Im baffled by the majority of their answers being about detail similarities such as pork and hijab and none of them mentioning the most obvious theological difference that is the trinity, and god taking the form of a human in Christianity which is considered blasphemy in both Islam and Judaism
a lot of muslims like me do not even think that some people believe in some thing really ludicrous like the trinity and because christians here in (the middle east) do not even breach the trinity .. so muslims for that reason do not connect between christianty and the trinity as the thing that mark christianty
I don't think they know much about Judaism other than the obvious external things. That's just due to lack of exposure and language barriers. Also it's the religion of their oppressor so its difficult to have the urge to learn about it.
@@kusari86 If that is the case, would you say these respondents were more attuned to the cultural stuff than the spiritual? Because it seemed like the main concerns were hijabs and pork, not much about spiritual life at all, or did i miss something?
Actually Christianity focus more on faith while Judaism focus more on laws. Islam take seriously on both belief/faith (i'tiqad/'aqidah) and laws (fiqh/ahkam).
What makes islam closer to judaism is tawheed (unicity of God). This is the fondation of monotheism. Ban on pork or wearing hijab are secondary considerations.
As a muslim I find Islam more similar to judaism in some points : -they both insist on the learning the holy books (Torah and Coran) but they have also religious laws that rule all the aspect of life (halakha with Talmud and Sunna with hadith) -examples : don't eat pork, women cover their head (not in the same way though), men have to grow beard, men and women must separate in some points and not shake hand each other, halal and Kashruth, Jews and Muslims perform ablutions, both think the soul leaves the body during sleeping, both are strict toward polytheism etc It's what I learned
Also daily prayer is part of Judaism & Islam (Jews 3 times a day). Do you know about the Muslim holiday of Ashura? Do you celebrate it? (I think it's only for Sunnis).
@@scottsimon8543 Ashura is a day that commemorate the episode when Moussa (Moses) crossed the red sea and was saved from Pharaon. It is narrated in sunnah that the prophet Muhammad ﷺ took it from the Jews. It's not as celebrated as the two 'eid. Shias have it too but give another symbooic.
@@MehdiZanjabil Thanks. I think this is one of the things that brings Muslims & Jews closer, because the Exodus is probably one of the most important things in Judaism.
Of all the important similarities that Islam and Judaism have, some pointed to "not eating pork" and hijab. They say nothing that they have the same prophets, except for two, they believe in the absolute uniqueness of God, they have similar moral laws and they do not use images for worship, among others.
Yes, Islam is based on Judaism. Most of the rituals are exact copy from the Talmud which what Mohammed would’ve been familiar with when meeting the descendants of the Hebrew nation
@@Yosaif-Israel Not really. Islam has a very ancient Abrahamic tradition that is related to the faith of the ancient Hebrews through Ishmael and Isau. Modern Judaism is a derivative of Pharisaism. What is certain is that Haredim and Salafis are very similar in doctrines and attitudes.
@@gerardodeoscar4875 It might seem so to someone from the outside on the surface, who is not very educated in either, but the Hebrew tradition is definitely more ancient then Islam and it’s continuous and live today as always by the descendants of Aber
The old man on the thumbnail comes to mind for me, he cites correctly that all 3 stem from Judaism yet concludes that the most recent addition to the trilogy must be correct
Definitely closer to judaism than Christianity. It is actually easier to list the differences than the similarities. Islam is technically Judaism to the whole world instead of only the tribes of Israel
Islam is far closer to Christianity. Judaism is a small ethnic folk religion while Islam and Christianity are giant missionary religions which seek as many converts as possible.
islam and judaism are way more similar than "they both dont eat pork" lol. the fundemental differnce between islam and christianity is the concept of trinity and their expression of worship
@@Ash_Queen16 the fundamental concept is always about God Himself, the core belief of monotheism. Regarding the law regarding religion in practice or as we said it as Syariah law, it was updated and renewed from predecessors but the core belief will never change.
According to Jewish law, a Jew is allowed to pray in a mosque, but forbidden to enter a church, because it is considered idolatry. Jews and Muslims pray to the same God, and even call him in a similar way. Christianity believes in the Trinity, which in the eyes of Judaism is a violation of God’s unity.
Superficially islam is similar to Judaism but the core of the difference is the fact that HaShem, yud-heh-vav-heh, is the name of our Creator while in islam they have a nameless god. One reason why G-d gave us His name is so that when the people of Israel would encounter the false gods of the nations, be it jezeus/yeshu or allah, they would immediately recognize that it is NOT the same deity as the G-d of Israel. Islam is a counterfeit religion that seems to mimic Judaism but is actually complete idolatry. Like a pig with split hooves, only by opening it up will a person realize that it is indeed not kosher. In islam, a reader of the quran is immediately given false information compared to what is in Tanakh. Muslims worships a nameless false god allah that has false prophets jezeus/yeshu/isa and mohammed who speak on his behalf. They have their Kaaba in Mecca, not the Beit HaMikdash in Yerushalayim. Yerushalayim is not mentioned once in the quran while Yerushalayim is where HaShem put HIs Holy name to live forever. Muslims face Mecca when praying and point their asses towards the holiest of holies on Temple Mount. Muslims believe that jezeus/yeshu/isa will return to kill a fictional dajjal and rule as Moshiach for 40 years while in Judaism Moshiach ben David is not a re-incarnation or return of a false prophet, and rules forever. The quran, like all islamic sacred texts, are all fiction. It is an error to think that islam's god and HaShem are the same. The muslims shout "allahu akhbar!" when they kill Jews.
For me as a musilm even if I don't agree with isreal (Zionists) doesn't mean I'm gonna denied the similarities between islam and Judaism it's the same in 95% , Christianity is a way different we share some things but the basic of their religion completely the opposite of ours.
@@Ash_Queen16 The origin of the belief is that God is one, He neither beget nor is born and not associate in the worship of his lord anyone. That's why they're similar, if they believe in Mohammed as last messager and Issa he is the messiah they'll be musilm. Unlike Christians, the whole foundation is different.
Islam is far closer to Christianity. Judaism is a small ethnic folk religion while Islam and Christianity are giant missionary religions which seek as many converts as possible. Christianity and Islam are religions, while Jews are a nation with a religion. Also Islam regards Jesus as a prophet and focuses on belief and the afterlife just like Christianity. I have to ask, from where/whom did you learn about Judaism and how many Jews do you know.
This makes me cry. The Muslims, Christians, and Jews are from the same prophet Abraham, yet there are people using religion to fight against each other.
In my opinion Islam is closer to Judaism just because of one thing and that’s sad that nobody brought it up because its the first thing we must believe in. We believe in one god (one being).
You posed the question in a way that gave them an existential problem. By asking which of the the two other religions Islam resembles, you are asking them to implicitly acknowledge that Islam is DERIVED from the other two religions. The question should have been: "which of the other two religions is more like Islam". In the interview, the first man to answer, and the translator missed this, mumbled: هم بيشبهوه, meaning that they (Christianity and Judaism) are the ones that resemble Islam. This is the same cognitive dissonance you got one time when you asked "what were you or your ancestors before you/they became Muslim", and they couldn't acknowledge that their ancestors at some point were not Muslim, but were Jews, Christians, or idol worshippers.
Nah Islam already explains tbis All Muslims know that Christianity and Judaism are similar to Islam (or say it other way around) and they also know that most people think that islam is derived from them Christianity and judaism and they're ok with it because they believe that earlier form of the true religion were corrupted into Christianity and judaism and last prophet came after that so they do acknowledge the fact that Christianity and Judaism are older in that sense because the previous true religion was not known to people as islam
@@supersaiyan3693 you know nothing about Islam. They absolutely DON'T don't believe that Islam is DERIVED. Islam is the direct word of God. Not derived from existing corrupted religions.
@@supersaiyan3693 lookup the video where they are asked what their ancestors were before Islam. Not a single one got himself to say something other than Islam. They say they were always Muslim. 🤷♂️
@@samispam1000 A religion can not be corrupted. Religious leaders can be corrupt or can misinterpret a religion. Which happens to every religion, even Islam.
They say that Islam is closer to Judaism, while completely ignoring the fact that Jews reject Jesus, while Muslims do acknowledge him as the Messiah, similar to how Christians consider Christ as the Messiah, and both Christianity and Islam believes in the Second Coming of Christ, while a Jew believes the Messiah has yet to come in the world.
@@Gazzapa57 Christian believe the first one coming to be Isa as "Messiah" which actually the Dajjal. Muslim believe Isa a.s will come after the Dajjal as the true Messiah that will destroy Dajjal
@@mohamadazliazman2899 Wrong. Similar to Islam, Christianity acknowledges that the Antichrist will come first. Then after the Great Tribulation and the persecution of everyone who shall not worship the Antichrist, then Jesus will come back to defeat the Antichrist in Armageddon.
Just discovered and joined your channel. This is so fascinating and insightful -- I'm looking forward to exploring the rest of your videos. I have a MA in Middle Eastern Studies and it's been years since I've been to Israel and the Occupied Territories but interesting to me some ideas havent changed. Thank you for your channel
3:18 in video guy says islam is closer to god then Christian because they can't eat pork? Why? Because the animal lives in its own filth? Chickens are dirty too birds are one of the dirtiest animals too
@@trinchuzosparty keep trying to shape the reality for your desire. No one, except a few countries, recognizes Israel's claim of the West Bank and Gaza Strip.
I feel sad about the difficulty of some of them to recognize the similarity of Judaism and Islam. Some reasons are superficial (eating pork and hijab) and the guy who said "Islam doesn't resemble to any religion" and can't motivate with words the answer, leaves me confused 😅 the curiosity to know about other cultures can only enrich somehow 😅
It's because of the lack of exposure to other religions. There are Arab Christian's who they've grown up with who speak their language, thus they might feel more of a connection with them. We aren't taught in depth about other religions unless we have a conversation with those who follow said religion.
They are answering based on observed behavior rather than theology. To be fair to your point, these people are probably not aware of the other theologies. It’s not so different in the west, people would say Islam has no similarity to Christianity, they worship a ‘moon God,’ they cover their women, etc.
@@cw6795 I mean based on the environment, you can't blame them. They've been colonised by them and mistreated which is why one of them said we feel closer to the Christians.
I am a Muslim, but the Jews worship the same God as us, and the Christians worship the Father according to their belief, and they also worship Jesus. This is different from us as monotheistic religions, and there are idols among Christians, and Islam and Judaism hate the worship of idols.
As a Christian I would say Protestant and Catholic Christianity is more similar to Reform Judaism but Islam is more similar to Orthodox Judaism and East Orthodox Christianity
Catholicism and Orthodox are very very similar. The doctrine is almost the same. Protestantism intead is different, no respect for BV Mary, scattered in many denominations etc...
as an israeli jew i feel Islam is much more similar. it makes sense since the romans made Christianity to fit european pagans at the time even though christianity originated in Judea. i speak some arabic so its worth mentioning that hebrew and arabic are like cousin languages.
Superficially islam is similar to Judaism but the core of the difference is the fact that HaShem, yud-heh-vav-heh, is the name of our Creator while in islam they have a nameless god. One reason why G-d gave us His name is so that when the people of Israel would encounter the false gods of the nations, be it jezeus/yeshu or allah, they would immediately recognize that it is NOT the same deity as the G-d of Israel. Islam is a counterfeit religion that seems to mimic Judaism but is actually complete idolatry. Like a pig with split hooves, only by opening it up will a person realize that it is indeed not kosher. In islam, a reader of the quran is immediately given false information compared to what is in Tanakh. Muslims worships a nameless false god allah that has false prophets jezeus/yeshu/isa and mohammed who speak on his behalf. They have their Kaaba in Mecca, not the Beit HaMikdash in Yerushalayim. Yerushalayim is not mentioned once in the quran while Yerushalayim is where HaShem put HIs Holy name to live forever. Muslims face Mecca when praying and point their asses towards the holiest of holies on Temple Mount. Muslims believe that jezeus/yeshu/isa will return to kill a fictional dajjal and rule as Moshiach for 40 years while in Judaism Moshiach ben David is not a re-incarnation or return of a false prophet, and rules forever. The quran, like all islamic sacred texts, are all fiction. It is an error to think that islam's god and HaShem are the same. The muslims shout "allahu akhbar!" when they kill Jews.
Islam is more similar to Judaism than mainstream Christianity. Because both Judaism and Islam believe in the oneness of God, they both have Halal and Kosher, although Kosher is more strict. But on the other hand, Islam believes in Jesus, while Jews don't believe in him. Muhammad is the latest and final prophet of God, he came with the Quran which replaced the Torah and the Gospel.
Islam and Judaism teach that you must save yourself. Christianity teaches that nothing you do can save you because God is Holy and just. If you sin, then you must be punished for breaking his laws and you are separated from him. God himself provided his Son to take our punishment and we are imputed Christ's righteousness when we trust in Jesus. Muhammad could not do one miracle to prove he was from God.
I can’t believe how people are missing the most crucial similarity : Islam and Judaism are pure monotheism and they prohibit idolatry, unlike Christianity
@@forlornhauntedghost It is. There are always statues, paintings, crucifixes and Christians look up to them when they pray to “God”. Just the fact that having them around is considered idolatry. Not to mention that it is really creepy and disgusting as well (no offense). Having such objects is a form of paganism. Islam and Judaism prohibit that. Christianity does not. If Jesus came back today, he would be upset towards Christians who made him a god and something he never claimed, and for the fact of all this idolatry stuff.
@@forlornhauntedghost yes Christians still do it. I respect Islam for at least being honest and pure about their faith in God. I have no issues with Christians, but they clearly practice idolatry and polytheism as understood by Jews and Muslims. Speaking as a Jew.
@@GhostPanther_X Please! The black stone of Kaaba is the worst object of idolatry in the world. Truly disgusting is that massive stampedes happen to just get to the stone to perform profane and blasphemous act of idol worship. Idolatry is precisely *worship* of idols. Christians do not worship crucifixes, statues or paintings. These are all part of rich religious cultural heritage Christianity has had over 2000 years. Also, you must have a misconception of Christian Trinity - Christianity is pure monotheism. Persons of God - Father, Son, Holy Ghost are all same God. Christians believe all persons are full incarnations of same Almighty.
@@terro3842 you lost me at Christianity is pure monotheism. Because it is far from the truth. Not even in the ball park. Christianity was assimilated from the Roman pagan beliefs by Constantin when Rome was having a Civil War and was being attacked by the “barbarians” across all of its borders. It was a way to unite people and the Trinity thing was created right there by the new Roman Catholic Church because it made it easy for the Roman pagans to accept it that way.
Islam and Judaism share the same god, Judaism prays 3 times a day while in Islam 5, we both pray in a direction to a specific monument (the West Wall and Mecca), Halal and Kosher are pretty much the same but Jews won't eat meat and dairy product together (both won't eat porky). We share the same father - Abraham who has 2 sons Ishmael and Issac (Jews and Muslims pretty much cousins) and much more. As a Jew, it's sad to see how little they know about us.
It's not about how little we know cause I'll tell you they VERY much know the similarities. But hundreds of years of Jews and muslims living together was wiped out in the last 75 years, that now older people feel hesitant to acknowledge these facts and younger people most of them are too blinded by what Zionists do that they feel like they cant trust any jew. It's sad now that in my country to insult someone who back stabbed u u just call them a jew. Hopefully the two cousins can reunite somehow.
The Rambam said that we are allowed to pray in Mosques but not churches because of the issue of Advodah Zara (idol Worship)... Its an issue that Christians deify a man. It is irrelevant that they deified a Jew
you believe we deified a man while we believe that the Deity itself "humanified" itself in a certain way because thats what a real and most loving God would do towards his own creatures. Christ was always God the Word as he is pre-existent to his incarnation, He created the world and controls all things and even while on earth he was present in heaven (the Bible says all of this). Read the scriptures well, you know : all of it ; the angel of the Lord, the messiah coming down a cloud (unique symbol of divinity in the Old testament) in the book of Daniel. all of it. you will see that its not other then God himself, who wrestle with jacob, visited abraham, spoke with moses etc. , that is the Messiah ,and will be shown to the eyes of the head to the world.
@@OrthoFireCrusaderThe Old Testament and the Tanakh while sharing similarities are not the same books and some verses sound very different in the Old Testament compared to the original Hebrew which makes sense since that's the only way to find jc in the book that you call OT so reading the Old Testament the only book that has some relevancy to Judaism since it's based albeit changed from the Hebrew Bible (Tanakh) would be useless to a Jew because we are not reading the same book.
@@LemonCamel It's disingenuous to call 150 words a wall of text. Certainly the scholars of the talmud wouldn't be put off by a medium-sized paragraph. I have no horse in this race, I'm a postmodernist. But if you want to talk comparative theology it's going to be longer than a five second sound bite.
Judaism and Christianity are more similar because both have the same holy book and both have the same religious history, Islam is the only monotheistic religion, the original heritage of the prophet Abraham!
Similarity between christianity and islam is that the followers converted a lot of other people from other regions , if they would have kept to themselves it would have been Middle Eastern sects.
@@rxtr664 Of course not. Millions of people were converted to Christianity and Islam through conquest. Judaism has always been a small ethnic folk religion which doesn't proselytize. Study history.
There are more similarities between Islam and Judaism. The reason is that both have the same concept and the ruled countries and so there are religious laws and concepts for the state. Something that many don't know is that Moshe Mimon or Mousa ibn Maimon, is the most well-known Jewish scholar in the last 2000 years. He was an assistant for Salahulden Al-Ayoubi, the well-known Islamic leader and he learned how to organize Jewish law from Muslim religious scholars. And as well, he added many things to the. Islamic history .
Fascinating. Hidjab and pork seemed to be the two central concerns, and maybe a couple other external things. Nothing about dogma, specific concept of divinity, eternal life, truth, ultimate reality, inner spiritual life, even worship services. I'm stunned frankly. Beyond that commonality was a strange diversity 'all over the place' kind of random perceptions. I suspect Christians would answer with a lot more consistency, especially Orthodox Christians. This is very eye opening. One of the best questions asked actually. Very revealing. Almost surprising but not really.
Their responses are based on observations of practices and culture. They see the Jewish women wear a hijab like them; they see the Jewish people don’t eat pork, like them. One guy sees that neither group washes for prayer or after the bathroom, so he thinks Islam is like neither. One guy knows Arabs who are Christians and therefore thinks Christianity is more similar. People are not factoring in theology, probably they don’t even know the beliefs of the other groups.
@@ahmeda.3198 Which is absolutely astonishing, because theology IS the main point of any religion BY FAR, unless it's really something else masquerading as religion.
@@comment6864 Ha, go and see the video where he asks this same questions to Israeli Jews. The answers he gets are variations of: 1. Muslims, because they have modesty. 2. Christians, because Jesus was Jewish 3. Muslims, because they are monotheistic. The Jewish answers are largely just as shallow as the Muslim answers, does your mind also suspect that Judaism is something else that’s simply masquerading as a religion? It’s obvious to anyone who isn’t a bigot these people don’t learn in depth about the deeper beliefs of any religions, and they probably don’t directly interact a whole lot, so this is what they observe.
@@comment6864 I want you to go watch the video this guy has where he asks Israeli Jews the same question, and when you see that they respond also based on observation, not theology, let us know is it still ‘eye opening’ and do you feel that Judaism is something else ‘masquerading’ as a religion? I really want to know, because I doubt you would reach the same conclusions. The Jewish people asked have no clue about Christian or Muslim theology. One guy says there is more similarity to Christians because Jesus was Jewish, and the next guy says more similarity to Muslims because Christians worship an alien pagan God. Do you think if we go find some Christians in that area that they will give a detailed critique of Jewish or Islamic theology. These are not sophisticated people like you such that they can discern what is some evil force masquerading as a religion; they don’t have the benefit of listening to all the paranoia podcasts you subscribe to that keep you vigilant against evil and all that. They are not as smart, not as worldly, not as brave as someone like you.
@@ahmeda.3198 I actually don't really disagree with anything you said. "does your mind also suspect that Judaism is something else that’s simply masquerading as a religion?" Well, actually, i think for many jews it is! That's been my impression for a long time. My observations have always been that jewishness is only like 50% about religion, at best, and i would say both as percentage of people as well as degree for any given person, roughly. I would go further and say that it is very spread among many Christian denominations as well this utilitarian approach to religion - something 'nice to have' when your raising kids LOL. Personally i am fascinated by this because to me it makes absolutely no sense. Religion makes no sense to me at all, UNLESS you believe it to be the truth, i.e. REALITY. Logically to me that is the only reason to have A religion - that it is in fact the bigger reality, NO LESS. For that obviously it has to be very concrete and specific.
I’d say it’s similar to Judaism in monotheism and in respect for the law. But similar to Christianity in not being obsessed with the law or ritual and focused on the spirit of the law.
@@Unlimi-PT not obsessed with laws and rituals surrounding food, bathing, sex, dressing, etc. I don’t mean it as an insult. The way Muslims are obsessed with tawhid or Christianity is obsessed with meekness and forgiveness.
@@Unlimi-PT In the Bible, there are two sacraments for Christians: holy communion and baptism. Neither is required for salvation. Salvation is by grace, a gift from God, just have faith in Jesus. The Catholics added other requirements like the Rabbis have added the oral Torah.
Many of the people talk from a very religious point of view and they simply don't know a correct answer. They simply can not even imagine that Islam can possible resemble any other religion. All monotheist religions resemble one another because they are versions of the same tradition, which emerged in the Middle East. different nations interpreted it differently and these three versions were developed. Coming from a Muslim country, in my opinion, Islam and Judaism are closer to each other than Christianity. Also, just look inside the synagogues, I sometimes get confused whether a building is a synagogue or a mosque. So much similarity.. Also the way people pray and sing is very similar.
Judaism is unique , Christianity is different , and Islam is the new Judaism for the Gentiles of the world , as Muslim copied parts that suit them the best , both from the Torah and the New testament .... Judaism is really unique
@@rollingknuckleball The Quran changed many times... Actually the Quran was compiled together only in 1924 , ( The Cairo edition , the King Fu"ad ) , which is different from the one of Abu baker , and today the entire Muslim world follows the Cairo edition , Muslim disagreement over whether to include the Basmala within the Quranic text , reached consensus following the 1924 Edition , which included it as the first verse ( āyah ) of the Quran chapter 1 , but otherwise included it as an unnumbered line of text preceding the other relevant 112 chapters. The Cairo Quran adopted the Kufan tradition of separating and numbering verses , and thus standardized a different verse numbering to Flügel's 1834 edition. It adopted the order of chapters attributed to Ibn Abbās , which became widely accepted following 1924. A large number of pre-1924 Qurans were destroyed by dumping them in the river Nile , meaning that you Muslims believe in a book that came 1300 years after Muhammad , so please don't try to argue with someone who is learning Arabic history and pre Arabic history .... By the way did you know that Islam is doomed to fade away from the world ( According to Islamic sources ) .. Hadith , Sunan Ibn Majah 4049,,,,,, ( It was narrated from Hudhaifah bin Yaman that the Messenger of Allah said.. Islam will wear out as embroidery on a garment wears out , until no one will know what fasting , prayer , (pilgrimage) rites and charity are. The Book of Allah will be taken away at night , and not one Verse of it will be left on earth. And there will be some people left , old men and old women , who will say , We saw our fathers saying these words , La ilaha illallah’ so we say them too. Silah said to him , What good will (saying) , La ilaha illallah do them , when they do not know what fasting , prayer , (pilgrimage) rites and charity are? Hudhaifah turned away from his. He repeated his question three times , and Hudhaifah turned away from him each time. Then he turned to him on the third time and said , O Silah , It will save them from Hell , three times ) ... Truth hurts
@@aqfj5zy First off , let's see one of the biggest mistakes the Quran has , which means that it cannot be the word of God... But read it till the end , if you are not afraid.... Surah 19 16-28 .. "And mention in the Book ˹O Prophet, the story of˺ Mary when she withdrew from her family to a place in the east ,,,,Surah 19 16 ..( this is talking about mary the mother of Jesus ) ... screening herself off from them. Then We sent to her Our angel, ˹Gabriel,˺ appearing before her as a man, perfectly formed,,,, Surah 19 17 , and it continues talking about Mary and the encounter with angel Gabriel , until she conceive , and in verse 27 , 28 we found this , Then she ( Mary , not Miriam ) returned to her people , carrying him ( baby Jesus ) . They said ˹in shock˺, “O Mary! You have certainly done a horrible thing! ( Yeah i personally agree becoming pregnant , while her man was away ) .. But then the biggest mistake , a writer can do happened in the next verse 28 , where the writer deliberately wrote , O sister of Aaron! 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣 ( wait a Sec ) 🤣🤣🤣 Your father was not an indecent man , nor was your mother unchaste.”🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣 , how did the sister of Aaron suddenly became the mother of Jesus 🤣🤣🤣🤣 wooooooow , how was this writer so ignorant and stupid , that he wrote , that the people who saw Mary mother of Jesus , will suddenly say to her , O sister of Aaron , your father was not an indecent man , nor was your mother unchaste 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣... Don't tell me that this is not a huge , huge mistake , that can never come from the words of the real creator... Please , tell me that you see the mistake , and if not , our conversation is Over , because im not ready to argue with a person who accepts Human mistakes , by saying that they are not , and are just the true Word of God .... Ok i know Muslims , you will even defend mistakes and Contradictions , when it talks about your faith .. But if you agree with the mistake , we can then continue to see mistakes , and more mistakes , that are being found in the book of the Arabs ..
Judaism and Christianity are more similar because both have the same holy book and both have the same religious history, Islam is the only monotheistic religion, the original heritage of the prophet Abraham!
@@anakgembala7253The Jews have the Tanakh and Talmud, while the Christians have the Bible, and Abraham was Jewish. Islam didn't exist until the 7th century CE.
Hi corey I am donating you Can you ask the palestinians what they think about left wing israelis who support peace with them but still love israel and know its their home? For example i am like that and i don’t care if israel will become one state called “israel&palestine” and both people live in peace together and equallity on the law. Or two states
hi, here is an answer, I am an atheist Palestinian, and I think the right on both sides is causing all this suffering, a one-state solution "secular state" would be the only solution for this problem, take religion out of the equation and the problem will become solvable.
@@darkenergy824 never heard before of Palestinian atheists But if you and me were the ones to choose what will happen here - there long before was peace
@@arielhatav0232 there are atheists in Palestine but, I am not open about it. I hope the number of those like us will increase in the future and finally, we can have peace.
@@darkenergy824 One-state solution that is secular would be the State of Israel. Israel allows freedom of religion, and there are considerable Arabs hold power in Israel. Particularly the Druze. Example: Ahmad Tibi, currently the deputy speaker of Knesset. Regardless, i do pray for immediate Peace in the region and may everyone prospers.
I think what happened with the Christianity of today is because it has been Westernised. Orthodox Christians are more traditional. But modern Christianity has been westernised
In comparison to islam, Judaism is not pure monotheism. Jews believe Jacob beat Allah in wrestling and then Allah had to take rest after 6 days of creation. These 2 things undermine Allah's majesty.
@@andys3035 lol, read the Qur'an before saying such hilarious things 😂😂 and for the hands and legs you clearly didn't read the old testament (Torah ) that says god was walking in heaven searching for adam who was hiding behind a tree and that Adam heard the steps of god lol (the Qur'an says that there is nothing like god so he isn't the same as us(The Creator of the heavens and the earth. He has made for you mates from yourselves, and for the cattle (also) mates. By this means He creates you (in the wombs). There is nothing like unto Him, and He is the All-Hearer, the All-Seer), God means Allah in arabic as human means insan in arabic)
@K.M4655 it appears you haven't read the verse you are using to try and prove your point. It never says God was walking in heaven or that Adam was hiding behind a tree, it just says among the trees. Genesis 3:8 And they heard the voice of the LORD God walking in the garden in the cool of the day: and Adam and his wife hid themselves from the presence of the LORD God amongst the trees of the garden. Our theology allows for God to incarnate, yours doesn't. So your allah has 2 right hands, one foot and gonads and is nothing like creation. So what is an uncreated foot like? You can't say because there is no direct analogical predication for it.
Only difference being that the quran is from god while the Torah and rabbinic literature comes from the remaking of the jewish scripture after it was destroyed.
first of all the translation should be worked on, specially that there are words added that aren't mentioned or meant by the context. the on ground translator isn't understanding well or translating well. 2nd of all it's weird to say Islam is closer just because they forbid pork.. The main problem between Christianity and Islam is the theological belief of Trinity vs Tawahid, then it follows the recognition of The prophet and his revelation. then finally those matters come back to the interprations of both faiths as every school of thought has different forbidden and allowed matters and if Muslims know Christians also have same things forbidden under Mosaic law but according to the majority of Christians those laws are no longer needed as Jesus was crucified for the People's sins. Muslims and Christians has more in common with the spiritual sides like (Tasawof for muslims) and (Monasticism for christians) - the believe that Sin is inevitable to humankind (muslims exempt the prophets from that) - Muslims believe that Jesus was born Miraculously from a Virgin birth - Muslims believe Jesus is the Massaih that will come at the end of days - Both have missionary in terms like Evangelism and Da'wah - Both believe in Universalism - Both Islam and Christianity spread rapidly and far from their places I didn't mention other core similarties that's also shared between Christians, Muslims and Jews like Scriptures, Eschatology, Ritual prayer, Social Justice, Pilgrimage, etc. However the main similarities that makes Muslims and Jews look more similar are: - the Monotheistic God (no trinity concept), - the rejection of Jesus being God - the similar practices and rules. It's very complicated topic, since Muslims also prefer the Christian universal look of things as both muslims and christians has rules like usury ban that is universal from and to all, however jews on the other hand has it forbidden but not from jews to none jews. those kind of details with other major one like the Rabias in the Talmud challenging and winning on God is also consider a big deviance from the monotheistic perspective of God to Muslims and Christians.
From the Christian perspective, Islam is more similar to Christianity than Judaism. Islam respects Christ, Judaism does not. But Islam is closer to Judaism than Christianity.
I feel like your translator should get some more credit in the after section of the videos TBH. She’s doing really good work. I think she should get more credit.
As a Muslim, I was surprised to learn that Judaism doesn't believe in the afterlife, they focus more on this life. slam and Christianity believe and focus on the afterlife.
you are suprised because its a lie, judiasm focus on the afterlife, most of their poems are about leaving the body and the matirial word in favor of praying and worshipping god
Islam is actually less similar to Judaism than Christianity is to Judaism. But it depends on which version of Judaism one means. In Jesus' time, there were the Pharisees, Sadducees, Zealots and Essenes. But even if a comparison is made to the common themes in those Judaisms, Islam doesn't have a priesthood, no Liturgy, no atoning sacrificial system, the temple layout is different from the mosque, divine imminence (God dwelling in the midst of His people as Yahweh was in the Ark of the Covenant). Islam is actually a mix of Arianism (heretical sect in Christianity), paganism and Judaism. All these elements were present in Arabia 1400 years ago and the result was Islam. St. John of Damascus documents how Muhammad was in contact with an Arian monk who probably had an impact on him. But Muhammad's knowledge of the Torah and Christian writings was limited and was at times relayed to him by word of mouth of the common people who lived among him. For example, there is a Surah in which Muhammad is called to judge a dispute of adultery between some Jews. He asks for the Torah and places it where he was sitting and says to judge according to it. That same Torah forbids the eating of camel of which the Hadiths confirm Muhammad ate.
Such theological differences like priesthood, Liturgy, atoning sacrificial system, the temple, divine imminence are above the average persons knowledge and in my exprience the vast majority of Muslims in middle east know next to nothing about even their own religions theology. btw the story of Muhammad judging by Torah is in hadith and Muhammad mixed gnostic and docetist theology
As a muslim myself, outwardly Judaism is Much closer but if i were to say which is closer holistically i couldn't objectively tell because they're both close but in vastly different ways. For jews Jews circumcise, don't eat pork, slaughter Kosher, have fixed prayer times, wear modest clothes, grow their beards, believe in One God, do passover to commemorate God leading his the followers of Moses out of Egypt. Follow laws etc. For Christians They believe in an hell and Paradise, believe Jesus عليه السلام is the Messiah. Believe in his second coming, believe there will be an antichrist. So it's pretty hard to say which is closer. Obviously Judaism is closer outwardly though and I'd rather live amoungst religious jews than Christians
Islam is far closer to Christianity. Judaism is a small ethnic folk religion while Islam and Christianity are giant missionary religions which seek as many converts as possible. I would like to respectfully ask from where/whom did you learn about Judaism, and how many Jews do you know?
@@burnin8orable from Chassidic Jews in Newyork. As i said tho, to say it's far closer to Christianity id disagree. Both have similarities but in vastly different ways
Christians are much more close to as a people and community, so we should prefer to live amongst them more, the Quran tells us that the closest and kindest people to us are those who say we are christians@@muwahid5022
Superficially islam is similar to Judaism but the core of the difference is the fact that HaShem, yud-heh-vav-heh, is the name of our Creator while in islam they have a nameless god. One reason why G-d gave us His name is so that when the people of Israel would encounter the false gods of the nations, be it jezeus/yeshu or allah, they would immediately recognize that it is NOT the same deity as the G-d of Israel. Islam is a counterfeit religion that seems to mimic Judaism but is actually complete idolatry. Like a pig with split hooves, only by opening it up will a person realize that it is indeed not kosher. In islam, a reader of the quran is immediately given false information compared to what is in Tanakh. Muslims worships a nameless false god allah that has false prophets jezeus/yeshu/isa and mohammed who speak on his behalf. They have their Kaaba in Mecca, not the Beit HaMikdash in Yerushalayim. Yerushalayim is not mentioned once in the quran while Yerushalayim is where HaShem put HIs Holy name to live forever. Muslims face Mecca when praying and point their asses towards the holiest of holies on Temple Mount. Muslims believe that jezeus/yeshu/isa will return to kill a fictional dajjal and rule as Moshiach for 40 years while in Judaism Moshiach ben David is not a re-incarnation or return of a false prophet, and rules forever. The quran, like all islamic sacred texts, are all fiction. It is an error to think that islam's god and HaShem are the same. The muslims shout "allahu akhbar!" when they kill Jews.
As a non religious person i'm a bit disappointed to see, that almost all of them only focused on the most shallow parts of their religions, only on what is forbidden. They seem to not know their own religion and it's history very well.
This question reminds me of a meme I saw online: Islam 🫱🏽🫲🏼 christianity: Jesus was important. Judaism 🫱🏽🫲🏼 islam: don't eat pork, circumcision. Judaism 🫱🏽🫲🏼 christianity: hebrew bible. Islam 🫱🏽🫲🏼 judaism 🫱🏽🫲🏼 christianity: atheists suck
Islam & Judaism have many similarities, & it's not just the connection to Abraham. Mohammed had a Jewish friend who taught him about Judaism. This is why Muslims have similar dietary laws like hallal, circumcision & they also have their sabbath on Friday. They also celebrate Ashura which commemorates the Jew's exodus from Egypt. Theologically they are also similar - there's only God, no human representatives, & no pictures in houses of worship unlike the Christians which have pictures & statutes of Jesus everywhere which is kind of like idol worship. Muslims pray 5 times a day, Jews 3, in Christianity there's no requirement for daily prayer. Even though Jesus was a practicing Jew, John removed all Jewish rituals & traditions to appeal to pagans.
This video is a perfect example of how a person's environment plays a major role in the answer they provide. I feel confident saying that everyone you just asked never read the Bible cover to cover. I would say Islam is closer to Judaism in more important aspects of the religion based upon the Islamic teachings, and that would be Tawheed or the first commandment in the forefront. Christians have a trinity, which is a teaching foreign to Judaism and Islam. If one were to make a list of similarities and differences between the three, it wouldn't be as black and white, due to them all overlapping one another in different regards. Also, each religion has its unique practice/belief in some aspects, for example, in Islam, there's the belief that God sent prophets throughout the globe since day one, while Christians and Jews don't have such a teaching in the Bible. We also have examples where Muslims and Christians match through their belief in Jesus' ministry. One of the biggest similarities between all three is that we share common values and the belief in an intelligent source to all existence. This is a big reason why we should work together against those who are trying to change our values and highlight our differences so that we are distracted by fighting one another, while they come from behind and poison our children.
You Muhammadan polytheistic pagans are unrelated to Christianity and true Judaism, and the God of Abraham, Isaac and Jacob is foreign to you Muhammadan Saracen pagans.
@@comment6864 no, the root is the Creator. And some Jews during his time did acknowledged him but they rejected him, some accepted him and his message, while some don’t acknowledge him at all
So we as Muslims in Palestine are raised to think of Christians as worshiping one god. We try to disassociate them from the trinity, we were raised this way to lessen the divide between Christians and Muslims.
I would have thought the trinity makes it impossible to reconcile Christianity with Islam or Judaism. At least that is some sort of theological difference between them. Pork and hijab are more like customs for some than core beliefs, not to mention all those graven images permissible in churches. When it comes to LGBT issues all three are much of a muchness.
@@dogbert52 I am sure you are right in Crhistian theology, but it is not allowed in Judaism (and Islam) where god is ONE - without a son and without a separate holy spirit.
Nope mate. Christianity in modern day has very little common root with the early christianity in the past. I mean the Trinity, and the over-forgiveness, acceptance of LGBT+, idol woreshipping, warmongering, adultery, etc and etc.
Doesn't make much difference. It's the same for modern Islam, or modern Jewish Religion. Also, I grew up in Catholic institutions. I know a lot more about the core of that religion.@@Commievn
@@CommievnYou clearly got your info from fakers 🤯 @kobea5wagyu642 Adultery is against the Bible! Literally says so in the 10 commandments. And no LGBTQ+ acceptance (we are nice to them yes and don't hate them), and no killing!!! No warmongering! Idk what type of Christianity you're on about? @kobea5wagyu642 But Trinity and forgiveness are what I agree with, you have to love thy enemy and forgive those who sin against us just as we ask for forgiveness for our sins but anyways I'm going to stop ranting sorry I was just so appalled 😅 And mine is no idol worshipping but I see what you mean by that because other denominations have something similar but it's a sin to worship an idol or golden bull, that makes God very angry
@@Ibrahim_12468 So, in America, women can apply perfume without a man giving her permission to. It’s funny she’s selling items that could get her beat or worse but all it is, is perfume! It’s a funny, but sad, picture to me.
@@danielstringhm3805 A women doesn’t need permission to apply perfume, she can only apply it in the presence of her husband, related family members, or other women.
Outwardly islam is more like Judaism. As they still follow many laws including some that can only be found in the Torah, e.g. male circumcision, tatoos forbidden. There is nothing in Quran that forbids these only by inference. Mohammed copied qibla and even sawm from Jews before the alleged ayat were revealed. As well ss set prayer times and how to pray. However islam copies christian eschatology, belief in an opposing force to the creator, shaytan. And also took on ideas from the like of Tertullian and simon the martyr who villainised Jews. The reality is Christianity & islam are really types of subsects of Judaism.
Islam is closer to Judaism but in the Quran, God mentions that Christians will be more loving to Muslims but that is because we love Jesus and Mary too.😊
Majority of Christian’s support the Gaza genocide. They are not our friends. O you who have believed, do not take the Jews and the Christians as allies. They are [in fact] allies of one another. And whoever is an ally to them among you - then indeed, he is [one] of them. Indeed, Allah guides not the wrongdoing people. Q5:51
Poor south and East Asians, native Australian and Native American and Africans. What is the name of the prophet/ s who was send to you? It seem to be God/ Alah is interested in one small geographical area.
In my opinion when it comes to worship Islam is closer to Judaism in its forbidden use of icons and images of prohpets and saints. In universal outreach Islam is more like Christianity in that it is a proselytizing religion and instead of the church they have the Ummah. What separates Christianity from both of them is its not really rooted in any particular ethnicity, culture, language etc...which probably makes Christianity more malleable to local cultures that were not Abrahamic in origin.
1. Before Israel, there was a British mandate, not a Palestinian state 2. Before the British Mandate, there was the Ottoman Empire, not a Palestinian state. 3. Before the Ottoman Empire, there was the Islamic state of the Mamluks of Egypt, not a Palestinian state. 4. Before the Islamic state of the Mamluks of Egypt, there was the Ayubid Arab-Kurdish Empire, not a Palestinian state. 5. Before the Ayubid Empire, there was the Frankish and Christian Kingdom of Jerusalem, not a Palestinian state. 6. Before the Kingdom of Jerusalem, there was the Umayyad and Fatimid empires, not a Palestinian state. 7. Before the Umayyad and Fatimid empires, there was the Byzantine empire, not a Palestinian state. 8. Before the Byzantine Empire, there were the Sassanids, not a Palestinian state. 9. Before the Sassanid Empire, there was the Byzantine Empire, not a Palestinian state. 10. Before the Byzantine Empire, there was the Roman Empire, not a Palestinian state. 11. Before the Roman Empire, there was the Hasmonean state, not a Palestinian state. 12. Before the Hasmonean state, there was the Seleucid, not a Palestinian state. 13. Before the Seleucid empire, there was the empire of Alexander the Great, not a Palestinian state. 14. Before the empire of Alexander the Great, there was the Persian empire, not a Palestinian state. 15. Before the Persian Empire, there was the Babylonian Empire, not a Palestinian state. 16. Before the Babylonian Empire, there were the Kingdoms of Israel and Judah, not a Palestinian state. 17. Before the Kingdoms of Israel and Judah, there was the Kingdom of Israel, not a Palestinian state. 18. Before the kingdom of Israel, there was the theocracy of the twelve tribes of Israel, not a Palestinian state. 19. Before the theocracy of the twelve tribes of Israel, there was an agglomeration of independent Canaanite city-kingdoms, not a Palestinian state. 20. Actually, in this piece of land there has been everything, EXCEPT A PALESTINIAN STATE. (Borrowed from a friend) A little more history for those wanting to 'restore Palestine'. In 132 AD the Emperor Hadrian resolved to stamp the Jews and their religion out of existence. He sold all Jewish prisoners into slavery after the revolt of Bar Kikhba, forbade the teaching of the Torah, renamed the province Syria Palaestina, and changed Jerusalem’s name to Aelia Capitolina. He renamed Israel to wipe out the national identity of Israel and the Jews. So if you are looking to 'restore Palestine to the Palestinians', you need to give it back to the Jews.
@@ori1676 But you don't and you can't. You are in your sins and separated from the holy and just God. It takes a blood sacrifice for forgiveness of sins. God let the temple be destroyed, but he first provided the perfect sacrifice, his Son. Like he provided a ram for Abraham to sacrifice instead of his son. Your good works cannot save you and you have not obeyed all of his commandments. Only Jesus did.
Islam and Judaism are closer: Strict Monotheism Importance of Keeping the Commands Importance of Kosher and Halaal Importance given to Modest dress Very large Majority of Jews know that Muslims worship the same God whilst alot Christians believe Muslims worship a Moon God or Demon.....
Judaism and Christianity are more similar because both have the same holy book and both have the same religious history, Islam is the only monotheistic religion, the original heritage of the prophet Abraham!
@@anakgembala7253 We don't believe in the same god as Muslims sorry to break it to you guys, muslims don't even know the name of god they think its "Allah".....
These seem to be well thought out answers. However both Christianity & Islam are both obsessed with the afterlife while Judaism pays very little attention to it.
Yes, because Judaism is obsessed with the worldly pleasures. They learn to be greedy from a young age. I've seen how the children eat food. Jews also created Usury, which is putting interest on the poor to become richer. Now, every bank follows this system. Pretty much they will do anything to get rich, even if it means changing the words of God. You believe Jacob wrestled with God, It was most likely an angel. But because of this, you think it's ok to argue with God and not obey him. Jews only care about their fellow jews. And your wrong Islam has equal importance for both this world and the hereafter.
Judaism and Christianity are more similar because both have the same holy book and both have the same religious history, Islam is the only monotheistic religion, the original heritage of the prophet Abraham!
@@salamyaya162 I never said the trinity, but the holy ghost is mentioned in the torah, the trinity is 3 in 1, god, holy ghost and the son. same entity in 3
@@JewFromIsrael55522 be careful & remember we will be judged in the Day of Judgement, to the One who owned the heaven and hell, before it's too late to regret. Have a good day.
Islam adopted many aspects of Judaism such as the dietary laws and the prohibition on graven images. It took little from Christianity except that they believe Jesus was a prophet.
Ironic, considering there are two main branches since the get-go (sunna, shia) and several off-shoots, which wouldn't be recognized by him (ismaili, ahmadiyya, sufi etc.)
Answer: more similar to Satanism. Take a look at the names given to Allah: Al-Mutakabbir (الْمُتَكَبِّر): This word means "The Arrogant" or "The Very Proud". It is often used to describe someone who is proud or arrogant to the point of defying God. Ad-Darr (الضَّارّ) : It means "The Causer of Damage" or "The Nuisher". It can be used to describe someone who intentionally causes harm or injury to others. Al-Muzil (المُذِلّ): This word means "The Lowerer" or "He Who Humbles". It is often used to describe God as the One who lowers or humiliates those He wishes. Al-Makir (المَكِّر): It means "The Great Strategist" or "The Great Planner". It is used to describe God as the Supreme Planner who can have mysterious and unfathomable purposes. Al-Fattan (الفَتّان): This word means "The Seducer" or "The Corrupter". It can be used to describe someone who tries to seduce or corrupt others.
Ironically the comment section on Corey's video's often speak readily of the similarities of Islam and Judaism. I am not referring to non religious Jews of course, but practicing ones. The laws of both Islam and Judaism both have circumcision, the head covering, the modesty in clothing, not only not eating pork for both, but special dietary law (halal & kashrut), they both have forms of religious cleansing (I won't elaborate there) but Christianity expects none of these of their practitioners. Muslims and Jews both pray several times a day Muslims five, Jews 3. Do Christians pray several times a day? Yes they can if they want to, but Christianity does not mandate how many times, they pray as often as they want!
palestinian orthodox christian here :) we pray 7 times a day and we fast for most of the year [vegan]. before taking the holy eucharist we also fast for 10 hours. modesty is also explicit and most orthodox women are veiled.
I was looking for a Orthodox Christian response because I’ve known a few from Muslim countries and as a Muslim I felt we were similar. I’ve known Jews and didn’t feel like the values were similar at all. By the way I’m a Black American born Muslim to “convert” parents.
christianity has laws on food. "abstain from food sacrificed to idols, from blood, from meat of strangled animals". But most people don't eat such meat anyways.
O People of the Scripture, there has come to you Our Messenger making clear to you much of what you used to conceal of the Scripture and overlooking much. There has come to you from Allah a light and a clear Book. By which Allah guides those who pursue His pleasure to the ways of peace and brings them out from darknesses into the light, by His permission, and guides them to a straight path. They have certainly disbelieved who say that Allah is the Messiah, the son of Mary. Say, "Then who could prevent Allah at all if He had intended to destroy the Messiah, the son of Mary, or his mother or everyone on the earth?" And to Allah belongs the dominion of the heavens and the earth and whatever is between them. He creates what He wills, and Allah is over all things competent. But the Jews and the Christians say, "We are the children of Allah and His beloved." Say, "Then why does He punish you for your sins?" Rather, you are human beings from among those He has created. He forgives whom He wills, and He punishes whom He wills. And to Allah belongs the dominion of the heavens and the earth and whatever is between them, and to Him is the [final] destination. O People of the Scripture, there has come to you Our Messenger to make clear to you [the religion] after a period [of suspension] of messengers, lest you say, "There came not to us any bringer of good tidings or a warner." But there has come to you a bringer of good tidings and a warner. And Allah is over all things competent. (Al-Quran translation 5: 15-19) فِي الْبَدْءِ خَلَقَ اللهُ (Allah) السَّمَاوَاتِ وَالأَرْضَ According to arabic translations of the bible that you can find online, Allah (الله ) is the Creator of the heavens and the earth in Genesis 1: 1 Indeed, your rabb (Lord) is Allah, who created the heavens and earth ... (Al-Quran translation 7: 54)
They say, "Be Jews or Christians [so] you will be guided." Say, "Rather, [we follow] the religion of Abraham, inclining toward truth, and he was not of the mushrikun." Say, [O believers], "We have believed in Allah and what has been revealed to us and what has been revealed to Abraham and Ishmael and Isaac and Jacob and the Descendants and what was given to Moses and Jesus and what was given to the prophets from their Lord. We make no distinction between any of them, and we are Muslims [in submission] to Him. (Al-Quran 2: 135- 136) Say, "O People of the Scripture, come to a word that is equitable between us and you - that we will not worship except Allah and not associate anything with Him and not take one another as arbaban (lords) instead of Allah ." But if they turn away, then say, "Bear witness that we are Muslims [submitting to Him]." (Al-Quran 3: 64) Abraham was neither a Jew nor a Christian, but he was one inclining toward truth, a Muslim [submitting to Allāh]. And he was not of the mushrikun (eg. polytheists.) (Al-Quran 3: 67) فِي الْبَدْءِ خَلَقَ اللهُ السَّمَاوَاتِ وَالأَرْضَ (Genesis 1: 1) In the beginning, God ( الله ) created the heavens and the earth -from arabic translations of the bible. Indeed, your rabb (Lord) is Allah, who created the heavens and earth ... (Al-Quran translation 7: 54) Aalaha or Alaha refers to God in Aramaic. Aramaic is a semitic language having similarities with Hebrew and Arabic.
Im baffled by the majority of their answers being about detail similarities such as pork and hijab and none of them mentioning the most obvious theological difference that is the trinity, and god taking the form of a human in Christianity which is considered blasphemy in both Islam and Judaism
this is because most people focus on the concrete rather than the abstract, and the superficial rather than the deeper significance
Replacment theologies focus on replacing the origin. The oldest theology.
@@dogbert52The most useless of the bunch, that is
a lot of muslims like me do not even think that some people believe in some thing really ludicrous like the trinity and because christians here in (the middle east) do not even breach the trinity .. so muslims for that reason do not connect between christianty and the trinity as the thing that mark christianty
I don't think they know much about Judaism other than the obvious external things. That's just due to lack of exposure and language barriers. Also it's the religion of their oppressor so its difficult to have the urge to learn about it.
Let me help you all what most Muslims think!
Muslims get along with Christians more than Jews!
However, Islam & Judaism are closer to each other!
But i like muslim and dont like jews and iam christian.jews are land thiefs
I get on well with Ultra Orthadox Jews aaaalas not Askenazi. \this is a bsd time to be alive.
CHistians are more friendly because they do not practice a strict religion.
Jrews believe this is the time of one world religion , much the same as the belief the Muslim Messiah.
Zionists are irreligious and will be cursed by the God of Jews.
Fascinating. I had always considered Orthodox Jews much closer to Muslims in beliefs and cultural practices. These guys agree.
Muhammadans are only similar to them in their hatred and envy of Catholics.
Spiritually we are closer to Christians and culturally Jews
@@kusari86 I could see that.
@@kusari86 If that is the case, would you say these respondents were more attuned to the cultural stuff than the spiritual? Because it seemed like the main concerns were hijabs and pork, not much about spiritual life at all, or did i miss something?
Actually Christianity focus more on faith while Judaism focus more on laws. Islam take seriously on both belief/faith (i'tiqad/'aqidah) and laws (fiqh/ahkam).
What makes islam closer to judaism is tawheed (unicity of God). This is the fondation of monotheism. Ban on pork or wearing hijab are secondary considerations.
As a muslim I find Islam more similar to judaism in some points :
-they both insist on the learning the holy books (Torah and Coran) but they have also religious laws that rule all the aspect of life (halakha with Talmud and Sunna with hadith)
-examples : don't eat pork, women cover their head (not in the same way though), men have to grow beard, men and women must separate in some points and not shake hand each other, halal and Kashruth, Jews and Muslims perform ablutions, both think the soul leaves the body during sleeping, both are strict toward polytheism etc
It's what I learned
Also daily prayer is part of Judaism & Islam (Jews 3 times a day). Do you know about the Muslim holiday of Ashura? Do you celebrate it? (I think it's only for Sunnis).
@@scottsimon8543 Ashura is a day that commemorate the episode when Moussa (Moses) crossed the red sea and was saved from Pharaon. It is narrated in sunnah that the prophet Muhammad ﷺ took it from the Jews. It's not as celebrated as the two 'eid.
Shias have it too but give another symbooic.
@@MehdiZanjabil Thanks. I think this is one of the things that brings Muslims & Jews closer, because the Exodus is probably one of the most important things in Judaism.
Circumcision, lunar calendar, fasting ....
@@jslevy2597 true. An original one I read from sunnah and heard from rav : the prohibition of drinking or eating standing
Of all the important similarities that Islam and Judaism have, some pointed to "not eating pork" and hijab. They say nothing that they have the same prophets, except for two, they believe in the absolute uniqueness of God, they have similar moral laws and they do not use images for worship, among others.
I could be wrong but I don't believe Muslims believe in any of our female prophets either.
Yes, Islam is based on Judaism. Most of the rituals are exact copy from the Talmud which what Mohammed would’ve been familiar with when meeting the descendants of the Hebrew nation
@@Yosaif-Israelbla bla bla
@@Yosaif-Israel Not really. Islam has a very ancient Abrahamic tradition that is related to the faith of the ancient Hebrews through Ishmael and Isau. Modern Judaism is a derivative of Pharisaism. What is certain is that Haredim and Salafis are very similar in doctrines and attitudes.
@@gerardodeoscar4875
It might seem so to someone from the outside on the surface, who is not very educated in either, but the Hebrew tradition is definitely more ancient then Islam and it’s continuous and live today as always by the descendants of Aber
This broadcast is intriguing on so many levels.
And your not cause all you know is lies.
Islam is definitely closer to judaism since we both believe in one true God Elohim/Elah/Allah.Shalom Aleichem Rabbi Singer :)
The old man on the thumbnail comes to mind for me, he cites correctly that all 3 stem from Judaism yet concludes that the most recent addition to the trilogy must be correct
@@lih-fk8by Exactly, all you know is lies. He said source not Judaism.
Tovia! You’re here! Did you recently discover this Chanel ? Or it’s just your first comment haha.?
Definitely closer to judaism than Christianity. It is actually easier to list the differences than the similarities. Islam is technically Judaism to the whole world instead of only the tribes of Israel
Wait u mean it's easier to list the similarities than the differences right?
Satanism is also monotheism.
@@kyumeko yes
Islam is far closer to Christianity. Judaism is a small ethnic folk religion while Islam and Christianity are giant missionary religions which seek as many converts as possible.
@@Cobra-gl7orIt could be considered by some to be monotheistic. It depends on whether you consider God, Satan, or both deities.
islam and judaism are way more similar than "they both dont eat pork" lol. the fundemental differnce between islam and christianity is the concept of trinity and their expression of worship
But in Judaism, alcohol is allowed and Muhammad isn’t regarded as a prophet. That’s a fundamental difference right there
@@arnoldzilban8274 Huh?
weird and not true@@arnoldzilban8274
@@Ash_Queen16 Also Muslims don't accept the Torah
@@Ash_Queen16 the fundamental concept is always about God Himself, the core belief of monotheism.
Regarding the law regarding religion in practice or as we said it as Syariah law, it was updated and renewed from predecessors but the core belief will never change.
According to Jewish law, a Jew is allowed to pray in a mosque, but forbidden to enter a church, because it is considered idolatry. Jews and Muslims pray to the same God, and even call him in a similar way. Christianity believes in the Trinity, which in the eyes of Judaism is a violation of God’s unity.
Superficially islam is similar to Judaism but the core of the difference is the fact that HaShem, yud-heh-vav-heh, is the name of our Creator while in islam they have a nameless god.
One reason why G-d gave us His name is so that when the people of Israel would encounter the false gods of the nations, be it jezeus/yeshu or allah, they would immediately recognize that it is NOT the same deity as the G-d of Israel.
Islam is a counterfeit religion that seems to mimic Judaism but is actually complete idolatry. Like a pig with split hooves, only by opening it up will a person realize that it is indeed not kosher.
In islam, a reader of the quran is immediately given false information compared to what is in Tanakh. Muslims worships a nameless false god allah that has false prophets jezeus/yeshu/isa and mohammed who speak on his behalf. They have their Kaaba in Mecca, not the Beit HaMikdash in Yerushalayim. Yerushalayim is not mentioned once in the quran while Yerushalayim is where HaShem put HIs Holy name to live forever. Muslims face Mecca when praying and point their asses towards the holiest of holies on Temple Mount. Muslims believe that jezeus/yeshu/isa will return to kill a fictional dajjal and rule as Moshiach for 40 years while in Judaism Moshiach ben David is not a re-incarnation or return of a false prophet, and rules forever. The quran, like all islamic sacred texts, are all fiction.
It is an error to think that islam's god and HaShem are the same. The muslims shout "allahu akhbar!" when they kill Jews.
Please look up Sam Shamoun on The Trinity.
"In the eyes of Judaism".. the Trinity is not and cannot be understood at all.
@@comment6864its too complicated for you to grasp, dont project your dumbness to all other people
As a Muslim i also believe its judaism that is most closer to islam. Theologically its very similar to
For me as a musilm even if I don't agree with isreal (Zionists) doesn't mean I'm gonna denied the similarities between islam and Judaism it's the same in 95% , Christianity is a way different we share some things but the basic of their religion completely the opposite of ours.
Jews don’t follow Muhammad so that’s a fundamental difference
@@Ash_Queen16 The origin of the belief is that God is one, He neither beget nor is born and not associate in the worship of his lord anyone. That's why they're similar, if they believe in Mohammed as last messager and Issa he is the messiah they'll be musilm. Unlike Christians, the whole foundation is different.
@@SD077Q They don’t believe in Jesus as a prophet, they don’t advocate for proselytizing, they allow alcohol consumption, they don’t believe in hell.
Islam is far closer to Christianity. Judaism is a small ethnic folk religion while Islam and Christianity are giant missionary religions which seek as many converts as possible. Christianity and Islam are religions, while Jews are a nation with a religion. Also Islam regards Jesus as a prophet and focuses on belief and the afterlife just like Christianity.
I have to ask, from where/whom did you learn about Judaism and how many Jews do you know.
Christians make idols Jews and Muslims don’t
This makes me cry. The Muslims, Christians, and Jews are from the same prophet Abraham, yet there are people using religion to fight against each other.
As a Muslim i feel the same 😢
The broblem of zionat wester
In my opinion Islam is closer to Judaism just because of one thing and that’s sad that nobody brought it up because its the first thing we must believe in. We believe in one god (one being).
You posed the question in a way that gave them an existential problem. By asking which of the the two other religions Islam resembles, you are asking them to implicitly acknowledge that Islam is DERIVED from the other two religions. The question should have been: "which of the other two religions is more like Islam". In the interview, the first man to answer, and the translator missed this, mumbled: هم بيشبهوه, meaning that they (Christianity and Judaism) are the ones that resemble Islam. This is the same cognitive dissonance you got one time when you asked "what were you or your ancestors before you/they became Muslim", and they couldn't acknowledge that their ancestors at some point were not Muslim, but were Jews, Christians, or idol worshippers.
Nah
Islam already explains tbis
All Muslims know that Christianity and Judaism are similar to Islam (or say it other way around) and they also know that most people think that islam is derived from them Christianity and judaism and they're ok with it because they believe that earlier form of the true religion were corrupted into Christianity and judaism and last prophet came after that so they do acknowledge the fact that Christianity and Judaism are older in that sense because the previous true religion was not known to people as islam
@@supersaiyan3693 you know nothing about Islam. They absolutely DON'T don't believe that Islam is DERIVED. Islam is the direct word of God. Not derived from existing corrupted religions.
@@supersaiyan3693 lookup the video where they are asked what their ancestors were before Islam. Not a single one got himself to say something other than Islam. They say they were always Muslim. 🤷♂️
Because Islam is derived from them.
@@samispam1000 A religion can not be corrupted. Religious leaders can be corrupt or can misinterpret a religion. Which happens to every religion, even Islam.
They say that Islam is closer to Judaism, while completely ignoring the fact that Jews reject Jesus, while Muslims do acknowledge him as the Messiah, similar to how Christians consider Christ as the Messiah, and both Christianity and Islam believes in the Second Coming of Christ, while a Jew believes the Messiah has yet to come in the world.
Wrong - Muslims acknowledge Jesus as a prophet and not a Messiah - quite different things.
Jesus is literally named "Al Maseeh"= " The messiah" in the Quran dude. Also muslims believe the second coming of the Messiah = "jesus"@@Gazzapa57
@@Gazzapa57 Christian believe the first one coming to be Isa as "Messiah" which actually the Dajjal. Muslim believe Isa a.s will come after the Dajjal as the true Messiah that will destroy Dajjal
@@Gazzapa57Jesus is a Messiah in Islam. This is basic facts. Next time refrain from speaking on things you don’t know. 🤡
@@mohamadazliazman2899 Wrong. Similar to Islam, Christianity acknowledges that the Antichrist will come first. Then after the Great Tribulation and the persecution of everyone who shall not worship the Antichrist, then Jesus will come back to defeat the Antichrist in Armageddon.
Just discovered and joined your channel. This is so fascinating and insightful -- I'm looking forward to exploring the rest of your videos. I have a MA in Middle Eastern Studies and it's been years since I've been to Israel and the Occupied Territories but interesting to me some ideas havent changed. Thank you for your channel
3:18 in video guy says islam is closer to god then Christian because they can't eat pork?
Why? Because the animal lives in its own filth? Chickens are dirty too birds are one of the dirtiest animals too
Not occupied territories. Oslo accords territories agreements.
STILL-occupied Territories. @@trinchuzosparty
@@trinchuzosparty keep trying to shape the reality for your desire. No one, except a few countries, recognizes Israel's claim of the West Bank and Gaza Strip.
I feel sad about the difficulty of some of them to recognize the similarity of Judaism and Islam. Some reasons are superficial (eating pork and hijab) and the guy who said "Islam doesn't resemble to any religion" and can't motivate with words the answer, leaves me confused 😅 the curiosity to know about other cultures can only enrich somehow 😅
It's because of the lack of exposure to other religions. There are Arab Christian's who they've grown up with who speak their language, thus they might feel more of a connection with them. We aren't taught in depth about other religions unless we have a conversation with those who follow said religion.
@@meez312 i doubt that's the case, they just probably don't like to be associated with zionists and zionist funders
They are answering based on observed behavior rather than theology. To be fair to your point, these people are probably not aware of the other theologies.
It’s not so different in the west, people would say Islam has no similarity to Christianity, they worship a ‘moon God,’ they cover their women, etc.
It's denial on their parts.
@@cw6795 I mean based on the environment, you can't blame them. They've been colonised by them and mistreated which is why one of them said we feel closer to the Christians.
Man just wanted a haircut
I am a Muslim, but the Jews worship the same God as us, and the Christians worship the Father according to their belief, and they also worship Jesus. This is different from us as monotheistic religions, and there are idols among Christians, and Islam and Judaism hate the worship of idols.
As a Christian I would say Protestant and Catholic Christianity is more similar to Reform Judaism but Islam is more similar to Orthodox Judaism and East Orthodox Christianity
Yep
Spot on.
Or in another word.
Liberal (Protestant/Catholic/Reform Judaism)
Conservative (Orthodox Judaism/Christianity and Islam)
But... Catholicism is essentially more strict than Protestants. No priest marries, until Luther went and married off a nun.
Catholicism and Orthodox are very very similar. The doctrine is almost the same. Protestantism intead is different, no respect for BV Mary, scattered in many denominations etc...
as an israeli jew i feel Islam is much more similar. it makes sense since the romans made Christianity to fit european pagans at the time even though christianity originated in Judea. i speak some arabic so its worth mentioning that hebrew and arabic are like cousin languages.
I hope you realize that not all Christians were or are Roman.
Superficially islam is similar to Judaism but the core of the difference is the fact that HaShem, yud-heh-vav-heh, is the name of our Creator while in islam they have a nameless god.
One reason why G-d gave us His name is so that when the people of Israel would encounter the false gods of the nations, be it jezeus/yeshu or allah, they would immediately recognize that it is NOT the same deity as the G-d of Israel.
Islam is a counterfeit religion that seems to mimic Judaism but is actually complete idolatry. Like a pig with split hooves, only by opening it up will a person realize that it is indeed not kosher.
In islam, a reader of the quran is immediately given false information compared to what is in Tanakh. Muslims worships a nameless false god allah that has false prophets jezeus/yeshu/isa and mohammed who speak on his behalf. They have their Kaaba in Mecca, not the Beit HaMikdash in Yerushalayim. Yerushalayim is not mentioned once in the quran while Yerushalayim is where HaShem put HIs Holy name to live forever. Muslims face Mecca when praying and point their asses towards the holiest of holies on Temple Mount. Muslims believe that jezeus/yeshu/isa will return to kill a fictional dajjal and rule as Moshiach for 40 years while in Judaism Moshiach ben David is not a re-incarnation or return of a false prophet, and rules forever. The quran, like all islamic sacred texts, are all fiction.
It is an error to think that islam's god and HaShem are the same. The muslims shout "allahu akhbar!" when they kill Jews.
Blood reletives
@@lookman-2844Muslims and Jews are not blood relatives, Muslims have nothing in common with Jews or Christian’s. I’m a Muslim myself.
and the feuds between relatives are the hardest, unfortunately @@lookman-2844
Islam is more similar to Judaism than mainstream Christianity. Because both Judaism and Islam believe in the oneness of God, they both have Halal and Kosher, although Kosher is more strict. But on the other hand, Islam believes in Jesus, while Jews don't believe in him. Muhammad is the latest and final prophet of God, he came with the Quran which replaced the Torah and the Gospel.
Islam and Judaism teach that you must save yourself. Christianity teaches that nothing you do can save you because God is Holy and just. If you sin, then you must be punished for breaking his laws and you are separated from him. God himself provided his Son to take our punishment and we are imputed Christ's righteousness when we trust in Jesus.
Muhammad could not do one miracle to prove he was from God.
Judaism also doesn’t believe in Muhammad
Yeah, both Judaism and Islam don't believe that God can come out of a vagina and get breastfed to then later getting killed by his own creation.
I can’t believe how people are missing the most crucial similarity : Islam and Judaism are pure monotheism and they prohibit idolatry, unlike Christianity
No idol worship! In Christianity that is forbidden
@@forlornhauntedghost It is. There are always statues, paintings, crucifixes and Christians look up to them when they pray to “God”. Just the fact that having them around is considered idolatry. Not to mention that it is really creepy and disgusting as well (no offense). Having such objects is a form of paganism. Islam and Judaism prohibit that. Christianity does not. If Jesus came back today, he would be upset towards Christians who made him a god and something he never claimed, and for the fact of all this idolatry stuff.
@@forlornhauntedghost yes Christians still do it. I respect Islam for at least being honest and pure about their faith in God. I have no issues with Christians, but they clearly practice idolatry and polytheism as understood by Jews and Muslims. Speaking as a Jew.
@@GhostPanther_X Please! The black stone of Kaaba is the worst object of idolatry in the world. Truly disgusting is that massive stampedes happen to just get to the stone to perform profane and blasphemous act of idol worship. Idolatry is precisely *worship* of idols. Christians do not worship crucifixes, statues or paintings. These are all part of rich religious cultural heritage Christianity has had over 2000 years. Also, you must have a misconception of Christian Trinity - Christianity is pure monotheism. Persons of God - Father, Son, Holy Ghost are all same God. Christians believe all persons are full incarnations of same Almighty.
@@terro3842 you lost me at Christianity is pure monotheism. Because it is far from the truth. Not even in the ball park. Christianity was assimilated from the Roman pagan beliefs by Constantin when Rome was having a Civil War and was being attacked by the “barbarians” across all of its borders. It was a way to unite people and the Trinity thing was created right there by the new Roman Catholic Church because it made it easy for the Roman pagans to accept it that way.
@corey love the videos, but could you consider not adding UA-cam close captions
Islam and Judaism share the same god, Judaism prays 3 times a day while in Islam 5, we both pray in a direction to a specific monument (the West Wall and Mecca), Halal and Kosher are pretty much the same but Jews won't eat meat and dairy product together (both won't eat porky). We share the same father - Abraham who has 2 sons Ishmael and Issac (Jews and Muslims pretty much cousins) and much more. As a Jew, it's sad to see how little they know about us.
Jews and Muslims miss out on bacon and delicious pork products. More for me!
Don’t call us your cousins, Muslims are not your cousins. We just want the Jews to leave the Palestinians alone and F off.
As a Muslim i agree ☝️
It's not about how little we know cause I'll tell you they VERY much know the similarities. But hundreds of years of Jews and muslims living together was wiped out in the last 75 years, that now older people feel hesitant to acknowledge these facts and younger people most of them are too blinded by what Zionists do that they feel like they cant trust any jew. It's sad now that in my country to insult someone who back stabbed u u just call them a jew. Hopefully the two cousins can reunite somehow.
The Rambam said that we are allowed to pray in Mosques but not churches because of the issue of Advodah Zara (idol Worship)... Its an issue that Christians deify a man. It is irrelevant that they deified a Jew
you believe we deified a man while we believe that the Deity itself "humanified" itself in a certain way because thats what a real and most loving God would do towards his own creatures. Christ was always God the Word as he is pre-existent to his incarnation, He created the world and controls all things and even while on earth he was present in heaven (the Bible says all of this). Read the scriptures well, you know : all of it ; the angel of the Lord, the messiah coming down a cloud (unique symbol of divinity in the Old testament) in the book of Daniel. all of it. you will see that its not other then God himself, who wrestle with jacob, visited abraham, spoke with moses etc. , that is the Messiah ,and will be shown to the eyes of the head to the world.
@@OrthoFireCrusaderwhat? Seems you're describing idol worship (I only skimmed your wall of text). What are you even trying to argue?
@@OrthoFireCrusaderThe Old Testament and the Tanakh while sharing similarities are not the same books and some verses sound very different in the Old Testament compared to the original Hebrew which makes sense since that's the only way to find jc in the book that you call OT so reading the Old Testament the only book that has some relevancy to Judaism since it's based albeit changed from the Hebrew Bible (Tanakh) would be useless to a Jew because we are not reading the same book.
@@LemonCamel It's disingenuous to call 150 words a wall of text. Certainly the scholars of the talmud wouldn't be put off by a medium-sized paragraph. I have no horse in this race, I'm a postmodernist. But if you want to talk comparative theology it's going to be longer than a five second sound bite.
Judaism and Christianity are more similar because both have the same holy book and both have the same religious history, Islam is the only monotheistic religion, the original heritage of the prophet Abraham!
Similarity between christianity and islam is that the followers converted a lot of other people from other regions , if they would have kept to themselves it would have been Middle Eastern sects.
Religion in service of imperialistic regimes.
Indeed
Gibberish
@@rxtr664 Of course not. Millions of people were converted to Christianity and Islam through conquest. Judaism has always been a small ethnic folk religion which doesn't proselytize. Study history.
@burnin8orable Really? You think Christianity reached Europe through conquest? 😂
There are more similarities between Islam and Judaism. The reason is that both have the same concept and the ruled countries and so there are religious laws and concepts for the state. Something that many don't know is that Moshe Mimon or Mousa ibn Maimon, is the most well-known Jewish scholar in the last 2000 years. He was an assistant for Salahulden Al-Ayoubi, the well-known Islamic leader and he learned how to organize Jewish law from Muslim religious scholars. And as well, he added many things to the. Islamic history .
It seems Palestinian youths are ignorant of teaching of Islam .
Fascinating. Hidjab and pork seemed to be the two central concerns, and maybe a couple other external things. Nothing about dogma, specific concept of divinity, eternal life, truth, ultimate reality, inner spiritual life, even worship services. I'm stunned frankly. Beyond that commonality was a strange diversity 'all over the place' kind of random perceptions. I suspect Christians would answer with a lot more consistency, especially Orthodox Christians. This is very eye opening. One of the best questions asked actually. Very revealing. Almost surprising but not really.
Their responses are based on observations of practices and culture. They see the Jewish women wear a hijab like them; they see the Jewish people don’t eat pork, like them. One guy sees that neither group washes for prayer or after the bathroom, so he thinks Islam is like neither. One guy knows Arabs who are Christians and therefore thinks Christianity is more similar.
People are not factoring in theology, probably they don’t even know the beliefs of the other groups.
@@ahmeda.3198 Which is absolutely astonishing, because theology IS the main point of any religion BY FAR, unless it's really something else masquerading as religion.
@@comment6864 Ha, go and see the video where he asks this same questions to Israeli Jews. The answers he gets are variations of:
1. Muslims, because they have modesty.
2. Christians, because Jesus was Jewish
3. Muslims, because they are monotheistic.
The Jewish answers are largely just as shallow as the Muslim answers, does your mind also suspect that Judaism is something else that’s simply masquerading as a religion?
It’s obvious to anyone who isn’t a bigot these people don’t learn in depth about the deeper beliefs of any religions, and they probably don’t directly interact a whole lot, so this is what they observe.
@@comment6864 I want you to go watch the video this guy has where he asks Israeli Jews the same question, and when you see that they respond also based on observation, not theology, let us know is it still ‘eye opening’ and do you feel that Judaism is something else ‘masquerading’ as a religion?
I really want to know, because I doubt you would reach the same conclusions. The Jewish people asked have no clue about Christian or Muslim theology. One guy says there is more similarity to Christians because Jesus was Jewish, and the next guy says more similarity to Muslims because Christians worship an alien pagan God.
Do you think if we go find some Christians in that area that they will give a detailed critique of Jewish or Islamic theology. These are not sophisticated people like you such that they can discern what is some evil force masquerading as a religion; they don’t have the benefit of listening to all the paranoia podcasts you subscribe to that keep you vigilant against evil and all that. They are not as smart, not as worldly, not as brave as someone like you.
@@ahmeda.3198 I actually don't really disagree with anything you said. "does your mind also suspect that Judaism is something else that’s simply masquerading as a religion?" Well, actually, i think for many jews it is! That's been my impression for a long time. My observations have always been that jewishness is only like 50% about religion, at best, and i would say both as percentage of people as well as degree for any given person, roughly. I would go further and say that it is very spread among many Christian denominations as well this utilitarian approach to religion - something 'nice to have' when your raising kids LOL. Personally i am fascinated by this because to me it makes absolutely no sense. Religion makes no sense to me at all, UNLESS you believe it to be the truth, i.e. REALITY. Logically to me that is the only reason to have A religion - that it is in fact the bigger reality, NO LESS. For that obviously it has to be very concrete and specific.
Thanks for asking this. And to your Arabic interpreter- many thanks ❤ -a former Catholic now atheist who's been to Israel/Palestine
This is the interpreter, and thank you for watching ❤
@@monamie691monamie can I ask you if you are a Palestinian or an Israeli arab/Israeli Palestinian?
@@monamie691 I wanna thank you as well! you are amazing!
@@monamie691Israel & Palestine must be heaven for Atheists.
This channel is a masterpiece
@@JewFromIsrael55522you are a satanist
'what's the next question' bro thought he was getting quizzed lol
I hope these people are still alive and well
A lot more jews were killed that WB palestenians in 2023. So try again.
Also both cultures have the concept - and use the same term - of "tzdaka" (charity).
@@ShaniHodia-wr3eb So if I found one Jew who's against charity, I could say the whole group is against it?
@@ShaniHodia-wr3ebyou are liar 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
Who dont do charity is kafir like jews
I’d say it’s similar to Judaism in monotheism and in respect for the law. But similar to Christianity in not being obsessed with the law or ritual and focused on the spirit of the law.
I'd say Christianity is pretty obsessed with its church rituals
@@Unlimi-PT not obsessed with laws and rituals surrounding food, bathing, sex, dressing, etc. I don’t mean it as an insult. The way Muslims are obsessed with tawhid or Christianity is obsessed with meekness and forgiveness.
@@Fivetimesthree just meekness, not forgiveness.
@@Unlimi-PT
In the Bible, there are two sacraments for Christians: holy communion and baptism. Neither is required for salvation. Salvation is by grace, a gift from God, just have faith in Jesus. The Catholics added other requirements like the Rabbis have added the oral Torah.
@@Unlimi-PT neither meekness, nor forgiveness.
Many of the people talk from a very religious point of view and they simply don't know a correct answer. They simply can not even imagine that Islam can possible resemble any other religion. All monotheist religions resemble one another because they are versions of the same tradition, which emerged in the Middle East. different nations interpreted it differently and these three versions were developed. Coming from a Muslim country, in my opinion, Islam and Judaism are closer to each other than Christianity. Also, just look inside the synagogues, I sometimes get confused whether a building is a synagogue or a mosque. So much similarity.. Also the way people pray and sing is very similar.
Corey great work you are doing...
What’s so great about it
As a muslim, I can say that Islam is closer to Judaism than to Christianity but that doesn't mean that we don't have common points with Christians
Islam and Muslims have nothing in common with Christianity and Judaism.
Judaism is unique , Christianity is different , and Islam is the new Judaism for the Gentiles of the world , as Muslim copied parts that suit them the best , both from the Torah and the New testament ....
Judaism is really unique
Did it also copy the part where it became a mathematical anomaly?
@@rollingknuckleball
The Quran changed many times...
Actually the Quran was compiled together only in 1924 , ( The Cairo edition , the King Fu"ad ) , which is different from the one of Abu baker , and today the entire Muslim world follows the Cairo edition , Muslim disagreement over whether to include the Basmala within the Quranic text , reached consensus following the 1924 Edition , which included it as the first verse ( āyah ) of the Quran chapter 1 , but otherwise included it as an unnumbered line of text preceding the other relevant 112 chapters.
The Cairo Quran adopted the Kufan tradition of separating and numbering verses , and thus standardized a different verse numbering to Flügel's 1834 edition.
It adopted the order of chapters attributed to Ibn Abbās , which became widely accepted following 1924.
A large number of pre-1924 Qurans were destroyed by dumping them in the river Nile , meaning that you Muslims believe in a book that came 1300 years after Muhammad , so please don't try to argue with someone who is learning Arabic history and pre Arabic history ....
By the way did you know that Islam is doomed to fade away from the world ( According to Islamic sources ) ..
Hadith , Sunan Ibn Majah 4049,,,,,,
( It was narrated from Hudhaifah bin Yaman that the Messenger of Allah said..
Islam will wear out as embroidery on a garment wears out , until no one will know what fasting , prayer , (pilgrimage) rites and charity are.
The Book of Allah will be taken away at night , and not one Verse of it will be left on earth. And there will be some people left , old men and old women , who will say , We saw our fathers saying these words , La ilaha illallah’ so we say them too.
Silah said to him , What good will (saying) , La ilaha illallah do them , when they do not know what fasting , prayer , (pilgrimage) rites and charity are?
Hudhaifah turned away from his.
He repeated his question three times , and Hudhaifah turned away from him each time. Then he turned to him on the third time and said , O Silah , It will save them from Hell , three times ) ...
Truth hurts
Judaism is a relic from the past that's irrelevant nowadays
As a Christian I agree...
@@aqfj5zy
First off , let's see one of the biggest mistakes the Quran has , which means that it cannot be the word of God...
But read it till the end , if you are not afraid....
Surah 19 16-28 ..
"And mention in the Book ˹O Prophet, the story of˺ Mary when she withdrew from her family to a place in the east ,,,,Surah 19 16 ..( this is talking about mary the mother of Jesus ) ...
screening herself off from them. Then We sent to her Our angel, ˹Gabriel,˺ appearing before her as a man, perfectly formed,,,, Surah 19 17 , and it continues talking about Mary and the encounter with angel Gabriel , until she conceive , and in verse 27 , 28 we found this ,
Then she ( Mary , not Miriam ) returned to her people , carrying him ( baby Jesus ) . They said ˹in shock˺, “O Mary! You have certainly done a horrible thing! ( Yeah i personally agree becoming pregnant , while her man was away ) ..
But then the biggest mistake , a writer can do happened in the next verse 28 , where the writer deliberately wrote ,
O sister of Aaron! 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣 ( wait a Sec ) 🤣🤣🤣 Your father was not an indecent man , nor was your mother unchaste.”🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣 , how did the sister of Aaron suddenly became the mother of Jesus 🤣🤣🤣🤣 wooooooow , how was this writer so ignorant and stupid , that he wrote , that the people who saw Mary mother of Jesus , will suddenly say to her , O sister of Aaron , your father was not an indecent man , nor was your mother unchaste 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣...
Don't tell me that this is not a huge , huge mistake , that can never come from the words of the real creator...
Please , tell me that you see the mistake , and if not , our conversation is Over , because im not ready to argue with a person who accepts Human mistakes , by saying that they are not , and are just the true Word of God ....
Ok i know Muslims , you will even defend mistakes and Contradictions , when it talks about your faith ..
But if you agree with the mistake , we can then continue to see mistakes , and more mistakes , that are being found in the book of the Arabs ..
Islam adopted many Jewish Prophets, kings and stories, and one Jesus. Now you are asking them what religion is closer to Islam.
Judaism and Christianity are more similar because both have the same holy book and both have the same religious history, Islam is the only monotheistic religion, the original heritage of the prophet Abraham!
@@anakgembala7253The Jews have the Tanakh and Talmud, while the Christians have the Bible, and Abraham was Jewish. Islam didn't exist until the 7th century CE.
@@burnin8orable Abraham was not a Jew because a Jew was not yet born because a Jew was born from Judah, Jacob's son, Abraham's great-grandson.
Hi corey
I am donating you
Can you ask the palestinians what they think about left wing israelis who support peace with them but still love israel and know its their home?
For example i am like that and i don’t care if israel will become one state called “israel&palestine” and both people live in peace together and equallity on the law. Or two states
As a foreigner from southeast asia i support this.
At the end of the day, we are all human being.
God bless us all ❤
hi, here is an answer, I am an atheist Palestinian, and I think the right on both sides is causing all this suffering, a one-state solution "secular state" would be the only solution for this problem, take religion out of the equation and the problem will become solvable.
@@darkenergy824 never heard before of Palestinian atheists
But if you and me were the ones to choose what will happen here - there long before was peace
@@arielhatav0232 there are atheists in Palestine but, I am not open about it. I hope the number of those like us will increase in the future and finally, we can have peace.
@@darkenergy824
One-state solution that is secular would be the State of Israel.
Israel allows freedom of religion, and there are considerable Arabs hold power in Israel. Particularly the Druze.
Example: Ahmad Tibi, currently the deputy speaker of Knesset.
Regardless, i do pray for immediate Peace in the region and may everyone prospers.
very interesting question, and interesting answers.
I think what happened with the Christianity of today is because it has been Westernised. Orthodox Christians are more traditional. But modern Christianity has been westernised
It's not about "western" but renaissance (the rise of secular science)
In comparison to islam, Judaism is not pure monotheism. Jews believe Jacob beat Allah in wrestling and then Allah had to take rest after 6 days of creation. These 2 things undermine Allah's majesty.
Allah has 2 right hands, a chin and gonads.
@@andys3035
lol, read the Qur'an before saying such hilarious things 😂😂 and for the hands and legs you clearly didn't read the old testament (Torah ) that says god was walking in heaven searching for adam who was hiding behind a tree and that Adam heard the steps of god lol (the Qur'an says that there is nothing like god so he isn't the same as us(The Creator of the heavens and the earth. He has made for you mates from yourselves, and for the cattle (also) mates. By this means He creates you (in the wombs). There is nothing like unto Him, and He is the All-Hearer, the All-Seer), God means Allah in arabic as human means insan in arabic)
@@andys3035you can find that in Genesis 3:8-10
@K.M4655 it appears you haven't read the verse you are using to try and prove your point. It never says God was walking in heaven or that Adam was hiding behind a tree, it just says among the trees.
Genesis 3:8
And they heard the voice of the LORD God walking in the garden in the cool of the day: and Adam and his wife hid themselves from the presence of the LORD God amongst the trees of the garden.
Our theology allows for God to incarnate, yours doesn't. So your allah has 2 right hands, one foot and gonads and is nothing like creation. So what is an uncreated foot like? You can't say because there is no direct analogical predication for it.
The Quran is an eloquent reworking of the Hebrew Bible (Tanakh) and the rabbinic literature (Midrash).
God said it is correction of what jews changed
So you are true lmao😂😂😂
Hahahahhah! @@manofwar2354
Only difference being that the quran is from god while the Torah and rabbinic literature comes from the remaking of the jewish scripture after it was destroyed.
first of all the translation should be worked on, specially that there are words added that aren't mentioned or meant by the context.
the on ground translator isn't understanding well or translating well.
2nd of all it's weird to say Islam is closer just because they forbid pork..
The main problem between Christianity and Islam is the theological belief of Trinity vs Tawahid, then it follows the recognition of The prophet and his revelation. then finally those matters come back to the interprations of both faiths as every school of thought has different forbidden and allowed matters and if Muslims know Christians also have same things forbidden under Mosaic law but according to the majority of Christians those laws are no longer needed as Jesus was crucified for the People's sins.
Muslims and Christians has more in common with the spiritual sides like (Tasawof for muslims) and (Monasticism for christians)
- the believe that Sin is inevitable to humankind (muslims exempt the prophets from that)
- Muslims believe that Jesus was born Miraculously from a Virgin birth
- Muslims believe Jesus is the Massaih that will come at the end of days
- Both have missionary in terms like Evangelism and Da'wah
- Both believe in Universalism
- Both Islam and Christianity spread rapidly and far from their places
I didn't mention other core similarties that's also shared between Christians, Muslims and Jews like Scriptures, Eschatology, Ritual prayer, Social Justice, Pilgrimage, etc.
However the main similarities that makes Muslims and Jews look more similar are:
- the Monotheistic God (no trinity concept),
- the rejection of Jesus being God
- the similar practices and rules.
It's very complicated topic, since Muslims also prefer the Christian universal look of things as both muslims and christians has rules like usury ban that is universal from and to all, however jews on the other hand has it forbidden but not from jews to none jews.
those kind of details with other major one like the Rabias in the Talmud challenging and winning on God is also consider a big deviance from the monotheistic perspective of God to Muslims and Christians.
That’s a more comprehensive way to look at it
a few typos you put muslim were christian should be for virgin birth and massaih
From the Christian perspective, Islam is more similar to Christianity than Judaism. Islam respects Christ, Judaism does not. But Islam is closer to Judaism than Christianity.
I feel like your translator should get some more credit in the after section of the videos TBH. She’s doing really good work. I think she should get more credit.
As part of the replacment theology , they would claim to be close or even the source itself for monotheism.
What is replacement theology?
Islam is closer to judaism althought it is an offspring of christianisty
That’s a fair point
Christians do idolatry
Making statues and idols of Christ ?
@@HK00088 Islam separated from christianity especially because of that
@@HK00088 We don’t make idols of him 🙄
As a Muslim, I was surprised to learn that Judaism doesn't believe in the afterlife, they focus more on this life. slam and Christianity believe and focus on the afterlife.
you are suprised because its a lie, judiasm focus on the afterlife, most of their poems are about leaving the body and the matirial word in favor of praying and worshipping god
Judaisim do believe in the afterlife, heaven, hell and punishment by God
@@ori1676I heard that they don’t believe in hell
@@Ash_Queen16 Yes we do, its called "Gehenom" in Hebrew wich means hell
@@ori1676 Oh I didn’t know that. Well now that you said so, who is reserved for that place?
This channel is GOLD 🏆
Islam is actually less similar to Judaism than Christianity is to Judaism. But it depends on which version of Judaism one means. In Jesus' time, there were the Pharisees, Sadducees, Zealots and Essenes. But even if a comparison is made to the common themes in those Judaisms, Islam doesn't have a priesthood, no Liturgy, no atoning sacrificial system, the temple layout is different from the mosque, divine imminence (God dwelling in the midst of His people as Yahweh was in the Ark of the Covenant). Islam is actually a mix of Arianism (heretical sect in Christianity), paganism and Judaism. All these elements were present in Arabia 1400 years ago and the result was Islam. St. John of Damascus documents how Muhammad was in contact with an Arian monk who probably had an impact on him. But Muhammad's knowledge of the Torah and Christian writings was limited and was at times relayed to him by word of mouth of the common people who lived among him. For example, there is a Surah in which Muhammad is called to judge a dispute of adultery between some Jews. He asks for the Torah and places it where he was sitting and says to judge according to it. That same Torah forbids the eating of camel of which the Hadiths confirm Muhammad ate.
Such theological differences like priesthood, Liturgy, atoning sacrificial system, the temple, divine imminence are above the average persons knowledge and in my exprience the vast majority of Muslims in middle east know next to nothing about even their own religions theology. btw the story of Muhammad judging by Torah is in hadith and Muhammad mixed gnostic and docetist theology
As a muslim myself, outwardly Judaism is Much closer but if i were to say which is closer holistically i couldn't objectively tell because they're both close but in vastly different ways.
For jews
Jews circumcise, don't eat pork, slaughter Kosher, have fixed prayer times, wear modest clothes, grow their beards, believe in One God, do passover to commemorate God leading his the followers of Moses out of Egypt. Follow laws etc.
For Christians
They believe in an hell and Paradise, believe Jesus عليه السلام is the Messiah. Believe in his second coming, believe there will be an antichrist.
So it's pretty hard to say which is closer. Obviously Judaism is closer outwardly though and I'd rather live amoungst religious jews than Christians
Islam is far closer to Christianity. Judaism is a small ethnic folk religion while Islam and Christianity are giant missionary religions which seek as many converts as possible.
I would like to respectfully ask from where/whom did you learn about Judaism, and how many Jews do you know?
@@burnin8orable from Chassidic Jews in Newyork. As i said tho, to say it's far closer to Christianity id disagree. Both have similarities but in vastly different ways
Christians are much more close to as a people and community, so we should prefer to live amongst them more, the Quran tells us that the closest and kindest people to us are those who say we are christians@@muwahid5022
Superficially islam is similar to Judaism but the core of the difference is the fact that HaShem, yud-heh-vav-heh, is the name of our Creator while in islam they have a nameless god.
One reason why G-d gave us His name is so that when the people of Israel would encounter the false gods of the nations, be it jezeus/yeshu or allah, they would immediately recognize that it is NOT the same deity as the G-d of Israel.
Islam is a counterfeit religion that seems to mimic Judaism but is actually complete idolatry. Like a pig with split hooves, only by opening it up will a person realize that it is indeed not kosher.
In islam, a reader of the quran is immediately given false information compared to what is in Tanakh. Muslims worships a nameless false god allah that has false prophets jezeus/yeshu/isa and mohammed who speak on his behalf. They have their Kaaba in Mecca, not the Beit HaMikdash in Yerushalayim. Yerushalayim is not mentioned once in the quran while Yerushalayim is where HaShem put HIs Holy name to live forever. Muslims face Mecca when praying and point their asses towards the holiest of holies on Temple Mount. Muslims believe that jezeus/yeshu/isa will return to kill a fictional dajjal and rule as Moshiach for 40 years while in Judaism Moshiach ben David is not a re-incarnation or return of a false prophet, and rules forever. The quran, like all islamic sacred texts, are all fiction.
It is an error to think that islam's god and HaShem are the same. The muslims shout "allahu akhbar!" when they kill Jews.
They don't know how much they have in common. the only thing they differentiate is pork lol.
Always an interesting insight.
As a non religious person i'm a bit disappointed to see, that almost all of them only focused on the most shallow parts of their religions, only on what is forbidden.
They seem to not know their own religion and it's history very well.
It's called "customs" - it's not shallow.
This question reminds me of a meme I saw online:
Islam 🫱🏽🫲🏼 christianity: Jesus was important.
Judaism 🫱🏽🫲🏼 islam: don't eat pork, circumcision.
Judaism 🫱🏽🫲🏼 christianity: hebrew bible.
Islam 🫱🏽🫲🏼 judaism 🫱🏽🫲🏼 christianity: atheists suck
That last part 😂
Why is nobody talking about the "Don't go there" at 4:50? What was that about?
Yeah, good question.
Islam & Judaism have many similarities, & it's not just the connection to Abraham. Mohammed had a Jewish friend who taught him about Judaism. This is why Muslims have similar dietary laws like hallal, circumcision & they also have their sabbath on Friday. They also celebrate Ashura which commemorates the Jew's exodus from Egypt. Theologically they are also similar - there's only God, no human representatives, & no pictures in houses of worship unlike the Christians which have pictures & statutes of Jesus everywhere which is kind of like idol worship. Muslims pray 5 times a day, Jews 3, in Christianity there's no requirement for daily prayer. Even though Jesus was a practicing Jew, John removed all Jewish rituals & traditions to appeal to pagans.
Christians don’t worship statues 🙄 And not all of them have that in churches
christians dont worship statues. its a reminder of the blood atonment jesus payed.
3:08 has the best haircut your eyes will ever see
Lmfao
Odd considering both Christianity and Islam believe in Jesus (but not entirely in the same way). And both are based on Judaism.
"Don't go there" loooool gotta love your translator
This video is a perfect example of how a person's environment plays a major role in the answer they provide.
I feel confident saying that everyone you just asked never read the Bible cover to cover. I would say Islam is closer to Judaism in more important aspects of the religion based upon the Islamic teachings, and that would be Tawheed or the first commandment in the forefront. Christians have a trinity, which is a teaching foreign to Judaism and Islam.
If one were to make a list of similarities and differences between the three, it wouldn't be as black and white, due to them all overlapping one another in different regards. Also, each religion has its unique practice/belief in some aspects, for example, in Islam, there's the belief that God sent prophets throughout the globe since day one, while Christians and Jews don't have such a teaching in the Bible. We also have examples where Muslims and Christians match through their belief in Jesus' ministry.
One of the biggest similarities between all three is that we share common values and the belief in an intelligent source to all existence. This is a big reason why we should work together against those who are trying to change our values and highlight our differences so that we are distracted by fighting one another, while they come from behind and poison our children.
You Muhammadan polytheistic pagans are unrelated to Christianity and true Judaism, and the God of Abraham, Isaac and Jacob is foreign to you Muhammadan Saracen pagans.
But isn't the whole root of existence of Islam the prophet Mohamed? And did Jews even acknowledge him?
@@comment6864 no, the root is the Creator. And some Jews during his time did acknowledged him but they rejected him, some accepted him and his message, while some don’t acknowledge him at all
So we as Muslims in Palestine are raised to think of Christians as worshiping one god. We try to disassociate them from the trinity, we were raised this way to lessen the divide between Christians and Muslims.
@@RiyadhElalami Christians DO worship one God, most definitely! The Trinity in no way contradicts that.
I would have thought the trinity makes it impossible to reconcile Christianity with Islam or Judaism. At least that is some sort of theological difference between them.
Pork and hijab are more like customs for some than core beliefs, not to mention all those graven images permissible in churches.
When it comes to LGBT issues all three are much of a muchness.
What do you mean by the last part?
The trinity are just 3 aspects of the same single god.... if i remember my sunday school well
@@dogbert52 Basically in a sense
@@Ash_Queen16 All three are rubbish at LGBTQ issues.
@@dogbert52 I am sure you are right in Crhistian theology, but it is not allowed in Judaism (and Islam) where god is ONE - without a son and without a separate holy spirit.
From an Atheist's perspective, the three religions are like Norwegian, Danish, and Swedish. Very similar and obviously from a common root.
Nope mate. Christianity in modern day has very little common root with the early christianity in the past.
I mean the Trinity, and the over-forgiveness, acceptance of LGBT+, idol woreshipping, warmongering, adultery, etc and etc.
Doesn't make much difference. It's the same for modern Islam, or modern Jewish Religion. Also, I grew up in Catholic institutions. I know a lot more about the core of that religion.@@Commievn
@@CommievnWhat!!! Ok that is all wrong!
@@CommievnYou clearly got your info from fakers 🤯
@kobea5wagyu642 Adultery is against the Bible! Literally says so in the 10 commandments. And no LGBTQ+ acceptance (we are nice to them yes and don't hate them), and no killing!!! No warmongering! Idk what type of Christianity you're on about?
@kobea5wagyu642 But Trinity and forgiveness are what I agree with, you have to love thy enemy and forgive those who sin against us just as we ask for forgiveness for our sins but anyways I'm going to stop ranting sorry I was just so appalled 😅
And mine is no idol worshipping but I see what you mean by that because other denominations have something similar but it's a sin to worship an idol or golden bull, that makes God very angry
@@forlornhauntedghost lol. No problem.
Peace.
The old arab man with the white thing on his head had the best answer!
The Muslim woman in a perfume shop?, hahaha 😂
So what? selling perfume is not the same as using it in public. In Islam women can apply perfume, just not in the presence of a an unrelated man.
@@Ibrahim_12468 So, in America, women can apply perfume without a man giving her permission to.
It’s funny she’s selling items that could get her beat or worse but all it is, is perfume! It’s a funny, but sad, picture to me.
@@danielstringhm3805 A women doesn’t need permission to apply perfume, she can only apply it in the presence of her husband, related family members, or other women.
@@Ibrahim_12468 what happens if she breaks the rules?
@@danielstringhm3805 Then she is sinful, simple as that.
Outwardly islam is more like Judaism. As they still follow many laws including some that can only be found in the Torah, e.g. male circumcision, tatoos forbidden. There is nothing in Quran that forbids these only by inference.
Mohammed copied qibla and even sawm from Jews before the alleged ayat were revealed.
As well ss set prayer times and how to pray.
However islam copies christian eschatology, belief in an opposing force to the creator, shaytan. And also took on ideas from the like of Tertullian and simon the martyr who villainised Jews.
The reality is Christianity & islam are really types of subsects of Judaism.
Should I be concerned that you asked 8 men, but only one woman?
Maybe the other orthodox Muslim women didn't want to be filmed?
@@ShaniHodia-bw4uqshe's definitely more beautiful than your mother I'm sure
@@ShaniHodia-bw4uq lol I don't think so. I can feel her mustache from here 🤣🤣🤣🤣
@@ShaniHodia-wr3eb 🤣
So many delusions in 1 paragraph, damn!
Islam is closer to Judaism but in the Quran, God mentions that Christians will be more loving to Muslims but that is because we love Jesus and Mary too.😊
Well said
Yes , from malmo to nigeria to pakistan christians feel the "love" ❤❤❤❤❤
@@dogbert52 I said Christians would be loving to Muslims, not really the other way around
@@dogbert52we also see this "love" from christians of usa and europeans countries
@@thomasmuller2233 usa is a jewish nation, not christian at all
Orthodox Christian are circumcised and don’t eat pork. We are allowed to eat pork but it’s very rare they do it’s more of a cultural thing
Although islam is more similar to judaism
We always find christians closer friends to us as muslims ❤
Majority of Christian’s support the Gaza genocide. They are not our friends. O you who have believed, do not take the Jews and the Christians as allies. They are [in fact] allies of one another. And whoever is an ally to them among you - then indeed, he is [one] of them. Indeed, Allah guides not the wrongdoing people. Q5:51
Poor south and East Asians, native Australian and Native American and Africans. What is the name of the prophet/ s who was send to you? It seem to be God/ Alah is interested in one small geographical area.
all Abrahamic religions are originated in the Middle East ( Judaisim, Christianity and Islam)
In my opinion when it comes to worship Islam is closer to Judaism in its forbidden use of icons and images of prohpets and saints. In universal outreach Islam is more like Christianity in that it is a proselytizing religion and instead of the church they have the Ummah. What separates Christianity from both of them is its not really rooted in any particular ethnicity, culture, language etc...which probably makes Christianity more malleable to local cultures that were not Abrahamic in origin.
@beaverofthepola2071 Shia's do have some carry over from Zorostrianism.
Islam came last.
Seventh Day Adventist here. We don't eat pork either.
But you guts hardly represent the majority of christians.
1. Before Israel, there was a British mandate, not a Palestinian state
2. Before the British Mandate, there was the Ottoman Empire, not a Palestinian state.
3. Before the Ottoman Empire, there was the Islamic state of the Mamluks of Egypt, not a Palestinian state.
4. Before the Islamic state of the Mamluks of Egypt, there was the Ayubid Arab-Kurdish Empire, not a Palestinian state.
5. Before the Ayubid Empire, there was the Frankish and Christian Kingdom of Jerusalem, not a Palestinian state.
6. Before the Kingdom of Jerusalem, there was the Umayyad and Fatimid empires, not a Palestinian state.
7. Before the Umayyad and Fatimid empires, there was the Byzantine empire, not a Palestinian state.
8. Before the Byzantine Empire, there were the Sassanids, not a Palestinian state.
9. Before the Sassanid Empire, there was the Byzantine Empire, not a Palestinian state.
10. Before the Byzantine Empire, there was the Roman Empire, not a Palestinian state.
11. Before the Roman Empire, there was the Hasmonean state, not a Palestinian state.
12. Before the Hasmonean state, there was the Seleucid, not a Palestinian state.
13. Before the Seleucid empire, there was the empire of Alexander the Great, not a Palestinian state.
14. Before the empire of Alexander the Great, there was the Persian empire, not a Palestinian state.
15. Before the Persian Empire, there was the Babylonian Empire, not a Palestinian state.
16. Before the Babylonian Empire, there were the Kingdoms of Israel and Judah, not a Palestinian state.
17. Before the Kingdoms of Israel and Judah, there was the Kingdom of Israel, not a Palestinian state.
18. Before the kingdom of Israel, there was the theocracy of the twelve tribes of Israel, not a Palestinian state.
19. Before the theocracy of the twelve tribes of Israel, there was an agglomeration of independent Canaanite city-kingdoms, not a Palestinian state.
20. Actually, in this piece of land there has been everything, EXCEPT A PALESTINIAN STATE.
(Borrowed from a friend)
A little more history for those wanting to 'restore Palestine'.
In 132 AD the Emperor Hadrian resolved to stamp the Jews and their religion out of existence. He sold all Jewish prisoners into slavery after the revolt of Bar Kikhba, forbade the teaching of the Torah, renamed the province Syria Palaestina, and changed Jerusalem’s name to Aelia Capitolina. He renamed Israel to wipe out the national identity of Israel and the Jews.
So if you are looking to 'restore Palestine to the Palestinians', you need to give it back to the Jews.
It was named palestinian mandate Not british Mandate so Yeah your copypaste is unvalid
Who cares.what it was called. The people.calling themselves palestenian started that in the 60s. Before that only.jews called themselves palestenian
Islam and Rabbinic Judaism teach that you can save yourself. Christianity teaches that you need a Savior.
In Judaisim you dont need a savior, you just need to follow God words (the Torah)
@@ori1676
But you don't and you can't. You are in your sins and separated from the holy and just God. It takes a blood sacrifice for forgiveness of sins. God let the temple be destroyed, but he first provided the perfect sacrifice, his Son. Like he provided a ram for Abraham to sacrifice instead of his son. Your good works cannot save you and you have not obeyed all of his commandments. Only Jesus did.
In terms of rituals, Judaism
In terms of ethics, Christianity.
In terms of ethics, .....
Absolutely not
Islam and Judaism are closer:
Strict Monotheism
Importance of Keeping the Commands
Importance of Kosher and Halaal
Importance given to Modest dress
Very large Majority of Jews know that Muslims worship the same God whilst alot Christians believe Muslims worship a Moon God or Demon.....
Judaism rejects Muhammad as a prophet, which is quintessential for Islam
Judaism and Christianity are more similar because both have the same holy book and both have the same religious history, Islam is the only monotheistic religion, the original heritage of the prophet Abraham!
@@anakgembala7253😂
@@anakgembala7253then why does the Quran get his name wrong?
@@anakgembala7253 We don't believe in the same god as Muslims sorry to break it to you guys, muslims don't even know the name of god they think its "Allah".....
Instead of interpreting أديان سماوية as "celestial religions" it's better interpreted as "abrahamic religions" in my opinion.
~900 Christians under Hamas in Gaza city.
~45,000 Christians live under the Palestinian Authority.
So?
These seem to be well thought out answers.
However both Christianity & Islam are both obsessed with the afterlife while Judaism pays very little attention to it.
One is eternal. The other is not. So what is the issue?
@@John-lf3xf
What do you mean?
why do you worship the eternal? to have reward in the afterlife or cause The eternal said that you must worship him? @@John-lf3xf
Yes, because Judaism is obsessed with the worldly pleasures. They learn to be greedy from a young age. I've seen how the children eat food. Jews also created Usury, which is putting interest on the poor to become richer. Now, every bank follows this system. Pretty much they will do anything to get rich, even if it means changing the words of God. You believe Jacob wrestled with God, It was most likely an angel. But because of this, you think it's ok to argue with God and not obey him. Jews only care about their fellow jews. And your wrong Islam has equal importance for both this world and the hereafter.
Judaism and Christianity are more similar because both have the same holy book and both have the same religious history, Islam is the only monotheistic religion, the original heritage of the prophet Abraham!
Judaism is monotheistic like Islam unlike Christianity which believes in trinity.
Christians believe in 1 god, you do know the holy ghost is in the torah
@@boobye6305
There is no trinity in the Torah, it's a Christian theology.
@@salamyaya162 I never said the trinity, but the holy ghost is mentioned in the torah, the trinity is 3 in 1, god, holy ghost and the son. same entity in 3
@@boobye6305same as the nescafe 3 in 1 😂
@@tarikidressi4383 and just as delicious
1:35 The old man answered it perfectly
Facts!
@@JewFromIsrael55522 as to be expected from Hasbara troll
@@JewFromIsrael55522 you should look at mirror
@@JewFromIsrael55522 be careful & remember we will be judged in the Day of Judgement, to the One who owned the heaven and hell, before it's too late to regret. Have a good day.
He did nothing of the sort. Islam has not remained unchanged. The Koran itself has undergone several changes.
it’s so funny because they are more similar to each other than people realize. you even find women veiling themselves in christianity.
Islam adopted many aspects of Judaism such as the dietary laws and the prohibition on graven images. It took little from Christianity except that they believe Jesus was a prophet.
Shame that barber guy didn't wanna be on video, my bro had a muscular built body and good masculine face to match. go find him for another interview!
You do understand this isn't a gay P channel right?
@@farsalami8605 It is now that you're here.
@@Muonium1lol
"Islam remains unchanged" Islam being the religion that came last.
Ironic, considering there are two main branches since the get-go (sunna, shia) and several off-shoots, which wouldn't be recognized by him (ismaili, ahmadiyya, sufi etc.)
Islam being the religion that came last.wrong.islam was there since the begenining
Answer: more similar to Satanism.
Take a look at the names given to Allah:
Al-Mutakabbir (الْمُتَكَبِّر): This word means "The Arrogant" or "The Very Proud". It is often used to describe someone who is proud or arrogant to the point of defying God.
Ad-Darr (الضَّارّ) : It means "The Causer of Damage" or "The Nuisher". It can be used to describe someone who intentionally causes harm or injury to others.
Al-Muzil (المُذِلّ): This word means "The Lowerer" or "He Who Humbles". It is often used to describe God as the One who lowers or humiliates those He wishes.
Al-Makir (المَكِّر): It means "The Great Strategist" or "The Great Planner". It is used to describe God as the Supreme Planner who can have mysterious and unfathomable purposes.
Al-Fattan (الفَتّان): This word means "The Seducer" or "The Corrupter". It can be used to describe someone who tries to seduce or corrupt others.
1st thing Muslims and Jews both reject the Trinity as it is idolatry which is worst of sins in both religions
So rejecting Muhammad as a prophet is fine?
he is a prophet@@Ash_Queen16
@@anywaytechreview Jews don’t believe that
@@Ash_Queen16 not at all that’s where we differ
Dropping it for algorithm
to judaism we plagiarize more from them😇
Islam is closer to Judaism and Muslims are closer to Christians, that’s the answer
Muslims are not close to Christians! What are you talking about
That's not at all how I see it. As a Jew, I feel far more similarity to Muslims that Christians.
Ironically the comment section on Corey's video's often speak readily of the similarities of Islam and Judaism. I am not referring to non religious Jews of course, but practicing ones. The laws of both Islam and Judaism both have circumcision, the head covering, the modesty in clothing, not only not eating pork for both, but special dietary law (halal & kashrut), they both have forms of religious cleansing (I won't elaborate there) but Christianity expects none of these of their practitioners. Muslims and Jews both pray several times a day Muslims five, Jews 3. Do Christians pray several times a day? Yes they can if they want to, but Christianity does not mandate how many times, they pray as often as they want!
palestinian orthodox christian here :) we pray 7 times a day and we fast for most of the year [vegan]. before taking the holy eucharist we also fast for 10 hours. modesty is also explicit and most orthodox women are veiled.
@@ايمان-ض2ح Very interesting! I studied Religions of the world, I have not heard that! TFS! 💗🙏🌺
yeah you should have a look into eastern christianity :)@@hipretty
I was looking for a Orthodox Christian response because I’ve known a few from Muslim countries and as a Muslim I felt we were similar. I’ve known Jews and didn’t feel like the values were similar at all. By the way I’m a Black American born Muslim to “convert” parents.
christianity has laws on food. "abstain from food sacrificed to idols, from blood, from meat of strangled animals". But most people don't eat such meat anyways.
this channel is so cool
She tells corey, "dont go there" after the guy with the bathroom remark
O People of the Scripture, there has come to you Our Messenger making clear to you much of what you used to conceal of the Scripture and overlooking much. There has come to you from Allah a light and a clear Book.
By which Allah guides those who pursue His pleasure to the ways of peace and brings them out from darknesses into the light, by His permission, and guides them to a straight path.
They have certainly disbelieved who say that Allah is the Messiah, the son of Mary. Say, "Then who could prevent Allah at all if He had intended to destroy the Messiah, the son of Mary, or his mother or everyone on the earth?" And to Allah belongs the dominion of the heavens and the earth and whatever is between them. He creates what He wills, and Allah is over all things competent.
But the Jews and the Christians say, "We are the children of Allah and His beloved." Say, "Then why does He punish you for your sins?" Rather, you are human beings from among those He has created. He forgives whom He wills, and He punishes whom He wills. And to Allah belongs the dominion of the heavens and the earth and whatever is between them, and to Him is the [final] destination.
O People of the Scripture, there has come to you Our Messenger to make clear to you [the religion] after a period [of suspension] of messengers, lest you say, "There came not to us any bringer of good tidings or a warner." But there has come to you a bringer of good tidings and a warner. And Allah is over all things competent.
(Al-Quran translation 5: 15-19)
فِي الْبَدْءِ خَلَقَ اللهُ (Allah) السَّمَاوَاتِ وَالأَرْضَ
According to arabic translations of the bible that you can find online, Allah (الله ) is the Creator of the heavens and the earth in Genesis 1: 1
Indeed, your rabb (Lord) is Allah, who created the heavens and earth ...
(Al-Quran translation 7: 54)
They say, "Be Jews or Christians [so] you will be guided." Say, "Rather, [we follow] the religion of Abraham, inclining toward truth, and he was not of the mushrikun."
Say, [O believers], "We have believed in Allah and what has been revealed to us and what has been revealed to Abraham and Ishmael and Isaac and Jacob and the Descendants and what was given to Moses and Jesus and what was given to the prophets from their Lord. We make no distinction between any of them, and we are Muslims [in submission] to Him.
(Al-Quran 2: 135- 136)
Say, "O People of the Scripture, come to a word that is equitable between us and you - that we will not worship except Allah and not associate anything with Him and not take one another as arbaban (lords) instead of Allah ." But if they turn away, then say, "Bear witness that we are Muslims [submitting to Him]."
(Al-Quran 3: 64)
Abraham was neither a Jew nor a Christian, but he was one inclining toward truth, a Muslim [submitting to Allāh]. And he was not of the mushrikun (eg. polytheists.)
(Al-Quran 3: 67)
فِي الْبَدْءِ خَلَقَ اللهُ السَّمَاوَاتِ وَالأَرْضَ (Genesis 1: 1)
In the beginning, God ( الله ) created the heavens and the earth
-from arabic translations of the bible.
Indeed, your rabb (Lord) is Allah, who created the heavens and earth ...
(Al-Quran translation 7: 54)
Aalaha or Alaha refers to God in Aramaic.
Aramaic is a semitic language having similarities with Hebrew and Arabic.