That liberal women was so disturbing, she was literally wrong in regards with everything, Islam isn't open to interpretation to this degree at all, the verses that speak about qawm Lut peace be upon him are very very clear. May Allah guide us.
@RYLO CBLOOD May Allah remove you from our minds and memories. Nothing in your comment history is beneficial, contrarily, its inflammatory and hostile and misguided. Have a good rest of your life under Allah anger.
@RYLO CBLOOD what about ANY verse in any book? Its easy for the sick mind to interperet however you please. In your case no one can guide you out of your abode of ignominy. You kfrs dont benefit from any scholar, or shaikh. Imam, student of knowledge telling you anything except that in your egotistical rampage just blabber about what about this or that to yourself while people who believe in the quran benefit from it. Which tells me you'e more atheist than christian, real christians when they hear the verses of quran weep and say this is none other than the word of Allah. I was a christian but not a liberal with a christian flavor like yourself.
For my muslim brothers and sisters who also live in the west like me, make sure to stay strong with your faith and don't let anyone pressure you into doubting it.
You should doubt it. There are clear errors. No evidence that Muhammad spoke to an angel. When you add all the other ridiculous stories like Adam and Eve, moon splittings and thieving stones, we can safely come to the conclusion that it is myth.
I am not sure but I can only imagine that this is exactly how the Jews and Christians changed their religion over time by complying to the "new moral values" in the society. They are applying the exact formula towards Islam. I know that islam cannot be changed but there will be people who go down with the stream. May Allah protect all the muslims from this fitnah.
the main reason for their decline were not outside reasons, but the destruction from within. Clergy, priests and rabies who mislead the people and many more reasons that are internal issues. Don't think we muslims are safe from this. Muslims are heading the same wrong direction...
"O you who have believed, upon you is [responsibility for] yourselves. Those who have gone astray will not harm you when you have been guided. To Allāh is your return all together; then He will inform you of what you used to do." -Quran 5:105
These liberal ethics have encircled not only today's Muslim youths but also the adults a lot. Brother Hijab's timely observation and reflection will work as tool to face these sorts of fallacies and ignorance. May Allah guide all of us. Ameen.
I feel like it's good that she was put in that position for the world to see , cause many young Muslims could have had similar beliefs to her without them knowing that they were wrong , now with everyone correcting her it might help some people to find the right path. May Allah guide us all❤️
Allah has taken personal responsibility to protect the Quran. Allah has protected the Quran for 1,400 years and will continue to protect it until The Last Hour. Allah never breaks his promise.
Qur'an may be protected but not from warped interpretations from Sunnis or other sects. 1400 years later and the Sunni world still has trouble properly interpreting even basic verses from the Qur'an because of their deviation from the straight path and being polluted by fairy tales.
@@jeff_costello where did you come up with that theory? so you're saying if Allah has a "part" then this in turn means that his miracles hold no weight? The only one that has no "part" is you because you are obviously missing part of your brain.
Make dua. Even if you think everything has been decided and nothing can be done. We are incapable of understanding how Allah handles our matters and a sincere dua goes a long way. "Perhaps the misfortune that you do not like, leads you to a beautiful destiny that you never dreamed of." people underestimate the power of dua. It’s the only thing that can change Qadr, so keep our needy brothers and sisters in Islam in your prayers. Whatever you’re going through, know that it’s going to be okay. Trust in your heart. Know that Allāh is watching and loves you more than any person on earth does. And that’s what’s so wonderful. It amazes me how the happiest days of your life can be followed by the saddest. And it amazes me just how beautifully the Light breaks in when we feel as if the darkness will never leave. All things pass, and that’s one of the most humbling things about this life.
Personally, I think God or Allah left us so many clues who was really responsible for nine 1 one. The BBC broadcasted the collapse of tower #7 twenty two minutes before it even happened. Nano thermite in all the dust samples. A camera crew just happens to quickly point his camera straight up, in the middle of massive skyscrapers, who does that? And every other inconsistencies, such as put options on airline companies. People were given a choice to question the inconsistencies or blindly invade another country and most chose the latter. I have desperately tried to educate many Americans to the inconsistencies and have been met with anger and aggression. Those people have dug their own karmic grave.
The clip about raising money is a good thing but because it’s done before every video, the effect of it is reduced and rather we are more prone to just skip it
I absolutely love hearing from you Brother. The fact you dissect it historically, socially, philosophically and even psychologically made me learn new things everyday. I wish you talk more about the video topics in depth but this slavery information is already quite fascinating and informative. Would love to hear more about it because it's rarely talked about from Islamic perspective.
The problem with that take is that people are put in prison for violating the law committing crimes so it is justified in a sense. What have people done to make themselves slaves? Just a question? Is it being prisoners of war? Wallahi, I want to know.
Asalam alaykum my brothers and sisters in Islam and fellow sons and daughters of Prophet Adam, peace be upon him. May Allah The Most Merciful bless you all! Ameen.
I was speaking with a colleague from work, night shift naturally opens up to deep conversations 😂 but he asked me if I had any fears or doubts, I said when I was in the process of reverting I thought Slavery was a deal breaker, but then I explained what it meant to him and asked him, “is there anything morally wrong with that” and he said “nah you gotta find a new name” 😂 Mashallah
@@deathmarch8354 pls don’t say the word murtad loosely without further investigation. If Allah decides they are not worthy of the takfir it may fall back on you
@@TheR3negadeMaster You should look at his other comments.I saw this guys comment in another page too defending haram.This ex muslims are deceptive and cunning.
There is always this darkness on their face. Whomever goes against the word of Allah and opposes it openly, Allah takes away the noor from their faces.
Its really sad and scary at the same time..its really true wat was bein prophesize by our prophet Muhammad SAW. Look at today’s world.. Muslim no longer will be like a Muslim and Islam will no longer be regarded like a religion. Even in the 1st place, there’s no such thing as conservative or liberal Muslims. We are just Muslims and just that. May Allah SWT guide us all to the right path… Amin……
The problem is that they are interpreting the Qur'an in English not in Arabic it has to be interpreted in Arabic and spoken in Arabic because it losses some meaning in translation to English
Fr, though, peeps be abstracting rulings from Saheeh International edition like, "This English verse about covering of women says 'should' not 'must', therefore it is not obligatory, and my textual criticism is totally valid and holistically informed and I am now the law." HUUUUH? LOL
@@ayyylmao101even Abubakr As Sideeq رضي الله عنه was afraid of talking about the Quran without knowledge. And nowadays you have people with the littlest of eemaan wanting to interpret it themselves لَا حَوْلَ وَلَا قُوَّةَ إِلَّا بِٱللَّٰهِ
Islam cannot be mankind, universal religion, other the quran would not be only the Arabic power... If mhmad was mankind prophet and the last prophet among all prophet, were are African, Australia, Indian, Buddhist, shinto and son prophet in the quran,?
Liberal munafiqs after they see dajjal Dajjal: I have one eye fallow me, kaffir is written on my forehead. Liberal munafaqs: only allah can judge he's head says, "kaffir" but he has a good heart.
They're still a minority. الحمد لله, the vast majority of Muslims take their Deen very seriously. May Allah ﷻ keep us steadfast and firm on His Deen. Ameen!
@@ayaan6373 Akhi, I'm not sure what country you're talking about. Take Arabs as an example, they're becoming more religious, especially the youth. The vast majority of Muslims *DO* take their Deen seriously.
Assalamualaikum Brother Hijab, I met you at Mount of Marwah while doing the Tahallul last week or so...lost the opportunity to greet you.personally. At least, I get to greet u here.
So now instead of taking the word of scholars who spent their whole life4 learning Arabic memorizing Quran thinking and writing about Islam we should be "open" and listen to random people just because it feels good to them or whatever , silly.
Why even bother following a religion that requires “reinterpretation” every time there’s a change in societal norms? Islam does not need to change to fit the society rather its the society who need to change to fit Islam.
Most of us know who controlled the Trans Atlantic Slave Trade. The Ukrainian Crest, the Khazarian Tamga and the Moloch Sigil all look identical. One other symbol on a country’s flag represents the same thing.
May Allah bless Mohammad hijab. I love all of his videos and how he presents himself. My conviction to islam always increases after watching his videos.
Yeah, when i really learn the ruling on that, it seems to be closer to public service (as a state punishment from breaking the law) compared to slavery. _Milkul yamiin_ is treated way way way way too much better compared to the concept of slavery that common people imagine in their head.
Alhamdulillah, the Quran is written in such a way its for all till the end... so ppl who think The HOLY QURAN needs be re-transalted need to re translate thr own lives. The true muslim followers are very happy with it ALHAMDULILAH, n may we understand it and follow it correctly, ameen..
These modern men and modern women will destroy religions by giving their own interpretations instead of what the original meanings are. We cannot allow this to happen.
The founding fathers of the United States, as they were debating the form of the legislative branch of government, were arguing about the worth of a slave and whether and how they would be counted in the population of slave-owning states. They finally agreed that a slave is worth 3/5 of a white man; as they included only that percentage of the population of slaves in each state. Which is mind-boggling really...that the heroes of liberty, individual rights and American values hold such malicious ideas about a people just because of their ethnicity and origin!
Hilarious that we are arguing about the right to vote at all. There is no two party system in the USA, both are bought and have to swear an allegiance to a different country. Property ownership used to be a requirement to vote in early America. Tells you that poor people in general weren’t considered human.
3/5 came out during the buildup to the civil war, it has nothing to do with the founding fathers. On the topic of slavery they did have legislation in place to put a ban into the constituition but was turned down by a single vote
If racism is outlawed in Islam then why did Muhammad called Ethiopians as raisins? Why did Muhammad had so many black slaves? Why did Muhammad sold 2 black slaves for one Arab slaves?
Islam slavery (the right hand) is putting shame to capitalism which is another type of slavery. The fact the slaves have rights, and can get married is beyond any definition.
I was telling one of my friends students loan is Haram and it has interests in it. The guy kept saying “ he can interpret the Quran the way he understands and he doesn’t need the scholars” So the modern liberals youngsters are confused wllhi
For someone not from the USA you are very sound in your knowledge of it's history, most Americans don't even acknowledge or know those facts you mentioned.
n today’s friday sermon at the masjid near my area was abt the danger of liberalism that’s creeping into local muslims…. may Allah protects muslims all over the world frm this calamity.. aammiiiiiinn…
I'm a revert Muslim I hated Islam and Muslims I'm 19 from Europe 2 months ago I accepted Islam alhamdulilah love the greatest human prophet Muhammad pbuh. And Allah swt. And my brothers and sisters Allahu Akbar
The Quran is a very short and vague book, which contains very little guidance, and even less clarifications of its claims, so the Quran itself is quite open for interpretation, however a reformation within Islam is only possible in case of the Quranists, who actually treat the Quran as a self-sufficient and complete holy book, because the Hadith which contains over 75% of Islam and serves as supplementation of the Quran, makes any reformation impossible.
@@MRshraaf The single fact that a Muslim needs a bunch of secondary books, like the Hadith, to avoid misinterpretation or for Islam to work in general.
@@MRshraaf I mean, if the Quran was clear/not vague, there would be no need for such a huge amount of secondary books like the Hadith, as supplementation/clarification of the Quran.
You can’t change God’s word to fit society but you should change society to fit God’s word . Even if it’s not physically changing words you’re still interpreting the Quran in a way that suits you and society .
It's not gods word so changing society to match it is literally DE-volving. Sex between 2 men who love each other is better than beating 8 women who's faces never see sunshine or equal treatment. Tell that to your imams who preach against homosexuality, yet have Chai boys. Don't try taqiyya lying with me either. I know your religion inside and out, backwards and forwards. Including your doctrine about lying in order to advance your evil religion.
@@horustrismegistus1017 First of all it is God’s word Second of all beating women is haram (not permissible) which shows me that you don’t know Islam “inside and out “. Third of all women have equal treatment and can see sunshine. It is haram to limit their rights like you stated . Fourth of all idk what a Chai boy is. Fifth of all Islam is not an evil religion, it is the complete opposite . You made 4 false claims that you didn’t back up with any evidence so I expect you to tell me why “ Islam is evil “ , where in the Quran or ahadith you read that we can beat women , where you read in the Quran or ahadith that we should lie to progress Islam even though it is haram to lie,where you read in the Quran and ahadith that we can limit women’s rights and imprison them and also if you don’t mind telling me what a Chai boy is and their supposed relations with imams . ( I didn’t give any evidence to my responses cuz they’re obvious and known things but if you want evidence for something just ask me )
@@horustrismegistus1017 we don’t think people are perfect but the religion is . For example beating women isn’t permissible yet some Muslim men do it but that doesn’t mean that Islam teaches us that it is permissible or that we should do it .
First of all it's not God's word, or I wouldn't be able to pick it apart so effortlessly like I do literally all the time with all imams and will happily do with you, right now, for free. You pick anything you wanna talk about with islam, and I'll pick you apart. Open invite ua-cam.com/video/w_qIF1VELj4/v-deo.html This is one video out of literally hundreds which quote the Quran directly. Even better, he is a former muslim. 1.) It is OK to beat your woman as "they are a degree beneath you" 2.) Mohammed was asked by a woman "why are women supposedly less intelligent than men?" Mohammed, in all his illiterate genius, said "is a woman's testimony not half that of a man's, in court?" "Yea?" "Then there is your proof." "But why is a woman's testimony less valuable than a man's?" "Because women are less intelligent than men." ^ that right there is called circular logic. A logical fallacy. A mistake that could not have possibly been made by "god"s favorite guy, or spokesman. Not gonna happen. "I know that this book is true." "How?" "Because the book says so." "I'm the best fighter ever." "How do you know?" "Because I said so." ^ circular logic. 3.) Let's see.. women in some muslim countries don't even get hijabs. They have to wear burqas. That alone is abuse. You can twist it into something benevolent all you want, but you'd be no different than Joe Biden claiming the green new deal is "for the people". A burqa isn't exaltation. It isn't protection. It isn't modest. It's abuse. Outright abuse. Now, in some of these terrible, horrible, awful, hellscape nations, they don't even wear burqas. They're FORCED to wear TENTS ⛺️
@@cheezy_nugget how dare you sit here and act pious with me? Lying through your viperian teeth. I've read your evil books. Quran, Hadith, Sira. I've studied under scholars for years. I'm even learning Arabic. You're not capable of making me doubt what I have seen. 1.) "War IS deception" - Mohammed 2.) "Taqiyya" is the NAME of the ART of deceiving the NON-BELIEVER .. 🤔 3.) Islam is AT WAR >>>with
She wasn't reinterpreting the Quran, she was lying to try and convince others of her twisted Haram views. The Quran is very clear in terms of our morality.
still didn´t watch the video, but anyway I'm gonna post what I commented on the jubilee video. I hope ppl see it there, but it's a new comment so idk if that'll happen. Anyway these were my responses: comment1: As a response to Nathalie: Here's a verse from the Holy Qura'an: قَالَ هَٰٓؤُلَآءِ بَنَاتِيٓ إِن كُنتُمۡ فَٰعِلِينَ " [ الحجر: 71] " "[Lot]said: These are my daughters - if you would be doers [of lawful marriage]" (Al Hijr: verse 71) Why did Lut say here are my "daughters", when the men clearly wanted homosexual intercourse? Why didn't he tell them (may God forgive me for even saying this): Since you're attracted to men why don't you guys marry one another? Because, acting upon homosexuality is a sin. It's crystal clear. You cannot deny it. Plus, she said that: no, other religions don't consider homosexuality as a sin. That isn't true. Why do you think ppl didn't accept homosexual behaviour in the past? Because they followed religion. Even homosexual marriage wasn't accepted by church until a couple of years ago. comment2: 14:30 Now Nathalie, please understand that : 1. those scholars always look back at the historical context of when a given verse was revealed, which helps them interpret it 2. they use hadeeth and sunnah too to interpret qura'an 3. they see what the salaf said (which are those who the prophet told us would have a good understanding of religious matter) I think the first comment is really important. I hope some youtuber adresses it when reacting to the jubilee video.
I agree with most of what you say. However, your point 2.... Yes, it is best to know the context and history of a verse. But we must beware of interpreting a verse completely in the light of the opinion of a scholar. A scholar is not always factually right he can be mistaken. The Quran can be interpreted on it's own and own context.
In the early years of Islam, Muslims were very open in their interpretations of the Quran. There was a centuries old debate between rationalists and dogmatism even. It was when the books of Hadith were compiled that any independent thinking was stifled. Notice science and mathematics flourished when Muslims were open minded. Mohammed Hijab's rigid and ultra Conservative approach is the reason why the lands of Hanbalism have NEVER been pioneers in any science or technology. It's time to bring back the spirit of reason in Islam. Less ibn Taymiyyah and more ibn Rushd.
You have no idea what you are saying. No interpretation of the Quran has ever hindered any scientific or mathematical pursuit rather it has cultivated it. Why do you liberals beat around the bush so much? Why dont you just say what you want, straight forward? You want Islam to change and do not think it is perfectly preserved for all time rather you think it must change based on your whims and desires. Hanbalis are not the only ones you call "conservative" all schools of thought are traditional and "conservative" by all means. Although I dont say there is a conservative or liberal Islam, I only believe in Islam. And although you say no land of Hanbalisim has ever been pioneers in any sicence, which is false, let me tell you no land of "Liberal" Islam has ever even existed. In fact the golden age of Islam was filled with scholars of Ahl Al Sunnah and most of the people were practicing the True Religion of Allah unlike you people nowadays who speak of a different religion then the Religion of the Messenger of Allah. The names you admire and associate yourself with would despise and reject you.
@@mahaduzumaki6643 I don't want islam.to change anything. We want it to stay crooked and backwards as long as possible, thar is what will bring new brain to oppose and leave it by the future generations, It will be great... The more science and technology bring proof life thee world is wrong not flat like the quoran quoran day, the more the revolution and rejection will happen .... Talking about the scientific from Muslim, these scientists were are atheists, many of them.were jailed fir their view and philosophy... Besides one of good philosopher was jailed many time and he said ( Muslim Arab are savage , they are willing to burn a library for a piece of goat) It is people like you who killed and poisoned and jailed these scientists atheists Muslim... You opposed their view and photos calling them disbelievers, kufar and unsubmissive to the traditional Muslim who live by the quran a d forsake any other way beside all.. You and Hijab and Daniel qiquat.. kille a d jailed them..
Who did own all those slave ships anyway? Unfortunately YT won’t allow me to post the names. However, I agree with you in that slavery has been in every race throughout history.
@@theredboneking Not really ? No one practiced chattel slavery like the Europeans which totally dehumanized and destroyed human beings to the point that there complete identity was erased . No one hung men , women and children and burned them at the stake as white people did to the Africans . No one ripped babies from the mother's womb and sold the child to different owners meanwhile raping the women and girls and flogging them for so called disobedience to them . Therefore , to equate any other slavery are servitude to trans Atlantic slavery is a unjust view of the atrocity . There is no comparison bar none .
@@saburrashid5566 Your comment has been shadow banned. It might appear to you that it has been added to the thread, but it is not. I received notification that you sent me the reply, but nobody else can read it. I agree with you, however I have not researched enough about slavery in other countries to say for sure. The Native Americans had a name for White settlers, WETIKO. It’s a term they used to describe people who they thought were possessed by a demon. The demon made them greedy and murderous.
You didn’t get a dime cause the message was clearly that reinterpretation is not needed and he is calling from them to return to traditionalism, which is the only right way to interpret the Quran.
Interpretation exists in Islam. It's called Tafsir. It is how the scholars explain certain verses in the Quran. However, we don't outright abolish any law in the Quran(Sharia). Then there is the Sunnah which entails sayings/actions of Rasul Allah(SAW) and we also use much of this to live life👍🏼
Great video, but I think it would've been better if there was a segment on why it is actually wrong to reinterpret the quran rather than focusing too much on the example.
Ngl when i saw that video i was eagerly waiting for a response from you and the lot. There's so much more to the video tho. wish u responded to the whole thing.
Dear sir please tell me about this Hadit... Is lt true.... If a believing woman needs to travel somewhere with a 'foreign' man or if there is a need to have a foreign man in the house! For example; Servants, gardeners, janitors, caretakers, etc.! In that case, the 'famous' hadith of the Prophet is, "If that man is made to drink milk by sucking her own breast ten times, then the 'holy' relationship (Mahram) will be established between them like mother and son!" This hadith narrated by Aisha is a Sahih hadith of Muslim Sharif! (Ifa Publications- 3463, 3466, Hadith Academy- 3490) This hadith about breast feeding an elderly man was one of the two verses in the Koran about the 'famous' goat feeding! That's why the verse is not in the Koran today, it is in the goat's stomach! As we know, some hadiths have been abrogated or abrogated by different narrators! The problem is, there is no counter-hadith to 'abolish' the hadith of feeding ten sips of milk anywhere in the entire six hadith books of Sihah Sitta! Therefore, if the 'pure' believers want to suck milk, there is no obstacle to practice it! And that's why in June 2010, Saudi Royal Court consultant and Islamic scholar Sheikh Abdel Mohsen Abeikan issued a 'fatwa'! It is said there, "Women do not need to put their mouths on their breasts to breastfeed! Just pump the breast a little and take out ten drops of milk and pour it into a glass, and the man will become a 'Mahram'!" But the Saudi scholars were divided on this fatwa! Those who follow the 'Original' Hadith, the 'Hambali' Madhab, said, "Glass Or do not feed the milk in the bottle! It must be sucking face!" In Saudi Arabia, many foreigners working in the Saudis' houses, such as male housekeepers, gardeners, janitors, car drivers, etc., were often caught having 'immoral' relations with Saudi women's daughters! And that's why the Saudi goats changed the hadith a little and were in favor of the fatwa of feeding milk instead of sucking the breast and pouring it in a glass! So that to some extent, a son-like 'holy' feeling comes in the minds of the daughters regarding the house workers and they 'save' themselves from the sin of sex! But because of the strong position of the hardline Hambalis against the fatwa, it did not become a law! Previously, in 2007, Egypt's famous Sharia scholar Izzat Atiya and Sheikh Abi Ishaq Hawani issued a 'fatwa' in favor of breastfeeding an elderly man with ten cups of breast milk! And the Shariah Department of Al Azhar University in Egypt recognized the fatwa as an unequivocal yes index! In this many women protect the "religious veil" by sucking the milk of their work colleagues, domestic workers or travel companions! Women who are unmarried or have no milk children - how can they make a virgin drink milk? This question goes on another great! Since the Prophet did not say anything clear about this! So in this case, some 'extreme' scholars in Iran are heard to have given an opinion in favor of sucking only the nip*le of the breast without milk!!...
I take comfort in the fact that no matter how hard these liberal muslims try to push their agenda, they will ultimately be shut down by staunch muslim conservatives with a firm yaqeen in the Quran and Sunnah and authentic hadiths everytime, Alhamdulillah.
One of the most important thinks in Islam is 'logic', to ponder, to think. It is mentioned even more "will they not ponder/think" than "will they not believe". So when we discuss slavery, what do you think is slavery according to your definition? In western discussions "slavery" is defined as the slavery which Europe experienced during the transatlantic slave trade. Then what is slavery according to Quran? The fact is that the Quran never promotes slavery and goes as far as to say, in multiple places, that it is one of the best deeds to free the slaves when you can. And all the universal values like being kind, act with justice, still need to be actualized too.
There is no such thing as liberal islam. Either practice as our Rasoul taught or make up your own interpretations to fit your feelings. Anas ibn Malik reported: The Messenger of Allah, peace and blessings be upon him, said, “A time of patience will come to people in which adhering to one’s religion is like grasping a hot coal.” Source: Sunan al-Tirmidhī 2260
I’m a Christian so there are obviously things we will disagree on but there were plenty of points made that are true. Liberalism as a religion is something that needs to be more talked about
Liberalism will backfire on and destroy itself the moment it becomes too progressive for its own good, much like a drug that you enjoy so much until it ends up k you.
I lost interest for Islam because of this, every time I talked to a Muslim scholar they said me about interpretations and that there are schools who do different interpretation, nothing is certain and you don't know what Muslim is in front of you and what he thinks.
Only few thinks are open to interpretation. Most things are fixed. The four school of thoughts only disagree on certain rulings, they agree on most things... Especially if it's related to aqeeda of Islam. You lost interest because you never tried to seek knowledge.
@@MultiOzzyProductionsI am not Muslim. I saw in my childhood a dervish going to Mecca, it was a surreal experience, to see a man straight from old times.. But some of my ancestors were Turkish and I read Quran and Sahih al-Bukhari and not only, in my teen years, as I was very sympathetic for Islam, went to mosques and still have Muslim friends.
That was embarrassing to watch. The two guys and the niqabi seemed the most grounded. The Somali sister knew what was right and wrong, but the Asian Donny and that black lesbian were making up their own religion. Cringe to listen to
The solution for Islam and the Quran is not to change it or modernize it but to understand it better. If sister at the beginning knew her Islam she wouldn't be falling into such a folly. I hate the word slave here. They are indentured servants. 1. You cannot enslave a free person 2. They were only prisoners of war 3. They cannot be beaten 4. They have to eat what you eat 5. They have to wear what you wear 6. We must help them with their task 7. If a "slave" is hit he is to be freed. 8. We must facilitate a way to free them. Does this sound like slavery to anyone when these people are POWs? Again, they need to slow down and stop listening to Islamically uneducated heathens and take a sincere approach to understanding Islam. Again it's not about changing it, it's perfect, it's about understanding properly.
That liberal women was so disturbing, she was literally wrong in regards with everything, Islam isn't open to interpretation to this degree at all, the verses that speak about qawm Lut peace be upon him are very very clear. May Allah guide us.
Aamiin yarobbal alamiin
@@boobaal1791 we don't need reinterpretation. We follow the Quran and the prophet Mohammed peace be upon him
@@boobaal1791 Pubertarian detected, opinion rejected.
Theyre plants
@@rimesherif5775 Correct.
I am a revert for a week. And it was so shocking to hear this from an apparent born muslim. Walahi, may Allah guide our hearts.
Mashallah welcome to the deen of our creator 🙂
may Allah guide you and preserve you and grant you the highest of heavens without judgment and through any door.
Great that you realise this sister 💯 May Allah keep you firm on your deen and grant you the highest ranks of jannah. Ameen
Welcome to Islam Amanda.
Welcome to Islam sister! I don’t believe she was born a Muslim, I believe she was also a revert, and Allah (swt) knows best.
‘They plot and plan, and Allah too plans; but the best of planners is Allah.’
Islam did away with slavery that's true but...are their RACIST muslims? YES
Truly these two seem more like enemies of islam than mumin.
@RYLO CBLOOD May Allah remove you from our minds and memories. Nothing in your comment history is beneficial, contrarily, its inflammatory and hostile and misguided. Have a good rest of your life under Allah anger.
@RYLO CBLOOD cope Lindo
@RYLO CBLOOD what about ANY verse in any book? Its easy for the sick mind to interperet however you please. In your case no one can guide you out of your abode of ignominy. You kfrs dont benefit from any scholar, or shaikh. Imam, student of knowledge telling you anything except that in your egotistical rampage just blabber about what about this or that to yourself while people who believe in the quran benefit from it. Which tells me you'e more atheist than christian, real christians when they hear the verses of quran weep and say this is none other than the word of Allah. I was a christian but not a liberal with a christian flavor like yourself.
For my muslim brothers and sisters who also live in the west like me, make sure to stay strong with your faith and don't let anyone pressure you into doubting it.
You should doubt it. There are clear errors. No evidence that Muhammad spoke to an angel. When you add all the other ridiculous stories like Adam and Eve, moon splittings and thieving stones, we can safely come to the conclusion that it is myth.
@@Jim-rk4db Let me summarise your comment
Appeal to the Stone fallacy
@@M7md-3la2 you mean stone myth? Lol
@@Jim-rk4db proving me right
Keep going 💪
@@M7md-3la2 stones don’t steal peoples clothes, prove me wrong
I am not sure but I can only imagine that this is exactly how the Jews and Christians changed their religion over time by complying to the "new moral values" in the society. They are applying the exact formula towards Islam. I know that islam cannot be changed but there will be people who go down with the stream. May Allah protect all the muslims from this fitnah.
Don't worry about them, Seeing, Knowing is Allah SWT in all affairs, this people have no Authority over Allah SWT and they can't change anything.
the main reason for their decline were not outside reasons, but the destruction from within. Clergy, priests and rabies who mislead the people and many more reasons that are internal issues. Don't think we muslims are safe from this. Muslims are heading the same wrong direction...
You condemn suicide bombers using the Koran?
"O you who have believed, upon you is [responsibility for] yourselves. Those who have gone astray will not harm you when you have been guided. To Allāh is your return all together; then He will inform you of what you used to do." -Quran 5:105
Sunan an-Nasa'i 326
أَخْبَرَنَا هَارُونُ بْنُ عَبْدِ اللَّهِ، قَالَ حَدَّثَنَا أَبُو أُسَامَةَ، قَالَ حَدَّثَنَا الْوَلِيدُ بْنُ كَثِيرٍ، قَالَ حَدَّثَنَا مُحَمَّدُ بْنُ كَعْبٍ الْقُرَظِيُّ، عَنْ عُبَيْدِ اللَّهِ بْنِ عَبْدِ الرَّحْمَنِ بْنِ رَافِعٍ، عَنْ أَبِي سَعِيدٍ الْخُدْرِيِّ، قَالَ قِيلَ يَا رَسُولَ اللَّهِ أَتَتَوَضَّأُ مِنْ بِئْرِ بُضَاعَةَ وَهِيَ بِئْرٌ يُطْرَحُ It
These liberal ethics have encircled not only today's Muslim youths but also the adults a lot. Brother Hijab's timely observation and reflection will work as tool to face these sorts of fallacies and ignorance. May Allah guide all of us. Ameen.
Zakir Naik is God. Zakir Naik is God because hes too handsome, smart and nice. Worship him like i do.
The Right-wing Christians here in the USA who bomb mosques are anti- Liberal/Liberalism as well.
I feel like it's good that she was put in that position for the world to see , cause many young Muslims could have had similar beliefs to her without them knowing that they were wrong , now with everyone correcting her it might help some people to find the right path. May Allah guide us all❤️
Zakir Naik is God. Zakir Naik is God because hes too handsome, smart and nice. Worship him like i do.
@@ZakirNaikIsGoddon't do this please for your sake. worship only Allah.
audhubillah@@ZakirNaikIsGod
Allah has taken personal responsibility to protect the Quran. Allah has protected the Quran for 1,400 years and will continue to protect it until The Last Hour. Allah never breaks his promise.
That's why it was written in Arabic so it can be protected and make sure no one can rewrite it and Change things to his liking
@RYLO CBLOOD if God could have parts then this means that you are not talking about God anymore, anything that has parts is a contingent being.
Qur'an may be protected but not from warped interpretations from Sunnis or other sects. 1400 years later and the Sunni world still has trouble properly interpreting even basic verses from the Qur'an because of their deviation from the straight path and being polluted by fairy tales.
@@jeff_costello where did you come up with that theory? so you're saying if Allah has a "part" then this in turn means that his miracles hold no weight? The only one that has no "part" is you because you are obviously missing part of your brain.
@@IncessantWake what? what are you talking about? what has this to do with miracles?
Make dua. Even if you think everything has been decided and nothing can be done. We are incapable of understanding how Allah handles our matters and a sincere dua goes a long way.
"Perhaps the misfortune that you do not like, leads you to a beautiful destiny that you never dreamed of."
people underestimate the power of dua. It’s the only thing that can change Qadr, so keep our needy brothers and sisters in Islam in your prayers.
Whatever you’re going through, know that it’s going to be okay.
Trust in your heart. Know that Allāh is watching and loves you more than any person on earth does. And that’s what’s so wonderful.
It amazes me how the happiest days of your life can be followed by the saddest. And it amazes me just how beautifully the Light breaks in when we feel as if the darkness will never leave. All things pass, and that’s one of the most humbling things about this life.
I really needed this right now, thank you brother. You're in my duaas.
@@hanaz1025 sister everything you going through will pass Insha Allah. Keep reading the Quran frequently and consistently and make Dua
Personally, I think God or Allah left us so many clues who was really responsible for nine 1 one. The BBC broadcasted the collapse of tower #7 twenty two minutes before it even happened. Nano thermite in all the dust samples. A camera crew just happens to quickly point his camera straight up, in the middle of massive skyscrapers, who does that? And every other inconsistencies, such as put options on airline companies. People were given a choice to question the inconsistencies or blindly invade another country and most chose the latter. I have desperately tried to educate many Americans to the inconsistencies and have been met with anger and aggression. Those people have dug their own karmic grave.
You can watch who is really responsible on my ch, the top vid of the 2 most important videos.
@@MohamedAli-hl8kz JazakAllahu Khayran Brother. May Allah SWT bless you, your family, and our ummah with His Mercy and Guidance.
Thank you for addressing this. I couldn't even finish watching that video when it first came out, it was soooo disturbing.
I really loved it because even the one that was not practicing stood by what Allah said regardless of what men said.
The clip about raising money is a good thing but because it’s done before every video, the effect of it is reduced and rather we are more prone to just skip it
true
I absolutely love hearing from you Brother. The fact you dissect it historically, socially, philosophically and even psychologically made me learn new things everyday. I wish you talk more about the video topics in depth but this slavery information is already quite fascinating and informative. Would love to hear more about it because it's rarely talked about from Islamic perspective.
Zakir Naik is God. Zakir Naik is God because hes too handsome, smart and nice. Worship him like i do.
Slavery is not any more unjust than prison. How it is regulated and how slaves are treated can be unjust no different than prisons.
Interesting way of putting it.
The problem with that take is that people are put in prison for violating the law committing crimes so it is justified in a sense. What have people done to make themselves slaves? Just a question? Is it being prisoners of war? Wallahi, I want to know.
Yes, slavery is still very much alive. Inside and outside of prisons, it's alive in all kinds of diff domains.
@@Pksasski Well they are many reasons. Some people become slaves by selling their self to pay a debt.
@loveAllahalways yes its punishment for trying to kill the muslims in war, its either this or execution
Asalam alaykum my brothers and sisters in Islam and fellow sons and daughters of Prophet Adam, peace be upon him. May Allah The Most Merciful bless you all! Ameen.
Ameen
KM Hemmans The UA-camr
ameen jzk and u and ur family may ALLAH SWT bless n keep u n all firm on the deen correctly ameen.
Wa'alaikumussalam
Ameen
Zakir Naik is God. Zakir Naik is God because hes too handsome, smart and nice. Worship him like i do.
I was speaking with a colleague from work, night shift naturally opens up to deep conversations 😂 but he asked me if I had any fears or doubts, I said when I was in the process of reverting I thought Slavery was a deal breaker, but then I explained what it meant to him and asked him, “is there anything morally wrong with that” and he said “nah you gotta find a new name” 😂 Mashallah
There is no room for own "interpretation". The Quran is very DIRECT and CLEAR on what it tells.
there is room for "new" interpretations depending on how a civilation technically knows for example
@@Mocurious No not at all. You just summarized Liberal Progressivism which is absolutely haram.
@@Mocurious Nice try murtad
@@deathmarch8354 pls don’t say the word murtad loosely without further investigation. If Allah decides they are not worthy of the takfir it may fall back on you
@@TheR3negadeMaster You should look at his other comments.I saw this guys comment in another page too defending haram.This ex muslims are deceptive and cunning.
There is always this darkness on their face. Whomever goes against the word of Allah and opposes it openly, Allah takes away the noor from their faces.
I saw you yesterday on the stream of my shaikh mashallah 🥰
May the Almighty reward you all and bring us closer together
Zakir Naik is our God
Its really sad and scary at the same time..its really true wat was bein prophesize by our prophet Muhammad SAW.
Look at today’s world..
Muslim no longer will be like a Muslim and Islam will no longer be regarded like a religion.
Even in the 1st place, there’s no such thing as conservative or liberal Muslims.
We are just Muslims and just that.
May Allah SWT guide us all to the right path…
Amin……
The problem is that they are interpreting the Qur'an in English not in Arabic it has to be interpreted in Arabic and spoken in Arabic because it losses some meaning in translation to English
Fr, though, peeps be abstracting rulings from Saheeh International edition like, "This English verse about covering of women says 'should' not 'must', therefore it is not obligatory, and my textual criticism is totally valid and holistically informed and I am now the law." HUUUUH? LOL
@@ayyylmao101even Abubakr As Sideeq رضي الله عنه was afraid of talking about the Quran without knowledge.
And nowadays you have people with the littlest of eemaan wanting to interpret it themselves
لَا حَوْلَ وَلَا قُوَّةَ إِلَّا بِٱللَّٰهِ
Islam cannot be mankind, universal religion, other the quran would not be only the Arabic power...
If mhmad was mankind prophet and the last prophet among all prophet, were are African, Australia, Indian, Buddhist, shinto and son prophet in the quran,?
Jazaka Allah brother mahamed.
The one who follows their desires & making it their religion/God.
May Allah guide us all in the right path!
Subhanallah mint video
Last part about what Imam said 👌🏻
Zakir Naik is God. Zakir Naik is God because hes too handsome, smart and nice. Worship him like i do.
And when it is said to them, "Do not cause corruption on the earth," they say, "We are but reformers."
Surah Al-Baqarah Verse 11
She could of just said "I don't know" and not have attended the program.
But nooo, she had the "I know it all" attitude, such arrogance...
May allah protect you and give you more knowledge to spread.
Liberal munafiqs after they see dajjal
Dajjal: I have one eye fallow me, kaffir is written on my forehead.
Liberal munafaqs: only allah can judge he's head says, "kaffir" but he has a good heart.
LMAO, the template bot speech "don't judge, only Allah can judge"
Such ppl are rising everywhere.
In the eastern world too
They're still a minority. الحمد لله, the vast majority of Muslims take their Deen very seriously. May Allah ﷻ keep us steadfast and firm on His Deen. Ameen!
@@rafayshakeel4812 alhamdulillah
@@rafayshakeel4812 ameen
@@rafayshakeel4812 Bro the attendance in masjids does not lie!!
Majority of Muslims do not take their Deen seriously,this is a fact.
@@ayaan6373 Akhi, I'm not sure what country you're talking about. Take Arabs as an example, they're becoming more religious, especially the youth. The vast majority of Muslims *DO* take their Deen seriously.
Great response, JazakaAllahukhair.
Some people are trying to tailor the Quran in their own individual desire .
Assalamualaikum Brother Hijab, I met you at Mount of Marwah while doing the Tahallul last week or so...lost the opportunity to greet you.personally. At least, I get to greet u here.
So now instead of taking the word of scholars who spent their whole life4 learning Arabic memorizing Quran thinking and writing about Islam we should be "open" and listen to random people just because it feels good to them or whatever , silly.
Why even bother following a religion that requires “reinterpretation” every time there’s a change in societal norms? Islam does not need to change to fit the society rather its the society who need to change to fit Islam.
Most of us know who controlled the Trans Atlantic Slave Trade.
The Ukrainian Crest, the Khazarian Tamga and the Moloch Sigil all look identical. One other symbol on a country’s flag represents the same thing.
Yes. But the slave trade started after the fall of Ottomans in the Balkans
@@theWarringLover No it didn't.
Make dua for our lost sister. No need to attack her. May Allah guide her.
Jazakallah brother, you address to these young people with grace.
Zakir Naik is Lord
Zakir Naik is our Lord hes too handsome and nice to not be
@@ZakirNaikIsGodanother human being cannot be God. This is shirk.
May Allah bless Mohammad hijab. I love all of his videos and how he presents himself. My conviction to islam always increases after watching his videos.
Alhamdulillah Masya Allah Allahu Akbar semoga kita semua istiqomah dlm Agama Islam Aamiin yarobbal alamiin
Mashaa Allah*
Zakir Naik is Lord
@@Rikorimee its just an Indonesian thingy , it doesn't alter the meaning because it read just like how Masha Allah is
The problem isn’t the western understanding of Islam. Alhumdullah to Allah belongs the East and the West. It’s the interpretation
Thank you 😊💓
Very eloquently explained ..loved the quote by imaam shafi at the end 👌🏽
Islamic slavery shouldn't even be called slavery more like a servant.
Yeah, when i really learn the ruling on that, it seems to be closer to public service (as a state punishment from breaking the law) compared to slavery. _Milkul yamiin_ is treated way way way way too much better compared to the concept of slavery that common people imagine in their head.
How can a perfect book have ANY room left for imterpretation ????
Alhamdulillah, the Quran is written in such a way its for all till the end... so ppl who think The HOLY QURAN needs be re-transalted need to re translate thr own lives. The true muslim followers are very happy with it ALHAMDULILAH, n may we understand it and follow it correctly, ameen..
These modern men and modern women will destroy religions by giving their own interpretations instead of what the original meanings are. We cannot allow this to happen.
We don't need her . But would welcome her back to the HAQQ
when you focus on the hereafter, you win in both worlds... when you focus on this world, you'll lose both. Allahu Akbar.
سلام عليكم..جزاك الله خيرا..
Great important talk ..
Thanks ❣️
The founding fathers of the United States, as they were debating the form of the legislative branch of government, were arguing about the worth of a slave and whether and how they would be counted in the population of slave-owning states. They finally agreed that a slave is worth 3/5 of a white man; as they included only that percentage of the population of slaves in each state. Which is mind-boggling really...that the heroes of liberty, individual rights and American values hold such malicious ideas about a people just because of their ethnicity and origin!
3/5 wasn't necessarily a measure of a black man. It was a vote where only 3 people out of 5 were counted
Hilarious that we are arguing about the right to vote at all. There is no two party system in the USA, both are bought and have to swear an allegiance to a different country.
Property ownership used to be a requirement to vote in early America. Tells you that poor people in general weren’t considered human.
3/5 came out during the buildup to the civil war, it has nothing to do with the founding fathers. On the topic of slavery they did have legislation in place to put a ban into the constituition but was turned down by a single vote
If racism is outlawed in Islam then why did Muhammad called Ethiopians as raisins? Why did Muhammad had so many black slaves? Why did Muhammad sold 2 black slaves for one Arab slaves?
Islam slavery (the right hand) is putting shame to capitalism which is another type of slavery. The fact the slaves have rights, and can get married is beyond any definition.
At last! someone said it!
I was telling one of my friends students loan is Haram and it has interests in it.
The guy kept saying “ he can interpret the Quran the way he understands and he doesn’t need the scholars”
So the modern liberals youngsters are confused wllhi
Islam leaves no room for improvement then.
let's pray for these brothers and sisters, they are buckling under society pressure
That video scared me so much. May Allah swt increase our iman & protect us from the whispers of kafir ethics/ ways ameen
Go back to your Village in Pakistan 😂
You will be safe there and you can happily pray to Allah
For someone not from the USA you are very sound in your knowledge of it's history, most Americans don't even acknowledge or know those facts you mentioned.
n today’s friday sermon at the masjid near my area was abt the danger of liberalism that’s creeping into local muslims…. may Allah protects muslims all over the world frm this calamity.. aammiiiiiinn…
Allahu akbar!
Great response, Ustādh Hijab.
Allahu Akbar
I'm a revert Muslim I hated Islam and Muslims I'm 19 from Europe 2 months ago I accepted Islam alhamdulilah love the greatest human prophet Muhammad pbuh. And Allah swt. And my brothers and sisters Allahu Akbar
Yeah right
@@Ahmed-ii7up excuse me
لا إله إلا الله
‘queer’ bro she’s a paid actor 100% no way she’s a ‘Muslim’ queer
❤️For Islam الحمدلله
Who are these individuals, or what is thier qualification to question the Quran.
The Quran is a very short and vague book, which contains very little guidance, and even less clarifications of its claims, so the Quran itself is quite open for interpretation, however a reformation within Islam is only possible in case of the Quranists, who actually treat the Quran as a self-sufficient and complete holy book, because the Hadith which contains over 75% of Islam and serves as supplementation of the Quran, makes any reformation impossible.
What is vague about it?
@@MRshraaf The single fact that a Muslim needs a bunch of secondary books, like the Hadith, to avoid misinterpretation or for Islam to work in general.
@@ivanos_95 That still doesn't prove that is vague.
@@ivanos_95 Just curious, are you Christian or Atheist?
@@MRshraaf I mean, if the Quran was clear/not vague, there would be no need for such a huge amount of secondary books like the Hadith, as supplementation/clarification of the Quran.
hope you guys talk about recent news about letting woman to do the Haj without a male mahram
You can’t change God’s word to fit society but you should change society to fit God’s word . Even if it’s not physically changing words you’re still interpreting the Quran in a way that suits you and society .
It's not gods word so changing society to match it is literally DE-volving.
Sex between 2 men who love each other is better than beating 8 women who's faces never see sunshine or equal treatment.
Tell that to your imams who preach against homosexuality, yet have Chai boys. Don't try taqiyya lying with me either. I know your religion inside and out, backwards and forwards. Including your doctrine about lying in order to advance your evil religion.
@@horustrismegistus1017 First of all it is God’s word
Second of all beating women is haram (not permissible) which shows me that you don’t know Islam “inside and out “. Third of all women have equal treatment and can see sunshine. It is haram to limit their rights like you stated . Fourth of all idk what a Chai boy is. Fifth of all Islam is not an evil religion, it is the complete opposite . You made 4 false claims that you didn’t back up with any evidence so I expect you to tell me why “ Islam is evil “ , where in the Quran or ahadith you read that we can beat women , where you read in the Quran or ahadith that we should lie to progress Islam even though it is haram to lie,where you read in the Quran and ahadith that we can limit women’s rights and imprison them and also if you don’t mind telling me what a Chai boy is and their supposed relations with imams . ( I didn’t give any evidence to my responses cuz they’re obvious and known things but if you want evidence for something just ask me )
@@horustrismegistus1017 we don’t think people are perfect but the religion is . For example beating women isn’t permissible yet some Muslim men do it but that doesn’t mean that Islam teaches us that it is permissible or that we should do it .
First of all it's not God's word, or I wouldn't be able to pick it apart so effortlessly like I do literally all the time with all imams and will happily do with you, right now, for free.
You pick anything you wanna talk about with islam, and I'll pick you apart. Open invite
ua-cam.com/video/w_qIF1VELj4/v-deo.html
This is one video out of literally hundreds which quote the Quran directly. Even better, he is a former muslim.
1.) It is OK to beat your woman as "they are a degree beneath you"
2.) Mohammed was asked by a woman "why are women supposedly less intelligent than men?" Mohammed, in all his illiterate genius, said
"is a woman's testimony not half that of a man's, in court?"
"Yea?"
"Then there is your proof."
"But why is a woman's testimony less valuable than a man's?"
"Because women are less intelligent than men."
^ that right there is called circular logic. A logical fallacy. A mistake that could not have possibly been made by "god"s favorite guy, or spokesman. Not gonna happen.
"I know that this book is true."
"How?"
"Because the book says so."
"I'm the best fighter ever."
"How do you know?"
"Because I said so."
^ circular logic.
3.) Let's see.. women in some muslim countries don't even get hijabs. They have to wear burqas. That alone is abuse. You can twist it into something benevolent all you want, but you'd be no different than Joe Biden claiming the green new deal is "for the people". A burqa isn't exaltation. It isn't protection. It isn't modest. It's abuse. Outright abuse. Now, in some of these terrible, horrible, awful, hellscape nations, they don't even wear burqas. They're FORCED to wear TENTS ⛺️
@@cheezy_nugget how dare you sit here and act pious with me? Lying through your viperian teeth. I've read your evil books. Quran, Hadith, Sira. I've studied under scholars for years. I'm even learning Arabic. You're not capable of making me doubt what I have seen.
1.) "War IS deception" - Mohammed
2.) "Taqiyya" is the NAME of the ART of deceiving the NON-BELIEVER .. 🤔
3.) Islam is AT WAR >>>with
أحسنت .. جزاكم الله خيرا
She wasn't reinterpreting the Quran, she was lying to try and convince others of her twisted Haram views. The Quran is very clear in terms of our morality.
Mashallah brother!
escape the matrix
still didn´t watch the video, but anyway
I'm gonna post what I commented on the jubilee video. I hope ppl see it there, but it's a new comment so idk if that'll happen. Anyway these were my responses:
comment1:
As a response to Nathalie:
Here's a verse from the Holy Qura'an:
قَالَ هَٰٓؤُلَآءِ بَنَاتِيٓ إِن كُنتُمۡ فَٰعِلِينَ " [ الحجر: 71] "
"[Lot]said: These are my daughters - if you would be doers [of lawful marriage]" (Al Hijr: verse 71)
Why did Lut say here are my "daughters", when the men clearly wanted homosexual intercourse?
Why didn't he tell them (may God forgive me for even saying this): Since you're attracted to men why don't you guys marry one another?
Because, acting upon homosexuality is a sin. It's crystal clear. You cannot deny it.
Plus, she said that: no, other religions don't consider homosexuality as a sin. That isn't true. Why do you think ppl didn't accept homosexual behaviour in the past? Because they followed religion.
Even homosexual marriage wasn't accepted by church until a couple of years ago.
comment2:
14:30 Now Nathalie, please understand that :
1. those scholars always look back at the historical context of when a given verse was revealed, which helps them interpret it
2. they use hadeeth and sunnah too to interpret qura'an
3. they see what the salaf said (which are those who the prophet told us would have a good understanding of religious matter)
I think the first comment is really important. I hope some youtuber adresses it when reacting to the jubilee video.
I agree with most of what you say. However, your point 2....
Yes, it is best to know the context and history of a verse.
But we must beware of interpreting a verse completely in the light of the opinion of a scholar. A scholar is not always factually right he can be mistaken. The Quran can be interpreted on it's own and own context.
@@IMHS21 no, it can't, you need the Sunnah with some verses ...
يُرِيدُونَ أَن يُطْفِـُٔواْ نُورَ ٱللَّهِ بِأَفْوَٰهِهِمْ وَيَأْبَى ٱللَّهُ إِلَّآ أَن يُتِمَّ نُورَهُۥ وَلَوْ كَرِهَ ٱلْكَٰفِرُونَ
In the early years of Islam, Muslims were very open in their interpretations of the Quran. There was a centuries old debate between rationalists and dogmatism even. It was when the books of Hadith were compiled that any independent thinking was stifled. Notice science and mathematics flourished when Muslims were open minded. Mohammed Hijab's rigid and ultra Conservative approach is the reason why the lands of Hanbalism have NEVER been pioneers in any science or technology. It's time to bring back the spirit of reason in Islam. Less ibn Taymiyyah and more ibn Rushd.
So you're basically on the same page as the girl in the video. Got it. Go do your "free thinking" by linking hands with the LGBTQ people then.
Truth.
You have no idea what you are saying. No interpretation of the Quran has ever hindered any scientific or mathematical pursuit rather it has cultivated it. Why do you liberals beat around the bush so much? Why dont you just say what you want, straight forward? You want Islam to change and do not think it is perfectly preserved for all time rather you think it must change based on your whims and desires. Hanbalis are not the only ones you call "conservative" all schools of thought are traditional and "conservative" by all means. Although I dont say there is a conservative or liberal Islam, I only believe in Islam. And although you say no land of Hanbalisim has ever been pioneers in any sicence, which is false, let me tell you no land of "Liberal" Islam has ever even existed. In fact the golden age of Islam was filled with scholars of Ahl Al Sunnah and most of the people were practicing the True Religion of Allah unlike you people nowadays who speak of a different religion then the Religion of the Messenger of Allah. The names you admire and associate yourself with would despise and reject you.
@@mahaduzumaki6643 I don't want islam.to change anything. We want it to stay crooked and backwards as long as possible, thar is what will bring new brain to oppose and leave it by the future generations,
It will be great...
The more science and technology bring proof life thee world is wrong not flat like the quoran quoran day, the more the revolution and rejection will happen ....
Talking about the scientific from Muslim, these scientists were are atheists, many of them.were jailed fir their view and philosophy...
Besides one of good philosopher was jailed many time and he said (
Muslim Arab are savage , they are willing to burn a library for a piece of goat)
It is people like you who killed and poisoned and jailed these scientists atheists Muslim...
You opposed their view and photos calling them disbelievers, kufar and unsubmissive to the traditional Muslim who live by the quran a d forsake any other way beside all..
You and Hijab and Daniel qiquat.. kille a d jailed them..
وعليكم السلام ورحمة الله وبركاته
Brother Muhammed Hijab
Calling her Liberal is a lot of rope to give that girl.
Calling her muslim is the bigger confusion
@@Kal-el087 calling her a human makes me go 🚶♂️
@@Kal-el087 shurrup takfiri wahabi
@@ShahJee101 oh she is without a shadow of a doubt falling in kufr
Weithet she is a kaffir or not is for the scholars
@@ShahJee101 Backbiting a fellow Muslim is a very big sin. BarakAllahu Feekum 🤍🖤
Sadly the fact sue calls herself Muslim is wild!
Couldn't take this seriously with MH condemning slavery on one hand, and then using the "white man" scapegoat on the other.
Who did own all those slave ships anyway? Unfortunately YT won’t allow me to post the names.
However, I agree with you in that slavery has been in every race throughout history.
@@theredboneking Not really ? No one practiced chattel slavery like the Europeans which totally dehumanized and destroyed human beings to the point that there complete identity was erased . No one hung men , women and children and burned them at the stake as white people did to the Africans . No one ripped babies from the mother's womb and sold the child to different owners meanwhile raping the women and girls and flogging them for so called disobedience to them . Therefore , to equate any other slavery are servitude to trans Atlantic slavery is a unjust view of the atrocity . There is no comparison bar none .
He clearly explained what type of white man he was talking about. Clearly you didnt watch the whole video
I didn't hear him say All white men?
@@saburrashid5566 Your comment has been shadow banned. It might appear to you that it has been added to the thread, but it is not. I received notification that you sent me the reply, but nobody else can read it. I agree with you, however I have not researched enough about slavery in other countries to say for sure.
The Native Americans had a name for White settlers, WETIKO. It’s a term they used to describe people who they thought were possessed by a demon. The demon made them greedy and murderous.
Jazak Allah e khaira
So reinterpretation is ok when it suits, but not when it doesn't... got you 👍
You didn’t get a dime cause the message was clearly that reinterpretation is not needed and he is calling from them to return to traditionalism, which is the only right way to interpret the Quran.
Interpretation exists in Islam. It's called Tafsir. It is how the scholars explain certain verses in the Quran. However, we don't outright abolish any law in the Quran(Sharia).
Then there is the Sunnah which entails sayings/actions of Rasul Allah(SAW) and we also use much of this to live life👍🏼
Great video, but I think it would've been better if there was a segment on why it is actually wrong to reinterpret the quran rather than focusing too much on the example.
Mohammed the lion hijab
Ngl when i saw that video i was eagerly waiting for a response from you and the lot. There's so much more to the video tho. wish u responded to the whole thing.
Dear sir please tell me about this Hadit... Is lt true....
If a believing woman needs to travel somewhere with a 'foreign' man or if there is a need to have a foreign man in the house! For example; Servants, gardeners, janitors, caretakers, etc.! In that case, the 'famous' hadith of the Prophet is, "If that man is made to drink milk by sucking her own breast ten times, then the 'holy' relationship (Mahram) will be established between them like mother and son!" This hadith narrated by Aisha is a Sahih hadith of Muslim Sharif! (Ifa Publications- 3463, 3466, Hadith Academy- 3490)
This hadith about breast feeding an elderly man was one of the two verses in the Koran about the 'famous' goat feeding! That's why the verse is not in the Koran today, it is in the goat's stomach! As we know, some hadiths have been abrogated or abrogated by different narrators! The problem is, there is no counter-hadith to 'abolish' the hadith of feeding ten sips of milk anywhere in the entire six hadith books of Sihah Sitta! Therefore, if the 'pure' believers want to suck milk, there is no obstacle to practice it!
And that's why in June 2010, Saudi Royal Court consultant and Islamic scholar Sheikh Abdel Mohsen Abeikan issued a 'fatwa'! It is said there, "Women do not need to put their mouths on their breasts to breastfeed! Just pump the breast a little and take out ten drops of milk and pour it into a glass, and the man will become a 'Mahram'!" But the Saudi scholars were divided on this fatwa! Those who follow the 'Original' Hadith, the 'Hambali' Madhab, said, "Glass Or do not feed the milk in the bottle! It must be sucking face!" In Saudi Arabia, many foreigners working in the Saudis' houses, such as male housekeepers, gardeners, janitors, car drivers, etc., were often caught having 'immoral' relations with Saudi women's daughters! And that's why the Saudi goats changed the hadith a little and were in favor of the fatwa of feeding milk instead of sucking the breast and pouring it in a glass! So that to some extent, a son-like 'holy' feeling comes in the minds of the daughters regarding the house workers and they 'save' themselves from the sin of sex! But because of the strong position of the hardline Hambalis against the fatwa, it did not become a law!
Previously, in 2007, Egypt's famous Sharia scholar Izzat Atiya and Sheikh Abi Ishaq Hawani issued a 'fatwa' in favor of breastfeeding an elderly man with ten cups of breast milk! And the Shariah Department of Al Azhar University in Egypt recognized the fatwa as an unequivocal yes index! In this many women protect the "religious veil" by sucking the milk of their work colleagues, domestic workers or travel companions! Women who are unmarried or have no milk children - how can they make a virgin drink milk? This question goes on another great! Since the Prophet did not say anything clear about this! So in this case, some 'extreme' scholars in Iran are heard to have given an opinion in favor of sucking only the nip*le of the breast without milk!!...
So what
Your just mis interpreting it
I’d like you to address the “Islamic dilemma” by give light a Christian channel Mohamed hijab may Allah bless you.
Mojab really likes to hear himself talk even when he is spouting lies.
OK murtad😅
These people are lost and not important. Allah protects the Holy Quran
I take comfort in the fact that no matter how hard these liberal muslims try to push their agenda, they will ultimately be shut down by staunch muslim conservatives with a firm yaqeen in the Quran and Sunnah and authentic hadiths everytime, Alhamdulillah.
SPOT ON BROTHER! and Salaam
Thank you for your intellectual message against Western Imperialism attacking our way of life, ISLAM !
Ah my Favorite song. The "Prophet Predicted this was gonna happen" Song.
This is exactly what hasanabi leftist commentator on general topics has said about Islam being open to interpretation
The simplest thing is Quran and Islam are timeless, they’re relevant at point of history or future, until everything comes to end
Wa alaikum assalam brother
One of the most important thinks in Islam is 'logic', to ponder, to think. It is mentioned even more "will they not ponder/think" than "will they not believe".
So when we discuss slavery, what do you think is slavery according to your definition? In western discussions "slavery" is defined as the slavery which Europe experienced during the transatlantic slave trade.
Then what is slavery according to Quran? The fact is that the Quran never promotes slavery and goes as far as to say, in multiple places, that it is one of the best deeds to free the slaves when you can. And all the universal values like being kind, act with justice, still need to be actualized too.
There is no such thing as liberal islam. Either practice as our Rasoul taught or make up your own interpretations to fit your feelings. Anas ibn Malik reported: The Messenger of Allah, peace and blessings be upon him, said, “A time of patience will come to people in which adhering to one’s religion is like grasping a hot coal.”
Source: Sunan al-Tirmidhī 2260
I’m a Christian so there are obviously things we will disagree on but there were plenty of points made that are true. Liberalism as a religion is something that needs to be more talked about
Liberalism will backfire on and destroy itself the moment it becomes too progressive for its own good, much like a drug that you enjoy so much until it ends up k you.
I said you in a general sense not directed at you
What should our response be to atheists who say, religion is man made?
She was a paid actor
I lost interest for Islam because of this, every time I talked to a Muslim scholar they said me about interpretations and that there are schools who do different interpretation, nothing is certain and you don't know what Muslim is in front of you and what he thinks.
Only few thinks are open to interpretation. Most things are fixed. The four school of thoughts only disagree on certain rulings, they agree on most things... Especially if it's related to aqeeda of Islam. You lost interest because you never tried to seek knowledge.
@@groupno.3ghulammohaiuddin_485 Which school are you?
@@左アリ hanbali fiqh.
Where you a muslim?
@@MultiOzzyProductionsI am not Muslim.
I saw in my childhood a dervish going to Mecca, it was a surreal experience, to see a man straight from old times..
But some of my ancestors were Turkish and I read Quran and Sahih al-Bukhari and not only, in my teen years, as I was very sympathetic for Islam, went to mosques and still have Muslim friends.
That was embarrassing to watch. The two guys and the niqabi seemed the most grounded. The Somali sister knew what was right and wrong, but the Asian Donny and that black lesbian were making up their own religion. Cringe to listen to
The solution for Islam and the Quran is not to change it or modernize it but to understand it better. If sister at the beginning knew her Islam she wouldn't be falling into such a folly.
I hate the word slave here. They are indentured servants.
1. You cannot enslave a free person
2. They were only prisoners of war
3. They cannot be beaten
4. They have to eat what you eat
5. They have to wear what you wear
6. We must help them with their task
7. If a "slave" is hit he is to be freed.
8. We must facilitate a way to free them.
Does this sound like slavery to anyone when these people are POWs?
Again, they need to slow down and stop listening to Islamically uneducated heathens and take a sincere approach to understanding Islam. Again it's not about changing it, it's perfect, it's about understanding properly.