He never said they left for allegations. He said they were unlikely to return because of allegations. I can tell you that in the case of John Barrowman and the guy who played Mickey they allegedly made crude jokes on set and Barrowman would pull out his dick in front of other cast members (allegedly).
@@Tom-vy4ue They probably won't return because each have had allegations of sexual misconduct brought up against them, one of them pleading guilty to them. It's not the reason they left the show but it does mean there's a lot of doubt about them being brought back for any future appearances.
it's a fair point you make but some of the reasons like with Noel and John are to do with questionable sexual themed things so it's quite a taboo subject ig
Bro I love your videos but can you slow down the talk speed abit haha , I know you can slow the videos down with X0.75 but it would just sound better if you slow your talking speed abit
3 of RTD’s original male companions have been cancelled for allegations, 2 of which occurred during their era of the show! Does the ‘different time’ excuse really apply to 2005?? With Eccelston also vehemently accusing RTD of a bad work environment why is he seen as a better show runner than Stephen Moffat??
I would really love all the Russell vs Eccleston stuff to finally come out in the public so we know what's what, I know a lot of people say it's just Eccleston being himself as he's like it with a lot of projects supposedly but I really want some clarity of the situation. Especially as the day "Rose" was about to air they special that got aired had Eccleston saying how great it was being on the show and working with Russell, so I wonder what actually changed or if Eccleston was just being nice to promote the show.
@@thewholook unfortunately they are both probably telling the truth, at least from their own perspective. But the majority of people think RTD is good or at least became better at show running over his era. Standards have changed and he’s probably better at managing people. By that same measure, Eccelston has that commendable northern working man complex that the boss is always the villain.
It’s just that in a comparison of the final products there’s basically no competition, it’s got flaws as well and there’s a few Moffat era episodes that rise above most of RTDs stuff, but it’s a general trend that an episode from RTD is probably better then one from the Moffat era (even ones by Moffat himself, showing he’s a brilliant writer, just overloaded a bit with show running).
@@flango348 personally, I think Moffat is brilliant at writing the individual episodes, but weak at writing the overall series arc, while RTD is good at writing big picture series arcs, but suffers from his overly goofy dialogue and odd choices
Yaz and Martha should both return in the same episode. I wanna see how Yaz feels about the Doctor now that he’s changed and Martha explain how you can’t really date the Doctor and he’s not that kind of person.
Even though Yaz isn’t my favourite character I’d actually like to see her return for a one off. It would be interesting seeing whether her romantic feeling would continue with another Doctor or if similar to Clara she decides she feels differently. I feel exploring this side would do a great deal for her character and would be a satisfying ending
Honestly, I think they kind of blew that chance when she was not there to see Whitaker regenerate and it might feel too similar to how it was done for Clara especially if it was only for one episode.
Same! Also for the doctors character as well would connect Jodie's and whoever is the doctor then's doctor as the same person, which I feel rarely the show does very well with how the doctor feels about different people when its a different face, probably apart from River Song. Do those same feelings for Yaz remain or do they disappear with that face? Would be interesting
I've been thinking it over as I've been watching Series 7. Although it is one of my favourites I did feel as though Clara seemed a bit too quick with the 11th Doctor. What might have been slightly better is if Amy and Rory left at the end of Series 7, just before The Name of the Doctor. It would have been cool to see them in discussion with Clara and help track her down as well as transitioning smoothly to the next companion.
Yeah apologies for that, had issues getting this one done and after so many attempts and finally getting it working I ticked a setting by accident that caused everything to seem faster, basically it stops recording between every quiet moment and pushes everything I said together, Setting deactivated now though and should be back to normal next video
Noel Clarke was accused of sexual harassment, which personally seems pretty geniune John Barrowman exposed himself on set many times during the production of s1 and s3, he made an apology in recent years Both definitely shouldnt come back
@@thewholook Would have liked to have seen her in Thirteen's run. I know it gets increasingly difficult to work out the timeline, but she doesn't travel in exact inverse order of the Doctor so she could really pop up at any time. Once they started with Yaz's romantic feelings, I really thought they needed more episodes to deal with that and having River would have been interesting. I kind of would have liked seeing Thirteen continue on with another showrunner for at least a season. I also would have liked seeing Bill doing a season with Thirteen instead of what happened, so what do I know. :)
@@HuntingViolets I don't want her to meet anyone after Peter. He's her perfect Doctor, the one that spent 23 years with her on Darillium. And The Doctor had to deal with her death after Darillium, reuniting them after her death would devalue it
@@SirSX3 Fair point. I certainly don't think it makes sense for her to meet Doctors pre-Ten, because he didn't know her and she hasn't changed faces from that face, although I'm hearing that's happened in Big Finish?
@@HuntingViolets yeah, I agree with you. I don't like her meeting the pre-Ten Doctors either, and yes, that's exactly what happened in Big Finish. She has her own series in Big Finish where she meets a different Doctor each season; I supposed they needed a selling point for the series. Since they have all the other Doctors under employment anyway, might as well have them hang out. She also has met Susan, the Doctor's granddaughter. Although they always have a cop out of using a fake name or erasing memories. Well, the thing about Big Finish and any other expanded media is you can decide for yourself what you consider as canon or not.
An interesting video but you need to slow down your commentary. It is far too fast to the point where it just becomes difficultto listen to. Take a breath!
Yeah apologies for that, had lots of technical issues trying to get this one done and the one time I get it working finally I accidentally ticked a setting that caused this. It’s unticked now so won’t be an issue next time
I think a lot of the time it’s the outgoing showrunners who cause them not to carry over rather than the new, but at the same time the new are probably grateful that they can just do their own thing without worrying about the previous companion
I did think about adding her and then completely forgot when I got round to recording. Thing with her though is she’s a recurring character rather than a true companion, whereas Jack also recurs, but he was a companion before recurring. But until she’s back, if at all, she’s left because she wasn’t asked back/her story was wrapped up(?). She has said she’d be up for returning though but this was like 5 years ago when she said that
Apologies about that, that’s completely my bad. I had lots of issues before hand getting things working and whilst trying to fix I accidentally activated a setting on my software that basically stops recording anytime it doesn’t pick up any sound so it pushed everything so close together. With all the difficulties I admitted defeat with it after the amount of times I recorded this one 😅 back to normal in the future!
intresting video i enjoyed a few mistakes here and there but nothing major just natural human mistakes i also enjoyed the speed and couldn't tell that there were technical issues, i just thought the speed made it a quicker video. again probably just a mistake or forgetfulness but surely if wilf is a companion so is the likes of river, also if adams classed as a companion could stax vastra and jenny also be classed as companions maybe i mean to memory i cant remember them travelling with the doctor however they were in a good few episode idk
That may have played a part in it but she talked about it on the radio a couple of years ago saying she didn’t feel like the show would be as successful when it returned and it got to her how famous she got from it
@@gaminglikeaproallthetime4563 Bruno was from 2017 and was put on sex register but I think he’s been removed now as it was only for 5 years I believe, and pretty sure he’s quit acting anyway now. Noel was a huge range from 2005 (maybe earlier) until 2021 when allegations came out, he apologised for it and said he was seeking help but denied he did it, charges were dropped and he said he denied it because he knows a of the accusations were lies, but some of the allegations came from doctor who set, a lot from elsewhere John was between 2005-2008 I believe and he got mentioned because of Noel’s stuff. He apologised as well saying he did it in good spirit to humour his colleagues and said he’s changed his behaviour once he was called up about it back in 2008 and he never meant it in a sexual way towards people, but it got him dropped from a few doctor who related stuff when it got mentioned with the Noel stuff. I mean Noel and John could potentially return, John more likely but I honestly can’t see either returning due to both coming from on set incidents but who knows, Johns situation was known about by the show when it happened and he still came back a couple years ago
Noel was sexual harassment/abuse, Bruno was SA, and John was for exposing himself. Johns has been well known publicly for many many years though and considered by a lot of people to just be a laugh on set but after complaints a couple of years ago John got removed from lots of doctor who related stuff.
@@boulevard14 you’re right! I definitely recorded it but I must’ve accidentally cut the audio in editing 🤦♂️ so yes you’re right, 15 in that case of what I said but yeah should be 13 if I wasn’t an idiot and didn’t cut it 😂
That issue will be sorted for the next video, I had software issues and when trying to fix it I accidentally activated a setting that caused it to only record when a certain volume was picked up, meaning gaps between words and sentences were pushed together🤦♂️😂
Saying they left for 'allegations' and not specifying the allegations completely undermines the point of the video.
He never said they left for allegations. He said they were unlikely to return because of allegations. I can tell you that in the case of John Barrowman and the guy who played Mickey they allegedly made crude jokes on set and Barrowman would pull out his dick in front of other cast members (allegedly).
As Henry said I never said they left because allegations, I just said it’s unlikely they’d return because of them
@@thewholookwhat do you mean by that
@@Tom-vy4ue They probably won't return because each have had allegations of sexual misconduct brought up against them, one of them pleading guilty to them. It's not the reason they left the show but it does mean there's a lot of doubt about them being brought back for any future appearances.
it's a fair point you make but some of the reasons like with Noel and John are to do with questionable sexual themed things so it's quite a taboo subject ig
It's so disheartening hearing three cast members in a row connected with the word 'allegations', notably all from RTD's first era
The RTD era was rife with poor management and working conditions. It's in part why Eccleston left
Fucking hell you talk fast. Only heard every other word lol
Do you think you could talk faster? 😄
Bro I love your videos but can you slow down the talk speed abit haha , I know you can slow the videos down with X0.75 but it would just sound better if you slow your talking speed abit
3 of RTD’s original male companions have been cancelled for allegations, 2 of which occurred during their era of the show! Does the ‘different time’ excuse really apply to 2005?? With Eccelston also vehemently accusing RTD of a bad work environment why is he seen as a better show runner than Stephen Moffat??
I would really love all the Russell vs Eccleston stuff to finally come out in the public so we know what's what, I know a lot of people say it's just Eccleston being himself as he's like it with a lot of projects supposedly but I really want some clarity of the situation. Especially as the day "Rose" was about to air they special that got aired had Eccleston saying how great it was being on the show and working with Russell, so I wonder what actually changed or if Eccleston was just being nice to promote the show.
@@thewholook unfortunately they are both probably telling the truth, at least from their own perspective. But the majority of people think RTD is good or at least became better at show running over his era. Standards have changed and he’s probably better at managing people. By that same measure, Eccelston has that commendable northern working man complex that the boss is always the villain.
It’s just that in a comparison of the final products there’s basically no competition, it’s got flaws as well and there’s a few Moffat era episodes that rise above most of RTDs stuff, but it’s a general trend that an episode from RTD is probably better then one from the Moffat era (even ones by Moffat himself, showing he’s a brilliant writer, just overloaded a bit with show running).
@@flango348 personally, I think Moffat is brilliant at writing the individual episodes, but weak at writing the overall series arc, while RTD is good at writing big picture series arcs, but suffers from his overly goofy dialogue and odd choices
Yaz and Martha should both return in the same episode.
I wanna see how Yaz feels about the Doctor now that he’s changed and Martha explain how you can’t really date the Doctor and he’s not that kind of person.
Cough cough, River Song.
Even though Yaz isn’t my favourite character I’d actually like to see her return for a one off. It would be interesting seeing whether her romantic feeling would continue with another Doctor or if similar to Clara she decides she feels differently. I feel exploring this side would do a great deal for her character and would be a satisfying ending
Honestly, I think they kind of blew that chance when she was not there to see Whitaker regenerate and it might feel too similar to how it was done for Clara especially if it was only for one episode.
Same! Also for the doctors character as well would connect Jodie's and whoever is the doctor then's doctor as the same person, which I feel rarely the show does very well with how the doctor feels about different people when its a different face, probably apart from River Song. Do those same feelings for Yaz remain or do they disappear with that face? Would be interesting
I would be so happy for her to meet Fifteen, who I'm confident would be far more open about things.
watching this on half speed
I've been thinking it over as I've been watching Series 7. Although it is one of my favourites I did feel as though Clara seemed a bit too quick with the 11th Doctor. What might have been slightly better is if Amy and Rory left at the end of Series 7, just before The Name of the Doctor. It would have been cool to see them in discussion with Clara and help track her down as well as transitioning smoothly to the next companion.
Matt Smith himself has recounted that he does wish that he got a full season with Clara instead of the half season.
Gave up on watching this. Voice over is way to fast. We will stick with Who Culture.
Yeah apologies for that, had issues getting this one done and after so many attempts and finally getting it working I ticked a setting by accident that caused everything to seem faster, basically it stops recording between every quiet moment and pushes everything I said together, Setting deactivated now though and should be back to normal next video
So many accusations ruined so many characters I loved
Noel Clark allegations were false. And barowmans allegations aren't really allegations
Noel Clarke was accused of sexual harassment, which personally seems pretty geniune
John Barrowman exposed himself on set many times during the production of s1 and s3, he made an apology in recent years
Both definitely shouldnt come back
@@funfairs__ukthere were accusations from 20 different people
Great video, interesting recap, no problems with how fast it was, I watched at an additional 1.75x speed 👍
I think river song could’ve been considered a companion, great video though!!
Funny thing is I said to myself “don’t forget river” and then forgot river 😅
@@thewholook Would have liked to have seen her in Thirteen's run. I know it gets increasingly difficult to work out the timeline, but she doesn't travel in exact inverse order of the Doctor so she could really pop up at any time. Once they started with Yaz's romantic feelings, I really thought they needed more episodes to deal with that and having River would have been interesting. I kind of would have liked seeing Thirteen continue on with another showrunner for at least a season. I also would have liked seeing Bill doing a season with Thirteen instead of what happened, so what do I know. :)
@@HuntingViolets I don't want her to meet anyone after Peter. He's her perfect Doctor, the one that spent 23 years with her on Darillium. And The Doctor had to deal with her death after Darillium, reuniting them after her death would devalue it
@@SirSX3 Fair point. I certainly don't think it makes sense for her to meet Doctors pre-Ten, because he didn't know her and she hasn't changed faces from that face, although I'm hearing that's happened in Big Finish?
@@HuntingViolets yeah, I agree with you. I don't like her meeting the pre-Ten Doctors either, and yes, that's exactly what happened in Big Finish.
She has her own series in Big Finish where she meets a different Doctor each season; I supposed they needed a selling point for the series. Since they have all the other Doctors under employment anyway, might as well have them hang out. She also has met Susan, the Doctor's granddaughter.
Although they always have a cop out of using a fake name or erasing memories.
Well, the thing about Big Finish and any other expanded media is you can decide for yourself what you consider as canon or not.
I gave up stop taking the speed speak slower
I wish Danny Pink became a companion....
I was so sure they were going to make him one during his time on the show, was shocked with how they went with his story.
RIP P.E.
An interesting video but you need to slow down your commentary. It is far too fast to the point where it just becomes difficultto listen to. Take a breath!
Yeah apologies for that, had lots of technical issues trying to get this one done and the one time I get it working finally I accidentally ticked a setting that caused this. It’s unticked now so won’t be an issue next time
I like that your videos are objective and to the point, it makes them very easy to watch.
I don’t think you talk too fast, great video 👍🏻
Wow theres really a lot of allegations
Will you do why each classic companion left the show?
I will do but not straight away, I’ll come back later on for that one
Didn’t u just say Captain Jack was on Doctor who just over a year ago?
Bro that was 2021 this is 2024 I’m so sorry time goes so quickly
Brain fart! No idea why I said 1 year ago, god knows what year I must think we're in 😂
I dislike the whole: "New showrunner so screw your companions" thing. Though same time I understand why.
I think a lot of the time it’s the outgoing showrunners who cause them not to carry over rather than the new, but at the same time the new are probably grateful that they can just do their own thing without worrying about the previous companion
I like the changing of companions with the new Doctor actors. But I also like seeing them coming back once in a while.
Suprised Alex Kingston wasn't here tbh
I did think about adding her and then completely forgot when I got round to recording. Thing with her though is she’s a recurring character rather than a true companion, whereas Jack also recurs, but he was a companion before recurring. But until she’s back, if at all, she’s left because she wasn’t asked back/her story was wrapped up(?). She has said she’d be up for returning though but this was like 5 years ago when she said that
There’s also no official confirmation that Millie has left
I came to loathe Graham.
Good video, but good lord the editing is cutthroat - had to rewatch parts of it because the delivery was too fast
Apologies about that, that’s completely my bad. I had lots of issues before hand getting things working and whilst trying to fix I accidentally activated a setting on my software that basically stops recording anytime it doesn’t pick up any sound so it pushed everything so close together. With all the difficulties I admitted defeat with it after the amount of times I recorded this one 😅 back to normal in the future!
Shit happens, still a great video!
You speak so fast, I get whiplash listening to you
intresting video i enjoyed a few mistakes here and there but nothing major just natural human mistakes i also enjoyed the speed and couldn't tell that there were technical issues, i just thought the speed made it a quicker video. again probably just a mistake or forgetfulness but surely if wilf is a companion so is the likes of river, also if adams classed as a companion could stax vastra and jenny also be classed as companions maybe i mean to memory i cant remember them travelling with the doctor however they were in a good few episode idk
I thought Billie left because she didn’t enjoy spending months filming in Cardiff, when her life was predominantly in London?
That may have played a part in it but she talked about it on the radio a couple of years ago saying she didn’t feel like the show would be as successful when it returned and it got to her how famous she got from it
What's with all the on set allegations???
I hope that wanting to keep things moving thing is true. I like when a Doctor gets lots of companion eras.
Please make a video also about why aren’t Doctors from 11 to 13 ever returning, not even for the 60th
It’s not exactly what you’ve asked for but I’ve got another video like this about all the doctors explaining why each actor left going up later!
Wait what, you said the ‘21 NY special was ‘just over a year ago’ (?????)
Yeah I had a massive brain fart with that one 😂 no idea why I said that, I must’ve thought it’s still 2022 or something 😅
What Allocations??!!!
So all 3 were accused of sexual allegations, Bruno was S.A, John was S. harassment /inappropriate behaviour and Noel was also S. harassment / bullying
@@thewholook you're running doctor who now =( lol. Has anything been proven and solved. How long has this been going on???
@@gaminglikeaproallthetime4563 Bruno was from 2017 and was put on sex register but I think he’s been removed now as it was only for 5 years I believe, and pretty sure he’s quit acting anyway now.
Noel was a huge range from 2005 (maybe earlier) until 2021 when allegations came out, he apologised for it and said he was seeking help but denied he did it, charges were dropped and he said he denied it because he knows a of the accusations were lies, but some of the allegations came from doctor who set, a lot from elsewhere
John was between 2005-2008 I believe and he got mentioned because of Noel’s stuff. He apologised as well saying he did it in good spirit to humour his colleagues and said he’s changed his behaviour once he was called up about it back in 2008 and he never meant it in a sexual way towards people, but it got him dropped from a few doctor who related stuff when it got mentioned with the Noel stuff.
I mean Noel and John could potentially return, John more likely but I honestly can’t see either returning due to both coming from on set incidents but who knows, Johns situation was known about by the show when it happened and he still came back a couple years ago
Curious what the allegations where for the companions
Noel was sexual harassment/abuse, Bruno was SA, and John was for exposing himself. Johns has been well known publicly for many many years though and considered by a lot of people to just be a laugh on set but after complaints a couple of years ago John got removed from lots of doctor who related stuff.
Wasn't it 15 years later??
15 years from Series 4 but 13 years (closer to 14 really) from The End of Time Part 2
@thewholook In the video you said she left after one series and then returned 13 years later. The brief End of Time cameo wasn't mentioned.
@@boulevard14 you’re right! I definitely recorded it but I must’ve accidentally cut the audio in editing 🤦♂️ so yes you’re right, 15 in that case of what I said but yeah should be 13 if I wasn’t an idiot and didn’t cut it 😂
Great video but please slow the talking down. 👍😁 Favourite new companion was Yaz!
That issue will be sorted for the next video, I had software issues and when trying to fix it I accidentally activated a setting that caused it to only record when a certain volume was picked up, meaning gaps between words and sentences were pushed together🤦♂️😂
😂😂
@@jochakram2363 clearly need to slow down even with the setting fixed 😅 had same comments again so gotta learn to talk slower I guess haha