“Ajit Doval Would've Known of CC-1’s Alleged Attempt to Have Pannun Killed”-Former RAW Head AS Dulat
Вставка
- Опубліковано 21 вер 2024
- Support The Interview with Karan Thapar - fij.mojo.page/...
In an interview to discuss and analyze the exclusive details revealed by the recently unsealed US Superseding Indictment, alleging that an Indian government official attempted to kill a US citizen on US soil, one of the most distinguished former heads of the intelligence agency, R&AW, has made many startling statements that will disturb both the Modi government and his former colleagues in the Indian intelligence fraternity. Amarjit Singh Dulat says that Nikhil Gupta, the man allegedly hired to arrange the murder, was an American agent set up as a trap to lure CC-1, the codename by which the Indian government official mentioned in the US indictment, who is the man who allegedly initiated the murder, is referred to. Mr. Dulat says CC-1 was clearly inexperienced, untrained and “sloppy”. Mr. Dulat says CC-1 walked into a trap that was set for him. Mr. Dulat says that CC-1 “bragged”, thus giving Nikhil Gupta, an American agent, a lot of detail and information. Finally and more importantly, towards the end of the interview, Mr. Dulat says repeatedly that Ajit Doval, the National Security Advisor, would have/should have known about what was happening but insisted that Mr. Doval would not be complicit. Mr. Dulat also clearly said that others, either “lateral” to Mr. Doval or above him might have also been in the picture.
Join The Wire's UA-cam Membership and get exclusive content, member-only emojis, live interaction with The Wire's founders, editors and reporters and much more. Memberships to The Wire Crew start at Rs 89/month. / @thewirenews
![If [Pannun plot] Happened Ajit [Doval] May've Been in the Know of it: Former R&AW chief AS Dulat](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/gdeQ6vwii0U/mqdefault.jpg)
Mr. Thaper’s is an interrogation to ‘win’ his ‘case’ and NOT a journalistic search for information and implication.
Absolutely. Eevn I felt the same
True 🙄
He’s a lawyer by profession
National security should weigh high not your fishing in troubled water. If you are really a patriot you should not have taken this topic.
you have been watching too much godi media haven't you? LOL
Mr Thapar, can you stop interrupting and allow him to complete his sentences?
@@hammer674591:09:55
So well put. KT made what could have been a very much more interesting and informative dialogue into such an irritating experience.
Hope some other channel or platform will invite Me Dulat and have a healthy, respectful and well-manered chat. I'm sure we will hear more from him .
Because the guest is being evasive.
Which part have you missed out? I bet it was about Pakistan 😂😂😂😂without Pakistan Hindutva doesn’t complete 😂😂😂😂
This is exactly why I dislike Karan Thapar. He is a narcissist. Not because I am anyone's bhakt, to be clear, I dislike Arnab's so-called debates just as much. I like hearing important people like the interviewee and not the journalists when watching interviews and debates. What Karan Thapar does is more debate-like than interview. Yes, some debate is good in an interview. But here there is only debate and no interview.
What an annoying journalist treating an ex RAW chief like a child. Shame on you Karan Thapar. I could barely watch ten minutes of this crap
To me it feels like Mr Dulat has more things in his mind and he is not supposed to share and acts like "karan you are right" (something that I do with my little kid 😊)
Exactly sir!
YES AND ALSO ITS CONCERNING HOW THE LINE OF QUESTIONING FROM THIS THAPPAR CHUTAD IS PRO AMERICAN. THIS IS HOW THE CIA WOULD QUESTION.
Yes, u r right
I don’t think Modi government is bothered about Pannun issue… because it is not going to affect their parliamentary poll prospects… in fact BJP supporters will be happy that Indian government is indulged in these allegations of state sponsored assassinations
This Is probably the worst Story or Covert Operation planned By R&AW...
I'm Sure it is made up story by USA
just like Salman khan movie Tiger Zinda Hai...where R&AW & ISI working together 😂 ...
If R&AW wants to plan a operation, they never leave a single trace of it..... & who uses Technology
to carry Covert Operation.....
& Normal text messaging App to Chat ??
& America CIA is Still coming out of its failures of 1998 pokhran nuclear tests & Article 370 abrogation in 2019.....
You are right, jumla bhazi 56 already knocked out a Gujarat ex minister before
@@sureshharinathbabu9717 & 56 inch Also killed close members of jaish-e- mohammed & lashkar-e-toiba inside pakistan & process is still going on .....
@@Kang.31when comes china usa 56 inc become 12 inc puppy 😂
@@ssktrucking4791 Lol, Indian Army Protects the territorial borders of India not politicians......
Let Indian Armed Forces say china has Taken our Land, I'll believe it not the politicians....
& Indian Armed Forces Have much more guts 56 inc guts
than honorable PM....
Was Mr. Dulat invited for the interview or was he there willingly. Mr. Thapar iam a great admirer of you for the straight forward talks & interrogating type of questions, but I would request you on behalf of the viewers to let the one interviewed to complete his answer.
Thats Karan. He doesnt interview people, he badgers them. I certainly am no admirer of him.
I can't approve of Karan cutting short answers being provided by the invitee. He jumps to conclusion based on which he wants answers.
The gist of the matter is that if the interviewee doesn’t answer what KT wants to hear then KT cuts them off. That’s pathetic because then you miss out on knowing what the interviewee wanted to say.
When you are watching an interview, you want to hear the interviewee, not the interviewer, this is a debate, not an interview. It is relieving that even fans of Thapar have found this wrong and unfair.
@@flyingsraco That is why Modi left. He was implying that he was a mass murderer. It is understandable why someone would go crazy if called a mass murderer, not once but multiple times. Don't forget also that this aggression was all in English and everyone knows that Modi cannot answer such difficult questions in English. If he wanted to give him a challenge, he could have done it in Hindi and Modi would have answered everything. This is not about being pro or against anyone, but I hate this heropanti style of Thapar's "journalism", just as I dislike Arnab Goswami in his debates.
I wish Karan would not interrupt Dulat all the time.
Then he wont be Karan. He is the entitled Lutyen's Media personified. He is history.
If Nikhil Gupta was indeed an agent of the US… why would they disclose his identity… when the same indictment conceals the identity of two other US agents… “UC” and “CS” associated with the DEA and FBI respectively…
Exactly my point. Americans don’t throw their agents under the bus this easy
Yeah, that's a good question, if he is an American agent, why would they disclose.
@@jattworld1984May be it is part of the plot, their story
To Give Credibility to the Allegations
Nikhil Gupta can operate as Naveen Kumar 2-3 Years Later.
They change Names all the Time.
@@kowsikr5428 to create confusion and chaos through anti nationals like Khangress and its stooges!
AS Dulat has been proven wrong about all his predictions on Kashmir post 370 but he is one person available every few months for Karan Thapar to interview
Wt he says wrong about Kashmir, i would like to hear
Karan Thapar doesn't want the guest to speak unless the guest says what confirms Thapar's preconceived conclusion. It is extremely annoying to see the guest being interrupted so often and so rudely.
Yes. Absolutely always the case.
He always butts in. Either to stop the guest from finishing a point which is too valid for Karan to accept. Or too true for Karan to rebut.
I haven’t ever seen an interview of his where the guest hasn’t be interrupted unduly.
Far better still than ornob gobarswami
Watch his interview with Modi also
OMG...I got a sense that the interviewer conducted the interview with a pre-decided and prejudiced agenda. He didn't allow the interviewee to state his views. I now know that my earlier decision not to waste time watching this interviewer was correct.
He is after all Karna in Mahabharstha, every thing is predetermined and prejudged like Romilla Thapar, his sistet(?) History expert is an expert writing movie scripts…
@@paanigrahanavivaha6019basically all he wants from Mr Dulat is to say that yes it was done by r&aw to assassinate pannun but according to Mr Dulat, it was a planned action by the US to put some geopolitical pressure on india(and we all know why). Atleast I came to that conclusion and I believe even pannun is a cia asset because why would he matter so much to the US? Romilla is his cousin.
not just the person you may want to reconsider if this channel is worth even one cent
Awesome and kudos to Mr Dulat who said everything without saying anything, I love it
That laugh at the end was priceless. This is the most fun I have ever had watching a Karan Thapar interview. Dulat is so used to all this hole and corner business that he would probably take an hour even to admit what his name is. That tie! What a character. This is better than anything John Le Carre could have written.
Hi! Allow me at this point to gently shift the focus from the topic of discussion, and express sincere gratitude for introducing me, albeit unintentionally, to John Le Carre. I've never read Le Carre's content, but I did some homework after reading this comment, and I see that a lot of people call him a master storyteller. I'll start off with The Spy Who Came in from the Cold, and it'd be great if you could recommend what you think are his best novels. Thanks! Always looking forward to reading quality content.
@@dhimankakati6991 Nice to meet you! John Le Carre is brilliant. A former M15 man himself. So A Small Town in Germany, Smiley's People, A Delicate Truth, A Legacy of Spies. There are many more. Try Fredrick Forsyth also - The Day of the Jackal. And then all the books and movies in the Cambridge Five. I just watched A Spy Among Friends on OTT inspired by this interview. Have fun!
@@suranyaaiyar3853 excellent! thanks a lot, Ma'am. I'll get back to you on this thread once I've done some amount of reading. Cheers!
Karan as usual strongly believes the story from the US establishment more than the US establishment itself or even the Ind side.
Nah, that's why I included "as usual" ;P@@hammer67459
@@hammer67459
NOT AT ALL. That's what he's all about, in this video moreso for the simple reason that Mr Dulat is a thorough gentleman and very intelligent, to add to his credit.
It would have been such a hit if Mr Dulat was in conversation with someone else instead of KT.
Almost fell off my chair when he said WaPo is the most, or one of the most, credible institutions. A paper publishing something written by a rabble rouser who has been rebuked by the Supreme Court of India for writing fiction posed as truth, cannot be the most reputable.
Wire please investigate what happens to dsp devi dher Singh .who is arrested with terrorist.
On this episode, viewers would have learnt so much more if the Interviewee was not being continuously interrupted. He was trying to make subtle points which got drowned in the din. Scope for improvement, said not as criticism but feedback.
Karan Thapaer has become disgusting, there was a time I used eagerly wait for his interviews.
His covering of Ukraine is very one sided, seems he is behaving like an asset of UK, US agencies.
Because the interviewee was trying to beat around the bush, not directly answering Thapar's questions, trying to divert the issue the question was trying to address, frequently saying things were different during his times, and most importantly saying 'I don't know' umpteen number of times whenever he could not come up with a proper answer. His attempt to bring in what happened in Pakistan and Kashmir and his judgement on how the system in Pakistan works etc are irrelevant to this discussion. Thapar did well in sticking to finding the truth, who, when and at what level knew happenings in India, USA and Canada, which are the sole objectives of this interview. Thapar was simply trying to logically and systematically connect the dots from information he gathered from various credible sources. In my opinion Thapar did not deviate from this position throughout the interview. Truth is higher than an individual or a nation state. Satyameva jayate.
@@JaRaIndianz There are very little truth in international politics. Do you believe any western politician? Are they virtue of truth. Regarding the interviewee dodging question, what do you expect from him? He has retired from agency 20 years back. Do you think CIA and MI5 tells anything truth? Truth for them is interest of their country. You seems to be a naïve person, don't know the activities / crimes of the US and its lackey's all over the world.
The interviewer is not allowing the guest to explain and convey his points. A poor interview.
KARAN IS trying hard to TURN A FICTION IN TO A REALITY 😂
This interview is can be considered as ISO Certified based on how Mr. Dulat helped karan connecting the dots without saying anything more . 21:08
Agreed...thus interview is a waste of time.
What Karan could not ferret out from Mr Dulat is that there were encrypted communications that were not sent to Gupta but were sent to Others by CC1 ...
...these communications were intercepted and decoded by USA ...
All BS and fake. Both US and India has conglomerated to fool people and spread narrative as per their interest. Nikhil Gupta might just be an another scapegoat.
Who told you sir to give interview to karan thapar without doing homework...
Kuki modi sahab ki 56 inch Sina ho to ja ke keh to h bus ki to interview kerke 😂ke dikhaye apke 56 inch ke modi ji ko
@@abhishekverma8410 This Is probably the worst Story or Covert Operation planned By R&AW...
I'm Sure it is made up story by USA
just like Salman khan movie Tiger Zinda Hai...where R&AW & ISI working together 😂 ...
If R&AW wants to plan a operation, they never leave a single trace of it..... & who uses Technology
to carry Covert Operation.....
& Normal text messaging App to Chat ??
& America CIA is Still coming out of its failures of 1998 pokhran nuclear tests & Article 370 abrogation in 2019.....
Fascinating to watch KT on a witch hunt and putting words in the mouth of Dulat
thapar is an annoying interviewer, just keeps blabbering without letting dulat to talk about what he really thinks
Mr Thapar, The video would have reached to CC-1 through a person, who got it through publicly available sources. How can you conclude that the video reached to CC-1, so there is a connection?
it wasn't available mere hours after killing in public
For as much as one respects Mr. Dulat, he has been away from the RAW for over two decades. Could a more currently retired RAW official have been interviewed instead?
No half-sane intelligence officer (even a retired one) would agree to get interviewed on camera, the fact that Mr. Dulat has given so many only points to his lack of credibility.
Mr. Daulat lost all his credibility and only stayed as a veteran khan market guy who peddles narratives for mere retirement hustle and recognition in commie parties.
To promote his book or may be a new book in pipeline.
@@berserkhorimiyaAll of them give interviews. How many CIA officials give interviews. Stop living in Bollywood. In real life Intelligence heads give interviews and lots of them.
All retired intelligence officers are as well informed 👍
With people like Karan Thapar… India does not need any more enemies!
This is like watching an unstoppable force meet an immovable object.
Karan Sir needs to listen more and let the other person complete himself.
FBI Director does'nt travel all the way for nothing. The plot was hatched at the top level and everyone knows it very well.
Oh he told you this the NSA can travel India multiple times but FBI director can't.
*Former IPS Officer says:-*
I was so upbeat when Shashi Tharoor came into politics in 2009. I still remember talking to so many of my NRI friends on how the politics of India will change for better with highly accomplished people and intelligent people like him joining politics. Then by 2013, I was disillusioned with congress and felt Anna Hazare supported by IITian Kejriwal, IPS Kiran Bedi, great actor Aamir Khan will usher in a new change in India. I even donated to India against corruption, went to Ramlila maidaan to shout slogans
*Now if I look back at it, the only thing I can do is laugh at myself. But I am happy that I realised the biggest flaw in my thinking. The reason we support people like Shashi Tharoor or a Kejriwal is they are well educated. We are brainwashed from childhood that education is equal to goodness*.
*NO, IT IS NOT*.
*Chidambaram is MBA from Harvard and we all know what he did. Mani Shankar Aiyar is from Cambridge - We all know what kind of rubbish he speaks. Kapil Sibal is Harvard Law graduate and all he does is write mercy petitions for terrorists*.
*It is not that congress didn’t have highly educated people in the party. There were lots of them but they were all crooks. And a highly educated crook is even more dangerous as he can dupe you in even more innovative ways*.
Everyone from *Islamic invaders to Britishers* were supported by *highly educated and intelligent* Indians. Yes, you need them to lord over the country? So *the rulers of India cultivated a group of crooks who were well read to rule over us and keep us poor. And Chachaji and his family also continued this trend and cultivated a group of highly educated crooks to rule India. Today we call this group as Lootyens as they stay in an area called Lutyens in Delhi and loot us.*
*What is the change that BJP and Modi brought into politics?*
*It made jokers like me realise that IVY LEAGUE DEGREES doesn’t make you a patriot, inculcate honesty or bring goodness.*
*But people who cultivate character, personality on the basis of ethos of Culture and civilisation of India have patriotism and goodness in them*.
*Do this experiment if you don’t believe me:*
*You go into any random RSS Shaka in any part of the country and any time in the year*.
*And see what they teach those students - Patriotism, Service, Goodness, Honesty and Simplicity.*
*It is done every day and all throughout the year.*
*Tell me which Ivy League Univ, IIT, IIM, St Stephens, Doon school or any school where you pay lakhs of rupees as fees teach it?*
*I have been to world’s top Universities, have 6 degrees but no where my education taught me patriotism or goodness*.
*It is my dad who taught me and the books I read written by Swami Vivekananda or the man I idolise Shaheed Bhagat Singh who did this.*
*RSS shakhas do it for all the Sangh goers everyday. Hence people like Modi are so patriotic and honest. I don’t care if he went to school or he has MA or not.*
*A person who reads Swami Vivekanand or goes to a RSS Shaka is any day better than a crook with IIT or Harvard degree.*
*Yes that is what we need to realise.*
*Believe in your own ethos or the goodness of your own country. You will any day be better than believing in those degrees*.
Pl. READ IT 👆, ONE OF THE BEST ARTICLES, AN EYE OPENER & 💁♂️PASS To UR Grp & OTHER INDIANS.😒
🇮🇳🚩🇮🇳🚩🇮🇳🚩🇮🇳
which former IPS officer said this
Karan keeps interrupting and talking over the guest. It is getting irritating. Could not get beyond 10 min.
@Wire - you are losing viewership
Excellent grilling of Mr Dulat! Hats off to Mr Thapar! 👏👏👏👍👍👍
I only watched this interview for the former RAW head, not for the rude and unprofessional chatterbox Karan Thapar.
This was indeed a very tough interview to get information out. No other journalist except Thapar can attempt this.
Looks like the CIA funded this episode with the instruction to Thapar to harass an 83 year old RAW chief with fading memory and a short attention span, in order to try and get expert indictment against GoI, which could then be played out on pliable international media outlets to pressurise GoI further. In the bargain, apart from the sponsorship and possible kickbacks, Thapar would get his few moments of fame on international media and possible assignments in future...
As Thapar says, it appears so....
Let me know what you are smoking
@@Suresh_Kamath Thoda sarcasm bhi appreciate kiya karo... you don't need to smoke anything for that 😏
Btw, its odd that you were willing to accept Thapars tenuous conflation of facts but couldn't extend the same to me. Telling...
@hkpandey1 Sometimes you do not recognize sarcasm unless you are told🙃. My bad...
This Channel is Funded by Americans and Chinese
and funded by Indian Billionaires ( on the orders of Americans ) or else the Indian Billionaires would lose business in America.
Interview with full of pre assumptions
Dulat thinks whole world is stupid. He wants us to believe that RAW sells vegetables 😂
Or may be Pani Puri !! LOL
@@jimmybindra
Or chai-pakodas ....😁
You expected him to accept the killings behind all these terrorists are raw?
@@asdasdasdqwe123 he and Karan Thapar wanted Dulat to lay it all out for them. Absolute clowns
That's true. Vegetables it is. Why would you think otherwise. You've seen so many failures right
With Mr Thapar’s interrogation skills he could easily have been a detective 😂. It’s nerve wrecking to be interviewed by him.
Wah Modiji Wah 😂😂😂
Ajit Doval had his brag moments on TV shows in India when he talked over his almost successful organized attempt, when he was a RAW agent living incognito in Pakistan, to take out Dawood Ibrahim while the latter was on a visit to Dubai. Surely, Mr. Dulat must have been aware of that fact! How can he then pretend that “it is not our style “?
So you're fretting over gangster Dawood now?
@@manofsan Not quite, as you seem to be implying ,manofsan! Have felt the same even when the CIA of the USA was strongly suspected of having hand in the deaths of Homi Bhabha by bomb plant in plane crash &Indian PM Lal Bahadur Shastri when he was on visit at Tashkent, Uzbezkistan. Motive was preventing India from atomic bomb weapon acquisition research both were interested in. Whether one be a journalist or spy for any country these days, the key motto lies in the so called Eleventh Commandment which reads as “Thou shalt not get caught”!
@@sudhakarrao4907 - the targeting of our people today is not unlike the targeting of Homi Bhabha, and is being done with a similar geopolitical purpose of containing India. West are using their huge resources to undermine India from within and from without.
@@manofsan Agree wholeheartedly with your viewpoint , reassured after your second note addressed to me, after your personal first comment had me worried for its straying off the topic momentarily! No hard feelings from my side! Best wishes.
Well done Mr Thapar. Throughout the interview Mr Dulat was trying to beat around the bush, not directly answering Thapar's questions, trying to divert the issue the question was trying to address, frequently saying things were different during his times, and most importantly saying 'I don't know' umpteen number of times whenever he could not come up with a convincing answer. His attempt to bring in what happened in Pakistan and Kashmir and his judgement on how the system in Pakistan works etc are irrelevant to this discussion. Thapar did well in sticking to finding the truth, who, when and at what level knew happenings in India, USA and Canada, which are the sole objectives of this interview. Thapar was simply trying to logically and systematically connect the dots from information he gathered from various credible sources. In my opinion Thapar did not deviate from this position throughout the interview.
Remember, truth is higher than an individual or a nation state. Satyameva jayate.
This is an Intelligence matter, and this interview itself shouldn't have happened and it was not Thapar seeking the truth bit heckling an ex army man, which he wouldn't have dared to with any politician. Transparency is good as long as it doesn’t affect national security!
Mr Thapar always wants to find problem with Modi Govt … call it anti-modi or is it anti-national?
I recommend Indian secret services hire Mr. Karen Thapar after they watch this interview. He is interviewing an out of date confused person. As an American i feel annoyed by his assumptions.
Be it as it may the operation went bad....
This was such a great interview. Very challenging questions. I was gripped!
Poor journalism thapar saab😅😅...what r u trying to say.... CC 1
Stop interviewing someone who retried 23 years ago, everything within the agency would have changed by now. Mr. Daulat is severely out of date in terms of reference but if you are at least let him speak, this isn't supposed to be an interrogation.
Karan you tried …..But AS Dulat did not give in..also ,probably, you were dead sure that CC1 was one Mr. Goel …but AS Dulat kept his cool and surely answered most of ur questions aptly …AS Dulat 🙏
Worst thing is that being a Khalistani is not illegal in India and peacefully working for Khalistan is not illegal in India. Our government broke its own laws, how unfortunate and made us look silly globally.
being a Khalistani peacefully is legal in every democratic country
I like how A S Dulat keeps repeating that “this isn’t our policy” but doesn’t realize how far the standards have fallen since he was in service. This whole episode sounds like the movie Burn After Reading or Johnny English. Incompetence runs rapid in this govt - in all arenas.
Let me tell you something. He wasn't RAW Chief. He was just a face. They never reveal RAW chiefs or Senior employees. They only tell the fake chiefs. He was just a face. The real chiefs would never be revealed
It's same in Pakistan. The ISI chiefs you see in media are fake. The real ones are not revealed to Media
I am not able to understand why the interviewer is heckling Dulat again and again. Feel like he is not from Indian media but American media.
Karan' s questioning has been outstanding in finding facts and listing them precisely.
BS, he has no journalistic standards. he is a paid stooge for Congress
This guy won’t let his guest speak!
Mr. Thapar great information, seems your guest loves to do interviews but can’t seem to recall a lot that’s been happening or just don’t want to admit that might land him in hot soup 😂
He is ex head of R&W , these guys won’t open much, i m surprised as much as he already accepted in this interview, great journalism.
Mr Dulat, you don't have to do this to yourself. You are an honorable part of the Indian State. Don't get bullied by this Thapar. Thapar and Wire wants to hear what they want to hear. Don't bring yourself down to these clowns
he's just having fun lmao
Some one who loves his nation and knows what it takes to keep the enemy of the states at Bay, would explain to me after hearing the entire interview, as to what exactly was Karan Thapar trying to do in the entire episode. I never saw him doing such interviews with enemy of States. Possibly trying to satisfy his master's. To Karan, I would say " All that glitters to you is not Gold".
An American law has been broken by an Indian official. What part of that is not understood by you? Karan Thapar has established that the Indian Government has reached out against foreign jurisdictions and broken the law. The Indian Government is not above International Law.
Karan the guy who you are talking to is a ex intelligence officer and he is not going to tell you all.
What else do you expect from former raw chief, defending his country and organization organization
Ajit Doval may have known of it, disapproved of it and may have been ordered to keep out of it, is my guess. The ex R&AW chief's rather colourful tie was a subtle advance clue as to how this 'cross examination' would proceed. Quite educational while being as entertaining as 'Tom & Jerry'.
Mr Thapar is perfect example of “Party Before Country”.
Mr.Thapar your guest is very smartly confusing you. He will never give you more information than he should.
Being fearless doesn’t have to mean being disrespectful and rude. It’s a fine balance that eludes most 😊😊
Thapar does not take nonsense. This is a tough topic. No other journalist dare touch it.
Karan Thapar expression as if he found something and is sniffing around .He is still using his animus against Modi to further his agenda
Thapar Sahib. I have not seen a tougher interview. The guest started with denying everything but that changed pretty quickly. Kashoggi's murder was the highest profiled such a murder. What a tough interview. The guest was thoroughly professional and slippery, but did not succeed.
Poor fella, knows Indian are caught red handed but despite there being undeniable evidence he can't admit it due to obvious reasons 😂😂
Excellent interview. Poor explanations by the interviewee.
Mr Thapar -- You are trying to put words into your Guest. IF you already believe it then WHY THE INTERVIEW
Karan really screwed up this interview. Kudos to Daulat to have kept his patience so much. Somebody else would have thrown karan out.
Bhai karan kya pee ke interview karne aaye te?
'''American Pee''' Peekar Interview Kiya
I don't know why Mr. Thapar bothered inviting a guest. He already decided what he wanted to say and he just wanted the guest to say "yes" to everything. Doesn't let the man speak or actually add value to the conversation.
Kudos Karan Thapar Sir, you made the former raw chief and the raw completely naked. Our intelligence is so horrible and inept. The gentleman is clean bowled when you told him that the Americans contacted CC 1 through Gupta before the Nijjar killing, he is swallowing his own words. Very very sad. You totally out smarted our James Bonds. What a security we have !!!!
@Karan this interview is so damaging to your credibility as it seemed like you were shooting off an old veteran’s shoulder. After so many good interviews this one could irreparably damage credibility. And the poor man was forcibly pushed to provide credibility to your narration. Especially when the poor man says “this is a good interrogation”.
Samant Goel is CC1
ASDulat should remove the 'Singh' from his name .. he is obviously not
True journalism, which is missing now these days
Don't interrupt the guest every time. It's very annoying. You should let the guest say what he wants to say.
50% of any Karan Thapar interview is Karan paraphrasing his guest's responses. What a overbearing journalist
Lot of assumptions and fiction the entire way. India has so many illegal entries. 50 million plus yet nothing done about this. The corruption is high so not sure how this is even possible. The clumsiness makes me wonder.
Earlier this year I read Mr. AS Daulat's memoir; A life in the shadows. Based on my observation, the ex RAW chief is upfront, ingenious, indulgent at the same time with easy going persona. It will be interesting to have a chit chat with him over a cup of tea especially at this age. Looks like he still has more insights yet to reveal in the game of spy operations.
He's done
This is not an interview, its a heckling session
Veteran Intelligence Chief let Karan Thapar posture up as an interrogative, tough guy without giving him any content to flash. Critical issues of Intelligence, Diplomacy and Foreign Affairs cannot be assessed, analysed or discussed applying the same scale of rationality that is applicable to routine administrative and social-political issues. Mr. Dulat is very impressive, inspiring.
Bcz he's not real former RAW chief. They never give real names in public. They appoint fake chiefs for public and he's one of those fake chiefs. Real ones are never revealed to Public and media
KT seems overbearing. The guest is very polite.
There are biases in every media groups...The Wire and Godi media are just same in terms of their biases...one will say anything to get bakt views..and other will go and do anything to get anti bakt views..why can't there be some objectivity...call a spade a spade. I find The Print and Brakha Dutt's show a little more objective in this regard..they go after Modi ,but they also praise policies if they like..really disappointed by The Wire..they should not have made a name public just based on rumors.
Everything is not black and white...there is a lot more Gray area.
Indian media is worse and worse day by day...Godi media and The Wire live in their own alternate world.
Print?
Please check what shekhar guptas involvement in the fake army coup case of 2013. He spread propaganda that indian army was launching a coup againt government of india.
We sab bike hue hai, 😀
It seems like Karan Thapar is a fanboy of Trudeau. He speaks with a hatred of his own country and I am saying this not because of any prejudice. Look how he gets agitated when the interviewee tries to raise questions regarding the Canadian government's claims and treats the interviewee, in this case a veteran of his own country, as if he is dumb. This is a debate, not an interview. When we are watching an interview, we want to hear what the interviewee has to say, not the interviewer. The start was so good, but as it progressed, it got irritating sometimes as all I could hear was Karan Thapar's voice, which I am not interested in. I wanted to hear what AS Dulat, someone far more knowledgeable had to say.
Stop begging for money each video
You are talking too much Mr Thapar, during the interview.
Why do sanghi bhakts hate questions being asked?
This’s an excellent interview. I must salute Karan for the perseverance with which he pursued with his incisive questions.
It’s pleasure watching an interview where the interviewer was virtually ‘interrogating’ a senior retired super cop.
I must the appreciate the professional commitments of both Karan and Amarjit Dullet.Great 👍
Sirji, is an interview supposed to be a fact finding mission or interrogation session? And what do you get from interrogating a retired RAW chief? What a useless piece of crap Karan Thapar is. He is advancing his theory instead of fact finding. First he says he doesnt want to talk about Canada and then he keeps bringing in Canada when it is convenient
India's competence, purely in display, in this interview...
Mr Thaper, great interview.
Showing the true colours of Indian intelligence who is looking to switch sides for money and safety. Showing how the government is prepared to go all out against minorities.
I will go ahead and donate for the first time.
KhalistanTaliban are themselves communalist separatists. They are no secularists. Congress chamcha Karan Thapar now going to bat for them seems to have forgotten who murdered Indira Gandhi. It shows how Congress has replaced Nehru-Gandhi family with Maino family.
Mr Thapar , please let other man to speak, pls listen to this video & see how many minutes you have talked 😮😮😮
@karan why do you do interviews filled with little fact and conjecture quizzing someone who has retired 23 years ago as a credible interviewee of RAW operations. I hope what they did 23 years ago is not relevant in todays context of intelligence. Either he is an old friend lending you a hand or you can’t get anyone else credible for an interview, both are quite indicting. It’s sad that a subject of intelligence is so lacking in it.
Karan thapar has done an interrogation rather than an interview .interrogations for helping the US to get a clear picture of the matter ,🙏 in hindi we says "घर के भेदी "😢
Yes. And I fail to understand why nobody is questioning the US on actions taken on Pannum (and his organisation) for the blatant threats to India, Indian citizens and various other activities against India. Why is the media and Mr KT silent on that?
Do you believe the wattsapp gyan and twiiter propaganda so easily and discredit multiple visits by all intelligence agencies, heads of states(US, Canada), US being friends with China again and Indian agencies closing in all 5 eyes countries, very possibly FATF grey list coming ?
Really? I really do not understand what parallel world do Indians live in? Or the propaganda by India so bad?@@rajivraghavan49
Thapar is cross examining and badgering Dulat not interviewing him..... Worst showing ever!!! Thapar is making a spectacle of himself.
Mr Dullat laughter at end makes this master piece interview more excellent
*Karan Thapar Seems More of an Advocate from Canadian and American side, Rather than a Journalist based in India*
Professionally , Doctors , Engineers and journalists are Ctizen of whole world .
A Doctor can bring relief to a patient of any country . A journalist can ask a question of anybody .
But some idiots are not aware of it .
Mr Thapar be clever enough to understand, Mr Quatra's letter is fake.
The point really is, can we believe that our Intelligence agencies, will tell us whatever they actually do? Of course not.
Point is if you won't believe your own, you should definitely not be believing America's either.
I am getting feeling from this interview that if this ex indian intelligent chief can be this much foolish then why not CC1
This Is probably the worst Story or Covert Operation planned By R&AW...
I'm Sure it is made up story by USA
just like Salman khan movie Tiger Zinda Hai...where R&AW & ISI working together 😂 ...
If R&AW wants to plan a operation, they never leave a single trace of it..... & who uses Technology
to carry Covert Operation.....
& Normal text messaging App to Chat ??
& America CIA is Still coming out of its failures of 1998 pokhran nuclear tests & Article 370 abrogation in 2019.....
😂😂😂
Great interview! Very enjoyable and very informative! Thank you!
Now this is called proper police grilling . Interrogator sticking to one sentence 😂
I love listening to KT but he can be many times, irritatingly intrusive , super imposing his own thoughts over his guests and in a way killing the interview and what we want to learn from the expert - he simply dilutes the effect. I suspect if he continues in this vein, many of us will disconnect from him and his channel
The interview is proceeding in a very irritating format. Mr Doval is not a schoolboy. Let him say it the way he considers appropriate.
Wonderful interview, full praise to both of you
I don’t understand why Dulat was interviewed. A report from KT of his own findings should have been good enough . Dulat didn’t add anything to what KT already knew.
At the end of the day,Karan entrapped Mr Dulat!
Thanks
For anyone questioning KT's interrogation style, my question is 'is there any other way to question ex-RnAW chief's?' If KT would have been "nice" and agreeable would Mr. Dulat have been so uncomfortable. This is a matter of security and intelligence and these people are trained to not give up evidence, lie and deceive. All we are left with 'what-ifs' and attempting to even addressing these 'what-ifs' could lead to nowhere.
But in conclusion, yes KT was a bit too harsh with the questions and atleast he should have listened more before asking the next question.