info: “A Tithing Autobiography.” (there are different versions found online circa 1915 and 1918) archive.org/details/tithingprosperit00unse/page/64/mode/2up The sacred tenth : or, Studies in tithe-giving, ancient and modern by Lansdell, Henry Volume 1 archive.org/details/thesacredtenthor01lansuoft/mode/2up Volume 2 archive.org/details/thesacredtenthor00lansuoft Tithing And Its Results by Layman (Kane) archive.org/details/tithing-and-its-results-layman-thomas-kane2 A collection of Kane's pamphlets (has duplicate pages) babel.hathitrust.org/cgi/pt?id=hvd.ah4g2z&seq=19 1914 article by Kane The Financial Side of Tithing archive.org/details/sim_herald-of-gospel-liberty_1914-11-26_106_48/page/16/mode/2up Brown, George. (1911) Gems of Thought on Tithing. archive.org/details/gemsofthoughtont0000brow/page/84/mode/2up An example of others during Kane's time with similar experience with prosperity, read: Blacksmith. (1888). The Path To Wealth: Or, Light From My Forge: A Discussion Of God's Money Laws, The Relation Between Giving And Getting, Cash And Christianity. Richmond, Va.: B. F. Johnson. 1-233 catalog.hathitrust.org/Record/102097741 To learn more about general history from this period I recommend: Salstrand, George (1956) The Story of Stewardship Powell, Luther (1962) Money And The Church See especially Chapter XII Calkins, Harvey Reeves (1914) A Man and His Money Croteau, David A., "A Biblical and Theological Analysis of Tithing: Toward a Theology of Giving in the New Covenant Era" (2005). pages 24-32
People who say those who collect the tithes are wicked men gratifying themselves. Often that is the case. Jesus spoke of those very people in the parable of the wicked husbandmen. And a preacher who takes the tithes to profit himself is among those evil men.
1838: Revelation to Joseph Smith..."In the July 8, 1838, revelation, the Lord answered the Saints’ question with these instructions: first, the Saints should make a one-time donation of all their surplus property; “and after that,” the revelation said, “those who have thus been tithed shall pay one-tenth of all their interest annually.” I would say that was a bit before Mr. Kane...
Oh you are Mormon...it is interesting that Mormons did not teach tithing until they had serious financial problems. From your own LDS website "In May 1899, President Snow received a powerful spiritual manifestation that later resolved the Church’s financial problems." Tithe teaching predates Mormonism by millenia and Mormons didn't take tithing seriously until well after Kane and the tithing revival began.
@@AndrewsTitheReview Give credit where credit is due will you! Yes many Saints were strapped thank in no small part to the wicked people of a few states, but the revelation happened on the date I posted...Well before Kane.
@@karlshaner2453 No that is not true, your own Church admits that early Mormons "at the time understood tithing to refer to any amount of freely consecrated goods or money." and " in 1837, Presiding Bishop Edward Partridge and his counselors defined "tithing" as two percent of a household's annual net worth." (See “The Tithing of My People” D&C 119, 120 by Steven C. Harper). Furthermore, the Bible only says we should support preaching the gospel (1 Cor 9:13-14) and Mormonism simply does not preach what the majority of Christianity would consider to be a gospel message so therefore the Mormon Church has no legitimate claim to receive tithe. Of the many problems, Mormonism claims the humans in the church actually have the priesthood of Melchizedek which is a blatant contradiction of the Bible that only Jesus is the High Priest after the order of Melchizedek (Hebrews 7). Good video here about a pastor who left Mormonism ua-cam.com/video/pfFIkY53tfA/v-deo.html
Tithe is typology of Jesus Christ, just like other things in old covenant which typology of Jesus Christ. 1/10 means because of One person sacrifiction, others are blessed. So, it is not about you give your 10% but about God became Man to bless humanity.
Well that's odd, if returning a tenth to preach about the Messiah is a type then why would the Messiah command this same system when the types were done away with? The Lord commanded a minimum tenth for the gospel ua-cam.com/video/2Jlpg0YIrq8/v-deo.html
@@AndrewsTitheReview Tithing is old covenant activity. However, Apostle Paul did not talk about tithing. He just said that you can live from the gospel ministry by the people's support. He used that old covenant activity where the minister of the gospel can live from the ministry. There is no tithing in gospel ministry. If you want to apply it apple to apple, then the gospel minister must do the new covenant activity precisely same as in the old covenant. Don't use the phrase "EVEN SO" as apple to apple precisely same. Look at the context.
@@AndrewsTitheReview if you said that tithing is required system in the gospel spreading then you must see that apostle Paul did not need that so called system to spread the gospel. He could do that without what you called as same system. 1 Corinthians 9:15 (KJV) But I have used none of these things: neither have I written these things, that it should be so done unto me: for it were better for me to die, than that any man should make my glorying void.
@@heyjude6584 "Tithing is old covenant activity." That is refuted by Hebrews 7:9 which proves that tithe was not confined to the old covenant, See here ua-cam.com/video/SHGy0WixD2M/v-deo.html and to the point about Paul he did affirm the right for others as well, see 1 Corinthians 9:12. And the reason why he himself did not accept financial support in Corinth, scholars and theologians addressed that here @22:53 ua-cam.com/video/kpG3ChJ0JUA/v-deo.htmlsi=uaYxE37B-wthqI7S&t=1373
Have you reviewed 'Tithing and Dominion' by Edward A. Powell & Rousas John Rushdoony previously? If not, you may find it to be an interesting treatment on tithing.
I did read it several years ago but found nothing remarkable. In my opinion the best books on tithing were published between about 1870 and 1940. Generally speaking, there are no good books on tithing after 1940.
Same way they did of old! You just have to find who he has given the authority to collect it. I could tell you, if you actually wanted an honest answer.
This sounds manipulative. Also, where do the tithes go? In the Old Testament era, there were tithes that the tither presented to God and then went home and ate or used in communal celebration; there were tithes that went to the Levites and temple service; there were tithes that went to the poor. Since there is no temple where God resides and which is maintained by priests, and since Jesus is our offering and atonement, the onus now is on giving rather than tithing and offerings.
For every person who testifies to an experience of prospering because of tithing there are a lot more who are have not experienced any financial miracles and are struggling as a result. Don't be scammed by these con artists
@@earlysda No because the money isn't going to God. If you do a search online for the number of people who paid tithes and then couldn't afford to pay their bills, I know of people first hand in that situation.
@@penttimuhli9442a tithe is a tenth of your increase. If you have no job, you have no increase then at that point there’s no obligation of tithe. Furthermore, working is also a command in the Bible, see 2 Thessalonians 3:10. Im not sure if that was an attempt to be facetious or not, but when we give to God and his cause, God never will leave us desolate.
@@penttimuhli9442 "not experienced any financial miracles" That is misleading because even Thomas Kane himself said that tithing was no guarantee of success or wealth. As was stated repeatedly in the video he was simply publishing the facts from his survey. You provided no facts but he did so for over 40 years. People across the USA, across denominations overwhelmingly reported being blessed as a result of tithing. And yes it is commanded ua-cam.com/video/2Jlpg0YIrq8/v-deo.html
Forget tithing the Lord, and tithe to YOURSELF!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! I you tithe to yourself from day one,you will never be poor in anyway!
"you tithe to yourself from day one,you will never be poor in anyway!" So if I have $100 and just keep the $10 rather than supporting the good news of Jesus then I will never be poor? 🤔
info: “A Tithing Autobiography.” (there are different versions found online circa 1915 and 1918) archive.org/details/tithingprosperit00unse/page/64/mode/2up
The sacred tenth : or, Studies in tithe-giving, ancient and modern by Lansdell, Henry Volume 1 archive.org/details/thesacredtenthor01lansuoft/mode/2up
Volume 2 archive.org/details/thesacredtenthor00lansuoft
Tithing And Its Results by Layman (Kane) archive.org/details/tithing-and-its-results-layman-thomas-kane2
A collection of Kane's pamphlets (has duplicate pages) babel.hathitrust.org/cgi/pt?id=hvd.ah4g2z&seq=19
1914 article by Kane The Financial Side of Tithing archive.org/details/sim_herald-of-gospel-liberty_1914-11-26_106_48/page/16/mode/2up
Brown, George. (1911) Gems of Thought on Tithing. archive.org/details/gemsofthoughtont0000brow/page/84/mode/2up
An example of others during Kane's time with similar experience with prosperity, read:
Blacksmith. (1888). The Path To Wealth: Or, Light From My Forge: A Discussion Of God's Money Laws, The Relation Between Giving And Getting, Cash And Christianity. Richmond, Va.: B. F. Johnson. 1-233 catalog.hathitrust.org/Record/102097741
To learn more about general history from this period I recommend:
Salstrand, George (1956) The Story of Stewardship
Powell, Luther (1962) Money And The Church See especially Chapter XII
Calkins, Harvey Reeves (1914) A Man and His Money
Croteau, David A., "A Biblical and Theological Analysis of Tithing: Toward a Theology of Giving in the New Covenant Era" (2005). pages 24-32
This was great. Thanks for putting this tribute together.
People who say those who collect the tithes are wicked men gratifying themselves. Often that is the case. Jesus spoke of those very people in the parable of the wicked husbandmen. And a preacher who takes the tithes to profit himself is among those evil men.
So, never mind charitable works. He will shower you with blessings if you pay him cash? He is God the Father not "the godfather."
@@frankbass7561 "never mind charitable works" What? Who said that?
1838: Revelation to Joseph Smith..."In the July 8, 1838, revelation, the Lord answered the Saints’ question with these instructions: first, the Saints should make a one-time donation of all their surplus property; “and after that,” the revelation said, “those who have thus been tithed shall pay one-tenth of all their interest annually.” I would say that was a bit before Mr. Kane...
Oh you are Mormon...it is interesting that Mormons did not teach tithing until they had serious financial problems. From your own LDS website "In May 1899, President Snow received a powerful spiritual manifestation that later resolved the Church’s financial problems." Tithe teaching predates Mormonism by millenia and Mormons didn't take tithing seriously until well after Kane and the tithing revival began.
@@AndrewsTitheReview Give credit where credit is due will you! Yes many Saints were strapped thank in no small part to the wicked people of a few states, but the revelation happened on the date I posted...Well before Kane.
@@karlshaner2453 No that is not true, your own Church admits that early Mormons "at the time understood tithing to refer to any amount of freely consecrated goods or money." and " in 1837, Presiding Bishop Edward Partridge and his counselors defined "tithing" as two percent of a household's annual net worth." (See “The Tithing of My People” D&C 119, 120 by Steven C. Harper). Furthermore, the Bible only says we should support preaching the gospel (1 Cor 9:13-14) and Mormonism simply does not preach what the majority of Christianity would consider to be a gospel message so therefore the Mormon Church has no legitimate claim to receive tithe. Of the many problems, Mormonism claims the humans in the church actually have the priesthood of Melchizedek which is a blatant contradiction of the Bible that only Jesus is the High Priest after the order of Melchizedek (Hebrews 7). Good video here about a pastor who left Mormonism ua-cam.com/video/pfFIkY53tfA/v-deo.html
@@karlshaner2453 Tithing is in the Old Testament and was long before Joseph Smith got his phony revelation.
Tithe is typology of Jesus Christ, just like other things in old covenant which typology of Jesus Christ.
1/10 means because of One person sacrifiction, others are blessed.
So, it is not about you give your 10% but about God became Man to bless humanity.
Well that's odd, if returning a tenth to preach about the Messiah is a type then why would the Messiah command this same system when the types were done away with? The Lord commanded a minimum tenth for the gospel ua-cam.com/video/2Jlpg0YIrq8/v-deo.html
@@AndrewsTitheReview
Tithing is old covenant activity.
However, Apostle Paul did not talk about tithing. He just said that you can live from the gospel ministry by the people's support. He used that old covenant activity where the minister of the gospel can live from the ministry. There is no tithing in gospel ministry.
If you want to apply it apple to apple, then the gospel minister must do the new covenant activity precisely same as in the old covenant.
Don't use the phrase "EVEN SO" as apple to apple precisely same.
Look at the context.
@@AndrewsTitheReview if you said that tithing is required system in the gospel spreading then you must see that apostle Paul did not need that so called system to spread the gospel. He could do that without what you called as same system.
1 Corinthians 9:15 (KJV) But I have used none of these things: neither have I written these things, that it should be so done unto me: for it were better for me to die, than that any man should make my glorying void.
@@heyjude6584 "Tithing is old covenant activity." That is refuted by Hebrews 7:9 which proves that tithe was not confined to the old covenant, See here ua-cam.com/video/SHGy0WixD2M/v-deo.html and to the point about Paul he did affirm the right for others as well, see 1 Corinthians 9:12. And the reason why he himself did not accept financial support in Corinth, scholars and theologians addressed that here @22:53 ua-cam.com/video/kpG3ChJ0JUA/v-deo.htmlsi=uaYxE37B-wthqI7S&t=1373
@@AndrewsTitheReview Jesus lived under the old covenant. 🤦
Have you reviewed 'Tithing and Dominion' by Edward A. Powell & Rousas John Rushdoony previously?
If not, you may find it to be an interesting treatment on tithing.
I did read it several years ago but found nothing remarkable. In my opinion the best books on tithing were published between about 1870 and 1940. Generally speaking, there are no good books on tithing after 1940.
@@AndrewsTitheReview
What do you recommend?
@@graspunwrapped1124 Check these out ua-cam.com/video/8_ZGQQ6QeJw/v-deo.html
must give to who ? The lord ? how to get it to him ?
Same way they did of old! You just have to find who he has given the authority to collect it. I could tell you, if you actually wanted an honest answer.
Hilarious!
This sounds manipulative. Also, where do the tithes go?
In the Old Testament era, there were tithes that the tither presented to God and then went home and ate or used in communal celebration; there were tithes that went to the Levites and temple service; there were tithes that went to the poor. Since there is no temple where God resides and which is maintained by priests, and since Jesus is our offering and atonement, the onus now is on giving rather than tithing and offerings.
For every person who testifies to an experience of prospering because of tithing there are a lot more who are have not experienced any financial miracles and are struggling as a result.
Don't be scammed by these con artists
@@earlysda No because the money isn't going to God.
If you do a search online for the number of people who paid tithes and then couldn't afford to pay their bills, I know of people first hand in that situation.
@@earlysda Are you willing to quit your job and keep paying tithes to prove it?
@@penttimuhli9442a tithe is a tenth of your increase. If you have no job, you have no increase then at that point there’s no obligation of tithe. Furthermore, working is also a command in the Bible, see 2 Thessalonians 3:10.
Im not sure if that was an attempt to be facetious or not, but when we give to God and his cause, God never will leave us desolate.
@@penttimuhli9442 "not experienced any financial miracles" That is misleading because even Thomas Kane himself said that tithing was no guarantee of success or wealth. As was stated repeatedly in the video he was simply publishing the facts from his survey. You provided no facts but he did so for over 40 years. People across the USA, across denominations overwhelmingly reported being blessed as a result of tithing. And yes it is commanded ua-cam.com/video/2Jlpg0YIrq8/v-deo.html
@@earlysda god doesnt tythe not one penny goes to god what would he do with money lol the bibles were written by men wake up fools
God gives us our daily breath, and yet people who call themselves Christian, does not pay a full 10% tithing.
Disgusting.
Because of Kane millions of people have heard about the goods news of Christ's love, why is that disgusting?
very disgusting no matter the beliefs how did kane get it to the lord if there is a god those that made use of tithing would be sent to hell
@@vincentvangogh8092 God calls men to disperse what is his to those in need. All one need do is look.
Forget tithing the Lord, and tithe to YOURSELF!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! I you tithe to yourself from day one,you will never be poor in anyway!
"you tithe to yourself from day one,you will never be poor in anyway!" So if I have $100 and just keep the $10 rather than supporting the good news of Jesus then I will never be poor? 🤔