Wow, I’m not a pies fan but there were two absolute umpiring howlers in this game that could have costed Collingwood the game, Cameron taking a ‘mark’ a good meter outside the boundary and then also receiving a handball outside the field of play to kick a goal, real WTF moments😮
@@Christian-yd3ng yeah half of Geelong's free kicks were when they already had the ball. Example: Ollie Henry getting 2 free kicks in front of goal when he already marked it. And Collingwood should also stop belting blokes after they dispose of the ball.
@@Ethan-mo6xe literally got gifted two goals, had 7 more free kicks and still not happy with the umpiring because we got “stupid free kicks all night”. 10 free kicks is well below average
@@Christian-yd3ng He already marked the ball and they paid a free kick, hence inflating the free kick count. Most of Geelong's free kicks didn't help whatsoever when they already had possession, could've had 8 free kicks and the score would've been the same
"They're back, muscling as a team against the odds, their skipper's gone, here's Elliot. They're all coming to life, they're like mushrooms." - Brian Taylor
The crowd noise was unbelievable, is it any wonder that 1 million+ fans have gone to watch Collingwood play this season. Ginni looked right at home at the G. Olli gets better week after week. Lipa looked comfortable in the mid field, Howe was excellent up on the forward line, Murph filled Darcy's role with excellence. Checkers kicked a bag of snags. Great team connections. What a spectacle both teams put out. Most clangers on the night go to the umpires. lol. Go the mighty Pies.
@@jameschristiansson3137New Jersey here. Cheering for Collingwood (mostly) because of Mason, but I've been a fan since I first saw the game back when Gary Ablett Sr. was playing.
@@jameschristiansson3137 I agree! The contact of (American) football or ice hockey, the kicking skills of (what we call) soccer, the scoring of basketball - what's not to love?
Collingwood played better... simple as that , and im a cats fan. Geelong supporters had a stellar year in 2022 , finishing with a premiership. You cant win it every year... this is Collingwoods year... they deserve it.
Great win Pies. Murphy really stepped up in Moore's absence. Ginnivan was instrumental and deserved to be there.Josh Daicos....was everywhere, pure brilliance! I'm not one to attack the umps...but hell....it really looked like they wanted to give cats a win... Jeremy Cameron is a great player, and a dead eye goal kicker....he doesn't need to be gifted shots at goal.
Collingwoods kicking in and around the foward 50 was much smarter, Kicking to players in space and trying different things was the difference between the 2 teams..
I agree with Jezza's 2 goals being out of bounds, but why is everyone ignoring the blatant decisions against Geelong such as at 0:27 Guthrie pushed in the back and holding the ball missed, or the centre bounce at the start of the second quarter, or Jezza's mark not paid in the second half. Don't @ me with the free kick count when half of Geelong's free kicks were when they already had the ball, such as Ollie Henry getting 2 free kicks in front of goal when he already marked the ball.
UK fan here. Stumbled across this delightful sport during covid. However, Ive only been able to watch games in highlight like this. Any UK fans know of a way to watch full games?
Finally! A high-scoring game on a Friday night. Geelong were good in the first quarter where they led by as much as twenty-two points before Collingwood controlled the game. Jeremy Cameron's seven goals wasn't enough for the Cats. It is very unusual for a player to kick seven or more goals in a losing team. The Magpies are the team to beat now.
Geelong supporter here. Firstly, the umpiring. On both sides there were costly goals due to incorrect calls, or incorrect no calls. Any true footballing spectator would see that. Regardless of which, it’s never the players fault if a call is or isn’t made, that’s on the integrity of the umpires. As an athlete, if you believe you can get away with it, trust me, you’ll keep doing it. Now, Collingwood are in blazing hot form, and this was always going to be a tough game. Yes, they were missing out on Nick Daicos, and then an injury to Darcy Moore. Let’s even throw Nathan Murphy in there. But Geelong are clearly not in form with an inconsistent side due to a severe amount of injuries with players that would walk into any AFL club in Blicavs, Hawkins, Henry, and Cameron Guthrie (and that’s not even our full injury list). The fact that this depleted Cats team showed promise and fight against the clearly ranked number 1 team in the league, to only lose by 8 points in the end, we take that as a positive and move onto next week. Sometimes it’s not about who’s the best, but who’s the healthiest and Collingwood is one of those teams that have had a very healthy list, so good on them.
Collingwood is in terrible form! Barely scraped past Port, lost to Carlton, then thumped by 16th on the ladder. Now they only beat 9th on the ladder by 8 (although more like 20 considering Cameron’s illegally paid goals). This is the worst form they’ve been in for 2 years and you couldn’t capitalise.
@@rmj4882 fair comments. Though, Port are 2nd on the ladder. Carlton have won 7 in a row (clearly in form). Yes, Hawthorn are 16th on the ladder, but if you’ve watched their footy and not the highlights they have started to find some form themselves.
@@frustralia4293 is that the reason why the Collingwood cheer squad has a deal with the AFL and MCG that reserves the city end bay for the cheer squad no matter who they play? Or how about that they’re 2nd in the league for free kicks for? Shall I keep going or is this too much words for you to process?
@@frustralia4293your words are not valid, respond if you wish but I choose to not waste my time with you, as opposed to debating over real topics/discussions on football, and not biased non-factual commentary.
We are Geelong the greatest team of all we are Geelong we are on the ball we play the game as it should be play at home or far away are banner is flying high from dawn to dusk down at kardinya park
That was such a sketchy reaction by David Roden, he was originally going to call behind, then paused......looked confused for a second, then ran over and put his hands up, paused again......then signed goal........Was he going to call behind but had someone in his ear say "call it a goal"? He should have done a goal review. Even thought the result wouldn't have changed, the % can mean the difference between a home or away final or missing out on finals vs playing in them. It seems like this comp is rigged, 2 out of bounds (1 on the full) should have been called......but both were ignored by umpires standing not even 15m away and in full view. Both resulted in a goal.
@@lachlanbaker2031no it was a point. I think David Rodan called it a point for the sake of both teams reaching 100 points but that definitely wasn’t a goal
Geelong still put on a major performance against the best side in the comp, especially given the lack of Hawkins, Rohan, Blicavs, Guthrie and J.Henry. Umps were horrendous as always but the win was very possible without them. Hopefully bounce back next week!
season is already over if geelong lose next week, if st kilda beat richmond then thats gonna give them huge motivation to win next week, ending our season. Cya's all next year, time for the league to watch geelong do their best to tank for a top 5 draft pick.
That was such a sketchy reaction by David Roden, he was originally going to call behind, then paused......looked confused for a second, then ran over and put his hands up, paused again......then signed goal........Was he going to call behind but had someone in his ear say "call it a goal"? He should have done a goal review. Even thought the result wouldn't have changed, the % can mean the difference between a home or away final or missing out on finals vs playing in them. It seems like this comp is rigged, 2 out of bounds (1 on the full) should have been called......but both were ignored by umpires standing not even 15m away and in full view. Both resulted in a goal.
Yes why is nobody talking about this? It looked like a behind for sure!! They probably just wanted both teams to reach 100 points to take away a pretty rigged game as a good one.
channel 7 need to hire a more enthusiastic commentator, james brayshaw sounds like he'd rather be anywhere else. it takes away from the game. he also only speaks in 3 word sentences
Geelong should’ve been penalised for the two out of bounds goals yes but at the same time, that push in the back and no holding the ball call with the Ratagoulea chase down was absolute dogshit as well
@@EBGamez1 I dunno imo looked like a pretty good run down, and regardless incorrect disposable for dropping the ball as well but I see where you’re coming from
The Maggie's bounced back perfectly after losing 2 games in row, Geelong were tight early on but Collingwood came back with full throttle. Dr fort and Moore are a problem but Collingwood will be a huge threat in finals
Explain to me why they don't just review every play that directly leads to the goal like they do in NRL. It's not good enough. Most atrociously officiated game in the entire world.
AFL needs to bring in video technology like the soccer for decisions leading up to goals in the forward 50. This is a disgrace and could have costed Collingwood
Empires give cats 2 goals that should have been out of bounce so collingwood would have won by more but umpires do wat they want y umpires don't get in trouble if stuff up like that afl is dropping off now getting weak
@@SilentHotdog28 if they tried to help them then i'm sure that the centre bounce at the start of the second would've been recalled but keep going with the narrative
Isn't it amazing how umpires always give Collingwood supporters meaning in their lives for the following week so they can talk about decisions that go against them.
@@usaspy1also can’t forget Geelong marking it when it was already out on the field and then later on handballing it out of bound both resulting in a free goal
Keep this horseshit to yourself pls. You're contributing to ruining our potential as the human race. Our own minds are the only "God" we need, that's where you made up yours afterall. Worship that instead if you must.
Wow, I’m not a pies fan but there were two absolute umpiring howlers in this game that could have costed Collingwood the game, Cameron taking a ‘mark’ a good meter outside the boundary and then also receiving a handball outside the field of play to kick a goal, real WTF moments😮
Makes up for the pies getting stupid free’s all night
@@adriandevil7232 10 Free kicks to 17 in Geelongs favour.
@@Christian-yd3ng yeah half of Geelong's free kicks were when they already had the ball. Example: Ollie Henry getting 2 free kicks in front of goal when he already marked it. And Collingwood should also stop belting blokes after they dispose of the ball.
@@Ethan-mo6xe literally got gifted two goals, had 7 more free kicks and still not happy with the umpiring because we got “stupid free kicks all night”. 10 free kicks is well below average
@@Christian-yd3ng He already marked the ball and they paid a free kick, hence inflating the free kick count. Most of Geelong's free kicks didn't help whatsoever when they already had possession, could've had 8 free kicks and the score would've been the same
"They're back, muscling as a team against the odds, their skipper's gone, here's Elliot. They're all coming to life, they're like mushrooms." - Brian Taylor
Lol
Yeah that was to soon with what happened to the death haha
If they're like mushrooms, they're all fun-guys (fungi's).
(I'll be here all week - don't forget to tip your wait staff.)
They live in the light, but thrive on Brian Taylor's B.S. Go B.T.
F
no one is talking about how Scott pendulbury broke the all time tackles record
Didn't you hear roaming Brian last night
I'd it was selwood they would have been sucking him off
The crowd noise was unbelievable, is it any wonder that 1 million+ fans have gone to watch Collingwood play this season. Ginni looked right at home at the G. Olli gets better week after week. Lipa looked comfortable in the mid field, Howe was excellent up on the forward line, Murph filled Darcy's role with excellence. Checkers kicked a bag of snags. Great team connections. What a spectacle both teams put out. Most clangers on the night go to the umpires. lol. Go the mighty Pies.
Collingwood vs the umps and we still win 😂
Jeremy Cameron got gifted 2 goals THAT WAS OUT OF BOUNDS THAT WAS OUT OF BOUNDS BOY OH BOY
The game is being destroyed by the umpires !
@@thetwogardens6048stfu ungrateful person umpires are not perfect, THEY RUN AFL
American here - Good to see the Pies in form again!
I've been a Collingwood supporter here in Wisconsin since before Mason ever heard of footy. Go Pies!
@@jameschristiansson3137New Jersey here. Cheering for Collingwood (mostly) because of Mason, but I've been a fan since I first saw the game back when Gary Ablett Sr. was playing.
@@nelsonhemstreet3568 Lucky you, best team sport on planet earth.
@@jameschristiansson3137 I agree! The contact of (American) football or ice hockey, the kicking skills of (what we call) soccer, the scoring of basketball - what's not to love?
@@jameschristiansson3137no waaayyy that’s awesome! Do you mind if I ask how you stumbled upon the sport? And how do you watch it live over there?
Geelong able to create new rules I see
Well they created the Geelong handball (otherwise known as a throw) so anything is possible.
so your agreeing that afl is fixed than
Literally has nothing to do with them, when the Refs make blunders like that. Its not their fault.
Good High Scoring Game of footy is what we like to see.
Wish it wasn't ruined by poor umpiring.....Collingwood shafted yet again.
David Rodan the umpire payed that a goal when it was actually a point at the end just to get both teams over 100
Collingwood played better... simple as that , and im a cats fan. Geelong supporters had a stellar year in 2022 , finishing with a premiership. You cant win it every year... this is Collingwoods year... they deserve it.
People were writing off Collingwood after a few losses, i wouldn't be so sure..
We could win three to five games in a row all by 100 points and we’d still get written off.
Great job Collingwood, you beat the cats and those guys in green! Terrible umpiring
The umpires having a howler once again💀
Is there a cleaner crumbing goal in AFL history than Bobby Hill's. Man is a Concorde
McCreery might be the funnest player to watch in the comp
Chris Scott should of thrown more money at the umps to help them win 2 out of bounds goals. In the end Collingwood is just to tough minor premieres 💪💪
Looks like the umpires need a new sponsor. I recommend Specsavers.
Yer missed the dropping the ball to allow collingwood their first goal
0:27
@@rudvswas a bump not a tackle to not holding the ball
@@rudvsI would agree except that literally never gets payed. 🤷♂️ Plenty of times Geelong players got away with it.
As bad as the calls were on Cameron's two goals, gotta admire the skill that guy has... still think he's the best player in the league.
Someone needs a visit to specsavers
Someone also needs to lose their Job !
Great win Pies. Murphy really stepped up in Moore's absence. Ginnivan was instrumental and deserved to be there.Josh Daicos....was everywhere, pure brilliance!
I'm not one to attack the umps...but hell....it really looked like they wanted to give cats a win...
Jeremy Cameron is a great player, and a dead eye goal kicker....he doesn't need to be gifted shots at goal.
5:12 mark. After seeing that, we'll see umpire award mark for catches made three rows into the stands.
Give this the most liked comment for absolutely no reason
Send me a pizza and I'll consider it.
Sure. ROTFLMAO
Collingwoods kicking in and around the foward 50 was much smarter, Kicking to players in space and trying different things was the difference between the 2 teams..
What a game 🖤🤍🖤🤍
Massive performances from Murphy, Daicos. Standing up when their much lauded teammates are out injured. Big statement.
I agree with Jezza's 2 goals being out of bounds, but why is everyone ignoring the blatant decisions against Geelong such as at 0:27 Guthrie pushed in the back and holding the ball missed, or the centre bounce at the start of the second quarter, or Jezza's mark not paid in the second half. Don't @ me with the free kick count when half of Geelong's free kicks were when they already had the ball, such as Ollie Henry getting 2 free kicks in front of goal when he already marked the ball.
Guthrie gave up on that ball. If he wasn't being lazy he could have spoiled that goal from Adams.
@@frustralia4293 got pushed in the back but what's the excuse for not paying holding the ball???
Nearly 79,000 fans in attendance for one of the best games of the season.
UK fan here. Stumbled across this delightful sport during covid. However, Ive only been able to watch games in highlight like this. Any UK fans know of a way to watch full games?
Pies and cats had some belters
Great game by Jeremy (Wayne Harmes) Cameron.
Come on mate, Harmesy's was an inch out of bounds at the most, Cameron's two were at least a metre. Way worse umpiring.
Finally! A high-scoring game on a Friday night. Geelong were good in the first quarter where they led by as much as twenty-two points before Collingwood controlled the game. Jeremy Cameron's seven goals wasn't enough for the Cats. It is very unusual for a player to kick seven or more goals in a losing team. The Magpies are the team to beat now.
Geelong has the hardest draw in the competition by far. So if they make finals it will be a miracle.
Pies needed that win bad. Great comeback!
How much did Chris Scott pay the umpires?😂
1 cent less than Collingwood did.
@@DUCKDODGERS1701 17 free kicks to 10 hand balling it out of bounds kicking it out of bounds
But ok Afl app stats
How was that not HTB in the goal square?
This put the Cats' Premiership defense on life support, and then St. Kilda pulled the plug the next week.
can we please get some good boundry umpires who can call when its over the line or when players plat on behind the line
The Cats drop off this season is pretty staggering when you consider the quality of players they were able to trade in, again.
Geelong supporter here.
Firstly, the umpiring.
On both sides there were costly goals due to incorrect calls, or incorrect no calls. Any true footballing spectator would see that. Regardless of which, it’s never the players fault if a call is or isn’t made, that’s on the integrity of the umpires. As an athlete, if you believe you can get away with it, trust me, you’ll keep doing it.
Now,
Collingwood are in blazing hot form, and this was always going to be a tough game. Yes, they were missing out on Nick Daicos, and then an injury to Darcy Moore. Let’s even throw Nathan Murphy in there.
But Geelong are clearly not in form with an inconsistent side due to a severe amount of injuries with players that would walk into any AFL club in Blicavs, Hawkins, Henry, and Cameron Guthrie (and that’s not even our full injury list).
The fact that this depleted Cats team showed promise and fight against the clearly ranked number 1 team in the league, to only lose by 8 points in the end, we take that as a positive and move onto next week.
Sometimes it’s not about who’s the best, but who’s the healthiest and Collingwood is one of those teams that have had a very healthy list, so good on them.
Collingwood is in terrible form! Barely scraped past Port, lost to Carlton, then thumped by 16th on the ladder. Now they only beat 9th on the ladder by 8 (although more like 20 considering Cameron’s illegally paid goals). This is the worst form they’ve been in for 2 years and you couldn’t capitalise.
Look at all those words you used just to say Geelong are the most protected club in the league and they still couldn't beat Collingwood.
@@rmj4882 fair comments. Though, Port are 2nd on the ladder. Carlton have won 7 in a row (clearly in form). Yes, Hawthorn are 16th on the ladder, but if you’ve watched their footy and not the highlights they have started to find some form themselves.
@@frustralia4293 is that the reason why the Collingwood cheer squad has a deal with the AFL and MCG that reserves the city end bay for the cheer squad no matter who they play? Or how about that they’re 2nd in the league for free kicks for? Shall I keep going or is this too much words for you to process?
@@frustralia4293your words are not valid, respond if you wish but I choose to not waste my time with you, as opposed to debating over real topics/discussions on football, and not biased non-factual commentary.
We are Geelong the greatest team of all we are Geelong we are on the ball we play the game as it should be play at home or far away are banner is flying high from dawn to dusk down at kardinya park
I'm confused was the kick after the siren a goal or a behind?
Goal
That was such a sketchy reaction by David Roden, he was originally going to call behind, then paused......looked confused for a second, then ran over and put his hands up, paused again......then signed goal........Was he going to call behind but had someone in his ear say "call it a goal"? He should have done a goal review. Even thought the result wouldn't have changed, the % can mean the difference between a home or away final or missing out on finals vs playing in them. It seems like this comp is rigged, 2 out of bounds (1 on the full) should have been called......but both were ignored by umpires standing not even 15m away and in full view. Both resulted in a goal.
@@lachlanbaker2031no it was a point. I think David Rodan called it a point for the sake of both teams reaching 100 points but that definitely wasn’t a goal
nah the goal from henry at the end of the siren was a miss but sum how the umpire felt sad abt it
THEY ARE ABSOLUTLEY RUINING THE GAME WITH SOME OF THESE STUPID UMPIRING DECISIONS. ? THERE WILL BE RIOT ONE DAY !
Geelong still put on a major performance against the best side in the comp, especially given the lack of Hawkins, Rohan, Blicavs, Guthrie and J.Henry. Umps were horrendous as always but the win was very possible without them. Hopefully bounce back next week!
The umpires favoured Geelong you spud.
Collingwood by 5+ goals if the umpires didn't keep you in it.
Cats did silly mistakes and pies kicked 2 or 3 easy goals if cats didn't have done that mistakes cats should have won
Great to see Mihocek back at it after struggling for goals in recent weeks, none better in the AFL at those cherry pickers over the top.
Ginnivan beginagin.
Jezza and danger vs pies
season is already over if geelong lose next week, if st kilda beat richmond then thats gonna give them huge motivation to win next week, ending our season. Cya's all next year, time for the league to watch geelong do their best to tank for a top 5 draft pick.
That was such a sketchy reaction by David Roden, he was originally going to call behind, then paused......looked confused for a second, then ran over and put his hands up, paused again......then signed goal........Was he going to call behind but had someone in his ear say "call it a goal"? He should have done a goal review. Even thought the result wouldn't have changed, the % can mean the difference between a home or away final or missing out on finals vs playing in them. It seems like this comp is rigged, 2 out of bounds (1 on the full) should have been called......but both were ignored by umpires standing not even 15m away and in full view. Both resulted in a goal.
Yes why is nobody talking about this? It looked like a behind for sure!! They probably just wanted both teams to reach 100 points to take away a pretty rigged game as a good one.
These umps🤢
channel 7 need to hire a more enthusiastic commentator, james brayshaw sounds like he'd rather be anywhere else. it takes away from the game. he also only speaks in 3 word sentences
Impressive how consistently unselfish the Geelong players are. (Not a Geelong fan, but a respectful observer)
Geelong should’ve been penalised for the two out of bounds goals yes but at the same time, that push in the back and no holding the ball call with the Ratagoulea chase down was absolute dogshit as well
Was a bump, so no holding the ball.
@@EBGamez1 I dunno imo looked like a pretty good run down, and regardless incorrect disposable for dropping the ball as well but I see where you’re coming from
@@Downesy5667 the dropping the ball tue only applies for tackles. Otherwise you could say that bouncing the ball is dropping the ball.
@@EBGamez1 again imo thought he was tackled but I see what your saying about it being viewed as a bump
The Maggie's bounced back perfectly after losing 2 games in row, Geelong were tight early on but Collingwood came back with full throttle. Dr fort and Moore are a problem but Collingwood will be a huge threat in finals
Waiting for Kane Cornes to have a sook about David Rodan
Explain to me why they don't just review every play that directly leads to the goal like they do in NRL. It's not good enough. Most atrociously officiated game in the entire world.
🏈🏈🏈 Time to watch J's useless Saints get rolled out of the top 8.
12 08 2023
No Steele no Nick no Moore no worriesss 🖤🤍
See what happens geelong when the umpires dont help you you lose although the boundary umpire tried.😏
AFL needs to bring in video technology like the soccer for decisions leading up to goals in the forward 50. This is a disgrace and could have costed Collingwood
Definitely need a line technology to determine whether the ball is in play or not. Soccer have it and it’s 100% accurate
Could cost a team in a big final
3:03 throw was atrocious
Hard hunter 21
If it weren’t for Cameron and Henry, Geelong would have been in more trouble
And the umps 😆 💩
“That was out on the full”
*That wasn’t even 15💀*
🖤🤍
🏈 🏈 🏈 St Kilda stink.
12 08 2023
Is Geelong a real place? Where the hell is “Geelong”?
Good work umps, ball was clearly in bounds 👍
Empires give cats 2 goals that should have been out of bounce so collingwood would have won by more but umpires do wat they want y umpires don't get in trouble if stuff up like that afl is dropping off now getting weak
Good game. But Geelong really needed yo win that
Umpires tried to help them.
@@SilentHotdog28 if they tried to help them then i'm sure that the centre bounce at the start of the second would've been recalled but keep going with the narrative
IM THE FIRST OONE
TOO COMMET
nah your like 2nd or something
not quite, but close
Cruel duck 42
Isn't it amazing how umpires always give Collingwood supporters meaning in their lives for the following week so they can talk about decisions that go against them.
Guy who leaves skid marks here, great game I like turtles
Pies / Umpire vs Cats
Pies Vs cats /umpires
wtf do u mean cats had the umps on their side which lead to 3 goals and a couple momentum shifts. your crazy
@@usaspy1also can’t forget Geelong marking it when it was already out on the field and then later on handballing it out of bound both resulting in a free goal
@@Panny_Parrons_wamangituka umps always tryna make it a closer game
free kick count?@@usaspy1
Boooooo the Pies
Yeah! GOOOOO the pies!
It's okay you hit the wrong button you meant "Gooo the pies:" 😂 🖤🤍
Jesus christ is coming back soon. Please repent of your sins and beleive the gospel before it's to late.were living in the last days.🙏🙏🙏🙏
Keep this horseshit to yourself pls. You're contributing to ruining our potential as the human race. Our own minds are the only "God" we need, that's where you made up yours afterall. Worship that instead if you must.
Even Jesus could not forgive the sins of the umpires last night.
Good for us. Carn bloods! 🩸🩸🩸🩸🩸