As one who has extensive painting experience I really think you'll find that while sulking room pink is in itself a gorgeous color, once you cover both walls with it, it will appear much darker and quite pink, than just the swatch. Especially with the white rug.
Yeah I’d say go with the eggshell. Even the middle color will appear much deeper. If there was something inbetween the middle color and the eggshell that would be great. But yeah the pink color will end up being dark
I vote for Dead Salmon because of a parallel, and ensuing analogy, to one previous video of yours: the insanely thorough review of your Babaa pullover, more specifically in reference to its colour. While I cannot quote you verbatim, you mentioned yearning for a hue you will not grow tired of AND will pair beautifully with the rest of your wardrobe, hence you opting for that dark brown shade. A similar situation is happening here in my humble opinion. HOWEVER, you can always incorporate dreamy, bohemian accessories in that Sulking Pink colour into the decoration of your beauty room.
My vote is for dead salmon--sulking room pink is my favorite but I think both your makeup and your clothes would pop so perfectly against dead salmon (your corals especially would work better with that option I think). BUT (and this might be absurd idk), have you considered painting the back wall with dead salmon, and the little side wall that's in frame with sulking room pink? Anyway, whatever you choose will be so pretty, especially with the rug!
okay, hear me out, i'm gonna suggest a wild idea. I've been seeing very strong arguments for both dead salmon and sulking room pink and with the rug now I honestly don't know which to pick. but... what if we don't have to pick? do both!! i think doing the wall directly behind you (and the 2 other unseen walls) in dead salmon would give you the much-needed neutrality, and then paint the wall next to you (the other one we see on camera) in sulking room pink as an accent wall to give you the lovely mauve that suits your brand (with the intro and such) while making the color concern for videos no longer a problem since only a little of it will appear on screen. i think this solution gives you the best of both worlds!! either way, they're both beautiful and I'm excited to see which one you pick (though hopefully both!)
I haven’t commented in ages because I’m a gremlin and I always just watch yt on my tv BUT I had to weigh in on the paint debate! Sulking room pink for sure. I agree, it makes me feel feelings and I love it a lot. Unrelated, I’ve really cut down on the beauty content I watch (which is good for me, it helps regulate my desire to spend) but I watch all of your videos pretty much as soon as you post them. I love the nuanced way you talk about beauty and I often go back to your no buy videos whenever I need a reminder as to why lipstick isn’t going to solve my problems. Thank you for being such a light in the community 💖
Wow, I have dead salmon AND sulking room pink in my house! Dead salmon is my living room colour, and it has so much dimension to it depending on lighting, time of day, and season. Depending on the lighting in your room and where your windows are, it can lean mauve, greyish, taupe and, my fave, chocolate milkshake coloured :') Sulking room pink is my makeup room colour, and while I find it beautiful in texture and finish, it is definitely quite intense. As this is a much smaller room, it works well. But I imagine in a room as big as yours appears, it could be slightly overwhelming! good luck either way - can confirm both colours are divine!
I LOVE the sulking room pink BUT I think all 4 walls would be overwhelming and it would appear darker. I think it would also affect the way makeup looks on camera. I think the folks are right. My vote is for 3 walls of the dead salmon and 1 accent wall in the sulking room pink. Me thinks that would be perfection! Love you! 😘
I keep my same vote. Sulking room pink is gorgeous, but I think you want your emotional impact to come from your makeup, clothes and most importantly, your rocking personality. Maybe a win-win would be dead salmon on walls (which looks soothing and grounding) and use home decor pieces in that sulking room pink. Love your choice of rug!
I think the pink makes the room feel cozy, especially when you add some trinkets, art and plants 🪴 in the background. I do not think it will affect the makeup presentation because of your lighting set up and your table top videos. Pick whatever sparks the most joy 💜
Both! Accent wall. Dead salmon on three, pink on one. Or horizontally split with dead salmon having a bigger slice of the wall. Or hell stripes! So many options I can’t decide.
Sulking room pink my pick! Especially as a contrast to the light rug. Having lived in a lot of cookie cutter apartments, dead salmon reminds me a bit of that default beige color the walls tend to come in. And the pink is just more original and HLP imho! Will be a lovely complement to your hair too
Your talking and physically breaking down the palette like that was so unbelievably helpful. And we have opposite instincts! I realized that this palette seems so practical for me because I tend to layer mattes and gravitate towards lighter shimmers for spotlighting. The only color I could we not using was the cranberry one. It just shows that no matter our preferences or specific bodily-beauty needs, this thought process before a purchase or in lieu, is incredibly helpful.
Watching your videos has really helped me to separate my “fantasy self” from “real life me”. I am easily drawn to many eyeshadow palettes, but in reality I have not ever put eyeshadow on that wasn’t pretty neutral or subtlety smoky and actually liked the result. I like colorful and dramatic looks on others and watching on UA-cam; I just do not like how it looks on me. So thank you for helping bring me to awareness of my real preferences vs my impulsive thoughts to buy things I KNOW I will not actually wear.
Ooufff, I forgot to post on the last video for the preferred background colour and it remains the same! I still believe sulking pink is the best one. I also believe that it’ll be a phenomenal contrast to your aesthetic ❣️ love you !
You know, I loved Dead Salmon in the last video. But when you covered up Sulking Room Pink with the rag, I felt like the whole energy of the room just dropped! Dead Salmon suddenly looked very beige-y, especially because the floor is now covered with the cream-colored rug. But I wonder if Sulking Room Pink would look really dark once it's all over the walls. It's a hard choice!
I feel like your look today very much embodies all 3 swatch shades we're debating on. With the rug, I think dead salmon compliments it!! Plus it's very much "old gum blush shade" vibes, which i love
Also, for anyone wondering, the cranberry color Hannah used is from the Juvia’s Place Saharan II palette. It is discontinued as the description box says but if anyone has that palette already now you know!
I just realized the pink paint matches your opening "title card" at the beginning of the video. Also the background of your thumbnail in this video. Based on how your thumbnail looks, I vote for the pink!
Im going with Dead Salmon. I was indecisive between that and Sulking Room Pink (but ultimately landed on Sulking Room Pink) before but now with the rug I think Dead Salmon works even better in the room and will still keep it bright comparative to Sulking Room Pink. Also, with the rug I am less concerned about coordination with the lamp from last time.
Omg, I am so invested in this paint decision. I am REALLY pulling for dead salmon. This video is such a good case study. Sulking Room is such a great color, it says a lot, it has such an impact on whatever colours are in the foreground. I feel like the eye look you put on today pops so much more against Dead Salmon than against Sulking Room! You're first instinct was correct Hannah, Dead salmon is perfect!
Sulking room pink!!! It really brings the room to life. Dead salmon is beautiful, but I don’t think it adds as much to the space… I am a bit biased having a pink office myself though, haha.
Great analysis Hannah. For a shimmers dupe the Flower Beauty Desert Lights provide 6 huge sparkling pans of pretty great formula for about 20 pct of the price
I understand dead salmon now that the rug is here BUT I’m still sticking to my guns with Sulking Room. Just imagining how beautiful it will look if/when you start placing your plant collection and other things from previous backgrounds and how well it relates to your opening vibe to of the pink , books, cat, animated hannah etc . I do feel it all will pop with that color more so than the dead salmon
I’m gonna agree with all the Dead Salmons (should be a band name). I love Sulking room pink but I think it might be better suited to a smaller, funkier area like an entryway or a half bath. For makeup filming purposes Dead Salmon provides some interest without too much interest. If I was just a friend advising you on a wall color for a sitting room not intended for UA-cam I would say “go with Sulking Room, live a little.” Both are beautiful colors!
I’m going to still go with sulking room pink in regards to the room/design itself bc it seems more eccentric. When you’re showing makeup items, you’re usually filming swatches top-down over a table so the wall color wouldn’t matter. Dead salmon is nice too, it makes the room a neutral canvas if that’s what you’re going for!
I think Dead Salmon is more neutral and won’t clash with anything that’s in the background. Additionally thanks for this video, I’ve been eyeing this palette since I got a Sephora gift card and I’m gonna try this before I decide on purchasing it.
I still love dead salmon but I’m glad you waited for the rug. It makes the beige in dead salmon pull more yellow. I think I change my vote to sulking room pink. I don’t even care for pink myself but it fits your branding(intro and digital cards) and your personal coloring so well. It’s lovely and cozy💜
Regarding your color clash or complement concerns with Sulking Room Pink, Raw Beauty Kristi painted her new wall deep green and I love it. It’s a color that flatters her and creates a very Kristi mood. But it has never affected how I see her makeup. I think the pink will be the exact same for you. It’s your romantic but grungy vibe. Will flatter you but not distract. I’m team SRP all the way! - plus you can wear that same shirt and you won’t look like a floating head like you would against Dead Salmon. 😂
This eye look is seriously fierce. I’m still loving sulking room pink, especially with the rug there. If anything I love it more with the rug, it just makes me happy.
Wow! Love the rug. I think dead salmon is my final vote after seeing the rug. But, as long as your lovely face is in the frame I don't care what the wall color is. ❤ 😘
My paint thoughts are that Dead Salmon is more practical for your video formats but I can't help but feel a certain way for Sulking Room Pink!! I just keep getting drawn to it. It's a calming but happy color, just like the feeling I get when watching you videos 💕 I also think that the tones in SRP go nicely with the cream colored rug as well as your own complexion. Then again, when you add decor peices to the room it may tie whichever color you choose in together nicely 😊
Ok, seeing the rug. I’m changing my mind. 100% Sulking Room Pink. It’s so pretty and romantic! It does invoke emotions in me. It also reminds me of a very, very small detail in my favorite book (Deeskin, by Robin McKinley) where the heroine has her bedroom painted a rose color. I love it! It feels so welcoming and now I want to paint a room that color myself 💖
Sulking room pink has me so inspired! Okay, so I could decorate the heck out of it with the cream rug base, oh what a vision in my head. Buuuuuut your unique vision must ultimately win out! I think whatever you end up choosing will be lovely and special.
With the neutral, bright rug, I vote for sulking room pink. I actually love how similar it is to many beautiful makeup colors. If you end up going with dead salmon I would recommend including more saturated and non-neutral colors in your decor palette to contrast.
Now that I've seen the lovely rug, I vote even more strongly and passionately for Sulking Room Pink. Yes, Dead Salmon would be more neutral, but when i envision it in this room, with this rug, I think it would be too neutral. I think the light color of the rug would contrast gorgeously with Sulking Room Pink. OK, now that I got that off my chest, I'm going back to watch the rest of the video!
I go back and rewatch your vids often when I’m tempted to buy things, this hair was so iconic 🫰🏻your hair now is also iconic, I love looking through the evolution of your style both in makeup and hair
Oh goodNESS. The zoomed in shots of your eyes blew me away! Love that view!!! Exhilarating! Makes me want to wash my face and play with makeup again today! I love that you played with majority shimmer/metallic shades. Feeling so inspired right now!
I still think Sulking Room Pink is my favorite, but Dead Salmon is oh so very tempting. But- alas- I will not be swayed. I can't wait to see which one you pick! 💕
Honestly either color will look great. I think it's all in how you style it. I still like the pink better, even though dead salmon is more neutral. Sulking room pink goes with your coloring really well and it's more fun! I also loved how the lamp you had in the last video looked next to it. So, yeah, either would be good, but I say go for the pink!!
I was team Sulking Room Pink after your last video and this video made me want to double down on it! While Sulking Room Pink does have a lot of makeup tones, Dead Salmon to me reads very much like a darker version of your olive skin tone and gives me "skin suit" vibes. More washed out. I also love that Sulking Room Pink seems very close to the wall colour in your intro animation!
Sulking Room Pink with this eye look reads very photoshoot hyper-specific color coordination, but with the rug the neutrality of Dead Salmon comes off almost too neutral. If SRP is emotionally activating and evocative, DS is reading like the emotional equivalent of that expanding crack-filler foam caulk, which could be good to showcase the looks and products and foreground their emotional effect! And it does kind of do that with the inserted images from the Patrick Ta palette, but now I'm wondering if it might lower the reaction baseline.
Gotta cast my vote for Dead Salmon! It manages to be beautifully neutral while still having so much personality, and I feel like it also echoes a lot of the colors in your wardrobe. My initial inclination in the last video was Sulking Room Pink, but now seeing the rug and with the extra consideration of how it might affect lighting in the room, Dead Salmon is the clear winner for me!
Sulking Room is lovely (plus 10 points for the name) but Dead Salmon is a great neutral that i think will work with whatever you want to “set dress” with- and that may evolve over time! But hey- you could always mimic wall panels and use both!
I have this palette and I’m in love with it. I love the textured shimmers, but the mattes😍😍 I think they might be better than Natasha denona. They’re like butter smooth and light shades actually shows up on my eyes. Usually those shades r like chalk on my brown skin. I’ve been on a low buy for 2 years and tho I was tempted by like all the rosy eyeshadows palettes that came out especially pat mcgrath divine rose ii, i didn’t buy them. I’m so glad I waited to buy something I really love.
Hi Hannah!! That rug is lovely, so beautiful!! I still love Sulking Room Pink, but I agree that Dead Salmon would be more neutral. Excited to see what you choose. Love you so much!! ❤️❤️❤️
Dear Hannah, thank you very much for your dupe the vibes videos. I have been coveting the Nocturnal Palette from Glaminatrix. I mean, drooling. But then I remembered that I bought Pat's Subversive with the same feelings (I can be grungy, I can do black eyeshadow, bla bla). So I took it out and paired it with my urban decay mini heat palette. As we are not duping the palette but the experience, I decided that the everyday friendly mattes of the mini heat would help. And O M G !!! I have rediscovered two items I had neglected for months, I've loved the looks I have created and I feel like I can keep exploring my grungy side without buying more makeup. And, if I still find myself craving a specific colour from Nocturnal, I will buy a single. Thank you Hanna!
I definitely vote for Dead Salmon. I prefer Sulking Room Pink but I think it would make the room feel darker and is a little less neutral. Seeing you in front of Dead Salmon with the rug is lush! Hannah, I have to tell you. I've done nothing but watch your videos for the past 4 days. We have similar skin tones/types which is really helpful, but I'm also really loving the way you interact with make up and your collection. I don't have plans to do a no buy but I am relating to my make up in a better way now, and I have you to thank for that. My husband is sick of hearing about you because I'm always raving about you haha! Thank you so much for your fresh take on make up and life ❤️
I know exactly what you're talking about -- bubbling with joy!! I've had that feeling before but never known how to explain it. Also, the color palette you've created between the eye, the cheek, the shirt, the hair, the rug, and the paint swatches is just _chef's kiss_ so comforting and cozy
I just cannot let go of my passion for sulking room pink. I need it in my life. I didn’t know I was capable of such feelings about a paint color, I WILL have a cozy pink sulking room of my own one day. That said, whichever choice you make will look lovely.
Oh. My. GOSH! I just am absolutely compelled to stop this vid & tell you that your breakdown of this palette; in your questioning which shade you would use first completely stopped my in my makeup tracks! THIS THOUGHT HAS CHANGED MY PROCESS OF NOT ONLY WANTING, BUT OF BUYING....FOREVER!! The bells they are a'ringing... THANK YOU! I adore makeup but have such a strange relationship with spending my extremely limited budget on it... THIS is a GAME CHANGER! I'm flabbergasted...
Sulking room pink is one of those shades I always include in a self made palette so I’m very partial to it but I love it even more with the rug in place!
I'm gonna say it, someone can wear the darkest shimmer all over their lids. It doesn't matter if they love it. So what if it seems more like an outer corner shade. It's like shimmer, they should put the eyeshadow where they want it, not by where the "makeup rules" say it should go. Hannah I love how you said your preferences because that should be what it is.
I think it’s a really good idea to “dupe the vibes” with everything coming out right now…I feel like this rosey neutral fixation has been going on for two years…I feel like we all have these colors. I just looked at my collection and I have all those colors too. Thanks so much for these videos.
I kinda think it’s been going on a bit longer than two years? Like, the matte lavenderish shade in the Patrick Ta palette was giving me ABH Buon Fresco vibes (it’s also in the Modern Renaissance palette, and that came out in, what, 2016?).
If there is one thing I know about paint, it is that it is easy to paint over it. And one tin of Farrow and Ball will easily do the two walls twice, so you could paint it sulking room pink, change your mind and paint over it with dead salmon, and then if you change your mind back, paint over it with sulking room pink. It will literally be the work of two hours. No need to stress. I vote dead salmon.
Agreed on not needing to stress: It’s just paint, and in a rental at that! So you might as well start with what’s tugging at your heartstrings. Fear (of making the wrong choice, going too dark, too pigmented, too much of a statement, whatever) is a powerful motivator, but love (of a gorgeous color … like Sulking Room Pink lol sorryyyyyy) is more powerful.
I saved myself from buying the Avatar palette by duping the vibes, à la HLP and it was so satisfying. For me swatches are what get me. Not the performance, but the richness of the swatch itself. So going to dig into my shadows helps to alleviate the urge buy.
I still like Dead Salmon the best, but I'm biased towards taupes. Your last video reminded me that underneath my framed prints were paint swatches for when I felt more like making a decision and its 50 shades of taupe in there now. 🤣I did finally pick Vintage Taupe by Benjamin Moore to do my entire bedroom/bookshelves in so I can cover that mess. Maybe making an accent zone in the Sulking Room Pink would make it work without it overpowering the perception of the makeup shades? That might be a neat way to add a color you really love.
Oh wow!! So first I chose Dead Salmon followed by Sulking Room Pink...but now I'm feeling the reverse! Sulking Room Pink has taken over #1 for my vote! But...truly I love both of them! Which...helps you not at all. But, this is fun! (Also, your shirt is kind of between the two...Dead Sulking Room? Sulking Salmon? 😂❤
I absolutely love the way you really zoomed in so we could see the final look! 😍 I think you’re doing a fantastic job learning new techniques with your new equipment! So excited to continue following your career with continued piqued interest!
Ooh the close up video of your eye look is awesome! I love the dupe the vibes videos, I have been watching you from the beginning of your channel and these videos were a game changer for me in how I look at purchasing palettes. I have really gotten my makeup spending under control and it feels great to watch content that doesn’t tempt me to buy things. And another vote for Dead Salmon!
Loving your hair today 😍 and I think Dead Salmon would be my choice. All of your choices are beautiful - I just think my brain would be happier seeing Dead Salmon every day 😊
I love 'duping the vibes' because even when someone loooooves a new palette release, there's usually some kind of change they'd make to the palette if they could. Maybe they'd wish for another shimmer, maybe they feel like it has a few more deeper shades than they actually need, and so on. Duping the vibes lets you create an even more perfect version of the palette. And hmmmmm I may be changing my vote to Sulking Pink. However, if you went with dead salmon and added some accent decorations (candles, lamp, etc) that are similar colors to Sulking Pink I think it would have the same overall result. I love you so much Hannah! Thank you for being such a thoughtful person!
I think with the rug I would choose dead salmon. Sulking room pink is my favourite of the three colours wise, but dead salmon just suits that room as a wall colour perfectly!
i really appreciate that sulking room pink is the background color of all your video thumbnails and tbh it's really grown on me, especially in this video with this eyeshadow palette. i think that it will really work as a room color, especially once you have decorations up. BUT, i'm still going with my original choice of dead salmon. it's the old gum blush in paint color and you pop with it as the background. only good choices!!! can't wait to see what you pick!!!
![Lp. Сердце Вселенной #60 РОЖДЕНИЕ ЛОЛОЛОШКИ [Финал] • Майнкрафт](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/YoR0pAV9FVQ/mqdefault.jpg)
As one who has extensive painting experience I really think you'll find that while sulking room pink is in itself a gorgeous color, once you cover both walls with it, it will appear much darker and quite pink, than just the swatch. Especially with the white rug.
This. Maybe use it as an accent color on the back wall only!
I agree. I originally chose that color in the last video. Now I want the middle shade
+++++
Yeah I’d say go with the eggshell. Even the middle color will appear much deeper. If there was something inbetween the middle color and the eggshell that would be great. But yeah the pink color will end up being dark
Same, mfa in painting, interior designer by profession, taught color theory. Dead salmon is the one
I vote for Dead Salmon because of a parallel, and ensuing analogy, to one previous video of yours: the insanely thorough review of your Babaa pullover, more specifically in reference to its colour. While I cannot quote you verbatim, you mentioned yearning for a hue you will not grow tired of AND will pair beautifully with the rest of your wardrobe, hence you opting for that dark brown shade. A similar situation is happening here in my humble opinion. HOWEVER, you can always incorporate dreamy, bohemian accessories in that Sulking Pink colour into the decoration of your beauty room.
👏👏👏 After reading your input, I too put my vote on Dead Salmon (RIP)
Absolutely this! Dead Salmon is just perfect 👍
This this this!
Dead salmon!!!!!!!!!
Agreed
This is what I tried to say and my tired brain failed me.
My vote is for dead salmon--sulking room pink is my favorite but I think both your makeup and your clothes would pop so perfectly against dead salmon (your corals especially would work better with that option I think). BUT (and this might be absurd idk), have you considered painting the back wall with dead salmon, and the little side wall that's in frame with sulking room pink? Anyway, whatever you choose will be so pretty, especially with the rug!
Oh I love this idea. Just a smudge of sulking room pink
Ooh I like this idea and your reasoning for it!!
okay, hear me out, i'm gonna suggest a wild idea. I've been seeing very strong arguments for both dead salmon and sulking room pink and with the rug now I honestly don't know which to pick. but... what if we don't have to pick? do both!! i think doing the wall directly behind you (and the 2 other unseen walls) in dead salmon would give you the much-needed neutrality, and then paint the wall next to you (the other one we see on camera) in sulking room pink as an accent wall to give you the lovely mauve that suits your brand (with the intro and such) while making the color concern for videos no longer a problem since only a little of it will appear on screen. i think this solution gives you the best of both worlds!! either way, they're both beautiful and I'm excited to see which one you pick (though hopefully both!)
I haven’t commented in ages because I’m a gremlin and I always just watch yt on my tv BUT I had to weigh in on the paint debate! Sulking room pink for sure. I agree, it makes me feel feelings and I love it a lot.
Unrelated, I’ve really cut down on the beauty content I watch (which is good for me, it helps regulate my desire to spend) but I watch all of your videos pretty much as soon as you post them. I love the nuanced way you talk about beauty and I often go back to your no buy videos whenever I need a reminder as to why lipstick isn’t going to solve my problems. Thank you for being such a light in the community 💖
Wow, I have dead salmon AND sulking room pink in my house! Dead salmon is my living room colour, and it has so much dimension to it depending on lighting, time of day, and season. Depending on the lighting in your room and where your windows are, it can lean mauve, greyish, taupe and, my fave, chocolate milkshake coloured :') Sulking room pink is my makeup room colour, and while I find it beautiful in texture and finish, it is definitely quite intense. As this is a much smaller room, it works well. But I imagine in a room as big as yours appears, it could be slightly overwhelming! good luck either way - can confirm both colours are divine!
I LOVE the sulking room pink BUT I think all 4 walls would be overwhelming and it would appear darker. I think it would also affect the way makeup looks on camera. I think the folks are right. My vote is for 3 walls of the dead salmon and 1 accent wall in the sulking room pink. Me thinks that would be perfection! Love you! 😘
Wowza! That close-up at 23:14! Love it! New lens for the win! ❤
The editing of this video is SUPERB. Honestly it is so satisfying to experience. Thank you. ♡
thank you so much!! I feel seen :)
I keep my same vote. Sulking room pink is gorgeous, but I think you want your emotional impact to come from your makeup, clothes and most importantly, your rocking personality. Maybe a win-win would be dead salmon on walls (which looks soothing and grounding) and use home decor pieces in that sulking room pink. Love your choice of rug!
I think the pink makes the room feel cozy, especially when you add some trinkets, art and plants 🪴 in the background. I do not think it will affect the makeup presentation because of your lighting set up and your table top videos. Pick whatever sparks the most joy 💜
Both! Accent wall. Dead salmon on three, pink on one. Or horizontally split with dead salmon having a bigger slice of the wall. Or hell stripes! So many options I can’t decide.
Sulking room pink my pick! Especially as a contrast to the light rug. Having lived in a lot of cookie cutter apartments, dead salmon reminds me a bit of that default beige color the walls tend to come in. And the pink is just more original and HLP imho! Will be a lovely complement to your hair too
oooh love the rug, it looks so soft i wanna roll around on it and get static shock.
Your talking and physically breaking down the palette like that was so unbelievably helpful. And we have opposite instincts! I realized that this palette seems so practical for me because I tend to layer mattes and gravitate towards lighter shimmers for spotlighting. The only color I could we not using was the cranberry one. It just shows that no matter our preferences or specific bodily-beauty needs, this thought process before a purchase or in lieu, is incredibly helpful.
Watching your videos has really helped me to separate my “fantasy self” from “real life me”. I am easily drawn to many eyeshadow palettes, but in reality I have not ever put eyeshadow on that wasn’t pretty neutral or subtlety smoky and actually liked the result. I like colorful and dramatic looks on others and watching on UA-cam; I just do not like how it looks on me. So thank you for helping bring me to awareness of my real preferences vs my impulsive thoughts to buy things I KNOW I will not actually wear.
Ooufff, I forgot to post on the last video for the preferred background colour and it remains the same! I still believe sulking pink is the best one. I also believe that it’ll be a phenomenal contrast to your aesthetic ❣️ love you !
You know, I loved Dead Salmon in the last video. But when you covered up Sulking Room Pink with the rag, I felt like the whole energy of the room just dropped! Dead Salmon suddenly looked very beige-y, especially because the floor is now covered with the cream-colored rug. But I wonder if Sulking Room Pink would look really dark once it's all over the walls. It's a hard choice!
Dead salmon is my vote for sure!
I'm still team "Dead Salmon." Mauve is definitely going to be a concern for colours.
Me too! Dead salmon is a beautiful neutral ish color that still has a bit of pink in it
I have always loved how Lisa Eldridge films with a pure white background and no decor. It sounds like you might feel the same.
Sulking room pink is still everything! Especially with the rug. Chefs kiss baby!
I feel like your look today very much embodies all 3 swatch shades we're debating on. With the rug, I think dead salmon compliments it!! Plus it's very much "old gum blush shade" vibes, which i love
Also, for anyone wondering, the cranberry color Hannah used is from the Juvia’s Place Saharan II palette. It is discontinued as the description box says but if anyone has that palette already now you know!
I just realized the pink paint matches your opening "title card" at the beginning of the video. Also the background of your thumbnail in this video. Based on how your thumbnail looks, I vote for the pink!
This is a solid solid argument!!!
Technically the color used in the thumbnail is more a mix of dead salmon and the pink, maybe 2 parts of dead salmon to 3 parts of pink ? Or even 1:1.
Im going with Dead Salmon. I was indecisive between that and Sulking Room Pink (but ultimately landed on Sulking Room Pink) before but now with the rug I think Dead Salmon works even better in the room and will still keep it bright comparative to Sulking Room Pink. Also, with the rug I am less concerned about coordination with the lamp from last time.
PINK!!!!!! 😁😁😁😁👌🏼
It’ll make it cozier and be beautiful in contrast with plants!! Pink and green are gorgeous together
SULKING ROOM PINK is still my top choice.
Also 10/10 for the editing with featuring specific shadows when referring to them.
OOOH i love the white/brown rug, really lightens the room! I love dead salmon now for sure.
The warm pink! It’s warm, beautiful, cozy, and contrasts with your skin beautifully!
Omg, I am so invested in this paint decision. I am REALLY pulling for dead salmon. This video is such a good case study. Sulking Room is such a great color, it says a lot, it has such an impact on whatever colours are in the foreground. I feel like the eye look you put on today pops so much more against Dead Salmon than against Sulking Room! You're first instinct was correct Hannah, Dead salmon is perfect!
Your hair looks amazing in this video and that shirt compliments your figure/torso really well 😊
Sulking room pink adds dimension to the space without being distracting. Dead salmon is too spot on with the rug.
Sulking room pink!!! It really brings the room to life. Dead salmon is beautiful, but I don’t think it adds as much to the space… I am a bit biased having a pink office myself though, haha.
Great analysis Hannah. For a shimmers dupe the Flower Beauty Desert Lights provide 6 huge sparkling pans of pretty great formula for about 20 pct of the price
I understand dead salmon now that the rug is here BUT I’m still sticking to my guns with Sulking Room. Just imagining how beautiful it will look if/when you start placing your plant collection and other things from previous backgrounds and how well it relates to your opening vibe to of the pink , books, cat, animated hannah etc . I do feel it all will pop with that color more so than the dead salmon
I’m gonna agree with all the Dead Salmons (should be a band name). I love Sulking room pink but I think it might be better suited to a smaller, funkier area like an entryway or a half bath. For makeup filming purposes Dead Salmon provides some interest without too much interest. If I was just a friend advising you on a wall color for a sitting room not intended for UA-cam I would say “go with Sulking Room, live a little.” Both are beautiful colors!
I’m going to still go with sulking room pink in regards to the room/design itself bc it seems more eccentric. When you’re showing makeup items, you’re usually filming swatches top-down over a table so the wall color wouldn’t matter. Dead salmon is nice too, it makes the room a neutral canvas if that’s what you’re going for!
I think Dead Salmon is more neutral and won’t clash with anything that’s in the background. Additionally thanks for this video, I’ve been eyeing this palette since I got a Sephora gift card and I’m gonna try this before I decide on purchasing it.
I still love dead salmon but I’m glad you waited for the rug. It makes the beige in dead salmon pull more yellow. I think I change my vote to sulking room pink. I don’t even care for pink myself but it fits your branding(intro and digital cards) and your personal coloring so well. It’s lovely and cozy💜
Dead Salmon! 🌸🧡😍 And then maybe have a few decorations/ Accents w that mauve color of sulking room pink. 😀
I LOVE how you decided to showcase the look once it was finished. It really shows the dimension and layering you did, in a classic HLP style🥰
Regarding your color clash or complement concerns with Sulking Room Pink, Raw Beauty Kristi painted her new wall deep green and I love it. It’s a color that flatters her and creates a very Kristi mood. But it has never affected how I see her makeup. I think the pink will be the exact same for you. It’s your romantic but grungy vibe. Will flatter you but not distract. I’m team SRP all the way! - plus you can wear that same shirt and you won’t look like a floating head like you would against Dead Salmon. 😂
Enjoying the spaciousness that a bright color brings, I prefer the lightest color of the three.
This eye look is seriously fierce. I’m still loving sulking room pink, especially with the rug there. If anything I love it more with the rug, it just makes me happy.
Wow! Love the rug. I think dead salmon is my final vote after seeing the rug. But, as long as your lovely face is in the frame I don't care what the wall color is. ❤ 😘
My paint thoughts are that Dead Salmon is more practical for your video formats but I can't help but feel a certain way for Sulking Room Pink!! I just keep getting drawn to it. It's a calming but happy color, just like the feeling I get when watching you videos 💕
I also think that the tones in SRP go nicely with the cream colored rug as well as your own complexion. Then again, when you add decor peices to the room it may tie whichever color you choose in together nicely 😊
Maybe she could do the salmon with the sulking room as just an accent?
THAT CLOSE UP FOOTAGE IS GORGEOUS. Kudos to Joe and the new space!!!
Ok, seeing the rug. I’m changing my mind. 100% Sulking Room Pink. It’s so pretty and romantic! It does invoke emotions in me. It also reminds me of a very, very small detail in my favorite book (Deeskin, by Robin McKinley) where the heroine has her bedroom painted a rose color. I love it! It feels so welcoming and now I want to paint a room that color myself 💖
I still like Dead Salmon, I just like the pink better now. I’ll still love your content either way 😊
Pink! Pink pink pink it goes with the rug, it won't be too dark now that the rug is there. You can always paint over it if you hate it but ISSA VIBE
Sulking room pink has me so inspired! Okay, so I could decorate the heck out of it with the cream rug base, oh what a vision in my head. Buuuuuut your unique vision must ultimately win out! I think whatever you end up choosing will be lovely and special.
With the neutral, bright rug, I vote for sulking room pink. I actually love how similar it is to many beautiful makeup colors. If you end up going with dead salmon I would recommend including more saturated and non-neutral colors in your decor palette to contrast.
Now that I've seen the lovely rug, I vote even more strongly and passionately for Sulking Room Pink. Yes, Dead Salmon would be more neutral, but when i envision it in this room, with this rug, I think it would be too neutral. I think the light color of the rug would contrast gorgeously with Sulking Room Pink. OK, now that I got that off my chest, I'm going back to watch the rest of the video!
I go back and rewatch your vids often when I’m tempted to buy things, this hair was so iconic 🫰🏻your hair now is also iconic, I love looking through the evolution of your style both in makeup and hair
Sulking room pink for me! It’s alluring yet refined. And adds a gentle elegance
Oh goodNESS. The zoomed in shots of your eyes blew me away! Love that view!!! Exhilarating! Makes me want to wash my face and play with makeup again today! I love that you played with majority shimmer/metallic shades. Feeling so inspired right now!
Sulking room pink. It’s so lovely, it’s cheerful and makes me smile.
I still think Sulking Room Pink is my favorite, but Dead Salmon is oh so very tempting. But- alas- I will not be swayed. I can't wait to see which one you pick! 💕
Honestly either color will look great. I think it's all in how you style it. I still like the pink better, even though dead salmon is more neutral. Sulking room pink goes with your coloring really well and it's more fun! I also loved how the lamp you had in the last video looked next to it. So, yeah, either would be good, but I say go for the pink!!
I was team Sulking Room Pink after your last video and this video made me want to double down on it! While Sulking Room Pink does have a lot of makeup tones, Dead Salmon to me reads very much like a darker version of your olive skin tone and gives me "skin suit" vibes. More washed out. I also love that Sulking Room Pink seems very close to the wall colour in your intro animation!
Sulking Room Pink with this eye look reads very photoshoot hyper-specific color coordination, but with the rug the neutrality of Dead Salmon comes off almost too neutral. If SRP is emotionally activating and evocative, DS is reading like the emotional equivalent of that expanding crack-filler foam caulk, which could be good to showcase the looks and products and foreground their emotional effect! And it does kind of do that with the inserted images from the Patrick Ta palette, but now I'm wondering if it might lower the reaction baseline.
“the emotional equivalent of that expanding crack-filler foam caulk” Oh my! That is quite the description 😂
my feelings exactly!
Gotta cast my vote for Dead Salmon! It manages to be beautifully neutral while still having so much personality, and I feel like it also echoes a lot of the colors in your wardrobe. My initial inclination in the last video was Sulking Room Pink, but now seeing the rug and with the extra consideration of how it might affect lighting in the room, Dead Salmon is the clear winner for me!
Sulking Room is lovely (plus 10 points for the name) but Dead Salmon is a great neutral that i think will work with whatever you want to “set dress” with- and that may evolve over time! But hey- you could always mimic wall panels and use both!
I have this palette and I’m in love with it. I love the textured shimmers, but the mattes😍😍 I think they might be better than Natasha denona. They’re like butter smooth and light shades actually shows up on my eyes. Usually those shades r like chalk on my brown skin. I’ve been on a low buy for 2 years and tho I was tempted by like all the rosy eyeshadows palettes that came out especially pat mcgrath divine rose ii, i didn’t buy them. I’m so glad I waited to buy something I really love.
Hi Hannah!! That rug is lovely, so beautiful!! I still love Sulking Room Pink, but I agree that Dead Salmon would be more neutral. Excited to see what you choose. Love you so much!! ❤️❤️❤️
Dear Hannah, thank you very much for your dupe the vibes videos. I have been coveting the Nocturnal Palette from Glaminatrix. I mean, drooling. But then I remembered that I bought Pat's Subversive with the same feelings (I can be grungy, I can do black eyeshadow, bla bla). So I took it out and paired it with my urban decay mini heat palette. As we are not duping the palette but the experience, I decided that the everyday friendly mattes of the mini heat would help. And O M G !!! I have rediscovered two items I had neglected for months, I've loved the looks I have created and I feel like I can keep exploring my grungy side without buying more makeup. And, if I still find myself craving a specific colour from Nocturnal, I will buy a single. Thank you Hanna!
I definitely vote for Dead Salmon. I prefer Sulking Room Pink but I think it would make the room feel darker and is a little less neutral. Seeing you in front of Dead Salmon with the rug is lush!
Hannah, I have to tell you. I've done nothing but watch your videos for the past 4 days. We have similar skin tones/types which is really helpful, but I'm also really loving the way you interact with make up and your collection. I don't have plans to do a no buy but I am relating to my make up in a better way now, and I have you to thank for that. My husband is sick of hearing about you because I'm always raving about you haha! Thank you so much for your fresh take on make up and life ❤️
I know exactly what you're talking about -- bubbling with joy!! I've had that feeling before but never known how to explain it.
Also, the color palette you've created between the eye, the cheek, the shirt, the hair, the rug, and the paint swatches is just _chef's kiss_ so comforting and cozy
I just cannot let go of my passion for sulking room pink. I need it in my life. I didn’t know I was capable of such feelings about a paint color, I WILL have a cozy pink sulking room of my own one day. That said, whichever choice you make will look lovely.
Oh. My. GOSH! I just am absolutely compelled to stop this vid & tell you that your breakdown of this palette; in your questioning which shade you would use first completely stopped my in my makeup tracks! THIS THOUGHT HAS CHANGED MY PROCESS OF NOT ONLY WANTING, BUT OF BUYING....FOREVER!! The bells they are a'ringing... THANK YOU! I adore makeup but have such a strange relationship with spending my extremely limited budget on it... THIS is a GAME CHANGER! I'm flabbergasted...
I still vote sulking room pink, I feel that it will look lovely with the more neutral rug, while the other two colors are already neutral themselves.
Exactly! The other two are way too same same to the rug etc
Haven't even watched the video yet, but, oh GOSH, the colors on this video and the look you have going, woman! It is jaw-dropping.
Sulking room pink is one of those shades I always include in a self made palette so I’m very partial to it but I love it even more with the rug in place!
Gurl. Your hair. Your makeup. Your eyeshadow. The rug. I live.
I'm gonna say it, someone can wear the darkest shimmer all over their lids. It doesn't matter if they love it. So what if it seems more like an outer corner shade. It's like shimmer, they should put the eyeshadow where they want it, not by where the "makeup rules" say it should go. Hannah I love how you said your preferences because that should be what it is.
I love sulking room pink, but you can't lose!
I love Angie! She's one of my favorites in the beauty community.
I think it’s a really good idea to “dupe the vibes” with everything coming out right now…I feel like this rosey neutral fixation has been going on for two years…I feel like we all have these colors. I just looked at my collection and I have all those colors too. Thanks so much for these videos.
Yesss🌻!!!
I kinda think it’s been going on a bit longer than two years? Like, the matte lavenderish shade in the Patrick Ta palette was giving me ABH Buon Fresco vibes (it’s also in the Modern Renaissance palette, and that came out in, what, 2016?).
I'm holding firm on Dead Salmon. Also, your duping the vibes videos are such an inspiration!
Sulking Room Pink seems to bring out your beautiful skin tone, as well as the contrast of your hair against it! Love it! ❤️
I love this vintage pink, the first color! So beautiful ♥
Something about that rug has moved me over from Team Dead Salmon to Sulking Room Pink! I love greys with pinks.
It's still sulking room pink for me. I'm always biased against anything too neutral but I'm just incredibly fond of the colour.
If there is one thing I know about paint, it is that it is easy to paint over it. And one tin of Farrow and Ball will easily do the two walls twice, so you could paint it sulking room pink, change your mind and paint over it with dead salmon, and then if you change your mind back, paint over it with sulking room pink. It will literally be the work of two hours. No need to stress. I vote dead salmon.
Agreed on not needing to stress: It’s just paint, and in a rental at that! So you might as well start with what’s tugging at your heartstrings. Fear (of making the wrong choice, going too dark, too pigmented, too much of a statement, whatever) is a powerful motivator, but love (of a gorgeous color … like Sulking Room Pink lol sorryyyyyy) is more powerful.
I love this. I am definitely open to painting it every few months just to keep it fresh! It's a good reminder that there are really no wrong answers.
I saved myself from buying the Avatar palette by duping the vibes, à la HLP and it was so satisfying. For me swatches are what get me. Not the performance, but the richness of the swatch itself. So going to dig into my shadows helps to alleviate the urge buy.
❤️
Salmon. For sure. Beautiful with your hair lol! And the rug. Love it.
Supercalifragilistic fireworks sparkle the house down boots I love you so much
✨
I still like Dead Salmon the best, but I'm biased towards taupes. Your last video reminded me that underneath my framed prints were paint swatches for when I felt more like making a decision and its 50 shades of taupe in there now. 🤣I did finally pick Vintage Taupe by Benjamin Moore to do my entire bedroom/bookshelves in so I can cover that mess.
Maybe making an accent zone in the Sulking Room Pink would make it work without it overpowering the perception of the makeup shades? That might be a neat way to add a color you really love.
Oh wow!! So first I chose Dead Salmon followed by Sulking Room Pink...but now I'm feeling the reverse! Sulking Room Pink has taken over #1 for my vote! But...truly I love both of them! Which...helps you not at all. But, this is fun! (Also, your shirt is kind of between the two...Dead Sulking Room? Sulking Salmon? 😂❤
I absolutely love the way you really zoomed in so we could see the final look! 😍 I think you’re doing a fantastic job learning new techniques with your new equipment! So excited to continue following your career with continued piqued interest!
Sulking Room is my first option, but with the rug in, Dead Salmon is like the perfect neutral.
Sulking room pink!! 🌸🧠👚👛🐽🎀💞💓
Ooh the close up video of your eye look is awesome! I love the dupe the vibes videos, I have been watching you from the beginning of your channel and these videos were a game changer for me in how I look at purchasing palettes. I have really gotten my makeup spending under control and it feels great to watch content that doesn’t tempt me to buy things. And another vote for Dead Salmon!
Loving your hair today 😍 and I think Dead Salmon would be my choice. All of your choices are beautiful - I just think my brain would be happier seeing Dead Salmon every day 😊
I love 'duping the vibes' because even when someone loooooves a new palette release, there's usually some kind of change they'd make to the palette if they could. Maybe they'd wish for another shimmer, maybe they feel like it has a few more deeper shades than they actually need, and so on. Duping the vibes lets you create an even more perfect version of the palette.
And hmmmmm I may be changing my vote to Sulking Pink. However, if you went with dead salmon and added some accent decorations (candles, lamp, etc) that are similar colors to Sulking Pink I think it would have the same overall result.
I love you so much Hannah! Thank you for being such a thoughtful person!
I wrote this before I had watched the whole video and I feel like you made the same statement but wayyyy more in depth at the end of the video.
I love the look you came up with! It's sooo Beautiful!❤️🤩 you are Beautiful!
Now you have your rug, I like the walls best just how they are. Nice, cool clean vibes.
Love your close up shots of the finished look! Very stunning and fun footage!
I think with the rug I would choose dead salmon. Sulking room pink is my favourite of the three colours wise, but dead salmon just suits that room as a wall colour perfectly!
i really appreciate that sulking room pink is the background color of all your video thumbnails and tbh it's really grown on me, especially in this video with this eyeshadow palette. i think that it will really work as a room color, especially once you have decorations up. BUT, i'm still going with my original choice of dead salmon. it's the old gum blush in paint color and you pop with it as the background. only good choices!!! can't wait to see what you pick!!!
It’s got to be Dead Salmon! The addition of the rug really confirmed it for me. Excited to see which you go with!