Parachinar Bleeds: Understanding the Politics of Hate

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 4 січ 2025

КОМЕНТАРІ •

  • @qaisarhussain7940
    @qaisarhussain7940 3 дні тому +7

    I must appreciate the Black hole for arranging such a fantastic programme and thanks Hasrat Turi for presenting case of kurram in a nice way.

  • @muhammadmalick3428
    @muhammadmalick3428 5 днів тому +47

    ہم فلسطین کو رو رہے ہین اور ہمارے بغل مین یہ حال ہے

  • @SyedAli-py1ly
    @SyedAli-py1ly 4 дні тому +7

    Against the road blockage in Parachinar since 80 days, Parachinar protest held in Karachi since 7 days Sindh police beaten and high shelling in the peaceful protester. Please raise voice.

  • @ShoukatAli-y7k8c
    @ShoukatAli-y7k8c 4 дні тому +9

    Thank you The Black Hole for thought provoking programme.

  • @zabnaqvi5393
    @zabnaqvi5393 4 дні тому +14

    ایک مخصوص طبقہ ہمیشہ سے ٹارگٹ رہا ہے پوری دنیا جانتی ہے اہل تشیع ہمیشہ سے قربان ہوتے آ ئے ہیں کتنے گھر ویران کر دیئے گئے تشیع کے

  • @khalidmufti4463
    @khalidmufti4463 5 днів тому +5

    The message of peace Let's make a wave of peace Make peace with everyone From your conscience From your opponent Make peace so that Make this world livable, future generations don't blame us
    Good luck
    Khalid Mahmood

  • @ShortBurstCuts
    @ShortBurstCuts 4 дні тому +3

    Outstanding documentary on Parachinar

  • @unmuktyatree8200
    @unmuktyatree8200 5 днів тому +5

    excellent program, i got master 101 class on Parachinnar issue

  • @primordialarchetypes2927
    @primordialarchetypes2927 5 днів тому +11

    Arz kiya hai, Kashti bhi nahi badli, dariya bhi nahi badla
    hum doobnay waalon ka jazba bhi nahi badla

    Hai shouq-e-safar aisa, ik umr hui hum ne
    Manzil bhi nahi payi, aur raasta bhi nahi badla

  • @amjadfiaz4830
    @amjadfiaz4830 5 днів тому +9

    I love❤shia sunia and Hinduism even humain tnks

  • @PakCurrentaffairs-qn9nq
    @PakCurrentaffairs-qn9nq 5 днів тому +5

    Excellent report and analysis..

  • @ehpasha1
    @ehpasha1 4 дні тому +1

    The most encouraging part about these discussions at Black Hole is that the attendees are also very well informed and ask intelligent questions.

  • @shujaathussain9708
    @shujaathussain9708 3 дні тому +1

    amazingly informative. i watched in a single go. Mashallah, beautiful and intelligent people.

  • @mubarakahmadnasir4242
    @mubarakahmadnasir4242 5 днів тому +16

    میں امریکہ میں ہوں مگر دل پاکستان دھڑکتا ہے پارا چنار نہیں بلکہ پورا میرا پاکستان لہو لہان ہے

  • @nadeemusmani3918
    @nadeemusmani3918 4 дні тому +4

    Very important aspect of the current situation is its international dimensions and regional politics

  • @mrhb1813
    @mrhb1813 День тому

    Mashallah very well, spread awareness among Pakistani nation regarding this game started since 2007 and till now Pakistani nation is suffering due to this terrarium

  • @rajeshkotian7926
    @rajeshkotian7926 4 дні тому +4

    At 18:56 😢 how can hate be so much drilled into a child!

  • @eng.mirzahussain8415
    @eng.mirzahussain8415 4 дні тому +3

    Establishment is responsible for unrest in parachinar

  • @professoraftab7488
    @professoraftab7488 4 дні тому +7

    پرویز ہودبھائی بالکل درست ہیں۔

  • @turiblvd
    @turiblvd 3 дні тому

    Awesome! Just loved this discussion. Thank you

  • @gnerjgvnskvdvnj
    @gnerjgvnskvdvnj 3 дні тому

    Great to see someone creating awareness of whole region

  • @TheMarvellousGB
    @TheMarvellousGB 3 дні тому

    Thanku so much for your support for voice less

  • @zulkifilmasood1817
    @zulkifilmasood1817 3 дні тому

    So much interesting session

  • @sultanaram8095
    @sultanaram8095 5 днів тому +8

    Kurram me peace ke liye frontier Gandhi ki jarurat h jo Aman and peace La sake .satyagrah kare jirga jesa kuchh jo udhar ki society ko qabul ho.

  • @syedaliagha2282
    @syedaliagha2282 День тому

    Appricated hasrat bro love from Germany 👍🏽

  • @ZohaibKhan-p9p
    @ZohaibKhan-p9p 4 дні тому

    Great tutor )-prof.
    Wasem sajjad

  • @313_Army
    @313_Army 3 дні тому

    Thanks for at least highlighting Parachinar issues, which were ignored everytime

  • @zakerin4777
    @zakerin4777 4 дні тому

    Great discussion ❤

  • @AliRaza-ed1zy
    @AliRaza-ed1zy 5 днів тому +1

    Excellent analysis

  • @shahadathussain6023
    @shahadathussain6023 4 дні тому

    Great discussion

  • @KhawajaHamidAli-b8g
    @KhawajaHamidAli-b8g 4 дні тому +5

    PARA CHANAR DIST KURAM OF KPK WAS PEACEFULL, FREE OF DRUG, ZERO MORAL CRIMES, AGAINT TERRIORIST, 100% LITERACY RATES, THIS ALL DRUG SMUGLERS CAME FROM AFGHANI YAZEEDI TALBAN

  • @fakharabbas3750
    @fakharabbas3750 3 дні тому

    excellent effort

  • @ZohaibKhan-p9p
    @ZohaibKhan-p9p 3 дні тому

    Well done Professor..

  • @ShoukatAli-y7k8c
    @ShoukatAli-y7k8c 4 дні тому

    Thank you The Black Hole for the thought provoking programme.

  • @Na51214
    @Na51214 4 дні тому

    Amazing ❤❤❤❤❤

  • @amoldurve1295
    @amoldurve1295 4 дні тому +13

    Nothing to worry about here.
    Since both parties are PEACEFUL, everyone will go to Jannat.
    Continue enjoying PEACE !

  • @razaturi1030
    @razaturi1030 3 дні тому

    Thanks Black holes
    For covering Parachinar issue

  • @Unknownman-j7x
    @Unknownman-j7x 3 дні тому +1

    Shukr hai hai Allah ka Aise debate hona bahut jaruri hai nahi to Maoulavi Pakistan ko jahanum bana dege

  • @drcynidejaffri3573
    @drcynidejaffri3573 День тому

    Thank you Black Hole for becoming our voice

  • @bhatraashid2864
    @bhatraashid2864 3 дні тому

    Kindly upload future videos in parts preferably of 30 minutes to sustain intrest of the audience.

  • @arifhussain217
    @arifhussain217 3 дні тому

    Great

  • @NoorHussain-x9f
    @NoorHussain-x9f 4 дні тому +1

    Our infamous army has to learn to maintain peace and not create chaos and mess

  • @safdar1955
    @safdar1955 5 днів тому +2

    If hate is the weapon of the greedy occupiers of the Kurram region; all the tribes of Kurram should use jirga culture and promote LOVE in the region to fail the designs of the Occupier establishment.

  • @Kenkalsi
    @Kenkalsi 3 дні тому

    1:38:47 great discussion.

  • @ZuhaibHayder
    @ZuhaibHayder 4 дні тому

    Tea was fantastic ❤

  • @NumberWorld
    @NumberWorld 5 днів тому +1

    *Very informative on Khurram Conflict :* this region& its ideology, and fight for resources will never possibly give it the Peace human deserve, all the signs in near time tells that Lumber one Pak Army will continue to play in the Geopolitics of larger region, state of Pakistan never got created, Angrez never LEFT Af-pak region, all ideology within Islam are FIGHTING here, but Label is of PEACE, with this they are in Perpetual unsettling WAR, to be exploited.

  • @AMIN-iu9ry
    @AMIN-iu9ry 4 дні тому +1

    Very unfortunate to listen, how the state is playing with poor Pakistanis.
    Please save the country, stop this dirty game.

  • @syafqil17
    @syafqil17 4 дні тому +1

    To say that Parachinar carnage is not 'secretarian' is side tracking from the facts. Why were the takfiris planted there? Who planted the takfiris?

  • @AlishbaAkram-x2x
    @AlishbaAkram-x2x 5 днів тому +1

    Salam
    I have a Question from pervez hoodbhoy Sir about my Physics degree.

  • @jaspal8jan
    @jaspal8jan 3 дні тому

    Why no session on deaths of 400000 in Yemen?

  • @nameisblank-b3o
    @nameisblank-b3o 3 дні тому

    Just a suggestion to the editor/creator of the video:
    Nobody likes to listen to an AI. I am sure you have a lot of people who could narrate the intro. If not I would love to volunteer. :)

  • @alihamza23478
    @alihamza23478 3 дні тому +1

    This is not shia sunni conflict this is another game imposed on them

  • @LACHIT-w9t
    @LACHIT-w9t 5 днів тому +2

    Pakistan militaries are busy in doing business, how would theu pay heed to these issue.

  • @amjadfiaz4830
    @amjadfiaz4830 5 днів тому +1

    ❤❤❤❤❤

  • @RajeevKumar-mf3lc
    @RajeevKumar-mf3lc 5 днів тому +4

    Eye opening/rasing reality , ground situation 😢

  • @abbasshah2957
    @abbasshah2957 4 дні тому

    The government is not serious to resolve their differences but also some groups exploiting the situation

  • @Guluna_06
    @Guluna_06 4 дні тому

    That's the real representation of Parachinar

  • @kohnasheen
    @kohnasheen 4 дні тому

    Jihad e Afghanistan has enriched the army and its generals but completely destroyed the Pashtun society. When the far sighted and prudent leaders like Bacha Khan criticized their policies they were called traitors.

  • @MohinKMoh_Kamran
    @MohinKMoh_Kamran 4 дні тому +1

    پاراچنار کا مسئلہ نیا نہیں پرانا ہے۔ اس کی مکمل ذمہ دار فوجی اسٹیبلشمنٹ ہے۔ کوئی اور نہیں
    ماشاءاللہ، ان مظاہروں کے لیے جو غیر متشدد ہیں۔
    130 بچے سردی سے اور 1400 بچے ادویات کی کمی کے باعث جاں بحق ہو چکے ہیں۔ یہ غزہ سے بھی بدتر ہے۔ پاکستان جیسا اسلامی ملک مسلمانوں کے ساتھ اتنا برا سلوک کیسے کر سکتا ہے؟

  • @Defender890
    @Defender890 3 дні тому

  • @snathan3198
    @snathan3198 3 дні тому +1

    Religion NOT weaponized in 1946-47?

  • @shaherbanowalajahi5075
    @shaherbanowalajahi5075 5 днів тому +1

    There appear some international hands involved in khurram unrest. Pakistani agencies and establishment is acting according to the instructions from somewhere else than Pakistan. Khurram's geography is attractive for those who eye upon the highly valuable natural resources of the area and its proximity to Afghanistan, Pakistan , central Asia and China.......
    Since 1980, khurram has been bleeding on sectarian lines. Who is the beneficiary?????

  • @shamshassan8848
    @shamshassan8848 4 дні тому

    Bangash, turi tribes are ideologically first line of defense against fitna e khwarij. Our forces need to understand this. Before we safeguard our borders with Afganistan, we need to provide safety and security to our own people.

  • @XandyRay-zv6wg
    @XandyRay-zv6wg 3 дні тому +2

    Shame on Pakistan government

  • @SyedSibteAsghar
    @SyedSibteAsghar 2 дні тому

    Very sorrily I have to say that the common people is waiting for state intervention. I will ask if there's any Ruler in Pakistan. No there is no government. In this case Effectives shouldn't wait for them. Shias have to stand for them. As there is no government.

  • @Bharatiya1998
    @Bharatiya1998 4 дні тому

    You reap what you sow.
    #PKMKB

  • @architectworld786
    @architectworld786 4 дні тому

    This channel’s slogan says “science, art, culture” & we hardly sees any of it in this channel’s videos. 😢 Wrong number

  • @noorbangash2342
    @noorbangash2342 3 дні тому

    جناب ہم 1979 سے پہلے ایک دوسرے کے دکھ درد اور خوشیوں میں شامل ہوتے تھے لیکن یہ جتنے بھی نفرتیں ہیں دونوں طرف سے جو لوگ لقمہ اجل بن چکے ہیں یا بن رہے ہیں یہ جنرل ضیاء الحق کے آخرت کے اکاؤنٹ میں جمع ہو جائیں گے اور وہاں پر ان کے جی او سی، جنرل، اور آرمی آفیسر نہیں ہو نگے نہ وہاں پر پاور ہو گی اور موجودہ جو مظلوموں پر حاکم ہیں چاہیے وہ پولیٹیکل، آرمی یا کوئی اور پاور والے ہیں۔پہلے والوں کے انجام اپنے سامنے رکھیں نہ یہ ہروقت حاکم رہیں گے نہ پاور میں ایک ذات پاک کے جوابدہ ہیں موجودہ آرمی چیف جنرل عاصم حافظ قرآن بھی ہیں۔آپ ہماری حفاظت یقینی بنائیں ہمیں پاگل کتے نے کاٹا ہے کہ اسلحے پر رقم خراب کردیں اور سال میں دو تین مرتبہ صفائی ستھرائی کریں۔یہ جتنے بھی منتظمین ہیں اللہ تعالٰی ان سب کو اجرعظیم عطا فرمائیں آمین ثم آمین۔

  • @il313li
    @il313li 4 дні тому

    Government should back anti taliban forces militarily. Let Shias defend themselves in Parachinar give them support

  • @sumaiyakhan1610
    @sumaiyakhan1610 3 дні тому

    Acha app nay Bagan ka zekar nahi kia jo wah zulam howa

  • @sailyousuf
    @sailyousuf 4 дні тому

    Though most of our woes are due to military occupation of Pakistan and low IQ of generals who have been ruling Pakistan directly or indirectly for seven decades but not every problem is made in GHQ some of our problems are older than Pakistan . It seems audience and experts have absolved across the border factors and local player's role in this slaughter of humanity and levelled major proportion of the blame on security forces as if this region was a utopia before 1947 .

  • @shinawarali313
    @shinawarali313 4 дні тому

    Barrister Saif will take a u turn later as his leader do. PTI's Provincial Government's irresponsible behavior is condemnable.
    One Bro is telling about Bagan Bazar is ablazed but ignoring innocent people traveling were martyred. Foods trucks are looted by these people how they are affected by the road block is sucha an absurd view.

  • @aijazali7667
    @aijazali7667 4 дні тому

    Sar agar secorti idare agar 1 ya 2 saall aman o aman qaim kar den to logon ka etmaad bahaall hoga bad me khud hi log asilahe ka Sahara chor den ge .

  • @NiazHJafri
    @NiazHJafri 4 дні тому

    😭😭😭

  • @allahdinosamo7654
    @allahdinosamo7654 4 дні тому +1

    All this discussion shows sectarianism is new Afghan jehad for them to earn dollars and have islands in Australia !!!

  • @zebaurang6590
    @zebaurang6590 5 днів тому

    Allah hamari army ko hadayat de

  • @YFi-Pk
    @YFi-Pk 4 дні тому

    Pakhtun Taba dy pa dee che deir khar demagh dy .... Punjabi eday pa kuna k jihad nabsalo and Punjab pa khapala aman k dy .... da malk nor nashi patay k dai ...

  • @AliKhan-me4mn
    @AliKhan-me4mn 4 дні тому

    india chand pe pohnch giya h our Pakistan ki awam ko apni Jaan ka tahafuz nhi h 💔

  • @NoorHussain-x9f
    @NoorHussain-x9f 4 дні тому +1

    Saudia involvement k baaray koi zikr nahi hua

  • @hitmanpubg1486
    @hitmanpubg1486 4 дні тому

    #Shiagenocide in Pakistan since 1980

  • @ZuhaibHayder
    @ZuhaibHayder 4 дні тому

    Devapunization should not be in view in any case.

  • @freetraveler865
    @freetraveler865 4 дні тому

    What will Muslims do with Peace...??

  • @SyedSibteAsghar
    @SyedSibteAsghar День тому

    Hai jurm zaeefi ki saza Marge mafajat. Deaponization, what does it means. ham Imam Hussain ki aulad Hain Sirf 72 afraid k Sath thousands ki fauj k samnay AA gayay Thay. Hamain APNA difa khud karna paraiga.

  • @atiquenawaz1477
    @atiquenawaz1477 5 днів тому +2

    دوسروں کو الزام دینے کی بجائے اپس میں اتفاق پیدا کریں۔ جرگہ میں بیٹھ کر بات کریں، یہاں انٹللیکٹیول کہانیاں مت سناہیں۔

  • @husseinjaffer1607
    @husseinjaffer1607 3 дні тому

    Yeh Bap ka naam khul kar ke lelo. Pakistan needs a grassroots revolution.

  • @DesiLiberalCommunity
    @DesiLiberalCommunity 3 дні тому

    Pakistan Army is doing all mess in Parachinar l.

  • @alinaqvi3702
    @alinaqvi3702 5 днів тому

    boltay raho

  • @irfanpasha5466
    @irfanpasha5466 3 дні тому

    herat,he,jo,log,,qtl,am,kerte,haen,wo,bhi,apne,ap,ko,musalman,kehte,haen,,,

  • @arungupta3509
    @arungupta3509 5 днів тому +2

    Since when is 35% literacy high literacy?????

  • @HOWTO-hh6kg
    @HOWTO-hh6kg 3 дні тому

    Allah Rahim

  • @kalidasswaminathan4341
    @kalidasswaminathan4341 4 дні тому

    Maulana Abul kalam Azad in 1947:
    ua-cam.com/video/LTr5MvkhKc8/v-deo.htmlsi=Ag3cEqN9JMRwxT0N

  • @zebaurang6590
    @zebaurang6590 5 днів тому +2

    When nation stand parachinar brother whether Shia or suni we r Pakistani no debate about sect we r Muslim foil our enemy efforts to divide us Pakistan zindabad ❤

    • @unmuktyatree8200
      @unmuktyatree8200 5 днів тому +1

      listen to vlogs on Identity crisis - its real ...

  • @prakashiyer8637
    @prakashiyer8637 4 дні тому

    Pak intellectualism. Only enumeration no solutions.
    Fire change hoodbhoy is forced to listen. All audiance are bored.

  • @Kanishka-d6w
    @Kanishka-d6w 5 днів тому +7

    *If I am correct, all 64 firkey of islam including ahmadiya or quadiyani live in india (which has almost 240 million muslims, though unofficially they are about 290-295 million) peacefully not only with each other but also with their hindu, sikh, christian, jain, buddhists and even tribal brothers and sisters*

  • @kalidasswaminathan4341
    @kalidasswaminathan4341 4 дні тому +1

    The pigeons are coming home to roost.

  • @atifakhatoon8369
    @atifakhatoon8369 3 дні тому

    Kalyan chorr

  • @indigenous_clips
    @indigenous_clips 5 днів тому

    Fate of Pakistan's hate politics

  • @hamzamahdi104
    @hamzamahdi104 4 дні тому

    The parachinar the most oppressed shiite Muslims on earth besiged from all sides facing discrimination, genocide, ethnic cleansing and targeting killing 😢 🇵🇰 ❤

  • @Mohed-g8i
    @Mohed-g8i 4 дні тому

    Blocking roads & water for minority is cowardice.

  • @Poison_Top
    @Poison_Top 4 дні тому

    guest ke rahe hai ke hum to sach bolne ki koshish kar rahe hai but har baat har fect ke sath galeban lagake konsa sach bola ja sakta hai mujhe to samjh nahi aata….