@@ChrisPropfeMusicallyObsessed Make sure to familiarize yourself with DAG NASTY "Can I Say" both musically & lyrically! Lyrically, it's the absolute epitome of straightedge hardcorepunk! Even though I'm not straightedge, every single lyric on that record speaks to me. Even now, at age 49!
DYS was militant straightedge, DAG NASTY a little less so. Neither Brian Baker nor Dave Smalley is straightedge anymore, though Smalley still sports his tattoo and never covered it. A lot of people are bummed when their heroes lose their edge, but it's never made a difference to me. All in all, I think straightedge is a positive thing and plays a prominent role in punk rock and hardcore history.
Smalley was in DYS early in the 80s. Legendary Boston straightedge hardcore! Then DAG NASTY and recorded the best album in the world, "Can I Say." Then he joined all.
Great vid! I'm a huge Descendents/All fan. Bill Stevenson is one of the best rock drummers of all time. I was hoping Pummel would give them the fame they deserved.
You're doing a massive public service to the world exposing folks to All/Descendents that may not have been before! Thanks! Every iteration of All holds a special place in my heart. I remember first hearing Just Perfect from Allroy Sez... and I said to myself and to other people... this sound is going to be huge, and I mistakenly thought that All would be the ones to take the sound to the masses. Turns out Green Day were the ones to grab the ball and run with it. Great video. Cheers.
I like all! Not a hardcore fan but I do have the first three chad price albums. I’m gonna check out your favs. A million bucks is one of my favorite songs of all time by any band!!!!
very nice. I have all the lps of descendents in sst and of All in cruz records. Chris you're doing very good presenting All cause some believe that green day first played pop punk!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! the truth is Descendents are the kings of the so called pop punk although Descendents are true punk comparing to the silly punk of todays
The All Great Hitz album is one of my favorites, because they went back and remixed/remastered all the early stuff and they sound SO much better. Especially Just Perfect.
Dave Smalley went to form DBL but Dag Nasty was a one off thing that happened when Brian Baker was in LA ( before Bad Religion ) but Dave Smalley had already been in Dag Nasty. Also, when Pummel came out Green Day and the Offspring were mainstream, Blink was still unknown. Pummel did, indeed, did a lot for them, when the advance money from Interscope they built their own studio in Ft Collins.
@@vadermasktruth Yes , obviously. I re read my message years later and it's kinda miswritten. What I meant is that Dag Nasty Four on the floor was a one off thing at the time, Dave was in DBL and Brian in BR. Cheers mate!
So the members of the Descendants formed the band All as well? Am I understanding correctly? I've never really listened to either group but I guess now I have to! All the best!
Yes. The Descendents and ALL are basically the same band just with different lead singers. The crazy thing is that the Descendents have an album called ALL. Lol.
Thank you!! Me ha encantado el video. ALL/Reynolds!!
Thank you for watching!
ALL is one of my all-time favorite hardcorepunk bands!
Such a great band. I also love Scott Reynolds post ALL bands too!
@@ChrisPropfeMusicallyObsessed Make sure to familiarize yourself with DAG NASTY "Can I Say" both musically & lyrically! Lyrically, it's the absolute epitome of straightedge hardcorepunk! Even though I'm not straightedge, every single lyric on that record speaks to me. Even now, at age 49!
DYS was militant straightedge, DAG NASTY a little less so. Neither Brian Baker nor Dave Smalley is straightedge anymore, though Smalley still sports his tattoo and never covered it. A lot of people are bummed when their heroes lose their edge, but it's never made a difference to me. All in all, I think straightedge is a positive thing and plays a prominent role in punk rock and hardcore history.
Dave Smalley is also known through his Down By Law band
I love Down By Law!
Smalley was in DYS early in the 80s. Legendary Boston straightedge hardcore! Then DAG NASTY and recorded the best album in the world, "Can I Say." Then he joined all.
Great vid! I'm a huge Descendents/All fan. Bill Stevenson is one of the best rock drummers of all time. I was hoping Pummel would give them the fame they deserved.
I agree! All got lost in the Green Day ocean even though All and the Descendents started the whole genre.
@@ChrisPropfeMusicallyObsessed Happy they were on epitaph during that time, I found them through the Punk O Rama stuff. :^)
I remember now....Scott Reynolds and the Steaming Beast was released with members of The Flaming Lips
You're doing a massive public service to the world exposing folks to All/Descendents that may not have been before! Thanks! Every iteration of All holds a special place in my heart. I remember first hearing Just Perfect from Allroy Sez... and I said to myself and to other people... this sound is going to be huge, and I mistakenly thought that All would be the ones to take the sound to the masses. Turns out Green Day were the ones to grab the ball and run with it. Great video. Cheers.
Thank you!!!! I have always loved ALL! She’s My Ex is one of my favorites. I still follow Scott Reynolds solo stuff too!
I like all! Not a hardcore fan but I do have the first three chad price albums. I’m gonna check out your favs. A million bucks is one of my favorite songs of all time by any band!!!!
Love it!!!! Such a great band!!!
very nice. I have all the lps of descendents in sst and of All in cruz records. Chris you're doing very good presenting All cause some believe that green day first played pop punk!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! the truth is Descendents are the kings of the so called pop punk although Descendents are true punk comparing to the silly punk of todays
Descendents were the originators!!!!
@@ChrisPropfeMusicallyObsessed I would also add the undertones from uk
Buenísimo video.
ALL es una de mis bandas favoritas y Allroy's Revenge es el album que mas me gusta.
Saludos desde Monte Grande, Argentina!
ALL!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
es su mejor album,me gustan todos,pero con scott reynolds fue su mejor epoca
My fave by All is "Breaking Things" heavy yeah and "Pummel" (this is for brokenhearted!!!!)lol
Breaking Things is becoming a favorite of mine too!
The All Great Hitz album is one of my favorites, because they went back and remixed/remastered all the early stuff and they sound SO much better. Especially Just Perfect.
I like the remixes and remasters as well! ALL rules!
Dave Smalley went to form DBL but Dag Nasty was a one off thing that happened when Brian Baker was in LA ( before Bad Religion ) but Dave Smalley had already been in Dag Nasty. Also, when Pummel came out Green Day and the Offspring were mainstream, Blink was still unknown. Pummel did, indeed, did a lot for them, when the advance money from Interscope they built their own studio in Ft Collins.
Thanks for the info brother! I love ALL and the ALL Family!
You're a little wrong. Smalley was in DAG NASTY in the early 80s. "Minority of One" that you're thinking of was record decades later.
@@vadermasktruth Yes , obviously. I re read my message years later and it's kinda miswritten. What I meant is that Dag Nasty Four on the floor was a one off thing at the time, Dave was in DBL and Brian in BR. Cheers mate!
So the members of the Descendants formed the band All as well? Am I understanding correctly? I've never really listened to either group but I guess now I have to! All the best!
Yes. The Descendents and ALL are basically the same band just with different lead singers. The crazy thing is that the Descendents have an album called ALL. Lol.
steve and karl are from a cool band called massacre guys check them out
I will check them out!!! Thank you!
7:27 Karl sang one, too: Guitar Case!
Yesss! Forgot about that!
I always like Descendents better but All have some amazing song over their career Just Perfect is well, Just Perfect.
Best musicianship though, it's amazing...that rhythm section!
I love the Descendents too but Scott Reynolds voice is killer! Not to mention his songwriting too...
Scary Sad
Yessss!
That song is a monument
tonyall- Karl sang a song (guitar case)
Yess!
I love ALL. Im more of a Chad Price fan. I got into the band when about the time “Pummel” came out.
Chad rules and Pummel is a kick ass album!