1. Shia & Sunni: Let's be real? | Night 1 | Sayed Ammar Nakshawani | Holy Ramadan 2024 | 1445
Вставка
- Опубліковано 7 сер 2024
- Imam Hussein TV 3 Presents this Holy Month of Ramadan:
‘Shia and Sunni: Rapprochement & Conflict’
An exclusive lecture series with the world-renowned Dr. Sayed Ammar Nakshawani
Dr. Sayed Ammar will provide an insight into some of the core topics which affect our beliefs, theology and jurisprudential system whilst also analysing the literature and viewpoints of scholars from other sects in the religion of Islam
0:00 Promo Ramadan Transmission's
6:12 Promoting Unity and Understanding: Addressing Misconceptions in the Shia-Sunni Dialogue
12:10 Misconceptions on Shia Thoughts
20:28 Different Sects of Sunnis
26:40 Different Reading of the Religion of Islam
32:50 Why do the Shia Differ on the Companions
35:56 Shia and Sunni coming Uniting is Very Difficult
41:47 Prophet had Appointed Ali as Successor
44:13 Thinking Negatively About the Shia
52:19 (TALBIS IBLIS) Deceit of Iblis
54:58 Dialogues and Debate
1:03:20 Imam Hussain Charity (IHC)
Join us every night for the first 22 nights of Holy Ramadan, starting at 19:30 U.K. exclusively on Imam Hussein TV 3
Like, follow and subscribe to Imam Hussein TV’s official UA-cam channel here: ua-cam.com/users/imamhuss...
Support Imam Hussein TV: www.imamhussein3.tv/donate
Make sure you're following Imam Hussein TV for all the latest.
Facebook: / imamhusseintv3
Twitter: / imamhusseintv3
Instagram: / imamhusseintv3
UA-cam: / imamhussein3tv
Website: imamhussein3.tv
Telegram: t.me/imamhusseintv3
WhatsApp: wa.me/447939917163
Watch IHTV3 using the following methods:
• Website: imamhussein3.tv/live
• Android & iOS App: onelink.to/ihtv
• UA-cam: ua-cam.com/users/imamhuss...
• Download on Smart TV's: Samsung TV, LG TV & Android TV
• Also on: Apple TV, RoKu, Amazon Fire & CTV
Imam Hussein TV 1 (Persian) : bit.ly/2zcmtCv
Imam Hussein TV 2 (Arabic) : bit.ly/2TwiXvk
Imam Hussein TV 3 (English) : bit.ly/2vfClRT
Imam Hussein TV 4 (Urdu) : bit.ly/2DvXrRH
AlZahra (Turkish): bit.ly/2ORtYnl
Morning Baraka: bit.ly/2OvrN9Z
As a revert i have found that nearly everything ive heard about shia and my persian brothers to be lies. My journey lead me to learn from anywhere where there is knowledge. insha'Allah i may meet you one day and discuss a few things that i have questions on.
Mashallah I'm happy you don't let people impose their view on you
@@AhmadFakih123 the questions I have are not like those who are born into Muslim families. In my studies and research I have found many questions and I've looked to see if it's been discussed and it has not.
@@11shah if I let people influence me I would be still in error. Al haadi guided me to his Deen even though I come from a atheist family and live amongst those who hate Islam. I fear Allah SWT more than I do them, I love Allah more than I love myself.
Ask Akhi ask۔۔۔openly feel free to touch base
One question which is relevant to right now is about Ramadan. During the life of Muhammad they used the solar hijri calender (Persian). 60 years after his death the third caliph changed it to the Luna hijri calender. The lunar calendar doesn't work the months jump around. Ramadan was the scorched month deriving it's name from Ramada. The lunar calender would be a innovation and it has really big implications. I am fasting I am committed to doing it for Allah SWT but... Is it the correct month? The name of the month suggests otherwise.
If you do just a little bit of research you will see what I have said is true and it does back up the hadith of the prophecy that in the future Muslims would pray in the wrong times (5 times a day) and there will be an age of religious ignorance.
My search for truth, the same one that lead me to Allah SWT the creator. Has lead me to this question and many more. Some have brought answers like, Who should of been the caliph after his death, it should of been Ali. Also that the hadith was banned during his lifetime but written 200 years later. Outside of the 3 best generations after our beloved prophet.
Excellent lecture sayed Ammar 🧠 greetings from an Algerian 🇩🇿 Muslim Sunni Maliki 👋 and I wish a blessed Ramadan to you and all the Islamic Ouma 🌙 Unity and mutual Respect are the keys to our salvation ☝️
Yaaaa doooin it yaa dooin it yaaa naughty naughty
@Phoenix Ramadhan Mubarak elhi. Insha'Allah it is a blessed one for you and your family! Alhamdulillah!
Do you know what imam maliki said sbout shias?
@@sus527 what's your point?? I don't have to blind follow everything Malik said .. just because I follow his madhab
Salamun alaikum brother. Ramadhan Mubarak
What a great man. Loved his lectures for a long time. Syed was here in Birmingham last Ramadan hugged him many times. 😂 May Allah grant you a long life brother.
Ameen
These misconceptions about shias make me laugh.Haha. PROUD SHIAT ALI
That's what the people of kufa said before killing imam hussein they where so called shias of ALi remember that
@@MuhammedKus-iu7lsImam Hussain a.s was martyred by the orders of yazeed who was the son of muawiya who is loved too much by the Sunnis and the army lead against Him (a.s) leader was umar ibn saad who was son of a famous sahabi, the governor of kufa was appointed by yazeed whose father in the past had left being Shia of Ali a.s and joined the camp of muaviya. That governor had arrested many Shia leaders when Imam Hussain a.s was coming towards kufa…… I am sure like syed mentioned you haven’t even tried studying on your own but to come and type only the crap that has been fed to you
@@MuhammedKus-iu7ls 😂😂
@@MuhammedKus-iu7ls
The cursed criminals who killed Imam Hussain peace be upon him, were sons of the first criminal Ayousha😂
@@hassanturi518 You can't help them, they're just corrupt, mendacious and greedy, dumb as a post. Fridays in their temple so they can be seen, the rest of the week they hang around the railway station district and in the bars.
I have had my ups and downs with my opinions towards dear Dr Nakshwani, but I give it to him, he is the most proactive, growing, maturing, and, even entertaining 😅, speaker we have ever had in the English world. No matter what your opinion of him is, you have to concede, whether you hate him or love him, you'd choose listening to his lecture over anyone else's ;)
Agreed
The difference between ammar nakshawani and other salafi so called dawah guys are quite evident, adnan and his gang are indeed drowned in the depths of arrogance, Syed on one side wants people to learn and read but salafi gang on other side tries lies, dishonesty and force their opinion on others, I still remember how they mislead people about syed ammar nakshawani debate challenge, Syed made a challenge about shia sunni marriage and they portrayed it as if syed challenged everyone on every topic and then run away
6:30, The lecture starts from here.
tysm my dear brother in islam
I am a sunni, I was indoctrinated.... it is not that we are blind followers, I think like me many of us never get much chance to hear the other side. Hadees e saqlain opened my eyes. It is my understanding placing the importance of the ahlul bayt a.s. at their rightful place in terms of beliefs.
Well from what ive seen we shias are always trying ti tell our side but sunnis keep attacking us, calling us kaffir, literally creates new accounts to tag me in videos where they bash shias etc so no i would say a lot of sunnis are ignorant and arrogant..
You were indoctrinated? No, you’re being indoctrinated now. This guy is nothing more than a scumbag who wants to create disunity among Muslims. We Suni have never had an issue with the family of the profit and actually love the family of the profit more than these disgusting heretics do. What were you indoctrinated with? the message of our Lord? The message of our profit? You can’t be indoctrinated if Shia never existed during the time of the profit to begin with.
I’ve never clicked on a video so fast in my life
Really really looking forward to it. The first episode was a bang🔥
i am so excited about this playlist - thank you all for your work
We either live as brothers in faith or as equals in humanity, Shia schools of thought are beyond the imagination of the Intellectual! 💥
Welldone Syed Ammar for this series. Very nessessary to clear the air ❤
One of the best videos I have seen. Ramadan Kareem to my Muslim brothers and sisters!
Such a brilliant speaker ! I’m watching this with open heart and open mind!
Ive been raised as a Sunni but after learning about Shi'ism in depth, I can agree with Shias on many points. I agree with the Shia historically/politically and Ghadir. But not with the theology..
Excellent. As always. Mashallah. ❤
Aslm mashallah great knowledge I learn a lot may Allah bless you and the whole team .Ramadan Mubarak to you all ameen
Asalam Brothers and sisters and
Dr Sayid mashallah Humdullah may Allah swt reward .we must stop this conflict between Sunna Shia have open mind learn from each others look what is happening to Palastainian we need to have good understanding have strong foundation to stand with enemies with all Muslims in the world .who is helping Palastainian Yemon Lebanon and both are Shia ,Palastainian are Sunna
Subhan'Allah❤🤲
What a worthy watch !
Great topic 👍🏽MashAllah
Mashallah good work.
There is no greater misfortune for converts than to fall into the hands of dubious Sunnis.
What a great lecture
the clickbait of the century
bro i was waiting for muhammed hijab 🤣🤣🤣
ua-cam.com/video/PEPwCs1oOxU/v-deo.htmlsi=TTWm8wxADD3jtUIe
InshAllah
Hijab struggled to explain the hadith on his appearance on Piers Morgan's show, which sadly failed to successfully counter the debaters' accusations against our Holy Prophet.
Mashallah ❤
As a born Sunni, Prophet Muhammad saw never brought Sunni or Shii but only Islam. Ultimately, the Shii also prescribe and practice the Sunna. Elhamdulilah we are Muslims and we need to accept, embrace and love one another. I personally corroborate hadeeth through Sunni and Shii sources which allow me to discern what are firm hadeeth from two different sources. Moreover, I reject Ibn Taymiyah and Abdul Wahab. Madad ya Ale Bayt.
We all Muslims are one family and our enemies have confused us from our brother's and sister's to not Unite please Muslims wake up 🙏🤲☝️we are one family with love and peace ❤️ 🙏🤲☝️🌹
MashaAllah 🌹
It's not just our different viewpoints we should try to learn about but our prayers. Beautiful duas such as those in the Sahifat Sajjadiyah or Dua Kumail deserve to be known and loved by all Muslims. Let's share our good stuff with each other.
I don’t understand the picture put on the video with presence of Mohamad Hijab and then other Sunni speakers when I look up the lectures on UA-cam! I thought they would present in the lecture!
Brother. We Shias are the True followers of Islam and Ahlbayt. We dont need recognition from the followers of Umar and Abu Bakr.
You can be proud but never arrogant.
@@SPACEMAN.313He didn’t say anything arrogant, that is the truth. We require no sort of validation from anyone else
yes but as people try to criticize us we should try to defend ourselves and educate others on our islam and our core beliefs.
Yes, but the Prophet (sawa) told us to be united as Muslims. Unless you are going to make Takfir on all Sunni's then you need to treat them as your peers in Islam
We are not followers of abu bakkar or umar.
We are follower of Muhammad sm.
And we respect abu bakkar, ummar, osman and ali.
SHIA and proud!
Allah (SWT), Muhammad (PBUH), Ahlul Bayt (AS)
DR. AMMAR🥰🥰🥰
why Sayed Ammar is copying Mohamed Ali from JUMAH NIGHT 😫
Regarding the discussion in video that "we are in a digital age of information and knowledge" this doesn't mean every Sunni will go online and search for the truth..
There is a first step before that, which is forbidden to them, in MOST Sunni sects religious logic "research in islam" is termed as "haram", because the early munafiqeen feared this will lead to truth, thus a majority still abide by this rule.. so, without the first step, the journey will not start and they are in the ditch forever until they die, except just a rare dozen sunnis per year.
Other than this, the reasons are hatred, they are taught the shia killed Ahlulbait, were rebels or jews, and their madrasas and schools teach: Shia are kuffar, never read their books, befriend them and don't go to their majalis gatherings, shia are evil magicians originated from Jews etc...the half-religious sunnis think "our scholars are saying this, so it must be the truth".
And if you don't believe me, ask a bunch of sunnis some religious questions they will not know anything, I've heard absurd answers always, and they don't care, they say 'we know how to do wadhu, and salah, and some know Arabic to read the quran (without understanding or bothering the translation) they say this is sufficient and no research is needed, as Islam is perfect (I wonder why they conflict their own belief when they suddenly start believing in imam and say "imam" mahdi will redeem and bring the true values of Islam (it's clashing with their logic that their version of islam is already perfect).
Also, talking about 12th imam, suddenly they try to believe and love imam mahdi while not knowing anything about the other 11 imams or often disbelieving in them (rare lazy sunnis who attempt research know about the hadeeth of 12 imams, and their version of 11 imams are various personalities including Yazeed, Muaviah) UA-cam has some interesting and funny responses to this question when asked to "learned" sunni scholars.
May Allah[SWT] bless you and grant you the highest ranks of Jannah Syed.
Hat taa na haa 'anhu 'Umar. It should be a ring tone.
Thumbnail is deceiving
I think the whole lecture and upcoming ones are directed towards people like Mohammad Hijab who always talk about face on debates and think he can 'finish' shias. He does debate with ego and becomes very condescending and rude. Using big vocabulary does not mean you are right..
Very deceiving
@@Mzshy786 but then face him live. Instead of using his pic on thumbnail
To follow Holy Quran and Sunnah only
Why would you risk ur integrity by putting Mohammad Hijab for click bait?
I want to see Ammar Nakshwani sir with "Shaikh Hasan Allahyari..."
Hey Syed why won't you go on mufti Aby layh Al Maliki ..the legendary don of the Maliki madhab
It's simple..if the concept one follows does not align with what was accepted during the life of Prophet PBUH then that concept is not part of Islam period. No one followed Hazrat Hussain and Hassan AS or even Ali the way shows wondering the life of Prophet PBUH or anyone else from Prophet PBUHs house hold. As such any explanation as to why Shia follow what they follow becomes a moot point. As the concept is innovation that came in to existence after Prophet PBUHs death. There was no one called Shia or any concept such during his time. So everything else is irrelevant. This is not coming from someone who calls him self sunni or anything else.. this is coming from someone who just calls himself as a Muslim.
*"...if the concept one follows does not align with what was accepted during the life of Prophet PBUH..."* You are right. Those times were times of Jahiliyya. People like Abu Bakr and Omar were polytheists. Islam couldn't fully instill in the hearts of the people. This is why the people didn't follow Hazrat Hussain [asws] and Hassan [asws] or even Ali [asws].
*"...There was no one called Shia or any concept such during his time..."* At least in the Holy Quran Allah says that Ibrahim [as] was Shia of Nuh [as]. See Sura Saffat, verse 83.
Shiasm did not exist in Prophet SAW time. End.
@Rafida_Twelver_Shia_Muslim are you insane. You think Allah SWT who appointed PBUH ad the last prophet among Hazrat Abu Bakr and Hazrat Umar wasn't enough that they had to follow his grandsons who have no greater value in Islam than to be the grandsons of PBUH. The fact that people like you call their names with respect in the same sentence than Hazrat Abu Bakr and Hazrat Umar explains all I need to no about the Shia and how much of haram/fitna it is.
@Rafida_Twelver_Shia_Muslim this explains all about Shia and people like you.. you read the arabic text and translated that into as Shia. Didn't even read the actual translation. Wow..ignorant and a liar through and through.. don't be this desperate to prove your haram and fitna right. Here is the Surah and it's translation since you clearly didn't read it.
وَإِنَّ مِن شِيعَتِهِ ۦ لَإِبْرَٰهِيمَ(Surah 37:83)
Verily among those who followed his Way was Abraham.
do not spread fittna and tafraqah just we are all muslim follow what Quran said, do not fullfill the enemy of ALLAH SWT dream to create separation
Speak about current subjects. Stop trying to divide the Muslims. This is a time where we should be uniting as Muslims not creating a wedge between us.
Did you even watch it? He is asking for unity and more understanding!
he's not dividing the muslims he is clearing what others think about shias. Bro just watch the vid before talking
Clearly an idiot who didn't understand the video😂
He is bringing awareness to all the lies about shias that are the main cause of disunity
You may explain all these in a debate with shaikh Adnan if you are honest.
ua-cam.com/video/xODGgA0Qrxc/v-deo.htmlsi=yaK_0qYX5KEUz9pE
Is Shaikh Adnan cruel in his debates? Or are you making an excuse to just run away from the truth?
Using click bait with fake images really colours your msg. I would destroy the coments section with bots if this was any other form of content. DONT PASTE MISLEADING THUMBNAILS FOR CLICKS
27:00
55:37 😂
Please collab with Hassan Allahyari
As a sunni, im going to watch this playlist with an open mind. But as a genuine question ustadh, why dont you dialogue with our public personalities, like Adnan Rashid and Mohammed Hijab?
Because they both are full of hatred against Shia's maybe...!!
@@PkTrek lol theyre going to talk and debate, not jump him
@@helpoj hijab embarrassed all Muslims when he was debating with non Muslims in a debate... And was defending some weaker Hadiths which are against the dignity of the holy prophet.
Now they always mentioned hijab and making videos....
Now you tell me hijab is worthy for any debate who defend his sect of Hadiths which were written under Banu ummmahya rulers but don't care about the dignity of the holy prophet (s).!
@@PkTrek even if thats true, that has no bearing on him debating Ammar lol if anything it should be easier to disprove him in a sunni-shia debate
@@helpoj bro hijab etc are full of sectarianism they can't see beyond the their sect's even they don't care about the dignity of the holy prophet but care about Banu ummmahya rulers written books more than Quran. Then you think they are worthy for debate...!!
Maybe some enlightened sunni can be debatable like omer maybe.
Great you deleted my comment nice
Shia or Sunni both are Muslims but does our religion allows us to have Tattoos in our body?
Where is written in Quran that tattoos are not allowed...!!
I only trust imam Khomeini . Arrogance and ego will destroy most humans . You guys are missing something important when it comes to be a real Muslim like imam Khomeini. Purify yourself so we can actually have a good leader
sorry to tell this. Real bad scenario with that angry grandpa at the start. Surely, the acting is done and videoed in Iraq in an exaggerated way. Bless your intention and your endeavours.
No nahijjul balagaha
Click bait
I’m pretty sure if any Shia brother or sister listened or read and tried to understand the Quran it will come back to right path. May Allah guide us all to the right path Amin
You guys have misconceptions about Shia's a kind of hatred which was poisoned by Banu ummmahya against family of prophet.
52:36 🤣🤣🤣
stop clickbaiting and acctually debate sunni scholars !!!!
When you realisw the shias are leaving so this Ammar guy comes with tattos and tries to help haha
I think Ammar shouldn't have begged for a debate then run away from the challengers...
Why not have a discussion with Adnan Rashid or Mohamed Hijab or Asrar Rashid and so on. Find common ground instead of trying to highlight differences.?
Subhanallah
Thank you for bringing these Einsteins' ideologies and lies to the light.
This man is of questionable lineage and he dares speak on things he isn’t even qualified from any madrassa
Which man?
please elaborate and back up your statement. if you cant, speak good or keep quiet.
@@MK-cf1rm nakshawani
@@nohackviet I did - he hasn’t graduated from any seminary. Not one. Even his “Doctorate” is honorary, not qualified.
@@wrs1627 and what about the "questionable lineage" you claimed. pls elaborate on it
Ammar is a coward and afraid of debating 😂😂😂
😅lol mate there are so much disunity amongst you Shia ..C'mon mate why don't U talk about that ??
Zaydi Ismaili ghulat , bohra ..imami Shia ..kaysania ..another billion other sects within shiaism ..alwai ..druse etc
You have no right to say that when sunnis also have barelvis, madkhalis, salafi, hanafi and shafii etc
@@snoopcat241 but Syed is only highloting our differences not his own sect
Billion more??😂
The difference is here, that we Shia don't accept them as a right sect but you accept that all 4 of you are right
@@ahmadrashidrizayee7478 you do know that these four madhabs have the same theology it's just minor rules that are different....hahhhahahahahaha
😂 Ammar where the 1 on 1 or 1 on run 😂 lucky is Ramadhan ❤
MashAllah Sheikh Ammar ❤️❤️
Syed
allahs blessing be upon the companions of the prophet saw omer and abu bakir sadik. may allah curse those who curse them
how about Ali? Do you know how much he was cursed?
i dont hate ur beliefs but i dont believe in it personally, so am i a bad person? now isnt that a good question?, we need to learn to discuss things with respect and alhlaq without cursing each other to death, after all we all came from 1 muslim ummah ❤️
Why don’t you debate Mohamed rather than using his picture for clout, he will embarrass you
Hijab embarrassed all Muslims when he said some worried things in a debate which now non Muslims always quotes
DR. AMMAR🥰🥰🥰
DR. AMMAR🥰🥰🥰