Lies of P: A Flawed Masterpiece

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 25 лис 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 289

  • @thebitten1
    @thebitten1 Рік тому +60

    To adress some critiscisms, the guy did know his wife was a puppet. When we show we got the ring, he mentions and assures us hes not crazy, she really loved him. And it turns into one of those lie choices we get on whether we think the feeling was mutual. Fun fact if we return to the wife by like the very end of the game, she has fallen over and theres a message on the wall from her confirming she loved him. The guy marrying a puppet plays into Paulendina's quest then when he admits to have feelings for Antonia. Asking if weve heard of a human and puppet romance.
    As for the King of puppets, while fair that there isnt a clear answer for why we cant understand him; we have been pushed by Gepetto at this point to go deal with him.
    As for the other things, yeah theres some polishing the plot could go through to work it out. Things like the tree and passageway feel like its that way for progression reasons, but it still couldve been handled a bit better. And yeah, Simon and Geopettos reasonings and methods couldve been more elaborated on. Personally, i feel Simon was introduced too late into the story and we get so little time to know more about him. I never trusted Geppetto though; man gave us strong "Would you Kindly?" vibes from his introduction

    • @C0LIN.
      @C0LIN.  Рік тому +13

      Fair, maybe I’m just dumb but I didn’t sense anything off about Gepetto (W Bioshock reference tho)

    • @ELDENLORD89
      @ELDENLORD89 Рік тому +14

      Also another thing to note to is that one of the lore notes in the game literally foreshadows that NPC because it talks about a “guy” that fell in love with a puppet and how society looked down on him for it. Then you meet the dude. I’m honestly surprised the guy just completely missed this.

    • @shawny5574
      @shawny5574 Рік тому +3

      I was looking for this comment about the guy knowing his wife was a puppet. There is also a document you pick up (I think it’s pretty early in the game) and it tells you about it and that his family didn’t agree with it

    • @thebitten1
      @thebitten1 Рік тому +5

      @@shawny5574 I believe it was a newspaper article you pick up in the factory, essentially roasting the guy for it

    • @shawny5574
      @shawny5574 Рік тому

      @@thebitten1 yeah I thought it was the factory! I’m onto my third playthrough and I remember it being pretty early game I read the item description about it 😂

  • @Ruush_
    @Ruush_ Рік тому +85

    The game definitely has some rough edges but It still does a great job at taking inspiration from the souls genre. And does a great job at doing its own thing

    • @Kazu-ow6ot
      @Kazu-ow6ot Рік тому +1

      ​@user-ky8nd2rz4fi hate the fact that you need to upgrade ur heart just to roll and wakeup roll like wtf??

    • @Cuozyyy
      @Cuozyyy Рік тому

      @@Kazu-ow6otyea cause when i played the beta i almost quit cause of the fact you cant use game mechanics until after beating the second boss☹️

    • @matthewolivas613
      @matthewolivas613 Рік тому

      i never got stun locked because i just spammed dodge after the first hit from stun lock combos, its once they get the second hit you get stunned locked usually. if anything the invincibility when youre getting up is useful most of the time. I just dont get why thats such a big deal to u guys, its a small part of the game and it doesnt really ruin the gameplay unless u let it by not adapting.@@Kazu-ow6ot

    • @parkout95
      @parkout95 Рік тому +1

      ​@@Kazu-ow6otsir its not as bad as what Dark Souls 2 did with the adaptability bs

    • @MrRobotboy123
      @MrRobotboy123 Рік тому

      Well shit atleast in dark souls the side bag works

  • @KiyoshiKenji881
    @KiyoshiKenji881 Рік тому +27

    The rare ergo says in its description that you can give them to alidoro
    King flames Fuocos flame attack can be evaded by going behind one of the pillars in the arena.punishing anyone who has been running around since he can also destroy them
    The archbishop laser attack can be evaded by going under it and then dodging or parrying once he lands
    All of Laxasias lightning attacks can be parried in the first and second phase

    • @youngboi382
      @youngboi382 Рік тому +3

      Nawww this pissed me off we don’t the tutorial for special ergos untill you meet Alidoro I’m pissed I consumed the kings flame, the broken hero and the parade leaders ergo bc of that shit, granted I might be stupid but I heard alot of players had that problem first run through,

    • @KiyoshiKenji881
      @KiyoshiKenji881 Рік тому

      king's flame ergo description:Ergo obtained from King's Flame, Fuoco. It is packed with immense power. A treasure hunter may want this rare Ergo. @@youngboi382 idk what u want the game to do m8 it isnt going to hold your hand.its in a seperate column under "rare ergo" and says it in the description

    • @NeloBladeOfRanni
      @NeloBladeOfRanni Рік тому +9

      ​@@youngboi382I mean if you've played souls games before you should know not to consume boss souls if you want their gear

  • @3ace9
    @3ace9 Рік тому +13

    I just wanna say a lot of these arguments happen because you didn’t read very clear dialogue or item descriptions

  • @Call0045
    @Call0045 Рік тому +19

    I saw some people already addressing some of the criticism towards the story, but I have yet to see someone talking about the reason Geppetto caused the Puppet Frenzy. So I'll do it myself (lol)
    Geppetto needed the arm of god to bring Carlo back, not only the arm of god, but our heart too (since we're a "failure"). And as we can see throught the story, This artifact is very well known and a lot of people have their eyes on it. So Geppetto used the puppet frenzy as a distraction to get his hands on the arm of god.

    • @C0LIN.
      @C0LIN.  Рік тому +1

      This is never stated in the story and if it is feel free to link me a time stamp to a video or something, also he could’ve still just worked with Simon since he was already doing that anyway…

    • @Delkesss
      @Delkesss Рік тому +3

      @@C0LIN.if you go back to the train car you started at in the beginning, once the area is more messed up in chapter 9, you can break the back to reveal a secret room with a note from Simon that talks about this, as he had just taken the arm back

    • @takeshikovacks6708
      @takeshikovacks6708 11 місяців тому +6

      To add to this too, Gepetto caused the puppet frenzy not only for the arm of god, but also being that ergo is the soul and life essence of a being frozen in time, he needed mass amounts of it to power up P’s heart so that it would be able to sustain the nameless puppet body. Gepetto basically caused mass genocide of a whole city, summoned literal capital G God, all to power up what is essentially a battery to bring his dead son back to life.

  • @KiyoshiKenji881
    @KiyoshiKenji881 Рік тому +13

    Ok soooo…
    the guy with the puppet wife knew she was a puppet but fell in love with her anyway.
    We learn how Carlo died on the beach of the alchemist isle
    Even if they knew the tree was next to the hotel they still didn‘t have a cure since that is provided by the half dead guy ,I forgot his name, that u rescue at the cathedral and his research
    Idk about this one but…Geppetto started the puppet frenzy to fight the petrification disease and sometimes I wonder if the puppets actually only killed ppl that were sick from the petrification disease but idk

    • @mob923
      @mob923 Рік тому

      I think, the puppets went haywire since almost everyone even those not infected with ergo’ petrification disease were at some level were targetted since they couldn’t specify at what level to address the disease. This might have led to dysfunction between the law and the new programming to attack petrified “zombies”? it ended up attacking everyone

    • @chantier24
      @chantier24 11 місяців тому

      Thank you. I cringed during the first part of this video.

  • @Lonewolf360gaming
    @Lonewolf360gaming Рік тому +21

    Can't say I'm gonna play this game because souls likes just ain't for me however the idea of Pinocchio being a mechanical lil badass and slaying other puppets sounds so raw

    • @Bloop635
      @Bloop635 Рік тому +6

      I’m on new game +2 you should definitely give it a play I love it it’s dope

    • @jei3970
      @jei3970 Рік тому +1

      Honestly that's what I said about souls games but then I tried and elden ring and fell in love with it and was one of the best experiences I've ever had in a game. Then I went and beat sekiro, bloodborne, ds3 and still have ds1 and 2 to play. Honestly you REALLY should play these types of games yeah sure they're hard but the challenge and rewarding feeling of beating a hard boss is a great feeling. I recommend if you ever do start with Elden Ring as you can make that game so easy for yourself. Definitely don't start with LOP that would be rough

    • @mikohaku
      @mikohaku Рік тому +2

      I'm a terribly bad gamer and never wanted to play a souls like game either but I just beat the endboss in the game after 5 hours of dying to him. And I've never been so happy after finishing a game. It's totally worth it even tho you might destroy a controller or two 👌😂

    • @Elyakel
      @Elyakel Рік тому

      ​@mikohaku honestly you can play the souls especialmy 1 and 3
      Sekiro and lies of p ask you to play really well
      But it's not the case with ds1 and 3
      In ds1 and 3 the game demand you a specific mindset of " not surrender" , they're fairly slow and you have a good margin of error
      They're more " knowledge based" than " input based"
      They have an aura of impossible games to beat but honestly they're not really hard if you take your time
      They're game you should play no matter how hard you struggle , it's part of journey
      No one knew to ride a bike before trying , it's the same

    • @Barney_rubble983
      @Barney_rubble983 Рік тому

      There's a decent size demo you can play

  • @WadetheBadger
    @WadetheBadger Рік тому +11

    Just gonna put this here. Julian did very much know his wife was a puppet. When you return with the ring he asks you if it is so wrong that he and a puppet fell in love. Kinda hard to miss if you do the quest. Just saying my dood.

    • @FizbanD5
      @FizbanD5 Рік тому +4

      he misses a lot of things like when he said the wish guy was good, c'mon man its literally the ending credit scene, or when he said there's no signs of poverty....the malum district where all the poor people lived who were left behind by the puppet industrial revolution. (Used to be a small fishing coastal city until the discovery of Ergo). His biggest criticism was not knowing why G started the puppet frenzy...literally to kill people and harvest their Ergo. Simon to try to wake up god, Gep to betray Simon (they orignally worked together) and use the harvested Ergo and the arm of god to bring his son back from the dead). The secret rule 0 of the covenant where their creator is named Gep, he just classified the infected people as non human to make the puppets kill them while Simon sits back and harvests all the Ergo released by killed humans and destroyed puppets. You get a lot of the story by looking at the environment and the items/collectibles within that environment which answers a lot of his questions/criticism's all within the grand covenant following the rules.

    • @C0LIN.
      @C0LIN.  Рік тому

      1. I didn’t say there was no signs of poverty I said they never really make a point about this in the story, or have any characters in the world struggling from this
      2. Ergo doesn’t come from humans lmfao it literally came from the puppets, and the bosses we killed there’s a whole cutscene that shows the bosses ergo being sucked up
      3. Where is it stated that Gepetto and Simon worked together…

    • @FizbanD5
      @FizbanD5 Рік тому +5

      Well id not lmfao about the ergo part coming from the puppets because they literally state during the course of the game that ergo is crystallized life essence (memories, experiences emotions ect) It doesn't come from the puppets they used it to power the puppets. That's why puppets started awakening and having memories of their past lives. They even have subject 826 who is forced to eat ergo so he can see memories for the alchemists. He's eating souls, i mean its even in the introduction cinematic to the game they discover ergo and use it to power the puppets. Sorry man ergo comes from life and it's not even a theory or hidden plot point, ergo is literally crystalized life essence.

    • @AegisKHAOS
      @AegisKHAOS Рік тому

      Even before that, there was literally a news article you pick up that talks about a man named 'J' who married a puppet, and he was considered a sick man while insisting that the two were in love. Thus when we do Julian's quest, we confirm he is the same man as 'J' in that article, AND he clearly knows the wife is a puppet. The story has few noticeable holes, if at all.

  • @LordJovi
    @LordJovi Рік тому +31

    The character animations in this game look really fluid and clean.

    • @C0LIN.
      @C0LIN.  Рік тому +2

      They are for the most part

  • @LostWallet
    @LostWallet 6 місяців тому +1

    Geopetto specifically cause the puppet frenzy to deal with the alchemist. the alchemist wont let him revive his son using puppet, because one of the ingredients he need was the arm of god, one of the alchemist relic. they wont give it to him, so he using the puppet to fight the alchemist, and the alchemist release the petrifying virus to deal with his puppet.

  • @bingbippo1073
    @bingbippo1073 Рік тому +8

    On the flame boss fight you are meant to run behind the pillars to avoid the fire

    • @C0LIN.
      @C0LIN.  Рік тому +2

      I mean sure but sometimes he’ll do it when no pillars are close enough, other times the pillars will get destroyed, or it’s both

    • @cirederfsamot2730
      @cirederfsamot2730 Рік тому +7

      ​@@C0LIN.Then it's failure on your part.
      It's your job to manage space in this fight to preserve enought pipes and escape the fire, it's part of the fight

    • @farquarwion4324
      @farquarwion4324 Рік тому +7

      ​@@C0LIN.Yeah that's a skill issue homie

  • @Ventus_S
    @Ventus_S Рік тому +6

    Seems to me you skip a lot of dialogues (or quick smash a lot of them )
    The submarine need Golden Ergo from Swamp monster to activate, thus why Antonia didn't give you the key earlier cuz it'd be pointless.
    As for the cure for Antonia, only that alchemist guy knows how to make. None of the people in the hotel have any knowledge of how to make the cure at that point.
    We dont encounter him until after we beat the Black Brotherhood, so it'd be pointless to give the golden fruit to Antonia first.

  • @KickThatZombie
    @KickThatZombie Рік тому +5

    the katana is just a harder parry, it supposed to parry attacks that happenns on the window of time where it produces a metalic sound, while the parry window seems to be a bit more forgiving it just requires alot more training since you have a whole cutscene before the actual parry

    • @brianswigers1874
      @brianswigers1874 Рік тому

      its not harder , actually has a much more lenient parry windows

    • @KickThatZombie
      @KickThatZombie Рік тому +1

      @@brianswigers1874 as I said, even if the parry windows are bigger you have to time the whole twirling thing to match with the actual attacking frames, but hey if it's easier for you congrats it's a slick way to play the game

    • @AegisKHAOS
      @AegisKHAOS Рік тому

      And that is why I find the Two Dragons to be the most fun weapon, even when I haven't fully figured it out. The R2 moveset in general is complicated, yet there's so much you can do once you can figure how you can even use some of its abilities.

  • @corey_clip
    @corey_clip Рік тому +4

    If you're having an issue with andreus's blue attack, get close to him and go to his right or left. The attack only hits where the two heads are so it's super easy to avoid. Also you can run behind a pillar to avoid fuoco's big flame attack

  • @TheKataclism
    @TheKataclism Рік тому +5

    When the furnace boss is about to spill fire on the ground, just hide behind the pillars and it doesnt damage you

  • @wildwombatarmy
    @wildwombatarmy Рік тому +16

    For your complaint around min 13: The game actually tells you that you should keep the boss ergos because you can exchange them for power full items later.
    Also for conusmables there is a vendor that sells them indefinetly.

    • @DnDM-
      @DnDM- Рік тому

      Can’t buy weapons back though

    • @Void-Knull
      @Void-Knull Рік тому

      @@DnDM- why would you sell a weapon?

  • @ozzyjb1533
    @ozzyjb1533 Рік тому +1

    regarding the secret passage to the alchemist island. Antonia did know about the passage but she tells us that its locked from the other side, when the cat and fox & maybe the black rabbit brotherhood sneak into and attack hotel krat it is presumed they used the secret entrance and left it unlocked allowing P to use it to reach the island. Up until that point the passageway was locked off so Antonia didn't think it worth mentioning. Now the next point this raises is if she knew then that meant that at any point an attack could've happened and she would've been able to warn us. To that i say that, at that point in the story the Alchemists weren't known to be a threat, the passageway was created out of a mutual trust between krat and the alchemists and with hotel krat acting as a safe haven in the puppet frenzy it was likely assumed by Antonia that the alchemists werent a threat.
    To address the gold coin fruit point. I think the gold coin fruit is meant to be a vital ingredient in creating powerful medicines but it on its own is not able to cure illness. "Giango" was a "rookie" alchemist and as such he couldnt synthesise a proper cure for Antonia and instead only made something to help ease her pain as she passed away. We know from the post credit scene that Giango or "philippus Paracelsus" (his real name) is a lot more interesting than he lets on and likely could've created a cure for Antonia but just didnt to help further his cover as a rookie alchemist.
    Regardless i liked your review Colin. Keep up the good work.
    p.s when you have the overheat affliction you can Roll to remove it fast making the kings flame boss a joke.

  • @morepower6800
    @morepower6800 Рік тому +3

    Lise of P is definitely is a lovely surprise and being the studio frist game and actually made it work and crafted in such passion is an achievement of its own and it doesn't deserve to be called flawed because the overall experience and execution is top tier even if i has minor issues but that's why it's minor because the great things overshadows it

    • @C0LIN.
      @C0LIN.  Рік тому

      Pretty much everything has “flaws” either subjectively or objectively saying something doesn’t have flaws is kinda weird. And I agree the great elements out shine the bad or decent elements but still don’t think this game is a 10/10

  • @bryantlebron6163
    @bryantlebron6163 Рік тому +2

    For anybody who wants an easier time playing through, do an advance build. It surprised me how many bosses I took out on my first try. Feel free to tell this to anybody that's still on the fence about the game.

  • @youngboi382
    @youngboi382 Рік тому +3

    Just beat it as well-44 hours I hated it up until after I beat the arch bishop. Just couldn’t get the perfect block timing down until I found a playstyle for me you still do have to have some type of a grasp on the mechanic but it’s not a make all break all, when you have Spector and broken throwable’s. Certain enemies and situations they set you up in is down write illegal but I wouldn’t say elden ring bad-some are very close mind you (cough cough the Barron swamp or any beam parkour obstacle). Game forces you to use everything literally roll,block, perfect block, and parrying is very iffy tbh they have a diff Rhythm then the PB. I got the true ending and seen the after credit scene I really like the fairy tale concept and the story was enjoyable but I do feel like the pacing and gameplay was rough at times. Overall better than most souls like games we get , I’d say it’s the one of the best if not the best along with wo long, remnant:from the ashes, & Nioh. not counting from software games obv.

  • @slashthejackal8558
    @slashthejackal8558 Рік тому +3

    Nah, the dude totally knew his wife was a puppet.

  • @stackedjack8886
    @stackedjack8886 Рік тому +4

    Another thing you overlooked. Antonia did know about the passage, and she does mention it. If you talk to her after the earthquake she'll mention it. The only reason you can't use it is because it's sealed from the alchemist side(which she does state.) You can only use it after the attack because the alchemist open it when they attack the Hotel.
    My man, you mashed buttons through this game or something.

    • @C0LIN.
      @C0LIN.  Рік тому +1

      “Another thing” bruh u mentioned one thing here lol. Also no she doesn’t state that “The alchemists opened the secret passage way” she literally only mentions it after they attack the hotel

    • @stackedjack8886
      @stackedjack8886 Рік тому +2

      @C0LIN. I meant "another thing:" based on the rest of the comment section railing you for missing the whole puppet wife thing you missed.

    • @C0LIN.
      @C0LIN.  Рік тому +2

      @@stackedjack8886 Got ya, should’ve clarified that better. But if u’ve seen those comments u already know I conceded to the point.

    • @Void-Knull
      @Void-Knull Рік тому +1

      @@C0LIN. that's why he made a new point :)

  • @youngboi382
    @youngboi382 Рік тому +2

    The mc names is P but Gepettos sons name was Carlo and our core/heart is his memories and personality so depending how you play you can become a real boy Carlo or stay a puppet P

  • @JbLoco
    @JbLoco Рік тому +1

    I personally love all of the Stalker boss fights and the normal sized puppet boss fights.
    I felt like Zoro competing to be the worlds strongest swordsman.
    Those bosses also just narratively were more interesting to me as well since almost every other boss was merely giant ass puppets.
    The Nameless Puppet is actually my favorite that or the Black Rabbit Brotherhood

  • @YoungLHProductions
    @YoungLHProductions Рік тому +3

    Lies of Colin. A mid flopsterpiece

  • @PouresMaggie
    @PouresMaggie Рік тому +1

    I remember I beat archbishop on one try, felt good, then 2nd phase came around and I had one pulse cell lmao. Took me about 5 tries til a friend told me to just focus on his backside during the 2nd phase. I beat the brotherhood on first try and was ready for phase 2, and was surprised it didn't happen... So far the only boss that really kept hammering me, was the king of puppets, like you said that 2nd phase was brutal, til I equipped a heavy ass weapon and realised I can interrupt him when he goes haywire. Anyway, LoP is GOTY for me, if not for anything else, you can pick up the cat and wiggle it.

  • @matthewweaver8212
    @matthewweaver8212 Рік тому +1

    That was a really solid video man. Nice job

  • @themasquerader101
    @themasquerader101 Рік тому

    I just love that this game is kind of the other side of the Dark Souls coin in a way. In DS, its all about not losing your humanity, whereas in LoP its about gaining your humanity.
    I think that was their original working concept, but i could be wrong

  • @16xthedetail
    @16xthedetail Рік тому +2

    Not at all defending puppet of the future, but there is a lever to get rid of the poison water so you just fight it on dirt. Of course it’s guarded by one of the fire shovel robots though lol

  • @nethal8506
    @nethal8506 Рік тому

    Oh yeah for the King of puppets in Ng+ you can actually understand him, and you get to realize that he actually disobeyed Geppetto and started fighting the Alchemists. As Geppetto started the puppet frenzy to fight defeat Simon and his beasts and also to gather ergo to revive Carlo(That is P). He ordered the puppets to start killing Krat population infected with the petrification disease (Which was like the entire population at this point), the king of puppets broke free of Geppetto's will and started focusing fighting the monsters created by the petrification disease. Geppeto used the king of puppets as a scapegoat and that's why our main character didn't hear him out.

  • @PeXis
    @PeXis Рік тому

    The attacks that push you back when perfect blocked are supposed to be forward dodged so you won't get pushed back. I think it was a good design choice.

  • @HorrorISPassion2
    @HorrorISPassion2 19 днів тому

    4:53 Because P sees everyone as a threat, even the KoP. Gepetto basically makes him believe that the puppets are out for harm and are no good.

  • @Budd631
    @Budd631 Рік тому +5

    Giving a review of bosses with a specter has to change your view quite a bit I would think. I did it solo the whole game and the bosses were oppressive at times. Every boss was 2 phases at the end and they became slogs to me. Just my thoughts..

  • @thecreator126
    @thecreator126 Рік тому

    I just used the booster glaive and wrench head until I got the live puppet axe then swapped out the wrench. Charge Heavy’s do about 2,000 damage and it carried me through the game.

  • @choonsik460
    @choonsik460 Рік тому +1

    2:30 Giangio is Paracelsus in credit secen so bad guy
    3:50 He knew her wife is puppet

  • @CygnusX-11
    @CygnusX-11 Рік тому +1

    most bosses were meh... still a very enjoyable game overall! the devs are definitely on my radar now and i'm really excited for their next project

  • @johnhealey6455
    @johnhealey6455 10 місяців тому +1

    Definitely a masterpiece. GOTY for me.

  • @iio_moon
    @iio_moon Рік тому +2

    The guy knows that his wife is a puppet. He believes in love between puppet and human and gives the ring to p if you fetch the ring to him after optaining it.

    • @Neeono
      @Neeono Рік тому +1

      SPOILER ALERT!!!
      later on you can find out that his wife, the puppet, actually did love him and developed a conscience or, got her conscience back, since Ergo is distilled human souls, so to speak.
      You have to free someone from the Alchemist Isle, he says he'll go to Rosa Isabelle Street, talk to him there, and he'll point out where you can read it.

    • @HorrorISPassion2
      @HorrorISPassion2 19 днів тому

      ​@@Neeono Yeah she writes it but it's hidden behind her back.

  • @supnep24
    @supnep24 Рік тому

    17 days. Great video Colin been loving the content

  • @Regufyz
    @Regufyz Рік тому +1

    I know a reason for shadowplay disabling is that a windows update is idle in the background. At least that was what happened to me alot

  • @justondement4458
    @justondement4458 Рік тому +1

    This game for sure has its hiccups, but those are overshadowed by its beauty

  • @haixaldonix4945
    @haixaldonix4945 9 місяців тому

    24:52 i don't know if anyone already told you but you can drain the poison water from the arena and it makes the fight a lot easier

  • @BeardedOneDuh
    @BeardedOneDuh Рік тому

    Some tips on laxasia.
    Summon a spectre with the acid wishtone equipped.
    Imbue your weapon on the grindstone with acid.
    Watch her melt

  • @YourMajeste503
    @YourMajeste503 Рік тому

    The two dragon sword does a little *ching* and sparkle, and seems to have a slightly more forgivong window then the perfect guard, but it does have a wind up

  • @Hjh826
    @Hjh826 Рік тому +1

    There are more videos about souls games called "title: A flawed masterpiece" than there are hairs on my bum.

  • @darrenfields7361
    @darrenfields7361 Рік тому

    I like taking the fire axe handle and putting the big pipe wrench head on it and then beating people with a wrench as Pinnochio is endlessly fun

  • @DnDM-
    @DnDM- Рік тому +1

    This game is nothing but anger and frustration. Currently on the last chapter, had no fun the entire playthrough besides the Archduke and King of Puppets who were actually fun to fight. Anyone else is a mess of spamming attack strings and delayed attacks. Attack window is pretty small for the weapon I like to use as well (electric chainsaw)

  • @loverofpeoplez
    @loverofpeoplez Рік тому

    the katana move parries when the weapon does the shiny thing

  • @thecreator126
    @thecreator126 Рік тому

    I have strong theory on what happened to Carlos. There’s only one other event mentioned in the story but was never elaborated on and that was a train accident. I remember reading something about how Veligni’s train project was supposed to connect all of Krat but was forced to stop after a “Terrible Accident” happened.

    • @ShuraSeverence
      @ShuraSeverence 11 місяців тому

      I believe he died of the petrification disease. If u have fought the nameless puppet it’s believed that’s Carlos body. The puppet has its legs and maybe other limbs cut off those might be the limbs effected by said disease

  • @allandm
    @allandm Рік тому +1

    I agree that combat just isn't as fun as jedi fallen order or sekiro.. lies of P is great, but enemies attacks are too awkward and unintuitive to get into a flow

  • @who_hurt_youproductions8826
    @who_hurt_youproductions8826 Рік тому +2

    Giorgio is not a good guy 😅 especially after that end credit scene

  • @YureiOni
    @YureiOni Рік тому

    I couldn’t believe that the tree they were looking for was right outside in the hotel courtyard…?

  • @kimetsunoacademia3528
    @kimetsunoacademia3528 9 місяців тому

    not to brag, but I was that guy. The only boss that took me while was Laxasia who killed my like 4 times. But other than that this game was a comfortable weekend completion for me. Nameless Puppet was actually piss easy for me because I just parry baited him a lot, and killed him on my 2nd try. It took me 29 hours in total to beat Lies of P

  • @brianswigers1874
    @brianswigers1874 Рік тому

    one thing in this video is concerning the Two Dragon sword parry, it has really consistent parry windows with much more leniency as well as a attack back stunning enemies

    • @C0LIN.
      @C0LIN.  Рік тому

      I’m talking about when u hold R2 and u get a parry with that, that was inconsistent and I couldn’t find a clear way to see when it would and wouldn’t parry

    • @synical69
      @synical69 Рік тому

      @@C0LIN.the parry window is at the tail end of the animation *before* the swing
      So the stance P does is the parry

  • @TTVBunnyDougie
    @TTVBunnyDougie Рік тому +5

    This game is a masterpiece. Period.

    • @mr.kinder4734
      @mr.kinder4734 Рік тому

      Nah, really good but not masterpiece

    • @hummus_boss
      @hummus_boss Рік тому

      ​@@mr.kinder4734far from being a great game! A masterpiece!!!!! Come on 😂

    • @mr.kinder4734
      @mr.kinder4734 Рік тому

      @@hummus_boss with some tweeks it could become a great game or its a masterpiece when it hits 15 dollars 😅

    • @saltycomet
      @saltycomet Рік тому

      💯

    • @Bulbaf3tt
      @Bulbaf3tt Рік тому

      @@mr.kinder4734skill issue

  • @HenriqueHCA14
    @HenriqueHCA14 Рік тому +1

    Played 7 hours, i really wanted to come back but only after they fix the parry/dodge mechanics. But the game is amazing though

  • @OTBASH
    @OTBASH Рік тому

    "Flawed Masterpiece." Literally used to describe just about any game these days.

  • @slaysyu915
    @slaysyu915 Рік тому +1

    80 hours!? Did you play with your feet?? Beat the game twice in less time...

  • @choonsik460
    @choonsik460 Рік тому

    attack that push you back

  • @greatdevan4084
    @greatdevan4084 Рік тому

    The king of puppets wants his heart that’s why he refuses

  • @IHAVENOLAWS
    @IHAVENOLAWS Рік тому

    I dont see anyone saying anything about this, but the reason you dont get access to the secret path to trismagistus from lady antonia is because you require the gold battery that you get from venigni after defeating the swamp monster in order to be able to call up the submarine that takes you to the alchemist island. without that lady antonia would just be opening up a secret passage to a dead end which would be of no use to you. Sure its not explicitly stated by neither antonia nor venigni but in my opinion thats pretty obviously the reason that she doesnt tell you ahead of time.
    Also to address the gold coin tree and why we didn't have access to it earlier in order to cure lady antonia before her disease even starts. You literally have to get the cure from Giangio, as he is actually a former alchemist he has experimented with the gold coin and he is the only one who both knows how to make the cure and is willing to help you. Just eating the gold coin fruit alone is not enough to cure the petrification so even if the people of the hotel had access to the tree, it would be of no benefit to any of them.

  • @unnoticed9988
    @unnoticed9988 Рік тому +3

    We getting a little loose with the word Masterpiece but yea it was a good game

    • @Bartman73135
      @Bartman73135 Рік тому

      That was my thought, he said its flawed so by definition it's not a masterpiece

    • @jei3970
      @jei3970 Рік тому

      ​@@Bartman73135I mean every game has flaws. Some games people consider masterpieces have flaws, nothing is perfect. For me personally this is easily the best soulslike we've ever had and a masterpiece with some flaws but overall a great game

    • @arielzaborski1789
      @arielzaborski1789 Рік тому

      It already was used loosely with bloodborne

    • @unnoticed9988
      @unnoticed9988 Рік тому

      @@arielzaborski1789 we talking about Lies of P

    • @arielzaborski1789
      @arielzaborski1789 Рік тому

      @@unnoticed9988 just saying it lost its meaning long ago

  • @andrewbryant6059
    @andrewbryant6059 Рік тому

    Romeo the puppet king was Carlos bf and he remembers us aka puppet Carlo but we don't remember him untill after the fight and we get the message from veninie

  • @HorrorISPassion2
    @HorrorISPassion2 19 днів тому

    Actually, that guy does know his wife was a puppet. Some notes hint at that, i forgot which one. And yes he sure does love her, but not society.

  • @MinecraftManager
    @MinecraftManager Рік тому +2

    I swear, every mf makes a review called “_ A Flawed Masterpiece” and think they’re Shakespeare

    • @C0LIN.
      @C0LIN.  Рік тому +2

      I am Shakespeare

    • @Bartman73135
      @Bartman73135 Рік тому +1

      ​@@C0LIN.Bruh if it's flawed, then by definition it's not a masterpiece.

    • @Wowowoi1
      @Wowowoi1 Рік тому

      ​@@C0LIN.Bro is Shakespeare🗣

    • @C0LIN.
      @C0LIN.  Рік тому

      @@Bartman73135 mas·ter·piece
      /ˈmastərˌpēs/
      noun
      a work of outstanding artistry, skill, or workmanship
      Everything has flaws so than nothing should be a masterpiece by YOUR definition

  • @varshard0
    @varshard0 Рік тому

    we kinda see some grafiti in Venini's workshop complained about not getting paid as well as his butler puppet, but not much complain about job lost.

  • @D.v-O4u2c
    @D.v-O4u2c Рік тому

    I FOUND THAT USING GUARD PARRY FABLE ART AGAINST ROMEO ABSOLUTLY STOMPS HIM OUT

  • @ZafoolTV
    @ZafoolTV Рік тому

    To be fair you should know bosses' souls can be exchanged for items at this point. Unless it is your first souls like

  • @JTD_infinity
    @JTD_infinity Рік тому

    I think that I can explain how you (Pinocchio) starts up that also adds gepetto into it
    Pretty much I think that geppeto was going to the train to start up Pinocchio but on his way he was stopped by the mad donkey. So I think he did plan on going to start up Pinocchio but just got stopped on his way there

    • @C0LIN.
      @C0LIN.  Рік тому +1

      I mean maybe, but you’re kind of writing for the story at that point bc nothing in the game tells us this

    • @ecchi12
      @ecchi12 Рік тому +1

      ​@@C0LIN.I mean in defense to you, since when is spending more time on a game a negative 😅

    • @JTD_infinity
      @JTD_infinity Рік тому

      @@C0LIN. that’s very true and it’s all my own speculation but it would make sense as to why he was on the bridge. But after all it’s just a theory

  • @Kaleb._
    @Kaleb._ Рік тому

    Can anyone tell me if the infected puppets (puppets with tentacles) are weak to fire or electricity.

  • @goomyliaplayz7911
    @goomyliaplayz7911 Рік тому +1

    Still isn’t beating Spider-man 2 💀🙏

  • @Kaimana.
    @Kaimana. Рік тому

    For the fuck off rush attack the king of puppets does in his second phase, you can very easily avoid it by dodging to the left. Makes its very easy to deal with. Still, very hard fight.

  • @RoyalAspects
    @RoyalAspects Рік тому

    I was interested in it I barely got into the souls games I started with bloodborne and now I’m on to demon souls. But I might play this alone with Spider-Man 2 before I continue with the souls games

  • @privatenorby
    @privatenorby Рік тому

    So im on NG++ and once you start playthrough 3, you can unlock a p-organ ability that allows you to block enemy red attacks. WHY IS IT LOCKED BEHIND 2 FULL PLAYTHROUGHS?!?!

  • @judgejohnson2796
    @judgejohnson2796 Рік тому

    3:52 uhm actually the guy that gave you the side quest for the wedding ring, he actually did know his wife was a puppet, he was pretending to not know because he didn't know how to explain that situation to you.

  • @SpartonWolf
    @SpartonWolf Рік тому

    Dude he knew his wife was a puppet, he specifically tells us

  • @ryancarberry2040
    @ryancarberry2040 Рік тому

    The game was fun, but it isn't a game I could see myself replaying in a long time.

  • @GetAwesomeGaming
    @GetAwesomeGaming Рік тому

    I thought I remembered that the guy knew his wife was a puppet but didn’t tell us because he was afraid we wouldn’t look for her if we knew??? I’m genuinely asking I have a terrible penchant for misremembering shit 🤔🤷‍♂️🤣

  • @wilfredwayne7139
    @wilfredwayne7139 Рік тому +1

    It's not a masterpiece it's good but far from a masterpiece.

  • @wilfredwayne7139
    @wilfredwayne7139 Рік тому

    I beat everything but can't get past the insta shock on door Guardian. It would be fine if it was like every other stat and built up but he hits you once and your stamina is pretty much f..ked.

  • @EthanVagnier
    @EthanVagnier Рік тому

    He definitely knew she was a puppet

  • @JLeviNow
    @JLeviNow Рік тому

    They explain everything you said they didn't explain you didn't read the collectables

  • @Tc.1289
    @Tc.1289 Рік тому

    Which ending did you get

    • @C0LIN.
      @C0LIN.  Рік тому

      The one where Geppetto says we’ll never be a real boy or some shit

    • @Tc.1289
      @Tc.1289 Рік тому

      @@C0LIN. nice

  • @igobystar5158
    @igobystar5158 Рік тому +1

    Your arguments at min 13 is my biggest problem with this game. The combination of Sekiro parrying+guarding but with Bloodborne combat pacing and health pools is aggravating… Enemies having combo after combo after combo that are impossible to avoid due to lack of stamina or just how poor the dodge roll is, not to mention red attacks that are impossible to avoid.
    The combat is just not satisfying to me, it is a huge struggle half the time, and I haven’t had this issue in any other souls like before.
    Outside of the combat, everything about this game is phenomenal. One of the best soulslike, honestly, but it makes me more disappointed and want to play anything else.
    Star Wars Fallen Order, I believe/agree, has better combat pacing and diversity. Overall more satisfying and fair, when something goes wrong I usually feel it is my fault, as opposed to the game’s janky gameplay.

  • @BMazeing
    @BMazeing Рік тому

    The only flaws I can find so far (just beat Andreus) are the pixellations/grainy mists on/around some character's faces when talking. Also, Andreus's skin textures take a hot second to load during one part of his boss cutscene. Finally, the animal masks/nicknames thing felt a little too adjacent to "furry" detritis

  • @LostInTranslation-kl2of
    @LostInTranslation-kl2of Рік тому

    You can drain the corruption in the robot of the future fivht

  • @Juice2k23
    @Juice2k23 Рік тому +1

    We need more spider man 2 news from you

    • @C0LIN.
      @C0LIN.  Рік тому

      Don’t talk about news unless it’s big, also the game comes out in 17 days lol

    • @Juice2k23
      @Juice2k23 Рік тому

      @@C0LIN. still miss seeing the spider man 2 news from you bro💯

  • @corey_clip
    @corey_clip Рік тому

    The puppets of the future are so stupidly easy it's almost laughable

  • @yevhentarik4551
    @yevhentarik4551 Рік тому

    Omg “challenge” uses summon in each fight

    • @C0LIN.
      @C0LIN.  Рік тому

      I didn’t really use summons all that much? I only used them when I’ve already beaten the first phase and wanted to fight the 2nd phase quicker. I said in the beginning of the video not all gameplay is mine

  • @Voideadd
    @Voideadd Рік тому

    He didnt work with simon because the alchemists created the disease that carlo died from

  • @Nomadestra
    @Nomadestra Рік тому

    Just so you all know, if you're going to start a new playthrough, you may want to wait for mid November. The devs are making a pretty major balance update set to come out then. Also why people should wait to make in depth reviews right off the go. Good chance this video will be outdated in several gameplay regards once the patch comes out.

  • @christianotto5553
    @christianotto5553 Рік тому

    If you think the shady-looking cylinder alchemist was good, watch the post-credit scene.

  • @Pyromaniac963
    @Pyromaniac963 11 місяців тому

    3:35 He literally says in his dialogue that she was a puppet, how did you miss that lmao

  • @dindoyop7478
    @dindoyop7478 Рік тому

    Ah i see, i sae your recommendation of that cool music game hi fi rush or something so i have another gamepass game to play

  • @Thonato420
    @Thonato420 Рік тому

    Lies of piss, approved
    btw, there's news about swing assist for spiderman 2, where the default is set to max (level 10, also considered to be as easy as spiderman 2018 and miles)
    so imagine how much more freedok you have when that assist goes down to 0, fuck and if we include the fact that we have loopy loops and fall damage
    ambatabust 😩

    • @nickypool415
      @nickypool415 Рік тому

      I would probably put on "no fall damage" for me to practice the Air tricks. After I master it, I probably turn it off.

    • @abstraktfilms
      @abstraktfilms Рік тому

      @@nickypool415ah but you haven’t mastered it unless it’s turned off

    • @nickypool415
      @nickypool415 Рік тому

      @@abstraktfilms huh??

    • @abstraktfilms
      @abstraktfilms Рік тому

      @@nickypool415 maybe not the best analogy but I immediately thought to martial arts. You can’t wait to master it before going toe to toe with someone actually trying to beat you. You master it BY going toe to toe. If you lose half your health bar, that lesson would probably be learned a bit faster than if you didn’t. Feel me?

    • @nickypool415
      @nickypool415 Рік тому

      @@abstraktfilms oh I get it ! Interesting concept! Thank you for the idea! Perhaps maybe Once I master it with no fall damage, I should push myself to master it with Fall damage.
      Thank you for such an inspiring ideas!

  • @Barney_rubble983
    @Barney_rubble983 Рік тому

    It took me 79 hours as well.

  • @ibonihs
    @ibonihs Рік тому

    the only bad thing about this game is very vague and sometimes (rarely) wrong information. it’s better than elden shit for me.

  • @birdsoup777
    @birdsoup777 Рік тому

    Just beat Mad Clown. Cleared the Opera house Opera House and got ass kicked by the boss. It's an awesome game but It's starting to suck and feels slapped together. Instead of getting better it's getting irritating and lazy redundancy. I do think it's awesome.

  • @AmadísdeGaulaa
    @AmadísdeGaulaa Рік тому

    have to agree with these criticism

  • @ydydg
    @ydydg Рік тому

    about the nivdia thing it will never work lol it happened to me and i never found the solution i even tried formatting my pc and it didnt work