i love seeing retarded comments everywhere constantly bashing anime for being "degenerate" or moe or some shit these people are so shallow and don't bother discovering anything other than whats in memes, its hilarious and frustrating
I still can't believe how this story has still not been recognized by the wider western audience. From what I've seen it's very popular in Japan but I'm guessing it's not easy to warm up to, it's a very unique story.
@@sparklesparklesparkle6318I started watching this with no idea of the Russo-Japanese war, I'm an American and they never taught me this shit. But this show was AWESOME. And as soon as I found out the Ainu were a real people, and about the war, and the legitimation from the Japanese government making the Ainu legally an indigenous people, I was in awe. Hate my schooling for not teaching me this.
Western weeb audiences prefer mediocre run of the mill anime unfortunately. And if it’s different but not shonen, then it tends not to gain much traction.
On Ainu culture, ‘Imeruat’ is a modern Ainu musician that produces music with both Ainu, Japanese and English vocals. Highly recommend her self titled track Imeraut from the album Black Ocean
I watched everything but the last 3 episodes so far. I had ABSOLUTELY no idea about the amount historical accuracy this show actually has. Never heard of the Ainu or the Russo Japanese war. But that could be due to U.S. schools refusing to teach japanese culture other than my japanese teacher in senior year of high school because of WWII. I did a decent amount of research recently and found this show is incredible. Not just for the story. For the actual factual portrayal of the indigenous japanese. I see in the comments "westerners" like me aren't really the ones watching it. And im upset with my fellow Americans. They wanna watch teenage girls in skimpy clothes, while this show is a TRUE GEM amongst anime I've seen.
Do American public schools really need to teach their students about EVERY war? You can find the most random topic or fact on UA-cam and they'll be a comment in the comment section saying, "Why weren't we taught this in school???" US schools now can barely teach their kids basic numeracy. Why don't you focus on that first?
Like all things American, it kind of depends on where you live; we didn't learn about the Ainu in school, but we did touch on the Meiji Restoration and the Russo-Japanese War (since Teddy Roosevelt actually played a role in the peace negotiations). More probably, I think a lot of US schools don't go too in-depth on Japanese history for the same reason they don't go too deep on the liberal nationalist revolutions of 1848 Europe or Canadian history in general; it has a lot more to do with time and resource constraints than WWII.
Reading this series felt like it came from another era of the industry, it was so goddamn good, and best of all, ended right, no unnecessary extras, milking, etc. Been so long since I've seen that.
Yeah I feel like it would have been very popular with Americans 20 years ago. The types that enjoyed Cowboy Bebop. If Cowboy Bebop was released today, it wouldn't be very popular because the audience is less sophisticated, less mature, and more childish.
@@breakmanradio2530Absolutely nailed it. Both you, and the OP. This is not only an action packed, comedy, fighting manga; but also a well crafted story with strong themes and something to say. While I won't get hyperbolic and call it high art, it's easily a shining example of what the genre of manga can achieve, and in my opinion one of the best and most cohesive manga of the last two decades.
Golden Kamuy is easily Top 5 Seinen manga of the last 20 years. Underrated is thrown around a lot, and I think a more fitting term is simply "unknown". I rarely see people talk about it, so thank you for your video. If you'll excuse me, I'm off to reread the manga for the fourth time.
I'm so glad my public library had most of the mangas. Now I'm a huge fan. Amazing artwork, great action, and I even enjoy the hunting cooking survival elements. Good stuff.
Golden Kamuy is one of the greatest adventure stories ever. All those overhyped big budget fantastical ictional universes like the MCU and Star Wars can't hold a candle to an earthbound tale crafted out through sheer dedication. Yes, in fantasy and sci fi based universes you have the licence to throw in all sorts of out of this world jaw dropping designs and looks to hide the shortcomings in telling a good story with strong emotional content. But Satoru Noda don't have that luxury or can even be said to be handicapped by setting his story in a place not many people in the world care about during a period of history that even fewer know about about a forgotten tribe that barely anyone outside Japan heard about. And he made us live and breath every second of the characters' lives.
Such an incredible series, it feels that not a scene or line of dialogue was wasted coupled with the vast array of characters that transform to fill many different roles around Asirpa makes this truly one for the ages. It's been almost 24 years since a series managed to force its way into my top 3 but Golden Kamuy has earnt its place there many times over, Hinna, hinna!
Apart form the superb story telling and wealth of knowledge about the Ainu. Another thing I love are the fights where everyone turns super human when not fatally wounded, like a real person would. You won't see anyone really useless, even the grunts in this series are seriously dangerous unless you kill instantly. Stabbed in the face? No problem, fight back! Lost your leg? No problem, fight back! They all react like how real people on the brink of death would - to struggle, trying their damnest to claw their way out of the predicament they are in until they run out of breath.
Congratulations on your imminent wedding, my friend. May you both have endless years of happiness and fortune together... Oh, and congrats on the great Golden Kamuy video too!
I just finished the manga as of 9:32 PM 21/10/2022. Golden Kamuy is ultimately a story about love. Be it the love of gold, sex, war, violence, religion, power, culture, nature, or, most importantly, the love and care of another. I will forever be in awe of Satoru Noda and the way he seamlessly transitions from scenes of emotional turmoil, life-threatening stakes, horrific violence, psychological manipulation and plot twists that'll leave you in utter disbelief to moments of casual conversation, sensual connections, natural beauty, serenity and incredibly detailed accounts of history and culture with a fair share of dick jokes in between so seamlessly, whilst not feeling forced or overdone at any point. It is this, combined with his mastery of writing such a wide array of unique, complex and compelling characters whilst still managing to interweave their lives in a way that doesn't detract from but rather compels each character's dreams, ideas and narrative, that easily makes this series a masterpiece in both storytelling and world-building. I will most definitely miss this series with all my heart. As Lt Tsurumi said, "The motivating force that can bring out the aggressiveness [desire to kill] in your soldiers... It isn't hatred of the enemy troops, nor is it fear... It isn't even a difference in political ideals... It's Love."
the last fight on the train is probably my favorite fight if not top 5 in any media i've seen. It's just so batshit insane and the characters just flow with it so well, along with 3 arcs of build up to it.
9:26 I wont lie, "Golden Kamuy boasts one of the strongest cast of characters ive ever encountered" as a sentence starting over a shot that includes Usami "semen detective" Tokishige just... took me the fuck out. They are very colorful indeed (there is something deeply wrong with every single one of them and i adore them for it
My friends and I talk about Golden Kamuy's gaggle of eccentric armed men collectively as the weird guys. Whenever a new one appears, we crow "time to meet another weird guy!" "Who's the next weird guy?" "Here comes Asirpa's security team of weird guys!" "Don't worry, the bath is just full of weird guys" etc. We love all of them. Except the taxidermist.
i've been reading manga for almost 15 years now, and golden kamuy excited and consumed me in a way that few manga ever have. extremely happy to have found it and hope that others get to experience it in one way or another
Thank you for doing a video essay on Golden Kamuy. I personally think that the series itself is very underrated among western audiences which is a shame because its better than your typical seasonal anime. I can't wait to see Golden Kamuy Season 4.
Best story, humor, characters and more realistic and not friendship and just getting stronger and stronger. Personally better then Dragon ball and One Piece and that stuff.
I've read this series twice now. During my second read I downloaded all their silly faces and antics. I would occasionally look back at some of them and laugh to myself and remember how fantastic this series is. Thank you for this video and it's beautiful analysis
One of the series biggest weaknesses is it's too funny. It gets me just about every time, but too often (more frequently in the second half) undercuts great dramatic tension with a (admittedly hilarious) punchline.
Ever since Shaman king’s Horohoro I had a curiosity about the Ainu people, but found most educational material rather dry or lacking or just plainly untranslated - you have my interest peaked!
I wish the whole manga would be adapted. It been a long while since I simultaneously watched multiple seasons of a single anime franchise, and that anime was Golden Kamuy.
Golden kamuy actually taught me to enjoy life. It taught me to simultaneously not take life so seriously while treating the life you live with the upmost importance. Despite the darker side of life there’s still joy and meaning to be found.
Golden kamuy is the reason why I’ll never be able to use miso without thinking “osoma” first and frowning. Thank you for covering this masterpiece I love it beyond words. May your marriage be full of joy!
Dude as much as you tend to cover some obscure anime that youtube algorithm doesn't like. The quality of these videos are unparralelled and I have never seen anything near this level of commitment. I legit hope that one day I can be as committed and talented in writing and editing and voice as much as is evident in all of your videos. For someone who is a generic anime critic but enjoys some of the films (like myself) its amazing to see an analytical and factual tone when it comes to these stories. I can't wait to see what is in store for the future and I would listen and watch any of your videos even if you began to explore new topics. (You probs won't see this but hey, I had to say somewhere how much I appreciate it)
This animanga has single handedly managed to make me laugh, educate me, touch my soul and has encouraged me to go back to my own roots and learn more about my own culture. Thank you Satoru Noda for this grim, strange, grotesque yet beautiful and touching story.
Golden Kamuy, my second favorite manga and third favorite anime. I haven't finished it yet, but I'd say it's truly a masterpiece I'll never forget as long as I live. I can't wait for the rest of the manga volumes to be published where I live, we're currently at Volume 18.
Golden kamuy is one of my favorite titles and I'm extremely glad that someone reviewed it! It's very underrated. The story, humour and characters in manga are just amazing. I think those who like JoJo's bizarre adventure should also like GK. Thanks for the video!
After completing the manga, it became my number 1 among all the manga... The narration method, the very elaborate plot, the manga's atmosphere, the comedy and the strange things are all wonderful
Beautiful video. Especially the part about acknowledging cultures not as exotic fixed points, but as people in change. Hope your marriage is beautiful as well - it too, isn’t necessarily an exotic fixed point, but about people in change, which can be beautiful in its own right
an amazing story, unlike any anime ever seen. A Japanese western, with comedy, culture and brutality. Golden Kamuy is a strong wine, enjoyed not by everyone, but delicious if you know how to drink it.
I just finished this series and it's an easy 10/10. It's so weirdly not represented on youtube and seeing and hearing this video makes me want to show ALL of my friends. You so perfectly encapsulate every single thing I loved about this story, it's actually incredible how consistent the opinions of people who have read this feel about it. What a beautiful story
0:21 This is the most beautiful graphic violence warning I've ever seen. Another wonderfully edited video as always, it really describes everything I love about Golden Kamuy. I never mind waiting for your videos because the wait is always worth the quality you deliver.
I'm now going to use this video whenever I want to get someone to read Golden Kamuy, you've explained better than I ever could why it's such an incredible series.
Finally someone extracts the huge value of this series, I must say, the characters are the most powerful aspect of the whole show, the author dives in each one’s interests and intentions deeply to the point you become attached to them. Thanks for another entertaining video, keep it up.
Great video on a great work, with perfect timing as season 4 is coming out soon. It really was a "lived" in world with "real" characters, all of them were morally grey which is how we are. More so it was great to see the understanding/highlight that most of the cast are broken former soldiers... we had little understanding of what PTSD did you back then (hell in WW1 they finally began labeling it Shell Shock after all). Also reminded me that one of the fan scangroups that covered hit always had a end page of history facts that were referenced in Noda's work which really showed how much it studied and how much history there was with in it.
Yes! Everyday Heroes provided incredible glossary pages that really elevated the reading experience and extrapolated on all the themes, history and culture of any given chapter. They also reminded you of callbacks and references you might have otherwise forgotten - and that really sold how intricate and well thought out Noda's storytelling was. I actually tried fitting in a paragraph about their incredible work into this video but couldn't find a way to talk about them without it feeling like I was endorsing scans over the official translations. Luckily, for anyone reading this that might be about to start reading GK, they provide a download of just those glossary pages on their website. Glad to see someone else who appreciated their work.
Have to admit this series passed me by but... Detailed depiction of Ainu culture? That at the very least grabbed my interest~ 30+ volumes would make my overstuffed bookshelves weep though
This was an absolutely brilliant video. The script, the editing, and the narration was phenomenal. I came across Golden Kamuy because of a recommendation after finishing JJBA and I fell in love with the anime. After I caught up to the anime I’ve been slowly collecting the manga so I can binge read it all in one go but they’re really hard to come by where I live. Your video has inspired me to start writing my own script so I can also share the wonders of GK!! I doubt it’ll be as good as yours but I really really want more Western anime/manga fans to experience GK so we can have a huge fan base to talk about how great it is❤❤
Finally! This is my favourite contemporary manga and anime by a long mile, and I’m surprised it isn’t more popular. Going to enjoy this video for sure. Meanwhile: congratulations on your marriage! 🎉🎉🎉
Great video. I have only watched the first 3 episodes of the anime but I am considering picking up the manga. This series is exciting and educational. A great combination. There is no need to apologise for the delay.
My first comment on your channel. Your regal voice reminds me of the amazing Brit actor Jared Harris. It makes this video on Golden Kamuy & the majestic Ainu sounds even more dramatic and indeed the subject matter deserves such royal treatment.
Finally, an analysis of Golden Kamuy I can respect! Thank you for making this, it kind of hurts my soul how poorly this manga/anime is represented on youtube, I've been looking for a decent analysis for a while now and yours might be the only one that holds up! Thank you for this well-made video that accurately highlights the beauty and unique nature of this story!
Thank you for making such a wonderfully produced video about a work that is so close to my heart. When I try to recommend the story to friends, I often don't know how to describe it. So thank you for now finding words where I was at a loss for words.
This has inspired me to pick up the manga and watch the anime. Thank you so much for covering this. You are by far my most favorite UA-camr when it comes to the coverage of anime. I've been subbed since you covered Cowboy Bebop, and you never fail to impress. Keep up the good work Joe! Also congratulations on your marriage, I pray that it endures until death.
Your work, beyond being thoughtful and beautifully presented, is so calming. Every time I see new video I’m so happy because I know a piece of serenity awaits me. Thank you.
I saw an Asirpa t-shirt was in a loot crate like last year. I immediately ordered it, but because I live in bumb fuck nowhere it cost a damn fortune in exchange rate and shipping and took 6 months, but yeah it arrived yesterday. Worth it. Hinna Hinna.
This anime took me by storm. I am still hooked to this day. Very sad that the production is at hold but it's completely understandable it has to be this way.
One of my friends continuously recommends this manga to me. And with this tone the video is setting, I am very excited to get back into it. Congrats are due as well, so congrats on the wedding. Wish you all the best going forward. Really good content here as always.
Thank you for the heart, Joe! You're the best! I meant every word. 💖 I really do want a list of your all-time favorite Manga, though. I'm caught up with all the ones I'm following right now & almost finished with the ones that are completed & would absolutely love to know your favorites so I can read them, too!
that's amazing narration and editing skills you got there, you earned a subscriber! This is something similar I try to create, but you already mastered that style. I'll check more of your stuff
Goddam it! after seeing all those incredible drawings i guess i'll have to buy the freaking Manga/Anime! Ty for making me waste my money!... True-talk: i'm gladly spending my money because the drawings look sick and the story is really interesting! LET'S GO! \o/
Hinna Hinna
Citatap
Google translate says it means "price price" lmao
Osoma 💩
Golden Kamuy is criminally overlooked by anime/manga fans in the West. I'm glad you're covering it.
Thankfully it's very popular and loved in Japan
Should i read the manga or watch the anime cause I'm interested in either but not sure about both
@@dilanrajapaksha IMO go with whatever medium you prefer to consume, but just be aware that the anime is way behind the manga.
@@dilanrajapaksha I recommend reading the manga first, then going back to the anime to relish the fun times while appreciating the animation
i love seeing retarded comments everywhere constantly bashing anime for being "degenerate" or moe or some shit these people are so shallow and don't bother discovering anything other than whats in memes, its hilarious and frustrating
"So what genre is Golden Kamuy?"
"Yes."
It’s clearly a cooking show.
Historical fiction.
A how to on building friendships
Low key yaoi too
I just finished Golden Kamuy after picking it up on a whim and holy shit this manga is insane
I think it’s genuinely my favorite manga of all time now
I still can't believe how this story has still not been recognized by the wider western audience. From what I've seen it's very popular in Japan but I'm guessing it's not easy to warm up to, it's a very unique story.
@@sparklesparklesparkle6318 I just explain that its a Western in Hokkaido, and replace the civil war with the Russo-Sino War
@@sparklesparklesparkle6318I started watching this with no idea of the Russo-Japanese war, I'm an American and they never taught me this shit. But this show was AWESOME. And as soon as I found out the Ainu were a real people, and about the war, and the legitimation from the Japanese government making the Ainu legally an indigenous people, I was in awe. Hate my schooling for not teaching me this.
i mean why would you learn about this war in an american school?@@CloneBiker
@@revolversnake126 it's better than most random bullshit they taught us.
Western weeb audiences prefer mediocre run of the mill anime unfortunately. And if it’s different but not shonen, then it tends not to gain much traction.
On Ainu culture, ‘Imeruat’ is a modern Ainu musician that produces music with both Ainu, Japanese and English vocals.
Highly recommend her self titled track Imeraut from the album Black Ocean
Thanks a lot for recommending, she sounds amazing!
I watched everything but the last 3 episodes so far. I had ABSOLUTELY no idea about the amount historical accuracy this show actually has. Never heard of the Ainu or the Russo Japanese war. But that could be due to U.S. schools refusing to teach japanese culture other than my japanese teacher in senior year of high school because of WWII. I did a decent amount of research recently and found this show is incredible. Not just for the story. For the actual factual portrayal of the indigenous japanese. I see in the comments "westerners" like me aren't really the ones watching it. And im upset with my fellow Americans. They wanna watch teenage girls in skimpy clothes, while this show is a TRUE GEM amongst anime I've seen.
Do American public schools really need to teach their students about EVERY war?
You can find the most random topic or fact on UA-cam and they'll be a comment in the comment section saying, "Why weren't we taught this in school???"
US schools now can barely teach their kids basic numeracy. Why don't you focus on that first?
Like all things American, it kind of depends on where you live; we didn't learn about the Ainu in school, but we did touch on the Meiji Restoration and the Russo-Japanese War (since Teddy Roosevelt actually played a role in the peace negotiations). More probably, I think a lot of US schools don't go too in-depth on Japanese history for the same reason they don't go too deep on the liberal nationalist revolutions of 1848 Europe or Canadian history in general; it has a lot more to do with time and resource constraints than WWII.
Reading this series felt like it came from another era of the industry, it was so goddamn good, and best of all, ended right, no unnecessary extras, milking, etc. Been so long since I've seen that.
Yeah I feel like it would have been very popular with Americans 20 years ago. The types that enjoyed Cowboy Bebop.
If Cowboy Bebop was released today, it wouldn't be very popular because the audience is less sophisticated, less mature, and more childish.
@@breakmanradio2530Absolutely nailed it. Both you, and the OP.
This is not only an action packed, comedy, fighting manga; but also a well crafted story with strong themes and something to say.
While I won't get hyperbolic and call it high art, it's easily a shining example of what the genre of manga can achieve, and in my opinion one of the best and most cohesive manga of the last two decades.
Golden Kamuy is easily Top 5 Seinen manga of the last 20 years.
Underrated is thrown around a lot, and I think a more fitting term is simply "unknown".
I rarely see people talk about it, so thank you for your video.
If you'll excuse me, I'm off to reread the manga for the fourth time.
I love all of their eyebrows!
Too real
I'm so glad my public library had most of the mangas. Now I'm a huge fan. Amazing artwork, great action, and I even enjoy the hunting cooking survival elements. Good stuff.
Golden Kamuy is one of the greatest adventure stories ever. All those overhyped big budget fantastical ictional universes like the MCU and Star Wars can't hold a candle to an earthbound tale crafted out through sheer dedication. Yes, in fantasy and sci fi based universes you have the licence to throw in all sorts of out of this world jaw dropping designs and looks to hide the shortcomings in telling a good story with strong emotional content. But Satoru Noda don't have that luxury or can even be said to be handicapped by setting his story in a place not many people in the world care about during a period of history that even fewer know about about a forgotten tribe that barely anyone outside Japan heard about. And he made us live and breath every second of the characters' lives.
Such an incredible series, it feels that not a scene or line of dialogue was wasted coupled with the vast array of characters that transform to fill many different roles around Asirpa makes this truly one for the ages.
It's been almost 24 years since a series managed to force its way into my top 3 but Golden Kamuy has earnt its place there many times over, Hinna, hinna!
Yesssss I love this series to death, can't wait to watch season 4!
What are/were your top 3 series, may I ask?
curious about your top 3!
Apart form the superb story telling and wealth of knowledge about the Ainu. Another thing I love are the fights where everyone turns super human when not fatally wounded, like a real person would. You won't see anyone really useless, even the grunts in this series are seriously dangerous unless you kill instantly. Stabbed in the face? No problem, fight back! Lost your leg? No problem, fight back!
They all react like how real people on the brink of death would - to struggle, trying their damnest to claw their way out of the predicament they are in until they run out of breath.
Congratulations on your imminent wedding, my friend. May you both have endless years of happiness and fortune together... Oh, and congrats on the great Golden Kamuy video too!
I just finished the manga as of 9:32 PM 21/10/2022. Golden Kamuy is ultimately a story about love. Be it the love of gold, sex, war, violence, religion, power, culture, nature, or, most importantly, the love and care of another. I will forever be in awe of Satoru Noda and the way he seamlessly transitions from scenes of emotional turmoil, life-threatening stakes, horrific violence, psychological manipulation and plot twists that'll leave you in utter disbelief to moments of casual conversation, sensual connections, natural beauty, serenity and incredibly detailed accounts of history and culture with a fair share of dick jokes in between so seamlessly, whilst not feeling forced or overdone at any point. It is this, combined with his mastery of writing such a wide array of unique, complex and compelling characters whilst still managing to interweave their lives in a way that doesn't detract from but rather compels each character's dreams, ideas and narrative, that easily makes this series a masterpiece in both storytelling and world-building.
I will most definitely miss this series with all my heart. As Lt Tsurumi said, "The motivating force that can bring out the aggressiveness [desire to kill] in your soldiers... It isn't hatred of the enemy troops, nor is it fear... It isn't even a difference in political ideals... It's Love."
the last fight on the train is probably my favorite fight if not top 5 in any media i've seen. It's just so batshit insane and the characters just flow with it so well, along with 3 arcs of build up to it.
9:26 I wont lie, "Golden Kamuy boasts one of the strongest cast of characters ive ever encountered" as a sentence starting over a shot that includes Usami "semen detective" Tokishige just... took me the fuck out. They are very colorful indeed (there is something deeply wrong with every single one of them and i adore them for it
My friends and I talk about Golden Kamuy's gaggle of eccentric armed men collectively as the weird guys. Whenever a new one appears, we crow "time to meet another weird guy!" "Who's the next weird guy?" "Here comes Asirpa's security team of weird guys!" "Don't worry, the bath is just full of weird guys" etc. We love all of them. Except the taxidermist.
Golden kamuy is one of the few anime. i will confidently give a 10/10, and i will die on this hill
i've been reading manga for almost 15 years now, and golden kamuy excited and consumed me in a way that few manga ever have. extremely happy to have found it and hope that others get to experience it in one way or another
Thank you for doing a video essay on Golden Kamuy. I personally think that the series itself is very underrated among western audiences which is a shame because its better than your typical seasonal anime. I can't wait to see Golden Kamuy Season 4.
Best story, humor, characters and more realistic and not friendship and just getting stronger and stronger. Personally better then Dragon ball and One Piece and that stuff.
Very blessed to have been to Hokkaido last year as the snows arrived - it is a magnificent country.
I've read this series twice now. During my second read I downloaded all their silly faces and antics. I would occasionally look back at some of them and laugh to myself and remember how fantastic this series is. Thank you for this video and it's beautiful analysis
The manga series is basically a meme farm, and I love it lol
One of the series biggest weaknesses is it's too funny.
It gets me just about every time, but too often (more frequently in the second half) undercuts great dramatic tension with a (admittedly hilarious) punchline.
How you ended the essay with hina hina made me very emotional. Like and follow!
Ever since Shaman king’s Horohoro I had a curiosity about the Ainu people, but found most educational material rather dry or lacking or just plainly untranslated - you have my interest peaked!
I wish the whole manga would be adapted. It been a long while since I simultaneously watched multiple seasons of a single anime franchise, and that anime was Golden Kamuy.
Golden kamuy actually taught me to enjoy life. It taught me to simultaneously not take life so seriously while treating the life you live with the upmost importance. Despite the darker side of life there’s still joy and meaning to be found.
This is exactly the kind of no spoiler review that I love but only from BG, but from any excellent UA-camr. Congrats on the wedding bells.
Golden kamuy is the reason why I’ll never be able to use miso without thinking “osoma” first and frowning. Thank you for covering this masterpiece I love it beyond words. May your marriage be full of joy!
Thanks for a heads up for a series I was unaware of 👍
Dude as much as you tend to cover some obscure anime that youtube algorithm doesn't like. The quality of these videos are unparralelled and I have never seen anything near this level of commitment. I legit hope that one day I can be as committed and talented in writing and editing and voice as much as is evident in all of your videos. For someone who is a generic anime critic but enjoys some of the films (like myself) its amazing to see an analytical and factual tone when it comes to these stories. I can't wait to see what is in store for the future and I would listen and watch any of your videos even if you began to explore new topics. (You probs won't see this but hey, I had to say somewhere how much I appreciate it)
It's already in my top favorite Manga. Absolutely brutal, but as you said, an Hokkaido epic, and a masterpiece.
Treasure hunt? What are you talking about, GK is a great - no the best - cooking show!
This animanga has single handedly managed to make me laugh, educate me, touch my soul and has encouraged me to go back to my own roots and learn more about my own culture. Thank you Satoru Noda for this grim, strange, grotesque yet beautiful and touching story.
"terrifyingly detached sniper Ogata" you mean: my poor little meow meow?
Golden Kamuy, my second favorite manga and third favorite anime. I haven't finished it yet, but I'd say it's truly a masterpiece I'll never forget as long as I live. I can't wait for the rest of the manga volumes to be published where I live, we're currently at Volume 18.
Golden kamuy is one of my favorite titles and I'm extremely glad that someone reviewed it! It's very underrated. The story, humour and characters in manga are just amazing. I think those who like JoJo's bizarre adventure should also like GK.
Thanks for the video!
After completing the manga, it became my number 1 among all the manga... The narration method, the very elaborate plot, the manga's atmosphere, the comedy and the strange things are all wonderful
Beautiful video. Especially the part about acknowledging cultures not as exotic fixed points, but as people in change. Hope your marriage is beautiful as well - it too, isn’t necessarily an exotic fixed point, but about people in change, which can be beautiful in its own right
an amazing story, unlike any anime ever seen. A Japanese western, with comedy, culture and brutality. Golden Kamuy is a strong wine, enjoyed not by everyone, but delicious if you know how to drink it.
It looks very interesting! Just so different from the usual "teenage boy saves the world" trope!
I just finished this series and it's an easy 10/10. It's so weirdly not represented on youtube and seeing and hearing this video makes me want to show ALL of my friends. You so perfectly encapsulate every single thing I loved about this story, it's actually incredible how consistent the opinions of people who have read this feel about it. What a beautiful story
Apparently it’s pretty huge in Japan but hasn’t really managed to be popular outside of it. It’s a shame tbh, golden kamuy is such a great manga.
Everything of golden kamuy is so lovingly written of a great comedy, tragedy and adventure with amazing historic accuracy. Also bear maulings
0:21 This is the most beautiful graphic violence warning I've ever seen. Another wonderfully edited video as always, it really describes everything I love about Golden Kamuy. I never mind waiting for your videos because the wait is always worth the quality you deliver.
I'm now going to use this video whenever I want to get someone to read Golden Kamuy, you've explained better than I ever could why it's such an incredible series.
Finally someone extracts the huge value of this series, I must say, the characters are the most powerful aspect of the whole show, the author dives in each one’s interests and intentions deeply to the point you become attached to them.
Thanks for another entertaining video, keep it up.
Great video on a great work, with perfect timing as season 4 is coming out soon. It really was a "lived" in world with "real" characters, all of them were morally grey which is how we are. More so it was great to see the understanding/highlight that most of the cast are broken former soldiers... we had little understanding of what PTSD did you back then (hell in WW1 they finally began labeling it Shell Shock after all). Also reminded me that one of the fan scangroups that covered hit always had a end page of history facts that were referenced in Noda's work which really showed how much it studied and how much history there was with in it.
Yes! Everyday Heroes provided incredible glossary pages that really elevated the reading experience and extrapolated on all the themes, history and culture of any given chapter. They also reminded you of callbacks and references you might have otherwise forgotten - and that really sold how intricate and well thought out Noda's storytelling was. I actually tried fitting in a paragraph about their incredible work into this video but couldn't find a way to talk about them without it feeling like I was endorsing scans over the official translations. Luckily, for anyone reading this that might be about to start reading GK, they provide a download of just those glossary pages on their website.
Glad to see someone else who appreciated their work.
It's 2024, real live action movie has been just released in Japan, I'm looking forward to seeing it.
It's a shame nobody gave this series a chance over the CGI bear. But at least it holds a loyal fandom
Yeah, that sucks ass. Only the bears were really CGI and that was only for 1 season.
I am so happy you decided to cover my favorite manga, excellent work as always
I always have time for a video on Golden Kamuy.
Yes! This show needs some appreciation!
Golden Kamuy is a brilliant manga. Severely underrated by modern audiences.
GOLDEN KAMUY!!! One of my favorites to read and watch! Thank you for making the video!
Also new season hype!
One of the best manga I've ever read. Masterpiece
I loved golden kamui s anime adaptation and you are making me read the manga now ! Thx for the reminder mate!
Fantastic video, it makes me happy to have more people talking about this wonderful series. There really is nothing else like it.
golden kamuy is just a cooking manga/anime with action on the side
Adding to the list, thanks for the recommendation
Thanks for discussing it so eloquently, Nispa.
Your videos give me chills everytime
This video was put together amazingly omg 😭 the editing is fantastic!!
Have to admit this series passed me by but...
Detailed depiction of Ainu culture? That at the very least grabbed my interest~
30+ volumes would make my overstuffed bookshelves weep though
This just got me so hyped for the new season!!
This was an absolutely brilliant video. The script, the editing, and the narration was phenomenal. I came across Golden Kamuy because of a recommendation after finishing JJBA and I fell in love with the anime. After I caught up to the anime I’ve been slowly collecting the manga so I can binge read it all in one go but they’re really hard to come by where I live. Your video has inspired me to start writing my own script so I can also share the wonders of GK!! I doubt it’ll be as good as yours but I really really want more Western anime/manga fans to experience GK so we can have a huge fan base to talk about how great it is❤❤
An anime that'll forever be one of the most magical for me! It's so full of everything and so well delivered, it's an anime for all my moods!
Finally some recognition for this amazing series.
Finally! This is my favourite contemporary manga and anime by a long mile, and I’m surprised it isn’t more popular. Going to enjoy this video for sure. Meanwhile: congratulations on your marriage! 🎉🎉🎉
Thank you for a truly beautiful video of one of the best Animes I've never managed to get my friends to watch
Great video. I have only watched the first 3 episodes of the anime but I am considering picking up the manga. This series is exciting and educational. A great combination.
There is no need to apologise for the delay.
Thanks for making a video about this series, truly banger
My first comment on your channel. Your regal voice reminds me of the amazing Brit actor Jared Harris. It makes this video on Golden Kamuy & the majestic Ainu sounds even more dramatic and indeed the subject matter deserves such royal treatment.
Finally, an analysis of Golden Kamuy I can respect!
Thank you for making this, it kind of hurts my soul how poorly this manga/anime is represented on youtube, I've been looking for a decent analysis for a while now and yours might be the only one that holds up! Thank you for this well-made video that accurately highlights the beauty and unique nature of this story!
Fantastic video essay, thank you for making this. As a GK fan, this made me really happy.
Thank you for making such a wonderfully produced video about a work that is so close to my heart.
When I try to recommend the story to friends, I often don't know how to describe it. So thank you for now finding words where I was at a loss for words.
This has inspired me to pick up the manga and watch the anime. Thank you so much for covering this. You are by far my most favorite UA-camr when it comes to the coverage of anime. I've been subbed since you covered Cowboy Bebop, and you never fail to impress. Keep up the good work Joe! Also congratulations on your marriage, I pray that it endures until death.
What an absolutely awesome video! Golden Kamuy is my all time favorite series, the manga is unmatched and I'm so glad to see it get more traction!!
Thank you Joe ! I was starting to worry. Glad to see you’re back 😉
Your work, beyond being thoughtful and beautifully presented, is so calming. Every time I see new video I’m so happy because I know a piece of serenity awaits me. Thank you.
I saw an Asirpa t-shirt was in a loot crate like last year. I immediately ordered it, but because I live in bumb fuck nowhere it cost a damn fortune in exchange rate and shipping and took 6 months, but yeah it arrived yesterday. Worth it. Hinna Hinna.
Your editing is as meticulous and mesmerizing as always, and perhaps only surpassed by your beautiful scripts! Incredible video!
great video as always - superb editing
Beyond Ghibli never fails.
CONGRATULATIONS
The manga was top 5 for me, ending seemed good to not rushed or anything, I really hope this did numbers and the author got good money out of this
This anime took me by storm. I am still hooked to this day. Very sad that the production is at hold but it's completely understandable it has to be this way.
I'm reading it, also one day i want to go visit Hokkaido, It's been a dream of mine for a long time.
One of my friends continuously recommends this manga to me. And with this tone the video is setting, I am very excited to get back into it.
Congrats are due as well, so congrats on the wedding. Wish you all the best going forward.
Really good content here as always.
Beautiful, beautiful essay about my favourite manga/anime. You really did the story justice, and the excellent editing is just a cherry on top!
I never wanted to eat the squirrels in my neighborhood but then i read this story. Now I want to eat them all.
You will be pleased to know you convinced me to watch. And I am not disappointed
I absolutely love golden kamuy and I totally missed that you did a video on them !! This is gonna be a treat
The single most underrated thing ive ever consumed
More please! I love listening to your video essays and gaining a new perspective on anime that I enjoy watching. Thank you!
Your uploads never fail to make my day!
Thank you for your work!
Thank you for the heart, Joe! You're the best! I meant every word. 💖
I really do want a list of your all-time favorite Manga, though. I'm caught up with all the ones I'm following right now & almost finished with the ones that are completed & would absolutely love to know your favorites so I can read them, too!
that's amazing narration and editing skills you got there, you earned a subscriber! This is something similar I try to create, but you already mastered that style. I'll check more of your stuff
Great video. I loved the anime. I will look for the manga next.
Goddam it! after seeing all those incredible drawings i guess i'll have to buy the freaking Manga/Anime! Ty for making me waste my money!... True-talk: i'm gladly spending my money because the drawings look sick and the story is really interesting! LET'S GO! \o/
A masterpiece. One of my top 10.