This song should have won a Grammy. The lyrics are brilliant, incredibly raw and relatable. She blended her vocal style with Bone Thugs seamlessly and the song is incredibly original.
Coolio said crossroads shoulda won the mtv award - and whatever the other song was…. Short story longer- Mariah bone thugz and even coolio - childhood heroes. This song is sooo good. Forgot it for years until now this is my raw reaction. No one cares but me. Loved it then and since all those mix CDs I made in 2005 disappeared like hearing it first time.
This is still cold af. The hook is sooo good. Her writing has always been top tier in my opinion. Adlibs, vocal stacking, tone, smooth riffs, sheesh! 90’s and early 00’s is the golden era of RNB. Some of the greatest vocalist, writers, producers of all time. Music that feels like butter
I don’t think people appreciate the immaculate songwriting that was done on this song. It’s beautifully written and vulnerable. I did a deep dive on Mariah’s songwriting and she’s honestly a poet. I never knew.
@@r0bz1985 lol, na far from it. But most dudes will meet a girl/woman they like and if it doesn't work out it hurts. Everybody can't be a super gansta like u all the time
The repeating "Cry... cry.. cry... cry..." at the end of the song actually sound like her crying... continuous, exhausted crying. What an artwork this song is!
Wow I never thought of it that way I love that…. Alicia Keyes reverently re did Fallin live and how she desricbed her background signers as their littelry fallin as their singing it
What many people fail to pay full attention to in this song is the lyrics. These lyrics are so deep. Mariah actually wrote this masterpiece just like she writes all of her other masterpieces. She has had huge success in her career, but she is HIGHLY underrated when it comes to her songwriting skills.
LO-KEY, she singing, BUT she 'singing' like she rapping. SHE "FLOWIN" like a rapper, & it sounds natural/easy to her. She really killed this. Bone Thugs too👏🏾👏🏾👏🏾👏🏾
they inspired her, their style, when writing it, and after writing and recording it, they somewhat reluctantly agreed to do it, and they have talked about how she served them weed and Henny on silver platters. I know everything about Mariah Carey. I've been a Mariah stan since 1995.
The melodies, the way she matches Bone Thugs N Harmony rapping. Simply iconic man. Butterfly is her best album and Breakdown and The Roof are top 10 in her discography. Non negotiable.
Her and Krayzie Bone have another song together called I still Believe. Kray also has songs harmonozing with Michael Jackson and Sade. Dude is so underrated and so versatile. He can hop on any track of any style and stand out.
@@nobodyspecial8452 youtube labels people who still use the played out and over used "hold my beer" lame meme sentence as sheep minded, unoriginal attention seekers and loserish
Her lyrical cadence is damn near perfect. The way she uses the syllables, rhyming and vocabulary is amazing..”that you care for me but, that you’re just not in love” “immediately I pretended to be, feeling similarly” she snapped🔥
It went over my head when I was Young Too: This song is Powerful and Most Definitely 100% overlooked💗💗💗NOONE Was Ready for HOODRIAH (they still not lol🤣). When She left Tommy She Came Hard!🔥🔥🔥🎶
My dad passed away yesterday and now I'm making a playlist with all the songs he loved and I remember him by. This is one of them. Thank you dad for showing me the greatest artists of all times. Loved, missed and never forgotten 🤘🔥❤
So sorry for your loss. How sweet of you, music transcends and can take you to another place. Listen and be with your father when a certain beat or melody takes you to him...
One of my favorite songs of all time. Mariah is the ultimate diva. No such thing as listening to it once... if you're listening to "Breakdown" it's gotta be on repeat.
9 років тому+737
And this ladies and gentlemen is... The best song that Mariah ever made. Hands downs
Butterfly is one of the best albums in history people who think mariah is just a belting machine need to listen to this masterpiece and see how she experimented with her voice ,the lyrics , the harmonies , the melodies are just genius . This is why i think mariah is the best femal vocalist no other explored and experimented with their voice the way she did she literally have used every insh of her voice
said everything the gift of MC is incredible is every masterpiece she makes you can't choose each song has your gift your touch all thanks to her she will always be the best female singer in this world queen MC.
I agree. I watched a video where she literally sung every genre of song it went from rock to country to rap..she's my favorite of all time bc of her versitality!!!
I agree and I love that she's able to adapt her voice through different music styles in different eras whether it was the 90s, 2000s and even the 2010s (Her album Caution is a perfect example of this), She's truly a timeless artist.
After my 7 yr relationship ended, every lyric of this song described what I went through. To those going through it, I pray for you, Yeshua loves you and You WILL get through it.
+Jocosta Raynor Mariah wrote this by herself, Jermaine doesn't even have a writing credit on this song. It's only Mariah, Wish Bone, Krayzie Bone, and Stevie J. Wish and Krayzie wrote their own parts and Mariah wrote the rest. The only reason Stevie J is listed is because he probably changed a word or two so it would fit better after production. Mariah always writes her own songs (by herself most of the time) and her co writers really don't do much other than slightly edit it.
I truly think this song is one of the best songs of all time. It’s not until you’re about 30 yo tho that you REALLY understand the magnitude of these lyrics.
Is** the gold standard. So many people still study the hell out of her voice and overall work today. And she's the one that the younger generations get compared to the most. Their fan bases try to diss her and say she's no longer great or a skilled vocalist. The reality is that Mariah is their fav's fav and their fav will NEVER reach such levels (strictly speaking music). Also, you can't take away greatness or legendary status, and one must never undermine one of the world's greatest musicians (not just a singer). Her highly acclaimed "Caution" album is up there with the work of the popular girls today but of course, the effects of ageism and lack of label push made it underperform. The fact that she can still explore and transform her sound time and time again proves her greatness.
Aside from her obvious skill in range and technique and feeling, her voice and tone are entirely unique. Some singers sing like other singers, but really no one's voice sounds like hers. Like when you here her it's always unmistakably her and no one else. Even her speaking voice is distinct.
She is Queen I been a Lamb 💯💯 She will always own a special place my heart ❤️ my childhood consists of Mariah’s timeless hits..firsthand from the beginning 🫠
First heard this song when I was a child in the early 00s (a few years after it came out) and here I am in 2023, it never got old. The whole album is so beautiful & legendary ❤
Sheryl Cares Most definitely. One of my favorite songs and collaborations Mariah did with one of my most favorite Hip Hop Groups. #TimelessClassic 😍😍😍😍😍💖💕👑👑👑🎵🎶🎼🎤
Wowwww, I can't believe time is passing this fast. I also can't believe she's almost 55, she looks so good I'd easily say she looks 25 years younger than that.
Her record label stifled her singles and promotion during this period of her career and yet this song, the whole album, is a testament of the genius of this woman, ahead of her time.
Tommy was still bitter about the divorce but this album still sold even though he tried everything to sabotage her sales to make her cower under his wrath. That's a testament to how strong of a person Mariah is to be able to escape a person like Tommy, who basically controlled every aspect of her life.
sold 13 million copies worlwide with only two singles that Sony promoted. Imagine how much more copies Butterfly could've sold if Breakdown was actually promoted.
It's why she's the goat and people that don't know the story behind her history don't understand why people feel that way. She had someone trying to get everyone to kill her career and she came out on top anyways. A rare story in high powered industry.
I really can’t think of another R&B singer that sang a breathy, rap cadence like this before Mariah Carey. And now this is the only style I hear in mainstream r&b these days.
"So what do you do when somebody you're so devoted to suddenly stops loving you?" Singing in two different octaves is something I will forever love in this song!
everything Mariah is popular here in the PH... here are the songs from each album that were hits: MC: Vision of love. love takes time emotions: emotions. make it happen music box: hero. without you. anytime u need a friend. dreamlover. daydream: one sweet day. open arms. forever. fantasy. always be my baby. butterfly: butterfly. breakdown. my all. whenever u call. honey. rainbow. heartbreaker. cant take that away. against all odds glitter: never too far. lead the way. charmbracelet: my saving grace. through the rain Emancipation: we belong together. its like that. dont forget about us. mine again. fly like a bird. e=mc2: bye bye. i stay in love. touch my body. ill be lovin u long time. memoirs: angels cry. obsessed. up out my face
"do you cling to your pride and sing i will survive...do you lash out and say..how dare you leave this way?!" maaaan loook lol. mariah said a mouthful! CLASSIC
jim murphy they recorded the original without her, she liked it and they did this. This shows how good Bone Thugs are as rappers. The slowed down for Mariah and they still were flawless
This has to be the best hip-hop + pop collaboration of all time. Everybody since Mariah has tried to replicate, but they haven’t even come close. Mariah’s artistic inclinations are unmatched. Those melodies.
Mariah and bone thugs killed this track. It is timeless. A classic. Everything from vocals, to the artistic video, and how they're voices match perfectly with this beat. Forever one of my favs by her.
it's crazy, mariah had so many hits, but she should have had even more. it blows my mind that this song didn't go #1, it's an r&b masterpiece. it's right there on the level of say my name and other HUGE r&b hits of the close of the 90s and opening of the 00s. people say mariah didn't take risks but she is such a versatile talent... from classic r&b to modern r&b with hip hop influences to pop ballads to whatever, mariah's voice was able to become the defining sound of more than 2 decades. WOW. you honestly just have to sit in awe.
I agree. I was SO surprised when I found out that this song would have been what some call a "flop" but then when I saw that it wasn't promoted properly, it made complete sense. Such a wasted opportunity.
It didn't go to number 1 because it was limitedly released. Apparently her record label didn't agree with it being a single because they didn't like her hip-hop transition. Mariah has been quoted saying, "I'll always be upset "Breakdown" never got its shot."
Christian M It was because she was starting to loose steam due to the pop craze.Nysnc and Backstreet sound was coming n. You're right, so many of her songs should have went to the top during the Butterfly era including Butterfly. That song and this is song are such gems. It's a shame.
Christian M I don't think it was officially released as a single. Not in the US anyway. It was coupled with the My All single which did go #1 so maybe Breakdown helped with that lol
Her pen is so good. Every word is chosen with such care, the chorus is beautifully written along with the melody. Songs like this and Underneath The Stars really showcase how good her writing is.
She was physically & mentally abused by her 1st husband she could of quit but 20something years later she still here all the pain and suffering and look how strong she is!!! IDGAF WHERE IM FROM SHE TOOK LIKE A G
She could have been an English teacher if she didn't become an artist. Her songs are so well written. This entire album was EPIC!!! I NEED A TIME MACHINE!
#facts #prayingemojiheartpprayingemojippccjbaabigheadinprayingmodesrnfshsasis ,_ "these is are forms of energy thru " .A.S.L. " #BIGHEADENRGY #BIGHEAD #BIGHEADENERGY #GODENERGY #BLESSINGSRNOTARNOTWRNBUSSBUSSBUSSARHYMESNOTESIAMJEANNETTE.R.BRYAN -" this is God speaking , divine timing is #nowtrendin
Whew Chile, when she said “How do I feel?! Whyyyy do you think you gotta know I’m suffering?!” She went off on the ad libs at the end of this song 💯❤️🎶🔥
This song is on my rotation in my car right now, still holds up, still fresh. I remember when this album came out, remember the Honey video was an event because Mariah was going through this transformation and new freedom in her sound, what a time! I still have the original CD boxed up somewhere.
en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_Billboard_Hot_100_chart_achievements_and_milestones She produced 14 of her 18 #1 hits and wrote 17 of them because one was a cover..if you search she has also wrote and produced much more songs that didnt go #1...so..yeah..try again
@T Br en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Category:Songs_written_by_Mariah_Carey Songs she wrote And you can go check that on every album she is credited as a producer
Who puts the word nonchalant in their chorus.....MARIAH DOES! She is literally the queen of putting big (sometimes have to look them up) words in her songs.
This song should have won a Grammy. The lyrics are brilliant, incredibly raw and relatable. She blended her vocal style with Bone Thugs seamlessly and the song is incredibly original.
FACTS!
Coolio said crossroads shoulda won the mtv award - and whatever the other song was…. Short story longer- Mariah bone thugz and even coolio - childhood heroes. This song is sooo good. Forgot it for years until now this is my raw reaction. No one cares but me. Loved it then and since all those mix CDs I made in 2005 disappeared like hearing it first time.
Preach!
This is still cold af. The hook is sooo good. Her writing has always been top tier in my opinion. Adlibs, vocal stacking, tone, smooth riffs, sheesh! 90’s and early 00’s is the golden era of RNB. Some of the greatest vocalist, writers, producers of all time. Music that feels like butter
@Danayah AGREED. Ps I think you meant Top tier (tier not tear); although that too. ;) ❤
Stevie J did his thing on this beat!
@@tonyadessasau2676 that’s why I respect him! I don’t care if people don’t know who he is, that man is talented and produced my favorite song!
❤️❤️
Yes, to everything you stated.. its definitely an art to it all.. you know its a thing when you know the adlibs are just as important as the words..
Some of yall just don't understand how EPIC this collab was back in the 90s 👏👏👏 just pure GOLD 😁
You ain't never lied
Mariah was doing r&b and hiphop/rap collaborations before it became the norm. She was way ahead of her time
Makes me appreciate Stevie J even more🌋
Tika L. And STILL is!!! ❤️
🤩😍💯✌🌻🥰💖😎
I don’t think people appreciate the immaculate songwriting that was done on this song. It’s beautifully written and vulnerable. I did a deep dive on Mariah’s songwriting and she’s honestly a poet. I never knew.
With you on this.
And as a poet, that’s why I really appreciate her work!
Who wrote this her
Couldn't tell me nothing at 15 when I learned the words lol 🔥🔥🔥🤣
You're barking up the wrong tree. I really appreciate it - from the Philippines 🇵🇭🇺🇲
“So i wear my disguise, till i go home at night then turn out all the lights and then i breakdown and cry” sisssss truer words have never been spoken
#word
Im a dude and that shit hits home
FACTS!!!
@@mauricewells7838 gay
@@r0bz1985 lol, na far from it. But most dudes will meet a girl/woman they like and if it doesn't work out it hurts. Everybody can't be a super gansta like u all the time
This song is criminally underrated! The chorus goes so hard.
@Tim Dewano this. They played the hell out of this when it came out lol
T This song wasnt underrated
Yes I remember when this song came out and I was so amazed and awe struck and it’s depth and lyrics; the beat still stands today.
FIRE!! SLOW JAM!!! DOPE!! Mariah Pipes And Bone's Flow And Love & Hip Hop Steven Jordan's (a.k.a. Stevie J) writing were Flawless!!!
Underrated? Well, I guess you're trying to be nonchalant about it.
The repeating "Cry... cry.. cry... cry..." at the end of the song actually sound like her crying... continuous, exhausted crying.
What an artwork this song is!
Thats my part 2..
I never noticed that before! I think it totally does.
The music video is iconic too, casino, other musicians in roles and the cabaret dancers style outfit in the dancers
This is perfect comment. Sublime singing style
Wow I never thought of it that way I love that…. Alicia Keyes reverently re did Fallin live and how she desricbed her background signers as their littelry fallin as their singing it
This song will NEVER GET OLD.
NEVER
Never
ever!
The fact that she has rappers singing background vocals tho... LEGEND!
I said the same thing! And they’re vocals gel together so beautifully.
They dont kno
And she flippin!!😍
Quite lyrically epic
The fact that she took a bone thugs hit and made another one.
This collab was perfect because Mariah was singing like she was rapping, and Bone Thugs raps like their singing! That Harmony was perfect! 🙌🏾
Dude fr✨✨✨
Seriously. They went together so well.
Well explained comment👏
all facts
Can't help but have love for both and my speakers in the trunk sing like love birds!
Mariah Carey had the 90s on lock!
What many people fail to pay full attention to in this song is the lyrics. These lyrics are so deep. Mariah actually wrote this masterpiece just like she writes all of her other masterpieces. She has had huge success in her career, but she is HIGHLY underrated when it comes to her songwriting skills.
Sophia Lucianna with the Help from Stevie J and Puff Daddy who co wrote and produced it
Facts up neva knew nd I been fukn wit this track since back when 2002
Damn right, this one tears me up every time
Absolutely!
Totally agree. These lyrics are so deep if u really listen. She's an amazing songwriter among everything else!
Mariah is known for her high notes, but these midtempo songs is really her voice shines.
Absolutely agree 💯
Some singers can also sing whistle notes, but nobody can sing like this!! Personally I think this is the most iconic Mariah's voice
Agreed!
She tore this song UP. Lyrically, emotionally, and vocally. TORE IT UP!
Yup! 💯💯💯
Yes
no crumbs!!
Agreed!!!
Yes she did!!!!
The fact Mariah writes a majority of her songs is amazing. These lyrics on this album were just fire!!
LO-KEY, she singing, BUT she 'singing' like she rapping. SHE "FLOWIN" like a rapper, & it sounds natural/easy to her. She really killed this. Bone Thugs too👏🏾👏🏾👏🏾👏🏾
Before Beyonce
Krayzie bone taught her how to sing that way. Its a bone song but she did her Thang though
@@broughammoore6168 No, he didn't she just modeled her vocal delivery after their flow.
@@brandonlambert9768 you do not know anything
they inspired her, their style, when writing it, and after writing and recording it, they somewhat reluctantly agreed to do it, and they have talked about how she served them weed and Henny on silver platters. I know everything about Mariah Carey. I've been a Mariah stan since 1995.
The melodies, the way she matches Bone Thugs N Harmony rapping. Simply iconic man. Butterfly is her best album and Breakdown and The Roof are top 10 in her discography. Non negotiable.
love this comment
KRAYZIE BONE KILLS THE TUNE FOR ME ☠☠☠☠☠☠☠☠☠☠☠☠☠☠☠☠☠☠☠☠☠☠☠☠☠☠☠☠
The Roof!
Mariah Carey is one of the best breakdown has been the best thanks to a singing artist she can sing
It really was. That was a completely listen from beginning to end.
Singing in a rapper's cadence. Lord she's beyond brilliant.
🙌🏼this comment soooo true 🤞🏽
Her and Krayzie Bone have another song together called I still Believe.
Kray also has songs harmonozing with Michael Jackson and Sade.
Dude is so underrated and so versatile.
He can hop on any track of any style and stand out.
She is totally underrated as a writer and composer. 99% of the time she writes her own songs and the music to them.
This would hit in this era
My favorite Mc song. She writes most of her own songs 🎵 😅
I remember when this came out. I was in middle school and it was great time to be a kid. What I wouldn’t give to go back when we truly had it all!
Same...miss the 90s
The hair. The makeup. The costumes. The jewelry. The vocals. The camerawork. The backgrounds. The birds chirping. This is a masterpiece.
Masterpiece
Birds chirping?...minnie riperton: hold my beer
@@nobodyspecial8452 youtube labels people who still use the played out and over used "hold my beer" lame meme sentence as sheep minded, unoriginal attention seekers and loserish
@@Macabre124 u lost me at "you tube labels people"..lmmfao
@@nobodyspecial8452 Google the UA-cam article the UA-cam moderators personnel released online for a better understanding
One of The Saddest and Most Realest Songs Ever Written.❤🌹
THIS!!!!!
it is...
Definitely! Just jam & keep pushing thru regardless of how heavy it still feels listening to it like hearing it for the first time all over again…🥺
Her lyrical cadence is damn near perfect. The way she uses the syllables, rhyming and vocabulary is amazing..”that you care for me but, that you’re just not in love” “immediately I pretended to be, feeling similarly” she snapped🔥
She's copying the Bone Thugs n Harmony flow to the t. And she can do it well
Exactly. Her talent here is impeccable and unmatched. Lyrical and melodic magic.
Nah it’s Absolutely Perfect 💯
Yesssssssds!!! She is a song writing genius toooooo!! What a blessing we were able to grow up listing to this kind of music
Perfectly analyzed!
Idc what anybody say 90s was the best decade
So happy I got to experience it so many incredible memories
THE BEST !!!!!
Oop
Facccctttss😭🥺😔
Almost 25 years later...this song still SLAPS. WHAT A MASTERPIECE. The lyrics, the beats, its everything.
Wow! I can't believe that! Thanks for sharing that info.
Time sure flew by
Yes
💯💯
Too emotional!
Most underrated song in the history of music
Time after time this song wins my heart Yoshi is making a remix
Eventions Gifts true.
Yes yes ya'll
It went over my head when I was Young Too: This song is Powerful and Most Definitely 100% overlooked💗💗💗NOONE Was Ready for HOODRIAH (they still not lol🤣). When She left Tommy She Came Hard!🔥🔥🔥🎶
@@joeyfigueroa6222 is it done yet??
My dad passed away yesterday and now I'm making a playlist with all the songs he loved and I remember him by. This is one of them. Thank you dad for showing me the greatest artists of all times. Loved, missed and never forgotten 🤘🔥❤
So sorry for your loss. How sweet of you, music transcends and can take you to another place. Listen and be with your father when a certain beat or melody takes you to him...
💓💓💓
Sorry
my condolences sorry for the passing ...your father definitely had a ear for good music
condolences. May he rest in peace.
One of my favorite songs of all time. Mariah is the ultimate diva. No such thing as listening to it once... if you're listening to "Breakdown" it's gotta be on repeat.
And this ladies and gentlemen is...
The best song that Mariah ever made. Hands downs
I really love her song with Young Jeezy too!
And "The Roof"
Kay L yeah, the top 2
Amen to that
Idk man lol. My top 5 (no particular order because I'm a coward)
Always be my Baby
Heartbreaker with Jay Z
Breakdown
Fantasy
I don't wanna cry
Cant stop repeating this song. Man I'm 40 years old and this is just flooding me with so many memories I don't want to stop hearing this.
2021 VISION BIG FACTS 🤔
Good times and good music! I’m 39 so I get it❤️
Me too!
Im 35 i was there u still older than me 😂😂 but i feel ya pain
40th in 3 days. Started slapping this on repeat yesterday, reflecting on the past. This takes me back for sure
She’s singing in Bone’s rap style, 🔥👍🏾🔥
I’m just catching on to it lol I haven’t listened to this in years and decided to come back
yes, noticed that too. She's so versatile.
She later went on to do the same thing on One & Only with Twista
@@FlashMcLightning that joint goes hard. I’m surprised they didn’t do a video.
yep...
This song is so slept on.
100000%
This song still the jam but the video is so boring.
Not by me ! Or anyone that can relate !
@@MSD.4543it is boring but she looks amazing
No it's not stfu
This is Mariah’s most underrated song
💯💯💯💯💯💯💯💯
One of my favorites of all time. Lyrically it’s genius.
I agree ... when she has bone thugs on its fire
yessssssss 💃🏻💃🏻💃🏻💃🏻❤❤❤❤
And best video
2019 anyone? One of my fave Maria Carey Songs . She is a legend ❤️
mine too :)
I love the mo thug remix with layzie bone added to the song and bones verses are longer
Mee forever love this song
Same ❤️
Me too. I agree with you.
Butterfly is one of the best albums in history people who think mariah is just a belting machine need to listen to this masterpiece and see how she experimented with her voice ,the lyrics , the harmonies , the melodies are just genius . This is why i think mariah is the best femal vocalist no other explored and experimented with their voice the way she did she literally have used every insh of her voice
said everything the gift of MC is incredible is every masterpiece she makes you can't choose each song has your gift your touch all thanks to her she will always be the best female singer in this world queen MC.
I agree. I watched a video where she literally sung every genre of song it went from rock to country to rap..she's my favorite of all time bc of her versitality!!!
@@Neen71 do you have the link for it?
@Lucky Spades I still have my butterfly cassette but I don't have a device to play it on lol. I purchased digital songs now. 🤭
I agree and I love that she's able to adapt her voice through different music styles in different eras whether it was the 90s, 2000s and even the 2010s (Her album Caution is a perfect example of this), She's truly a timeless artist.
I wish they would do an entire album together 😭 Mariah and Bone Thugs always make magic ❤
Facts
Mariah Carey killed this shit. Krayzie Bone did his thang on this record too.
Krayzie bone bodied this
That's Wish also harmonizing with Krazie. Rumor has it she had a thing for Krazie Bone.
After my 7 yr relationship ended, every lyric of this song described what I went through. To those going through it, I pray for you, Yeshua loves you and You WILL get through it.
AN Morgan thank you 🙏🏾💔
AN Morgan 💗💗💗
Facts
AN Morgan ❤️
Thank you.
3:12 till the end. Her runs, adlibs, etc. are absolutely incredible. Powerful, smooth, deep, creative. She’s the best
My fav part of the song
Omggg the truth she ate this up
mariah harmonizing with Herself 🔥🔥 Clock IT!
Ppl don't understand how REAL these lyrics are. Emotionally, Mariah's pen is lethal. 🙌🏾🙌🏾🙌🏾🙌🏾
Mariah didn't write this Jermaine Dupri did .
Mariah didn't write this Jermaine Dupri did .
+Jocosta Raynor Mariah wrote this by herself, Jermaine doesn't even have a writing credit on this song. It's only Mariah, Wish Bone, Krayzie Bone, and Stevie J. Wish and Krayzie wrote their own parts and Mariah wrote the rest. The only reason Stevie J is listed is because he probably changed a word or two so it would fit better after production. Mariah always writes her own songs (by herself most of the time) and her co writers really don't do much other than slightly edit it.
Speak on it
+donjuan2704 The lyrics are actually very profound it should've been a heartbreak anthem of 1998.
I truly think this song is one of the best songs of all time. It’s not until you’re about 30 yo tho that you REALLY understand the magnitude of these lyrics.
This comment is so real. Always loved the song, finally understand the lyrics
Factssss when I young I just used to sang this song with my whole heart and now that I’m 30 I’m like damn 🥺😩
💯 💯
Mariah's 90s and early 2000s work was the gold standard. No one has replicated her work.
It's virtually impossible...sure there are other artists out there with real talent, but MC is beyond incomparable
Is** the gold standard. So many people still study the hell out of her voice and overall work today. And she's the one that the younger generations get compared to the most. Their fan bases try to diss her and say she's no longer great or a skilled vocalist. The reality is that Mariah is their fav's fav and their fav will NEVER reach such levels (strictly speaking music).
Also, you can't take away greatness or legendary status, and one must never undermine one of the world's greatest musicians (not just a singer).
Her highly acclaimed "Caution" album is up there with the work of the popular girls today but of course, the effects of ageism and lack of label push made it underperform.
The fact that she can still explore and transform her sound time and time again proves her greatness.
Aside from her obvious skill in range and technique and feeling, her voice and tone are entirely unique. Some singers sing like other singers, but really no one's voice sounds like hers. Like when you here her it's always unmistakably her and no one else. Even her speaking voice is distinct.
Good
She is Queen I been a Lamb 💯💯 She will always own a special place my heart ❤️ my childhood consists of Mariah’s timeless hits..firsthand from the beginning 🫠
Who’s here in December 2024?❤🙌🏾🎁🦋🎄🫶🏾 One of my fav songs of all time!
Still smacks in 2023. 🥵 Mariah and Bone Thugs such a perfect combination. 🔥
My song👩🏾🎤☺️
@@jessykappp1081mines 3 🔥🔥🔥
Well said😭😭😭
@@jessykappp1081 💯🥵🔥
First heard this song when I was a child in the early 00s (a few years after it came out) and here I am in 2023, it never got old. The whole album is so beautiful & legendary ❤
One of the most underrated unexposed colabs Mariah did!! 1 of my many favs for sure! ❤
@Hate Spreader hahaha!!
When I was a kid this was everybody's jam
Sheryl Cares Most definitely. One of my favorite songs and collaborations Mariah did with one of my most favorite Hip Hop Groups. #TimelessClassic 😍😍😍😍😍💖💕👑👑👑🎵🎶🎼🎤
@@blvckfiretrvpfire15 a song the honeys can love and the homies feel
@@freddieboo.45 fact's 💯
2020 and this still hits hard. Mariah's voice is unmatched 🦋
By anyone!!! & I mean that... of all types..
Mapillar Dahn she’s a legend. 👑
Mapillar Dahn so hard bro!
i like the other version where the other bonethugz are in it
Mapillar Dahn agreed!!
The vernacular is spectacular. The timing of her words, and the duplication of her voice is so genius. This is a sad song BUT it's such a bop.
This could be a 2020 hit.
Sureeeeee can honey
Todays youth prefer no clothing and autotune so would not even make top 40 charts!
It’s still a hit tho🤔
@Kane Cantell you old heads so annoying 💀
@Kane Cantell you realize you can listen to more than just one genre/style/era of music at a time right? 😂😭
The 90s was like a whole other dimension.
It really was lol
I want the Dolorean and travel back to the 90s.
On Life - on my soul the 1990-99 was everything wishing I could go rite back immediately expeditiously 😂 Morgan freeman voice
@Bob Anderson back when everybody especially kids were safe to chop it up and ball out 🙏.
Facts , leave my ass there.
Mariah was hitting notes without even opening her mouth 😳. Effing legend!
Legend say that she still does not open her mouth when she sings. She's a butterfly, that's why, violet and blue, I dodge corona and so do you
😩😩😩 I just love her
Happy 54th birthday, Mariah! 🎉🎊🥳🎈🎁🎂
Wowwww, I can't believe time is passing this fast. I also can't believe she's almost 55, she looks so good I'd easily say she looks 25 years younger than that.
@@ajack1312
Thank you 💖
I am cooking for my health every day.
Her record label stifled her singles and promotion during this period of her career and yet this song, the whole album, is a testament of the genius of this woman, ahead of her time.
Tommy was still bitter about the divorce but this album still sold even though he tried everything to sabotage her sales to make her cower under his wrath. That's a testament to how strong of a person Mariah is to be able to escape a person like Tommy, who basically controlled every aspect of her life.
sold 13 million copies worlwide with only two singles that Sony promoted. Imagine how much more copies Butterfly could've sold if Breakdown was actually promoted.
A highly-underrated song
That's why she a a real breakdown.
But she bounced back.
It's why she's the goat and people that don't know the story behind her history don't understand why people feel that way. She had someone trying to get everyone to kill her career and she came out on top anyways. A rare story in high powered industry.
I really can’t think of another R&B singer that sang a breathy, rap cadence like this before Mariah Carey. And now this is the only style I hear in mainstream r&b these days.
I never noticed that but that so true though!
She doesn't get enough credit for this!
She is the pioneer! A icon!
She singlehandedly changed remixes and brought rap to the pop charts.
Facts 💯💯
"So what do you do when somebody you're so devoted to suddenly stops loving you?" Singing in two different octaves is something I will forever love in this song!
Her Butterfly era songs were the most popular here in the Philippines. This may be underrated in other countries, but it was a big hit here.
Sometimes I wish I was from Philippines... In my country, they only know All I Want for Christmas 😟
everything Mariah is popular here in the PH... here are the songs from each album that were hits:
MC: Vision of love. love takes time
emotions: emotions. make it happen
music box: hero. without you. anytime u need a friend. dreamlover.
daydream: one sweet day. open arms. forever. fantasy. always be my baby.
butterfly: butterfly. breakdown. my all. whenever u call. honey.
rainbow. heartbreaker. cant take that away. against all odds
glitter: never too far. lead the way.
charmbracelet: my saving grace. through the rain
Emancipation: we belong together. its like that. dont forget about us. mine again. fly like a bird.
e=mc2: bye bye. i stay in love. touch my body. ill be lovin u long time.
memoirs: angels cry. obsessed. up out my face
I find it hard to believe this song could be underrated anywhere. Banger 🔥
Well I'm from America and that was the best thing that ever happened to R&B
@@marinettematerna410 What country are you from?
"do you cling to your pride and sing i will survive...do you lash out and say..how dare you leave this way?!" maaaan loook lol. mariah said a mouthful! CLASSIC
That was that part okay!!!!
Mariah and Bone should have done a whole album together
facts bro check out Static ft. Krayzie Bone 2020!! (on my page)
Buba sparks gonna be ajj
Hole
DOÑUTMDAHHC
Bubba sparks give a minñtvit
Yessss omg
Yesssss!!! Omg ❤️🔥👌🏾
This is my comfort song 💚
A VERY underrated Mariah Carey song...this is fantastic! Seamless collaboration
Its a bone thugs song just more marketable to have her first
supastar-My 2nd favorite BTNH only 2nd to Notorious Thugs with Biggie
jim murphy they recorded the original without her, she liked it and they did this. This shows how good Bone Thugs are as rappers. The slowed down for Mariah and they still were flawless
I wonder if anyone noticed the magician is Red Man
Chavius Randall of course!!
One of her best song and totally underrated
They still can! And should !
Yeeeeeees
Big facts!!!
This has to be the best hip-hop + pop collaboration of all time. Everybody since Mariah has tried to replicate, but they haven’t even come close. Mariah’s artistic inclinations are unmatched. Those melodies.
Jock Marais ASMR r&b*
Butterfly was a hell of an album.
Rnb and rap
What? Fool shut up. Clown.
If I'd have a Gay-dar... it would go of the charts... WHUHAAHA... Best Hip-Hop/Pop collabo!!! I'd just pissed myself... 😖
This song is beautiful
Hands down one of the best songs ever written
People don’t talk enough about the writing in the song
Love it
Harmony
Mariah and bone thugs killed this track. It is timeless. A classic. Everything from vocals, to the artistic video, and how they're voices match perfectly with this beat. Forever one of my favs by her.
Only a singer like Mariah and rappers like BONE can be melodically on point & balanced! There is no other song like this in existence Period. LEGENDS
I did like the one she did with snoop...
This is the best!
Agreed.
Of course there is another song like this. Check out Krayzie Bone feat. Mariah Carey - I still believe
My mom said she would be happy to have me in the morning when do we need it was not a bad idea to be a little boy
Nonchalant and criminally underrated record.
it's crazy, mariah had so many hits, but she should have had even more. it blows my mind that this song didn't go #1, it's an r&b masterpiece. it's right there on the level of say my name and other HUGE r&b hits of the close of the 90s and opening of the 00s. people say mariah didn't take risks but she is such a versatile talent... from classic r&b to modern r&b with hip hop influences to pop ballads to whatever, mariah's voice was able to become the defining sound of more than 2 decades. WOW. you honestly just have to sit in awe.
I agree. I was SO surprised when I found out that this song would have been what some call a "flop" but then when I saw that it wasn't promoted properly, it made complete sense. Such a wasted opportunity.
It didn't go to number 1 because it was limitedly released. Apparently her record label didn't agree with it being a single because they didn't like her hip-hop transition. Mariah has been quoted saying, "I'll always be upset "Breakdown" never got its shot."
Christian M It was because she was starting to loose steam due to the pop craze.Nysnc and Backstreet sound was coming n. You're right, so many of her songs should have went to the top during the Butterfly era including Butterfly. That song and this is song are such gems. It's a shame.
Her ex husband made sure that her success without his direction was very limited....its public knowledge...hence the glitter era...
Christian M I don't think it was officially released as a single. Not in the US anyway. It was coupled with the My All single which did go #1 so maybe Breakdown helped with that lol
One word - MASTERPIECE. Highly underrated song. The lyrics are razor sharp. Look them up and sing along!.. simply mind blowing
lol razor-sharp huh. simply magical i love this song
+kimi jackson I heard dat
Wodz30
underneath the guise of a smile tragically I'm dying inside
The phrasing and arrangements are so good.
underneath the guise of a smile ... gradually ... I'm dying inside
Underrated Masterpiece.
LegendMariah it ws a big hit year 1997-98 it ws my fave those days and she ws everywhrre on MTv
Yes.. I love this song
LegendMariah I love this song and Mariah ijs classy break it down,
Did it chart? I can't remember. I don't think it went to number 1.
LegendMariah yessssssss
This song got me through a very depressing and sad state of my life....
I played this song in my car every single day on repeat for 8 months straight
Her pen is so good. Every word is chosen with such care, the chorus is beautifully written along with the melody. Songs like this and Underneath The Stars really showcase how good her writing is.
Bonethugs wrote it ..
Nah, Mariah writes all of her own lyrics@@callidawkins85
@@callidawkins85mmm Mariah wrote her part for sure
@@callidawkins85Mariah wrote her part and Bone Thugs wrote theirs as well
@breyonabanks1364Mariah wrote her part; stop lol. Y’all can’t stand to give this woman credit for her songwriting.
Mariah did soo much for the music industry. She's a Legend & will always be.
You are absolutely correct...I don't care what anyone says; I'm a forever fan #triedandtrue!
She was physically & mentally abused by her 1st husband she could of quit but 20something years later she still here all the pain and suffering and look how strong she is!!! IDGAF WHERE IM FROM SHE TOOK LIKE A G
Aaliyah Haughton yeah she dope especially when she drunk af
FACTS and if anybody say otherwise they delusional
Floety
I can never get tired of this song ❤️
Me too
Me either
Ikr💯🎧🎤🎵🎶♥♥♥🔥🔥🔥
Everyday repeat
It’ll never get old been playing it for years
One of the best collabs ever 2024 still here 💯🥰
She could have been an English teacher if she didn't become an artist. Her songs are so well written. This entire album was EPIC!!! I NEED A TIME MACHINE!
You & I both lol.
She's not a songwriter, she's a poet
No... she's an effing genius.
no.... she's my wife@@danielshannon6027
Stevie j wrote her lyrics
its her voice and control that is mind blowing
@@zacfun that´s not true. Indeed, Mariah wrote alone her lyrics.
I learned the word nonchalant through this song. And more words from her other songs. Thank you Mariah for enriching my vocabulary 😃
Same 😂❤️
me toooo!
Sameee lol
Lol I learned incessantly
Same here!!
Rocking this jam on Xmas eve instead of her Xmas anthems. Mariah was just on another level of sexy in her prime❤
Picking an all-time favorite Mariah song is an impossible task, but this beauty certainly makes the finals.
Agree
Hi Atlantic City.
Mr. Vegas reopen. Miss Melody thank you
The finals
Yaaassss!
Mariah and Bone Thugs created magic with this record.
Thanks To Stevie J
+Erie Cowson yes!!! just found that out the other day...
Stevie J and Puff Daddy or whatever he goes by now lol
MoetDior lol, 😂😂 take that, take that. I think Stevie J. did he produced all or most of the songs on her Butterfly c.d.
Omg! Yes they did ❤❤❤❤❤
Is Mariah inducted in the songwriter's hall of fame?? Cause this woman is beyonddddd talented.
Lisa Smart No, she keeps getting robbed 😑
@@HallOfMimi i thought she just very recently did
music4life Oh that comment was 4 months ago anyways finally Mariah got inducted 😍
speaking of, is jermaine dupri in there?
@@mooreoftre yeah he got inducted in 2017 or 2018.
Being a 80s baby in the 90s our music was the greatest i dont want you say aint no music like that 90s early 2000s music our music was so soulful.
Exactly. Born in '84 n I couldn't agree more. '90's n early 2000's was the best!
She’s the greatest vocalist and songwriter of all she literally wrote this in an hour
Really??? This is one of her best written songs. Wow
❤❤
Shes really a rapper she just sings instead.
DAMN really that's f*cking amazing I feel like this is one of her best songs
She sang the heck out of this song. Felt every word.
Alivia Nicole Holmes i felt it too
Yes she did
The Butterfly album was just amazing!!! Honey, My All, Babydoll, The Roof, Breakdown, Butterfly!!!! All such amazing songs!
victorb2696 close my eyes is one of my faves
victorb2696 Outside is my fav.
victorb2696 Add 'Fourth of July' on that..
victorb2696 It's why her prime is referred to as "The Butterfly Era" - her voice, her lyrical prowess was top then!
victorb2696 is not the case with most people are going to be in town
I don’t care I will play this over and over I miss this ERA PERIOD! 2024😫😢
#facts #prayingemojiheartpprayingemojippccjbaabigheadinprayingmodesrnfshsasis ,_ "these is are forms of energy thru " .A.S.L. " #BIGHEADENRGY #BIGHEAD #BIGHEADENERGY #GODENERGY #BLESSINGSRNOTARNOTWRNBUSSBUSSBUSSARHYMESNOTESIAMJEANNETTE.R.BRYAN -" this is God speaking , divine timing is #nowtrendin
Yes indeed ❤
I'm going to "We Belong Together" next. I was delightfully surprised with it back in 2005.
Who's listening this during quarantine? Ugh this song is perfect! Love every second of this second. Mariah simply the best!
I am! My new favorite song!
Memories of better times. No diseases, pandemics or recessions.
perfect song!
Here. Here for Bone though, but respect to Mariah!
Me! lol
I remember being obsessed with this song and singing this when I was in middle school. You couldn't tell me I hadn't experienced heartbreak.
Right?! Lol same
Facts!!!
Same girl same lol
😐
Lmao that's funny
Whew Chile, when she said “How do I feel?! Whyyyy do you think you gotta know I’m suffering?!” She went off on the ad libs at the end of this song 💯❤️🎶🔥
Yessss!!! My fave part!
I use this song to channel my anger..... Specifically on that part =(
I run that part back over and over and over again!
I felt that part; WHY!
How do I feel? WHAT do you think? You got to know I'm suffering.
Omg yes, she absolutely snapped 🔥
This song is on my rotation in my car right now, still holds up, still fresh. I remember when this album came out, remember the Honey video was an event because Mariah was going through this transformation and new freedom in her sound, what a time! I still have the original CD boxed up somewhere.
The way they harmonized with her 🔥🔥🔥
right?
That's BTNH baby. The GOATs
That's why they my number 1s I promise this was so beautiful
😐
I'm telling you!!🙌🏾
The vocal chemistry between MC and BTH in this jam is amazing
Spice Shabalala you just realized that?
Spice Shabalala her whole style changed after this song
Spice Shabalala Every time Bone thugz does a song with someone the chemistry is amazing. Be it 2pac, Mariah, Biggie whoever.
Spice h
the harmony is just amazing
These lyrics are sooo underrated 😩 Mariah doesn’t get the recognition she deserves as a writer 😩
Rahmel Music so true! Taylor Swift got nothing on her!
@T Br she did write and produce 80% of her work
en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_Billboard_Hot_100_chart_achievements_and_milestones
She produced 14 of her 18 #1 hits and wrote 17 of them because one was a cover..if you search she has also wrote and produced much more songs that didnt go #1...so..yeah..try again
@T Br en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Category:Songs_written_by_Mariah_Carey
Songs she wrote
And you can go check that on every album she is credited as a producer
@T Br LOL
Man its crazy how loss of your mom an your love breaks you down
Mariah is a lyrical beast
She truly is...
lyrical and vocal beast...there isn't like 2 singers who can match her pitch for pitch...
This song is so sonically rich and complex. This is a modern masterpiece that I'm surprised wasn't duplicated to death.
Lol duplicated to death but yes never
Because they can't and that's the tea
@@jonadol oop
This is the song that solidified my opinion that Mariah Carey is a songwriting genius! She captures the feeling of heartbreak beautifully.
Hannah Obsiye yes
Hannah Obsiye she and Amy Winehouse are the two women who I swear read my diary.
Mariah’s voice is ethereal- only angels could compete with her voice. ♥️
Who puts the word nonchalant in their chorus.....MARIAH DOES! She is literally the queen of putting big (sometimes have to look them up) words in her songs.
Nonchalant is not a big word lol
matibay
+Tinker B not the point of the comment lol
I know right I love reading her lyrics I was thinking no way she is rhyming with big words.
agree agree agree!!!