this is one of those crazy ideas where at the beginning you think "well, of course he's not ACTUALLY going to go minute by minute... that's impossible!" but here i am, standing corrected... it was possible and done... great vid!
Something funny that I just noticed: They misspelled "Receiving" on the webcam video player thingy that shows up during Minute #61 (1:02:50). Really shows how that graphic really must've been thrown together last minute. I probably would've even bumped it down from Low C-tier to D-tier if I had noticed while filming or editing.
This is such a funny idea and I love how you put this all together! Iconic movie with so many iconic minutes. Kenny Ortega really did that! And yesss shouting out band kids and theater kids! Also I think it was an unspoken rule on Disney around that time that the leads can’t kiss until the sequel. So it was entertaining to see how much you wanted it to happen and it kept not happening.
Also forgot to say how much I used to love those HSM Dance-alongs that they used to show. Watching you do the We’re All in This Together dance at the end brought back a lot of memories, and you did it well!
When I showed this to my middle school choir students, they loved Status Quo, and we would talk about how yes! These stereotypes the students are singing about ARE ridiculous! It was really important for some of my students, because they could realize “yeah if it’s not ridiculous for him to skateboard and also play the cello, it’s not crazy for me to be in choir AND sports.” Also Alec that bit with superimposing your bearded mouth over any character is S Tier please bring it back
once I started superimposing my mouth and beard onto characters, I even went back and did it for some bits earlier in the video that I didn't do it for. For example, the first time I do it in the video, with Troy's mom in Minute #2, that was like one of the last edits I did the day I finally finished editing the video
Excellent video as always. Your editing is only becoming more and more top tier. I am not responsible for the disappearance of 32 people between 1985 and 1989 from the upper Midwest.
I want to as well, eventually! This just took me 3 months of editing so I need a break from HSM for a bit and tackle some of my other ideas for video topics. Thanks for watching!
The amount of hard work you put into your videos is incredible, and it shows! Always excited when I get the notification that you uploaded something new, keep it up! Toxic behavior towards friends is always a guaranteed Shadow Realm moment.
1:01 Not to flout your dcom knowledge, but Cow Belles is one of the easier movies to remember because of its notable spin on a classic concept(rich girl). I’m pretty sure its actually based off The Simple Life with Paris Hilton and Nicole Richie. It was a (I assume popular) reality tv show where they did farm stuff and menial labor as a penance for being rich. Or are you implying that you in particular aren’t the Cow Belles/Simple Life type? Not to make assumptions about your personal taste, because now that I’m thinking about it, it also seems like it’s being referenced in ‘The suite life of Zach and Cody’ and that was a pretty popular Disney channel show for(I’m guessing) your age group. But my views may be skewed from watching too much Keyan Carlisle. Do you think Paris Hilton could sue? …I have no idea why my brain latched onto this, but apparently I have pertinent feelings on Cow Belles. So I guess I’m recommending it?
This was really fun! Which is impressive for a 2 hour tier list, especially since it isn't the first time you've managed it. Totally agree with your rankings, and LOVE the editing!
Have never watched your vids before, but I’m SO glad I did. I did not expect to make it all the way through but it flew by. I really thought hop to the top would be S tier but I get it 🥹. Great content man!
Just a note, there is already a ranking of every from 108th to 1st Disney Channel Original Movies in UA-cam, it was made by caitlin mckillop, this base is already covered
Yeah this video has 100k views, to me. Insane undertaking but turned out hilarious and a fun exploration of the movie, respect. I rewatched these movies recently expecting them to be worse than I remember but noooope still iconic and actually really well made in a way I can appreciate more as an adult? Kenny Ortega is a legend. If you ever make one for the sequel I'll definitely be watching o7
I guess it's weird but I feel like I will aleays love this childhood trilogy of mine,I like genuinely care for it. I listen to the songs still today. I think graduating on we're all in this together just brought it back in my heart for good 😂 I really laughed in this video omg Troy is my favourite,Gabi too. Yeah I guess I shouldn't love this as much as I do but it's too iconic not too. I love the 3rd movie better but the whole phenomenon really
Wait what? Start of Something New is VERY memorable, ok, it is not my go-to karaoke song from this movie bc Breaking Free exists, but that is the only reason, Start of Something New is my secong go-to.
I love high school musical movies still I was a a Troy and gabriella shipper but I think it would have been a lot better if Gabriella was with Ryan because I love them :::ryella a lot better today because Ryan and Gabriella have a lot of things in common and they been both hurt by Sharpay and Troy
is it bad that i can now see why the team was so against troy auditioning? i mean the biggest game of their lives is coming up and their team captain isn't "focusing" on that. but they should really have said it in a better way. saying NO SINGING. EVER. is fucked up. but hey, it's a kids movie and they need conflict so :))
oh lord. Now, since I was interested, I looked into it. HSM is a 97 minute and 54 second long film, coming out to just around 140,976 frames. The rest of this comment will now contain spoilers for the end of this video. I also did the math and considering Minute 90 is my top minute, which consists of frames 128,160 through frames 129,600, I scoured the minute and have decided that frame #129,417 is the best frame of this movie. It's right after Breaking Free ends as Troy looks at Gabriella and the audience cheers. Perfection.
Yep, life has just been really busy so I haven’t had a ton of time to make a normal commentary video, but I’ve been making some UA-cam shorts here and there. I am currently working on a new video, don’t really have a timeline on when it will come out, but it will! I also think the things taking me away from editing will die down here soon so I will go back to editing more regularly. Thank you for asking and sorry for my long winded answer lol
1:01 Not to flout your dcom knowledge, but Cow Belles is one of the easier movies to remember because of its notable spin on a classic concept(rich girl). I’m pretty sure its actually based off The Simple Life with Paris Hilton and Nicole Richie. It was a (I assume popular) reality tv show where they did farm stuff and menial labor as a penance for being rich. Or are you implying that you in particular aren’t the Cow Belles/Simple Life type? Not to make assumptions about your personal taste, because now that I’m thinking about it, it also seems like it’s being referenced in ‘The suite life of Zach and Cody’ and that was a pretty popular Disney channel show for(I’m guessing) your age group. But my views may be skewed from watching too much Keyan Carlisle. Do you think Paris Hilton could sue? …I have no idea why my brain latched onto this, but apparently I have pertinent feelings on Cow Belles. So I guess I’m recommending it?
this is one of those crazy ideas where at the beginning you think "well, of course he's not ACTUALLY going to go minute by minute... that's impossible!" but here i am, standing corrected... it was possible and done... great vid!
Thank you! I always commit to the bit and i’m glad my commitment is appreciated!
Of course Kenny Ortega knows what obnoxious theatre kids are like. HE CREATED US. 1992 Newsies?? We were forever changed.
Is he related to Jenna ortega
@@randomreviews4278 no lmfao 💀💀
Something funny that I just noticed: They misspelled "Receiving" on the webcam video player thingy that shows up during Minute #61 (1:02:50). Really shows how that graphic really must've been thrown together last minute. I probably would've even bumped it down from Low C-tier to D-tier if I had noticed while filming or editing.
This is the most ridiculous, unnecessary video concept I’ve ever seen. I love it
That's what I was aiming for haha!
This is such a funny idea and I love how you put this all together! Iconic movie with so many iconic minutes. Kenny Ortega really did that! And yesss shouting out band kids and theater kids! Also I think it was an unspoken rule on Disney around that time that the leads can’t kiss until the sequel. So it was entertaining to see how much you wanted it to happen and it kept not happening.
Also forgot to say how much I used to love those HSM Dance-alongs that they used to show. Watching you do the We’re All in This Together dance at the end brought back a lot of memories, and you did it well!
When I showed this to my middle school choir students, they loved Status Quo, and we would talk about how yes! These stereotypes the students are singing about ARE ridiculous! It was really important for some of my students, because they could realize “yeah if it’s not ridiculous for him to skateboard and also play the cello, it’s not crazy for me to be in choir AND sports.”
Also Alec that bit with superimposing your bearded mouth over any character is S Tier please bring it back
once I started superimposing my mouth and beard onto characters, I even went back and did it for some bits earlier in the video that I didn't do it for. For example, the first time I do it in the video, with Troy's mom in Minute #2, that was like one of the last edits I did the day I finally finished editing the video
Excellent video as always. Your editing is only becoming more and more top tier. I am not responsible for the disappearance of 32 people between 1985 and 1989 from the upper Midwest.
1:21:10 That "I'm in" and the hacking edits instantly made me want you to do a similar video for the old Hackers movie from 1995 lol
This is BRILLIANT. I need this #1 on trending, UA-cam! cmon!!
That’s what I’m saying too! C’mon UA-cam, bop it to the top!
I know this just came out... but I hope you do 2 and 3.
I want to as well, eventually! This just took me 3 months of editing so I need a break from HSM for a bit and tackle some of my other ideas for video topics. Thanks for watching!
absolute genius idea please do this for the other movies
This is the most perfect video I’ve ever seen I adore how random some of your videos are lol
dude you’re so funny and entertaining, you deserve more subs!!!
Thank you so much! I really put my all into making each moment of this enjoyable so I'm glad to see people like it!
I laughed way too hard with the “Everyone is here” bit. Great video, Alex!
This was amazing Alec, your editing and commentary made me laugh so much
The amount of hard work you put into your videos is incredible, and it shows! Always excited when I get the notification that you uploaded something new, keep it up!
Toxic behavior towards friends is always a guaranteed Shadow Realm moment.
U deserve MANY MORE VIEWS HERE I know u worked hard! Don’t stop ranking! I would do maybe the dances or songs of stuff etc haha
1:01 Not to flout your dcom knowledge, but Cow Belles is one of the easier movies to remember because of its notable spin on a classic concept(rich girl). I’m pretty sure its actually based off The Simple Life with Paris Hilton and Nicole Richie. It was a (I assume popular) reality tv show where they did farm stuff and menial labor as a penance for being rich.
Or are you implying that you in particular aren’t the Cow Belles/Simple Life type? Not to make assumptions about your personal taste, because now that I’m thinking about it, it also seems like it’s being referenced in ‘The suite life of Zach and Cody’ and that was a pretty popular Disney channel show for(I’m guessing) your age group. But my views may be skewed from watching too much Keyan Carlisle. Do you think Paris Hilton could sue?
…I have no idea why my brain latched onto this, but apparently I have pertinent feelings on Cow Belles. So I guess I’m recommending it?
This was really fun! Which is impressive for a 2 hour tier list, especially since it isn't the first time you've managed it. Totally agree with your rankings, and LOVE the editing!
You’re doing the lord’s work Alec
You are truly a madman.
Also funny thing is I realized the "going from one basketball movie to another" thing a few weeks ago
Have never watched your vids before, but I’m SO glad I did. I did not expect to make it all the way through but it flew by. I really thought hop to the top would be S tier but I get it 🥹. Great content man!
I’m glad you decided to check it out and liked it! Thanks for watching!
YES I had no idea I wanted this but its exactly what I needed. I love it. Please do more!
Incredible. Amazing. You always inspire me. Thank you for the great content! 😊
I mean this in the most respectful way...this video is bonkers
Honestly, valid.
Did you see the Defunctland video
I did, amazing video, loved every minute of it.
1:13:51 Troy checks a non-existent watch. tbh my fav scene in the whole movie
great content!! binge watching all your videos rn 😂 p.s: status quo deserved better
Just a note, there is already a ranking of every from 108th to 1st Disney Channel Original Movies in UA-cam, it was made by caitlin mckillop, this base is already covered
you could have put that first part of gabriella's solo in c it kinda deserves it lmao
edit: holy shit you actually put it in d and i fully support you
lol just wait until the end you'll be happy
@@AlecComes you done did it! i'm so glad you saw the light, even i was trying to be nice by saying it should've been in c only :))
Yay! I love your content so much!
And I love you so much
you are so underated omg
Sending Humuhumunukunukuapua'a from HSM2 straight to the shadow realm
I'd be down for another minute tier video in the future
Yeah this video has 100k views, to me. Insane undertaking but turned out hilarious and a fun exploration of the movie, respect. I rewatched these movies recently expecting them to be worse than I remember but noooope still iconic and actually really well made in a way I can appreciate more as an adult? Kenny Ortega is a legend.
If you ever make one for the sequel I'll definitely be watching o7
Thank you so much for the nice words, I really appreciate it! This video was a labor of love and I'm glad those that have watched it enjoy it so much
I guess it's weird but I feel like I will aleays love this childhood trilogy of mine,I like genuinely care for it. I listen to the songs still today. I think graduating on we're all in this together just brought it back in my heart for good 😂 I really laughed in this video omg
Troy is my favourite,Gabi too. Yeah I guess I shouldn't love this as much as I do but it's too iconic not too. I love the 3rd movie better but the whole phenomenon really
Not weird at all, making this video made me really re-appreciate the HSM series. Thanks for watching!
This should have so many more views.
Wait what? Start of Something New is VERY memorable, ok, it is not my go-to karaoke song from this movie bc Breaking Free exists, but that is the only reason, Start of Something New is my secong go-to.
your dedication is admirable king shit fr
bless the algorithm for suggesting this video to me
Bless the algorithm for working for once 🙏
I love high school musical movies still I was a a Troy and gabriella shipper but I think it would have been a lot better if Gabriella was with Ryan because I love them :::ryella a lot better today because Ryan and Gabriella have a lot of things in common and they been both hurt by Sharpay and Troy
is it bad that i can now see why the team was so against troy auditioning? i mean the biggest game of their lives is coming up and their team captain isn't "focusing" on that. but they should really have said it in a better way. saying NO SINGING. EVER. is fucked up. but hey, it's a kids movie and they need conflict so :))
This Movie Came Out On January 20th 2006
I've decided this will be the rest of my night
That is a good choice, if I do say so myself
Please do the sequels
You officially have too much time in your hands... Thank you
I had too much time... and a dream to make this video
Wake up babe new Alec Comes video just dropped
These type of comments always make me laugh and to see one on a video of mine makes me so happy. Thank you for watching and being a loyal fan!
Great video. Now do every frame.
oh lord. Now, since I was interested, I looked into it. HSM is a 97 minute and 54 second long film, coming out to just around 140,976 frames. The rest of this comment will now contain spoilers for the end of this video.
I also did the math and considering Minute 90 is my top minute, which consists of frames 128,160 through frames 129,600, I scoured the minute and have decided that frame #129,417 is the best frame of this movie. It's right after Breaking Free ends as Troy looks at Gabriella and the audience cheers. Perfection.
I love the chaos
This is an s tier video.
can you please make more.
Gods work
Do hsm 2 and than 3
commenting for algorithm
I appreciate you 🙏
GOOD VIDEO GREAT VIDEO AMAZING I AM BUG
HI BUG
I would honestly found this cool
i love this lol
Still making vids?
Yep, life has just been really busy so I haven’t had a ton of time to make a normal commentary video, but I’ve been making some UA-cam shorts here and there. I am currently working on a new video, don’t really have a timeline on when it will come out, but it will! I also think the things taking me away from editing will die down here soon so I will go back to editing more regularly. Thank you for asking and sorry for my long winded answer lol
1:01 Not to flout your dcom knowledge, but Cow Belles is one of the easier movies to remember because of its notable spin on a classic concept(rich girl). I’m pretty sure its actually based off The Simple Life with Paris Hilton and Nicole Richie. It was a (I assume popular) reality tv show where they did farm stuff and menial labor as a penance for being rich.
Or are you implying that you in particular aren’t the Cow Belles/Simple Life type? Not to make assumptions about your personal taste, because now that I’m thinking about it, it also seems like it’s being referenced in ‘The suite life of Zach and Cody’ and that was a pretty popular Disney channel show for(I’m guessing) your age group. But my views may be skewed from watching too much Keyan Carlisle. Do you think Paris Hilton could sue?
…I have no idea why my brain latched onto this, but apparently I have pertinent feelings on Cow Belles. So I guess I’m recommending it?