The Physics of GriGri | When does No-Hands Belay Fail?
Вставка
- Опубліковано 8 чер 2024
- Physics and Experiments demonstrating GriGri slipping in No-Hands Belay.
Head to brilliant.org/hardiseasy to get a 30-day free trial + the first 200 people will get 20% off their annual subscription.
Thank you Brilliant for stimulating our scientific thinking.
▀▀▀
00:00 Introduction
01:54 Physics
07:11 Experiments
14:31 Comparing Tests with Real World
16:03 New vs Old GriGri
▀▀▀
A huge thank you to those who helped me to understand this topic:
Prof. Pietro Meschini
Prof. Rainer Schad
Richard Delaney - www.ropelab.com.au/files/phys...
All Instagram people answering my random physics questions.
▀▀▀
And also If you are getting value out of my videos and wanna feel good - consider supporting me: hardiseasy.com
Because that makes a big difference and is the main reason that allows me do this project!
Deep Thanks!
Ben - Спорт
a small correction to the physics here - there is a difference between static and dynamic mu, because friction is higher when two surfaces are not in motion relative to each other. Dynamic coefficient of friction is not equal to static coefficient of friction, so as soon as a rope starts to move through a gri gri , the friction is slightly less than when it is fully arrested.
Yes dynamic friction is usually lower than static, but in the formula I used what's been tested by experiments.
You can find more info here:
www.ropelab.com.au/files/physics.pdf
Page 86
Its not a meaningful difference as both cases show the same relation between the tension applied and the torque created across the device. If either µs or µk give the same relation, then its normal to drop the case outside of numerical analysis or further relations into a dynamic system.
this might make a great difference if there is slack on the rope from the grigri to the climber, in a way that by the time there is force on the rope at the grigri, there is a considerable speed, and since you use the larger coefficient, the grigri is supposed to engage easier.
@@xxrgxxcasco Yeah but thats using dynamics at that point, and the entire presumption of this analysis is using statics. It would overcomplicate the model and at the end of it all it could simply be replaced by some coefficient (lets assume phi) to be placed alongside the tension relationship. Still doesn't change the overall model, only numerically. By the way, I am a physicist (but work as an engineer), though I try to not be presumptuous.
@@Doctor_Yuri No need to explain yourself as a physicist, you certainly write the part leaving physicist trails. I agree with you entirely.
As a Dutch climbing instructor I am going to show this to every new lead climber that follows my course. Thanks for the in depth information!
Hey thank you so much!
The quality of this video is so insanely high, both in production as content. Keep it up man!
+1 . Probably my favorite grigri video of all time!! Thanks Ben! Can't wait for the next one with other belay devices 🙂
F anyone that uses Content to describe a fucking video
I work as a Climbing Instructor and every time someone asks why I advise them not to hold the climber side and the brake side of the rope parallel above the grigri I wish I could sit them down to watch this video, so many of your videos explain things that people don't usually have the time to explain, teach or read into.
A great service to the climbing community❤
The gym i sometimes climb at have floor anchors attached to the top rope and grigri. They are anchored low and there is literally no way to belay the proper way ( unless you are kneeling down) They advise and continue to advise parallel rope method that you mentioned. As far as I know thay have been operating like this for years with no incidents. I’ve been trying to find out more info on this topic. Seems like the grigri will hold when held parallel( tension on the brake end or course)
@@TheWayThePath Did you find out more about that?
It’s vitally important for the entire community that we learn all the possible modes of failure. If we know when and how they fail, we can put proper safety checks in place that will ensure these failures never happen. Thank you for working hard to make sure we all stay safe!
The best GriGri video ever. Definitely broke my misconceptions, I too thought that probability of locking goes up with the force on the climber's side of the rope.
Thanks for doing this work, you rock!
I think it technically does since there is a term he neglects in the theory which is the extra tension on the brake side from the force needed to accelerate the rope. F=ma so if it free fall is assumed (big simplification I know) and the hanging rope weight is 80g then it’s about 0.8 newton
So many climbers are often in danger, and they even don't know it.
.
The rope starting to slip in the diagram shot is so cool.
This is more in depth and well made than my thesis.
Love the safetey crocs you are wearing while doing the weight testing. Stay safe!
Proper gear is important in lab env
Glad you wore your crocs in safety mode while dropping weights on a crashpad ! Great video as always, thanks for doing the work of putting the theory to the test of reality !
Yea safety equipment is important:)
Glad to see a new video from you. I like your teaching style.
Bro! This is dope! I'm a physicist and you communicate exponentially better than lots of physicists themselves. Keep climbing and keep learning! Love your videos!
@10:10 the rope starts slipping through with sufficient enough velocity that you’re getting a sort of inverse chain fountain where the momentum of the moving rope is throwing the rope above its defined pivot point leading to the rope settling into the ideal position to continue slipping. That fall could have been indefinite
Edit: time stamp correction
Did you watch that video by Steve Mould on this? Noticed that too
@@jeldrikhartmann531 100% where I first saw the phenomenon
Thank you for making this video series, keeping people safer with more knowledge about gear is a pretty awesome thing to do, keep on keepin on!
Awesome video, as usual. And I swear the production and editing are getting smoother and smoother. Actually really psyched for the next one on the range of self-locking devices. A subject I'm really interested in and follow closely.
as a mega jul user. im really curious what he has to say
I'm sure this will just be another common comment, but this video is absolutely fantastic man. If almost every video you make is a 10/10, you have surpassed the level in this one, congrats and thank you for this content.
I appreciate every comment, not only for the algorithm, but it's really nice to feed back to my energy to create more ;)
Really excited to watch the video, i feel like there are so many misconceptions about the grigri and its safety in a hands free scenario!
What a piece of work ! Thanks a lot for such dedication into this topic !
This is super important information I think - a while back, I saw some very young children in my local gym who were belaying with grigris but holding both sides of the rope together in the same hand, parallel. I was worried it would stop the cam from engaging, but when i went to ask other climbers about it, they told me I worried for nothing and shouldn't say anything (the children were supervised by gym staff, who know better etc etc). They even said, these children are so lightweight that it's a struggle to even lower them after the climb, so there's no way this is dangerous. But I still felt like it was dangerous to hold the break strand parallel to the climbers side. This video shows why that might be! So thank you so much for sharing it.
It is true that some children are so lightweight its hard to get them down after the climb. Still I consider it a bad idea to let them use bad and possibly dangerous belaying technique. With quite a high probability those children will grow and get heavier by time. Or other children that are already older and heavier might see that technique and think its the normal way to belay. Anyway, who decides at what weight you should start to belay properly?
i dont see how you can imply from this video that holding the brake strand parallel might be bad?
It only implies that if you don't hold the brake rope and certain other conditions are met (i.e. climbers rope going vertical, you use skinny rope with low friction, etc) then the cam might not engage.
Brake strand parallel on a tube-style device is a different story of course.
This video is so helpful beyond the scope of the grigri - your curiosity ended up illustrating real world examples of physics and engineering so beautifully. I hope it encourages kids to study them with more interest. Well done.
Amazing video! Very well researched and also great videography to show what you are explaining
I have a hypothesis on why it is more likely to lock when the rope is yanked hard:
During a fall, the rope gets accelerated. This acceleration should be the highest at the beginning of the catch, when the rope is under tension the first time and the rope on the belayer side goes from zero to the speed of the falling climber very quickly. And in this case, the force on the brake side isn't just the static weight, but also the force required to accelerate the rope.
In a static scenario, the force is F = mg.
For a rope accelerated by a, the force is F = m(g+a).
My thought exactly, it's not (just) the weight of the rope on the break side that matters, it's also the force required to accelerate it, which is probably why a sudden hard pull is more likely to engage the cam than a gradually increasing speed. Regardless i think the main message of the video holds really well, and this is fantastic work to show how and why it is important to provide a breaking force even with assisted breaking devices
precisely!
True.
Great video my dude, very well done 🙌
Another amazing video, backed by science! I hope you realise you are literally a lifesaver by bringing this to our attention
I liked this video a lot! for a safety recomendation, I would separate more the 2 pulleys on the beam when you are doing this, having heavy weights falling just next to your head sounds a little bit risky 😅
but but.... I would have to walk more ... :))) haha thanks 👍
As long as we're not returning to the days of @HardIsEasy creating a fall while holding a sharp knife, I'm good. Those got my anxiety up :p
@@HardIsEasy dont get hurt on our behalf
And wearing no safety shoes sounds also risky.
.
Yes, I was going to say something similar! Although I think his head is reasonably safe (the weight is unlikely to swing that much sideways as it drops) I was very worried about how/where the weights would bounce to after hitting the floor!
Also, spreading the pulleys out would be a bit safer on the beam, especially if the weight is dropped as close to a pillar as is safe, and the belayer is as close to another pillar as is safe!
I really like your videos. You spent a lot of time investigating to find the drawbacks of the Gri Gri. This will help a lot of people becoming better belayers. Also, perfect explanation of the physics involved. Thanks for all your effort!
Love your content man, keep going. Well explained, great production and topics of broad concern.
as a mechanical engineer and aclimber i would to say, very good job ! showing forces and moments in a clear and accurate way. starting from first princibles and working your way up to theory and expirament. very impressive
Fantastic video Ben! 👍
So nicely done, clear, on par, extensive, and comprehesible... truly a masterpiece! WOW 😯
Your videos are incredibly valuable for the climbing community. Great video as always, thank so much and congratulations for the amazing work
Great, thorough video! Loved the physics explanations and the time taken to make this video, keep it up 👍🏼
Ben.. this is exactly why I am happy to be a monthly Patreon supporter of your channel. This is simply the best climbing information on the internet.
For me, the big lesson (as a grigri user) is that the brake hand is not only being used in case the cam doesn't engage, but that the break hand creates the friction required for the cam to engage. This is such valuable knowledge.
Ah, this takes time to make, so having people like you supporting me is amazing, puts my pressure on finances lower and helps me to focus on investigating and creating.
Thank you so much!
Well, thats not quite the truth though. Every time i climb i yank the rope at my partners grigri before to extra-confirm that its fed correctly (its just part of the standard check). My partner never holds the brake line in the "correct position" at that point as we are doing the partner checks. And yet every time it engages, never failed so far in hundreds of checks.
Can it fail? Im sure. Will it? Probably not? Should you hold the brake line? Of course. Is the extra safety still good to have? Yes.
@@Monscent I do the same, also as part of the regular partner check. I may be wrong here, but I think it engages due to the massive acceleration you achieve when you yank the rope during the check. This acceleration causes the brake rope's mass to generate a higher resistance force than it does with its own weight (i.e., under 1g). But you probably wouldn't get that acceleration when your climber falls because their theoretical max acceleration of 1g is reduced by the quickdraw friction. So the brake rope wouldn't put up the same resistance as in the "yank test". I.e., you have to put up that resistance with your brake hand. If you "yank" a bit more slowly in the test, it will slip (at least it does for me).
Great video. You're research went far into the physics involved behind all this. And the way you explain makes it very understandable for everyone. Can't wait to see the next video and your experiments on the others auto-locking devices. 🧐
This is great, especially with the balance between physics/demonstration/practicality. Will definitely be rewatching in the future and learned a lot
Thank you so so much for all of this work that you are putting in to test and find what can go wrong and how.
I wish more people would watch your videos. I share them with my friends to try and spread the word.
I like to get into this nerdy details of climbing 🤓
Ur work helps many climbers and enthusiasts around the world to learn more. Thanks!
Wow, what a great video! I'll have to watch it a few times to wrap my head around it all.
Thanks so much. I was wondering about this for so long. You've answered all my questions. Super!
Great instructive video. It demonstrates that explaining how something works is a great way to train someone to use it well.
I was very curious on how the physics explenation in this video was going to be, based on your instagram posts. But I have to say I'm impressed by the quality, and think you nailed it! Good work
Amazing video, yet again. Thanks Ben 🙏 Cannot wait until the next one 😃
Super engaging stuff man! Love it thanks for your dedication
This is insanely good. Thanks for all your work !
Very high quality content, as always. Thanks!
Thank you so much Jeremie, and extra cheers for long term support!
The amount of time and knowledge he put into this is incredible. Thanks man!!
Amazing video! Some really interesting outcomes there.
What a fantastic video! This is a terrific example of applied newtonian physics. Love it!!
Great video ! Glad to see you're back, I was wondering what your next video might be...
Thank you for this kind of videos. Necessary and important
Thank you for what you doing.
Ill show this video for all my friends
This video is pure satisfaction to me, sendig it to friends who won´t listen about not holding the break strand, too 🙂
Thank you so much!
Love your videos as always. Excellent job
perfect sponsorship segment. First ad I actually appreciated seeing -- applied to the content and non-intrusive. Thank you Ben for all that you do
Awesome, thank you!
As always an awesome video. Keep going. Can't wait for the upcoming video.
11:53 man's gigantic balls for trying out this experiment for the sake of all human life. Mad respect.
Amazing video, from the climbing information to the physics its a masterclass in merging real life with school and making it super interesting
Dude this is simply amazing and so well done! Thank you!
Super high quality video, this was awesome!
The feeling of a new video is like a new season of my favorite tv series kkkkkkkk niceeee
So good! Thanks for all this detail still easy to understand
I just realized you are the same guy who created the video about the effects of dirt on climbing rope. Your videos are fascinating and educational to me. Knowing how to keep ourselves safe empowers us to enjoy ourselves in the moment. I would enjoy more content like these last two videos!
Thanks for the video! I love each one of those tests that you do. So informative!
Great video with great insights and great entertainment. Love it! Also, can't wait for the follow up!
Doing a lot of similar testing with belay devices. Using my findings for teaching a better understanding of the different devices. And in every workshop there are at least a few usually experienced climbers, stating "Grigri grips the rope no matter what!" and "Grigri is the best device! ... always!! ... and for everybody!!!" (exclamation marks included).
The only device i could not outsmart was the REVO. Looking forward to see your findings!
Keep up the great work. It makes our favorite sport a safer one.
Great vid, Ben. I might try to use some of this GriGri knowledge to get smoother with paying slack as well!
I'm glad you went deeper into this topic! Great work putting this together.
Thx for the video. This is again some valuable content!
Amazing scientific overview! This is probably the most rigorous study on grigri available to public 🙏🙏🙌
Comment for support. Huge and important info, very cool, thank you
Superb video. I love your approach to climbing!
Thank you very much. And special appreciation for the torque calculation snapshot at the end.
Usually I never comment youtube videos but could not help myself, this is just awesome work! Thank you!
Impressive video.
Very interesting content.
Great way to aproach the subject.
Clear way to explain it.
Amazing!!!!!
Thanks a lot, guy!! 🙌🙌🙌👏👏👏
Thank you for investigating and explaining!
Wow, amazing video. The production value was great, but the carefully documented (and clearly presented) results were eye opening and super valuable. I always assumed the camming action would be a function of the force of the falling climber and/or the brake strand resistance. I never would have imagined it was *just* brake strand resistance.
Thank you! This is the kind of information I use in my job as a RAT SL. So many good videos 🥳
Great video! Thank you so mcuh for doing all the work for us
Can wait to see your next video!!!
Thanks for making these videos!
Incredible content! Thank you so much!
Thanks, this really improved my understanding of how to use these correctly. That's what we use at our local climbing gym and outside of their instruction this has been very helpful.
I've never been in to climbing or heared of a grigri, but man the UA-cam also was on point, I loved this video.
It was both good in science, production, safety education and the jankieness I love.
You had fun and hopefully saved some lives.
Would it be interesting to test the gg in an inverted position as in solo lead climbing? Quite a niche scenario but quite useful 😅 Incredible production with slow motion and zoom-in!
Such terrific graphics and video footage.
Really looking forward to the next video.
I was very interested in the Wild Country Revo, but as it took ages to actually hit the market, I eventually got a grigri.
Great video, thanks for your hard work. I bought a Revo instead of a Gri Gri, can't wait to see your next video to see how it performs.
Thanks and yea working on that video as you read this msg ;)
As a revo user I can tell you that for lead belaying it’s great as it gives rope like a charm. But in my opinion it can be scary in some situations as the revo only locks once a certain rope speed is reached (speed of climber falling) ; So in some specific situations it can be tricky and not lock on time (ie: top rope on slabs ) or not lock at all if fall speed is slow (ie:positive incline)
Amazing video! Will definitely share with my climbing partners
Great video! This helps address peoples positions that it is ok to take the brake hand off the brake end of the rope!
worth the wait- always. Great work. And now I have a video to share to all the ignorants that wońt believe that how they use the grigri is wrong. Thanks a lot
Really excellent video, it changed the way I think about how the Grigri locks for sure.
Excellent video!!! Keep us informed!!!
This is more in depth and well made than my thesis.. This is more in depth and well made than my thesis..
Thank you! Amazing test, and mind blowing informations.
That's an interestin effect that, once the break side of rope has gained enough speed, it will no longer engage even when it moves to the "front". This seems a lot like that chain fountain effect, that steve mould is so obsessed with. Also, I have seen so many plugs for brilliant, but yours is by far the one that made me most curious. Well done!
so excited to see the next video comparing different devices. thank you for the in-depth explanation. i get worried with grigri that it teaches people to be lazy with the brake strand, compared to like a tubular belay device.
great video, as always
Another great fun and informative video!
This is a great video and I appreciate the graphics to explain the physics. My physics math is good but by physical intuition is awful so this was really effective in helping me understand how the grigri works
Hi! I haven't adjetives for describe my opinion for this video... Thank you very much! It is really excellent!
I appreciate all your work. Really do.
Absolutely fascinating!