GOOD vs BAD RELATIVE COMPRESSION TEST [PicoSope 2204A and Hantek CC-650] Mechanic Mindset

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 15 вер 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 108

  • @MechanicMindset
    @MechanicMindset  4 роки тому +2

    Check out this cool misfire test!! ua-cam.com/video/MOLj5vGIDsg/v-deo.html

  • @weloveups831
    @weloveups831 10 місяців тому +2

    Just picked up this pico 2204. This man's UA-cam has been an invaluable learning tool.
    Thank you for your work!
    Started with this scope, thinking I will probably over voltage my first scope! Lol

    • @MechanicMindset
      @MechanicMindset  10 місяців тому

      It’s a great scope to start learning with 👍 quite robust too 😅

  • @phillipjlynch9340
    @phillipjlynch9340 Рік тому

    Awesome videos
    I am a retired mechanic. But I still like to help my friends and neighbours with their car repairs. Because of watching you on UA-cam. I have decided to pull out my old Fluke 97 Auto Scope.
    Thanks

  • @mechanicmatt871
    @mechanicmatt871 4 роки тому +3

    This shows the benefits of having a scope, nice explanation. Cheers Matt

    • @MechanicMindset
      @MechanicMindset  4 роки тому +2

      So many great uses for this tool. It really is under used!

  • @shauncraggs4447
    @shauncraggs4447 4 роки тому +2

    Excellent video mate just got the pico 2204A your video's are a great help cheers Shaun

    • @MechanicMindset
      @MechanicMindset  4 роки тому

      shaun craggs Thanks! Glad they help you out! Pico 2204A is a great tool!

  • @IamReadyToRock
    @IamReadyToRock 3 роки тому +1

    Estoy pensando seriamente en comprar este osciloscopio, gracias por el video, desde Peru 👍🏽👍🏽👍🏽

  • @inhopeofabettername
    @inhopeofabettername 7 місяців тому

    This is cool as hell. I never though of pulling the scope out to check compression

    • @MechanicMindset
      @MechanicMindset  7 місяців тому

      Can be a real time saver. Customer will be impressed too 😎

  • @hectorcoronado4042
    @hectorcoronado4042 6 місяців тому

    Great video was having can issue going to use scope to figure it out could find video how to set it up very detailed video.

  • @TheGibby3340
    @TheGibby3340 4 роки тому +1

    Nice clear demo...well done. Simple synch. Thx

    • @MechanicMindset
      @MechanicMindset  4 роки тому +1

      TheGibby3340 Thanks for the feedback. Glad you liked it! 👍

  • @arthurfricchione8119
    @arthurfricchione8119 3 роки тому +1

    Yes Darren it’s me again. If my updated cables come tomorrow I’ll be out in the shop. I’m truly enjoying the fact that us diyers can use. Much appreciated. Are you using Pico 6 or Pico automotive? I have regular Pico 6 downloaded. I had Pico 6 automotive but I deleted it a while back. That’s why I’m asking which program your using. Thanks for sharing your knowledge and videos 😊 Artie

    • @MechanicMindset
      @MechanicMindset  3 роки тому +1

      Hey Artie, I just use normal Pico 6. There aren’t many advantages of using the automotive software with the 2204A. And on for the main features, they are both exactly the same 👍 Thanks for all the great comments!!

  • @polnashautosgarage0001
    @polnashautosgarage0001 Рік тому

    Thank's Bro,The Content is Very Informative,Keep up!

  • @seshachary5580
    @seshachary5580 Рік тому

    very educative. Thank you regards

  • @stephanevaucelles6378
    @stephanevaucelles6378 4 роки тому +1

    Thanks for the video

  • @4YouWHOyou
    @4YouWHOyou Рік тому +1

    If you could connect third sonde to manifold vacuum you would see why cranking waveforms are falling at the end.

  • @jma8352
    @jma8352 6 місяців тому

    Thank you for the great teaching! Please tell me or if anyone else knows on a coil pack 99 ranger 3.0 how can you perform this test?

  • @1chrisandrew1
    @1chrisandrew1 4 місяці тому

    Is the trigger on the signal wire of the coil, or the +ve or -ve feed? I'm assuming signal wire. Thanks

  • @KFCMasa
    @KFCMasa 2 роки тому

    brilliant thaaaaaaank you from Iraq

  • @daviid77
    @daviid77 3 місяці тому +1

    Channel b where do u connect on coil On positive or on signal wire?

    • @MechanicMindset
      @MechanicMindset  3 місяці тому

      It would be signal wire. You might need an attenuator too 👍

  • @DavidYoung-wp3ur
    @DavidYoung-wp3ur 7 місяців тому

    why not monitor battery voltage on the oscilloscope for compression testing? It gives the same waveform the voltage dips as the current increases.

    • @MechanicMindset
      @MechanicMindset  7 місяців тому

      We have a video on that too actually 😁
      Using an amp clamp is much simpler and more accurate, especially with this low spec oscilloscope

  • @user-rq8nb6bu7d
    @user-rq8nb6bu7d 7 місяців тому +1

    With pico 2204a equipment
    PicoDiagnostics Relative Compression Test
    Can you do a test?

  • @domcadle2355
    @domcadle2355 Рік тому

    Great but when I do it using same setting same equipment picture not like yours

    • @MechanicMindset
      @MechanicMindset  Рік тому

      Does the amp clamp read anything at all? For example, with the ignition on

  • @saif1002
    @saif1002 8 місяців тому +1

    Bosch ECUs burn out quick, once I touched a rached spanner on the side of the ECU and it blew, cost me £400.

  • @gavinfeng6568
    @gavinfeng6568 3 роки тому +2

    Thanks for sharing your excellent knowledge. Can I ask if one car failed relative compression test, should I still need to check coil plug and spark plugs condition?

    • @MechanicMindset
      @MechanicMindset  3 роки тому

      I would probably look at what is causing the low compression 👍 Thanks!

  • @mrracer98
    @mrracer98 4 роки тому

    I am loving your videos. Best training for newbies like myself. I have a question. The lead that you plug into the coil, that is always grounded as well? And if you are using more than one, each one is grounded I assume, because they need a reference point (and they all have a ground clamp as well...?) Thanks

    • @mrracer98
      @mrracer98 4 роки тому +1

      To anyone wondering similar questions how to actually plug stuff in for the tests, here is a great link from pico
      www.picoauto.com/library/automotive-guided-tests

    • @MechanicMindset
      @MechanicMindset  4 роки тому +2

      Jeremy Hi, re, the grounds, it depends on the scope. The grounds on this scope are joined, so in theory you only need to connect one ground, and both channels will receive it; I always connect both from habit and to avoid a spare lead lying around. Some scopes (like 4425) have floating grounds and are independent of each other. The need to have their own ground but also provide other benefits/safety for measuring more than one circuit. I am going to explain in a video I have planned! Glad you’re enjoying the channel, more to come! Thanks 👍

    • @MechanicMindset
      @MechanicMindset  4 роки тому +1

      PS, clamp doesn’t have a ‘ground’. Imagine the two ends are connected to the electronics in the clamp

  • @bdboy007
    @bdboy007 2 місяці тому +1

    How did you get the automotive version of pico6 to work with this scope?

    • @MechanicMindset
      @MechanicMindset  2 місяці тому

      I’m not using the Automotive version 👍 There was a little trick to make it work but it’s not possible anymore. We never used automotive in any of our videos with 2204A 👍

    • @bdboy007
      @bdboy007 2 місяці тому

      @@MechanicMindset I just seen the automotive tab on the screen of your video and realized my version of pico 6 does not have it

  • @markhb3346
    @markhb3346 4 роки тому +1

    Does Euro cars have clear flood mode ?? On many U.S OBD2 vehicles that are below 8601lb GVWR have clear flood mode. If you hold the accelerator pedal to the floor (WOT) it will disable the injectors hand will not start . Also I think the pattern is inconsistent because if it is an electronic throttle body the ECM might be moving it thus changing how much air in going into the cyl effecting compression .

    • @markhb3346
      @markhb3346 4 роки тому +1

      You VVT theory may be correct as well , most system only advance the VVT when it's running but I'm not familiar with that make car so they may doing it while cranking .

    • @MechanicMindset
      @MechanicMindset  4 роки тому

      Mark HB I’ll be honest, not heard of the clear flood mode before. That would bank on the driver knowing to put their foot on the gas while cranking. Most ‘Joe Public’ would just keep cranking and make it worse; so your idea about it opening throttle stacks up. Let’s see if any Ford experts can help confirm 👍

  • @manuellopez8455
    @manuellopez8455 5 місяців тому

    When taking measurement on number 1 ignition coil, did you ground the other lead or is it just one lead going straight to power?

    • @MechanicMindset
      @MechanicMindset  5 місяців тому +1

      Can’t remember how I took this measurement. If measuring direct voltage, use a ground. If just picking up the spikes, no ground needed

  • @stevem.8032
    @stevem.8032 4 роки тому +1

    Did you set up the cc-650 amp clamp in picoscope 6, if so how was it done. If not what probe did you set ch. A to? Thank you

    • @MechanicMindset
      @MechanicMindset  4 роки тому

      Steve M. Hi, I didn’t set it up. I just used the normal voltage scale and converted it 1mV=1A or 10mV=100mA, depending on the switch setting

  • @StanislavTsonchev
    @StanislavTsonchev 4 роки тому +1

    I have tried same configuration, however I do get a lot of noise and not very definitive picture. You have very clear peaks and easily determined cylinders. With mine it looks like earthquake graph with many highs and lows...
    Any suggestions?

    • @MechanicMindset
      @MechanicMindset  4 роки тому

      Stanislav Tsonchev Hi, maybe check the clamp is not on the low current setting, that is very noisy. You can also reduce the sample rate which might help a bit. You can see my other video where I review the clamp, I play with a few setting due to the noise issue 👍

  • @alexandrumardare828
    @alexandrumardare828 6 місяців тому

    How does the common ground on the picoscope not hurt what the ampclamp shows?

    • @MechanicMindset
      @MechanicMindset  6 місяців тому

      The amp clamp isn’t coupled to the vehicle ground 👍

  • @HerrDagerman
    @HerrDagerman 2 роки тому +1

    One question: when you're using the amp-clamp, it measures voltage... (in Pico), is that to do with ohms-law? Decrease in current means drop in voltage?

    • @MechanicMindset
      @MechanicMindset  2 роки тому

      Great question. You should consider the amp clamp, like an ‘amp sensor’.
      Like a pressure sensor, it sends a voltage signal to the scope which is relevant to the current it measured.
      We change Pico to convert the voltage to an amp reading (eg 100mV = 1Amp)

    • @HerrDagerman
      @HerrDagerman 2 роки тому

      @@MechanicMindset It measures the EMF-field in the wire right? So there's a setting in the software to convert the voltage to amps?

    • @MechanicMindset
      @MechanicMindset  2 роки тому

      @@HerrDagerman That’s right. Any wire with current flowing has a magnetic field around it, the clamp measures is and sends a voltage signal that’s relative

    • @HerrDagerman
      @HerrDagerman 2 роки тому

      @@MechanicMindset Ok, understood :) Thanks for taking the time to help :) I went to collage for this you know but there's always something new to learn. Thanks again for introducing me to Picoscope. Your channel made me upgrade (I had a cheap Hantek oscilloscope before, I didn't like the software) to a Pico 2000-series :) Also made me order an attenuator from Amazon and two great Hantek probes :) Made me understand sample-rate too :) Golden! Really helpful in my work

  • @wildcat22
    @wildcat22 2 роки тому +1

    Could a 65 amp clamp with attenuator be used for this?

    • @MechanicMindset
      @MechanicMindset  2 роки тому +1

      I like your thinking , but it doesn’t work like that. The amp clamps only have a small voltage output. It’s the amp clamps capability to measure the height current that is required 👍

  • @Romulus1001
    @Romulus1001 8 місяців тому

    How did you identify cylinder number 1 at 3:25? The second line under the compression wave form makes tick marks under cylinder 1. I assume the ignition (spark) needs to stay on for the test to work?

    • @MechanicMindset
      @MechanicMindset  8 місяців тому +1

      Yes, I’m using ignition for trigger 👍

    • @Romulus1001
      @Romulus1001 8 місяців тому

      ​@MechanicMindset thank you! I edited my original comment so that it actually reads like English and makes sense but you understood my question nevertheless :]

  • @matthewlorenzidefretes2262
    @matthewlorenzidefretes2262 Рік тому

    mind blown

  • @edlu73
    @edlu73 3 роки тому +1

    can you explain the wire back probe into coil #1 at 58sec mark. I assume you back probing the power wire on the COP, do you need to clamp the ground wire to the car with the HT30A wire set you using? or just leave the black connector alone?

    • @MechanicMindset
      @MechanicMindset  3 роки тому +1

      Ed Lu Hi, for the COP, red wire in ignition trigger from ECU, black wire to ground. The clamp doesn’t have any extra cable for ground so just connect directly to scope 👍

    • @edlu73
      @edlu73 3 роки тому

      @@MechanicMindset thanks! going to buy your set up and test it out!

    • @MechanicMindset
      @MechanicMindset  3 роки тому

      Ed Lu Cool, let me know how you get on and if you have any questions 👍

    • @edlu73
      @edlu73 3 роки тому +1

      @@MechanicMindset I finally got all the parts. Tried it the first run today on a F150 v8. I set the pico to everything in the video ChA 200mv. ChB 20v and 200ms/div. Only thing is my result the ChA blue graphic is no way as clean as in your video. I only can make out 4 peaks not 8 between each ChB. I can send you the wave file via email

    • @MechanicMindset
      @MechanicMindset  3 роки тому

      @@edlu73 OK, send it over. My email is in about section 👍

  • @alexandrumardare828
    @alexandrumardare828 Місяць тому

    Im using pico 7 with the 2204a but my relative compresiune is very noisy, do you know what i could be doing wrong?

    • @MechanicMindset
      @MechanicMindset  Місяць тому

      @@alexandrumardare828 using a battery charger? It’s quite hard to suggest without seeing the set up

  • @ilovear15
    @ilovear15 Рік тому

    Can I do the same compression test with pico 2204a on picoscope7 non automotive software?

  • @christyashe1936
    @christyashe1936 2 роки тому

    Hi I have just received a 2204a mainly from your recommendations thanks
    My question is on this test you use a hantek amp clamp, I have a 600a clamp that wanted to use for doing this sort of test but the pico 6 software only shows 60a

    • @MechanicMindset
      @MechanicMindset  2 роки тому

      You can either just use the voltage scale and convert to Amps (it should say conversion on clamp), or you can make a custom probe using that conversion in the probes menu 👍

    • @christyashe1936
      @christyashe1936 2 роки тому

      Ok thanks

  • @sokakutakeda1500
    @sokakutakeda1500 3 роки тому +1

    hi sir! may I ask what probe settings you used for that cc 650 hantek in non-automotive scope thank you.

    • @MechanicMindset
      @MechanicMindset  3 роки тому

      Hi! I don’t think I used a probe setting in this video, just voltage scale. I don’t think I have a custom probe for this, I need to make one and share!

    • @sokakutakeda1500
      @sokakutakeda1500 3 роки тому +1

      @@MechanicMindset ah... so that's why I didn't see how you set your probe settings because you used a voltage scale for 200mv=200A? because your clamp setting is 1mv/1A. I'm also interested in 2204A I'm just new also into scoping. thank you sir God bless to your channel.

    • @MechanicMindset
      @MechanicMindset  3 роки тому

      @@sokakutakeda1500 That’s right, the scale isn’t so important for relative compression, we just want to compare each peak. It is really easy to set up a custom probe; just need basic maths.
      You can’t go wrong with the 2204A to start 👍

    • @sokakutakeda1500
      @sokakutakeda1500 3 роки тому

      @@MechanicMindset yes sir I'm already saving money to buy that one instead of hantek. i already have the software in my laptop for 2000 series and the automotive one to play with the settings. i just saw some videos that you can add new custom probe on non-automotive scope but you just have to know the minimum and maximum input and scale like for instance you can add the hantek cc65 and 650 in library of the 2204A but I'm still need to learn a lot and research a lot to know how it supposed to be done so I will not have incorrect measurement in the future.

    • @NorthEastRepair
      @NorthEastRepair 3 роки тому

      Hi @mechqnic mindset i have the cc650 amp clamp and the pico 2000 do you a probe setting the i can use for relative compression test. Much appreciated thanks

  • @kennethkristensen5537
    @kennethkristensen5537 Рік тому +1

    How do you Mount the leads on Channel B.?

    • @MechanicMindset
      @MechanicMindset  Рік тому

      For the cylinder trigger? Many options, any way you like to pick up the coil signal, could probe the primary trigger, use the coin on coil trick, or secondary clamp if you have one. Hope that helps 👍

    • @kennethkristensen5537
      @kennethkristensen5537 Рік тому

      @@MechanicMindset if I use primary trigger I use it in respect to ground.

  • @judgedead7182
    @judgedead7182 3 роки тому +1

    recantly got into scoping but come across few of the videos where you explain the attenuator because the scope you use is 20v max. but if it reads over 20v do you mean it just will max out on the scale at 20v evan tho it read 25v or will over 20v fry the scope? thanks!.

    • @MechanicMindset
      @MechanicMindset  3 роки тому +1

      Great question: it will max out the scale on the scope. 2204A has 100V over voltage protection. I have exceeded 20V a number of time with no issue but be careful! The manufacturers recommended not to exceed the max input. 👍

    • @judgedead7182
      @judgedead7182 3 роки тому +1

      @@MechanicMindset thanks for the reply! picked up a cheap verus pro but perfer the layout of pico for adjustibility compared to snapon!

  • @kamilalabd8827
    @kamilalabd8827 Місяць тому

    I saw this Video and bought pico2204a scope for doing relative compression test but the test not success with me … please I need your help sir how can contact you

  • @abdullbasitosman5070
    @abdullbasitosman5070 4 роки тому +1

    you use 2204a as an automotive scope, do you think it is good to buy it? at leat iwant to use it to detect engine,abs sensors signal

    • @MechanicMindset
      @MechanicMindset  4 роки тому

      abdullbasit osman Hi, yes for sure. This is great for automotive use. For basic functions, it’s very similar to the Pico Automotive kit. Check out this video where I take a few different measurements. ua-cam.com/video/1LBKtlpCj_4/v-deo.html Also, list of the kit you need is in the description. Thanks!

    • @abdullbasitosman5070
      @abdullbasitosman5070 4 роки тому +1

      @@MechanicMindset why pico manufucturer says 2204a is not automotive device? is it because 2204a cant do other automotive dignosis or it does but not good ?

    • @MechanicMindset
      @MechanicMindset  4 роки тому +1

      @@abdullbasitosman5070 Hi, PicoScope make the automotive scope that has some extra benefits for testing automotive components. For example, it has a higher input (200V now I think), and on the later scopes the grounds for each channel are separate which will avoid short circuits when measuring multiple components (like 12V ground switched injectors). Other than that, i think it is mostly marketing plus the automotive software (which is good if you are new to using a scope). This is only my opinion of course! 2204A is great for automotive if you know it's limits; 4 channels would be nice

    • @abdullbasitosman5070
      @abdullbasitosman5070 4 роки тому +3

      @@MechanicMindset thank u for all your reply. not all reply people questions

    • @MechanicMindset
      @MechanicMindset  4 роки тому +1

      abdullbasit osman You’re welcome!

  • @domcadle2355
    @domcadle2355 2 роки тому

    How comes I copy the setting but don’t get same pattern I have to go to 500mv to get waveform

    • @MechanicMindset
      @MechanicMindset  Рік тому

      Hi, it depends what you are using to take the measurement. If it's an amp clamp, did you change the probe type?

    • @domcadle2355
      @domcadle2355 Рік тому

      Same hantek as yours

  • @Mrkerrypray
    @Mrkerrypray 2 роки тому

    Hello, I got a 2040a after watching your channel. Doing a relative compression test today my image was extremely pixelated and not really detailed. Do you know what setting I should use to get a better image? Thank you.

    • @MechanicMindset
      @MechanicMindset  2 роки тому

      Hi, with voltage or amp clamp?

    • @Mrkerrypray
      @Mrkerrypray 2 роки тому

      Hello, I use a pico amp clamp.

    • @MechanicMindset
      @MechanicMindset  2 роки тому

      @@Mrkerrypray You can adjust the vertical resolution in the channel A option menu 👍

  • @sebczajna700
    @sebczajna700 3 роки тому +1

    You shouldn’t count cylinder 1-3-4-2?