If I had a nickel for every time Dylan has re-named a monkey in a movie to Travis, I'd have two nickels. Which isn't a lot, but it's weird that it happened twice.
Funny that you pointed out how well maintained Elizabeth's nails were because Keira Knightly admitted in the film's commentary that she went out and got a manicure when they told her not too 😂 They knew it wasn't realistic and she was like 'lol nah imma do it anyway'
This WAS definitely peak attractiveness for all the main cast. An almost scary amount of pretty filling the screen considering it's a gritty-goofy pirate romp. Thank you for the trip down memory lane!
This movie is better than it had any right to be considering it's just based on a lazy river ride. The music, the writing, the action, the cinematography it just oh CHEF'S KISS. And then the sequel actually does what a sequel SHOULD and BUILDS on that first movie. And for a movie that came out in 2006 the fact that Davy Jones looks AS GOOD AS HE DOES even now... Incredible.
the first 3 pirates movies are such a great trilogy. The first one is a masterpiece. The second one builds on the story and adds a great new villain. The third is an epic conclusion to it all and has one of the best act 3 battles I've ever seen.
To lift the curse, they needed the blood of the whole crew. The rest of the crew had already given theirs as they returned the gold, and Bootstraps was the one left they needed (or Will’s blood) to lifts the curse.
@@f.earless. I think during the day they still bleed when they’re hurt, but not at night when the curse is active, for example when they step in the moonlight?
@@egygizdaIn the standoff in the cave, Jack cuts his hand on his coin, and throws it to Will. Will drops both coins into the chest, alongside both of their blood.
The first film was genuinely so well made, they knew Pirate films had always been flops before this so they put so much effort into it, an ICONIC character introduction for Jack Sparrow and the right amount of fantasy, action that tells the story such as Will's fighting style vs Jack's, comedy and so on, perfectly paced, THE MUSIC... Keira Knightly.... what's not to like?
I also think the authentic feel was amazing between the costumes and props and makeup and especially the dialogue. They didn’t dumb it down for the audience but used what at least seems like “piratey talk” and language common to that era.
The first 3 films were soooo good, they are so well done I cannot even pick my favourite of the 3, but all are done so so well and I love the gradual transition in sadness and loss and seriousness from the first to the 3rd film. The 4th is okay, the romance thing between Jack and Anjelica is keeping the plot very interesting and fun to watch. The 5th one was honeslty kinda boring to me.. They stopped really caring about the quality of the movie, but just about "Yeah, it's already famous, let's just mass produce it". Even the Sparrow's lines became boring. They somehow made him into a boring character which is honestly disappointing but not surprising knowing Disney.
And something I noticed in this commentary was how excellent all of the setpieces were. Every fight scene was incredibly unique, none were simply people smashing swords together. Great film.
This movie is actually outrageously good though, like it’s the kind of movie your meant to think of as a guilty pleasure and just a kids movie, but it’s an actual masterpiece, everything about it. From the characters to the costumes to the soundtrack to Kiera knightly to dialogue to the setting to the plot to the hidden meanings and morals ect. ect. It’s incredible.
Right? I also saw a video by Stephan Krosecz here on youtube called "Accidentally Genius" about this movie. It sheds so much light on how much nuance and brilliance this movie has. Highly recommend giving it a watch.
The fact that Keira Knightley was literally EIGHTEEN when they started filming will ALWAYS blow my mind. It’s so crazy that these films have aged so beautifully and they’ll always be some of my favorites :)
she was 17 when they started filming but turned 18 on set. on the dvd special features lee arenberg did a video diary and filmed the moment when they brought her cake out.
The fact that Dylan says he was born in 2002 when we all know he’s 30 is the best subtle joke I’ve ever heard. Especially since it ties in to the fact that he constantly says he’s bad at math. This joke has layers which ties in to his Shrek video. Mind blown
I love how much Dylan appreciates the sword fighting scene with Will and Jack at the beginning. That scene is a whole category onto itself in mixing amazing cinematography, choreography, and score together into something outstanding and extraordinary.
It also establishes multiple character and plot elements, something only the best action scenes can do. Establishes that both Will and Jack are skilled swordfighters, Will because he wants to impress Elizabeth. Sets up Jack's pistol being important to him, and the mystery of who the bullet is for. Once again shows Will's master being given the credit for Will's work, which will be paid off later. Will throws a sword to stop Jack escaping, in the last scene Will throws a sword to stop Jack from being hanged and help him escape. There's probably more that I'm missing.
@@ForeverTraitor Absolutely, 100,%. Also some great character development as well, where some of their personality and thought processes are established too.
This movie was my awakening of bisexual panic purely due to Orlando Bloom and Keira Knightley. The writers knew what they were doing because I refuse to believe that they did not suffer the same panic. It is simply not possible they are too attractive even for straight people, you can’t only be attracted to one I simply refuse
Im a straight girl and.. Not attracted by any. Keira is really pretty but appreciating it doesnt make it attraction, and Orlando is not my type at all, but he is not ugly obviously I guess im a white bread then :(
@@youtubewontletme Orlando never did it for me either. Doesn't mean he aint handsome, dude def is hot as any. But being hot alone is not enough for me or it really has to be a certain type.
not only are we grateful for your uploading consistency, but we would also like to thank you for finishing and releasing that book in the shortest time ever AND going shopping. truly, thank you.
@@katrinabjorgan5516 that is the joke- there is no book cause he never released it cause he never finished it even though he says he’s almost done with it.
i honestly like how cartoonish these movies can get with the action scenes. nowadays everything has to be so realistic, it needs to be believable and logucal. i kinda miss this kind of movie that can be serious but goofy and a little cartoonish at the same time.
Not sure what action movies you've been watching that "have to be so realistic, believable, and logical." The majority are still cartoonish. The entire MCU, the Fast and Furious movies, Uncharted, Jurassic World, Jungle Cruise, etc.
@@amityislandchum i think they meant something like this: take the MCU, those movies are goofy and cartoonish in concept but they take themselves WAYY too seriously in their fights (outside of pretty lackluster one-liners). Pirates embraces its goofy moments by being over the top and ridiculous about them since the concept for a good fight is better than the logical aspect of it MCU fights only serve to move the plot forward, not to have fun. MCU movies as a whole ignore their silly origins most of the time and just focus on making them look mpre mature Uuhhhhhh yeah if that makes any sense lmao
@@amityislandchum The feeling that I get, is that this movie knows its there to just have fun. I was on the original Pirates ride in Disneyland a lot as a kid, and the scenes of people being chased by pirates or shot at by them was still cartoonish in its sense of humor even if it was a rather dark concept. Unlike a lot of the modern big blockbuster films, this movie's action scenes have a definite style of "playing pirates". It rings more of the 80s action scenes that despite being dangerous situations, just make me smile and have a good time. Most modern hollywood action films go for making me cringe or think about how bad a hit hurt. Both can be good, depending on what you want you audience to feel. I will give MCU a couple points to humor in a few of their fights, but because they're so CGI oriented they tend to be more about spectacle of powers and such rather than fun flavor. Its not bad to make the audience wince during fights, but we do seem to have a lot more of the gritty types of action scenes, and are seriously lacking in humorous fight choreography (think of the clever humor of Jackie Chan) as of the last decade.
Dylan, thank you SO MUCH for mentioning the SOUND EFFECTS! Sound designers get next to no credit for most movies because people just take it as a given.
Dylan gaslighting us into thinking it's Monday whenever he uploads will never stop being my favorite 😅 Edit: im glad im not the only one who falls for it🤣🤣🤣
Dylan constantly acknowledging how good looking both Keira Knightley and Orlando Bloom are in this movie is just to relatable. This movie was my Bisexual awakening
No one ever mentions how bootstrap was both cursed by the Aztec gold and a member of the Dutchmen later. He seems to go through the crew transformation faster than ANYONE, and personally I think that's why.
Hi Dylan, in case you're still wondering, they needed William Turner's blood to reverse the curse because they needed the blood of every crewmember that took the treasure when returning every single coin and they did so, with one coin unaccounted for (the one Elizabeth had that she took from Will when she saved him) and his blood, but since they couldn't find him anymore and when they got the coin they thought they came across his child (cuz ofc, she had his coin, saw the ship and her last name was Turner) they figured it would be much easier to use her blood than finding Will.
Dylan being turned on by sound effects is so funny, and him not giving a shit if there's people in his house or not just took the cake for me And funnily enough...I relate to all of it lol 🤣
Barbosa's last line of the movie kills me though because they've all become so depressed hanging in between death and life they don't feel anything anymore so he gets shot and says, "I feel...cold" with a smile on his face like he's happy to feel anything at all hsefhksh this movie is so unexpectedly good for just being based off of a disney ride it's crazy. edit: bro i got more to say actually, the consistency I just remembered when he comes back in a future movie he's eating an apple with a smile like that's such a small call back to this movie but clearly meant so much to his character why is the writing so GOOD??
dylan is notorious for two things. 1) making me hit the like button before the 30-second mark on every single video 2) consistently uploading videos every single monday for movie commentary monday
25:20 they needed Bill's blood (Will's blood) because Bill had stolen a coin from the chest. Barbossa and his crew had already given back their blood but the curse didn't lift because they needed everyone's blood. Since Bill left the crew after they abandoned Jack on an island he wasn't with them to lift the curse and give them/the chest his blood (with left I mean was thrown into the ocean). They weren't able to find him cuz he joined Jones's crew. I hope that helped!
bill never left the crew he was basically tide up and tossed overboard only joining jones crew basically under duress cause it was join the crew or die lol
I was legit thinking "Dylan hasn't watched a movie that actually gives him joy" and I am only 7 mins in and I love how happy Dylan is right now! Adorable!
Barbossa said that the curse applies only to those who stole the coin from the chest, Elizabeth didn’t steal it from the chest, she took it from Will who also didn’t take it from the chest, however Jack and the rest of the crew took it directly from the chest so the curse only applied to them. He also said the blood needs to be repaid, I assume the rest of the crew also gave their blood when they returned the coin, only Bootstrap’s (Will’s by proxy) and Jack’s blood was missing
The reason Jack got cursed and Elizabeth didn’t is that Jack took the coins from the chest. Elizabeth just “found” the coin on Will. I think the act of taking them from the chest specifically is what curses you.
I have developed a soft spot for James as I’ve grown up watching these movies cause he’s honestly such a good guy- putting aside the age difference thing- but he’s such a respectful, kind, and sweet man and if it weren’t for Will’s existence I think he would have been a good man for Elizabeth, he’s just a little boring since he’s so proper.
I watched POTC after watching tons of Jack Davenport in the show Coupling. His character was in that show was hilarious, so I was predisposed to favor his character in POTC. I was so glad they didn’t make him a total villain!😂
It's honestly so wholesome to watch Dylan gush over the more technical aspects of film like- the atmospherical elements and the sound effects and the way the movie is generally structured ? you can tell he's passionate.
this was a top-notch commentry dylan, i was laughing throughout the whole thing. you're so right about the vibes in this movie just making the leads so attractive. it sucks that the working environment wasn't the best bc it really is such a fun film.
Is this about Disney not providing the cast and crew life jackets while they filmed the movie and Depp giving everyone life jackets from his own money?
And if he heard anyone ask their servants to fetch anything besides butter, he could be like: "I can't believe it's not butter!" (Not sorry for aging myself with that joke.)
The coins themselves aren't cursed. It is the act of taking them, hence why Jack was cursed and not Elizabeth or Will. It's also interesting to think about how Bootstrap Bill has been immortally drowning for the past 10 years until the curse was finally lifted and Davy Jones abducted him onto the Flying Dutchman for even more eternal suffering :)
I read a post (on Tumblr I believe) that said that Norrington is a hero/romantic lead, but he’s in the wrong story. Norrington would make a FANTASTIC male lead in a Jane Austen-esque book/movie. He’s handsome, well-spoken, good, kind to others, high ranking in the military. If this was a Jane Austen book, Elizabeth would ADORE him. But alas, this is a ghost/pirate fantasy story, so he gets screwed over because in this genre good guys are bad guys.
potc is one of the best franchises i’ve ever watched, especially the original trilogy. the filmography, costumes, acting, plot line, script etc is impeccable. curse of the black pearl is one of my favourite films; i don’t think i’ll ever get tired of watching it. keira, orlando and johnny are such an amazing trio
don't know if you'll watch the rest, but i think the third movie you would REALLY love: - great cinematography - the prettiest everyone has ever been - the SCORE - the plot and the fight scenes and the story behind everything - THE CINEMATOGRAPHY it's truly a stunning movie just a recommendation
I hyperfixated on this movie so hard as a child, I had so much Pirates merchandise, I even had a Pirates themed birthday party and it was just a bunch of 11 year old girls dressed as pirates with fake moustaches and beards running around. It was great.
This movie franchise as well as Jurassic Park and Indiana Jones where my hyper-fixations as a kid, and honestly I still love them. I dressed up as Jack Sparrow in prep(?) but I got in trouble because the sword talked for some reason and wouldn’t stfu 😭😂
He had to cut out so much cool moments yet it still was hella fun. This movie is iconic. Dylan I beg you, do the trilogy because this movies are just amazing.
Dylan in this commentary: Did you hear that kid, you have to be a psychopath not to feel anything when that kid cried. Dylan in literally every other video: *Kill the child*
Can't remember where I read it, but Captain Jack walks like he's drunk on land because he's so used to being on the ocean. When he's on a ship, he walks perfectly straight. Fun fact :) Also, LOVE that Dylan wore his pirate outfit for this commentary.
Dylan appreciating both Keira and Orlando's attractiveness throughout this movie has me living. Who says we can't appreciate attractive people regardless of our sexuality??? Yahssss
@@realdavidjones1623 This is the comment section of a commentary video. This is literally the place to bring things like that up and it was a very real part of the commentary. Dylan expressed a significant amount of times how attractive he found them both. He isn't concerned about perceptions or assumptions. You on the other hand appear very insecure.
The way I've always thought Barbossa's death was meant to be explained is that going in and out of moonlight basically reset their bodies when their flesh disappeared and then reappeared. Hence why Jack's injury from being stabbed by Barbosa didn't kill him.
Maybe, but I think them being cursed in general is why nothing happened. Barbossa wasn't in the moonlight when he was killed, and Jack could've been acting when he was stabbed. Plus, Barbossa wasn't affected at all when Elizabeth stabbed him before seeing all of them cursed. But, I see your point.
@@monsterhanna6691 Well, when Jack shot him, Barbossa didn't go back into the moonlight before the curse was lifted, but Jack did go back into the moonlight and back several times after being stabbed.
Something I feel like we don’t appreciate Dylan for enough is that he’s worked behind the scenes on shoots and he knows a lot about filmmaking. I legitimately learn something every time I watch one of his videos and it’s great. Didn’t know what rack focus was until today, now I do~
The thing is, they need everyone’s blood (all the pirates who stole and used the gold) to free the curse. The whole crew. William Turner father was also cursed so they needed his blood as well. The other pirates already gave their blood and gold, but they got rid of Turner and then discovered they needed his blood.
@@juliak8684 but Jack was cursed when he took the gold in the final scene, so that Barbossa couldn't kill him. Will gave his blood and the curse was broken vor everyone, including Jack (who never gave his own blood)
I love how Dylan’s like “why’s everyone so attractive in this movie” when this movie was used in Heartstopper to help show one character’s bisexuality 😭🤣😭
So you’re telling me…that one “that looks like a man who just won a lawsuit” line is what people wanted to cancel you over?!?!?!?! People can’t be serious
All I’m saying is if you did a commentary on the entire franchise that would be the most entertaining thing ever! But under no circumstances is this a recommendation 😉
Absolutely loved this movie. Fun Fact: The ship the used for the Interceptor was also Captain Hook's Jolly Roger in the show Once Upon A Time where Lee Arenberg (one of the pirates from this movie) plays Grumpy the dwarf
25:20 They needed the blood because when the crew stole the coins, they fell under a curse. To break it, they needed to return all pieces and their blood. However because they cast away Will's dad, not all pieces were returned. So with the medallion and Will's blood, they could become human again
One of my favorite details about this movie is Jack's line: "This shot is not meant for you." It is a very vague but intriguing line that introduces the upcoming villain in this story!!!! And it opens up the question, "What is Jack's story?"
Dylan if you haven’t watched the behind the scenes videos documenting the making of these movies, I suggest you do (not for UA-cam, just for you) as they were filmed on location and used practical effects as much as possible. It’s a really interesting watch!
Do you think it was Dylan’s fantastic Jack Sparrow impression that caused his college to go “right that’s it, we won’t get any better than this dude right here” and closed up for good?
Gosh, the PotC trilogy is literally such a masterpiece (4 and 5 don't exist). I'm so glad Dylan agrees on how well it still holds up!! Also that Elizabeth & Will are the hottest fictional couple ever put to screen.....Heartstopper did not lie, they were legit my bisexual awakening 😂❤ Hope you keep watching the next 2 movies!!
The 4th movies wasn't terrible and its actually connected to the trilogy even thought its a "breakaway" from the original story line of the trilogy. At the end of the 3rd movies Jack is seen with the chart and it shows one of the Chalices "Aqua De Vida" and "Ponce De Leon" who the chalices belong too leading Jack to look for the Fountain of Youth. But yeah the 5th movie defiantly isn't great. But if you look up the time lines of all 5 movies it makes since how they all sort of connect.
Eh, even if you believe JD's team didn't use DARVO to win... he was such a disgusting POS in his text messages that I don't know how anyone can enjoy his movies now. Granted, I would never remotely call any of those movies a "masterpiece" to begin with, they were just fun action movies that Disney pumped a lot of money into, and don't we just love Disney profits 🤩
@@emmar2675 thats good for you, truly! personally tho i rlly didnt enjoy the 4th movie, to me PoTC works best with Will and Elizabeth's dynamic being intertwined with Jack's journey...without it Jack is just comedy relief without much heart anymore. Thats my opinion though.
Are you telling me we are just starting the week?? All this time I thought it was Thursday, but it definitely is Monday if Dylan is posting a movie commentary! He's always so consistent.
how thoughtful of him to remind us what day of the week it is just in case we lose track. I for one also thought it was Thursday today, clearly I need my brain checked 😂
It's so refreshing to see Dylan watch (an enjoy!) an actually good movie. It's also fun to see him thirst over Orlando Bloom and Kiera Knightley as Will and Elizabeth, who are very much a classic I-had-my-bisexual-awakening-seeing-them-together-and-can't-choose-one-or-the-other couple
When this movie came out on DVD, my sister set a goal to watch it everyday for a month (we were weird) and I often watched it with her and yet I've never grown tired of this movie. It's just fun and exciting the whole way through.
Would really love Dylan to watch “The road to El Dorado” it’s an animation but this was definitely made for adults 😂!! the humour is excellent and very underrated!
11:43 "you need a crew like a minimum of 10 men" I honestly can't tell if this is a One Piece joke. You need: 1: A capitan, 2: First mate, 3: Storyteller, 4: Chef, 5: Navigator, 6: Doctor, 7: Historian, 8 Shipwright, 9: Musician, 10: Helmsman
I remember being obsessed with these movies as a teenager. I also remember watching it with commentary from Keira Knightly and Jack Davenport and they pointed out the Beverly Hills manicure too 😂
I always assumed the "blood to be repaid" was each one of the pirates that took the coins had to repay with blood. So when Will's dad was sent to the depths of the ocean(cursed to live forever in the crushing black thanks to sending a coin to his son) the pirates weren't able to repay everyone's blood and break the curse. That's how I understood the needing the blood of Will🤗.
Thats exactly what had to be done. Jack also bled on the coin he took, you can see it being bloody when he throws it to Will......I always thought that part was very obvious 🤷♀ But I guess Dylan just didn't catch it.
I literally just go back to my home page and low and behold there's Dylan, just making my day on this lovely Monday. Pirates of the Caribbean will always be my favorite, a staple of my childhood.
The scene in Heartstopper where Nick watches this movie and then googles “bisexuality” is honestly the best choice they could have made because everyone in this is beautiful
7:44 the thing about the first POTC movie is that no one thought it would work...before it ever became a franchise, it was a theme park ride turned into a movie (something the Jungle Cruise movie desperately tried to recreate)... and it did so well and that's owed to just how free everyone was in this film... you can see how much fun they're having both in front and behind the camera..
I think this is my favourite commentary you've done. This whole thing was us getting to laugh with you, and then Dylan being so turned on by the actors, crushing on Will, Elizabeth and Jack hahaha
Everyone who stole the gold needs to give their blood to remove the curse, thats why they need Will's blood, because his father was part of the crew that removed the coins from the chest.
I remember watching this movie when I was in 7th grade and having such an in-depth realization about Jack Sparrow and Will Turner's first fight scene: Jack and Will are essentially character foils of each other. Both pirates (or of pirate origin) and both excellent swordsmen. However Jack Sparrow's moral compass is skewed. He is chaotic, sly, and breaks rules left and right. By contrast, Will Turner is a law abiding citizen with a strong sense of morality. We can literally see this in their fighting styles. Will's sword fighting is learned and follows the rules of fencing with perfect form. Jack's is just as quick and skilled, but is chaotic and unexpected. Pitted against each other, they are an even match. The only reason Jack wins is because he cheats! The writers did such an excellent job of telling us all about their personalities in a 3 minute fight scene 😂
It's 3.17am, finished uni, summer holiday has started, eating a lolly pop, some fruits shoot and having a rewatch binge of Dylan. Overlooking being back at the house that makes me want to....life is a vibe rn.
I’d love to be a pirate. Setting aside the fact that I can’t swim, get extreme motion sickness, have a fear of the ocean, have pasty skin that burns in seconds, get crippling guilt whenever I break rules, and hate most alcohol… outside all of that I think it would be awesome!
Dylan is the absolute best movie commentator! He is always speaking exactly what we're all thinking while simultaneously pointing out things I have never noticed before, all while being freaking hilarious.
Dylan is literally one of the only youtubers i laugh out loud to each time i watch his videos. I DIED laughing when that kid at the beginning screamed i just KNEW he was going to laugh and comment on it. this is one of my fav movie commentaries
Actually the stuff we know about pirates is wildly wrong. They weren't as filthy and bathed as regularly as they could, few had guns because they were expensive and required a bit of knowledge to use. Most you'd find the captain with a gun. Pirates used mostly crude weapons. There are so many myths that are laughable but that does change how awesome the stories are.
@@audramcdonaldapologist3676 well every sailor had those, not just pirates. They were diseases you would get from lack of good food after months at sea. Now, for the STDs.... well, cant get condoms in the 17th century
A lot of them were also former Navy soldiers who weren't compensated after fighting and losing limbs, so they turned to piracy to spite the government that abandoned them. I learned about this years ago when I was studying children's literature, specifically a section that discussed Hook's character in Peter Pan and the possibility that he was a soldier before he became a pirate! Post-Edit: Once Upon A Time actually went down the route of Hook (Killian Jones) being a former soldier.
![Lp. Сердце Вселенной #60 РОЖДЕНИЕ ЛОЛОЛОШКИ [Финал] • Майнкрафт](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/YoR0pAV9FVQ/mqdefault.jpg)
Dylan's urge to call every monkey Travis is just hilarious.
No, I think it's quite the travisty...👀
@@joex1084 I hate that I find this funny
Imagine him watching and commenting Planet of the Apes, calling every ape Travis.
@@zeroknight4517 Well, to be fair, I'm sure at least *one* of them would earn the name Monk-Monk. 😆🐵
yes
Dylan works with Audible so much, I can’t wait for them to advertise his book when it comes out in the year 2050
🤣🤣🤣🤣
😂😂😂
Shots fired 🤣🤣🤣
@Mickey Holmes fr give him more time😂
2050... ya maybe the first draft
If I had a nickel for every time Dylan has re-named a monkey in a movie to Travis, I'd have two nickels. Which isn't a lot, but it's weird that it happened twice.
i definitely saw it coming but at the same time i didn’t haha
LMFAOOO 😭😭
I literally thought all of this too while watching it. I bestow a like upon you. ;)
Is this a John Mulaney reference?
@@gambare.gambare it's a Phineas and Ferb reference
Funny that you pointed out how well maintained Elizabeth's nails were because Keira Knightly admitted in the film's commentary that she went out and got a manicure when they told her not too 😂 They knew it wasn't realistic and she was like 'lol nah imma do it anyway'
Dude that's really interesting! Thanks for sharing!
Idk, they could have still made them look a bit dirtier at leastXD
Okay but like why is the thumbnail so much longer than all the others? Am I the only one who noticed that?
That is the most pirate thing I've ever heard 😂
@AZBYCX spill what movie
Dylan constantly being in awe of the incredible beauty that Keira and Orlando possesses is so relatable. They really are gods
I always hated their characters in this movies 😂
@@Shaea_Q I just didn't like Keira's character. Kinda irritating to me, but I get irritated easily anyway.
Jack Davenport got called average looking bruh imagine what an ugly guy looks like to dylan
Eww
I don’t know about you…but I’d hitch my wagon to Jack Davenport rather than the other two😂
dylan literally thinking someone could possibly be robbing his house while filming this video and then subsequently deciding not to care is a MOOD
TF does that mean
@@captainjacksparrow1518 the statement is pretty self explanatory. What might you need help with?
@@captainjacksparrow1518 just watch this 23:20 again.
the comment was basically saying Dylan's monologue & reaction to his situation was funny
This happened in the video right when I read this comment lol
@@shi.survives LMFAOOO the way you said this
I genuinely can’t remember ever seeing Dylan this happy on a commentary
tangled erasure
LITERALLY WHAT I SAIS WATCHING THIS
Besides tangled
Him watching The oc is so cute and happy
tangled is prob the only time
This WAS definitely peak attractiveness for all the main cast. An almost scary amount of pretty filling the screen considering it's a gritty-goofy pirate romp. Thank you for the trip down memory lane!
I’d argue Kiera Knightley was more attractive when she was of legal age buddy. 👮♀️
the cast of the first scream movie fits that description perfectly too.
after watching Dylan suffer through a WHOLE lot of garbage movies it is nice to see him actually enjoy this
Yes! I wanna see him watch more good movies too
@@katiehaley2850 planet of the apes trilogy is a must
I literally wouldn’t know what day it was if not for Dylan always being on schedule.
Exactly
I literally base my schedules off movie commentary Mondays because Dylan is so consistent.
Happy movie commentary Monday guys
My meetings applaud him
Right! Dylan is sooo consistent on knowing what day it is 😄
This movie is better than it had any right to be considering it's just based on a lazy river ride. The music, the writing, the action, the cinematography it just oh CHEF'S KISS.
And then the sequel actually does what a sequel SHOULD and BUILDS on that first movie. And for a movie that came out in 2006 the fact that Davy Jones looks AS GOOD AS HE DOES even now...
Incredible.
the first 3 pirates movies are such a great trilogy. The first one is a masterpiece. The second one builds on the story and adds a great new villain. The third is an epic conclusion to it all and has one of the best act 3 battles I've ever seen.
And then we don’t speak of 4 or 5.
@@camillechandler4431 Movies 4 and 5 who's she never heard of her.
Wait non american here i didnt know the ride was created before the movie
@@anais6654 yeah I was abt to write a sarcastic comment until I found it that it’s true and the ride was made before the movie
To lift the curse, they needed the blood of the whole crew. The rest of the crew had already given theirs as they returned the gold, and Bootstraps was the one left they needed (or Will’s blood) to lifts the curse.
👁️👄👁️ omg
But if cursed members of the crew don’t bleed then how did they give their blood while returning the gold? That’s the part I never understood
@@f.earless. I think during the day they still bleed when they’re hurt, but not at night when the curse is active, for example when they step in the moonlight?
but wouldn't they need jack's blood then too, since he cursed himself at the end?
@@egygizdaIn the standoff in the cave, Jack cuts his hand on his coin, and throws it to Will. Will drops both coins into the chest, alongside both of their blood.
I like how Dylan just casually threw us into another dimension by saying he was born in 2002.
Lol he was joking. He's 30 or 31, I believe. Haha
I'm gay (essentially bad at maths) so I thought that was a normal year for him to he born than I was like 'oh aye hold the jar of dirt'
babe is gaslighting us and we don't even complain
Lmao there’s no way he was gonna be younger than me
i’m born in 2002 and i got so shook i thought he was serious😭
the fact that people are genuinely believing he’s 20 when he just turned 31 is sending me into orbit 💀 lol he really do be lying for fun
I BELIEVED HAHAHAHAHA
I actually malfunctioned for a sec I was like how is he 2 years older than me
How can people think that he was 15 in his first videos 😁
I believed it for a second and then was like wait that doesn’t make any sense!!!
Dude I almost lost my mind until I saw this comment
The first film was genuinely so well made, they knew Pirate films had always been flops before this so they put so much effort into it, an ICONIC character introduction for Jack Sparrow and the right amount of fantasy, action that tells the story such as Will's fighting style vs Jack's, comedy and so on, perfectly paced, THE MUSIC... Keira Knightly.... what's not to like?
I also think the authentic feel was amazing between the costumes and props and makeup and especially the dialogue. They didn’t dumb it down for the audience but used what at least seems like “piratey talk” and language common to that era.
I feel dead man's chest was the best of the bunch. I don't know I just love davy jones. Then come curse of the black pearl.
The first 3 films were soooo good, they are so well done I cannot even pick my favourite of the 3, but all are done so so well and I love the gradual transition in sadness and loss and seriousness from the first to the 3rd film.
The 4th is okay, the romance thing between Jack and Anjelica is keeping the plot very interesting and fun to watch.
The 5th one was honeslty kinda boring to me.. They stopped really caring about the quality of the movie, but just about "Yeah, it's already famous, let's just mass produce it". Even the Sparrow's lines became boring. They somehow made him into a boring character which is honestly disappointing but not surprising knowing Disney.
And something I noticed in this commentary was how excellent all of the setpieces were. Every fight scene was incredibly unique, none were simply people smashing swords together. Great film.
Just based on the 'attractiveness' factor, Keira was number 1. I honestly wasn't able to not look at her throughout this trilogy.
This movie is actually outrageously good though, like it’s the kind of movie your meant to think of as a guilty pleasure and just a kids movie, but it’s an actual masterpiece, everything about it. From the characters to the costumes to the soundtrack to Kiera knightly to dialogue to the setting to the plot to the hidden meanings and morals ect. ect. It’s incredible.
Right? I also saw a video by Stephan Krosecz here on youtube called "Accidentally Genius" about this movie. It sheds so much light on how much nuance and brilliance this movie has. Highly recommend giving it a watch.
I like that you’re listing the things that make this movie a masterpiece and you simply said “and Keira Knightly”
Keira Knightly as her own category is so real
@@nicholesandlin5141 she deserves her own category
The fact that Keira Knightley was literally EIGHTEEN when they started filming will ALWAYS blow my mind. It’s so crazy that these films have aged so beautifully and they’ll always be some of my favorites :)
Actually, she was 17 when they filmed it. It's just weird to me to watch some of the scenes now.
I never think about her being that young in this! 😱
As someone already commented, she was 17 during filming. Orlando was 24-25 and Johnny was almost 40. Just some context.
@@edwardcullenasseater 40!? I mean, that tracks numerically, but damn, I thought he was in his early 30's here.
she was 17 when they started filming but turned 18 on set. on the dvd special features lee arenberg did a video diary and filmed the moment when they brought her cake out.
The fact that Dylan says he was born in 2002 when we all know he’s 30 is the best subtle joke I’ve ever heard.
Especially since it ties in to the fact that he constantly says he’s bad at math. This joke has layers which ties in to his Shrek video.
Mind blown
I was like "Dude, stop lying" LOL
@@Eringdahls LOL I love when he changes his age constantly.
He actually got me for like a split second, i was like 🤔🤔 "I thought... But he... What?" And then remembered 😂
I was so confused cause I know he was suppose to be much older
@@annasim3651 He has a new age in every video and it kills me in the best way possible haha
I love how much Dylan appreciates the sword fighting scene with Will and Jack at the beginning. That scene is a whole category onto itself in mixing amazing cinematography, choreography, and score together into something outstanding and extraordinary.
It also establishes multiple character and plot elements, something only the best action scenes can do.
Establishes that both Will and Jack are skilled swordfighters, Will because he wants to impress Elizabeth.
Sets up Jack's pistol being important to him, and the mystery of who the bullet is for.
Once again shows Will's master being given the credit for Will's work, which will be paid off later.
Will throws a sword to stop Jack escaping, in the last scene Will throws a sword to stop Jack from being hanged and help him escape.
There's probably more that I'm missing.
@@ForeverTraitor Absolutely, 100,%. Also some great character development as well, where some of their personality and thought processes are established too.
it’s one of my fav movie scenes ever.
This movie was my awakening of bisexual panic purely due to Orlando Bloom and Keira Knightley. The writers knew what they were doing because I refuse to believe that they did not suffer the same panic. It is simply not possible they are too attractive even for straight people, you can’t only be attracted to one I simply refuse
The guy from Heartstopper is feeling you ahah
Im a straight girl and.. Not attracted by any. Keira is really pretty but appreciating it doesnt make it attraction, and Orlando is not my type at all, but he is not ugly obviously
I guess im a white bread then :(
@@youtubewontletme Orlando never did it for me either. Doesn't mean he aint handsome, dude def is hot as any. But being hot alone is not enough for me or it really has to be a certain type.
it was depp and knightly for me. i like orlando but depp stole the show imo
@@youtubewontletme same
I love the fact that Dylan just agrees that Keira Knightley and Orlando Bloom in Pirates Of The Caribbean are the best looking people to ever exist
It's giving "the casting director for The Mummy (1999) must have been bi to chose such overwhelmingly attrative leads" vibes
Nick Nelson agrees
@@emilybanks5055 😭bahaha
@@emilybanks5055 I loved that scene gbhahaha
@@emilybanks5055 I was thinking about that lol
not only are we grateful for your uploading consistency, but we would also like to thank you for finishing and releasing that book in the shortest time ever AND going shopping. truly, thank you.
DAMN he is productive
The book was amazing, but the ending was a bit rushed
Not to mention his fashion sense is amazing. Like who would ever wear a backpack shirt? Not our god of fashion that’s for sure.
what book??
@@katrinabjorgan5516 that is the joke- there is no book cause he never released it cause he never finished it even though he says he’s almost done with it.
i honestly like how cartoonish these movies can get with the action scenes. nowadays everything has to be so realistic, it needs to be believable and logucal. i kinda miss this kind of movie that can be serious but goofy and a little cartoonish at the same time.
Not sure what action movies you've been watching that "have to be so realistic, believable, and logical." The majority are still cartoonish. The entire MCU, the Fast and Furious movies, Uncharted, Jurassic World, Jungle Cruise, etc.
@@amityislandchum lmaooo agreed. Maybe they mean more “mature”?
@@amityislandchum i think they meant something like this: take the MCU, those movies are goofy and cartoonish in concept but they take themselves WAYY too seriously in their fights (outside of pretty lackluster one-liners).
Pirates embraces its goofy moments by being over the top and ridiculous about them since the concept for a good fight is better than the logical aspect of it
MCU fights only serve to move the plot forward, not to have fun. MCU movies as a whole ignore their silly origins most of the time and just focus on making them look mpre mature
Uuhhhhhh yeah if that makes any sense lmao
Recently i rewatched a few 2000s Bollywood movies and this is particularly apparent in those lol
@@amityislandchum The feeling that I get, is that this movie knows its there to just have fun. I was on the original Pirates ride in Disneyland a lot as a kid, and the scenes of people being chased by pirates or shot at by them was still cartoonish in its sense of humor even if it was a rather dark concept. Unlike a lot of the modern big blockbuster films, this movie's action scenes have a definite style of "playing pirates". It rings more of the 80s action scenes that despite being dangerous situations, just make me smile and have a good time. Most modern hollywood action films go for making me cringe or think about how bad a hit hurt. Both can be good, depending on what you want you audience to feel. I will give MCU a couple points to humor in a few of their fights, but because they're so CGI oriented they tend to be more about spectacle of powers and such rather than fun flavor. Its not bad to make the audience wince during fights, but we do seem to have a lot more of the gritty types of action scenes, and are seriously lacking in humorous fight choreography (think of the clever humor of Jackie Chan) as of the last decade.
Dylan, thank you SO MUCH for mentioning the SOUND EFFECTS!
Sound designers get next to no credit for most movies because people just take it as a given.
Dylan gaslighting us into thinking it's Monday whenever he uploads will never stop being my favorite 😅
Edit: im glad im not the only one who falls for it🤣🤣🤣
Nah cuz I really thought it was a Monday for a minute💀💀
Oh shit it's not Monday.....I literally thought it was until I read this comment🤣🤣
@@fflarexx9061 what are you talking about… it is Monday
@@jads_edwards2818 no it is Monday! Obviously it is or Dylan wouldn’t be uploading 🥱
times really going fast, damn, its already monday 😔 👊
Dylan constantly acknowledging how good looking both Keira Knightley and Orlando Bloom are in this movie is just to relatable. This movie was my Bisexual awakening
But then I remember Kiera was 17 at the beginning of filming (lying about her age at audition) 😳😳
Thats literally nick nelson
@@saramendoza7375 bro literally 😭
I watch trap videos as well good sir
Literally me hahahahaha
No one ever mentions how bootstrap was both cursed by the Aztec gold and a member of the Dutchmen later. He seems to go through the crew transformation faster than ANYONE, and personally I think that's why.
There's also the fact he pledged his soul for eternity by losing the game between him, Will, and Jones
Man is just handing out his soul and getting cursed like he's the Dragonborn, you kinda gotta respect it.
Hi Dylan, in case you're still wondering, they needed William Turner's blood to reverse the curse because they needed the blood of every crewmember that took the treasure when returning every single coin and they did so, with one coin unaccounted for (the one Elizabeth had that she took from Will when she saved him) and his blood, but since they couldn't find him anymore and when they got the coin they thought they came across his child (cuz ofc, she had his coin, saw the ship and her last name was Turner) they figured it would be much easier to use her blood than finding Will.
Isn't there some medieval logic where you get your flesh from your ma but your blood is your dad's? I'm sure I'm misremembering that
I think you mean Finding bill turner right? Cause they don’t know will?
@@BungieBannana They left bootstrap bill at the bottom of the ocean. They were looking for his child, they just didn’t know who his child was.
But they can't bleed while still cursed? So how are they supposed to shed their blood?
@@sheaneal290 That's what I'm wondering..
as a 02' kid, the amount of people actually believing dylan was born in 2002 is extremely hilarious
Ik I was like sir I thought u were thirty
i’m a 01’s kid but still, i don’t understand how everyone thought he was around our age 😭😭
im a 01 kid and i was so confused, bc i know there's no way hes my age or younger but my brain stopped working lol
I’m those people. Only reason I came to comment section.
@@ashleygoetz7847 dude same, this man is my age? with this humor? damn lmaoo
Dylan being turned on by sound effects is so funny, and him not giving a shit if there's people in his house or not just took the cake for me
And funnily enough...I relate to all of it lol 🤣
Barbosa's last line of the movie kills me though because they've all become so depressed hanging in between death and life they don't feel anything anymore so he gets shot and says, "I feel...cold" with a smile on his face like he's happy to feel anything at all hsefhksh this movie is so unexpectedly good for just being based off of a disney ride it's crazy.
edit: bro i got more to say actually, the consistency I just remembered when he comes back in a future movie he's eating an apple with a smile like that's such a small call back to this movie but clearly meant so much to his character why is the writing so GOOD??
dylan is notorious for two things. 1) making me hit the like button before the 30-second mark on every single video 2) consistently uploading videos every single monday for movie commentary monday
I hit the like button before even watching. I know I’m not gonna unlike it.
25:20 they needed Bill's blood (Will's blood) because Bill had stolen a coin from the chest. Barbossa and his crew had already given back their blood but the curse didn't lift because they needed everyone's blood. Since Bill left the crew after they abandoned Jack on an island he wasn't with them to lift the curse and give them/the chest his blood (with left I mean was thrown into the ocean). They weren't able to find him cuz he joined Jones's crew. I hope that helped!
Oh and for the people wondering why Jack didn't give his blood. He did actually. Right before he throws the coin at Will!
bill never left the crew he was basically tide up and tossed overboard only joining jones crew basically under duress cause it was join the crew or die lol
@@dustincieslik5397 yeah I know! I meant that he wasn’t part of the crew anymore 😅
@@novamariewilson7414 and I get that just wanted to clarify further xD hope you are having a good day btw
@@dustincieslik5397 yeah thanks! ✨ I’m having a great day wbu?!
I was legit thinking "Dylan hasn't watched a movie that actually gives him joy" and I am only 7 mins in and I love how happy Dylan is right now! Adorable!
Oh but he enjoyed titanic and tangled a lot too!! They're impeccable commentaries as well. Just him having a good time
and harry potter
Barbossa said that the curse applies only to those who stole the coin from the chest, Elizabeth didn’t steal it from the chest, she took it from Will who also didn’t take it from the chest, however Jack and the rest of the crew took it directly from the chest so the curse only applied to them. He also said the blood needs to be repaid, I assume the rest of the crew also gave their blood when they returned the coin, only Bootstrap’s (Will’s by proxy) and Jack’s blood was missing
The reason Jack got cursed and Elizabeth didn’t is that Jack took the coins from the chest. Elizabeth just “found” the coin on Will. I think the act of taking them from the chest specifically is what curses you.
I think this is also true because the people they have sold the coins to would have also been cursed
I feel bad for people who don’t watch Dylan consistently and believe everything he says like the first minute and a half of this video 💀
I’ve been watching him for a while and I believed it oml 😭
Me 🙃
I believed it and thought it was hilarious that he looks this old already. He'll purchase a rotary phone off Craigslist by age 25 lol
and monday???
People really out here saying Dylan isn’t the most consistent UA-camr. smh
i swear like am out here needing breaks from all his constant uploads
Dylan got turned on by a sword sound affect
@@Glynn1087 are you implying that you didn't?
@@Glynn1087 we all did what are you talking about 🤨🤨
They're very clearly delusional
I have developed a soft spot for James as I’ve grown up watching these movies cause he’s honestly such a good guy- putting aside the age difference thing- but he’s such a respectful, kind, and sweet man and if it weren’t for Will’s existence I think he would have been a good man for Elizabeth, he’s just a little boring since he’s so proper.
I love James!!
Legit, Elizabeth was the worst thing to happen to James. Like, she played his heartstrings to his very death
I watched POTC after watching tons of Jack Davenport in the show Coupling. His character was in that show was hilarious, so I was predisposed to favor his character in POTC. I was so glad they didn’t make him a total villain!😂
It's honestly so wholesome to watch Dylan gush over the more technical aspects of film like- the atmospherical elements and the sound effects and the way the movie is generally structured ? you can tell he's passionate.
this was a top-notch commentry dylan, i was laughing throughout the whole thing. you're so right about the vibes in this movie just making the leads so attractive. it sucks that the working environment wasn't the best bc it really is such a fun film.
Oh, really? Apart from the actress of Anamaria everyone seemed to praise the working environment... especially our 3 leads
Is this about Disney not providing the cast and crew life jackets while they filmed the movie and Depp giving everyone life jackets from his own money?
You having your "servants" fetch butter is actually very realistic as fresh butter would have been a wealthy/royal thing to have. Good job, Dylan. A+
And if he heard anyone ask their servants to fetch anything besides butter, he could be like: "I can't believe it's not butter!" (Not sorry for aging myself with that joke.)
The coins themselves aren't cursed. It is the act of taking them, hence why Jack was cursed and not Elizabeth or Will. It's also interesting to think about how Bootstrap Bill has been immortally drowning for the past 10 years until the curse was finally lifted and Davy Jones abducted him onto the Flying Dutchman for even more eternal suffering :)
Dylan starting the video by gaslighting us is honestly a blessing
Wdym gaslighting he uploads every monday😡
@@hamnahiftikhar8958 it’s Thursday
@@moviemelody2210 it’s clearly monday. he said it’s monday, so it must be. why would he lie?
I read a post (on Tumblr I believe) that said that Norrington is a hero/romantic lead, but he’s in the wrong story. Norrington would make a FANTASTIC male lead in a Jane Austen-esque book/movie. He’s handsome, well-spoken, good, kind to others, high ranking in the military. If this was a Jane Austen book, Elizabeth would ADORE him. But alas, this is a ghost/pirate fantasy story, so he gets screwed over because in this genre good guys are bad guys.
great point! i’ve always thought of norrington as a fine gentleman, and it is sad seeing how he ends
love this point!
How is he a good guy? He groomed her since she was a little girl.
Great character. Wrong Elizabeth
potc is one of the best franchises i’ve ever watched, especially the original trilogy. the filmography, costumes, acting, plot line, script etc is impeccable. curse of the black pearl is one of my favourite films; i don’t think i’ll ever get tired of watching it. keira, orlando and johnny are such an amazing trio
I can't describe how much I love the first three movies
don't know if you'll watch the rest, but i think the third movie you would REALLY love:
- great cinematography
- the prettiest everyone has ever been
- the SCORE
- the plot and the fight scenes and the story behind everything
- THE CINEMATOGRAPHY it's truly a stunning movie
just a recommendation
I hyperfixated on this movie so hard as a child, I had so much Pirates merchandise, I even had a Pirates themed birthday party and it was just a bunch of 11 year old girls dressed as pirates with fake moustaches and beards running around. It was great.
Honestly sounds like a great Birthday Party.
This movie franchise as well as Jurassic Park and Indiana Jones where my hyper-fixations as a kid, and honestly I still love them. I dressed up as Jack Sparrow in prep(?) but I got in trouble because the sword talked for some reason and wouldn’t stfu 😭😂
that sounds awesomee
Dylan trying to convince me that he’s only one year older than me, an 18 year old born in 2003, is honestly the highlight of my day
i started watching him years ago knowing he was grown man and i was actually born in 2002 and he still had me convinced for like, half a second
Same
Same. I believe him to be honest
He had to cut out so much cool moments yet it still was hella fun. This movie is iconic. Dylan I beg you, do the trilogy because this movies are just amazing.
Dylan in this commentary: Did you hear that kid, you have to be a psychopath not to feel anything when that kid cried.
Dylan in literally every other video: *Kill the child*
Can't remember where I read it, but Captain Jack walks like he's drunk on land because he's so used to being on the ocean. When he's on a ship, he walks perfectly straight. Fun fact :)
Also, LOVE that Dylan wore his pirate outfit for this commentary.
Dylan appreciating both Keira and Orlando's attractiveness throughout this movie has me living. Who says we can't appreciate attractive people regardless of our sexuality??? Yahssss
Must you be so cringey? That didn't even have to be brought up
@@realdavidjones1623 This is the comment section of a commentary video. This is literally the place to bring things like that up and it was a very real part of the commentary. Dylan expressed a significant amount of times how attractive he found them both. He isn't concerned about perceptions or assumptions. You on the other hand appear very insecure.
It kinda reminds of the scene in Heartstopper where Nick realizes how bi he really is by watching this movie
This is normal tbh. I'm not even bi/lesbian but women be hitting different for me every time, man.
You’re the one making it seem out of ordinary to find more than one gender attractive.
I love the repertoire of inside jokes that Dylan has built up over the years with his viewers. What skill 👏
Classic misdirect!
*cough COLLEGE IS A SCAM *cough
TRAVIS
I just click on his videos an wait for the moment he yells 'misdirect' to then get misdirected by the thing he said wasn't a misdirect
@@ianagulino6653 Is your name Lana?! I can't tell if it's a lower case L or a capital I
My name is Lana (too?!) 😜
29:39: "you can't be in the same room together, it's unfair"
The way I've always thought Barbossa's death was meant to be explained is that going in and out of moonlight basically reset their bodies when their flesh disappeared and then reappeared. Hence why Jack's injury from being stabbed by Barbosa didn't kill him.
Maybe, but I think them being cursed in general is why nothing happened. Barbossa wasn't in the moonlight when he was killed, and Jack could've been acting when he was stabbed. Plus, Barbossa wasn't affected at all when Elizabeth stabbed him before seeing all of them cursed. But, I see your point.
o.o
Omg I’ve never thought of this
@@monsterhanna6691 Well, when Jack shot him, Barbossa didn't go back into the moonlight before the curse was lifted, but Jack did go back into the moonlight and back several times after being stabbed.
Something I feel like we don’t appreciate Dylan for enough is that he’s worked behind the scenes on shoots and he knows a lot about filmmaking. I legitimately learn something every time I watch one of his videos and it’s great. Didn’t know what rack focus was until today, now I do~
The thing is, they need everyone’s blood (all the pirates who stole and used the gold) to free the curse. The whole crew.
William Turner father was also cursed so they needed his blood as well. The other pirates already gave their blood and gold, but they got rid of Turner and then discovered they needed his blood.
And not to mention, Bootstrap Bill had given one of the pieces of eight to Will, so they didn't have all of the gold, either
@@thylionheart the pieces of eight is another thing (third movie), but yes, they also needed that one piece.
But if they need everyone's blood, wouldn't that mean that they also need Jack's blood in the end to lift the curse? Not only Will's 🤔
@@Blubbergirlie no because they had already mutineered when they took the gold from the chest so jack wasnt cursed ergo they dont need his blood
@@juliak8684 but Jack was cursed when he took the gold in the final scene, so that Barbossa couldn't kill him. Will gave his blood and the curse was broken vor everyone, including Jack (who never gave his own blood)
8:54 “If you don’t feel anything you’re a sociopath” I felt something and that was humor
I love how Dylan’s like “why’s everyone so attractive in this movie” when this movie was used in Heartstopper to help show one character’s bisexuality 😭🤣😭
birates of the caribbean 😭
honestly it helped show all of our bisexuality lmfaooo
Ah, so nice to see all of the iconic characters that I loved as a child; Captain Solomon Bartosso, Travis and Saltine
Lmao 😂😂😂
So you’re telling me…that one “that looks like a man who just won a lawsuit” line is what people wanted to cancel you over?!?!?!?! People can’t be serious
That makes him a radical alt-right, white supremacist ,antivaxx, transphobic , Trump supporting incel in some people 's eyes
yeah I was thinking the same thing!
AYO? That's why he was cancelled? I'm cry-laughing at this.
@@mariaszmyt8542 it’s so ridiculous
@@dumbledorf5029 I’m still so confused cause ain’t no way people were actually mad at that
All I’m saying is if you did a commentary on the entire franchise that would be the most entertaining thing ever! But under no circumstances is this a recommendation 😉
Absolutely loved this movie.
Fun Fact: The ship the used for the Interceptor was also Captain Hook's Jolly Roger in the show Once Upon A Time where Lee Arenberg (one of the pirates from this movie) plays Grumpy the dwarf
REALLY?! I had no idea and I love OUAT!
How did I not know this! I love hook!
OMG REALLY? HOOK IS MY FAVORITE CHARACTER IN THAT SERIES!
Wait really? That’s awesome
My favorite is the second movie because of the amazing story and william meeting his father. Also davy jones was amazing
25:20 They needed the blood because when the crew stole the coins, they fell under a curse. To break it, they needed to return all pieces and their blood. However because they cast away Will's dad, not all pieces were returned. So with the medallion and Will's blood, they could become human again
Ohhhhh right they needed ALL the crew’s blood, not just one man specifically to break it for all of them
Dylan's method of incorporating his sponsors in his videos are always effortless and entertaining.
Orlando Bloom is really attractive, but Orlando Bloom with long hair(in this one and Kingdom of Heaven) is just other level prettiness.
especially him as legolas in the hobbit and lord of the rings
Literally thought today was Thursday, that’s how mixed up I would be without Dylan’s reliable uploads.
underrated comment
It is thursday
@@kaidblick5171 it's Monday 👀👀
One of my favorite details about this movie is Jack's line: "This shot is not meant for you."
It is a very vague but intriguing line that introduces the upcoming villain in this story!!!! And it opens up the question, "What is Jack's story?"
as someone who had their bi awakening thanks to this movie, dylan's exasperation over how attractive kiera and orlando are together is a big mood lol
Dylan if you haven’t watched the behind the scenes videos documenting the making of these movies, I suggest you do (not for UA-cam, just for you) as they were filmed on location and used practical effects as much as possible. It’s a really interesting watch!
Do you think it was Dylan’s fantastic Jack Sparrow impression that caused his college to go “right that’s it, we won’t get any better than this dude right here” and closed up for good?
things to think about fr
lol, that was my 1st thought as well!
Gosh, the PotC trilogy is literally such a masterpiece (4 and 5 don't exist). I'm so glad Dylan agrees on how well it still holds up!! Also that Elizabeth & Will are the hottest fictional couple ever put to screen.....Heartstopper did not lie, they were legit my bisexual awakening 😂❤ Hope you keep watching the next 2 movies!!
The 4th movies wasn't terrible and its actually connected to the trilogy even thought its a "breakaway" from the original story line of the trilogy. At the end of the 3rd movies Jack is seen with the chart and it shows one of the Chalices "Aqua De Vida" and "Ponce De Leon" who the chalices belong too leading Jack to look for the Fountain of Youth. But yeah the 5th movie defiantly isn't great. But if you look up the time lines of all 5 movies it makes since how they all sort of connect.
Eh, even if you believe JD's team didn't use DARVO to win... he was such a disgusting POS in his text messages that I don't know how anyone can enjoy his movies now. Granted, I would never remotely call any of those movies a "masterpiece" to begin with, they were just fun action movies that Disney pumped a lot of money into, and don't we just love Disney profits 🤩
same!! i wish he binged them all in one video
@@NickaLah lol, agree to disagree. sorry for you, but to me these movies shaped my childhood and mean a lot.
@@emmar2675 thats good for you, truly! personally tho i rlly didnt enjoy the 4th movie, to me PoTC works best with Will and Elizabeth's dynamic being intertwined with Jack's journey...without it Jack is just comedy relief without much heart anymore. Thats my opinion though.
Are you telling me we are just starting the week?? All this time I thought it was Thursday, but it definitely is Monday if Dylan is posting a movie commentary! He's always so consistent.
how thoughtful of him to remind us what day of the week it is just in case we lose track. I for one also thought it was Thursday today, clearly I need my brain checked 😂
@@amyb0621 I need my iPhone and Alexa checked because obviously they aren’t working correctly.
@@undercoverfangirl5491 ikr 🙄
2:20 dylan asking if it collects dust and then realizing he just doesn’t care has me dead 💀
It's so refreshing to see Dylan watch (an enjoy!) an actually good movie.
It's also fun to see him thirst over Orlando Bloom and Kiera Knightley as Will and Elizabeth, who are very much a classic I-had-my-bisexual-awakening-seeing-them-together-and-can't-choose-one-or-the-other couple
Such a Heartstopper moment 😂
Mine also involved Orlando Bloom, but in the LOTR franchise 🤣
The OG bi awakening will always be The Mummy, I’d sleep with everyone except Benny
When this movie came out on DVD, my sister set a goal to watch it everyday for a month (we were weird) and I often watched it with her and yet I've never grown tired of this movie. It's just fun and exciting the whole way through.
Oh i did that when i got prisoner of azkaban's DVD hahaha everyday after school.. ohh time flies
I used to do that with the Chronicles of Narnia 😄 nice to know I’m not alone!!
I did that with Peter Pan and Holes, but now I just watch the same 3 shows over and over.
Would really love Dylan to watch “The road to El Dorado” it’s an animation but this was definitely made for adults 😂!! the humour is excellent and very underrated!
YES!
Enough sarcasm and sass for his liking lol. Its still one of my favorites
and now he is never going to watch it lmaooo
YES OMFG
no recs !!
11:43 "you need a crew like a minimum of 10 men" I honestly can't tell if this is a One Piece joke.
You need:
1: A capitan,
2: First mate,
3: Storyteller,
4: Chef,
5: Navigator,
6: Doctor,
7: Historian,
8 Shipwright,
9: Musician,
10: Helmsman
I remember being obsessed with these movies as a teenager. I also remember watching it with commentary from Keira Knightly and Jack Davenport and they pointed out the Beverly Hills manicure too 😂
I’m glad Dylan talked some sense into me. I was an aspiring pirate, but hearing the cons, he really brought me back to land
I always assumed the "blood to be repaid" was each one of the pirates that took the coins had to repay with blood. So when Will's dad was sent to the depths of the ocean(cursed to live forever in the crushing black thanks to sending a coin to his son) the pirates weren't able to repay everyone's blood and break the curse. That's how I understood the needing the blood of Will🤗.
Thats exactly what had to be done. Jack also bled on the coin he took, you can see it being bloody when he throws it to Will......I always thought that part was very obvious 🤷♀ But I guess Dylan just didn't catch it.
He needs to see this
I'm still not over the fact of how excited you got about two guys engaging in a sword fight
The underwater scene with all the skeletons walking is *chefs kiss* perfection. These movies had no business being as good as they are
I literally just go back to my home page and low and behold there's Dylan, just making my day on this lovely Monday.
Pirates of the Caribbean will always be my favorite, a staple of my childhood.
It's thursday?
@@bhelliom3 it’s clearly movie commentary Monday
@@alexithymiaah I get it now, thanks
The fact Dylan is gaslightung us twice in the first 5 minutes of the commentary is honestly hilarious 😂
I was like, "there's no way I'm two years older than Dylan!"
THIS! 😂
I thought he was thirty 😂
I was literally like, I looked up ur age before ur soo much older than me, shut up.😂🤦🏽♀️
I was like “No You Are NOT!” 😅😂
I love how the smithy fight is in tune with the music 🎶 it just makes the whole thing so *chef's kiss*
The scene in Heartstopper where Nick watches this movie and then googles “bisexuality” is honestly the best choice they could have made because everyone in this is beautiful
These movies were literally my sexualities awakening🤫🏳️🌈🤣
This and the mummy are responsible for an entire generation of bisexuals figuring it out 🤣
that's exactly what i was thinking haha
7:44 the thing about the first POTC movie is that no one thought it would work...before it ever became a franchise, it was a theme park ride turned into a movie (something the Jungle Cruise movie desperately tried to recreate)... and it did so well and that's owed to just how free everyone was in this film... you can see how much fun they're having both in front and behind the camera..
The way I SCREAMED "oh, yes!" When I saw Dylan AND pirates of the Caribbean. So unbelievably excited to watch this
Same here!!! I burst out in happiness and childlike joy
😩😩
@@kayckdantas why is this the cutest comment I've ever seen
@@cranberryrosebud I cant express well enough how much his videos bring me joy!!
@@kayckdantas that’s good, it’s good to have things that make you happy (:
There has been NO onscreen chemistry this hot since Will and Elizabeth 🔥🔥🔥
I think this is my favourite commentary you've done. This whole thing was us getting to laugh with you, and then Dylan being so turned on by the actors, crushing on Will, Elizabeth and Jack hahaha
Everyone who stole the gold needs to give their blood to remove the curse, thats why they need Will's blood, because his father was part of the crew that removed the coins from the chest.
Finally someone that answered his question!
Was looking for this comment!
Yeah, but the pirates didnt bleed, it doesnt at up
I remember watching this movie when I was in 7th grade and having such an in-depth realization about Jack Sparrow and Will Turner's first fight scene:
Jack and Will are essentially character foils of each other. Both pirates (or of pirate origin) and both excellent swordsmen. However Jack Sparrow's moral compass is skewed. He is chaotic, sly, and breaks rules left and right. By contrast, Will Turner is a law abiding citizen with a strong sense of morality.
We can literally see this in their fighting styles. Will's sword fighting is learned and follows the rules of fencing with perfect form. Jack's is just as quick and skilled, but is chaotic and unexpected. Pitted against each other, they are an even match. The only reason Jack wins is because he cheats! The writers did such an excellent job of telling us all about their personalities in a 3 minute fight scene 😂
Exactly! Brillent writers and director! And they have good chemistry reacting to each other in situations. Should have gotten more oscar nominations
One of my favorites fight scenes apart from prob. Princess Bride & too many anime to mention esp. Attack on Titan & Bleach.
@@alwaysapirateroninace443 oh I love the princess bride fight scene too! It was so theatrical and satirical 😂😂😂
@@phoebeahn8941 Yes! Jill Bearup here on UA-cam has an excellent, independent yet gushing analysis of it. It's wonderful!
It's 3.17am, finished uni, summer holiday has started, eating a lolly pop, some fruits shoot and having a rewatch binge of Dylan. Overlooking being back at the house that makes me want to....life is a vibe rn.
I’d love to be a pirate. Setting aside the fact that I can’t swim, get extreme motion sickness, have a fear of the ocean, have pasty skin that burns in seconds, get crippling guilt whenever I break rules, and hate most alcohol… outside all of that I think it would be awesome!
Haha!
Omg this is me 😂
Dylan is the absolute best movie commentator! He is always speaking exactly what we're all thinking while simultaneously pointing out things I have never noticed before, all while being freaking hilarious.
Dylan forgetting his nose ring every video will never not make me laugh
Dylan is literally one of the only youtubers i laugh out loud to each time i watch his videos. I DIED laughing when that kid at the beginning screamed i just KNEW he was going to laugh and comment on it. this is one of my fav movie commentaries
Actually the stuff we know about pirates is wildly wrong. They weren't as filthy and bathed as regularly as they could, few had guns because they were expensive and required a bit of knowledge to use. Most you'd find the captain with a gun. Pirates used mostly crude weapons. There are so many myths that are laughable but that does change how awesome the stories are.
Didn’t pirates have scurvy? And syphilis among other diseases? Sounds pretty filthy to me
@@audramcdonaldapologist3676 good pirates probably don’t
@@audramcdonaldapologist3676 well every sailor had those, not just pirates. They were diseases you would get from lack of good food after months at sea. Now, for the STDs.... well, cant get condoms in the 17th century
I mean old timey pirates yeah.
A lot of them were also former Navy soldiers who weren't compensated after fighting and losing limbs, so they turned to piracy to spite the government that abandoned them. I learned about this years ago when I was studying children's literature, specifically a section that discussed Hook's character in Peter Pan and the possibility that he was a soldier before he became a pirate!
Post-Edit: Once Upon A Time actually went down the route of Hook (Killian Jones) being a former soldier.