Hong Kong is DANGEROUS!
Вставка
- Опубліковано 13 чер 2019
- What is happening right now in Hong Kong can affect you! It's a massive eye-opener!
Tune in for our live show this coming Thursday about Hong Kong over on the ADVPodcasts channel: / advpodcasts
Dave's instagram @coulsondave
Stay Awesome China (my new documentary): vimeo.com/ondemand/stayawesom...
Discount code: STAYAWESOME
For Motorcycle adventures around the world, and a talk-show on two wheels go to ADVChina every Monday 1pm EST
/ advchina
Cost Of Living in Vietnam vs. China
• Go to Vietnam, NOT China!
For a realistic perspective on China and world travel from an American father and a Chinese mother with two half-Chinese daughters go to Laowhy86 every Wednesday 1pm EST
• Chinese People Won't T...
The End of Hong Kong - Extradition Law Explained
• The End of Hong Kong -...
For a no-nonsense on the street look at Chinese culture and beyond from China's original UA-camr, join SerpentZA on Friday at 1pm EST
/ serpentza
How China stops Overseas Students Integrating
• How China stops Overse...
Support Sasha and I on Patreon: / serpentza
Join me on Facebook: / winstoninchina
Twitter: @serpentza
Instagram: serpent_za
Well, as a HongKonger, i can tell you that you cant say anything bad about CCP in Hong Kong anymore.
Unless you wanna go to jail.
China is the best place in the planet!.. he he.
China, the nation of the best government system, the nation of the bear pooh
Farewell,Brother. Sorry to hear that.
@@neometalx9 yes,yes. And my Penis is an AK47
@@hahgay3837 say with me, China rules!.
Without a doubt. Hong Kong has has made such a huge impact on me. My most memorable memories has came from that city. It is such and amazing place that I always urge everyone to visit. I applaud you and C-Milk for making these videos. Respect
Thanks mate! Yeah we can't stay silent on this one, Hong Kong is too important and too special
"I wish I could have been to Tibet before China got there" - David Attenborough
"I wish I could have been to Hong Kong before China got there" - me after watching this video
Maybe China destroys the system of HK, however, the Tibet before China is total hell...You could search the web and have some knowledge about how the Tibet authority treats Tibet people, or they should be called slaves ...
@@xiaolongwang6657 Maybe you are right. But Attenborough didn't talk about Tibet from the perspective of politics. He is a naturalist; he was talking about the environment.
I decided to quote him because I think that destruction of both, the political culture of Hong Kong & ecology of Tibet, stem from the same source - the imperialist actions of CCP.
@@shaktiman11 Okay... Hong Kong will be stable than even and dead...it is history now.
I was lucky to go before China took over. But now it looks like I might not be able to go back.
@@shaktiman11 These peaceful monks in Tibet used to drink wine from human skulls.
After living in China for nearly 7 years myself, this kind of stuff is what drove me away. Not just the gross behavior of spitting, snot blowing, and public urination/defication (which is done everywhere, even in upscale buildings), but also the staring, the pushing to get on or off public transit, the general rudeness...it wears you down.
I moved to Hong Kong from New Delhi to work as a Computer Engineer. Never did I imagine that a city could impress me this much!
The amazing culturally rich museums, A night life 2nd to none (Oh the memories at lkf...), The really amazing and diverse group of people you meet, Absolutely gorgeous skyline and equally gorgeous nature hikes, public parks and beaches, The reliant MTR and the buses that run all night to ensure you'd get home safe....I can really keep going until I get to the max limit.
I am so glad and feel lucky that I got a chance to live in this city before CCP got its hands on it.
Long live Hong Kong!
@boshi liu you ARE shit right now!
tears in my eyes while watching this after a year.. everything sucks a little bit more but we started to see hope
I really hope one day you all can be free again, the sooner the better. I wish that the world would help you more, stay strong HK.
Was the bill passed?
Lived in HK for 25 years when it was British, still consider it home and have brothers there, Its a great place. Hope it survives.
Hi from Oamaru, Waitaki Districts New Zealand Tony.
I hope all is well there?.
Hey may i ask which part of H.K?.
We had a flat on Sai Yeung Kai just off Nathan Rd up to 7 yrs ago but made to sell it as we got over ruled as all majority of other owners wanted to sell. It was a 1950's era flat the size of 6 x 4 meters on a 6 level building with no lift. We sold it for $H.K.d 5 million but i reckon we may had got more .
Cheers Carl
@@conmanumber1 we lived all over HK over 30+ years, Sai kung, The peak, repulse bay 2 times and NT. My Father worked for Crown motors, Toyota..
@@tonyyoung6951 I remember Uncle sending Walkie Talkies and a Hitachi cassete recorder to us in 1977 when shopping was cool back then and our dollar got 5 H.Kd. the Nritish at that time came to N.Z and they got for their lb Steriling $3.00. now we are so low we only can buy 65 American cents per dollar.
I think we now get better rate from Canada...Carl
When did it stop being british?
@@deadinside8781 1997
We all admire your courage to speak the truth, Winston. Be awesome and be safe, my friend.
Great points well presented, good mix of facts with your own opinion thrown in, keep it up!
Taiwan will be the last chinese democracy country . .
Taiwanese people don't see themselves as Chinese anymore for the most part, most Taiwanese see China as a foreign country Taiwan is it's own thing. China and Taiwan split in my opinion in 1850.
@@iceomistar4302 as race . . Not nationality . .
Im chinese but indonesian as nationality . .
@Ne Zha idk how long communism can last in a capitalist country . .. once the economic ruined, there will be more people start talking politic . .
@@eliungcong No, Singapore will last longer than Taiwan because they are not on land claimed by China. Also remember that new Chinese countries may prop up over next century. Vancouver will be majority Chinese city soon. Over next few decades British Columbia or at least part of it will probably break away and become new a Chinese Country. Same thing could happen in Southern California.
Hi Winston, as an expat Aussie married to a Hong Konger and our daughter we absolutely applaud you Sir for doing this video and more importantly taking the ""HIGH RISK"" in doing this report you have done, your an absolutely rock solid person with genuine principals and beliefs and true values, and I can say without doubt my wife, daughter and myself are completely with your thoughts all the way, Thank You so much for risking your own personal security, we absolutely appreciate you and your UA-cam Channel very much indeed.
Regards and Many Thanks, and we would like to help support your channel also, so we will be in touch soon Winston 🙏🇭🇰🇦🇺
I used to visit Hong Kong quite a lot between the early 80’s till the end of the 90’s. I was a flight crew then and Hong Kong was indeed one of my favorite stop over cities across the world. The vibrancy and pulsating culture and tradition amongst such a diverse society. I’ve also made quite a few local friends in Hong Kong during my tour of duty whenever I get a chance to stop over. The hospitality and charm of Hongkongers amazes me a great deal and has made an impeccable imprint in my life. Unfortunately ever since the umbrella movement and the kill the Bill protest in 2019, many of the friends I know and the people I’ve been acquainted to at one point in time have left the colony. Many changes have taken place in Hong Kong as new laws are being enforced from time to time to clamp down on anti-ccp movements, anti-ccp sentiments or anything at all pertaining to shedding bad light on the ccp. Though my last stop over in Hong Kong was the early part of 2000 where i transit there for two nights from Hainan island before homeward bound and needless to say a wave of nostalgia swept over me when I saw Hong Kong again. That was and will perhaps be my last memory of the awesome Hong Kong I’ve come to experience personally in my lifetime. 🙏
I have been many times in China and in Hong Kong, and HK is really a different country in all the good ways. CCP should better keep their fatty greddy fingers off this nice place.
Well, not anymore.
Snaga Klem Nation they shady
well, that was quick... ultimate ko to all hk dreams about independence and others..
but well, HK is from China in the end, they can enforce the country law on a territory from its own country i guess, and thats pretty much what they did and holding on.
too late
homg kong belomgs to china and ccp needsto maintain law and order or hkg will be destroyed
Freedom is NOT free. It's worth fighting for. My heart and mind are with Hong Kong people.
2nd Amendment is what you need.
In 1986 the song "Impossible Dream" was popularized in the ousting of Marcos. Today, Philippines has digressed and reverted back in some aspects. We see vestiges of the rule of the lawless and road anarchy. For those million HK protesters who sacrificed today for what they believed in, I hope that it will has lasting effect until 2047.
this comment almost made me vomit.
A girl worth fighting for!!! Have to let that one out.
True I feel sorry for the citizen of Hong Kong.
Give me a break , You don't even have freedom of thought. Look up "REMOTE NEURAL MONITORING", in short they are using technology to read your thoughts, are using AI to monitor your thoughts. And I know what I am talking about, I am not just passing on 2nd hand information.
I am from Hong Kong and living in the US now. Whatever you were saying here is SO TRUE! I hope more and more people will be viewing all of your videos.
I am glad u are here . China is oppressing Chinese people
You could help with the Chinese translation and spread it around.
@@hotpepper5037 non-chinese people are too busy with all the drama between communist huawei of china and usa
I am from mainland China, I also support all the Hong Kongers, you are brave!
Most chinese in and out of china are completely brainwashed by the ccp, lots of them in malaysia, singapore and australia.
I went to Hong Kong just before the protests started and absolutely loved Hong Kong. It is indeed a jewel. I'd previously been to mainland China twice and could definitely sense the difference in culture with Hong Kong. Thanks for taking a strong stand Winston. It's good that you can now speak your mind openly while outside of China, however you have to have great caution if you intend to return to China at any stage. Take care buddy.
@Dark Vadertrauebrein It did appear a bit polluted, but i could not tell how much was pollution and how much was atmospheric conditions. It was very hazy, but the air did not seem polluted. I went there in early June this year. From the top of the International Commerce Center, the view was not that great, i have to admit. But still, i loved the food and culture. It was great up Victoria Peak too.
人山人海，horrendous! No way l would live there or be a tourist there.
It’s good now that you can share your experiences with us, since you married a Chinese, will she ever be able to visit her family in mainland?
@@JHall-dl1sb Did you mean to reply to me or Winston? I didn't marry a Chinese girl. My opinions remain the same about Hong Kong. I really enjoyed it there. On a wider note, I'm not a fan of the CCP, but I like China in general and definitely Hoing Kong.
To Justburger, sorry! The reply was to Winston, l messed up.
I live in Hong Kong,and I love my city,I will protect it.
Cat Silver that means you are a protester
Hussain Ali Musa Yes,I am
Cat Silver so did you protest in mong kok yesterday
Chengshun (Shuin) Tan are you from China
You block the airport. You are selfish.
As a clueless foreigner who has just started living in Hong Kong, I really love your channel full of contents that I find knowledgeable and useful.
You're a fool if you support this. That hk was stolen by the British during the opium war to begin with was disgusting as it is, now a few of those morons have Stockholm syndrome and want to run off with their rapist
@@goldsilvervscrisiscollapse4320 The Hong Kong people are fighting for freedom and democracy. The people protesting at 16:18 are holding signs of "No extradition (to China)". So tell me, how does it relate to Stockholm syndrome?
@@John-mu2zz Stockholm syndrome is a condition which causes hostages to develop a psychological alliance with their captors as a survival strategy during captivity.
HK was kidnapped during the Opium War, and while the Colonial masters did bring much wealth to the nation, much of this opulence came from China when it was forced to trade with the Brits via HK- this is largely forgotten to this day. in truth, neither HK nor their masters were the cause of HK's rise, for really the Brits could have chosen any rock strategically positioned near China for a trading post.
For this reason, even after being "freed" HK still sees itself as having more in common with the UK, despite NEVER having had any democratic freedoms while under colonial rule. Why Britain the kidnapper is seen as a better master than China, the rape victim is thanks to Western dominance of the media
@@goldsilvervscrisiscollapse4320
Dude. What are you talking about?
Yes, it is Stockholm syndrome what you're describing. But you can't apply that on a a group of several million people over four generations. That's not how psychology works.
Also, Hong Kong Chinese could leave Hong Kong anytime. There were not kidnapped. Without being kidnapped they couldn't develop Stockholm syndrome.
On top of that many mainland Chinese and people from other nations immigrated to Hong Kong. BECAUSE IT'S SO AWESOME. Why would somebody voluntary go into abduction? Why would somebody want to be kidnapped? That Stockholm syndrome comparison is nonsense. Yes, you're right: lot's of things went wrong in the day. But Hong Kong is awesome today nevertheless.
At last you would never, NEVER, N E V E R ! ! ! talk like you do if you've been to mainland China AND Hong Kong. Never.
I just visited to hongkong, amazing city, very nice people...
People are very helpful..
I still remember the lady that helped me alot to reach at my office on first day as I am unable to explain address to bus driver...She was awesome like all other people in HK, I was there for just 4 days before coming to china ..
Love you HK...
Saurabh vijayvargiya HK is not china😁
I lived in China and Hong Kong for a couple of years in the mid 1970s. The people in Hong Kong at that time had a great fear of being handed back to China. I met many wonderful people in Hong Kong and a few in China, although the only people I usually spoke to in China were interpreters, Chinese Teacher, taxi drivers, staff and a few others, normal citizens were too frightened to speak to me except for the children who wanted to practice their English, and they all called me Joe. There were numerous reports of Hong Kong locals being kidnapped and taken to China on boats. I had an English friend who worked for the Hong Kong Shanghai Banking Corporation who was kidnapped and thrown in a Shanghai jail for eight months during a dispute between China and Britain, after which he immigrated to New Zealand.
I'm a HongKonger and so, thank you.
Hope your safe!
Hey now gorgeous !
Fuck hong kong shithole,
And also, you are not a hongkongner, you are a CHINESE! So get that right ar first
@Daniel Oliveira so my Japanese friend is Chinese? My German friend is Chinese?
Well Hong Kong freedom is over which is sad
Title should be "Hong Kong is in danger"
Then it wouldn't get that much views. That's usually better for UA-cam in my view, but would it be in this case¿
ur right😊
That's one of the clickbait techniques.
remember, he lives in China
Yeah i find Serpentza videos very informative but i wish he stops with these clickbait titles (and most importantly the thumbnails), i don't think he needs them.
As an 18 year old kid who have lived in this place for my whole life having both parents from Hong Kong, I am blessed to be aware and educated of the things that have occurred around the world because of the freedom we have in the pursuit of knowledge and truth. I do not want to lose the freedom to speak confidently in peace about my views about the society. The government has recently delayed the extradition law from passing i hope it never passes in the future. Bless Hong Kong.
3 years have passed. Im so sorry. My heart cries for hong kong. I hope you are safe and well.
Agree, HK is so beautiful and even glamorous. It's a diamond and like a different world.
Hong Kong is love, Hong Kong is life.
Just a cramped concrete jungle with lots of Rolex and Prada ads.
I have heard it called the Pearl of the Pacific.
@J K npc spotted
@J K lmao y u mad bro, seriously, the Chinese government doesn't care about you, this guy speaks from a neutral point of view and and looks at things objectively, you people seem to be the only ones spreading 'vicious lies and misinformation' lmao do you really believe the shit you're typing or are they paying you lmao i really wonder
I visited Hong Kong several times during the mid 1960s while I was in the US Navy. Pretty amazing place I thought. A buddy and I stepped out of what was called the China Fleet Club wondering what we were going to do and how we were going to do it. A man approached us and told us that for 25 US dollars each, he would drive us around the city and show us all the sights. He had a black Mercedes and as neither of us had ever been in one we said OK. We also figured that once we got out at the first stop, that would be the last we saw of the guy. Not so! He did take us all over, including up into the hills where the "rich British" lived. He finally let us out at dark in front of a steak restaurant. He was a great guy and we had one of the best meals ever, then we took the boat back out to our ship at anchor in the harbor. We never once felt unsafe.
Sadly Hongkong is eventually going to be at best swallowed by the mainland party or at worst cause an international crisis, the more depressing part is that Hongkong isn't the only thing the mainland government has set its sights on.
If it falls will Macau and Taiwan be next?
haha LOL haha, Macau maybe. Taiwan can put up a fight but more importantly tens of millions of Americans livelihood depends on trade with Taiwan and the U.S. Navy exists to keep the trade lanes open.
@@hahaLOLhaha72 Taiwan is it own country and probably not because close relation with the United States. And for Macau probably not because it's part of Portugal colonies and Macau Is Part with the EU.
You know bout CCP plans for the Philippines?
Q S Sri Lanka already handed over their port to China by default under the Belt n Road Initiative....red flag !
I’m a Hong Konger and I’ve watched your videos for years. Thank you for covering this important topic ❤️
China number one
@Tin Jenny Stay strong, the EU is with Hong Kong.
Me too 多謝你
What are people going to do? Try to move out to a western country?
Maybe if they don't pass this extradition law China has something worse in mind
Admire your courage, Winston...well done.
@One Time why do you have to say stupid? Are you mainlander?
You are not allowed to be courageous or brave in CHINA!!!! That's the ugly truth between China and HK.
Also amazing way he explained the bill! People who lived in a western culture just can't explain it very well, and he summed it up perfectly even without too much context
It's such a shame the CCP laws have been passed in Hong Kong ,I feel your pain and feel the Hong Kong people are true heroes for continuing with there demonstrations ,I live in the UK and are mp,s are so nieve and weak I'm sure we shall have the same problems here very soon . Just think of the economy ,that's are mp,s
I was in HK a couple of years ago. Absolutely love the city. Clean, organised, yet fun and a nice asian flavour.
Very sad to see it being sucked into the mainland politics.
I think Hong Kong is not as organized and clean as Tokyo.
Might be. Don‘t know, have not visited Tokyo (yet).
Triple D
Toyko. Is beautiful 👊🏽
R-Mon Solace I‘ll accept invitations ;-)
Triple D my home country Macau is cleaner and mote organized
Thank you Winston and C-Milk for dedicating this week to us people of Hong Kong. We are so proud of you!
Sonny Chow Bow to XI!!!!
@@cgreglenfound8421 go duck yourself.
Sonny - the people of HK have many millions of supporters throughout the world
haha you can thank him but one thing you should know is: he's paid
Stand up for what you believe it, never give up. Best wishes.
Thanks to British government Hongkong became a civilized society .. I Love Hongkong .. I work for 25 years in HK .
Thank you for your honest commentary on a very serious situation keep up the excellent work
"Good ol' Winnie the Pooh" that got a laugh out of me. Great video man. I 110% agree.
I wish my college instructors were this interesting . But that was many years ago . Thanks for the news in an educational non political manor .
Winston will make a good Professor of Asian studies with emphasis on China. He;s cocky, condescendingly arrogant (typical African) and knows his shit. He's got the uppity superiority charisma down to an art. The guy's well blended and balanced Renaissance man. Teaching and holding seminars will be perfect trade for him.
Most of them wont even talk about the negatives of China, atleast not in the west.
Why watch CNN when I have honest commentary with Winston...great job...you live there and can talk the talk, because you have walked the walk, thank you, keep up the informative commentary...
The Extradition Ordinance is not like what you said... the people who abuse the Chinese government will not be extradited! You should really go back to the beginning, the ordinance itself then reconsider what you should say to the people only can get information in English and UA-cam and CNN.
CNN is shit. They only like to say one sided things without perspective of people.
why watch CNN anyway?
CNN is filthy propaganda lies
C*NN is go*v contr*olled prap*aganda.
"Hong Kong is the most beautiful city. It is the most amazing international place and anyone who's spent any time there will be able to vouch for that."
I fully agree with this statement. Hong Kong is incredible. I was just blown away during my trip there last year 👍🏼
The people of Taiwan must be watching what is happening to Hong Kong very closely. And hopefully they will vote accordingly.
Unbelievably there is a political faction in Taiwan that desires closer cooperation with the PRC. Hopefully this ordeal convinces them not to give the PRC even an inch. "One country, two systems" is a lie.
@@brettfafata3017 which faction is that?
@@zd1322 Kuomintang
@boshi liu What system should that be though? Communism?
@People Evil It is certainly the more traditional and worthy arbiter of Chinese civilization than is the commified Mainland. The Mainland destroyed what was left of Chinese culture and history with The Great Leap _Backwards_ , and the Guomindang took it with them to Taiwan.
Coming from a Hong Konger, your video clearly explained the situation, and is really well made, thank you for supporting us!
So I shouldn't come teach English there? Taiwan?
Singapore is much better than Hong Kong now. But why don’t they ask Singapore to be more democratic?
@@wisetour4ever If you say down with CCP in mainland China, you disappear at least for a while. If you say down with Singapore government in Singapore, you'll be fine. That's the main difference. The freedom of Speech is the main difference. Deng xiaoping was right about a lot of things. Unfortunately, Xi is not so open to see that.
Add oil, Hong Kong!
@@yufengliu836 what's freedom of speech? even USA calls free press "fake news". What do you really know? in Singapore you say shit about that peninsula they FROCK you you idiot
That guy blowing his nose all up in the air and his hands is truly disgusting 🤮
I was in Hong Kong the end of last November. Wound up in a protest on a Saturday night. Loved Hong Kong and look forward to visiting again.
I am a Korean and my gf is from Hongkong. Your video touches me a lot, just like you said “Hongkong is a jewel of Asia”. If anybody ever visited hongkong he/she will love this place. The hongkong movie was dead after 1997, I don’t want the beautiful night view die someday in the future. Strongly support hk people, love from Korea.
You're a fool if you support this. That hk was stolen by the British during the opium war to begin with was disgusting as it is, now a few of those morons have Stockholm syndrome and want to run off with their rapist
@Franklin Lockhart 50 cent army detected.
1st Hk population is not just 2 million, 2nd HK 's economy depends on mainland China, without mainland China support, Hk will be another argtila
@Franklin Lockhart thanks for your passionate comment. It proves my point: 50 cent army are a bunch of riffraff who resort to verbal abuse to promote their ideology. Hmm I wonder if that is an effective strategy to win the heart of the people? But I guess you guys like to make war not love. Well anyway I am getting lazy to make any more comments; can't be bothered to give you financial incentive to earn an extra 50 cent with your comments.
What happened in Hong Kong serves a wake up call for the rest of the world.
nobody cares man its internal china now game over you.s are on your own
@munchkin42 It doesnt matter , its still and internal problem. Absolutly nobody is going to react. Tell me who is strong eaugh to beat China? The entire world is depened on it for production. China is Earth's workshop. The British empire that build that city is gone , the UK cant even solve its own parlament , let alone help its former colony. The US? - Trump can talk as much he want ,but he cant do anything because he knows that China has a loaded gun - 28% of US forain dept (1.12 Trilion USD). If Chaina wants , they can ruin the US econamy in 1 day - just dump all that goverment bonds to the stock market and watch how the USD becomes worthless.
Who esle is left? India? - they cant even solve their major problems, let alone save someone esle.
It pains me ,but HK is on her own - nobody is going to help them. In Europe -the protests are not even covered in the media (in Bulgaria - just 1 short news article and that is it), look at the EU news agensies - blackout.
@@mowtow90 US bonds held by China isn't a big deal. Both Japan and China want to keep the value of the dollar higher than the value of their own currencies, because they want to export. Drop the value of the dollar and everyone around the world will flock to US suppliers(goods and services). Then the US will be the export king and shitty plastic manufacturing will move back to the US. In the current state the US economy is growing while the Chinese economy is about to go bust as manufacturing moves out of China to other parts of the world.
The US isn't reliant on other countries as much as you think. The US economy is driven by advancement in idea's mostly. The US can have those idea's manufactured any where. China can't have advancement in idea's if people are scared to talk about things openly with each other. The US can debate every aspect of every idea about everything until the best idea is then moved forward. This is the reason other countries especially those countries that do not have freedom of speech will never beat the US.
Remember my brothers and sisters, we are avengers if China is Thanos. Whatever it takes. We are very tired fighting against China. Please help us. We hang in there, but don't know one day we will have to become the commie Chinese, many people in Hong Kong have become part of the ccp, they are quasi communists, they are so strong. They try to assimilate the people of Hong Kong. If you know what I mean.
munchkin42 i can see any fear among them
It has been a year when the protest began. I had watched this video a year ago and i founded this video encouraging. I never thought the tide was so rough that lots of Hong Kongers were injured and founded guilty unreasonably. This time when i watch the video again, i am heartbreaking. We Hong Kongers have already tried our best to defend our freedom of speech and human right since the bomb ignited. However, our goal seems moving far away from us. We all know it is a tough age but we never surrender. Thank you for everyone supporting over the world. All the best!!
I always hoped that China would be like Hong Kong in the future. Now it seems more likely that the opposite happens.
reality can often be disappointing
I was hoping for that too. Hong Kong and Taiwan lifting the mainland up would have been an awesome thing to see. But looks like the poison of communism will drag down all of the chinese civilisation.
The great leap backward.
Mainland Chinese population outnumbered Hong Kong's population. With CCP in charge it looks like the opposite happens, which is inevitable and unfortunate.
@@praisejesus6750 no way. Mainland china detest the Taiwanese culture. They want to keep their people in a proletariat and ignorant fashion.
Really good points. As a mainland Chinese person, I will educate myself and my children to be more civilized.
That's why I still have hope
@Nav V "mainland Chinese" people don't live in the US, imbecile...
Hrundi Bakshi was a joke
@@hrundibakshi6830 yet it still shithole country were mass killings take place and most in importantly look at USA president being extremely ultra stupid live on camera in front of entire world. No specially Americans should ever have opinion on such issue. Look at their evil history.
Anyale Cawale so u r labelling a Country only by their worst points?
Thank you so so much for sharing what's happening in Hong Kong right now. It's a long story and you've explained it exceptionally well. We really, truly appreciate it.
HK is one of my favorite cities. Been there many times. I hope the HK people can safely and peacefully get what they're fighting for.
Thank you 💛
Peace is not an option in Hong Kong sadly.
Ofc, thanks for your support anyway🙏
naa, it wont happen, HK is a special territory from China but still their territory, other countries might do similar if one of their cities try to go independent from the country.
@@neometalx9 HK never "tried to go independent" from anything.
Yep - been to HK three times. You DO NOT lie! Its an amazing city =)
sorry for using your comment bro but i should say - Britain did nothing except colonial atrocities. It is only chinese men who built HK. Saying that not even being chinese
@@user-fj6mf3xv4p i disagree. if it wasnt because of the british taking over hk for the times they did, HK would be a lot less significant that it is today
@@user-fj6mf3xv4p the UK was more like a catalyst, if you will. it makes a difference, even though they didn't make the actual changes you see today
@@user-fj6mf3xv4p Fool! If it wasn't for the British, Communist China would have destroyed everything in Hong Kong like they did on the Mainland. All that culture & architecture was saved because of the British.
@@user-fj6mf3xv4p as someone who is from a former British colony i can tell you beyond a shadow of doubt that unlike the soviet union, every colony Britain has taken was left in a better shape once it left. some then improved others worsened. Hong Kong is the best example of one that improved the most by far.
Thank you for reporting. We are facing a serious problem here in HK.
Hey what's happening in HK, any detail info would be appreciated.
Franklin Lockhart 🙄
@Franklin Lockhart---That's why grampy's offsprings are so fucked up, hi hi hi!
@Franklin Lockhart you could f*k yourself. Enjoy it please.
"good old Winnnie the Pooh"! LOL!!
12:48
This one was powerful, man. I could feel how much it means to you. I wish I could express myself so well. All we can hope for is a peaceful resolution. All the best.
Thank you very much for speaking up for Hong Kong.
Here we go again. Same b-roll footage of people spitting since months. Is that the only thing that you have to show from mainland?
Speaking up for HK? He doesn't. The local silent majority speaks for HK. If you don't like HK a Chinese autonomous region ain't yer cup of tea, or if you think European shit somehow don't stink, pack up and leave. You know nothing about inservitude when every legislative member, every judge and every so-called "governor" was appointed by London. Free speech? They beat the shit out of you protesters if you did what your doing back then.
I am from mainland, i also hate the extraction law. But why do i feel the purpose of this guy is not just supporting hongkong.
@@odixu651 his accent suggests he's some kind of a fucking brit or Aussi what not. the last time a brit put his hostile hand on me *I kicked him in the mouth and his teeth fell out.*
@@odixu651 not extraction. that's pulling teeth. extradition.
12:52 "Good ol' Winnie the Pooh" lol I love you, man.
I love your name .l.
I have only just seen this piece. As someone who worked and loved Hong Kong in 1992 and 1993, while it was still under UK rule, my heart breaks and bleeds for all the lovely people that are still there. I feel so embarrassed that UK Prime Minister (Margaret Thatcher) failed to work harder to come to a better decision and result for the Hong Kong people who unfortunately were not allowed to take part in the negotiations. If only the UK could have found a way to renew the lease.
1 Problem with Hong Kong is its too expensive to rent an apartment there, most people are living in closet sized rooms sharing facilities with others, its not exactly paradise now is it ?
Most places were worse when you live there.
Very well said on the background of hong kong-china relation, thank you for bringing this up to youtube
Kenneth Cheng Learn how to bow to Xi and Lam!!!! It will serve you well!!! BOW!!!!
In Hong Kong, no “cultural revolution” or genocide of entire classes/ethnicities/religions ever took place. I’d argue HK is more authentically Chinese than mainland China.
MrMigraine can confirm that
This is what British are fighting against....the EU.
I concur to that. From an ex Hong Konger
Same as Macau.
So is Taiwan. They still have Chinese culture intact.
My respect for you grows with each video Winston, keep going
I love how real and true this video is
Well said Wilson very eloquent and thanks for the video
This is one of my favorite video of yours! Excellent work!
Jackson O'Neil Bow to XI!!!!!
Hong Kong is the most adaptable city in the world. Just look at the language and how fast it evolves. Smart sophisticated - high underrated people. Wonderful Vlog here
As a mainlander living overseas, I appreciate honest, clear and respectful elaboration. You stayed neutral and calm. I hope HongKong protests can make a visual presentation with like this, not breaking social orders.
'The Extradition Ordinance is not like what you said... the people who abuse the Chinese government will not be extradited! You should really go back to the beginning, the ordinance itself then reconsider what you should say to the people only can get information in English and UA-cam and CNN. '
It won't do them any good. Their government would just as soon kill them and replace them. You cannot protest vs. a totalitarian system. It NEVER works. The only way to get out from under totalitarianism is revolution.
First, the sovereignty of HK belongs to China. There are no Chinese invaders but only mobs who are now ruining their own city. Second, Beijing has nothing to do with HK riots. What's happenning in HK is merely local mobs vs local police.
@@evani4910 Look, everyone!!! A Party Member from the Ministry of Lies has come to educate you all! You are SUCH an obvious propaganda pusher it's not even funny. The China officers have been proven to be among the protestors instigating violence. Stop your lying.
@@basedbear1605 That's a sure way to getting killed. :-)
Thanks for showing the nose guy twice, second time in slow-mo. I really appreciate that.
yeah that was beautiful. Who edited this, and thought we need to see it in slow fukking motion the secoind time?
Yup can't erase seeing that.
That's how propaganda works - show one nose guy often enough and everyone is convinced that in mainland China all people blow their nose on the street.
Oh man, that was disgusting.
Yeah,I was just tucking into my steak!!! 🤣🇬🇧
Winston! Thank you for this video. I totally agree with you 100%.
I am so worried for the people of Hong Kong. May they stay strong.
Pray for Hong Kong!
We will.
May they keep the Filipina maid a slave with horrible working conditions and lowest of wages
You should be worried about their victims. If you would like to see some real HK footages of the recent protest, check out the playlist “Hong Kong unrest” in my profile.
@Brownebunny ,
It is hard to get an education on the actual events by looking at the biased corporate media.
They started mass violence back in June. Digging up bricks from sidewalks and threw them at the cops is lethal violence! Kicking cops on the ground and bit off a finger was also started In June. They smashed into the legislative building in June and caused over a billion damage. Their mass attacks on civilians had also started in June. They smashed local shops run by HKers and threatened them not to sell to mainland tourists. Some of the videos were uploaded early and UA-cam deleted them due to censorship. Police were very restrained. Only the anti-China propaganda in corporate “free” press distort the facts and never show you what’s on the playlist.
They even x10 and x20 to the actual number of protesters. For example, Victoria Park has a size around 130,000 square feet. Somehow all the “free press” reported 1.7 million protesters... you have to stack 10-15 people on the top of each other to get that many!
They also ignore the massive counter-protests. There were three of them at least numbered at 250k, 160k, and 470k. Do you even see the coverage?
Did they report the protesting organizers receive fund from NED? A civilian arm of CIA. It is on NED’s own website which organizers receive money from them.
I lived in Hong Kong in '97, when it switched from British to Chinese control. I was too young to understand, but it's really sad to see how fast the prosperity is likely to end. Such a shame.
I was about to put the honey in my tea. Then the guy "cleaned" is nose
Well, honey is technically bee puke, so the pictures fit well together.
also, honey is pure sugar and makes you fat.
@@sonarsphere Thank you for letting us know.
@@sonarsphere 1 spoon in a tea per day is healthy.
When I jerk off it looks like that when I clean up ☺
I was born and bred in New York City and was a bit wary about making the transition to Hong Kong, but I was surprised at the beauty of the city and culture.
I saw a video on this recently where they said during the initial handover of Hong Kong by the Brit’s, mainland China was fine with the 50 year self rule thing because at that time (1995 or 1997 or whatever) Hong Kong represented like ⅓ or something of the entire Chinese GDP so they wanted to keep them happy but within the last 20 years, with the rapid economic progression of other Chinese cities, Hong Kong now represents only a very tiny part of the GDP like 1% or something very small so mainland China is less inclined to abide by previous agreements. It’s a shame because within the next 20 years I don’t think the unique Hong Kong culture will still be around. I think it’ll just be another communist strangled city with no freedoms and horrible human rights.
A couple of years ago an old friend of my mom moved back home .
And one day as my mom was scrolling down her phone she saw something her friend had posted which alarmed her.
She called her and learned of the terrible news .💔
Her youngest son and his pregnant wife went to HK on holiday .They dined at a 5 star restaurant ,fell I'll and were rushed to the emergency room !
They were both diagnosed with food poisoning !
His condition worsened quickly so his family was contacted .His older brothers flew to HK to be by his side . He died a few days later !
When my mom told me I asked her 'What about his wife and baby ,are they Ok ' ?!
She said "I Was in shock the the whole time and couldn't bring myself to ask her ".
😭😭😭
Cant agree more what you have said about Hong Kong where I grew up but moved to UK in 1997. My heart goes out to the protestors in Hong Kong from UK. ❤
Florence Tou You need to learn how to bow to XI or face re-education!!!!!!
@@cgreglenfound8421 go fuck yourself
@boshi liu you need to have your face bruised up
Move like jagger haha
Hong Kong is marvelous, it must be protected from this invasion!
Raymundo Torres to late. It’s fucked now the Chinese have taken it over and that’s the end of it. 🤷♂️
@boshi liu yeah because that makes a lot of sense. Fuck the Chinese government. Not the average Chinese person, but their shitty government and those who follow blindly.
boshi liu why?
Invasion?? How ironic! White people invaded first you idiot.
@@anyalecawale635 what has this to do with COLOUR you fool ?
I live in Hong Kong the things happening now , makes me and my family very mad , my mom told me to leave Hong Kong after high school 😤😤
where will you head to?
don't do after high school, just leave now. do you want me call a uber for you? hey one more thing do me a favor don't wear a seatbelt.
Don’t leave! Stay and fight for your country. Protect it from China! If they get their way, it’ll lose so much and set a precedent for China to impede other countries in Asia. I love Hong Kong and would hate to see it become part of Mainland.
@@lyndsay4153 I don't get the protests for democracy. How does it help Hong Kong in any way if it achieves democracy or independence? Yes, democracy is good, but it doesn't always work. If Hong Kong achieves independence whats next? They have nothing to export (nothing much). The only reason why Hong Kong is still relevant is because things still go through Hong Kong to get into China, this, however, is slowly fading away as things go directly into China now. It would probably be best if it gets absorbed into the mainland as bad as it sounds. It will probably be better for the economy there. But that's just a theory, a...theory...
@@AF-qc5vo Winston thinks HK is the only port,
I once knew one girl from HK. She was a rich girl, she was sweet, polite, civilized and energetic like no mainland china girl are in their upbringing. I had a crush on her, and ages were mismatched. She graciously reject me and remained my friend respectfully. That is something i did not expect and not what you see from any girl, they'll just shun you after rejecting you. And for that reason i always kept a positive memory of her.
I hope Taiwan is looking at the CCP absolutely being brutal with the young HK people protesting. That is going to happen to Taiwan if they vote pro-Beijing leadership in January.
Taiwan will be hard to conquer. Taiwanese are aware and developed weapons to stop China long enough so the U.S. could kick in.
@@LucasPereiradaSilva Plus Taiwan has more influence worldwide compared to HK.
I believe most politicians are not pro Beijing. As a KMT support a lot of people will point fingers saying we're pro CCP but that's not the case. At our border Mainland has everything they got to take over Taiwan. Either by cooperation or war we have to decide. Taiwan has been going downhill since martial law has been lifted. We need to enforce our military, economy and technology to keep up with mainland China and we're not hitting our targets Becuase the current government is too focused on political correction. If people of Taiwan can't have a happy life, people will support the CCP if things look bad there. My advice is thst everyone should vote with their brains, keep CCP at an arms length and strengthen our economy through them. And build train our own defences in case of war. I don't believe there can be one country two systems, there's no way ccp would allow that. The more people cries about indepence from ROC, PRC would gladly take over by force if necessary. I don't wish we would come to that.
@@msndotnet01 It will not be easy for China because the US would certainly get involved, as Taiwan is clearly an ally, and the US-Taiwan relationship got better under Trump's administration. As an outsider, I see Taiwan doing a great job, at least compared to Brazil, where I live. Their weapons are far more advanced than ours, and it's remarkable for such a relatively tiny island with only 22M people living on it, less than the 37M in Tokyo.
@@LucasPereiradaSilva I personally don't think it's a good idea poking a stick on an aggressive tiger. US may be an ally but to what cost. When we poke the tiger and it strikes the only ally that can back us up is across the Pacific ocean lol. Again peaceful negotiation is the most logical way.
The comparison between Hong Kong and China are so true. The descriptions of Chinese Communist's willingness to destroy democracy and decent human values at any cost is 100% out of question.
as an american i support the extradition laws. the west has to stop being hypocritical about this situation. people attack china for not having free speech yet we dont have free speech in the west either, if we did julian assange and edward snowden would not be locked up. i trust a human like xi jinping who came from poverty more than racist rothchilds vampires. no more DOUBLE STANDARDS.
materialism has little value to me i dont care how big hong kong's buildings are, i care more about the integrity of its family values and tradition. from what i hear from china is that chinese have very good family values and tradition. asian culture is simply superior than sjw culture here in the west. let asian culture grow and western culture die out.
wish i could leave america to find a good chinese wife and start new. materialism is hell.
the usa is eventually going to become desolate so its good for china to take hong kong. with the usa destroyed by revelation 17 and 18 the eu, south america, middle east and africa would have no choice but to do more trade with china and russia through the belt and road initiative. china will prosper and no longer will the world suffer under rothchilds sanctions and wars.
@@jakemoreno9092 Yeah America is full of shit and has its fair share of nonsense, but as an ethnic Chinese person myself, the so called Chinese 'family values' do not apply much in real life anyway, just as the Christian values. We also have very similar issues like everyone else. Most Chinese, especially mainlanders are agnostics (like myself, although i am a Malaysian) or pagans/Buddhists (which i am still, technically).
@@jakemoreno9092 Materialism is even more prevalent in Chinese society. About the 'revelation' part, you seem like a Christian nutjob. Fuck the Rothschilds though.
@crim sin
it doesnt matter what the constitution says, the rothchilds can loophole through it. why do you think were not allowed to own machine guns
juillian assange and edward snowden are still locked up
UK and Portugal shouldn't given back Macau ang Hong Kong to China
5 years after revisiting this video Serpantza just got everything right about it and is exactly what's happening right now. Seems like he has the crystal ball. Salute!
Mainland and Hong Kong remind me of the parable of the Cobra and the Elephant:
Elephant, "You promised not to bite me if I saved you from drowning. Now I'll die. Why did you bite me?"
Cobra, "Because I'm a cobra."
Excellent video Winston! All the best from Slovakia!
Bow to Xi
@@cgreglenfound8421 fuck you
@boshi liu Where ya live ya little bitch?
I love Hong Kong. It's arguably the most exciting city on the planet.
it's too enjoyable a city for the mainland to enforce this frightening extradition bill.
Here in Australia, as of 13 September, 2023, one fact is reality. Hong Kong is is betrayed, ruined, destroyed. I lived there in the early 1980's, I know.
When I lived in Guangzhou, HK was also my break from a lot of the nonsense, including internet restrictions. Sometimes I even spent the weekend there just to use the internet and upload/download. I've been to HK more than 30 times and I do like it. It's truly an international city.
It can't compare in the "clean and orderly" department with Tokyo, but it kills places in mainland China. Going from Japan to HK was alarming to me, but from HK to GZ was shocking. Huge difference.
Yep, us Chinese will never be as clean and orderly as the Japanese it's just how we are, Taiwan I feel is somewhere in the middle as well, though, I'm probably going to get shot down by a bunch of Mainland Chinese now. Hong Kong is miles better than China, I've never liked Mainland China nor do I intend to ever go back to stay longer than a week.
@@iceomistar4302 Why didn't you like mainland China?
I would like to visit Hong Kong someday. But I heard its very expensive.
I understand the attraction of Hong Kong, if you live in the Chinese neighbourhood. I did, too. Though I personally concluded it is not a nice place to live long term.
@@iceomistar4302 for the love of god, please don't go back, we don't want you there.
You need to be careful too Winston.Good luck and thx for the video.
It kind of doesn't even matter; the government plays dirty and will go after innocent people you know, like friends and family, which is absolutely immoral and unethical. I'm surprised the UN or NATO hasn't condemned it. I suppose by comparison to their neighbor, North Korea, China is definitely happy fun land when it comes to government.
@@social3ngin33rin well the only reason the North Korean government is still up, is because of the support of China. If China wouldn't have stepped in during the Korea War, South Korea would have won and we would only know about Korea.
The reason China backs NK then and now is that they want to have a cushion between them and US allies....
M B you make a fair point, but at the same time you acquiesce to the villain if you shut down your own speech due to fear.
Thank you for speaking up
I visited Hong Kong for the Chinese New Year back in 2000. It was beautiful and spotlessly clean. Every local we meet was polite, helpful and seemed genuinely nice. They all were very concerned about the future and China tho. Looks like they were right. Damn shame.
Well said Winston! I very much enjoy your videos and the different perspectives you are sharing about Hong Kong and China. Keep up the good work!
When I lived in China in the mid-90s my family went to Hong Kong monthly for shopping, eating and unwinding. It was just a long weekend, but it helped. I appreciate your views on the issue. Keep up the good work.
i wish the best of luck to Hong Kong freedom
Thank you!
Thank you!
Hong Kong is a beautify territory. I was there few months ago 😁can't wait to go back again! Definitely worth visiting. I love to travel; love to take pics and videos and share my experience😁
I love HK, it is my favourite city.
Days are numbered, time to leave
civil unrest can lead to revolution. Seems china is a shithole and trying to drag HK down. FUCK CHINA
Me too I live on Lantau
@@averiesalerno1348 When Lantau was still an island I trekked from the Golf Course (Silvermine?) over the peak, camped in the valley and then up the other peak (Sunset?) and on to the Buddha. Visited las year and it seems to have got horribly urbanised round the airport but the rest of the island still pretty rural.
Honolulu is mine
Already foreigners are no longer registering offshore entities in HK because they are worried about capital controls that are coming.
very true went to an international school in HK, foreigners are leaving by the day in masses.
Oh yeah? How come they don't register them in Australia too?
foregin pig get out china get out of HK!
高子健 uneducated idiot
@@user-bt2xq8ks2l HK would be fucked without foreigners. Fuck you.
I feel for HK families who thought they had generations and time to prepare and that security was stolen from them.
Hahaha security stolen. Sorry, but no one thinks like this. Do you even speak Chinese?
We all understand what you mean. You guys are all on our prayers. GOD BLESS & STAY HEALTHY 🙏👼
Hanman ... what’s your problem? And what does speaking Chinese have to do with anything? These people aren’t only having their security taken away, they are having their FUTURES taken away.
@@johnlacey3857 someone who can't speak Chinese means that person doesn't fully understand what's going on. The only thing they do know is what English-speakers tell them and what Western media says. A lot of Hong Kongers are pro China. I am friends with quite a few of them who are pro China. And no, they're not "bribed" like Winston and Matt claim. They are real people. I have friends who are party members and work in local governments. A good friend of mine works in a state foreign affairs office. Hardcore CCP supporter and party member. He's not oppressing people. He generally looks out for China's future.
People like Winston would never know people like that, would never be friends with them and wouldn't care. They have a superiority complex when it comes to the Chinese government. But when you accuse them of that, they just call you a coward and say "I married a Chinese woman so that's proof I'm not a bigot." Sorry but that doesn't work.
I've offered to sit down and explain to these guys all of their misconceptions, but they're not interested in the truth. They only want to push their ideas. I live an hour away from where Winston stays. I've offered to go confront him like he challenged us in the video when he called us trolls. Yet he refuses. Why is that?
Hanman
Seems you’re trying to subtly divert the conversation from the subject of the *unconscionable* HK extradition bill (clearly driven by the CCP) to the credibility of Mr Sturzil.
I’m sure there are some decent people who are also CCP party members, but that doesn’t mean the CCP is any less evil.
You say you know a lot of HK people who are pro-China. I’m sure you do; I’m pro-China and pro-Chinese as well. However I’m very much anti-CCP, and recent events indicate over one million HK people are too.
I’m confused about your statement about Winston... you say he’s against the Chinese government - and I think you’re right. But accusing him of bigotry against Chinese people is completely different. His response seems logical - if he were bigoted against Chinese people, why would he marry a Chinese wife, and live amongst Chinese people all these years? I’m pretty sure his problem is with the CCP, not ordinary Chinese people. Same with me, and I’m sure with many others.
Your disdain of bigotry is laudable. But then I find it confusing that you would use the expression “doesn’t speak Chinese” to describe someone who doesn’t know what’s going on. Implication of course being that people who don’t speak Chinese are stupid. Gee, that’s not bigoted at all!
So... back to the real subject of the video... whether you think Winston is misguided or not is irrelevant. What is relevant is that the CCP is about to implement this grossly unconscionable law in Hong Kong; civilized people everywhere should stand up, cry foul, and push back.
I feel sorry for all the HK people and their families who will have their lives impacted by this unjust law.
And I feel sorry for all the 五毛党who are brainwashed and have the truth kept from them.
A few years ago, i was having a conversation with a good Chinese friend. I argued that democracy in China is inevitable given the high economic success, education achievements, and overall status that China has reached. I argued that Chinese people don't have much to prove now except for a free and democratic society.
He looked straight at me and said with absolute confidence: Chinese people don't want democracy.
Did he happen to say why they don't want Democracy?
my dad used to live there and left before the handover ... I love it there so much, CCP will ruin it
Thanks for those who love Hong Kong ♥️
Thank you, Winston, for supporting Hong Kong
Although the bill has been postponed, the fight is not over yet.
In fact, they are having a protest right now and occupied the same place as in 2014
God Bless Hong Kong
Atleast the people of hong kong are aware what is going on. In the eu they passed the european arrest warrant, without anyone knowing.
God bless Hong Kong.
You talk so much sense, and you are spot-on!!! Love all you have to say! I'm hooked and have already watched many of your videos... Thank you. I've lived in HK for over 40 years and yes, it is a very special place.
Oh I love your commentary so correct and exactly right- this from someone’s who’s lived there.