Why Andrew Garfield Is My Favorite Spider-Man
Вставка
- Опубліковано 1 тра 2020
- Well, here we are.
Today we are going to be taking a look at why I love Spider-Man. More specifically, why Andrew Garfield's Spider-Man is my FAVORITE. Please hold your comments until the end of the video, and try to keep it civil.
Like what you see? If you'd like to support the KYD project, please visit our Patreon. / kydfilms
Be sure to follow the KYD Twitter account for consistent updates. / kydfilms
Don't forget to share the video around, and of course, leave a like if you enjoyed.
If you have any suggestions on what I should cover next, let me know in the comments. - Фільми й анімація
Go check out the official trailer to my upcoming feature film: Birds & Worms ‼️
ua-cam.com/video/VWylY6bgsYw/v-deo.htmlsi=94G02JSelZ0Kz5zJ
One thing which no one appreciates but i don't know why, is his body language as spiderman. He's long, slender, he crawls, arches his back, he's the only spiderman that feels like a spider, and I love that. His completely black eyes in the first movie add to that. I love that suit
Although it seems to be unpopular, I like that suit too. I think it brought something new to an already well know visual. First time I saw I was like "wow he looks like an alien" (which is pretty cool for me, specially with the outsider vibe of the character)
Sleek
@@lucasparolin5507 EXACTLY he doesnt look like a guy in a costume and thats amazing
I heard that Webb said that the suit look like that cause that the suit a normal person can make
Absolutely facts
that suit was so bad ass i was mad that they changed it in tasm 2 the eyes were so cool and spidey like. i love how he taunts his enemies with jokes and stuff too it adds more personality to spiderman
Another talented marvel actor that was thrown away like trash.
**SONY**
Blame that to fucking avi arad.
I'm not saying that he's not a good actor! Just The movie sucked because the script wasn't written correctly!
He’s coming back 😁
@@danielcooke3732 cap
I really wish we got a TASM 3 to see how Peter’s character would develop after Gwen’s death
Same
Hopefully no way home can wrap those movies up
Hopefully No Way Home will give him that opportunity if he does show up.
I hated how they ended TASM2 with him about to fuck up rhino and we don't get to see it
With rhino!
Andrew definitely had the best poses, web slinging, and quips. His sense of humour and acting is similar to how Peter Parker is portrayed in the comics.
yeah his stunt doubles were great
Is that, is that a real knife? NO! NO! ANYTHING BUT A KNIFE! THATS MY WEAKNESS, SMALL KNIVES!
"And I, will be like a god to them."
"A god named sparkles?"
Still love that line
I hate how people say he’s the worst Spider-Man but then can’t even back themselves up when I ask why they say that
>every single TASM 1 video on UA-cam except this one apparently.
Same thing happened to me
asked one. This is the answer : "iTs n0T cOmIC aCCuraTE!"
Bro. This Spider Man is Comic Accurate. People say he is way way to handsome and that Spider Man isn't handsome. While I do agree a little but you can have a face like Andrew but still don't have much friends due to you being introverted or just socially awkward. Peter in the comic isn't even that bad looking. Its disappointing really. Although I do agree about highschoolers being to adult like. Maybe its just my country but highschoolers here mostly look like young teens and not adults. Would've been better if this was set in a University tho.
All Spider Man is good on its own way. But this is and still will be, MY and many others, Favourite Spider Man.
Paradoz1 agreed! His Peter Parker might’ve needed some work but I’d honestly prefer this Spider-Man over Tom’s. And Tom isn’t a bad Spider-Man but he doesn’t feel like what Spider-Man should be to me
Heartbreak Soldier I prefer both his Peter and Tom as I feel as though in both ways it does a good job of modernizing both versions of the character, while Tom’s Peter just feels like an awkward teen, but doesn’t feel like Peter Parker. He doesn’t feel like the Everyman Peter Parker was meant to be, and he definitely doesn’t feel like your neighborhood Spider-Man. We get one montage of Peter in homecoming actually helping people and that’s it. We’ve seen the other two Spider-Men do that too. And to greater extents I might add. We see his Peter go through it beyond just obvious backstabbing (Mysterious) and the death of someone cared about (Tony Stark)
While I don’t think his Peter/Spidey is perfect. I do think it’s the most real/comic accurate but only that, a version of Peter Parker that is the most relatable when compared to any on screen version, while still having everything that makes Peter Parker, Peter Parker. As well as Spider-Man. Not only does his portrayal slightly reinvent the character, it never took anything away from what made him.
The thing about Andrew’s Peter is that he was more based off of the ultimate comics Peter. That version is a bit more arrogant and hotheaded but still a bit of an awkward kid. I think Andrew did a great job for this version of Peter.
60s Peter was also a jackass in high school. He'd talk back to Flash as well and make snarky remarks etc. He was also smooth with ladies, he wooed Betty Brant in his high school years. Andrew isn't so farfetched from early Ditko era
@@jezzaissmol 100% agreed
Lol he said Andrew’s Peter
@@jezzaissmol all fax
Mixed of both
After no way home I can confidently say that Andrew is the best spiderman
And low-key the best lookin
@@tangemclemore177 true
@@tangemclemore177 "low-key"??? There is no discussion, he is
@@elriane94 lol ok
@@tangemclemore177 high-key not low-key haha
Garfield is fantastic. His Peter Parker, while different from the comics, feels more realistic than any other portrayal. He really brought to life the emotional baggage of someone who was basically abandoned as a kid and tried to deal with the hand he was dealt in his own way. His Spider-Man was perfect.
Different from Earth 616 Peter you mean. Because Andrew portrays Peter from Earth-1610 which is pretty comic book accurate if you ask me.
See I'm always confused by this, and I wonder why people keep saying it. Andrew is easily the most comic accurate Peter Parker when you take into account the comic Peter's genius, quips, and spider-like fighting style. Ironically large portions of what people complain about Andrew's spider-man actually comes from the comics. Peter Parker gets girls a fair bit, so I don't see where people get this idea that he's romantically inept. Even his spy parents, which a lot of people complain about, is directly ripped from the comics.
@@charlesoflyon6578 Yes, different from the classic nerdy Peter Parker.
I love The Amazing Spider-Man 2. My only complaints are the Dr. Kafka character and almost Schumacher take on Max Dillon.
As for realism no one even comes close to Tobey ...but still if you want your Peter to be less nerdy but not be a literal child Andrew is the way to go...For me SpiderMan will always be a nerd introvert guy(more relatable for me I guess 🙂)turning into a super hero...that been said I love Andrew's Peter and I am loving Tom's Peter ever since watching NWH
He actually has the Spidey humor.
Thank you, that's what everybody forgets.
exactly, it’s actually so funny to watch the car scene especially. no other spiderman has actually made me laugh. i cant even take tobey’s spiderman seriously.
@Tanay Sengupta OMG I HAVE THOUGHT THE SAME THING
@Tanay Sengupta I agree heavily, he’s always been my favorite so now when I see people hopping on the bandwagon it kinda makes me a little upset
Yesssssssssd
Don’t care what anyone says Andrew is my favourite. Tasm1 is underrated af.
Agree
Ikr. Tasm1 is my second favorite spidey movie behind spider-man 2
Yea I honestly think the first amazing Spider-Man movie is a really good spiderman but I like Tobey the best
But tom Holland’s spiderman sucks he is not spiderman at all
Agreed!!!!
This aged well. Everyone loves Andrew's Peter now!
Them the same people saying “ToBeY wOUlD NevEr”
@@daddyvelvet4428 Andrew is the best
and im glad!
Finally
All in the directing
Hes by far the best spider man bc of his suit, his jokes, his body movements, and his personality. He’s also a great Peter parker because he’s still awkward and does a great job of looking like a smart quiet kid. He has the darkest story arch too. He’ll always be my favorite Spider-Man.
omg thankyou for saying what i was thought 🙄 i really miss amazing spiderman, the story so deep, the actors nails each characters
so his jokes, body language and personality makes up for all of the people killed by that truck in the start of the 2nd movie? because he couldve tried to stop it but he was literally too busy fucking around with that bald guy
@@nowherenearby9461 it’s a movie bro.
@@nylotical so a movie doesnt need to make sense now?
Andrew was a good superficial Spider-Man but he lacked the character's core whose morals flip flopped too much, not his fault due to the writing.
Andrews performance when he loses Gwen is actually stunning to watch I’m so glad there are other people like me who love this version and appreciate what Andrew did for the role and how this version of Spider-Man was written
Nice profile
It really did lose ceasar with it
@C J where’s Smokey?
Oh Carl Johnson what are you doing here LoL x3 XD
@@solarsetschannel he be chillin with Lisa Lisa
Even his Spider-Man is slightly more accurate. He actually makes smart and quick witted jokes in his fights and we didn’t get that with Tobey and Tom
So he is more accurate because of jokes?
@@caponeeeexx yes he is
@@caponeeeexx Yes, Spidey literally said multiple "youre so fat" jokes while fighting Kingpin.
@@caponeeeexx lmfao YES. Because he keeps up the morale instead of hopelessness, buy his humour haha
@@caponeeeexx Stings, Doesn't it?
Everyone thinks Tobey is the best because he’s the first, he is one of the most comic accurate spider man yet. But I agree Andrew has always been my favorite spider man, and he always will be because of his sad history
Tobey really isnt comic accurate tbh i mean the characterizations of the characters in the raimi trilogy all were way off (except jjj and norman osborn)
@@joshuaignacius9765 for me, Tobey spidey is basically MIguel Mighara spiderman 2099 COMIC versions.
Tobey is laughably different than comics Peter Parker. We really laugh off the organic web shooters, but we literally see nothing of Tobey's science side. Even the spy parents are from the comics.
Andrew's Spiderman is more comic accurate for me. The Amazing Spider-man is not as nerdy as the original Spider-Man, acts really arrogant and is the very definition of "what if a normal teen gets a superpower". But that's your opinion and I respect that, and this is my opinion and I'm just saying what I think is a fact.
For me? Tobey Maguire's first movie from a story-telling standpoint was amazing, I loved it, I still do, it's simple, shows good contrast between Peter and Spider-Man, but when I think of Tobey's Spider-Man I think of a different person, and Peter built walls around himself with the mask of Spider-Man.(Also, in the second movie Alfred Molina's Doctor Octavius is amazing) The reason why I think Tobey's is the most appreciated, especially in nostalgia, is because it's easy to follow as someone completely new to Spider-Man. It starts straight from the beginning. Nothing lives up to it's standard because it just told the story as it was. Andrew has the emotional response, which Tobey only really had when his arc was over, and he truly became Spider-Man. His (Andrew's) body language completely sold it for me. Tom's is odd to me, can't put my finger on why.. Maybe the lack of quips. Andrew set up that side of the character great! Dialogue sucked though, but the emotion was definitely there.
However, the lack of quips for Tobey's Spider-Man? (Apart from the meme-worthy ones) Well, tbh, it didn't feel needed as much to me. Tobey's Spider-Man is the most cliché, with MJ always being in danger, but I still loved it.
Tobey's Spider-Man feels like a brand (for the lack of a better word), not a person. When the suit's ripped however, you're reminded of who he really his. Me and my nostalgia-clouded vision have to hand it to Sam. He killed it.
Never understand why people hate it so much. Definitely my favourite. He’s chemistry and potrayal of love with gwen was just borderline perfection
I was a production assistant for this movie and at the time Andrew and Emma were dating. They hadn't spoken to each other all day if not a few days before the capture of Gwen's death. This is a technique called method acting so the emotional disconnect and loss of Emma's presence would force the emotion out of Mr. Garfield. What Peter felt there was genuine fear and grief.
This was the first take but there were a total of 3, the first one was all that was needed.
Now you know why that scene was so powerful.
-_-
Ok bud
Defo not a production assistant
@@merryethan2497 are you actually saying I'm lying? lol why are there so many Karen's on the internet these days
Tooooooootallllllly 😑
I still can’t get over how for a few years it was universally accepted that Andrew was the worst but now people are finally coming to the realization that he’s actually really good in the role
Not as good as Tom but better than Toby imo
@@p4nther521 Tom is shit he will never be spider man just iron boy jr his acting isn’t actually good either
@@TheWalkingDeadFanBoy5321 Jesus Christ man can't a guy have an opinion
@@stoneocean5341 Im a banana not a fucking guy
@@TheWalkingDeadFanBoy5321 if ur gonna talk about acting then i cant take you seriously because tobey s acting was atrocious and tho i like Andrew Garfield tom does a much better acting job as spider man.
One little detail that you missed is that Peter being a douche to Flash Thompson is what causes Uncle Ben to have to change shifts at work to meet with the school principal, which is why he couldn't pick up Aunt May and asked Peter to do it instead. Peter misusing his powers by being a dick to Flash is literally the first domino in a chain of events that directly leads to the death of Uncle Ben.
Damn, I never thought of that
Actually before the Raimi films, Garfield’s depiction of Peter Parker is 80% accurate (minus the slate boarding, etc) In the comics, Peter is a selfish, flawed asshole and it takes time for him to grow into the Spider-Suit. Upon getting his powers he becomes a bully and grows to embrace his responsibility over the city. He’s not cool, he’s an outsider. Not the nerd or the jock, just someone you know exists but wouldnt really care to talk to
Idk why people say this Peter is “cool” just because he rides a skateboard and is a little cocky doesn’t mean he is cool. This is probably the most accurate/up to date Peter we have had.
But he’s cool😭
I remember being in 6th grade frickin acting and wanting to be him just cause he was my greatest role model. HE is the reason why spiderman is my favorite hero.. after the new spiderman came out I started saying captain America was my favorite hero but I rewatched “the amazing Spider-Man” and I remembered why spiderman was my favorite.. him with the nostalgia is killing me.
@@matiasmuttoni9044 bruh. Rewatch it he is not cool. Again just because he rides a skateboard and is slightly cocky doesn’t mean he is as cool as everyone is making him out to be lol. Most nerds now are not going to be like tobey maguire because that was almost like a different era because of how things haved changed. Most “nerds” now are really just a loner and this Peter fits the definition of a nerd perfectly
@@UnderscoreAd it does make him cool.. and forget the skateboard, I’m talking about his persona. He’s outgoing, flashy, has this wicked ass character… you might not find it cool but everything ab his character is awesome.
@@UnderscoreAd and I’ve watched it as many times as I can count.. if he weren’t cool I wouldn’t have been obsessed w him when I was a kid😬
@@UnderscoreAd Peter was actually cool in comics
A lot of people forget that the comic's Peter Parker is a kinda a douche when he starts out too. People like to think that Peter should be a goody two shoes perfect good hearted character from the start, but he really shouldn't. I really respect the way Andrew played Peter, he did an Amazing job.
Meanwhile Tobey spider mans version:Doesnt stop a criminal that results his uncle death and in the start he just want to take revenge after that he learns his mistale and what his uncle meant bby with great power comes great responsibility
@@VergilDarkslayer you tryna start something you weeb?
@ramen? what Peter Parker yall know? because I grew up on Tobey and I read some comics.
Prior to his powers he was angry and frustrated but wouldn't pick fights or challenge the bully. Steve Rogers pre-serum would step in and challenge the bully if he was picking on someone but not Peter Parker. But Andrew's Peter seems to be a douche just for the sake of it sometimes. Even in the early days in the comics shortly after his powers he had to restrain himself and not lash out for fear of exposing his secret identity.
@ramen? Not even close. He breaks the promise at the end of the film. That's not Peter Parker.
I love how Andrew was shitted on by like everybody but then after he got his redemption now they just love him because of no way home but other genuinely loved andrews spiderman even before tom holland was ever spiderman
and now suddenly andrew is everyone's favorite.
I personally like Andrew Garfield spiderman because he doesn't' have the entire avengers right behind his back.
EXACTLY
That "Stay with me, stay with me." part was really his best acting.
Wasnt his best acting but it’s up there. Hacksaw ridge is his best work tbh
@@magggmae8880 tobey alert
@@0percent378 He's not being a Tobey Stan lmao, he's just stating that Hacksaw ridge was his peak of acting, which I agree, his acting in that movie was marvelous
@@neow6289 ok that was stupid of me I was doing team tobey stuff I like Andrew but the problem is that tasm 2 was bad but I'm looking forward to no way home but I think tobey is going to steal the spotlight from everyone
And the fact his face actually turned red in that scene is amazing
I disagree with alot of people’s take about Andrew not being a good Peter Parker he looks and the most like Comic Book peter to me. I do like the little quirks they added with the movies and Tv shows but you can’t ignore the original source material. Andrew Garfield was a great comic book spiderman.
I'm not going to discredit Tobey or Tom because both of them were made for the role of Spiderman. But in my opinion and I'm sure many agree, Andrew was the best Spiderman. He kept his originality but also kept to the comic. His emotions were out of this world. Tobey and Tom's emotions were spot on but it felt like it was a movie, which isn't bad at all! With Andrews, I felt like what was happening on screen, was happening in real life. His emotions made it real for me. Andrew was always humble within his character as Peter Parker and I hope, I really hope that he gets to complete his trilogy of being The Amazing Spiderman
Great post. I sure do agree.
The number 1 tip for writing the perfect protagonist is in all Spider-Man portrayals
1). Competence
2). Respect
3). Imperfection
3). Unfairly beat the everliving apricots out of him
Spider-Man embodies every single one of these attributes, which is why he is my favorite character in fiction
You have two number 3’s
@@justnate7196 He's asian.
He is my favourite character in all of fiction.
@@justnate7196 lol yeah like wtf
@@justnate7196 o-
As more a Tobey fan, Andrew is underrated.
Not anymore everyone loves him now Tom is massively underrated Ik ima get shit on but he is in my opinion
@@jaysalinas2 I don’t think Tom Holland is underrated … he’s helped make the Spider-Man franchise bigger then it ever has before
@@doccalis3150 he’s overhated his movies are so good and tons of people just shit on them
@@jaysalinas2 rly? I havnt heard about that, I suppose ppl hate on every Spider-Man. But personally iv heard nothing but great things abt Tom Holland’s Spider-Man. Each Spider-Man has their own weaknesses and strengths
@@doccalis3150 go all over Reddit and Twitter on you’ll see tons of ppl just shitting on his Spider-Man the main think you’ll see is iron boy jr
I've always loved TASM movies. In my opinion, the casting and acting are nearly perfect, and Andrew's Peter/Spiderman is genuinely witty and enjoyable to watch! Also can we talk about the directing and creative direction in these movies???? Especially the swinging through New York scenes at the beginning of Spiderman 2 and at the end??? I ABSOLUTELY love all of it.
my god so true!! the story in TASM is so deep and heavy!! i don't like home home spiderman this day, it's just bad writting or kind like such kids movie, but they make spiderman no way home now and give a chance to andrew that so fantastic!! i heard that's gonna be the third TSMA and andrew will fight venom i can't hardly wait
Gwen dying scene gets me everytime
Edit:
Also I love that this community all recognizes how good Andrew is
When Gwen died I never really realized how good Andrew Garfield was. He started off in denial telling her to stay with him and making it seem like she’d just wake up. But you can see it seriously sink in. Great performance
It's funny because Andrew's douchyness as Peter Parker is far more accurate to the early dikto comics than any other adaptation. The skateboard and all that is dumb but the chip on his shoulder and so on is amazing.
.
I think the skateboarding aspect isn't too far fetched, as skateboarding is one of the only sports that doesn't rely on other people. I used to be a skateboarder because I felt like an outcast, and skateboarding was all I had. It kinda reflects on Peter's personality
Thank you Peter isn't a perfect Saint and Andrew wasn't too douchy just felt like a regular teen
@@dylanhutto3971 people hated on the scene because it wasn't realistic and I was like you're watching spiderman skateboarding of course it wasn't realistic
@@theoutsiderjess4869 Ah, yeah I never heard that but I'm only recently a Spidey fan
Andrew was always my favorite Spiderman, and nothing can change my mind.
Butterfingers
Andrew Garfield was handed a shitty script because of corporate drama between Sony & MCU & he did the best he could do with what the directors & script told him. TASM was supposed to be 5 part series but they wrapped it up without even giving Andrew time to shine. Andrew Garfield will always be MY SPIDERMAN. Like dude totally nailed the acting as both Peter Parker & Spiderman. He really got the body language of Spiderman & Peter. You could actually feel this is the spiderman we have all grown up with reading the comics. His sense of humour, the facial expressions and his delivery of emotional dialogues were perfect. It's almost like could see his expressions under the mask even though you couldn't see it. He didnt even have those adjustable eyes like Tom has. No wonder Andrew Garfield has been nominated to the Oscars TWO TIMES for Best Actor category. He's a talented actor, too bad they didnt give him as much chance as they gave Tobey & Tom. Had TASM got 5 movies, I guarantee you no one would even dare to question who the best Spiderman is.
Not to mention the swinging is TASM is umatched. No one, not even Raimi & MCU spiderman comes close to the parkour scenes of TASM. Also Andrew Garfield's spiderman gave the most " your friendly neighbourhood spiderman" vibes than Tobey & Tom. The way he connected to people & kids in the movie like that scene where he saves the kid from the burning car & talks to him gives him his mask or when he pulls up to fight Rhino at the end of TASM 2 when that kid is standing all alone.... That is the essence of Spider-Man for me. Tom Holland's spiderman went to picnic in Washington DC in 1st movie & UK in 2nd movie. So much for "your friendly neighbourhood spiderman"💀
Man I really hope now that No way home has confirmed 3 spiderman can exist together & this whole concept of "Spiderverse" is being loved by people(Both No way home & Across the Spiderverse have been superhit at the box office while other superhero movies are failing)... I really hope Sony brings back Andrew Garfield as Spiderman for TASM 3 or a TV series. Tom Holland can still remain the Spiderman of the MCU universe but Andrew Garfield can be the spiderman of the Sony universe where Venom, Morbius, Kraven,Rhino etc exist. Why can't we have both?? Even Andrew has said it in interviews he's ready to play the role for the fans. Man it feels like such a wasted opportunity if Sony doesn't make this happen 😭...
I still think to this day that Andrew Garfield should’ve been the MCU Spider-Man. Tom Holland’s personality is more Miles than Peter. Andrew deserved better. TASM 1 and 2 actually feel like Spider-Man movies. Homecoming and FFH felt like MCU spin-off movies and simply just that. They just didn’t have that spark that the Raimi Trilogy and the Webb Duology had. Peter actually had to take responsibility. Gwen’s death actually felt like it had an impact. The MCU hasn’t done Peter justice and I hope they can fix that. Maybe Spider-Man 3(MCU) can finally mold Tom into his own hero.
Nah miles is black 😔
@@MoodyW0rld his personality isn't
Also Andrew and tobey are supposed to be back in spiderman 3
@@huntersolo8322 no he is by his music and style
@@MoodyW0rld and his exaggerated swagger
The TASM movies are a masterpiece, complete, comprehensive it captures the Spider-Man experience.
Absolutely, these movies are what made me like spidey and in turn made me like comic book characters
It is quite literally the most underrated film of all time maybe. The whole plot line makes sense for people aren't easily confused. The fight scenes are better than the Sam Raimi trilogy and the MCU Spider-Man movies. Andrew Garfield and Emma stones chemistry easily made them a better love interest then Kirsten Dunst and Tobey Maguire. The suits are better, the acting is a little better than others, and best of all, the reality of villains. It's not all light and sunny in these movies. It makes you feel the Spider-Man experience. Turning into Spider-Man trying to catch his Uncle's killer. In my opinion, I feel like TASM 1 & 2 are THE best Spider-Man movies, and I say nothing, NOTHING can change my mind.
Cringe
you deserve my Praise.
‘Masterpiece’ lmao please😭
This has aged brilliantly
I always liked how his was no arrogant and hot-headed because you can't just have a perfect character from the beginning and have him be same because starting imperfect and becoming better is called Character Development
I agree. His Spider-Man is so underrated.
Yess!
Bruh no you dont agree. Tobey is the best one. Yall just dont want to admit it because of this video.
@@caponeeeexx Did u just liked ur own comment?🤣
@@imnoone6008 Yes i did.
@@caponeeeexx Tom is the most popular Spider-Man Tobey is a good Peter and Andrew is a good Spider-Man but Tom is best of both tbh I don’t even like the original 3 movies
Many people think that he’s the worst due to the 2nd movie. But if you are a teen, you need responsibility, you are a nerd, a quiet kid. It’s just like a teen. I agree with you. Andrew is the most realistic Spidey ever. Peter should be like this and he is! Tho sam Raimi is awesome, Andrews is super great. I don’t understand how people hate him. You’re going to have thousands of subs. Just like hitop films. Can’t wait to see you get more popular!
Andrew garfield is a perfect spiderman because well tom holland is young but a bit cringy will tobey maguire was perfect but his performance was cheesy
@@ItsFox Thank you for standing up for Andrew he was so underrated he did not deserve the hate he got
It was Sony and avi arad who fucked him and Marc webb over sony got too involved and tried to rush it And ruined TASM 2
I personally like all three of them the same
He he’s very realistic
Noone says he's a terrible Spider-Man he's just the worst Spider-Man between the three
Gotta say, Andrew's performance when he lost Gwen is EXTREMELY underrated.
andrew is incredible in any role he gets, i seriously love him as spider-man
This movie had the best swinging in my opinion.
Moreover this movie feels more human and focuses on emotions and you can see the growth in peter parker.
"You have been a bad lizard"
That's 100% Spiderman 🤣
You’re a real one man, you recognized Andrew’s greatness long before the No Way Home bandwagons ✌️
I think the silent majority prefers Andrew Garfield and I say silent because everybody has been screaming through the roof for Andrew to get a final chapter in his trilogy he never got. Nobody's shouting for more Toby movies or even more Tom Holland movies, but everybody seems to want another Andrew movie. I think his movies are aging very well. He has been my favorite since I first saw the movies and I saw them late, I didn't watch them until far from home came out and I decided to check out his films
The thing I appreciate the most about TASM movies, is that they're very grounded when it comes to the consequences of Peter's actions.
He goes through a lot of sadness, and the people closest to him always end up dying, which is a very realistic take for a superhero.
Thank you for making this video, you hit the head on the nail on why I love Andrew's Spidey :)
Na even Kevin fiege said that since he cries in every other scene it dilutes his performance in the real sad moments like gwens death
@@Brawlypython244 I don't agree at all. His performance during Gwen's death was gut-wrenching.
@@lil7725 ikr
@@lil7725 when I saw this in theaters her death caught me so off guard cause like, in my mind Heroes always won and to see him win the fight but lose in such a horrible way made this movie one of my favorites
@@Brawlypython244 Kevin Feige a PC hack now thanks to Ethernals Captain Marvel.
I feel these movies are totally underrated, the fact that Sony interfered so much and still Marc Web was able to put out such great films is a testament to the sheer effort and love put into them. Could they have been better if Marc Web had total creative freedom? Probably, we’ll never know, but what we got are good movies and I’m grateful for that
Man that’s always the story I hear with these movies. Creator tries to make his own thing, company interferes, said thing basically gets trimmed apart and now gets negative feedback. Why can’t these companies just let people do what they want to do? God.
Great film? Ok 😂😂😂
If anyone noticed, he also moves completely different, than any other Spider-Man. He moves like an actual Spider and has the agility of a Spider.
All of the actors who have played Spider-Man have good things about them and so do their series. With that being said, TASM movies are easily my favourite. I love Andrew's portrayal of Peter/Spider-man. I just feel most connected to him. Also, the chemistry in these movies is totally unmatched by any of the other romantic pairings from the other Spider-Man movies.
Not gonna lie I’m so glad that more people see what I see in his Spider-Man. Watching TASM 1 in the theaters was one of the best theater experiences I’ve had. He isn’t as good as Maguire, but I think he’s leagues above Holland. He just evokes Spider-Man. Because He’s a nerd, but they don’t make him stick out like a sore thumb. Which was Stan Lee’s intention. To have him just be a pretty smart, but overall ordinary teen. And I hate how people bring up that uncle Ben’s killer was never caught as a plot hole, when it’s literally integral to his character that he DOESNT get that revenge.
In TASM2 videogame the killer was killed by Cletus Kasady actually.
Well i watched TASM2 ON THEATER it was epic and fun
Tom is the most comic book accurate. You all disagree because you're blinded by the hate.
@@okand6770 in what way. Read literally the first Spider-Man comic and you’ll see that raimi spidey was the most comic accurate. They took a lot from miles Morales and gave it to MCU Peter. A hero that’s his mentor and he looks up to, a chubby best friend who’s really smart (gankee but now Ned).
@@movieblocks9164 you do realize tony was Peter's mentor in the comics right?
Andrew Garfields spider man was the most realistic, meaning that his flaws greatly resembled a lot of people therefore it makes him more relatable. Yeah he’s not like the comic book peter Parker we know, but that’s what I like about them he’s different and relatable.
Comic book Peter was vengeful and egotistical until he found out he was responsible for Uncle Ben's death. Andrew's Peter goes through the same arc in TASM1
Tobey was also a pretty flawed person in the Rami trilogy. He gave up being Spider Man for a while and didn’t do anything to help a guy getting mugged and beaten in an alleyway. Not to mention how he becomes an egotistical asshole in 3.
Andrew Garfield's Peter stands up to bullies like Flash Thompson in a much more assertive way, to the point of arguably being a jerk. This is much more in line with Peter in the comics' early days, who had loads of contempt for his classmates and pretty much anyone who happened to get on his nerves. Likewise, Andrew's incarnation had a much easier time of cracking wise and coming off as a jokester, albeit in a way that was still assertive and didn't reduce him to comedic relief. Tobey's Spidey rarely joked, and when he did, it came off as unnatural, especially given how serious the movies themselves were. Andrew's spiderman had the most accurate arcs to the comics, he had the mannerisms of spiderman well done and was acrobatic,agile with spider like movements. Andrew's peter didn't look upto anyone other than his uncle and aunt, like his own man. He overcomed his own problems and portrayed the brilliant witty side of the spider. He's also the exact height as parker in comics and has demonstrated the typical life of a struggling teen well.
After watching NWH, I’m super super glad to see people finally recognising and giving credit to Andrew’s portrayal of Spiderman. His lean and slender demeanour, is how I would imagine the person behind the spiderman mask would be. And man, dont even get me started on his acting chops. My man made everyone teary eyed in that one single scene from NWH which lasted about 6 secs (y’all know what scene I’m talking about).
Personally, whilst I love how Gwen's death was handled at the end of the second film, I would have preferred it to lead into the 3rd film with Peter still struggling from that loss and not having come to terms with it completely yet so that the third film could focus primarily on Peter overcoming that grief, rather than them wrapping up that plotline so quickly. Obviously that was never to happen anyway as we never even got a 3rd film but I feel it would have made for a great arc for Andrew's Peter if we ever did get that 3rd film
That's actually a really interesting idea but at the same time i also liked how they ended tasm 2, one of my favorite endings and really captures what spidey means to the city and people all together and shows that he truly is a hero. Him facing gwen's death would've been amazing for the 3rd movie but then most of the movie would be more of Peter and not spidey which lot of people sadly wouldn't like. Maybe if it were a tv series that arc would've made a lot more sense
Apparently he was supposed to bring her and others he loved back to life using his blood in the 3rd TASM.. but seems a bit wack to me. I would have loved to see how they make it work though.
I'll be hoping to see him overcome his grief fighting his past monsters in Far From Home while also saving MJ from the fall 👀
I think they had planned for more movies but the second one didnt do good enough to make a third one not sure tho
boy do I got some news for you
I feel like Andrew’s Peter Parker is actually close to the comics mixed with realism. One way Marc Webb described it was making Peter an outsider instead of a nerd since nerd has a different meaning nowadays. He’s a kid with a chip on his shoulder. Remember in Amazing Fantasy when Peter says “they’re the only ones who’ve ever been kind to me. I’ll see to it that they’re always happy, but the rest of the world could hang for all I care”? You see that here. His relationship with Uncle Ben and Aunt May feel like a real relationship between a son and his parents. And after getting picked on for so long, when he finally has the ability to fight back, Peter takes a shot at Flash. Who wouldn’t do that? Lee and Ditko Spidey was wise beyond his years, but he was still a sarcastic immature kid with anger issues and I think Andrew Garfield nailed that. Or at least, he did perfect with the material he was given
the scene where hes crying over gwen brought me to tears watching the film and not many films do that at all. incredible performance by garfield
He is my favourite Spider-Man too. He is more realistic because of all the different feelings he go through. The other Spider-Man variants are too perfect for me. I hope he comes back as Spider-Man
You seriously calling Tobey perfect when in 3 he becomes a egotistical asshole who almost destroys the relationships he has with his loved ones?
@@austinjohnsen4430 Not tobey… Andrew
@@paranormalbabi You said the other Spider Man variants are too perfect when that couldn’t be further from the truth. Tobey in the second movie gives up being Spider Man for a while and ignores such things like a car chase and a guy getting mugged in an alleyway. Moving on to Tom Holland, his first solo movie as Spider Man is essentially a comedy of errors that culminates in people on a ferry almost getting killed, and he needed Iron Man to bail him out of that one.
Rather than being a Comic Accurate Peter Parker, he feels more... realistic (I think), I mean like there ain't that many "Nerds" nowadays. Andrews Peter feels more of a loner or introvert, and I feel like he is the most relatable Spide man (except the stalker for Gwen part lol), but if we're going to talk about his Spider man, then he will definitely be the most accurate one out of Tobey and Toms Spidey
I'm not hating on Tobey and Toms Spidey, just stating my opinion here
For me I consider the Tobey spider man *movie* the best...
Good story,nice action,and overall easy to watch and understand..its got the classic movie vibe
Where as in tasm its a lot more hard ...
I feel like Andrews spider man shruggles in the movie were a bit depressing and he got the edgy teen sad vibes
But in between the two spider man actors I'd prefer Andrew a bit more
Very true by 2012 being nerdy wasn't seen as being a bad thing unlike the original spiderman movies
@@bigchungus5366 I love Tobey but something about his performance always felt lacking to me it felt like I was watching actor be spiderman instead of spiderman
He actually is a more comic accurate in a lot of ways as in og comics peter was a duche and wasnt a saint kinda like andrew is
No matter what anyone says, the TASM series will always be my favorite, i feel like they captured spiderman and peter parker perfectly and it just felt right, plus i also loved the suits for both movies, great series overall
Tobey used to be my favorite due to nostalgia but after having read the comics from the 60s-80s, I have to say I prefer Andrew. He's probably the most accurate Spider-Man and brings the Peter from the comics just to life
I grew up with the TASM movies, not the Raimi trilogy. So i feel very nostalgic about Andrew's Spider-Man.
Andrew's performance was absolutely fantastic. I loved him in both the movies and he will always be my favorite Spider-Man. Nobody can change my mind.
for real
SAME
Andrew wasn’t a great Spider-man, he was the best!
You had me in the first half not gonna lie
The best. He proved it in NWH.
@@itsxavier6173 when standing among the other spidermen he was the best , that really shows how great he is
No no he was amazing, alright I will see myself out now
But you know when everyone says your fav spider man is the worst then you start crying..... I always do that because I love Andrew.. 😭
This is one of the most sad movies i have ever seen, the connection in between Andrew and Emma is incredible. Not only that, i also think that he is the best spider-man, but the sequence of the films just weren’t perfect.This film made me cry like no other.
2002 Peter: Nerdy but comic accurate.
2012 Peter: average high school loner
2017 Peter: Comic accurate....If he was Miles Morales.
ur totally off
@@thenarcissist7885 You don’t think Homecoming Peter was greatly inspired by Miles but to better fit in the MCU?
- Peter went to a public high school called Midtown High.
- Miles went to Brooklyn Vision Academy a school for the academically gifted.
And what type of school does MCU Peter go to? An academically gifted academy type of school.
- Peter has a best friend name Harry Osborn, he’s super rich and good looking well fit dude who has daddy issues.
- Miles has Ganke Lee is super smart and loves being Spider-Man’s tech guy and physically a bit overweight. (Not that matters, just stating it.)
And what type of best friend does MCU Spider-Man have? A kid named Ned Leeds (who’s not really THE Ned Leeds as far as I can tell.) What type of friend is Ned? Hmmm let me think.. he’s a super smart dude that loves being Spider-Man’s tech guy and is physically a bit overweight. (Although the actor is physically getting into shape probably for a roll.)
- Peter finds motivation to be Spider-Man by the death of his TRUE father figure and the man that raised him Ben Parker. “great power comes great responsibility.”
- Miles Finds motivation to be Spider-Man because of the death of a former hero and trying to live up to that shadow that will always be placed upon him. Only to realize HE and only HE himself can live up to his own expectations.
From what I can tell MCU Peter became Spider-Man obviously because of the death of his uncle it doesn’t have to be stated when it comes to the backstory because everyone knows the story, BUT that doesn’t mean we just forget about it too, you can argue..”BuT PeTe HaD A OlD sUitCase FroM UnClE BeN”
Yeah? And what happened to that suite case? Destroyed. And he didn’t seem to care about the sentimental value of it too. He seems more
motivated to be Spider-Man because of the death of a former hero and trying to live up to that shadow that will always be placed upon him.
Edit: Should I go on?
If you want comic accuracy, then read the damn comics, let the movies have their own thing
@@vesha6274 yeah I kinda agree, personally tho I would love it if Spider-Man life story becomes a 1 season show on Disney plus or it could be animated too!
Edit: or a multiple season type of thing and each season can represent a new decade
0:42 No, you're dead wrong. That's exactly what Peter was for most of his comic run.
He got his redemption in Spider-Man No Way Home. Hope we get more of him in future. We need TASM3
Indeed
@@justsmith3423 Indeed Indeed
@@remambane69420 Indeed Indeed Indeed
@@tuffgab Indeed indeed indeed indeed
@@vicenzomcblitz4435 indeed indeed indeed indeed indeed
He's the underappreciated middle child, and the most mature a Spider-Man will ever get while still retaining some comic charm. The new spiderman movies are just a cashgrab but the amazing spider-man was a flawed but very entertaining experiment.
at 4:12 when he says “just look at garfields performance” I’ve felt a wave of sad emotions through the whole cinema. I heard nothing but sniffles and sobbing within the audience. Andrew did such an amazing job. Props to Tobey, Andrew, and Tom for being the Spider-Mans we need. With great power comes with great responsibility.
I don’t know if he’s my favorite, but this series is way underrated and I adore it.
TASM was literally the first superhero movie i watched (i was 10 or so) and I fall absolutely in love with Andrew Garfield. back then i wasn't really a big fan of superhero movies. TASM gives me more of a high school movie vibe more than superhero movies and introduced me to other superhero movies, that's why i love TASM 1-2 so much like they literally mean so much to me. Also Andrew's performance is LEGEND man, like cool Peter Parker? Count me in
I feel so validated! Webb and Garfield nailed the beautiful depth of emotions and pain. Emma Stone’s Gwen and Garfield’s Peter are phenomenal together! I saw TASM2 in the theater’s years ago, and Gwen’s death still hurts just as bad.
This video deserves 100 million views and an Oscar
Andrew Garfield will forever be the only true Spider-Man
im so disappointed they threw him and his franchise away people just like to criticize. his franchise for me at least was one of the best superhero movies i seen becouse unlike other people i let my self connect to the new peter parker the peter parker which is cool guy douchy and not cringy like the other two
I still think maguire and Holland are better
@@spiderman4538 I just don't really like Garfield.
@@FATI_SZN he is the best
@@adhithyanvsanthosh8200 no not really
Tobey's peter: Comic accurate
Andrew's peter: realistic
Tom's peter: i don't even know.....
edited: I'm not hating on mcu spidey, there are a couple aspects of him i really like but maguire and garfield's version is superior, in my eyes i can't see tom holland's performance as Peter Parker, i see him moree as Miles Morales. (this is my opinion don't hate)
I don't know but as a high-school student I can say that tom is the most relatable spider man
@@knightgamer1533 I am a high school student too but Andrew is the most relatable to me
Maguire's peter ain't even accurate
Stan Lee's peter is a lady's man and a bit of an asshole
Dan Slott's peter focuses more on his genius
Straczynski's peter is much more confident(I mean the peter in this run is a teacher),
Bendis's peter has a huge anger issues(calling flash a retard,m.j stupid and humiliated his teacher in front of the class)
These guys are some of the best and most famous writers for Spider-man and none of their peter acts the same way Maguire does(awkward,spineless loser)
Andrew might not be a better character but his peter is more accurate than Maguire
@@PhantommJ OK but...
@@knightgamer1533?
I used to be very Tobey biased cus I grew up watching him, but after watching the new Spiderman having all three together and going back watching the old ones I definitely appreciate and enjoy Andrew’s more cus I mean come on we love a cool Spiderman.
andrew’s peter parker went through endless torment. his parents dying, uncle ben dying, the captain dying, gwen dying.
yet he still went on. he is such an impeccable character.
i need TASM 3!!
Andrew Gardfield is actually also my favorite Spider-Man
Same!!
Bruh i want to know whats good about this movie? He gets bitten on the back of the neck and he doesnt even do photography. The only thing that was nice was the suit.
@@caponeeeexx Did u just liked ur own comment?🤣
The one thing I will say about Tom Holland is that he actually looks like he can possibly be in high school without an extreme debilitation. At least the kids will watch it without getting the impression that you should be a full grown adult before leaving grade 12.
So true, I remember as a kid watching Spider-Man (2002) I always got confused as to why the students were older than the teacher
@@bluesEvanskro I'll add that adults are likely cast in highschool roles in series such as Riverdale because the ongoings of those shows could amount to CP if the actors were underaged.
@@alexandermccalla5098 actually its more just the work laws in place for people under a certain age, its much easier to just cast and adult on almost any production
i've seen highschoolers with beards that looked 20
His my favorite because the way he crawls around lizard is like a real spider
I like this Spiderman the best because it reveals some very dark sides to his existence. It also mirrors the feel, if in only a few aspects, of the Superman reboots. Kal-El felt the same kind of loneliness that Peter felt, albeit, for different reasons. They both lost father figures in their lives while not having experience with their natural fathers (and with both viewing the essence of their fathers in similar ways, how ironic!) The main difference in the two is Peter's a mutant and Kal's an alien.
I love Andrews' portrayal of the character in general, including his Peter Parker. I'd argue his Peter is better than Tobeys' version since before he became Spider-Man, Peter was kind of a dick in the early Lee/Ditko and Ultimate comics, which is what these movies mainly draw inspiration from. To me, Tobeys' Peter is TOO awkward and nerdy, to the point where he's just pathetic and unlikeable lol.
I had friends argue that he wasnt "nerdy" enough and said andrew garfield is like a model. 1. For the time period the first asm was made nerds weren't the stereotypical way shown in the early marvel days. They arent wearing sweater vest and pocket protectors with thick glasses. In 2012 the outsider or the kid picked on was someone like garfield portrayed. As far as him being "too pretty" my arguement for that was he isnt like some stacked dude that screams the American idea of attractive. If anything his features are pretty average. Brown hair, brown eyes, toned but not muscular, no hipster beard or stache, just a normal looking dude. I'd say he is better looking than toby, but my opinion is that doesnt mean much tbh. I never understood their hate for asm. I get why people dont like the 2nd one, but that first one is the spiderman movie and character I remember reading in the mid to late 90s (mostly the ultimate run which I find extremely similar to the movie in a lot of ways). I think people just remember the classic stories and want like a 60s spiderman...but to me that's just not relevant anymore. Those stories have already been told, and the world is a much different place. Sad thing is that if they got what they wanted they'd probably shit on it...people are fickle.
@@tigmil8116 I don't know why people say Garfield was "too good looking", Peter is never described as being unattractive in the comics.
@@tigmil8116 problem is people sees tobey peter as the true peter parker which is not , spiderman's charm was also peter's charm and if riding a skateboard was too cool for peter then i dont know what you called it after peter take mj on a date with a motor bike in college. Peter has some coolness in his body too, tobeys peter or the peoples definition of true peter is mainly the reason why they hate andrews peter
Tobey is better dumbass!
@@beck3094 Tobey IS the true Peter Parker dumbass!
About Andrew's Peter being arrogant and careless... in the Ditko's early stories he is a lot like that even after Ben's death. I think Marc Webb got more inspiration from that era for this Peter. The Ultimate version is kind of like that sometimes too.
NOW people are appreciating him??? 😩
what you said in the end is what ive been thinking all this time. Andrew garfield really is the most REALISTIC spiderman on screen. Everything from way of being, to his transition, to his way of moving on screen. Andrew isnt too heavy and bulky as toby is in my opinion, and at the same time hes not a light feather like tom holland. Theres actually human in him, while showing that he is irregular, which means so much to me.
This is awesome! Andrew Garfield’s Spider-Man is my favorite for all the reasons you stated. I will say he’s not the best (my opinion) but he’s definitely better than Tom Holland’s Spider-Man. I still hate that we never got to see Tasm 3 and Andrew stay as Spidey, he was robbed of his role.
Tasm3 it Will be crazy(yes i am fucking creep)
But there is a Hope Left
Spider verse 😀😍
Andrew is my favourite Peter Parker because he embodies a modern teenager perfectly. The arrogant, chip on his shoulder that most teenagers have. We were and still are irresponsible at times and probably have a lot of anger at the world.
Andrew portrays the emotional trauma that comes with losing one's loved ones really well, which is why I like him the best. Tobey goes straight into doing the right thing; Tom doesn't even get to show his grieving.
I also think that his character is more relatable, compared to just being the smart nerdy one and that's all people see, Andrews peter parker show more of his hobbies and interest and he is more in touch with his emotions.
This is the most realistic peter parker and spiderman.
It took him half a film to actually be spiderman(bridge scene)
His a teenager thats undergoing changes, has a complex, and is immature. Thats very relatable to an extent. The whole first movie was about more than great power come great responsibility. Its about doing the right thing because you can, and the hardest decisions are what makes him a hero. Peter in the beginning made a mistake which he regrets and in the end he makes a decision that he will regret.
Pretty much the same thing in the 2nd one. He makes a mistake which he regrets in the end because he thought he could have a normal life but that is far from it. But in the end of that movie he makes a decision that he wont regret is that by continuing to be spiderman.
Same thing as Tobey Maguire Spiderman. He took risks. And how is Andrew more realistic? because he doesnt even do photography like the normal peter.
@@caponeeeexx My guy what does realistic have to do with photography?
@@ashtonshannon762 My guy what does my comment have to do with your personal life?
@@caponeeeexx The stupidity of the comment disturbed my personal life
@@ashtonshannon762 Oh wow. Thanks man. Im so glad that im part of your personal life when I dont even know you. But its good to have a friend thats obsessed with me. Maybe a little too much.
I was so sad when I heard he was recasted
Same
Same here
I was mad.
Tom is the best, you may not agree but don't piss off Tom's fans
@@renujha6373 in my opinion tom is kinda bad, his character and arc is too soft for an actual Peter or Spider-Man. Maybe if he had better writers yes but I’d rather have the non perfect life that Andrew and Tobey have to realistically show Peter.
I like the dark gritty take on Spidey so TASM 1 is my favorite.
Out of all 3, Andrew is the only one who had a new species if spiders named after him. This due to his spider like portrayal to spider man
You're 100% on point. Tobey's Spider-Man is like the character in the pages come to life, but Garfield's is easily the most real (Holland is in a weird gray area I'm not a huge fan of). While Tobey will always be my Spider-Man because Nostalgia, I really hope that people look fondly back on Garfield's and how he handled the direction he was given.
tasm is dogshit
@@rdrdrdrdrdrdrdrdrdr8675 You are completely entitled to your own opinion and I respect you for putting yourself out there
@@rehmanmir7865 yeah i sounded like a dickhead sorry lol
@@rdrdrdrdrdrdrdrdrdr8675 it is all good my friend
@@rdrdrdrdrdrdrdrdrdr8675 man he is not talking about the story and direction he's talking about the actor who played spider man so well
Wow this really opened my eyes, I always thought Andrew’s version was so bad because it felt too edgy. I need to watch these movies again he really did amazing and the comic influence is definitely there showing him as a broken, struggling hero.
Respect
ye i think you bring that edgy sort of spiderman out now and everyone will post about it saying they 'relate' and they 'felt that'
That fact that you said edgy makes your opinion invalid. Peter wasn’t even remotely edgy you sheltered weirdo.
i loved his black eyes and he arches his back and his crawling is so cool