the Near/Middle East on the contrary there are Middle Easterners moving to the Balkans since forever.
@@steadyandready6795 created I wouldn't say, but supported/ignored would be correct.
Although thinking about it the CIA have shown to be sick f's...
Beirut incident: happens
UA-cam: you wanna learn the shit Lebanon faced before that tragedy?
Ouch
@John D then tell us your great truth messiah
Everytime we say shit can't get worse in this country it does... we're the most cursed country on the world and I have yet to figure out why because we never hurt anyone, it's always others that hurted us and still are. Just pray for lebanon man💔🇱🇧🙏
discord.gg/at4bk3Ut
My dad grew up in this in the 80s btw
As a Lebanese native, I feel it's rewarding to get a western point of view about the Lebanese war, we thought it ended, but looks like all parties are ready for it again. There is a 30 years time lapse since physically no more war, but you can truly make many other documentaries about those 30 years. Good work.
One of the best UA-cam channel.... Worth too much.
Aye
Should never have let those palestinians in
As if they were the true cause?! No, if you read further, you’ll see the root cause was injustice suffered by Muslims and others who weren’t Maronite Catholics! Money and power in the hands of this group, favoring this group politically, and channeling money to their areas while everyone else suffered! Is this fair?! Pls read abt Danny Chamoun and how he mocked the Muslims of West Beirut (as opposed to “French and upscale East Beirut”) there were many factors for the war, including Palestinians, but historians like Robert Fisk say tensions were boiling over before they even got there!
@@handsanitiser9832wrong, and they should not have kicked Palestinians from their homes in the first place, kissinger promised them Lebanon and the Christians leaves for US and Canada. This what kicked started the Civil war
@@zik0v Nope, you're negating what was happening in Beirut years before they came in. The stark corruption at the hands of Maronite Catholics, wherein tensions were boiling over between the groups. Go read about how Beirut was increasingly becoming dangerous at night b/c people were hungry. Or the Sidon fisherman revolts. Or how Tripoli was (and still is) a "forgotten city" wherein efforts to circumvent a port there stemmed from--you guessed it--those in charge. Again, if you read you wouldn't even be posting in the first place. Is it a coincidence the biggest calls for M uslim unity are coming from Lebanon? Or how, considering how things were going in Lebanon at the time, heck, it's not that the welcomed them, it's that they didn't have the means of stopping them! They lived in squalor and many died from disease. Whatever was promised them obviously wasn't communicated, b/c the still live in refugee camps to this day, no?
@@handsanitiser9832to my knowledge is that those areas you named were controlled by Muslims feudal lords, in which Moussa Sadr per example conducted many charity organizations to liberate the southerners from their grips, what got Maronites have to do with it, if they at fault, it isn't that they over-reached, it's that they did the opposite.
As for Tripoli, you know the power shifted many times in Lebanon and still forgotten as before, why didn't we see it become remembered in the Hariri era?
As for the biggest calls for Unity it's because the civil war and division took toll on the Lebanese public, what use did division and sectarianism do?
Do you want me to name the calamities that happened in this country for the better half of a century?
Hello Caspian, as a Lebanese I must say that this is one of the most objective documentaries of the Lebanese civil war I have ever seen. This is a conflict that is still present in the Lebanese mentality and political scenario. Excellent work!
it's honestly heartbreaking. Imagine losing 15 years of your life as a civilian. 15 years. My mother lived this war from 5 to hear 20 years of age. god
Along with losing friends, family, proper sleep etc. Sad
Israel and the maronite traitors
A close family friend since i was born fled from Lebanon but did partake in fighting in the conflict, he never talked about it EVER we all just knew. He had brought back a souvenir, a 100mm shell he now uses as a doorstop in the hallway. All i knew was that he would have these horrible nightmares from time to time, now atleast, i understand a little more what he must have gone through.
Thanks for the vid!
Im not sure if he brought back that 100mm shell? How could he have brought it back exactly?
@@paulbrajuha6555 Probably just an empty casing from a fired shell.
Ironic now that Syria is on the receiving end, so sad
Things may be bad in Syria and Lebanon, but its even worse in Yemen with the civil war going on there. To make matters worse, separatists in the South have just declared independence there. There’s an interesting video analysing the Yemen secession crisis as well as a background explainer of Yemen's Civil War and US involvement in it: ua-cam.com/video/oqpHV3xBCBE/v-deo.html
@@drunkensailor3736 It's really unfortunate how little attention the yemeni civil war has had.
@@drunkensailor3736 US is involved in everything just like Russia and China...Yemeni people should stop forwarding Iran's proxy warfare and take care of their own interests....I don't like Saudis but in this case I can totally understand how Iran is trying to choke and control Saudi access to the sea by blocking both ends of the Arabian Peninsula with their proxies in Yemen..
nikita gold But there was no chemical massacres in yemen, some of the worst massacres in the 21st century happened in Syria. That’s plus the fact that half the population of syria are refugees according to the UN which is not the case in yemen.
@@mayarkaze6141 This is no way to measure how war affects human lives, Syria got media coverage and a ton of propaganda spewed on every news and media outlet Yemen barely gets any attention as the conflict directly affects a huge US ally namely Saudi Arabia thus is would be better to quell coverage as there is nothing to be gained from it politically unless you're on Iran's side. Atrocities have been committed in both countries but that doesn't mean *Chemical Massacres* are the measure of which one should receive media coverage, this goes to prove that you only see what *they* want you to see not everything and certainly not the truth its always muddied by all the events and propaganda of the various sides concerned. And fyi 3+ million people have taken refuge outside of Syria in the conflict from a population of 22 million, granted that is significant, but please there's no need to exaggerate so much.
UA-cam algorithm engagement comment. Coz Shirvan said so.
Feeding the YT algo because it was hungry!
I'm doing my part!
PLO is a cancer destroying countries in the Middle East
Let's go more conments
same
Feeling sorry for lebanese Christians.
*May lord will bring light to Lebanon.*
❤
Your religion only brings darkness , hate and Genocides , while you preach bes tolerance .
Yes because God definitely gives a shit
Is Shirvan, the host, Islamic?
✝️❤🇱🇧
It is the PLO; they are the root of suffering in Lebanon and in Palestine.
PALESTINE and Lebanon were one country before the British and French Colonies, and the reason of all these. Because Sykes Biko and Balfour promised
It was and still conspiracy against arm struggle against PLO and not against those who betrayed
@@fadiabdulah8883 There was no state in the region before the modern day states: just a handful of imperial occupiers.
@@fadiabdulah8883 PLO actually relocated to South Lebanon after Black September in Jordan in attempt to bring communism to the former British mandates. In the midst of the conflict, they fled to Tunisia. No one would’ve started a conflict if it weren’t for worries about PLO.
@@HappyGuy-cn9po I know this and what you are saying I knew it
thanks shirvan i've been waiting for this
As a Lebanese this is not bad for a 20 minute video. Lots of stuff missing but major timeline is explained pretty good. You should be teaching in a university.
sorry for the late reply but why don't you produce a video filling in some of the missing info?
Do you have any books that goes in further detail to the conflict?
I dated a Lebanese girl a long time ago. I liked her a lot!... (his dad didnt)
@@dv2045 You're lucky. I think Lebanese women are gorgeous.
@@arnaldogonzalez1678If you're into middle(near) eastern history/politics, you may check out "jabzy" or "casual historian". I think the later has a two hour version for this conflict.
Rewind every 20 seconds, still losst
It took me 45 min to goes through a 19 min vid
jeesh. I guess Arab history is confusing to others
@@OmarSlloum is it confusing for you aswell? ;)
This is a topic that I have no problem in admitting that I need it in a drawing to understand. This level of complexity represents a challenge to my atention spam.
I don't blame you, this is probably the most confusing war of the 20th century
My dad had to fight in this war. It was the worst time of his life.
Sad to hear.
Was he FORCED to fight?
Same here, my parents and family friends always avoid speaking of those times as its too painful to remember. I remember once they drank a bit too much and started sharing war stories and I was absolutely horrified at what they had to go through as teenagers and young adults. War is hell is an understatement of that war.
Mine fought in it too. To keep the peace for the United Nations. He played cards on a post for ten months and nothing happened. Guess he kept the peace.
@James Adams it wasn't that simple, groups weren't divided simply along religious lines. Christians fought Christians (Kataeb, Ahrar, Tiger forces, Lebanese forces, Aoun's 8th Infantry Brigade, Marada, Hobeika are but of a few of the Christian groups/leaders who alternatively fought, allied with, or forcefully integrated, each other), Muslims fought Muslims (whether Amal versus Hezbollah who are both Shiite Mulsim, or the various Sunni groups like the Murabitouns, the Palestinians of the PLO, or the Syrians who are considered Muslim overall) and Druze more or less fought and/or allied with all other factions at one moment or another, including Israel, the Palestinians, Syria, and Lebanese groups from all sects.. sorry for the long /disorganized post but I did my best trying to sum it up yet still it's only the tip of the tip of the iceberg
So Lebanon is a good example of why other Arab countries are smart to not allow Palestinian refugees.
@omorfia5726
စောက်ပေါ
This is the first time I’ve taken an depth look at the conflict and you seemed very thorough in your analysis. Appreciate the time and effort you put into this I learned a lot. Thank you!
As a Lebanese, thank you for this informing video and bringing this information to the world.
As an israeli , it makes me so sad to see how the beautiful country of lebanon, the pearl of the middle east , with its green landscape and blue beachs , deteriorated to such a mess. Im no historian and all i know is that in the 80's israel invaded lebanon twice , aiming to creat a buffer zone between israel and lebanon , in order to protect us from the raiding of hostile groups in lebanon. The consequence of these actions r still visible in israel , as during our withdrewal israel took in many lebanese refugees of the South Lebanon Army.
I really hope Lebanon will recuperate from all this mess and hope to reinstall relations between us 🇮🇱❤🇱🇧
Inshallah..
Well... this aged well... since you're trying to steal out wealth now and all
Your Army Committed a War Crime int he Village of Qana. There will no relation with baby killers. It would be in our Heart. Your Army killed innocent in Qana. You think We will forget? No we won't. Your Army is Babies Killer not only in Lebanon also in Palestine (Gaza). and those Lebanese who Live in Israel They are Traitors. They run away Like Rats after Your Army Withdraw Defeated and Humiliated.
You took traitors
Hopefully one day israel and lebanon could recognize each other as sovereign states 🇱🇧🤝🏻🇮🇱
I enjoyed your analysis as always, but I think you left out a very important point. That is, the changing demographics of Lebanon. Where once the Maronite Christians where the majority, that has (probably) changed significantly over the last few decades, and hence the political structure of the government is under strain.
@@islamisthetruth3402 no he is right in 1920 the population of Lebanon under french mendate was 51% Christian
Guys sources...
@@islamisthetruth3402 lol no hahaha the guy is right
They still are 30% of lebanon is Maronites
@@akeelhoteit6888 45%
Now I understand why a Lebanese I've met said Lebanon is a strange country. I really failed to understand what he meant😧 So sad indeed but he was such a nice man.
The 13 april 1975 bus massacre that ignitated the war was a response to the assassination attempt of the christian leader pierre gemayel earlier that day.
Palestinians wanted to make lebanon their new palestine. Yasser aarafat used to say that "the road to jerusalem passes through jounieh (a lebanese city)"
Syria never accepted lebanon's independance and always considered it a syrian province. The main reason of the syrians entry in lebanon was trying to annex it to syria. They played a divide and conquer game in lebanon switching sides everytime a group is taking over to keep every group weak and divided which enabled syria to control lebanon more easily.
Kamal jumblatt was assasinated by Syria
You didn't mention the zahle war in 1981, where syrians besieged the christian town of zahle for 90 days, pounding it with rockets at a rate of 3 rockets per minute sometimes. The inhabitants of zahle aided by christian militias sent from beirut defended the town and forced the syrians to lift the siege.
Bachir gemayel was voted president on 23 august 1982, which should have ended the civil war because he was lebanon's strong man with a nationalistic stand that earned the respect of every lebanese from every group and from the foreign armies that were present on lebanese lands, whether it was the syrians or israelis, to get out of lebanon in the upcoming months. His assassination 3 weeks later created a huge vaccum which reagnited the war and changed the whole country's landscape forever. Lebanon has yet to recover his loss. His brother amine gemayel, who is viewed as much weaker and less respected, was voted president a couple of days later.
You didn't mention the 1983 mountain war, where an alliance of leftitsts, syria and remaining palestinian refugees kicked out the christian inhabitants from the mixed shouf area by massacring thousands of christians along their way.
You didn't mention the 1986 lebanese forces intifada, where samir geagea overthrew the lebanese forces leader elie hobeika after signing an agreement with the syrians that was refused by most of the christians.
Amine gemayel's presidency ended in 1988. After his presidency's end, a military government was created and commanded by the christian general of the lebanese army, michel aoun, who de facto had the power of a president and a prime minister combined, enraging the muslims, who's the prime minister seat was reserved to them.
Finally and most importantly, you didn't mention the devastating intra-christian war, opposing the michel aoun forces to the christian lebanese forces militia commanded by samir geagea: The 1989 taif aggreement was supposed to end the war by stripping the christian lebanese president some power and giving it to the sunni prime minister and by giving a 50/50 quota between christians and muslims in the parliament and the government. Samir geagea and most of the muslim militias accepted the deal, while michel aoun strongly opposed it. This started a intra-christian war between aoun's and geagea's forces, destroying the christian areas and forcing 800 000 christians to flee lebanon. This war, which was named the "elimination war", weakened the until then strong christian front which paved the way for the syrian invasion of christian areas, which were until then free of syrian soldiers for the entierety of the war. A decessive battle on 13 october 1990 saw a syrian led invasion of the presidential palace in baabda, where aoun was enclaved, aided by a joint lebanese forces and muslim militias alliance, defeated the forces of aoun, forcing him to flee to france, where he remained until the end of the syrian occupation of lebanon which lasted until 2005. The fleeing of aoun marked the end of the civil war and the beginning of the syrian occupation of lebanon which controlled every aspect of lebanese politics and is viewed as a very oppressive occupation, censuring any news outlet that dared oppose it and assassinating dozens of anti-syrian politicians, journalists and figures, namely pierre gemayel (bachir's nephew and amine gemayel's son), gebran tueni, samir kassir, georges hawi, rafiq hariri and many others. Samir geagea, the lebanese forces militia leader, was thrown in prison in 1994 for his anti- syria view, which created a gap in the christan leadership as all their leaders were either killed(bachir, dany chamoun,...) in exile (michel aoun, amine gemayel) or in prison (samir geagea). After prime minister rafic lhariri's assasination in 2005, huge anti syrian protests named "the cedar revolution" saw a million people protesting against the syrian occupation. After huge international pressure, the syrians were forced to pull out of lebanon, thus giving the chance to the exiled anti-syrian leaders (aoun and amine) to come back to lebanon and the release of samir geagea from prison. Once syria left, the power vaccum was filled by the powerful iranian proxy militia, hezbollah, who has been rulling the country ever since. In order to reach the presidency, michel aoun decided to side with hezbollah. Even though fiercely opposing it at first, he knew he needed its backing to reach his goals. This alliance created 2 major fronts in lebanon. The 8 march alliance, composed by the shia parties amal and hezbollah and the the christian FPM led by aoun, were pro syria and iran and opposed the west and the gulf countries. On the other hand, there was the 14 march alliance, composed by the sunni future party, led by saad lhariri, rafic lhariri's son, the christian lebanese forces party, led by samir geagea and the druze progressive party, led by kamal jumblatt's son, walid jumblatt. These are pro-west and gulf countries and strongly opposed to the hezbollah arms, calling for the army to be the sole protector of the lebanese lands, while the 8 march camp supports the hezbollah arms, calling it a "resistance" against israel. In 2016, michel aoun was voted president and in 2018, parliamentery elections gave the majority to the march 8 camp. Ever since, lebanon was hit hard by american sanctions, because the USA considers hezbollah a terrorist organization who took lebanon hostage of its arms. These sanctions, combined with massive corruption, created a big economical crisis, triggering the lebanese revolution of october 2019, that is still ongoing today. The economical crisis has only worsen since and 1 US dollar today equals 8000 lebanese lira, up from 1500 lebanese lira before the start of the revolution. And here is where lebanon is today, at the brink of a war, economical collapse and stuck between 2 giant powers competing over the control of the region: USA and Iran. A big big support for my lebanese brothers going through these hard times in lebanon from a fellow lebanese brother living in montreal! Much love! We got ur backs! Better days are coming, don't give up! At the end of the day, we have been present on this land for 6000 years and nobody was able to kick us out, it's not today that they will!!❤🇱🇧🙏💪
I'm curious to know what your predictions for Lebanon's future are?
bro wen ma bittala3 btotla3 inta bwejje khalik b toronto
@@mar1446 it's only a question of time before a war errupts between hezbollah and israel, and this time hezbollah will be defeated. After its defeat, a peace deal could be reached with israel and we could finally live in peace.
@@haithamskin809 montreal*. Glad I have fans now❤
THANK YOU! Any TRUE Lebanese person will tell you that Lebanon was a peaceful and prosperous country until Muslims became the majority.
Ah, Sykes-Picot keeps on giving. Thanks, Britain and France!
Thanks to the Sykes-Pikot agreement Lebanon was finally independent after 3000 years of getting conquered.
@@theredstonesword9293 Lebanon was never a nation prior to the agreement, and was forced to become one! Therein lies the biggest issue.
El Bandito
Lebanon is an extension of Mont Lebanon, which is dominated by Maronites.
Lebanon was built for the last Christians in the middle east, as myself.
France wasn't bad compared to the dumb British who drew straight lines everywhere. This video wrongfully blames France for the civil war but they had nothing to do with it. Now all the stupid americans in the comment section are acting like experts of the region as always
Before France even arrived in the Levant, Lebanese people (mostly Christians in Mount-Lebanon, to be more specific) signed a petition and sent a delegation from Mount Lebanon (the precursor to modern-day Lebanon) to the Paris Peace Conference to ask for a Lebanese state, independent from both Ottoman and Arab rule (there was a plan to create a large pan-Arab country, but even before the British and the French foiled it, the people of Mount-Lebanon wanted nothing to do with it).
Such a shame what’s happened to this beautiful country. I wish Lebanon and Syria peace. Love from Iraq
And I wish you the same, love from Lebanon
@@FreeGumFighter same here, I knew a lebanese girl who really hated to mention the subject of the Lebanese civil war thats why I never talked about it much around her, seemed to bring about a lot of anger especially concerning the tribe that must not be named and she is a Shia. Although Im sure the west definitely took advantage of the situation as well, all part of the geopoltics show.
But yes I agree some of your comments above it was simply weak and a union could have protected the people who were basically forced to fight had they not been so divided. I can agree they were divided along religious lines but ethnically they were mostly the same people so its weird how the war still got so bloody; I mean they were not so diverse as say some countriues where we might see a true race war in the future like in Europe, UK or the USA where there is some real diversity going on in those nations.
I suppose it ranks up there as some of the other really bloody conflicts like Iran-Iraq war, the chechen-russian, Algiers and what occured after the breakup of Yugoslavia amongst others in Africa, SA.
Religion only divides.
@@karthikeyanm.v8381 I agree. People should accept Jesus as their Lord & Savior and put that religious foolishness behind them.
@@BillyJack85 I agree, people should accept islam as the true religion and ignore other fake ones
I honestly love this video, but as a Lebanese person I have to say that you really butchered the names 😂
honestly only one that was really butchered is how he was saying michael "aounoun" the first few times lol, but he did correct it near the end.
Leave him alone at least he is trying!
@@TheMMC001 exactly, the best explanation there is about Lebanon!
Aunum
Shirwan is an Iranian name.
France: hey man, you wanted independence😬
France leave minefields in all their colonies to say exactly what you said. And people still think Britain is the worst colonial power.
@@MsGreenlamp To be fair, the region had always be divided between different religious groups, and even under the Ottoman rule, Druzes, christians and turks often fought in the region
Let's promise them an Arab state and then divide them irreparably
1000 years later, and the Lebanese will still blame France instead of trying to clear their land from terrorist forces aka Hezbollah.
"The truth is, the game was rigged from the start"
as a lebanese i want to clarify that syria entered lebanon because of the ancient dream of a united syria that treats lebanon as part of it
it was invented by the lebanese gov of that time. it was a military invasion but after war tried to control many aspect of the country
How ancient is it though?
Assad actually disclosed the real reason in an interview ... it was basically what Shirvan said .
Uniting Lebanon and Syria was far from reality back then.
@@Rod-wi1ht
Got a link for the interview?
@@markenlightenment7101
to Clarify: There was a biography interview for Dr.Azmi Bishara . In it he tells the story when he met with Assad probably around 2000s in an effort to convince the Syrians not to give up a lot during the peace negotiations with Israel because Israel wasn't serious about making just peace . (his assessment was right ). Anyway he mentioned a couple of reasons in the interview that Assad said them to him about why he invaded Lebanon . moreover he wrote about them somewhere. Thats all I can remember , its easy to search for videos\articles of Bishara.
I only say this,beacuse the man has no reason to lie and his words are trustworthy. (unless your a conspiracy maniac type of guy ).
Dont get me wrong Syria is built on the idea of pan-Arabism and they claimed Lebanon all the time, but I dont think that was the real motive back then.
@@dodovomitory3496 dude it dates back waay before it... syria treats lebanon as a small region that belongs to it under the name سوريا الكبرى
So palestinians took refuge in lebanon, got armed and then attacked lebanese 🤦♂️
And I thought Syria was complicated. I wonder what would have happened in terms of length if you went into the subfactions.
Syria is a piece of cake in front of Lebanon. I'm a Lebanese and still don't get it all.
J. K. What do you mean?
@@hassooonnn6504 I mean if you think Syrian politics are complicated, Lebanon is 1000x worse.
@@hassooonnn6504 the syrian conflict is much simpler, there are (essentially) two factions : government v/s anti-government. Yes there are lots of subfactions within those blocs, and foreign support to different sides have influenced the outcomes, but the two major blocs are pretty clear-cut and participants have largely remained within their groups. In Lebanon there were dozens of groups split among various and fluid lines, whether political ideals, religions, leading families and alliances kept shifting. Where Israel occasionally bombs Syria, and Turks made some small incursions, in Lebanon both Syria and Israel went all-in and they had shifting alliances with local groups while the US & France also played a murky game
not to mention the government collapsed and was replaced several times, once with an israeli puppet president who was killed, other times by syrian puppets, and finally the power was shifted to prime minister and filled with a saudi puppet
The most confusing war in history
*Chinese civil war has entered the chat*
apperantly u never herd of When italians fought a bitter war over a bucket
I thought Syrian civil war was confusing enough.
@@rohanr.9714 Indian civil war joined the chat .
@@taufiqutomo Nah, is not that confusing since most of the rebels are foreign-backed and are usually takfiri fundamentalists that are against the secularism and tolerance on which the Syrian Arab Republic is based.
I was born in Beirut in 1975. My parents met there . I left in 1977. This is a good history video !
I'm up voting because of the title alone
What is wrong with the title?
Always great stuff from Shirvan. I wanna hear Caspian Report talk about the situation in Hong Kong. The Chinese are really exploiting the pandemic to fully takeover there. Found a great analysis on what's happening there and whether we're headed for a new Cold War: ua-cam.com/video/uMm67LHxR7M/v-deo.html
@@Jason-rk3xo nothing, it's perfect
Anywhere muslims go they bring war
Sad to hear that the "Pearl of the Orient" has fallen so far. I wish nothing but the best for all in Lebanon.
We will rise
Bilal Saad lol ive lost all hope for my country 😔
Karl man I wonder if this is what will happen to Hong long
Pearl of my ass
@@kaka3661able have you been there?
I visited Lebanon in 2019, truly a bizarre place for a westerner. This video was very useful to me as I am considering writing my masters thesis on ethnic conflict in Lebanon and Iraq and making sense of the former is really difficult. Thanks for the video
As a lebanese youtuber I agree with everything that has been said and I congratulate you for having successfully explained such a complex subject🔥🇱🇧
Why's your channel in French then?
hi kifak cava ? ;)
@@Napoleonpilled probably because Lebanon partially speak french...
@@FreeGumFighter ???
@@Napoleonpilled remember french colonisation
Here after the the explosion in Beirut.
yeah me too. people's brains these days are like peace in the middle-east; non-existential
Me too. P.S.- Beirut was the Paris of The East only 60 years ago. It was lovely and sophisticated.
Same...
@@BlankRami peace in the Middle East has never read Sartre
this makes it make more sense to me
As a Lebanese this was hard to watch.
Same bro same
It got me in a spiritual level 😖
Me too. I miss my homeland so much.
Same
I'm reading books about the Lebanese civil war and I can't even finish one complete page without feeling like fainting especially when you realize how perfect Lebanon was before this conspiracy
@@Phoenix-ho5kh what’s the book called?
I lost you at the part where you mentioned Lebanon.......
This is soooooo complicated!
Who here after the explosion??
Exactly
just came see this
Yea im trying to figure out who did that bomb and I have no clue what's going on but my guess some other country are probably involved in this.
@@jc-zp1de it was by itself theres no country envolved in this rip all these lebanons who died
Me
Thank you for the detailed breakdown, it has been pretty hard to puzzle together.
I saw it on the Lebanon Subreddit before my notification even popped up!
Lebanese here, if anyone has questions.
Very accurate video! But you understated some stuff: The Israeli army, while occupying lebanon, tortured and killed hundreds of Lebanese people, which lead to most of them joining the resistance against them. Also, the Syrian regime and the PLO often had multiple check points attacking innocent lebanese people and abducting them for torture. Many lebanese are still missing to these days with the Syrians still refusing to give information about them. The lebanese people were and still are the greatest victim with the regional power struggle.
Well said
who did they torture?
True
Cap and there's no proof of that. My dad recounted stories of him in war and Palestinian threw grenade into civilian home and almost killed him. Then palestone commit the first war crimes before any major event. The big massacre could be over exxaggetred form yassar atarafat. My dad doesn't remember any crimes that Israel did and only sluggish palestian military offense
Amazingly narrated and analyzed. As Lebanese, we struggle to understand our own history, you've done an amazing job at putting the highlights together. Thank you.
Really great video! As a Lebanese I have to say you did a great job with this, there are some very key parts that are missing (PLA war crimes which sparked that Maronite attack, Soviet proxies that caused all sides to fight together to defeat them then went back to killing each other) but honestly the civil war is such an absolute mess that I applaud you for being able to piece it together as you did. Even schools in Lebanon barely bother teaching the full extent of the war as it is so polarizing and ridiculously complex. All in all great work!
this is a comment, algorithm do your thing
I will give you a hand. Hello Algorithm
hello algorithm
hello algo lets rithm
I
Hello algorithm
Never take too much refugees
The bus holding palastenians who was shot at was not ambushed! This bus passed by a very well known Christian controlled area carrying palestinian militia members with full uniform, holding machine guns out of the windows while blasting palestinian revolutionary songs. All of this was a few days after a car with palestinian militants inside, opened fire and killed 3 unarmed christian militia members leaving the church after a sunday service.
spin spin sugar
@@papakael8247 that's the truth 😊
It was the same day actually
Lebanon: falls for civil war
UN:
Syria: gets involved
UN:
Israel: gets involved
UN: we strongly recommend you cease your aggression and withdraw
Excellent. I lived in Beirut during most of the civil war and this report provides a balanced and clear understanding of a very complex situation.
I remember hearing news stories about Lebanese Civil War when I was younger. I never understood about the confliict, let alone understood who was fighting. I remember the truck bomb killing 241 marines. Thank you so much for making sense of this "Insane War.
I’m not sure but I’m guessing that there isn't even a memorial at the location of the Marine barracks where 241 Americans were murdered. From the Lebanese you don't get remorse or gratitude. _I don't care about Lebanon. No aid._
I lived in Lebanon for a year.
You can kinda feel the uneasiness between all the groups depending on where you go. Just don't talk about religion, politics and travel to south Lebanon and you'll be fine.
Lebanon does have some of the most beautiful women in the world.
I've never met a women with red or gold eyes before.
My wife is lebanese
@@elijahmonreal1027 Does she have beautiful red eyes?
@@menumlor9365 I was there 3 weeks and I left with headache, and a sad, strong, beautiful, gold eyes girl in the heart. Sajida, I will never forget you
@@micocyan My man.
what's wrong with South lebanon 🤔
I can't even imagine the amount of research that has gone into making this video. I thank you for bringing this into light and I hope peace will eventually find its way to this corner of the Earth.
Not that much he got a lot wrong
Lebanon has the best food in the Middle East #Fact
Tru
Absolutely!
name 3 dish's then.
Oh man, the same food as Syria and the same Palestinian food too
Must be the colonial French influence I guess🤔
Did my mom really live through this whole mess?
cherish your mum she is certainly a hero
My mom was at Dahmour when the Dahmour massacre happened my grandpa had to fight with the dahmour men to give time for the women and children to escape they all escaped on a boat at the end. This was a bloody war your mom is a hero
My parents did. My grandpa was shot in the leg. My parents relocated twice. My dad was a young boy who volunteered in training with Lebanese Front. It was brutal especially when my parents were kids who witnessed brutal murders.
Lmao i thought the same about my dad! He was only 10 in 1979
Actually she died many times over(emotionally) but didnt tell you to have ambitions for your country.
Ironically being colonized gave you peace and being independence gave you chaos.
My grandfather left Lebanon before the start of the civil war. I never knew him, so this is all I have of that part of his life. Thanks for making this video
Fellow ex-Lebanese your country is evolving every year, visit it and enjoy what's left of it
You forgot to mention that Shias where aligned with Israel at the begining of the war. They were even throwing rice at Israeli soldiers as a sign of welcome. The Iranian revolution made them switch sides.
It was actually the occupation that made them switch, Initially the Israelis were welcomed as liberators b/c the Shiites thought they wouldn't stay long, however as the Israeli occupation continued, the locals turned on them.
well even at the end some shias were fighting for the South Lebanon Army that was allied with Israel. Truth is if you don't do your own research you will never understand thid conflict and you can see that judging by the comments here but to make it easy for the americans reading this. this wasn't a religious war. christians were killing christians as much as muslims were killing muslims. it was driven by ideologies
Lobster Man
The occupation was a mistake. Just like the Iraq war, soldiers didn’t know what they were doing in this country. Had no mission.
Just because some people threw rice at the Israeli soldiers doesn't mean that the shias were aligned with Israel.
@@alih3254 most of them were. Coming from a southerner
Im lebanese and would like to thank you for everything you have done to get it so accuratly and for putting in time to make this video , Ive just subscribed good luck
I've watched this video 15 times and it is still confusing.
@@craigthecraig9176
Ironically, the conflict began when Christian factions attempted to dominate the entire country after French colonial rule.
Great video! A bit superficial but it's very complicated so I can't blame you. Cheers from Lebanon!
I know what you mean, but I had to make it work within a short timeframe. So, the subplot was left out.
@@CaspianReport thank you for doing the best job possible
@@CaspianReport this is a great effort. I've followed you for years and always learn something new when I watch your videos. Keep up the excellent work!
Hey Kameel. I'd like to read more about the subplots that were not mentioned in the video but am not sure what to look for online. Any heads up for these subplots I can look for?
@@ht-cr3ms There's no one book that explains it all, you'll need to read multiple books because there are multiple perspectives. Unlike other wars, there's no definite consensus on winners or losers and who was right or wrong. Best option is talking to a bunch of lebanese people and piece together your own opinion, but I'm in lebanon so I'm to be able to do so.
Nice video bro, btw bachir hay fina
2ila l2abad🇱🇧🇱🇧🇱🇧🇱🇧❤❤❤❤
If Bachir wasn't assassinated our country would be perfect right now
based
Lebanon is like all arab countries squeezed in one box
But they aren’t even arab
Rick Yes they are, they speak arabic
@@Rick-qc9xt They are XD
@@Rick-qc9xt By that logic just use the word for all people living in North Africa, and around the Sahara Belt as Arabs. Nice leap of logic.
Rick You are correct my friend, they/ we are Phoenicians
Solid overview, my only comment has to do with the title, it wasn’t a civil war, just a war. The PLO was a foreign, armed force encrusted in Lebanon waging war from its territory, which created all sorts of conflicts resulting in the involvement of multiple foreign forces. Syria, Iraq, Israel, the US, France, the UN - it was a war first, a civil war second.
Except it's a civil war because that's how most of the country viewed it and continues to do so. Foreign intervention is typical in geopolitics, and that includes civil wars. PLO wasn't a foreign entity per SE because it was deeply tied and tangled with local nationalist groups. Even within the same religious sect there's plenty of tensions and killings. For example on thing this video misrepresents is Shia lebanese who quickly split into two major sides: amal and hezbollah. There were plenty of wars fought between these two and to this day plenty of trauma within families who's different members split different ways. This video is good for 20 minutes but keep in mind he glossed over more than two decades of conflict, and it is primarily civil war and conflict worsened and taken advantage of by foreign entities
I like you
Lebanon is such a beautiful country, one of the best I've ever been to. It's sad to see what happened there so recently.
A few inaccuracies:
1. The Cairo Agreement was signed in 1969, not 1970.
2. The South Lebanese army was, contrary to popular belief, not mostly Christian, but mostly Shia, as they constituted 2/3 of the entire army.
3. The Taef Agreement had MAJOR changes to the Lebanese political and governmental scene, as the Parliament had now a 5:5 ratio between muslims and Christians, and the executive powers shifted entirely from the Maronite Presidential Seat to the Sunni Prime Minister.
4. Part of Lebanese Forces *debatably* went rogue and executed the Sabra and Shattila massacres, but big LF figures like Elie Hobeika (Head of the LF Intelligence) and Joseph Edde were held responsible.
But all in all, as a Lebanese myself, I loved this video. Till this day, this is arguably one of, if not, the most accurate representations of the Lebanese Civil War on the UA-cam platform.
I applaud you. Much love.
Well the Majority of SLA High Officers Were Christians. The Founder is Christians. in south Lebanon there is Towns with Majority Christians. Such as Ain Ebel. Qaouzah. Rmaich. Many Lebanese in those Town Were recruited to SLA. And when they Collapse after Israel Withdraw from South . There is 1000 Of SLA member are now live in Israel and they all 100% Christians. They are traiter.
@@mohammadbazzi3072 70% members of the sla were shiia noss bnt jbeil kenet b la7d shaklak nesse m3almak l jalbout 3a 7ejez bet ya7oun
I spent 10 years of my childhood in the Middle East, the best food overall in the Arab world is Lebanese, period! Many countries have national dishes that are also amazing but if you have a street of middle eastern restaurants and have no other recomendations, the Lebanese restaurant is the one to bet on. I was only briefly in Lebanon, Lebanon's natural beauty and greenery is the stuff of legends, the Cedars of Lebanon are giant trees that are the definitive cedars by which all cedars of the world are judged, California Redwoods & Cypress are cousins of the Cedars of Lebanon and the former are the only trees in the world to eclipse the mythology of the Cedars of Lebanon.
So much of world history passed through Lebanon, what is amazing is how many majestic oceanfront ruins still stand today through all the civil wars
We can thank the Maronite Christians and muslim Druze for the preservation of past cultures, the virus of Hezbollah is almost as debilitating as the zombie infection of hosts that ISIS and Al Queda islam cause their hosts, eliminating the infection of ISIS and Hezbollah is a thankless and gruesome job but will hopefully eradicate the deadly virus.
as a canadian i fell i should highlight how much of our money whent to these wars via black market transactions. very well known that profits from drug sales would be sent to buy goods for malitias
Lebanon is the perfect experiment to see if Christian, Shia, and Sunni can live together in relatively equal numbers.
*without talking
The sultans of Cordoba had great border control and received plenty of immigration most of wich took a few generations before conversion with little issues before the reconquista.
Obviously Germany isn't religious to that extend but the Berlin City Council (were Catholics and Muslims are unifyed as "conservative" minority) underlines how not religion but communication is so devastating.
Ps. France could have done some "pice building" or even started a federal structure less likely to cause a struggle for hegemony.
@@fionafiona1146 honestly, those examples are not very good. Al-Andalous was not really peaceful nor great for Christians, and it happened in a premodern world that doesn't exist anymore. Contemporary Germany is better but the numbers are very different between Christians and Muslims, and the country is highly secular. Maybe a better example would be Guyana and Surinam.
Surprise they can't
@@anthonywakim2480 they can, it was an outside force that started the war. before it was a good country that everyone remembers fondly of but later destabilized by arabists. shame on you talking about your countrymen like that. if you don't like them why did you ask france to include Muslim lands for greater lebanon?
when christians were the slight majority in power, lebanon was a thriving economy, the best in the middle east without having any oil reserves. when the majority muslims palestinians came and the lebanese muslims sided with them, hell descended
I feel a lot of commentors don't give you enough credit for sqeeuzing this much information in a small time frame. It's a balancing act where you also have to keep the impact of your content in mind, as to not 'pick sides' by highlighting one event and/or party over another. As usual, great job to everyone who works on this channel!
Things just got even more confusing
People in Beirut running away from the explosion.
*ua-cam.com/video/w2k-Yy7uDTM/v-deo.html*
My whole family came to America a few years after the civil war, and we’ve been hoping ever since that Lebanon would bounce back to its former glory... it breaks my heart to see my country like this 🥺
Many Lebanese also came to Brazil. I think it's hard for a small country as Lebanon in a region like the middle east to be stable.
F. OPE yes I’ve heard Brazil has one of the largest (if not the largest) Lebanese population outside of Lebanon. Until the economy and political situation gets better I don’t think any of us are going to be moving back to Lebanon though
@@matthewsebaaly8484 yeah but most came here even before the war. Honestly, I don't think there'll be a lot of retournés anyway, I know maybe two cases of people who came since the 70s going back but there's still more people coming in than returning, and as time passes and people settle here returning becomes more unlikely.
Same bro, my family came after the war to Africa and I swear not one day has passed since I was about 8 where I haven’t thought about Lebanon. Regardless of the problems I love it and I hope to return next year. Even though I’m currently In a ‘stable’ country compared to Lebanon, I feel I need to return to experience what Lebanon goes through
The Maronites are traitors
lebanon people: you have freed us!
hezbollah: oh, i wouldnt say "freed", more like "under new management".
@@m-hellothere4167 good joke!
there is 100 things wrong with hezbollah but i give you only one example.
why hezbollah is not joining lebanon army? why keep a organization inside a country when they DONT take orders from the country?
there is no explanation for hezbollahs actions, as long as they dont join lebanons army they are a iranian puppet that has no legitimacy in any country.
Mahdi Ismail hezbollah are not pro Lebanese. They are puppets for the Iranian regime just like Assad. If what you said about every faction receiving their share after the war, why aren’t the kataeb, the Lebanese forces, tayyar, the PSP etc. allowed to have their own armies? Lebanon should have one armed force that stands for Lebanon. Not a militia funded by outsiders that carries out their orders. If they are so pro Lebanese why are they fighting in Syria? The real Lebanese patriots are all dead cause they didn’t follow the orders or agendas of Syria, Iran or even Israel.
@@maskedsardine1772 without Hezbollah, Lebanon will be a part of the Greater Israel's land... Lebanon's national army is useless, everyone know that...
@@m-hellothere4167
1) hezbollah takes no order from the gov and they dont even inform the gov about anything they are doing. hezbollah is totally independent militia that doesnt care about the country.
2)all the parties in lebanon came to a agreement on how to divide the power between the parties so that there wont be another civil war. only hezbollah is outside that agreement and does what ever they want.
there wont be a civil war again!
3)when i say hezbollah must join the army that means give their weapons and soldiers to the army. that will make the army powerfull enough to protect the country.
4)do you really believe Iran's Supreme Leader? he isnt capable of lying?
after israel left lebanon (in year 2000) hezbollah lost any legitimacy to exist outside of the army, that means that this organization exist 20 year without any legitimacy.
the only explanation for why hezbollah is not joining the army is that hezbollah dont want to ask permission from lebanon gov to attack israel. they want to force lebanon to go to war against israel even if they dont want too, like they did in 2006.
in 2006 (6 year after israel left lebanon) hezbollah decided to kill and kidnapp 2 israeli soldiers without any permission from lebanons goverment. they forced a war on lebanons people, a war that lebanons people didnt wanted.
@@milliyetci5672 so why not joining the army and make it usefull?
Very good video, thanks. Israel's success in 48 (and 67), plus the end of British and French rule, gave the peoples of the Levant an EXCELLENT reason to dial down inter-tribal grievances and establish cooperative or at least not overtly hostile relations to allow them to build up their economies and societies (and militaries and diplomatic heft). So it seems that the peoples of the Levant have a very hard time avoiding violent destructive winner-take-all approaches, even against people who were their neighbors for centuries under the Ottomans. Also, destructive aggression is something we see in many places in the ME/NA very far from the Israel-Palestine dispute.
You again like many others, forget what demographic changes do in time. The ratio 6 for Christians vs 5 for muslims was a actual representation of the people there at that time. Due to wars in the surrounding countries muslims fled to Lebanon. That made a big contribution to the unrest as well!
It is the same in Former Yugoslavia, Europe as a whole, the US, South Africa, Africa as a whole, and so on....
They allowed the Palestinians in, that's what happened. After Jordan's experience, that was a stupid move.
Yeah, they brought upon themselves. However Jordanians are now a minority in their own country and Palestinians are dominating demographically that's why Jordanians refuse the arab part of west bank which Israel offered in exchange of peace because it would mean that Jordanians will be a tiny minority in new territory.
Well, it was less that they allowed them in, and rather that they were too weak to refuse.
@@gostavoadolfos2023 socialists
Just now I joined a channel for the first time on UA-cam. Excellent content with every video!
France after abandoning Lebanon: hey guys... *this civil war is very NOT cash money of you....*
You only talked about 40% of the whole civil war events, there is a very large protion still missing.
i agree. all the americans in the comments are acting like experts on this subject
I agree. But I wish it wasn’t true.
Part 2?
@?,?, shut up your comment is bad. civil war was 15 years and your brain is small. bet you're a j(1)arab too
@?,?, Yes, My country is a Mess, and are you know assuming that I want trouble, anyways, a very large important portions of facts and important figures were omitted, which gives wrong images and impressions to people, and that is a problem in itself, you are not going to teach me about my own country are you.
Gamal Abdelnasser: The Arab world is totally ready to unify.
Meanwhile in Lebanon a few years later:
القومية العربية my ass
Thank you Shirvan neftchi for such an informative video !!
"Those who cannot remember the past are condemned to repeat it"
See all these parties ? each party has their own side of the story.
And there's me trying to gtfo of this country. PEACE
Wish u success brother
Same.
The past is memory. We run on psychological memory , therefore we are bound to repeat our pattern of destruction. Mankind has never learnt from history, because we have not learnt to look at our destructive minds.
What about the 1990s war? This was so wonderfully done. You explained such a complex situation better than many textbooks! Great job.
I lived in lebanon from 2001 till 2009 and i miss lebanon so much. I can remember 2006 where Israel launched air strikes in lebanon and i was frightened, i am carrying this memory since today.
What I am shocked about in Lebanon is the amount of city planning they do for a war torn country. If only there was peace there.
It kind of makes sense, though. Every time war levels a city, it has to be rebuilt. Lebanese city planners likely have a depressing amount of experience.
There WAS peace and prosperity. Lebanon was the breadbasket of the Middle East before Muslims became the majority.
@@briantravelman breadbasket? Really??
Ok I know that Muslims are all very good with interacting with other religions but breadbasket? Seriously?
@@MohOEM no they aren't good. Whenever they go, usa and civil war follows. They fight with others and themselves too. I have whole history to back me up
Prayers to Lebanon
I pity Lebanon. 3rd most indebted country in the world.
Where will they get money?
They don't have anything to sell that the world wants.