Lead White vs Titanium White Oil Paint
Вставка
- Опубліковано 13 лип 2024
- This video compares Lead White Oil Paint (PW1) and Titanium White Oil Paint (PW6).
Some observations:
- Gamblin’s Titanium White and Michael Harding’s Titanium White are both opaque bright whites. Michael Harding’s Titanium White has more of a buttery texture and appears to have a higher tinting strength. Gamblin uses alkali refined linseed oil as its binder while Michael Harding uses Safflower Oil.
- Rublev’s Lead-Titanium White has a sticky texture and is the warmest of the whites. It also has the highest tinting strength of all the whites. Michael Harding’s comparable Foundation White was easier to work with and slightly brighter. Both use linseed oil as their binder.
- Michael Harding’s Cremnitz White was the hardest to spread and the least opaque of all the whites. This paint only contains lead carbonate and uses linseed oil as its binder.
- In general, I found it more difficult to get a uniform texture with paints containing Lead White.
Product links are below:
- Gamblin Titanium White (PW6): bit.ly/gamblin-titanium-white
- Michael Harding Titanium White no 1 (PW6): bit.ly/mh-titanium-white-no1
- Rublev Lead-Titanium White (PW1 and PW6): www.naturalpigments.com/lead-...
- Michael Harding Foundation White (PW1 and PW6): bit.ly/mh-foundation-white
- Michael Harding Cremnitz White (PW1): bit.ly/mh-cremnitz-white
- Nitrile Gloves: amzn.to/3GGr0PG
PDF of the white paint chart: www.dropbox.com/scl/fi/2kpg8l...
PDF of my entire preferred paints list: www.dropbox.com/scl/fi/eg3k4e...
Regarding the safety of using Lead White oil paint, Natural Pigments, the maker of Rublev, said: "Nitrile, vinyl, and latex gloves are adequate skin protection from lead white paint. Please be aware that ingestion is the main route of exposure to lead paint. There are no toxic fumes or vapors from lead white paint. You can clean your palette of lead white paint the same as you do with any other color."
If you are concerned about skin absorption, please read this article: paintingbestpractices.com/pai...
Please contact paint manufacturers directly with any additional questions you may have about product safety and your individual needs.
Side note: keep an eye out for paints containing Zinc White (PW4). Some manufacturers have removed PW4 from their formulations because the latest research has shown it can cause a paint film to become brittle and crack. However, other manufacturers continue to use it, especially in paints containing multiple pigments. For example, paints labeled Titanium White and Flake White will sometimes contain PW4. This article explains the issues well: www.naturalpigments.com/artis...
Want to see more? Check out...
My site: www.nikitacoulombe.com
List of essential studio supplies: www.nikitacoulombe.com/artsup...
Instagram: / nikitacoulombe
Prints and merchandise: nikita-coulombe.pixels.com
Note: this page contains affiliate links. If you decide to make a purchase through one of these links, I will make a small commission. There is no additional cost to you and your purchase supports the creation of more tutorials.
#bestoilpaintbrands
#gamblinoilpaint
#leadwhite
#leadwhiteoilpaint
#michaelhardingoilpaint
#michaelhardingoilpaintreview
#rublevoilpaint
#titaniumwhite
#titaniumwhiteoilpaint
This is super helpful! Thank you!
Glad it’s helpful!
This is really awesome info (speaking for myself) I love doing black & white paintings of Great White Sharks. So finding a strong white would definitely transition my work. Thank you Nikita.
I was interested in the difference of color. Facinating!
Same here! Did you have a favorite?
Great information, thanks!
Glad it was helpful, thanks, DJ!
Perfect review, thank you very much for this!
How about your experiences with drying times of all of these?
By the way - Cremnitz used to be in Austro-Hungarian Empire back in the day, but nowadays it lies in Czech Republic and we call it Kroměříž 🙂
Thank you! And thank you for the details on the original location. If I'm remembering correctly, the Titanium and Titanium-Lead blends took a few days to be touch dry while the Cremnitz took slightly longer to dry. Still, it didn't take as long to dry as an Ivory Black.
@@NikitaCoulombe It is forbidden to buy any lead-containing paints in EU, so I was very happy that I was able to obtain that Michael Harding´s Foundation white and Cremnitz.
But to be honest... I will get back to titanium white.
Cremnitz, altough it has nice yellow undertone, it is good for some impressionistic use since it is very thick, but as you said - really weak tinting strenght and not as opaque as one would desire from white to be. And it takes eternity to dry, even though it is lead.
I cannot see any advantages in combination of PW1 and 6 in foundation white. I was expecting it to dry in a day maximum, but I was wrong...
I haven´t used stack lead white, which is supposed to have that desired effect of fast drying, but... it is expensive for white.
Not to mention that I am tired of beeing constantly aware, wheter my cat wouldn´t accidentally touch the painting containing lead...
@@naarji7787 lol, yes, pets are definitely a factor in paint choice. I actually like Michael Harding's Foundation White the most (PW1 and PW6). It's pretty opaque, still bright, I didn't notice that it dried slower than Titanium White, and it has some of the strengthening properties of Lead White. To me, it's the best of both worlds. This site has more great technical info, if you're interested: traditionaloilpainting.com/white-pigments/
Gracias por la ofrecer la comparación de tus materiales
¡Mi placer!