HITLER: THE ATHEIST (Quiz Show)
Вставка
- Опубліковано 1 жов 2024
- See below for footnotes.~~~ So here I go again, addressing the absurd claim that Nazi atrocities are inextricably linked to atheism. (Read on...)
---------------
website and blog: www.nonstampcol...
twitter: / nonstampnsc
BUY ME A COFFEE: www.buymeacoff....
PATREON: / nonstampcollector
-----------------
Maybe Hitler was indeed an atheist. I don't know. Who can? But given what he said on the subject throughout his whole life, I'd find that position pretty hard to defend. And what it had to do with his evil acts... well you get the idea of what I think of that argument.
Astute viewers will notice that throughout the movie I don't blame Hitler's actions upon his being a Christian. Indeed -- was he a Christian?! Some may differ with me on this, but I say No, he wasn't. Not in any practical sense of the label.
Saying his evil actions are linked to his status as a Christian either way would be as stupid as saying that they are linked to his moustache, or his atheism.
Indeed -- that's the point. Atheist or theist, Christian or Hindu, Catholic or Lutheran: none of it matters. HE WAS A NAZI: ISN'T THAT ENOUGH?
He was a frigging NAZI, with incredible political power that he'd achieved through shrewd statecraft over many years. Obviously THAT is the lethal combination. Not his moustache, not his vegetarianism, not his atheism/religion.
As close as I could come to linking religion with his actions was actually a portion of the script that didn't make it to the final cut, in which a description of totalitarianism is read out, the contestants are asked to identify what is being described, and it plays out that after all, totalitarianism and religion sound an awful lot like each other.
Initially I had intended to put the laugh segment last, but was afraid that the other sections might be too slow and boring to sit through, and people might leave before seeing all those fantastic quotes of Hitler talking about his love of the Creator etc. So -- if you think the vid goes downhill a bit after that, I kind of agree. It's just the best format I could come up with, and I tried them all, I think!
Great thanks to those who responded to my call for voice extras to carry out quite a task: recording themselves laughing their heads off for a full minute. The response was fantastic, and very very funny to listen to and mix.
Also, to those who helped me find videos of people claiming that Hitler was an atheist and did his evil in the name of atheism. **Especially OGJimbo.** The clip of Father Jonathon from FOX News I had in mind from the start. Fuck you, Fr. Jonathon.
And to the others featured in the ads (anyone who'd put themselves in front of a camera and declare that Hitler acted out of atheism deserves to be ridiculed. The ad breaks are my contribution to that ridicule.) : if you DMCA me for including your clips, despite their certainly coming under FAIR USE for criticism; I'll put the video file on mediafire and it will be mirrored on hundreds of channels within a few hours. Shoot yourselves in the foot if you really really want to.
FOOTNOTE 1: "I am ...a catholic...."
en.wikiquote.or...
FOOTNOTE 2: "God's will...":
Adolf Hitler, "Mein Kampf" Vol. 2 Chapter 10
FOOTNOTE 3: "my conduct..."
Adolph Hitler, _Mein Kampf_, pp. 46
FOOTNOTE 4: "God With Us":
McConnel, W 1998 "A Companion to the Nibelungenlied" Boydel & Brewer, New York, p.1
FOOTNOTE 5: "I pledge never to tie myself..."
The Speeches of Adolph Hitler, 1922-1939, Vol. 1 (London, Oxford University Press, 1942), pg. 871-872
FOOTNOTE 6: German Freethinkers' League
New York Times, May 14, 1933, page 2
FOOTNOTE 7: Pope Aggressive secularism: www.ft.com/cms/...
FOOTNOTE 8: Hitler's Birthday:
Stevenson, J 2006 "Hitler's Home Front" Hambledon Continuum, London, p.355
FOOTNOTE 9: Woman priest excommunicated: www.nytimes.com...
FOOTNOTE 10: Pedo priest www.theage.com....
FOOTNOTE 11: Abortion for raped 9 year old: www.msnbc.msn.c...
www.medicalnews...
FOOTNOTE 12: Concordat:
Cornwell, J. 1999 "Hitler's pope: the secret history of Pius XII" Pengiun pp6-7
and
Kreig, R. A. (2003) "The Vatican Concordat with Hitler's Reich" in America; the National Catholic Weekly, Sept 1, 2003
www.americamaga...
FOOTNOTE 13: The heaviest blow.... etc
en.wikipedia.or...
FOOTNOTE 14: 1 Sam 27:8-12, 1 Chron 18:5, 2 Sam 8:5, Numbers 31, Judges 12: 6, Judges 7-8
(Read on...)
---------------
website and blog: www.nonstampcol...
twitter: / nonstampnsc
-----------------
Even if he was atheist, he was also a vegetarian and a non smoker. So are those things inherently evil now?
Heh (now I'm defending a video I disagree with as far as underlying message) to play devil's advocate the point of the video was to make fun of the idea that Christians think all evil people are atheists.
@@Roescoe A small percent think that athieitist are evil, if most did you will see discrimination.
yes
healsolikeddogs
@@erules2534 I like dogs. With a little soy sauce.
Just use the good old Christian excuse: He wasn't a TRUE atheist...
Also "real Nazism has never been tried before."
@@Knightmessenger lmao
Militant Atheists say Communism is a Religion and The Communist's worshipped The State as a God. Thus The COmmunists were not "True Atheists". Christians dont use the No True Christian Fallacy anywhere near as often as Atheists do. Just like Christians don't really say God Works in Mysterious Ways as an Argument, even though this is said by Atheists to be one of the most common Arguments You hear from Christains. its not. You won't find it on any Christian Site. The Phrase sure, but not as an Argument. No Apologist uses it.
@@skwills1629 just like the atheists saying christian magic thing as strawman
you are strawmanning atheists
@@lesscringeymapperdude - No, Im not. And tryign to say You are just as bad to deflect doens't mitigate the Cnern. Atheists like this Strawman Christianity to much.
“Have you read mein kampf?”
*slams it on the table*
Idk have you? Cuz he talks a lot about what he’s doing is God’s work
s a r c a s m
Yes, they probably read it and I wouldn't be surprised if they held it as a higher book then the bible.
Republican / right-wing christian is an oxymoron anyway. Jesus hated rich people.
Robert Coxswain its thought that a jew denied him for the art institute he wanted to go to which stemmed the beginning of his hatred for jews.
"So you're read Mein Kampf? A big fan of Hitler, are you? Wow."
You've got to admire that question. There's so delightfully no right answer. Say "no" and you shouldn't be listened to because you don't know what you're talking about. Say "yes" and you shouldn't be listened to because you're morally compromised - not only is admitting to reading "Mein Kampf" almost like admitting you're a nazi, but as a bonus puts you in a position of having to go "I've read Hitler's book and you've got him all wrong!"
I literally had this exact talk with my mom the other day, I said “hitler was bad because he killed millions right” she said yes, and then I said “and God is good for killing all those people in the Bible?” And she said “you don’t understand the Bible you need to go to bible school”
Ask her why Moses, after giving the commandment "Thou Shalt Not Kill" told God's people to kill their brother, friend and neighbor, claiming it was what God said.
"26 So Moses stood at the entrance to the camp and said, “Whoever is for the LORD, come to me.” And all the Levites gathered around him. 27 He told them, “This is what the LORD, the God of Israel, says: ‘Each of you men is to fasten his sword to his side, go back and forth through the camp from gate to gate, and slay his brother, his friend, and his neighbor.’” 28 The Levites did as Moses commanded, and that day about three thousand of the people fell dead."
Exodus 32 : 26-28 Biblehub . com
(10 Commandments: Exodus chapter 20)
@@wownewstome6123 funny. I was confirmed catholic and i never remember going over that part. I wonder why...
@@Knightmessenger haha, I'm Anglican or was rather and I also don't remember them using this verse in church to talk about how gwad will grant you a Mercedes Benz, a job, a hot wife and a luxurious life. I thought the Bible was applicable to every day life lol...
The bilical god is as good as hitler? I think hitler was lacking in the genocide department, nice try tho
You do need actually
Perhaps you ought to watch the video and try to get the point it's making. With your sarcasm detector turned on, you'll notice that it's making the point that you're attempting to make. I dare say, in fact, that the video does a better job, but then I do have a bias towards proper punctuation.
Ummmm what? hahaha. Of course it was linked to atheism. Nothing is more pathetic than an atheist that tries to defend nothing
@@hayteren in an atheist perspective, religious people are the ones defending nothing lol.
Please make more videos. They are just...so enjoyable. Im late to the party, but this is great stuff
@RadioTSM {Operator Teddy Timis} I can't understand what you said...
@RadioTSM {Operator Teddy Timis} Really. Now.
It's really strange how many people in the English speaking world believe that Hitler was an atheist. In Germany no educated person would assume this. It's pretty clear that he believed in a superior power. He frequently employed supernatural lingo in his speaches. Just learn German, you Amis! :-P
In America the Catholic church is powerful enough to influence what is taught in history classes. Plus most Americans are Christians and they have that fantasy that they are better and would never do commit such atrocities. (They forgot what happened to the native indians)
Actually, we were never taught about this in Austria. They actually highlighted the pope's opposition to facism.
I mean... It seems like it, but that doesn't have to be the case, he might have used religion as a tool to gain power
@@random6033 as another comment so wonderfully pointed out, let's suppose that he was an atheist despite the fact that he wasn't, and that he was only using religion to gain power.
Now, what does that say about the religion, if he could use it to justify genocide?
@@fluffynator6222 The Pope backed up the Croatian Fascist regime and helped its leaders escape justice after war's end
I thought the "trick question" on "scientific theory" was very creative. Also, if you quote Hitler "I believe in God," you would probably get the same old "That's out of context!"
nope, you would get my "that doesn't make him a Christian at all" :)
All the historical evidence suggests, that he was indeed a confessing catholic. On what basis do you make the claim, that he isn't a "true" christian? Can you read the minds of dead people?
that first, most catholics aren't Cristians^^ second, that his acts were simply completely opposite to those of a Christian :)
renounce to your multi fiber clothes, you filthy pagan!!!!
Sell all you have and give it to the poor, you not-really-christian-because-your-actions-speak-otherwise.
+ppaaccoojrf: I agree, Albert Einstein was perhaps a deist in the same sense as Carl Sagan (clearly there are laws of nature). In a letter to a friend Einstein wrote, "From the viewpoint of a Jesuit priest I am, and have always been an atheist."
I had an old friend who was a very religious claim that Hitler was not a Christian or even an Athiest but a Satanist. The fact that certain people will do anything to paint the "other side" in a bad light and ignore all historical accounts or evidence to glorify their Religion and reinforce their bias that their side can never be wrong always infuriated me. I wish I knew about this video during that time so I could show it to him.
Did satanism even exist back then lol
Satanism isn't even a bad religion, it not got much at all to do with Satan. From what I've heard, it's all about us being the gods of our lives. The name is misleading
@@guineapiglads4786 thats laveyan satanism. The real satanism is pretty horrible, some are nazi terrorist groups.
@@jamesclark976 Hitler Pretended To Believe In GOD So That Christians Would Vote For Him, He Then Proceeded To Kill Millions Of Christians,
Such A Person Is Called The AntiChrist So Hitler Was Definitely A Satanist.
So you disagree with putting Hitler in a bad light. 🤨
4:13
Clearly you haven't!
I bet he practiced that line and the slamming of the book on the table before filming instead of reading it haha
jep
It's obvious that this isn't what causes people to be evil monsters. After all, Hitler, Mao, Stalin, Pol Pot all had dark hair, so there ya go, it's because of dark hair.
Jonathan Allard
My uncle had dark hair and he’s in jail for assault. Coincidence? I think not
In the novel "A Midnight Clear" by William Wharton, set in WW2, a devout Catholic US soldier (who dropped out of a seminary) accuses another soldier of spouting atheism and suggests perhaps he should be on the Nazi side. The other soldier retorts that they have captured German soldiers who had breviaries and missals, and the Germans were the ones who had "Gott mit uns" on their belt buckles.
Funny no one talks about King Leopold II of Belgium, who was a Catholic, and more than 10 million Congolese died indirectly from his rule, cruel slavery and starving the people to death so often. Why doesn't anyone talk about this?
“Not real Christians”
Because it is an invonvinient truth, just like Hitler being a Catholic, Stalin being brought up as an Orthodox-Christian priest and Pol Pots being brought up as a Buddhist.
Because the world doesn't care about millions of black people dying.
Obviously because Belgium doesn't exist, so Leopold II is a made up being like unicorns, the tooth fairy and YAHWEH.
As a more serious answer, Belgium has sadly been able to largely sweep the atrocities of it's king under the rug thanks to it's political status and due to people in third world countries having been seen as inferior for the longest time.
Hitler ended up on the losing side of a war, so it was much easier for the victors of the second world war to paint him in a bad light.
Because they are black people and those don't count.
king of sarcasm....subscribed
Hah! Not even close. More like village idiot.
David huh?
David okay buddy
@BoomerLemon Only if you ignore the fact that he left the Catholic faith and espoused "Positive Christianity," a version of Christianity that basically claimed that Jesus and all the disciples and apostles were German, except of course for Judas Iscariot, who was naturally made out to be Jewish (naturally he would insist the person who turned on Christ was Jewish to further his anti-Semitic propaganda).
“Driven by a radical Atheism”
Says all you need to hear really. How exactly does a person be ‘radically’ unconvinced by a proposition?
I mean I suppose one could out of his own lacke of believe become to annoyed by people with believe that you try to use violence, legislation and bulling to get everyone else to also ether lose there believe or become so suppressed that with in a few generation the believe died out.
I'm not saying that's what Atheist do (I mean I am even one my self)I just say humans can become radical over just about everything.
I'm a radical a strologist
@@rynobehnke8289 I believe the only two political powers who did that were The union of Soviet Socialist republics and the people's republic of china, I believe they target and targeted theist with policy and violent action
So it exists
when the hitler thing comes up i usually just say to christians. "You have a bigger chance of meeting hitler in heaven than i have." They look at me suprised and i just say casually "because im atheist and he was a catholic and all of his sins are forgiven." I like to think that the times when i say that it makes them maybe think about what they actually believe and just maybe get some small critical thinking.
@benji X Didnt know that about ted bundy. Might use that aswell thank you. And what justice would it be for any christian victims of bundy to meet him again in heaven? I mean the whole thing is silly and i hope that someday (Probably not in our lifetimes) we have moved on from religions. Where science and reason and understanding and being okay with not knowing everything but still working to find it out is the norm.
Hitler Is In Hell.
@@Dark_Force_Of_Wishes How can you know that? Have a direct line to some deity?
@@Dark_Force_Of_Wishes dude, if he confessed his sins and let Jesus into his heart he went to heaven, his other actions do not matter
@@angelman906 Hitler Is In Hell, He Was An AntiTheist And He Killed Millions Of Jews, Christians And Muslims.
lol at the part of "did you read mein kampf?" Slam
Do some people actually think Hitler was an atheist? I've never heard that claim, except in rhetorical videos like this one.
Can't have done much research then. Can't have read The God Delusion very carefully, either.
What the hell youre still here?
I live in Germany and I can assure you: Devout christians ALWAYS come up with the myth of Hitler and the nazis were atheists. Right after the collapse of the 3rd Reich - only a few days later - the catholic church began to install this myth by preaching against the "godless" nazis, while they were helping nazi officers to escape justice -->google "ratlines"
The churches do it until today. They call the ISIS terrorists "godless", too. So they basically claim, that ISIS is an atheist organization.
Yes, sadly, a lot of people.
Christian argument, "without God we would have no morality. Look at Hitler!"
The scrolling of quotes from Mein Kompf while the characters are laughing is actually disturbing as fuck. It's eerie and troubling because of how shockingly real the hypocrisy is.
It was eerie-- disturbing and troubling-- at first for me, as well. I also found it a bit funny, from the absurdity of the hypocrisy. I mean, these could very well represent real people, but the views themselves, of those people, are absurd. Goes to show the great procrustean power of undiversified discussion. But, when there's little can be done to ameliorate that on its face, maybe it's better to laugh. I don't know
People can be a monster whether they believe in god or not. It does not matter whether Hitler believed in god. That being said, paraphrasing from Richard Dawkins-
A belief in a higher power has a logical progression to violence (not that it does in every case of course, stay with me). If one believes a creator of the universe, an all powerful lord, and follows a religious interpretation of that deity, they are more likely to commit atrocities than someone who does not hold that a belief. For example, extremist do not wake up everyday saying, "What can I do to spread evil today?" Most believe that the horrible things they do are holy/just and they will be rewarded by "god" in the afterlife. There is no progression from an atheist world view to that state of mind.
That being said, evil and cruelty is everywhere. I wish we would set aside our petty religions and insatiable hunger for power and just fucking leave together in peace. Can we all do that? No..? OK.
Well said you summed it up beautifully. I
No it doesn’t matter. What DOES matter is how Christians try to hide his beliefs so they don’t have to accept credit for yet another mass murder. As if the crusades, Spanish Inquisition, and Salem witch trials weren’t enough.
@@conundrum60690 Your trying say that if a man committes atotricies that their belief system should be blamed of the mans crimes?Or am I not understanding you?
@@Wartenss A man didn't commit these atrocities. These were organized actions OF the religion.
@@conundrum60690 No,A man that committed atrocities is the one to blame. In this case that's Hitler,if you want to blame a man's religion of their action I could do that for atheism.I can blame 100 million+ deaths committed by atheistic and anti theism governments on atheism.Millions of deaths under the reign of Mao Zedong and Joseph Stalin can be blamed on atheism.
In the name of the lack of belief in god 😂
L0gical ATHEIST
Ikr?
L0gical ATHEIST in the name of the lack of belief in God, atheist communists murdered 60 million Russians, 40 million Chinese, 6 million Ukrainians, 2 million Cambodians, 1.5 million Poles, 1 million Ethiopians, and millions more Eastern Europeans, Africans, Asians and Latin Americans
@@realitywins9020 To spread atheism or spread communism? I'm edging towards the second.
@@realitywins9020 And those atheist commies did it all just so they could eat their babies!!
@@realitywins9020 Pray that Moses gets access to the same weapons and you would get the end of humanity. Oh and some other things you probably heard about: the crusades, the KKK, slavery (justified by the bible), rape (justified by the bible), murder in recent years in the usa (justified by the bible and constitution), murder in the bible, Anton Pavlic, the whitchhunts, the entire reign of the Ludwig's in France; causing millions of deaths, the entire dark ages; over a billion deaths due to Christians, etc.
But hey, that doesn't count, because they were not really christian!
I'd like to see Hitler's references to god after he had a firm grip on power. Being the natural skeptic that I am, I've always believed his references to god during his rise was meant to appeal to the population and aren't truly reflective of his belief in god. After all, nothing has proven to be more effective to justify extreme actions and genocide than appeal to the divine. He's just following the historical how-to manual on genocide. It seemed to me that after he got power, he used less divine rhetoric.
Also, I think it's worth pointing out that to prop up Hitler, Ho Chi Min, Stalin, Richard Dawkins (yes, I actually saw these guys grouped together in a meme) as morality-starved atheist leaders, you need to ignore every other war, leader, "christ-chosen" king, etc. throughout history.
+Chris O:
I am now as before a Catholic and will always remain so.
- Adolf Hitler, to General Gerhard Engel, 1941
"Also, I think it's worth pointing out that to prop up Hitler, Ho Chi Min, Stalin, Richard Dawkins (yes, I actually saw these guys grouped together in a meme) as morality-starved atheist leaders, you need to ignore every other war, leader, "christ-chosen" king, etc. throughout history. "
==That's how wars are fought sometimes. When there is no physical violence, they use words.
Oh for the love of God I'm just gonna come out and say it, it didn't matter if these tyrants believed in god or not, it doesn't erase or worsen the fact that these were militaristic monsters.
+Giorno Giovana
So you're saying that it had more to do with their Nazism? Revolutionary concept!!
NonStampCollector
Second time you replied to me, I feel lucky
+NonStampCollector it did
Well it's more about the fact that christian use hitler 'belief' as proof that atheism lead to mass murder
Gio gio
People, Hitler did believe in God, just admit it. Doesn’t make anyone who believes in God any worse of a person as those were Hitler’s actions
"His actions in the name of his god."
You seem to not have included that part, how come not?
Idk why but I lost it when one of the contestants shouted "THE MAGIC SANDWICH?"😂
let's all send this to bill o'reilly
I don't always drink beer, but when I do,
its usually with my mouth.
"usually"
@@cinnamonperoxide2161 cause enimas seem to disturb the other transit riders
lol
Any resemblance to a modern political party in the USA is pure coincidence….
Well, seeing as we ALL KNOW Hitler was definitely an Atheist Vegan Cyborg, that automatically makes those things bad...
Logic applied ;D
burrhe 🖖 that is logical
Don't forget
He also liked dogs
He also liked movies
Are movies evil now?
And he had a mustache, so anyone with a mustache must be evil!
I laughed during whole vid! Thanks guys for making these lol
How do you make such round circles?
braddockakalatis2 With the circle tool.
NonStampCollector So are you going to do the sketch where the guy is going to get a vasectomy to protect his kids from hell? Matthew 7:13-14?
Yes. I will use the circle tool to draw his now defunct testicles.
NonStampCollector God bless you.
braddockakalatis2
No, not "God bless you"... We say "Dog bless you".
I saw in a documentary where Stalin had confession with a priest twice while he was ruler. I've not been able to find that anywhere else and don't remember the documentary. I think it was the son of the priest that told the story, but I might have it wrong. But I do remember he'd had confession a time or two.
This video deserves a massive audience. The humour is first class and is delivered in a style that undermines its ostensible foundation. Masterfull indeed.
Youre right (9 years later)
I was very shocked, even as a forever non-christian, at the citations referencing reasons for excommunications (9, 10, 11). Even though this was a system I never believed in I had at least some modicum of faith in their ability to govern themselves humanely. So I made sure to check each of the sources to confirm their points. I noticed that the source for 11 leads me to a page that no longer contains an article. I know it has been a long time since you made this video and there are many reasons that it could no longer be there, but if anyone has a link to the intended article I would appreciate it. The very idea of that topic scares and disgusts me, and I feel that it is something I need to see if it still exists. Thank you.
Mein Kampf quotes Martin Luther and New testament.
Htlr said publicly Germany was a Christian nation..
He was NOT an atheist..
He attended ' passion plays ' and met with Lutheran bishops praised by church leaders .
He had gold coins minted with Luther.
Do you research more carefully.
Yes because he wanted to maximise his chance of winning upcoming elections. No surprise he never said those things once the Nazi dictatorship was in place.
@@sarfcowst except after he was elected the Protestant bishops of Germany and the Pope praised him..
Krystal Nacht occurred on Luther's birthday.
The third reich minted gold coins with Luther.
Majority of nazi high command were church going Christian s during ww2 and Holocaust.
@@MitzvosGolem1 People praising you doesn't make you a believer. So if I praise you will other people conclude that you concede to me? Actions speak louder than words! You're also mixing up the Nazi ministerial council (which had no believers in it) with Army High Command that was officers and not all nazis. Most importantly Nazis after the war all said Hitler personally despised Christianity. They outweigh anything this video poster tries to insinuate.
I'd forgotten how fun & witty your videos are! Spending too much time on other atheist channels. Thank you.
I see a lot of people in the comments don't get that this is sarcasm.
Let me clarify:
Hitler was a catholic. Murdered millions.
Stalin was an atheist. Murdered millions.
Hence, religion or lack of one does not mean that a person would be driven to murder. That's my logic. I'm sorry if my english was too barbaric for internet.
"In boundless love as a Christian and as a man I read through the passage which tells us how the Lord at last rose in His might and seized the scourge to drive out of the Temple the brood of vipers and adders. How terrific was His fight for the world against the Jewish poison. Today, after two thousand years, with deepest emotion I recognize more profoundly than ever before the fact that it was for this that He had to shed His blood upon the Cross."
-Adolph Hitler
I fucking love this
This kind of parody does nothing for me anymore.
Sure it was well thought out and entertaining as always; but the christians and other theists are are so consummate in their ignorance, this depiction _actually_ does them an order of justice, as their actual claims get FAR more ridiculous than this, and entirely *impossible* to actually satirise.
This video is a colossal understatement of the truth and depicts devout theists to be smarter than in actual reality.
You're a smug fuck, just like the Christians are. When you walk down the street do you see meaningless consumerist fat swine herding themselves into the NE-VR save or do you see actual human beings? Is society now so far beneath your conscious level of thought that Atlas should shrug and you should be named King?
"meaningless consumerist fat swine herding themselves into the NE-VR save" is the correct answer. Though, I don't understand what your objectivist rhetoric has to do with anything.
Poe's Law.
Postghost without theism, you have no basis for morals, intelligence or life itself. You're literally just a walking sack of excrement!
Postghost and you're far more ignorant than the theists you criticize! How many PhDs do you have? seeing as you think you're so smart! Your smugness and arrogance is pathetic!
“Iam doing gods work”
~Hitler
Yeah... He did YHWH's work
@@D-Realitymy dyslexic ahh read that as YMCA.
The satire is great with this one
Fuck yeah papa tuanuku! Shot for the Maori reference
Wow, not so high intellectual satire NSC, Im afraid the fundamentalists wont understand any of that xD
8:50 bottom left, that's a 617 Sqn Avro Lancaster dropping a bouncing bomb as used in Operation Chastise to break the Ruhr dams.
Funny never in my life did I think he was an atheist. I just didn’t know what religion he was until today.
Religion? RELIGION???
Well.. he started out Catholic... but he was trying to forge a "state religion" which mirrored his racism... so many of his senior people were dabbling in the pagan/occult... as they tried to use Religion to crown the Fuher as king of the world.... and all the non-aryans as... well... people who need to die. *Shrugs*
There is no doubt that he was, for the vast majority of his life, Christian though! At the end of it... he might have changed... but... we don't know for sure.
Brilliant! So clever. Intelligent and well researched. Oh...and funny.
''Newton caused Nazism'' lol that was hilarious! I love these videos. I've just found them and they're awesome!
0:25 Kind of want to see a quiz show for the other categories lol
Good work, after a few videos, I'm convinced your work deserves far more recognition.
I think like the modern preachers of today Hitler knew invoking Gods name could get people to obey him. Using religion as a tool is what some intelligent authoritarians do.
Kit Eizenga If people are willing to follow a false leader because he claims to invoke god, it says more about theism than atheism.
A very good point. We're not defined by those systems we reject, but by those we accept. A Christian theist, as example, is not defined by his lack of belief in Krishna. I've been an atheist for a long time, but it never compelled me to action. In those instances where I was compelled to action, it was usually because of humanism.
Whenever there is a bad religious person I tell to a religious person I know, they just say ,,well they weren't really religious then"(to say that not only non christians can be bad people).. guess I'll also say ,,well they weren't a true atheist" then to a horrible person who is an atheist.
I get that it’s not the point of the video, and I understand that your positions may have changed, but I tend to dislike the “Stalin and Mao being mass murderers” thing. I’d argue that most deaths under communist regimes are more complicated than murder. If you haven’t changed your mind on the subject that’s fine, and I doubt I’ll be able to convince you in a UA-cam comment, but I figured it not a waste to mention. Love your videos.
I saw this a few years ago and it made me laugh because of its witt. Seeing it today, its genius.
This guy is a genius!
Didn't the Nazi belt buckles say something like "Under God"? And didn't Hitler believe the whole "master race" thing was God's work? I'm not saying Hitler was a proper Christian but it seems he used Christianity (or monotheism for most other dictators) to accomplish his goals.
or maybe watch the video please, and listen to what it has to say about what Hitler's Wrote in Mein Kampf. Because if you're asking the Belt Buckle thing (which was pointed out in the video, so you wouldn't have to ask the question) then you obviously haven't watched it, so please, before commenting, watch the video fully, Then comment.
The actual words was "Gott mit uns", which is directly translated into "God with us".
People who deny facts make me sick. Christians in this case must know they are wrong but keep going on saying the same shit.
This guy has a very pleasant speaking voice. He should do radio, if people are still doing that.
Someone definitely pointed it out already but i love how the contestants are named after Stalin and Mussolini
Man I love this guy, from pointing flaws in the Bible and making people smarter with this kind of stuff... well, open minded people
Did you know Hitler had a dog? Do you own a dog? I mean, that’s pretty antisemitic if you ask me.
Lovely. Hate theism, hate conservatism.
My favourite part about this and a joke that might get unnoticed: Sir Isaac Newton was as well a christian, lmao.
Dude belived God caused gravity
Baptised. Raised Catholic. Placed "God is with us" on each Nozi's belt buckle.
Also...
"As a Christian I have no duty to allow myself to be cheated, but I have the duty to be a fighter for truth and justice."
They’ll do this about President jackass in 10 years. He doesn’t just act like he’s godly. He acts like he’s a god.
MyQueenFreddyMercury because he is.
Good video. The problem is that this is humor for atheists only. A christian is too stupid to understand it so this video won't show them how they're wrong. But nevertheless, it made me laugh-
What makes me laugh is that you think any christian would watch this video all the way. Oh you poor naive child, that would actually require one to think for themselves.
LOL, right sure. That must explain why the most educated and higher IQed countries in the world are the most atheistic ones as well.
+Vote for what Why In contrast, here's an article which discusses a meta-analysis of 63 studies which finds a negative correlation between religiosity and IQ is much more common. Studies showing a strong negative correlation are about eighteen times more common than studies showing a strong positive correlation.
www.independent.co.uk/news/science/religious-people-are-less-intelligent-than-atheists-according-to-analysis-of-scores-of-scientific-8758046.html
+Vote for what Why ... A cursory Google search returns absolutely nothing on such a poll. It also doesn't recognize "Farsworth" and recommends "Farnsworth" instead. The only poll found conducted by "Farnsworth" was a fairly dubious presidential poll about mid-last year, and then they just vanish.
On top of that, the act of vetting participants to ensure "equal numbers" of each group would skew results. Proper polls are blind, to ensure as close to a representative sample as possible.
Please link your source on this poll, so it can be scrutinized.
I watched the video all the way through.
Shout out to Paptuanuku :D
A truly underrated deity.
+NonStampCollector love your content
"He was quite likely either a Deist"
"on a mission ~ chosen by a higher fate or something"
These two statements conflict. Hitler was no deist. Deists don't claim to work for god. Doing so = the antithesis of deism.
de·ism [dee-iz-uhm] noun
1.belief in the existence of a God on the evidence of reason and nature only, with REJECTION OF SUPERNATURAL REVELATION (distinguished from theism).
'my conduct is in accordance with the will of the Almighty Creator.'
- Adolf Hitler, Mein Kampf, Vol. 1
How is something done in the name of atheism?
With stick figures, apparently
These are brilliant. Very clever.
Put aside whether or not Hitler was a Christian. His plans were carried out by millions of ordinary Germans who were overwhelmingly Catholic or Protestant. Try has hard as you want to relabel Hitler as an atheist, it is impossible to do so for the people who carried out the genocide.
now make a video saying, "Was Stalin a Christian." that should really spice things up
Marco Eribes
Stalin was a good Christian boy who did nothing wrong
Stalin was Eastern Orthodox
This one isn’t true Stalin was an atheist. Hitler obviously wasn’t one, but Stalin was definitely one
This is so educational! Love it!
"Have you read Mein Kampf?" Have you?
One of Hitler's paintings is called Mother Mary with the Holy Child Jesus Christ.
And here it is:
en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Paintings_by_Adolf_Hitler#/media/File:HitlerMaryWithJesus.jpg
5:00 wow, now that's really heavy.
Gott mit uns... is what the belt buckle said. God with us
The 6 minute mark had me laughing out loud uncontrollably. Awesome video!
I don't understand the Hitler being an atheist. Regardless of whether it's true... so what? If Hitler was an atheist, then good for him, how would that ever affect any other atheists around the world, EVER?
I just don't see why it matters either way. If he was atheist it means nothing about other atheists, same with Christians. Not all are purely good or bad.
Exactly, and yet Christians try to distance themselves from Hitler against that very reason, as if "Hitler was an atheist" is undeniable evidence to support that godless atheists are simply evil. But obviously, such an evil man couldn't possibly be a part of our ~peaceful~ (read: genocidal) religion.
It's just that Hitler is so hated (understandably), that neither christians nor atheists want him on their team so they keep passing him to one another
They both be like -No you take him. -No you take him.
I can feel the sarcasm leaking from my monitor lmao
Christian: HAVE YOU READ MEIN KAMPF!
Me: Yes I have. It's surprisingly similar to the best selling fiction book, the Bible.
Quick clarification. I haven't actually read Mein Kampf, but I have read more of the Bible then Christians.
I'm almost tempted to tell you to keep your nose out of the Christians business but I don't want any unforgivable curses used upon me XD
I've read The Bible and Mein Kampf, cover-to-cover, and can honestly say they both sucked. Easily Top-3 in "most difficult to finish" category out of the thousands of books I've read.
@@proculusjulius7035 good.
@@hewhomustnotbenamed5912 I made that comment six months ago, where have you been my lord? 😂
@@proculusjulius7035 I was notified by that other person's new comment.
The point of these videos is not to make fun of all religious people, it’s just to make fun of specific groups of beliefs that directly contradict large quantities of evidence.
To any theists arguing that this doesn't matter, and that Hitler's religious views didn't reflect Christianity as a whole... You're right. Completely. He could've believed in Unicorns and it wouldn't have changed what happened. Radical anything is typically bad, so don't use hitler as an argument against endorsing atheism. Or anything, other than genocide.
+Nathan Deaton "Radical anything is typically bad" ... Except Atheism. I don't how you can have too much reason. There's no scripture for atheism commanding its followers to put an end to all religion. We're literally just a band of people who reject these ridiculous hypotheses and would like to educate religion out of society.
I know this isn't the main topic but the word unicorn in the king James version of the bible refers to rhinos it is an old book and words change.
Yes, people should be very careful when looking at event such as this to suddenly come to the conclusion that it was one causal factor which makes a person evil.
glad someone took the time to pull all this together.. well done
Excellent research. Well done!! 👏👏
God damn, this is still fresh as the day it was made.
im not an atheist, im a monotheist, but i believe it is the most spiritual thing to search for truth and to think deeply and critically about where we learn "the truth" from, especially religious institutions and scripture which have been used as a tool to abuse and oppress others each and every time a prophet left. Know the lies intimately and reject them openly.
I might not believe in God, but those who believe in God might not understand the sarcasm in this one.
You'd have to be a fucking idiot to not understand that this is sarcasm.. oh wait, we're talking about Christians here, sorry you're right, carry on.
@@Zeppelin616 So true.
you deserve more subs really, brilliant channel
Before watching this I'd heard mixed things about Hitler's spirituality. Great video!
X D Great video my balls .
So tell me how many bible verses talk about Aryan master race .
Fucking idiot .
Com on can you idiot's even read yet .
I don't think that you guys can you selfs even hardcore skeptic when you lag the ability to read even basic English yet .
@@lildms3691 Bad day?
@@jacoblinde7486 do you know how to fact check .
Or is relaing on believe only .
Also Hitler has nothing on mao and Stalin who are athiest who in total killed over 80 million religious people .
Or are you a holucost dynier.
Also I am not having a bad day when I can call out NPC progressive like you to bad that burny don't give refunds when he fails .
@@lildms3691 I just said that I liked the video. Calm down.
I never really thought about Hitler Following a religion before this and I always kind of assumed in the back of my mind that his religion consisted of "Jews bad, Racism", but I guess not.
his religion did consist of "Jews bad, Racism" actually. he was a christian after all.
Thank you so much for your videos
But Hitler WAS. an atheist.
….wait…
…my wife said I made a typo. Asshoke. Hitler was an asshoke.
…wait…
….I accidentally used a k instead of a l…but to be fair; UA-cam would delete my comment had I not done that typo.
You're allowed to say asshole
Look, religious people, fuck, fucker, are fuckedy fucking assholes
Does that mean... hitler went to heaven? Wtf I’ll gladly go to hell
@@somenameidk5278 it depends on what sect but in a lot of them it’s totally fine to commit suicide as long as you’re saved
Hitler Is In Hell
J
E
W
www.polityka.pl/galerie/1505482,5,gruzy-na-szczycie---galeria.read In fact this is a photo of the abbot being evacuated, with a German general helping him into the car.
1:44ff - The words "God With Us" were traditionally on the belts of the Prussian army since 1847 and later the German Reichswehr since 1871 and all throughout the Weimar Republic, and the Bundeswehr even continued to use these words as well after WW2 all the way until 1962. This was just the Nazis keeping what was already there. Of course Hitler wasn't an atheist, but this piece of "evidence" for his theism is bad.
I mean he did change the uniforms used from ww1 to ww2 SO if he didnt like the phrase, I think he had enough power to change it😂
@@nekhrunoblivion Fair, I guess. I'm just saying the origin of these is a Prussian-German tradition, not Hitler's theism.
I read a rather large book which devoted a large portion to Hitler. Apparently he said whatever he needed to whoever just to get what he wanted. He had no problem going back on his word which he did after swearing he wouldn't on so many occasions. You just couldn't believe anything he said. Its hard to say exactly WHAT he believed.
I have no way of accessing that book, or knowing if it is even credible. I, however, will shut my eyes and put blind faith that you are telling the truth and have a completely valid claim.
@@duckfacemcgee3271 William Shirer. The Rise and Fall of the 3rd Reich.
Why would you respond to an 11 year old comment and expect someone to actually cite it? Fortunately for you it is still sitting on my shelf.
@@aworldwithoutsin6384 Thanks for the information. Also, yeah I wasn't actually expecting an answer, let alone an answer this quick.
@@duckfacemcgee3271 You were correct to point out my statement erring in logic. At that time I had not studied any logic. I still get triggered easily sometimes. A side effect of my Christian upbringing
I am also here to respond to an 11 year old comment
This video has aged poorly. Nowadays even gravity isn't considered real anymore.
I know, right? I dropped a bowling ball on my foot the other day, and it just floated away.
Thus video has indeed aged badly.
Am I making sense?
@@NonStampCollector wow, you actually respond to comments on a 13 year old video. I'm actually from Austria, so I've heard quite some stories about Hitler growing up but never that he was an atheist. That's something I've learned rather recently, maybe 2 years or so ago. I do not know about the bowling ball though since I'm not a flat earther, you might consider one of those.
Blud doesn’t believe in gravity LOL