Okay first of all, I ABSOLUTELY LOVE THEIR NAMES IN THE DESCRIPTION IM WHEEZING ~now let me enjoy the video even tho its almost midnight and i have school tomorrow~
Omg you don’t know how much I love the cast you picked and specially for Christopher Lightwood ( to be honest Louis Partridge is my fav choice for Jesse Blackthorn since the moment I saw him )
I love this especially Matthew! I've found him so hard to cast myself. Personally I've always seen Will (especially dad! Will) as Benedict Cumberbatch especially after my Sherlock binge!
I’m so happy you love my Matthew! As soon as I saw those pictures I was like, that’s it!! That’s him!! And ooh yes I love that as well - it’s definitely the curly black hair I think 😉
Grace is perfect!!!!!!!!!1!!!!11!! imagined her having a shy soft yet angular face and basically everything grey and pale and white. basically not someone who would give off necromancer vibes
OMG ....that one picture with Timothee and Mackenzie doooo give me young James and Lucie vibes! Great choice for Grace too! I actually did see a video somewhere in youtube, some sort of like an edit where Timothee and Anya-Taylor Joy are both in tho each from different films. And they were in these Edwardian clothes (I think) ....and they're perfect for James and Grace. Medalion Rahimi is perfect as Daisy too....I just wish she is as young as Anya and Timothee who are both about the same age (24 and 25 respectively).. Overall this is the perfect fan-casting for TLH. I love it
Doesn't it! As soon as I saw it I was like, that's a young James and Lucie haha!! I honestly love Anya as Grace and I'm sure I haven't seen anyone else suggest her for Grace, but for me she is perfect! (I think the edits must be from Timothee in Little Women, and Grace in Emma - but please send me this video, I would love to see it!) And yes I agree about Medalion, but she is just so perfect as Cordelia I'm happy to look over the age thing ;) But thank you SO MUCH. I'm absolutely ecstatic that you like my choices, I consider you one of the biggest TSC fans out there so this means a lot!
LOVE your pick for Christopher, Matthew and Cordelia!!! I always imagined Ian Somerhalder as the aging Will Herondale 😭 The Vampire Diaries has a lot of content for him in victorians days lol, i also liked Egor Telenchenko for Jesse and Amalie Snolos for Grace 🤔 but tbh as i read, my imagination always jumps between a combination of a few different fan casts for each character haha, yours will definitely be incorporated now😁
I so totally needed this video, and I'd also thought of Mackenzie for Lucie, and Timothee for James (or WIll)!! I practically SCREAMED when they came on-screen, and I am soo hyped for Chain of Iron now (well, a little more than I was before, that is.) Except for her eyes, however, Mackenzie is perfect, and that scene is literally her seeing Jesse!!! I really, really, *really* loved your picks, and you are definitely one of my favourite BookTubers! Great video, Tilly!
Huh, now that I think about it, and read the other comments here, Timothee could also be a great Jesse... And, like, I can picture him and Mackenzie in the 'famed' Lucie/Jesse moments in the first two chapters of Chain of Iron.
I’m so happy that people are commenting their own casts as well, I’m really enjoying Louis Partridge as Jesse as well! I might have to do a part 2 at some point 😉
Lily James (blonde) is actually who I imagined as jessamine when reading TID! But I love all of these but I agree with Elle fanning as Grace. I imagined her with a softer face but very icy coloring. I also think dark haired cara delavigne could play Anna!
I absolutely love this cast! I've never noticed how much Timothée looks like James from my imagination..And Anya as Grace? It's amazing because as you said, Grace is obv very pretty but also *striking* and Anya has this striking feature. Good video
YES I LOVE DAISY RIDLEY AS TESSA! What a great choice! Omg Colombia?!! I can’t believe this video has reached Colombia!! But greetings from a very wet and rainy England 😭😭
I would go with: Isabelle Fuhrman for Anna Lightwood Zoe Margaret Colleti for Lucie and not sure but kinda Diana Silvers gives me Tessa Gray vibes recently... Also I was wondering about how Elijah Stevenson would fit as Matthew, but well I've changed my mind... he is 100% Jace haha. Love your picks tho ❤❤❤
Maybe Laura Vandervoort as Grace? She's older now but she played Kara Kent/Kara Zor-El on Smallville, Sadie Harrison on Instant Star quite some years ago. LOVE your dreamcast!!!
Thank you so much for this video! Now I'll have some nice imagination inspiration when Chain of Iron comes out. I totally agree with Henry Cavill for Daddy Will! When I was watching Enola Holmes, I also thought Louis Patridge would be a good Jesse. Thoughts?
Gurl, I hadn’t seen tumblr fan casts but I’ve been saying young Henry= young Will older will= present time Henry and Timothee as James SUPERIOR. Your only cast I didn’t like was jesse’s, I don’t really like Grace but ANYA?? My crush on her is huge and she’d be an amazing grace! I loved your fantast so much.
I really know very few actors lol so I don’t have any recs, but omg NOOO TOM Holland could never be Chris for meee! But otherwise I love your choices, I’m a bit iffy on Alastair but he’s my other fave so it’s one of those “no one will ever be the perfect them” scenarios. And omg you omitting Charles Fairchild is sending meeee that’s a power move right there^_^
@@MyYAFictionAddiction lmaoooo you know I’m not from the uk when I had to look up the meaning of cba:) Love you work for those that matter like omg medalion really has the same eyebrows as cordelia!!
Well, hello friend! I love you're casting, you've even made me change my mind about a couple of the actors I chose for my fan cast! But there are some differences in our casts and I will write them down and why I prefer them (because I can) and please let me know what you think; So our James and Thomas are the same which is cool! You have now made me change my mind on Cordelia, I have to go and change that. But the first difference for me is, my baby, my heart, my husband, Matthew. I picture him as Max Barczak. Now I know he's a model but just the hair and the face.
I'm so glad you enjoyed the video and I love that you've also shared your own fan cast with us! Honestly, Medalion as Cordelia is just flawless, I'm not sure anyone can change my mind on that - Louis Partridge as Jesse, however, my mind has definitely been changed!! You're one of many that like Louis as Jesse and I'm so grateful because he's now my fave Jesse as well! I love that you gave Charles a fan cast, I'm just too sour to give him any more page time lmao, he gives me big PERCY WEASLEY vibes and I have 0 time for that
That’s totally okay!! We all read books differently, that’s why I wanted to make this video!! But I just can’t NOT see Jacob as Noah from The Kissing Booth 😭😭
Agree with all of these except Ian Somerhalder will always be my older Will. And honestly when he was younger if he had darker hair he could be the young Will too. I just feel like he could play Will so well! :)
Ahhhhhh! This is awesome! I've seen so many people fancast Timothée Chalamet as James 𝘢𝘯𝘥 Julian he fits both in my opinion You should do a The Dark Artifices fan casting and a The Mortal Instruments one....(I'm not happy with any of the actors/actresses except Matthew Daddario [perfection],Harry Shum Jr and maybe Emeraude and Alberto.. I've not watched the series... i don't think i will.. the only reason i want to is cuz of Malec xD and i do not like any of the movie cast. Except for Jamie Campbell Bower.. he was a good Jace but i think he would play a better Sebastian in my opinion ... also.... dont come at me but i dont like Henry Cavil and i dont like him as Will.
Haha don’t worry! Everyone reads books differently and imagines different people - books are a personal thing and it’s so interesting to see how everyone’s imagination differs!! I want to do both a TDA and a TMI one but I still haven’t found my perfect Julian!! Tbh I could probably do a TMI one soon I feel like I’ve got choices for all those characters, which includes Matthew and Harry from the show!! They were the perfect Magnus and Alec in my eyes.
@@MyYAFictionAddiction 😁😁 I dont have a perfect Julian too... tbh in my opinion.. the TDA characters are pretty hard to cast... I love love love Matthew and Harry. Yes they were perfect.. if they do have more adaptations... Harry should stay Magnus in all of them. Will be waiting for the videos!! 😊
@@MyYAFictionAddiction uhhhh Tilly, so on tumblr(I joined cuz of u) I saw someone cast this person as Thomas Lightwood..... But I've seen people cast him as Julian and I think he is a Julian more than Thomas for me... I think he just might be the perfect Julian for me... though I'm not super sure.. Check him out... His name is Froy Gutierrez
@@ednajoseph4149 thats who I used as Thomas for this video! To me he is the perfect Thomas but I can see how you can get Julian vibes from him as well!
Does kit come back from dying because I’ve got to the chapter were he does die but I’ve also seen the light wood family tree which said that he married grace and had a son with her.
Okay first of all, I ABSOLUTELY LOVE THEIR NAMES IN THE DESCRIPTION IM WHEEZING
~now let me enjoy the video even tho its almost midnight and i have school tomorrow~
HAHA IM SO GLAD YOU NOTICED THEM!! Please enjoy this midnight viewing 😉
Thomas the tank (engine) killed me 😆
@@katariinablom6710 where is the lieeeeeee
I think as a collective fandom can agree that dad!will/ wilf is henry cavil
This is 100% fact and no one can change our minds!
Omggg both young and older will! I have no idea who he is, but I love him for will 😂
@@meh5069 same omg yes. i saw will in him when i first watched enola holmes
the grace one OMG ANYA IS PERFECT
I can’t believe I didn’t realise until now that Anya IS Grace Blackthorn
Omg you don’t know how much I love the cast you picked and specially for Christopher Lightwood ( to be honest Louis Partridge is my fav choice for Jesse Blackthorn since the moment I saw him )
Oh yes Louis as Jesse could work as well! Okay he’s now my SECOND favourite for Jesse! A sexy ghost boi xxxxx
I love this especially Matthew! I've found him so hard to cast myself. Personally I've always seen Will (especially dad! Will) as Benedict Cumberbatch especially after my Sherlock binge!
I’m so happy you love my Matthew! As soon as I saw those pictures I was like, that’s it!! That’s him!! And ooh yes I love that as well - it’s definitely the curly black hair I think 😉
@@MyYAFictionAddiction yes the hair and the cheekbones 😂also his whole dramatic flair in Sherlock just screams Will to me but I love your choice too!
Grace is perfect!!!!!!!!!1!!!!11!!
imagined her having a shy soft yet angular face and basically everything grey and pale and white. basically not someone who would give off necromancer vibes
OMG ....that one picture with Timothee and Mackenzie doooo give me young James and Lucie vibes!
Great choice for Grace too! I actually did see a video somewhere in youtube, some sort of like an edit where Timothee and Anya-Taylor Joy are both in tho each from different films. And they were in these Edwardian clothes (I think) ....and they're perfect for James and Grace.
Medalion Rahimi is perfect as Daisy too....I just wish she is as young as Anya and Timothee who are both about the same age (24 and 25 respectively)..
Overall this is the perfect fan-casting for TLH. I love it
Doesn't it! As soon as I saw it I was like, that's a young James and Lucie haha!! I honestly love Anya as Grace and I'm sure I haven't seen anyone else suggest her for Grace, but for me she is perfect! (I think the edits must be from Timothee in Little Women, and Grace in Emma - but please send me this video, I would love to see it!) And yes I agree about Medalion, but she is just so perfect as Cordelia I'm happy to look over the age thing ;) But thank you SO MUCH. I'm absolutely ecstatic that you like my choices, I consider you one of the biggest TSC fans out there so this means a lot!
@@MyYAFictionAddiction I did think Anya as Grace after watching Queens Gambit and "The Witch".....she has very pale blonde hair in that film.
LOVE your pick for Christopher, Matthew and Cordelia!!! I always imagined Ian Somerhalder as the aging Will Herondale 😭 The Vampire Diaries has a lot of content for him in victorians days lol, i also liked Egor Telenchenko for Jesse and Amalie Snolos for Grace 🤔 but tbh as i read, my imagination always jumps between a combination of a few different fan casts for each character haha, yours will definitely be incorporated now😁
I also looked at Amalie Snolos for Grace, so great minds think alike! I'm also honoured to be a part of your imagination now haha!
I know it's not about our topic but you look ✨gorgeous✨
Omg thank you 😭😭
I really love timmothee chalament as James :)
And your cast is perfect!!:D
MATTHEW IS MY FAV AND HIS CAST IS PERFECT OMGG
I’m so glad you liked young Jude Law as Math! He really is my fave ❤️❤️
I so totally needed this video, and I'd also thought of Mackenzie for Lucie, and Timothee for James (or WIll)!! I practically SCREAMED when they came on-screen, and I am soo hyped for Chain of Iron now (well, a little more than I was before, that is.) Except for her eyes, however, Mackenzie is perfect, and that scene is literally her seeing Jesse!!! I really, really, *really* loved your picks, and you are definitely one of my favourite BookTubers! Great video, Tilly!
Huh, now that I think about it, and read the other comments here, Timothee could also be a great Jesse... And, like, I can picture him and Mackenzie in the 'famed' Lucie/Jesse moments in the first two chapters of Chain of Iron.
Oh wow!😭 thank you SO MUCH for this!! I really love Mackenzie for Luce and I glad you do too!
I’m so happy that people are commenting their own casts as well, I’m really enjoying Louis Partridge as Jesse as well! I might have to do a part 2 at some point 😉
@@MyYAFictionAddiction Yes, I would absolutely adore that!!
Lily James (blonde) is actually who I imagined as jessamine when reading TID! But I love all of these but I agree with Elle fanning as Grace. I imagined her with a softer face but very icy coloring. I also think dark haired cara delavigne could play Anna!
Yes that’s who I cast as Jessamine for my TID fan cast as well!! Lily James really does belong in the Shadowhunter universe!!
my heart..... it just stopped beating when i saw Anna Lightwood .......
I definitely also envisioned Anya and knew you were going to say her once you mentioned the striking features for Grace
I absolutely love this cast! I've never noticed how much Timothée looks like James from my imagination..And Anya as Grace? It's amazing because as you said, Grace is obv very pretty but also *striking* and Anya has this striking feature. Good video
Thank you so much I’m so happy you enjoyed!❤️ honestly Anya is my fave Grace for sure xx
Daisy Ridley gives me Tessa vibes idk, I love all of your videos. Greetings from Colombia!!
YES I LOVE DAISY RIDLEY AS TESSA! What a great choice! Omg Colombia?!! I can’t believe this video has reached Colombia!! But greetings from a very wet and rainy England 😭😭
I absolutely love this entire cast 🤩🤩🤩
Thank you so much!! I’m so pleased!!
I do think Amita Suman would make an amazing Ariadne Bridgestock.
Yes yes yes I LOVE her
SHE'S QUEEN♥️
Your castings for Jamie,Chris and Anna are just perfect, you NAILED it
I picture James as Logan Lerman, now with his long hair, but golden eyes. 🙂
Love ya! Great vid as always
Oh I love him!! What a great choice 😍
@@MyYAFictionAddiction Percy Jackson makes a good Herondale🤷♀️😆
I would go with:
Isabelle Fuhrman for Anna Lightwood
Zoe Margaret Colleti for Lucie
and not sure but kinda Diana Silvers gives me Tessa Gray vibes recently...
Also I was wondering about how Elijah Stevenson would fit as Matthew, but well I've changed my mind... he is 100% Jace haha. Love your picks tho ❤❤❤
Omg Isabelle Fuhrman as Anna?! YES! I've never considered her but I really love that! And Elijah Stevenson as Jace? YES YES YES
omg tom holland as christopher lightwood..yesss!🥺🥰
Nothing but respect for MY Christopher
also A+ on the puns in the description LOLLL ESP THE CORDELIA ONE
Thank you very much, these are their official nicknames now x
You are absolutely amazing...thank you for all the effort u put in to all your videos! ❤️
Thank you for taking the time to watch them!!❤️
Charles is basically percy from harry potter movies
excuse me but Kristen Stewart as Anna Lightwood would be a cultural reset
MY QUEEN KRISTEN AS MY QUEEN ANNA? WHEN WORLDS COLLIDE
THESE ARE ALL SO RIGHT
THANK U I FEARED THEY WOULD BE ALL WRONG BUT I THINK PEOPLE ARE ENJOYING IT
ik it's not tlh but you look like how I imagine Emma Carstairs!
OH MY GOD I HAVE JUST DIED. SHE IS LITERALLY MY FAVOURITE TSC CHARACTER YOU DO NOT KNOW HOW MUCH THIS MEANS TO ME!!
these are literally perfect
I was so worried people wouldn’t like my choices SO THIS MEANS A LOT
Maybe Laura Vandervoort as Grace? She's older now but she played Kara Kent/Kara Zor-El on Smallville, Sadie Harrison on Instant Star quite some years ago. LOVE your dreamcast!!!
Ooh NICE suggestion ❤️
I absolutely love your accent! I think I would have picked about the same except I pictured the Carstairs with darker skin. ❤️❤️
Cameron Monaghan is my perfect Charles
Thank you so much for this video! Now I'll have some nice imagination inspiration when Chain of Iron comes out. I totally agree with Henry Cavill for Daddy Will! When I was watching Enola Holmes, I also thought Louis Patridge would be a good Jesse. Thoughts?
Yes yes yes! I love Louis as Jesse!!
I see Henry cavil more as James then will
Anya Taylor Joy is the ultimate Grace Blackthorn.
Oh 1000%
Gurl, I hadn’t seen tumblr fan casts but I’ve been saying young Henry= young Will older will= present time Henry and Timothee as James SUPERIOR. Your only cast I didn’t like was jesse’s, I don’t really like Grace but ANYA?? My crush on her is huge and she’d be an amazing grace! I loved your fantast so much.
I literally love this
I think Louis partridge would make a perfect James (plus he's British and in Enola Holmes alongside Dad Will) and Timothee I pictured as Christopher
Oh yes 100% Louis is now my Jesse! I feel like I should update my video hahahah
oooooh i pictured him but blonder for matthew!! probably the personality lol
@@strangepineapples3375 I pictured lucky blue smith (when he had goldish warm blond hair) as Matthew!
OMG I LOVE THIS! YOU SHOULD DO A TDA FANCAST VIDEO
I’m gonna do it on my Instagram account!!!
✰ ahhh i love this casting so much!!! My only differences are Louis Partridge as Jesse Blackthorn and young Alex Pettyfer as Matthew ✰
I LOVE Louis as Jesse!! And ooh I like that Matthew choice as well!!
Fun fact: Jude Law played Oscar Wilde in a 1990's biopic!
I really know very few actors lol so I don’t have any recs, but omg NOOO TOM Holland could never be Chris for meee! But otherwise I love your choices, I’m a bit iffy on Alastair but he’s my other fave so it’s one of those “no one will ever be the perfect them” scenarios. And omg you omitting Charles Fairchild is sending meeee that’s a power move right there^_^
Hahahahahah honestly fuck Charles Fairchild I cba
@@MyYAFictionAddiction lmaoooo you know I’m not from the uk when I had to look up the meaning of cba:) Love you work for those that matter like omg medalion really has the same eyebrows as cordelia!!
Well, hello friend! I love you're casting, you've even made me change my mind about a couple of the actors I chose for my fan cast! But there are some differences in our casts and I will write them down and why I prefer them (because I can) and please let me know what you think;
So our James and Thomas are the same which is cool! You have now made me change my mind on Cordelia, I have to go and change that.
But the first difference for me is, my baby, my heart, my husband, Matthew. I picture him as Max Barczak. Now I know he's a model but just the hair and the face.
I'm so glad you enjoyed the video and I love that you've also shared your own fan cast with us! Honestly, Medalion as Cordelia is just flawless, I'm not sure anyone can change my mind on that - Louis Partridge as Jesse, however, my mind has definitely been changed!! You're one of many that like Louis as Jesse and I'm so grateful because he's now my fave Jesse as well! I love that you gave Charles a fan cast, I'm just too sour to give him any more page time lmao, he gives me big PERCY WEASLEY vibes and I have 0 time for that
@@MyYAFictionAddiction that’s because he IS the Percy Weasley of the TSC world. I honestly don’t think anyone likes him
The way she pronounces “carstairs”...I fell in love
Wait the way WHO pronounced it??
@@MyYAFictionAddiction The way YOU pronounced it. You have a beautiful accent :)
@@sunjichoi3290 🥺🥺
THE NAMES IN THE DESCRIPTION IM DYING 😂😂😂😂
IM SO GLAD YOU SPOTTED THEM
Also grace is perfect
ISNT SHE
@@MyYAFictionAddiction yup! I’m watching the queen’s gambit on Netflix n I can’t unsee it
@@kylahross5103 I'm not even sorry!!
I fancasted froy as matthew and Jacob Elordi for Thomas (My opinion)
That’s totally okay!! We all read books differently, that’s why I wanted to make this video!! But I just can’t NOT see Jacob as Noah from The Kissing Booth 😭😭
Agree with all of these except Ian Somerhalder will always be my older Will. And honestly when he was younger if he had darker hair he could be the young Will too. I just feel like he could play Will so well! :)
You’re the second person that’s said he would make a good Will!! WE ARE ALL JUST SLUTS FOR WILL HERONDALE LMAO
Not me finishing watching this video after my mom took my phone last night😭😭😭
IM CRYING WHY I AM CAUSING DRAMA BETWEEN YOU AND YOUR MOM
My YA Fiction Addiction lol no dont worry❤️ it happens on a regular basis😂
4:18 thing is there's no one like my jessie 😔💔
That’s okay!! I still can’t properly cast Emma Carstairs Becuase shes my favourite either 🥰
me gonna be late for school:
Also me: might as well finish this vid and be late :)
you are the second person who said watching this video made them late for school, I HOPE I DONT START A TREND
@@MyYAFictionAddiction HAHAHAHA MEE TOO dont worry i wasnt late lol :)
😍❤️
❤️❤️
Ahhhhhh! This is awesome!
I've seen so many people fancast Timothée Chalamet as James 𝘢𝘯𝘥 Julian he fits both in my opinion
You should do a The Dark Artifices fan casting and a The Mortal Instruments one....(I'm not happy with any of the actors/actresses except Matthew Daddario [perfection],Harry Shum Jr and maybe Emeraude and Alberto.. I've not watched the series... i don't think i will.. the only reason i want to is cuz of Malec xD and i do not like any of the movie cast. Except for Jamie Campbell Bower.. he was a good Jace but i think he would play a better Sebastian in my opinion ...
also....
dont come at me but i dont like Henry Cavil and i dont like him as Will.
Haha don’t worry! Everyone reads books differently and imagines different people - books are a personal thing and it’s so interesting to see how everyone’s imagination differs!! I want to do both a TDA and a TMI one but I still haven’t found my perfect Julian!! Tbh I could probably do a TMI one soon I feel like I’ve got choices for all those characters, which includes Matthew and Harry from the show!! They were the perfect Magnus and Alec in my eyes.
@@MyYAFictionAddiction 😁😁
I dont have a perfect Julian too... tbh in my opinion.. the TDA characters are pretty hard to cast...
I love love love Matthew and Harry. Yes they were perfect.. if they do have more adaptations... Harry should stay Magnus in all of them.
Will be waiting for the videos!! 😊
Hopefully I can find a Julian soon 😉
@@MyYAFictionAddiction uhhhh Tilly, so on tumblr(I joined cuz of u) I saw someone cast this person as Thomas Lightwood.....
But I've seen people cast him as Julian and I think he is a Julian more than Thomas for me...
I think he just might be the perfect Julian for me... though I'm not super sure..
Check him out... His name is Froy Gutierrez
@@ednajoseph4149 thats who I used as Thomas for this video! To me he is the perfect Thomas but I can see how you can get Julian vibes from him as well!
Zendaya é a própria Cordelia
Eu adoro Zendaya!!
I feel like timothee could be Jesse
Honestly Timothee was born to be in the Shadowhunter universe
I think the horrible being of Charles could never be casted
Honestly he is just the Percy Weasley of the Shadowhunter universe
@@MyYAFictionAddiction 😂
I would swap you James and Jesse
sorry darling, but Tom Holland as Kit ain't it
Does kit come back from dying because I’ve got to the chapter were he does die but I’ve also seen the light wood family tree which said that he married grace and had a son with her.
@@gizzmowalliss bruh, that is a huge spoiler
Just stopped watching after timothy chalomet was suggested 🤢 gross
smh