3:10 the long version: "Letters patent" is a fancy way of saying "a document that is officially issued by the Monarch." Like much UK law, what this technically means, and how this practically works in the real world, are different things. Technically, the Monarch can choose any town or village or motorway service he likes, and bestow city status upon it. But practically, it's the government of the day who makes the decision, and then the ceremonial stage is the bit where the Monarch signs a big piece of paper. Another important thing to note is that even in the olden days, when the Monarch had genuine power, he wasn't actually turning places that were not cities into cities. He was merely making their already established city status into official, monarchy-endorsed city status. If you've got time to pause this video and read this essay, you've got time to reply to that email.
Interestingly, Ely cathedral actually has an octagonal tower rather than the usual square. The original square crossing tower collapsed in 1322, so they replaced it with an octagonal one. Your little bit of trivia from an Ely resident.
Ely does still have a square tower at the west end, which is also unusual because it's more common for medieval English cathedrals to have two towers in that position. It's a really interesting church
IIRC the original was stone, but the new is octagonal because it was made of wood, and it was an easier build design, or something. (Visited in 1996, from NZ)
@@cvbattum also, their railway station actually has an insanely good variety of services for its size (long distance trains to Leicester and Birmingham by XC and Nottingham, Sheffield, Liverpool and Manchester by EMR as well as the usual services to Peterborough, Cambridge, Norwich and London) which kinda helps its image - there are other cities of a similar size (Ripon and Armagh) which don't even have train stations!
It takes absolute ages to watch a Map Men episode as I have to pause and read all the delightful little quirks thrown in at every possible opportunity. Lovely episode as always, lads.
As someone from Reading, I dont want to become a City. Being the largest town in the UK is at least an interesting fact to tell people, if we get city status then we wont have any interesting facts to tell people Great episode as always, chaps
There's a joke in here about Reading being so boring that it being a town is what's considered an interesting fact there but it would be mean to say it, so I won't. The remodelled train station is a bit of an improvement although it desperately needs shops upstairs and more seats (although literally every train station needs more seats, and shops).
@@jonevansauthorhehe the train station? Readings response to being boring and nothing to do is to build lots of stuff that looks like an airport? They also have these featureless glass offices now too. One interesting thing was the previous brutalist weird buildings i hope they dont get rid of them all! Tbh living there is not too bad its surrounded by great country towns, scenery, oxford and london under an hour. Its just the bit you have to leave to get somewhere else that's the problem. The main historical fact being "we jailed a homosexual"!?
Your wrong. It was the same sign, but they scraped off the word "Alban's" and welded on some metal letters reading "David's" so the signs said "st. David's" Clever!
I live in reading, the most notable feature recently about it is that we managed to have both of our football teams (men and women) relegated in the same season, also there's a very boring plaque that says something along the lines of: King Henry is buried here somewhere-ish (we think)
This is the most at-ease I have ever seen Jay and Mark in a video (and the most British). They feel like a proper UA-cam “institution” in their own right. Two old friends who have been in the “business” for (literally) decades continuing their great tv series.
I am an American who was living in Reading in 1999 and 2000. I remember how pumped people were to gain city status and how no one could tell me why it was important. I also remember how disappointed everyone was when it did not get it. Seeing the list of new "cities" since then does make me wonder what Reading ever did to Elizabeth II? I happened to have liked it and would grant it city status in a heartbeat.
Reading is one of the dreariest places in England. It has no character at all compared to the vast majority of UK towns and has no right to be a city. I'm pleased to hear you enjoyed your time there but I bet you would have enjoyed most towns in England a lot more.
What I find interesting is how Colchester, despite only being given city status in 2022, still advertises itself as Britain's FIRST city, because technically it was a roman city when they first colonised
The Netherlands also used to do it with City Privileges. They aren't given out anymore (last ones being from 1819), but one notable town that isn't a city if you use this definition is The Hague, our 3rd largest "city"
I assumed St David's was always a city because of the cathedral, but to find out it became one in my lifetime is making me doubt everything I ever thought I knew
They simplified a bit - St Davids was a city for 600 years because of its cathedral and cultural importance in Wales. It lost its status in the 1800's and regained it in 1996.
I wish people would realise that having a cathedral doesn't make a place a city. It's related to civic charters and isn't remotely dependent on Cathedral presence
The level of effort put into each episode is a joy to behold, all the animations, cut away, jokes, in-jokes, many of them painstaking done for a mere few seconds of use - an utter treat! Thanks Jay and Mark. (ps. Getting Roger Tilling involved is next level)
Totally agree with this. And I know they are more experienced now than at the start, but I do have an urge to go back and watch all the other episodes. But with much more generous use of the pause button to pick up all the cleverly put-together jokes that flash by too fast to read normally. The dictionary, future cities and especially the list of what else Parliament has to do in this episode are just hilarious
@@Varksterable stopping to read all of them (getting burned by the one that said "you have time to write that email"), I half expected an Achievement Unlocked notification! (also, Neil Buchanan should alsolutely be given a knighthood)
It's the same in Germany, although not with cities but with towns. In Germany, a place can only call itself a “town” if it has been granted the so-called “town rights”.
Wikipedia says to "town privileges": Common privileges were related to trading (to have a market, to store goods, etc.) and the establishment of guilds. Some of these privileges were permanent and could imply that the town obtained the right to be called a city, hence the term city rights (Stadtrecht in German). In other words: British city status and German Stadtrecht are literally the same.
Edit: A year later and I no longer understand what exactly I was trying to say with that comment 😅. @@NeovanGoth It actually makes sence for countries like the uk or the us, but i guess in germany is it slightly different. A small town (kleinstadt) with a small population (up to a few thousand people) maybe has an elementary school, a highschool and sometimes it has an local mayor. A big town (population between 50000 and 100000 people) has a lord mayor (oberbürgermeister), schools for higher education, is moustly a local powerhouse and, in some cases, the countytown like my hometown gotha. A city (population more than 100000), in my understanding, is nearly every time also a county in its own (like greater manchester or frankfurt/main), has a huge impact to the surounding areas (because of its huge size) and, sometimes, can be a state with its own government (like the city and state of berlin).
@@riesenmax92 No, it's not. Terms like "Kleinstadt" and "Großstadt" are statistical categories used by the Federal Ministry for Housing, Urban Development and Building and have no legal meaning whatsoever. The Stadtrecht however is a privilege originally granted by the monarch. The smallest Gemeinde that has the Stadtrecht (and hence is allowed to call itself a Stadt) is Arnis in Schleswig-Holstein, which has a population of less than 300 (and hence doesn't even fall into the statistical category of Kleinstadt), while the biggest Gemeinde _without_ Stadtrecht is Seevetal in Niedersachsen with a population of over 40.000 (which is categorized as "kleine Mittelstadt"). In former times having the Stadtrecht granted a bunch of additional privileges like the right to host a market, and a certain amount of self-governance, but nowadays it's _only_ the right to call itself a Stadt.
@@makesomenoiseagency2815 A German teacher explaining German grammar to foreigners with a straight face is one of the finest examples of deadpan stand-up in the world.
I love how Wokingham, Pangbourne, Winnersh and Bracknell all turn up on the “Millennium 3000 cities” list, as they’re all much smaller towns very close to Reading
Pangbourne is just about a village, and the only thing notable about Winnersh is that it has a Park and Ride with no buses. Still, potentially more going for them than "used to make biscuits".
@@mr22bishop and seeds and a brewery and a gaol for playwrights and a ruined church with some French speaking English kings buried there. Oh, and a battle against the Vikings and the walls of a Roman town/city. Still a rather ugly town, glad I lived on the outskirts.
Wokingham is pretty nice when it comes to connectivity, average salaries, average school ratings and just general feel. Its better than Slough, lets say that
As a resident of Reading, we are used to the constant tease of not being given City Status. I love how on the very last list, you listed all our neighbouring towns except us! Great episode!
I spotted this too. Grew up in the Town of Reading, now I live in the City of Milton Keynes :) It used to be said that the statue of Queen Victoria in Reading faces the railway station because she hated the place so much.
I've always been interested in why Stoke-on-Trent, as a city, is actually 5 towns, of which Stoke is only 1 of the towns. And the official city centre is Hanley which is a different 1 of the 5 towns to Stoke which is not the city centre of Stoke-on-Trent
I'd be more interested to know why someone thought "Stoke-on-Trent" is a sensible name for a city, rather than some kinda curse directed at a guy named Trent.
@@fireazaIt's because it's a town next to the river Trent. There's another town called stoke elsewhere in the country and on Trent clarifies which one you mean. There are also 2 Newcastles, one of which is Newcastle on Tyne. It's like how in the US there are lots of towns with the same name and you specify the State to differentiate, except we do it with rivers.
I went to university in Reading and one of the urban legends we were told was that when Queen Victoria first visited Reading, she reportedly didn’t like it. Some say that the statue of her in Reading town centre is also deliberately facing away from the centre of Reading. Of course like most urban legends, no one has been able to verify this
All of our local legends (both true and false) are depressing as hell 😂 I forgot about this one. Don't know if it's true but I heard it too growing up here.
If you know any local Reading history, you know why. Reading in those days lacked a sewer system among other things. It stunk to high heaven and there was excrement everywhere. Reading at that time epitomised all the social ills of the day which Dickens wrote about in his novels. Disease, poverty, child labour, debtors prisons, workhouses, etc. It was pretty bad. In fact, there is some evidence to suggest that during his time in Reading, Dickens witnessed things which may have inspired some of his works. Particularly, Oliver Twist.
Thanks, from Reading. I don't think many of us here feel particularly aggrieved the Queen turned us down three times, more bemused. We were more upset when the council wanted to rename us Reading-On-Thames (something to do with search engines getting confused with the word reading). Also, very interesting to hear that Greater London isn’t a city. When I was a kid in 1987 we moved to Reading from London and my parents have always referred to visiting London as “going to town” and only referred to it as a city when they meant the very centre (Westminster). Goin into Reading town centre was always just “going to the centre”.
City status is granted to a council (a legal corporation. In the 1960s they expanded the County of London to include parts of Essex, Kent, Surrey, Hertfordshire and almost all of Middlesex. London County Council never had city status, as that was held by the City of London Council (the Square Mile). Essentially, places like Southall, Croydon etc are towns, that at some point were in the same county as the City of Westminster, and so were towns of the COUNTY of London, not the City of London, which was not in the County of London. Greater London no longer exists, so now we just have a bunch of towns that are part of "London Boroughs". A Borough Council or Town Council is renamed a City Council if it gets status. Like Southend-on-Sea Borough Council is now Southend-on-Sea City Council. Today only City of Westminster and City of London have City status. The rest of the boroughs are just collections of towns, villages and housing estates
@@aodhanmonaghan1268 If there's no council, a city status can be granted to a charter trustee, Carlisle for example. Greater London still exists as both a county, region and administrative area (Greater London Authority).
As someone born and raised in Northampton, the rage I felt when Milton Keynes became a city is unfathomable Edit: This isnt to say MK is underserving of being a city, in terms of population, economy, relevancy and future potential. its probably superior to Northampton but it feels wrong that they got it before us. Afterall they were only built a little over 50 years ago, paling in comparison to our roughly 1100 years of solid history. But if it comes down to the Monarchs choice i guess we're still reaping the rewards from turning against the crown a couple times. Having one of the worst councils in the country also doesnt help.
I agree. Where is MiltonKeynesShire after all!!? I've previously lived in both places and am fond of both, but I do feel that Northampton is more deserving than MK .
I mean all the criteria mentioned aside, MK certainly feels like more of a city, with its vast and varying districts, quirky 60s features and excellent connectivity, all designed to be self sufficient. Its the fastest growing place in the UK, it certainly deserves city status. This is from someone who lives near Reading
the fact that they made a two page bogus dictionary at 2:44 for like 3 frames of screentime is the type of unnecessary high effort that I want to see from this channel. keep it up!
@@arthurb6882Absolutely. I strongly disagree with them in both directions. They have almost _nothing_ in common stylistically. MP was Avant-garde, surreal. Mm is almost surgically constructed and highly educated. The only commonality is that (some people) find both very funny. And both use words. That's it.
"could write Monty Python level sketches.." Hmm. I do wonder how much of Monty Python you have seen, outside the well worn classics? And also how much of the intricacies of Map Man you actually 'get'. To paraphrase OP; "Being thrown into the Panama canal is like drinking a glass of sparkling Perrier water." Because both are wet, right? I do agree with your closing remark, though. They are all brilliant writers, performers and comics. And _always_ top-notch entertainment. Heck; Map Men even make their sponsorship ads worth watching. I want to start another company up just to sponsor them and see what they come up with!
First time i’ve found you guys. This has part of the energy of horrible histories, but its its own universe. I love this so much. Subscribed in the first 20 seconds
Fascinating and very British indeed. We have a similarly quaint system in the Netherlands. Cities were allowed to raise taxes, but in return they had to protect the population, so only towns with defensive fortifications were given city status. Resulting in lots of cities that are still very small by modern standards, and some big towns that aren't cities, like The Hague.
@@highpath4776 Technically Amsterdam is the capital. The Hague is just the seat of Government. I have no idea how the seat of Government isn't automatically the capital (other than in the event of a short term relocation).
It always takes me approximately twice the running time to finish a Map Men episode, because I have to constantly pause and read all of the clever graphics.
Since Germany was mentioned, there is a list of requirements for a place to call themselves a "Kleinstadt" meaning "small city". Some citys don't meet all of the requirement but are still allowed to call themselves a city. And yes we do have a list of requirements for a place to call themselves a "Kleinstadt" "Großstadt" (big city) "Millionen Stadt" (roughly city of millions).
In case the Germany reference wasn't done on purpose: German city status is also fairly random, mostly based on historical claims to cityhood, that granted some political independence from the nobility.
@@randuru City is by far the more common translation for Stadt, and it's also more historical accurate, as the German Stadtrecht corresponds closely to English city status.
I am fascinated by this subject and as a Reading native, I'm okay with us being a humble town but I've also wondered why our fellow Berkshire friends in Windsor aren't a city. I'd have thought being a home of the monarch is a good case for somewhere being a city. Also as a Reading native, the skit from 10:46 is especially hilarious as Wokingham, Winnersh and Pangbourne all practically border Reading and Bracknell and Henley are close enough to walk to in a single day. Loved this.
London not technically being the capital city reminds me of my hometown of Douglas, which serves as the capital city of the Isle of Man but didn't actually become a city until 2022!
Love watching map men so well produced and I can’t believe you guys go through the effort to put all those small jokes and Easter eggs in single frames but they’re always a little treat
Fun fact. In Italy, we use a system similar to the British one: the title of city is granted to municipalities that have been awarded it by decree of the King of Italy (until 1946), or of the President of the Italian Republic (after 1948), by virtue of their historical, artistic, civic or demographic importance. Some cities even boast of the title by virtue of legislative acts of the pre-unification Italian states (pre 1861), or they do so due to very ancient and uninterrupted custom: in some cases, titles granted by pre-unification states have been ratified with norms of the Italian Republic; in other cases, the right to city status is instead sanctioned only by pre-unification deeds, technically not being even addressed by modern Italian legislation!
They do seem quite ignorant on how countries outside their own operate, usually defaulting to some bland statement that everything is better elsewhere.
In Italy nobody cares about the official status of a city. My city has a thousand-year history behind it, it has been capital of an empire and capital of several barbarian kingdoms. And that is only for the first thousand years of its history So how can the official status of city give by the monarch really matter?
Was hoping you'd mention the City of Llandaff. Llandaff has it's own cathedral (about 900 years old) and was given city status. But Llandaff is IN Cardiff, which is also a city. Which is in Wales, which is in the UK. So Llandaff has the peculiar status of being a city, in a city, in a country, in a country. (Llandaff's city status was never formally recognised by the modern UK government, however the welcome sign still reads "Welcome. City of Llandaff. City within a City)
Llandaff's historic city status in kinda on the same boat with St Asaph and St Davids cos both were cities by virtue of their cathedrals, but never formally recognised by the modern post-1974 government (Bangor was the only historic cathedral city in Wales to have its city status formally recognised in 1974). Incidentally, St Davids did actually lose its city status in 1888 when they abolished the cathedral rule to allow Belfast and Birmingham (later most of the other industrial giants) to become cities, only for it to be reinstated over a century later.
one moment "...or Laws of England in their Natural Order, according to Common Use." (in four Books), Tommy Wood, 1724 **flips pages** ah yes, Book 1, Chapter 8, "Of Corporations or Bodies Politick"... **it was right here somewhere** "A Corporation is a Person in a Political Capacity created by the Law, and is a Body Politick fram'd by Policy or Fiction of Law to endure in perpetual Succession with Capacity to take and grant, to sue and be sued, & c. He who gives the first Possessions is the Founder of it, tho they are but of small Value. So that a common Person may be Founder, tho' the King shall afterwards endow it with great Possessions. It differs from a Franchise or Liberty, because they are Estates of Inheritance, and may be granted over from one to another." (More on Letters Patent as Company Charters later, with Gerard Malynes and Thomas Hobbes...or Lord Coke.) Okay so it says right there you can stack personal fictions as corporations, since corporations are personal fictions, using the Law of Transportation (Beyond the Seas) to stack Personae Cities-zens (denizens and inhabitants) on and in Cities, as long as Bocland Ledger Dominii is preserved in the Kings-Dome (Domes-Day Book)...as long as the royal company office (the royal we incorporated) does of course agree that it can be done and is not an unnatural impossible fiction since all fictions in pleadings are hereby abolished...yadda yadda... It's how they made a penal company called "Australia" in Britain, then set up the court system (probatio) with George 3 on the company books internally, then shipped the books (transported beyond seas) to Auscorp Prime along with convicts, while retaining "proprietorship and good graces, et al." in Britain. So technically, Australia was never a city or county or country, it was a probate court system run by an Admiral with a special charter commission by King George 3 (the absolute madman GENIUS!) to run "Auscorp Prison Industries".
@@garethaethwy never heard of that claim before, but what is certain is that Cardiff was awarded city status in 1905 after it petitioned for it, irrespective of any cathedrals within its boundaries at the time.
I paused for the "important things the government has to deal with" list and literally the first thing I read was "Install giant anti-rain dome over UK" 😂 The Level of Detail you put into these Videos is just brilliant!
10:31 Germany is actually really inconsistent with city status. The city of Arnis in Schleswig-Holstein only has around 300 people, and there are in total 11 cities with less than 1000 inhabitants throughout the country
Just like Poland! Here, technically speaking settlement may be either "miasto" (city) or "wieś" (village). There are no towns in legal language. Well, we have word "miasteczko" (literary a diminutive for miasto), but is used only colloquially and there is no real consensus what it means. Therefore smallest Polish city has 300 (sic!) inhabitants, whereas biggest village has 12.000. BTW it is also mostly a status thing - city does not have any special powers - these are held by "gmina" (community), which may consist of only one city, city and surrounding villages, few cities and surrounding villages or no cities at all. The only legal differences are probably in agricultural law, with some privileges for villages.
@@menoflowicz I have heard an argument that Poland _does_ make a distinction between a town and a city - they just call them both _miasto_ anyway for some reason. The argument is that “towns” have a mayor, and “cities” have a president. But while it is true that the mayor-president distinction exists in Poland, whether this is equivalent to the town-city distinction is debatable. It certainly isn’t as much of a status symbol as in the UK!
1:58 i finally get this! its not just a reference to a gameshow, its a reference to a gameshow whose cannidates represent universities! thats why it makes sense there!
Correct! It’s a reference to the very long-running gameshow University Challenge (featuring a guest voiceover from Roger Tilling - the ACTUAL voice from the ACTUAL University Challenge!)
Medway forgot to reapply for city status because they were in the middle of a court case with Kent County Council over the correct reallocation of rescources. It got so petty that they asked for 1/3 of a minibus.
The building now known as Sheffield Cathedral was built in around 1200, however it was not called a Cathedral until 1914 when the diocese was formed, many years after Sheffield became a city. Confused? Yes, so am i.
That was definitely sharp. Cathedral City sharp. (For those outside the UK, Cathedral City is a brand of less than good cheddar, sharp is a word used to describe cheddar that cheddar purists would probably be just as offended by as the concept of extra mature cheddar)
A Cathedral is a church that contains the throne of a bishop. Cathedra = latin for seat or throne. Also "Satellite map animations PEADAR DONNELLY" probably explains why it was Derry on the map and not Londonderry. Thanks Peadar :)
I was always curious about this topic as I am from Doncaster and can remember the town submitting multiple bids and not getting it despite much smaller places getting city status then Doncaster finally got it in 2022 for the platinum jubilee, good video and nice to know its because Britain does it's own thing lol
The amount of detail on that page of definitions is extraordinary, great job! "Beef Jerky: doesn't start with M, shouldn't be on this list" and the sneaky merch promo are my favourites.
How Southend-on-Sea gained it's city status last year is extremely interesting. Our MP David Amess campaigned for his entire career to become a city but never succeeded. He was assassinated 2 years ago while meeting constituents and his wish was granted posthumously as a mark of respect.
@@bruhnglit's surprisingly more common per capita than many other similar countries in the past few decades, but by and large historically speaking? It's fine... I guess.. probably. ?
I've just watched a couple of your Map Men videos with my grandma, she's 90. She finds this kind of stuff fascinating! The first video we watched was the one about counties (we are from Yorkshire by the way ;) ) and her first reaction was "heck, those lads are clever aren't they?" and then went on to say "do they get paid for doing all this?" She found it funny to learn that Ripon has got city status, and was blown away by the fact that achieving city status can basically be boiled down to "the monarch says so". She's become a real fan of yours, keep up the amazing work! :)
The US definition of the city is inconsistent and depends on the state. In California, for instance, all incorporated communities are cities like you described, but in some states, you have towns and villages that also have incorporated governments. Sometimes the definition is population-based and sometimes it is completely arbitrary.
Precisely. In Virginia, where I live, there are no cities, per se, there are instead independent cities, which function like counties. This is unique among states and leads to all sorts of difficulties with census data
Here in Oregon, every incorporated community is considered a city. The exception is Clackamas County, which has a separate category of "village," which includes exactly one place, Mt. Hood Village.
In Massachusetts every piece of land is incorporated as either a town or a city, villages are located entirely within 1 town or city and do not have a government of their own. Towns can have some form of town meeting as governance. While cities have to have a mayor/manager and a council.. Some cities still choose to keep "town of" in their name, like the City of the Town of Randolph, MA.
California does have a handful of incorporated towns, but they are functionally identical to cities. Also California used to have townships, which were unincorporated towns and villages. When my mom was born, for instance, East Los Angeles was Belvedere Township, and before my hometown of Pasadena incorporated in 1886, it was two villages, Indiana Colony and Lake Vineyard, which were administered as part of San Gabriel Township.
Long version's a bit hard to read at 3:10, so: '"Letters patent" is a fancy way of saying "a document that is officially issued by the Monarch." Like much UK law, what this technically means, and how this practically works in the real world, are different things. Technically, the Monarch can choose any town or village or motorway service station he likes, and bestow city status upon it. But practically, it's the government of the day who makes the decision, and then the final ceremonial stage is the bit where the Monarch signs a big piece of paper. Another important thing to note, is that even in the olden days, when the Monarch had genuine power, he wasn't actually turning places that were not cities into cities. He was merely making their already well established city status into official, monarchy-endorsed city status. If you've got time to pause the video and read this essay, you've got time to reply to that email.'
I'm from Reading although moved away as an adult! Our theory as to why we never got city status was always general monarch dislike. Local legend was that Queen Victoria also hated Reading, based on the fact her statue in town faces away from the main town, towards the train station. If you look at the facts, yeah, it's a Saxon town, been there over 1000 years, has an abbey that was destroyed by Henry VIII, is mentioned in accounts of the English Civil War, has the prison where Oscar Wilde was locked up, a university that's fairly highly regarded (in some very niche areas anyway) and a decent amount of industry. There's even a Banksy now, so it's gotta happen soon right? Right???
I always though it was so it doesnt overshadow Windsor in prestege. Though they do like to misrepresent the population a bit by quoting the Reading Urban Area (233k ish) rather than actual Reading (174k ish) so while it is still a big town they still like to cheat a bit. (And theres otehr wierdness like i live in Lower Early 2 miles from reading centre but i am technically part of wokingham (7 miles away)
As someone from Reading, my theory is its because Reading is shite and lack enough culture to be a city, but rather a commuter base for people working in london. Plus, quite possibly the overinflated population figures due to being an ever-growing amoeba of suburbia and towns that are actually outside of Reading.
@@75oharasyeh, its cheating with the population. I believe they extended to nearby town of wokingham to include that which i would never say was reading. Centrally, its not small yet not really anything in comparison to actual cities. I mean, Bath or Oxford are smaller but internally seem to have features of being a city somehow...because in many ways are more facilitated centrally. There is a lot of large suburbs that could be (and probably are..) towns in their own right and are attached, so maybe that gives it cause for being a city? Or does it give it less cause by just having filled in gaps with stuff without necessarily doing much city-like facility? It does have a laarge red-brick university so perhaps.
Now I'm hoping to see a spinoff entitled "It's Something to Do with Cheese" where Jay and Mark attempt to build a city made entirely out of cathedrals made of cheese.
Yes, but when youtubers incorrectly call small places "a town" we get to correct them in the comments, pretend we live there, and act offended, which is fun! And listing Derry as a UK city, as a monarch presumably once did just can't be argued with or cause any problems. jk
3:10 ""Letters patent" is a fancy way of saying "a document that is officially issued by the Monarch." Like much UK law, what this technically means, an dhow this practically works in the real world, are different things. Technically, the Monarch can chose any town or village or motorway services station he likes, and bestow city status upon it. But practically, it's the government of the day who makes the decision, and then the final ceremonial stage is the bit where the Monarch signs a big piece of paper. Another important thing to note, is that even in the olden days, when the Monarch had genuine power, he wasn't actually turning places that were not cities into cities. He was merely making their already well established city status into official, monarchy-endorsed city status. If you've got time to pause this video and read this essay, you've got time to reply to that email."
As a german I can confirm that we have a strict set of rules by which we promote a bunch of houses to a city! It's something like: if it's a city, it's a city...
You Germans also got rid of all the crazy little borders you had during German Empire times. Kings for Bavaria and Hanover, Prussian borders all over the place, with exclaves here and enclaves there. Made the county map of England look like a piece of rationality and logic. Thank God certain, ahem, ***events*** transpired to rationalize German maps. Huzzah!
In Germany the term „Stadt“ (city) doesn’t mean anything but that the place once was awarded the right to call themself city. All that counts is the municipality as that’s the important unit. So some municipalities are allowed to call themselves city, others can call themselves market (as they had the right to host a market) but it all has no real value other than bragging rights.
I mean at least we TRIED to rationalise the rules by adding the rule of number of inhabitants to the existing rules. So basically now there is three ways to become a city in Germany. Why...
@@chcucivtxzclccucifudohzfu6766 and the bragging rights are meager at best. Though is has the nice side effect (at least in Hesse) that the city governement/ the local council can call themselves "Magistrat". But it is just as vague as you said, though there will be a ministerial guidline somewhere that makes the rule more concrete.
You've mentioned that Japanese cities are defined by population size. That is true when the central govt awards city status to a town or village. Though, the city status won't be deprived even if the population falls below the 50k threshold. There are a handful of cities in Hokkaido region which once thrived with coal miners but now got less than 10k of population.
In Finland, a municipality can decide freely to become a town/city (the same word in Finnish). The smallest town is Kaskinen with 1 200 people (it was granted the status by the king of Sweden in 1785) and the largest rural municipality is Nurmijärvi with 44 000 people. Like in the UK, town/city is just a title and they no longer have differing rights and obligations compared to the rural municipalities.
That's so funny to me, because in the United States, we distinguish between administrative statuses by "municipality" of which city, town, and "village"* are all flavors you can choose for your municipality that don't make any real difference. Although the laws vary state to state, so this might not be true in other parts of the country. To make the matter more confusing, in my home stare, anywhere can "incorporate" as a municipality meaning it's no longer directly governed by the county, but it must have a population of 25,000 before it can become "home rule", meaning it has more flexibility in what laws it creates separate from the state. For example, you can't have your own fire code in a town of 18,000, it has to be the state fire code. *I put this one in quotes because there aren't too many places in North America that are genuine villages in the Old World sense. Typically you'll see smaller towns and suburbs use village in their official documentation if they're trying to appeal to some sort of rural nostalgia, completely irrespective of their true size or economic function. For example, the suburban town of 30,000 I grew up in used to be a farming town of 5,000 along a river before suburban expansion came and ate all the surrounding farmland. It still uses "Village of ______"
We have a somewhat similar system in Norway. Historically, city status was granted by royal decree, like in England, but since 1996, any municipality can decide to give themselves city status, given that they meet two criteria: At least 500 inhabitants in the municipality A settlement with concentrated centres of population and services. This leads to a lot of small towns having city status, with the smalles one, Kolvereid, having just 1448 inhabitants
The reason I love these videos so much is the insane amount of detail you put into them. Like no one else except Jay (I assume you edit these but if you don't well done to the editor) would put the effort into to making all the funnny definitions at 2:45. I'm off to make mashed potato now
As you mention Germany in the end: It actually is quite similar to the UK there. In history City status was granted by monarchs as well. All these historic cities still have city status (the smallest German city, Arnis, actually has less than 300 inhabitants). The way to become a city then is quite similar to the UK just without involving a monarch of course: Many federal state governments can hand out city status if they please. There are some definitions by number of inhabitants (e.g. in North Rhine-Westphalia) but in many federal states to be granted city status a town only has to be perceived as city without any strict minimal requirements in terms of inhabitants, etc., just like with the UK's city applications.
Great video! Interesting to note that Colchester was Britain's first established city in AD49 and its first capital (before London) but has taken 2,000 years to get its title back as it was only granted in 2022 after five attempts over 30 years! Also, Interesting that Essex now has three cities in the space of a decade, much to the annoyance of many counties, like neighbouring Suffolk, which have none.
Yes but Suffolk is dreadful. Take it from me, someone who hails from the county immediately to the north of it. We have three, even though two of them are ghastly dumps. For instance, the best thing about King's Lynn is that it has a nice bypass so you don't have to go through it.
@sillypuppy5490 what?! 😂 Kings Lynn is considered the perfect destination by the King and Queen before, that is, they catch the bus home to Sandringham, and ….. Lynn, my beauty, deserves city status. Grey Friars Tower is the 8th wonder of the world, closely followed by The Guildhall Theatre….the oldest working theatre in the UK and is the only theatre that can claim to have hosted Shakespeare. Bypass indeed!
Hello Jay and Mark. I grew up in Bradford, a city that often feels as ignored as Reading. It was good to see you mention it right at the start. The first person I met, when I went away to university, was from Reading. He is now an MP there and the last time I saw him he was on TV, stood between the King and the PM. I often point out on Scotland History Tours channel that Yorkshire and Scotland have similar population. Bruce from that channel, who tells very good stories, claims that Doncaster is Scottish by treaty. This would stop the city count being eight each. I wonder if Wales could similarly claim Reading, as per a popular comment posted already?
My home town in Czechia refuses to ask for the city status (even though it could), simply because there are no benefits and it would only mean having to redo all the signs and official stamps :D
I feel like this video was perfectly made for me! 1. I’m from Norwich, so the mention and prize of a holiday to Ipswich is very amusing to me 2. I also lived in Reading for a few years, so I loved all of that! Especially the end card with all the random towns/villages outside of Reading getting city status in the year 3000 3. I now work for Global, who own Radio X (previously XFM) - not only was that a surprise mention, but Global have an office IN Reading! Absolutely perfect. 4. This is just an aside, and I’ve lost the time stamp annoyingly, but why was Enniskillen listed at one point? 😅 5. Ban the number 71 :)
Norwichian here too! Hardly see it mentioned anywhere which is surprising given we've got two Cathedrals, one of which is really fucking tall, and have the most medieval churches in Northern Europe! Also, Puppet Man.
Had to smile at the reference to Germany in the end. There may well be a size-regulation nowadays which can be revoked again, but there are quite many cities around here with "historic city right" which stays in place, even if the population is negligible. Similar to Britain, the right was granted by a souvereign and usually entailed such additional rights as holding a market or building a wall and taking tolls. Anyway, I discovered MapMen last week and I'm hooked. Well done!
I whole-heartedly support item number 59 on the list. One of my earliest memories in life, was realising that the indicator of the car in front didn't match ours. I've been struggling to make sense of this incomprehensibly chaotic existence ever since.
Same story in Czechia, except since we no longer have a king, the power is in PM's hands. And also the transition is not from town to city but from village to town/township (městys) or city (město). However since the list of cities is really old we have a city with only 79 inhabitants called Přebuz.
When a new Mesto is designated, the officials sport tight checkered slacks (so women can see their bulges) and blue denim hats (which they bought at the gift shop) while they celebrate at the local disco bar with all the SWINGING FOXES!!!!
9:21 _"Preston said gaining City status in 2002 put them on the map, even though our research has shown that Preston was already on most maps"_ - *LMAO*
PLEASE never stop doing the small jokes inserted into every episode, like how "david" is lazily edited on top of the St. Albans sign, "cities with a cathedral of any kind," how a segment suddenly turns into an entire gameshow, and all the small unexpected twists on phrases you know. This is why I watch Map Men.
Northern Ireland is just the chunk of the island of Ireland that's part of the United Kingdom. St. Patrick's Saltire originally represented Ireland as part of the UK, then the Republic left and had its own flag, so technically that's still the flag of Ireland, but it was never official as a separate emblem. The previous Northern Irish government had a flag called the Ulster Banner, but that government got abolished and reformed, now with no flag.
3:38 Glad to have St.Albans mentioned, being not only the closest *city* to London, but also the first *city* to have a Saint in Britain. 3:50 Love our ground chimneys (not seen any other city / town / village / etcetera with anywhere near similar signs!)
As a person who was born and still lives in Reading I find the jokes quite funny. Not sure why the council keep wasting money on bidding for city status when they could be filling in the paddling pools in the roads!
The dictionary, the long explanation, the SimCity 2000 sprite for the cathedral, the pamphlets, the big list without number 71. Even the sponsor message is funny. Oh my god this is the best episode yet
Get an exclusive @Surfshark deal! Enter promo code MAPMEN for an extra 3 months free at surfshark.deals/mapmen
Hello!
If you think about it Surfshark is a brilliant answer: you can eat the shark and presumably it comes with a surfboard which can take you home.
Did you fully research Neil Buchanan before making that joke?
technically #94 has been done in the past.
i fucking love you mate
Wow - the budget on this episode... being able to buy three large packs of Cathedral City cheese is quite a feat
And don't forget travelling to the sign for St. Albans!
Clearly that's where the Surfshark VPN money went.
@@youcanlearnalotfromlydiaand they also went all the way to the sign for St David's in Wales!
Quite a feast, too! ❤
Throw one of them on beans on toast
To add to the confusion: most British people who live in cities refer to the city centre as 'town'
Every center where all the shops are at are called town, unless it's a village from my experience.
Toon.
@@EdDueimNewcastle
@@EdDueim Gannin duuuun the tuuuuuuun
That makes sense. In the US, the city center is usually referred to as "downtown".
I greatly appreciate whoever put "make clothes sizes consistent" on the list of more important things to do cause it truly should be the top prority
I have the mosquito thing 1st, but yah, consistent clothes sizes is top 5.
Also Ban Twitter and Ban the number 71 at number 70. The attention to detail for such a small bit 😂😂
Invading Canada has me irrationally worried.
@antonioarroyas7662 at least they'll apologize right after😊
@@f.eugenedunnamiii9452the mosquito thing? Isn't that a bit far-fetched?
3:10 the long version:
"Letters patent" is a fancy way of saying "a document that is officially issued by the Monarch." Like much UK law, what this technically means, and how this practically works in the real world, are different things. Technically, the Monarch can choose any town or village or motorway service he likes, and bestow city status upon it. But practically, it's the government of the day who makes the decision, and then the ceremonial stage is the bit where the Monarch signs a big piece of paper. Another important thing to note is that even in the olden days, when the Monarch had genuine power, he wasn't actually turning places that were not cities into cities. He was merely making their already established city status into official, monarchy-endorsed city status. If you've got time to pause this video and read this essay, you've got time to reply to that email.
If you’ve got time to pause this video and type out this essay into the comments section, you’ve DEFINITELY got time to reply to that email.
@@JayForeman I'll have you know I'm illiterate.
So letters patent is kind of like a Papal Bull?
dammit i should've checked the notes first before trying to pause it without it blurring into illegibility
What email
Interestingly, Ely cathedral actually has an octagonal tower rather than the usual square. The original square crossing tower collapsed in 1322, so they replaced it with an octagonal one. Your little bit of trivia from an Ely resident.
Ely does still have a square tower at the west end, which is also unusual because it's more common for medieval English cathedrals to have two towers in that position. It's a really interesting church
IIRC the original was stone, but the new is octagonal because it was made of wood, and it was an easier build design, or something. (Visited in 1996, from NZ)
So that means they _do_ deserve to be a city!
this is an unexpected crossover of my subscriptions.
@@cvbattum also, their railway station actually has an insanely good variety of services for its size (long distance trains to Leicester and Birmingham by XC and Nottingham, Sheffield, Liverpool and Manchester by EMR as well as the usual services to Peterborough, Cambridge, Norwich and London) which kinda helps its image - there are other cities of a similar size (Ripon and Armagh) which don't even have train stations!
Simple solution: Move Reading to Wales.
And suddenly Wales' GDP doubles
We should take [Reading] and push it somewhere else!
'Accidentally' drop it on the way, shattering it into a thousand pieces and losing nothing of value.
But then you’d have to change the spelling to “Rwding”
@@ThatGuyNicho causing millions of pounds worth of improvements
I can't get over how they stop in the middle of the video to congratulate each other for being brilliant.
So wholesome and factually correct.
Hahaha that was excellent.
And knowing them, there's about a 60% chance that the one congratulating is the one who wrote the bit
So basically Reading was left on Read
😂😂😂 underated comment
*Bdum, tss*
LOL
ing
…ing.
It takes absolute ages to watch a Map Men episode as I have to pause and read all the delightful little quirks thrown in at every possible opportunity. Lovely episode as always, lads.
You have the time
@@doxielain2231 Brb, replying to emails...
@@hux2000 But how do you have time?!
Should be easier moving forward with lists being banned.
I read the entire list at the end and now have a whole new perspective on how the uk needs fixing
As someone from Reading, I dont want to become a City. Being the largest town in the UK is at least an interesting fact to tell people, if we get city status then we wont have any interesting facts to tell people
Great episode as always, chaps
There's a joke in here about Reading being so boring that it being a town is what's considered an interesting fact there but it would be mean to say it, so I won't. The remodelled train station is a bit of an improvement although it desperately needs shops upstairs and more seats (although literally every train station needs more seats, and shops).
@@jonevansauthorhehe the train station? Readings response to being boring and nothing to do is to build lots of stuff that looks like an airport? They also have these featureless glass offices now too. One interesting thing was the previous brutalist weird buildings i hope they dont get rid of them all!
Tbh living there is not too bad its surrounded by great country towns, scenery, oxford and london under an hour. Its just the bit you have to leave to get somewhere else that's the problem.
The main historical fact being "we jailed a homosexual"!?
Us Northamptonians grew up believing that WE were the biggest town. We still say it today, hoping that people are too lazy to look it up themselves.
Reading is best observed from a train window.
Is it even the most populous town. Bolton is a town and has double the population of reading?
The absolute dedication it must take to visit both st David's and st albarns for one video is incredible. They're even in different countries...
Who knew they had the same sign too
@@b3yourself91 Budget cuts. It's easier for the government to reuse the signs.
Your wrong. It was the same sign, but they scraped off the word "Alban's" and welded on some metal letters reading "David's" so the signs said "st. David's"
Clever!
@@EggPotionFilms damn really? Because nobody could ever make a joke in a youtube section
@@EggPotionFilmsr/whooosh
I live in reading, the most notable feature recently about it is that we managed to have both of our football teams (men and women) relegated in the same season, also there's a very boring plaque that says something along the lines of: King Henry is buried here somewhere-ish (we think)
Was he playing for the men or women?
Which Henry?
@@MirzaAhmed89 late but it was henry the first
This is the most at-ease I have ever seen Jay and Mark in a video (and the most British). They feel like a proper UA-cam “institution” in their own right. Two old friends who have been in the “business” for (literally) decades continuing their great tv series.
I am an American who was living in Reading in 1999 and 2000. I remember how pumped people were to gain city status and how no one could tell me why it was important. I also remember how disappointed everyone was when it did not get it. Seeing the list of new "cities" since then does make me wonder what Reading ever did to Elizabeth II? I happened to have liked it and would grant it city status in a heartbeat.
Passed over for city status not once but 4 times. Even has a king buried there. Probably just considered as bad neighbours from windsors pov.
It has a stupid name that connotes a boring hobby done by lazy people who act soooo smart!
maybe books weren't her thing?
"Everyone"? Not by a long chalk. Unless you were talking mainly to royalists and local government panjandrums.
Reading is one of the dreariest places in England. It has no character at all compared to the vast majority of UK towns and has no right to be a city. I'm pleased to hear you enjoyed your time there but I bet you would have enjoyed most towns in England a lot more.
What I find interesting is how Colchester, despite only being given city status in 2022, still advertises itself as Britain's FIRST city, because technically it was a roman city when they first colonised
I think they would change the slogan, but "Britain's last city" might sour the mood a bit.
They did that after Chelmsford became Essex’s first city. I think they were a bit salty about that.
@@JimCroz oh rest assured, they were. XD
I bet, the Romans wouldn´t have forgotten to fill the paperwork, for keeping the city-status
We hate the 'first city' nonsense. Everyone loved the 'oldest recorded town' signs and slogan and wish they would bring them back
The Netherlands also used to do it with City Privileges. They aren't given out anymore (last ones being from 1819), but one notable town that isn't a city if you use this definition is The Hague, our 3rd largest "city"
I assumed St David's was always a city because of the cathedral, but to find out it became one in my lifetime is making me doubt everything I ever thought I knew
Tbf, I’ve been caught out by the “It’s a city because of its church” thing multiple times since living in the UK. 😅
They simplified a bit - St Davids was a city for 600 years because of its cathedral and cultural importance in Wales. It lost its status in the 1800's and regained it in 1996.
I wish people would realise that having a cathedral doesn't make a place a city.
It's related to civic charters and isn't remotely dependent on Cathedral presence
@@sandersson2813 Yes, we've seen the video too.
@@sandersson2813 Did you not watch the video?
I'm surprised you didn't give Welwyn Garden City a shout. Considering it has "City" in it's title and is still considered a Town.
Welwyn wasn't even the first garden city, that tile goes to Letchworth, which is also in Hertfordshire interestingly enough
They're a garden city,not a plain city "garden city" is a phrase coined by the creator of such style of settlement 🎩
Or as I call it - Welwyn City Garden Centre
@@mattjackson9859the Welwyn City town centre shopping centre?
There is also a settlement on the Dee called Garden City
The level of effort put into each episode is a joy to behold, all the animations, cut away, jokes, in-jokes, many of them painstaking done for a mere few seconds of use - an utter treat! Thanks Jay and Mark. (ps. Getting Roger Tilling involved is next level)
Totally agree with this. And I know they are more experienced now than at the start, but I do have an urge to go back and watch all the other episodes.
But with much more generous use of the pause button to pick up all the cleverly put-together jokes that flash by too fast to read normally.
The dictionary, future cities and especially the list of what else Parliament has to do in this episode are just hilarious
@@Varksterable stopping to read all of them (getting burned by the one that said "you have time to write that email"), I half expected an Achievement Unlocked notification! (also, Neil Buchanan should alsolutely be given a knighthood)
It's been months and I just found the 'Beef Jerky' entry.
It's the same in Germany, although not with cities but with towns.
In Germany, a place can only call itself a “town” if it has been granted the so-called “town rights”.
Wikipedia says to "town privileges": Common privileges were related to trading (to have a market, to store goods, etc.) and the establishment of guilds. Some of these privileges were permanent and could imply that the town obtained the right to be called a city, hence the term city rights (Stadtrecht in German).
In other words: British city status and German Stadtrecht are literally the same.
Edit: A year later and I no longer understand what exactly I was trying to say with that comment 😅.
@@NeovanGoth It actually makes sence for countries like the uk or the us, but i guess in germany is it slightly different.
A small town (kleinstadt) with a small population (up to a few thousand people) maybe has an elementary school, a highschool and sometimes it has an local mayor.
A big town (population between 50000 and 100000 people) has a lord mayor (oberbürgermeister), schools for higher education, is moustly a local powerhouse and, in some cases, the countytown like my hometown gotha.
A city (population more than 100000), in my understanding, is nearly every time also a county in its own (like greater manchester or frankfurt/main), has a huge impact to the surounding areas (because of its huge size) and, sometimes, can be a state with its own government (like the city and state of berlin).
@@riesenmax92 No, it's not. Terms like "Kleinstadt" and "Großstadt" are statistical categories used by the Federal Ministry for Housing, Urban Development and Building and have no legal meaning whatsoever. The Stadtrecht however is a privilege originally granted by the monarch.
The smallest Gemeinde that has the Stadtrecht (and hence is allowed to call itself a Stadt) is Arnis in Schleswig-Holstein, which has a population of less than 300 (and hence doesn't even fall into the statistical category of Kleinstadt), while the biggest Gemeinde _without_ Stadtrecht is Seevetal in Niedersachsen with a population of over 40.000 (which is categorized as "kleine Mittelstadt").
In former times having the Stadtrecht granted a bunch of additional privileges like the right to host a market, and a certain amount of self-governance, but nowadays it's _only_ the right to call itself a Stadt.
@@NeovanGoth danke √√√√ and we are not boring.....
@@makesomenoiseagency2815 A German teacher explaining German grammar to foreigners with a straight face is one of the finest examples of deadpan stand-up in the world.
I love how Wokingham, Pangbourne, Winnersh and Bracknell all turn up on the “Millennium 3000 cities” list, as they’re all much smaller towns very close to Reading
Pangbourne is just about a village, and the only thing notable about Winnersh is that it has a Park and Ride with no buses. Still, potentially more going for them than "used to make biscuits".
Wokingham?
@@mr22bishop and seeds and a brewery and a gaol for playwrights and a ruined church with some French speaking English kings buried there. Oh, and a battle against the Vikings and the walls of a Roman town/city. Still a rather ugly town, glad I lived on the outskirts.
Wokingham is pretty nice when it comes to connectivity, average salaries, average school ratings and just general feel. Its better than Slough, lets say that
@@Kromiballthere’s a movie studio near there if that counts?
As a resident of Reading, we are used to the constant tease of not being given City Status. I love how on the very last list, you listed all our neighbouring towns except us! Great episode!
Also, Reading is a shithole
Come to think about it, you have weird neighboring villages and towns. Playhatch, Wargrave, Three Mile Cross...
Indeed we are! And rather annoyed by the fact that we're still just a town ...
I spotted this too. Grew up in the Town of Reading, now I live in the City of Milton Keynes :)
It used to be said that the statue of Queen Victoria in Reading faces the railway station because she hated the place so much.
Fucking Milton Keynes as if a worse shithole couldn't be given city status. What's next? Slough? @@andyhoudini
I've always been interested in why Stoke-on-Trent, as a city, is actually 5 towns, of which Stoke is only 1 of the towns. And the official city centre is Hanley which is a different 1 of the 5 towns to Stoke which is not the city centre of Stoke-on-Trent
Stoke-On-Trent is actually 6 towns. Fenton, Longton, Hanley, Burslem, Tunstall ...and Stoke-upon-Trent
I'd be more interested to know why someone thought "Stoke-on-Trent" is a sensible name for a city, rather than some kinda curse directed at a guy named Trent.
so Stroke-on-Trent is 6Towns-on-Trenchcoat?
where is the exit?
I think one of us had a stroke, I just don't know jet who.
@@fireazaIt's because it's a town next to the river Trent. There's another town called stoke elsewhere in the country and on Trent clarifies which one you mean. There are also 2 Newcastles, one of which is Newcastle on Tyne. It's like how in the US there are lots of towns with the same name and you specify the State to differentiate, except we do it with rivers.
3:10 That email isn't an episode of Map Men! And can therefore wait!
I went to university in Reading and one of the urban legends we were told was that when Queen Victoria first visited Reading, she reportedly didn’t like it. Some say that the statue of her in Reading town centre is also deliberately facing away from the centre of Reading.
Of course like most urban legends, no one has been able to verify this
Urban legend here, I can verify that it’s true.
I'm from Reading, was told the same thing as a kid
All of our local legends (both true and false) are depressing as hell 😂 I forgot about this one. Don't know if it's true but I heard it too growing up here.
If you know any local Reading history, you know why. Reading in those days lacked a sewer system among other things. It stunk to high heaven and there was excrement everywhere.
Reading at that time epitomised all the social ills of the day which Dickens wrote about in his novels. Disease, poverty, child labour, debtors prisons, workhouses, etc. It was pretty bad.
In fact, there is some evidence to suggest that during his time in Reading, Dickens witnessed things which may have inspired some of his works. Particularly, Oliver Twist.
I don’t blame her. It hasn’t improved over the years either unless you like chicken shops and fancy getting your nails done.
Thanks, from Reading. I don't think many of us here feel particularly aggrieved the Queen turned us down three times, more bemused.
We were more upset when the council wanted to rename us Reading-On-Thames (something to do with search engines getting confused with the word reading).
Also, very interesting to hear that Greater London isn’t a city. When I was a kid in 1987 we moved to Reading from London and my parents have always referred to visiting London as “going to town” and only referred to it as a city when they meant the very centre (Westminster). Goin into Reading town centre was always just “going to the centre”.
City status is granted to a council (a legal corporation.
In the 1960s they expanded the County of London to include parts of Essex, Kent, Surrey, Hertfordshire and almost all of Middlesex.
London County Council never had city status, as that was held by the City of London Council (the Square Mile).
Essentially, places like Southall, Croydon etc are towns, that at some point were in the same county as the City of Westminster, and so were towns of the COUNTY of London, not the City of London, which was not in the County of London.
Greater London no longer exists, so now we just have a bunch of towns that are part of "London Boroughs". A Borough Council or Town Council is renamed a City Council if it gets status. Like Southend-on-Sea Borough Council is now Southend-on-Sea City Council. Today only City of Westminster and City of London have City status. The rest of the boroughs are just collections of towns, villages and housing estates
this is so interesting
@@aodhanmonaghan1268 If there's no council, a city status can be granted to a charter trustee, Carlisle for example.
Greater London still exists as both a county, region and administrative area (Greater London Authority).
You can change the name of Reading but my satnav will always pronounce it 'reading'.....
It's also peculiar that British monarch cannot enter the City of London without permission. From whom and how, go look up.
As someone born and raised in Northampton, the rage I felt when Milton Keynes became a city is unfathomable
Edit: This isnt to say MK is underserving of being a city, in terms of population, economy, relevancy and future potential. its probably superior to Northampton but it feels wrong that they got it before us. Afterall they were only built a little over 50 years ago, paling in comparison to our roughly 1100 years of solid history. But if it comes down to the Monarchs choice i guess we're still reaping the rewards from turning against the crown a couple times. Having one of the worst councils in the country also doesnt help.
I agree. Where is MiltonKeynesShire after all!!? I've previously lived in both places and am fond of both, but I do feel that Northampton is more deserving than MK .
Northampton has the Saints so if nothing else then this really should show we deserve to be a city
I mean even though it’s literally barely more than 50 years old, it is larger than Northampton now so it seems about right
Queen must've seen something in Milton Keynes that literally no one else saw
I mean all the criteria mentioned aside, MK certainly feels like more of a city, with its vast and varying districts, quirky 60s features and excellent connectivity, all designed to be self sufficient. Its the fastest growing place in the UK, it certainly deserves city status. This is from someone who lives near Reading
Brilliant, as always. Especially liked the typeface and colour you used for 'Salisbury', but there are so many clever little things in this video.
the fact that they made a two page bogus dictionary at 2:44 for like 3 frames of screentime is the type of unnecessary high effort that I want to see from this channel. keep it up!
with Chat GPT it takes 5 minutes bruh
@@adiq6360no it’s personalised and fitted to the channel
I broke the 100 likes
@@adiq6360 but it would be shit bruh
Indeed! That "dictionary" is quite funny!
Honestly these two could write Monty python level sketches if that’s what they got into. Brilliant witty & funny writing. Everytime. Love these guys!
"In the majority of the world, where it's not Britain" is a line that happens in the first 30 seconds and is pure, undiluted Monty Python.
The intermission is very pythonescque
I hate these Monty Python comments
@@arthurb6882Absolutely. I strongly disagree with them in both directions.
They have almost _nothing_ in common stylistically.
MP was Avant-garde, surreal.
Mm is almost surgically constructed and highly educated.
The only commonality is that (some people) find both very funny. And both use words. That's it.
"could write Monty Python level sketches.."
Hmm. I do wonder how much of Monty Python you have seen, outside the well worn classics?
And also how much of the intricacies of Map Man you actually 'get'.
To paraphrase OP; "Being thrown into the Panama canal is like drinking a glass of sparkling Perrier water."
Because both are wet, right?
I do agree with your closing remark, though.
They are all brilliant writers, performers and comics. And _always_ top-notch entertainment.
Heck; Map Men even make their sponsorship ads worth watching. I want to start another company up just to sponsor them and see what they come up with!
YES! NEW MAPMEN!!!!!!! MY LIFE HAS MEANING AGAIN
+1
When new MM comes - HYPE!!!
Cyanide and Happiness pic+Map Men fan = certified man of culture
𝚂𝙰𝙼𝙴
You mean your life has cartography again
Much better than meaning
Lol
First time i’ve found you guys. This has part of the energy of horrible histories, but its its own universe. I love this so much. Subscribed in the first 20 seconds
I lost it at "bursting with factory workers" while panning across the picture of elementary school children.
Glad i'm not alone!
The children yearn for the factory floor. You can’t blame them
Listen, structural steel doesn't hammer itself. Little Billy can buy shoes with his first paycheck.
Fascinating and very British indeed. We have a similarly quaint system in the Netherlands. Cities were allowed to raise taxes, but in return they had to protect the population, so only towns with defensive fortifications were given city status. Resulting in lots of cities that are still very small by modern standards, and some big towns that aren't cities, like The Hague.
wasnt The Hague created to stop Amsterdam and Rotterdam fighting for who had the right to be capitol of the neatherlands?
@@highpath4776No, you're thinking of Brasilia.
@@cecasanderno, he's thinking of Canberra. Brasília was not built to stop any dispute.
@@TCA17 No, I'm pretty sure he's thinking of how Washington D.C. isn't part of any state.
@@highpath4776 Technically Amsterdam is the capital. The Hague is just the seat of Government. I have no idea how the seat of Government isn't automatically the capital (other than in the event of a short term relocation).
It always takes me approximately twice the running time to finish a Map Men episode, because I have to constantly pause and read all of the clever graphics.
Since Germany was mentioned, there is a list of requirements for a place to call themselves a "Kleinstadt" meaning "small city". Some citys don't meet all of the requirement but are still allowed to call themselves a city. And yes we do have a list of requirements for a place to call themselves a "Kleinstadt" "Großstadt" (big city) "Millionen Stadt" (roughly city of millions).
In case the Germany reference wasn't done on purpose: German city status is also fairly random, mostly based on historical claims to cityhood, that granted some political independence from the nobility.
That's town status, not city. A city - or Großstadt - is quite clearly defined by a population of 100k within city limits.
it's the first time I hear someone translating City as Großstadt instead of Stadt. I would have used major city as Großstadt. And town for Gemeinde.
I refuse to accept that there isn't a properly written rule with three exceptions that everyone has to learn in school. And a very long word for it.
@@DuskHorizon How else should we get Lernlebensfreude?
@@randuru City is by far the more common translation for Stadt, and it's also more historical accurate, as the German Stadtrecht corresponds closely to English city status.
I am fascinated by this subject and as a Reading native, I'm okay with us being a humble town but I've also wondered why our fellow Berkshire friends in Windsor aren't a city. I'd have thought being a home of the monarch is a good case for somewhere being a city.
Also as a Reading native, the skit from 10:46 is especially hilarious as Wokingham, Winnersh and Pangbourne all practically border Reading and Bracknell and Henley are close enough to walk to in a single day. Loved this.
i think being the biggest town in the UK is much better than being some random city anyways
I always say that the reason Reading never gets city status is because the queen - or king now - is from Slough.
hey, let's not be greedy - Windsor is already part of a Royal Borough with Crossroads on Thames (otherwise known as Maidenhead).
Reading can't become a city because the name confuses tourists. I was reading about it last week... oh wait!
Loved that bit of Detail 😂
Paused to read the pamphlets and I died laughing at the Doncaster one, the attention to detail in these videos is astounding
"And Hove!"
Make Tesco's sell Golden Grahams again!
That ugly flyover is my reminder to brace myself for having to change trains at Donny.
Bloody, he's right. I do have time to reply to that email.
the black and white animated thingy in the corner ITV used before ad breaks was a great touch :D
London not technically being the capital city reminds me of my hometown of Douglas, which serves as the capital city of the Isle of Man but didn't actually become a city until 2022!
Hands up for who cares?
@@marmac83
liar@@remonmasselink5748
@@marmac83✋
@@marmac83 Lol, ratioed.
Love watching map men so well produced and I can’t believe you guys go through the effort to put all those small jokes and Easter eggs in single frames but they’re always a little treat
the black and white corner thing before a break got me
The list of things for the government to do first is hilarious. "make google pay taxes"
legends
Beatles reference in the Blackburn city bid (4,000 holes).
Fun fact. In Italy, we use a system similar to the British one: the title of city is granted to municipalities that have been awarded it by decree of the King of Italy (until 1946), or of the President of the Italian Republic (after 1948), by virtue of their historical, artistic, civic or demographic importance. Some cities even boast of the title by virtue of legislative acts of the pre-unification Italian states (pre 1861), or they do so due to very ancient and uninterrupted custom: in some cases, titles granted by pre-unification states have been ratified with norms of the Italian Republic; in other cases, the right to city status is instead sanctioned only by pre-unification deeds, technically not being even addressed by modern Italian legislation!
They do seem quite ignorant on how countries outside their own operate, usually defaulting to some bland statement that everything is better elsewhere.
@@JohnyG29to be fair it usually is. But in this case, no!
Sweden used a similar system until Säffle got City status. Then we stopped. Anyone who has been to Säffle understands why.
Grazie for this municipo-political insight
In Italy nobody cares about the official status of a city. My city has a thousand-year history behind it, it has been capital of an empire and capital of several barbarian kingdoms.
And that is only for the first thousand years of its history
So how can the official status of city give by the monarch really matter?
4:34 Sainsbury's, Aldi and co-op are some of the best shops so im glad he is now Sainsbury's
Was hoping you'd mention the City of Llandaff. Llandaff has it's own cathedral (about 900 years old) and was given city status.
But Llandaff is IN Cardiff, which is also a city. Which is in Wales, which is in the UK.
So Llandaff has the peculiar status of being a city, in a city, in a country, in a country.
(Llandaff's city status was never formally recognised by the modern UK government, however the welcome sign still reads "Welcome. City of Llandaff. City within a City)
The UK is in Europe, which is in Eurasia.
So Llandaff is a city in a city in a country in a country in a continent in a continent.
Llandaff's historic city status in kinda on the same boat with St Asaph and St Davids cos both were cities by virtue of their cathedrals, but never formally recognised by the modern post-1974 government (Bangor was the only historic cathedral city in Wales to have its city status formally recognised in 1974). Incidentally, St Davids did actually lose its city status in 1888 when they abolished the cathedral rule to allow Belfast and Birmingham (later most of the other industrial giants) to become cities, only for it to be reinstated over a century later.
@@AymanTravelTransport there's them what says that Cardiff only got it's city status because of Llandaff... Not sure how true that is mind...
one moment
"...or Laws of England in their Natural Order, according to Common Use." (in four Books), Tommy Wood, 1724
**flips pages**
ah yes, Book 1, Chapter 8, "Of Corporations or Bodies Politick"...
**it was right here somewhere**
"A Corporation is a Person in a Political Capacity created by the Law, and is a Body Politick fram'd by Policy or Fiction of Law to endure in perpetual Succession with Capacity to take and grant, to sue and be sued, & c.
He who gives the first Possessions is the Founder of it, tho they are but of small Value. So that a common Person may be Founder, tho' the King shall afterwards endow it with great Possessions. It differs from a Franchise or Liberty, because they are Estates of Inheritance, and may be granted over from one to another." (More on Letters Patent as Company Charters later, with Gerard Malynes and Thomas Hobbes...or Lord Coke.)
Okay so it says right there you can stack personal fictions as corporations, since corporations are personal fictions, using the Law of Transportation (Beyond the Seas) to stack Personae Cities-zens (denizens and inhabitants) on and in Cities, as long as Bocland Ledger Dominii is preserved in the Kings-Dome (Domes-Day Book)...as long as the royal company office (the royal we incorporated) does of course agree that it can be done and is not an unnatural impossible fiction since all fictions in pleadings are hereby abolished...yadda yadda...
It's how they made a penal company called "Australia" in Britain, then set up the court system (probatio) with George 3 on the company books internally, then shipped the books (transported beyond seas) to Auscorp Prime along with convicts, while retaining "proprietorship and good graces, et al." in Britain.
So technically, Australia was never a city or county or country, it was a probate court system run by an Admiral with a special charter commission by King George 3 (the absolute madman GENIUS!) to run "Auscorp Prison Industries".
@@garethaethwy never heard of that claim before, but what is certain is that Cardiff was awarded city status in 1905 after it petitioned for it, irrespective of any cathedrals within its boundaries at the time.
I paused for the "important things the government has to deal with" list and literally the first thing I read was "Install giant anti-rain dome over UK" 😂
The Level of Detail you put into these Videos is just brilliant!
10:31 Germany is actually really inconsistent with city status. The city of Arnis in Schleswig-Holstein only has around 300 people, and there are in total 11 cities with less than 1000 inhabitants throughout the country
Just like Poland! Here, technically speaking settlement may be either "miasto" (city) or "wieś" (village). There are no towns in legal language. Well, we have word "miasteczko" (literary a diminutive for miasto), but is used only colloquially and there is no real consensus what it means. Therefore smallest Polish city has 300 (sic!) inhabitants, whereas biggest village has 12.000. BTW it is also mostly a status thing - city does not have any special powers - these are held by "gmina" (community), which may consist of only one city, city and surrounding villages, few cities and surrounding villages or no cities at all. The only legal differences are probably in agricultural law, with some privileges for villages.
I came to the comments because I figured that they picked Germany in jest. Thank you for the confirmation
but at the same time we have fixed numbers for different levels of cities. there is no city under 5k unless it fulfils a central role in the region.
In my opinion Arnis is a town - not a city.
@@menoflowicz
I have heard an argument that Poland _does_ make a distinction between a town and a city - they just call them both _miasto_ anyway for some reason. The argument is that “towns” have a mayor, and “cities” have a president. But while it is true that the mayor-president distinction exists in Poland, whether this is equivalent to the town-city distinction is debatable. It certainly isn’t as much of a status symbol as in the UK!
1:58 i finally get this! its not just a reference to a gameshow, its a reference to a gameshow whose cannidates represent universities! thats why it makes sense there!
Correct! It’s a reference to the very long-running gameshow University Challenge (featuring a guest voiceover from Roger Tilling - the ACTUAL voice from the ACTUAL University Challenge!)
The number of random references to british media institutions in these videos makes me immensely happy. Love a good episode of University Challenge
I was just about to watch the latest episode 😂
Plus the little code in the top right before the advertisements
Medway forgot to reapply for city status because they were in the middle of a court case with Kent County Council over the correct reallocation of rescources. It got so petty that they asked for 1/3 of a minibus.
That's the Britain I know and love
Medway was never a city. The ancient city of Rochester was, until its incompetent council screwed up and lost its status.
@@pyromanic8Glorious
Front, middle or back?
@@TomDestry left side, middle down the length, or right side? Or, top third, middle third or bottom third?
The rewatchability of map men videos is objectively greater than that of most modern blockbusters.
The building now known as Sheffield Cathedral was built in around 1200, however it was not called a Cathedral until 1914 when the diocese was formed, many years after Sheffield became a city.
Confused? Yes, so am i.
That handshake for Jay after sticking the landing for "cathed-rules" was well appointed! I couldn't agree more! One of your finest.
That was definitely sharp. Cathedral City sharp.
(For those outside the UK, Cathedral City is a brand of less than good cheddar, sharp is a word used to describe cheddar that cheddar purists would probably be just as offended by as the concept of extra mature cheddar)
(For those outside the UK, “extra mature cheddar” can also refer to an unexpectedly attractive pensioner.)
A Cathedral is a church that contains the throne of a bishop. Cathedra = latin for seat or throne. Also "Satellite map animations PEADAR DONNELLY" probably explains why it was Derry on the map and not Londonderry. Thanks Peadar :)
Thanks Father
The font used for Lord Salisbury (04:22) was pure genius.
I was always curious about this topic as I am from Doncaster and can remember the town submitting multiple bids and not getting it despite much smaller places getting city status then Doncaster finally got it in 2022 for the platinum jubilee, good video and nice to know its because Britain does it's own thing lol
The amount of detail on that page of definitions is extraordinary, great job!
"Beef Jerky: doesn't start with M, shouldn't be on this list" and the sneaky merch promo are my favourites.
Yeah, don't know why people are not talking about it.
Mexico is not happy. No bueno.
How Southend-on-Sea gained it's city status last year is extremely interesting. Our MP David Amess campaigned for his entire career to become a city but never succeeded. He was assassinated 2 years ago while meeting constituents and his wish was granted posthumously as a mark of respect.
why are political assassinations so common in the UK??
@@waspsandwich6548they aren't. Aside from David Amess, the last one was in 2016 and before that it was 1990. That's not exactly common.
@@bruhngl 3 in about 3 decades, and 6 in 45 years, is actually very frequent.
Jo Cox.
@@bruhnglit's surprisingly more common per capita than many other similar countries in the past few decades, but by and large historically speaking? It's fine... I guess.. probably. ?
As someone from Reading. Seeing Wokingham, Winnersh, Bracknell, Henley and Pangbourne on the future list made me cry with laughter.
As someone from wokingham... I agree😂
@@CluelessNerd Wokingham gang ✊
as someone from Bracknell ... i hope we win , just for LULZ
@@VadimkaMrLULZ is that like ULEZ?
If Winnersh gets to be on that list, I think Woosehill should get a shout as well!
I’ve passed through places named a city in the USA, that consist of a trailer park, a gas station, and burger joint.
I live in a city with less than 1300 residents. It's madness.
I've just watched a couple of your Map Men videos with my grandma, she's 90. She finds this kind of stuff fascinating!
The first video we watched was the one about counties (we are from Yorkshire by the way ;) ) and her first reaction was "heck, those lads are clever aren't they?" and then went on to say "do they get paid for doing all this?"
She found it funny to learn that Ripon has got city status, and was blown away by the fact that achieving city status can basically be boiled down to "the monarch says so".
She's become a real fan of yours, keep up the amazing work! :)
2 wholesome
Please tell your Grandma that a stranger on the internet thinks she sounds like a nice lady.
Doesn't anything in the UK happen only when the monarch says so?
No, England sports teams get knocked out of tournaments entirely at their own will.
Oh, no you're not. Yorkshire doesn't exist, but you almost got us with that one!
This series fills me with so much joy. Please never stop.
Did you see #101 on the to-do list? 10:20
The US definition of the city is inconsistent and depends on the state. In California, for instance, all incorporated communities are cities like you described, but in some states, you have towns and villages that also have incorporated governments. Sometimes the definition is population-based and sometimes it is completely arbitrary.
Precisely. In Virginia, where I live, there are no cities, per se, there are instead independent cities, which function like counties. This is unique among states and leads to all sorts of difficulties with census data
In North Carolina municipalities can choose to be a village, town, or city no matter the population.
Here in Oregon, every incorporated community is considered a city. The exception is Clackamas County, which has a separate category of "village," which includes exactly one place, Mt. Hood Village.
In Massachusetts every piece of land is incorporated as either a town or a city, villages are located entirely within 1 town or city and do not have a government of their own. Towns can have some form of town meeting as governance. While cities have to have a mayor/manager and a council.. Some cities still choose to keep "town of" in their name, like the City of the Town of Randolph, MA.
California does have a handful of incorporated towns, but they are functionally identical to cities. Also California used to have townships, which were unincorporated towns and villages. When my mom was born, for instance, East Los Angeles was Belvedere Township, and before my hometown of Pasadena incorporated in 1886, it was two villages, Indiana Colony and Lake Vineyard, which were administered as part of San Gabriel Township.
Long version's a bit hard to read at 3:10, so:
'"Letters patent" is a fancy way of saying "a document that is officially issued by the Monarch." Like much UK law, what this technically means, and how this practically works in the real world, are different things. Technically, the Monarch can choose any town or village or motorway service station he likes, and bestow city status upon it. But practically, it's the government of the day who makes the decision, and then the final ceremonial stage is the bit where the Monarch signs a big piece of paper. Another important thing to note, is that even in the olden days, when the Monarch had genuine power, he wasn't actually turning places that were not cities into cities. He was merely making their already well established city status into official, monarchy-endorsed city status. If you've got time to pause the video and read this essay, you've got time to reply to that email.'
I'm from Reading although moved away as an adult! Our theory as to why we never got city status was always general monarch dislike. Local legend was that Queen Victoria also hated Reading, based on the fact her statue in town faces away from the main town, towards the train station. If you look at the facts, yeah, it's a Saxon town, been there over 1000 years, has an abbey that was destroyed by Henry VIII, is mentioned in accounts of the English Civil War, has the prison where Oscar Wilde was locked up, a university that's fairly highly regarded (in some very niche areas anyway) and a decent amount of industry. There's even a Banksy now, so it's gotta happen soon right? Right???
"it's gotta happen soon"
↑ Oy! Stop trying to spend my council taxes on fawning to the monarch
I always though it was so it doesnt overshadow Windsor in prestege. Though they do like to misrepresent the population a bit by quoting the Reading Urban Area (233k ish) rather than actual Reading (174k ish) so while it is still a big town they still like to cheat a bit. (And theres otehr wierdness like i live in Lower Early 2 miles from reading centre but i am technically part of wokingham (7 miles away)
As someone from Reading, my theory is its because Reading is shite and lack enough culture to be a city, but rather a commuter base for people working in london. Plus, quite possibly the overinflated population figures due to being an ever-growing amoeba of suburbia and towns that are actually outside of Reading.
@@75oharasyeh, its cheating with the population. I believe they extended to nearby town of wokingham to include that which i would never say was reading. Centrally, its not small yet not really anything in comparison to actual cities. I mean, Bath or Oxford are smaller but internally seem to have features of being a city somehow...because in many ways are more facilitated centrally. There is a lot of large suburbs that could be (and probably are..) towns in their own right and are attached, so maybe that gives it cause for being a city? Or does it give it less cause by just having filled in gaps with stuff without necessarily doing much city-like facility? It does have a laarge red-brick university so perhaps.
"in some very niche areas" - is maths considered niche?
Now I'm hoping to see a spinoff entitled "It's Something to Do with Cheese" where Jay and Mark attempt to build a city made entirely out of cathedrals made of cheese.
That. Sounds. Rubbish.
@@JayForemanYou are rubbish!
@@JayForeman Its a good idea, we can call it Red Leicester.
@@eihcra_ UK remake of The Americans?
@@eihcra_Or on the second attempt ( the first having run into some rather melty problems) we could call it double Gloucester .
Yes, but when youtubers incorrectly call small places "a town" we get to correct them in the comments, pretend we live there, and act offended, which is fun!
And listing Derry as a UK city, as a monarch presumably once did just can't be argued with or cause any problems. jk
at least they spelled Derry correctly, meaning Map Men have won the internet today
@@jayplay8140 I thought it was spelled Londonderry. With a massive emphasis on the London?
@@drunkenhobo8020cos it is
@@drunkenhobo8020 Only word in the English Language with 6 silent letters
Oh no, it's happening again! Someone get the Good Friday Agreement in here!
3:10 ""Letters patent" is a fancy way of saying "a document that is officially issued by the Monarch." Like much UK law, what this technically means, an dhow this practically works in the real world, are different things. Technically, the Monarch can chose any town or village or motorway services station he likes, and bestow city status upon it. But practically, it's the government of the day who makes the decision, and then the final ceremonial stage is the bit where the Monarch signs a big piece of paper. Another important thing to note, is that even in the olden days, when the Monarch had genuine power, he wasn't actually turning places that were not cities into cities. He was merely making their already well established city status into official, monarchy-endorsed city status. If you've got time to pause this video and read this essay, you've got time to reply to that email."
As a german I can confirm that we have a strict set of rules by which we promote a bunch of houses to a city!
It's something like: if it's a city, it's a city...
You Germans also got rid of all the crazy little borders you had during German Empire times. Kings for Bavaria and Hanover, Prussian borders all over the place, with exclaves here and enclaves there. Made the county map of England look like a piece of rationality and logic. Thank God certain, ahem, ***events*** transpired to rationalize German maps. Huzzah!
If it was bombed by the RAF from 1940 to 1945 then it's a city!!
In Germany the term „Stadt“ (city) doesn’t mean anything but that the place once was awarded the right to call themself city. All that counts is the municipality as that’s the important unit. So some municipalities are allowed to call themselves city, others can call themselves market (as they had the right to host a market) but it all has no real value other than bragging rights.
I mean at least we TRIED to rationalise the rules by adding the rule of number of inhabitants to the existing rules. So basically now there is three ways to become a city in Germany. Why...
@@chcucivtxzclccucifudohzfu6766 and the bragging rights are meager at best. Though is has the nice side effect (at least in Hesse) that the city governement/ the local council can call themselves "Magistrat".
But it is just as vague as you said, though there will be a ministerial guidline somewhere that makes the rule more concrete.
Drinkin' coffee in my Map Men mug, doing map regression research while watching Map Men. At this point, I think *I* might be map.
As a fellow map, i can confirm you are a map
Why not also be men?
You should be careful saying you are map. You might get on an FBI watch list.
Unfortunate time for the mapping community. Can't even call themselves a map without sounding like a pedophile.
Wow, that's a big mug. Is your computer in it as well?
You've mentioned that Japanese cities are defined by population size. That is true when the central govt awards city status to a town or village.
Though, the city status won't be deprived even if the population falls below the 50k threshold.
There are a handful of cities in Hokkaido region which once thrived with coal miners but now got less than 10k of population.
Tokyo's districts are all called cities, so I guess Tokyo is like a mega-Stoke-on-Trent.
@@stephenderry9488Tokyo I believe is translated as being a metropole and is the only one in Japan.
@@stephenderry9488 That's because they where all cities that grew to the point of merging together into a big massive megalopolis.
@@stephenderry9488 Right so technically Yokohama is the largest city in Japan
@@dosta5652 That depends on the time of day
Mark and Jay never get old! Have just been watching all the episodes from Season 1 etc, they look the same as young as six years ago
In Finland, a municipality can decide freely to become a town/city (the same word in Finnish). The smallest town is Kaskinen with 1 200 people (it was granted the status by the king of Sweden in 1785) and the largest rural municipality is Nurmijärvi with 44 000 people. Like in the UK, town/city is just a title and they no longer have differing rights and obligations compared to the rural municipalities.
Yes, I have considered making my house a city.
That's so funny to me, because in the United States, we distinguish between administrative statuses by "municipality" of which city, town, and "village"* are all flavors you can choose for your municipality that don't make any real difference. Although the laws vary state to state, so this might not be true in other parts of the country. To make the matter more confusing, in my home stare, anywhere can "incorporate" as a municipality meaning it's no longer directly governed by the county, but it must have a population of 25,000 before it can become "home rule", meaning it has more flexibility in what laws it creates separate from the state. For example, you can't have your own fire code in a town of 18,000, it has to be the state fire code.
*I put this one in quotes because there aren't too many places in North America that are genuine villages in the Old World sense. Typically you'll see smaller towns and suburbs use village in their official documentation if they're trying to appeal to some sort of rural nostalgia, completely irrespective of their true size or economic function. For example, the suburban town of 30,000 I grew up in used to be a farming town of 5,000 along a river before suburban expansion came and ate all the surrounding farmland. It still uses "Village of ______"
We have a somewhat similar system in Norway. Historically, city status was granted by royal decree, like in England, but since 1996, any municipality can decide to give themselves city status, given that they meet two criteria:
At least 500 inhabitants in the municipality
A settlement with concentrated centres of population and services.
This leads to a lot of small towns having city status, with the smalles one, Kolvereid, having just 1448 inhabitants
Eipä oo kylä ja kaupunki kuule sama sana
@@reisiramv Kaskinen on kaupunki. Kylä on village.
The reason I love these videos so much is the insane amount of detail you put into them. Like no one else except Jay (I assume you edit these but if you don't well done to the editor) would put the effort into to making all the funnny definitions at 2:45. I'm off to make mashed potato now
Reading the list of things that government should worry about was the most hilarious experience that I had today
Reading, or Reading? Given the video 😂
@@PJWey I don't know why I laughed at that!!
I think make Reading a city did not make the list... Am I wrong?
@@juanpablosaenz9037 indeed it did not. Somehow make Neil Buchanan a knight did. Which I think is absolutely necessary.
Unironically a great manifesto for a progressive party 😂
I don't see how the production of this piece could be made any more British than it is. Brilliantly evocative!
As you mention Germany in the end: It actually is quite similar to the UK there. In history City status was granted by monarchs as well. All these historic cities still have city status (the smallest German city, Arnis, actually has less than 300 inhabitants). The way to become a city then is quite similar to the UK just without involving a monarch of course: Many federal state governments can hand out city status if they please. There are some definitions by number of inhabitants (e.g. in North Rhine-Westphalia) but in many federal states to be granted city status a town only has to be perceived as city without any strict minimal requirements in terms of inhabitants, etc., just like with the UK's city applications.
And that is also why the parliament of the Netherlands is not in the capital, but in the not-city of The Hague.
I'm guessing they were being sarcastic
This is exactly what a German would say.
i was looking for this comment
I think it is perhaps more or less the same in most of Europe. City status is just something granted by Kings or Emperors and makes little sense.
Great video! Interesting to note that Colchester was Britain's first established city in AD49 and its first capital (before London) but has taken 2,000 years to get its title back as it was only granted in 2022 after five attempts over 30 years! Also, Interesting that Essex now has three cities in the space of a decade, much to the annoyance of many counties, like neighbouring Suffolk, which have none.
Thank goodness for that, Ipswich doesn't deserve city status and will hopefully never get it 😁
Yes but Suffolk is dreadful. Take it from me, someone who hails from the county immediately to the north of it. We have three, even though two of them are ghastly dumps. For instance, the best thing about King's Lynn is that it has a nice bypass so you don't have to go through it.
@sillypuppy5490 what?! 😂 Kings Lynn is considered the perfect destination by the King and Queen before, that is, they catch the bus home to Sandringham, and ….. Lynn, my beauty, deserves city status. Grey Friars Tower is the 8th wonder of the world, closely followed by The Guildhall Theatre….the oldest working theatre in the UK and is the only theatre that can claim to have hosted Shakespeare. Bypass indeed!
Norfolk is honestly awful unless ur a cow in a field then its probably amazing
@@cale5035 😜
Hello Jay and Mark. I grew up in Bradford, a city that often feels as ignored as Reading.
It was good to see you mention it right at the start.
The first person I met, when I went away to university, was from Reading. He is now an MP there and the last time I saw him he was on TV, stood between the King and the PM.
I often point out on Scotland History Tours channel that Yorkshire and Scotland have similar population. Bruce from that channel, who tells very good stories, claims that Doncaster is Scottish by treaty. This would stop the city count being eight each. I wonder if Wales could similarly claim Reading, as per a popular comment posted already?
Doncaster *is* Scottish by treaty. It's why we give each other nice metal Souvenirs every so often haha
Love the little flicky box in the corner before the ad, gave me a proper rush of Nostalgia
You guys carry the torch for that great old-school British humor that I love so much.
My home town in Czechia refuses to ask for the city status (even though it could), simply because there are no benefits and it would only mean having to redo all the signs and official stamps :D
City status is a scam invented by the companies that make the signs.
Your style of humor is perfect. You make boring subjects so entertaining its remarkable
Thank you for a well-researched, informative and entertaining video! I have no doubt that you have put a lot work into it. Thank you! 🙏
Absolutely love the detail on the list by 3000, everywhere around Reading has been made a city, but they still refuse to let Reading have anything
Especially since they made "Reading 2: Electric Boogaloo" a city in 2401 and because was in Wales, it got accepted.
The little thing in the corner before the “ad break” was perfect. Chefs kiss
I feel like this video was perfectly made for me!
1. I’m from Norwich, so the mention and prize of a holiday to Ipswich is very amusing to me
2. I also lived in Reading for a few years, so I loved all of that! Especially the end card with all the random towns/villages outside of Reading getting city status in the year 3000
3. I now work for Global, who own Radio X (previously XFM) - not only was that a surprise mention, but Global have an office IN Reading! Absolutely perfect.
4. This is just an aside, and I’ve lost the time stamp annoyingly, but why was Enniskillen listed at one point? 😅
5. Ban the number 71 :)
does 71 means something there?
@@davidklein987 10:19
135. Ban lists
Norwichian here too! Hardly see it mentioned anywhere which is surprising given we've got two Cathedrals, one of which is really fucking tall, and have the most medieval churches in Northern Europe! Also, Puppet Man.
@@Booker8991 Gentleman’s Walk just hasn’t been the same since the Puppet Man left…
Had to smile at the reference to Germany in the end. There may well be a size-regulation nowadays which can be revoked again, but there are quite many cities around here with "historic city right" which stays in place, even if the population is negligible. Similar to Britain, the right was granted by a souvereign and usually entailed such additional rights as holding a market or building a wall and taking tolls.
Anyway, I discovered MapMen last week and I'm hooked. Well done!
I whole-heartedly support item number 59 on the list. One of my earliest memories in life, was realising that the indicator of the car in front didn't match ours. I've been struggling to make sense of this incomprehensibly chaotic existence ever since.
Apparently you're not alone. ua-cam.com/video/2z5A-COlDPk/v-deo.html
the synchronisation of car indicators is the biggest problem facing our generation
Maybe, but I want to know what's so bad about the number 71?
Technology Connections has the video for you ua-cam.com/video/2z5A-COlDPk/v-deo.html
We could standardise them to sync using GPS now - imagine the terrifying sound of The Universal Tick
Same story in Czechia, except since we no longer have a king, the power is in PM's hands. And also the transition is not from town to city but from village to town/township (městys) or city (město). However since the list of cities is really old we have a city with only 79 inhabitants called Přebuz.
When a new Mesto is designated, the officials sport tight checkered slacks (so women can see their bulges) and blue denim hats (which they bought at the gift shop) while they celebrate at the local disco bar with all the SWINGING FOXES!!!!
Is it pronounced Check-ee-er?
@@Skiddins if you speak a non-rhotic dialect of English, yes
(Look at me being a smartypants)
@@Muzikman127 there's no R though
its more check-ee-yah
@@Sem5626 google non-rhotic :)
9:21 _"Preston said gaining City status in 2002 put them on the map, even though our research has shown that Preston was already on most maps"_ - *LMAO*
As a citizen of Beep Boop Boop, thank goodness the UK is now recognising the charm my hometown has.
PLEASE never stop doing the small jokes inserted into every episode, like how "david" is lazily edited on top of the St. Albans sign, "cities with a cathedral of any kind," how a segment suddenly turns into an entire gameshow, and all the small unexpected twists on phrases you know. This is why I watch Map Men.
Not to mention the endless jokes in the graphics! Did you read the 8007 reasons? 😂
There was a cue mark before the advert. I thought it was a beautiful hallucination, but it wasn't. Bravo.
The University Challenge segment was absolutely perfect - getting Roger Tilling to do the voice was a wonderful touch
8:47
We definitely need exactly that "long story" why Northern Ireland has a "No flag, long story" flag
Northern Ireland is just the chunk of the island of Ireland that's part of the United Kingdom. St. Patrick's Saltire originally represented Ireland as part of the UK, then the Republic left and had its own flag, so technically that's still the flag of Ireland, but it was never official as a separate emblem. The previous Northern Irish government had a flag called the Ulster Banner, but that government got abolished and reformed, now with no flag.
CGP Grey has a good video on it "No Flag Northern Ireland"
3:38 Glad to have St.Albans mentioned, being not only the closest *city* to London, but also the first *city* to have a Saint in Britain.
3:50 Love our ground chimneys (not seen any other city / town / village / etcetera with anywhere near similar signs!)
As someone from Lisburn, the Portuguese border force personnel had a right old chuckle at my passport last year 😂
Yep. Lisburn people are very welcome in Portugal. Ronaldo should visit Lisburn.
As a person who was born and still lives in Reading I find the jokes quite funny. Not sure why the council keep wasting money on bidding for city status when they could be filling in the paddling pools in the roads!
The dictionary, the long explanation, the SimCity 2000 sprite for the cathedral, the pamphlets, the big list without number 71. Even the sponsor message is funny. Oh my god this is the best episode yet
@@Violet_Knight"70. Ban the number 71."
@@ahreuwuYeah sorry about that, made the comment before I got to that part of the video.
@@ahreuwu what is wrong with 71 ?
@@highpath4776 it's on the list of problems that the uk has to solve, not sure lol