I loved the video! also I kept getting distracted by the chonky cat vibing to the point where u were talking with your hands while holding them😂 10/10 love fnaf and it makes it even better watching cats be adorable! ❤ this is why I love ur videos!
I love your theroy but I have one complaint the person from fnaf 6 comes back and he says that your getting trained for different jobs like health and safety as well as fizzy faz manager so it means that your getting trained for the job and your not in a game or anything like that
Just want to add one thing to your idea about Carnie being a rebuilt Lefty. Look at the shot at 13:50 of Fazerblast, and see who is blocking Dreadbears arm from moving...
Did Henry start Fall Fest and Afton burned it down to buy Henry out for cheap? That might be “the wound first afflicted on me” destroying Henry’s business, possibly even killing someone Henry cared about. I also love the irony of Afton’s crimes starting and ending with fire.
I don’t think anything has ever been said about Henry’s wife existing, so it could potentially be that she could have been lost in the fire? I don’t know timeline stuff so I don’t know if that would have any bearing on children’s birth years, but something like that could be up William’s alley if there was a good reason for him to think it would work to buy out Henry. Plus maybe there could be something that triggers the Remnant experiments idea? Wasn’t one of the issues with certain timelines being that there was no reason to have William looking into this stuff with murders so early on? Maybe him figuring something out happened here, or something.
In the fnaf 3 level,we’re attacked by something representative of William after burning the place down. To me,it would suggest William is angry about the Fallfest fire. Plus,William isn’t associated with fire. At least not causing them. Henry is and Charlie is just as likely as Mike to have burnt down fnaf 3. If anything,it’d be the other way around
Wait, what if it was Sammy (Charlie's twin brother from the books) and that's why he's never referenced in the games. but also, if it was him and you believe in Dual Process's theory then that means there where (at least) 7 people who died at Fazbear's Locations within the span of a few months which begs the question... HOW THE HELL WHERE THEY ABLE TO OPEN AT LEAST 5 MORE LOCATIONS WHICH HAD A MINIMUM OF 21 DIFFERENT DEATHS!!!!!!
The old lore doesn't need changing. What Henry meant by that was losing his daughter charlie, and changing that for some fire at a festival just seems cheap, like bringing William back after FNAF 6 and ucn.
Ironically, circuses are common to have at a carnival. And a lot of traveling circuses would run carnivals around their shows. Being pedantic about the difference in the words is mostly not constructive arguing. It's right up there with the whole jesters versus clowns thing. Clowns have worn jester outfits. So arguing that a jester is not a clown is not as important. If a clown is dressed in a jester outfit, can you call it a jester or a clown? If a carnival is hosting a circus, can you call it a circus or a carnival? Or do both words fit? And remember we are talking about a series with robots that are called animatronics.
If Cassie's dad is bonnie bro.. tbh either way he could be traumatized of birthdays. Imagine growing up knowing you were part of a prank that unalived your friend's brother.
Rye I don't know if you will see this...BUT PLEASE DON'T PREMIERE YOUR VIDEOS! If someone clicks off during the video youtube thinks that they did not watch it and it does not count as a view. SO PLEASE stop premiering your videos if you want more views and watch hours. If you don't believe me test it by not premiering this video and see if you get more views
Bro we want him to have less watch hours he is an overrated overpowering tyrant over the fnaf community is a complete idiot rude disrespectful and degrading un inclusive to people that aren’t in the lgbtq community and don’t believe in pride like me and doesn’t deserve what he has as in views and subscribers like its very nice of you to try and help someone i can respect that you’re a very good person for doing that but rye doesn’t deserve it no one in the community deserves this and to be frankly honest he is a big A-hole and people like this are alive but don’t live this is the definition of an internet troll so thanks for being a nice person but no a-fence he will probably see this be like man he’s an idiot ignore you and get you banned so you’re a good person but next time be a good person to a good person
Bro we want him to have less watch hours he is an overrated overpowering tyrant over the fnaf community is a complete idiot rude disrespectful and degrading un inclusive to people that aren’t in the lgbtq community and don’t believe in pride like me and doesn’t deserve what he has as in views and subscribers like its very nice of you to try and help someone i can respect that you’re a very good person for doing that but rye doesn’t deserve it no one in the community deserves this and to be frankly honest he is a big A-hole and people like this are alive but don’t live this is the definition of an internet troll so thanks for being a nice person but no a-fence he will probably see this be like man he’s an idiot ignore you and get you banned so you’re a good person but next time be a good person to a good person
The trail of fire from the carousel to the barn or vice versa is so strange. It’s so intentional. Like it could have been someone looney tunes pouring gasoline from one area to another to make sure a fire spread. What I think would be really really interesting though is if an animatronic caught fire and walked from one place to another, unintentionally spreading the fire. Like if Sun/Moon caught fire on the carousel and ran towards the barn for help/ tell people the carousel is on fire, bringing the fire with him and putting more people in danger.
I think Fall Fest might be intended to be the "origin" of the urban legend the original timeline games are now being portrayed as. Carny being linked so closely to Lefty would seem to make Lefty an easter egg, and the fire would fit nicely into the endings of a lot of horror films, where they try to end the curse or killer by fire. I think this is Fazbear trying to turn it into Wes Craven's Final Nightmare.
Honestly I think fall fest might have been the magic that inspired either William or Henry (possibly both) to create their restaurants. That said I think the most resent fall fest might be Gregory's origin story.
@@RyeToastI might be wrong, but if Grimm Foxy is the Curse of Dreadbear maze Foxy (I’m not completely sure😅), that could be what the Fall Fest foxy looked like after the fire happened, or during the fire :)
FNAF no doubt has gotten interesting ever since Steel Wool has been involved, and I love it. Despite Security Breach’s flaws, it was a cool experience, and the fact there’s still mysteries that haven’t been solved and hasn’t payed off yet is crazy. Overall, I’m excited to see where FNAF will go next, and I’m excited for the 10th anniversary!!!!! 😱😀👍
Indeed. Plus, I am curious to if we’ll get a DLC and update like with HW 1. Like, HW 1 had a DLC that revealed Vanny to us, and we got an update that revealed the Pizzaplex being built. Maybe HW 2 will have a DLC that could reveal Cassie getting corrupted by the Vanni mask, and we’ll get an update that reveals where the next installment takes place? Regardless, I’m excited!!! 🙏😱👏😀
Fun fact: fall fest has been hinted at since Fnaf 6. There was a random clown poster in the office (not Baby or lemonade/fruit punch clown, looked nothing like that) and a poster in an alleyway for Spook Fest. Obviously the name got changed, but the theming of the poster was the same. In UCN, we got another poster of the same clown from the Fnaf 6 office with the words "come join the circus" on it. So yeah, this has been cooking for a LONG time.
Fun fact: When I was at John Funnaff's stream when he played the flat mode release of Help Wanted 2, while he was playing Princess Quest 4 I remember calling out how Cassie's dad has a distinct connection to Fall Fest. I mean, he plays a lot of carnival games, fixes carnival rides, collects old posters, heck he even witnesses them in the aftermath of the fire! Not to mention that in Ruin, when Cassie picks up the Bonnie mask from AR world, it's the same one from the Curse of DreadBear DLC, which also takes place in Fall Fest, meaning that this Bonnie mask is a Fall Fest Bonnie mask. It's because of this mask that people believe that Cassie's dad is Help Wanted 1's Jeremy (not a theory I necessarily believe in but it's out there). But the Bonnie mask we collect in Help Wanted 2 is different. It looks very similar to the Bonnie mask that Bonnie bro wore in FNaF 4 during the bite, rather than the Fall Fest mask. But that begs the question, why the distinction between the two masks? Why is Cassie's dad always put in these situations that happened at Fall Fest? Why is he even there at the aftermath? Did he go to Fall Fest when he was younger and in 1983 before the bite everything burnt down? Did he witness everything? Did he own two separate Bonnie masks? I don't know about the last one but it's very interesting to call out- especially considering that Cassie connects the Fall Fest mask to her dad (m'kay, well she did not directly state it it's mostly implied because it's an old Bonnie and not a Glamrock Bonnie). What are your thoughts on this?
HW 1 had 2 DLC’a. One that revealed the mask that gave us Canny, then we got a second update that revealed the Pizzaplex being built. Maybe for Help Wanted 2’s DLC, we might get a reveal to maybe Cassie becoming corrupted, or maybe something to do with the Old Endo/The Mimic, and maybe for a second DLC, Steel Wool will have a reveal what the next game will look like? Either way, I’m excited to see what will be revealed? 👏🤔😀
I doubt that Henry kept Lefty. As he says in his speech: “My daughter, if you can hear me… I couldn't save you then, so let me save you now. It's time to rest, for you, and for those you have carried in your arms.“ And it’s strongly implied that Henry also dies in the pizza sim fire, more evidence that he wouldn’t let Lefty survive.
Interestingly, in Tales there was a carnival held close to the under-construction Pizzaplex, and the Pizzaplex itself was initially built as an indoor carnival rather than the mall it morphed into.
I think it's worth noting that Lefty isn't part of Tangle, but the puppet mask is. This indicates that someone removed the puppet from Lefty (possibly using the nearby scooper) so it could be after this that Fazbear turned Lefty into Carny if they are going for a fall fest revival, the franchise is certainly popular enough to do so. Lefty not being present in the Tangle indicates that at the very least Lefty wasn't around during the Tangle's creation It even possibly hints that Henry just might still be around. I mean if your trying to save your daughter's trapped soul your not going to Game End yourself without seeing it through and making sure their definitely free. He might have been the person to remove the puppet from lefty.
I like most of this theory, but there isn't a ton of evidence that Cassie's dad wasn't there for her birthday. Its entirely possible she was just sad none of her friends showed up.
@@macintoshhjball4686 I think that its more likely than not, yeah. We have hints that she frequented the pizzaplex, so I think that he decided to bring her for her birthday out of necessity.
Im sorry rye ;-; But the last part about Cassies dad having his bday ruined in the barn fire, and that's why he wasn't on cassies bday, doesn't really work. Since if he's the bonnie bully, he would be on the Bite Victims bday, which was in 1983, which is the last date the fall fest was a thing according to the dates we have. And i think that accidentally killing someone would be way more traumatic than what you proposed. Sorry for my mid english, btw :( Love your vids :)
Something to take note of is that Carnie talks to Jeremy about him looking old enough to have kids. This would mean that Carnie is in a new Fallfest and not the ones 70-83 because Jeremy would still be a kid and not look like he has kids.
Oh my GOD! Cassie's dad's birthday being in the original Fallfest, at the very BEGINNING, and then being at the END when he's old asf, is SOOOO GOOD! GOD I WANT THIS TO BE TRUE!!!
Fire is commonly used as a method to "end tragedies" in this series. It's not an odd choice, but it is a repeated method that is shown to be THE solution for haunted robots. Fall Fest seems to portray itself with a "where it all began" sort of feel, so maybe the idea of burning Fazbear related things stemmed from this event. Symbolic destruction is a sure-fire way of getting rid of the agony that comes with paranormally affected technology.
One thing to note is the similarities between the rockstars and springlock animatronics (primarily FNAF 4 Fredbear). They both share the same jaw mechanism with the two steel rods on the side of their mouths, they both have five fingers, Freddy has a purple hat and bow for some reason, and when I was watching a video of someone showing off the models to everyone’s endoskeletons Carnie/Lefty’s endo head looked like one used in the FNAF 4 parts & service room. I think it’s possible the rockstars are springlock suits and (maybe existed at fallfest) a lot earlier in the timeline. Rockstar Freddy might even be a repurposed Fredbear. You also mentioned the Rockstars were made for the fake pizzeria when that isn’t entirely the case. Lefty was definitely made to capture the puppet. But if Henry built the rockstars for this new pizzeria we wouldn’t have to buy them at Rare Finds Auctions like we do in the catalog in FNAF 6, they’d just be there at the beginning for us to use.
Personally for my own head cannon, I like Fall Fest as the origin point for The Afton/Henry arc. Perhaps Henry's family being the owners of the business and Afton working there. The tragedy of the fire leading to the discovery of Agony for Afton. From there they enter into business together with Afton trying to experiment /create more Agony. Insert MCI and Afton/Henry children deaths before Henry discovers the underlying motive and is now trying to make things right.
My current theory is that William caused the fall fest fire, & Henry’s son Sammy was killed in/ during the fire. This way, Henry’s line “a wound first inflicted on me” actually makes sense for Sammy, but Charlie doesn’t HAVE to be the first child to die, because of the order we were given in Help Wanted 2
Oh my god, Rhy, wow. I never EVER noticed that Lefty was not shown to be burnt in Pizza Sim, thats *huge* . You are absolutely so smart with this franchise in pointing out stuff thats so obvioud but nobody catches. What could this mean? This is insane. And this whole Carvival Fall Fest Fredbear stuff is absolutely crazy, and I'm excited to see what Steelwool and Scott do next.
I don't have a full theory here, but possibly unrelated connection to fall fest: The security logbook on pg 56, Faded Text asks "Was your favorite ride the carousel?" Have we ever seen another carousel in FNAF? Was there one in pizzeria sim? IDR
Noticed this while rewatching markiplier play help wanted 1. The announcer specifies where the circuit boards that were used to create the game came from. They were the show controls for the animatronics. Don't know how that ties in with glitchtrap, but thought it was interesting
Bruh Bonnie bro went through so much. He killed a kid by accident, his birthday party got ruined by a fire, was given the bite of 87 and he was killed by glitchtrap but before he died he saw his kid get given the mask that got him killed
When it comes to why a fire would be important, it might have something to do with the Mimic. In the Tales books when the Mimic arrives at the Pizzaplex it's stated to looked burnt everywhere aside from it's head (atleast I think, it's been awhile since I've read them) and currently we have no known event involving the Mimic where a fire happens, so a fallfest game could explain that.
Rye I found one of your theories by accident but stayed cause it was a decent length and kept me engaged. A little while later you’re on GTLive. It’s so cool to see the progress just from the little time I’ve been here and I’m excited to see what comes from you and the franchise we all love
HO THERE RILEY! ITS ME CASSIE! I HAVE COME WITH A MAJOR FNAF TIMELINE CALCULATION: Charlotte had to have died at or CLOSE to the time fall fest caught on fire! We see this in the fall fest poster at the winning screen for the background of da claw machine: if shows mari as a scarecrow but… IT HAS PURPLE TEARS MEANING CHARLOTTE IS POSSESSING IT!
15:29 ore maybe we get an answer why Crying Child is so afraid of the Animatronics Goldenbunny and Freadbear. (Maybe he saw an springlock costume burning down with or with out a Person inside) After all this costume can exist a year for the bite of 1983.
I always thought that In the Fazerblast Minigame in vr 2 Dreadbear replaces Lefty and that Lefty and Carnie were supposed to be a duo in this minigame but Lefty got squirrel distracted by the Puppet and chased it leaving the people at the attraction to put dreadbear in instead.
1-Good theory. I do wanna believe the same, that's it's about Fallfest, that all recent clues point to it, etc. 2-Indigo Park retro gameplay segment! Yay! 3-Voidkitty goes brrrrr
@@RyeToast The game was sooooo gooood! I love what UniqueGeese did with Indigo Park so far! That PS1-style segment was a nice change from FNAF's Atari-style retro minigames.
I think there was a fire and someone was hurt or died due to it and William was either directly or indirectly responsible. That way Henry's line about 'a wound first inflicted upon me' can make sense even if Charlotte was killed after other kids. Henry could have been hurt in a different way. Maybe it was his idea to have Fall Fest. Maybe someone close was killed in the fire. Either way, SOMETHING happened when a fire broke out.
I have an answer to 5:50. Help wanted 2 is an augmented Reality made to prepare new employees for the actual Job. I also think that the Hard mode is intentional. They simply just updated the Training Vr game due to the earthquake at the pizzaplex. This would make employees more familiar with their surroundings while restoring the Pizzaplex. I also think they only added The SL bunker mini games to test their reaction time if any free roaming character were to go haywire. BUT that’s only my theory, it’s not canon.
Steelwool are gonna announce something the day before My Hero Acadamia ends. Fucking wild. I’ve just finished school snd things are changing fast. MHA ending,Matpat retiring,no more math classes ,no more PE (thank God) but FNAF is a constant. Also,can we talk about Michael’s favourite ride as a kid being the carousel? I maintain that William’s brother died in the fallfest fire and Carnie literally represents a Carnie in a bear costume. I mean,we burn him and then Will (or something representative of him) attacks us. Plus,why give us burned Carnie for winning? Why the hell is he so special?
I'm gonna be honest the most farfetched theories you have revolve around Cassie's dad being horrifically traumatized in a fazbear location, and then coming to work for them as an adult
Great theory I like the connectios to fall fest and fazbear remaking the event that happened years ago, although I don't think that Bonnie Bro/Cassies dad's birthday happening on the day that fall fest burned to the ground was the reason that Cassie's dad never showed up for any birthday party, I think it was actually because of the bite of 83 when he and Michael accidentally got the crying child killed, and because Bonnie Bro/Cassies dad was so traumatized and felt so guilty because of it he never went to another birthday party so that he wouldn't make the same mistake again. But that my thought.
I think we might see Mrs. Afton in the game, and her passing at the place and the fiery disaster causing William's sanity go down the drain. And the fire could've been an accident by Henry because of a Faulty Animatronic. And William is getting back at Henry, where The Puppet gets possessed at that time.
Do you think the fire was an accident or sabotage by someone? The line of fire from barn to carousel seems intentional as if it wasn’t the fire would be more widespread. Also water tower and windmill are on fire suggesting sabotage
Not so much about why the fire is so important, but I have a theory about an animatronic group becoming more and more associated with Fall Fest, the Jack-o-Animatronics. I believe the Jack-o-Animatronics are either a part of Faz-Ent's Fall Fest cover-up or an allusion to what actually happened to Fall Fest. The fire is a key part of Fall Fest's history and in two separate Faz-Ent official homages to Fall Fest a new Jack-o-Animatronic was created. Grim Foxy in Help Wanted and Jack-o-Moon in Help Wanted 2. I'm theorizing that it was an animatronic at Fall Fest which started the fire and Faz-Ent is using these characters to make light of it.
I find it interesting that in help wanted 2 Lefty's endoskeleton doesn't have the mechanism to trap the puppet, because I doubt a regular endoskeleton like his would be capable of trapping the puppet inside Maybe after the FNAF 6 fire fazbear RetroFit lefties endoskeleton to not have the capturing mechanism within it so it's more good friendly or something like that, something to better fit in with whatever there doin
in Help Wanted 1 we know that testers where able to put recordings into the game. so we know that not everything in it is a creations of Fazbear Entertainment. can we realy say that the Fredbear Update and everything in it is realy all made by Fazbear?
Right as always, I am here for the heavy speculation! I was afraid you wouldn't do it for a second there, but I love this narrative. I think it's crazy town banana pants and would be so bonkers if it happened, but I love that you're taking the big swings! 10/10 for guts, keep throwing out crazy stuff like that because theorizing is supposed to be FUN. Cassie's dad/ Bonnie Bro/ Cry Child Death Accomplice's birthday ruined Fall Fest in '83 and that's why we haven't had it since. Ruined it with fire. That's so fun! No sarcasm, seriously I'm loving it.
1) JTop said that his plans for the 10 year anniversary is "carrot cake" which is Cassie's favorite. 2) I think you may be onto something, 1983 around spring/ summer, CC got bit, so, if it was Jeremy's bday that got lit on fire at a Fallfest, it would imply that his bday is in fall (probably October because pumpkins and such) William might've committed arson to to try to "avenge" CC (and if you are correct with Mike and the nightmare gas) William would be getting back at Michael, and it seems like him to attack the ones that accidentally killed his son. 3) if the above is true, that would mean that he would also have to go after the other two, and possibly one was the person involved in the multiple simultaneous springlock failures mentioned in FNaF 3, a year or two, and they could very well be an adult, and due to the death being classified as a freak accident (most likely), so, he may have caused that too. And then, number four may be Hudson from What We Found from Gumdrop Angel.
Love the content Rye, as always! I honestly hope the announcement is a dlc for help wanted 2, the help wanted games (dlc's included) have tp be my favorite games of the fnaf games.
This makes SO MUCH SENSE! What are we doing in Fazerblast? We’re playtesting it! What are we doing in Carousel? We’re fixing it! Fazbear Entertainment is up to something, I just know it!
Interesting theory. One aspect from fazbear frights that could actually support lefty being intact even better is that seemingly only the puppet mask was found in the ffps fire as evidence, not stuck to the lefty suit at all. Henry couldve left his daughter roam free in her final moments while the suit survived .
15:05 I dont think It was his own Party That made him hate birthday partys but that of the crying childs I mean if he was realy the Bonnie Bully the the bite of 83 musst have been traumetising
I know it's cringe but ur legit the type of person my mom raised me to be also I feel u with adhd I have it and a ton of other stuff and js want to let u know I feel u
Im just curious if Scott just knocked on your door and he tells you he can answer one fnaf question what would it be that's hard either moltenmci are what year sister location take place for me
It's interesting, not seen anyone talk about carnival being doing in the current time of fnaf before, instead of the past, which could work pretty well! Now that you mention the theory of Cassie's dad's birthday, I can't help but think, would that mean that Micheal and him were both born in 1970 and it was the same time Fallfest startet?
I think the rockstar animatronics may actually be either based off of an older design circa Fredbear’s family diner, or polished and fixed up ones from the diner directly. They each have 5 fingers per hand, as well as jaws that move up and down like Fredbear’s does in the fnaf 4 end-of-night mini game
Having a nostalgic FallFest throwback by Fazbear Entertainment would be a fun little curveball from what all the community thinks, but i don't really think the Carnie - Lefty endo similarity is much to drive home about since Steel Wool prolly just recolored and suited up the Lefty model and didn't think twice about the inside endoskeleton. Especially since you wouldn't even be able to see it till a half a year later when the flat mode came out. But this is fun nonetheless
It's interesting that the only real connection between Fall Fest and a circus is the poster specifically advertising Fall Fest of 1970. It makes me wonder if Fall Fest might have a different theme every year like a lot of other small festivals would have, which would potentially set 1970 as the year when Circus Baby and the other circus-themed characters might have debuted.
The only thing holding me back with carnie being a new rather than old animatronic is his wooden teeth (which could just be fazbear trying to make him seem old) and his animatronic shins. His shins are the exact same ones as the endoskeleton shins that the mediocre melodies have.
I love the majority of the theory, my only problem is the last part. I think the reason he avoids the parties is because of not something that happened at HIS party, but at his friends brothers party, when the crying child was bitten by fredbear
My theory about Help Wanted 2 is that it’s intended to be a training simulator for Pizzaplex workers, with some of the games like Ruined Roxy makeup or the Daycare arts and crafts levels functioning through controlling a STAFF bot like Gregory did. Some of the others, like Fazer Blast or the Circus Baby levels are Fabear Entertainment’s second attempt to discredit the games and make the employees think they are actually going to have a safe work environment.
I think the Fall Fest fire being Cassie's dad's birthday is an interesting idea. I don't think he could be the bonny bully if that was the case though because if he avoids birthday parties, why would he be at the cc's birthday party and do a traumatizing prank? I could also see the fall fest fire being something that loosely connects to the story like maybe Afton tried kidnapping a kid and the kid freaked out and started the fire on accident or purpose trying to escape so Afton switched to kidnapping at Freddy's. Maybe the mascot costumes were the common foam and fabric kind and they caught on fire too and that's why Fazbear started making robots instead. I think there are a lot of options and I'm excited to see if Steel Wool tells us the story or just leaves hints
love these theories man, i swear ur possibly one of the new matt pats of the fnaf universe haha, im rlly hoping for a fnaf ruin 2 DLC tho i lovedd ruin and i for no reason wanna see more of the ruined pizza plex
I saw a reddit post saying the next game might be in the water park from the books. I kinda hope it takes place there rather than fall fest because of how unique it would be for mascot horror.
I could really see this being the case. I think either way it has to be a modern game because of the "Carrot Cake" hint so surely Cassie has to be there somewhere.
Trying out some algorithm stuff, so no premiere today either
I loved the video! also I kept getting distracted by the chonky cat vibing to the point where u were talking with your hands while holding them😂 10/10 love fnaf and it makes it even better watching cats be adorable! ❤ this is why I love ur videos!
I love your theroy but I have one complaint the person from fnaf 6 comes back and he says that your getting trained for different jobs like health and safety as well as fizzy faz manager so it means that your getting trained for the job and your not in a game or anything like that
Just want to add one thing to your idea about Carnie being a rebuilt Lefty. Look at the shot at 13:50 of Fazerblast, and see who is blocking Dreadbears arm from moving...
you did something cause this video wont get out of my recomendations
By the designs of the rockstar animatronics, we can tell their spring locks
Did Henry start Fall Fest and Afton burned it down to buy Henry out for cheap? That might be “the wound first afflicted on me” destroying Henry’s business, possibly even killing someone Henry cared about. I also love the irony of Afton’s crimes starting and ending with fire.
I don’t think anything has ever been said about Henry’s wife existing, so it could potentially be that she could have been lost in the fire? I don’t know timeline stuff so I don’t know if that would have any bearing on children’s birth years, but something like that could be up William’s alley if there was a good reason for him to think it would work to buy out Henry.
Plus maybe there could be something that triggers the Remnant experiments idea? Wasn’t one of the issues with certain timelines being that there was no reason to have William looking into this stuff with murders so early on? Maybe him figuring something out happened here, or something.
That’s a good theory
In the fnaf 3 level,we’re attacked by something representative of William after burning the place down. To me,it would suggest William is angry about the Fallfest fire. Plus,William isn’t associated with fire. At least not causing them. Henry is and Charlie is just as likely as Mike to have burnt down fnaf 3. If anything,it’d be the other way around
Wait, what if it was Sammy (Charlie's twin brother from the books) and that's why he's never referenced in the games.
but also, if it was him and you believe in Dual Process's theory then that means there where (at least) 7 people who died at Fazbear's Locations within the span of a few months which begs the question...
HOW THE HELL WHERE THEY ABLE TO OPEN AT LEAST 5 MORE LOCATIONS WHICH HAD A MINIMUM OF 21 DIFFERENT DEATHS!!!!!!
The old lore doesn't need changing. What Henry meant by that was losing his daughter charlie, and changing that for some fire at a festival just seems cheap, like bringing William back after FNAF 6 and ucn.
As far as I figured, a carnival is an entire event, while a circus is mainly a show.
Essentially
Ironically, circuses are common to have at a carnival. And a lot of traveling circuses would run carnivals around their shows.
Being pedantic about the difference in the words is mostly not constructive arguing.
It's right up there with the whole jesters versus clowns thing. Clowns have worn jester outfits. So arguing that a jester is not a clown is not as important.
If a clown is dressed in a jester outfit, can you call it a jester or a clown? If a carnival is hosting a circus, can you call it a circus or a carnival? Or do both words fit?
And remember we are talking about a series with robots that are called animatronics.
Freddyland, hell yeah!
If Cassie's dad is bonnie bro.. tbh either way he could be traumatized of birthdays. Imagine growing up knowing you were part of a prank that unalived your friend's brother.
Honestly, that's an angle I didn't think about
@@RyeToast1983 was just a really bad year to have a birthday party
@@TheWizardMus That's the year my mother got born
You can say killed, you know
This also works for the trauma, however if that's true, why would he make her daughter's birthday at the Pizzaplex?
Rye I don't know if you will see this...BUT PLEASE DON'T PREMIERE YOUR VIDEOS! If someone clicks off during the video youtube thinks that they did not watch it and it does not count as a view. SO PLEASE stop premiering your videos if you want more views and watch hours. If you don't believe me test it by not premiering this video and see if you get more views
Bro we want him to have less watch hours he is an overrated overpowering tyrant over the fnaf community is a complete idiot rude disrespectful and degrading un inclusive to people that aren’t in the lgbtq community and don’t believe in pride like me and doesn’t deserve what he has as in views and subscribers like its very nice of you to try and help someone i can respect that you’re a very good person for doing that but rye doesn’t deserve it no one in the community deserves this and to be frankly honest he is a big A-hole and people like this are alive but don’t live this is the definition of an internet troll so thanks for being a nice person but no a-fence he will probably see this be like man he’s an idiot ignore you and get you banned so you’re a good person but next time be a good person to a good person
Bro we want him to have less watch hours he is an overrated overpowering tyrant over the fnaf community is a complete idiot rude disrespectful and degrading un inclusive to people that aren’t in the lgbtq community and don’t believe in pride like me and doesn’t deserve what he has as in views and subscribers like its very nice of you to try and help someone i can respect that you’re a very good person for doing that but rye doesn’t deserve it no one in the community deserves this and to be frankly honest he is a big A-hole and people like this are alive but don’t live this is the definition of an internet troll so thanks for being a nice person but no a-fence he will probably see this be like man he’s an idiot ignore you and get you banned so you’re a good person but next time be a good person to a good person
Really
@@JoenilEDITS yup
@@NaiFarang wow I didn’t know that
I too talk with my hands, but seeing Rye do the same, but with a CAT in hand just made my day. XD
He really does just vibe
I scream, you scream, we all scream in the terrible barn fire at Fall Fest
True I was there
In the terrible house fire at the family reunion (Legends of Avantris reference?? 👀)
@@bellslimes "God I wish there was wine in hell" - William Afton, probably
@@bellslimes👀 chuckles who?
nothing can ever kill grandma nut
The trail of fire from the carousel to the barn or vice versa is so strange. It’s so intentional. Like it could have been someone looney tunes pouring gasoline from one area to another to make sure a fire spread. What I think would be really really interesting though is if an animatronic caught fire and walked from one place to another, unintentionally spreading the fire. Like if Sun/Moon caught fire on the carousel and ran towards the barn for help/ tell people the carousel is on fire, bringing the fire with him and putting more people in danger.
I think Fall Fest might be intended to be the "origin" of the urban legend the original timeline games are now being portrayed as. Carny being linked so closely to Lefty would seem to make Lefty an easter egg, and the fire would fit nicely into the endings of a lot of horror films, where they try to end the curse or killer by fire. I think this is Fazbear trying to turn it into Wes Craven's Final Nightmare.
Honestly I think fall fest might have been the magic that inspired either William or Henry (possibly both) to create their restaurants.
That said I think the most resent fall fest might be Gregory's origin story.
rye toast putting out dad energy with the pun in the description 🎉
I had to
@@RyeToastI might be wrong, but if Grimm Foxy is the Curse of Dreadbear maze Foxy (I’m not completely sure😅), that could be what the Fall Fest foxy looked like after the fire happened, or during the fire :)
@@BlitzoBuckzoImpWeren’t there multiple Halloween animatronic skins at some point that were on fire/burning?? It’s all coming together!
13:36 Rye bouncing his cat as he talks, meanwhile, kitty (can’t remember their name): Dis is fine😊 Also big fan btw
He really just vibes (name is Casey by the way)
FNAF no doubt has gotten interesting ever since Steel Wool has been involved, and I love it. Despite Security Breach’s flaws, it was a cool experience, and the fact there’s still mysteries that haven’t been solved and hasn’t payed off yet is crazy.
Overall, I’m excited to see where FNAF will go next, and I’m excited for the 10th anniversary!!!!! 😱😀👍
Same!! It's been such a wild couple of years, especially since we're past the halfway point of steel wool's involvement
Indeed. Plus, I am curious to if we’ll get a DLC and update like with HW 1.
Like, HW 1 had a DLC that revealed Vanny to us, and we got an update that revealed the Pizzaplex being built.
Maybe HW 2 will have a DLC that could reveal Cassie getting corrupted by the Vanni mask, and we’ll get an update that reveals where the next installment takes place?
Regardless, I’m excited!!! 🙏😱👏😀
Fun fact: fall fest has been hinted at since Fnaf 6. There was a random clown poster in the office (not Baby or lemonade/fruit punch clown, looked nothing like that) and a poster in an alleyway for Spook Fest. Obviously the name got changed, but the theming of the poster was the same. In UCN, we got another poster of the same clown from the Fnaf 6 office with the words "come join the circus" on it. So yeah, this has been cooking for a LONG time.
Fun fact: When I was at John Funnaff's stream when he played the flat mode release of Help Wanted 2, while he was playing Princess Quest 4 I remember calling out how Cassie's dad has a distinct connection to Fall Fest.
I mean, he plays a lot of carnival games, fixes carnival rides, collects old posters, heck he even witnesses them in the aftermath of the fire! Not to mention that in Ruin, when Cassie picks up the Bonnie mask from AR world, it's the same one from the Curse of DreadBear DLC, which also takes place in Fall Fest, meaning that this Bonnie mask is a Fall Fest Bonnie mask.
It's because of this mask that people believe that Cassie's dad is Help Wanted 1's Jeremy (not a theory I necessarily believe in but it's out there).
But the Bonnie mask we collect in Help Wanted 2 is different. It looks very similar to the Bonnie mask that Bonnie bro wore in FNaF 4 during the bite, rather than the Fall Fest mask.
But that begs the question, why the distinction between the two masks? Why is Cassie's dad always put in these situations that happened at Fall Fest? Why is he even there at the aftermath? Did he go to Fall Fest when he was younger and in 1983 before the bite everything burnt down? Did he witness everything? Did he own two separate Bonnie masks?
I don't know about the last one but it's very interesting to call out- especially considering that Cassie connects the Fall Fest mask to her dad (m'kay, well she did not directly state it it's mostly implied because it's an old Bonnie and not a Glamrock Bonnie).
What are your thoughts on this?
Steel wool announcement is probably dlc for help wanted 2
Probably. Still might be fall fest tho
HW 1 had 2 DLC’a. One that revealed the mask that gave us Canny, then we got a second update that revealed the Pizzaplex being built.
Maybe for Help Wanted 2’s DLC, we might get a reveal to maybe Cassie becoming corrupted, or maybe something to do with the Old Endo/The Mimic, and maybe for a second DLC, Steel Wool will have a reveal what the next game will look like?
Either way, I’m excited to see what will be revealed? 👏🤔😀
@@RyeToast Or both, a HW2 fall fest dlc
I doubt that Henry kept Lefty. As he says in his speech: “My daughter, if you can hear me… I couldn't save you then, so let me save you now. It's time to rest, for you, and for those you have carried in your arms.“
And it’s strongly implied that Henry also dies in the pizza sim fire, more evidence that he wouldn’t let Lefty survive.
Totally fair, I wonder if leftie's room was more delicate then. Like still burn away the remnant, but do it in a nice way for Charlie
Interestingly, in Tales there was a carnival held close to the under-construction Pizzaplex, and the Pizzaplex itself was initially built as an indoor carnival rather than the mall it morphed into.
I think it's worth noting that Lefty isn't part of Tangle, but the puppet mask is. This indicates that someone removed the puppet from Lefty (possibly using the nearby scooper) so it could be after this that Fazbear turned Lefty into Carny if they are going for a fall fest revival, the franchise is certainly popular enough to do so. Lefty not being present in the Tangle indicates that at the very least Lefty wasn't around during the Tangle's creation
It even possibly hints that Henry just might still be around. I mean if your trying to save your daughter's trapped soul your not going to Game End yourself without seeing it through and making sure their definitely free. He might have been the person to remove the puppet from lefty.
I could understand Cassie’s dad also hating birthdays since it was at a birthday party where the bite of 83 happened
8:20 Both Carousel games end in fire, it's just that Hard Mode starts off already burnt.
Ah yes my bad
I like most of this theory, but there isn't a ton of evidence that Cassie's dad wasn't there for her birthday. Its entirely possible she was just sad none of her friends showed up.
Totally fair. Like I said, I'm not really sure what the fire could be otherwise but we just don't have info on it
I can see this angle. Do you also think that it’s possible that casey’s dad was working at the pizzaplex which is why her birthday party was there?
@@macintoshhjball4686 I think that its more likely than not, yeah. We have hints that she frequented the pizzaplex, so I think that he decided to bring her for her birthday out of necessity.
15:15 if he is bonnie bro I can think of another reason to avoid birthdays
Yeah I kind of. Didn't think about that LMAO
Im sorry rye ;-;
But the last part about Cassies dad having his bday ruined in the barn fire, and that's why he wasn't on cassies bday, doesn't really work. Since if he's the bonnie bully, he would be on the Bite Victims bday, which was in 1983, which is the last date the fall fest was a thing according to the dates we have. And i think that accidentally killing someone would be way more traumatic than what you proposed.
Sorry for my mid english, btw :(
Love your vids :)
Honestly I could see going either way. I think the birthday trauma being from the bite of 83 does make more sense though
If the Steelwool announcement is a HW2 dlc then it could be us experiencing what actually happened at Fall Fest from Jeremy’s pov
12:51 "Did Henry keep him around in the hopes that he might be able to bring back Charlette?" Didn't he kill himself 💀
Something to take note of is that Carnie talks to Jeremy about him looking old enough to have kids. This would mean that Carnie is in a new Fallfest and not the ones 70-83 because Jeremy would still be a kid and not look like he has kids.
Oh my GOD! Cassie's dad's birthday being in the original Fallfest, at the very BEGINNING, and then being at the END when he's old asf, is SOOOO GOOD! GOD I WANT THIS TO BE TRUE!!!
Every Fnaf theory: I solved everything with one pixel. I actually did this.
And I'll do it again lmao
HE CaNt KeEP gEtTiNg aWaY wITh T H I S
And then they show you the pixel but don't actually explain how it links up to anything
@@RyeToast I'm doing it first. Well, I hope so
@@SquidXx00 Don't worry, I've already thought of the pixel that will solve FNAF
Fire is commonly used as a method to "end tragedies" in this series. It's not an odd choice, but it is a repeated method that is shown to be THE solution for haunted robots. Fall Fest seems to portray itself with a "where it all began" sort of feel, so maybe the idea of burning Fazbear related things stemmed from this event. Symbolic destruction is a sure-fire way of getting rid of the agony that comes with paranormally affected technology.
One thing to note is the similarities between the rockstars and springlock animatronics (primarily FNAF 4 Fredbear).
They both share the same jaw mechanism with the two steel rods on the side of their mouths, they both have five fingers, Freddy has a purple hat and bow for some reason, and when I was watching a video of someone showing off the models to everyone’s endoskeletons Carnie/Lefty’s endo head looked like one used in the FNAF 4 parts & service room.
I think it’s possible the rockstars are springlock suits and (maybe existed at fallfest) a lot earlier in the timeline. Rockstar Freddy might even be a repurposed Fredbear.
You also mentioned the Rockstars were made for the fake pizzeria when that isn’t entirely the case. Lefty was definitely made to capture the puppet. But if Henry built the rockstars for this new pizzeria we wouldn’t have to buy them at Rare Finds Auctions like we do in the catalog in FNAF 6, they’d just be there at the beginning for us to use.
Personally for my own head cannon, I like Fall Fest as the origin point for The Afton/Henry arc. Perhaps Henry's family being the owners of the business and Afton working there. The tragedy of the fire leading to the discovery of Agony for Afton. From there they enter into business together with Afton trying to experiment /create more Agony. Insert MCI and Afton/Henry children deaths before Henry discovers the underlying motive and is now trying to make things right.
My current theory is that William caused the fall fest fire, & Henry’s son Sammy was killed in/ during the fire. This way, Henry’s line “a wound first inflicted on me” actually makes sense for Sammy, but Charlie doesn’t HAVE to be the first child to die, because of the order we were given in Help Wanted 2
Jacko Foxy in the maze minigame makes me think an anamatronic caught fire
All of the Halloween designs TBH
It’s even more ironic when you remember that during the movie’s production, foxy actually did catch on fire 😂😂
Oh my god, Rhy, wow. I never EVER noticed that Lefty was not shown to be burnt in Pizza Sim, thats *huge* . You are absolutely so smart with this franchise in pointing out stuff thats so obvioud but nobody catches. What could this mean? This is insane. And this whole Carvival Fall Fest Fredbear stuff is absolutely crazy, and I'm excited to see what Steelwool and Scott do next.
LOOK AT THAT FLUFFY LAP BABY
I don't have a full theory here, but possibly unrelated connection to fall fest: The security logbook on pg 56, Faded Text asks "Was your favorite ride the carousel?"
Have we ever seen another carousel in FNAF? Was there one in pizzeria sim? IDR
Fnaf 2
Fnaf 2..
Fnaf 2
Noticed this while rewatching markiplier play help wanted 1. The announcer specifies where the circuit boards that were used to create the game came from. They were the show controls for the animatronics. Don't know how that ties in with glitchtrap, but thought it was interesting
Bruh Bonnie bro went through so much. He killed a kid by accident, his birthday party got ruined by a fire, was given the bite of 87 and he was killed by glitchtrap but before he died he saw his kid get given the mask that got him killed
When it comes to why a fire would be important, it might have something to do with the Mimic.
In the Tales books when the Mimic arrives at the Pizzaplex it's stated to looked burnt everywhere aside from it's head (atleast I think, it's been awhile since I've read them) and currently we have no known event involving the Mimic where a fire happens, so a fallfest game could explain that.
Rye I found one of your theories by accident but stayed cause it was a decent length and kept me engaged. A little while later you’re on GTLive. It’s so cool to see the progress just from the little time I’ve been here and I’m excited to see what comes from you and the franchise we all love
HO THERE RILEY! ITS ME CASSIE! I HAVE COME WITH A MAJOR FNAF TIMELINE CALCULATION: Charlotte had to have died at or CLOSE to the time fall fest caught on fire! We see this in the fall fest poster at the winning screen for the background of da claw machine: if shows mari as a scarecrow but… IT HAS PURPLE TEARS MEANING CHARLOTTE IS POSSESSING IT!
15:29 ore maybe we get an answer why Crying Child is so afraid of the Animatronics Goldenbunny and Freadbear. (Maybe he saw an springlock costume burning down with or with out a Person inside) After all this costume can exist a year for the bite of 1983.
Interesting how the trees in the back of the fall fest 1970 poster look kind of like fire.
I always thought that In the Fazerblast Minigame in vr 2 Dreadbear replaces Lefty and that Lefty and Carnie were supposed to be a duo in this minigame but Lefty got squirrel distracted by the Puppet and chased it leaving the people at the attraction to put dreadbear in instead.
1-Good theory. I do wanna believe the same, that's it's about Fallfest, that all recent clues point to it, etc.
2-Indigo Park retro gameplay segment! Yay!
3-Voidkitty goes brrrrr
I looooove that Indigo Park section
@@RyeToast The game was sooooo gooood! I love what UniqueGeese did with Indigo Park so far! That PS1-style segment was a nice change from FNAF's Atari-style retro minigames.
I think there was a fire and someone was hurt or died due to it and William was either directly or indirectly responsible.
That way Henry's line about 'a wound first inflicted upon me' can make sense even if Charlotte was killed after other kids. Henry could have been hurt in a different way. Maybe it was his idea to have Fall Fest. Maybe someone close was killed in the fire. Either way, SOMETHING happened when a fire broke out.
I have an answer to 5:50. Help wanted 2 is an augmented Reality made to prepare new employees for the actual Job. I also think that the Hard mode is intentional. They simply just updated the Training Vr game due to the earthquake at the pizzaplex. This would make employees more familiar with their surroundings while restoring the Pizzaplex. I also think they only added The SL bunker mini games to test their reaction time if any free roaming character were to go haywire. BUT that’s only my theory, it’s not canon.
So i dont know if anyone else thought of this, but could fall fest be where the wonderful fredbear singing show takes place ?
Steelwool are gonna announce something the day before My Hero Acadamia ends. Fucking wild. I’ve just finished school snd things are changing fast. MHA ending,Matpat retiring,no more math classes ,no more PE (thank God) but FNAF is a constant.
Also,can we talk about Michael’s favourite ride as a kid being the carousel? I maintain that William’s brother died in the fallfest fire and Carnie literally represents a Carnie in a bear costume. I mean,we burn him and then Will (or something representative of him) attacks us. Plus,why give us burned Carnie for winning? Why the hell is he so special?
this is the best theory/speculation, but can I just say your cat chilling the entire video feels like my spiritual animal😂
I'm gonna be honest the most farfetched theories you have revolve around Cassie's dad being horrifically traumatized in a fazbear location, and then coming to work for them as an adult
5:56 well, fazbear entertainment calls Fnaf hw, “the fazbear virtual experience”, and not the game title. Does this change anything?
The last fall fest was 83, which is the same year as fnaf 4, so could Afton have started the fire to get back one of the kids who killed his son?
i love when you have the cats just one handed, and they just kinda vibe while you gesture with them
Great theory I like the connectios to fall fest and fazbear remaking the event that happened years ago, although I don't think that Bonnie Bro/Cassies dad's birthday happening on the day that fall fest burned to the ground was the reason that Cassie's dad never showed up for any birthday party, I think it was actually because of the bite of 83 when he and Michael accidentally got the crying child killed, and because Bonnie Bro/Cassies dad was so traumatized and felt so guilty because of it he never went to another birthday party so that he wouldn't make the same mistake again. But that my thought.
I think we might see Mrs. Afton in the game, and her passing at the place and the fiery disaster causing William's sanity go down the drain. And the fire could've been an accident by Henry because of a Faulty Animatronic. And William is getting back at Henry, where The Puppet gets possessed at that time.
Imagine a Fnaf game where we get animated cinematics of the burning festival.
Do you think the fire was an accident or sabotage by someone? The line of fire from barn to carousel seems intentional as if it wasn’t the fire would be more widespread. Also water tower and windmill are on fire suggesting sabotage
There's a theory suggesting fall fest evolved into spook fest. The evidence is a poster that appeared in FNAF 6.
This is a really good theory, and I was skeptical of a Fall Fest game, but now I would love it!
9:02 kitty likes the fall fest poster :)
You’re my new matpat 😂 seriously these theories are great and they actually make me think
Not so much about why the fire is so important, but I have a theory about an animatronic group becoming more and more associated with Fall Fest, the Jack-o-Animatronics. I believe the
Jack-o-Animatronics are either a part of Faz-Ent's Fall Fest cover-up or an allusion to what actually happened to Fall Fest. The fire is a key part of Fall Fest's history and in two separate Faz-Ent official homages to Fall Fest a new Jack-o-Animatronic was created. Grim Foxy in Help Wanted and Jack-o-Moon in Help Wanted 2. I'm theorizing that it was an animatronic at Fall Fest which started the fire and Faz-Ent is using these characters to make light of it.
I love the way your cat looks around like 'hey why aren't you petting me' while you're trying to explain what you're talking about lol
I find it interesting that in help wanted 2 Lefty's endoskeleton doesn't have the mechanism to trap the puppet, because I doubt a regular endoskeleton like his would be capable of trapping the puppet inside
Maybe after the FNAF 6 fire fazbear RetroFit lefties endoskeleton to not have the capturing mechanism within it so it's more good friendly or something like that, something to better fit in with whatever there doin
how is Casey SO chill
also love the speculation, can’t wait to see what drops regarding Fall Fest
in Help Wanted 1 we know that testers where able to put recordings into the game. so we know that not everything in it is a creations of Fazbear Entertainment. can we realy say that the Fredbear Update and everything in it is realy all made by Fazbear?
Right as always, I am here for the heavy speculation! I was afraid you wouldn't do it for a second there, but I love this narrative. I think it's crazy town banana pants and would be so bonkers if it happened, but I love that you're taking the big swings! 10/10 for guts, keep throwing out crazy stuff like that because theorizing is supposed to be FUN. Cassie's dad/ Bonnie Bro/ Cry Child Death Accomplice's birthday ruined Fall Fest in '83 and that's why we haven't had it since. Ruined it with fire. That's so fun! No sarcasm, seriously I'm loving it.
I hope we learn a lot of things in fest like Cassie‘s dad and Henry Emily
1) JTop said that his plans for the 10 year anniversary is "carrot cake" which is Cassie's favorite.
2) I think you may be onto something, 1983 around spring/ summer, CC got bit, so, if it was Jeremy's bday that got lit on fire at a Fallfest, it would imply that his bday is in fall (probably October because pumpkins and such) William might've committed arson to to try to "avenge" CC (and if you are correct with Mike and the nightmare gas) William would be getting back at Michael, and it seems like him to attack the ones that accidentally killed his son.
3) if the above is true, that would mean that he would also have to go after the other two, and possibly one was the person involved in the multiple simultaneous springlock failures mentioned in FNaF 3, a year or two, and they could very well be an adult, and due to the death being classified as a freak accident (most likely), so, he may have caused that too. And then, number four may be Hudson from What We Found from Gumdrop Angel.
Love the content Rye, as always! I honestly hope the announcement is a dlc for help wanted 2, the help wanted games (dlc's included) have tp be my favorite games of the fnaf games.
This makes SO MUCH SENSE! What are we doing in Fazerblast? We’re playtesting it! What are we doing in Carousel? We’re fixing it! Fazbear Entertainment is up to something, I just know it!
Interesting theory. One aspect from fazbear frights that could actually support lefty being intact even better is that seemingly only the puppet mask was found in the ffps fire as evidence, not stuck to the lefty suit at all. Henry couldve left his daughter roam free in her final moments while the suit survived .
15:05 I dont think It was his own Party That made him hate birthday partys but that of the crying childs I mean if he was realy the Bonnie Bully the the bite of 83 musst have been traumetising
Nice job again! Love your evidence based and transparent approach, and your theories make sense even when they are speculation. Thank you
I know it's cringe but ur legit the type of person my mom raised me to be also I feel u with adhd I have it and a ton of other stuff and js want to let u know I feel u
I love theorizing while Helpy is getting absolutely destroyed in the background
KITTY!!!
Okay its outta my system on with the video
Im just curious if Scott just knocked on your door and he tells you he can answer one fnaf question what would it be that's hard either moltenmci are what year sister location take place for me
For me, I’d just want to use it to end the Mimic debates
I want to know if the DCI was a thing, or if it's just the MCI being misinterpreted for another set of killings.
The books
Probably which books are in the games continuity
@@RyeToast THANK YOU!
Trying very hard to pay attention but all I can do is admire how chill your cat is
It's interesting, not seen anyone talk about carnival being doing in the current time of fnaf before, instead of the past, which could work pretty well! Now that you mention the theory of Cassie's dad's birthday, I can't help but think, would that mean that Micheal and him were both born in 1970 and it was the same time Fallfest startet?
I think the rockstar animatronics may actually be either based off of an older design circa Fredbear’s family diner, or polished and fixed up ones from the diner directly. They each have 5 fingers per hand, as well as jaws that move up and down like Fredbear’s does in the fnaf 4 end-of-night mini game
Morning, im watching this before i heard to the airport. Thanks for accompanying me.
Sure thing!
Really good theory, honestly the ending about Cassie's dad was really good.
Into the Pit:
Every theorist: "WHAT WILL THE NEXT FNAF GAME BE?!?!!?!!?"
great theories btw :D
how am i supposed to pay attention to the lore when there's a precious black cat here?!
Having a nostalgic FallFest throwback by Fazbear Entertainment would be a fun little curveball from what all the community thinks, but i don't really think the Carnie - Lefty endo similarity is much to drive home about since Steel Wool prolly just recolored and suited up the Lefty model and didn't think twice about the inside endoskeleton. Especially since you wouldn't even be able to see it till a half a year later when the flat mode came out. But this is fun nonetheless
It's interesting that the only real connection between Fall Fest and a circus is the poster specifically advertising Fall Fest of 1970. It makes me wonder if Fall Fest might have a different theme every year like a lot of other small festivals would have, which would potentially set 1970 as the year when Circus Baby and the other circus-themed characters might have debuted.
The only thing holding me back with carnie being a new rather than old animatronic is his wooden teeth (which could just be fazbear trying to make him seem old) and his animatronic shins. His shins are the exact same ones as the endoskeleton shins that the mediocre melodies have.
I love the majority of the theory, my only problem is the last part. I think the reason he avoids the parties is because of not something that happened at HIS party, but at his friends brothers party, when the crying child was bitten by fredbear
My theory about Help Wanted 2 is that it’s intended to be a training simulator for Pizzaplex workers, with some of the games like Ruined Roxy makeup or the Daycare arts and crafts levels functioning through controlling a STAFF bot like Gregory did. Some of the others, like Fazer Blast or the Circus Baby levels are Fabear Entertainment’s second attempt to discredit the games and make the employees think they are actually going to have a safe work environment.
I think the Fall Fest fire being Cassie's dad's birthday is an interesting idea. I don't think he could be the bonny bully if that was the case though because if he avoids birthday parties, why would he be at the cc's birthday party and do a traumatizing prank?
I could also see the fall fest fire being something that loosely connects to the story like maybe Afton tried kidnapping a kid and the kid freaked out and started the fire on accident or purpose trying to escape so Afton switched to kidnapping at Freddy's. Maybe the mascot costumes were the common foam and fabric kind and they caught on fire too and that's why Fazbear started making robots instead. I think there are a lot of options and I'm excited to see if Steel Wool tells us the story or just leaves hints
IT IS ABOUT THE FALLFEST HOLY SHIT
love these theories man, i swear ur possibly one of the new matt pats of the fnaf universe haha, im rlly hoping for a fnaf ruin 2 DLC tho i lovedd ruin and i for no reason wanna see more of the ruined pizza plex
I enjoy your theories but I think I enjoy watching your cat's expressions as you gesticulate with it in your hand a little bit more hahaha
I saw a reddit post saying the next game might be in the water park from the books. I kinda hope it takes place there rather than fall fest because of how unique it would be for mascot horror.
What if the next Fnaf game shows fallfest taking place in the present and the past
I could really see this being the case. I think either way it has to be a modern game because of the "Carrot Cake" hint so surely Cassie has to be there somewhere.
Hi Rye!!!! Love your videos I watch all of them ❤ Keep up the great work
Thank you!
I feel like help wanted 2 dlc being about fallfest makes perfect sense considering help wanted 1 dlc took place during a fallfest as well