@Jack Reid If you listen with headphones you can hear that it's Robs voice. Metallica to my knowledge have never used backing tracks while playing at any of their concerts, and I have listened to an embarrassing amount of their gigs. What's more likely is that there is editing after the fact. Whether that's re-recording the backing vocal, editing it in pro tools with tuning or just adding compressors etc to even out the volume. But I am positive that it is Robs voice, not Hetfield. We will find out for sure very soon whether or not he can do it again, when they play it live in a few days. But another issue with the suggestion that it's a backing track... the band needs to play to a click, and Metallica don't play to a click live... and they aren't on a click here either.
Idk why but 72 seasons kind of hangs in my head lol, it’s not only a great song, but the album is damn good in my opinion. The more you listen the more you’re like holy shit that’s really good. Long songs, but hey, that’s Metallica! Someone’s gotta make the longer jams.
@Jack Reid I'm a little skeptical about Rob. I think it's more likely that he was singing live but that they fixed it in post. Not the hardest line to sing though, so it's reasonable to assume he could pull it off... even with his limited vocal ability.
Robert's vocals are fucking awesome on 72seaons, great performance from all! Can't wait to see them live. You can see that they are fired up for the new tour, specially Lars, the man sounds tight.
People are saying his vocals are fake and they are just using a backing track, I don’t think so cause there is a section where there are clearly vocals overlapped in the studio version, but here there aren’t. Rob deserves more for that performance
@@Shredder_games People have always liked to hate on Metallica, just ignore them. If you're as great as Metallica, you will see trolls every now and again.
@@multiestonian lol it has nothing to do with trolls as it does just calling out what's there. Backing tracks are almost *always* changed for the live performance from the studio version to give it a more "real" feel. This is an industry standard for layering vocals live. That is not Robs voice and when the tour kicks off and there's thousands of videos proving such, the real trolls gaslighting people(you) will be exposed for the blatantly obvious facts put out there. I don't understand why you guys can't just accept Rob is not good on the vox. Backing vocals left Metallica's chat the moment Jason left and they never plan on returning except in the form of layered backing vocals...from James.
Cant wait Amsterdam concert on 29th of April… as a kid I never had any money to attend their concert but now with 27 times have change. I am doing it for that old kid that still live inside of me 🤘
I hope you have a great show, buddy! I'm on the opposite side, I've seen them several times (first one in 99, at age 12) but can't go this time. It will be an unforgettable experience for you, that's for sure! 🤘🏻
What ever they do is just fine by me!!!! God bless em o course!!!! Welcome back to So CA USA in October!!!!! Am soooo there!!!! Indio CA. Can't wait!!!!!
Πράγματι φίλε,το ίδιο πηγα να γράψω και γω.Πολύ καλύτερα που το wrath of men το λέει ο Trujillo.Aκούγεται υπέροχα.Παρότι τα φωνητικά του Trujillo είναι γενικά για τα μπάζα το συγκεκριμένο το λέει καλυτερα απο ότι θα το έλεγε ο James..Φανταστική εκτέλεση,επίσης και to Lux Eterna
@@marek9427 nope, it's 100% Rob, this theory is debunked via voice isolation, clear as day. BUT I understand why would you think otherwise, we never heard Rob like this before.
That's the best I've ever heard sad but true. 72 seasons sounds way too watered down on the recording, but the guitars here sound so raw and full here . Makes the songs so much better sounding to me.
I respect METALLICA for being able to perform their new songs live. I know another thrash/heavy metal band that seems to be unable to play their new material live, save for maybe one or two songs.....🤔
![Metallica Live: Ride The Lightning / Full Album [2022-2023]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/hpylhI_El8g/mqdefault.jpg)
lars has lifted his game in his 60's amazing
Yeah for sure. Even looking back at vids from 18-19, he looks thinner so I’m sure he prioritized his heath and fitness. Props to him.
@ 5:43 flashback to 1989 Seattle in the harmony at the end of “and justice for all” fugggggin sick!!!!!!
They nailed 72 live :) at 60 years young
Old*
Yeessss!!! ❤
60 y Young!!!!
Hetfield has been sounding better and better since Hardwired. So cool to see.
Since James' last cure, I feel his former form.
Whoa! Rob sounds great on the 72 Seasons chorus!
He just opens his mouth, never seen such thing at metallica live.
@Jack Reid I don’t want to believe this… but it did kinda look like it :-/
@Jack Reid If you listen with headphones you can hear that it's Robs voice. Metallica to my knowledge have never used backing tracks while playing at any of their concerts, and I have listened to an embarrassing amount of their gigs.
What's more likely is that there is editing after the fact. Whether that's re-recording the backing vocal, editing it in pro tools with tuning or just adding compressors etc to even out the volume.
But I am positive that it is Robs voice, not Hetfield. We will find out for sure very soon whether or not he can do it again, when they play it live in a few days. But another issue with the suggestion that it's a backing track... the band needs to play to a click, and Metallica don't play to a click live... and they aren't on a click here either.
Definitely a vocal backing track, that's James's backing vocals used from the studio version (+ toned down)
@@tommurrayGTR I think it's Rob's voice but they've definitely been on a click since they came back from the pandemic
James voice in Sad But True sounds fucking awesome
For nothing
Dude rob in the chorus just gave me goosebumps
Rob’s bass tone is fucking monstrous
Just perfect! Hope they play Shadows Follow too in this tour.
New Jersey August 4th! Shadows follow debut! I was there! Like fuckin A!
Idk why but 72 seasons kind of hangs in my head lol, it’s not only a great song, but the album is damn good in my opinion. The more you listen the more you’re like holy shit that’s really good. Long songs, but hey, that’s Metallica! Someone’s gotta make the longer jams.
Omg 72 Seasons sounds AMAZING!
I LOVE THEIR TONE 🔥 🔥
That squelchy tone
Axe FX 3, Mesa Mark IIC++ and Diezel VH4 models.
this new album sounds so good im going to get when i can with out a doubt props to these guys for having so much life into this new record so awesome
You guys are amazing Kirk's riffs that why your my favorite guitarist ever 🎸🎶🤘👍🖤🖤🖤🖤
72 seasons sounds fucking badasss
Hell yeah 🔥🔥🔥🔥
amazing live. especially Robert did backing vocal well at 72 seasons.
This is the playback on this recording. rob moves his mouth and you hear James. no sense.
@@marek9427 that's robs voice bro
its not a rob voice.
@@marek9427 its 100% rob's voice lmao what are you hearing? someone isolated them and its defo rob.
@@Squall6575 Marek hasn't musical ear XD
The best band in the world!
I had NO idea Rob sang that line in the chorus. Sounds so much like James. Damn!
It’s only on the live versions :[ the studio version is all james
WOW how exciting that Lux Eterna is made me want to move with it. Thanks for sharing and you all have a great day/night too
Lars is especially tight! Good job! Rob sounds great and James is like always a beast! Kirk is doing his stuff and he's doing great!
@Jack Reid well he seems to be screaming his head off.
@Jack Reid I'm a little skeptical about Rob. I think it's more likely that he was singing live but that they fixed it in post. Not the hardest line to sing though, so it's reasonable to assume he could pull it off... even with his limited vocal ability.
Especially tight between 0:50 and 1:00 when he realizes he is dragging and eventually speeds up and catches up lol
@@VStozhkov compared to his usual self...
this whole performance is heavily edited. just watch lars, tons of inconsistencies
This is the first album since justice that I'm so pumped to hear every track. Thanks guys! Ps thanks Rob !!!!❤❤❤❤
Why is that?
Yep ... and likely the best album since justice
Wonderful job guys!!!!! 💯
Robert's vocals are fucking awesome on 72seaons, great performance from all!
Can't wait to see them live.
You can see that they are fired up for the new tour, specially Lars, the man sounds tight.
People are saying his vocals are fake and they are just using a backing track, I don’t think so cause there is a section where there are clearly vocals overlapped in the studio version, but here there aren’t. Rob deserves more for that performance
@@Shredder_games People have always liked to hate on Metallica, just ignore them. If you're as great as Metallica, you will see trolls every now and again.
@@multiestonian lol it has nothing to do with trolls as it does just calling out what's there. Backing tracks are almost *always* changed for the live performance from the studio version to give it a more "real" feel. This is an industry standard for layering vocals live. That is not Robs voice and when the tour kicks off and there's thousands of videos proving such, the real trolls gaslighting people(you) will be exposed for the blatantly obvious facts put out there. I don't understand why you guys can't just accept Rob is not good on the vox. Backing vocals left Metallica's chat the moment Jason left and they never plan on returning except in the form of layered backing vocals...from James.
@@thefriedpiper Totally agree dude, i couldn't have put it better.
@@thefriedpiper🎯
*_Thank you so much for this incredible moment and for sharing it here!!_* ❤️🔥🖤🤘💀
One of the best albums since the Black Album...
72 seasons is a killer song...
Did anyone else hear James @11:56 and was blown away? I know I was.
dang your right!! That sounds badass jeez i hope he do that again
Rob is kicking major ass! AWESOME
The best Live vocal take on sad but true ever!!!
I actually know the vocal coach who has helped james. He sounds good here
同じようでいつも新しい！
ギターがとにかくいつでもかっこいい！
強い気分になれるメタリカの最強音楽！
ほんと感謝しかありません！
Forever legends, heavy metal is life!
Cant wait Amsterdam concert on 29th of April… as a kid I never had any money to attend their concert but now with 27 times have change. I am doing it for that old kid that still live inside of me 🤘
I hope you have a great show, buddy! I'm on the opposite side, I've seen them several times (first one in 99, at age 12) but can't go this time. It will be an unforgettable experience for you, that's for sure! 🤘🏻
If you only went one day you got lucky on the 29th. We went both days (we live 30 mins away) and second day was much better than the 27th.
Best they've sounded in a long while. Rob! 🤘
@@RiddlesInStoneno backing tracks sorry
somehow this sounds faster than the album
I'm pretty sure they tend to play faster anyway
They always play faster in live concert than the album for many many years !
BIGGEST METAL BAND 🤘
So good!! Can t pass a day without listening to this now!!😂❤❤❤
New album is legit AMAZING. I like it more every time I hear it. Well done, boys. 🔥🔥🔥
James needs to do more of those growls from the last verse of Sad But True
I really love this songs, one of my favourite
Lux sounds better each time it is played live
Solid live performance
@7:06 this part is fukcin' awesome. its like trying to restart an old worldwar 2 war plane engine in the middle of the freakin air combat. damn
What ever they do is just fine by me!!!! God bless em o course!!!! Welcome back to So CA USA in October!!!!! Am soooo there!!!! Indio CA. Can't wait!!!!!
Absolutely fantastic performance from the aging metal gods.
My favourite from the new album
Έχω μείνει άναυδος!! Πολύ ωραία εκτέλεση! Πολύ ωραία φωνητικά από James και απρόσμενα ωραία φωνητικά από Trujillo!!
Πράγματι φίλε,το ίδιο πηγα να γράψω και γω.Πολύ καλύτερα που το wrath of men το λέει ο Trujillo.Aκούγεται υπέροχα.Παρότι τα φωνητικά του Trujillo είναι γενικά για τα μπάζα το συγκεκριμένο το λέει καλυτερα απο ότι θα το έλεγε ο James..Φανταστική εκτέλεση,επίσης και to Lux Eterna
Ειναι ψευτικα ρε φιλε του Rob τι δε καταλαβαινετε?
PERFECT...unbelievable.
Sound amazing and Rob on vocals! 🔥 Where is this recorded?
This is the playback on this recording. rob moves his mouth and you hear James. no sense.
Ready Set Studios, Amsterdam, Netherlands
@@marek9427 nope, it's 100% Rob, this theory is debunked via voice isolation, clear as day.
BUT I understand why would you think otherwise, we never heard Rob like this before.
Its a backing track for sure
@@marek9427 in another one its 100% rob and i think his voice is heavy in the mix of the song for that reason
Great to hear Rob open his voice up more than he used to from his more barking style of backup vocals!
Still great after all these years.....
Metallica being iconic again here....🤘🤘🤘
flawless absolutely brilliant
This song is dangerous!! Having trouble multitasking driving and head banging at the same time!
Great song
Great music from a great band
❤
Genial... very best song of last time
Everything sounds fuckin awesome. Great tones. Metallica always makes the songs sound better playing live.
Can’t believe I am gonna miss them live when I will be on vacation this year 😢
😍
❤️🔥🤘
✨
Rob man, ya sound good on the album. Not just vocally but, the bass is really amazing on the album.
13:58 nice kick fill from lars
In short, lifestyle 🤘🏼😎🤘🏼🖤🖤
My God these new songs sound amazing live...
❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤
Джеймс,дай Бог здоровья Монст,Голос с ума сойти,ВАУ!!!!Профи самые крутые !!! Ненаслушаешься,ненасмотришься на них,хоризма страшная!🤘🖤🤘
METALLICA!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!🤘🤘🤘🤘
Took me a while to get into the album, but the album, and especially the song 72 seasons, is superb
Sounding better than ever! Hope to see you soon down in South America
There is only one word from INDONESIA for this living legend band, namely Great and Incredibly Cool.
I thought the Beatles invasion was something else, then came YOU !! 😁 !
Should have played You Must Burn! Instead of sad but true
Fuck yea! Hopefully we'll get it in Amsterdam.
They must leave somethin to regular tour
They are the same song practically 😂😂😂
@@unleashthebloodthirst69420 Well, the album is a concept of their past seasons.
@@NHR_Music looks like they just debuted You Must Burn in Amsterdam!
Holy shitttt this was tight!
I wish we can get audio files of this.
That's the best I've ever heard sad but true. 72 seasons sounds way too watered down on the recording, but the guitars here sound so raw and full here . Makes the songs so much better sounding to me.
Really solid sound live, they boys kick ass! 💥
Español!!!esperando al día 12 viernes y 14 domingo pa ir a escuxar sus temazos!!!
Nailed it..
Ready Set studios,Amsterdam 18.04.2023
WRRRATHHH OF MAAAANNNN !!!!
I respect METALLICA for being able to perform their new songs live. I know another thrash/heavy metal band that seems to be unable to play their new material live, save for maybe one or two songs.....🤔
Which band would that be? (honest question, just being curious here 😊)
@@SardaukarX M******H. I'm sure you probably know.
Megadeth are doing fine...Dave will slowly get his voice back into shape after surgery
Sounds monstrous.
Este album es una experiencia compleja, está llegandome al alma
Awesome!
Lars has clearly been practicing. Can't remember the last live video I saw where he was pushing the pace on the rest of the band.
Rob's vocals have dramatically improved.
Saudades eternas 🇧🇷.
ABSOLUTELY BRILLIANCE!!!
Epic, one of the greatest metal albums in the past 30 years.
Yes agree 👍👍 friend been fan since 84.
James Guitar for Sad But True looked sick af, I don’t remember ever seeing that one
Sound massive with this lower tuning
YES!!! Lars can play double bass again! Maybe they'll finally do Dyer's Eve or Fight Fire with Fire properly.
He even had problems to record Dyers Eve. Way too fast for him.
Lars can play double bass fine. He has been able to play it fine since the 80s. He’s not any better this year than last year.
But lars is not capable of playing dyers eve, and never has been.
Потрясающе,Грандиозно,Боже! Это шедеврально!Огромное спасибо!за это исполнение!Вот оно Счастье ...!!!!❤❤❤
Amazing !!! Trully amazing
That was pretty epic! Thanks. 🤘🏼😈
Please may we have more? 🙏🏼
I do think the 72 Seasons song as an opener in the M72 world tour will start with an intro tape (bass intro) and then take off on the fast riff intro.
Yeah, that’s what I think, too.
Maybe for show 2 in Amsterdam 🤘🏽
Bad ass!
Damn this sounds so good!!
По мне наикрутейшие музыканты!... не хочу многих обидеть. 👍👍🤘💪🤝
nice job robert!
It’s backing tracks
@@jd0879 it is not!
@@RiddlesInStone
You're completely tonedeaf lmao