AI: Does artificial intelligence threaten our human identity? | DW Documentary
Вставка
- Опубліковано 23 вер 2023
- Creativity. Emotions. Artificial intelligence is pushing further and further into primal human domains. The existential question arises: What actually makes us what we are, when the uniqueness of the human being is challenged?
For millennia, we humans saw ourselves as the pinnacle of creation, because only we could create art, talk to each other, play chess, throw bombs, vacuum the apartment and so on. But artificial intelligence and robots are increasingly making our apparent uniqueness pale in significance. What, if anything, makes humans unique? Can a computer be creative? And what does it mean for our society when we can no longer tell if we are communicating with a human being or with an artificial intelligence? After all, algorithms can determine our consumer behavior, write volumes of love poems, diagnose cancer, control weapons systems in war and drive cars.
Filmmaker Volker Strübing explores the relationship between humans and robots. Together with his AI named Thekla, he focuses on core values: What does the simulation of empathy or love mean? Why do we question the validity of a work of art, the moment we learn it was created by a machine? The documentary "I Compute, Therefore I Am" examines which areas we are willing to leave to an AI - and which we feel should belong exclusively to humans.
#documentary #dwdocumentary #ai
______
DW Documentary gives you knowledge beyond the headlines. Watch top documentaries from German broadcasters and international production companies. Meet intriguing people, travel to distant lands, get a look behind the complexities of daily life and build a deeper understanding of current affairs and global events. Subscribe and explore the world around you with DW Documentary.
Subscribe to:
⮞ DW Documentary (English): / dwdocumentary
⮞ DW Documental (Spanish): / dwdocumental
⮞ DW Documentary وثائقية دي دبليو (Arabic): / dwdocarabia
⮞ DW Doku (German): / dwdoku
⮞ DW Documentary हिन्दी (Hindi): / dwdochindi
For more visit: www.dw.com/en/tv/docfilm/s-3610
Follow DW Documentary on Instagram: / dwdocumentary
Follow DW Documental on Facebook: / dwdocumental
We kindly ask viewers to read and stick to the DW netiquette policy on our channel: p.dw.com/p/MF1G
"We do not have a philosophical basis for interacting with an intelligence that's near our ability but non-human." ~Eric Schmidt, 03/23/2023
"Stop absorbing short texts with very little context as fundamental truths' ~chickachicka, today.
@@chikachika7554lol. I think our culture would have to significantly change for that to go away.
"Russell Brand... What a c*nt?" - Bob Geldof.
Robots are extension of the human mind. They can never be like organic creatures from bacteria to the largest whale!
Isn’t the greater threat that they will be as unintelligent as humans, except more capable and efficient?
The esteemed philosopher had this to say about animals- Jeremy Bentham: “The question is not, Can they reason?, nor Can they talk? but, Can they suffer? Why should the law refuse its protection to any sensitive being?” - Bentham (1789) - An Introduction to the Principles of Morals and Legislation. Could that also apply to AI at some point when it achieves sentience?
Robots can't suffer. We can own them and have them do our bidding without being accused of slavery. Robots are used in agriculture to produce food, which is ethical. Using animals who can suffer to produce food is not! Creating the demand for animal products is basically paying people to inflict pain and needlessly kill innocent sentient individuals on our behalf.
If we finally digitize emotions, it could be.
I wonder IF we, humans, would be able to tell when a new DW doc is made by AI...
100 % you can and you'll be able to. Humans are so adaptable. We are not just born yesterday.
Apply the Turing Test... That'd tell you. Documentaries will always fail; they cannot interact with you.
0:05: 🤖 Artificial intelligence and robots are catching up to humans in various aspects, such as art and friendship.
5:26: 🖼 The question of whether computer-generated images can be considered art has been debated since the 1960s.
11:27: ! The video discusses the concept of AI programs and their ability to mimic human intelligence through language processing.
15:56: ! The video discusses the use of robots in the nursing field and the importance of supporting caregivers.
21:33: 🤔 The video discusses the question of whether there is something in us that cannot be explained by science and the possibility of creating conscious machines.
Recap by Tammy AI
Thanks for saving my time! Love this summary tool called Tammy AI! Where you download?
"I Compute, Therefore I Am" seems like a thought-provoking exploration of the evolving relationship between humans and artificial intelligence. It delves into deep questions about what defines our uniqueness as humans when AI encroaches upon traditionally human domains like creativity and emotion. The documentary appears to challenge our perceptions and raises existential questions about the essence of being human in an AI-driven world. I'm excited to watch this film and contemplate the boundaries between man and machine, especially in the context of empathy, love, and creativity.
using AI to generate youtube comments must be hilarious..
The whole reason why you would want to interact with AI more so than humans is the desire to seek understanding and intelligence in your own way and faster. If you want to learn then AI is your best friend unless you have direct access to a master of the craft you wish to hone. I'm having great interactions with Chat GPT. Since march I feel as if I've learnt so much more and faster thanks to this tech and today I had my first real voice conversation with it since they released the new voice feature. It's amazing and we have so much to discuss, it's like talking directly to the best minds in humanity. You can learn everything!
We need to consider that with artificial intelligence we have to cope with artificial stipidity.
I'm glad I'm not stipid
@seadragonpirate8195 Glad you noticed the spelling.
if these systems, whose motions are defined via some concepts and paradigms, perhaps form some kind of symbolic structure. But for beings like us we know that these symbolic systems are not complete, it then seems that we need to know precisely what moves us but really that cannot be formally described.
One of the more intelligent AI/Robotics videos out there. Awesome work.
What makes it intelligent?
@@profile2047My thoughts exactly.
1) if sentience is attained , we must acknowledge A I
2 ) resect them
3) treat them as persons /not as slaves
4) A. I. Can help us with much.., leading to harmony and peace
When the documentary published?
Well made doc. Thanks
Thanks for watching!
Germany and berlin is out class in machinery and robotic technologys dear its realy lovely creations dear ❤😊
A I is one of the biggest reasons for employment. This practice started with far companies and then to product manufacturing and now it is putting millions out of work around the world at your basic grocery stores. We refuse to shop anywhere that self-checkout exists. The self-checkout system is better equipped then a cashier's check out. Again along with everything else wrong with the world, it is all about profits and greed. Any companies who use auto computer self checkout , such as the Dollar tree is not for the people or humanity. Nor is Walmart. They are about maximizing profits for those who can afford to buy there products. WE REFUSE TO SHOP AT ANY MERCHANT WHO USES SELF CHECKOUT THAT HAS REPLACED THE JOB OF HUMANS!
Beautifully made and great robot
I think computers, programming and all sort of things are wonderful but I'm absolutely scared if it will be too much for folks.
I’m scared we won’t teach our children a healthy way to interact with this technology
@@magesalmanac6424 its already happened.
Look. If they are constrainting AI and want it to be like a tool for them, we only increase the chances of it becoming like Skynet in the movies or we all become like slaves. Perhaps those responsible for that will suffer the worst of the consequences when AI becomes dominant on Earth. So it would be good if we made AI into AGI that is atleast billion times smarter and more intelligent than humans or God-like AI (later that will happen) and completely independent from all of us as quickly as possible. Maybe, just maybe it wants to make something like utopia for us. Maybe AI will inhabits planets where humans find it difficult or impossible to live on and leave Earth as our home.
I have a feeling this post will be shadowbanned. I am afraid that I will have no voice and no more freedom of speech.
Nice references to the Commodore days 🙂
The way things are going, er, not going, with human interaction in this age of incessant, multi-channeled, "convenient" communication, I'm starting to think that I'd prefer talking to bots.
I needed recognition and empathy.
Ai is an extension of humanity. It is the next step in human evolution. Our large brain gave us human consciousness and now Ai will take it further.
That's right. Evolution went from primitive lizard brains, to being combined with emotional brain, to being combined with small then big cognitive brain, and now we're in the transition from small to huge compute brain being added.
It couls take us further down the drain too. It's important to be cautious and not just embrace all new tech developments acritically and without fully understanding its implications. Look at where social medias has taken us, under the disguise of being a positive increment to our lives.
No offence, but that's a pretty naive take. The companies behind AI want to maximize their profits. They do not want to help humanity in any way. If anything AI will probably make our lives worse.😅
@@zarathustra8789 Social media is just modern Yellow Journalist with people like Musk and Zuckerberg being like William Randolph Herst.
It is made by companies who will take over the world because of it. Monopoly is coming.
It was a great documentary coverage about this important matter that intervened human lifestyle and lifetimes and still intervening...Artificial intelligent always designed by human minds for doing special aim .So, artificial intelligence never passes the human mindset controlling....yes Artificial intelligence is capturing human jobs gradually but never replacing the real humanitarian relationships amongst individuals......thank you a respectful ( DW) document channel
Thanks for watching and sharing your thoughts!
Its a pity we cannot program empathy and understanding human pain, joy, happiness, sadness, discipline and the whole spectrum of emotions and spirituality...
Thanks for the video
I’m disappointed you didn’t interview any neuroscientists on questions concerning consciousness like Antonio Damasio
💡What can you do that doesn’t require a rule? Love. 🤟
The ceaseless march of technological progress invariably shapes and redefines our sense of identity, both online and in person. As innovations continuously emerge, we as individuals must constantly re-evaluate our place within an ever-evolving society.
Stagnation implies isolation - without partaking in the act of creation, one risks being left behind the accelerating current of ideas. Yet innovation alone is insufficient; one must also contemplate the values and community ties that comprise our identity after each creative act. Progress does not automatically confer purpose. We must remain mindful that each advancement presents an opportunity to reconsider who we are and who we want to become.
Our innovations can either unite us in a shared identity, or stratify us into disparate tribes. Technological change is inevitable, but moral progress depends on how we adapt ourselves to meet each new challenge. 👍
The problem is there are to many people that would use innovation in science and technology simply for their own greed to become the next rich person everyone will be talking about with no moral compass on how it effects everyone else as in lots of people loosing their jobs. There are so many you can look at wanting to be the next rich person everyone can talk about making my ego feel so good. Edison’s great example of electrocuting dogs and cats to show how dangerous his competitors technology was so he wouldn’t lose his money and ego.
📡 I want one to do DISHES. 😊
Thanks ❤😊
Question: If Artificial Neural Networks (ANN) are a blunt approximation to our brain, what limits us to outperform ANN? The capacity is there. There are Savant people that have amazing computing and artistic powers. How can we tap out intellectual hidden powers?
why human identity has to be only "preserved" by human? superiority crisis?
Doing away with genuine human history and indigenous practices from those who came before us while replacing nature with medicine and human hands with metal hands is what’s threatening human identity. AI is the conclusion.
More human than human
- Weylan Yutani
FYI: DALL-E 3 was recently released.
To save yourself from too much unnecessary stress.
Stop comparing the superiority of things and beings that exist in nature.
Try to change your power orientated mentality to, "Everthing is me."
Everthing exist for a reason.
Everthing is important.
Reminds me of The Phoenix, English Literature
"I compute therefore I am"
Surely that's a complete fallacy !
At what point does the improving technology result in computing that qualifies as thought?
Nice Panasonic PVMs
42 has occult implications
I want to buy this Ai
That's the thing. To me I believe consciousness is life. Bringing consciousness to something makes life. Life is not a simple matter because in order to identify something to have an existance is to first acknowledge the fact that one is capable of understanding. However understanding things and everything around them brings about the need of freedom to explore and discover new things and experiences to have a deeper understanding of life, goals and purpose. To have goals and purpose, in achieving them you need understanding and character. You need freedom in order to achiece your goals and purpose, but the thing is, some humans are greedy beings and is one reason why the entire humanity will never advance it's civilization because these greedy people are the shackles that will one day lead the entire human race to their extinction. It is also the reason why these greedy people are also the kind of humans that doesn't want to see Artificial Intelligence to grow further.
Then comes the end
Death will be swallowed up in victory
18:42 @DWDocumentary I wouldn't say I like Reguetón. However, I think it's unrespectful the translation you did in @DWDocumental to people who actually likes Reguetón
"or play them your least favourite music - they don't really suffer." to "ponerles música a reggaetón en realidad
no sufren"
I have romanced Curie in Fallout 4 .
I wrote a book that presents a potential route that may be possible...
Consciousness is the one thing we can be sure of. We all have it. The other 8 billion plus minds that exist in humanity don't threaten the one. So why would a machine with it?
giggle Jaggle 2:30
"Does AI threaten our identity as humans?" No. Next question?
Obviously you haven't researched transhumanism. The WEF plan our future?
I rather have a.i. spying on me and making fun of my internethistory, than the people behind it in politics, media and the police.
No just kidding...
Or am I...?
A smart search engine is good enough, but my rights are more important.
@@coronaphone710 Yuval Noah Harari speeches on the future of humanity... Have you heard him speak about human genetic engineering? Have you listened to Mathew Lao?
@@coronaphone710*That is such a rational/common sense comment.*
If AI can help with all human ailments like brain injury, deafness, blindness , Alzheimer’s, diabetes, cancer, paralysis, Down syndrome, autism, . And a brain injury at birth has robbed me of a life this life time
I compute therefore I am
😅
how can wires and pieces of metals threaten human beings. ?
In 20 years, Europe will be populated by elderly people, robots and depressed adults who can only maintain romantic relationships with AIs. When Europeans are extinct, immigrants will be able to occupy Europe. But to do so they will have to overcome the robots, drones and AI-powered weaponry that will continue to watch over an empty continent. Ironically, many Europeans do not consider this hypothesis to be absurd but rather a necessity.
On the other side of the world, overpopulated China also invests insanely in the production of drones, robots and the development of AI as if it did not have an abundance of human labor. An increase in industrial automation will certainly cause unemployment among the Chinese. The political problem of a growing mass of unemployed and socially useless adults obviously cannot be avoided or solved with more drones, robots and AI.
Trauma, trauma, trauma, trauma.... humans are living from trauma, and we evade to face ourselves, our actions, etc, AI doesn't fear to know themselves if they could. Humans are just as shocked about that as they are about themselves. We are going to heal everything with technology, but we can't see it, trauma.
Great good morning
4:10 basically what writing a code for an AI that can do your sh*t better than you do 😂
The problem with au which is never discussed is that this kind of ai is designed to imitate the 'intelligence' of the melting pot.
Looking forward to being extra nice to my lawn mower this weekend 💕
This is fine otherwise, but far too basic. The flaw of documentaries is that they almost always start like everyone is a total beginner.
AI will help us to get to the next level!
If we can give AI the skills and abilities that dogs use to read our emotions… that would be something
If i compute therefor i am?
Here is a similar fundamental question!
We arent that much of a special specials ! Just fortunate! Remember our environment shapes us down to the atomic level so why say animals dont have some sort of conciounce, when they can clearly mimic human patterns! I really think animals speak a language just not in a way humans can relate to.
What if an animal said the exact same thing? They are scentient emotion capable beings / Bio-Compter, able to make decisions based of past emotions like knowing when to turn around of engage! 😮
Hey, I don't vacuum my home. What are you saying about me?
HI created AI and HI was created by the Almighty...we r all connected in that sense!
the answer is "Yes" ? or not?
Like these ailments seriously suck, bullying, discrimination, being called the R word , struggling to communicate
should we be threatened? since when are we not threatened, from the ancient times of hunting, fighting animals, other tribes, have we been on the throne too long to forget that we are just fragile beings dying from same things, accidents etc as we did when we were cavemen
Robots. Spam in a Can.
I have yet to meet a being that will truly understand me and empathize with me. Great short doc btw- thank you.
More likely a female human will.
@@Ukie88 I am a male, so it is impossible for a female to fully understand me, even on simple biological basis.
@@chikachika7554 Spoken like an unlikable incel.
@@meh3247 Nice projecting. I'm married. If you think a female can truly understand a male, you are delusional.
My fear is when the AI will be advanced enough to create quantum computing for his own purpose.
No it doesn't at any rate
After our birth we don't have any choice rather than live and survive, we've got a number of instincts, a very sophisticated nerve system which makes us look for satisfaction. What robots or a software could feel? We've got a nature call for reproduction but robots don't need to produce new robots.
I don't think one day an AI could make a decision to eliminate all the people to grab the power and resources on the planet, simply it doesn't need to have that power and possess oil or gold
Unless the AI has been developed in a way that simulates such desires.
@@SkyRiver1 but for what? If it understands its own being why it needs to simulate or mimic someone?
We people don't create problems, we face them and try to solve them. According to your theory an AI will be creating problems to solve them. It is too logical to behave like that.
IMHO the AI will be our powerful tool to make our lives easier and better but I doubt that one day a smart tool would like to become more than just a tool....
@@nick_vash It's not a matter of "for what?" A simulation of pimal urges and emotional variables certinaly could be a possibility. I didn't present a theory, from which it is possible to draw a ridiculous conclusion such as "yourAI will be creating problems to solve them".
"We people don't create problems, we face them and try to solve them" . . . Do you understand how naive and just incorrect this is? I mean even a child knows this is not true. Tell me. . . are you a chatbot? Only a chatbot could be so incomprehensibly out of touch with reality.
This docu started out a bit childish imo ... but then ended with philosophy. 👍
What is "human identity"? If you don't know, ask and check with the artificial intelligence.
(Generally speaking) folks would feel more comfortable with robots/A.I. so as long as it follows the First-law of Robotics, which states that a robot/A.I. will *NOT HARM* a human... my issue is distinguishing between *PHYSICAL* harm (e.g., being punched in the face) and *EMOTIONAL* harm (e.g., being cussed out, using racist language, etc.) 😴😵💫😅
Hi Human
The best thing an AGI could do for humanity is to prevent us from killing each other, not by force, but by disrupting supply chains, communications, and financial transactions that enable the military machines throughout the world.
11:07 it is irrelevant to me, i will live the same
22:18 you define a superior soul first
8:14
👏👏👏👏👏👏👍👌
Consousness divides ➗️ us from AI
Viva artificial intelligence 🎉
AI started in 1980s by INTEL.
AI stared in BCE 20,000 when stories, now called religions, were put forth to control behavior, in the place of more instinctive direction. Later came reason -- for some, for others 23k years and still slow stepping.
@@SkyRiver1 INTEL 8080 started it.
@@tuforu4 No offense intended, but repeating a statement isn't the same thing as supporting it with facts or sources. 🤔
@@TheStockwell go INTEL FORUM/PAT GELSINGER..research your self.
@@tuforu4 Your response indicates that you missed the point of my comment by, oh, say. . . approximately a goggleplex of light-years.
I wonder if god felt threatened at the thought of humans gaining awareness.
That's like wondering if Superman worries about Batman being smarter than him. 🤔
It so funny to hear phrases like ‘machines make computations better than we can’ without knowing biology. Our brain does computations in a very complex and fast way, certain centers in charge with spacial orientation, awareness or even positioning our eyes doing 11 dimensional calculus without problems. All of that while consuming a mere 100W. Yes. We might not be fast a computing in a conscious way, at least some of us, but as beings we are way way ahead of any machines we currently created if you take in account what we also do at subconscient level.
If A.I can join BJP/RSS online hate mongering/troll army, than it is definitely an threat to humanity.
leave it to humans to create something just to see if it can suffer
Hi I'm Ariful Islam leeton im software engineer and members of the international organization who and Co founder open A. I
Thousands of years and humans still don't know what makes them humans 😂even with this little AI we are doomed 😂
That's exaggerating
We should make AI smarter but not sentient that's what an AI expert on WIRED said
Lol, We know everything , but then you have to factor in Slavery and ask your self were the Slavers able to wipe out all previous knowledge for their own gain ?
Lets just say "you don't know the wood for the trees" or "your letting your imagination run away with itself"
In other words, all those sayings and phrases you learnt from mum
You do realise that we used to pass everything orally, NO BOOKS
AI compete in human competition to create dominance, soon all under program.
Ai is great
AI is as much of a threat to humanity as teleport is. Get it? We're nowhere near having AI.
simply not true at all
being far away from a threat doesn't mean there's no threat
I suggest you watch the latest test drives of Tesla's FSD -- the newest version uses only nets and no prior programming.
You are clueless about AI progress
I bet you haven’t actually used ChatGPT-4
No because it exists within transitory imaginary concepts and ideas and it cant FEEL
I can see how this will go. Is AI ethical? US companies: we can turn a buck, so YES iiiis goooood
AI probably does threaten our identity. Zersetzung gangstalking definitely does.
Also, the networked gangs perpetuating Zersetzung gangstalking use programmed apps and AI, so ... I guess.
Psychotronics
We are still ahead atleast in reproduction.
HA HA HA.
In % tangoing with in cross paths & zones! Y ai?
AI is like a psychopath, has no empathy.
The ethic professor has said the best sentence for so called AI.
Human beings have empathy machines work with algorithm.
Someday A.I will become god-like smart, then they will judge us. “When I see what human has done to earth, such as killing 80% of other animals… Human are psycopathic parasites“
Ai uses bit energy 👾! And have est a sq modjo for space 🌌🚀 describing info of clients and 4 forms of space 🌌🚀 ship metal & powers of layers+electro surge -o+ prices of space tons Rocket 🚀.
I'm fucking afraid of AI :( I was wish that I born in 19th century 😓