Sir, sword has been the main instrument of making muslims. It was done 1st by Muhammad followed by Abu Bakr in Arab peninsula. Umardid the same with persia with a huge bonus of trained standing persian army. Withina period of about 20 years entire middle east has become muslim with the help of swords. In fact islam always had a standing army all through its history. As a result as of now 95% of muslims globally are non Arabs/mawalis/ pseudo Arabs suffering from identity crisis leading to instabilities.
Aki abaas your view if you and Pakistan concede to real history almost all problems and misconception between india and pakistan and bare sageer this indian subcontinent would disappear. Hindus have agreed to concede the reality of islam even though it is an imported religion and not born on this bare sageer this continent.
I condemn the killings of both sides. Not at all justified killings of muslims in India even if the train full of dead bodies coming to India. At least both sides should have given safe passage both sides. It all started by muslims in Rawalpindi The first few trains of dead bodies originated from Pakistan. Like dr rashid forefathers, almost all Hindu Sikhs were under the wrong impression that after partition we continue to stay and live in Pakistan.
You are right actually Salman was in hurry due to his session in SLF and was trying to trying to quit and that's why you could feel that I was trying to grab as much I could.
The English pronunciation of Ali Abbas is as bad as his Urdu pronunciation. Sometime I felt as if a kid is asking random aimless questions. The majority of the people in the Indus Valley converted to Islam through the efforts of Sufi missionaries. There was no mass forceful conversion. The spread of Islam was largely a gradual process influenced by various factors including the work of Sufi missionaries. I would also be interested to know how the shoodra ancestors of this baba were treated by their Brahmin masters before the so called "bad Turks" came and rescued them from perpetual humiliation. This is just another type of propaganda.
@Offmusic-u3f That wasn't my intentoin. His previous podcast on the water related issue was very informative. I was genuinely impressed and complimented him for leading such a thoughtful discussion on an important topic. His guests also conducted themselves in a mature and educated manner. I would have been just as justified in criticizing him if the conversation had lacked focus or included random and sometimes childish questions. Salman Rashid can be just as much of a propagandist as the state. He has a tendency to exaggerate issues and making fun of his own people. Not everyone claims Arab ancestry, the overwhelming majority is attached to this land both emotionally and mentally and consider it to be their ancestral homeland. He also portrays Muslim rulers as entirely negative, and he is also full of prejudice agianst Pashtuns/Afhgans. Would he bother to tell us how the uppers caste Hindus treated the Hindus of the lower castes before the arrival of Islam I this region? What was the relation between Hindus and Budhists? The peaceful albeit gullible Punjabi Muslims were tricked into leaving their culture, history and language by the bad people from UP, but who forced the Hindu Punjabis to shun their mother tongue in favour of Hindi?
@@User-b-o9h Dear Bro really Thank you for your constructive criticism I always take it positive. I'll work on these things. You are always welcome to criticize according to your knowledge and opinion. . However Salman Rashid also has pointed out the Class based society and the brutalities of Barhamns as major reason of local support for Arabs during Chuch and Raja Dhahir era. Thankful once again Bro.
Alhamdulillah Proud to be Punjabi Arain❤
Arains are no Brahmins …….
Rashid sir is one of very few brave Pakistani.
Excellent
Great man
हिन्दू समाज हिन्दू संस्कृति और हिन्दू धर्म ही पाकिस्तान बांग्ला देश कश्मीर की असली पहचान है उसी में खुश और तरक्की कर सकते है
It is next to impossible to expect something good in the country
Great personality
Sir, sword has been the main instrument of making muslims.
It was done 1st by Muhammad followed by Abu Bakr in Arab peninsula.
Umardid the same with persia with a huge bonus of trained standing
persian army.
Withina period of about 20 years entire middle east has become muslim with the help of swords.
In fact islam always had a standing army all through its history.
As a result as of now 95% of muslims globally are non Arabs/mawalis/ pseudo Arabs suffering from identity crisis leading to instabilities.
Perfect analysis perfect 👌. But No One could convert india 😂
Stay Blessed 😇🙏
Ali Abbas, your homework is not complete about your guest.
Oh who asks from you
Thankful bro I'll improve it
Khan-you need to show respect
Aki abaas your view if you and Pakistan concede to real history almost all problems and misconception between india and pakistan and bare sageer this indian subcontinent would disappear. Hindus have agreed to concede the reality of islam even though it is an imported religion and not born on this bare sageer this continent.
🎉 Vadde Paaji di Balle balle 🎉
Paaji j mai kadi Lahore aaya taa tuhanu pakka milna Party de dena Murshid 😂
I condemn the killings of both sides. Not at all justified killings of muslims in India even if the train full of dead bodies coming to India. At least both sides should have given safe passage both sides. It all started by muslims in Rawalpindi The first few trains of dead bodies originated from Pakistan. Like dr rashid forefathers, almost all Hindu Sikhs were under the wrong impression that after partition we continue to stay and live in Pakistan.
Alibhai aap kam bola kare
Apko kaya takleef ha 😂
@@Khan-o6z3pRight 👍
Host is in loss of proper words, most of the time.
You are right actually Salman was in hurry due to his session in SLF and was trying to trying to quit and that's why you could feel that I was trying to grab as much I could.
The English pronunciation of Ali Abbas is as bad as his Urdu pronunciation. Sometime I felt as if a kid is asking random aimless questions.
The majority of the people in the Indus Valley converted to Islam through the efforts of Sufi missionaries. There was no mass forceful conversion. The spread of Islam was largely a gradual process influenced by various factors including the work of Sufi missionaries.
I would also be interested to know how the shoodra ancestors of this baba were treated by their Brahmin masters before the so called "bad Turks" came and rescued them from perpetual humiliation.
This is just another type of propaganda.
Why are you judge people you will best in English but plz don't judge someone and last thing don't lose someone confidence
@Offmusic-u3f That wasn't my intentoin. His previous podcast on the water related issue was very informative. I was genuinely impressed and complimented him for leading such a thoughtful discussion on an important topic. His guests also conducted themselves in a mature and educated manner. I would have been just as justified in criticizing him if the conversation had lacked focus or included random and sometimes childish questions. Salman Rashid can be just as much of a propagandist as the state. He has a tendency to exaggerate issues and making fun of his own people. Not everyone claims Arab ancestry, the overwhelming majority is attached to this land both emotionally and mentally and consider it to be their ancestral homeland. He also portrays Muslim rulers as entirely negative, and he is also full of prejudice agianst Pashtuns/Afhgans. Would he bother to tell us how the uppers caste Hindus treated the Hindus of the lower castes before the arrival of Islam I this region? What was the relation between Hindus and Budhists? The peaceful albeit gullible Punjabi Muslims were tricked into leaving their culture, history and language by the bad people from UP, but who forced the Hindu Punjabis to shun their mother tongue in favour of Hindi?
@@User-b-o9h Dear Bro really Thank you for your constructive criticism I always take it positive. I'll work on these things. You are always welcome to criticize according to your knowledge and opinion. . However Salman Rashid also has pointed out the Class based society and the brutalities of Barhamns as major reason of local support for Arabs during Chuch and Raja Dhahir era.
Thankful once again Bro.
Sir, very good historical analysis. Kindly inform about first arrival of syyd or sharif in India who are the major fuedal of Sind and Punjab.
@@Ehsan-bm2st However different Historical books quote various timings but Ummayad period was the starting era for Alids emigration.
duniya ki sari Barkat dariyai Sindh ki Jameen mein hai bhai logon main bheel bol raha hun