Macaulay's Method - Problem 1 - Slope and Deflection of Beams - Strength of Materials

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 13 гру 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 139

  • @Ekeeda
    @Ekeeda  4 роки тому +2

    Hello Friends
    Please watch the updated version here - ua-cam.com/video/VhYZ8NrLDS4/v-deo.html
    Watch complete video series of subject Strength of Materials only on Ekeeda Application.
    Download Ekeeda application to get 1000 Studycoins and use it to access free courses.
    Steps to follow:-
    1. Download Ekeeda application from the link given below.
    2. Sign up or Log in to your account.
    3. You will get 1000 Studycoins worth Rs 1000.
    4. Add the courses to your cart.
    5. Select Study coins option to get free access.
    Android App : play.google.com/store/apps/details/?id=student.ekeeda.com.ekeeda_student
    iOS App : apps.apple.com/in/app/ekeeda/id1442131224

  • @swapnilkumar7432
    @swapnilkumar7432 7 років тому +12

    Since the beam is symmetric therefore the slope at either side of the beam extremities should be equal.
    I guess the problem here is that, for taking the slope at left hand side reaction just the first part of slope equation should be considered..

    • @Joe_SZN
      @Joe_SZN 3 місяці тому

      Thought that too 😅

  • @shivaprasads6606
    @shivaprasads6606 3 місяці тому

    for engineering students these lessons are very useful and thanks for all your videos

  • @temet01
    @temet01 Рік тому +7

    First of all thank you for giving us more clarification on deflection of beams .
    But I have a question ,when x=o, how C2=0??, please check it at x=0, C2 is not equal to zero.

    • @neharadhp9944
      @neharadhp9944 Рік тому

      youre right!

    • @swapnilk.b1396
      @swapnilk.b1396 Рік тому

      so.. I was not wrong.

    • @aliasgar9645
      @aliasgar9645 24 дні тому

      Actually when u put x as zero in second section eqn u get singularity function as negative which is not desired so the eqn is terminated there itself

  • @manupriya280
    @manupriya280 5 років тому +10

    At both ends the slope magnitude should be same because of symmetry but you are getting different value sir.

    • @rajeshseetha9686
      @rajeshseetha9686 2 роки тому +1

      I too have the same doubt

    • @metro......3977
      @metro......3977 2 роки тому

      you are right. but sir didn't neglect the Macaulay's function when found the maximum slope in point A(x=0). that's why values are change

    • @rijulsharma675
      @rijulsharma675 11 днів тому

      it is same because in a simply supported beam one end has fixed support and other end has roller support

  • @Ekeeda
    @Ekeeda  7 років тому

    To Get Full Course Of Strength Of Materials, Click ekeeda.com/chapterlist/Mumbai-University/Mechanical-Engineering/Strength-of-Materials/1

    • @Sa_1747
      @Sa_1747 Рік тому

      sir link is not working

  • @dheerajkataria9603
    @dheerajkataria9603 5 років тому +5

    Sir where u come from.. I have never seen a single teacher as like you in my whole life from schooling to engineering.. It is clearly visible that how you teach the students in very much intrested way and your skills is awesome that make u different from others.. Thank u very much to teach complex and confusing topic of engineering in a easy and interested way..
    Many times i am trying to understand this but never understand becz of feeling boring and a lot of confusions.. But today i have totally understand macaulay method and feeling proud and happy..

    • @JK-ql2yp
      @JK-ql2yp 5 років тому

      U haven't understand anything

  • @mdsana7580
    @mdsana7580 3 роки тому +1

    Thanku Zafar sir... I like your explanation.... It helps me alot

  • @abdxlive
    @abdxlive Рік тому +1

    Nice Sir!

  • @deepaksah8667
    @deepaksah8667 7 років тому +10

    sir,Slope at A and B should be equal in magnitude(by symmmetry)?? plz rply.

    • @rijulsharma675
      @rijulsharma675 11 днів тому

      it is same because in a simply supported beam one end has fixed support and other end has roller support therefore different values

  • @JIN-bz1sk
    @JIN-bz1sk 7 років тому +2

    Well explained sir!!!

  • @HarishKumar-hh8dr
    @HarishKumar-hh8dr 5 років тому

    Thank u sir.... 👌👌👌bahut hi badiya smjaya .😊😊😊

  • @suryamanswain522
    @suryamanswain522 Рік тому

    beautifully explained,

  • @safallamichhane6272
    @safallamichhane6272 5 років тому +1

    Thank You Sir a lot

  • @arijitsarkar6490
    @arijitsarkar6490 5 років тому +1

    Sir you are the best teacher 🙂🙂.
    Thank you so much sir for teaching us.

    • @Ekeeda
      @Ekeeda  5 років тому

      We are always happy to help you!
      Use Coupon Code "NEWUSER" and access any one Subject free for 3 days!
      Download Ekeeda Application and take advantage of this offer.
      Android:- play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=student.ekeeda.com.ekeeda_student&hl=en
      iOS:- itunes.apple.com/tt/app/ekeeda/id1442131224

  • @basharadnan2635
    @basharadnan2635 6 років тому +1

    very helpful video thanks sir..!!

  • @mirzaiddin6204
    @mirzaiddin6204 7 років тому +2

    Thank You, Sir! You really help me a lot

    • @ynishant17
      @ynishant17 6 місяців тому

      kitni back lgi teri ?

  • @iamkzed170
    @iamkzed170 7 років тому +1

    Thank you so much professor.

  • @muhamadkhairulfirdausmohda5967
    @muhamadkhairulfirdausmohda5967 5 років тому

    Good explanation, easy to understand

  • @tanujafadol2004
    @tanujafadol2004 11 місяців тому

    Thanks sir😊

  • @mandlasiddhartha6531
    @mandlasiddhartha6531 2 роки тому +1

    Nice sir 👍❤️

    • @Ekeeda
      @Ekeeda  2 роки тому

      We are happy that our content is helpful to you and it motivates us to keep focusing on the content. Download Ekeeda App where you will get courses with all the concepts from basics, practice problems and doubt asking facility from top educators.
      Download App - ekeeda.com/download.html

  • @rakeshmahato3347
    @rakeshmahato3347 6 років тому +3

    Slope at end are always Equal but change in sign then how slope at A become = -3WL²/16EI ???
    In general Slope at ends are always WL²/16EI in simple supported beam at load in the center

  • @akshayjadhav-jt7jb
    @akshayjadhav-jt7jb 7 років тому +3

    good video...........helpful for us........
    but i'm having problem at slope 'a'

  • @aguyfromparalleluniverse
    @aguyfromparalleluniverse 6 років тому +9

    u missed (1/EI) in deflection

    • @UCHIHAMZ
      @UCHIHAMZ 5 років тому +3

      Yeah...in Max deflection...

  • @stanlylouis3687
    @stanlylouis3687 6 років тому +28

    How C2 becomes zero... y u r neglecting remaining parts as zero when u r applying BC

    • @kuldeepsinghaniashorts7346
      @kuldeepsinghaniashorts7346 2 роки тому +2

      @@HS-fw6ij Corrct broo

    • @myself-shada6594
      @myself-shada6594 Рік тому +18

      ​@@HS-fw6ijappreciated your answer, but by the time this guy who asked the question at first place might had completed his engineering😂

    • @lukejussa7905
      @lukejussa7905 Рік тому

      ​@@myself-shada6594😂😂

    • @aliasgar9645
      @aliasgar9645 24 дні тому

      Actually when u put x as zero in second section eqn u get singularity function as negative which is not desired so the eqn is terminated there itself

  • @Creativeconquer
    @Creativeconquer Рік тому

    Fantastic

  • @venkatesh2285
    @venkatesh2285 8 років тому +13

    SLOPE AT A AND B SHOULD BE WL^2/16EI.
    NOT SLOPE AT A IS 3WL^2/16EI AND SLOPE AT B IS WL^2/16EI.

    • @Ekeeda
      @Ekeeda  8 років тому +2

      Venkatesh janakiraman We recorded your response. We will Come back to you shortly.
      Stay tuned with ekeeda channel for more videos.
      You can Subscribe by clicking on below link
      ua-cam.com/users/ekeeda
      Venkatesh janakiraman you can Help Us to Improve our Service.
      #Venkatesh janakiraman #Ekeeda #YourVirtualTeacher #LoveEducaion #OnlineLectures
      For more Educational Information or to Ask Question to #SubjectExpert
      Visit
      ekeeda.com

    • @businessmindset6966
      @businessmindset6966 5 років тому

      Bro he has made a mistake in plus minus
      1/EI (WL^2/16- WL^2/16)=-WL^2/16EI

    • @Ysshyam-m4m
      @Ysshyam-m4m 4 роки тому

      You are right. He shouldn't have included (x-l/2)^2 term when x

  • @theshoaib652
    @theshoaib652 2 роки тому

    thankyou sir

  • @rahulrahul-yr7me
    @rahulrahul-yr7me 8 років тому +1

    cantilever, beam overhanging cantilever beam for calculating slope,deflection... problem s plz upload ......

  • @shreylakhani3998
    @shreylakhani3998 3 роки тому +5

    When you put X=0, Y=0 at that time you neglect the second step of the equation but when you put X=L, Y=0 at that time you did not neglect why sir?

    • @saurabhmaurya6031
      @saurabhmaurya6031 2 роки тому

      because second step for second section only and first section is valid for 1st section only

  • @vigilante191
    @vigilante191 4 роки тому

    Helpful sir

    • @Ekeeda
      @Ekeeda  4 роки тому

      Thankyou for the appreciation.its good to hera that the video has helped you.
      For much easier learning I would suggest you to go through this link bit.ly/353lpP2 and download the Ekeeda-The Learning Application.You can also
      share this with your family and friends.

  • @AhmedGamal-m1m4w
    @AhmedGamal-m1m4w Рік тому

    god bless you

  • @shyamsundarmeena4750
    @shyamsundarmeena4750 2 роки тому +1

    What is the difference between double integration and mackolay's method

  • @ClemenceCamel16
    @ClemenceCamel16 11 місяців тому

    sir in the right hand side of the equation we integrate each term with respect to what?

  • @yogeshshinde5389
    @yogeshshinde5389 7 років тому

    Thanks sir ....

  • @ankitbhardwaj1702
    @ankitbhardwaj1702 7 років тому

    Good video

  • @swarajk999
    @swarajk999 7 років тому +8

    Sir your videos are extremely helpful...
    But I want to give my humble suggestion please edit videos before uploading..i am playing with 1.5x speed and it feels normal...make it little faster so duration will be less.....no offense and lots of thanks for making things easier

  • @qazihamid664
    @qazihamid664 2 роки тому

    error in calculation at 17:58 if we move C1L to the other side it becomes negative changing the equation

    • @Ekeeda
      @Ekeeda  2 роки тому

      We noted your query. Our academic team is working on it and will update you once the issue is resolved. You can download our app where you will get all the concepts from basics, practice problems and doubt asking facility.
      Download App - ekeeda.com/download.html

  • @shareefalhussain
    @shareefalhussain 6 років тому +3

    C2 is not =0 , C2=-w/48 *L^3

  • @onkarvyawhare7062
    @onkarvyawhare7062 5 років тому

    Sir in which case section is take in right hand side direction

  • @naveedladha4211
    @naveedladha4211 6 років тому +2

    At 25:40 finding the slope eqn at A he clearly forgot to multiply by
    -1/EI
    Correct me If I am wrong pls

    • @HarishKumar-hh8dr
      @HarishKumar-hh8dr 5 років тому +1

      Phir kya hua ..agar itna smja h to Ye to aap bhi lga skte ho.....🙏🙏🙏

  • @pankajkalve
    @pankajkalve 5 років тому +5

    28:48 Wtf is going on. This is an engineering subject.

    • @dheerajkataria9603
      @dheerajkataria9603 5 років тому

      Then get lost u bloodyfool person.. It is for our better understanding to help students their concepts strong step by step.. If we missed any petty value.. So that will become a big problem for us to finding the mistake in whole solution.. Becz this method wants practice and concentration to every steps clearly... If you are a genious then do your own studies and no need to watching videos here...

    • @JK-ql2yp
      @JK-ql2yp 5 років тому

      @@dheerajkataria9603 u re a stupid ,what the hell are you talking about.he is talking about the calculations

    • @lightningmcdweeb
      @lightningmcdweeb 3 роки тому

      @@dheerajkataria9603 bhai bakwas bandh kar tumhara izzat ka sawaal hai

  • @satendragerman7516
    @satendragerman7516 6 років тому +2

    if length becomes 2L and one end is load is W on length L and other load is on 2L
    so how to solve this problem sir.

  • @karthikeya__6896
    @karthikeya__6896 Рік тому

    Is this problems use ful for gate

  • @Vilayat_vlogs
    @Vilayat_vlogs 4 роки тому +1

    C1=wl3/36

    • @Ekeeda
      @Ekeeda  4 роки тому

      Grateful to you for bringing an error to our notice and helping us by giving us an opportunity to alter it to a correct one soon.

  • @GESSESSGetaw-ln7ts
    @GESSESSGetaw-ln7ts 6 місяців тому

    Sir,Would u tell me How the value of C1 comes to 0?

  • @prat7137
    @prat7137 5 років тому

    At slope equation while putting x=0 for max slope. You forgot to multiply(-) sign.

  • @popularfunny1583
    @popularfunny1583 3 роки тому +1

    Why we remove that section in first boundary condition, why not in second

  • @KomugishaMackline-u2h
    @KomugishaMackline-u2h 3 місяці тому

    Why do we consider only first section in first boundary

  • @aadilone8572
    @aadilone8572 7 років тому

    sir how we can downlaod notes of these chapters

  • @asimkumar174
    @asimkumar174 7 років тому +2

    sir while finding c1 you have neglected the second part of deflection equation while in finding c2 you concluded it.. please explain this

  • @venkatesh2285
    @venkatesh2285 8 років тому +5

    In this problem the given beam is symmetric. when the bean is symmetric means slope at A will be equal to slope at B. BUT here in this problem the answer for slope at A is not equal to slope at B. HOW IT IS CORRECT??
    COULD YOU PLEASE CLEAR MY DOUBT?

    • @Ekeeda
      @Ekeeda  8 років тому

      Venkatesh janakiraman We recorded your response. We will Come back to you shortly.
      Stay tuned with ekeeda channel for more videos.
      You can Subscribe by clicking on below link
      ua-cam.com/users/ekeeda
      Venkatesh janakiraman you can Help Us to Improve our Service.
      #Venkatesh janakiraman #Ekeeda #YourVirtualTeacher #LoveEducaion #OnlineLectures
      For more Educational Information or to Ask Question to #SubjectExpert
      Visit
      ekeeda.com

    • @Sunny55333
      @Sunny55333 6 років тому

      Venkatesh janakiraman slope at a and b are same as the load is symmetric...he has done a mistake in calculations...!!

    • @abhishektambe1000
      @abhishektambe1000 6 років тому

      Yes you're right the slope should be same for both A and B but at A slope will be positive and and at B slope is negative

  • @sachinkumar064
    @sachinkumar064 7 років тому

    Why are you not considering the support reaction at B, while taking moment about the section X-X ??

  • @swaroopsai9657
    @swaroopsai9657 6 років тому

    Hello sir...While ur teaching 3 page it must be w/2 but why u wrote only w..

  • @arjunshirsath8353
    @arjunshirsath8353 8 років тому

    more problem should be taken on different type of beam..................

  • @Ani-uc5ph
    @Ani-uc5ph 6 років тому +2

    look at all those ADS

  • @venkatesh2285
    @venkatesh2285 8 років тому +9

    I have found that where he has commited the mistake. in order to calculating the slope at A SHOULD not consider the full equation only should have to consider upto C1 in the slope equation then only slope will be equal to A AND B. please kindly verify this one.
    Thank you

    • @Ekeeda
      @Ekeeda  8 років тому +1

      Venkatesh janakiraman We recorded your response. We will Come back to you shortly.
      Stay tuned with ekeeda channel for more videos.
      You can Subscribe by clicking on below link
      ua-cam.com/users/ekeeda
      Venkatesh janakiraman you can Help Us to Improve our Service.
      #Venkatesh janakiraman #Ekeeda #YourVirtualTeacher #LoveEducaion #OnlineLectures
      For more Educational Information or to Ask Question to #SubjectExpert
      Visit
      ekeeda.com

    • @stanlylouis3687
      @stanlylouis3687 6 років тому

      Same doubt

    • @perfectmaster9
      @perfectmaster9 6 років тому

      But if we consider upto C1,we will be getting same values of slope but the sign is opposite.. please clear my doubt..

    • @naveedladha4211
      @naveedladha4211 6 років тому

      @@perfectmaster9 yes the signs will not be the same meaning that we should not consider the first section till C1

    • @perfectmaster9
      @perfectmaster9 6 років тому

      @@naveedladha4211 Thanks..

  • @darshanundhad2080
    @darshanundhad2080 5 років тому

    Sir, can give me all lecture note please....?

  • @SUNITADEVI-bq5qw
    @SUNITADEVI-bq5qw 5 років тому +2

    36 min may ek qustion sahi hai 😂😂

  • @shivamchaudhary2802
    @shivamchaudhary2802 4 роки тому

    When every thing is symmetry then why slope at A and B is different

  • @rabintajpuriya6299
    @rabintajpuriya6299 4 роки тому +1

    mISTAKE WHEN CALCULATION MAXIMUM SLOPE
    SIGN MISTAKE

  • @SoumitraVadnerkar
    @SoumitraVadnerkar 7 років тому

    Can anybody tell me the significance of '-ve' sign?

  • @magnetar_nks5514
    @magnetar_nks5514 5 років тому

    The method that has bee used to find the deflection of slopes, is wrong as the brackets behave as unit step function according to macaulay,but you have just neglected the brackets while calculating slope and deflection, whereas while applying boundary condtn used it

  • @vijaypadhiyar9546
    @vijaypadhiyar9546 4 роки тому

    Sir why are you taken c2 =0 ?

  • @siegregoirehien1890
    @siegregoirehien1890 7 років тому +1

    how slopes at A and at B can be differente since the beam is loaded symmetrically?

  • @deeekqueen6939
    @deeekqueen6939 6 років тому

    Sir second section ko consider kyu nahi karege

  • @hiteshc3974
    @hiteshc3974 6 років тому +1

    Wrong answer for slope at A.

  • @ammuchannel7347
    @ammuchannel7347 6 років тому

    Explain derivations sir

  • @nanudayum9723
    @nanudayum9723 6 років тому +2

    How -1/EI disappeared....explain plz...

  • @rithinreddy2215
    @rithinreddy2215 Рік тому

    Why do you always take direct steps?
    ?

  • @Vijay...._
    @Vijay...._ Рік тому

    wrong at 13:40

  • @dibyamohan67
    @dibyamohan67 5 місяців тому

    Why it is (x-L/2 )² in the eqn 1 here L is a const then why r u squaring it ...??

  • @timothyarnoldopeche6944
    @timothyarnoldopeche6944 2 місяці тому

    Macaulay's method when [x-a] < 0 we ignore the term.
    This is completely opposite. Help defend your approach.

  • @avinashpatel4
    @avinashpatel4 4 роки тому

    Value of C2 is not 0

  • @vamshineeraj7452
    @vamshineeraj7452 5 років тому

    Y c2 = 0 ????

  • @wcc2gamer442
    @wcc2gamer442 Рік тому

    When I put only right ear bud your voice was not audible

  • @Complete501
    @Complete501 Рік тому

    16:10 it's (8)^3 but you multiplied, 6*8 instead of, 6*(8) ^3 ...
    This mistake spoiled your hole problem

  • @pov_Two024
    @pov_Two024 9 місяців тому

    c2 is not zero here !!!

  • @nitinmaharjan3174
    @nitinmaharjan3174 5 років тому

    Blunder Mistake.

  • @nahasnoushad9208
    @nahasnoushad9208 6 років тому +1

    Teaching wrong concepts should be removed ,it makes confusion for students

  • @cibi5514
    @cibi5514 5 років тому

    Kind attention C2 is not zero when you apply BC : x=0 , y=0
    It's C2 = (WL^3)/48

  • @svrt5832
    @svrt5832 2 роки тому

    Sir please please please please don't speak from just on side of the mike. It becomes impossible to listen to you after 30 mins as only one ear starts paining.

  • @aartimore4678
    @aartimore4678 6 років тому

    Too many adds

  • @naveedladha4211
    @naveedladha4211 6 років тому +1

    Hi ekeeda as I have watched this video and read comments there has been a mistake in the calculations but nothing is corrected
    This is really not helping us rather it is misguiding us
    Pls rectify your mistakes ASAP

    • @Ekeeda
      @Ekeeda  6 років тому +1

      Okay Naveed . We will upload a video with rectified calculation.

  • @godmodegfx2071
    @godmodegfx2071 6 років тому +1

    Too much "hence" and "therefore". Please revise your script and also don't give wrong information about such technical subject. It may cause damage. I found lot of things worng in this video. Correct it in time

  • @singhiskingsher5360
    @singhiskingsher5360 5 років тому +1

    Wrong explanation

    • @Ekeeda
      @Ekeeda  5 років тому

      Dear user
      Please notify us what is wrong with this video
      we will surely correct it!

  • @venkat2962
    @venkat2962 5 років тому

    be spelling wrong lolz........

  • @sujohndey2935
    @sujohndey2935 6 років тому

    Kabhi thoda tough question b utha le Bhai

  • @playmon7443
    @playmon7443 4 роки тому

    🤣🤣lol tchr dont spread wrong concept..slope will be wl²/16EI

  • @alokminz7500
    @alokminz7500 2 роки тому +1

    Thank you sir...

    • @Ekeeda
      @Ekeeda  2 роки тому

      We are happy that our content is helpful to you and it motivates us to keep focusing on the content. Download Ekeeda App where you will get courses with all the concepts from basics, practice problems and doubt asking facility from top educators.
      Download App - ekeeda.com/download.html