This is the best version I've heard. George was kindness, happiness, humour, intelligence and spirituality personified. Hari Om 🕉 Jaya Sri Krishna 🙏🏼 🌈 🕉
Love the chanting of Dehra Dun. Thank goodness songs by Harrison like Dehra Dun and Old Browne Shoe can be enjoyed on their own merits. Maybe the Beatles should have made more albums.
Yeah, no question. This is a keeper. Smart, effective, supportive of the vocal, and restrained. Well done. It's truly time for Dhani to seek out the very best of these youtube tributes, and give us an album of his fathers lost songs using ideas from arrangements such as this. Given an equal amount of subtlety and empathy for the songs, Dhani's versions could make for a smash album and truly launch his career as a performer.
When this album came out i was not old enough mentally to hear it it took 30 years to finally get to a place where i could understand hari chresna George
I love when these demos that were never properly produced by artists get the love they need thanks to fans! I would love to see you do similar magic to some of John’s demos like You Saved My Soul, Sally and Billy, One of the Boys, Friend of Dorothy’s, Etc etc
Related note : so weird in Peter Jackson’s Get Back when he used a snippet of George from 1994 singing this while sitting with Paul and Ringo, its from the Anthology documentary when they’re talking about writing songs in India. Same clip. It’s played up as being a vintage clip in Get Back.
You are indeed the Walrus, excellent work my Beatles friend, you wouldn't be able to have a crack at their 1967 song Carnival of Light, adding some spacey slide guitar perhaps. Its screaming out for a revisit /remix ;-D
Love these so much. Your Mother Devine video gets consistent play here in my house, adding this to the list as well. Would love to know more about your thought process and arranging work!
I first try to find the demo's tempo and chord structure. I then cut up the demo WAV according to choruses and verses. Then I basically strum the acoustic thru that structure, but just with George's vocal and the metronome. Then I add either real or program drums, with appropriate drum fills or what have you. Then I add everything else: more acoustics, electrics, keyboards, bass, percussion, vocals. I try to build the tune up, then have a break, then an ending of some sort. I must have had the basic Beatles/harrison song structure burned in my brain, because I really don't find it hard to do. Plus I've recorded tons of my own stuff, so I have lots of experience with putting together a tune. Probably the funnest part is singing harmonies with George's vocal. And trying to do lead guitar, especially slide. It feels spooky when I listen back to it sometimes. I hope the Harrison's don't mind these...I'm not looking to profit from them. Thanks for the interest!
Walrusz.. your tracks are amazing!... ever thought about approaching the Harrison estate to do something formal with them? The tracks really are that good!
I had a friend hand deliver a letter to Friar Park a few years ago...just asking what Olivia and Dhani thought of my work, and inform them that I've never tried to profit from the re-worked tunes...but never got a reply. I would hope Dhani might have clicked on one of my versions somewhere along the way...still would be thrilled to know if he gave them a listen!
@@walrusz shame, seems such a natural fit, and there's good imagination in the arrangements .. not just a copy of Jeff Lynne's approach (which I admire too). Imagine if you had access to the original source material. Can't really imagine more finished viable versions than what you've produced. Their / our loss I suppose. Much respect
You did great on this one, makes it sound more like a song on ATMP(and this song was an outtake from that album). I think you told me you were gonna do going down to golders green next, right?
Great idea! Another suggestion if you haven't already considered it, Sour Milk Sea from the White album 50th anniversary package (there's an outfake out there from years ago using the Jackie Lomax backing track, but it has terrible sound quality).
Another job well done, Walrusz. Did you know your version of Harrison's Fear of Flying was one of my most played tracks this year (I downloaded it onto itunes -- I hope you don't mind). I hope you continue this worthy cause. I recommended one for you earlier this year, and it seemed like a good choice, but for the life of me I can no longer recall what it was. Should you continue forward, any thoughts as to what's next?
@@walrusz I think Dear John or India, India would be neat. The audio quality isn't as good as George's demos, though. ua-cam.com/video/FWnR_xOCqJE/v-deo.html ua-cam.com/video/4JLQvEsHXJo/v-deo.html
Thanks for your kind words. I use an old Adobe Audition program, a FirePod 8 channel interface, a Focusrite preamp, a line 6 guitar pod, a Yamaha p-200 keyboard, various electric guitars and acoustics and a few other things.
@@walrusz I used old Nero 6 wave editor to make something cohesive out of that old "When Every Song Is Sung" demo. It made more sense as a complete song, though of course could do nothing about sound quality....
Yes I did all the backing....hmmm... Now and then has been done to multiple times really well... Don't think I could do anything better than I've already heard.... Thanks so much for your kind comment.
Thats why they chose more Lennon-McCartney songs…this is nothing of that kind. This is a NORMAL. Not the work of a genius like Let it Be, Lady Madonna or Two of us.
Finally after all the versions out there, this is the Best sounding complete song by George.
Thank you
Well...this is George 🙏 . Thid is one of those inner Masterpieces He wrote and used to play. All is in our within.
Love ♥️ ♥️ ♥️
This is the best version I've heard. George was kindness, happiness, humour, intelligence and spirituality personified. Hari Om 🕉 Jaya Sri Krishna 🙏🏼 🌈 🕉
Love the chanting of Dehra Dun. Thank goodness songs by Harrison like Dehra Dun and Old Browne Shoe can be enjoyed on their own merits. Maybe the Beatles should have made more albums.
Wonderfull! Great George Song!
Thanks Luigi
Yeah, no question. This is a keeper. Smart, effective, supportive of the vocal, and restrained. Well done. It's truly time for Dhani to seek out the very best of these youtube tributes, and give us an album of his fathers lost songs using ideas from arrangements such as this.
Given an equal amount of subtlety and empathy for the songs, Dhani's versions could make for a smash album and truly launch his career as a performer.
Thanks
💯 yes
Dehra Dun is a village half way from Delhi to Rishekesh...Thank you George, Hare Krsna.
Excellent - So DeraDun is the liminal "middle space" where one transitions from Nirvana back to the mundane world, and vice-versa.
When this album came out i was not old enough mentally to hear it it took 30 years to finally get to a place where i could understand hari chresna George
Oh, how I miss him!
This, and your “Cosmic Empire” are like the best records I’ve heard in decades.
Thanks!
Único, sublime,nadie como el puede expresar tanto en una canción ,su Voz es maravillosa y cálida y me llena de paz mi Alma❤George forever❤❤
Beautifully done with a lot of respect.
I study the life and work of George Harrison since 1971.
I love when these demos that were never properly produced by artists get the love they need thanks to fans! I would love to see you do similar magic to some of John’s demos like You Saved My Soul, Sally and Billy, One of the Boys, Friend of Dorothy’s, Etc etc
wow!! well done! sounds absolutely awesome.... totally ATMP vibe!
Thanks themastroiannis!
This sounds like something that would be on All Things Must Pass or Living in the Material World.
All Things Must Pass outtake!
.. Should of put it on material world with, live for you.. such a massive disappointment after atmp
There are some exquisite pictures of George. Thank you. xx
Related note : so weird in Peter Jackson’s Get Back when he used a snippet of George from 1994 singing this while sitting with Paul and Ringo, its from the Anthology documentary when they’re talking about writing songs in India. Same clip. It’s played up as being a vintage clip in Get Back.
Good job putting this together as a Harrison fan I really appreciate it keep doing what you doing
Thanks Cynthia...I appreciate your comments!
Thank you for getting back to me on my comment I appreciate it I guess George fans are very thoughtful of course
You are so talented. You have captured the sound brillianty, and your slide guitar is perfect. I love it!
Tout simolement geni en paix avec lui et les autres a 62 ans tu es encore mon model merci pr tout je t'aime apres la vie
Repose en paix
How great was George
Great backing which respects George and his song! Thanks for being creative.
Thank you!
Great photos❤
Awesome!
Que versión tan hermosa, muy bien lograda. Gracias por tu trabajo.
Beautifully done my friend
Thanks Orton!
You are indeed the Walrus, excellent work my Beatles friend, you wouldn't be able to have a crack at their 1967 song Carnival of Light, adding some spacey slide guitar perhaps. Its screaming out for a revisit /remix ;-D
Thanks for your comments Stan! btw if you ever find a link to the REAL "Carnival of Light", please send it along!
this is so good
Amazing. Congratz!!t
Amazing! Shit, looks like I'll have to re-do my "Nowhere To Go" fantasy CD again. Bah! Thank you so much for this gift.
Oh yeaaaah you're back! This is fantastic
Thanks Francesco!
Thank you so much 😊
Magnificent.
Amazing work man!
Brilliant you should be in the new all things must pass 50 th anniversary album , with your versions
Amazing. Congratz!!
Love these so much. Your Mother Devine video gets consistent play here in my house, adding this to the list as well. Would love to know more about your thought process and arranging work!
I first try to find the demo's tempo and chord structure. I then cut up the demo WAV according to choruses and verses. Then I basically strum the acoustic thru that structure, but just with George's vocal and the metronome. Then I add either real or program drums, with appropriate drum fills or what have you. Then I add everything else: more acoustics, electrics, keyboards, bass, percussion, vocals. I try to build the tune up, then have a break, then an ending of some sort. I must have had the basic Beatles/harrison song structure burned in my brain, because I really don't find it hard to do. Plus I've recorded tons of my own stuff, so I have lots of experience with putting together a tune. Probably the funnest part is singing harmonies with George's vocal. And trying to do lead guitar, especially slide. It feels spooky when I listen back to it sometimes. I hope the Harrison's don't mind these...I'm not looking to profit from them. Thanks for the interest!
Niiice dude. I really loved Fear of Flying
This is terrific
It wasn't on the white album , what a pity!
Great entanterer for us to hear
That's Amazing 🤟
Hare Krishna
So beautiful, thank you for this and Cosmic Empire🥰❤💕. Where did you find them a few years ago?
Somewhere online...can't remember!
Fucking phenomenal
Walrusz.. your tracks are amazing!... ever thought about approaching the Harrison estate to do something formal with them? The tracks really are that good!
I had a friend hand deliver a letter to Friar Park a few years ago...just asking what Olivia and Dhani thought of my work, and inform them that I've never tried to profit from the re-worked tunes...but never got a reply. I would hope Dhani might have clicked on one of my versions somewhere along the way...still would be thrilled to know if he gave them a listen!
@@walrusz shame, seems such a natural fit, and there's good imagination in the arrangements .. not just a copy of Jeff Lynne's approach (which I admire too). Imagine if you had access to the original source material. Can't really imagine more finished viable versions than what you've produced. Their / our loss I suppose. Much respect
@@lewgoram Thanks Lew, your comments are much appreciated!
George would have loved your work thats all that matters!@@walrusz
@@marksimons9359 thanks Mark!
If you ever need any synth hit me up!
Great job!
Thanks Sean...I'll keep that in mind!
Hare Krishna Hare krishna Krishna krishna hare hare Hare Rama Hare Rama Rama Rama Hare Hare!@@😂🎉😢😮😅😊2024🤔👧👨👩🤩🤗😶☺😚😗
Very nice, just a little correction with the title, it's Dehra Dun :)
oooops
You did great on this one, makes it sound more like a song on ATMP(and this song was an outtake from that album). I think you told me you were gonna do going down to golders green next, right?
Maybe Relkinstein!
Great idea! Another suggestion if you haven't already considered it, Sour Milk Sea from the White album 50th anniversary package (there's an outfake out there from years ago using the Jackie Lomax backing track, but it has terrible sound quality).
Another job well done, Walrusz. Did you know your version of Harrison's Fear of Flying was one of my most played tracks this year (I downloaded it onto itunes -- I hope you don't mind). I hope you continue this worthy cause. I recommended one for you earlier this year, and it seemed like a good choice, but for the life of me I can no longer recall what it was. Should you continue forward, any thoughts as to what's next?
Thanks Geo., I think there isn't much more out there to try...it's been fun though!
Have you ever considered doing this to any of John's demos?
Any particular suggestion?
@@walrusz I think Dear John or India, India would be neat. The audio quality isn't as good as George's demos, though.
ua-cam.com/video/FWnR_xOCqJE/v-deo.html
ua-cam.com/video/4JLQvEsHXJo/v-deo.html
@@DrMarvello82 Thanks Dr. Marvello...I'll look into it. And...are you by any chance a Klaatu fan?
@@walrusz Yes, I am! They're one of my favorite bands
Incredible. How is your studio set up? I'd love to get into producing like this, how do you recommend to start?
Thanks for your kind words. I use an old Adobe Audition program, a FirePod 8 channel interface, a Focusrite preamp, a line 6 guitar pod, a Yamaha p-200 keyboard, various electric guitars and acoustics and a few other things.
@@walrusz I used old Nero 6 wave editor to make something cohesive out of that old "When Every Song Is Sung" demo. It made more sense as a complete song, though of course could do nothing about sound quality....
if god want's to show us his humor, he gives us a George, a John, a Paul and a Ringo
Amazing,,,,Please do Now and then,,,did you do all the backing........??
Yes I did all the backing....hmmm... Now and then has been done to multiple times really well... Don't think I could do anything better than I've already heard.... Thanks so much for your kind comment.
When did George record this song?
Sometime in 1970
his guitar singing high
@0:29 ❤
Awesome 1:27 1:30
He looks like Rasputin in the thumbnail wth
Thats why they chose more Lennon-McCartney songs…this is nothing of that kind. This is a NORMAL. Not the work of a genius like Let it Be, Lady Madonna or Two of us.