Hindi imposition, Feminism, and the illusion of Equality
Вставка
- Опубліковано 26 тра 2023
- Vimoh Live is a bi-weekly call-in show where I talk with callers about religion, culture, and atheism.
Support the channel by clicking the JOIN button and becoming a member.
Or become a patron at / vimoh
Or make a one-time donation at vimoh.stck.me
Want to create live streams like this? Check out StreamYard: streamyard.com/pal/d/61809340... - Розваги
You challenged Hindi imposition so well, Vimoh! Thank you from a South Indian.
He is also an Odia
@@ashwinvk4124odisha doesn't come in South india tho
@@playerjack2566 I know but hindi imposition is not just about South India
@@ashwinvk4124 yeah
Hindi too is not a uniform language,, hindi ( khadi)is actually newest language,,,, haryanvi, braj,rajasthani, bhojpuri gharwali, kumaoni, ,, which form of hindi to be used, i m hindi native speaker
Excellent chat about cow urine at 55:00. What Vimoh said about how the people who propagate cow urine don’t drink it themselves but suggest it to everyone (especially the poor ones) - is exactly what I saw around me. Disgusting behaviour during covid times.
There are other aspects of cow urine too, i have used it for skin diseases and it has worked.
I ll do a video call on telegram and ll apply it on my skin. And it has helped. You dont need to believe it but yes it works.
The Unbiased One forgets that before independence all the federal states were independent princely states. So all languages except the local one would be foreign to each state. The only language which was common across the princely states was English.
The unbiased one is most biased one on language 😂
मेरे मन में जो topic आ रहा था उसी पर discussion हो गया, बेहतरीन विमोह जी|
Excellent points! Indians common language is English not Hindi… otherwise we won’t be outsourcing human resource all over the world. The issue we face is not language but political issue…. is how this government is restricting all general exam and forms like tax Ect to be filed in Hindi… let’s try to address right problems which is what will provide right answers
Great I have listened your channel name on Science Journey Sir's youtube channel "Rational World". Great keep it up. I wish to see you and science journey sir sitting togather in live stream.
LOVE AND APPRECIATE YOUR WORK VIMOH..
TO MY UTTER SURPRISE
MR AMIT TIWARI JI APPEARS OUTTA NO WHERE IN THE LAST😮
HE IS LIKE A FLYING REAPER AND COLLECTS SOULS OF THOSE WHO SPREAD MISINFORMATION AND HATE😅😂😂😂..
1:19:13 excellent thought,, constructivism ki theory ki baat karre bhai ap, nice👌
People talk about Hindi imposition but also a large number of people despise and hate on those who speak English well in our country because they never grew up in environments where they could learn English with native fluency (in a cognitive sense), and hence they talk about English imposition too. The latter group of people want you to be good at Hindi rather than English which would close you off to a lot of the world (just like the Chinese who mostly stick to their own internal social media). I'm very happy I learnt English well and have been speaking it with native fluency since I was a child. It has enabled me to interact with and even make close friendships with so many people even from outside our country and it enabled me to escape the orthodoxy of my rural family. But someone like me will also never be fully accepted in India (nor in other countries). English-fluent Indians are a cursed lot. Sometimes though, I do feel like life would have been better if I spoke toota-phoota angreji, perhaps just enough of it to professionally work and not well enough to be resented. Those are the people who survive best here.
I’ve come across comments which say “English is being imposed, education is being denied to natives; in Europe they learn in their native language” and then going onto degrading Indian English speakers by calling us "pajeets", "kanjras", "macaulay ke bacche" etc. We have a Hindi vaala PM, Hindi vaala CM, Malayalam medium ISRO chief, people like Laxmi Niwas Mittal are from Hindi medium, in my own family I have Telugu medium educated people who reached high positions in the government and private sector, CBSE provides courses in both Hindi and English medium, UPSC is available in Hindi and English medium, private companies like Zerodha provide their stock trading courses in both Hindi and English, most content in India on UA-cam is in vernacular languages, outside Tier-1 and the larger Tier-2 cities most correspondence is in vernacular languages, most parliamentary debates are in vernacular languages, there are a number of news channels in Hindi: Aaj Tak, ABP News, India TV, NDTV India, News18 India, TV9 Bharatvarsh, Zee News, DB Live, BBC News Hindi, News 24. I’ve talked to plenty of Europeans and once they get to the level of degrees, they learn in a combination of both English and their home language. The “English imposition” guys just speak out of resentment and jealousy. I am an Indian too. I want to learn new things in English. That’s cognitively my strongest language. Not Hindi, Telugu, Bangla etc. Highly vernacular areas in India with poor English fluency are some of the most rustic and socially backward parts of the country. Just see the crap in Hindi media compared to English channels. Accusing those who can speak fluent English of "denying knowledge to others" is like blind people accusing sighted people for them not being able to see. You are free to access all the knowledge that is there in languages you understand. Don't blame us for being able to access knowledge that's in English because you don't know the language yourself. You are free to learn English.
You said your Native language is odia. It was unexpected you're somewhere from Odisha. I am so happy to heard that. Bdw i am from kalahandi. Bahut khushir katha😁
Thanks for speaking up about non-Hindi-speaking Indians! Hindi imperialism just irritates me so much. so many North Indians gave up their languages because they were shamed into it, and now they expect us in the south to do the same?? Instead of parroting stuff about how Hindi is India's national language etc etc, why don't they ask themselves why they don't fight for their own languages?!
hindi imposition is bad.
and why are you assuming northies have left there languages and not defending them. Which language do you think is not there coz northies have not defended them?
See its all about economics, the time economy ll grow in that part of north, the pride with religion ll come back. Moreover those areas are too imp for politics of lok sabha and hence they ll always be more in news. so take things with a pinch of salt.
@@voiddoingnothing5266 bhojpuri, braj awadhi , haryanvi all these languages got no recognition as sperate languages. they all combined it and said it is dialects of Hindi which is not true.
@@booksanimeenthusiast3802 enthu bro, you seem a sensible guy, but now you are confusing imposition with recognition.
Both are different and i can talk about recognition too, but lets stick to imposition now, no awadhi speaker has been asked to say that speak hindi we dont accept awadhi.
@@voiddoingnothing5266 I get it that in north it is not imposed like they do it in south because southern language are already recognised ,so they impose Hindi over there.
In north side they have very clearly sideline these language in favour of Hindi long before people had ability to fight over this. Even today they are still not capable of doing anything. Soon these language will be gone as new generation speaks Hindi .
@@booksanimeenthusiast3802 bhai yaar jane do. Whatever you are saying ll never happen. But still if people want to cry they can cry. I have written the makn crux in earlier tweet only. Make awadhi people rich they ll use there local lingo more, make bhojpuri econ strong and they ll talk to each other in bhojpuri. These languages ll never go away, you think bhojpuri awadhi ll go away and bundelkhadi ll go Away, never.
Other part south of india, leave that apart currently south has more strength and economically more sound they ll say things. Wait for 30 40 years. Things ll change.
Hindi to me is as foreign as English. I better learn English instead of Hindi so that I can communicate with people all over the world.
8:00 Vasudhaiva Kutumbakam is a Buddhist doctrine. Later stolen by Brahmanism aka Hinduism.
Bro can I have some sources please.
Source ??? Moreover shit can't be stolen.. it's just a buncha words, it's not like a particular language belongs to any religion or something... 2000 yrs back even theists spoke sanskrit...and atheists spoke sanskrit as well cuz they live in the same place. It's just a language 😂
@@NeKo19113 yeah source is necessary. Buddhism was preached in languages like pali-prakrit.
We are taught by Hinduism to ‘cut the buttocks of the Shudra who dares to sit in the presence of a Brahman’ . Which is a “PERFECT” division of labour!
But if you look at the image of ‘Brahma and the origins of caste’, ‘Shudras’ ( who are born to just do jobs like street sweepers or toilet cleaners) are part of Brahma’s feet.
It means they are part of Brahma’s lowest area. If their buttocks are cut (obviously with a sharp knife or sword in public) then how Brahma will walk without his feet’s buttocks? I am really confused here because it is a serious matter for Brahma becoming paralyzed.
Brahma is didn't think this one through cz thinking ain't his strong suit.
Certain geographies in bhaarath are exempt from such smritis as they have different interpretations
@@-_.0O The Manusmriti is very clear so no interpretation is needed. It is the only law book of Hinduism. That is why Dr. Ambedkar wanted to get rid of it. But he failed so he change his relgion to Buddhism. If you are an Indian and Hindu then you need to save your buttocks from Brahmins. Because even Brahma cannot save his own buttocks. And if you are Shudra and untouchable, then don't try to teach Vedas to any Brahmin. Please take care of your buttocks!
@@cauliflowerhead2735 What language you are writing in?
religious ppl be like: one day they will act benign.. donate... spread good thought
next day: they are having mutton and chicken party with alcohol.
@1:18:40 Why it is wrong to compartmentalise and cherry-pick JP ? He definitely has lot of good things offer. In any case, I will not find a single person who will be aligned with every element of my world view.
North indians getting imperialistic,, courtesy rss
The unbiased one does not understand the meaning of the word "foreign ".