How to prank someone: Step 1: fake your death in april Step 2: wait 7 or 8 years Step 3: suprise your friend while him trying to kill the guy that killed you
John: For 8 years?! Arthur: Does it look like I've been takin' a nap for 8 years? Hell no, it was only for a few hours. John: Then, who the hell did I buried? Arthur: ...
"lets act as if we hate each other but then plot together when the time is right, noone is going to expect it" "ok cowpoke" "WHAT DID YA CALL ME?!!!" *so they became enemies for real and thats why rdr2 played out like it did.*
Imagine instead of Micah shooting Arthur in the bad ending, the screen fades to black before he pulls the trigger. Johns epilogue happens as normal and then we get this scene.
No the low honor endings and high honor should switch. Micah lets low honor Arthur live and kills high honor Arthur. Then this scene can happen for low honor players. Forcing the player to kill the monster Arthur they created and loved
Stauss was sitting on a rock when he sent Arthur to Downes so if you move the rock, Strauss may have sent someone else to beat up Downes. 1 tb free low honor Arthur playthrough later and we end up here
@@debilman9065 I really hate how they made it so Arthur had to die. They could have just as easily made it so he didn't have to if you played the right way, and they wouldn't have needed to change much of the story to allow for it.
I agree that this would have been a bigger shock than the Dutch reveal. It also would have made no sense whatsoever. That being said, this video is still impressive if only for the fact that it's actually Arthur's voice we hear, so massive kudos to whoever created that mod!
@@Resi1ience how about you relax buddy go back to your grand theft auto san andreas sun bed playing with legos like albert speer and eating mcdonalds every 5 minutes like a american kid 🤡
Tbh as much of a masterpiece rdr2 is I kinda wish it did end this way. I think if you were honorable you should get the canon mountain ending but if you were dishonorable the missions would change to side with Micah. In a way it would make sense why John didn’t talk about Arthur because 1. He betrayed him and 2. He would have been dead cause John would shoot both of them and there’s no use bringing it up.
Imagined being so low honor in the game that it triggers an ending where Arthur remains fully loyal to Dutch and goes after John in the end, Arthur escapes to NA never to be seen until the last mission
@@dankbacon55 if he went to NA which is hot and warm and rested he could've last a few more years, the whole reason his TB got to where it did so quickly was mostly because of Guarma and the constant physical stress from the situations
@@WalrusWinking majority of who played rdr2 never had played the previous series. mostly because it was only available to consoles. if it was only released to PC, it'd be a different story. so u really cant blame some people liking arthur more than john.
unfortunately, red dead protagonist dont have a good track record when it comes to not dying. tho either way, jack Marston best protag, arthur and john can go kick rocks in hell lol.
Exactly it would've been cool if low honor went out of the rdr1 canon lore and low honor went as a what if this happened and we already know the true story so
Well, it does make a difference in the interactions you have with NPCs in the game, and also how they speak about him after he is gone, so is a bit more than just how he dies.
dbdvdvbhddbdbb didn't mean that he shouldn't die, but a dishonorable playthrough should have Arthur be John's enemy,go crazy and team up with Dutch and Micah and you get to kill him as well
_"Like I said, John, you can't be two people at once. I'm a warrior, a crazy old outlaw, and a killer. I couldn't be as a good man in this world even if I wanted to..."_
I think Low Honor Arthur used this philosophy more to stick to his guts, help John and fight Dutch and Micah, not to be convinced that he might as well go crazy like Micah.
I wish there was an actual "bad ending" when you have bad honor and Arthur teams up with Micah for the money, flipping John and the whole gang. Rdr2 really only has 1 ending despite the "freedom of choice" and it only changes a few lines and scenes no matter if you play "good" or "bad" Arthur, and it all leads to the same outcome anyways
@@windowsVD I know but... it could be cool... on GTA V you could literally end the game with no killing anyone, or killing Trevor or Michael... I'm not saying Arthur should not die... but definetely... it would change a lot... imagine John killing Arthur, being the reason he doesn't talk about him... much... and there is no mention of it on RDR2... either way... it would not destroy the timeline of Red Dead Redemption 1...
@@keraxp599 I found the endings in GTA V to be pretty tacked on and rushed, so I’m not sure if I consider it to be a good example. The choices given to the player felt rather artificial because there was no meaningful incentive to kill either Trevor or Michael other than just for the sake of it. The good ending felt rushed because Michael and Trevor just sort of haphazardly get over their differences because the plot demanded it. I’d rather they focus on one or two endings that are well-executed than multiple endings that exist just for the sake of having multiple endings.
The most insane twist, Micah was playing the bad guy all along so he and Arthur would escape the criminal life. Arthur didnt had TB, but a tapeworm from Pearsons stew and lung probles from all these cigars we had him to smoke. After fooling everyone, John included, they both run away.
I would actually love this twist. Expect it would be kinda impossible to fake his death like that but man my jaw would go through the floor if I saw this
I was kind of hoping that the Low Honor go for the money option would have had Arthur bail on everybody, takes the cash for himself, heads into New Austin and holes up at Venter's Place in Cholla Springs. Eventually though Micah and his gang track him down and they have a massive shootout with Micah eventually getting the better of Arthur; killing him and taking the cash.
I don't think LH Arthur would've bailed on everyone (he even tried to get the money for John) I think he would've split the cash between him and the Marstons and went to New Austin. Regardless, I would've loved something like that because something that was always lacking to me about the multiple endings is variety of outcomes. You could still have Arthur ultimately die, but it would've better if in some endings, he managed to get away first then later die in the epilogue.
Agreed. I think it would have been cool if low honor Arthur managed to live and escaped somewhere and created his own gang Bill style after recovering from TB. I know it wouldn't fit with RDR1, but still.
Eh, I think an ending like this wouldn't make sense with Low Honor Arthur at all. People think Low Honor is basically evil Arthur who never found an inkling of redemption and would go to on to team up with Micah. Low Honor Arthur still redeemed himself to an extent by helping the people he loves, even if he didn't become a much better person by the end. Realistically, if LH Arthur survived, he'd live alone in New Austin and then team up with Dutch only to kill Micah and actually get the money this time.
@@oflippert Hell, it wouldn't fit with Low Honor Arthur imo. People seem to miss that while LH Arthur didn't end his story a much better person like HH Arthur did, he didn't go full evil outlaw neither (canonically) and redeemed himself to an extent by helping the indebted people, the Downes and John and his family. He even tried to get them the money at the end.
@@themadtitan7603 Just because he starts his own gang doesn't mean he's an evil outlaw. I can see him starting his own gang while still following Dutch's teachings. He could just as easily live alone like you said, or team up with Dutch again and try to bring him back from his dark place.
@@anthonylombardo4829 John wasn't even better than Micah on his own And Arthur out-drew Micah - managed to fuck him up while he should've been on his deathbed. Honestly Arthur would probably give even RDR1 John a run for his money.
This could’ve been the low honor ending when in the middle of the fight with Micah it just ends with no result at all leaving a black screen and then starting the epilogue. Altho the problem is Arthur tb so there could be a main choice in the game to kill thomas with a gun right away or doing the normal thing Advising you that one will low your honor greatly, and basically telling you there is no way back
in this scenario Arthur and Micah were secret lovers, but the views at the time wouldve sent them both to the gallows so they hid their relationship by posing as enemies to eachother, Arthur faked his TB infection so he could escape the gang while Micah would stick around a while longer to gather the gang’s money and then they would live together and start a new life Or something.
That's something I actually thought about when I think about an ending where Arthur lives. Arthur would have some side mission where he gets something to help with his TB, and in the Micah fights, he destroys him, and leaves with Dutch in the end. But, some wolves eat Micah's corpse or something and when Charles finds the body, he thinks it's Arthur, so the epilogue stays the same until they hear about some gang that is robbing a bank in the west, and after a mission like American Venom but somewhere in New Austin, you find out that it wasn't Micah, but it was Arthur who was the leader. Arthur is finally dying from the TB and he wanted to get some money to help Dutch live a peaceful life after all this, but it all went wrong, and now his gang is dead, he has no money and who knows how much longer does he have to live. So, as the cops arrive at the hideout, Arthur distracts them so John, Charles, Sadie and Dutch can escape, but he dies because he isn't as skilled as he once was. And in this timeline, John and Dutch know they could have stayed and helped Arthur, but he knew it was a losing battle, so he didn't want to let anyone else get killed in this. Sorry for the movie script here, just had too much free time and wanted to share my thoughts
A few unexpected twists could be made in this scene. A few momentary loose ends for some of the gang at the end, like Karens cold split and Bill, Pearson too. Pearson ends up owning the general store in Rhodes, But with what money did he manage to buy that.
If they hadn’t committed so fully to Arthur getting TB or had given more options through the story to branch rather than “Hey there” vs “Whatchu lookin’ at” then this ending would have been perfect. The secret Micah/Arthur rat pact would’ve been sick and canon compliant for John rather than what we got.
@@anthonylombardo4829no John wouldn't even been able to kill Arthur especially healthy Arthur because Arthur would have beated the John ass for it because he wasn't skilled at this time
@@n3kst167 Yeah, maybe. While Dutch betraying Micah made sense, Arthur betraying him as well, makes sense too. It would also add to why John doesn't talk about Arthur
It’d be sick if, after Arthur kills Micah, you have to have a standoff/duel with him. Him also having deadeye would be really neat as he’d have to be just as fast at the draw as you. (Maybe even faster depending on your deadeye level as Arthur?)
Imagining folks doing an evil Arthur playthrough and then getting upset when he pairs off with Micah in the epilogue
Evil or not they hated each other the entire time. Imagine being so cringe.
It's micah who killed the Dutch, it's Arthur Morgan let him die. It makes sense now...
@@WiseOwl_1408 Yep. But evil arthur should be friend with Micah. I love this more.
Yeah, low honor Arthur really doesn't have his own route. The game REALLY pushes you to be high honor.
@@waxerwaer9700 yeah there's not much difference except for interactions and the scenery of the ending
Oh yes "Micah without his mustache" shocks me way more than the original.
Micah lowkey handsome under that Hulk Hogan stache
Looking like B. J. Blazkowicz with out the ‘stach
I'm pretty sure that was Beau Gray...
@@ollikoskiniemi6221 yo?🤨
Micah with a 'stache reminds me of 90's James Hetfield
I was expecting Arthur to say "Okay I'll catch you later then" and go back inside.
This shit deserves more likes. 😭😭😭
Hi there mister
He probably would have said that after shooting Micah
"Alright then."
Im on break at work and I just cackled
John: "Say something, Arthur!"
Arthur: "You, sir, are a fish."
Love it
Yurr a good boah
How to prank someone:
Step 1: fake your death in april
Step 2: wait 7 or 8 years
Step 3: suprise your friend while him trying to kill the guy that killed you
wtf
@@QuisshyNo it was 8 years. The main game takes place in 1899 while the epilogue is in 1907.
Lol
@@galacticgull2249 And he "faked" in June 1899
@@1TacitusKilgore899 September
Damn, nobody expected Beau to go that path
Underrated comment
Lol micah has beaus hair
@@aadyndenny8319 Underrated comment on a comment
@@AlexLarning underated comment left commentating on an underated comment
@@genericname1672 Underated comment left commentating on an Underated comment left commentating on an Underated comment
Dutch's plan: *actually works*
The timeline:
Dutch escapes to tahiti but only him and arthur having low honor
Time traveler: Kills butterfly in past
Reality in the present:
Old Arthur looks awesome. Especially in Dutch's epilogue snow coat.
Playing like this would be great.
Dutch showed up, they killed him, ate him, and took his coat 💀
@@marypalmer00 WTF they eat him.
Old arthur it is like joel from tlou
@@marypalmer00 Also Arthur ate Micahs Mustache and gave him a wig.
charles: SO WHO THE FUCK DID I BURY...?
Dutch
Grimshaw
Fenton ;)
Tacitus Kilgore
Dutch and grimshaw
John: "I THOUGHT YOU DIED?"
Arthur: "I was just restin' my eyes"
John: For 8 years?!
Arthur: Does it look like I've been takin' a nap for 8 years? Hell no, it was only for a few hours.
John: Then, who the hell did I buried?
Arthur: ...
does it pay well??
@@xtrashtmac "Eventually"
@@elitegamer9310didn’t Charles bury Arthur and Ms.Grimshaw, he says he did in the mission Bare Knuckles Friendship.
"I never had tb john.."
John: Godamn it, Arthur!
Arthur: Oh, I was just kidding around.
Arthur: Whoa, sorry there Cowpoke.
J: “Uh thank you!”
A: “Okay I’ll catch you later then” (walks off)
Arthur: Alright, keep your head on
@@oldmancorecentral A: "Outta tha way!"
@@oldmancorecentral
Arthur: Outta the damn way!
The gay story telling ending😊
I think a better twist would be to have Jack come out. He was the real rat all along and Micah was just a pawn in his game.
Jack's Revenge for Cain
@@MariusBoss11458 🤣🤣🤣🤣
How dare you
Lmaooo
@@mahawyshnaw.5680 Why are you laughing? I mean. Wouldn't YOU want to kill that Rat for Killing that cute doggo?
Yea Arthur and Micah being secret partners in crime from the beginning 😂
I think he would've worked with Micah enough to get him to make a mistake and trust him leading to Arthur getting to end him.
Evil Arthur: sooo Micah, about that money from Blackwater. Still wanna get it? The gang's about to split up, might as well get the cake
"lets act as if we hate each other but then plot together when the time is right, noone is going to expect it" "ok cowpoke" "WHAT DID YA CALL ME?!!!" *so they became enemies for real and thats why rdr2 played out like it did.*
If RDR2 gave players alternative story arcs and didn't make Micah another cliched mustache twirling villain.
Think Micah is actually supposed to be beau gray
Imagine instead of Micah shooting Arthur in the bad ending, the screen fades to black before he pulls the trigger.
Johns epilogue happens as normal and then we get this scene.
No the low honor endings and high honor should switch. Micah lets low honor Arthur live and kills high honor Arthur.
Then this scene can happen for low honor players. Forcing the player to kill the monster Arthur they created and loved
Black hair Arthur = the most dangerous guy in the red dead verse.
The secret route : you don't choose gold or John but the Rat route.
Imagine than when you loot Arthurs body you find a legendary rat
@@papdm7218 And the code name was micah
Lol
@@samueljose7715 timmy!!!
you'd still die from tuberculosis 💀
Arthur: Mr. Marston. Mrs. Adler. Nice day huh.
John: Arthur.
Arthur: okay I'll catch ya later than.
*PROCEED TO WALK AWAY LIKE NOTHING HAPPENED*
@@emtcantaluope1367Proceed to sit down sip coffee and sing ring dang doo. 🤣
@@ernie_like_hemingway not ring dang doo 😂
Okay Arthur! 😊
Underrated comment
time traveler: moves chair
the timeline:
Can't imagine Dutch died because of TB
🤣
Stauss was sitting on a rock when he sent Arthur to Downes so if you move the rock, Strauss may have sent someone else to beat up Downes. 1 tb free low honor Arthur playthrough later and we end up here
@@debilman9065 I really hate how they made it so Arthur had to die. They could have just as easily made it so he didn't have to if you played the right way, and they wouldn't have needed to change much of the story to allow for it.
Micah without his mustache looks like one of the founding fathers
That's how you know Arthur is a badass character because not only he made it this far in this final mission, but he cured that TB like it was nothing.
He was taking ginseng and other herbs
Arthur’s terminal lumbago subdued the effects of his TB until eventually, it left his system entirely. It’s very serious you know
So Dutch had a plan all along clone Arthur! Or fake his death I'm not sure which one it is but hey it works.
I agree that this would have been a bigger shock than the Dutch reveal. It also would have made no sense whatsoever. That being said, this video is still impressive if only for the fact that it's actually Arthur's voice we hear, so massive kudos to whoever created that mod!
the creator of the mod took existing voiceline and put it there
@@hira2840duh you re re
Thanks captain obvious. Who the hell said this made any sense to begin with?...
@@MisterDevos Bruh, relax.
@@Resi1ience how about you relax buddy go back to your grand theft auto san andreas sun bed playing with legos like albert speer and eating mcdonalds every 5 minutes like a american kid 🤡
Since there's no mention of Arthur in RDR1, this is genuinely how I thought the game would've ended
If I remember correctly there was some random dialogue between abigail and uncle but that's about it
Tbh as much of a masterpiece rdr2 is I kinda wish it did end this way. I think if you were honorable you should get the canon mountain ending but if you were dishonorable the missions would change to side with Micah. In a way it would make sense why John didn’t talk about Arthur because 1. He betrayed him and 2. He would have been dead cause John would shoot both of them and there’s no use bringing it up.
Imagine if you got the ending where Arthur gets his head blown off and that was when you’d finally realize that’s not how the game ended 💀
@@wolfborn3359 ? Arthur didn’t exist when RDR1 was made
He wasn’t mentioned cause he didn’t exist… so they just made part 2 with likkle things from part 1 to actually make it make sense
Imagined being so low honor in the game that it triggers an ending where Arthur remains fully loyal to Dutch and goes after John in the end, Arthur escapes to NA never to be seen until the last mission
no sense
So what about the TB
If you think Dutch partnered up with Micah, you didn't understand the ending.
@@lucifer_69960 explain
@@dankbacon55 if he went to NA which is hot and warm and rested he could've last a few more years, the whole reason his TB got to where it did so quickly was mostly because of Guarma and the constant physical stress from the situations
John: "Thank you.. I.. I.."
Arthur: "okay i'll catch you later then"
"Dutch saved my life more than once!"
-Alternative John Marston
Son you need to make the rest of this scene with Arthur I want to what happens next
Double Deadeye showdown I'm calling it
you looks like you have a plan
@@Cristiano_Ronald0 we just need
mOnEy
@@FaithEditz1899 they say Tahiti is a really good place
@@Cristiano_Ronald0 As long as we can be pickin mangoes
God could you imagine how many people would go from loving Arthur to absolutely despising him 🤣🤣
Qqq
I don't think so
people would Gaslight themselves thinking Arthur's right either way
Why would they despise him?
@@Papa_Burton Because he’s siding with Micah
@@Dumberoosci sure, but everything else he's done for them I would think they would be shocked but not despise him
I would have loved to just see him live. I didnt grow up with the first part so im kinda really attached to Arthur. But I like John as well
feel this to my soul man
Bros never played Red Dead Revolver OR Red Dead Redemption? 😑😑
@@WalrusWinking u gotta buy a xbox specifically for that 😑😑
@@WalrusWinking majority of who played rdr2 never had played the previous series. mostly because it was only available to consoles. if it was only released to PC, it'd be a different story. so u really cant blame some people liking arthur more than john.
unfortunately, red dead protagonist dont have a good track record when it comes to not dying. tho either way, jack Marston best protag, arthur and john can go kick rocks in hell lol.
This is exactly how low honor ending should be like, making an actual difference in the story and not just how he dies.
Exactly it would've been cool if low honor went out of the rdr1 canon lore and low honor went as a what if this happened and we already know the true story so
Well, it does make a difference in the interactions you have with NPCs in the game, and also how they speak about him after he is gone, so is a bit more than just how he dies.
dbdvdvbhddbdbb didn't mean that he shouldn't die, but a dishonorable playthrough should have Arthur be John's enemy,go crazy and team up with Dutch and Micah and you get to kill him as well
Arthur would shoot the guy with tb instead of beating him to death
“Mr. Marston, Mrs. Adler, you sir, are a fish”
_"Like I said, John, you can't be two people at once. I'm a warrior, a crazy old outlaw, and a killer. I couldn't be as a good man in this world even if I wanted to..."_
I think Low Honor Arthur used this philosophy more to stick to his guts, help John and fight Dutch and Micah, not to be convinced that he might as well go crazy like Micah.
But he just said he was three people. 🙁
This is so well made
I know right!? People don't seem to acknowledge that fact too much
@@Abogado13 Exactly, especially the voice lines for Arthur, they fit too well
@@Abogado13 Yeah, everyone is talking about the possibility of the ending but not how well edited and in sync the lines are.
@@Red_Dead_Entertainment I thought he just played the lines and got them to sync with their mouth movements.
Lol what is dat Micah!?😂 0:10
I think its beau gray
@@2x_Playsit’s Micah without mustache
@@jaynumbr3 it is
@@jaynumbr3with beau’s hair
If Dutch went to the Downes Ranch:
"nice day huh?" 😂😂😂 His face killed me
Holy shit, Micah turned into Ric Flair!
Woooooo!
Woooooooooooo!
Short hair Micah with the moustache would be Hulk Hogan
thought it was arthur with beau gray as his protégée
@@ollikoskiniemi6221brother 😅
This time, Arthur has a goddamn plan..
“Say something Arthur, say something!” 😂 I need that part to be included
Then he says: Okay ill catch you later then.
"Got some Jellybeans."
.....Where's mah muneh John ?
I wish there was an actual "bad ending" when you have bad honor and Arthur teams up with Micah for the money, flipping John and the whole gang.
Rdr2 really only has 1 ending despite the "freedom of choice" and it only changes a few lines and scenes no matter if you play "good" or "bad" Arthur, and it all leads to the same outcome anyways
That wouldn't have made sense with the "Redemption" part of the title. Plus Rockstar don't make RPGs.
@@windowsVD Rocket Propelled Grenades?
@@windowsVD I know but... it could be cool... on GTA V you could literally end the game with no killing anyone, or killing Trevor or Michael... I'm not saying Arthur should not die... but definetely... it would change a lot... imagine John killing Arthur, being the reason he doesn't talk about him... much... and there is no mention of it on RDR2... either way... it would not destroy the timeline of Red Dead Redemption 1...
@@keraxp599 I found the endings in GTA V to be pretty tacked on and rushed, so I’m not sure if I consider it to be a good example. The choices given to the player felt rather artificial because there was no meaningful incentive to kill either Trevor or Michael other than just for the sake of it. The good ending felt rushed because Michael and Trevor just sort of haphazardly get over their differences because the plot demanded it. I’d rather they focus on one or two endings that are well-executed than multiple endings that exist just for the sake of having multiple endings.
@@keraxp599 bro out here trying to use more ellipses than Oscar Wilde
seeing arthur walk out instead of dutch gave me more whiplash than micah's haircut
Just imagine if rdr2 was a movie and we'll be watching this in the theatres.
Everyone would sigh so loudly I can feel it lmao
The most insane twist, Micah was playing the bad guy all along so he and Arthur would escape the criminal life. Arthur didnt had TB, but a tapeworm from Pearsons stew and lung probles from all these cigars we had him to smoke. After fooling everyone, John included, they both run away.
so Arthur had tapeworm from Pearson's stew but no one else did? From the communal pot? That's really unlucky 🤣
@@marypalmer00 yes, pearson took that insult about pig personally
tapeworm from his stew. lkmaoo
I can't stop laughing about the way Arthur says "Mr Marston."
Strauss: *Sends Bill to Thomas Downes to retrieve debt*
Rdr2 TL:
Micah looks like a One Direction band member with that hair style 😂
Handsome Micah isn't real, he can't hurt you
Handsome or ghastly, Micah can always hurt you
OH NO HES *HANDSOME*
I would actually love this twist. Expect it would be kinda impossible to fake his death like that but man my jaw would go through the floor if I saw this
Wouldn't be that hard to fake it. Micah in both situations is the last person to see Arthur alive.
he literally shot Arthur in the face
@@rileys.9901low honor ass mf
@@rileys.9901 Someone likes their low honor.
@@rileys.9901 Or stabbed him in the back...
Dutch saved my life more than once!
Dutch went to tahiti a long time! This is the new century
I love when Arthur teamed up with Micah in the Epilogue and came outta that door saying “It’s Arthurin’ time, boah!”
I thought Micah was Beau Gray for a second 💀
I was kind of hoping that the Low Honor go for the money option would have had Arthur bail on everybody, takes the cash for himself, heads into New Austin and holes up at Venter's Place in Cholla Springs.
Eventually though Micah and his gang track him down and they have a massive shootout with Micah eventually getting the better of Arthur; killing him and taking the cash.
I don't think LH Arthur would've bailed on everyone (he even tried to get the money for John) I think he would've split the cash between him and the Marstons and went to New Austin.
Regardless, I would've loved something like that because something that was always lacking to me about the multiple endings is variety of outcomes. You could still have Arthur ultimately die, but it would've better if in some endings, he managed to get away first then later die in the epilogue.
This could actually work on a dishonorable playthourgh if Arthur didn’t have TB
No but seriously, an low honour Arthur who never found redemption is the one who survives.
It's gut wrenching and cruel and I love it.
Agreed. I think it would have been cool if low honor Arthur managed to live and escaped somewhere and created his own gang Bill style after recovering from TB. I know it wouldn't fit with RDR1, but still.
Eh, I think an ending like this wouldn't make sense with Low Honor Arthur at all. People think Low Honor is basically evil Arthur who never found an inkling of redemption and would go to on to team up with Micah.
Low Honor Arthur still redeemed himself to an extent by helping the people he loves, even if he didn't become a much better person by the end. Realistically, if LH Arthur survived, he'd live alone in New Austin and then team up with Dutch only to kill Micah and actually get the money this time.
@@oflippert Hell, it wouldn't fit with Low Honor Arthur imo. People seem to miss that while LH Arthur didn't end his story a much better person like HH Arthur did, he didn't go full evil outlaw neither (canonically) and redeemed himself to an extent by helping the indebted people, the Downes and John and his family. He even tried to get them the money at the end.
@@themadtitan7603 Just because he starts his own gang doesn't mean he's an evil outlaw. I can see him starting his own gang while still following Dutch's teachings. He could just as easily live alone like you said, or team up with Dutch again and try to bring him back from his dark place.
They should remake RDR1 but with an option to replace dutch with arthur in the main storyline.
the way arthur says mr marston and mrs adler is like it’s an actual ending and it was actually supposed to be in the game
Micah looks like the dude from the Gray family thats in love with the Braithwaite Girl 😭
Beau?
you guys can say all u want but Id say this is some shocking plot twist that could make the story even more interesting seriously
I was waiting for Arthur to just say "Ok I'll catch you later then!" after shooting Micah 🤣
If that was real, nothing in this world could stop that duo
Aethur and Beau?
John could. At this point he is better tha both
@@anthonylombardo4829 John wasn't even better than Micah on his own
And Arthur out-drew Micah - managed to fuck him up while he should've been on his deathbed.
Honestly Arthur would probably give even RDR1 John a run for his money.
@@anthonylombardo4829John reaches his peak in RDR1 when he met Landon Ricketts
“Me and Arthur are teaming up once more… We got money, we got dreams…”
micah got the beau gray haircut
If Arthur was teaming up with Micah to end dutch’s gang would’ve been an EPIC twist.
Dutch goes to Tahiti by himself.
This:
Bro this is way too well made
Black hair Arthur doesnt exi-
Black hair Arthur:
Why does Micah look like the Gray dude we were a messenger boy for
This could’ve been the low honor ending when in the middle of the fight with Micah it just ends with no result at all leaving a black screen and then starting the epilogue.
Altho the problem is Arthur tb so there could be a main choice in the game to kill thomas with a gun right away or doing the normal thing
Advising you that one will low your honor greatly, and basically telling you there is no way back
The problem with TB could be resolved if Arthur lives in New Austin's warm weather in 1899.
Or they could have given a subtle choice whether to carry out this mission or kick Strauss out of camp earlier.
Micah looks kinda like the Grey kid Arthur helped in Chapter 3.
Edit: is his name Beau?
I think it was intentional
Yes his name Is Beau
I was surprised when even Dutch showed up. I can't imagine what I would think if this was the actual epilogue ending
in this scenario Arthur and Micah were secret lovers, but the views at the time wouldve sent them both to the gallows so they hid their relationship by posing as enemies to eachother, Arthur faked his TB infection so he could escape the gang while Micah would stick around a while longer to gather the gang’s money and then they would live together and start a new life
Or something.
and they say those rainbow stuff weren't forced
Shit fam, these theories are going more insane than Dutch was at the end of the game. Sign me up for this scenario though.
If there's ever a RDR3 and it's another prequel then this is exactly how I want Arthur to be introduced
Rdr3 has been announced.
@@adamxiong1817where
As an old man? Wouldn’t make much sense
@@The_Bigot "prequel"
Imagine if this happened for everyone who got bad honor as Arthur
actually looked more promising than the actual ending
You need to to a full video on this from the start of American Venom to the end
I guess Beau Greay lost Penelope and came back for that Braitwaite gold
Micah got a new haircut xd
That's something I actually thought about when I think about an ending where Arthur lives. Arthur would have some side mission where he gets something to help with his TB, and in the Micah fights, he destroys him, and leaves with Dutch in the end. But, some wolves eat Micah's corpse or something and when Charles finds the body, he thinks it's Arthur, so the epilogue stays the same until they hear about some gang that is robbing a bank in the west, and after a mission like American Venom but somewhere in New Austin, you find out that it wasn't Micah, but it was Arthur who was the leader. Arthur is finally dying from the TB and he wanted to get some money to help Dutch live a peaceful life after all this, but it all went wrong, and now his gang is dead, he has no money and who knows how much longer does he have to live. So, as the cops arrive at the hideout, Arthur distracts them so John, Charles, Sadie and Dutch can escape, but he dies because he isn't as skilled as he once was. And in this timeline, John and Dutch know they could have stayed and helped Arthur, but he knew it was a losing battle, so he didn't want to let anyone else get killed in this.
Sorry for the movie script here, just had too much free time and wanted to share my thoughts
Perfect intro to a DLC RDR 2: Undead Nightmare - where Arthur's come back from the dead.
Holy crap your right
I actually need this now rockstar please
Micah without a mustache gives sundowner vibes from MGR, i dont know why tho
POV: *If Dutch got killed in the Saint Dennis heist and Molly was the actual rat...*
John:dutch saved my life more than once!
A few unexpected twists could be made in this scene. A few momentary loose ends for some of the gang at the end, like Karens cold split and Bill, Pearson too. Pearson ends up owning the general store in Rhodes, But with what money did he manage to buy that.
Hard earned money
More like this would of been the stupidest thing ever
John in that moment:wtf arthur i take this revenge for you how did u survive that?and why did u join with micah?😮
why does micah look like beau gray 💀💀💀
If they hadn’t committed so fully to Arthur getting TB or had given more options through the story to branch rather than “Hey there” vs “Whatchu lookin’ at” then this ending would have been perfect. The secret Micah/Arthur rat pact would’ve been sick and canon compliant for John rather than what we got.
This would have been pretty good for an evil playthrough as a "bad" ending
Honestly this is the ending we all wanted because at least he lived 😭
Fax because god damn I miss this sone of bitch very much 😢
No. If this was the ending john would have killed Arthur for siding with michq
@@anthonylombardo4829no John wouldn't even been able to kill Arthur especially healthy Arthur because Arthur would have beated the John ass for it because he wasn't skilled at this time
@@Drexzzz4 John is equal or at least surpassed Arthur by this point
@@anthonylombardo4829 ye that's what I'm saying John is not way better than Arthur at shooting he is at least equal or barley better than him
Why does Micah look like Shane dowson without his mustache 😭
Imagine if this was the bad honor ending
This honestly would’ve made the game even better. What an amazing twist it would’ve been
Not really.
The twist would have made no sense.
Arthur was sickly and on the brink of the death, now he's back and well?
@@NoBandwidth-0not only that he fucking died. We saw him die no matter what ending he always dies. Still a really cool idea tho
@@NoBandwidth-0R* can switch some in 1-6 chapter. Just idea is great
@@n3kst167 Yeah, maybe.
While Dutch betraying Micah made sense, Arthur betraying him as well, makes sense too.
It would also add to why John doesn't talk about Arthur
Is it me or does anyone else dig Micahs look with the hair and no moustache?
I love this change to the story. It’s very creative. 🤣
Even low honor Arthur despises Micah, would be impossible for this to happen lol.
So nobody is gonna talk how Micah looks like Luke Skywalker?
WHAT IS BEAU DOING THERE
It’d be sick if, after Arthur kills Micah, you have to have a standoff/duel with him. Him also having deadeye would be really neat as he’d have to be just as fast at the draw as you. (Maybe even faster depending on your deadeye level as Arthur?)
They've been BFF since that day in Rhodes where Micah saved Arthur.
Arthur had an evil twin the whole time. Damn it, I couldn't see it coming.
The real Tacitus kilgore
I had no idea Micah was so handsome
Why has Micah transformed into Beau Gray