In Stars and Time #30 | A WISH SHARED IS A PROBLEM HALVED

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 17 гру 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 87

  • @caiterbunch3932
    @caiterbunch3932 6 місяців тому +180

    SO ENDING THE WORLD FOR LOVE IS COOL WHEN SIFFRIN DOES IT BUT WHEN I, THE KING,

    • @Ruminations09
      @Ruminations09 6 місяців тому +21

      This comment genuinely made me cackle

  • @mubbachubba6124
    @mubbachubba6124 6 місяців тому +142

    Fun fact! The mirror scene was original going to have it's own custom scene where Siffrin approached the mirror alone and pressed the button by himself. However, during play-testing, the player encountered an error that connected it to the first version of the mirror scene instead. The play-tester realized it was a bug after the fact and begged them to include it because it unsettled them.

  • @Amelthon
    @Amelthon 6 місяців тому +51

    siffrin really just gets dragged towards a good ending kicking and screaming

  • @CaitlinMagness
    @CaitlinMagness 6 місяців тому +79

    Isabeau carrying your sorry carcass, Odile walking alongside you, Bonnie holding your hand, and Mirabelle walking ahead, leading everyone to the end while the world breaks apart around you, is one of the most beautiful moments I’ve seen in a video game

  • @eli_three
    @eli_three 6 місяців тому +43

    "Travelling one! Y-"
    sif: "LALALA I CAN'T HEAR YOU!! NOT LOOPING TODAY!!! LALALALA!!!!"

  • @UwUable_guy
    @UwUable_guy 6 місяців тому +105

    Mal du pays is "homesickness" from French. No need to thank me (⁠◍⁠•⁠ᴗ⁠•⁠◍⁠)

    • @Saiavinn
      @Saiavinn 6 місяців тому +5

      Thank you, dear Change God~

    • @deadkill33
      @deadkill33 Місяць тому

      Oh mighty change god i offer thee my thanks

  • @CaitlinMagness
    @CaitlinMagness 6 місяців тому +50

    “DON’T FEED ME PINEAPPLE SLICES”

    • @Blwbelle
      @Blwbelle 4 місяці тому +4

      So abrupt and hilarious

  • @CaitlinMagness
    @CaitlinMagness 6 місяців тому +39

    I understand Gina being bothered that “Siffrin never had to actually communicate,” but I really think that, given his mental state, just being able to say “I wished to stay with everyone” was a *huge* breakthrough in terms of communication for him, and took a lot of courage even if, from an objective standpoint, he didn’t really have a choice at that point
    even then, they still could’ve chosen to let their friends continue to beat them up for all eternity rather than finally just spitting it out, lol

  • @CaitlinMagness
    @CaitlinMagness 6 місяців тому +42

    the idea of Siffrin just yeeting the Head Housemaiden out of existence is very funny ngl

  • @smokewthedevil
    @smokewthedevil 6 місяців тому +36

    i always interpret the end of the mal du pays scene as siffrin starting to turn into a sadness . which yknow just makes the scene feel worse now that i think about it

    • @countlessCritters
      @countlessCritters 6 місяців тому +18

      I don't just interpret the END as Sif starting to turn into a sadness, I interpret the entire mal du pays scene as the gradual process of wearing them down until they give into their own sadness and become it.

  • @ronanhartman8942
    @ronanhartman8942 6 місяців тому +47

    The randomnized rooms on the later floors prevents you from being trapped in one of thje impossible routes in addition to be highly creepy, love that you finnally got the ending, I hope you talk to loop in the end.

    • @lasagna3289
      @lasagna3289 4 місяці тому +4

      They're not actually randomized. You still need to use the Star Crest on the right Tears - but if you try to use it on a different row of Tears, Siffrin will just say "(Not this one.)"

  • @Ruminations09
    @Ruminations09 6 місяців тому +43

    No matter how many times I see the fight against the party and the following scene, I still am left a sobbing mess at the end of it. The final shot of the group hug breaks me every time.
    Also, "I Won't Let You Go Home" is probably my favorite musical track in the game.
    EDIT: OMG, Y'ALL, PLEASE MARK YOUR SPOILERS!
    Gina and Allison have already expressed that they prefer to play blind. Please respect that.
    I know exactly why you are all so eager, but please recognize that your enthusiasm has the potential to leech some of the enjoyment out of the game for them.

    • @smokewthedevil
      @smokewthedevil 6 місяців тому +8

      i wont let you go home is my fav track on the ost its so good bro

  • @joshvandeleuv1595
    @joshvandeleuv1595 6 місяців тому +21

    The way this game works, my first thought when reading the title of this episode was 'oh god, someone else is going to get stuck in a separate time loop and they're going to break down.'

    • @YarnJam
      @YarnJam 6 місяців тому +17

      In response to fanfiction about the other characters getting stuck in the time loop, the creator of the game said that they think anyone but Siffrin would have escaped in five loops tops, because none of them have the concoction of mental illness that keeps Siffrin from telling their family his problems. Sorry if this is worded badly I'm typing through tears.

  • @mabman3235
    @mabman3235 6 місяців тому +22

    TITLE DOESN'T SAY END! LET'S GOOOO!!!

  • @crowsenpai5625
    @crowsenpai5625 6 місяців тому +13

    So the whole deal with Mal Du Pays, my theory is Siffrin was THIS👌 CLOSE to becoming a Sadness.
    I also feel the Craft Type of a Sadness is dependent on the Craft Type of who it was, and Powerful Sadness (Sif definitely qualifies there) are also capable of channeling multiple Craft Types, so I feel Mal Du Pays would have Sif’s 2 affinities: Piercing Craft…and Wish Craft! And a Sadness with control over WISH CRAFT sounds nigh unstoppable.
    In his final battle Sif was able to use the might of the Universe Itself, the only reason the party survived was Sif was in the drivers seat and he COULDN’T annihilate his family…but a Sadness would be heartless and wouldn’t hesitate. Forget Vaugaurd, the entire world would be threatened.

  • @Bea-zel
    @Bea-zel 6 місяців тому +29

    Okay so. Personal theory time. Odile! She can stop time craft. How? One of these theories is directly related to her knowing the slow spell which is not linked to a craft type. So what craft would slow be? That's right. Odile can use a bit of time craft which allows her to stop Sif
    Stupider theory time: In this one timeline Odile is the one person whose wish is not achieved. Bonnies sister is saved and vagaurde is safe due to stopping the king and Isa found Sif due to help from loop but due to their travel Odile never managed to flip her coin. Keeping her wish in a quantum state of being achieved or not.
    This in turn would give her the power to stop the wish craft due to having a wish in the stock yet to be granted or not granted

    • @paulomatute4114
      @paulomatute4114 6 місяців тому +6

      Sadly she didn't knew the ritual for making a wish, so it isn't a real wish and that can't be it

    • @tomaskadlec6407
      @tomaskadlec6407 6 місяців тому +10

      Or she just learns a version of her Craft Break skill and disrupts Sif with that. Mira has an improved shield/reflect as well.
      .. hehe, everyone gets even stronger skills than after family quests because siffrin is not with them because he is so disgusting and useless and they hate him and-

    • @tartarsauce1495
      @tartarsauce1495 5 місяців тому +7

      i really like the idea that it's just her regular slow spell and it was one hell of a bluff, like
      odile: NUH UH *ODILE BLAST* I STOPPED YOU
      sif: (OH STARS OF COURSE SHE'D FIGURE OUT HOW TO STOP ME OH STARS OH NO) *stops trying to rewind*
      odile:

  • @paulomatute4114
    @paulomatute4114 6 місяців тому +16

    50:27
    completely seriously, I was expecting some twist that Sif would turn into a sadness, and something along the lines of the sadnesses of the castle are mostly other fallen versions of Sif
    glad it wasn't that at all, but also would have been a wild twist

    • @retrogamingcommentary4163
      @retrogamingcommentary4163 Місяць тому +4

      For a while, I thought that Sif was going to turn out to be the King, with the hair-brushing scene being a hint that he would eventually let it grow out and show its true light color.

  • @CaitlinMagness
    @CaitlinMagness 6 місяців тому +14

    *eternity is within your grasp* gives me goosebumps

  • @tomaskadlec6407
    @tomaskadlec6407 6 місяців тому +22

    I wonder what's the deal with the "battle with yourself", or, well, the "homesickness" Sadness. Is it something that happened to Siffrin specifically, because he started to refuse and hate his own wish, or does it happen to everyone who gets got by King's time-stopping curse.. and that's how all the Sadnesses are created? Perhaps as Sif completely refuses to loop back to start in this loop he got properly time-stopped by the King for the first time, unlike looping back the second he touches a tear and feels like it's his end.

  • @starlesscitiess
    @starlesscitiess 6 місяців тому +10

    holy voice acting batman

  • @lasagna3289
    @lasagna3289 4 місяці тому +4

    Your acting of Sif was so good

  • @worthythaneofross3925
    @worthythaneofross3925 6 місяців тому +17

    Hot damn the voice acting

  • @CaitlinMagness
    @CaitlinMagness 6 місяців тому +13

    32:54 eloquent commentary on the situation

    • @CaitlinMagness
      @CaitlinMagness 6 місяців тому +7

      Allison: ohhhhh uuueegghhhh uuuuuuuu
      Gina: GIH

  • @4threset251
    @4threset251 6 місяців тому +4

    Allison : oh god oh no, dont do that nono nO! 😭
    Gina : We've been better! 😄
    Also Bonnie going : "Like crafting an entire painting for weeks at a time?" felt like a personal call out, go away Bonbon

  • @paulomatute4114
    @paulomatute4114 6 місяців тому +10

    29:25
    but nobody came...
    31:55
    the King is literally Sans in this situation
    38:39
    now we are in Omori

  • @rklover13
    @rklover13 2 місяці тому +3

    By the time the party shows up, I was tense the entire time. I basically didn't think they were really there until almost the very end. This game did such a good job. This ending just.. ugh made my heart sick.
    Still so many questions, like I also want to know what is up with Euphrasie. Compared to EVERYONE else, her behavior in any loop is off..
    And ODILE IS THE BIGGEST BADASS EVER. She learned how to use time craft just by learning about it from Loop, and books in the house. She is amazing.

  • @WD_Gaster66
    @WD_Gaster66 6 місяців тому +3

    13:49 What if you are the universe? You lead Siffrin to where he has to go and do, and he follows

  • @megabutler08
    @megabutler08 6 місяців тому +17

    Glad you finally made it. Thanks for the Extra large Episode. Hope someone has told you: You can head south from the Final Room to talk to more people. There's still quite a bit to see...

  • @salthien
    @salthien 6 місяців тому +8

    I was so excited for this episode and am SO SO SO SO excited for the next!! Also amazed at your fortitude and ability to not cry at parts that made me bawl, LMAO

  • @Hallasammal
    @Hallasammal 6 місяців тому +5

    ODILE BLAST

  • @paulomatute4114
    @paulomatute4114 6 місяців тому +6

    1:44:25
    I mean, Sif is almost done with a "don't open up, prefer the world to end over talking about your feelings" run, he wasn't gonna throw now, just say what it is needed to progress
    the "talk about your feelings" runs speedrun must be so fast, but Sif isn't going for that, so gonna stick with the longer and more traumatic run until completion

  • @caiterbunch3932
    @caiterbunch3932 6 місяців тому +4

    (presumably) one more episode before i can start looking at in stars in time content without getting hit spoilers... just a little longer i can make it... just a little further...

  • @myrandajo9280
    @myrandajo9280 6 місяців тому +3

    wow wow wow wow tears tears tears for hours and hours!!!!!
    y'all absolutely KILLED it with the voice acting and the commentary. hhhhhhhhhhh excellent stuff so glad you made it :',)

  • @CaitlinMagness
    @CaitlinMagness 6 місяців тому +6

    38:41 it’s Omori again all of a sudden

  • @CheeseCake4Not
    @CheeseCake4Not 6 місяців тому +6

    The Episode Title doesn't say End, and now I am EXTREMELY worried!

    • @blainewheaton9679
      @blainewheaton9679 6 місяців тому +2

      Just put the playlist on loop, I don’t see the probl-“vvvwup!”

  • @firemansam263
    @firemansam263 6 місяців тому +2

    oh my godddd I am openly weeping 😭❤

  • @starlesscitiess
    @starlesscitiess 6 місяців тому +3

    oh god this is like the third time this part has made me SOB

  • @everything_cooler_here
    @everything_cooler_here 4 місяці тому +3

    37:13 this reminded me of omori lol

  • @karinaanderson9533
    @karinaanderson9533 6 місяців тому +4

    Was it perhaps the best decision to stay up til almost 3 a.m. to watch this episode right after coming home from a concert that gave me a headache? Certainly not. But really it was the only decision to be made, you understand. SUPERB job on the voice acting!! This game is spaghettifying my body, mind, and soul!!! Super Cool That The Video Isn't Titled "End"!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! What's a trust issue?? I've never heard of one and this game is Definitely Not Giving Me Any! :DDDDD

  • @qisforcucumber
    @qisforcucumber 6 місяців тому +1

    this episode made me cry 97 times in rapid succession

  • @starlesscitiess
    @starlesscitiess 6 місяців тому +3

    OHHHH MY GOD. OH MY GOD WE’RE HERE

  • @ThePiachu
    @ThePiachu 6 місяців тому +2

    Me listening to the start of the episode: "Loop doesn't agree with this, she's a hater, and we don't have time for haters!" ;)
    The epilogue so far is so good! Looking forward to the finale!
    Also would be nice to hear your reflection on the series as a whole, plus what tips / hints / etc. the developer shared with you that you mentioned way back when!

  • @Fangria
    @Fangria 6 місяців тому +10

    fucking awesome title

  • @lordk.gaimiz6881
    @lordk.gaimiz6881 6 місяців тому +4

    My god, crying is great! Just like this game ^^
    Can't wait to see the end, and whether.or not there are multiple endings... 'cause i genuinely don't know ^^')

  • @Leapdayart
    @Leapdayart 6 місяців тому +3

    I was so so so excited for this episode :DDD AND OH BOY!! Lots of feels :’D this series has been so fun and such an emotional rollercoaster (I don’t really have the proper words to describe how I feel rn). Both of you do the voice acting a great service and make the story all the more immersive. Looking forward to the epilogue :))

  • @CaitlinMagness
    @CaitlinMagness 6 місяців тому +5

    the music in the House is going off 😳

  • @NeechanJudi
    @NeechanJudi 6 місяців тому +3

    I love it. Thank you, guys!

  • @Vlad-t3f6q
    @Vlad-t3f6q 6 місяців тому +2

    yes! yes! yes! yes!
    aaand now i’ve got a hunger for some fics
    have fun exploring! the rest!! :3c i shan’t say too much (the next video might have already been recorded for all i know)
    but! you can check the door out!!! (it’s not super obvious and i missed half the epilogue over it lol)

  • @Shwindu
    @Shwindu 6 місяців тому +7

    51:32 ok so. I feel like I have a differing opinion on this scene than most do, and I don't know if it's intentional or not. When I got to this in my own game, and later seeing others reach this point, this scene always felt off. Siffrin got worn down so much from Mal du pays. He lost all will to fight, he hit the bedrock. The tone has never been lower. And then suddenly a *super* cheery song plays and everything is *bright* and everyone appears and is smiling? It never hit well for me. It felt like too much. Too abrupt, too happy-go-lucky. Too *sweet* one could say. And it's only now during this playthrough that I'm putting it together and finding an explanation for this that makes me a lot more amenable to these turns of events. This could be wish craft really pushing it to lift Siffrin back up from their pit and grant their wish back to them. They've been gone, they've been without their party for hours so the wish has been straining, and now it's snapping back with a KICK to give Siffrin what he wants again, resulting in a really saccharine taste. Overcompensating until it evens itself back out after the king fight. It feels off because it's purposely pushed and slightly artificial to get Siffrin his wish.
    I could be spouting nonsense to "fix a problem" that only I'm feeling, but thinking about the situation like this really eases the somewhat sour taste in my mouth from this scene.

    • @ZUDwarf
      @ZUDwarf 6 місяців тому +5

      I don't think a sudden triumphant moment is a problem that needs fixing, really? It hit exactly right for me, and the game then goes on to show that this one event didn't fix everything, it, at most, put a small band-aid on a gaping wound.
      If anything, it's in-line with how the rest of the game has made use of the common elements of these sorts of stories: when the protagonist is at their lowest, when defeat is inevitable, when they've given up, the party appears and reassures them that they are loved and valued and can win this. So, we get that...and then it turns out that that wasn't enough.

    • @02miguener99s
      @02miguener99s 6 місяців тому +5

      for me it was less the moment itself and more the smiling portraits, to me it feels like those expressions just don't fit either the previous scenes or the implied ocurrances that the party went through going up the house, maybe if the faces looked more determined rather than hyper-optimistic it would feel less off? although I guess part of the impact of the scene is because of the sudden shift from the all consuming depression and self-loathing to the realization the the family is here.

  • @everything_cooler_here
    @everything_cooler_here 4 місяці тому +1

    1:44:32 this complicated ahh relationship can all be solve if they all just TALK

  • @Circus_Balloon
    @Circus_Balloon 6 місяців тому +2

    😭
    (Also I'm so scared to see what happens next)

  • @unicornilluminati9019
    @unicornilluminati9019 6 місяців тому +8

    Remember to head south to go back to Dormont in the Epilogue! There's still some content left with Loop there if you head to the Favor Tree!

  • @undergnomes6248
    @undergnomes6248 6 місяців тому +2

    Woooo been waiting for this! Can't wait for the next one!

  • @plida27
    @plida27 6 місяців тому +5

    Yes yes yes yes!!!!!

  • @gabrote42
    @gabrote42 6 місяців тому +1

    1:17:01 May or May not be a spoiler based on a devlog
    0:08 Good fluid time segment to you too
    0:50 I really hope thise come back for the ending. Would be sad if they didn't matter in the grand scheme of things
    1:32 Ouch. Very far off the deep end. Good that they wear gloves to stop themselves from biting their nails off, or they'd have lost half ther fingers already
    4:10 Apparently Insertdisc5 called streamers and fanfic writers cowardly for not shipping The King more aggressively. Apparently they can recognize cowards when they see them, despite being aroace
    4:48 "[Y]ou and your _actors_ arereflected in it", emphasis mine
    6:26 Omori microwave moment. That stewk was raw and we all know it!
    7:02 Finally, what we are all thinking!
    9:38 "Disimular, el espectáculo debe continuuaaar!" -El Viejo Varieté, María Elena Walsh. Hopefully I'll make an animatic with it down the line. The Universe is meant to be followed unquestioned, but it is not leading. Also, thisis still blatantly impossible XD.
    13:45 May he find existentialism. Man, wish i knew more Wayne June quotes to lighten the mood. Maybe one forthe Hopeless affliction
    15:05 The machinery strains against a purpose it was not meant for. Wether it's Wish, or Siffrin, that is mlre than I can say.
    16:05 If he could have held it together just a bit longer!
    19:33 The QoL of putting an exclamation point there is very cool, still
    22:59 A whole day and a bit more without eating, with that much stress... they are a dead enby walking.
    23:54 In The Presence of the King, such as it is...
    25:47 What an interesting character he is. And now, "Do You Remember?" In the traped style. Oh boy. I wonder if the vision will kill sif
    28:33 Everyone saw that flash. Siffrin wisthood. This is going to be bad
    33:03 Thisis a true masterpiece right there. A glorious example of all it set out to do. This deserves an award
    35:42 Not good enough. The King was prepared. And emptiness will bring you back again. Now onto the guitar of sadness
    37:14 The song was not the same. I guess there is a secret boss. How terrible
    39:56 Homesickness, right? Pretty sure that's it, if I remember the tour in france right. What culd it possibly want from you? So intense.
    43:28 Not quite Omori, but not far off either
    49:02 Siffirn feels like he's dying more than any of his real deaths. This must be horrible. I hope to never condemn anyone to such a position.
    50:34 So this is what happens to those beaten by the King. And the Sadness is what remains of them. This is some top notch horror.
    51:36 RESPECTFUL! YESSSSSSS!!!!
    53:35 LOOP YOU ABSOLUTE UNIT!
    53:44 FAIR!
    55:49 THE CHANGE GOD PROTECTS!
    58:07 What an emotional moment. A true ending, maybe
    1:03:49 This is so awesome
    1:08:19 The world strains, still. This outcome is too far removed. This game is perfect
    1:13:43 True, your attacks had no cooldown, so you must have pushed yourself more than what's possible.
    1:16:01 PLEASE BE HALLUCINATORY PTSD I BEG OF YOU
    1:16:37 REALITY DREAM CONSTRUCT! Also, nice name for Head Housemaiden
    1:17:01 Such delusion... onto the ne t and final act, according to prerelease material I suppose
    1:19:18 Oh you absolute fool. Here we go.
    1:21:30 The Hollow Knight battle too? Oh we are so spoiled
    1:23:26 VERY SMART!
    1:27:33 COUNTER! BEAUTIFUL!
    1:36:13 A ritual improper... this is so sad
    1:38:43 Classic Abilene Paradox. Simple and crushingly poetic
    1:41:38 Huzzah! Friendship! This is now my 3rd favourite game of all time. Wow. How glorious
    1:47:33 Hey anybody seen Euphrise? Or Loop? Did anyone call out to mr stark?
    1:50:49 Time for the victory lap! I suppose the spoiler was wrong!

  • @epicacia1782
    @epicacia1782 6 місяців тому +4

    I love the series! I am so excited to see you get to the very end. By the way, just letting you know, you can leave that final room, and there will be stuff outside. Sorry about back seating a little with that, but I really don't want you two to miss everything that's happening out there. Thank you for making this fantastic series!

  • @hypoconductor
    @hypoconductor 6 місяців тому +2

    We’re so back (?)

  • @wrath2509
    @wrath2509 6 місяців тому +1

    Welp now is a perfect time to remind you guys to go down for some extra bits before finishing.

  • @erikm8373
    @erikm8373 Місяць тому +2

    Shit man, this time loop is fucked. I just saw Siffrin pull out their dagger, say "(Scissors.)" or some similar shit, and all the sadnesses around him took 6000 damage and died instantly. There wasn't even any unique dialogue, that's how common shit like this is. My ass is casting Paper III and Slow IV. I think I just heard Power Word: Skip, two rooms over. I gotta get the fuck out of here.

  • @YarnJam
    @YarnJam 6 місяців тому +2

    😭😭😭

  • @CaitlinMagness
    @CaitlinMagness 6 місяців тому +5

    TWO HOURS 🎉

  • @kchgamer1788
    @kchgamer1788 6 місяців тому +2

    So far my main two nitpicks with this game is that it’s very obvious what the problem with the loop is and the fact that communication could have fixed so much. It made it somewhat annoying to ‘play as’ sif and have them never even attempt to when that would clearly have been a helpful solution. Maybe even just for one loop.
    Besides those two things I’ve absolutely adored this game and I don’t get how this channel continues to find games I’ve never heard about before but I absolutely adore.

    • @Ruminations09
      @Ruminations09 6 місяців тому +8

      I mean, yeah, communication could have fixed so much. Which is exactly the point - Siffrin was precisely the wrong person to get stuck in this situation because they fundamentally can't communicate. The story is a character study of Siffrin and their fatal flaw. A character study is - by design - meant to highlight one or two key aspects of a character that make them uniquely unable to solve the (comparatively) simple situation they find themselves in.
      A famous example is the fact that if Hamlet and Macbeth swapped places, then *neither* story would be a tragedy.
      So yes, it's true. Communication *would* have solved Siffrin's problem. Because the story was specifically written to highlight Siffrin's inability to communicate.

  • @madhippy3
    @madhippy3 6 місяців тому +1

    I feel a little cheated that we don't naturally come to the point where we have to talk to them, and that Loop had to stop hiding and literally explain everything short of our wish to them. This is fine, it works, but it also feels rushed just in the one loop.

  • @GlitchyGalaxies
    @GlitchyGalaxies 6 місяців тому +6

    PLEASE go back to Dormont next time! There's a bit more content over there post-game!

  • @assassincat4942
    @assassincat4942 6 місяців тому +3

    Are you going to do the secret boss?
    Also you can go outside and talk to everyone outside.
    To get secret boss go outside and go to favor tree and interaction with coin

    • @GlitchyGalaxies
      @GlitchyGalaxies 6 місяців тому +3

      Shhh spoilers

    • @assassincat4942
      @assassincat4942 6 місяців тому +1

      ​@@GlitchyGalaxiesOops. Well it seems like they have already recorded this video and the next one so it should be fine...?

  • @fairiesandlillies3471
    @fairiesandlillies3471 6 місяців тому +2

    Go back to the favor tree