Harry Potter Theory: Why Is Peeves Allowed To Stay At Hogwarts?
Вставка
- Опубліковано 17 жов 2024
- SCB STICKERS!
store.dftba.co...
Today J dives into the wizarding world of Harry Potter to discuss Peeves the Poltergeists, Ghosts and ghouls and tries to determine where Peeves came from and why he is allowed to stay at Hogwarts.
Short Stories from Hogwarts of Power, Politics and Pesky Poltergeists:
usd.shop.potte...
Hey Super Carlin Friends! ►► bit.ly/196DDlu
Google Autofill Playlist ►► bit.ly/1DCdQNm
Theories ►► bit.ly/1z5uZcS
Super Carlin Gaming ►► bit.ly/1CRM5Bq
- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
BECOME A SUPER CARLIN FRIEND➜ / supercarlinbrothers
- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
FOLLOW US:
I N S T A G R A M➜ / jonkerlin & / scb_ben
F A C E B O O K➜ / supercarlinbrothers
G A M I N G ➜ bit.ly/1CRM5Bq
P A T R E O N ➜ / supercarlinbrothers
- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
Want to send us something?
Super Carlin Brothers
PO Box 4339
Roanoke, Virginia 24015
- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
Business Inquiries Only: carlinbrosrtp@gmail.com
- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
Every time you give us a thumbs up a Narwhal gets its horn! (maybe..)
![Why Does The Elder Wand Keep Losing? [Harry Potter Theory]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/kvYeg0Ipj8Q/mqdefault.jpg)
Who is your favorite non human character in Harry Potter??
SuperCarlinBrothers nearly headless nick
SuperCarlinBrothers dobby
The unicorn
my common answer: Dobby
dobby
Whenever someone tells me they love Harry Potter, I tell them how much I love Peeves to test whether they've read the books or just seen the films…
Seamus Gorman Ello there how ya doing
lol
Seamus Gorman I do too. It's always hilarious when they give you that confused look because they don't know who he is
I do the same thing except i say Winky
Seamus Gorman 😂
I think J.K. missed a great opportunity with Peeves. Right near the end of Deathly Hallows, where Professor McGonagall tells Filch to "Find Peeves". But then nothing happens with him, other than some minor mischief. I think it would have been so great if Peeves turned out to be some super powerful guardian of the castle, and that is why he was allowed to stay.
Archimagus agreed that would be awesome
WHY DID I NEVER THINK OF THIS
Archimagus maybe if they ever remake these films in 30 years or so they would take this into account, I hope this is the case
I would say that since Peeves was made from the mischief of the students that mischief of the students is also what keeps him there and "alive" in a sense. With that, I would say that yes Peeves would definitely become a type of guardian even if only to make sure he doesn't disappear.
Archimagus That would be AWESOME!
Peeves must have been at his strongest when the Marauders were active and then again when the Weasley twins were at Hogwarts.at the school
There's not just a couple of people "powering" him in a whole school, with such a large history.
The Weasley Twins were probably 2 of his favorite kids in all of his time in Hogwarts
*space after the period
I think a better question is why the Bloody Baron actually has control over him.
Daniel Pryde Maybe it came out of all the students fearing him from the start?
I was thinking he was somehow created by the Baron through suppressed magical abilities much in the same way an obscurial is created. But the difference being once extracted when he actually got to Hogwarts it fed and morphed off of the other students powers creating Peeves.
It's just because he's afraid of the Baron I read it somewhere and the reason why he's so afraid of him is because he was the one who killed the grey lady and killed himself RIGHT afterwards.
@@executedcode4280 Yeah, The bloody baron loved the grey lady, Helena Ravenvlaw, he asked her to be his girlfriend when she was in Albania and when he refused he got mad and killed her. He was so upset after this so he killed himself.
Shayla YT he didn’t ask for her to be his girlfriend he was asked to go and take her back to her mother aka Rowena Ravenclaw was very sick but she said no and he got mad and killed her then he was so mad at himself he killed himself aswell
Why wasn't he in the movie is the real question.
Epickitty102 He was originally, but they couldn't get through the scene without the kids laughing, after many attempts they got it right... Then ended up cutting the scenes for time
Epickitty102 he was in the first but was cut
Epickitty102 It's a good thing he wasn't in the movie though the concept art is terrifying
Epickitty102 He was at first, but he was cut. I think it was because he made the kids laugh too much at the time. Apparantly, he told his kids he played Hagrid instead XD
Epickitty102 maybe he was but you never saw him!?
If peeves has a bit of pranksters from Hogwarts, that means he has James, Sirius, Fred, George, and possibly Remus and Peter in him. No wonder Mcgonagall wants him gone
Aubrey
I’d definitely assume Remus did as much as James and Sirius. Have a feeling he did a lot of the planning.
Ah well Mcgonagall’s troubles never got over. Imagine she was relieved when the Marauders left school but then came along Fred,George,Harry,Ron and Hermione to some extent.When they left there was James ,Albus ,Lily ,Teddy and the rest .Poor Mcgonagall.😂🤣😂😂😂
Mcgonagal : finally the marauders are gone
Fred and Gorge : hi
I dont think she really ever really wanted him gone, at least not after the Orded of the Pheonix book. He also helped in the battle of Hogwarts, I think. Honestly, I'd rather fight a deatheater rather than Peeves!
Edit: havent watched the full video yet so idk
@@arandomuser9459 Yeah I totally imagine Lupin as the mom of the group being like "you guys are crazy ... But here's the best plot to do the thing sensibly you goofs" with all their wild plans lol. Acting serious on the surface but delighted enough at the creative challenge of each shenanigan to go for it anyway :)
Fred and George should both have their personal poltergeists.
Speaking of the Weasley Twins, they actually have a very good relationship with Peeves, and he somewhat respects them. During their exit from Hogwarts in the Order Of The Phoenix book, they tell him to "Give [Umbridge] hell from us, Peeves!" and not only does he bow in respect, for a while, Umbridge was the sole target of his pranks afterwards!
Heck, Umbridge was so terrible, even the McGonagall got on friendly terms with Peeves, telling him how to properly unscrew chandeliers and even gave him her walking stick to hit Umbridge with it.
Keva the Half-Kestora "Even the McGonagall"
Keva the Half-Kestora **claps**
Keva the Half-Kestora definitely,
Do a episode on infinity train
Like if you reply
I guess you could say Peeves has a lot of...
School spirit
that is what i was going to say
Pet Peeves, you are a funny one ,SherLachNess
👏👏👏👏👏
But dum tss
Ayyyeeeee
If Peeves is indeed a Manifestation of the students unruliness (and probably significant amount of angst and anxiety) then chances are good that even Dumbledore would not find a way to get rid of him. At least not permanently, he would always eventually reappear as long as there are students to power him.
But frankly, I just don't think Dumbledore would waste his time on such a trivial matter when there were intrigues to spin and dark magic to arm against. Peeves is only a nuisance in the grand scheme of things, and unlike other authority figures, Dumbledore was always smart enough not to be distracted by those sorts of things.
This actually makes him fairly unique. Dumbledore always knew to let Hogwarts be Hogwarts and remained laser-focused on the real danger. This is part of what makes him so powerful as he ends up commanding loyalties from all sectors of magic society. Dumbledore could be the most successful anarchist in literature.
Dumbledore know how to get him under control but the price is to high .
Who do you call to deal with a teen ...... THEIR MOTHER.
That makes me think that there might be different types of gheists based on other emotions.
I would think dementors might be a type of gheist. Just like him poldergheists are created from mischievousness dementors are made from despair.
you're welcome for litsening to your ted talk
Also i think Dumbledore woud Not want to get rid of Peevs because Peevs do es Not real Harm and He is a Part of Hogwarts History...
I bet Albus secretly loved Peeves
I can't shake the feeling that at least a 3rd of peeves is Fred and George
And another third is the Marauders
And not to mention the golden trio, they were super mischevious as well...
@@thathsaraamarasinghe6774 who?
@@theenthusiast304 Ron Harry and Hermione duh.
@GAYATHRI MURALI MURALEEDHARAN no it is because they are more mischievous than him so he respects them.
No wonder he likes the Weasly twins they are probably the cause of half his power! 😂😂 Edit: ps. Hedwig will always be my favorite.
They're probably only 20% of hos power. The rest is from the Marauders.
Even after all this time?
@@worldbingochampion2022 always
There's not just a couple of people "powering" him in a whole school, with such a large history.
Ben Tarr it’s a joke. Obviously the twins aren’t his only source of power.
I always wondered. HOW CAN MOANING MYRTLE FLOOD THE LAVATORY WHEN SHE'S A GHOST?
1. Her crying
2. Another way is her passing through the pipes causing the ice to expand maybe a few times. This with the backing water pressure will break the pipes and do not forget, the castle pipes are old and would not have preventative instruments on them.
Magic?
He said that ghosts can disturb elemental substances like air and water
In this video he says ghosts can effect air, fire, and WATER.
Her crying. It can disrupt the water. It's the same reason why you can create an avalanche by screaming on a snowy mountain.
Around 3:36 poltergeist activity in 3... 2... 1... *light turns off*
The picture of the turtle having strange lights on it! Creepy lol
I think the lights going off and the reflection on the Blastoise pic are connected. Pc screen goes into screensaver mode, dimming the light projected on the wall, and then the reflection is the old screensaver with a line of light that spins around... you know the one i mean.
OOOH MMY GODDD GET OUT OF THEAR BEFORE PEVES GRABS YOU BY THE EARS!!!😲😲😨😰
Look to 3:36
Peeves the Poltergeist was going to feature in the first harry potter movie. Scenes featuring him had been filmed. they were sadly cut as they didn't have the space for those scenes in the films. Peeves was to be played by the late British comedian Rik Mayall who sadly died in like 2012. This information was only released after his death. I don't know if those scenes can be found anywhere but they happened.
It was also very hard to film them because the rest of the cast couldn't stop laughing.
Favorite non-human character is probably Dobby because I mean, come on, it's freaking Dobby! But also maybe the Swedish Short-snout that Cedric fights in the Tri-Wizard Tournament because I'm Swedish and I love dragons.
Also I just read about something in the Harry Potter universe called the annual broom race that's held every year in Sweden where witches and wizards compete on brooms flying from Kopparberg to Arjeplog through a literal Dragon reservation and the trophy awarded to the winner is designed after the Swedish short-snout, and now I really want to participate just to get my hands on that trophy. This is obviously a reference to Vasaloppet, a ski race held every year in Sweden, one which my mom has aprticipated in twice and an event which I've spectated several times in the past, and I think that's just awesome.
Dobby?🤢
Serpens Lestrange wdym?
Hungarian horntail for life!!!
That sounds nice!
So...if Peeves was generated through the mischief of the Hogwarts students...does that mean that there's a small part of Fred in him?
Chloe M FRED WILL LIVE FOREVER
Chloe M honestly, he's probably created FROM Fred and George 😂
Chloe M so he was created from people like Fred George James Remus Sirius and Peter
Chloe M not crying
Chloe M fred lives on
In the lake scene in prisoner of Azkaban my favorite non-human character is seen. The fourth dementor from the left on the third from bottom row.
Hoppy's Pond yea, I liked him too, I think his name was Greg, Greg the dementor, funny guy
Xuma_Gaming Are you sure I was certain his name was Chris.
Arianna Velez They kind of look alike but i'm pretty sure it's Greg.
He's right above Greg
Arianna Velez Here I am! How's I do?
I'd say Firenze.
I have always seen him as a character who tries to be a bridge between two cultures (centaurs/humans).
If only wizards can be ghosts, and the Headless Haunt rides ghost horses... are there wizard horses?
Moriah Homminga
How does a thestral die?
Animagi maybe?
@@arandomuser9459 stab it?
Maybe the wizard died while riding the horse so it just went with him lol
Mine blown
i'd think dumbledore would see expelling peeves as an attempt to curb an essential part of hogwarts and its students, almost like abolishing a house or deforesting the forbidden forest
firudu I think Dumbledore is really irresponsible and liked seeing Peeves wreck shit.
I think Peeves is the leader of the Illuminati and is secretely controlling everyone.
i bet even if they got rid of him another poltergeist would just be generated
I would have loved to see what peeves would do to umbridge.
I like all of your answers.
Snape's thoughts on the matter:
“A five-year-old could have told us as much,” sneered Snape. “The Inferius is a corpse that has been reanimated by a Dark wizard’s spells. It is not alive, it is merely used like a puppet to do the wizard’s bidding. A ghost, as I trust that you are all aware by now, is the imprint of a departed soul left upon the earth, and of course, as Potter so wisely tells us, transparent.”
Who else can't hear 'Harry Potter' and 'Ghost' without thinking of this! :-)
Same though.
snape 4ever :P
yeah
R.I.P Alan rickman
you are gonna make me cry!!
I can because I haven't read that book yet XD
As far as I understand, Hogwarts is for the witches and wizards of the British Isles.
Ilvermorny spans the whole of North America.
Can you imagine the kind of poltergeist in Ilvermorny?
The Doctor. simply The Doctor. jesus christ
Really? The Doctor? Created in North America, of all places?
I'd rather expect a Jim Carrey.
Master Of Chaos Oh. That makes me wonder, wasn't there a Hungarian school in the competition at Goblet of Fire? I might be confused with one type of dragon being a Hungarian what's-its-face, but if there's a school in Hungary, why go all the way to Britain?
That mostly counts USA, Canada and Mexico, so I would imagine the poltergeist would probably be an obese dumb-ass (cause many North Americans are), walking around wearing football and baseball merch (like American stereotypes), with a burrito and a taco in both hands (Mexican stereotype), and yelling non-stop like an idiot, "Eh, eh, eh, sorry, eh, eh, eh, what aboot you, eh?" (Canadian stereotype).
Totally XD
Peeves adds character to the castle.
definetly
That character would be described as pranking
He does. In the book.
In the movies, he was a distraction from a purposefully more serious tone, and cutting him was correct.
In the books, they are so long and often serious, that an injection of silliness is effective.
To sum up:
Ghosts are once human entities which most likely have chosen to remain in the living world in one way or another.
Poltergeists have never been human and do not wish to kill but merely maim and injure but preferring to move items or pull certain "pranks"
Ghouls are aggressive entities that choose to attack and kill or haunt the living.
fortune_cookiy. cc I see that sneaky Dobby reference
Gummy Bear 😉
You are channeling your inner Jimmy Neutron with that hair?
kristal burns nah he's the human embodiment of pride rock
kristal burns I didn't notice that but now it's all I can see
Or Syndrome
kristal burns lol
no, hes got the adam from adam ruins everything hair
My “favorite” (most notable)non human character is Umbridge, seriously that lady is not human!
Edit-
OMG THANKS FOR ALL THE LIKES THIS IS THE MOST AMOUT IVE EVER HAD😊
Prettypants 55 favourite?
Ayden Sauvageau well..not favorite but one of the most known in my brain
Prettypants 55 I figured, It was far too purfict not to make a joke at umbrige😀
Ayden Sauvageau true!
Prettypants 55 opinions on professor trelonie? I cant spell srry
Dobby...
Or Fluffy...
Or Crookshanks...
Or the Threstals...
Or Fleur Delacour (she’s at least part Veela)
Or Kneazels...
I like Dobby... EVERYONE SAY IT WITH ME! DOBBY IS A FREE ELF! DOBBY IS A FREE ELF! DOBBY IS A FREE ELF!
@@aquapenguin9697 dobby is a free elf
@@pingatraaonIG LOUDER GOSH HECCING DARN IT
Briana GregoryHowe DOBBY IS A FREE ELF!!!
maya Ruth Muth I know, but crookshanks is only part kneazel
what would happen if you go trough the veil in the ministry of magic while you have the recurrection stone?
Would it be possible to return from there by using the stone to bring yourself back to live?
Is it important that your body is on the other side aswell?
if you go trough the veil with the stone, would it be possiblie to bring Sirius back since he actually fell with his body trough it?
Could you guys please make a video about this? Would be amazing, thanks.
Schnuller The veil is a gate. Once passed through, the spirit is severed from the soul and the body, killing the individual who passed through. Considering the veil's age, it is possible that it is just an incarnation of Earth's need to limit the numbers of humanity, I.E., Death. The question is not "If", but possibly should be "how"? We do not know how something so ancient as the veil and something as recent as the Stone would react. We do not know anything of the magics that created the veil, and is likely forgotten or lost by Witch kind by the point in time Harry Potter exists. It is entirely possible that one or the other will simply cease to function, or perhaps both will counter act one another. Perhaps, the elemental forces within each totem would work WITH eachother, maybe killing the user and placing a dead man's spirit within the recently dead corpse. There really is no way to know, unless Rowling herself makes commentary. Which, believe me, is murder waiting for it not to happen.
Schnuller The resurrection stone just lets you see your deceased loved ones. It does not make you immortal.
I'd hazard a guess that the veil and the stone are connected in some way. They both act as a sort of gateway to the other side. The veil is basically a physical portal to the spirit realm, while the stone gives you the ability to somewhat see into the spirit realm. That being said, jumping through the portal with the stone probably wouldn't do anything spectacular. You'd die, just like everybody else. Maybe if you possessed all three Hollows (especially the cloak, which allows you to "hide" from death), you'd be able to walk among the dead without killing yourself in the process. Technically, you'd be master of death (or so the Legend goes), but it's a bit of a long shot.
if you have all the hallows i believe you could bring someone back using the wand to make a body the stone to bring the soul and the veil for the rest
even if you could why would you want to?
"why it's Potty Wee Potter!
Young potter you're ugly but what can we do.
everyone says you belong in a zoo.
if you look in a mirror it surely will crack.
the best thing to do is wear a nice sack!"
*insert Peeves laugh*
26magicman26 "hahahHahahahahahaHAHAHAHhahahee"
why potter you rotter,your killing off students,you think it's great fun.LAUGHS AND ZOOMS OF DOWN THE HALLWAY.
WE DID IT WE BASHED HIM WEE POTTER IS THE ONE AND VOLDYS GONE MOLDY SO NOW LETS HAVE SOME FUN
What about... Potty lurves Loony! Potter lurves Loony! When Harry asked Luna to Slughorn's party
My favorite non human Harry Potter character is Snuffles, aka Padfoot. If that doesn't count, then it's Hedwig. And Fluffy. And Crookshanks.
I don’t think Sirius counts but Remus definitely does so I would go with him
Hedwig and Sunffles
The reason he wasn't in the movies was that kids couldn't stop laughing when they were with him. He was cast.
Incredible Imogen ahhhhhhh why haven’t I seen any deleted scenes of this that sounds amazing!!!
Incredible Imogen it was actually because Chris Columbus didn't think the character fit the theme of the film.
He was going to be played by Rick Mayall: ua-cam.com/video/S9pioZ9TQ9E/v-deo.html
Raph c-j Chris Columbus is an idiot
Ant Cannone ikr he thought he discovered America when the Norse did
Favorite non-human character in Harry Potter?
It's a coin toss between Buckbeak the hippogriff and Fawkes the phoenix.
Arttu Malin yes!
Kreacher
How can you choose one?
Fawkes for me.
The Basilisk. The power of Sltherin strikes fear into the hearts of the weak.
I can't pick between Dobby and Hedwig
Yeah . I miss BOTH of them
what about buck- i mean witherwings
The Half-Blood Princess lol
Carrie Poulter Dobby is a piece of meat. I dont see why anybody would ever like him for any reason
Gilani Rogushvili I like him
The real question for me since i first read the books is how on earth did they manage to give the mandrake potion to nearly headless nick in chamber of secrets, considering he's a ghost and can't touch stuff much less ingest it...
My personal headcanon is that they evaporated some and blew it into him or something along those lines 🤷
my favourite non human character was the Centaur Firenze who became a teacher at the school just because he broke the role he was meant to (and he wasn't really mentioned in the movie which was a shame)
Pity we don't see that in the movie
Karl Kelley Fawkes is best birb.
Karl Kelley Frank is not a Phoenix he is in fact a Thunderbird.
My favorite non human character is the sorting hat.
Ian Frew mine is Buck beak lol
+Laser Cat do you mean witherwing
Sean Tolson no the bird in the 3rd movie
Nice one xD
I always thought that since peeves is a poltergeist and therefore a manifestation of mischief at Hogwarts he couldn't leave because without the presence of the other mischief he would cease to exist.
And if you remove Peeves, would Hogwarts not run the risk of 'creating' something worse?
Claudia Province This is almost correct, but not quite. He is not the manifestation of mischief, but the manifestation of psychokinetic and emotional energy of children, or any youth, for that matter, but particularly children. If he were to leave Hogwarts he would not fade or disappear. Rather, the lack of energy may lower his status to haunting, or possibly phantom.
Leskolt Hunter Peeves want created by Hogwarts, he was created (quite unintentionally) by the staff and students. The only reason something worse could be created is if someone or something intentionally did so.
Does anyone else hope that Fred Weasley became a ghost and stayed at Hogwarts messing about with peeves
Ps my favourite non human character is Sirius black as a dog
Omg that's an amazing idea
HP books show the dead like a good thing so i hope he take his way happy
This needs to be a whole tv series about Peeves and Fred. I will watch that till the day I fie
As much as that would be amazing, and as much as I hate to be this person. I doubt Fred would choose that path. He wouldn’t be able to go on to the afterlife if he wanted to later on. (I think) So Fred would 99% choose the afterlife. He would have probably 0.01 seconds to consider. People who are scared of death, or are destined to haunt somebody (Example: Elizabeth Wareren Myrtle) , or want to do something that they couldn’t do in their lifespan, go on as a ghost. Fred wasn’t in any of those categories. And Fred probably heard a lot of ghost’s experience from the ghosts. He’d definitely chose the afterlife.
That and Hedwig
Abducting children
possessing clown dolls
knocking over glasses of milk
bringing up dead skeletons
One of these is not like the others.
answer: #2. It doesn't have any A's.
Are you saying we shouldn't cry over spilt milk? :)))
#2 is just regular clowns... trying to kill us
Mr Peanut Butter Octopus I read your comment EXACTLY when he said that
Same!
Even if one did manage to remove/destroy Peeves, I expect he'd just re-manifest from the Mischief brought into the school by new waves of students.
Kreacher, "Fight, fight for my master, the defender of the house-elves!"
When someone tells you they love Harry Potter but have only
Seen the movies "tell me do you like peeves?"
Anna Irwin
That’s my question anytime someone says they like Harry Potter. Not to mention I just love Peeves.
@@arandomuser9459 Tell me, did you mature during this year or are you still a childish book snob?
A ghost is a the spirit of someone who died unrested, a poltergeist is the spirit of someone who died angry and unfairly who inhabits a building and moves physical objects and a ghoul is basically a zombie with a brain. Why does it annoy me so much when someone can't tell the difference? I can sort of understand ghost and poltergeist, but a ghoul is a physical thing. How do you get those confused?
I think that a Poltergeist is the anger and the built up feeling of teens feeling misunderstood. This is cool to think because I mean, look at just the main characters in Harry Potter. Harry, Hermione, and Ron all feel emotionally misunderstood at some times but imagine that from all of the Hogwarts students.There are also some very cool Scary Stories about evil Poltergiest spirits.
A poltergeist doesn't have to be the anger from humans. I believe a spirit can become one if they gather enough anger.
Yes, agreed
Harry Potter fantastic beasts≠Real world myths with the same name.
ghouls are really dangerous, they can turn invisible too.
Buckbeak... I MEAN WITHERWINGS is my favorite non-human in Harry Potter
And then you get the people who don’t even know who peeves is😂
OMG READ THE BOOKS!!!!!!!!!!
The people who only watch the films...
Never heard of him
#Read all the books twice and movies twice
Peeves whas even on the psone HP games.
Dobby!!! (Snaps voice) “obviously”
ohh that's why the weaslys had a ghoul in their attic!
To save money on mothballs
TBH it's probably because Dumbledore just likes seeing Peeves wreck shit that sentimental man
Emma Ottosen lol true
How many people saw the "poltergeist activity in 1 2 3 "?
Saketh Machiraju me
Saketh Machiraju me
27 people apperently
Me but I didn't see anything happen after the count down
Saketh Machiraju omg I thought I was crazy
4:10
Muggles can come back as ghosts!
Forgotten Frank Bryce? The caretaker of riddle mansion?
(Though I agree it was on special condition, ghost is a 👻)
Frank Bryce never came back as a ghost. At the end of Goblet of Fire Dumbledore explains to Harry that the people that appeared during Priori Incantatem were not ghosts, just pale imitations. I think of them basically as images that have taken on a personality of sorts
MY favourite non-human character is definitely The Sorting Hat. It is so wise and knowledgeable! Not to mention it drops some sick beats.
I live in Wisconsin the iced tea thing is true and the sugar never dissolves to!!
Elizabeth Frohn-hengst Yes! It only dissolves in hot water. Definitely not cold or even room temperature.
I thought everyone knew sugar deosn't permanently dissolev
I grew up in the South. I live in WA state now, at a higher elevation, and there is no difference. Sugar still takes much longer to dissolve in cold water than it does hot.
the first items aren't socks? Well that seems like a missed opportunity
So true, with the iced tea, the sugar most certainly does not desolve in the cold water especially of theres ice in it. I always found that annoying.
Dobby
Elliott Woodward
SAME!!!!
Elliott Woodward Dobby is the S.H.I.T.
thank you
TEXAS NATIVE that is soooo not true
Hayler Kilpatrick Dobby is my Nigga...
I have a question: So, when Harry uses the resurrection stone in The Deathly Hallows and Sirius, Lilly, James, etc. come back to life, are they ghosts? I'm guessing not, but I just want to know.
Mellowyellow9917 not really. I think they were described as something between solid and ghost like
Because while hermione was reading the story and said about the bride coming back, Harry said 'so she was a ghost?' And they were like no the bride came back but not really ... it's hard to describe but I think they're like the memories in the penseive (i don't know hot that is spelled) so yeah that's my thought
Mellowyellow9917 They aren't ghosts. The dead brought back by the stone are not dead, they are the actual spiritual embodiment of the person past.
They're called *shadows* or *reflections*
What are you talking about? In the book it says very specifically that he drops the stone.
And no one here said he kept hold of it.
Buckbeak/Witherwings
Witherbeak? Buckwings? No one will really know...
So if a ghost decides they want to move on, can they?
Apparently not according to Headless Nick in Order of the Phoenix, he clearly regretted his decision to not "go on".
No they can not
Whoops, I have this as part of my comment, you beat me to it by months
If they find the veil? Could they use that??
@@arandomuser9459 I have no idea. I don't think the Department of Mysteries have tested that but that would be interesting. I'll look it up!
I always thought of Peeves as somebody who lived the life of an evil troublemaker and stayed as a poltergeist instead of passing on because he was afraid of what the afterlife might have in store for him.
Sure, we mostly associate Peeves with things like slapstick, and singing songs with rude words, and childish but not really harmful things like that, but we forget that he gleefully waited to watch Sirius having his soul sucked out by a dementor because he thought it would be hilarious. He was actually disappointed when Sirius escaped that fate.
I think somebody who could find that funny would have been capable of some terrible deeds in life.
Of course, none of that explains why he is a poltergeist and not a ghost, or why he is still allowed at Hogwarts. I was sort of under the impression that Dumbledore was a troll who found it amusing.
That is so true
LeakinBrolly -----Since Peeves would be the embodiment of mischievousness of all the students, that would include some pretty serious Death Eaters, Jrs. too. It is interesting that we usually do remember the inhabiting of the armor over the deadlier aspects of Peeves' humor.
LeakinBrolly what afterlife might hold for him.
Translation: HELL
A poltergeist is not the spirit of the dead. They are an embodiment of a live persons spiritual angst. They are created by a persons subconscious usually someone going through puberty. At least that is the theory of what a poltergeist is.
LeakinBrolly j
Nice timing for that light to burn out.
7:05 what is that rainbow glowy octopus thing at blastoise's leg
Turtle Warcry
Look at it at 4:16
If you really want to know...
(spoilers)
It's the reflection of a mac screensaver.
It says ghost activity
My fav:
Peeves in the books
Fawkes or Nagini in the Movies
Species-wise I'd say dragons or merpeople
Are you going to do a video on how delphi might not be voldermorts child like you referenced in your cursed child video?
can someone please explain the towel section. I've been watching the channel for ages but never knew why
Oscar James I wonder the same.
I thought he was saying toil section.
IDK either but I just role with it
Towel section because the comments are down below the video, that's where you put your towel first after being in water
_Fake Fans_... The towel section is from J's video, 42 uses for a towel.
I'm pretty sure in the goblet of fire Fleur makes a comment about Peeves, saying something like 'We don't have those at our school'. If your theory is correct could that mean that Beauxbaton is too strict or something so there is no mischief to generate a poltergeist?
Sound theory.
Nina Sullivan A poltergeist is not only generated through active mischief- any overactive emotional or psychokinetic energy is enough. That said, I doubt that Beauxbaton is that strict, rather I think they have more varied methods, or more advanced methods, of teaching discipline. Actually, though, your idea is a sound one.
Yeah sound theory. Also we have the same last name lol.
aren't you funny....
Hahah I'm actually a comedian so yes! 😂
I love peeves a shame he’s not in the movies
He is but his scenes were deleted Rick Vail played him may he RIP
did anyone else notice poltergeist activity in the background at 3:40
I love all your Harry Potter videos! Thanks for making another nerd happy.
Slight point of order from a metaphysical practitioner (and drawing on European folklore): Poltergeists aren't the embodiment of trickery or mischief. You get a poltergeist from suppressing really strong and usually negative emotions like anger, grief, or um... hormonal urges. So Peeves is more like the embodiment of teen wizard angst.
Leetah45 It can also be generated by any emotional or overactive psychokinetic energy... I've been trying to explain the concept to what seems the entire world for the past day.
Its impossible to hear the words "teen wizard angst" and not immediately think of potter puppet pals
i better start killing then...i don't want peeves cousins in my home...
Leetah45 So a poltergeist is basically an obscurus feeding off strong emotion instead of suppressed magic?
Aditya Narayan While that gives the wrong impression, it isn't entirely incorrect. Yeah, you could use that definition.
I’ve always thought of ghouls as the Scooby-Doo hotel ghosts
New Cursed Child Theory:
Delphi is not Bellatrix' daughter, because she was 47 when she died and it would be a miracle if she gave birth with 47. Furthermore Delphini said that she was born in Malfoy Manor a few days/weeks before the battle of Hogwarts, which means that Draco must have known that Bellatrix was pregnant and he most likely knew that Voldemort is the father. But if this is true Draco would have told someone after the battle of Hogwarts.
I think that Delphi isn't the daughter of Bellatrix and she isn't the daugther of Voldemort either, because she is another Horcrux. That's why she can fly and speak parseltongue.
I have no idea who her real parents could be, but I have a theory about when and why Voldemort created this Horcrux.
It was on May 2, a few hours before the battle of Hogwarts and shortly after Voldemort realized that Harry was searching for his Horcruxes.
After he looked for the ring and realized that it was destroyed, he created a new Horcrux. Voldemort didn't know that Harry was a Horcrux and he thought that Harry would be thinking that a person can't be a Horcrux and he knew that Harry would never kill someone (except Voldemort himself) especially a little baby, so he made Delphini his new Horcrux. Maybe she was the daughter of a different Deatheater, but she wasn't Bellatrix' daughter or Voldemort's. That's why Delphi has the ability to fly and to speak parseltongue, because a part of Voldemort lives inside of her and this part made Harry's scar hurt. And since Delphini didn't die at the end of CC this means that Voldemort could still come back.
And being a Horcrux would make her a cursed child.
Laura Except that Harry had to die (and come back clean of Voldemort's piece) as the final Horcrux for Voldemort to die. With your theory, he would not have been defeated because there was still a piece of him intact. I think Draco didn't tell anyone because people might've tried to get rid of the baby born of evil parents before it grew and did more evil. You know that a good many of the remaining Order would do it.
Laura
Pregnant* parseltongue* theory* realized* know* horcrux* daughter* parseltongue*
Cassidilillah Oaks really! Thats just kinda rude
Cassidilillah Oaks Sorry, I'm not a native tongue, but you're right some of these mistakes are stupid. I should have checked the text.
crazyshipper girl222
That's not rude. It's just me correcting her so she can write more fluidly in the future :)
DOBBY LONG LIVE DOBBY
no rest in peace dobby
what's up with the background?
there's a poltergeist fooling around
You mean the swirly rainbow light thing?
Ursula Cortez what about the light?
Laura M you mean when b it turned off, the ' poltergeist activity in 3, 2, 1? someone probably just turned it off or something, or the light bulb broke
1:32 I know this is just an example BUT ITS SO TRUE
My favourite is the Baskilisk.
Yes! Every time I say that I love the basilisk people look at me like " are you demented?!?"
But why? I mean I get it when it's not deadly, but are you also including the deadly part?...
You’re dementored (it’s a pun)
Was that a Magic the Gathering Card you used
Classic 😆😆
so if Peeves is the manifestation of the the naughtyness from the kids who have been at Hogwarts would there be a similar manifestation for other emotions kids have that builds up? and surely would be more than one Peeves type? or at least enough emotion for more than one. Great research as ever J
RJ Hobbes I'm sorry to say, not Rowling got some things wrong, particularly how poltergeists work. Other than Peeves, she got plenty more right.
I don't think she got poltergeists wrong, she just made up her own version of them.
Sorry, I can't see the conversation anymore. What were you saying?
Liam Powell Oh. Now I see it. Yeah, artistic license is a law protected right. And technically, they are myth and legend. It just sorts bothers me that that's the way she chose to profile them is all.
i was replying to Js video, going on what he was saying and taking that to a next step logically thinking.
Im from the South but I moved up north about 4 years ago, I ABSOLUTLY love your comment about sweet tea vs iced tea. lol you couldn't be more right!!!
After reading the books, I was so pissed that that dude wasn't in the movies! There's a lego minifig of him atleast...
SAME i was so looking forward to seeing how they would have portrayed peeves!! and then i was super disappointed 😂😂
My favorite non-human character from Harry Potter is ironically peeves. Even though I saw the movies first once I had read the books peeves became my favorite non-human character.
Evelyn Gauthier I was introduced to him first in the games. He only appeared in the first game, which disappointed me a great deal.
Why didn't Voldemort become a ghost? If anyone would manage to die wrong it'd be him.
maybe there wasn't enough left of his soul to manifest an actual gost?
milly e didn't it say in the half blood prince he teared apart to much of his soul to leave an imprint of himself on earth after he died
He would probably end up as seven different ghosts that are all pieces of his body. Maybe one of them would be his nose.
TheMagicalC he didn't have a nose
TheMagicalC what did happen to his nose and how would it become its own ghost if it doest have a mind or even a soul to live on
Peeves does have his uses. He’s come in handy at times (pestering Umbridge, fighting Deatheaters) and can be an ally.
Saying that bigfoot and yeti are the same thing is like saying polar bears and grizzly bears are the same thing.
Joshua Moyer in Fantastic Beasts and Where to Find Them (book not film) it says that the Yeti is also referred to as an Abominable Snowman or a Big foot
Fantastic Beasts and Where to Them is wrong.
Joshua Moyer aren't they?
Joshua Moyer hey idiot the only differnce is in nepal they refer to him as the yeti and in north america we refer to him as bigfoot
The Yeti, also known as the Abominable Snowman, is a creature from ancient Himalayan mythology, but it is thought to be real and for over 100 years people have searched for it. A Yeti is a beast very similar to Big Foot or the Sasquatch of America but it supposedly inhabits the mountains of Nepal and Tibet.
My favorite non human character is Buckbeak the hippogriff
Sageus Vixous Buckbeak/Witherwings
If you're not early and you know it clap your hands 👏🏻👏🏻
👏👏
*CLAP* *CLAP*
kynnadea sloan *you're
kynnadea sloan 👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻
MCWaxC - she had it right the first time.
What is that lumbering I heard? Do you have a Ghoul upstairs??
Yes, yes that is my ghoul... That is my AcTuAL MoNsTeR living in my attic
😂🤣
Who else noticed the little text in the background at 3:35?
Isa de Meijer I did! I thought I was going mad
Isa de Meijer "Poltergeist activity in.." what does it mean?
Isa de Meijer The light turned off
also there is some rainbow lights on blastoise and a liggt bar on buzz
Amber Shoffren There's a countdown after it says that to the light turning off in the back
Bringing up "Dead Skeletons" as opposed to ? Living ones??
There's a living skeleton inside you right now
poltergeist can move things. ghost are just dead lost soul . ghoul is any monster.
i knew that since i was 5.
Well done.
Errr... Ghouls aren't just any monsters. Ghouls are necrophagic burial ground dwelling demons (or Jinns) of the arabic folklore. They are believed to be children of Iblis, or the devil.
Still A Gamer I don't know if it's one person or everyone has that same profile picture
Jack Williams it's because of something pewdiepie did
On having ghouls as pest control: when I was young my family lived in a place that got really bad ant problems in the summer. One year a wild lizard wandered in from outside and decided to stay in our house. We didn’t bother it and that year none of us saw any ants
Hello!!!!!!!! I LOVE YOUR THEORIES!!!!
I've been waiting for you to use that intro for a week and a half because I was in the front row and I wanted to appear in the video, but I got cut off and you only see my hand :/
Oh well. Still fun and maybe now I'll start a vlog.
How about this: Rowling sat down in that café of hers, sipped her coffee and said: "It's a magic school, right? Be'er put summat ghosts in'ere. Poltergeist. Heard tha' one before." And then she wrote it down and went on.
i just love the fact that the light goes off in 3:43 when he says trickery
Here's a good question, how'd Voldemort have a daughter?
Don't get me started on Cursed Child.
Or how the movie portrayed Voldemort as the noseless guy when he killed the potters? Shouldn't he be normal?
CuteCat2 not normal, the books describe him as pale and sickly and definitely not normal, but definitely not as snakelike
Voldemort split his soul so many times, surely it had an effect on his reproductive organs.
Logan Smith actually he is. Go to the first book when Harry meets him
SuperCarlinBrothers I have A Video Idea for you. Can Wizards Patronus Charm Be a Dementor?
I wouldn't want to meet that person. Patronoses are the animal you are most like.
Yes but they would be pure evil as they love dementors more than anything and dementors represent fear
@@telluricdeer7611 I got it. I said I wouldn't want to meet them for precisely that reason
they arent animals, they do not breed, they manifest, its not an animal or any sort of creature so they could not be a dementor, they are purely are manifestation of fear so there is no way they would be a patronus
Could Giants be a Patronus??
Yeti are basically sasquatch that are well adapted to cold, mountainous regions, so not too far off but not exactly interchangeable. Bigfoot is a sasquatch, the abombitable snowman is a yeti
IS THAT A MAGIC CARD?? YAAS! (5:22)
I believe I even have that one...
Infinity squared yassss
As someone from the South, I have not yet managed to live far enough north to experience this horrible thing you describe with tea. That said, I tend to order unsweet tea when I go to restaurants, so I can sweeten it to my preferred level without it coming oversweetened. I also don't use actual sugar, as the various other sweeteners both dissolve better and use less packets to achieve the same level of sweetness.