3. Mut'ah (Temporary Marriage) in Bukhari & Muslim | Sayed Ammar Nakshawani | Holy Ramadan 2024/1445
Вставка
- Опубліковано 12 бер 2024
- Night 3 | Topic: Mutah - Holy Ramadan 2024/1445
London, U.K.
3. Mut'ah (Temporary Marriage) in Bukhari & Muslim | Sayed Ammar Nakshawani | Holy Ramadan 2024/1445
Ammar Nakshawani Reply to Mufti Menk
Mutah in Sunni Books: Bukhari & Muslim
#AmmarNakshawani #Ramadan2024 #Mutah
--------------------------
Subscribe to Sayed Ammar’s official online platform, consisting of bespoke courses, exclusive content, brand new podcasts & more!
www.sayedammar.com
it’s funny how he repeated the statement so many times😭. but you can’t blame him it’s hard getting simple things through our brothers ears.
Exactly for them it goes from ear out the other end.
and I don’t mean the other ear.
🤣🤣🤣that was funny🤣🤣🤣but even if he repeated 10000000 times,Umar! Wa maa adraka ma Umar! He is still right 😂
Yes looks funny but so understandable !!
We are repeating and proving by their books for ages, .... and they are all deaf. Like brainwashed
@@thelion2087that’s funny 😂
It’s hard to get things through thick skulls. It’s actually not funny because we get harassed every year, every day, every second, every opportunity possible. Like d[am]… you psychologically hurting people and make us depressed/angry/sad with these harassments.
@37:09
I had this exact thought a few months before Ramadan 2024 began. I was listening to a lecture by Shiej Qomi (Iranian who gives Dawah in Latin America) and he made me realize this:
Much like followers of God are the minority and the non-believers are the majority,
Much like how the Tribes of Judah were the minority and the Tribes of Israel were the majority,
Much like how the Jewish-Christians were the minority and the Paulene Christians the majority,
Followers of Imam Ali (as) and Ahlul Bayt, the Shia’a, are the minority and the Sunni are the majority.
Sheikh Qomi says that the original Sunni were Jewish spies trying to get revenge against God, Gabriel, and Muhammad for getting rid of the covenant with the sons of Isaac and instead making the covenant with the children of Ishmael (the Muslims). And till this day, we see how it’s the Sunni nations that refuse to defend Palestine and that have ties with Israel and Western nations, and it’s the Shia’a, like Iran, who support Palestine and who don’t care if they become targets to the West. It’s Iran, the Shia’a, who support Yemen in their blockade against imports to Israel. It’s the Houthis, a Shi’i group, that’s supporting Palestine. It’s the Shia’a who believe most strongly in Imam Mahdi. It was a Sunni who stopped Prophet Muhammad (saw) from speaking his final words which is believed by the Shia’a to have been his address to let us know who the next leader would be (Imam Ali as). It was the Sunni who attacked and killed the Ahlul Bayt.
I’m a revert to Islam. Since 2017 I’ve been studying Islam but from a Sunni perspective, and now in 2024 I am finally learning from the Shi’a and what I love is how concrete and deliberate the Shi’a are. Thanks to people like S.A.N, Sheij Qomi, and Sayed M Jawad Qazwini for allowing me to learn and love Ahlul Bayt for the first time as a Muslim revert
Wow, now where do I start with my reply? First off it really shows how shiism is just made to hate on sunnism and nothing else considering the fact that the Iranian (which is funny because shiism is dying in Iran yet the Iranian Shia are silent about this and they don’t seem to want to convert them back to shiism, as long as they don’t become Sunni that’s fine for them) doesn’t give dawah to Christians which make up majority of Latin America but rather focuses on the sunnis that barely make up 0.1 percent of Latin America (due to Sunni dawah of course since Shias don’t discuss with Christians except to team up with them). And funny how you speak on Palestine yet forget the religion of the Palestinians which is Sunni Islam and there is virtually no Shia in Palestine, and I would like for you to research who spread Islam to Palestine and made it under Muslim rule for over a millennia, if you haven’t guessed it’s Omar Ibn Al khattab RA and I would also want to research who freed Palestine from the Christians and if you haven’t guessed it’s salahudeen al ayubee RA, both of these magnificent figures are hated by the Shia yet you expect use to believe the Shia are going to free Palestine if they hate the ones who actually freed? And btw the Shia haven’t done much for Palestine except send a few threats and a bit of weapons, this is evident by the fact that Iran is basically silent since oct 7. And on your point on majority, using your logic I have to be an ahmadi since the ahmadiyya are the minority. And even if your premise is true, that still doesn’t disprove sunnism as sunnis are minority in comparison to the world’s population. I would like for you to answer my questions, what made you convert to Islam? Is it sunni dawah? Is it sunni books? Because I ‘now for a fact that the Shia had nothing to do with your conversion to Islam because like I said before, shiism is built on the destruction of sunnism and no the victory of Islam, this is why the Shia only and ONLY target sunnis (and maybe other Shias but you get the point) and don’t even touch a single atheist or Christians. I really hope you read and understand my reply and may Allah SWT guide you to the truth
@@user-ie7tk9zj5f first off, Salaam Wa Alaykum and Ramadan Mubarak. You sound upset in your post even though it’s Ramadan and you should try your best not to get angered…especially with internet posts.
And yes I’ll answer your questions. What made me convert to Islam? The fact that for about 14 years I looked into and studied multiple religions: Hinduism, Buddhism, Jainism, New Age, Christianity, etc. And only when I learned to pray as a Muslim, prayed 5 times a day, I felt peace in my heart. Then I bought the Quran and as I was reading it, I would feel that same peace and I would cry. It felt like I was finally aware of the truth.
So neither Sunni nor Shi’a dawah converted me. It was Allah SWT who knew that I was looking for the truth and He revealed it to me. Al Hamdulillah.
And as I began to get more and more curious, it was videos and lectures regarding Tassawuf and Al Ghazali from Sh. Hamza Yusuf. Learning the spiritual esoteric side of Islam really appealed to me…exactly how Islam easily appealed to many/most nations throughout history. It was the Sufis that went over into new nations and converted the local peoples. It was their openness and their wide understanding and acceptance that allowed people to fall in love with Islam
Then for 5 years I studied lectures and attended a Sunni masjid. But I never considered myself Sunni nor Shi’a because I’m a revert. I’m Muslim. I didn’t grow up in a Sunni home following Hanbali law, for example. So as a revert, I study a little bit of everyone in Islam to see what makes the most sense because Inshallah if I have a family by the will of Allah, they will follow the Islam that I follow for many generations. So I need to get it right
I’ve always been aware of the Shi’a but never gave as much attention as I did with the Sunni scholars. But now I owe it to the Shi’a, to myself, and to my future generations to study Shi’i Islam to see what nuggets of truth it holds and to see if it resonates best with me or not-and so far, it does.
And it’s not the “hate for Sunnis” that you mentioned, instead it’s the “love for Ahlul Bayt” that attracts me the most to Shi’i Islam. Never have I heard a khutbah at a Sunni masjid talk as much about the family of the Rasool (sawa) in 5 years combined as I hear in just one khutbah from any Shi’i scholar.
The next thing that attracts me is how everything that is confusing or uncertain in Sunni Islam (for example how many rakaats in Taraweh; how to position in prayer; do you shake your finger or not or simply keep it extended when finishing your Salat), there’s certainty in Shi’i Islam.
And as a side note, you’re wrong about Shiej Qomi giving dawah to Sunnis in LatAm rather than the Christians/Catholics. His videos and lectures are primarily focused on debunking the Christian and Catholic religions and teaching about the Shi’a. Of course some videos talk about the Sunnis but the majority of his videos are focused on dawah to the Christians and Catholics of LatAm
@@juanjimenez384 sorry if I sound angry, maybe it’s the way I write but please don’t take this as an aggressive approach, at the end I just want to have meaningful conversation. When you prayed and felt peace, what prayer did you pray? The Shia prayer or the Sunni prayer? Because according to the Shia, the prayer of a Sunni is not accepted. And on your point about the family of the prophet not being mentioned that much in Sunni mosques in comparison to Shia mosques, I want to ask you this question, in which mosque did you hear more about Allah SWT and the prophet SAW? And on your point about certainty and uncertainty, we are only uncertain about some things that are considered sunnah or not, they’re not that big of a deal, meanwhile the Shia are unsure whether the Quran is corrupted or not or whether the imams control the universe or not, so the certainty and uncertainty in the Shia school of thought is a lot more severe than in the Sunni one
@@user-ie7tk9zj5f I prayed Salat following Sunnis, specifically Shafi’i rulings. And Allah knows best if my Salat is accepted or not. Allah SWT is The Most Compassionate and Oft Forgiving. Even the Shi’a say that because Arabic isn’t my first, nor second, nor even third language…the fact that I’m trying to learn for the sake of getting closer to Allah SWT and to praise Him is suffice.
And yeah, at the Sunni masajid I heard about Allah SWT and Prophet Muhammad (sawa)-but again, I’m also talking about Ahlul Bayt. Im talking about the beloveds of THE beloved. Maybe only once or twice have I heard the name of Imam Ali (as) throughout the 5 years of attending Sunni masajid. Same with Imam Hussein (as). Never have I heard the name Zaynab (ra) for example at a Sunni masjid. Prophet Muhammad (sawa) loved his family (as) and hardly are they ever mentioned-not even during the 10th of Muharram. It breaks my heart that the Sunni don’t talk as much about Ahlul Bayt for God knows whatever reason.
@@juanjimenez384 your salah is accepted, but not according to the Shia. But where did you hear about Allah and the prophet more? In the Shia or the sunnis mosque. And if you think simply not mentioning the people that are beloved to the prophet, imagine cursing those people, Aisha, abu bakr and umar RA are the most beloved to the prophet yer they are cursed by the Shia. And in the Shia mosques, when is the Quran mentioned? Or when is the prophet or Allah mentioned when it doesn’t have anything to do with the ahlul bayt? Also we do mention and love the ahlul bayt, this is why many of our hadiths are from the ahlul bait, like from Aisha and Ibn Abbas (did you hear that name in the Shia mosque?), the Shia just pick and choose who is the ahlul bayt and who isn’t
Dr Sayed Ammar will always be a legend in the making. exposing them from their own books.
sure... but he is afraid to debate anyone after the tens of challenges he has received. He is only hiding behind his gullible followers
@@AbuFadllol Mohammed Ali would never fight a garage fighter …
@AbuFadl we see how corrupt the people were who changed the texts. We see the same thing that happened to the Christians. History repeating itself. Evil individuals took a hold of the information and we see it quiet clear today. If you want to see real debates. Research the ones from the early days. No comparison how those debates were setup. You will know the truth when you Research Inshallah
@@AbuFadli can’t believe after being exposed from your own books you are still trying to find something else 😂
@@AlinaGulestani-vz3fzwhat did he expose, all the points he raised have been refuted thousands of times.
Throughout my years of listening to sayed Ammar nakshwani, this is the best refutation/analysis he has done showing references from Sunni books and disecting such topics by showing it and discussing the ahadith. Instead of a point it two in a majlis, having a whole series on each topic only, showing references, is really good may Allah ﷻ bless sayedna
He doesnt show the hadiths when Prophet a.s himself Banned Temporary marriage forever. See Muslim 1407C.
@@iMan-610
So then you’re admitting your own books are filled with contradiction, because he repeatedly showed timelines AFTER Khaybar which clearly showed Sahaba continuing temporary marriage contracts.
Kindly make up your mind on it
@@iMan-610bro u good their is a lot of Hadith on this topic. Even if he showed it why is ibn abbas one of ur biggest narrators and Quran tafseer expert arguing the mutah was allowed after the prophet?
@@corpsefoot758these man call this collection of hadith 'sahih' 😅😅 they should rename it to sitat kutub min al'akadhib 😅😅😅
This man takes the time to educate us through Shia & Sunni books. I’ve not seen a single Sunni scholar sensibly debate or delve into Shia books as they prefer to remain tunnel visioned & pedal hate. Hence I respect this gentleman for demystifying the divide as you aren’t going to do the work. Bravo 👏🏼 the net result is not to create a bigger divide but for the ignorant ( I know plenty educated ones) to comprehend the FACTS & as much as you don’t like history , everything is seeped in it today.
Furthermore Temporary marriage in the Middle East is a very common & well accepted practice- it’s not called Mutah but it certainly isn’t any different to it.
Yeah he mentioned it. Years ago Sunnis practice it but have 5 different names for different situations 😂😂😂
@@BayaanOfWisdom if only they learnt their seen better than we are learning about theirs , it would certainly help
watch shikh walid ismail or othman alkamis, they destroyed the shia fake religion
have you read Tohfa Ithna Ashariyyah
You got scholars and pseudo scholars. Dr Nakshawani is definitely, marshallah , a scholar. He put to shame those who argue like the pagans of yore, who said our ancestors told us so.
This man single handedly destroyed the sunni wahhabi religion followed by nearly 2 billion sheeps
sure... but he is afraid to debate anyone after the tens of challenges he has received. He is only hiding behind his gullible followers
@@AbuFadlInform them about hassan allahyari as he a debator not syed ammar
@@AbuFadland lets see who will run
Challenging syed ammar for debates is like shia debators calling out to mufti menk for debates, they are not people who know the art of debate, they are people who can discuss as syed ammar is doing
@haqqulyakeen4661 lol lame excuse. Adnan rashid challenged him, Mohammad hijab challenged him & they both are skilled debators, who have debated major debates against Christians & athiests. He refused both... so he is a coward
I can't wait for all the shorts, reels that will be seen on social media on all the topics he will be dissecting till the proves are all out 👏🏼 thankyou Dr Sayed Ammar Nakshawani
Huge respect for all the effort that is put into these episodes! May ALLAH (azjl) be pleased with you and the full team that makes this possible!
Mashallah. Mashallah. Mashallah. Mashallah. Mashallah. Mashallah. Mashallah. Mashallah. Mashallah and Mashallah once more - keep it up Sayed. You helped this sunni find the path of Ahlulbayt (AS)
Honestly it's so surprising to see a small group of people in the comment section still arguing over such topics even though the entire video is filled with historical evidences and logical reasoning. It's as if they refuse to see what's right is front of their eyes and continue to follow their beliefs blindly.
nope, shia books are false, only used as toilet paper
@@Ma5asak45 did you even watch the video haha, he literally used only sunni books for a purely academic discourse to prove the legitimacy of mutah, while you have nothing to argue back with, what a shame.
@@hmr313_ i dont watch the majos talking about islam
@@Ma5asak45bro is so afraid of people reading their own Sunni hadith, that he didn't even watch it.
@@kazimsyed7367i dont have to eat shit to know it tastes like shit
For any one who says he's causing a rift in the month of Ramadan, I think you are wrong. If you've ever had to deal with a situation where our Sunni brothers approach us with these topics, you would understand. They speak to us with pure hideousness as if we are not worthy of being Muslims; as though we practice some outright distorted version of Islam. This series of lectures is giving us the ground we need to stand on. Mad respect Sayed Ammar.
Cause you do
Mutah is exploitative
I’m a Shia and I think mutah is not good
I’m not in favour of it either. It’s so easy to see how this can be exploited, but let’s keep our emotions aside and think pragmatically.
Fornication or Mutah?
Sorry bro. It can’t get more distorted than realising you’ve been following Umar ibn Al Khattab the whole time.
Thanks but I’ll stick to the Prophet and his Ahlulbayt
This Shahri Ramadaan is going to be really interesting with your lectures, Sayed Ammar, dear brother.
are you a shia or a muslim? u cant be both
@@Ma5asak45why not, if isis can call themselves muslims why can't we call ourselves for muslims
@@Ma5asak45 Certified kaffir, possibly.
@@Ma5asak45
Why does your opinion matter?
@@corpsefoot758because i am a muslim and you are not
7:31: ⚖️ Discussion on the practice of temporary marriage in Sunni world and its validation in the teachings of Prophet Muhammad.
13:26: ⚖️ Prohibition of temporary marriage with an expiry date based on authentic Hadith.
19:31: 📚 Analysis of potential relationship between Battle of H and restrictions on eating donkey meat or engaging in mut'ah.
25:28: ⚖️ Discussion on temporary marriage (Mut'ah) permissions and practices among companions of the Messenger of Allah.
31:41: 🕌 Analysis of the prohibition of Mut'ah in Islamic history and the contradictions surrounding it.
38:08: ⚔️ Omar's stance on temporary marriage and his punishment for those who practice it. (“HATTA NAHA ANHU UMAR”😅 x Infinity)
43:48: ⚖️ Prohibition of temporary marriage in Islamic texts and scholars' debates on its permissibility.
49:59: 🤔 Controversial discussion on the permissibility of mut'ah marriage among Shia youth.
Thank you Syed Amaar Sir. I will surely show it to my non-shia brothers. Thank you once again.
1. Rafidhi Munafiqeen believe the Quran is distorted:
Kulayni. “Usool al-Kafy” vol. 2, Kitaab: Fadlul-Qur’an, narration # 28:
“Ali b. al-Hakam from Hishaam b. Salim from Abu Abdullah [as] saying: Verily, the Qur’an which Gibril [as] came up with to Muhammad [saw] is 17,000 verses”.
Majlisi said: ” This tradition (about 17000 verses in Quran) is authentic and it cannot be hidden that this traditon and many more authentic traditons are explicit in (saying) that the Quran is missing and has changed. For me, (I believe) that the traditions have reached tawatur (i.e they are numerous) with regards to the meaning, and ignoring all of it would mean ignoring all traditions accordingly , but I think that the narrations in this meaning are not less than the narrations if Imamah so how do they confirm it using traditions?”
Mirat Al-Uqool Vol 12 p. 525
* Al-Majlisi I (Majlisi’s Father) said this hadeeth is SaHeeH (Authentic) -> RawDah Al-Muttaqoon, vol. 10, pg. 21
* Hoor Al-‘Aamilee said this hadeeth is SaHeeH (authentic) -> Al-Fuwaa-id Al-Toosiyyah, topic # 96, pg. 483
2. Rafidhi munafiqeen believe the imams know everything: The foremost Shi’ite cleric Al-Kulaini mentioned in his book, Usul al-Kafi (1/258-260)
“If the Imams desire to know something, they come to know it. They know when they will die - and none of them dies unless they choose to do so themselves.”
Whilst Allah says in Surah Luqman 34 (interpretation of meaning) “No soul knows what it will earn for tomorrow, and no soul knows in what land it will die.”
Shia lies caught.
One of your Scholars, Hashim al-Bahrānī stated in his book, Yanābi’ ul-Ma’ājiz wa Usul ud-Dala’il (Chapter 5, p. 35-36) regarding the Twelve Imāms of the Shi’ah:
“They have knowledge of what is in the Heavens, and knowledge of what is in the Earth, they have knowledge of what has passed and they have knowledge of what is to come, and they know what happens in the night and the day, and from one hour to the next hour - and they have the knowledge possessed by the Prophets and even more than it.”
Whilst Allah says in Surah An-Naml 65: (interpretation of meaning) “None in the heavens and the earth has knowledge of the unseen except Allah. Nor do they know when they will be resurrected.”
Shia lies caught.
One of your important shaikhs of this era, Abdul-Muhsin al-Amini an-Najafi stated in his book Al-Ghadir (1/214-216):
“Verily the [Twelve] Imams are the sons of Allah and from the offspring of ‘Ali.”
@@Akhi_Umar brother the person who speaks truth and that too written in your books might have been called Rafidhi. Then we Shias are Rafidhi. Aisha also narrates about the Quran. The ignorant always use the tactics that you are using here. Rather than replying to his questions, you are crying Rafidhi Rafidhi Rafidhi.
@@SameerHaiderAbbas The whole video is based upon the topic of Mutah. I don’t even have to bring evidence from my book, I can provide evidence from your book admitting the prohibition of mutah. Mutah forbidden in shii’ books: We find in Al-Istibsar by Al-Tusi (p. 689) from Mohammad bin Ahmad bin Yahya from Abi Al-Jawza’a from Al-Hussain bin Ulwan from Amr bin Khalid from Zaid bin Ali from his fathers from Ali - peace be upon him - that he said: The Messenger of Allah - peace be upon him - forbade the meat of the domestic donkey and mutah marriag
The thumbnails are absolutely brutal.
The content of the lectures have absolutely proven the Shia school to be 100% correct.
no ot doesnt, the shia is a fale religion with no facts
@@Ma5asak45
Thanks for watching!
Only Allah swt. can make you listen and learn though.
@rcmysm9123 lol. Dude don't even wanna listen to his own hadith collection.
@@kazimsyed7367i dont listen to lies of the majos
@@rcmysm9123i dont watch non muslims talking about muslim matters
Also here again for all non believers:
Mutah and the Kuffr of Omar by forbidding something, that Allah allowed:
muslim:1405d
muslim:1405c
muslim:1405e
muslim:1404a
muslim:1406b
muslim:1405a
bukhari:5075
bukhari:5117
mishkat:3157
Muwatta malik urn: 511370
nasai:2723
And here the hadith about the verse of mutah in the quran and that nothing came in Revelation that forbids it:
bukhari:4518
So again: its the kuffr of omar going against the quran, where its says: "dont forbid something, that allah has allowed you."
So your Omar is now somehow above allah, that he can allow and forbid things, right?
Now answer, yallah im silent. Go ahead and answer.
Bismillah
Why didnt you post Muslim 1407C when Prophet a.s banned Mutah forever
@@iMan-610 look at your Argument 🙄 vallahi i dont understand you. We dont believe in your hadith books. If you want to prove us a point, you have to make it clear from shia Sources, in order for us to take it. Not from YOUR own sources... its like a Christian telling me that there are 3 gods because its written in the Bible. The whole mashab is wrong. And thats the same with your bida-mashab. Thats why you cant use your own books against us. But we can use your books against you! Since you believe in that. Yallah
Mut'ah has conditions. Mut'ah has dowry. There is eddah period after Mut'ah...It is not forced. It is based on free will. It is for a stipulated time. The lady is let aware of the duration. A married lady is prohibited to practise it. Mut'ah does not degrade a woman. The man has to take responsibility of her during the duration. A child conceived is legitimate. Sharing some knowledge on Mut'ah. Salaam
Mutah can be only for one Night and without witnesses
@@iMan-610
Mutah can last anywhere from a few nights to a few months.
@@iMan-610rubbish. Prove it
give me your sister for $2 dollars please?
@@iMan-610the Quran is clear about whether or not it was permitted based on duration and having the freedom to yourselves stipulate that duration. We don’t argue with Quran.
Wallahi thanks a ton for clearing the cobwebs on this topic...May Allah bless u dr.Ammar Nakshwani
Jazakallah 😊
Where did he cleared things? Please help understand. It is clear in every passage that Mutah was later prohibited.? No where it says it was still valid.
The lies of the Rawafidh are blatant and will be exposed Insha’Allah .
1. Mutah forbidden in shii’ books: We find in Al-Istibsar by Al-Tusi (p. 689) from Mohammad bin Ahmad bin Yahya from Abi Al-Jawza’a from Al-Hussain bin Ulwan from Amr bin Khalid from Zaid bin Ali from his fathers from Ali - peace be upon him - that he said: The Messenger of Allah - peace be upon him - forbade the meat of the domestic donkey and mutah marriages.
2. Rafidhi Munafiqeen believe the Quran is distorted:
Kulayni. “Usool al-Kafy” vol. 2, Kitaab: Fadlul-Qur’an, narration # 28:
“Ali b. al-Hakam from Hishaam b. Salim from Abu Abdullah [as] saying: Verily, the Qur’an which Gibril [as] came up with to Muhammad [saw] is 17,000 verses”.
Majlisi said: ” This tradition (about 17000 verses in Quran) is authentic and it cannot be hidden that this traditon and many more authentic traditons are explicit in (saying) that the Quran is missing and has changed. For me, (I believe) that the traditions have reached tawatur (i.e they are numerous) with regards to the meaning, and ignoring all of it would mean ignoring all traditions accordingly , but I think that the narrations in this meaning are not less than the narrations if Imamah so how do they confirm it using traditions?”
Mirat Al-Uqool Vol 12 p. 525
* Al-Majlisi I (Majlisi’s Father) said this hadeeth is SaHeeH (Authentic) -> RawDah Al-Muttaqoon, vol. 10, pg. 21
* Hoor Al-‘Aamilee said this hadeeth is SaHeeH (authentic) -> Al-Fuwaa-id Al-Toosiyyah, topic # 96, pg. 483
3.
Rafidhi munafiqeen believe the imams know everything: The foremost Shi’ite cleric Al-Kulaini mentioned in his book, Usul al-Kafi (1/258-260)
“If the Imams desire to know something, they come to know it. They know when they will die - and none of them dies unless they choose to do so themselves.”
Whilst Allah says in Surah Luqman 34 (interpretation of meaning) “No soul knows what it will earn for tomorrow, and no soul knows in what land it will die.”
Shia lies caught.
One of your Scholars, Hashim al-Bahrānī stated in his book, Yanābi’ ul-Ma’ājiz wa Usul ud-Dala’il (Chapter 5, p. 35-36) regarding the Twelve Imāms of the Shi’ah:
“They have knowledge of what is in the Heavens, and knowledge of what is in the Earth, they have knowledge of what has passed and they have knowledge of what is to come, and they know what happens in the night and the day, and from one hour to the next hour - and they have the knowledge possessed by the Prophets and even more than it.”
Whilst Allah says in Surah An-Naml 65: (interpretation of meaning) “None in the heavens and the earth has knowledge of the unseen except Allah. Nor do they know when they will be resurrected.”
Shia lies caught.
One of your important shaikhs of this era, Abdul-Muhsin al-Amini an-Najafi stated in his book Al-Ghadir (1/214-216):
“Verily the [Twelve] Imams are the sons of Allah and from the offspring of ‘Ali.”
The lies of the Rawafidh are blatant and will be exposed Insha’Allah .
1. Mutah forbidden in shii’ books: We find in Al-Istibsar by Al-Tusi (p. 689) from Mohammad bin Ahmad bin Yahya from Abi Al-Jawza’a from Al-Hussain bin Ulwan from Amr bin Khalid from Zaid bin Ali from his fathers from Ali - peace be upon him - that he said: The Messenger of Allah - peace be upon him - forbade the meat of the domestic donkey and mutah marriages.
2. Rafidhi Munafiqeen believe the Quran is distorted:
Kulayni. “Usool al-Kafy” vol. 2, Kitaab: Fadlul-Qur’an, narration # 28:
“Ali b. al-Hakam from Hishaam b. Salim from Abu Abdullah [as] saying: Verily, the Qur’an which Gibril [as] came up with to Muhammad [saw] is 17,000 verses”.
Majlisi said: ” This tradition (about 17000 verses in Quran) is authentic and it cannot be hidden that this traditon and many more authentic traditons are explicit in (saying) that the Quran is missing and has changed. For me, (I believe) that the traditions have reached tawatur (i.e they are numerous) with regards to the meaning, and ignoring all of it would mean ignoring all traditions accordingly , but I think that the narrations in this meaning are not less than the narrations if Imamah so how do they confirm it using traditions?”
Mirat Al-Uqool Vol 12 p. 525
* Al-Majlisi I (Majlisi’s Father) said this hadeeth is SaHeeH (Authentic) -> RawDah Al-Muttaqoon, vol. 10, pg. 21
* Hoor Al-‘Aamilee said this hadeeth is SaHeeH (authentic) -> Al-Fuwaa-id Al-Toosiyyah, topic # 96, pg. 483
3.
Rafidhi munafiqeen believe the imams know everything: The foremost Shi’ite cleric Al-Kulaini mentioned in his book, Usul al-Kafi (1/258-260)
“If the Imams desire to know something, they come to know it. They know when they will die - and none of them dies unless they choose to do so themselves.”
Whilst Allah says in Surah Luqman 34 (interpretation of meaning) “No soul knows what it will earn for tomorrow, and no soul knows in what land it will die.”
Shia lies caught.
One of your Scholars, Hashim al-Bahrānī stated in his book, Yanābi’ ul-Ma’ājiz wa Usul ud-Dala’il (Chapter 5, p. 35-36) regarding the Twelve Imāms of the Shi’ah:
“They have knowledge of what is in the Heavens, and knowledge of what is in the Earth, they have knowledge of what has passed and they have knowledge of what is to come, and they know what happens in the night and the day, and from one hour to the next hour - and they have the knowledge possessed by the Prophets and even more than it.”
Whilst Allah says in Surah An-Naml 65: (interpretation of meaning) “None in the heavens and the earth has knowledge of the unseen except Allah. Nor do they know when they will be resurrected.”
Shia lies caught.
One of your important shaikhs of this era, Abdul-Muhsin al-Amini an-Najafi stated in his book Al-Ghadir (1/214-216):
“Verily the [Twelve] Imams are the sons of Allah and from the offspring of ‘Ali.”
The lies of the Rawafidh are blatant and will be exposed Insha’Allah .
1. Mutah forbidden in shii’ books: We find in Al-Istibsar by Al-Tusi (p. 689) from Mohammad bin Ahmad bin Yahya from Abi Al-Jawza’a from Al-Hussain bin Ulwan from Amr bin Khalid from Zaid bin Ali from his fathers from Ali - peace be upon him - that he said: The Messenger of Allah - peace be upon him - forbade the meat of the domestic donkey and mutah marriages.
2. Rafidhi Munafiqeen believe the Quran is distorted:
Kulayni. “Usool al-Kafy” vol. 2, Kitaab: Fadlul-Qur’an, narration # 28:
“Ali b. al-Hakam from Hishaam b. Salim from Abu Abdullah [as] saying: Verily, the Qur’an which Gibril [as] came up with to Muhammad [saw] is 17,000 verses”.
Majlisi said: ” This tradition (about 17000 verses in Quran) is authentic and it cannot be hidden that this traditon and many more authentic traditons are explicit in (saying) that the Quran is missing and has changed. For me, (I believe) that the traditions have reached tawatur (i.e they are numerous) with regards to the meaning, and ignoring all of it would mean ignoring all traditions accordingly , but I think that the narrations in this meaning are not less than the narrations if Imamah so how do they confirm it using traditions?”
Mirat Al-Uqool Vol 12 p. 525
* Al-Majlisi I (Majlisi’s Father) said this hadeeth is SaHeeH (Authentic) -> RawDah Al-Muttaqoon, vol. 10, pg. 21
* Hoor Al-‘Aamilee said this hadeeth is SaHeeH (authentic) -> Al-Fuwaa-id Al-Toosiyyah, topic # 96, pg. 483
3.
Rafidhi munafiqeen believe the imams know everything: The foremost Shi’ite cleric Al-Kulaini mentioned in his book, Usul al-Kafi (1/258-260)
“If the Imams desire to know something, they come to know it. They know when they will die - and none of them dies unless they choose to do so themselves.”
Whilst Allah says in Surah Luqman 34 (interpretation of meaning) “No soul knows what it will earn for tomorrow, and no soul knows in what land it will die.”
Shia lies caught.
One of your Scholars, Hashim al-Bahrānī stated in his book, Yanābi’ ul-Ma’ājiz wa Usul ud-Dala’il (Chapter 5, p. 35-36) regarding the Twelve Imāms of the Shi’ah:
“They have knowledge of what is in the Heavens, and knowledge of what is in the Earth, they have knowledge of what has passed and they have knowledge of what is to come, and they know what happens in the night and the day, and from one hour to the next hour - and they have the knowledge possessed by the Prophets and even more than it.”
Whilst Allah says in Surah An-Naml 65: (interpretation of meaning) “None in the heavens and the earth has knowledge of the unseen except Allah. Nor do they know when they will be resurrected.”
Shia lies caught.
One of your important shaikhs of this era, Abdul-Muhsin al-Amini an-Najafi stated in his book Al-Ghadir (1/214-216):
“Verily the [Twelve] Imams are the sons of Allah and from the offspring of ‘Ali.”
We have been deprived of the holy family's merits and knowledge it's time for the truth to be known inshallah
Wowww, iam literally sitting with cheez cruncherz and watching you sir. Iam Looking forward to see more of your videoes inshallah. May Allah subhanahu wa taala bless you more. You are blessing for us. May ALlah subhanahu wa taala guide our sunni brothers and sisters to the real Islam.
As a Sunni, I knew mut’ah was permissible as it is in our books. Everyone should know, it should not come as a surprise.
i wish there was more like you akhi but there are so many ignnorant people in world its honestly sad
Ahsant Sayed Ammar. May Allah (SWT) reward you for your service. We are indebted to you for your fantastic work.
1. Rafidhi Munafiqeen believe the Quran is distorted:
Kulayni. “Usool al-Kafy” vol. 2, Kitaab: Fadlul-Qur’an, narration # 28:
“Ali b. al-Hakam from Hishaam b. Salim from Abu Abdullah [as] saying: Verily, the Qur’an which Gibril [as] came up with to Muhammad [saw] is 17,000 verses”.
Majlisi said: ” This tradition (about 17000 verses in Quran) is authentic and it cannot be hidden that this traditon and many more authentic traditons are explicit in (saying) that the Quran is missing and has changed. For me, (I believe) that the traditions have reached tawatur (i.e they are numerous) with regards to the meaning, and ignoring all of it would mean ignoring all traditions accordingly , but I think that the narrations in this meaning are not less than the narrations if Imamah so how do they confirm it using traditions?”
Mirat Al-Uqool Vol 12 p. 525
* Al-Majlisi I (Majlisi’s Father) said this hadeeth is SaHeeH (Authentic) -> RawDah Al-Muttaqoon, vol. 10, pg. 21
* Hoor Al-‘Aamilee said this hadeeth is SaHeeH (authentic) -> Al-Fuwaa-id Al-Toosiyyah, topic # 96, pg. 483
2. Rafidhi munafiqeen believe the imams know everything: The foremost Shi’ite cleric Al-Kulaini mentioned in his book, Usul al-Kafi (1/258-260)
“If the Imams desire to know something, they come to know it. They know when they will die - and none of them dies unless they choose to do so themselves.”
Whilst Allah says in Surah Luqman 34 (interpretation of meaning) “No soul knows what it will earn for tomorrow, and no soul knows in what land it will die.”
Shia lies caught.
One of your Scholars, Hashim al-Bahrānī stated in his book, Yanābi’ ul-Ma’ājiz wa Usul ud-Dala’il (Chapter 5, p. 35-36) regarding the Twelve Imāms of the Shi’ah:
“They have knowledge of what is in the Heavens, and knowledge of what is in the Earth, they have knowledge of what has passed and they have knowledge of what is to come, and they know what happens in the night and the day, and from one hour to the next hour - and they have the knowledge possessed by the Prophets and even more than it.”
Whilst Allah says in Surah An-Naml 65: (interpretation of meaning) “None in the heavens and the earth has knowledge of the unseen except Allah. Nor do they know when they will be resurrected.”
Shia lies caught.
One of your important shaikhs of this era, Abdul-Muhsin al-Amini an-Najafi stated in his book Al-Ghadir (1/214-216):
“Verily the [Twelve] Imams are the sons of Allah and from the offspring of ‘Ali.”
Thank you brother Sayed for such an amazing lecture ! I wish for this Ramadan all people will start and read at least their own books ! Reading , understanding and getting knowledge is definitely maybe the most important thing on this earth ! It can save you from ignorance ! May you and your family be blessed with the highest rank in heaven ! ❤
1. Rafidhi Munafiqeen believe the Quran is distorted:
Kulayni. “Usool al-Kafy” vol. 2, Kitaab: Fadlul-Qur’an, narration # 28:
“Ali b. al-Hakam from Hishaam b. Salim from Abu Abdullah [as] saying: Verily, the Qur’an which Gibril [as] came up with to Muhammad [saw] is 17,000 verses”.
Majlisi said: ” This tradition (about 17000 verses in Quran) is authentic and it cannot be hidden that this traditon and many more authentic traditons are explicit in (saying) that the Quran is missing and has changed. For me, (I believe) that the traditions have reached tawatur (i.e they are numerous) with regards to the meaning, and ignoring all of it would mean ignoring all traditions accordingly , but I think that the narrations in this meaning are not less than the narrations if Imamah so how do they confirm it using traditions?”
Mirat Al-Uqool Vol 12 p. 525
* Al-Majlisi I (Majlisi’s Father) said this hadeeth is SaHeeH (Authentic) -> RawDah Al-Muttaqoon, vol. 10, pg. 21
* Hoor Al-‘Aamilee said this hadeeth is SaHeeH (authentic) -> Al-Fuwaa-id Al-Toosiyyah, topic # 96, pg. 483
2. Rafidhi munafiqeen believe the imams know everything: The foremost Shi’ite cleric Al-Kulaini mentioned in his book, Usul al-Kafi (1/258-260)
“If the Imams desire to know something, they come to know it. They know when they will die - and none of them dies unless they choose to do so themselves.”
Whilst Allah says in Surah Luqman 34 (interpretation of meaning) “No soul knows what it will earn for tomorrow, and no soul knows in what land it will die.”
Shia lies caught.
One of your Scholars, Hashim al-Bahrānī stated in his book, Yanābi’ ul-Ma’ājiz wa Usul ud-Dala’il (Chapter 5, p. 35-36) regarding the Twelve Imāms of the Shi’ah:
“They have knowledge of what is in the Heavens, and knowledge of what is in the Earth, they have knowledge of what has passed and they have knowledge of what is to come, and they know what happens in the night and the day, and from one hour to the next hour - and they have the knowledge possessed by the Prophets and even more than it.”
Whilst Allah says in Surah An-Naml 65: (interpretation of meaning) “None in the heavens and the earth has knowledge of the unseen except Allah. Nor do they know when they will be resurrected.”
Shia lies caught.
One of your important shaikhs of this era, Abdul-Muhsin al-Amini an-Najafi stated in his book Al-Ghadir (1/214-216):
“Verily the [Twelve] Imams are the sons of Allah and from the offspring of ‘Ali.”
Wallahi Ammar Nakshawani is the goat 😂
I couldn't agree more
Certified. Bodied the entire Speakers Corner without setting foot in it
He is!
@@puseletsomonnaemang2958how
He is liar. Soon his lies will be exposed inshAllah
Sayedna where is the thobe from?🤓
This series is everything, we all need this so badly. I was on this journey and my sister sent me one of the videos in this series, thank you for doing most of the 'legwork' for us. I will be watching them all.
The quran is our reference point. If mutaah was banned at a later stage then Allah (swt) should have let us know through further revelations rather than making us to second guess ourselves by relying on old hadith.
You've clearly missed the point, the prophet said I will behind the Quran annnnd the ahlubayt... if you followed the ahlulbayt and not simply rely on the Quran, things would be much easier. It's never too late
Its allowed in quran if I am not wrong.
@@kazimsyed7367you are wrong
With all due respect, who are you to say that Allah almighty should have let us know through further revelation? Are you saying that Allah swt was wrong? Who are you to say that the almighty 'should' have done anything?
@sdaafasfad I agree with you...if the Quran and the revelations sent down to out prophet wasn't enough then nothing else will be
Respect brother, may you be rewarded for your efforts. Love the references from Bukhari and Sahih Muslim ( THEIR Books)
The lies of the Rawafidh are blatant and will be exposed Insha’Allah .
1. Mutah forbidden in shii’ books: We find in Al-Istibsar by Al-Tusi (p. 689) from Mohammad bin Ahmad bin Yahya from Abi Al-Jawza’a from Al-Hussain bin Ulwan from Amr bin Khalid from Zaid bin Ali from his fathers from Ali - peace be upon him - that he said: The Messenger of Allah - peace be upon him - forbade the meat of the domestic donkey and mutah marriages.
2. Rafidhi Munafiqeen believe the Quran is distorted:
Kulayni. “Usool al-Kafy” vol. 2, Kitaab: Fadlul-Qur’an, narration # 28:
“Ali b. al-Hakam from Hishaam b. Salim from Abu Abdullah [as] saying: Verily, the Qur’an which Gibril [as] came up with to Muhammad [saw] is 17,000 verses”.
Majlisi said: ” This tradition (about 17000 verses in Quran) is authentic and it cannot be hidden that this traditon and many more authentic traditons are explicit in (saying) that the Quran is missing and has changed. For me, (I believe) that the traditions have reached tawatur (i.e they are numerous) with regards to the meaning, and ignoring all of it would mean ignoring all traditions accordingly , but I think that the narrations in this meaning are not less than the narrations if Imamah so how do they confirm it using traditions?”
Mirat Al-Uqool Vol 12 p. 525
* Al-Majlisi I (Majlisi’s Father) said this hadeeth is SaHeeH (Authentic) -> RawDah Al-Muttaqoon, vol. 10, pg. 21
* Hoor Al-‘Aamilee said this hadeeth is SaHeeH (authentic) -> Al-Fuwaa-id Al-Toosiyyah, topic # 96, pg. 483
3.
Rafidhi munafiqeen believe the imams know everything: The foremost Shi’ite cleric Al-Kulaini mentioned in his book, Usul al-Kafi (1/258-260)
“If the Imams desire to know something, they come to know it. They know when they will die - and none of them dies unless they choose to do so themselves.”
Whilst Allah says in Surah Luqman 34 (interpretation of meaning) “No soul knows what it will earn for tomorrow, and no soul knows in what land it will die.”
Shia lies caught.
One of your Scholars, Hashim al-Bahrānī stated in his book, Yanābi’ ul-Ma’ājiz wa Usul ud-Dala’il (Chapter 5, p. 35-36) regarding the Twelve Imāms of the Shi’ah:
“They have knowledge of what is in the Heavens, and knowledge of what is in the Earth, they have knowledge of what has passed and they have knowledge of what is to come, and they know what happens in the night and the day, and from one hour to the next hour - and they have the knowledge possessed by the Prophets and even more than it.”
Whilst Allah says in Surah An-Naml 65: (interpretation of meaning) “None in the heavens and the earth has knowledge of the unseen except Allah. Nor do they know when they will be resurrected.”
Shia lies caught.
One of your important shaikhs of this era, Abdul-Muhsin al-Amini an-Najafi stated in his book Al-Ghadir (1/214-216):
“Verily the [Twelve] Imams are the sons of Allah and from the offspring of ‘Ali.”
Exemplary, what an intricate breakdown.
They should be ashamed those who mock this practice of the sahaba.
Ya Hussein!!! Ya Hussein!!! Ya Hussein!!! 😭😭😭
YA HOE ZEEN
@@Ma5asak45 ^this guys is a clown bot^ ignore him hes mad because today has been a day of exposing the realities of following Omar over the prophet 😌😌
@@Ma5asak45at least respect your Prophet’s progeny omg
@@razlb5395i am not the one who called my prophet a cuck, you majos did
@@razlb5395
Now you are seeing their true colors
Descendants of pagans will never respect the Ahlul Bayt🤷♂️
Thank you Sayed, this is all so eye opening. May Allah swt bless you inshaAllah
The lies of the Rawafidh are blatant and will be exposed Insha’Allah .
1. Mutah forbidden in shii’ books: We find in Al-Istibsar by Al-Tusi (p. 689) from Mohammad bin Ahmad bin Yahya from Abi Al-Jawza’a from Al-Hussain bin Ulwan from Amr bin Khalid from Zaid bin Ali from his fathers from Ali - peace be upon him - that he said: The Messenger of Allah - peace be upon him - forbade the meat of the domestic donkey and mutah marriages.
2. Rafidhi Munafiqeen believe the Quran is distorted:
Kulayni. “Usool al-Kafy” vol. 2, Kitaab: Fadlul-Qur’an, narration # 28:
“Ali b. al-Hakam from Hishaam b. Salim from Abu Abdullah [as] saying: Verily, the Qur’an which Gibril [as] came up with to Muhammad [saw] is 17,000 verses”.
Majlisi said: ” This tradition (about 17000 verses in Quran) is authentic and it cannot be hidden that this traditon and many more authentic traditons are explicit in (saying) that the Quran is missing and has changed. For me, (I believe) that the traditions have reached tawatur (i.e they are numerous) with regards to the meaning, and ignoring all of it would mean ignoring all traditions accordingly , but I think that the narrations in this meaning are not less than the narrations if Imamah so how do they confirm it using traditions?”
Mirat Al-Uqool Vol 12 p. 525
* Al-Majlisi I (Majlisi’s Father) said this hadeeth is SaHeeH (Authentic) -> RawDah Al-Muttaqoon, vol. 10, pg. 21
* Hoor Al-‘Aamilee said this hadeeth is SaHeeH (authentic) -> Al-Fuwaa-id Al-Toosiyyah, topic # 96, pg. 483
3.
Rafidhi munafiqeen believe the imams know everything: The foremost Shi’ite cleric Al-Kulaini mentioned in his book, Usul al-Kafi (1/258-260)
“If the Imams desire to know something, they come to know it. They know when they will die - and none of them dies unless they choose to do so themselves.”
Whilst Allah says in Surah Luqman 34 (interpretation of meaning) “No soul knows what it will earn for tomorrow, and no soul knows in what land it will die.”
Shia lies caught.
One of your Scholars, Hashim al-Bahrānī stated in his book, Yanābi’ ul-Ma’ājiz wa Usul ud-Dala’il (Chapter 5, p. 35-36) regarding the Twelve Imāms of the Shi’ah:
“They have knowledge of what is in the Heavens, and knowledge of what is in the Earth, they have knowledge of what has passed and they have knowledge of what is to come, and they know what happens in the night and the day, and from one hour to the next hour - and they have the knowledge possessed by the Prophets and even more than it.”
Whilst Allah says in Surah An-Naml 65: (interpretation of meaning) “None in the heavens and the earth has knowledge of the unseen except Allah. Nor do they know when they will be resurrected.”
Shia lies caught.
One of your important shaikhs of this era, Abdul-Muhsin al-Amini an-Najafi stated in his book Al-Ghadir (1/214-216):
“Verily the [Twelve] Imams are the sons of Allah and from the offspring of ‘Ali.”
Explained with clarity, supported by evidence. The first English speaker scholar who makes lectures and majalis a daily dose. Thank you 🙏
The lies of the Rawafidh are blatant and will be exposed Insha’Allah .
1. Mutah forbidden in shii’ books: We find in Al-Istibsar by Al-Tusi (p. 689) from Mohammad bin Ahmad bin Yahya from Abi Al-Jawza’a from Al-Hussain bin Ulwan from Amr bin Khalid from Zaid bin Ali from his fathers from Ali - peace be upon him - that he said: The Messenger of Allah - peace be upon him - forbade the meat of the domestic donkey and mutah marriages.
2. Rafidhi Munafiqeen believe the Quran is distorted:
Kulayni. “Usool al-Kafy” vol. 2, Kitaab: Fadlul-Qur’an, narration # 28:
“Ali b. al-Hakam from Hishaam b. Salim from Abu Abdullah [as] saying: Verily, the Qur’an which Gibril [as] came up with to Muhammad [saw] is 17,000 verses”.
Majlisi said: ” This tradition (about 17000 verses in Quran) is authentic and it cannot be hidden that this traditon and many more authentic traditons are explicit in (saying) that the Quran is missing and has changed. For me, (I believe) that the traditions have reached tawatur (i.e they are numerous) with regards to the meaning, and ignoring all of it would mean ignoring all traditions accordingly , but I think that the narrations in this meaning are not less than the narrations if Imamah so how do they confirm it using traditions?”
Mirat Al-Uqool Vol 12 p. 525
* Al-Majlisi I (Majlisi’s Father) said this hadeeth is SaHeeH (Authentic) -> RawDah Al-Muttaqoon, vol. 10, pg. 21
* Hoor Al-‘Aamilee said this hadeeth is SaHeeH (authentic) -> Al-Fuwaa-id Al-Toosiyyah, topic # 96, pg. 483
3.
Rafidhi munafiqeen believe the imams know everything: The foremost Shi’ite cleric Al-Kulaini mentioned in his book, Usul al-Kafi (1/258-260)
“If the Imams desire to know something, they come to know it. They know when they will die - and none of them dies unless they choose to do so themselves.”
Whilst Allah says in Surah Luqman 34 (interpretation of meaning) “No soul knows what it will earn for tomorrow, and no soul knows in what land it will die.”
Shia lies caught.
One of your Scholars, Hashim al-Bahrānī stated in his book, Yanābi’ ul-Ma’ājiz wa Usul ud-Dala’il (Chapter 5, p. 35-36) regarding the Twelve Imāms of the Shi’ah:
“They have knowledge of what is in the Heavens, and knowledge of what is in the Earth, they have knowledge of what has passed and they have knowledge of what is to come, and they know what happens in the night and the day, and from one hour to the next hour - and they have the knowledge possessed by the Prophets and even more than it.”
Whilst Allah says in Surah An-Naml 65: (interpretation of meaning) “None in the heavens and the earth has knowledge of the unseen except Allah. Nor do they know when they will be resurrected.”
Shia lies caught.
One of your important shaikhs of this era, Abdul-Muhsin al-Amini an-Najafi stated in his book Al-Ghadir (1/214-216):
“Verily the [Twelve] Imams are the sons of Allah and from the offspring of ‘Ali.”
The lies of the Rawafidh are blatant and will be exposed Insha’Allah .
1. Mutah forbidden in shii’ books: We find in Al-Istibsar by Al-Tusi (p. 689) from Mohammad bin Ahmad bin Yahya from Abi Al-Jawza’a from Al-Hussain bin Ulwan from Amr bin Khalid from Zaid bin Ali from his fathers from Ali - peace be upon him - that he said: The Messenger of Allah - peace be upon him - forbade the meat of the domestic donkey and mutah marriages.
2. Rafidhi Munafiqeen believe the Quran is distorted:
Kulayni. “Usool al-Kafy” vol. 2, Kitaab: Fadlul-Qur’an, narration # 28:
“Ali b. al-Hakam from Hishaam b. Salim from Abu Abdullah [as] saying: Verily, the Qur’an which Gibril [as] came up with to Muhammad [saw] is 17,000 verses”.
Majlisi said: ” This tradition (about 17000 verses in Quran) is authentic and it cannot be hidden that this traditon and many more authentic traditons are explicit in (saying) that the Quran is missing and has changed. For me, (I believe) that the traditions have reached tawatur (i.e they are numerous) with regards to the meaning, and ignoring all of it would mean ignoring all traditions accordingly , but I think that the narrations in this meaning are not less than the narrations if Imamah so how do they confirm it using traditions?”
Mirat Al-Uqool Vol 12 p. 525
* Al-Majlisi I (Majlisi’s Father) said this hadeeth is SaHeeH (Authentic) -> RawDah Al-Muttaqoon, vol. 10, pg. 21
* Hoor Al-‘Aamilee said this hadeeth is SaHeeH (authentic) -> Al-Fuwaa-id Al-Toosiyyah, topic # 96, pg. 483
3.
Rafidhi munafiqeen believe the imams know everything: The foremost Shi’ite cleric Al-Kulaini mentioned in his book, Usul al-Kafi (1/258-260)
“If the Imams desire to know something, they come to know it. They know when they will die - and none of them dies unless they choose to do so themselves.”
Whilst Allah says in Surah Luqman 34 (interpretation of meaning) “No soul knows what it will earn for tomorrow, and no soul knows in what land it will die.”
Shia lies caught.
One of your Scholars, Hashim al-Bahrānī stated in his book, Yanābi’ ul-Ma’ājiz wa Usul ud-Dala’il (Chapter 5, p. 35-36) regarding the Twelve Imāms of the Shi’ah:
“They have knowledge of what is in the Heavens, and knowledge of what is in the Earth, they have knowledge of what has passed and they have knowledge of what is to come, and they know what happens in the night and the day, and from one hour to the next hour - and they have the knowledge possessed by the Prophets and even more than it.”
Whilst Allah says in Surah An-Naml 65: (interpretation of meaning) “None in the heavens and the earth has knowledge of the unseen except Allah. Nor do they know when they will be resurrected.”
Shia lies caught.
One of your important shaikhs of this era, Abdul-Muhsin al-Amini an-Najafi stated in his book Al-Ghadir (1/214-216):
“Verily the [Twelve] Imams are the sons of Allah and from the offspring of ‘Ali.”
The lies of the Rawafidh are blatant and will be exposed Insha’Allah .
1. Mutah forbidden in shii’ books: We find in Al-Istibsar by Al-Tusi (p. 689) from Mohammad bin Ahmad bin Yahya from Abi Al-Jawza’a from Al-Hussain bin Ulwan from Amr bin Khalid from Zaid bin Ali from his fathers from Ali - peace be upon him - that he said: The Messenger of Allah - peace be upon him - forbade the meat of the domestic donkey and mutah marriages.
2. Rafidhi Munafiqeen believe the Quran is distorted:
Kulayni. “Usool al-Kafy” vol. 2, Kitaab: Fadlul-Qur’an, narration # 28:
“Ali b. al-Hakam from Hishaam b. Salim from Abu Abdullah [as] saying: Verily, the Qur’an which Gibril [as] came up with to Muhammad [saw] is 17,000 verses”.
Majlisi said: ” This tradition (about 17000 verses in Quran) is authentic and it cannot be hidden that this traditon and many more authentic traditons are explicit in (saying) that the Quran is missing and has changed. For me, (I believe) that the traditions have reached tawatur (i.e they are numerous) with regards to the meaning, and ignoring all of it would mean ignoring all traditions accordingly , but I think that the narrations in this meaning are not less than the narrations if Imamah so how do they confirm it using traditions?”
Mirat Al-Uqool Vol 12 p. 525
* Al-Majlisi I (Majlisi’s Father) said this hadeeth is SaHeeH (Authentic) -> RawDah Al-Muttaqoon, vol. 10, pg. 21
* Hoor Al-‘Aamilee said this hadeeth is SaHeeH (authentic) -> Al-Fuwaa-id Al-Toosiyyah, topic # 96, pg. 483
3.
Rafidhi munafiqeen believe the imams know everything: The foremost Shi’ite cleric Al-Kulaini mentioned in his book, Usul al-Kafi (1/258-260)
“If the Imams desire to know something, they come to know it. They know when they will die - and none of them dies unless they choose to do so themselves.”
Whilst Allah says in Surah Luqman 34 (interpretation of meaning) “No soul knows what it will earn for tomorrow, and no soul knows in what land it will die.”
Shia lies caught.
One of your Scholars, Hashim al-Bahrānī stated in his book, Yanābi’ ul-Ma’ājiz wa Usul ud-Dala’il (Chapter 5, p. 35-36) regarding the Twelve Imāms of the Shi’ah:
“They have knowledge of what is in the Heavens, and knowledge of what is in the Earth, they have knowledge of what has passed and they have knowledge of what is to come, and they know what happens in the night and the day, and from one hour to the next hour - and they have the knowledge possessed by the Prophets and even more than it.”
Whilst Allah says in Surah An-Naml 65: (interpretation of meaning) “None in the heavens and the earth has knowledge of the unseen except Allah. Nor do they know when they will be resurrected.”
Shia lies caught.
One of your important shaikhs of this era, Abdul-Muhsin al-Amini an-Najafi stated in his book Al-Ghadir (1/214-216):
“Verily the [Twelve] Imams are the sons of Allah and from the offspring of ‘Ali.”
God Bless Ammar and protect him.
Temporary marriage was allowed when Abo Bakr was a ruler or khalif, so the prophet s.w. did not prohibit Temporary marriage or muta marriage.
اللهم صل على محمد وآل محمد الطيبين الطاهرين المعصومين
kis imk w emon
Great series Ma’Sha’Allah
May Allah reward you for these eye opening informations
The comparison between Paul and Umar is exactly what I was thinking about. As a convert, I see that the shia point of view is the closest to the original Islam.
Well then you’re severely ignorant.
1. Rafidhi Munafiqeen believe the Quran is distorted:
Kulayni. “Usool al-Kafy” vol. 2, Kitaab: Fadlul-Qur’an, narration # 28:
“Ali b. al-Hakam from Hishaam b. Salim from Abu Abdullah [as] saying: Verily, the Qur’an which Gibril [as] came up with to Muhammad [saw] is 17,000 verses”.
Majlisi said: ” This tradition (about 17000 verses in Quran) is authentic and it cannot be hidden that this traditon and many more authentic traditons are explicit in (saying) that the Quran is missing and has changed. For me, (I believe) that the traditions have reached tawatur (i.e they are numerous) with regards to the meaning, and ignoring all of it would mean ignoring all traditions accordingly , but I think that the narrations in this meaning are not less than the narrations if Imamah so how do they confirm it using traditions?”
Mirat Al-Uqool Vol 12 p. 525
* Al-Majlisi I (Majlisi’s Father) said this hadeeth is SaHeeH (Authentic) -> RawDah Al-Muttaqoon, vol. 10, pg. 21
* Hoor Al-‘Aamilee said this hadeeth is SaHeeH (authentic) -> Al-Fuwaa-id Al-Toosiyyah, topic # 96, pg. 483
2. Rafidhi munafiqeen believe the imams know everything: The foremost Shi’ite cleric Al-Kulaini mentioned in his book, Usul al-Kafi (1/258-260)
“If the Imams desire to know something, they come to know it. They know when they will die - and none of them dies unless they choose to do so themselves.”
Whilst Allah says in Surah Luqman 34 (interpretation of meaning) “No soul knows what it will earn for tomorrow, and no soul knows in what land it will die.”
Shia lies caught.
One of your Scholars, Hashim al-Bahrānī stated in his book, Yanābi’ ul-Ma’ājiz wa Usul ud-Dala’il (Chapter 5, p. 35-36) regarding the Twelve Imāms of the Shi’ah:
“They have knowledge of what is in the Heavens, and knowledge of what is in the Earth, they have knowledge of what has passed and they have knowledge of what is to come, and they know what happens in the night and the day, and from one hour to the next hour - and they have the knowledge possessed by the Prophets and even more than it.”
Whilst Allah says in Surah An-Naml 65: (interpretation of meaning) “None in the heavens and the earth has knowledge of the unseen except Allah. Nor do they know when they will be resurrected.”
Shia lies caught.
One of your important shaikhs of this era, Abdul-Muhsin al-Amini an-Najafi stated in his book Al-Ghadir (1/214-216):
“Verily the [Twelve] Imams are the sons of Allah and from the offspring of ‘Ali.”
@@Akhi_Umar
"O you who have believed, if there comes to you a disobedient one with information, investigate, lest you harm a people out of ignorance and become, over what you have done, regretful." Quran 49:6. Maybe it's time for you to really investigate what Shia believes are before calling them bad names, just as the Quranic verse advised. Copying paste fragments from sunni, wahabi or salafi books is not investigation and doesn't help anybody. Any judge has to hear the both sides of the story.
@@Akhi_Umarbro you gonna copy and paste ur comment on everybodies comment??😂😂😂
@@Chungu22 Yep
“ I sahih Muslim engaged sahih Muslim” funnest thing wallah
Thank you ustadh for the reality
Literally the greatest lecture I’ve ever heard
That’s so sad.
@@Akhi_Umar did you watch the video? He explained it really well
@@jamaicajohnson4373 You need to start watching more reliable lectures, you’d be surprised what’s out there.
The verse in the Quran truly makes sense when Allah says most people will be deaf blind and dumb ! No matter what proof you bring even from their own books they will still not understand the verses ! May Allah illuminate the minds of our Muslim brothers and open their hearts to what is just and right in general not necessary about this topic if they don’t like it but there are other topics too which they don’t like ! An advice from a Muslim revert to all brothers ! Read your own books and read the other side books so you can compare Otherwhise you cannot have an opinion regarding us as Shia ! I get slander so much and mocked and I have to explain myself all times , makes me tired ! Please pray for me so I get stronger during this Ramadan ! Ramadan Mubarak to everyone
Prophet a.s himself BANNED Mutah. See Muslim 1407C
I have read shia books,and mosguidance and Shirk in shia books is disturbing.
@@iMan-610 you start reading your own books first , which most of you you don’t read ! It’s Ramadan now maybe it’s the time to go and start reading them
@@iMan-610what is this brother? A man have just exposed a whole truth that has had contradictions thru history and this is your answer 👎🏼 We are fellow Muslims and take this video as learning, to strengthen your iman what is that comment? Is your only goal to separate us?
Wow mashallah great lecture
Sharing and liking.
ما شاء الله يحفظكم من مكروه يابن الزهراء عليها السلام
kis imk w emo
great job Sayed Ammar
The lies of the Rawafidh are blatant and will be exposed Insha’Allah .
1. Mutah forbidden in shii’ books: We find in Al-Istibsar by Al-Tusi (p. 689) from Mohammad bin Ahmad bin Yahya from Abi Al-Jawza’a from Al-Hussain bin Ulwan from Amr bin Khalid from Zaid bin Ali from his fathers from Ali - peace be upon him - that he said: The Messenger of Allah - peace be upon him - forbade the meat of the domestic donkey and mutah marriages.
2. Rafidhi Munafiqeen believe the Quran is distorted:
Kulayni. “Usool al-Kafy” vol. 2, Kitaab: Fadlul-Qur’an, narration # 28:
“Ali b. al-Hakam from Hishaam b. Salim from Abu Abdullah [as] saying: Verily, the Qur’an which Gibril [as] came up with to Muhammad [saw] is 17,000 verses”.
Majlisi said: ” This tradition (about 17000 verses in Quran) is authentic and it cannot be hidden that this traditon and many more authentic traditons are explicit in (saying) that the Quran is missing and has changed. For me, (I believe) that the traditions have reached tawatur (i.e they are numerous) with regards to the meaning, and ignoring all of it would mean ignoring all traditions accordingly , but I think that the narrations in this meaning are not less than the narrations if Imamah so how do they confirm it using traditions?”
Mirat Al-Uqool Vol 12 p. 525
* Al-Majlisi I (Majlisi’s Father) said this hadeeth is SaHeeH (Authentic) -> RawDah Al-Muttaqoon, vol. 10, pg. 21
* Hoor Al-‘Aamilee said this hadeeth is SaHeeH (authentic) -> Al-Fuwaa-id Al-Toosiyyah, topic # 96, pg. 483
3.
Rafidhi munafiqeen believe the imams know everything: The foremost Shi’ite cleric Al-Kulaini mentioned in his book, Usul al-Kafi (1/258-260)
“If the Imams desire to know something, they come to know it. They know when they will die - and none of them dies unless they choose to do so themselves.”
Whilst Allah says in Surah Luqman 34 (interpretation of meaning) “No soul knows what it will earn for tomorrow, and no soul knows in what land it will die.”
Shia lies caught.
One of your Scholars, Hashim al-Bahrānī stated in his book, Yanābi’ ul-Ma’ājiz wa Usul ud-Dala’il (Chapter 5, p. 35-36) regarding the Twelve Imāms of the Shi’ah:
“They have knowledge of what is in the Heavens, and knowledge of what is in the Earth, they have knowledge of what has passed and they have knowledge of what is to come, and they know what happens in the night and the day, and from one hour to the next hour - and they have the knowledge possessed by the Prophets and even more than it.”
Whilst Allah says in Surah An-Naml 65: (interpretation of meaning) “None in the heavens and the earth has knowledge of the unseen except Allah. Nor do they know when they will be resurrected.”
Shia lies caught.
One of your important shaikhs of this era, Abdul-Muhsin al-Amini an-Najafi stated in his book Al-Ghadir (1/214-216):
“Verily the [Twelve] Imams are the sons of Allah and from the offspring of ‘Ali.”
You’re a legend. This was destruction 😭
RIP Sunnism
@@RocketAfriqueZA how can something that was never alive RIP...
Lethal reply hahah.
@@RocketAfriqueZArip shia, fake religion, born in the toilet, ended up in the toilet
@@mujih7Good point tbh
FACT: It is not Wajib in SHIA Islam.
there is no shia islam, its either shia or islam
@@Ma5asak45 Pure Umari logic
@@Ma5asak45 you would have won with this one in the 19th century. Sadly, for you, world is more literate and connected
@@baqiliciousit is, but for some reason, the shia are still ignorant.
@@Ma5asak45 bring evidence or stop yapping!
😂 the repetition is clearly needed
Great Series !
“And I did not come out until the messenger of Allah forbade it” what does this mean ? So it was forbidden after? (31:25 into the video)
Please answer this, was wondering the same
He is highlighting that according to sunni books the ban has taken place multiple times and not just khybar …
He is one of the most top Islamic scholars that exists today. All his lectures are fantastic, this is one of his top in my opinion. I have many Sunni friends that mock many Shia traditions. Because of Sayed Ammar I have been able to show them the truth and put them in their place. May Allah bless you and all your family.
Mufti Menk said his role model is Abu Bakr lol great credibility for his followers. I’ll stick to rasoolallah and Ali
rasoolallah and ali are sunni figures
@@jj-yi1ne^^😂😂😂😂^^
@@jj-yi1ne
Incorrect. They are slandered as forgetful, sinful, drunkards etc. etc. within Bakri books
True love for Ahlul Bayt is only found within the Shi’a of Ali. Not the Bakri or Umari sects
1. Rafidhi Munafiqeen believe the Quran is distorted:
Kulayni. “Usool al-Kafy” vol. 2, Kitaab: Fadlul-Qur’an, narration # 28:
“Ali b. al-Hakam from Hishaam b. Salim from Abu Abdullah [as] saying: Verily, the Qur’an which Gibril [as] came up with to Muhammad [saw] is 17,000 verses”.
Majlisi said: ” This tradition (about 17000 verses in Quran) is authentic and it cannot be hidden that this traditon and many more authentic traditons are explicit in (saying) that the Quran is missing and has changed. For me, (I believe) that the traditions have reached tawatur (i.e they are numerous) with regards to the meaning, and ignoring all of it would mean ignoring all traditions accordingly , but I think that the narrations in this meaning are not less than the narrations if Imamah so how do they confirm it using traditions?”
Mirat Al-Uqool Vol 12 p. 525
* Al-Majlisi I (Majlisi’s Father) said this hadeeth is SaHeeH (Authentic) -> RawDah Al-Muttaqoon, vol. 10, pg. 21
* Hoor Al-‘Aamilee said this hadeeth is SaHeeH (authentic) -> Al-Fuwaa-id Al-Toosiyyah, topic # 96, pg. 483
2. Rafidhi munafiqeen believe the imams know everything: The foremost Shi’ite cleric Al-Kulaini mentioned in his book, Usul al-Kafi (1/258-260)
“If the Imams desire to know something, they come to know it. They know when they will die - and none of them dies unless they choose to do so themselves.”
Whilst Allah says in Surah Luqman 34 (interpretation of meaning) “No soul knows what it will earn for tomorrow, and no soul knows in what land it will die.”
Shia lies caught.
One of your Scholars, Hashim al-Bahrānī stated in his book, Yanābi’ ul-Ma’ājiz wa Usul ud-Dala’il (Chapter 5, p. 35-36) regarding the Twelve Imāms of the Shi’ah:
“They have knowledge of what is in the Heavens, and knowledge of what is in the Earth, they have knowledge of what has passed and they have knowledge of what is to come, and they know what happens in the night and the day, and from one hour to the next hour - and they have the knowledge possessed by the Prophets and even more than it.”
Whilst Allah says in Surah An-Naml 65: (interpretation of meaning) “None in the heavens and the earth has knowledge of the unseen except Allah. Nor do they know when they will be resurrected.”
Shia lies caught.
One of your important shaikhs of this era, Abdul-Muhsin al-Amini an-Najafi stated in his book Al-Ghadir (1/214-216):
“Verily the [Twelve] Imams are the sons of Allah and from the offspring of ‘Ali.”
@@corpsefoot758 1. Rafidhi Munafiqeen believe the Quran is distorted:
Kulayni. “Usool al-Kafy” vol. 2, Kitaab: Fadlul-Qur’an, narration # 28:
“Ali b. al-Hakam from Hishaam b. Salim from Abu Abdullah [as] saying: Verily, the Qur’an which Gibril [as] came up with to Muhammad [saw] is 17,000 verses”.
Majlisi said: ” This tradition (about 17000 verses in Quran) is authentic and it cannot be hidden that this traditon and many more authentic traditons are explicit in (saying) that the Quran is missing and has changed. For me, (I believe) that the traditions have reached tawatur (i.e they are numerous) with regards to the meaning, and ignoring all of it would mean ignoring all traditions accordingly , but I think that the narrations in this meaning are not less than the narrations if Imamah so how do they confirm it using traditions?”
Mirat Al-Uqool Vol 12 p. 525
* Al-Majlisi I (Majlisi’s Father) said this hadeeth is SaHeeH (Authentic) -> RawDah Al-Muttaqoon, vol. 10, pg. 21
* Hoor Al-‘Aamilee said this hadeeth is SaHeeH (authentic) -> Al-Fuwaa-id Al-Toosiyyah, topic # 96, pg. 483
2. Rafidhi munafiqeen believe the imams know everything: The foremost Shi’ite cleric Al-Kulaini mentioned in his book, Usul al-Kafi (1/258-260)
“If the Imams desire to know something, they come to know it. They know when they will die - and none of them dies unless they choose to do so themselves.”
Whilst Allah says in Surah Luqman 34 (interpretation of meaning) “No soul knows what it will earn for tomorrow, and no soul knows in what land it will die.”
Shia lies caught.
One of your Scholars, Hashim al-Bahrānī stated in his book, Yanābi’ ul-Ma’ājiz wa Usul ud-Dala’il (Chapter 5, p. 35-36) regarding the Twelve Imāms of the Shi’ah:
“They have knowledge of what is in the Heavens, and knowledge of what is in the Earth, they have knowledge of what has passed and they have knowledge of what is to come, and they know what happens in the night and the day, and from one hour to the next hour - and they have the knowledge possessed by the Prophets and even more than it.”
Whilst Allah says in Surah An-Naml 65: (interpretation of meaning) “None in the heavens and the earth has knowledge of the unseen except Allah. Nor do they know when they will be resurrected.”
Shia lies caught.
One of your important shaikhs of this era, Abdul-Muhsin al-Amini an-Najafi stated in his book Al-Ghadir (1/214-216):
“Verily the [Twelve] Imams are the sons of Allah and from the offspring of ‘Ali.”
Very interesting! History hides many answers.
45:45 May Allah reward you abundantly for all your hard work and efforts, for these thought provoking and eye opening discussions Ameen. May I ask, Is it possible that the practice of Mutah is used and abused or exploited, in current times? Some Sunnis practice Nikkah misyar which is similar. But in this type of marriage, women does not know end date, so she can be divorced 5 mins later. With mutah, end date is agreed in advance ❤
The book telescope needs too be a little closer so we can read it
So do we depend on the Sahih or Dhaeef hadith? And if it was banned during the farewell address, then when was it allowed again?
Some defend the religion from usurpers by sword, and some defend the religion from usurpers by word. This, my friend, is a mujahid in action. We are proud of you, seyed.
This is a very important topic. People need to learn how to defend your beliefs.... hes 100% correct when he says it was sanctioned by the HEAVENS! so why make fun?
Mabyd the one is battle of khaybar was only during war ?
I have a question. Did Prophet or Ahlul Bait ever do mut’ah? Is it true that there is no evidence of this in both Sunni or Shia books? Is it possible that they would promote something but not lead by example? It could be the case that they did mut’ah but it was not recorded in history. But if their divorces were recorded, which is something most disliked among halal things, then how is it possible that their Mut’ahs were not recorded, especially when there was a need to prove that it was halal as the then anti Shias believe it was haram?
Is it possible that Mutah is halal to support and protect only the destitute women and their children?
❤❤❤
golden!
The lies of the Rawafidh are blatant and will be exposed Insha’Allah .
1. Mutah forbidden in shii’ books: We find in Al-Istibsar by Al-Tusi (p. 689) from Mohammad bin Ahmad bin Yahya from Abi Al-Jawza’a from Al-Hussain bin Ulwan from Amr bin Khalid from Zaid bin Ali from his fathers from Ali - peace be upon him - that he said: The Messenger of Allah - peace be upon him - forbade the meat of the domestic donkey and mutah marriages.
2. Rafidhi Munafiqeen believe the Quran is distorted:
Kulayni. “Usool al-Kafy” vol. 2, Kitaab: Fadlul-Qur’an, narration # 28:
“Ali b. al-Hakam from Hishaam b. Salim from Abu Abdullah [as] saying: Verily, the Qur’an which Gibril [as] came up with to Muhammad [saw] is 17,000 verses”.
Majlisi said: ” This tradition (about 17000 verses in Quran) is authentic and it cannot be hidden that this traditon and many more authentic traditons are explicit in (saying) that the Quran is missing and has changed. For me, (I believe) that the traditions have reached tawatur (i.e they are numerous) with regards to the meaning, and ignoring all of it would mean ignoring all traditions accordingly , but I think that the narrations in this meaning are not less than the narrations if Imamah so how do they confirm it using traditions?”
Mirat Al-Uqool Vol 12 p. 525
* Al-Majlisi I (Majlisi’s Father) said this hadeeth is SaHeeH (Authentic) -> RawDah Al-Muttaqoon, vol. 10, pg. 21
* Hoor Al-‘Aamilee said this hadeeth is SaHeeH (authentic) -> Al-Fuwaa-id Al-Toosiyyah, topic # 96, pg. 483
3.
Rafidhi munafiqeen believe the imams know everything: The foremost Shi’ite cleric Al-Kulaini mentioned in his book, Usul al-Kafi (1/258-260)
“If the Imams desire to know something, they come to know it. They know when they will die - and none of them dies unless they choose to do so themselves.”
Whilst Allah says in Surah Luqman 34 (interpretation of meaning) “No soul knows what it will earn for tomorrow, and no soul knows in what land it will die.”
Shia lies caught.
One of your Scholars, Hashim al-Bahrānī stated in his book, Yanābi’ ul-Ma’ājiz wa Usul ud-Dala’il (Chapter 5, p. 35-36) regarding the Twelve Imāms of the Shi’ah:
“They have knowledge of what is in the Heavens, and knowledge of what is in the Earth, they have knowledge of what has passed and they have knowledge of what is to come, and they know what happens in the night and the day, and from one hour to the next hour - and they have the knowledge possessed by the Prophets and even more than it.”
Whilst Allah says in Surah An-Naml 65: (interpretation of meaning) “None in the heavens and the earth has knowledge of the unseen except Allah. Nor do they know when they will be resurrected.”
Shia lies caught.
One of your important shaikhs of this era, Abdul-Muhsin al-Amini an-Najafi stated in his book Al-Ghadir (1/214-216):
“Verily the [Twelve] Imams are the sons of Allah and from the offspring of ‘Ali.”
The lies of the Rawafidh are blatant and will be exposed Insha’Allah .
1. Mutah forbidden in shii’ books: We find in Al-Istibsar by Al-Tusi (p. 689) from Mohammad bin Ahmad bin Yahya from Abi Al-Jawza’a from Al-Hussain bin Ulwan from Amr bin Khalid from Zaid bin Ali from his fathers from Ali - peace be upon him - that he said: The Messenger of Allah - peace be upon him - forbade the meat of the domestic donkey and mutah marriages.
2. Rafidhi Munafiqeen believe the Quran is distorted:
Kulayni. “Usool al-Kafy” vol. 2, Kitaab: Fadlul-Qur’an, narration # 28:
“Ali b. al-Hakam from Hishaam b. Salim from Abu Abdullah [as] saying: Verily, the Qur’an which Gibril [as] came up with to Muhammad [saw] is 17,000 verses”.
Majlisi said: ” This tradition (about 17000 verses in Quran) is authentic and it cannot be hidden that this traditon and many more authentic traditons are explicit in (saying) that the Quran is missing and has changed. For me, (I believe) that the traditions have reached tawatur (i.e they are numerous) with regards to the meaning, and ignoring all of it would mean ignoring all traditions accordingly , but I think that the narrations in this meaning are not less than the narrations if Imamah so how do they confirm it using traditions?”
Mirat Al-Uqool Vol 12 p. 525
* Al-Majlisi I (Majlisi’s Father) said this hadeeth is SaHeeH (Authentic) -> RawDah Al-Muttaqoon, vol. 10, pg. 21
* Hoor Al-‘Aamilee said this hadeeth is SaHeeH (authentic) -> Al-Fuwaa-id Al-Toosiyyah, topic # 96, pg. 483
3.
Rafidhi munafiqeen believe the imams know everything: The foremost Shi’ite cleric Al-Kulaini mentioned in his book, Usul al-Kafi (1/258-260)
“If the Imams desire to know something, they come to know it. They know when they will die - and none of them dies unless they choose to do so themselves.”
Whilst Allah says in Surah Luqman 34 (interpretation of meaning) “No soul knows what it will earn for tomorrow, and no soul knows in what land it will die.”
Shia lies caught.
One of your Scholars, Hashim al-Bahrānī stated in his book, Yanābi’ ul-Ma’ājiz wa Usul ud-Dala’il (Chapter 5, p. 35-36) regarding the Twelve Imāms of the Shi’ah:
“They have knowledge of what is in the Heavens, and knowledge of what is in the Earth, they have knowledge of what has passed and they have knowledge of what is to come, and they know what happens in the night and the day, and from one hour to the next hour - and they have the knowledge possessed by the Prophets and even more than it.”
Whilst Allah says in Surah An-Naml 65: (interpretation of meaning) “None in the heavens and the earth has knowledge of the unseen except Allah. Nor do they know when they will be resurrected.”
Shia lies caught.
One of your important shaikhs of this era, Abdul-Muhsin al-Amini an-Najafi stated in his book Al-Ghadir (1/214-216):
“Verily the [Twelve] Imams are the sons of Allah and from the offspring of ‘Ali.”
❤❤
🎉
Thats Gud important Topics Disscussed
31:00 "I did not come out until the messanger of Allah forbade it" what does that mean?
What a legend 👍
The fact is sunni n syiah agreed nikah mut'ah were already in Ialam...they differ who prohibited it.
Sunnah said the Prophet (s) himself where by syiah said it was Umar prohibited it towards the end of his reign...
Histories and hadis recorded there are 20 sahabah still practicing nikah mut'ah after dimised of the Prophet (s)...
👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻
Mashaallah ❤
Assalamu alaikum!
A very important topic for all Muslims, regardless of their sects, especially in an era in which temptations are dominant. But I wish the sheikh would tell us about Imam Ali's (as) opinion on temporary marriage.
Thankyouu
Mashallah
Outstanding
Title should be how to expose the Sunnis in Mutah or their beliefs and hadith books.
no need to repeat! we get it :)
Trust me it needs to be repeated more times to our Sunni brothers always pointing at Shia doing this practise
❤
We hope that our Sunni brothers will turn to reason and make amendment.🇦🇫
masha Allah my inspire
My Sunni friend once told me that Shia are more knowledgeable than Sunni and he always tell me that he would prefer to be called a Muslim and my response was I am a Muslim with a preference to follow the teachings of our Prophet Muhammad (pbuh) and his Ahlulbayt
Shias are more knowledgeable. Tell me a good joke. You guys don’t even have proper Sahih collection.
Sheikh Sayed is amazing and shout out to the production team, which is amazing too
26:21 :) Sayed Ammar, we love you bro!!! :)
It makes sense if im a 65 year old man and divorced or widowed i meet a lady but have no intention of getting permanently married, because of financials or just because i dont want to live with anyone i would like to use the temporary marriage instead if the lady agrees.
That's not islam religion, its Shia religion...q
Islam is a very logical religion, if it's in the Quran who are you or anyone else to say it's forbidden. Of cause anything can be abused but as I showed there are times when mutah makes sense.
@binsuleiman-us2lm
It is you you have deviated from the right path and have divided into sects. Umar banned a practice that was allowed in Islam, by whose authority he is not the Prophet of God.
Sahih Muslim 3416
Ch 17 The Book of Marriage
Jabir b. 'Abdullah reported: We contracted
temporary marriage giving a handful of (tales or flour as a dowry) during the lifetime of Allah's Messenger SAWW and during the time of Abu Bakr
until `'Umar forbade it in the case of 'Amr b.Huraith.
@taqiuk4688 Totally agree there no one can make illegal what Allah says is legal, as followers of the Prophet's house hold we give full respect to the Prophet, and we do not take lightly anyone disrespecting him, and what some of his companions did after he left was disrespectful.
umer is hujjat for sunni people's not Quran and hadit
king omar is better than ali
@@Ma5asak45Omar was gay and have men penterate him.
@@Ma5asak45king Omar? 😂😂😂 Omar wasn’t a king. Kingship isn’t allowed in Islam. Only 1 king. ALLAH SWT. not your Omar
@@delavagavaga7540muwaiah AS was a king, ali was a king, thats what amir il mo2mnen means, and there i no rule agaisnt being a king in islam, you would know that if you were one.
@@Ma5asak45
Mu’awiya (LA) executed another Sahabi, Hujr bin Adiy.
I thought your Bakri sect “respects all Sahaba”, though?
Dr ammar what is halala in shia islam .i as a Muslim always get questioned by non Muslim about it and i am not able to answer it .
Secondly i want to know anout tripple talak .i know as a shia we have to whole process to get divorce and in sunni word it is just 3 word talak talak talak
That is true
If we don't look into hadith literature at all, but only in the Quran, shouldn't we conclude that verse about Muta'h is talking about the time of giving them their dowry. It is the time after we have pleasure with them, right? So, Quran alone doesn't speak about any temporary marriage, but only about the time of giving them their dowry. I am Quran alone oriented, so that is what I see from that verse...
Best speaker for Islam ❤
shia are not muslim
The lies of the Rawafidh are blatant and will be exposed Insha’Allah .
1. Mutah forbidden in shii’ books: We find in Al-Istibsar by Al-Tusi (p. 689) from Mohammad bin Ahmad bin Yahya from Abi Al-Jawza’a from Al-Hussain bin Ulwan from Amr bin Khalid from Zaid bin Ali from his fathers from Ali - peace be upon him - that he said: The Messenger of Allah - peace be upon him - forbade the meat of the domestic donkey and mutah marriages.
2. Rafidhi Munafiqeen believe the Quran is distorted:
Kulayni. “Usool al-Kafy” vol. 2, Kitaab: Fadlul-Qur’an, narration # 28:
“Ali b. al-Hakam from Hishaam b. Salim from Abu Abdullah [as] saying: Verily, the Qur’an which Gibril [as] came up with to Muhammad [saw] is 17,000 verses”.
Majlisi said: ” This tradition (about 17000 verses in Quran) is authentic and it cannot be hidden that this traditon and many more authentic traditons are explicit in (saying) that the Quran is missing and has changed. For me, (I believe) that the traditions have reached tawatur (i.e they are numerous) with regards to the meaning, and ignoring all of it would mean ignoring all traditions accordingly , but I think that the narrations in this meaning are not less than the narrations if Imamah so how do they confirm it using traditions?”
Mirat Al-Uqool Vol 12 p. 525
* Al-Majlisi I (Majlisi’s Father) said this hadeeth is SaHeeH (Authentic) -> RawDah Al-Muttaqoon, vol. 10, pg. 21
* Hoor Al-‘Aamilee said this hadeeth is SaHeeH (authentic) -> Al-Fuwaa-id Al-Toosiyyah, topic # 96, pg. 483
3.
Rafidhi munafiqeen believe the imams know everything: The foremost Shi’ite cleric Al-Kulaini mentioned in his book, Usul al-Kafi (1/258-260)
“If the Imams desire to know something, they come to know it. They know when they will die - and none of them dies unless they choose to do so themselves.”
Whilst Allah says in Surah Luqman 34 (interpretation of meaning) “No soul knows what it will earn for tomorrow, and no soul knows in what land it will die.”
Shia lies caught.
One of your Scholars, Hashim al-Bahrānī stated in his book, Yanābi’ ul-Ma’ājiz wa Usul ud-Dala’il (Chapter 5, p. 35-36) regarding the Twelve Imāms of the Shi’ah:
“They have knowledge of what is in the Heavens, and knowledge of what is in the Earth, they have knowledge of what has passed and they have knowledge of what is to come, and they know what happens in the night and the day, and from one hour to the next hour - and they have the knowledge possessed by the Prophets and even more than it.”
Whilst Allah says in Surah An-Naml 65: (interpretation of meaning) “None in the heavens and the earth has knowledge of the unseen except Allah. Nor do they know when they will be resurrected.”
Shia lies caught.
One of your important shaikhs of this era, Abdul-Muhsin al-Amini an-Najafi stated in his book Al-Ghadir (1/214-216):
“Verily the [Twelve] Imams are the sons of Allah and from the offspring of ‘Ali.”
Masha الله Sheik,I love ur works may الله grant u Jannah with the Imam Insha الله
subhanAllaah. May we all return to the Sunnah of Prophet sallalaho-alayhe-wa-alayh
Is shamless how they are willing to throw their prophet under dr the bus for person that I don't ever believe was a true muslim.who is Omar the fact is if they accept the fact their whole life livelihood business friends and life as they know it will be destroyed they rather have this life than the Jana worse than the jeuw village worst than them sham on you mufti and your cronies that will never accept the truth as is in Koran your eyes and hearts are sealed
Does Muhammad have even the authority to stop Mutah?
Since it’s from Allah in the Quran
So how can a man abrogate Allahs words?
“He (i.e. the Prophet) does not speak of his own desire, it is nothing but a revelation revealed.” (53:3-4)
he forbade it during specific days of that certain war if im understanding correctly? which would make sense?
@@sammarabbas1914 if u keep reading the next verses you will see it’s referring to revelation brought down by the angel
Otherwise this would contradict Quran 33:37 where it shows Muhammad speaking of his own desires not Gods words as you were alluding to.
Let me know what u think.
@@glitchinthematrix9306 it’s possible but personally it seems that those Hadith prolly aren’t legit.
Since I doubt Muhammad would believe his words can abrogate Allahs even for a day.
Regardless both are possible
@@Sks750s The Holy Prophet (saws) may do and say things that are not written in the Holy Quran, but does not mean his actions or words are from him/desire, rather “He (i.e. the Prophet) does not speak of his own desire, it is nothing but a revelation revealed.” (53:3-4)", as brother @sammarabbas1914 mentioned.
If the Holy Prophet (saws) forbids something, (temporarily or permanently), it is from Allah (swt) and not his own opinion.
Marshallah, Sayed Ammar you do justice to your Ph.D. Unlike some Muslim pseudo scholars you provide evidence from the Sunni school that support Shia believe and practices. I am having a dim view of Omar just now. Just like non Muslims scoff about we marrying up to 4 wives (with conditions) and they keeping mistresses ( no issue for them) Mutah makes our temporary desire Halal while Omar's prohibition cause our desperate Sheikhs to go to Lebanon, Africa and the West to commit zena. Thanks to Omar.
Who can forbid what Allah prohibits? A mu'min?
Pls highlight the health of the hadith and the chain of narration as per different scholars. They are graded according to the authenticity of narrations. Mere reference to the hadith is not acceptable argument in the academicia and could be misleading.
Omar (LA) the king of Bidaah
king omar is better than ali, cry majosi
@@Ma5asak45 the one who changes rulings of the Holy Prophet (PBUH) is only a clown not a king. And you shall be raised with your clown leader on day of judgement.
@@Ma5asak45
Umar himself admitted jealousy of Ali on multiple occasions
All you have is a pile of lies lol
@@corpsefoot758nope, typical fake news shia
@@syedhabbas1thankful king omar AS didnt do anything the majos claim he did
As much as I am free from Shiism the analysis of mutah is sound. Mutah is more valid than misyar.
the way he skims the word messenger of Allah forbade like it didnt exist.. 31:26
Brother: Im not Suni but muslim. All the passages you have gone through show that ,yes, Mutah marriage was acceptable but later on prohibited. If the practice continued to be allowed as you struggled to demonstrate, why would the companions require permission from the prophet every time they wanted to engage? Don't you see that this by itself demonstrates that permission was only given on special cases by the prophet himself because he knew in which situation they were in?
Exactly what I was thinking.
We can also say it was permitted by default and hence, prophet should have temporarily prohibited it everytime
anyways I prefer not to go around this marriage as its not 100% clear
@mahdifalahi5900 What I really don't understand is leaving the religion aside. Why would someone want to engage on this? And the shias seem to like it so much so that they will go and dig every possible reason to justify it. Yes, we should all just stop it.
@@ssmamry it's not common in shia society at all, but in the end it's mentioned in Quran and part of prophet's sunnah and was happening in the time of Abubakar as well. Anyways I don't find this a big issue rather a difference in readings of hadith.
@@ssmamryMisiyari and Halala Nikkah. Do you really think the Shuyukh in Saudi are clean ?