Corey will probably never see this comment; but I will go ahead and write it anyhow. I have a problem with the question. "Do you want to ethnically cleanse Palestinians?" Would only get a no as an answer because no one should answer yes to that on a camera. Here is a way to rephrase it: What do you think would be the best solution to the conflict: A) The Palestinians move to neihbouring Arabs lands. B) The Palestinians get their own sovereign country in accordance with the 1967 boarders. C) The Palestinians remain where they are and live in a Jewish state under laws that reflect Jewish heritage as the center of identity and politics (Jewish supremacy) D) The Palestinians remain and Israel and Palestine become one secular democratic state (like a federation) with equal rights for all. I'd be way more interested in answers to this type of phrasing from both sides.
E) Israel decides on becoming a republic, annexes Judea and Samaria, and the Gaza Strip, and offers non-Israeli Arab individuals a choice to start on a path towards becoming full citizens. Read Moshe Berent's "A people like all peoples" (2009).
Palestine will come under the rule of turkey as it was before nd settlers will test their dna nd if they are European they will be deported @@sofsof4950
@@sofsof4950 that sounds like another version of what is going on now; Israel treats the Palestinians as second class citizens because they are not full citizens. How long would that pathway take😅 another 75 years? Why don't the Israelis get a pathway to citizenship? This is that Jewish supremacy talk all over again. One secular democratic state with equal rights for all is the only just course to take. I understand no one is interested on either side, but what else can be fair and just?
@@curious493 It's nothing like what is going on now. The specifics of the pathway are debatable. The idea really is a secular democratic state with equal rights for all.
Iraqi American here, I wish to see a day on earth just one day where all of us humans sit together and share cultures regardless of who we are because we all have more in common than we know. I wish we stop listening to BS media and news stations worldwide because they are the causers of division. One day we will all leave this earth it really technically does not belong to any of us we are here for a short period of time and I wish we use our time filed with love. Let your neighbor worship 1 or 100 gods it shouldn’t be anyone’s concern the only concern we should focus on is love and respect
@@Kurdishboy2698 well I tend to not lean towards any sect I am Muslim and that’s it I want to worship a One God and live with peace. I’m sick of humans fighting one another over things that will also perish along with us
I hope you understand that the Jews of Iraq were violently disposed of their property and were treated as dhmmi. Do you know about the Fauhoud of 1941?
When you translate "ethnic cleansing" into לנקות it means "to clean" (like cleaning the floor), the correct term is לטהר אתנית. But I would argue that this is not the term Israelis use. They use words like: לשטח את עזה or לגרש את כל הערבים. You have to adjust the term to the culture. It's just like you wouldn't translate a Kibbutz as a village, and "village" is usually reserved to Arab settlements only. Other than that, you have to read between the lines of what people have just said. I believe the 1st two actually do mean they do not support ethnic cleansing, but, and this is a huge but, the guy that said, for example, that we need to "speak like Arabs" actually means to hit the Arabs hard. It's a term used with Israeli right-wingers who support the coalition. What they mean with that is that we shouldn't show weakness, and every blow we receive should be met with a deadlier response. I do think, however, that what most Israelis want is simply security. What security means to Israelis is a scale, though. For example, the mainstream view of security is to "respond hard". When we're attacked, we'll attack twice as hard. People then will ask: "Why didn't we attack sooner?" It stems from pure fear, and this is the number one issue Israelis vote for. Netanyahu knows how to utilize this.
Nothing to do with Netanyahu. I voted for Hertzog (Labour - left of centre) previously. It is to do with neighbours who are self-declared terrorists who want to kill all Jews and Israelis (and other Infidels). Israel, from all political factions, is united to destroy Hamas from Gaza so what happened on 7th October cannot happen again. The bigger picture is that: World peace cannot permit millions of people to support terror and the murder of innocent people who think differently from you. World peace cannot allow a North Korea with nuclear weapons that threatens SK, Japan, US, etc. World peace cannot permit an Iranian apocalyptic regime, that longs for Armageddon, to exist among civilised nations. The equilibrium is too fragile now and can be tipped over far too easily.
Just to clarify: when we say "speak like Arabs" it means loosely "to speak [the language of] Arabs", ie, "the language they understand best/use on us"= violence. Just breaking down the linguistic underpinning here.
But how can you have security while having as an official State policy the occupation and colonization of another people land and denying the right for the forced expelled to get back to their land? Don't Israelies see that they cannot have both?
Go ask the Gazans that Israel has kept in an open Air prison and killed their women and children. Have been forced to live in Gaza because they ethnically cleansed them from their land. What answer do you expect to get. Israil has been exposed for the racist apartheid state it is.😂.
I can't believe that people here, hundreds or thousands of miles from the conflict, think they know what the Isrselis think better than the Israelis. There is a massive difference between the view of us outside abd those who really have skin in the game. It's like listening to boring, righteous pontifucating football pundits rather thsn the players themselves
We also have opinions on the Holocaust but I guess you're not upset about that because we're aligned on the subject. Palestine is thousands of miles from the sites of European atrocities against Jews, yet they have paid the price with their homeland. The US is thousands of miles from israel and yet their essential support guarantees the continuation of this conflict.
@HumanBeingsRThinkingBeings I live in Israel, and I have heard no "Death to Arab" chants. I am sure there are pockets of idiots who do that, as there are anywhere. Regarding Death to Jew chants, it's not pockets: it is the majority doing that.
@HumanBeingsRThinkingBeings Both are terrible. But the world has gone cold towards Muslims and genocides towards Muslim populations in the last 3 decades proves that.
What's weird is that you're in the city... where most of these Israelis are liberal. Conservatives are the majority now. Go to the small towns, ask them, and they will tell you 90% of the time they want to remove Palestinians from the land. Don't word it "ethnically cleanse" just ask "if you could press a button, would you remove all Palestinians outside of Israel, West Bank, and Gaza."
It is amazing how many think their was peace on Oct 6th. Most of these people stated that they are fine with Palestinians as long as they stop hurting us, but seem completely oblivious to the harms they have been doing them. It's weird.
@@dogzdigital all the harm that was ever done to the Palestinians was done to prevent them from hurting Israelis. The previous rounds in Gaza happened because they were shooting rockets into Israel, by thousands, and needed to be stopped. All the damage their sustained was following Arab loses in wars Arabs started. They never want peace!
You're flipping things around. the settlements didn't exist until later during this conflict. in fact Jordan was in control of the west bank and Egypt in control of Gaza until 67. Many years and a lot of violence later the settlements started being built BECAUSE of constant Palestinian violence. not the opposite way around.
Sweetheart, no one is doing any violence in west bank, except for illegal.settlers so stop yapping. Settlers are there for a reason to annex west bank. How do you think israel was found settlers from european countries.
@@einefes keep telling that to urself...will make you feel pretty. USA the unyeilding ally of israel doesnt recognize the settlements. As of now settlements are the main things which is eroding the required two state solution. Every bloody state except israel is willing for a two.state. You should know that by now. I.thought iran was good in taqiya but wow israelies or their.supporters are steps ahead of them
THIS IS A BAD QUESTION. Too many people incorrectly think "ethnic cleansing" means "genocide". So people think you are asking "Do you want to genocide all the Palestinians". Of course they will say "NO". The question you should ask is "Do you think we should make most Palestinians move out of Gaza (and the West Bank) ?"
The Hamas Charter answers that question. Then there is this ==> Arab child abuse fuels Mideast Wars. Look up - "Is Arab hatred for Israel a product of the child abuse normative in the Arab world?" American Thinker September 29, 2024
doesnt gaza and the west bank belong to palestine? i was always under the impression israel had occupied it for counter-insurgency similar to what we did in afghanistan? or is that seriously how fucked this thing is?
It's even worse. They are effectively in internment or concetration camps. Why they even control everything including water sources. They deliberatly destroy water wells for livelihoods within the west bank and ban collecting rainwater. And Gaza has been aptly described as an open air prison, often being bombed for decades by Israelis as "mowing the lawn" and now it's a zone where deliberate mass starvation and genocide is taking place.
@@jpmorganandco-k1y they occupy Gaza and keep a blockade around it so they control who and what enters or leaves. They take tax money from the west bank but give them zero rights in the country, no right to vote or freedom of movement. So they take their money the west bank pays not only the Palestinian authority but the Israeli government in taxes yet have no say in any government issues. The Isntreali government can take their land not allow them to farm on land they OWN. So much its too much to say.
@@liamlinson7563 ..."every Palestinian, in Gaza and throughout Palestine, can prove his Arab roots - whether from Saudi Arabia, from Yemen, or anywhere. We have blood ties. Personally, half my family is Egyptian. We are all like that. More than 30 families in the Gaza Strip are called Al-Masri ["Egyptian"]. Brothers, half of the Palestinians are Egyptians and the other half are Saudis. Who are the Palestinians? We have many families called Al-Masri, whose roots are Egyptian. Egyptian! They may be from Alexandria, from Cairo, from Dumietta, from the North, from Aswan, from Upper Egypt. We are Egyptians." Hamas Minister of the Interior and of National Security Fathi Hammad, aired by Al-Hekma TV on March 23, 2012. The so called Palestinians are not even from the region known as Palestine!!!!!! www.memri.org/tv/hamas-minister-interior-and-national-security-fathi-hammad-slams-egypt-over-fuel-shortage-gaza
I like the guy that basically said there is what I want and there's reality. He's right. You can only do the best you can in an impossible situation like that.
If you ask most o the Israelis if they want an ethnic cleansing, they will say. Only right extremists maybe say " yes but". 95% of jews will say no. If you ask palestinians the same question about ethnic cleansing of jews , at least 75% will say yes.
why are yo going into hypotheticals when the Israeli government is actually pursuing the policy of ethnically cleansing Gaza, at least the Northern Gaza, of Palestinians?
@@sureyyaekinci4630 Don't think, watch the other videos from the Ask Project, read the studies done in Gaza, etc. The Arab Muslims who call themselves Palestinians to the exclusion of Jews and Christians, are clear the majority is fine with ethnically cleanse (or worse) Jews and Israelis, as well as "collaborators". This is in parts due to Hamas indoctrination and the success of Wahabi/Islamist thoughts and propaganda in the MENA region and the West.
@NasirAli-r1c First of all we are speaking about people's opinion, not government. Second, recording to hamas ministry of health 45000 were killed during this war that hamas started on October 7th , 70% terrorists from the age of 15. Maybe 15000 civilians were killed because they were used as a human shield. In the same time, recording to the same hamas ministry of health, 60000 babies were born. It doesn't look like ethnic cleansing or genocide. If Israel wanted to destroy all palestinian population in gaza and west bank it could take few days . The ratio between armed terrorists and civilians that were killed in this war is 2 to 1. 2 terrorists for 1 cevilian . In all history of wars never been such a ratio. But for people like you the facts and truth doesn't matter.
@@mironlempert5737 Israeli government has been elected and 94% of the israeli population supports the genocide (or "war" as they call it). Just because a lot of israelis are smart enough not to be caught on camera defending genocide in english, does not mean they do not support it.
I love the clever answers from these wonderful Israeli Jews ❤. Israeli Jews really want peace and are good people. Love the Israeli Jews! They are telling you the truth about them which has been twisted in the media. Stay safe! 🕊🕊🕊
@@AnaUnknown-s4v twisted by the media? the medias literally defending them so much lmaoo this channel also asking jewish people if it's OK to spat at christians, and unsurprisingly majority of them said if it's OK to even m*urder them
@@Drippygoku But yes in the West Bank and you can find countless videos, where the majority answer yes. How does it make you feel to try to disavow a comment that was fundamentally true, because of a marginal error?
What a silly question, no one is going to say yes. Totally loaded. You're heading in the right direction Cory, but please select questions better. What stood out for me is thinking everything was ok before Oct 7. Not understanding what it is like to be Palestinian in Gaza, West Bank is at the root of this perception. Maybe if you asked questions to Israelis like " If you were Palestinian and having you're lives controlled by people who restrict how you live, imprison you for minor offences and take your land, what would that be like? Or to Palestinians " If you were Israeli and felt threatened by your neighbours, had rockets fired at you and had what happened on Oct 7, what would that be like?" Imagining what it is like to be the other is the way forward here. But this is very very hard to do, because it is seriously uncomfortable. We like thinking we are the victim and they are the perpetrator. The reality is EVERYONE is both. Keep up the great work Cory, but I urge you to select questions a little better.
You are mistaken. what you wrote is False: "controlled by people who restrict how you live, imprison you for minor offences and take your land" - Gaza since 2005 governed by HAMAS. And they got billions of dollars which they could have used to make Gaza the Singapore of the middle east. they chose to "invest" in Terror, and this is the result.
I also think a good question to ask Israelis is, "Do you think a Palestinian that that is born and grows up in the West Bank or Gaza would believe Israel has a right exist?" A good question to ask to Palestinians is, "Do you think an Israeli that is born and grows up in Israel support the destruction of Israel and the explosion of Jews from the land?"
One of the reasons nations tend to demonize each other is the lack of direct, meaningful communication between their people. This unfortunate void is often filled with doubts, mistrust, and hatred. Corey, I deeply appreciate your efforts to bridge this gap. There is a pressing need for more direct, open communication between Arabs and Jews. A platform where individuals from both communities can openly discuss and debate their concerns could play a vital role in dismantling misunderstandings perpetuated over time, often by their leaders. I sincerely wish for peace and harmony for everyone in the Holy Land.
Not sure they were given the correct definition of ethnic cleansing. At one point they even translated it to Hebrew as "genocide." It can involve killing, but it can also involve simply expelling them from an area. It sounded as though some were against killing, but also didn't want them there anymore.
@@amystern123 I thought many of them do and want to see it officially annexed, but alright. Regardless, I think these people realise that the word "palestinian" means people inside the West Bank.
@@dustopian some settlements yes others no. some supposed settlements are essentially a city that's been there for a long time. during the last negotiations they wanted to take those settlements and give the west bank other equivalent land in exchange.
A better set up question is: "Let's assume the Palestinians will never accept Jewish sovereignty in the land and will resist the "Occupation" for as long as Israel exists as a sovereign Jewish state. Should the Palestinians be expelled from Gaza and the West Bank?"
palestinians for sure, if you look up corey's channel, he has done videos with palestinians in the past... hamas and hesbollah, on the other hand is trickier : - first, getting to interview them is probably way harder, especially for someone that is looking to contact them from within israel - second, why should we ask these organisations ? is corey asking people from the israeli government or even people affiliated to the party in office these days ? no he does not - why then should palestinians be accountable for the crimes of these organisations, when they did not elect them in a even remotely democratical way (which is the case for bibi, though) ? your question sounds like palestinians should be considered suspect from the start, when the israeli shouldn't, yet, it is not the palestinians who have murdered the most civilians in the last year...
May God bless and protect Israel 🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱 History of PALESTINIAN STATE: 1. Before Israel, there was a British mandate, not a Palestinian state 2. Before the British Mandate, there was the Ottoman Empire, not a Palestinian state. 3. Before the Ottoman Empire, there was the Islamic state of the Mamluks of Egypt, not a Palestinian state. 4. Before the Islamic state of the Mamluks of Egypt, there was the Ayubid Arab-Kurdish Empire, not a Palestinian state. 5. Before the Ayubid Empire, there was the Frankish and Christian Kingdom of Jerusalem, not a Palestinian state. 6. Before the Kingdom of Jerusalem, there was the Umayyad and Fatimid empires, not a Palestinian state. 7. Before the Umayyad and Fatimid empires, there was the Byzantine empire, not a Palestinian state. 8. Before the Byzantine Empire, there were the Sassanids, not a Palestinian state. 9. Before the Sassanid Empire, there was the Byzantine Empire, not a Palestinian state. 10. Before the Byzantine Empire, there was the Roman Empire, not a Palestinian state. 11. Before the Roman Empire, there was the Hasmonean state, not a Palestinian state. 12. Before the Hasmonean state, there was the Seleucid, not a Palestinian state. 13. Before the Seleucid empire, there was the empire of Alexander the Great, not a Palestinian state. 14. Before the empire of Alexander the Great, there was the Persian empire, not a Palestinian state. 15. Before the Persian Empire, there was the Babylonian Empire, not a Palestinian state. 16. Before the Babylonian Empire, there were the Kingdoms of Israel and Judah, not a Palestinian state. 17. Before the Kingdoms of Israel and Judah, there was the Kingdom of Israel, not a Palestinian state. 18. Before the kingdom of Israel, there was the theocracy of the twelve tribes of Israel, not a Palestinian state. 19. Before the theocracy of the twelve tribes of Israel, there was an agglomeration of independent Canaanite city-kingdoms, not a Palestinian state. 20. Actually, in this piece of land there has been everything, EXCEPT A PALESTINIAN STATE.
Basically you asked people if they support or want do crimes and most of them said no even after a long time thinking what to say I have a question. is this a video for children or morons? I wish both sides peace of course that is horrible what we witnessed last year thats realky shocking to see what humans are capable of
@@Itsdifferent-wv4johow deluded. So bc we are a different religion and race we should not have a right to live in a land not only we were BORN ON, our parents, great grandparents, great grandparents back over 1000 years have lived on? Is that what you just said? THAT IS THE DEFINITION OF RACIST, SUPREMACY, and ETHNIC CLEANSING you bigot
@@Itsdifferent-wv4joyou yourself weren’t even born there lol yet you think you have more rights than the Palestinians who lived there for centuries 🤣 the delusion and entitlement
Cheers on this channel which is basically the holy land's version of 1420. May the Ask an Israeli/Ask a Palestinian project keep ongoing until peace there becomes realized.
Research by Pew in 2016 suggested almost 50% of Israeli Jews wanted Arabs ethnically cleansed. 80% said Jews should receive preferential treatment. I don't think the figure has reduced in the intervening years.
There was two charters first one said they wanted to eradicate all Jews in Israel and the world. The revised was to eradicate the Zionist as not to be antisametic@@nessimbencheik8308
Majority of sensible people will never say yes to such a question, especially in front of the camera 😂. You watch some with the hesitation and you know they at the very least have such an idea in their minds.
It's not even about racism, there were 4 different "races" that merged in the Levant even as late as 1500 BC. This is why you see a variation of skin colours and features. It wasn't even that homogenous as of 1500BC. The problem is Islam is still stuck in the stone age and most followers are still living in it.
And that is a racist comment. This is blood libel against the Islamic people. BTW - Islam did not even exist in the stone age, and it is historically more modern than Judaism and Christianity.
Update your 2014 playbook. Thanks! We've all moved on to the originator of all the chaos. PS. Cute how you try to create different "races" out of Semites 😂 Ignorant.
@@shadyaymannoor It seems they are less violent about it. I didn't say Israel was 100% right about everything. I'm sure there are some valid criticisms, but it's clear from these videos of civilians, which civilians are more tolerant and civilized.
As an Israeli Jewish person a lot of these views have changed drastically since 7/10 looking at them cheering on the streets at massacre of Jewish people was a real wake up call
Did you view on Isrealis change two after seeing the soldier make a mockery and partying while going through destroyed houses and ppls underwear or while blowing up universities? hmmmm
The Israelis before 7/10 are the same as after 7/10-your actions and mindset have never changed. The clearest proof lies in what you’ve done in Gaza. But rest assured, every crime you’ve committed in Gaza will haunt you. Retribution is inevitable. Mark my words well, and never forget them.
he was shocked because they are public relations savvy and understands that direct questions and true answers on this topic are not to be recorded / broadcast. this is why most of them gave sanitized broadcast-ready answers. this is not a reliable way to uncover their true feelings on this matter. you have to ask multiple indirect questions from different angles to zero-in on their real thoughts / intentions. several commenters already gave example lists of effective questions in this comment section, so I won't repeat them.
@@viosh7137 yep, they could attend some of those IDF public relation and propaganda workshops to train high schoolers in wikipedia rewriting and comment section manipulation. or better yet, stop the generational occupation and subjugation so we can finally see an end to this mess.
I can understand if some Isrlis are so angry that they emotionally find it difficult to care, but intellectually most everyone understands what is correct.
2:50 I have a feeling that the question could be clearer. This woman shows that the Israelis are interpreting this question to mean whether the Israeli arabs should be ethnically cleansed from Israel. All Israelis believe in demographic domination of all of Israel including Gaza, "Judea" and "Samaria" which would entail ethnic cleansing of millions of Arabs.
@krishnaveganathar You'll have to explain your reference. I don't watch the Boys. All I remember is when Bassem Youssef referred to Israel as Homelander but didn't get the joke.
@@adischenker1851 Staatsrason of Israel is a Jewish state. If you don't have demographic domination then you don't have a Jewish state. One can reasonably exclude Anti Zionist Israelis (including Israeli Arabs) without loss of generality.
@@malinia.20 hate to break it to you there is no ethnic cleansing de facto, what's the ethnic difference between Palestinians in judea and gaza and Israeli arabs?
Chronological Incidents of Violence Against Jews in the Ottoman Sanjak of Jerusalem, Sanjak of Acre, and Sanjak of Nablus (1800-1917) 1834 Safed Riots - Muslims attacked Jews in Safed. 1834 Hebron Massacre - Muslims attacked Jews in Hebron. 1834 Jerusalem Pogrom - Muslims attacked Jews in Jerusalem. 1834 Nablus Riots - Muslims attacked Jews in Nablus. 1834 Jaffa Riots - Muslims attacked Jews in Jaffa. 1838 Safed Pogrom - Druze attacked Jews in Safed. 1847 Hebron Pogrom - Muslims attacked Jews in Hebron. 1847 Acre Riots - Arabs attacked Jews in Acre. 1847 Tiberias Massacre - Muslims attacked Jews in Tiberias. 1848 Tiberias Incident - Arabs attacked Jews in Tiberias. 1856 Safed Riots - Arabs attacked Jews in Safed. 1860 Damascus Affair - Impact on Jewish communities in Ottoman Palestine. 1869 Jaffa Riots - Arabs attacked Jews in Jaffa. 1871 Jaffa Riots - Arabs attacked Jews in Jaffa. 1873 Jaffa Riots - Arabs attacked Jews in Jaffa. 1873 Nablus Pogrom - Arabs attacked Jews in Nablus. 1874 Nablus Riots - Arabs attacked Jews in Nablus. 1875 Safed Riots - Muslims attacked Jews in Safed. 1876 Jaffa Riots - Arabs attacked Jews in Jaffa. 1881 Safed Riots - Arabs attacked Jews in Safed. 1882 Tiberias Riots - Arabs attacked Jews in Tiberias. 1886 Safed Pogrom - Arabs attacked Jews in Safed. 1886 Petaḥ Tikvah Incident - Arabs attacked Jews in Petaḥ Tikvah. 1890 Haifa Riots - Arabs attacked Jews in Haifa. 1891 Hebron Riots - Arabs attacked Jews in Hebron. 1893 Jaffa Riots - Arabs attacked Jews in Jaffa. 1895 Beersheba Incident - Arabs attacked Jews in Beersheba. 1895 Jerusalem Riots - Arabs attacked Jews in Jerusalem. 1901 Gedera Incident - Arabs attacked Jews in Gedera. 1903 Motza Riots - Arabs attacked Jews in Motza. 1903 Rehovot Incident - Arabs attacked Jews in Rehovot. 1903 Tiberias Riots - Arabs attacked Jews in Tiberias. 1908 Acre Riots - Arabs attacked Jews in Acre. 1908 Jaffa Riots - Arabs attacked Jews in Jaffa. 1909 Hebron Riots - Arabs attacked Jews in Hebron. 1911 Jaffa Riots - Arabs attacked Jews in Jaffa. 1911 Safed Riots - Arabs attacked Jews in Safed. 1913 Tel Aviv Riots - Arabs attacked Jews in Tel Aviv. 1913 Rehovot Riots - Arabs attacked Jews in Rehovot. 1917 Jerusalem Riots - Arabs attacked Jews in Jerusalem. Chronological Incidents of Violence Against Jews in British Mandate for Palestine and OETA (1917-1948) 1920 Nebi Musa Riots - Arabs attacked Jews in Jerusalem. 1920 Jaffa Riots - Arabs attacked Jews in Jaffa. 1921 Jaffa Massacre - Arabs attacked Jews in Jaffa. 1921 Petah Tikvah Riots - Arabs attacked Jews in Petah Tikvah. 1929 Safed Massacre - Arabs attacked Jews in Safed. 1929 Hebron Massacre - Arabs attacked Jews in Hebron. 1929 Haifa Massacre - Arabs attacked Jews in Haifa. 1936-1939 Arab Revolt - Arabs attacked Jews across Palestine. 1936 Safed Riots - Arabs attacked Jews in Safed. 1936 Jaffa Riots - Arabs attacked Jews in Jaffa. 1936 Tiberias Riots - Arabs attacked Jews in Tiberias. 1937 Kfar Etzion Massacre - Arabs attacked Jews in Kfar Etzion. 1938 Tel Aviv Riots - Arabs attacked Jews in Tel Aviv. 1938 Haifa Riots - Arabs attacked Jews in Haifa. 1938 Safed Riots - Arabs attacked Jews in Safed. 1939 Petah Tikvah Riots - Arabs attacked Jews in Petah Tikvah. 1947 Jerusalem Riots - Arabs attacked Jews in Jerusalem. 1947 Haifa Riots - Arabs attacked Jews in Haifa. 1947 Safed Riots - Arabs attacked Jews in Safed. 1947 Jaffa Riots - Arabs attacked Jews in Jaffa. 1948 Kfar Etzion Massacre - Arabs attacked Jews in Kfar Etzion. 1947 Hebron Massacre - Arabs attacked Jews in Hebron. 1947 Acre Riots - Arabs attacked Jews in Acre. 1948 Latrun Massacre - Arab forces attacked Israeli convoys and civilian targets, killing Jews. 1948 Safed Massacre - Arabs attacked Jews in Safed during the Arab-Israeli war. 1948 Haifa Riots - Arabs attacked Jews in Haifa during the 1947-1948 Civil War. 1948 Jerusalem Riots - Arabs attacked Jewish neighborhoods in Jerusalem. 1948 Old City of Jerusalem - Arab forces attacked Jewish residents in Jerusalem's Old City. 1948 Gush Etzion Massacre - Arabs attacked Jewish settlements in Gush Etzion, killing civilians. 1948 Mount Scopus Convoy Attack - Arabs ambushed and killed Jewish civilians during the 1948 siege. 1948 Tel Aviv Attacks - Arab militants carried out a series of attacks in Tel Aviv. Chronological Incidents of Violence Against Jews and Israelis since the establishment of the State of Israel(1948-Present) 1948 - Arab States and Militias to Israel: Arab-Israeli War 1954 - Egyptian Forces (Arab Fedayeen) to Israel: Lavon Affair 1955 - Arab Fedayeen to Israel: Gaza Raid 1956 - Egyptian Fedayeen to Israel: Eilat Raid 1965 - Fatah (Palestinian Arab Militants) to Israel: The Battle of Karameh 1967 - Arab States to Israel: Six-Day War 1968 - PLO to Israel: Kiryat Shmona Bus Attack 1972 - Black September (PLO) to Israel: Munich Olympics Massacre 1973 - Arab States to Israel: Yom Kippur War (October 1973) - Surprise attacks by Egypt and Syria on Israel, including numerous civilian casualties. 1974 - PLO to Israel: Ma’alot Massacre 1975 - Fatah to Israel: Coastal Road Hijacking 1982 - PLO to Israel: Beirut Bombings 1985 - PLO to Israel: Achille Lauro Hijacking 1987-1993 - PLO, Hamas, Islamic Jihad to Israel: First Intifada 1989 - Hamas to Israel: Hebron Bus Bombing 1996 - Hamas to Israel: Dizengoff Center Bombing 1997 - Hamas to Israel: Mahane Yehuda Market Bombings 2000-2005 - Hamas, PLO, Islamic Jihad to Israel: Second Intifada 2001 - Hamas to Israel: Dolphinarium Disco Bombing 2002 - Hamas to Israel: Passover Massacre 2002 - Islamic Jihad to Israel: Maalot-Tarshiha Bus Attack 2003 - Hamas to Israel: Haifa Bus Bombing 2004 - Hamas to Israel: Ashdod Port Attack 2005 - Hamas to Israel: Eilat Terror Attack 2006 - Hezbollah to Israel: Second Lebanon War 2006 - Hezbollah to Israel: Northern Border Attacks 2011 - PLO to Israel: Itamar Massacre 2012 - Hamas, Islamic Jihad to Israel: Tel Aviv Bus Bombing 2014 - Hamas to Israel: Gaza-Israel War 2014 - Hamas to Israel: Kfar Darom Attack 2015 - Hamas, PLO, Lone Wolf Attackers to Israel: Stabbing Intifada 2015 - Hamas to Israel: Continued rocket fire into southern Israel in the aftermath of the Stabbing Intifada 2017 - Hamas to Israel: Jerusalem Truck Attack 2021 - Hamas, PLO, Islamic Jihad to Israel: Operation Guardian of the Walls 2021 - Hamas to Israel: Jerusalem Rocket Attack 2022 - Hamas, Islamic Jihad to Israel: Ramallah, Jenin Attacks 2023 - Hamas to Israel: October 7th Attack 2024 - Hamas to Israel: Rocket Strikes and Border Crossings 2024 - Hamas to Israel: Eilat Rocket Strike 2022 - Hamas to Israel: Be’er Sheva Attack 2023 - Hezbollah to Israel: Northern Border Rocket Attack 2023 - Hamas to Israel: Ashkelon Rocket Attack 2023 - Houthi Rebels to Israel: Missile attacks on Israeli shipping vessels in the Red Sea 2023 - Hezbollah to Israel: Cross-border fire into Israeli territory 2024 - Iranian Forces (via proxies) to Israel: Further attacks through Hezbollah and other Iranian-backed groups 2024 - Hamas to Israel: Continued rocket fire and attempted border infiltrations from Gaza 2024 - Hezbollah to Israel: Cross-border skirmishes, with missile fire targeting civilian areas in northern Israel 2024 - Hamas to Israel: Large-scale rocket and drone attacks targeting Israeli cities and military bases 2024 - Hezbollah to Israel: Attacks targeting IDF positions and civilian infrastructure in the north 2024 - Palestinian Arab Militants (various groups) to Israel: Coordinated attacks along the Gaza-Israel border 2024 - Hamas to Israel: Multiple mortar shell attacks across the border into Israel’s southern regions etc...
Good boy. Now do one against Jews against Arabs, Armenians and Iranians. Don't forget to give a shout-out to the Js multiple genocides in both the Old Testament and last 100 years. They invented the idea of genocide and holds the world record funnily enough.
It must be hard to live next to people who want to erase you from this earth. Most of the people killed on 10-07-23 were people who supported peace. It is hard because there are many good people amongst the Palestinians. I don't know if people are being honest... really.
Why don't you ask arabs/muslims in Israel/Judea/Samaria/Gaza/egypt/syria/jordan/lebanon/iraq/iran, if they want to ethnically cleanse The Jews from The Middle East? Also, please ask them what happened to The Jews who lived in gaza prior to 1929, Jews who lived in Judea/Samaria prior to 1948, The Jews who lived in egypt, syria, iraq, iran, lebanon, tunisia, turkey, etc..?
@@shadyaymannoor , it's because that's what it is. This area was known as Judea and Samaria till hashemites renamed it after they illegally occupied it in 1948 with the help of british(ex: arab legion). There has never been a "palestine" kingdom, country, etc.. Area is not a country. As for ethnic cleansing, If its okay for arabs/muslims, its okay for The Jews. What is good for the goose, is good for the gander.
Why do you add Turkey? Turkey didn’t expel the Jews. Historically Turks and Jews got along very well. What kind of hateful and manipulative person you are?
@@alexjohnson9630 - I've seen maps in one of the videos that goes back before '48 that has the word palestine on it, so that's not true. And if memory serves, either Herzl or one of the other terrorists called it that too.
Now ask the same question of Palestinians, the answers will be mostly yes. I think Corey has a few videos that are shocking. Most dont want peace, most dont want a compromise.
I would say that the people who do support it are the ONLY people from Israel you will see in most mainstream media. That's the point this whole channel. To show the real people on the ground, and not the ones the media wants you to see.
@@angelalewis4213 growing up around Muslim males, spending time in madrassas (Quran practice classes in a mosque), always hearing Muslim youth praising terror attacks on innocents in western countries, liberals like you will never be useful for anything other than your legs wide open for people accept your help but then talk against you behind your back. Liberals are a bigger cancer than the cancer as they feed the cancer to grow.
@@angelalewis4213 growing up around Muslim males, spending time in madrassas (Quran practice classes in a mosque), always hearing Muslim youth praising terror attacks on innocent "infidels" in western countries, liberals like you will never be any help for anything other than your gap wide open for people who "accept" your help but then talk against you behind your back. Liberals are a bigger cancer than the cancer as they feed the cancer to grow.
@angelalewis4213 growing up around Muslim males, spending time in madrassas (Quran practice classes in mosques), always hearing Muslim youth praising terror attacks on innocent "infidels" in western countries, liberals like you will never be useful for anything other than your aid to anyone without awareness. You entertain people who "accept" your help but then talk against you behind your back. Liberals are just a fuel to a growing destruction.
I’m so happy to see Corey and Adar are friends, and cooperating even. Two of my favourite people, and the only YT producers I’ve donated money to thus far. Keep it up, you are needed. Are you aware of Robert Wright, of Non Zero and Bloggingheads? You guys are swimming in the same waters. Regarding the video, it’s striking that the interviewees often say they want to live happily for ever after with the other side, but seem oblivious to their very real grievances. Except for that one guy. But no one mentions the land grabs, historical and ongoing. Having your people being continually pushed off their land and out of their homes would indeed be intolerable, to anyone.
I wonder how many of the men you interviewed personally shot a child in the head or heart with their sniper rifle, seeing as we have heard western doctor reports of daily child cases of sniper shots to the head and heart. What a society you have…
They were shot by Islamic Jihad, that is pretty obvious. They want children dead specifically so they can blame Israel. And you fell for it because you’re a naive fool. When will the world wake up to the dangers of radical Islam. Islamists are not victims. They are child killers and would do it to all non-Muslims if they could.
Anyone who understands what ethnic cleansing is, and refuses to give a yes or no answer to whether they support ethnic cleansing of a given peoole or population when asked by someone who is not obviously in favour of such ethnic cleansing, supports that ethnic cleansing. Maybe only in what they perceive to be particular circumstances that they think necessitate or justify it. But support all the same.
You are reaching. If you for once want to get a definitive answer to this question ask a palestinian. The majority would most probably simply say "Yes".
@hausofdownboots you're engaging in whataboutery, when I wasn't making a point exclusive to one group of people. What I said holds true of anyone who refuses to give a yes or no answer to this question, as a simple thought experiment shows. Take anyone who genuinely doesn't support ethnic cleansing of a particular group. Ask them if they support it. It is completely inconceivable they would say anything except "no", unless they had some reason to fear that doing so would put them in danger. As to your unrelated point, I don’t doubt there are *some* Palestinians who would refuse to give a yes/no answer if asked by a non-threatening person if they support ethnic cleansing of Jews. Just as there are *some* white Americans or white Europeans who would refuse to answer yes/no to whether they support ethnically cleansing Jews, Muslims, Black people, people of Asian decent, etc. And, as this video shows, *some* Jewish Israelis who refuse when asked by a non-threatening person to give a yes/no answer to whether they support ethnic cleansing of Palestinians. In all those cases I would say exactly the same thing: that person supports the ethnic cleansing in question. History tells us, to our cost, that there are supporters of ethnic cleansing in all communities. But the fact there are some doesn't mean most people in that community support it. This is blindingly obvious from a logical, evidentiary and epistemological perspective (some ≠ all).
@@davidloveday8473 His reaction is obviously because he's ok with it and you called him out on it
Місяць тому+2
@@davidloveday8473 Not necessarily. It cud just be they are suspicious of the interviewer or his agenda, they thinknit might be a trap, or simply dont want to be on camera.
This was really surprising to me. I've seen what people have said in similar interviews and the Israeli tv I've seen was horrific. I'm the kind of people who doesn't just evidence that doesn't fit what I already think but this is the opposite of everything else I've seen. Corey, does this fit what you've heard off camera?
Its not the opposite, as there's a lot of anger here in Israel towards gaza, esp after Israelies die. However as a country and population we dont let that guide us, we're generally lawful and prefer to be left alone. The gazans however do let it guide them on a national and operational level
@@einefes Thank you so much for replying. Would you mind watching this tv clip and helping me put this in context? Maybe this is the Israeli Fox News which would give people a skewed view of America. ua-cam.com/video/ex2c08g4zpM/v-deo.htmlsi=ESZ4sdc1duzIX-X_
Don't forget that for what you see in the media, including Israeli media, the purpose is to tell a narrative, either for a financial of a political purpose. Corey's purpose with this channel is to show people from around the world what real Israelis and Palestinians on the ground think.
@@einefes Oh shut up!!! The Gazans are suffering through a holocaust and not to mention 76 years of ethnic cleansing, and you expect them to not act defensively? Faulting an occupied people for reacting to being occupied is absurd. "We're generally lawful" lol exactly how lawful are the settlements in the West Bank??
@malinia.20 blah. Blah. Blah. Dude, NOTHING you wrote is correct no matter how passionate you are about it. No 76 years of occupation, no ethnic cleansing, certainly no holocaust. I dont even know how people come to a conclusion that these things are real, simply 0 evidence of any. You're like a freaking flat earther. What I expect of them is to take responsibility for their actions of past and present, and choose a better life for themselves for the future.
The ones who say everything was good up to 6 October shows us how self deluded, entitled and twisted thier view is. It’s actually part of the main problem.
Before October 6th if they'd come peacefully or just were peaceful In general. October 7th no one wants neighbours that say they want to do this every year again and again.
It's not self delusion or entitlement. But it is twisted. He's saying everything was fine, because a state if cease fire is the most peace Israel has ever had, so for most Israelis, as long as there is no active open warfare, it's fine. Because it's as much "fine" as they've ever known...
@@AndreyKrichevsky Like the guy that talked about realist questions. Some may theoretically support a Palestinian state, but know that the current situation is not a time to get that result *quickly* as some delluded commentators in the West seem to believe it is. If they don't talk about Palestinian statehood as much as outsiders do, it is because they feel it is not feasible within the timeframe of the next election in 2026.
@hanidekel15 but they are committing genocide. So it does not matter 1 percent or 90 percent. Also Israel also stealing land from Palestine in west bank.
israel has 20% arab population. now its important to note that the arab population is the exact same as the palestinians. the only difference is, that those arab did not change their names to palestinians in the 60's. palestinians are not an ethnic group, and if they are, then israelis are to be considered palestinian because ethnicity is based not on specific people but on the general coltures that lived in a certain area. and even if people dont agree with me, still a lot of israelis also have acestors that lived during the british mandate and that shouldnt be of any problem to call them palestinian ethnicly. so the question is inherently confusing to ask because you cant reallly ethnicly cleans people if they arent an ethnicity.
Decades of violence and hatred had an unimagenable impact on all people on both sides.So questions like this after all of happend before are very inaccurate and it cant be answered honestly and without any bias on both sides.
Why are they so mad? I am enjoying my food and warm showers and well funded state, why do the Palestinians have so much anger? - Every blissfully unaware Israeli
@@solvingpolitics3172 palestinians r descendants of original jews and xtian they just speak arabic does not mean they r from same grp as gulf arabs stop trying to smart or something.
And what the government is actively doing is not ethnically cleansing anyone. If they wanted to do that, Palestinians would have been forgotten from this earth a year ago.
The truth is that since October 7, 2023, the births in Gaza have exceeded the war deaths. So, by definition, it is not ethnic cleansing - even if there have been many palestinian casualties from the war. And no, the fact that they are Israeli would not make them complicit in what the IDF does. By that logic, all palestinians are complicit in the October 7th atrocities committed by their government. And I don't think you want to suggest that.
@@Taryag613 Danny the Israeli government said it was holding all the Palestinians responsible for Oct 7th and they have blockaded and starved the people there. That is why there are arrest warrants for those leaders. Bombing every hospital, school, sewage, water etc is to make Gaza uninhabitable. We have viewed the IDF footage, boasting about it. GEN.O.CIDE
@Taryag613 and how would you know that? It couldn't be from the hospital records look at what's been done to them. You don't even know how many people have died who are you kidding?
@@jaspernewcomb5656 I never denied the number of Gazan casualties. I am taking Hamas's numbers at face value, and comparing that to the documented Gaza birth rate. But here's one thing neither of us know because Hamas isn't telling us: How many of 40,000-45,000 gazan deaths are civilian and how many are combatants? How many of the palestinian civilians were killed by Israeli munitions and how many by Hamas munitions? How many of the civilians were killed in situations where they were in proximity to a legitimate military target? Without answers to these questions, neither of us know what is really going on...
I wish it wasn't do you want to ethnically cleanse the Palestinians and instead "Do you want to kick the Palestinians out of the West Bank" (or judea and sumeria whichever is less charged). It's the same question, but far less charged and you'll get more reprehensive answers I think.
I'm Israeli and can answer your question :) harming a Palestinian just because he is a Palestinian is wrong and most other israelis would agree with me.
@RovexHD when Palestinians are asked they answer their truth. You don’t believe Israeli’s because it doesn’t fit your skewed narrative. You don’t know us!
Meanwhile Palestinians happily say yes quite often. What's so different about these answerers you can't trust them? After a certain point, Jews can't answer either way to make you people happy.
@@justinstewart4889 Opinions on camera matter little when the government embodies lovely characters like Smotrich and gvir, elected by the people themselves.
The problem is the ideology from the 🌙📖. I don’t understand why still people don’t want to understand 🤷♂️ Here’s an example: Commentary on the quran (Tafseer) (7)"You (true believers in Islamic Monotheism, and real followers of Prophet Muḥammad pbuh and his Sunna) are the best of peoples ever raised up for mankind..." (V.3:110). Sahih al-Bukhari 4557 Narrated Abu Huraira: The Verse:--"You (true Muslims) are the best of peoples ever raised up for mankind." means, the best of peoples for the people, as you bring them with chains on their necks till they embrace Islam. Reference : Sahih al-Bukhari 4557 In-book reference : Book 65, Hadith 79 USC-MSA web (English) reference : Vol. 6, Book 60, Hadith 80
Your channel is a blessing! We need your interviews more than ever! My best regards from Amsterdam (I am still ashamed what happened to Israelie people here a couple of weeks ago).
It is "proceed with ethnic cleansing" of an area or nation of a given population. Not "ethnically cleanse" the population. The term means to expel or eliminate a group of people defined by their ethnicity or religion.
@@LtGregoryStevens He didn't ethnically cleanse them, there were some Jewish tribes there did bad things against Muhammad pbuh. But he didn't ethnically cleanse them because you still had Jewish tribes in yemen that lived up until the 1950s. They had a treaty with eachother and lived in peace. But they sided with the pagans and even fought against their own Jewish brothers. So Allah gave the prophet the command to take care of them because of their actions, similair to how the prophet Elijah took care of the worshippers of Ashur and Baal. They did have an option to repent and to convert, but they refused. The Muslims never had the intention to do it, they brought it upon themselves by doing very bad things.
Unfortunately, the elected officials of Israel and the US don’t have the best interest in of their citizens in mind. Our collective interest is peace but our leaders won’t allow it.
Question: do you confess on you tube that you support war crimes ? Answer: no , of course not Question: do you support the war crimes committed by you and your military? Answer: Yes but I don’t call it war crimes I call it self defense. Here I just summarized the episode.
@@Levich1 A place where all religions living together has a name: PALESTINE 🇵🇸 A place where only one group can ethically cleanse everyone else has a name too it’s called ; israel.
War crimes? What is your source, the UN? Remember the UN is very biased against Israel with majority Muslim country resolutions (if you want to call it resolutions) When you look into nearly all of the cases, Israel was simply protecting itself, whereas the UN has never once condemned the groups like Hamas for war crimes of teaching little children in all of the Palestinian schools to martyr themselves by killing Jews, using people as human shields, and on and on.. Also when it was estimated by Hamas that 30k Palestinians were killed (using their numbers that doesn't distinguish between civilians and Hamas members) there was about 26K buildings leveled by Israel in Gaza by a minimum of one bomb per building (an independent study from satellite images, you can look it up) From this ratio of around 1 to 3 bombs per building for every 1 person killed. Thats right, this means that Israel is terrible at killing civilians. It is clear that they are not only not targeting civilians but have done a much better job of not killing civilians than any country at war in history.
When a group of people are _accused of something,_ it is "fair" to give them an opportunity _to respond._ They are _accused_ of "ethnic cleansing," so, _yes,_ let them respond to that accusation. The accusation is stupid. The question is not.
The power of 'hasbara'... But when the government is forbidding to share information contrary to hasbara, killing the journalists in Gaza, kicking out Al Jazeera, etc. etc., what can you expect? I believe that in this bubble, many truly believe that 'everything was fine' to some extent, before that day.
@@ehuddadian5500 Israel claim there was a ceasefire, yet you see they shot Palestinian protesters Oct 5th and bombed Gaza for 3 days straight Sept 23rd to 25th. Your hasbara lies will only fly on the ignorant
So depressing. I am an old man in Sydney who did however once teach in an Orthodox Jewish school. I am not Jewish, but many of my classmates in Sydney in 1959 were, and for them of course the Holocaust directly or indirectly shadowed their growing up. Let me quote one of those classmates who, after spending some time in East Jerusalem, returned to Australia. In 1998 he gave a lecture -- he is a historian and social scientist of some note -- and in it he said: 'As new maps were drawn to reflect these newly created “facts on the ground” in Israel/Palestine, legitimization was incrementally given to processes for which the world has since coined the ominous and chillingly appropriate term “ethnic cleansing"".' So while I can empathise with these interviewees I can say I found many of these answers very depressing. Yes, I am an outsider, but I think my friend was right back then, and, as he is still alive and I am still in contact with him, I can tell you my friend, who is quite unwell at 81, has not changed his mind. Another of my 1959 Jewish classmates has gone so far as to support the Australia Palestine Advocacy Network. Myself -- I am a great admirer of what Daniel Barenboim and Edward Said attempted with the Divan Orchestra, and what the people in the Hand-in-Hand Schools are doing. Such are points of light in what to us seems a very dark place indeed. I also admire this Project, I must say.
To answer your question: No, Palestine was never established as an independent state before 1948. Before that time, it was part of the Ottoman Empire and later came under British rule as the Mandate of Palestine. In the years following the 1948 Arab-Israeli War that initiated by several arab countries Palestinians lived under Israeli, Jordanian, or Egyptian control, but no Palestinian state existed. While there have been efforts toward Palestinian statehood, especially after the 1967 Six-Day War initiated by arabs and the Oslo Accords, full Palestinian sovereignty has not yet been achieved. The issue of Palestinian statehood remains central to the ongoing Israeli-Palestinian conflict
@@neilwhitfield5026 Than why you divide Jerusalem into parts? As historian you should know better than us that by devision plan of UN in 1947 Jerusalem was claimed neutral territory neither Israel or Palestinian. Did UN demanded Jordan to withdraw from Jerusalem and pass control to UN during 1948-1967 occupation? After Israel freed Jerusalem this whole city is Israel and can't be by any means Palestine. They had never 1 ounce of rights for any part of this city
Say something and do the opposite..facts on land say they are really doing it. And the question should have precised that it’s about what is happening in Gaza
nobody will say outright yes to a word like think cleansing, better ask how they feel about the statement made like this one "If you gave me a button to just erase Gaza, every single living being in Gaza would no longer be living tomorrow. I would press it in a second" The Two Nice Jewish Boys podcast Because that podcast claims everybody agrees with that, so ask how people feel about that
That's really just a strawman argument dude, I won't deny the questions could be asked more aggressively but all you're doing is asking in a more convoluted and confusing manner. Please form better questions before making a comment like this.
I don’t understand why this is an appropriate comparison. Did Black people attack white people en masse in an organized fashion? Did the Jews enslave the Arabs and import them from a foreign land against their will? Help me out here. I do believe there is a class element that people don’t talk about enough, but that’s about where the comparison dries up. It’s very thin, and is a total distraction from this very real and very different conflict. And frankly to me it cheapens and obscures the experience of Blacks in America, which is also very real and deserves its own serious analysis.
@thehocean It is appropriate. It speaks to how people can hold conflicting beliefs. The schism comes from the same place. Even though the specifics are different. Claiming friendship doesn't absolve you. You're reading a bit more into this than intended. It's not a point by point comparison. But it works.
@ I see your point and I appreciate the respectful reply. I have two issues with the comparison, one I outlined above and the other to this new point you are making- I think white people say that when they feel defensive and confused about the idea of holding latent racist beliefs. I think Israelis (and a thousand percent this is true on the other side too) are genuinely afraid for their safety. The guy on the laptop explained It. There’s no trust. And of course, Palestinians don’t trust Israelis. And maybe a third objection to this comparison is that it rubs me the wrong way that there is what seems to me to be an effort to sort of unite people against Israel by comparing (in my opinion misleadingly) the experience of other subjugated peoples to the plight of the Palestinians. It can get very antisemitic very quickly. The class thing is worth looking at, though, because it existed since the beginning of Zionism, and I think (I hope!) will ultimately be an important and productive conversation to have amongst Israeli/Arab society. May we all live to see peace and coexistence between these two peoples and all peoples. I’m an MLK fan myself :)
@thehocean I understand your concerns and respect them. They make a great deal of sense. These are murky waters. It's not my intention to be disrespectful, reductive or antisemitic. I appreciate your approach. I am tired of antisemitism being thrown out at times when it isn't present.(not insinuating you're doing this) I truly believe you can be against a country's government's actions without being against them as a people. For example. You can be against America's foreign policy without being anti white. Though I will admit that many struggle to separate these things. I am an MLK admirer as well as Malcom X. I'll mull over the points you made.
You should have asked in a cleaner way. Something like : Do you want the land of Israel/State of Israel clean from Arabs/Palestinians. You would have received different answers. Of course it depends who you ask. From right wing Israelis you would probably get very positive answers to this question. If they were honest with you. Just to be fair it is also important to note that the Palestinian State in the 2-state solution is clean from Jews. Every Palestinian would tell you that including Abu Mazen their leader. That's their default & he's considered a 'moderate' Palestinian.
Corey will probably never see this comment; but I will go ahead and write it anyhow. I have a problem with the question. "Do you want to ethnically cleanse Palestinians?" Would only get a no as an answer because no one should answer yes to that on a camera. Here is a way to rephrase it:
What do you think would be the best solution to the conflict:
A) The Palestinians move to neihbouring Arabs lands.
B) The Palestinians get their own sovereign country in accordance with the 1967 boarders.
C) The Palestinians remain where they are and live in a Jewish state under laws that reflect Jewish heritage as the center of identity and politics (Jewish supremacy)
D) The Palestinians remain and Israel and Palestine become one secular democratic state (like a federation) with equal rights for all.
I'd be way more interested in answers to this type of phrasing from both sides.
E) Israel decides on becoming a republic, annexes Judea and Samaria, and the Gaza Strip, and offers non-Israeli Arab individuals a choice to start on a path towards becoming full citizens. Read Moshe Berent's "A people like all peoples" (2009).
Palestine will come under the rule of turkey as it was before nd settlers will test their dna nd if they are European they will be deported @@sofsof4950
@@sofsof4950 that sounds like another version of what is going on now; Israel treats the Palestinians as second class citizens because they are not full citizens. How long would that pathway take😅 another 75 years? Why don't the Israelis get a pathway to citizenship? This is that Jewish supremacy talk all over again.
One secular democratic state with equal rights for all is the only just course to take. I understand no one is interested on either side, but what else can be fair and just?
He's not writing the questions, people send him questions and he asks them exactly as written without editing. You can send him your questions too
@@curious493 It's nothing like what is going on now. The specifics of the pathway are debatable. The idea really is a secular democratic state with equal rights for all.
Iraqi American here, I wish to see a day on earth just one day where all of us humans sit together and share cultures regardless of who we are because we all have more in common than we know. I wish we stop listening to BS media and news stations worldwide because they are the causers of division. One day we will all leave this earth it really technically does not belong to any of us we are here for a short period of time and I wish we use our time filed with love. Let your neighbor worship 1 or 100 gods it shouldn’t be anyone’s concern the only concern we should focus on is love and respect
Beautifully stated, couldn’t agree more 🫶
@@zahra87118 your good thoughts are cuz we are Shias.
Sorry not gonna happen.
@@Kurdishboy2698 well I tend to not lean towards any sect I am Muslim and that’s it I want to worship a One God and live with peace. I’m sick of humans fighting one another over things that will also perish along with us
I hope you understand that the Jews of Iraq were violently disposed of their property and were treated as dhmmi. Do you know about the Fauhoud of 1941?
When you translate "ethnic cleansing" into לנקות it means "to clean" (like cleaning the floor), the correct term is לטהר אתנית. But I would argue that this is not the term Israelis use. They use words like: לשטח את עזה or לגרש את כל הערבים.
You have to adjust the term to the culture. It's just like you wouldn't translate a Kibbutz as a village, and "village" is usually reserved to Arab settlements only. Other than that, you have to read between the lines of what people have just said. I believe the 1st two actually do mean they do not support ethnic cleansing, but, and this is a huge but, the guy that said, for example, that we need to "speak like Arabs" actually means to hit the Arabs hard. It's a term used with Israeli right-wingers who support the coalition. What they mean with that is that we shouldn't show weakness, and every blow we receive should be met with a deadlier response.
I do think, however, that what most Israelis want is simply security.
What security means to Israelis is a scale, though. For example, the mainstream view of security is to "respond hard". When we're attacked, we'll attack twice as hard. People then will ask: "Why didn't we attack sooner?" It stems from pure fear, and this is the number one issue Israelis vote for. Netanyahu knows how to utilize this.
Nothing to do with Netanyahu. I voted for Hertzog (Labour - left of centre) previously.
It is to do with neighbours who are self-declared terrorists who want to kill all Jews and Israelis (and other Infidels).
Israel, from all political factions, is united to destroy Hamas from Gaza so what happened on 7th October cannot happen again. The bigger picture is that:
World peace cannot permit millions of people to support terror and the murder of innocent people who think differently from you.
World peace cannot allow a North Korea with nuclear weapons that threatens SK, Japan, US, etc.
World peace cannot permit an Iranian apocalyptic regime, that longs for Armageddon, to exist among civilised nations.
The equilibrium is too fragile now and can be tipped over far too easily.
@@saulger6409 World peace cannot allow for a lunatic state to exterminate an entire population
Just to clarify: when we say "speak like Arabs" it means loosely "to speak [the language of] Arabs", ie, "the language they understand best/use on us"= violence. Just breaking down the linguistic underpinning here.
But how can you have security while having as an official State policy the occupation and colonization of another people land and denying the right for the forced expelled to get back to their land? Don't Israelies see that they cannot have both?
I believe a commonly phrased question in Hebrew would be:
האם אתה בעד טרנספר לערבים?
Unsurprisingly, the vast majority of Israelis are not extremists or bigots.
Who says bigot?😂
As if we're not all intolerant of *some* people🙄
Grow up.
yes they are
@theLoneWarriorofAllah78611O evidence? Most it seems disapprove of netanyahu. I think like around 60% disapprove.
@@SerafinaP that is why he won the democratic elections - some common sense please
@@SerafinaP well i only watched half way but you can tell through the first half they all feel entitled and superior. Only the first guy was cool
Now ask the same question to palestinians in the West Bank
Why would the Palestinians in the West Bank want to ethnically cleanse themselves?
The Palestinian people in the West Bank are under SEVERE occupation and ongoing Genocide too
"Palestinians: If Israel left the West Bank and Gaza, would there be peace with Israel?"
Answer is no because it's all our land.
He has, cutie. Enjoy my country's money, dear.
Go ask the Gazans that Israel has kept in an open Air prison and killed their women and children. Have been forced to live in Gaza because they ethnically cleansed them from their land.
What answer do you expect to get.
Israil has been exposed for the racist apartheid state it is.😂.
I can't believe that people here, hundreds or thousands of miles from the conflict, think they know what the Isrselis think better than the Israelis. There is a massive difference between the view of us outside abd those who really have skin in the game. It's like listening to boring, righteous pontifucating football pundits rather thsn the players themselves
Our lives are at stake.
We also have opinions on the Holocaust but I guess you're not upset about that because we're aligned on the subject.
Palestine is thousands of miles from the sites of European atrocities against Jews, yet they have paid the price with their homeland.
The US is thousands of miles from israel and yet their essential support guarantees the continuation of this conflict.
Mind Begs the Question:
▪︎D3ath to Jews chants - Holocaustic
▪︎D3ath to Arabs chants - Democratic?
@HumanBeingsRThinkingBeings I live in Israel, and I have heard no "Death to Arab" chants. I am sure there are pockets of idiots who do that, as there are anywhere.
Regarding Death to Jew chants, it's not pockets: it is the majority doing that.
@HumanBeingsRThinkingBeings Both are terrible. But the world has gone cold towards Muslims and genocides towards Muslim populations in the last 3 decades proves that.
What's weird is that you're in the city... where most of these Israelis are liberal.
Conservatives are the majority now. Go to the small towns, ask them, and they will tell you 90% of the time they want to remove Palestinians from the land. Don't word it "ethnically cleanse" just ask "if you could press a button, would you remove all Palestinians outside of Israel, West Bank, and Gaza."
Nonsense.Ashkelon is bordering gaza and is a right wing city
It is amazing how many think their was peace on Oct 6th. Most of these people stated that they are fine with Palestinians as long as they stop hurting us, but seem completely oblivious to the harms they have been doing them. It's weird.
@@dogzdigital all the harm that was ever done to the Palestinians was done to prevent them from hurting Israelis. The previous rounds in Gaza happened because they were shooting rockets into Israel, by thousands, and needed to be stopped. All the damage their sustained was following Arab loses in wars Arabs started. They never want peace!
You're flipping things around. the settlements didn't exist until later during this conflict. in fact Jordan was in control of the west bank and Egypt in control of Gaza until 67.
Many years and a lot of violence later the settlements started being built BECAUSE of constant Palestinian violence. not the opposite way around.
Sweetheart, no one is doing any violence in west bank, except for illegal.settlers so stop yapping.
Settlers are there for a reason to annex west bank.
How do you think israel was found settlers from european countries.
@@ibnelkhanthat is straight up false
@@einefes keep telling that to urself...will make you feel pretty.
USA the unyeilding ally of israel doesnt recognize the settlements.
As of now settlements are the main things which is eroding the required two state solution.
Every bloody state except israel is willing for a two.state.
You should know that by now.
I.thought iran was good in taqiya but wow israelies or their.supporters are steps ahead of them
THIS IS A BAD QUESTION. Too many people incorrectly think "ethnic cleansing" means "genocide". So people think you are asking "Do you want to genocide all the Palestinians". Of course they will say "NO". The question you should ask is "Do you think we should make most Palestinians move out of Gaza (and the West Bank) ?"
The Hamas Charter answers that question. Then there is this ==> Arab child abuse fuels Mideast Wars.
Look up - "Is Arab hatred for Israel a product of the child abuse normative in the Arab world?" American Thinker September 29, 2024
doesnt gaza and the west bank belong to palestine? i was always under the impression israel had occupied it for counter-insurgency similar to what we did in afghanistan? or is that seriously how fucked this thing is?
@@msimon6808 how on earth does that make any sense?
It's even worse. They are effectively in internment or concetration camps. Why they even control everything including water sources. They deliberatly destroy water wells for livelihoods within the west bank and ban collecting rainwater.
And Gaza has been aptly described as an open air prison, often being bombed for decades by Israelis as "mowing the lawn" and now it's a zone where deliberate mass starvation and genocide is taking place.
@@jpmorganandco-k1y they occupy Gaza and keep a blockade around it so they control who and what enters or leaves. They take tax money from the west bank but give them zero rights in the country, no right to vote or freedom of movement. So they take their money the west bank pays not only the Palestinian authority but the Israeli government in taxes yet have no say in any government issues. The Isntreali government can take their land not allow them to farm on land they OWN. So much its too much to say.
The Palestinians will not be ashamed to say yes
UNWRA education
after what israel did to them, i cant blame them, i would say the same thing if i was palestenian
@@liamlinson7563 ..."every Palestinian, in Gaza and throughout Palestine, can prove his Arab roots - whether from Saudi Arabia, from Yemen, or anywhere. We have blood ties. Personally, half my family is Egyptian. We are all like that. More than 30 families in the Gaza Strip are called Al-Masri ["Egyptian"]. Brothers, half of the Palestinians are Egyptians and the other half are Saudis. Who are the Palestinians? We have many families called Al-Masri, whose roots are Egyptian. Egyptian! They may be from Alexandria, from Cairo, from Dumietta, from the North, from Aswan, from Upper Egypt. We are Egyptians."
Hamas Minister of the Interior and of National Security Fathi Hammad, aired by Al-Hekma TV on March 23, 2012.
The so called Palestinians are not even from the region known as Palestine!!!!!!
www.memri.org/tv/hamas-minister-interior-and-national-security-fathi-hammad-slams-egypt-over-fuel-shortage-gaza
They both say something and do the opposite just like these people in the video but they are in reality ethnically cleansing palestinians
@liamlinson7563 so you support a position that will all but guarantee a neverending war...
I like the guy that basically said there is what I want and there's reality. He's right. You can only do the best you can in an impossible situation like that.
If you ask most o the Israelis if they want an ethnic cleansing, they will say. Only right extremists maybe say " yes but". 95% of jews will say no. If you ask palestinians the same question about ethnic cleansing of jews , at least 75% will say yes.
why are yo going into hypotheticals when the Israeli government is actually pursuing the policy of ethnically cleansing Gaza, at least the Northern Gaza, of Palestinians?
I think both sides hate each other but they won’t say it . Maybe it’s 50 percent
@@sureyyaekinci4630 Don't think, watch the other videos from the Ask Project, read the studies done in Gaza, etc. The Arab Muslims who call themselves Palestinians to the exclusion of Jews and Christians, are clear the majority is fine with ethnically cleanse (or worse) Jews and Israelis, as well as "collaborators".
This is in parts due to Hamas indoctrination and the success of Wahabi/Islamist thoughts and propaganda in the MENA region and the West.
@NasirAli-r1c First of all we are speaking about people's opinion, not government. Second, recording to hamas ministry of health 45000 were killed during this war that hamas started on October 7th , 70% terrorists from the age of 15. Maybe 15000 civilians were killed because they were used as a human shield. In the same time, recording to the same hamas ministry of health, 60000 babies were born. It doesn't look like ethnic cleansing or genocide. If Israel wanted to destroy all palestinian population in gaza and west bank it could take few days . The ratio between armed terrorists and civilians that were killed in this war is 2 to 1. 2 terrorists for 1 cevilian . In all history of wars never been such a ratio. But for people like you the facts and truth doesn't matter.
@@mironlempert5737 Israeli government has been elected and 94% of the israeli population supports the genocide (or "war" as they call it). Just because a lot of israelis are smart enough not to be caught on camera defending genocide in english, does not mean they do not support it.
I love the clever answers from these wonderful Israeli Jews ❤. Israeli Jews really want peace and are good people. Love the Israeli Jews! They are telling you the truth about them which has been twisted in the media. Stay safe! 🕊🕊🕊
Yeah they really wanna peace .. the peace that tell them to steal palestinian homes and kick them out 😂😅
Fuck you, I got you to 20 likes >:)
Act speak louder, and they act otherwise.
@@AnaUnknown-s4v they act otherwise...
@@AnaUnknown-s4v twisted by the media? the medias literally defending them so much lmaoo this channel also asking jewish people if it's OK to spat at christians, and unsurprisingly majority of them said if it's OK to even m*urder them
Now go ask the gazans.... oh wait you already did.And they said yes.
All that blockage and genocide of course they would say yes
He’s never been to Gaza, does it make you feel more complete to sit here and lie online?
@@Drippygokuwhats the difference? Its all ancient native balastinians..... gaza or not habubu
@@haronli5575
Low IQ guy. Explain how they have been genocided when their population has not even dropped 😂
@@Drippygoku
But yes in the West Bank and you can find countless videos, where the majority answer yes. How does it make you feel to try to disavow a comment that was fundamentally true, because of a marginal error?
Thanks!
thanks barry.
What a silly question, no one is going to say yes. Totally loaded. You're heading in the right direction Cory, but please select questions better. What stood out for me is thinking everything was ok before Oct 7. Not understanding what it is like to be Palestinian in Gaza, West Bank is at the root of this perception. Maybe if you asked questions to Israelis like " If you were Palestinian and having you're lives controlled by people who restrict how you live, imprison you for minor offences and take your land, what would that be like? Or to Palestinians " If you were Israeli and felt threatened by your neighbours, had rockets fired at you and had what happened on Oct 7, what would that be like?" Imagining what it is like to be the other is the way forward here. But this is very very hard to do, because it is seriously uncomfortable. We like thinking we are the victim and they are the perpetrator. The reality is EVERYONE is both.
Keep up the great work Cory, but I urge you to select questions a little better.
You are mistaken.
what you wrote is False: "controlled by people who restrict how you live, imprison you for minor offences and take your land" - Gaza since 2005 governed by HAMAS.
And they got billions of dollars which they could have used to make Gaza the Singapore of the middle east.
they chose to "invest" in Terror, and this is the result.
The question is why the arab leadership didn't agree to any of the options to change the situation in Gaza. There were many, they refused them all.
I also think a good question to ask Israelis is, "Do you think a Palestinian that that is born and grows up in the West Bank or Gaza would believe Israel has a right exist?" A good question to ask to Palestinians is, "Do you think an Israeli that is born and grows up in Israel support the destruction of Israel and the explosion of Jews from the land?"
Oh please, as restrictive as it may be, it is a hundred times more restricted in the surrounding Arab and Muslim countries.
@@suereed3474 exactly
One of the reasons nations tend to demonize each other is the lack of direct, meaningful communication between their people. This unfortunate void is often filled with doubts, mistrust, and hatred. Corey, I deeply appreciate your efforts to bridge this gap. There is a pressing need for more direct, open communication between Arabs and Jews. A platform where individuals from both communities can openly discuss and debate their concerns could play a vital role in dismantling misunderstandings perpetuated over time, often by their leaders. I sincerely wish for peace and harmony for everyone in the Holy Land.
You are light 💫✨ i love you 💎
Not sure they were given the correct definition of ethnic cleansing. At one point they even translated it to Hebrew as "genocide." It can involve killing, but it can also involve simply expelling them from an area. It sounded as though some were against killing, but also didn't want them there anymore.
You are loved❤️🩵💝❤
I wish cory would stop lumping in Israeli arabs with palestinians because a lot of these people think he was talking about israeli arabs.
They are ethnically the same. Many of these people would consider Israel stretching to the West Bank and would consider those people the same.
@@dustopianMost Israelis don’t think Israel includes the West Bank. If he were asking inside the settlements, that would be the case, but he wasn’t.
@@amystern123 I thought many of them do and want to see it officially annexed, but alright. Regardless, I think these people realise that the word "palestinian" means people inside the West Bank.
the fuck are you on about? most of them literally spoke of October 7th and Gaza. that's in clear reference to Gaza + west bank Palestinians.
@@dustopian some settlements yes others no. some supposed settlements are essentially a city that's been there for a long time. during the last negotiations they wanted to take those settlements and give the west bank other equivalent land in exchange.
A better set up question is: "Let's assume the Palestinians will never accept Jewish sovereignty in the land and will resist the "Occupation" for as long as Israel exists as a sovereign Jewish state. Should the Palestinians be expelled from Gaza and the West Bank?"
Yes.
Yes.
How about end the occupation of west bank and gaza
@@ibnlahad2982 Gaza wasn't occupied since 2005. So it's really only the West Bank that we're talking about.
@@rockysandman5489 Gaza is still pretty much an open air prison, walled up and blockaded.
i love when people say "oh hey there" like they dont know the recording is happening
This is the most interesting from the videos I watched on this channel. Israelis are very smart and moral. Other nations can learn so much from them.
Why not ask Hamas, Hezbollah and Palestinians the same question?
Maybe because they are the ones subject to the GENOCIDE????
I Imagine their response may be different. And if I were in their shoes I would completely understand.
@@tye1939the sing from the river to the sea..thts enough to say they dnt wnt us to exist
check his channel - he already asked plenty of palestinians the same questions and the answers were not suprising
palestinians for sure, if you look up corey's channel, he has done videos with palestinians in the past...
hamas and hesbollah, on the other hand is trickier :
- first, getting to interview them is probably way harder, especially for someone that is looking to contact them from within israel
- second, why should we ask these organisations ? is corey asking people from the israeli government or even people affiliated to the party in office these days ? no he does not - why then should palestinians be accountable for the crimes of these organisations, when they did not elect them in a even remotely democratical way (which is the case for bibi, though) ? your question sounds like palestinians should be considered suspect from the start, when the israeli shouldn't, yet, it is not the palestinians who have murdered the most civilians in the last year...
May God bless and protect Israel 🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱
History of PALESTINIAN STATE:
1. Before Israel, there was a British mandate, not a Palestinian state
2. Before the British Mandate, there was the Ottoman Empire, not a Palestinian state.
3. Before the Ottoman Empire, there was the Islamic state of the Mamluks of Egypt, not a Palestinian state.
4. Before the Islamic state of the Mamluks of Egypt, there was the Ayubid Arab-Kurdish Empire, not a Palestinian state.
5. Before the Ayubid Empire, there was the Frankish and Christian Kingdom of Jerusalem, not a Palestinian state.
6. Before the Kingdom of Jerusalem, there was the Umayyad and Fatimid empires, not a Palestinian state.
7. Before the Umayyad and Fatimid empires, there was the Byzantine empire, not a Palestinian state.
8. Before the Byzantine Empire, there were the Sassanids, not a Palestinian state.
9. Before the Sassanid Empire, there was the Byzantine Empire, not a Palestinian state.
10. Before the Byzantine Empire, there was the Roman Empire, not a Palestinian state.
11. Before the Roman Empire, there was the Hasmonean state, not a Palestinian state.
12. Before the Hasmonean state, there was the Seleucid, not a Palestinian state.
13. Before the Seleucid empire, there was the empire of Alexander the Great, not a Palestinian state.
14. Before the empire of Alexander the Great, there was the Persian empire, not a Palestinian state.
15. Before the Persian Empire, there was the Babylonian Empire, not a Palestinian state.
16. Before the Babylonian Empire, there were the Kingdoms of Israel and Judah, not a Palestinian state.
17. Before the Kingdoms of Israel and Judah, there was the Kingdom of Israel, not a Palestinian state.
18. Before the kingdom of Israel, there was the theocracy of the twelve tribes of Israel, not a Palestinian state.
19. Before the theocracy of the twelve tribes of Israel, there was an agglomeration of independent Canaanite city-kingdoms, not a Palestinian state.
20. Actually, in this piece of land there has been everything, EXCEPT A PALESTINIAN STATE.
Why should we care? There was never a Kosovo state before 2008 but the west seems to care about Kosovo being independent.
You are light 💫✨ i love you 💎❤
Basically you asked people if they support or want do crimes and most of them said no even after a long time thinking what to say
I have a question. is this a video for children or morons?
I wish both sides peace of course that is horrible what we witnessed last year thats realky shocking to see what humans are capable of
I'm an Israeli Jew, I want to see Palestinians happy and free but away from the land of Israel
we love Palestinians and we want peace, but others refuse peace because they see us as occupiers
@@Itsdifferent-wv4johow deluded. So bc we are a different religion and race we should not have a right to live in a land not only we were BORN ON, our parents, great grandparents, great grandparents back over 1000 years have lived on? Is that what you just said? THAT IS THE DEFINITION OF RACIST, SUPREMACY, and ETHNIC CLEANSING you bigot
@@Itsdifferent-wv4joyou yourself weren’t even born there lol yet you think you have more rights than the Palestinians who lived there for centuries 🤣 the delusion and entitlement
@@ArabianConjure Read a Bible, G-d gave us the land
Danke!
Cheers on this channel which is basically the holy land's version of 1420. May the Ask an Israeli/Ask a Palestinian project keep ongoing until peace there becomes realized.
Research by Pew in 2016 suggested almost 50% of Israeli Jews wanted Arabs ethnically cleansed. 80% said Jews should receive preferential treatment. I don't think the figure has reduced in the intervening years.
Corey's video asking Palestinians about Israel is very telling.
Can you pls provide a link or something to back this up? Thx 🙏
@@thehocean It should be easy to Google - UA-cam always gives me spam warnings when I try to post links.
@@BasilBeatonthats the same people cleansed from 22 arnab is lamic countries?
Have you read hamas charter? Ev 8:04 en Abbbas want no jews in his "Palestine". Israel is a civilized country. Am Yisrael Chai ❤🇧🇻🇮🇱
What is Hamas charter?
There was two charters first one said they wanted to eradicate all Jews in Israel and the world. The revised was to eradicate the Zionist as not to be antisametic@@nessimbencheik8308
oh gawd here we go. The charter was changed. Isreal is a genocidal society
@@nessimbencheik8308Something made up to justify the existence of the criminal state
@@Arish-s3m avalon.law.yale.edu/20th_century/hamas.asp
There is no radical ☪️ just ☪️. Thats why I left.
Majority of sensible people will never say yes to such a question, especially in front of the camera 😂. You watch some with the hesitation and you know they at the very least have such an idea in their minds.
It's not even about racism, there were 4 different "races" that merged in the Levant even as late as 1500 BC. This is why you see a variation of skin colours and features. It wasn't even that homogenous as of 1500BC. The problem is Islam is still stuck in the stone age and most followers are still living in it.
And that is a racist comment. This is blood libel against the Islamic people.
BTW - Islam did not even exist in the stone age, and it is historically more modern than Judaism and Christianity.
Explain why Christian Palestinians protest Israel’s occupation every day then.
Update your 2014 playbook. Thanks! We've all moved on to the originator of all the chaos.
PS. Cute how you try to create different "races" out of Semites 😂 Ignorant.
@@shadyaymannoor It seems they are less violent about it. I didn't say Israel was 100% right about everything. I'm sure there are some valid criticisms, but it's clear from these videos of civilians, which civilians are more tolerant and civilized.
@@aaronwood161 - yes christian arabs are always better to deal with IMO, but that isn't why this is happening.
Lol in the comments they seem to be upset that the Israelis answered the question in the negative
As an Israeli Jewish person a lot of these views have changed drastically since 7/10 looking at them cheering on the streets at massacre of Jewish people was a real wake up call
This video IS after 7/10... People are talking about the war in Gaza in the video...
Did you view on Isrealis change two after seeing the soldier make a mockery and partying while going through destroyed houses and ppls underwear or while blowing up universities? hmmmm
The outside world doesn’t care about the reductive Israeli opinion of things having started only on 7/10 gobbledygook
The Israelis before 7/10 are the same as after 7/10-your actions and mindset have never changed. The clearest proof lies in what you’ve done in Gaza.
But rest assured, every crime you’ve committed in Gaza will haunt you.
Retribution is inevitable.
Mark my words well, and never forget them.
@@Salara2130 did u hide weapons in the university?
The first guy genuinely looked shocked that you would ask something like that
he was shocked because they are public relations savvy and understands that direct questions and true answers on this topic are not to be recorded / broadcast. this is why most of them gave sanitized broadcast-ready answers.
this is not a reliable way to uncover their true feelings on this matter. you have to ask multiple indirect questions from different angles to zero-in on their real thoughts / intentions. several commenters already gave example lists of effective questions in this comment section, so I won't repeat them.
@@the80386 cant say the same about the arabs
@@viosh7137 yep, they could attend some of those IDF public relation and propaganda workshops to train high schoolers in wikipedia rewriting and comment section manipulation. or better yet, stop the generational occupation and subjugation so we can finally see an end to this mess.
I can understand if some Isrlis are so angry that they emotionally find it difficult to care, but intellectually most everyone understands what is correct.
2:50 I have a feeling that the question could be clearer. This woman shows that the Israelis are interpreting this question to mean whether the Israeli arabs should be ethnically cleansed from Israel. All Israelis believe in demographic domination of all of Israel including Gaza, "Judea" and "Samaria" which would entail ethnic cleansing of millions of Arabs.
Homelander?
@krishnaveganathar You'll have to explain your reference. I don't watch the Boys. All I remember is when Bassem Youssef referred to Israel as Homelander but didn't get the joke.
@@SuperKripke how do you know what "All israelis believe in"?
*that's a rhetorical question no need to respond.
@@adischenker1851 Staatsrason of Israel is a Jewish state. If you don't have demographic domination then you don't have a Jewish state. One can reasonably exclude Anti Zionist Israelis (including Israeli Arabs) without loss of generality.
As an Israeli. Youre wrong. And you ate up baseem propaganda i see.
A lot of waffling. Answer should be "NO"
And so should the answer from the other side. But it's not.
@@8aNda1d Hate to break it to you, but there's no such thing as reverse genocide.
@@malinia.20 genocide is such a jewish term. What even do u mean with reverse genocide lol.
@@malinia.20 hate to break it to you there is no ethnic cleansing de facto, what's the ethnic difference between Palestinians in judea and gaza and Israeli arabs?
Chronological Incidents of Violence Against Jews in the Ottoman Sanjak of Jerusalem, Sanjak of Acre, and Sanjak of Nablus (1800-1917)
1834 Safed Riots - Muslims attacked Jews in Safed.
1834 Hebron Massacre - Muslims attacked Jews in Hebron.
1834 Jerusalem Pogrom - Muslims attacked Jews in Jerusalem.
1834 Nablus Riots - Muslims attacked Jews in Nablus.
1834 Jaffa Riots - Muslims attacked Jews in Jaffa.
1838 Safed Pogrom - Druze attacked Jews in Safed.
1847 Hebron Pogrom - Muslims attacked Jews in Hebron.
1847 Acre Riots - Arabs attacked Jews in Acre.
1847 Tiberias Massacre - Muslims attacked Jews in Tiberias.
1848 Tiberias Incident - Arabs attacked Jews in Tiberias.
1856 Safed Riots - Arabs attacked Jews in Safed.
1860 Damascus Affair - Impact on Jewish communities in Ottoman Palestine.
1869 Jaffa Riots - Arabs attacked Jews in Jaffa.
1871 Jaffa Riots - Arabs attacked Jews in Jaffa.
1873 Jaffa Riots - Arabs attacked Jews in Jaffa.
1873 Nablus Pogrom - Arabs attacked Jews in Nablus.
1874 Nablus Riots - Arabs attacked Jews in Nablus.
1875 Safed Riots - Muslims attacked Jews in Safed.
1876 Jaffa Riots - Arabs attacked Jews in Jaffa.
1881 Safed Riots - Arabs attacked Jews in Safed.
1882 Tiberias Riots - Arabs attacked Jews in Tiberias.
1886 Safed Pogrom - Arabs attacked Jews in Safed.
1886 Petaḥ Tikvah Incident - Arabs attacked Jews in Petaḥ Tikvah.
1890 Haifa Riots - Arabs attacked Jews in Haifa.
1891 Hebron Riots - Arabs attacked Jews in Hebron.
1893 Jaffa Riots - Arabs attacked Jews in Jaffa.
1895 Beersheba Incident - Arabs attacked Jews in Beersheba.
1895 Jerusalem Riots - Arabs attacked Jews in Jerusalem.
1901 Gedera Incident - Arabs attacked Jews in Gedera.
1903 Motza Riots - Arabs attacked Jews in Motza.
1903 Rehovot Incident - Arabs attacked Jews in Rehovot.
1903 Tiberias Riots - Arabs attacked Jews in Tiberias.
1908 Acre Riots - Arabs attacked Jews in Acre.
1908 Jaffa Riots - Arabs attacked Jews in Jaffa.
1909 Hebron Riots - Arabs attacked Jews in Hebron.
1911 Jaffa Riots - Arabs attacked Jews in Jaffa.
1911 Safed Riots - Arabs attacked Jews in Safed.
1913 Tel Aviv Riots - Arabs attacked Jews in Tel Aviv.
1913 Rehovot Riots - Arabs attacked Jews in Rehovot.
1917 Jerusalem Riots - Arabs attacked Jews in Jerusalem.
Chronological Incidents of Violence Against Jews in British Mandate for Palestine and OETA (1917-1948)
1920 Nebi Musa Riots - Arabs attacked Jews in Jerusalem.
1920 Jaffa Riots - Arabs attacked Jews in Jaffa.
1921 Jaffa Massacre - Arabs attacked Jews in Jaffa.
1921 Petah Tikvah Riots - Arabs attacked Jews in Petah Tikvah.
1929 Safed Massacre - Arabs attacked Jews in Safed.
1929 Hebron Massacre - Arabs attacked Jews in Hebron.
1929 Haifa Massacre - Arabs attacked Jews in Haifa.
1936-1939 Arab Revolt - Arabs attacked Jews across Palestine.
1936 Safed Riots - Arabs attacked Jews in Safed.
1936 Jaffa Riots - Arabs attacked Jews in Jaffa.
1936 Tiberias Riots - Arabs attacked Jews in Tiberias.
1937 Kfar Etzion Massacre - Arabs attacked Jews in Kfar Etzion.
1938 Tel Aviv Riots - Arabs attacked Jews in Tel Aviv.
1938 Haifa Riots - Arabs attacked Jews in Haifa.
1938 Safed Riots - Arabs attacked Jews in Safed.
1939 Petah Tikvah Riots - Arabs attacked Jews in Petah Tikvah.
1947 Jerusalem Riots - Arabs attacked Jews in Jerusalem.
1947 Haifa Riots - Arabs attacked Jews in Haifa.
1947 Safed Riots - Arabs attacked Jews in Safed.
1947 Jaffa Riots - Arabs attacked Jews in Jaffa.
1948 Kfar Etzion Massacre - Arabs attacked Jews in Kfar Etzion.
1947 Hebron Massacre - Arabs attacked Jews in Hebron.
1947 Acre Riots - Arabs attacked Jews in Acre.
1948 Latrun Massacre - Arab forces attacked Israeli convoys and civilian targets, killing Jews.
1948 Safed Massacre - Arabs attacked Jews in Safed during the Arab-Israeli war.
1948 Haifa Riots - Arabs attacked Jews in Haifa during the 1947-1948 Civil War.
1948 Jerusalem Riots - Arabs attacked Jewish neighborhoods in Jerusalem.
1948 Old City of Jerusalem - Arab forces attacked Jewish residents in Jerusalem's Old City.
1948 Gush Etzion Massacre - Arabs attacked Jewish settlements in Gush Etzion, killing civilians.
1948 Mount Scopus Convoy Attack - Arabs ambushed and killed Jewish civilians during the 1948 siege.
1948 Tel Aviv Attacks - Arab militants carried out a series of attacks in Tel Aviv.
Chronological Incidents of Violence Against Jews and Israelis since the establishment of the State of Israel(1948-Present)
1948 - Arab States and Militias to Israel: Arab-Israeli War
1954 - Egyptian Forces (Arab Fedayeen) to Israel: Lavon Affair
1955 - Arab Fedayeen to Israel: Gaza Raid
1956 - Egyptian Fedayeen to Israel: Eilat Raid
1965 - Fatah (Palestinian Arab Militants) to Israel: The Battle of Karameh
1967 - Arab States to Israel: Six-Day War
1968 - PLO to Israel: Kiryat Shmona Bus Attack
1972 - Black September (PLO) to Israel: Munich Olympics Massacre
1973 - Arab States to Israel: Yom Kippur War (October 1973) - Surprise attacks by Egypt and Syria on Israel, including numerous civilian casualties.
1974 - PLO to Israel: Ma’alot Massacre
1975 - Fatah to Israel: Coastal Road Hijacking
1982 - PLO to Israel: Beirut Bombings
1985 - PLO to Israel: Achille Lauro Hijacking
1987-1993 - PLO, Hamas, Islamic Jihad to Israel: First Intifada
1989 - Hamas to Israel: Hebron Bus Bombing
1996 - Hamas to Israel: Dizengoff Center Bombing
1997 - Hamas to Israel: Mahane Yehuda Market Bombings
2000-2005 - Hamas, PLO, Islamic Jihad to Israel: Second Intifada
2001 - Hamas to Israel: Dolphinarium Disco Bombing
2002 - Hamas to Israel: Passover Massacre
2002 - Islamic Jihad to Israel: Maalot-Tarshiha Bus Attack
2003 - Hamas to Israel: Haifa Bus Bombing
2004 - Hamas to Israel: Ashdod Port Attack
2005 - Hamas to Israel: Eilat Terror Attack
2006 - Hezbollah to Israel: Second Lebanon War
2006 - Hezbollah to Israel: Northern Border Attacks
2011 - PLO to Israel: Itamar Massacre
2012 - Hamas, Islamic Jihad to Israel: Tel Aviv Bus Bombing
2014 - Hamas to Israel: Gaza-Israel War
2014 - Hamas to Israel: Kfar Darom Attack
2015 - Hamas, PLO, Lone Wolf Attackers to Israel: Stabbing Intifada
2015 - Hamas to Israel: Continued rocket fire into southern Israel in the aftermath of the Stabbing Intifada
2017 - Hamas to Israel: Jerusalem Truck Attack
2021 - Hamas, PLO, Islamic Jihad to Israel: Operation Guardian of the Walls
2021 - Hamas to Israel: Jerusalem Rocket Attack
2022 - Hamas, Islamic Jihad to Israel: Ramallah, Jenin Attacks
2023 - Hamas to Israel: October 7th Attack
2024 - Hamas to Israel: Rocket Strikes and Border Crossings
2024 - Hamas to Israel: Eilat Rocket Strike
2022 - Hamas to Israel: Be’er Sheva Attack
2023 - Hezbollah to Israel: Northern Border Rocket Attack
2023 - Hamas to Israel: Ashkelon Rocket Attack
2023 - Houthi Rebels to Israel: Missile attacks on Israeli shipping vessels in the Red Sea
2023 - Hezbollah to Israel: Cross-border fire into Israeli territory
2024 - Iranian Forces (via proxies) to Israel: Further attacks through Hezbollah and other Iranian-backed groups
2024 - Hamas to Israel: Continued rocket fire and attempted border infiltrations from Gaza
2024 - Hezbollah to Israel: Cross-border skirmishes, with missile fire targeting civilian areas in northern Israel
2024 - Hamas to Israel: Large-scale rocket and drone attacks targeting Israeli cities and military bases
2024 - Hezbollah to Israel: Attacks targeting IDF positions and civilian infrastructure in the north
2024 - Palestinian Arab Militants (various groups) to Israel: Coordinated attacks along the Gaza-Israel border
2024 - Hamas to Israel: Multiple mortar shell attacks across the border into Israel’s southern regions
etc...
Good boy. Now do one against Jews against Arabs, Armenians and Iranians. Don't forget to give a shout-out to the Js multiple genocides in both the Old Testament and last 100 years. They invented the idea of genocide and holds the world record funnily enough.
I’m not racist I have black friends
Did you watch the video with your eyes closed and your ears clogged?
Yes, generally when someone had black friends they are not racist….
Do you really, rahul ahmed? Do u have black friends?
We know who Israhellis are!
Sure Muslim...
Love to Israel from America ❤
It must be hard to live next to people who want to erase you from this earth. Most of the people killed on 10-07-23 were people who supported peace. It is hard because there are many good people amongst the Palestinians. I don't know if people are being honest... really.
Most Palestinians do not seek peace or coexistence but want to take everything the Jews have created and built in Israel.
Why don't you ask arabs/muslims in Israel/Judea/Samaria/Gaza/egypt/syria/jordan/lebanon/iraq/iran, if they want to ethnically cleanse The Jews from The Middle East? Also, please ask them what happened to The Jews who lived in gaza prior to 1929, Jews who lived in Judea/Samaria prior to 1948, The Jews who lived in egypt, syria, iraq, iran, lebanon, tunisia, turkey, etc..?
You imply you’re against ethnic cleansing yet in the same breath, call Palestine ‘Judea and Samaria’ lol.
@@shadyaymannoor , it's because that's what it is. This area was known as Judea and Samaria till hashemites renamed it after they illegally occupied it in 1948 with the help of british(ex: arab legion). There has never been a "palestine" kingdom, country, etc.. Area is not a country. As for ethnic cleansing, If its okay for arabs/muslims, its okay for The Jews. What is good for the goose, is good for the gander.
Why do you add Turkey? Turkey didn’t expel the Jews. Historically Turks and Jews got along very well. What kind of hateful and manipulative person you are?
He knows how genocidal 95% of arnab nuzlinz..... its their sole cultural feature
@@alexjohnson9630 - I've seen maps in one of the videos that goes back before '48 that has the word palestine on it, so that's not true. And if memory serves, either Herzl or one of the other terrorists called it that too.
Israelis: Do you want to ethnically cleanse the Palestinians while you are ethnically cleansing the Palestinians?
Why expose yourself as an idiot? If you didn't say anything, people wouldn't know.
LOL I'm shocked Cory didn't know the correct translation. He should have known that before he even started filming.
This video gives me so much peace. Shows us the Israelis are just like anybody else, may Allah grant peace to everybody in this region
Asking colonizers if they want to ethnically cleanse Palestinians is an oxymoron
"The Ethnic Cleansing of Palestine"
Book by Israeli writer Ilan Pappe
The son of hamas leader says there is no Palestinian people . I think he is more reliable than a random Israeli
Palestine doesn't exist.
Once Upon a Potty
Book by Israeli writer Alona Frankel
@@untitled7184incidentally, great book!
I guess for you, he's one of the only good Israelis.
The Israelis are far more charitable than I would be in the same situation. What does one do with a dog who has hydrophobia?
Comparing Palestinians to dogs tells us everything we need to know about you.
Pro pals desperately trying to make Israel look bad in the comments 😂
Now ask the same question of Palestinians, the answers will be mostly yes. I think Corey has a few videos that are shocking. Most dont want peace, most dont want a compromise.
There has been footage of people saying that explicitly and with certainty in the media. Some Israelis support it, others do not.
I would say that the people who do support it are the ONLY people from Israel you will see in most mainstream media. That's the point this whole channel. To show the real people on the ground, and not the ones the media wants you to see.
Stupid question, reword it to not sound so aggressive and I guarantee the answers change lol
If you think you can do better just grab your phone, fly to Israel, and ask your questions the way you want them asked.
Im a Kurd and I want aza, judea and samarea return to their true motherland israEL. Her bijî yisraÊL❤☀️💚🇮🇱.
Amen
Kurds have always been traitors
Turkish win the kaffir like you
lol average kurd:
@@luxcvy average Kurd was Piruz of nahawand (Abulolo)💪🏻💪🏻
As an ex Muslim I must say, pest control is not genocide, get that straight.
What a horrible response. People are capable of change; you did.
@@angelalewis4213 growing up around Muslim males, spending time in madrassas (Quran practice classes in a mosque), always hearing Muslim youth praising terror attacks on innocents in western countries, liberals like you will never be useful for anything other than your legs wide open for people accept your help but then talk against you behind your back. Liberals are a bigger cancer than the cancer as they feed the cancer to grow.
@@angelalewis4213 growing up around Muslim males, spending time in madrassas (Quran practice classes in a mosque), always hearing Muslim youth praising terror attacks on innocent "infidels" in western countries, liberals like you will never be any help for anything other than your gap wide open for people who "accept" your help but then talk against you behind your back. Liberals are a bigger cancer than the cancer as they feed the cancer to grow.
@angelalewis4213 growing up around Muslim males, spending time in madrassas (Quran practice classes in mosques), always hearing Muslim youth praising terror attacks on innocent "infidels" in western countries, liberals like you will never be useful for anything other than your aid to anyone without awareness. You entertain people who "accept" your help but then talk against you behind your back. Liberals are just a fuel to a growing destruction.
@@Moshe-e1l Hitler called it that too. He would be proud but surprised to see his ideology still lives on through you Moshe
I’m so happy to see Corey and Adar are friends, and cooperating even. Two of my favourite people, and the only YT producers I’ve donated money to thus far. Keep it up, you are needed. Are you aware of Robert Wright, of Non Zero and Bloggingheads? You guys are swimming in the same waters.
Regarding the video, it’s striking that the interviewees often say they want to live happily for ever after with the other side, but seem oblivious to their very real grievances. Except for that one guy. But no one mentions the land grabs, historical and ongoing. Having your people being continually pushed off their land and out of their homes would indeed be intolerable, to anyone.
I was quite surprised that Michael at 0:52 knew about how so many Jewish people were received with open hearts by the Palestinians in the past.
the jewish guy didnt mention that altho a lot of arabs accepted jews. most of the arabs in the british mandate really didnt.
I wonder how many of the men you interviewed personally shot a child in the head or heart with their sniper rifle, seeing as we have heard western doctor reports of daily child cases of sniper shots to the head and heart. What a society you have…
Agreed, it is sickening.
They were shot by Islamic Jihad, that is pretty obvious. They want children dead specifically so they can blame Israel. And you fell for it because you’re a naive fool. When will the world wake up to the dangers of radical Islam. Islamists are not victims. They are child killers and would do it to all non-Muslims if they could.
Anyone who understands what ethnic cleansing is, and refuses to give a yes or no answer to whether they support ethnic cleansing of a given peoole or population when asked by someone who is not obviously in favour of such ethnic cleansing, supports that ethnic cleansing. Maybe only in what they perceive to be particular circumstances that they think necessitate or justify it. But support all the same.
You are reaching. If you for once want to get a definitive answer to this question ask a palestinian. The majority would most probably simply say "Yes".
@@davidloveday8473 "The Ethnic Cleansing of Palestine"
- Book by Israeli writer Ilan Pappe
@hausofdownboots you're engaging in whataboutery, when I wasn't making a point exclusive to one group of people. What I said holds true of anyone who refuses to give a yes or no answer to this question, as a simple thought experiment shows. Take anyone who genuinely doesn't support ethnic cleansing of a particular group. Ask them if they support it. It is completely inconceivable they would say anything except "no", unless they had some reason to fear that doing so would put them in danger. As to your unrelated point, I don’t doubt there are *some* Palestinians who would refuse to give a yes/no answer if asked by a non-threatening person if they support ethnic cleansing of Jews. Just as there are *some* white Americans or white Europeans who would refuse to answer yes/no to whether they support ethnically cleansing Jews, Muslims, Black people, people of Asian decent, etc. And, as this video shows, *some* Jewish Israelis who refuse when asked by a non-threatening person to give a yes/no answer to whether they support ethnic cleansing of Palestinians. In all those cases I would say exactly the same thing: that person supports the ethnic cleansing in question. History tells us, to our cost, that there are supporters of ethnic cleansing in all communities. But the fact there are some doesn't mean most people in that community support it. This is blindingly obvious from a logical, evidentiary and epistemological perspective (some ≠ all).
@@davidloveday8473 His reaction is obviously because he's ok with it and you called him out on it
@@davidloveday8473 Not necessarily. It cud just be they are suspicious of the interviewer or his agenda, they thinknit might be a trap, or simply dont want to be on camera.
Actions speak louder than words, and their actions say otherwise.
And yet, they are also by far the most ethnically diverse country in the Middle East😁
@@mattclayer6541 yep so many white people claiming to have more ancestrial ties there than the people who's skintone actually matches the region
Of cause they are not going to admit to it on camera.
this is not a religious war. this is a colonial project
Nope..never going to aid developing an AI in doing what should be essential human interaction
Yeah seriously! What a dumb idea
The 🇮🇱surveys show that 70% of Israelis agree with the genocide in Gaza and some even think that it’s not enough 😂 the world has eyes
@@tatiana_saady And they protested about having the right to rape Palestinian prisoners
The "ps" surveys show that 72% of "palestinians" support with October 7th
You believe in everything that agrees with your opinion. The rest is Israel propaganda.
Bro got his facts from skibidi toilet😅
@@jubanvidoes347 channel 14 🇮🇱 you can call it whatever you wish 🤩
The Opposite is true.
This was really surprising to me. I've seen what people have said in similar interviews and the Israeli tv I've seen was horrific. I'm the kind of people who doesn't just evidence that doesn't fit what I already think but this is the opposite of everything else I've seen. Corey, does this fit what you've heard off camera?
Its not the opposite, as there's a lot of anger here in Israel towards gaza, esp after Israelies die.
However as a country and population we dont let that guide us, we're generally lawful and prefer to be left alone.
The gazans however do let it guide them on a national and operational level
@@einefes Thank you so much for replying. Would you mind watching this tv clip and helping me put this in context? Maybe this is the Israeli Fox News which would give people a skewed view of America. ua-cam.com/video/ex2c08g4zpM/v-deo.htmlsi=ESZ4sdc1duzIX-X_
Don't forget that for what you see in the media, including Israeli media, the purpose is to tell a narrative, either for a financial of a political purpose. Corey's purpose with this channel is to show people from around the world what real Israelis and Palestinians on the ground think.
@@einefes Oh shut up!!! The Gazans are suffering through a holocaust and not to mention 76 years of ethnic cleansing, and you expect them to not act defensively? Faulting an occupied people for reacting to being occupied is absurd. "We're generally lawful" lol exactly how lawful are the settlements in the West Bank??
@malinia.20 blah. Blah. Blah.
Dude, NOTHING you wrote is correct no matter how passionate you are about it.
No 76 years of occupation, no ethnic cleansing, certainly no holocaust. I dont even know how people come to a conclusion that these things are real, simply 0 evidence of any. You're like a freaking flat earther.
What I expect of them is to take responsibility for their actions of past and present, and choose a better life for themselves for the future.
Surprisingly,these answers give me hope
The ones who say everything was good up to 6 October shows us how self deluded, entitled and twisted thier view is. It’s actually part of the main problem.
@@hamidh9637 He meant to say it was a more manageable situation for everyone (including Hamas) than the current round of war.
Their fault is to be a Jew. To have peace with Hamas Israel has to get rid off the Jews.
Before October 6th if they'd come peacefully or just were peaceful In general. October 7th no one wants neighbours that say they want to do this every year again and again.
It's not self delusion or entitlement. But it is twisted. He's saying everything was fine, because a state if cease fire is the most peace Israel has ever had, so for most Israelis, as long as there is no active open warfare, it's fine. Because it's as much "fine" as they've ever known...
@@AndreyKrichevsky Like the guy that talked about realist questions. Some may theoretically support a Palestinian state, but know that the current situation is not a time to get that result *quickly* as some delluded commentators in the West seem to believe it is. If they don't talk about Palestinian statehood as much as outsiders do, it is because they feel it is not feasible within the timeframe of the next election in 2026.
What about radical judaism?
Only 1%
@hanidekel15 but they are committing genocide. So it does not matter 1 percent or 90 percent. Also Israel also stealing land from Palestine in west bank.
Talmudic and Kabbalahic Judaism
we don’t see radical judaism blow itself in crowded areas as they chant god is great don’t we?
what about it?
Sadly, they don't even hide it or even denied it too neither, anyway....., so..... 🤷🏼♀️
Neither did the Palestinians who said Israel shouldn't exist, when he asked them🤷
Most of them literally denied it.
@justinstewart4889
Not true 👎🏻. Or, at least, not convincing.... 🙄 😒
You are light 💫✨ i love you 💎❤
israel has 20% arab population. now its important to note that the arab population is the exact same as the palestinians. the only difference is, that those arab did not change their names to palestinians in the 60's.
palestinians are not an ethnic group, and if they are, then israelis are to be considered palestinian because ethnicity is based not on specific people but on the general coltures that lived in a certain area. and even if people dont agree with me, still a lot of israelis also have acestors that lived during the british mandate and that shouldnt be of any problem to call them palestinian ethnicly.
so the question is inherently confusing to ask because you cant reallly ethnicly cleans people if they arent an ethnicity.
Decades of violence and hatred had an unimagenable impact on all people on both sides.So questions like this after all of happend before are very inaccurate and it cant be answered honestly and without any bias on both sides.
Why are they so mad? I am enjoying my food and warm showers and well funded state, why do the Palestinians have so much anger? - Every blissfully unaware Israeli
Stay mad
@@viosh7137 Learn English. Then you'll under stand my comment properly.
@@allroundladcry cope and seeth
the palestinians get showers and aid from the UN. couse they are somehow refugees.
Doesn't matter what the people want. The fact is that's what their government is actively doing.
Wow so tell us when the Palestinians were founded? Their founding father. They are Arab invaders as real as the Easter bunny.
@@solvingpolitics3172 palestinians r descendants of original jews and xtian they just speak arabic does not mean they r from same grp as gulf arabs stop trying to smart or something.
The government is eradicating Hamas and Jihadists. Are you saying Palestinians are synonymous with those two groups?
Repeating a lie doent make it true
And what the government is actively doing is not ethnically cleansing anyone.
If they wanted to do that, Palestinians would have been forgotten from this earth a year ago.
Their opinions don't matter the truth is it's happening and therefore it makes them complicit in the action.
Well said
The truth is that since October 7, 2023, the births in Gaza have exceeded the war deaths. So, by definition, it is not ethnic cleansing - even if there have been many palestinian casualties from the war.
And no, the fact that they are Israeli would not make them complicit in what the IDF does. By that logic, all palestinians are complicit in the October 7th atrocities committed by their government. And I don't think you want to suggest that.
@@Taryag613 Danny the Israeli government said it was holding all the Palestinians responsible for Oct 7th and they have blockaded and starved the people there. That is why there are arrest warrants for those leaders.
Bombing every hospital, school, sewage, water etc is to make Gaza uninhabitable. We have viewed the IDF footage, boasting about it. GEN.O.CIDE
@Taryag613 and how would you know that? It couldn't be from the hospital records look at what's been done to them. You don't even know how many people have died who are you kidding?
@@jaspernewcomb5656 I never denied the number of Gazan casualties. I am taking Hamas's numbers at face value, and comparing that to the documented Gaza birth rate.
But here's one thing neither of us know because Hamas isn't telling us: How many of 40,000-45,000 gazan deaths are civilian and how many are combatants? How many of the palestinian civilians were killed by Israeli munitions and how many by Hamas munitions? How many of the civilians were killed in situations where they were in proximity to a legitimate military target? Without answers to these questions, neither of us know what is really going on...
I wish it wasn't do you want to ethnically cleanse the Palestinians and instead "Do you want to kick the Palestinians out of the West Bank" (or judea and sumeria whichever is less charged). It's the same question, but far less charged and you'll get more reprehensive answers I think.
Corey, maybe ask them "Do you think that harming Palestinians is OK"
I'm Israeli and can answer your question :) harming a Palestinian just because he is a Palestinian is wrong and most other israelis would agree with me.
@@Lily-sy5gz And the history of the state of Israel proves otherwise, as do the events transpiring today
@@Lily-sy5gz So why don't the most Israelis who think so have for decades allowed the state of Israel discriminate against the Palestinians?
@@Lily-sy5gz ua-cam.com/video/whLuMJZ2WwA/v-deo.html
@@teknomajik23 every country discriminate against the non citizens. Whats your country?
Why ask such a question, that will never be answered truthfully on camera.🤦
@RovexHD when Palestinians are asked they answer their truth. You don’t believe Israeli’s because it doesn’t fit your skewed narrative. You don’t know us!
Same question was asked to palestinians - the answers were a lot dofferent from those in this vidwo.
Meanwhile Palestinians happily say yes quite often. What's so different about these answerers you can't trust them? After a certain point, Jews can't answer either way to make you people happy.
@@justinstewart4889
Opinions on camera matter little when the government embodies lovely characters like Smotrich and gvir, elected by the people themselves.
@@RovexHDnuzlinz have no problem saying this on camera in arnabic.
They are proud of their 1400 years of ji had
The problem is the ideology from the 🌙📖.
I don’t understand why still people don’t want to understand 🤷♂️
Here’s an example:
Commentary on the quran (Tafseer)
(7)"You (true believers in Islamic Monotheism, and real followers of Prophet Muḥammad pbuh and his Sunna) are the best of peoples ever raised up for mankind..." (V.3:110).
Sahih al-Bukhari 4557
Narrated Abu Huraira:
The Verse:--"You (true Muslims) are the best of peoples ever raised up for mankind." means, the best of peoples for the people, as you bring them with chains on their necks till they embrace Islam.
Reference : Sahih al-Bukhari 4557
In-book reference : Book 65, Hadith 79
USC-MSA web (English) reference : Vol. 6, Book 60, Hadith 80
This is exactly right. When will the world wake up?
Your channel is a blessing! We need your interviews more than ever! My best regards from Amsterdam (I am still ashamed what happened to Israelie people here a couple of weeks ago).
Feel the love 💝🙏
Bless you
Are you not ashamed of what your government let the Israelis do in your city? A genocide supporter, aren't you?
Your work is a true "divine" in our small patch of land. Hopefuly it would not turn into a montage of how we lost ourselves
It is "proceed with ethnic cleansing" of an area or nation of a given population. Not "ethnically cleanse" the population. The term means to expel or eliminate a group of people defined by their ethnicity or religion.
great video
I'm a proud kahanist and I say yes. Just like how the muhammad ethnically cleansed the jewish tribes in Arabia.
@@LtGregoryStevens You do know Palestinians make up Christians, Athiests etc. as well as Muslims?
Is that why Israel 🇮🇱 wants to normalize relations with Saudi Arabia 🇸🇦? 😂😂😂….
@@zaidal-hindawi1784 אני רואה אותך בכל מקום ביוטיוב
@@LtGregoryStevens He didn't ethnically cleanse them, there were some Jewish tribes there did bad things against Muhammad pbuh. But he didn't ethnically cleanse them because you still had Jewish tribes in yemen that lived up until the 1950s. They had a treaty with eachother and lived in peace. But they sided with the pagans and even fought against their own Jewish brothers. So Allah gave the prophet the command to take care of them because of their actions, similair to how the prophet Elijah took care of the worshippers of Ashur and Baal. They did have an option to repent and to convert, but they refused. The Muslims never had the intention to do it, they brought it upon themselves by doing very bad things.
@@smrzgklol you guys always have excuses for your genocides 😂😂😂😂😂😂
Now ask the question to Palestinians in the West Bank if they feel they are being ethnically cleansed.
They are actually. Look up the data and see how many Palestinians have been killed by Israel OVERALL
Thanks
I have to take these answers with a grain-of-salt. It's one thing people say on camera, and another they say to each other off-camera.
Unfortunately, the elected officials of Israel and the US don’t have the best interest in of their citizens in mind. Our collective interest is peace but our leaders won’t allow it.
Question: do you confess on you tube that you support war crimes ?
Answer: no , of course not
Question: do you support the war crimes committed by you and your military?
Answer: Yes but I don’t call it war crimes I call it self defense.
Here I just summarized the episode.
Palestinians had no problem to do so
Summarized for biased people.
@@Levich1
A place where all religions living together has a name: PALESTINE 🇵🇸
A place where only one group can ethically cleanse everyone else has a name too it’s called ;
israel.
War crimes? What is your source, the UN? Remember the UN is very biased against Israel with majority Muslim country resolutions (if you want to call it resolutions) When you look into nearly all of the cases, Israel was simply protecting itself, whereas the UN has never once condemned the groups like Hamas for war crimes of teaching little children in all of the Palestinian schools to martyr themselves by killing Jews, using people as human shields, and on and on..
Also when it was estimated by Hamas that 30k Palestinians were killed (using their numbers that doesn't distinguish between civilians and Hamas members) there was about 26K buildings leveled by Israel in Gaza by a minimum of one bomb per building (an independent study from satellite images, you can look it up) From this ratio of around 1 to 3 bombs per building for every 1 person killed. Thats right, this means that Israel is terrible at killing civilians. It is clear that they are not only not targeting civilians but have done a much better job of not killing civilians than any country at war in history.
When a group of people are _accused of something,_ it is "fair" to give them an opportunity _to respond._
They are _accused_ of "ethnic cleansing," so, _yes,_ let them respond to that accusation.
The accusation is stupid. The question is not.
“Until October 7th everything was fine….”
The ignorance. Precisely why events like Oct 7th happen.
The power of 'hasbara'... But when the government is forbidding to share information contrary to hasbara, killing the journalists in Gaza, kicking out Al Jazeera, etc. etc., what can you expect? I believe that in this bubble, many truly believe that 'everything was fine' to some extent, before that day.
actually it wasn't, there was a terror attack each week in israel by the peaceful "palestinians" also couple of wars that hamas started like now
@@ehuddadian5500 Israel claim there was a ceasefire, yet you see they shot Palestinian protesters Oct 5th and bombed Gaza for 3 days straight Sept 23rd to 25th. Your hasbara lies will only fly on the ignorant
So its their fault ?
@@viosh7137 Do some independent research, listen to what anti zionists Israelis have to say and then google their claims
@5:30 love when he goes “before oct 7 everything was fine” .. lol!
Stop acting like an idiot and everything would be fine bud
It's easy to say no when you're the oppressors
" everything was ok before Oct 7" - hahahahahahahahahhahahahhahaha
"Amalek"
- Smotrich
@@The_Voice_of_Reason_is_here actually thats the thora ;)
You know yourself that you are being dishonest. What motivates you? Fear? Hatred?
@@MrJREllman have you read the thora thats just the word for the amalek people
Jews refer to anyone who wants to destroy them "Amalek". It's just another way of saying "they are our enemy." And is he wrong?
@@Taryag613 You've never heard Jews referring to anyone as 'Amalek'. You're just making stuff up, as usual. Hope you're enjoying your nasty fantasy.
So depressing. I am an old man in Sydney who did however once teach in an Orthodox Jewish school. I am not Jewish, but many of my classmates in Sydney in 1959 were, and for them of course the Holocaust directly or indirectly shadowed their growing up. Let me quote one of those classmates who, after spending some time in East Jerusalem, returned to Australia. In 1998 he gave a lecture -- he is a historian and social scientist of some note -- and in it he said: 'As new maps were drawn to reflect these newly created “facts on the ground” in Israel/Palestine, legitimization was incrementally given to processes for which the world has since coined the ominous and chillingly appropriate term “ethnic cleansing"".' So while I can empathise with these interviewees I can say I found many of these answers very depressing. Yes, I am an outsider, but I think my friend was right back then, and, as he is still alive and I am still in contact with him, I can tell you my friend, who is quite unwell at 81, has not changed his mind. Another of my 1959 Jewish classmates has gone so far as to support the Australia Palestine Advocacy Network. Myself -- I am a great admirer of what Daniel Barenboim and Edward Said attempted with the Divan Orchestra, and what the people in the Hand-in-Hand Schools are doing. Such are points of light in what to us seems a very dark place indeed. I also admire this Project, I must say.
To answer your question: No, Palestine was never established as an independent state before 1948. Before that time, it was part of the Ottoman Empire and later came under British rule as the Mandate of Palestine. In the years following the 1948 Arab-Israeli War that initiated by several arab countries Palestinians lived under Israeli, Jordanian, or Egyptian control, but no Palestinian state existed. While there have been efforts toward Palestinian statehood, especially after the 1967 Six-Day War initiated by arabs and the Oslo Accords, full Palestinian sovereignty has not yet been achieved. The issue of Palestinian statehood remains central to the ongoing Israeli-Palestinian conflict
Ah yes, the typical tokenism.
@@Ykrmnon Thanks. I do know the history very well. I am a retired History teacher.
@@neilwhitfield5026 Than why you divide Jerusalem into parts? As historian you should know better than us that by devision plan of UN in 1947 Jerusalem was claimed neutral territory neither Israel or Palestinian. Did UN demanded Jordan to withdraw from Jerusalem and pass control to UN during 1948-1967 occupation? After Israel freed Jerusalem this whole city is Israel and can't be by any means Palestine. They had never 1 ounce of rights for any part of this city
Says the guy living in Australia-the poster boy for ethnic cleansing
last question was translated wrong, the guys with says he wants to "expel" but not to kill them all....
its a bit different...
Say something and do the opposite..facts on land say they are really doing it. And the question should have precised that it’s about what is happening in Gaza
How many arnab is lanic countries were cleansed from j e ws ?
nobody will say outright yes to a word like think cleansing, better ask how they feel about the statement made like this one "If you gave me a button to just erase Gaza, every single living being in Gaza would no longer be living tomorrow. I would press it in a second"
The Two Nice Jewish Boys podcast
Because that podcast claims everybody agrees with that, so ask how people feel about that
That's really just a strawman argument dude, I won't deny the questions could be asked more aggressively but all you're doing is asking in a more convoluted and confusing manner. Please form better questions before making a comment like this.
They have that button.
@@krishnaveganathardo they use it?
Notice how they have to think about it
7:02
"Would you support the death penalty?"
Yeah. The Palestinians didn't blink an eye about saying Israel shouldn't exist when he asked them a similar question.
So critical thought deserves criticism? Maybe listen to their words and compare to the other team.
But I have black friends and work with black folks.
I don’t understand why this is an appropriate comparison. Did Black people attack white people en masse in an organized fashion? Did the Jews enslave the Arabs and import them from a foreign land against their will? Help me out here. I do believe there is a class element that people don’t talk about enough, but that’s about where the comparison dries up. It’s very thin, and is a total distraction from this very real and very different conflict. And frankly to me it cheapens and obscures the experience of Blacks in America, which is also very real and deserves its own serious analysis.
@thehocean It is appropriate. It speaks to how people can hold conflicting beliefs. The schism comes from the same place. Even though the specifics are different. Claiming friendship doesn't absolve you. You're reading a bit more into this than intended. It's not a point by point comparison. But it works.
@ I see your point and I appreciate the respectful reply. I have two issues with the comparison, one I outlined above and the other to this new point you are making- I think white people say that when they feel defensive and confused about the idea of holding latent racist beliefs. I think Israelis (and a thousand percent this is true on the other side too) are genuinely afraid for their safety. The guy on the laptop explained It. There’s no trust. And of course, Palestinians don’t trust Israelis. And maybe a third objection to this comparison is that it rubs me the wrong way that there is what seems to me to be an effort to sort of unite people against Israel by comparing (in my opinion misleadingly) the experience of other subjugated peoples to the plight of the Palestinians. It can get very antisemitic very quickly. The class thing is worth looking at, though, because it existed since the beginning of Zionism, and I think (I hope!) will ultimately be an important and productive conversation to have amongst Israeli/Arab society. May we all live to see peace and coexistence between these two peoples and all peoples. I’m an MLK fan myself :)
@thehocean I understand your concerns and respect them. They make a great deal of sense. These are murky waters. It's not my intention to be disrespectful, reductive or antisemitic. I appreciate your approach. I am tired of antisemitism being thrown out at times when it isn't present.(not insinuating you're doing this) I truly believe you can be against a country's government's actions without being against them as a people. For example. You can be against America's foreign policy without being anti white. Though I will admit that many struggle to separate these things. I am an MLK admirer as well as Malcom X. I'll mull over the points you made.
Dont be manipulative
You should have asked in a cleaner way. Something like : Do you want the land of Israel/State of Israel clean from Arabs/Palestinians. You would have received different answers. Of course it depends who you ask. From right wing Israelis you would probably get very positive answers to this question. If they were honest with you. Just to be fair it is also important to note that the Palestinian State in the 2-state solution is clean from Jews. Every Palestinian would tell you that including Abu Mazen their leader. That's their default & he's considered a 'moderate' Palestinian.