Nick Saban vs. Urban Meyer - Who is the best coach in college football? | UNDISPUTED
Вставка
- Опубліковано 21 вер 2024
- Joel Klatt, Skip Bayless and Shannon Sharpe debate who is better: Urban Meyer or Nick Saban.
SUBSCRIBE to get the latest UNDISPUTED content: foxs.pt/Subscri...
▶Watch our latest NFL content: foxs.pt/NFLonUN...
▶Watch our latest NBA content: foxs.pt/NBAonUN...
▶Watch our latest MLB content: foxs.pt/MLBonUN...
▶The Herd with Colin Cowherd’s UA-cam channel: foxs.pt/Subscri...
▶Speak for Yourself’s UA-cam channel: foxs.pt/Subscri...
See more from UNDISPUTED: foxs.pt/UNDISPU...
Like UNDISPUTED on Facebook: foxs.pt/UNDISPU...
Follow UNDISPUTED on Twitter: foxs.pt/UNDISPU...
Follow UNDISPUTED on Instagram: foxs.pt/UNDISPU...
Follow Skip Bayless on Twitter: foxs.pt/SkipBay...
Follow Shannon Sharpe on Twitter: foxs.pt/Shannon...
About Skip and Shannon: UNDISPUTED:
UNDISPUTED is a daily two-and-a-half hour sports debate show starring Skip Bayless and Shannon Sharpe. Every day, Skip and Shannon will give their unfiltered, incisive, passionate opinions on the biggest sports topics of the day.
Nick Saban vs. Urban Meyer - Who is the best coach in college football? | UNDISPUTED
• Nick Saban vs. Urban M...
Skip and Shannon: UNDISPUTED
/ undisputedonfs1
Nick Saban is a coaching God in college football
As an LSU fan, as much as I hate to say it, Nick Saban no questions. He's the goat.
MsMrapplepie why do you hate that he won y'all a natty
Neither are.....
Coaches do not win or lose games.
Players do.
@@Cmurphy_27 He should’ve stayed with us bruh. You see the dominance Alabama has? It’s supposed to be LSU.😔
@@MsMrapplepie regardless Alabama and LSU (Two of the greatest rivalry ever) are/were lucky to have him as both coach
@@philadelphiaeagles834nope coaches do that why no matter who saban has he can win chips so your logic is delusional
Nick Saban is the best and it's not even close.
Saban is the best but it is definitely close.
Saban is GOAT
if Pete Carrol stayed nick wouldn't be all that
agreed
Babahoe_ But Pete pussied out
Yeahhhh Skip lost this argument LMAO. He looks completely overmatched in this one lol.
Klatt always do that to skip
Skip is overmatched in every debate
Skip likes to talk down The G.O.A.T. SABAN and it's clear he can only see threads of the sweater, i.e. the losses.
Skip is outmatched by these two. Skippy is just mad that Saban owns college football.
harbaugh is a better nfl coach obviously but saban is a better college coach hands down
Dylan Vickers Best Coaches would be
1) Nick Saban
2) Urban Meyer
3) Jim Haurbaugh
4) Dabo Swenney
Matt TheDestroyer 2 DABO >>>>>>>>>>>> Harbaugh
Lmaoooo that’s a good one
Harbaugh is better than Dabo
"khaki pants aint gone do nothing" I'm weak
Alex Skowron - Had me dyin' as well!
Aged well
Joel klat to me is the scariest guy to debate because he has so much knowledge, is calm no matter what, and knows when he’s winning and will press the matter
Joel is amazing. Truly the mind of a qb
Saban Duhh
Urban 3-0 against Saban really
@@darrylcrane253 don't matter since saban the goat
Darryl Crane awesome so urban has the 3-0 I beat nick Saban championship while nick Saban has the 6 time college football championship. Congrats urban!
@@darrylcrane253 who was the coach at Florida with Tebow as QB that Saban beat in the SEC Championship game.... then all of a sudden had "heart issues".... Urban Myer.... so he's not 3-0 again Saban.... gtfoh
@@darrylcrane253 actually look up some records.... they're 2-2 vs each other..... where do u get your stats, Fairytale Land
Which coach is better? Nick Saban or Urban Meyer?
UNDISPUTED ON FS1 Nick Saban will go down as one of the greats
Tough but give it to Urban.
Saban!
UNDISPUTED ON FS1
Saban. National Champions with 3 different offensive coordinators at one school. 3 different QBs.
I know he's won 4 at BAMA but, McCarron won 2 of those.
Urban Meyer ⭕️🍃
Your OG look what just happened last night!! Huge L!
Paul Fedorowicz True. I kinda expected the loss but I didn't think it would be THAT bad
st. Nick of course
We need more Joel Klatt and less Chris Carter
Hamburger247 agreed
agreed, I would like more nick wright
Nick wrights the man 2nd Joel Klatt cris carter just has that annoying voice plus he's doing what got him fired from espn
Action Jackson
Lol true. CC is the type that act's like he's the greatest ever and speaks as such but doesn't say much whenever he opens his mouth
I actually like CC speaking more on the NBA than I do like him talking about the NFL. CC is my fave NBA guy on this network.
I think Shannon is a little more qualified to pick a good football coach then Skip.
True that
Nick Saban over everything
Saban almost killed him in 2009, literally, - Meyer had a pharmaceutical overdose - and Saban ran him into retirement and out of the SEC by blowing him out 2x. If it weren't for the 2014 Sugar Bowl loss this discussion never happens. And that OSU team was LOADED.
Saban best in the nation
Because of Nick Saban, Urban Meyer left the SEC
Well, you know those "health problems" he had! LMAO! You're exactly right, Saban and also Urban knew the cupboard was bare after Tebow. He left UF in a dumpster fire. I think how a coach leaves a program says how good he is also. I may be mistaken but wasn't bowling green and Utah put on probation after he left?
Did Skip rethink this after Urban Meyer crashed at the Jaguars?
They are talking college football here not nfl
Nick Saban rtr
So funny that after this Ohio State puts up a goose egg.
I'm an OSU fan and alumni, and I think right now you have to go with Saban. It's really 1A and 1B because they are both so good, and I think head and shoulders above everyone else, but Saban has two more titles, I think he is the better recruiter (very slight edge), and I think from 2008-2013 he was coaching in the best conference and was absolutely dominating the competition on his way to 3 national titles.
Nick got the upper hand in 09. Urban got revenge in 2014. I would really love them going head to head in the National Title game this year. I think it would be amazing because both teams have strengths and weaknesses. These arent all time great teams so I think it would come down to coaching.
Yea that would be a badass Championship Game
Nick Saban is riding on the shirt tails of the "BEAR" Bryant! The "Bear" built such a dynasty that so many great High School players would chose Alabama over most everybody else. Obviously all of them couldn't go there, so many had to go other places even though they want to go to Alabama. Now, some of those better players are choosing other schools and some chose to stay in their home states. So in a way, Saban is very fortunate to be at Alabama because many great high school players desire to go to that school. He really doesn't have to do much recruiting. Urban Meyer is getting that way at Ohio State as he gets great players as well! As for Harbaugh, he hasn't proved anything yet to put him anywhere near the coaching ability of several other college coaches.
Bama wins by either or.
@@dhornish Look, I have nothing but absolute respect for Bear Bryant. I'm a lifelong fan, I came in a few years after Bear was gone but I heard the stories, I read the books. Bear was the greatest of his era. Now, to say Saban owes his success at Bama to the Bear....that's ridiculous. If there was a hint of truth to that why didn't Perkins? How about Curry? Stallings was great, he just didn't stay long enough. What about Shula? He had the best pedigree, qb'd at Bama, son of the greatest NFL coach, still couldn't win. Bear was gone in '82. Saban came in '07.....long way down the line. Saban wins because he knows how. He's the greatest of his era. He's tied with Bear in nat'l titles! Man, when I was a kid I thought that was untouchable. We should be grateful as Bama fans we got 'em both.
You saying Saban doesn't have to do much recruiting? That's just crazy! Why do think he gets these players? Because Bear coached there 40 years ago? Saban is relentless as a recruiter. He's relentless as a coach. Skip is a fkn idiot....give harbaugh time. OK, how much time do we need to spot him 5-6 years? Will that be enough? I can't stand someone who's hatred is so strong it clouds their common sense!
Saban
Saban easy
Skip stay hating on saint nick
Does Skip ever tire of being wrong?
Nick Saban is the best college football coach and it’s not even close
Saban over Meyer.
the fact that skip said Jim Harbauh is a better college coach than saban should be all you need to know about skip
I love it when Skip gets a hate on against a coach or team. Nick is so far ahead of Meyer that you need welder's glasses and a cane to not see it.
"KHAKI PANTS AINT GONNA DO NOTHIN"
-Shannon Sharpe 2016
Aged poorly
Skip was looking for help the whole time😂
Since this aired Alabama played for and lost a National Championship to Clemson, played for and won a Nation Championship against Georgia (beating Clemson 24-6 in the playoff's) and is currently 10-0. Ohio St. was absolutely CURB STOMPED TWICE, by Iowa 55-24 in 2017 and Purdue 49-20 this year. Not to mention being shut out by Clemson 31-0 a week before this airing. Had a wife better assistant coach who Urban Cryer's covered for. Cryer's is great.
Obviously saban
Meyer
nick gaming dvs
😜😇😇😋😍😋😝😙☺️
@@morestevedeacegiggles6708 lmao it's Saban
I think when you become as great as either of these two coaches you're basically comparing apples to oranges.
Skip lost this argument when he said in another debate that Jim Harbaugh was a better coach than Nick Saban. And I'm a Michigan fan
Saban, of course. Meyer ran away from Saban to join the Big Easy.
Urban Meyer
ROLL TIDE🌊🌊🌊🌊🌊🐘🐘🐘
Skip is one of those people who finds a point a view and only pay attention to information that backs him up and ignores everything else.
i dont even have to watch this to know what skip will say.
How about Coach Urban losing by 31 to Iowa this year, Skip???
A good way to get the answer to their question is to rephrase it -- -- "If my favorite coach, from my favorite school, had Saban's record of success, how would I rate him?" In all honesty, I'd brag that my fave coach is the all-time best. Until someone knocks Saban off the throne, he wears the crown. Now, having said that, Go Buckeyes!
Lol isn't it normal to hire coordinators to run your offense and defense or am I missing something
Exactly
Nick Sabin is the MJ of college football coaches
Saint Nick!!!
Urban will be back in the game this year
Shannon love Saban to damn much. St.Nick this St.Nick that. Kind of annoying.
Like anybody gives af lmao, cry me a river and Roll Tide miserable one.
Urban produces better NFL players
He's produced more murderers
same thing
Jimbo Vice Who u talkin bout? I'm ignorant and I'm just windering
Vincent Lucic this guy - en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Aaron_Hernandez
Sean Legghette Lol Yeah
If there was a special Olympics for sports talk skip would be the Michael Phelps
I'm a lifetime diehard buckeye fan but saban is the best and it isn't even close
skip keeps talking about the soonest but when was the last time they won a national championship?
The Re Tro Nerds without Nick Saban Alabama wouldn't be where they are so yeah as a Sooner fan he's the best coach
why does skip try to win with this same bs argument. ive heard him say this over 10 times. Joel destroys it everytime
7:40
It's because they are the best team in their conference, Shannon.
i am a lsu tiger through and through since birth and now attend college at lsu and no one is a better college football coach than nick saban give me a year when lane kiffin wasn't there oh yeah they were still destroying every season
khaki pants lol
just coming back to this after the urban and jags situation. remove all their college accolades and wins. just look at the time in the NFL. atleast nick saban survived 2 seasons and left on his own and atleast had a winning season and even 6-10 with a past his prime coming of injury qb. if urban was a better coach would he be canned before his first year was over
not even close nick saban is by far the best
all I know is last time they played urban won easily with a backup QB
Sean Legghette Michigan state always plays the buckeyes well. that's nothing new
Sean Legghette to be fair, Zeke only got 12 carries. Urban Meyer should have been ashamed of that
Wasn't Bama winning 21-6 at one point??
ChristopherX30 yes
ChristopherX30 Yup, they choked.
Why is this even a question Nick Saban is the best recruiter in college football and he has more rings. 5 Rings and 8 straight years with the Top recruiting class and he did it with two different schools.
5 > 3. Saban is the better coach
thepac12andbig10suck .... 6 > 3
If I had to pick one, I would have to pick Paul Chryst.
Damn Skip got schooled.
Florida Gators fan here hate to say it but Nick Saban is the best NCAA college football coach of all time. Fan of Saban or not we all have to respect him
Only reason these guys are on here is because it's college football, it's not a draft. Top football players want to go to top football schools. Alabama and Ohio have been the best since forever, especially Alabama. Put these two in the NFL, Nick had his career in the NFL and didn't do so well.
Okay... well what about Texas with Mack Brown? They had top 10 recruiting classes year in and year out, why did he only win one NC? If winning is so easy with top recruits... getting top recruits is one thing, developing these players and building great teams is another. NFL coaching is completely different than college coaching, some guys just can't mesh with NFL personalities, it's just how it goes.
nick is a recruiter, in the nfl theres a salary cap and everyone is a billionaire, in college most schools dont have the same resources as an alabama or ohio state, easier to recruit
Jimbo Vice If the BEST football players want to go to Alabama, then common sense would have you that they'd win the NC every year. For example, Najee Harris, top running back prospect, and he's committed to Alabama. That's one of many, many players. But one thing's for sure, these Alabama players don't do so well in the NFL, because they don't unlock their full potential when in college as opposed to schools with low ranked prospects. They have to put 110% every time and they make it big in the NFL.
Ryder Washington JULIO JONES. Clinton Dix. Sooner than later "Henry" . Amari cooper. Cj Mosley? Landon Collins for the New York giants? SABAN doesn't produce good nfl players? 😂😂😂😂 besides zeke. Who in the nfl is a top 10 player at their position that came from Urbana Florida Gators orrrrr His Ohio State Buckeyes? JULIO IS TOP 2 WR in the league. Landon Collins is top 5 safety in the league! Cj Mosley is top 10 linebacker in the league!!! Amari Cooper is top 10 wr. Derrick Henry will be top 10 rb soon.
Ryder Washington lol sure they don't. Ask Atlanta fans how NOT well Julio Jones has done... Ask Raider fans if they would prefer having Kevin White on their team over Amari Cooper... Alabama has quite a few players playing well in the NFL... do me a favor... could you tell me what number is next to Alabama's name on this list? - bleacherreport.com/articles/2637667-10-college-football-teams-with-most-players-in-nfl-today/page/11
Oh that's right, number 1... but sure they don't turn out so well, huh?
And 4 years later Nick Saban has won 2 more chips and is a Bonafied Solidified LEGEND! And im a Longhorn Fan
It's funny how he brings up the osu and Bama game when the Alabama defense had hella injuries smfh. Same for this year. Alabama always has injured draft picks every national championship game. Ohio state loses to the most mediocre teams and they'll still be top 5 in people eyes because the committee doesn't want Alabama to be #1 every year because they seem "boring" to Americans.
Kvng Amo What mediocre team did Ohio state lose to in Urbans tenure? That answer is none. They've only lost to MSU, Clemson, VTech, and PSU. VTech is the only one that was mediocre.
jmaal2345 they just loss to Clemson, save your reply
Kvng Amo Okay. They obviously aren't mediocre. I mentioned Clemson. Did you read? It was a playoff game. Duh.
Ummm, Ohio State had their 3rd string QUARTERBACK! If you want to talk about injuries. 3rd!
Kvng Amo thats stupid. Alabama is good and Ohio State is good. Ohio State beat them with a back up qb and bama was#1 so you could argue for both. 2 best football schools all time.
Nick Saban is a way better coach the Urban Meyer. Look at recruiting to the school. There record as a head couch. How many national championships have they won. Nick Saban has turned two SEC programs from sub par 500 teams to championship competitions teams every year. Nick Saban is in my mind the best college football coach ever. The reason why Urban Meyer is so good is the Big 10 is weak compared to the SEC
Guess who strengthened 2 conferences... Not Nick Sabin. Urban Meyer did though.
Exactly Urban was amazing.
You could say, he grinded it out
How is it that Skip keep referring to the NFL coaching career of Nick Saban when he has evidently lost his argument . I guess Skip says he will go down swinging and drowning trying to take shots at St. Nick.
Saban is the "Goat" in college football!
This is what happens when you argue apples and oranges.
However, Urban should not have even been in the playoff. Refs definitely helped them out with their eagle eye view on that 4th down play.
Urdan Myer--great Offense coach, produces amazing NFL prospects and recruiter
Nick Saban--great coach period, produces amazing NFL prospects and recruiter
I have no idea which is better how bout we give each coach their best them ever and have them play
Guess we know who the best is now lol
Meyer....Saban just gets the best players
Urban Meyer did the same at Florida.... Tebow, Hernandez, etc.... it's called recruiting..... and Saban beat Urban Meyer, Tebow & that stacked Florida team in the SEC Championship game, had Tebow crying at the end of the game and Meyer left Florida with "heart issues"
@@stufrankie8332 well, we will see if Urban cowards like Saban did in the NFL...Saban can't coach, his NFL failure speaks for itself.
You can hate him.... but you can't over rate him... Saban is clearly the guy. Not to knock a great coach in Meyer.
skip I usually say "stop it skip" and back up my man Shannon but this right here is an excellent explanation of why urban is better
At the time of this debate, Nick Saban Coached against 3 Heisman trophy winning Quarterbacks in the SEC alone during his tenure. He faced 2 of them twice;(Manziel and Tebow) splitting victories against both of them. Of course he was going to give up points.
Urban Meyer, everywhere he goes he wins .
Khaki pants ain't gon do nothing!! Lmao
Wow, Skip Bayless is right about something for once. mark the date: 12/30/2016
I think most teams would take EITHER of these coaches so whichever one I say is better doesn't mean that the other one sucks, but I'd take Saban. Almost every single year, Alabama is by FAR the best team
Saban never got shut out at the big stage by 31 points so this is easy lol
Skippppp bama has been dominant for almost 10 years and has won 5 and could win 6 and u pick urban omg skippp, and this comes from a Texas fan
Skip you're one of those haters, coach Saban is referring as RAT POISON! You're disgusting! Lmao. You're a sry. Looser Skip!!!!!
Skip sounds so desperate. lol
I can't wait for tomorrow's show. Shannon is going to make skip eat his words...I love it
Urban had Tom Herman from Utah + that's why they struggled offensively.
Urban Meyer had a Heisman hopeful at Bowling Green State University by the time he left for Utah.
Urban had the ability to be better than Nick Saban but his health issues keeps him in and out of coaching.
Get off the drugs
@@grid-natics2983 I mean he’d have at least 2 more titles probably
Love how Shannon said that Ohio State didnt deserve to get in the playoffs even though they didnt win their conference. This year Bama does the same thing and he'll defend them until the day he dies
what about all the zero points games scored skip. skip its all about rings not how many points u give up skip!!!!
dolomite Rydah - How about his boy, Urban, getting blanked tonight?! LOL
yep! first time in his career. ohio st. first bowl shutout since 1920
But Pete carrol wasn’t with usc as long as nick was with Alabama, and usc got pushed out in 06&07&08
First of all,You ain't sorry skip,other teams have great players too,and they want to win too.
Skip Bayless is making such an illogical argument lmao. He's basically saying "if both Urban Meyer and Nick Saban both have NICK SABANS PLAYERS, Urban Meyer would be better"....umm...the fallacy in that argument is built-in to the argument itself.
Skip Bayless, when another college football coach wins 5 Natty’s in 9 years, than you can start saying that he is as good as Nick Saban! But, nit until!
Ohio State got thumped by Iowa last year.....
Saban > Meyer. Also, I'm completely convinced that the only reason that Skip picks Meyer, is cause he coached Tebow. If Tebow had went to Alabama, then Skip wouldn't be able to shut up about praising Saban. #RollTide
Coach Saban needed LK so much, that he only just won another NC again.
It's so close