Mary Poppins - What's the Difference?
Вставка
- Опубліковано 12 гру 2018
- With Mary Poppins Return-ing to theaters, this time with Emily Blunt taking the lead (and with a little help from Lin-Manuel Miranda), it's time to look back at the original Disney classic starring Julie Andrews and Dick Van Dyke, as well as PL Travers' iconic character and ask, what's the difference?
Follow us Twitter: / cinefixnetwork
And we're on the Facebook: / cinefixnetwork
More Recent CineFix Videos:
7 Things You (Probably) Didn't Know About Elf
• 7 Things You (Probably...
Starship Troopers - What's the Difference?
• Starship Troopers - Wh...
The 5 Most Idiosyncratic Directors
• The 5 Most Idiosyncrat...
How an Opening Scene Tells the Whole Story
• How an Opening Scene T...
Even MORE Brilliant Moments in Film
• Even MORE Brilliant Mo...
Bram Stoker's Dracula - What's the Difference?
• Bram Stoker's Dracula ... - Фільми й анімація
It's Dick Van Dyke's birthday today so this is very fitting
_Van_
@@Life-Row-Toll bloody autocorrect, thanks for spotting that
@@ashleightompkins3200 Yeah, it's the worst! AND IT'S ALMOST 2019 RIGHT, AUTOCORRECT ISN'T SO AUTO hehe
@@Life-Row-Toll It isn't so correct either
@@ashleightompkins3200 lol best to say you are correct and I'm very much wondering the internet manually. Never mind me. Haha
the book mary sounds more like nanny mcfee
They are quite a lot like Nanny McPhee, yes. I loved both the Mary Poppins books as a child, and the original book that Nanny McPhee was based on (Nurse Matilda).
For me I prefer the movie
marcela zimmerle EXACTLY! Not this lovey dovey sugar coated thing. Even though it’s nothing like the books I love it
@All Things Safeya. Well, I think Mary Poppins actually not good nanny. I read books.
Actually Yondu has a lot in common with Mary Poppins. They both baby sat a kid for a father who wasn't there, went on adventures together and gave them tough love before leaving their lives forever...
If Saving Mr Banks has taught me anything, it's that A Lot is Different
Bryce McKenzie mostly that the author hated the movie
Like stealing title ideas from Steven Spielberg and make them sound worse than Vin Diesel's Groot voice.
Hopefully it didn't teach you much, since that movie was basically a Disnified movie about he Disnification process and, well, not particularly accurate.
Yes, they even if they lied and said the author liked the movie at the end, when in reality she hated it. But anyway, I was happy Disney placed Walt as a "villain" sort of speak as an apology... And now they spit a bit more on the source material...
@@MrPOKER725 She actually did come to like the film, but not immediately. She stated in 1977, "I've seen it once or twice, and I've learned to live with it. It's glamorous and it's a good film on its own level, but I don't think it is very like my books."
"SupercalifragelisticexpiWhatsTheDifference?"-
Lol (You have no idea how much I loved that)
Julie Andrews back then was smokin lol
Now she plays a beautiful and powerful sea beast in Aquaman who can tear apart anybody.
Agreed highly. She was hot like flame.
Thinking of the story where Jane's actress said she caught Julie Andrew smoking between takes, while still dressed as Mary Poppins.
She is the reason why Mary Poppins is magical in live action. There's a certain beauty, grace and charisma about Julie Andrews in whatever role she plays.
I'm glad I'm not the only one who thinks Julie Andrews is beautiful. She is the quintessential "girl next door" that can fly my kite any day!!!😁😁😁
All my favourite channels are uploading Mary Poppins related stuff and I love it! Such a wonderful movie.
"... two-hour movie." I THOUGHT I remembered the movie being really long.
I'm reading the Mary Poppins books for the first time ever right now, and what you mention about how they are just small vignettes has been the biggest surprise. As somebody who grew up watching the movie a lot, it feels like I'm reading a "greatest hits" list without any connective tissue. I'm sure at the time they were beloved because of the way magic is woven throughout, but as an adult reader I just want a narrative to sink my teeth into. So, for once, I think I prefer the film version because of that small change.
Well the books were designed to be children’s books, with individual stories and lessons. It’s the same problem the Hobbit had
@@biteme9486 Yes, children's books will often have the same problem. I guess I just prefer stuff like Wizard of Oz or Alice in Wonderland where there is still a story happening. And I disagree about The Hobbit. The Hobbit also has a story and is not just a bunch of individual stories that have no connective tissue.
That’s absolutely not why
Well according to saving Mr Banks P l Travers hated the movie
same with me
I regret not reading them as a child
seems they have been re relaesed thanks to the movie "saving mr banks"
same with narnia and oz books
and even harry potter
it takes a movie for a book to be known internationally
I’m now thinking Mary Poppins takes place in the same universe as Harry Potter
Alot of people think Mary is a witch
Did Mary learn sorcery at Hogwarths?
Yes, Mary Poppins is a witch. Established in the 60s. Instead of suing each other the teams behind the different supernatural characters of the time got together with the idea that common threads provided continuity. Is Harry Potter in the same universe as Mary Poppins, Samantha, Hagatha, Enchantra, Jeannie, and Phoebe Figalilly? Probably.
Mary probably went to Hagatha's "where all the really chic" went.
Some people think Mary is either a witch or a timelord from Dr. Who
Is Nanny McPhee related to Mary Poppins? They almost do the same thing.
My headcanon is that theres magical nannies everywhere, and they have different methods of teaching morals.
@@Jill4ChrisRedfeild Yes, and Pennywise the Clown is one of them.
You guys are the amazing!!!!!!!!!! Keep the amazing work up!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Please some do some top ten videos for:
1) Cameos
2) Comic Relief Characters
3) Fourth Wall Breaks
4) Franchises
5) Musicals
As a film student I just want to say, I love your videos 💖
Obvious fan theory: Mary Poppins is a Time Lord.
@WesleyB1994 Well she and the rest of the Poppins Flying Corps did fight Voldemort and his evil minions during the opening ceremony for the 2012 olympics.
No. Her body merely absorbed alien bloody, which enables her to _LIVE, DIE, REPEAT_
Can she kill Thanos or Dormammu the dark magic being?
She actually is she regenerate into a much younger person. Which is wierd actually.
Actually, it's made clear in the books that all babies are magical. Mary Poppins is just one of the rare ones that never grew out of it.
Never stop doing this series, it is genuinely fantastic! Y'all have such a fantastic chemistry and the scripts are wonderful not to mention the editing! I could go on, but my point is this series is a ray of creative joy in the youtube landscape. Never stop doing what you do best because you're fantastic at it.
I swear your mothers didn't pay me to write this.
I spent 8 years in the navy before ships were co-ed. To say there was a fair amount of machismo amongst the crew would be an understatement. We used to play movies on the mess decks after the evening meals for the recreation of the crew; you must remember this was before _Blockbuster_ and other video rental stores had hit their height~ People were not used to having movies at their fingertips. So playing a film, projected up onto a screen was still kind of a big deal.
We had several projectors on board, and it was common that someone would borrow a projector and a film that wasn't being shown on the mess decks, and run the movie privately in a work space or an office that had a large enough flat place on the wall to project upon.
We had a _Family Day_ where all the ship's crew were allowed to invite kids, mom's, dad's, wives, etc to the ship for an extra special meal and a movie.
We showed _Mary Poppins_ for the kids. It was the only time _Mary Poppins_ got shown in the general mess, but my pal who ran the film library for the ship told me they had had the film aboard for just over a month. There was a waiting list for the film and a projector. Everyone wanted to watch the movie, but nobody wanted to be _seen_ watching the movie... LMAO!
Yes, I borrowed the film one night and played it in the line-locker with one other guy watching with...
They assigned me the book for a children literature for next semester so this is pretty helpful 😄
I'd love to see a What's the difference - Trainspotting. "Choose Trainspotting!"
You know Mary Poppins and Bert were DTF buddies...
I never thought Mrs. Banks was ditzy! I've always seen her as the smarter of the two Banks parents who indulges her narrow minded husband by letting him THINK he's in charge and smarter than her because his narrow little mind would explode if he even tried to contemplate the truth: Women are just as capable as men. Which bring us to Mrs. B's song, "Sister Suffragette," a song that never fails to get me choked up.
Well, she wasn't listening to Katie Nanna when she was singing her suffragette song. If she's not being ditzy, what would you call it?
Had no idea that they paid homage to characters from the book during the first seen.
Epic Rap Battles of History!
Mary Poppins vs. Nanny McPhee
Wow!
The animation for this video is great 👏👍
Yondu: I am mary poppins y'all.
Okey I did what I came to do.
Please for Easter this year or Passover, do a What’s the Difference episode on The Ten Commandments.
Tarzan of the Apes vs Disney's Tarzan, if thou wilt.
Yeah the original stories of Mary Poppins specifically the magical world behind setting feels like ancient magus’ bride setting. Which I do enjoy
You know that theory Mary Poppins is probably part of the Wizarding World? Well...
What’s the Difference? How to Train your Dragon
Answer: fucken everything
Thanks, enjoyable as always :-)
If love the tripple-features, how about a "What's the difference?" for "The Pledge (Author Dürrematt)", "It Happened in Broad Daylight (1958)", "The Pledge (2001)",
I have been reading The Firm by John Grisham
, and that would be a good one for What's The Difference
I'd add that the wind that blows Mary Poppins in in the book to the Banks' house seemed beyond her control. In the movie she seems to want to show up, to want to help, but in the book it reads more like a mission given to her and one she maybe doesn't even want. And she isn't waiting for the wind to change as a metaphor, but because she literally can't leave until it does. And the second it does, she's outta there! And Mrs. Corrie is way past "centuries" old. She's downright ancient. Easily thousands of years, tens of thousands maybe. Also, she literally breaks off her fingers and hands them out as candy and each tastes different and even she isn't sure what each flavor will be. It's way weirder than anything in the movie.
Very nice.
I've got one for reccomendation. What's the Difference? - City of Ember. The movie wasn't great and I still need to read the books, but it seems like an interesting one.
So this may seem a little obscure to do an episode on, but an episode covering the differences between the movie/show Shooter vs Point of Impact (the source material) would be really cool, maybe?
Mary Poppins was my first movie in a cinema :)
Would recommend saving mr bank.
The bird lady makes me cry a little
do watership down next
This new movie was amazing
I would love to see a whats the difference on The Departed and The Infernal Affairs Trilogy
Nice
Big trouble in little china Pork Chop express tune when he is talking about the star on the cow's horn! 4:21
Can you make a what's the difference video for Mary Poppins returns & hellboy Golden army.
Please put these in the third most iconic lines video. Because I feel that you missed a lot of really iconic lines. Some of these are my own very personal choices and you don't need to feel inclined to choose them all. Just throwing out examples is all I'm doing. DON'T STOP BEING AMAZING!!!!
1) "I feel like I'm talking cray pills!!!
2) "YOU. ARE. A. TOOOOOYYYY!!!!!!"
3) "You wanna know how I got these scars?"
4) "Let it go"-Frozen
5) "This is Berk."
6) "Do you want to build a snowman?"
7) "It's not easy being green."
8) "The cold never bothered me anyway!"
9) "This is my house and I have to defend it!"
10) "Hakuna matata."
11) "Supercalifragilisticexpialidocious!"
12) "Use the force Luke."
13) "It's 106 miles to Chicago we got a full tank of gas, half a pack of cigarettes, it`s dark...and we`re wearing sunglasses. Let's go!"
14) "NNAAAZZZIIVVAAANYYYAAAAAAAA!!!!!!!!" (The Lion King)
15) "Come with me if you want to live!"
16) "Bippity boppity boo."
17) "One ring to rule them all."
18) "Let my people go!!!"
19) "Don't cross the steams!"
20) "Live long and prosper."
21) "Shoot her!!!"
22) "Chewy, we're home."
23) "WWIILLLSSSOOOOONNNNNN!!!!"
24) "Bueller...Bueller...Bueller."
25) "I'll get you my pretty, and your little dog too!"
26) "I'm gonna steal the Declaration of Independence."
27) "WHERE IS MY SUPER SUIT?!?!?!"
You should do a What's The Difference with the Conan movies.
Please, do comparisons of "The Giver" (Lois Lowry), "Jack Reacher" (One Shot), "Jack Reacher: Never Go Back" - both by Lee Child, "The Fifth Wave" (Rick Yancey), "Intensity", "The Watchers" (Dean Koontz), "Intensity" (also Dean Koontz), "Village of the Damned" (John Wyndham's "The Midwich Cuckoos"), "A Monster Calling"), "The Thief Lord" (Cornelia Funke).
Which version of Mary Poppins would YOU bang?
A.) Julie Andrews
B.) Yondu
Yondu
C.) Princess Leia in The Last Jedi
No homo but it’s not a competition in the slightest 🅱️
Can’t it be both?
A
Oh Yea Im Jerry Poopens ya all! Here take a piece of this sugar paper under your tongue and lets go on a magical ride.
Now the i know the difference between the books and the movie, makes me love and adore more the orignal version, the new one is good but it lacks more passion.
0:50 - Okay, did the voice just change pitch or am I having a stroke?
It’s a different person
In the book, Mary Poppins was based on Pamela Travers/Helen Goff's Aunt who failed to save Helen's dying father, on whom George Banks was based
It made me want to read those weird books
You should do Misery next
you guys should do Stephen King books vs movie's!!
The other leg's Name is Jones of course.
I absolutely adore the book. The film, it so much actually.
Do a What's the Difference on The Hunchback of Notre Dame (Disney Version Vs Novel)
Please do a list of the best movies of the year, I really want to hear your opinion.
when you hit 5 millon subs you should make a fullmovie
This is a series done right.
You should compare all of the books and all the movies.
Next do what's the difference for the Jungle book, Watership down, Forest Gump, and the Life of Pi please?
Top 10 Movie deaths or
Top 10 sidekicks please.
Please do Bambi: Whats the Difference.
I’d forgotten a lot about the book, i remember when I first watched the movie I thought it was quite different though
Do a video of (SAVING MR. BANKS(-2013)
Hey cinefix. Please do a what's the difference on metro 2033. PLEASE.
Metro 2033 was adapted onto a game, not a movie. Nonetheless, I'm a fan of both and even hope there's a movie made that's good.
I wonder if Mary Poppins was the inspiration for Nanny McPhee. :)
You guys should do Ender's Game.
can you do the difference between the exorcist and the novel
Can yo dough Frankenstein next?
yes can i
First cinemasins now cinefix.
Just wait for Honest Trailers and How It Should Have Ended if they haven't done it previously.
@@BioniclesaurKing4t2 I can say about HISHE but looking for Honest Trailer and Mary Poppins doesn't show up so hope they do one
Gotta pimp the Google analytics.
Plot twist, Yondu shows up in Mary Poppins returns carrying Julie Andrews
Can you do the godzilla kimg of the Monsters trailer?
Do The Road - What's the Difference
wow I love the movie but these books sound amazing I daresay they sound more magical than even the Harry Potter books
Are you going to compare Mary Poppins Returns to the book? Because I doubt there are any real similarities, but I want a big UA-camr going over all the cool scenarios they COULD’VE used instead of just retracing old steps.
Blast, I was hoping this was going to be a comparison of the two movies...
You ought to do Holes
Can you please do a book vs movie on Rise of the Guardians
can you guys do the difference between THE LAST TEMPTATION OF CHRIST and the novel of the same name. maybe even a three way between the book movie and gospel would be crazy
How about Nurse Matilda and Nanny McPhee? That's another magical nanny .
So the books are Harry Potter meets Nanny McFee?
I’m frustrated at how unlikely it is that Michael Rooker will cameo in the new Mary Poppins movie
The sequel to Mary Poppins is closer to the book than the original
And Disney continues to spit on P.L. Travelers with the new movie. :P XD
Hi can you make the miles Morales spider man costume with the jackets and shorts for a dyi vid??
The movie is different from the books you say? I'm shocked!
In the book, Mary is there to save the father
Watership down should be the next what's the difference
Do The Terror
Pretty much all of Disney's adaptations, different as they are from the books, are unique and good enough to stand on their own apart from their sources - in a couple of cases, like Pinocchio, I'd even argue the movie is superior to the book. In fact, the only Disney movie where I'll say the book was better is The Black Cauldron. That's one case where the book is DEFINITELY better than the Disney version.
Top 10 Film Noirs!!!
Do drive 2011 and the book
Is it just me, or is the guy who plays Mr. Banks the same guy who plays Major Hochstetter in Hogan's Heroes? They look the same.
Apparently Howard Caine played Hochstetter (I've never seen Hogan's Heroes, so I didn't know). Mr. Banks is played by David Tomlinson, whom I love. 😊
@@dragonheart8706 sorry, nobody cares if you love him. You didn't need to see that
what about the musical play?
Sometimes I wonder how many people heard of Mary Poppins for the very first time on GOTG 2.
And do what's the difference Saving Mr. Banks and P.L. Travers' biography!!!!! Please?
Do the jungle book
Is not "Bedknobs and Broomsticks" not part of the original storyline?