Islamic Republic or Secular State? Decoding Pakistan’s Identity Dilemma with Qaiser Raja

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 1 лют 2025

КОМЕНТАРІ • 165

  • @PakistanNowGlobal
    @PakistanNowGlobal  2 місяці тому +5

    What’s your take on Pakistan’s identity-Islamic Republic or Secular State? Drop your thoughts below! 👇
    Also, who would you like to see us talk to next, and what topics do you want us to cover? Let us know!
    Don’t forget to like, subscribe, and share for more real talks!

    • @1234fsdfdsf
      @1234fsdfdsf 2 місяці тому

      Should india be a secular state or have a Hindu majority state

    • @faisalsalehvlogs3367
      @faisalsalehvlogs3367 2 місяці тому

      @@1234fsdfdsf Whatever they like

    • @junikhannalyst
      @junikhannalyst 2 місяці тому

      Islamic republic

    • @dreamworld309
      @dreamworld309 2 місяці тому

      Islamic Republic

    • @ibrahimrashied9707
      @ibrahimrashied9707 2 місяці тому

      Secular state but it should be decided via a democratic way and then implemented so onwards without hesitation. If people of pakistan chose a secular way of governing than system closer to us model should be implemented in which state doesn't dictate what religion to follow and also isn't biased against a certain religion like in china france and post world war 2 turkey. If some one wants to be ultra religious its their choice no one should stop them from practicing their religion but if some one wants to be non religious then it's their choice and they will be answerable for their deeds in the afterlife. If people decide for an islamic state then it should be an truly islamic state in which principle like zakat should be compulsory sociolosim rather than capitalism should be promoted. Since capitalism is anti islamic as you can get. Islam believes in equity and equality capitalism does not it believes in survival of the fitest. Riba which means in excess of anything in Arabic should be discontinued . Most companies have 20 percent profit margin or more that is considered riba weather we like it or not. And this means no loans with interest for any one weather your a normal citizen or the government. You can't have one set rules for the masses while another set of rules for the government. Either way it should be the people's choice what they want by a referendum.its we the people who have to liver our life's not our ancestors so we as a people should decide. And it's kind rich that people with dual nationalities preach islam when they are in pakistan but have taken loans with massive interests in westrens countries to build their wealth.

  • @Abhishek-ef2er
    @Abhishek-ef2er 2 місяці тому +28

    Islamists when in minority want secularism
    When in majority ask what is secularism, only Sharia

    • @csbarolaca1
      @csbarolaca1 2 місяці тому

      USE AI TO ENHANCE FREEDOM OF SPEECH - RIGHT TO OFFEND - ISLAM CANNOT NOW STOP FREEDOM OF SPEECH: ua-cam.com/video/AWN0R5xFA3g/v-deo.html

    • @unknown-vn6bq
      @unknown-vn6bq 2 місяці тому

      Islamists when in minority also want sharia.

    • @TahsanHasan-x7q
      @TahsanHasan-x7q 2 місяці тому +3

      Those who want sh.ar.ia, always want it. No matter the minority or the majority. I'm one of them.

    • @csbarolaca1
      @csbarolaca1 2 місяці тому

      @@TahsanHasan-x7q THESE PEOPLE ARE INTILLIGENT but these people are not able to oversee the power of AGI and these people dont understand what is happning world wide. As AGI increases the Hindu Deep state will increase in power as Multi God religion will get connected, PREVIOUSLY IT WAS DIFFICULT FOR HINDU RELIGION TO GET CONNECTED, NOW AGI HAS COME. THE PROBLEM IS THESE PEOPLE DOES NOT INDERSTAND WHAT IS HAPPENING. THEY ARE NOT ABLE TO SEE THE STRATEGIC REASON. Already RSS+ Hindu Swaymsewak Sangh + Hindu Podcasters likeJaipur Dialogues + Charvaka Pocast and others +Modi+ Jews - modi had whole night meeting with BIBI Natenyahu + Musk + Unknown Gunmen + bishnoi + MODI CONSTANTLY linking with foreign diaspora and creation of world wide HSS + Tusli Gabbard + purchase of X by Musk and then hitting the Wikipedia. Adani is now has a table in deep state &will soon replace SOROS 95 years will die soon. No doubt this is CRONY Capatilism but in inital state the CRONY rises and Adani is the first Crony, its happening all around. See Bangladesh first time Hindu are rising. Once, Trump comes and Elon Musk gets a seat in Crown Council the characterstics of Deep state will change. Initally, it was Adani and Ambani but then Ambani took a step back and did mandwali that they are not interested in deep state and Rahul gandhi forgot him. BUT ADANI STOOD UP and now he controls the world wide ports and choke points. THE POWER OF HINDU DEEP STATE IS INCREASING. AND SLOWLY SINO+ WAHABI + LEFTIST ALLIANCE IS DROWNING. AFTER 20 FEB ONCE TRUMP TAKES OVER THE WORLD DIGITAL CHOKE POINTS WILL BE CONTROLLED BY NEW DEEP STATE, THAT IS RSS + JEWS + ISREAL + MUSK + TRUMP and so and so forth for next atleast 10 years. In next 10 years Artificial intilligence which is doubling every 5 months will become 100 Crores times powerful and the world will change. PROBLEM IS THESE PEOPLE ARE INTILLIGENT BUT IN TIME WRAP. MODI GIVES THEM ONE ITEM AND THEY FIGHT OVER THAT ITEM AND AT THAT TIME HE IS SILENTLY WORKING ON 10 MORE ITEMS, HE IS 50 STEPS AWAY FROM THESE PEOPLE.

    • @csbarolaca1
      @csbarolaca1 2 місяці тому

      @@TahsanHasan-x7q USE AI TO ENHANCE FREEDOM OF SPEECH - RIGHT TO OFFEND - ISLAM CANNOT NOW STOP FREEDOM OF SPEECH: ua-cam.com/video/AWN0R5xFA3g/v-deo.html
      As AGI increases the Hindu Deep state will increase in power as Multi God religion will get connected. Already RSS+ Hindu S S + Hindu Podcasters likeJaipur Dialogues+Modi+ Jews+Musk is comming. Adani is now has a table in deep state &will soon replace SOROS 95 years will die soon

  • @mrkeshav736
    @mrkeshav736 2 місяці тому +7

    2:45 ki Tum Hindu Se Convert hue Hai ya nhi ye hai Identity crisis 😂😂😂to...

  • @sapiens6875
    @sapiens6875 2 місяці тому +7

    It is unfortunate to see most muslims are leaving the land of pure and migrating to land of kuffar and are more happy to living in the land of kuffar. Ummah should come back and live along with ummah whether it is pakistan, afghanistan, sudan, somalia, etc and make ummah nation greater again..

    • @jacksparow25
      @jacksparow25 2 місяці тому

      Lindu😂😂😂

    • @AbhayPeshin
      @AbhayPeshin 2 місяці тому

      ​@@jacksparow25chuslim

    • @ibrahimrashied9707
      @ibrahimrashied9707 2 місяці тому

      Well they are happy there because they are allowed to follow their religions and have freedoms that every civilised country gives its citizens.

  • @love_raj_jumar
    @love_raj_jumar 2 місяці тому +19

    But want secularism in india ,Europe and west

    • @everybodykungfufighting2230
      @everybodykungfufighting2230 2 місяці тому +3

      What he saying is any 'Ism' by vote not by force. Unfortunately pseudo-secularism and desi pseudo-liberlism is imposed on the Pakistanis by ruthless elite.

    • @Hitchens-k9s
      @Hitchens-k9s 2 місяці тому +2

      @@everybodykungfufighting2230already 72 firqas,now further segregation…liberal,secular etc…😂😂😂 while he lives as a citizen of Netherlands 😂😂😂

    • @moonisra702
      @moonisra702 2 місяці тому +1

      ​@@Hitchens-k9s secularism has multiple versions and firqa. Sha*ia is same, but fiqh is different. But secularism don’t have any devine things, so everyone can make his own version of secularism.
      And Qaiser is Against secularisation of Pakistan. But Netherlands is secular by democratic way. In Pakistan secularism will only possible by force..

    • @industrial1515
      @industrial1515 2 місяці тому +4

      We want you to be truthful. If pakistan include Islamic Republic with its name then be truthful with it. If west include secularism with there name just be truthful. Or else call your self hindu Republic of India. Then we don't have problem,

    • @Hitchens-k9s
      @Hitchens-k9s 2 місяці тому +1

      @@industrial1515 status of shia,ahmediya and other religions wil become wuuurrt in sharia implemented contrys

  • @Laiba-q7j
    @Laiba-q7j 2 місяці тому +3

    Qaiser sahib is a legend Pakistani 🇵🇰😊

  • @drirbazawan1247
    @drirbazawan1247 2 місяці тому +5

    Israel k Supporter Aur West Ke Liberal Secular Mulk Netherlands Ka Passport Chorein Raja G

  • @NatureNow-k4q
    @NatureNow-k4q 2 місяці тому +4

    Pakistan already has Islamic Law in its constitution example ban on alcohol, marriage laws, property laws etc. Those demanding Islamic Laws are actually demanding that Pakistan should go to stone age like Afghanistan where females are not allowed to go schools and parks. Entertainment and sports like chess are not allowed & according to recent updates they even banned TV channels from displaying living things lol. Its all about how you do interpretation.

  • @notorious25796
    @notorious25796 2 місяці тому +11

    Pakistan is "La ilaha illallah"
    Oue elders hav given sacrifices for it....

    • @ibrahimrashied9707
      @ibrahimrashied9707 2 місяці тому

      Our elders aka jinnah were seculars as hell. And kind of hypocrites aswell

  • @sapiens6875
    @sapiens6875 2 місяці тому +25

    Funny that these pakistanis when leave Paksitani and move to UK, scotland, canada, US, etc. speak about secularism like London mayer, scotland priminister, etc.🤣

    • @syednasrulla8249
      @syednasrulla8249 2 місяці тому +1

      First Study about Islamic text Quran and then Answer. In shariya the cut the hand of rubber, Innocent people killed it's a punishment in death. In Islam alcohol is haram, Gambling is haram, Girlfriend and boyfriend is haram ,love in relationship is haram.only Halal is marriage to do relationship to man and woman. It's called Islam❤️❤️🇮🇳❤️❤️

    • @sapiens6875
      @sapiens6875 2 місяці тому

      @syednasrulla8249
      Say to ummah living in the land of kuffar...

    • @syednasrulla8249
      @syednasrulla8249 2 місяці тому

      @sapiens6875 First bro First Study about kafir.
      Answer : kafir is how are not Believeing in Parmatma. And what ever Parmatma Create Sun,Moon, mountain, Sky, water every things.He is parmatma only one not others. We muslim pray only parmatma the creator. Not the Creation like Sun , Moon, mountain ,water, Autar, Idols. Frist you Study the Vidas .The Creator is one not others. Not hindu brother in pakistan and Bangladesh. There are Sow many muslim countries the will stay and do job and send billion of money to India.Example Malaysia 7%, Indonesia 4%,UAE 7%, Kuwait 14% and other countrie. ❤️🇮🇳❤️

    • @1008apocalypse1008
      @1008apocalypse1008 2 місяці тому

      Beauty of Islam ❤

  • @Believer493
    @Believer493 2 місяці тому +10

    Came here for qaiser sab.

    • @PakistanNowGlobal
      @PakistanNowGlobal  2 місяці тому +4

      Glad to have you here! Qaiser Sab never disappoints!
      What’s your favorite part of the discussion?

  • @drirbazawan1247
    @drirbazawan1247 2 місяці тому +4

    Hadees aur Orthodoxy k champion bnne se pehle , Hadees k mutabiq Darhi to rakh lein Raja G

    • @Suleman123-f9n
      @Suleman123-f9n Місяць тому

      استاد محترم سے کہیں تھوڑی ہمت کرے اور میدان میں آئے اور دلیل دے بقایا اللہ ہدایت دے آمین 😮

    • @drirbazawan1247
      @drirbazawan1247 Місяць тому

      @Suleman123-f9n ... Is baat se Raja G ki Darhi Hadees aur Orthodoxy k mutabiq sabit ni hoti

    • @Suleman123-f9n
      @Suleman123-f9n Місяць тому

      @@drirbazawan1247 ap apny koi ustad muhtrm hmy kyu ni pash kr rhy jo hmy bta sky darhi kasy rakhni ha

    • @drirbazawan1247
      @drirbazawan1247 Місяць тому

      @Suleman123-f9n ... Orthodoxy kay champion se kahein k Apne Mufti Tariq Masood ,,, Mufti Wajidi etc se Puch lein

    • @Suleman123-f9n
      @Suleman123-f9n Місяць тому

      @@drirbazawan1247 ni hm ap k ustad muhtrm ki b hadayat suna chaty hain

  • @moonisra702
    @moonisra702 2 місяці тому +1

    Only for Qaiser Ahmed Raja
    From Bangladesh ❤

  • @manishkumar-ou4dt
    @manishkumar-ou4dt 2 місяці тому +5

    Ex muslim sahil ne khub dhoya tha raja ko debate me...ask him 1 question.... does he feel proud in killing a chameleon 😂

    • @BABA-ORUC1761
      @BABA-ORUC1761 2 місяці тому +5

      Zaid Patel ny joh pela hai hajama wale ko😂😂😂
      Upar Awaze haq ny tumhare shastr kholy hain😂😂😂

    • @moonisra702
      @moonisra702 2 місяці тому

      When debate occurred?

    • @manishkumar-ou4dt
      @manishkumar-ou4dt 2 місяці тому

      @BABA-ORUC1761 TM padho aasmani kitab...hm kuch na padhte ye sab...Bane rho zahil...🤣

    • @manishkumar-ou4dt
      @manishkumar-ou4dt 2 місяці тому

      @@moonisra702 exmuslim sahil uncensored...ye channel par search karna

    • @moonisra702
      @moonisra702 2 місяці тому +1

      @@manishkumar-ou4dt keu ki tumhara kitab authentic nehi hain.
      Aur casteism hain.
      Humara kitab main casteism, satidah ye sab stupidity nehi hain.
      Aur Islam fastest growing religion hain.

  • @spreadingpeace893
    @spreadingpeace893 2 місяці тому

    May Allah pak rewards you Qaiser bhae for uncovering truth to public

  • @lucky8724
    @lucky8724 2 місяці тому +3

    Best❤

  • @SaheelHussan
    @SaheelHussan 2 місяці тому +5

    Follow Maldives model it's peaceful, developing and 100% Muslim country.

    • @ibrahimrashied9707
      @ibrahimrashied9707 2 місяці тому

      That's even worse than pakistan and their model contradicts islamic values. Islamic teach8ng doesn't forbid non muslims from practicing their religion while in the Maldives it's against their constitution.

  • @warriorpoet-bc5td
    @warriorpoet-bc5td 2 місяці тому +1

    Outstanding.

  • @bilalkhan7881
    @bilalkhan7881 2 місяці тому

    A great and amazing guy who know science philosophy and relegion deply

  • @arjunr5578
    @arjunr5578 2 місяці тому +1

    Pakistanis when they go to western country they start believing in 3 nation theory 😂😂

  • @tauseefkiani-
    @tauseefkiani- 2 місяці тому

    17:05 vote is mulk mn aik zra brabar bhi tabdeeli nahi la skta kyun k vote "company" k hath mn hy, form 47 etc etc wala hath to abhi hua hy is mulk k sath, is liye vote se umeed lgana baykaar hy us k liye koshish krna sai-e-laa-hasil hy qaiser bhai. 😢

  • @everybodykungfufighting2230
    @everybodykungfufighting2230 2 місяці тому +4

    Podcast is the new entertainment in Pakistan.

  • @ibrahimrashied9707
    @ibrahimrashied9707 2 місяці тому

    And trasngeder is halal according to shia theology. That is why its legal to have sex change surgeries in iran and its government sponsored. Fatwa given by the late ayotullah khameni made it legal. And the current one isnt opposed to it. This is another reason why religion and state do not mix one person can dictate for the whole community what is islamic and whats not.

  • @Emmiyounas.
    @Emmiyounas. 2 місяці тому +5

    Qaisar Ahmed Raja❤️‍🔥

  • @almisbahnews
    @almisbahnews 2 місяці тому +2

    This podcast is worth watching.

  • @amjadfiaz4830
    @amjadfiaz4830 Місяць тому

    Aj ka sb sa bara issue land reform ka ha is ka bad he pakistan ma kuch stability a skti ha religies har baday ka prrsonal issue hota ha

  • @subramayamrvr8774
    @subramayamrvr8774 2 місяці тому +2

    Unless you love your motherland history culture traditions and civilization of more than 5000 years you cannot appreciate human rights civil liberties democracy and freedom.

    • @jacksparow25
      @jacksparow25 2 місяці тому

      5000 years of caste system 😂😂

  • @onegoodthought12-vk4bh
    @onegoodthought12-vk4bh 2 місяці тому +2

    One of the best podcast hosts. Although I subscribe to liberalism and secularism, which are opposed to the views promoted throughout the discussion, I acknowledge that the host was asking genuine questions. However, I take issue with the TLP question, where they seemed to defend that right-wing fascist party.....................................
    REGARDS.............................

  • @Suleman123-f9n
    @Suleman123-f9n Місяць тому

    SIR QAISER AHMED RAJA IS DIMOND ❤

  • @ibrahimrashied9707
    @ibrahimrashied9707 2 місяці тому

    I believe if pakistan wants to succeed ahead its needs to become secular otherwise no hope.but it has to be by democratic means only. As for an islamic state if people chose that then it should be a truly islamic state which is frankly no country on earth. Islam is fundamentally against capitalism and all forms of capitalism should be halted. Islam has made it compulsory to g8ve zakat which we as acountry do not enforce. And zakat by its very nature is socialisim. Islam believe in taxing un realized gains as in on the worth of a buissness or assets or company rather than on profits or income only. This very notion is anti capitalist. As of now we cherry picked laws that we deem to be islamic to subjugate the masses while our whole government structure is anti islamic. Even our criminal code is un islamic. In islam only fir adultary is there capital punishment. For all other sins you are either give lesser sentence but for that the burden proof is huge and large ammounts of cases wont stand for trial. Or the offenses can be forgiven entirely if the person ask for forgiveness. And one other principle we seem to neglect of islam is the principle of privacy which is is stated in islam as being fundamental. Yet our state spys on its citizens to catch what we are doing on-line. Even registration of vpn would go against it this principle.

  • @amjadfiaz4830
    @amjadfiaz4830 Місяць тому

    Kabi dr mubarik ali professor ishtiaq or salman rasheed sb ko b bulay tnks

  • @YaseenPatel-o1d
    @YaseenPatel-o1d 2 місяці тому

    Islamic identity
    Thats why it waa created

  • @sha587
    @sha587 2 місяці тому +1

    So many pajeets in the comment section.

  • @AdnanKhan-bw9yf
    @AdnanKhan-bw9yf 2 місяці тому +1

    Qaiser sey mera bohat hadd tak ikhtilaaf hai,
    Per Secularism per qatann yaqeen nahien rakhta.

    • @csbarolaca1
      @csbarolaca1 2 місяці тому

      USE AI TO ENHANCE FREEDOM OF SPEECH - RIGHT TO OFFEND - ISLAM CANNOT NOW STOP FREEDOM OF SPEECH: ua-cam.com/video/AWN0R5xFA3g/v-deo.html

    • @Hitchens-k9s
      @Hitchens-k9s 2 місяці тому

      44 million mslms livin on chaa..rrity of Europeans will prefr secularism,liberalism,democracy 😂😂😂..only unedu Mslms livin in mslm contrys want Afghanistan style sharia 😂😂😂

    • @jacksparow25
      @jacksparow25 2 місяці тому

      Tu kon hai jo unsay ikhtalaf rakhein
      Who knows you?😂😂😂

    • @AdnanKhan-bw9yf
      @AdnanKhan-bw9yf 2 місяці тому

      @ Mein Ghamidi Sahib ka perokaar hoon,,, jis kay saamney baithey ki sakat bhi nahien hai aap kay iss so called Radical Islamist Raja Sahib mein…
      Jis ki wajah sey poorey Pakistan mein khoon ki Nadiyaan beh rahi hai, sirf iss ki mazhabi soch ki wajah sey.
      Ab shabash gumraahi ka fatwah laga do shabash beta…

    • @AdnanKhan-bw9yf
      @AdnanKhan-bw9yf 2 місяці тому

      @ Baqi tu aur tery Rajay kay haath na tou Kashmir aaney wala hai aur na hi Palestine…
      Democracy ko maantey hain aur osi kay liye jiddojehed karein gey baaqi terey Raja kay har os Talibani soch ko Aalmi taaqaton kay saath mil kar chakma detey rahein gey.
      Waisey aap logon ka woh Kabul kis muqaam ko pohonch gaya hai,,, suna hai 50 lac Pakistani job dhoondney wahan chaley gaye??? Hahahahahahahahahahaahahahahahahahaha

  • @anilsingh-zo8jr
    @anilsingh-zo8jr 2 місяці тому +4

    Musalim aour secularism lm possibly

  • @mr___swag925
    @mr___swag925 2 місяці тому +1

    Kyuki tum Kashmir ke bareme jhutt propaganda karteho tum jo bola te ho o reality nehi hotahe ess lia tumari batt koe nehi sunutahe😂😅😂