You did not refute Hebrews 7:9 which proves that tithe is not only from Mosaic law and you did not refute 1 Cor 9:13-14 which cites the model of tithing for the support of the gospel. I already made videos on these points here: ua-cam.com/video/SHGy0WixD2M/v-deo.html and ua-cam.com/video/kpG3ChJ0JUA/v-deo.html
Abraham had no law to give tithe. He gave the tithe freely. So if Abraham is our model we should only give when we want to. Also we should give 90% to the gays because Abraham gave the 90% to Sodom and Gomorra. So we really should give 100% whenever we want to and when we take spoils in battle we should donate 90% to the gay lobby and gift the 10% to a Jew.
@@AndrewsTitheReviewin regard to 1 Cor 9:13-14 nobody said or implied that giving is wrong ( God loves a cheerful giver). It's making people feel guilty when they don't give, that's the problem.
Robert Breaker speaks truth when he preaches. He backs everything up with scripture! I don't understand why people speak ill of him. He is a man of God!!!
@@mercyfaith2928 You did not refute Hebrews 7:9 which proves that tithe is not only from Mosaic law and you did not refute 1 Cor 9:13-14 which cites the model of tithing for the support of the gospel. I already made videos on these points here: ua-cam.com/video/SHGy0WixD2M/v-deo.html and ua-cam.com/video/kpG3ChJ0JUA/v-deo.html
Robert Breaker has been a blessing to me for a while now. Dispensation makes the most sense out of everything i have studied. When you don't divide the word and try to force it all on our current generation it gets very confusing and contradictory!
EQOAnostalgia I did a study on dispensation and from Gods word what Robert Breaker claims it to be didn’t match... I understand what R.B is claiming it be.. gods word is not contradictory.. God had a plan for mankind when he created us.. sin was not meant to be apart of that plan. God knew we would fall, knew He would send His son to redeem us.. redeem us for what.. back to His original plan.. sin separates us from God.. The Bible is a guide so we can know who God is and what we need to do to make heaven our home.. plus so so so so much more..
Three problems with your criticisms of Robert Breaker’s video. 1. You don’t rightly divide the word (2 Timothy 2:15) of truth since Abraham’s dispensation and the Jewish nation are different to the church today 2. You quoted from a different Bible to the one Robert used. Hence your maths is wrong 3. He provided plenty of Biblical evidence which you did not refute entirely
That’s what’s crazy. Defending the lie. Wouldn’t it make more sense to search the scriptures and be able to say .... (means your findings) how bad would it be to miss heaven because you chose to believe a lie. You were exposed to the fact that’s it’s a lie. The Bible says you need to work out your own salvation.
@@alexandrinamayberry603 the same could be said for the person who's attempting to expose Robert Breaker. Why he wouldn't dare to ask Mr Breaker for a online debate for recording and UA-cam if he tried because he'd be cooked by counter scripture verses on the spot.
You did not refute Hebrews 7:9 which proves that tithe is not only from Mosaic law and you did not refute 1 Cor 9:13-14 which cites the model of tithing for the support of the gospel. I already made videos on these points here: ua-cam.com/video/SHGy0WixD2M/v-deo.html and ua-cam.com/video/kpG3ChJ0JUA/v-deo.html
@@AndrewsTitheReview if I'm not mistaken, tithes and offerings was originally instituted, so that sacrifices could be offered up for sins. Even before the law, sacrifices had to be offered up, so that sin's could be covered. Now that Christ has died on the cross, so that our sins could truly be cleansed. We no longer need to give tithe of our agriculture so that it can be sacrificed, since that is what tithes and offerings was originally instituted for. Now in the New Covenant, we should give freely and generously to our Church, but it can be more or less than 10%. When it comes to Christ, we give Him our whole hearts, and not 10% of our income.
@@bmlove81 If that is true can you explain why Paul in 1 Cor 9:13-14 would appeal to tithes and offerings and claim this is commanded by the Lord for the gospel? And if your argument is true can you explain why the Levites were said in Hebrews 7:9 to symbolically pay tithe to Melchizedek?
You did not refute Hebrews 7:9 which proves that tithe is not only from Mosaic law and you did not refute 1 Cor 9:13-14 which cites the model of tithing for the support of the gospel. I already made videos on these points here: ua-cam.com/video/SHGy0WixD2M/v-deo.html and ua-cam.com/video/kpG3ChJ0JUA/v-deo.html
DJ KENOTIX no he isn’t... I’ve watched several of his videos ALL OF THEM ARE LACED WITH LIES.. WHICH MEANS THERES NO TRUTH.. JESUS IS TRUTH.. THE DEVIL IS THE FATHER OF LIES
If he is so great with the Bible then why not refute Hebrews 7:9 which proves that tithe is not only from Mosaic law and you did not refute 1 Cor 9:13-14 which cites the model of tithing for the support of the gospel? I already made videos on these points here: ua-cam.com/video/SHGy0WixD2M/v-deo.html and ua-cam.com/video/kpG3ChJ0JUA/v-deo.html
@AndrewsTitheReview because those verses say nothing about tithe being mandatory. The verses speak of a time ago during time of Levi. Its not an instruction. Stop forcing this verse even when it does not apply.
@AndrewsTitheReview the corinthians verse says pastors should live by what they get from church. ŸES they must but not TITHE but the congregation should GIVE and NOT PAY.
@@AndrewsTitheReview You have not rightly divided the word my friend. Are you even saved? I noticed someone asked you what is the gospel, and you did not answer. How is this edifying to anyone in the body of Christ? If you are saved, wouldn't your time be better spent sharing the gospel of salvation with as many people as possible in these last days of the church age - you know, serving Jesus?🩸✝
@@wyattearpswoman838 Can you provide a biblical answer or are you just going to deflect and avoid the problem? Breaker made false claims that have been refuted and you have no evidence to defend him.
Dean Tiu .. yes I believe I’m a sinner saved by grace. That Jesus Christ is the son of God and he died on the cross, rose again on the 3 day. Rom 10;9 I need to believe and confess that Jesus is lord.. I don’t pretend scriptures don’t exist.. the. I le talks about names being blotted out of the book of life.. whose names.. the ones that got saved and fell away.. which makes osas. A lie.. the Bible talks about a thief that comes to steal kill an destroy.. who is that the devil... lol... you laughing.. Eve had never sinned and your crazy enough to think your guaranteed heaven.. NOW the flip side.. IT IS POSSIBLE TO STAY SAVED.. the Bible talks about your heart being wicked .. you have to do your part by staying close to Jesus.
I don't believe in the curse of not tithing according to OT (Malachi ) ... I learned to Give well over 10% ( with discernment ) early as a Christian to worthy ministries , Fundamental, Evangelical, Gospel Preaching ( 1 Cor 15, Eph 2:8-9 ) , before I heard Sermons on Tithing. One preacher discouraged me by stating my Giving was in vain ( No Reward in Heaven ) IF I didn't Tithe First ( Tithe to Their Local Church ) . Some Assemblies of God imply you loose Salvation for Not Tithing . Free Will Giving, Will Out Give any Tithing Principle IF the preacher will Encourage his flock to Lay Up Treasure in Heaven
Man where you came out from. Mr Breaker pulls everything from the Bible, he's 100% correct and in line with scripture. What is your purpose here on UA-cam?
You did not refute Hebrews 7:9 which proves that tithe is not only from Mosaic law and you did not refute 1 Cor 9:13-14 which cites the model of tithing for the support of the gospel. I already made videos on these points here: ua-cam.com/video/SHGy0WixD2M/v-deo.html and ua-cam.com/video/kpG3ChJ0JUA/v-deo.html
Did Abram tithe to Melchizedek weekly? It seems that Abraham met Melchizedek once in his entire life, so Abraham tithed once in his life, so we should tithe once in our entire lives? The same goes for Jacob, who after his dream of the angels going up & down the ladder, woke up to say, “If the Lord is with me I will give Him 10%” It’s never even seen whether or not Jacob kept his word, but if he did, he probably did it once, not weekly, so once again we should tithe once in our life by that logic. Now am I an Israelite, am I a Levite, am I Jewish, no? Then the Jewish Levites should pay tithes + keep the other legalistic 612 Laws in order to appease. My issue with tithing is that once you indoctrinate 10% into someone’s mind then that’s where they remain & never advance on to 11% or 12% or more. So if a Pastor gets upset at me for saying “I do not tithe, I am not a tither.” What’s the problem? I’m trying to add more onto his paycheck. I’m trying to put more gas in his tank. I’m trying to add more steak to his plate. Add rims to his Escalade. I do not tithe, I’m not a ten percent-er. I want to be a 100%-er. Joseph the Levite aka Barnabas gave 100% to the cause ✝️ Ananias & Saphirra pretended to give 100% to the cause & we all know what happened to them.
"they remain & never advance on to 11% or 12% or more." What a flat out lie. This is what antitithers do, they can't refute the argument so they strawman and use logical fallacies.
Abram took no spoil. His offering was not a tithe. The first tithe is Jacob’s bargain with the god at the ladder - offering 10% for gain = quid pro quo = Matt 4:11 Satan gives “if...” This is a very angry hatchet video. Seek Peace with your brother or move on. John 8:40
If he is right how come not one single person can defend Mr. Breaker's claims nor can anyone refute Hebrews 7:9 which proves that tithe is not confined only to Mosaic law and neither can anyone refute 1 Cor 9:13-14 which cites the model of tithing for the support of the gospel. If Mr. Breaker and his supporters are correct then why can't they refute these Scriptures?
Peter Heinz that’s sad.. it’s not about for the win. Think.. if you believe a lie and miss heaven what was won.. listen to the video and hear what he has to say.. Robert Breaker is trying to prove a point with nonsense like going on the price is right.. outrageous.. tithing IS biblical..
You did not refute Hebrews 7:9 which proves that tithe is not only from Mosaic law and you did not refute 1 Cor 9:13-14 which cites the model of tithing for the support of the gospel. I already made videos on these points here: ua-cam.com/video/SHGy0WixD2M/v-deo.html and ua-cam.com/video/kpG3ChJ0JUA/v-deo.html
Mate, your so far off the mark. Brother Breaker backs EVERYTHING up by scripture & not opinion. I pray you repent & take this great error of yours off UA-cam.
If the claims are based on scripture then why don't you refute Hebrews 7:9 which proves that tithe is not only from Mosaic law and you did not refute 1 Cor 9:13-14 which cites the model of tithing for the support of the gospel. I already made videos on these points here: ua-cam.com/video/SHGy0WixD2M/v-deo.html and ua-cam.com/video/kpG3ChJ0JUA/v-deo.html
What are the consequences of not tithing ? The open window has nothing to do with money. Even those who don't tithe have. Church support is very important. Putting a % is already a compulsion. Give
"Tith is to the priests. No priests, Levites. Christians are all priests." That's not true, even the Levite priests paid tithe, read Numbers 18:25-29. The only person who did not tithe was the high priest and the only high priest now is Jesus.
Question: would God have had to institute tithing had Israel not rejected Him as His firstborn, and had to be replaced by Levi Numbers 3? What was the fundamental reason God instituted tithing? I believe God was more concerned about His word being established. He has promised to bring His Son out of Egypt. His "son", Israel rejected Him Exodus 19, He got angry amd would have wiped them out, but Moses interceded and God replaced them with the tribe of Levi- He called them His firstborn Numbers 3:12, and became their portion instead of giving them a physical inheritance in the promised land. They had to be pure and Holy, so as to be able to represent Israel and carry their sins, and atone once a year for them. They mustn't be distracted, so God made available tithes to them, to ensure that they ate the best as if they had produced them by themselves and not some left overs. Unfortunately, later on in the time of kings of Israel, the temple doors were shut and the eternal fire went out, the Levites went out to fend for themselves, and werr not sanctified as they should. God's grace bore with them, and the last Levitical priest was Eli and his sons. King Saul was permitted to send Doeg to kill them all. Some escaped but it was never the same. Samuel from the tribe of Judah ushered in the era of priests. It ended with the advent of Elijah the prophet, which ended with Malachi. Then Elijah, returned to finish his commission which he quit when Jezebel threatened him and asked to die. He single handedly cut off the heads of 850 prophets of baal and ashera and he subsequently-after preaching repentance to Israel to make way for their last hope of reconciliation, he paid with his head as well. God made another way to fulfill His word in Jesus- the Son of man, becoming the Son of God, by letting Him be taken back to Egypt because of the same event that that brought about the salvation of Moses, and now He is coming out as the Son of God, to complete the journey the Israelites and Levites came short of. Matthew 2:13-15. He came to bring them back to Himself and they still rejected Him, so He extended salvation to all- both Jews and gentiles John 12:32 and paid the penalty that would please God. He was nailed to the cross, died was buried but was raised up from the dead, that all who would simply believe in Him Ephesians 2:8, would not perish, but have everlasting life John3:16. He wasn't sent to root out law breakersand deal with them. He instead sent His Holy Spirit to teach, lead and interpret His will to all those who would simply believe! Is that so difficultto understand?. During this church era, God isn't dealing with Israel as a nation, thus all the laws and statutes do not apply to believers Romans 9:4-5, except for believers to love others as He has loved them- as unlovable as they are, so He can bring them unto Himself is Jesus Christ as members of His body. But duringthe last 7 week years, Israel will go back to the point where her book was shut, Daniel 12:4, and continued until the conclusion of the world system by tribulation and armageddon battle. Jesus will now return with members of His body whoch completed Him as the Head during the catching away- a gigantic Creature; and rest His feet on the mount of Olives Zechariah 14, to make way of escape for the remnants of Israel and then destroy the enemy by His Breath and the Sword that comes out of His mouth. Then the 1000 of destruction of the last curse upon man- death will give way to judgment and reward and the new heaven and new earth, with new Jerusalem coming down into earth so that God can finally be Emmanuel- in the midst of His people. In conclusion, none of them is right. Love of money is definitely the root of all evils and debates.
The bottom line is that we are not required to tithed 10% under the new covenant. Abram gave 10% and that was great but GOD did not tell Abram to tithed 10%, he did that on his own. I agree with Robert Breaker that today we should tithed and using 10% as a bench mark is a good place to start and you can give more; however, you are not required to give any percentage. The old law does not apply to us today. Like Paul says, just because we are not under the law any more does not mean that we should disregard it, as there is so much truth and wisdom that we can benefit and apply to our lives from these laws that God gave exclusively to the Jews. The problem was that the law was a burden and the Jews could not keep the laws, that's why God sent Jesus to free the Jews from the law, and by freeing the Jews from the law, salvation became available to the Jews and Gentiles, which is us or anyone who is not Jewish and believe in Jesus. Salvation is not base on the law any longer or on works, just faith is required. I appreciate the constructive criticism that Andrew makes on Robert Breaker explanation on Tithing, however, it seams that by his comments that he subscribed to the notion that today we all have to tithe 10% of our income which I respectfully disagree with. God Bless
If what you say is true that giving %10 is a matter of the mosaic "old law" then why don't you refute Hebrews 7:9 which proves that tithe is not confined only to Mosaic law? Your claims contradict the Scripture. Furthermore you made no attempt to refute 1 Cor 9:13-14 which cites the model of tithing for the support of the gospel, why did you ignore this? Paul says this is commanded by the Lord. And if we Christians are now compelled by love (2 Cor 5:14) then why would love compel us to give less than the minimum %10 that was compelled of the Jew? Does the cross and love of Jesus compel us to become more stingy and give less? I already made videos on these points here: ua-cam.com/video/SHGy0WixD2M/v-deo.html and ua-cam.com/video/kpG3ChJ0JUA/v-deo.html
@@AndrewsTitheReview1 Cor 9: 15 states that he used none of those things: neither did he write those things that it should be done so unto him, for it were better for him to die than for any man to make his glorying void.
@@damarismuigai2527 Yes that is 1 Cor 9:15 but Paul specifically affirmed the rights of others to receive support in 1 Cor 9:12. I made a video about this. Furthermore 2 Cor 8:7-8 is the basis for giving more than %10, see the #1 Best argument for tithing here: ua-cam.com/video/BqA_xfPlzzY/v-deo.html and the video on 1 Cor 9:13-14 here ua-cam.com/video/kpG3ChJ0JUA/v-deo.html
@@AndrewsTitheReview2 Corinthians 9:7 (KJV) Every man according as he purposeth in his heart, so let him give; not grudgingly, or of necessity: for God loveth a cheerful giver.
It's simple my friend, tithing is under the old covenant law. It is finished, we are not under the law. Give cheerfully, but you decide what and to whom.
The Abraham tithing was from the heart, he never tithed from his but from the spoil, hence Isaac never even started to tithe. The law started from Mosheh of Israelites to pay tithes. El-Avram was under grace I can say🙏🙏
Dude, you're speaking gibberish. I agree with Robert Breaker all the way. You're taking a lot out of context and it sounds like you don't like him very much.
Do you love Jesus? How come not one single person can defend Mr. Breaker's claims nor can anyone refute Hebrews 7:9 which proves that tithe is not confined only to Mosaic law and neither can anyone refute 1 Cor 9:13-14 which cites the model of tithing for the support of the gospel. If Mr. Breaker and his supporters are correct then why can't they refute these Scriptures? If you love Jesus you will love the Scriptures.
No wonder Mr. Breaker had a "cloud" ministry 😂...no need to support the gospel at all! It's going to be hard to send out people to spread the gospel as commanded by our Lord because of a few bad people who abuse the concept of money...even if people disagree on the %, they should consistently GIVE...but they simply don't Then they bash those who obey scriptural giving...this way, they feel better about themselves. Truth is, they don't give consistently, they give excuses and they blablablah a lot. Don't waste your time. You already said what GOD put in your heart to be said. Now it's on them! Blessings!
I watched this. I had to stop when he said we are free to give more. After that o could not listen. Try “ the door” micheal pearl. I love his teachings. He teaches tithe is sin because it puts us back under law. 1 Corinthians 16 has a verse somewhere about the first day of the week to set aside ( I found this in a sermon by dr gene kym. ) So we are to be charitable but what is in our hearts not for the geeed of the synagogue. I grew up being taught tithing is wrong so I’m Sorry but i agree with that. You give what is in your heart
Robert actually mentions "a time before the law " further on in his teaching on tithing in regards to Abraham. There are so many good teachers on this subject, and they all get tithing in context, saying the same thing with the use of proper exegesis and hermeneutics!
Which one do you like more, Robert Breaker or Jesus? Hebrews 7:9 and 1 Corinthians 9:13-14 prove that Breaker's claims are false so you have to choose, Breaker or Jesus?
Sorry but we give as we prospere according what the Holly Spirit put on our hearts we don't give by law or according to a vlontary committement by our father of faith Abraham and even if we do good not by moving by the Holly Spirit we do wrong I hope you know why.
In Deutoronomy 14, you can use your tithing to go buy liquors and wine and go have a good time. Now to all proponents of tithing: how come, I have never heard any preaching about that?
According to you John McCarther is also wrong. There are many tithes, including the ones for the widows. This is for a group of people that had a theocratic government. How about Rom 12:1-2, Phil 2:13. Holy Spirit in us leads us to give all of us for His purpose. Give cheerfully, because one wants to. I think that legalism misses the Heart Of Christ.
God is not the author of confusion. I heard that Jesus did not tithe. If that is true, I suppose it's because He *was* the tithe. Thanks for this info. It was enlightening.
If he is so sound in preaching the Bible then why not refute Hebrews 7:9 which proves that tithe is not only from Mosaic law and you did not refute 1 Cor 9:13-14 which cites the model of tithing for the support of the gospel? I already made videos on these points here: ua-cam.com/video/SHGy0WixD2M/v-deo.html and ua-cam.com/video/kpG3ChJ0JUA/v-deo.html
If you tell the story in it’s entirety, Abraham tithing is mentioned only once. Second, he didn’t go to war for the spoils, he went to save his people. They decided to take the spoils after there was no one left. Second, in that same story…. Abraham then gave the remaining 90% to the king back to the king of sodom. Should we tithe our 10% and let the government keep the rest? Not to mention the king of Sodom offered Abraham to keep what he wanted and Abraham stated, 22 But Abram said to the king of Sodom, “With raised hand I have sworn an oath to the Lord, God Most High, Creator of heaven and earth, 23 that I will accept nothing belonging to you, not even a thread or the strap of a sandal, so that you will never be able to say, ‘I made Abram rich.’ Abraham clearly states none of it belonged to him but to the king Solomon. I agree with brother Breaker.
I don't have time to address all of the many errors in Robert Breakers tithes teaching but I will state that tithing was established with Abel & Cain. It was a requirement set up by God. Genesis 4:3-7; Hebrews 11:4. Abraham paid tithes. Genesis 14:28-20 & Hebrews 7:2-4. Jacob paid tithes. Genesis 28:20-22. Levi paid tithes in Abraham. Hebrews 7:9-10. This was required before the law and was required also under the law & so it is today to be paid without the law. It was never eliminated from the time of Cain & Abel. Don't be fooled. Don't pay? That decision comes with a curse. Seeing tithe was established before the law the scripture still stands: will a man rob God? Malachi chapter 3. We don't throw out the Old Testament, we learn from it. Regarding the New Testament, the Apostles were setting up churches from scratch in the business of saving souls. Most were poor. Acts 4:34 Neither was there any among them that lacked: for as many as were possessors of lands or houses sold them and brought the prices of the things that were sold, Verse 35...and distribution was made unto every man according as he had need. This is also in a time of great persecution. Also the priests in that day are called pastors in our day. I am amazed & so surprised that Breaker of all people went so far off on this teaching. God says pay Me 1st. Abraham paid 10% tithe directly to God in the appearance of Melchizedek in the flesh realm. Genesis 14:18-20. Read Hebrews chapter 7. Verse 2- God is the King of Righteousness & Peace. Jerusalem was called Salem 1st. In this chapter it gives you a description of who God is in the body of Melchisedec. Verse 3 - He has/never had a father, no mother, no descent (meaning no ancestor, birth or lineage) no beginning of days nor end of life--from everlasting to everlasting thou art God. Melchisedec in the old testament is Jesus in the new testament which is God hidden in human flesh so we could see Him real time. John 10:30 I and my father are one. You can't separate me. John 14:9-10 ...hast thou not known me Philip? He that hath seen me hath seen the Father; and how sayest thou then, show us the Father? 1 John 5:20...and we are in him that is true, even in his Son Jesus Christ. This (Jesus) is the true God, and eternal life. Revelation 17:14 These shall make war with the Lamb (behold the lamb of God which taketh away the sins of the world)....for he is Lord of lords & King of kings) God came in many appearances. Melchisedec is one of them. Jesus is another amongst others. You must know your word so you'll know when someone is off tract. Do Malachi or be cursed God woll get his money one way or another. All your resources come from Him & He has power to remove them. I've seen the results of Christians who decided they didn't need to tithe. One lost job & basically ate cereal mostly everyday for years. Ypu cannot tell her not to pay tithes today. Another lost job, car & home. She used not attending her church services is why she didn't pay & spent it. Lame excuse. She could have mailed them. He gave you a job & says pay me 1st. Give me 10 % off the top before taxes & you can have 90%. God is not playing. Heed the warning.
Explain the Son when he prayed to the Father. I believe what Jesus told Thomas have I been so long with you and yet you don't know me. But was he praying to himself? Please Explain
I believe you would do well to refer to and understand these two scriptures. 2 Timothy 2:15 15 Study to shew thyself approved unto God, a workman that needeth not to be ashamed, rightly dividing the word of truth. Galatians 3:24-26 24 Wherefore the law was our schoolmaster to bring us unto Christ, that we might be justified by faith. 25 But after that faith is come, we are no longer under a schoolmaster. 26 For ye are all the children of God by faith in Christ Jesus.
Robert breaker is a biblical scholar! He knows his stuff backwards and forwards! I read my Bible and go to Bible college. I understand that we should give but it's not that we have to! There's also a ways of giving also like.. serving etc. God bless brother. Don't be so mad!
Why can't a "biblical scholar" refute Hebrews 7:9 which proves that tithe is not only from Mosaic law and you did not refute 1 Cor 9:13-14 which cites the model of tithing for the support of the gospel? I already made videos on these points here: ua-cam.com/video/SHGy0WixD2M/v-deo.html and ua-cam.com/video/kpG3ChJ0JUA/v-deo.html
I agree with Robert Breaker 100% Tithing has been abused in a fashion that Christians are forced to do it. In some churches the stance on tithing is too cardinal even for salvation which is false. Tithing is not required for Christians.
If tithing is not required why does the Lord command this for the gospel? Why don't you refute Hebrews 7:9 which proves that tithe is not only from Mosaic law and then refute 1 Cor 9:13-14 which cites the model of tithing for the support of the gospel? I already made videos on these points here: ua-cam.com/video/SHGy0WixD2M/v-deo.html and ua-cam.com/video/kpG3ChJ0JUA/v-deo.html
If he is so great with the Bible then why not refute Hebrews 7:9 which proves that tithe is not only from Mosaic law and you did not refute 1 Cor 9:13-14 which cites the model of tithing for the support of the gospel? I already made videos on these points here: ua-cam.com/video/SHGy0WixD2M/v-deo.html and ua-cam.com/video/kpG3ChJ0JUA/v-deo.html
The answer is not either man BUT: God's directive from God's Apostle to the church Paul. 2Pe 3:15 And account that the longsuffering of our Lord is salvation; even as our beloved brother Paul also according to the wisdom given unto him hath written unto you; 2Pe 3:16 As also in all his epistles, speaking in them of these things; in which are some things hard to be understood, which they that are unlearned and unstable wrest, as they do also the other scriptures, unto their own destruction. The answer to you sirs is directly from God and His Word sirs:1Co 16:2 Upon the first day of the week let every one of you lay by him in store, as God hath PROSPERED him, that there be no gatherings when I come. [The Holy Spirit And God's Apostle to new testament church Paul]
"The answer to you sirs is directly from God and His Word sirs:1Co 16:2"...Why are you conflating this text with tithe? As every single commentary attests this is about the collection of freewill offerings, not about supporting the gospel which Paul addressed in 1 Cor 9:13-14 where he appealed to the tithe model. See my video on that.
from one aspect your comment is funny. Biblically incorrect and indefensible but funny. Sad though when you think of the loss you will incur and that is not funny.
@@AndrewsTitheReview If I believe that tithing is a horrible false doctrine that rips off millions of Christians then would I be welcomed in your church?
@@jamesirvin7799 I'm not talking about financially well off churches, I'm talking about missionary minded churches who send out evangelists, missionaries, and pastors to unreached areas. This is about preaching the gospel of Christ to the lost. Do some churches spend extravagantly and wastefully? Sure. But there are many churches who do not so your exception does not nullify the rule. Don't you want the lost to hear the gospel and be saved?
Totally agree with Robert breaker. I dont how many pastorsare beating their congregation into that 10% submission. But I guess you can do that to Christians when they don't have a dispensational view.
Abraham was not compelled by any law or other to give ten percent of all he had won in battle to Melchizedek. Melchizedek gave Abraham some bread and wine then blessed Abraham and In return, Abraham gives him a tithe of the booty.
I don't go along with you at all, because you get it all wrong! my goodness, try to reconcile your thoughts my friend flika, what Robert here is saying something so different that you don't understand and need to study a lot more. Joe.
I will say even if you are correct and looks like you are, you don’t have to be this rude about it. Did Robert Baker do something to personally make you mad?
What exactly did I say that was rude? Jesus said in John 18:23 that if you accuse someone you must provide evidence, where is the evidence that I was rude?
If he is so careful with the Bible then why not refute Hebrews 7:9 which proves that tithe is not only from Mosaic law and why not refute 1 Cor 9:13-14 which cites the model of tithing for the support of the gospel? I already made videos on these points here: ua-cam.com/video/SHGy0WixD2M/v-deo.html and ua-cam.com/video/kpG3ChJ0JUA/v-deo.html
@@AndrewsTitheReviewthe word " tithe" is not used, but rather to give joyfully. That could mean to give less than a tenth, or even more, either way God is not going broke. God bless.
@@andynaz5631 Actually, no that is not true. The Holy Spirit cited the model of tithes and offerings in 1 Corinthians 9:13-14 and said this is commanded by the Lord for the gospel, I already made a video on that here ua-cam.com/video/kpG3ChJ0JUA/v-deo.html and your reference to giving joyfully is from 2 Cor 9 which refers to supporting humanitarian needs, not to the gospel, I already addressed that here ua-cam.com/video/dJF5X-wcrR8/v-deo.html
@@andynaz5631 That is incorrect for two reasons. The system of tithes and offerings referred to in 1 Cor 9:13-14 has a minimum %10 for the gospel work. Your claim contradicts this Scripture because if it's less than %10 then it cannot be "even so" per 1 Cor 9:13-14. Furthermore, by claiming the children of Abraham had to give a %10 minimum before but that the children of Abraham today can give less you are arguing that the love of Christ and the Holy Spirit make people stingier than the Jews of the Old Testament. That is incorrect and you have no evidence for this claim. This was already addressed in the video, "#1 best argument" which nobody in the anti-tithing community has ever been able to refute ua-cam.com/video/BqA_xfPlzzY/v-deo.html
I stopped watching when he said a taxi driver should tithe gasoline to the church..... Nope. Duh.... Gasoline is consumed by the taxi - not produced by it. Tithe was on the overall increase the person had.... Not what they consumed. Plus he refused to understand the simple principle that if tithe is on whater assets increased for the person, then yes! - MONEY would be what is tithed in a modern society. If a farmer still lives on and trades on ONLY livestock and crops then he would tithe of those things. But if the farmer trades livestock and crops for money - then money would be what he would tithe on. There was no overarching standard of "money" or coins or any such thing in the days of Moses. So they couldn't tithe on money - since it was not a marker of increase in assets.
I also believe the teaching of Robert, He is just more educated than you. you are just a person looking to pretend that you have more knowledge. I rebuke you on the fact that you are just a person looking to cause discord and division.
@ What stops me from saying the same to you? The thing is, one person made a supposed Bible based claim against a teaching supposed also to be Bible based. You have made your own assessment of the argument against tithing as a Christian which I found unconvincing. You are assuming because I disagree with you it means I disagree with the Bible. You are not the bible, dear brother. I am disagreeing with you not with the Bible. Did the Bible talk about tithe? Yes. Can it be concluded in anyway that Christians are bound by the law of tithing? Yes. Can it be concluded in someway that Christians are not bound by the law of tithing? Yes. Arguments can be made either way, even with scriptures quoted. Those who preach tithing do not preach it to be practiced as prescribed in the Bible, at least I'm yet to see or hear of anyone that does. If you want to be bound by the law, go all the way. In my understanding, I have been set free from the law by the blood of Christ. I owe no debt of tithe, I pay no tithe. I give not because I'm compelled by law which I'm no longer bound by, I give willingly, bountifully and cheerfully. That is the understanding I have from reading the Bible and that is what I practice.
@@johnshama214 "If you want to be bound by the law, go all the way. " That is a serious error, Hebrews 7:9 proves that tithe is not bound under Mosaic law, you have made a conclusion that contradicts the Holy Spirit inspired words of Hebrews, already addressed in this video ua-cam.com/video/SHGy0WixD2M/v-deo.html
@@AndrewsTitheReview Again, you go on a tangential course. I read the Bible with open mind, I don't try to inject into it. You don't want to be disagreed with, but I disagree with you on your explanations. I will not accuse you of falsifying or trying to deceive, I believe you really are saying what you stand for as you understand it. I read, I find almost the opposite of what you claim and I disagree with you. You cannot guilt-trip me with words into accepting your view. As far as I can see, your view is in error. You and I, like all Christians, are not infallible in our understanding. Know this and learn the humility of relearning.
@@johnshama214 " I disagree with you" Do you love Jesus? His word says be always ready to give a defense for your faith (1 Peter 3:15) so if you disagree then please do what God's word says and please exegete and refute Hebrews 7:9. Even the Levites symbolically paid tithe through Abraham thus proving that tithe is not bound only to the Mosaic law. If you disagree with that you are disagreeing with God the Holy Spirit who gave that Scripture.
If he is so great with the Bible then why not refute Hebrews 7:9 which proves that tithe is not only from Mosaic law and you did not refute 1 Cor 9:13-14 which cites the model of tithing for the support of the gospel? I already made videos on these points here: ua-cam.com/video/SHGy0WixD2M/v-deo.html and ua-cam.com/video/kpG3ChJ0JUA/v-deo.html
Please take time to read all the comments below and notice that not one single person can defend Mr. Breaker's claims nor can anyone refute Hebrews 7:9 which proves that tithe is not confined only to Mosaic law and neither can anyone refute 1 Cor 9:13-14 which cites the model of tithing for the support of the gospel. If Mr. Breaker and his supporters are correct then why can't they refute these Scriptures? Why avoid these verses? The Lord Jesus commanded tithing for the support of the gospel, otherwise 1 Cor 9:13-14 is wrong. And if we Christians are now compelled by love (2 Cor 5:14) then why would love compel us to give less than the minimum %10 that was compelled of the Jew? Does the cross and love of Jesus compel us to become more stingy and give less? I already made videos on these points here: ua-cam.com/video/SHGy0WixD2M/v-deo.html and ua-cam.com/video/kpG3ChJ0JUA/v-deo.html
Neither of those are about tithing. Hebrews 7:9 talks about Melchizidek, the context isn't about tithing, it is about Melchizidek himself, and Abraham meeting him and tithing, but that is not the point of the whole context.
@@wyattearpswoman838 Please explain how the tithe of mosaic law (Numbers 18:24) could be said in Hebrews 7:9 to be given by the Levites to Melchizedek who was completely outside their priesthood? You didn't answer the question. You avoided the problem. Breaker claims it's ONLY from mosaic law so you need to answer this problem and not avoid it. And who are you praying to? Jesus is the High Priest after the order of Melchizedek which is the exact same priesthood that receives tithes so if you reject tithing then by definition you reject the priesthood of Christ so I am not sure who you are praying to. The tithe is holy and due to Christ and Hebrews 7:9 proves that the holiness of tithe did not change with different priesthoods.
Hebrews 7: 11-13: " If therefore perfection were by the Levitical Priesthood for under it the people RECEIVED THE LAW, what further need was there that another Priest should arise after the order of Melchizedek, and not called after the order of Aaron? For the PRIESTHOOD BEING CHANGED, there is made of necessity A CHANGE ALSO OF THE LAW. For He (JESUS) of Whom these things are spoken pertains to another tribe (JUDAH) of which no man gave attendance at the alter." Jesus is our ever present High Priest. Hebrews 7:5" And verily those who are of the sons of Levi, WHO RECEIVED THE OFFICE OF THE PRIESTHOOD, have a COMMANDMENT to take tithes of the people ACCORDING TO LAW, that is of their brethren, though they came out of the loins of Abraham." We are gentiles and certainly not from the bloodline of Levi, nor Aaron; we are not to usurp the authority of a Levite Priest to take any tithes from anyone in this dispensation of Grace. John 1:7 "For the LAW was given by Moses but Grace and Truth came by Jesus Christ."
You did not refute Hebrews 7:9 which proves that tithe is not only from Mosaic law and you did not refute 1 Cor 9:13-14 which cites the model of tithing for the support of the gospel. I already made videos on these points here: ua-cam.com/video/SHGy0WixD2M/v-deo.html and ua-cam.com/video/kpG3ChJ0JUA/v-deo.html
If Mr. Breaker is correct then why can't he or any of his followers refute Hebrews 7:9 which proves that tithe is not only from Mosaic law and 1 Cor 9:13-14 which cites the model of tithing for the support of the gospel? The Lord Jesus commanded tithing for the support of the gospel, otherwise 1 Cor 9:13-14 is wrong. I already made videos on these points here: ua-cam.com/video/SHGy0WixD2M/v-deo.html and ua-cam.com/video/kpG3ChJ0JUA/v-deo.html
Did not Jesus deserves tithes? He never got not even one to show that we are in the new covenant. Let's not rob people through scriptures please. We free from Mosaic law please 😢
I agree with Robert Breaker. He’s been a blessing to me.
You did not refute Hebrews 7:9 which proves that tithe is not only from Mosaic law and you did not refute 1 Cor 9:13-14 which cites the model of tithing for the support of the gospel. I already made videos on these points here: ua-cam.com/video/SHGy0WixD2M/v-deo.html and ua-cam.com/video/kpG3ChJ0JUA/v-deo.html
Bro get a job
Abraham had no law to give tithe. He gave the tithe freely. So if Abraham is our model we should only give when we want to. Also we should give 90% to the gays because Abraham gave the 90% to Sodom and Gomorra. So we really should give 100% whenever we want to and when we take spoils in battle we should donate 90% to the gay lobby and gift the 10% to a Jew.
Which scripture is that that says he gave 90% to Gomora? I only know that he never took😢
@@AndrewsTitheReviewin regard to 1 Cor 9:13-14 nobody said or implied that giving is wrong ( God loves a cheerful giver). It's making people feel guilty when they don't give, that's the problem.
Robert Breaker speaks truth when he preaches. He backs everything up with scripture! I don't understand why people speak ill of him. He is a man of God!!!
Because Robert speaks the Bible truth that is why many hates him. If he is a false teacher, many will love him and he would be popular.
Yes you answered the question yourself! Because he is a man of God
@@mercyfaith2928 You did not refute Hebrews 7:9 which proves that tithe is not only from Mosaic law and you did not refute 1 Cor 9:13-14 which cites the model of tithing for the support of the gospel. I already made videos on these points here: ua-cam.com/video/SHGy0WixD2M/v-deo.html and ua-cam.com/video/kpG3ChJ0JUA/v-deo.html
@@AndrewsTitheReview. If you follow tithing as a standard of giving to God, its good but i think the new covenant speaks more than 10% to honor God
Robert Breaker has been a blessing to me for a while now. Dispensation makes the most sense out of everything i have studied. When you don't divide the word and try to force it all on our current generation it gets very confusing and contradictory!
EQOAnostalgia I did a study on dispensation and from Gods word what Robert Breaker claims it to be didn’t match... I understand what R.B is claiming it be.. gods word is not contradictory.. God had a plan for mankind when he created us.. sin was not meant to be apart of that plan. God knew we would fall, knew He would send His son to redeem us.. redeem us for what.. back to His original plan.. sin separates us from God.. The Bible is a guide so we can know who God is and what we need to do to make heaven our home.. plus so so so so much more..
SPOT ON
very well put!
Three problems with your criticisms of Robert Breaker’s video. 1. You don’t rightly divide the word (2 Timothy 2:15) of truth since Abraham’s dispensation and the Jewish nation are different to the church today
2. You quoted from a different Bible to the one Robert used. Hence your maths is wrong
3. He provided plenty of Biblical evidence which you did not refute entirely
"He provided plenty of Biblical evidence which you did not refute entirely" Sure. Subscribe and stay tuned, more videos on the way.
@andrew tithes review. You are absolutely right in speaking this. Expo the false teaching of Robert breaker
Go n talk to him face to face, thats what is required of you...instead of calling a man of God fake...i rebuke you in Jesus Name
That’s what’s crazy. Defending the lie. Wouldn’t it make more sense to search the scriptures and be able to say .... (means your findings) how bad would it be to miss heaven because you chose to believe a lie. You were exposed to the fact that’s it’s a lie. The Bible says you need to work out your own salvation.
@@alexandrinamayberry603 the same could be said for the person who's attempting to expose Robert Breaker. Why he wouldn't dare to ask Mr Breaker for a online debate for recording and UA-cam if he tried because he'd be cooked by counter scripture verses on the spot.
I so agree with Robert ! Clear and backed up with scripture - logical
You did not refute Hebrews 7:9 which proves that tithe is not only from Mosaic law and you did not refute 1 Cor 9:13-14 which cites the model of tithing for the support of the gospel. I already made videos on these points here: ua-cam.com/video/SHGy0WixD2M/v-deo.html and ua-cam.com/video/kpG3ChJ0JUA/v-deo.html
@@AndrewsTitheReview if I'm not mistaken, tithes and offerings was originally instituted, so that sacrifices could be offered up for sins. Even before the law, sacrifices had to be offered up, so that sin's could be covered. Now that Christ has died on the cross, so that our sins could truly be cleansed. We no longer need to give tithe of our agriculture so that it can be sacrificed, since that is what tithes and offerings was originally instituted for. Now in the New Covenant, we should give freely and generously to our Church, but it can be more or less than 10%. When it comes to Christ, we give Him our whole hearts, and not 10% of our income.
@@bmlove81 If that is true can you explain why Paul in 1 Cor 9:13-14 would appeal to tithes and offerings and claim this is commanded by the Lord for the gospel? And if your argument is true can you explain why the Levites were said in Hebrews 7:9 to symbolically pay tithe to Melchizedek?
@@AndrewsTitheReviewit says offerings, not tithing 10%.
I agree with Robert Breaker
You did not refute Hebrews 7:9 which proves that tithe is not only from Mosaic law and you did not refute 1 Cor 9:13-14 which cites the model of tithing for the support of the gospel. I already made videos on these points here: ua-cam.com/video/SHGy0WixD2M/v-deo.html and ua-cam.com/video/kpG3ChJ0JUA/v-deo.html
ROBERT BREAKER IS A GREAT TEACHER
i agree
DJ KENOTIX no he isn’t... I’ve watched several of his videos ALL OF THEM ARE LACED WITH LIES.. WHICH MEANS THERES NO TRUTH.. JESUS IS TRUTH.. THE DEVIL IS THE FATHER OF LIES
@@theresaschutrum4387all is man made teaching
Pst Breaker is very clear with his scripture...thats great..
He didn't say tithing began in the law. You may want to go listen again and listen carefully
I agree with robert braker..❤❤❤👍👍👍👏👏👏
I love Robert breaker's teachings
Everyone is with robert , kinda sad that you went this far out of your way to try and bring down his teaching. Sad boy
Robert Breaker ❤👍👍👍
Robert Breaker backs it up with the Bible. He’s a great teacher
If he is so great with the Bible then why not refute Hebrews 7:9 which proves that tithe is not only from Mosaic law and you did not refute 1 Cor 9:13-14 which cites the model of tithing for the support of the gospel? I already made videos on these points here: ua-cam.com/video/SHGy0WixD2M/v-deo.html and ua-cam.com/video/kpG3ChJ0JUA/v-deo.html
Since the bible is made up, I assume breaker is false too.
Robert Breaker puts it so clearly. Now we do not pay tithe but we give as our hearts permit. Why is it so hard to grasp this.
Why is it so hard for you to refute Hebrews 7:9, 7;8, and 1 Corinthians 9:13-14 which proves that the tithe is still holy and due to gospel work?
@AndrewsTitheReview because those verses say nothing about tithe being mandatory. The verses speak of a time ago during time of Levi. Its not an instruction. Stop forcing this verse even when it does not apply.
@AndrewsTitheReview the corinthians verse says pastors should live by what they get from church. ŸES they must but not TITHE but the congregation should GIVE and NOT PAY.
@@AndrewsTitheReview You have not rightly divided the word my friend. Are you even saved? I noticed someone asked you what is the gospel, and you did not answer. How is this edifying to anyone in the body of Christ? If you are saved, wouldn't your time be better spent sharing the gospel of salvation with as many people as possible in these last days of the church age - you know, serving Jesus?🩸✝
@@wyattearpswoman838 Can you provide a biblical answer or are you just going to deflect and avoid the problem? Breaker made false claims that have been refuted and you have no evidence to defend him.
Why dont you just teach something else, instead of this critizism? You wanna be famous ha? Why dont you correct him in private?
@@theresaschutrum4387 do you even hear what you are saying?..LOL God bless you and in what you believe.
Dean Tiu .. yes I believe I’m a sinner saved by grace. That Jesus Christ is the son of God and he died on the cross, rose again on the 3 day. Rom 10;9 I need to believe and confess that Jesus is lord.. I don’t pretend scriptures don’t exist.. the. I le talks about names being blotted out of the book of life.. whose names.. the ones that got saved and fell away.. which makes osas. A lie.. the Bible talks about a thief that comes to steal kill an destroy.. who is that the devil... lol... you laughing.. Eve had never sinned and your crazy enough to think your guaranteed heaven.. NOW the flip side.. IT IS POSSIBLE TO STAY SAVED.. the Bible talks about your heart being wicked .. you have to do your part by staying close to Jesus.
I don't believe in the curse of not tithing according to OT (Malachi ) ... I learned to Give well over 10% ( with discernment ) early as a Christian to worthy ministries , Fundamental, Evangelical, Gospel Preaching ( 1 Cor 15, Eph 2:8-9 ) , before I heard Sermons on Tithing. One preacher discouraged me by stating my Giving was in vain ( No Reward in Heaven ) IF I didn't Tithe First ( Tithe to Their Local Church ) . Some Assemblies of God imply you loose Salvation for Not Tithing . Free Will Giving, Will Out Give any Tithing Principle IF the preacher will Encourage his flock to Lay Up Treasure in Heaven
Best comment
Man where you came out from. Mr Breaker pulls everything from the Bible, he's 100% correct and in line with scripture. What is your purpose here on UA-cam?
You did not refute Hebrews 7:9 which proves that tithe is not only from Mosaic law and you did not refute 1 Cor 9:13-14 which cites the model of tithing for the support of the gospel. I already made videos on these points here: ua-cam.com/video/SHGy0WixD2M/v-deo.html and ua-cam.com/video/kpG3ChJ0JUA/v-deo.html
@@AndrewsTitheReviewsend him a message to state his theology of hebrews 7
Don't attack fellow believers
You can rebuke them and correct them
Did Abram tithe to Melchizedek weekly?
It seems that Abraham met Melchizedek once in his entire life, so Abraham tithed once in his life, so we should tithe once in our entire lives?
The same goes for Jacob, who after his dream of the angels going up & down the ladder, woke up to say, “If the Lord is with me I will give Him 10%”
It’s never even seen whether or not Jacob kept his word, but if he did, he probably did it once, not weekly, so once again we should tithe once in our life by that logic.
Now am I an Israelite, am I a Levite, am I Jewish, no?
Then the Jewish Levites should pay tithes + keep the other legalistic 612 Laws in order to appease.
My issue with tithing is that once you indoctrinate 10% into someone’s mind then that’s where they remain & never advance on to 11% or 12% or more.
So if a Pastor gets upset at me for saying “I do not tithe, I am not a tither.”
What’s the problem?
I’m trying to add more onto his paycheck.
I’m trying to put more gas in his tank.
I’m trying to add more steak to his plate.
Add rims to his Escalade.
I do not tithe, I’m not a ten percent-er.
I want to be a 100%-er.
Joseph the Levite aka Barnabas gave 100% to the cause ✝️
Ananias & Saphirra pretended to give 100% to the cause & we all know what happened to them.
"they remain & never advance on to 11% or 12% or more." What a flat out lie. This is what antitithers do, they can't refute the argument so they strawman and use logical fallacies.
@@AndrewsTitheReviewdoes JESUS command tithes
@@ce6236no he never did
Abram took no spoil. His offering was not a tithe. The first tithe is Jacob’s bargain with the god at the ladder - offering 10% for gain = quid pro quo = Matt 4:11 Satan gives “if...”
This is a very angry hatchet video. Seek Peace with your brother or move on. John 8:40
Robert Baker is absolutely right. Scripture answer Scripture.
If he is right how come not one single person can defend Mr. Breaker's claims nor can anyone refute Hebrews 7:9 which proves that tithe is not confined only to Mosaic law and neither can anyone refute 1 Cor 9:13-14 which cites the model of tithing for the support of the gospel. If Mr. Breaker and his supporters are correct then why can't they refute these Scriptures?
@@AndrewsTitheReview Have you read Hebrews7:11, infact read the whole chapter
Another vote for Robert breaker. You’re just mad no one likes you. Big crybaby. Robert breaker for the win!!!
Peter Heinz that’s sad.. it’s not about for the win. Think.. if you believe a lie and miss heaven what was won.. listen to the video and hear what he has to say.. Robert Breaker is trying to prove a point with nonsense like going on the price is right.. outrageous.. tithing IS biblical..
You did not refute Hebrews 7:9 which proves that tithe is not only from Mosaic law and you did not refute 1 Cor 9:13-14 which cites the model of tithing for the support of the gospel. I already made videos on these points here: ua-cam.com/video/SHGy0WixD2M/v-deo.html and ua-cam.com/video/kpG3ChJ0JUA/v-deo.html
Get off his back. He is preaching the gospel. Stop picking at him. Get a life .if you want to do something tell people about Jesus. Your pathetic.
Mate, your so far off the mark. Brother Breaker backs EVERYTHING up by scripture & not opinion. I pray you repent & take this great error of yours off UA-cam.
If the claims are based on scripture then why don't you refute Hebrews 7:9 which proves that tithe is not only from Mosaic law and you did not refute 1 Cor 9:13-14 which cites the model of tithing for the support of the gospel. I already made videos on these points here: ua-cam.com/video/SHGy0WixD2M/v-deo.html and ua-cam.com/video/kpG3ChJ0JUA/v-deo.html
I agree ☝️ Robert Breaker
What are the consequences of not tithing ? The open window has nothing to do with money. Even those who don't tithe have. Church support is very important. Putting a % is already a compulsion. Give
Tith is to the priests. No priests, Levites. Christians are all priests.
"Tith is to the priests. No priests, Levites. Christians are all priests." That's not true, even the Levite priests paid tithe, read Numbers 18:25-29. The only person who did not tithe was the high priest and the only high priest now is Jesus.
Question: would God have had to institute tithing had Israel not rejected Him as His firstborn, and had to be replaced by Levi Numbers 3? What was the fundamental reason God instituted tithing?
I believe God was more concerned about His word being established. He has promised to bring His Son out of Egypt. His "son", Israel rejected Him Exodus 19, He got angry amd would have wiped them out, but Moses interceded and God replaced them with the tribe of Levi- He called them His firstborn Numbers 3:12, and became their portion instead of giving them a physical inheritance in the promised land. They had to be pure and Holy, so as to be able to represent Israel and carry their sins, and atone once a year for them. They mustn't be distracted, so God made available tithes to them, to ensure that they ate the best as if they had produced them by themselves and not some left overs. Unfortunately, later on in the time of kings of Israel, the temple doors were shut and the eternal fire went out, the Levites went out to fend for themselves, and werr not sanctified as they should. God's grace bore with them, and the last Levitical priest was Eli and his sons. King Saul was permitted to send Doeg to kill them all. Some escaped but it was never the same. Samuel from the tribe of Judah ushered in the era of priests. It ended with the advent of Elijah the prophet, which ended with Malachi. Then Elijah, returned to finish his commission which he quit when Jezebel threatened him and asked to die. He single handedly cut off the heads of 850 prophets of baal and ashera and he subsequently-after preaching repentance to Israel to make way for their last hope of reconciliation, he paid with his head as well. God made another way to fulfill His word in Jesus- the Son of man, becoming the Son of God, by letting Him be taken back to Egypt because of the same event that that brought about the salvation of Moses, and now He is coming out as the Son of God, to complete the journey the Israelites and Levites came short of. Matthew 2:13-15. He came to bring them back to Himself and they still rejected Him, so He extended salvation to all- both Jews and gentiles John 12:32 and paid the penalty that would please God. He was nailed to the cross, died was buried but was raised up from the dead, that all who would simply believe in Him Ephesians 2:8, would not perish, but have everlasting life John3:16. He wasn't sent to root out law breakersand deal with them. He instead sent His Holy Spirit to teach, lead and interpret His will to all those who would simply believe! Is that so difficultto understand?. During this church era, God isn't dealing with Israel as a nation, thus all the laws and statutes do not apply to believers Romans 9:4-5, except for believers to love others as He has loved them- as unlovable as they are, so He can bring them unto Himself is Jesus Christ as members of His body. But duringthe last 7 week years, Israel will go back to the point where her book was shut, Daniel 12:4, and continued until the conclusion of the world system by tribulation and armageddon battle. Jesus will now return with members of His body whoch completed Him as the Head during the catching away- a gigantic Creature; and rest His feet on the mount of Olives Zechariah 14, to make way of escape for the remnants of Israel and then destroy the enemy by His Breath and the Sword that comes out of His mouth. Then the 1000 of destruction of the last curse upon man- death will give way to judgment and reward and the new heaven and new earth, with new Jerusalem coming down into earth so that God can finally be Emmanuel- in the midst of His people. In conclusion, none of them is right. Love of money is definitely the root of all evils and debates.
And he teached how it should be preached . God bless Robert breaker .
Man, where you come out from... You so foolish. Mr Breaker pulls everything from the Bible and never assume anything. What is your purpose on UA-cam.
The bottom line is that we are not required to tithed 10% under the new covenant. Abram gave 10% and that was great but GOD did not tell Abram to tithed 10%, he did that on his own. I agree with Robert Breaker that today we should tithed and using 10% as a bench mark is a good place to start and you can give more; however, you are not required to give any percentage. The old law does not apply to us today. Like Paul says, just because we are not under the law any more does not mean that we should disregard it, as there is so much truth and wisdom that we can benefit and apply to our lives from these laws that God gave exclusively to the Jews. The problem was that the law was a burden and the Jews could not keep the laws, that's why God sent Jesus to free the Jews from the law, and by freeing the Jews from the law, salvation became available to the Jews and Gentiles, which is us or anyone who is not Jewish and believe in Jesus. Salvation is not base on the law any longer or on works, just faith is required. I appreciate the constructive criticism that Andrew makes on Robert Breaker explanation on Tithing, however, it seams that by his comments that he subscribed to the notion that today we all have to tithe 10% of our income which I respectfully disagree with. God Bless
If what you say is true that giving %10 is a matter of the mosaic "old law" then why don't you refute Hebrews 7:9 which proves that tithe is not confined only to Mosaic law? Your claims contradict the Scripture. Furthermore you made no attempt to refute 1 Cor 9:13-14 which cites the model of tithing for the support of the gospel, why did you ignore this? Paul says this is commanded by the Lord. And if we Christians are now compelled by love (2 Cor 5:14) then why would love compel us to give less than the minimum %10 that was compelled of the Jew? Does the cross and love of Jesus compel us to become more stingy and give less? I already made videos on these points here: ua-cam.com/video/SHGy0WixD2M/v-deo.html and ua-cam.com/video/kpG3ChJ0JUA/v-deo.html
@@AndrewsTitheReview1 Cor 9: 15 states that he used none of those things: neither did he write those things that it should be done so unto him, for it were better for him to die than for any man to make his glorying void.
@@damarismuigai2527 Yes that is 1 Cor 9:15 but Paul specifically affirmed the rights of others to receive support in 1 Cor 9:12. I made a video about this. Furthermore 2 Cor 8:7-8 is the basis for giving more than %10, see the #1 Best argument for tithing here: ua-cam.com/video/BqA_xfPlzzY/v-deo.html and the video on 1 Cor 9:13-14 here ua-cam.com/video/kpG3ChJ0JUA/v-deo.html
@@AndrewsTitheReview2 Corinthians 9:7 (KJV) Every man according as he purposeth in his heart, so let him give; not grudgingly, or of necessity: for God loveth a cheerful giver.
@@AndrewsTitheReviewhow about the 10 commandments. Does tithing necessary for salvation?
It's simple my friend, tithing is under the old covenant law. It is finished, we are not under the law. Give cheerfully, but you decide what and to whom.
The Abraham tithing was from the heart, he never tithed from his but from the spoil, hence Isaac never even started to tithe. The law started from Mosheh of Israelites to pay tithes. El-Avram was under grace I can say🙏🙏
Dude, you're speaking gibberish. I agree with Robert Breaker all the way. You're taking a lot out of context and it sounds like you don't like him very much.
Do you love Jesus? How come not one single person can defend Mr. Breaker's claims nor can anyone refute Hebrews 7:9 which proves that tithe is not confined only to Mosaic law and neither can anyone refute 1 Cor 9:13-14 which cites the model of tithing for the support of the gospel. If Mr. Breaker and his supporters are correct then why can't they refute these Scriptures? If you love Jesus you will love the Scriptures.
No wonder Mr. Breaker had a "cloud" ministry 😂...no need to support the gospel at all! It's going to be hard to send out people to spread the gospel as commanded by our Lord because of a few bad people who abuse the concept of money...even if people disagree on the %, they should consistently GIVE...but they simply don't
Then they bash those who obey scriptural giving...this way, they feel better about themselves. Truth is, they don't give consistently, they give excuses and they blablablah a lot. Don't waste your time. You already said what GOD put in your heart to be said. Now it's on them! Blessings!
I watched this. I had to stop when he said we are free to give more. After that o could not listen. Try “ the door” micheal pearl. I love his teachings. He teaches tithe is sin because it puts us back under law. 1 Corinthians 16 has a verse somewhere about the first day of the week to set aside ( I found this in a sermon by dr gene kym. ) So we are to be charitable but what is in our hearts not for the geeed of the synagogue. I grew up being taught tithing is wrong so I’m
Sorry but i agree with that. You give what is in your heart
Robert actually mentions "a time before the law " further on in his teaching on tithing in regards to Abraham.
There are so many good teachers on this subject, and they all get tithing in context, saying the same thing with the use of proper exegesis and hermeneutics!
I like Robert breaker
Which one do you like more, Robert Breaker or Jesus? Hebrews 7:9 and 1 Corinthians 9:13-14 prove that Breaker's claims are false so you have to choose, Breaker or Jesus?
the hirlings are starving out and are mad , get a job it want hurt you to work .
SORRY, I LAKE ROBERT BRECKIN.
Sorry but we give as we prospere according what the Holly Spirit put on our hearts we don't give by law or according to a vlontary committement by our father of faith Abraham and even if we do good not by moving by the Holly Spirit we do wrong I hope you know why.
Let him not grudgingly
In Deutoronomy 14, you can use your tithing to go buy liquors and wine and go have a good time. Now to all proponents of tithing: how come, I have never heard any preaching about that?
Tithing is taught because it brings in the most money. Simple as that.
According to you John McCarther is also wrong.
There are many tithes, including the ones for the widows. This is for a group of people that had a theocratic government.
How about Rom 12:1-2, Phil 2:13.
Holy Spirit in us leads us to give all of us for His purpose.
Give cheerfully, because one wants to.
I think that legalism misses the Heart Of Christ.
God is not the author of confusion. I heard that Jesus did not tithe. If that is true, I suppose it's because He *was* the tithe. Thanks for this info. It was enlightening.
❤ don't get mad brother.,👍Pstr. Robert Breaker has a sound Bible preaching. God Bless Pstr. Robert.
If he is so sound in preaching the Bible then why not refute Hebrews 7:9 which proves that tithe is not only from Mosaic law and you did not refute 1 Cor 9:13-14 which cites the model of tithing for the support of the gospel? I already made videos on these points here: ua-cam.com/video/SHGy0WixD2M/v-deo.html and ua-cam.com/video/kpG3ChJ0JUA/v-deo.html
If you tell the story in it’s entirety, Abraham tithing is mentioned only once. Second, he didn’t go to war for the spoils, he went to save his people. They decided to take the spoils after there was no one left. Second, in that same story…. Abraham then gave the remaining 90% to the king back to the king of sodom. Should we tithe our 10% and let the government keep the rest? Not to mention the king of Sodom offered Abraham to keep what he wanted and Abraham stated,
22 But Abram said to the king of Sodom, “With raised hand I have sworn an oath to the Lord, God Most High, Creator of heaven and earth, 23 that I will accept nothing belonging to you, not even a thread or the strap of a sandal, so that you will never be able to say, ‘I made Abram rich.’
Abraham clearly states none of it belonged to him but to the king Solomon.
I agree with brother Breaker.
I don't have time to address all of the many errors in Robert Breakers tithes teaching but I will state that tithing was established with Abel & Cain. It was a requirement set up by God. Genesis 4:3-7; Hebrews 11:4. Abraham paid tithes. Genesis 14:28-20 & Hebrews 7:2-4. Jacob paid tithes. Genesis 28:20-22. Levi paid tithes in Abraham. Hebrews 7:9-10. This was required before the law and was required also under the law & so it is today to be paid without the law. It was never eliminated from the time of Cain & Abel. Don't be fooled. Don't pay? That decision comes with a curse. Seeing tithe was established before the law the scripture still stands: will a man rob God? Malachi chapter 3. We don't throw out the Old Testament, we learn from it. Regarding the New Testament, the Apostles were setting up churches from scratch in the business of saving souls. Most were poor. Acts 4:34 Neither was there any among them that lacked: for as many as were possessors of lands or houses sold them and brought the prices of the things that were sold, Verse 35...and distribution was made unto every man according as he had need. This is also in a time of great persecution. Also the priests in that day are called pastors in our day. I am amazed & so surprised that Breaker of all people went so far off on this teaching. God says pay Me 1st. Abraham paid 10% tithe directly to God in the appearance of Melchizedek in the flesh realm. Genesis 14:18-20. Read Hebrews chapter 7. Verse 2- God is the King of Righteousness & Peace. Jerusalem was called Salem 1st. In this chapter it gives you a description of who God is in the body of Melchisedec. Verse 3 - He has/never had a father, no mother, no descent (meaning no ancestor, birth or lineage) no beginning of days nor end of life--from everlasting to everlasting thou art God. Melchisedec in the old testament is Jesus in the new testament which is God hidden in human flesh so we could see Him real time. John 10:30 I and my father are one. You can't separate me. John 14:9-10 ...hast thou not known me Philip? He that hath seen me hath seen the Father; and how sayest thou then, show us the Father? 1 John 5:20...and we are in him that is true, even in his Son Jesus Christ. This (Jesus) is the true God, and eternal life. Revelation 17:14 These shall make war with the Lamb (behold the lamb of God which taketh away the sins of the world)....for he is Lord of lords & King of kings) God came in many appearances. Melchisedec is one of them. Jesus is another amongst others. You must know your word so you'll know when someone is off tract. Do Malachi or be cursed God woll get his money one way or another. All your resources come from Him & He has power to remove them. I've seen the results of Christians who decided they didn't need to tithe. One lost job & basically ate cereal mostly everyday for years. Ypu cannot tell her not to pay tithes today. Another lost job, car & home. She used not attending her church services is why she didn't pay & spent it. Lame excuse. She could have mailed them. He gave you a job & says pay me 1st. Give me 10 % off the top before taxes & you can have 90%. God is not playing. Heed the warning.
Explain the Son when he prayed to the Father. I believe what Jesus told Thomas have I been so long with you and yet you don't know me. But was he praying to himself? Please Explain
I find it ironic that what you found to disagree with just happens to effect your own wallet...
Can you refute the #1 Best argument for tithing here: ua-cam.com/video/BqA_xfPlzzY/v-deo.html
OK if Robert is wrong with the bible tell us what we're to give
I believe you would do well to refer to and understand these two scriptures.
2 Timothy 2:15
15 Study to shew thyself approved unto God, a workman that needeth not to be ashamed, rightly dividing the word of truth.
Galatians 3:24-26
24 Wherefore the law was our schoolmaster to bring us unto Christ, that we might be justified by faith.
25 But after that faith is come, we are no longer under a schoolmaster.
26 For ye are all the children of God by faith in Christ Jesus.
Robert breaker is a biblical scholar! He knows his stuff backwards and forwards! I read my Bible and go to Bible college. I understand that we should give but it's not that we have to! There's also a ways of giving also like.. serving etc. God bless brother. Don't be so mad!
Why can't a "biblical scholar" refute Hebrews 7:9 which proves that tithe is not only from Mosaic law and you did not refute 1 Cor 9:13-14 which cites the model of tithing for the support of the gospel? I already made videos on these points here: ua-cam.com/video/SHGy0WixD2M/v-deo.html and ua-cam.com/video/kpG3ChJ0JUA/v-deo.html
Dude, whoever you are, you are missing the whole point and confusing. Apparently you are confuse yourself.
l'm going to blame myself for being foolish enough to waste over 14 minutes of my time.
Hebrews 7:9 is still there in the Bible
I agree with Robert Breaker 100% Tithing has been abused in a fashion that Christians are forced to do it. In some churches the stance on tithing is too cardinal even for salvation which is false. Tithing is not required for Christians.
If tithing is not required why does the Lord command this for the gospel? Why don't you refute Hebrews 7:9 which proves that tithe is not only from Mosaic law and then refute 1 Cor 9:13-14 which cites the model of tithing for the support of the gospel? I already made videos on these points here: ua-cam.com/video/SHGy0WixD2M/v-deo.html and ua-cam.com/video/kpG3ChJ0JUA/v-deo.html
Robert breaker is one of the greatest preachers close to the Bible
If he is so great with the Bible then why not refute Hebrews 7:9 which proves that tithe is not only from Mosaic law and you did not refute 1 Cor 9:13-14 which cites the model of tithing for the support of the gospel? I already made videos on these points here: ua-cam.com/video/SHGy0WixD2M/v-deo.html and ua-cam.com/video/kpG3ChJ0JUA/v-deo.html
@@AndrewsTitheReview i will check those videos
Grow up brother.
Exactly.
You are mad because YOU WANT MONEY…. sorry…. you,ve been busted. River Breaker is CORRECT!
What a clown this UA-camr is. Hang it up cupcake. Everyone knows Robert Bleaker is solid. Go elsewhere to sell your cult teachings.
Do you pray to a holy God with that same mouth you used to insult this gentleman?
The answer is not either man BUT: God's directive from God's Apostle to the church Paul.
2Pe 3:15 And account that the longsuffering of our Lord is salvation; even as our beloved brother Paul also according to the wisdom given unto him hath written unto you;
2Pe 3:16 As also in all his epistles, speaking in them of these things; in which are some things hard to be understood, which they that are unlearned and unstable wrest, as they do also the other scriptures, unto their own destruction.
The answer to you sirs is directly from God and His Word sirs:1Co 16:2 Upon the first day of the week let every one of you lay by him in store, as God hath PROSPERED him, that there be no gatherings when I come. [The Holy Spirit And God's Apostle to new testament church Paul]
"The answer to you sirs is directly from God and His Word sirs:1Co 16:2"...Why are you conflating this text with tithe? As every single commentary attests this is about the collection of freewill offerings, not about supporting the gospel which Paul addressed in 1 Cor 9:13-14 where he appealed to the tithe model. See my video on that.
I will cheerfully give 3% and if anybody doesn't like it then they can make up the difference.
from one aspect your comment is funny. Biblically incorrect and indefensible but funny. Sad though when you think of the loss you will incur and that is not funny.
@@AndrewsTitheReview
The church has a rock band, program and jumbotron. They won't miss my money.
@@AndrewsTitheReview
ua-cam.com/users/live_IDAiick-xw?si=5GtFaUmCmkXPqyGP
@@AndrewsTitheReview
If I believe that tithing is a horrible false doctrine that rips off millions of Christians then would I be welcomed in your church?
@@jamesirvin7799 I'm not talking about financially well off churches, I'm talking about missionary minded churches who send out evangelists, missionaries, and pastors to unreached areas. This is about preaching the gospel of Christ to the lost. Do some churches spend extravagantly and wastefully? Sure. But there are many churches who do not so your exception does not nullify the rule. Don't you want the lost to hear the gospel and be saved?
Totally agree with Robert breaker. I dont how many pastorsare beating their congregation into that 10% submission. But I guess you can do that to Christians when they don't have a dispensational view.
This guy is so trivial in criticizing Robert Breaker. No matter how you slice it, Christians are not under the law of tithing.
Abraham was not compelled by any law or other to give ten percent of all he had won in battle to Melchizedek. Melchizedek gave Abraham some bread and wine then blessed Abraham and In return, Abraham gives him a tithe of the booty.
That because it was Abraham chose to tithe. To be fair, the bible don't speak of no body else tithing, not even Lot that traveled with him.
Robert Breaker has explained this clearly scripture after scriptures. Get a life.
I don't go along with you at all, because you get it all wrong! my goodness, try to reconcile your thoughts my friend flika, what Robert here is saying something so different that you don't understand and need to study a lot more. Joe.
I will say even if you are correct and looks like you are, you don’t have to be this rude about it. Did Robert Baker do something to personally make you mad?
What exactly did I say that was rude? Jesus said in John 18:23 that if you accuse someone you must provide evidence, where is the evidence that I was rude?
Robert Breaker is very careful in studying God's word. This is not a dividing issue.
You have valid points, but so does Breaker. Iron sharpens iron.
If he is so careful with the Bible then why not refute Hebrews 7:9 which proves that tithe is not only from Mosaic law and why not refute 1 Cor 9:13-14 which cites the model of tithing for the support of the gospel? I already made videos on these points here: ua-cam.com/video/SHGy0WixD2M/v-deo.html and ua-cam.com/video/kpG3ChJ0JUA/v-deo.html
@@AndrewsTitheReviewthe word " tithe" is not used, but rather to give joyfully. That could mean to give less than a tenth, or even more, either way God is not going broke. God bless.
@@andynaz5631 Actually, no that is not true. The Holy Spirit cited the model of tithes and offerings in 1 Corinthians 9:13-14 and said this is commanded by the Lord for the gospel, I already made a video on that here ua-cam.com/video/kpG3ChJ0JUA/v-deo.html and your reference to giving joyfully is from 2 Cor 9 which refers to supporting humanitarian needs, not to the gospel, I already addressed that here ua-cam.com/video/dJF5X-wcrR8/v-deo.html
@@AndrewsTitheReview I'm talking about the amount.
@@andynaz5631 That is incorrect for two reasons. The system of tithes and offerings referred to in 1 Cor 9:13-14 has a minimum %10 for the gospel work. Your claim contradicts this Scripture because if it's less than %10 then it cannot be "even so" per 1 Cor 9:13-14. Furthermore, by claiming the children of Abraham had to give a %10 minimum before but that the children of Abraham today can give less you are arguing that the love of Christ and the Holy Spirit make people stingier than the Jews of the Old Testament. That is incorrect and you have no evidence for this claim. This was already addressed in the video, "#1 best argument" which nobody in the anti-tithing community has ever been able to refute ua-cam.com/video/BqA_xfPlzzY/v-deo.html
❤thank God one man know the truth and every body else lie he knows everything
Robert beaker is true paster true guide ❤
Bottom
Line God luvs a cheerful giver.
Why would you cheerfully not support the gospel work? Returning %10 to support the gospel is a command of the Lord.
@@AndrewsTitheReviewbecause Scripture tells us let every one give as He PURPOSES IN HIS OWN HEART NOT GRUDGINGLY OR OF NECESSITY
@@leandrewking5150 actually that is not correct, addressed here ua-cam.com/video/dJF5X-wcrR8/v-deo.html
Your wrong! It's to lsrael. Not gentiles.we are not under the
Law in this dispensation.
I stopped watching when he said a taxi driver should tithe gasoline to the church..... Nope. Duh.... Gasoline is consumed by the taxi - not produced by it. Tithe was on the overall increase the person had.... Not what they consumed.
Plus he refused to understand the simple principle that if tithe is on whater assets increased for the person, then yes! - MONEY would be what is tithed in a modern society. If a farmer still lives on and trades on ONLY livestock and crops then he would tithe of those things. But if the farmer trades livestock and crops for money - then money would be what he would tithe on.
There was no overarching standard of "money" or coins or any such thing in the days of Moses. So they couldn't tithe on money - since it was not a marker of increase in assets.
I saw the math thing 😂 I like rob b mostly but i don’t agree with his teachings about this
I also believe the teaching of Robert, He is just more educated than you. you are just a person looking to pretend that you have more knowledge. I rebuke you on the fact that you are just a person looking to cause discord and division.
🐩💨
Your arguments are not convincing
The Bible is true whether you believe it or not.
@ What stops me from saying the same to you?
The thing is, one person made a supposed Bible based claim against a teaching supposed also to be Bible based. You have made your own assessment of the argument against tithing as a Christian which I found unconvincing. You are assuming because I disagree with you it means I disagree with the Bible. You are not the bible, dear brother. I am disagreeing with you not with the Bible.
Did the Bible talk about tithe? Yes.
Can it be concluded in anyway that Christians are bound by the law of tithing? Yes.
Can it be concluded in someway that Christians are not bound by the law of tithing? Yes.
Arguments can be made either way, even with scriptures quoted.
Those who preach tithing do not preach it to be practiced as prescribed in the Bible, at least I'm yet to see or hear of anyone that does. If you want to be bound by the law, go all the way.
In my understanding, I have been set free from the law by the blood of Christ. I owe no debt of tithe, I pay no tithe. I give not because I'm compelled by law which I'm no longer bound by, I give willingly, bountifully and cheerfully. That is the understanding I have from reading the Bible and that is what I practice.
@@johnshama214 "If you want to be bound by the law, go all the way. " That is a serious error, Hebrews 7:9 proves that tithe is not bound under Mosaic law, you have made a conclusion that contradicts the Holy Spirit inspired words of Hebrews, already addressed in this video ua-cam.com/video/SHGy0WixD2M/v-deo.html
@@AndrewsTitheReview
Again, you go on a tangential course.
I read the Bible with open mind, I don't try to inject into it. You don't want to be disagreed with, but I disagree with you on your explanations. I will not accuse you of falsifying or trying to deceive, I believe you really are saying what you stand for as you understand it. I read, I find almost the opposite of what you claim and I disagree with you. You cannot guilt-trip me with words into accepting your view.
As far as I can see, your view is in error. You and I, like all Christians, are not infallible in our understanding. Know this and learn the humility of relearning.
@@johnshama214 " I disagree with you" Do you love Jesus? His word says be always ready to give a defense for your faith (1 Peter 3:15) so if you disagree then please do what God's word says and please exegete and refute Hebrews 7:9. Even the Levites symbolically paid tithe through Abraham thus proving that tithe is not bound only to the Mosaic law. If you disagree with that you are disagreeing with God the Holy Spirit who gave that Scripture.
Do your video. Let's listen. Don't waste time on others.
You are very far from the truth poster...
My running partner is Pelegrino, nice
Gentiles are not under the Law
Yes they are. If you are drunkard you will not be saved (1 Cor 6:9-10) just one of many laws.
Tithing is a good way to be poor.
Why didn't God give an exception for poor people not to tithe in the Old Testament? God wanted people to remain poor?
you have a problem with coz you want other ppl’s money
Where did I say I want people's money? Maybe you are thinking of someone else.
Robert 6 crybaby 0.
If he is so great with the Bible then why not refute Hebrews 7:9 which proves that tithe is not only from Mosaic law and you did not refute 1 Cor 9:13-14 which cites the model of tithing for the support of the gospel? I already made videos on these points here: ua-cam.com/video/SHGy0WixD2M/v-deo.html and ua-cam.com/video/kpG3ChJ0JUA/v-deo.html
Please take time to read all the comments below and notice that not one single person can defend Mr. Breaker's claims nor can anyone refute Hebrews 7:9 which proves that tithe is not confined only to Mosaic law and neither can anyone refute 1 Cor 9:13-14 which cites the model of tithing for the support of the gospel. If Mr. Breaker and his supporters are correct then why can't they refute these Scriptures? Why avoid these verses? The Lord Jesus commanded tithing for the support of the gospel, otherwise 1 Cor 9:13-14 is wrong. And if we Christians are now compelled by love (2 Cor 5:14) then why would love compel us to give less than the minimum %10 that was compelled of the Jew? Does the cross and love of Jesus compel us to become more stingy and give less? I already made videos on these points here: ua-cam.com/video/SHGy0WixD2M/v-deo.html and ua-cam.com/video/kpG3ChJ0JUA/v-deo.html
I agree with Robert Breaker
So tell me now. What is the gospel?
Is the name of the book "Gentiles"? Or is it Hebrews?
Neither of those are about tithing. Hebrews 7:9 talks about Melchizidek, the context isn't about tithing, it is about Melchizidek himself, and Abraham meeting him and tithing, but that is not the point of the whole context.
@@wyattearpswoman838 Please explain how the tithe of mosaic law (Numbers 18:24) could be said in Hebrews 7:9 to be given by the Levites to Melchizedek who was completely outside their priesthood? You didn't answer the question. You avoided the problem. Breaker claims it's ONLY from mosaic law so you need to answer this problem and not avoid it. And who are you praying to? Jesus is the High Priest after the order of Melchizedek which is the exact same priesthood that receives tithes so if you reject tithing then by definition you reject the priesthood of Christ so I am not sure who you are praying to. The tithe is holy and due to Christ and Hebrews 7:9 proves that the holiness of tithe did not change with different priesthoods.
Hebrews 7: 11-13: " If therefore perfection were by the Levitical Priesthood for under it the people RECEIVED THE LAW, what further need was there that another Priest should arise after the order of Melchizedek, and not called after the order of Aaron? For the PRIESTHOOD BEING CHANGED, there is made of necessity A CHANGE ALSO OF THE LAW. For He (JESUS) of Whom these things are spoken pertains to another tribe (JUDAH) of which no man gave attendance at the alter." Jesus is our ever present High Priest.
Hebrews 7:5" And verily those who are of the sons of Levi, WHO RECEIVED THE OFFICE OF THE PRIESTHOOD, have a COMMANDMENT to take tithes of the people ACCORDING TO LAW, that is of their brethren, though they came out of the loins of Abraham." We are gentiles and certainly not from the bloodline of Levi, nor Aaron; we are not to usurp the authority of a Levite Priest to take any tithes from anyone in this dispensation of Grace.
John 1:7 "For the LAW was given by Moses but Grace and Truth came by Jesus Christ."
You did not refute Hebrews 7:9 which proves that tithe is not only from Mosaic law and you did not refute 1 Cor 9:13-14 which cites the model of tithing for the support of the gospel. I already made videos on these points here: ua-cam.com/video/SHGy0WixD2M/v-deo.html and ua-cam.com/video/kpG3ChJ0JUA/v-deo.html
@@AndrewsTitheReview You have clearly have a lying twisted spirit on you.
@@AndrewsTitheReviewdoes it mean Jesus command the gentiles also to follow the tithes and not need the 612 mosaic law as what the jews did?
I agree with Robert Breaker.
I agree with Robert Breaker
If Mr. Breaker is correct then why can't he or any of his followers refute Hebrews 7:9 which proves that tithe is not only from Mosaic law and 1 Cor 9:13-14 which cites the model of tithing for the support of the gospel? The Lord Jesus commanded tithing for the support of the gospel, otherwise 1 Cor 9:13-14 is wrong. I already made videos on these points here: ua-cam.com/video/SHGy0WixD2M/v-deo.html and ua-cam.com/video/kpG3ChJ0JUA/v-deo.html
But you going back to the book of Genesis which is Old Covenant, this chapter was trying to show Jews the Jesus is the type of Melkizedek
Malkiy-Tsedeq😂
Did not Jesus deserves tithes? He never got not even one to show that we are in the new covenant. Let's not rob people through scriptures please. We free from Mosaic law please 😢