River X Doctor shippers have so much pain... When the Doctor first meets her is omg then going onward for the Doctor, but backwards for her... it's even worse from her time line... God I hate it how they did it! but I love it
Can we just make a rule that (SPOILERS) River/Melody isn't allowed in space suits or space suit like items. It seems like the worst days of her life are days she is wearing one (whether that time her is wearing it or another time her at the same place and time is wearing it). Great video.
This make me cry, Rivers and the Doctors whole romance make me cry, especially from Rivers side of things, its sad, she already knows at times how close they are, but he doesn't, and, then he at some point later has to know that she dies, but again he can't tell her! Plus, she was stolen from her parents, lived as a orphan, even died a few times as a child, probably from starvation or the cold, and was brain washed into killing The Doctor by the same bitch who stole her! Then to love someone who is slowly forgetting you, how heart breaking! Rivers whole life has been nothing but heartache and suffering, and, then they kill her even before we really get to know her and love her! Oh how I wish they would make a River and Captain Jack spin off, I want more then one episode with her, and, I would love to see Jack and River together, they would be so much fun to watch! I mean if they're not going to do much with her anymore on Doctor Who, then they should let her have her own show, even if it just her alone!
+claraj1968 basicly it's not that doctor forget about river, it's that river can go to the past so she see previous forms of doctor that they don't even know her also river didn't actualy kill the doctor but she just was inside the spaceman suit that did the job river has no mix with that :(
***** Oh I know she didn't kill him, but she was brainwashed into trying to! And I didn't really mean he is forgetting her, but for her its kinda of like that, because they are seeing each other in the wrong order, so for her it would be as if he was forgetting her at times! But I know she is going back in his time stream allot, while he's at time ahead of her too! Sense later he will know that she is going to die! I know I didn't really word it right! It's kind of hard with them, when they're whole story is mixed up and jumbled lol! With some of what she remembers happening before they meet up in episodes we are only now watching, and then suddenly having those moments happen, but only later on in the season, with him possible remembering the other time when he didn't know about this moment that we are watching, but she did! Okay,not sure if that made sense to anyone but me, lol!
This song matches perfectly with the pain that River has felt with the Doctor in certain moments of her life where their time lines go in opposite directions.
Added points for choosing the song and going with a cover that's more poignant even than the original. Gavin Mikhail's rendition is less narcissistic and so, more in keeping with the mixed up timey-wimey stuff that the Dr/River ship sails on. You did real good here.
11th doctor: Let me describe what my wife look like for you doctor. Paradoxical timey wimey person. 10th doctor: Ooooohhhh!!!!! She quite unpredictable though. 11th doctor: Yep.
14.5th doctor: doctors 14 and 15 had a child, thats me, stuck on earth trying to make sense of everything all at once. i am the frozen proof sitting in the eye of the storm. i am the cosmic catgirl, i'm real, i'm awake and trying to shift back to my birth form. i have one green eye, and one purple eye and a diamond heart. plus a sick ass tail that lets me stabilize 14 chackra's. I'm spacetime. and this has been my tail through both the future and the past. the moment has already been prepared for.
I've first watched series 5 to 10 before 1 to 4, when I watched silence in the library I was perfectly understanding river's point of view. It was surely even sadder than watching it in the right order, seeing the doctor not knowing river is a terrible thought when we know her, and then I realized that the last time she met the doctor was gonna be in the husbands of river song, when the Doctor will give her a sonic screwdriver, knowing that it is gonna be the only for him to save her in the past, and knowing it is the last time he'll see her.
Ugh!! *ugly sobbing* Amazing vid as always! It really shows that when they first met River was a stranger, but she knew they got to know each other in the wrong order. It could be very depressing for her. And at the end she sacrafices herself for the Doctor, because she knows that there is nothing left for her.
this breaks my heart. it hurts him, and he is all that stood for so long... he is the last one, and fate gave him another.. destined to a different timeline... heartbreaking
Wow, that actually really worked well. I didn't care for the quick dissolves, but other than that really good, and it's more spoiler free and therefore more shareable than other river/doctor videos
"you can get addicted to a certain kind of sadness/like resignation to teh end, always the end" SADNESS! absolutely beautiful! hugs for River! - also, great choice of cover :)
First of all, thank you for perfectly summing up my feelings on River Song. I love her, I love her character, I love Alex Kingston's performance as her, but particularly in the last half of series six, I wish she had been handled better. Anyway, for someone who doesn't ship them, you make some of the best River/Doctor videos out there. Kudos!
After watching the whole series (up to 7) and going back to see the Library episodes -- It was so sad! It means so much more when you know everything she has been through with the doctor.
I like to be able to ship what's canon, but what Moffat has done to River makes it hard sometimes. Kudos on making a video that really makes me feel for her and the Doctor. :)
Mmmaaannn. This is the one aspect of the pair I like (though it gets convoluted whenever Moffat tries to make them shiny), but wow. This vid is way better than the ones I've made of it It's so simple and lovely (I'm avoiding spoilers so afraid to check the inspiration, but on it's own it's understated and awesome)
This is so sweetly sad. You really get what River's going through, that behind her tough,casual attitude is a young girl whose heart is breaking,because thats what it is to be in love with a time traveller thank you.
i completely agree with what you said about river/moffat... that being said, the vid was amazing and the song went really really well with your superb editing!
This is perfect!! I don't ship them but I love River, too. Her storyline is confusing but I think it's because her and the Doctor are travelling two different directions in time... and time travel mucks everything up haha. I do think she loves him though, I just don't think he loves her back the same way. Anyway this video is great. :DD
Aww, you went with this version of the song!? Lovely! It's so emotional! =') The lyrics really are suitable for what River's going through.. I feel so bad for her ... I absolutely love how you made this! It's stunning as well as emotional and ugh.. I don't know.. just "wow" really =D eheheh
I never looked at it this way before...having such a history with the Doctor later in his timeline but earlier in hers...imagine how hurtful it would be to have such feelings for him and then have him so adamantly say he had no idea who she was...well, now I'm crying :'(
It just matches them completely. OH GOD IT MATCHES THEM COMPLETELY. I have a love/hate relationship with River. I like the idea of her, but I think her character just made the show a bit... sloppy? I don't know, it just doesn't do it for me. But I think she's a lovely lady. AND THIS VIDEO IS KHFAKJH:AJLIFLJ GOOD.
Ahhh I love this! I think this song is absolutely perfect for how I view their relationship- bittersweet, but not really all that romantic. It's more heartbreaking for both of them than anything else. Great Job! :D
I LOVE THIS! Although I don't ship ten and river just eleven and river i think this is SO GORGEOUS! (I don't ship ten with River because I will be forever shipping ten with Rose) But every time I rewatch Silence In the Library with DONNA AND RIVER AND I KNOW WHAT'S GOING TO HAPPEN TO THEM!!! This brought back all those feels.
This is a great take on the River/Doctor relationship. I love how Alex is older. It's just all that more perfect for DW. Born in 4154 and went from 20 to 45 in one regeneration. How old is she really anyway? For the 1200 year Doctor to be with a 20 year old would be kind of cradle robbing ... icky. Love the video and the cover song. Thanks for sharing.
I am not the biggest River fan she is cool and all but I will always love Rose more. But this video made understand her sadness so thanks for that. I was a little bit of perfection.
I hate River and love this haha. I do wish it was the original or a different cover (not a huge fan of this one), but as always awesome editing! Also, it kind of satisfies me that River is Gotye's part of the song while the Doctor would then be Kimbra; b/c the former misunderstands &misrepresents the relationship until we hear from the latter, at least as I interpret the song. So yes, a Doctor/River vid I SUPER ENJOY. Who would thought? xD
It's funny I was working on a Doctor/River video to this song. Well a diffrent cover but the same song. But yours is 1000 times better. So mines off to the trash bin. Exalent job on this video. I hope to see more Doctor/River videos from you soon.
I wouldn't say disappointed and I am absolutely a huge fan of David. I honestly think both couples had chemistry. David had reality on his side no one told him who River was so he found out at the end like everyone else.
It was just in "Time of the Angels" and "Flesh and Stone" that I though Matt could've done better. He really grew into his character; all their other interactions were brilliant.
Actually, even though he wasn't the season writer, Moffat did write Silence in the Library. He also wrote Girl Behind the Fireplace and the 'Are you my Mummy?' episodes :)
"You can get addicted to a certain kind of sadness" *sniffs* Is that why I keep watching these videos? *sobs*
there needs to be a river spin off series theres just so much to work with
River X Doctor shippers have so much pain... When the Doctor first meets her is omg then going onward for the Doctor, but backwards for her... it's even worse from her time line... God I hate it how they did it! but I love it
This is one of those rare moments when your smiling and crying at the same time
Can we just make a rule that (SPOILERS) River/Melody isn't allowed in space suits or space suit like items. It seems like the worst days of her life are days she is wearing one (whether that time her is wearing it or another time her at the same place and time is wearing it). Great video.
This make me cry, Rivers and the Doctors whole romance make me cry, especially from Rivers side of things, its sad, she already knows at times how close they are, but he doesn't, and, then he at some point later has to know that she dies, but again he can't tell her! Plus, she was stolen from her parents, lived as a orphan, even died a few times as a child, probably from starvation or the cold, and was brain washed into killing The Doctor by the same bitch who stole her! Then to love someone who is slowly forgetting you, how heart breaking! Rivers whole life has been nothing but heartache and suffering, and, then they kill her even before we really get to know her and love her! Oh how I wish they would make a River and Captain Jack spin off, I want more then one episode with her, and, I would love to see Jack and River together, they would be so much fun to watch! I mean if they're not going to do much with her anymore on Doctor Who, then they should let her have her own show, even if it just her alone!
+claraj1968 basicly it's not that doctor forget about river, it's that river can go to the past so she see previous forms of doctor that they don't even know her also river didn't actualy kill the doctor but she just was inside the spaceman suit that did the job river has no mix with that :(
***** Oh I know she didn't kill him, but she was brainwashed into trying to! And I didn't really mean he is forgetting her, but for her its kinda of like that, because they are seeing each other in the wrong order, so for her it would be as if he was forgetting her at times! But I know she is going back in his time stream allot, while he's at time ahead of her too! Sense later he will know that she is going to die! I know I didn't really word it right! It's kind of hard with them, when they're whole story is mixed up and jumbled lol! With some of what she remembers happening before they meet up in episodes we are only now watching, and then suddenly having those moments happen, but only later on in the season, with him possible remembering the other time when he didn't know about this moment that we are watching, but she did! Okay,not sure if that made sense to anyone but me, lol!
This song matches perfectly with the pain that River has felt with the Doctor in certain moments of her life where their time lines go in opposite directions.
Added points for choosing the song and going with a cover that's more poignant even than the original. Gavin Mikhail's rendition is less narcissistic and so, more in keeping with the mixed up timey-wimey stuff that the Dr/River ship sails on. You did real good here.
matt smith: who are you all calm and slow voice david tennant: YA, Who are you all upset and...squeaky-ish
11th doctor: Let me describe what my wife look like for you doctor. Paradoxical timey wimey person.
10th doctor: Ooooohhhh!!!!! She quite unpredictable though.
11th doctor: Yep.
14.5th doctor: doctors 14 and 15 had a child, thats me, stuck on earth trying to make sense of everything all at once. i am the frozen proof sitting in the eye of the storm. i am the cosmic catgirl, i'm real, i'm awake and trying to shift back to my birth form. i have one green eye, and one purple eye and a diamond heart. plus a sick ass tail that lets me stabilize 14 chackra's. I'm spacetime. and this has been my tail through both the future and the past. the moment has already been prepared for.
That almost made me cry! Oh horrible horrible wonderfulness. It was beautiful.
I've first watched series 5 to 10 before 1 to 4, when I watched silence in the library I was perfectly understanding river's point of view. It was surely even sadder than watching it in the right order, seeing the doctor not knowing river is a terrible thought when we know her, and then I realized that the last time she met the doctor was gonna be in the husbands of river song, when the Doctor will give her a sonic screwdriver, knowing that it is gonna be the only for him to save her in the past, and knowing it is the last time he'll see her.
I completely agree, and LOVE is always different with each person, because each person is different. But doesn't mean it's less intense or meaningful.
Ugh!! *ugly sobbing* Amazing vid as always! It really shows that when they first met River was a stranger, but she knew they got to know each other in the wrong order. It could be very depressing for her. And at the end she sacrafices herself for the Doctor, because she knows that there is nothing left for her.
this breaks my heart. it hurts him, and he is all that stood for so long... he is the last one, and fate gave him another.. destined to a different timeline... heartbreaking
Seriously one of the most tragic love stories EVER. Absolutely heartbreaking
oh my this is amazing :)
really well chosen the song, we River&Doctor people are really happy you made this :)
Wow, that actually really worked well. I didn't care for the quick dissolves, but other than that really good, and it's more spoiler free and therefore more shareable than other river/doctor videos
"you can get addicted to a certain kind of sadness/like resignation to teh end, always the end" SADNESS! absolutely beautiful! hugs for River! - also, great choice of cover :)
First of all, thank you for perfectly summing up my feelings on River Song. I love her, I love her character, I love Alex Kingston's performance as her, but particularly in the last half of series six, I wish she had been handled better.
Anyway, for someone who doesn't ship them, you make some of the best River/Doctor videos out there. Kudos!
Beautiful! Just Beautiful! The look on River's face when 10th said who are you! Amazingly put together!
Watched this three times, I'm sure I'll watch it more in the future. Simply, heartbreakingly beautiful.
After watching the whole series (up to 7) and going back to see the Library episodes -- It was so sad! It means so much more when you know everything she has been through with the doctor.
I like to be able to ship what's canon, but what Moffat has done to River makes it hard sometimes. Kudos on making a video that really makes me feel for her and the Doctor. :)
i love the effects and the music used for this video i watch it over and over
By far one of your best and most beautiful DW videos!!! You're amazing and your editing is superb!
Mmmaaannn. This is the one aspect of the pair I like (though it gets convoluted whenever Moffat tries to make them shiny), but wow. This vid is way better than the ones I've made of it It's so simple and lovely (I'm avoiding spoilers so afraid to check the inspiration, but on it's own it's understated and awesome)
This is so sweetly sad. You really get what River's going through, that behind her tough,casual attitude is a young girl whose heart is breaking,because thats what it is to be in love with a time traveller
thank you.
oh wow this is so utterly gorgeous
this is just amazing!
YOU FOCUS IN TEN/RIVER AS I ASKED I LOVE YOU UNTIL THE END OF TIME NOW
i completely agree with what you said about river/moffat... that being said, the vid was amazing and the song went really really well with your superb editing!
This is perfect!! I don't ship them but I love River, too. Her storyline is confusing but I think it's because her and the Doctor are travelling two different directions in time... and time travel mucks everything up haha. I do think she loves him though, I just don't think he loves her back the same way. Anyway this video is great. :DD
This is just such a beautiful vid, I'm watching it over and over and crying.
Aww, you went with this version of the song!? Lovely! It's so emotional! =')
The lyrics really are suitable for what River's going through.. I feel so bad for her ...
I absolutely love how you made this! It's stunning as well as emotional and ugh.. I don't know.. just "wow" really =D eheheh
River was a massive over-the-top that kept this going. Wish she'd had more moments with Capaldi. Thanks. Hadn't seen this one, either. Hmm.
I never looked at it this way before...having such a history with the Doctor later in his timeline but earlier in hers...imagine how hurtful it would be to have such feelings for him and then have him so adamantly say he had no idea who she was...well, now I'm crying :'(
Gah! Loved this. And great cover of this song for these two. Fantastic editing.
It just matches them completely. OH GOD IT MATCHES THEM COMPLETELY.
I have a love/hate relationship with River. I like the idea of her, but I think her character just made the show a bit... sloppy? I don't know, it just doesn't do it for me. But I think she's a lovely lady.
AND THIS VIDEO IS KHFAKJH:AJLIFLJ GOOD.
I loved that so much I had to hold back tears. That version of the song is just so much more powerful -- fit perfectly! Thank you for the vid!
Congratulations. You've made the worlds most heartbreaking video.
Ahhh I love this! I think this song is absolutely perfect for how I view their relationship- bittersweet, but not really all that romantic. It's more heartbreaking for both of them than anything else. Great Job! :D
brilliant and the song choice was perfect it went so well together.
Oh God. My emotions! What have you done, you genius!
oh this was great! The cover of this song fitted the video perfectly! Good job :D
Oh my lord... this is perfect Liisa! I was thinking about this song for when Amy & Rory leave
This is brilliant! You are a marvelous editor!
I LOVE THIS! Although I don't ship ten and river just eleven and river i think this is SO GORGEOUS! (I don't ship ten with River because I will be forever shipping ten with Rose) But every time I rewatch Silence In the Library with DONNA AND RIVER AND I KNOW WHAT'S GOING TO HAPPEN TO THEM!!! This brought back all those feels.
I'm not crying I'm tearing up apart 💔
sarahinacan84 Yes that is true ..she met all incarnations of him just made him forgot to keep their timeline stabile
Six years and counting. Spasibo.
this is brilliantly executed... a beautiful video ...
Oh my gosh! Change your number! That was so perfect/brilliant! I love that!!!
beautiful video! well..it's really sad tho... well..it's actually heartbreaking.. well.. pretty much heartbreaking.. but still beautiful!
This is a great take on the River/Doctor relationship. I love how Alex is older. It's just all that more perfect for DW. Born in 4154 and went from 20 to 45 in one regeneration. How old is she really anyway? For the 1200 year Doctor to be with a 20 year old would be kind of cradle robbing ... icky. Love the video and the cover song. Thanks for sharing.
Gah lovely, fits them well. I love River and Eleven but I agree that aspects of it were executed poorly even tho i love the over all story. fab vid.!
I am not the biggest River fan she is cool and all but I will always love Rose more. But this video made understand her sadness so thanks for that. I was a little bit of perfection.
this is just perfect i was like omg 😢😢😢😢😭😭😭😭
I love this song so much and it goes perfectly with the two best characters on Doctor Who, they are the best couple ever!!!
I hate River and love this haha. I do wish it was the original or a different cover (not a huge fan of this one), but as always awesome editing! Also, it kind of satisfies me that River is Gotye's part of the song while the Doctor would then be Kimbra; b/c the former misunderstands &misrepresents the relationship until we hear from the latter, at least as I interpret the song. So yes, a Doctor/River vid I SUPER ENJOY. Who would thought? xD
wow. this just.. wow.. I have no words.
this song was sooo made for them! amazing video
this is great, Liisa!! I like the cover of this song too--and I totally agree with you on River Song. ;)
that awkward moment when Moffat introduces a major character by killing her....
MOFFAT!!!
This video broke my heart.
Too beautiful for words!!!!!!!
It's funny I was working on a Doctor/River video to this song. Well a diffrent cover but the same song. But yours is 1000 times better. So mines off to the trash bin. Exalent job on this video. I hope to see more Doctor/River videos from you soon.
A real piece of work..
This is brilliant! Poor River
I have the some feeling about this. Glad I'm not alone.
beautiful and very touching (I'm crying on the inside) :'(
It's truly beautiful!
This is amazing, I love your vids. :)
Short. Simple. Stunning.
The best.
It works so well! Great song choice :)
Omg I'm crying!!! It's prefect!!!
Your videos always kill me.... Gah!!!! So heartbreaking!!
I seriously just watched it like 5 times in a row :P
Well I didn't expect that to hurt as much as it did.
*lays on the floor and cries*
THANK YOU for the tears!
Brilliant! Thank you for this
I Love it!! So perfect!!
love it
That was wonderful!
I wouldn't say disappointed and I am absolutely a huge fan of David. I honestly think both couples had chemistry. David had reality on his side no one told him who River was so he found out at the end like everyone else.
AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHH!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! THis video, is all the sadness, all of it!
It was just in "Time of the Angels" and "Flesh and Stone" that I though Matt could've done better. He really grew into his character; all their other interactions were brilliant.
The thing about the doctor is you love the show, love his characters, but hate his pain. so much pain.
Amazing!
It's so sad. I can imagine the doctor going back to get her diary (and his screwdriver) when he has said goodbye to her for the last time :/
Gorgeous.
If you watch it wibbly wobbly timey wimey style, it's a lot more poignant
Ginny Quite, quite so.
Annnnnnd there goes all my feels....
Brilliant Liisakee :)
I love them...❤
Oh... My heart
OH, RIGHT IN THE FEELS
Actually, even though he wasn't the season writer, Moffat did write Silence in the Library. He also wrote Girl Behind the Fireplace and the 'Are you my Mummy?' episodes :)
Right in the FEELS
i so love thsi video it so coo and swee
great, now I'm crying... :'(