Fighter Tier List

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 4 гру 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 103

  • @savenok4869
    @savenok4869 7 годин тому +105

    Hm... I dont think this video is about missiles

    • @Kuba_K
      @Kuba_K 7 годин тому +28

      What are fighters if not smart missiles

    • @etieskrill7565
      @etieskrill7565 6 годин тому +3

      @@Kuba_K Dude i just watched your vid on Kite vs High-Tech SF in disbelief, and read your tease in the description about Wolf vs Ziggy on 500 subs, so i was like - where's the video, huh? Let's just say my jaw dropped when i looked at your newest rendition (ik those uploads were 6mo ago, but i didn't get any recommends on you sadly)

    • @SneedRemembrancer
      @SneedRemembrancer 3 години тому +1

      Some fighters also shoot missiles

  • @funnyscope5414
    @funnyscope5414 7 годин тому +48

    Conceptually, fighters always seen cool to me - starwars and stuff, right? But I always have trouble making anything other than bomber spam work, hopefully this tierlist helps

  • @TheHuffur
    @TheHuffur 4 години тому +5

    Its brought up at the end of the Trident segment but I think the Defensive Targeting Array itself is worth highlighting for use with bombers, in general the bombers seem reluctant to use their weapons from max range likely due to aiming issues so they often fly almost/into even 400-500 range where they get shot down by PD even though their torpedoes have like a 1200 range.
    On the other hand if you tie them to the ship with the DTA they become much more willing to fling their torpedoes from longer range.
    Having Longbows and Tridents flinging Sabo/guided Atropos from the "safety" of their carrier where they almost instantly reload might be such a dirty tactic you have to take a shower afterwards.

    • @vos2693
      @vos2693 14 хвилин тому

      Wow, that's interesting, never thought of this.

  • @Propietario283
    @Propietario283 5 годин тому +7

    What I appreciate about these tier lists is that you acknowledge existence of boring tactics, like SO or fighter spam, but don't praise them as the best way to play.
    Only thing to add here is that (for me) role of carriers in the fleet is to compensate for something it lacks. Struggle with big meaty targets - get bombers, struggle with fighters swarms - get interceptors. It's a nice way to round your composition up a little.

  • @DreamingAboutDragons
    @DreamingAboutDragons 5 годин тому +13

    The mining pod has a somewhat unique use on a Legion build that focuses on the battle half of "battlecarrier". It's a lot of ablative hitpoints that hang out in front of your shield, still work while you vent, and still do PD (via a million tiny lasers or facetanking) while you vent - and they'll never wander away to do other things, without any need to spend points on mods for that behavior.

    • @vos2693
      @vos2693 34 хвилини тому

      Very much this. Mining pods can facetank reapers, and these are drones so having them won't drain your crew in super-long expeditions. Logistics matter.

  • @Aereto
    @Aereto 7 годин тому +10

    Swarm missiles turning from frag to HE gave Talons formidable glass cannon teeth.
    They will destroy shieldless wings when they are left to wreak havoc, and frigates that lack point defense coverage will find their armor ripped apart by missiles, then hull shredded by vulcans. They are easily taken out by most weapons, so they are better leveraged with other fighters who cover other roles.

  • @poi9311
    @poi9311 7 годин тому +10

    I WAS IN YOUR TOP %4 VIEWERS IN 2024 ACCORDING TO UA-cam WRAPPED!! YOU WERE ALSO MY FAV UA-camR WHICH CHECKS OUTTT

  • @ahmataevo
    @ahmataevo 2 години тому +2

    On an Odyssey using tachyon lances or plasma cannons, claws help a lot for additional point defense, especially as the player ship when the enemy fleet sends literally ALL their fighters and bombers at the Odyssey. Odyssey is built for flanking and outmaneuvering the enemy fleet (with the right skills and mods) so it doesn't make sense to use its bays for normal fighter or bomber runs.

  • @Mudsson
    @Mudsson 2 години тому +3

    I had a bad day then I saw this notification. I am having a good day.
    Thank you Mr bigbrain

  • @DrmChsr0
    @DrmChsr0 5 годин тому +2

    Finally... a video tutorial on how to meme using Buffalo MkIIs and Mules (with Converted Hangars)!

  • @TNTacdc
    @TNTacdc 4 години тому +3

    I always found fighters the most difficult to use, probably because it's hard to keep track of their performance during a fight, so this tier list should help me suck less with them!

  • @tetriscleveland3478
    @tetriscleveland3478 6 годин тому +6

    Surprised to see sarissa so high. In my experience canister flak is fantastic in theory but they literally never use to stop missiles unless they are already engaging bombers, presumably because they don't see themselves as the target.

  • @TheSweetSpirit
    @TheSweetSpirit 5 годин тому +5

    Your video is well composed and good quality like usual. I’ve actually been looking into all vanilla fighters a lot and I have a lot of experience with when and how to use each one.
    Gladius needs to be at least one tier below wherever the broadsword is, if not the same tier of wherever you put the broadsword. You mentioned how broadsword can’t sustain their machienguns dps. Gladius has much better flux dissipation, with the same amount of light machineguns per model. It takes about 2? seconds for the DPS of 2 gladius models to surpass outputs to surpass 3 models. The Gladius very rarely fires its ir pulser, so it doesn’t reduce its light machinegun dps. You mentioned this later on when talking about the claw, but the Gladius is also faster on top of higher sustained DPS. It’s outright just better at working with fighter wings. Gladius also works well as a higher kinetic dps variant of an escort for battle carriers. Personally, I would put Gladius one tier lower than broadsword, but not any more than that.
    Claw and Thunder - just want to mention, their emp doesn’t benefit from target analysis elite so if the enemy happens to have damage control wlite, the emp damage they deal is almost worthless. Most relevant when fighting remnant.
    Spark - these are more like C tier to me, for two reasons. One, they are a high model count with shields, so they can actually be extremely annoying to protect a ship by escorting a ship with their shields. That wouldn’t be enough for me, but also the spark (or any wing!) can benefit from an officer using point defense, including the elite point defense version. Spark with 50% more damage to missiles/fighters and +200 range is really, really good at clearing missiles and fighters, it might even outrange flare fighters before they launch flares. If you also use DTA, that’s an even bigger damage bonus. None of this is like, meta defining, but it’s very notably powerful support solution.
    I’ll make a reply later with more thoughts once I get to watch more. I don’t think I’ll have much to say based on the whole tier list, maybe I’d suggest dagger and flash be higher but it depends

  • @Stlaind
    @Stlaind 4 години тому +3

    I'm going to advocate a bit for the sparks. In a general sense they're really not great, but conditionally they can be fantastic.
    I've found that they make a fantastic use for the fighter slots on the Odyssey. There they solve the problem I need fighters for most there, where I want the short term extra PD while I dash in, and then while I boost out to dump flux they recharge and finish replenishment.
    I won't argue that they're A, or even B, but i think they have uses beyond what I would put in D.
    I'm also going to advocate for Warhogs in B. I did a lot of testing with the Legion as a battlecarrier using 2 onslaughts as my benchmark opponent, no officer (can't remember if i had the carrier fleet skills). The only fighters that contributed meaningfully to the fight were the Warthogs. That extra armor kept them in the fight, kept the pressure up on the PD, and chewed up armor fast when they got to it.

  • @yassinet5
    @yassinet5 7 годин тому +16

    Broadsword spam my beloved

  • @magimagi5004
    @magimagi5004 5 годин тому +1

    1:30 that's a cool detail that I didn't know! But what happens if timid officer commands bomber-only heron? I'm sure you could make a whole video about officers, skills and personalities!

  • @GarncarzLizyp
    @GarncarzLizyp 7 годин тому +8

    Gonna watch the shit out of this one when I'm back from work. Loved two previous ones. You make premium content good sir. Cheers!

  • @donk8961
    @donk8961 2 години тому +1

    I’m just here to say
    Fighter spam alone? Countered by PD
    Missile spam alone? Countered by PD
    MISSILE AND FIGHTER SPAM? WOE UNTO MY ENEMIES

  • @MrLuu-iw6wr
    @MrLuu-iw6wr 7 годин тому +29

    You missed motes /s.

    • @digitalizedmind6784
      @digitalizedmind6784 6 годин тому +1

      Those are projectiles not fighters so they will be in the missile tier list

  • @warriorfire8103
    @warriorfire8103 6 годин тому +2

    Not even done and already definitely my favorite video of the series. I don't recall anyone else covering them this well

  • @aspol15
    @aspol15 Годину тому +1

    I love so much this cannel, thank you for the effort

  • @insomnifaxxwmaxx7244
    @insomnifaxxwmaxx7244 4 години тому +2

    I think you could get a lot if humor value of hypothetical discussions between Paul Bingus and Chaddikus Rex

  • @awesierra704
    @awesierra704 5 годин тому +1

    I used to like the mining pod specifically for converted hangars back in 0.91, since mining drones have an above average hull and armour they could just facetank shots for your enforcers and make them into even more of a low tech brick, but now that converted hangars increase the DP of the ship I don't think it's worth using at all.

  • @magimagi5004
    @magimagi5004 7 годин тому +5

    I'm half an hour late, and there's so much comments already... Glad to see so many ppl respecting the only right opinion out there

  • @Bvoid-b
    @Bvoid-b 3 години тому

    Really good video, I like how you thoughtfully share your opinions on each part! Sarissa

  • @WormF00od_
    @WormF00od_ 6 годин тому +3

    i love the concept of the piranha i just wish they got a buff

    • @bigbrainenergyguy
      @bigbrainenergyguy  6 годин тому +3

      I forgot to mention they are getting a buff next patch. We'll have to wait and see how that plays out.

  • @singpizza8547
    @singpizza8547 7 годин тому +6

    I honestly would love a video simply about commanding a fleet. I mainly just make escort groups focused on a larger ship. Sometimes it's a cruiser with a frigate, or a capital with a couple cruisers and a few destroyers. I don't really focus on the objectives, but if I can grab one I do. I know I'm not doing it well, and I'm pretty much at a standstill when I'm reaching the point when I'm fighting larger fleets with my large fleet beyond just brute force and more ships. I try watching other people play the game and command their fleets, but it's difficult to understand what is happening and why they use the different orders that they do.

    • @bigbrainenergyguy
      @bigbrainenergyguy  7 годин тому +7

      It's going to take some time, but that is something I've got in the works.

    • @WhiteFang103
      @WhiteFang103 7 годин тому

      It's a complex subject. All the ships you have and the loadouts you chose to them all the way to ordering them and who is piloting them in combat effects everything dramatically.
      Some fleets literally require zero orders and you can wipe everything, while if you start to order them around they take losses / gets defeated. Meanwhile another fleet comp requires specific orders to succeed.
      This also makes Starsector so good. So many playstyles, ships and fleet builds.

  • @georgestarkey5448
    @georgestarkey5448 7 годин тому +2

    I always enjoy using the khopesh and seeing it just piss missiles, but the cobra is just, the cobra y'know

    • @georgestarkey5448
      @georgestarkey5448 7 годин тому +1

      Also, wanted to know what peeps think of Corvette sized fighters from different mods

    • @sgi_cris3780
      @sgi_cris3780 4 години тому

      @@georgestarkey5448 i wish corvette craft were an actual thing in the game, working like fighters where they can keep being replaced, but being able to change their loadout according to your needs

  • @KidMangaX
    @KidMangaX 28 хвилин тому +1

    Woah, an actually good tier-list! Only thing I'd change is move Dagger to A, they are fantastic on the Astral. Everything else is fine, and I _definitely_ agree on the Sarissa. Recently, they're my favorite fighter wing. Perditions need a buff, they are in a sad state at the moment. Might even move them to F until it happens.

    • @vos2693
      @vos2693 6 хвилин тому

      Perdition is worse than nothing (mining drone), put it in P-tier.
      Perdition could be buffed by some serious reduction of its replacement time, to reflect its low-tech lore.

  • @exbenn
    @exbenn 6 годин тому +1

    TIL that Sarissas actually are not as bad as I thought they were. Might try it in my next run.

  • @veritascalivmeir3708
    @veritascalivmeir3708 6 годин тому +2

    If you think about it, fighters are basically missiles anyway

  • @dakota0000001
    @dakota0000001 5 годин тому

    Was expecting missiles first, but fighters is a pleasant surprise.

  • @starrfluff9236
    @starrfluff9236 2 години тому

    Funny thing is that I find the speed of Perditions to actually synergize really well with Pilums. They go about the same speed, so if you put two Pilums, two Perdition wings and a Broadsword wing on a Mora the entire strike package of missiles, escort and bombers will arrive at the target at the same time and absolutely overwhelm PD.

  • @hotdog9262
    @hotdog9262 7 годин тому +1

    wasps and talons get incredible dps and range with defensive targeting array and elite PD skill. their dps vs fighters and missiles increase with 100% and range 200

  • @szilagyimate
    @szilagyimate 4 години тому

    Man, that was such a good watch, and also educational. So much info that explains the fighter's occasional stupidity in battle. I always used the shielded fighters thinking that they would do better because of survivability, but seeing almost all of them placed lower in the tier list just confirms my feelings of disappointment when it came to them. Thats why I started just spamming warthogs, but man... poor warthog got robbed hard with that C. However, going unga bunga warthog spam generally worked "fine" so that C checks out I guess. Also, I always thought that cobra would be shit when it comes to replacement, so I never really used them. Gonna try out them and the other combos you mentioned on my upcoming playthrough.

    • @bigbrainenergyguy
      @bigbrainenergyguy  3 години тому +1

      Warthogs are mostly held back by forcing the carrier to get close and stay close to the target. Battlecarriers can do this, but they will usually prefer support fighters.
      If your carriers are survivable enough to pull it off, then the warthogs shine.

    • @szilagyimate
      @szilagyimate 2 години тому

      @bigbrainenergyguy Also, that legion build with the kopesh and gauss seems cool. Never even thought of that combo, with legion being flux starved. But that is why im here, I can always use more bigbrainenergy.

  • @Spencer-q9h
    @Spencer-q9h 5 годин тому +1

    My issue with fighters has always been that they are cool in concept but simply do not perform that well unless you have a LOT.
    Or they do reasonably well if they are tough single entities, but then they are technically corvettes/light frigates.
    They can be very good as point defense, very cost effective if you get 0 point drones to defend you. Suddenly you have another 12 point defense weapons that can all point in any direction.
    The biggest issue though is the game performance impact. I found that the game was far happier once I banned myself from using missiles and fighters, it just struggles with so many independent enemies. Especially fighters that are all trying to pathfind, attack, and take damage.

  • @dakota0000001
    @dakota0000001 4 години тому +1

    It often feels like fighters are pretty nice right up until I fight an onslaught with two devastators and take note that my fighter wings are just dead the whole time if they get near it. I wonder what would be the ideal fighter against such powerful anti fighter.

    • @bigbrainenergyguy
      @bigbrainenergyguy  3 години тому +1

      In that case the best thing is to bring direct combat ships that can confront the onslaught head on with some hefty emp. Devastators aren't much of a threat when they're offline.

    • @ahmataevo
      @ahmataevo 2 години тому

      They can't make a frontal assault in that situation, against an onslaught you're better off having a carrier on each side launch towards it. It can only turn to one side at a time if it chooses to turn to face the fighters, and one group will be certain to hit the engines. Tactics is just as important as the ships you're using after all.

    • @dakota0000001
      @dakota0000001 Годину тому

      @@bigbrainenergyguy Yea, the EMP is pretty nice for that, rounds out what the carriers can't handle. I feel I tend to go too all or nothing with fleet compositions at times.

    • @dakota0000001
      @dakota0000001 Годину тому

      @@ahmataevo I guess the main issue is the devastators cover the left and right side and the front melts whatever comes at it from all the guns firing and there's a shield, so I'd have to get it from behind, but they usually have a fleet backing them from that side. The Onslaught would likely be facing forward towards a combat ship infront of it rather than bothering to turn towards the fighters. Besides that fighters tend to circle an enemy ship and die regardless of direction they come in from.

  • @MrKadulal
    @MrKadulal 4 години тому

    One iteresting take for mineing pods is useing it a "replacement" for the small weapon slots you would normaly use for PD anyway, in theory Freeing OP for a more offensive loadout.

  • @szilagyimate
    @szilagyimate 7 годин тому +3

    oh wow, spoiler alert for the hiver run
    Thx for the fighter tier list! I love em but suck using them (unless its the warthog... love me some warthog spam)...

  • @arbikiuszelemelek3347
    @arbikiuszelemelek3347 6 годин тому

    Finally I will now know how to use anything that isnt broadsword

  • @iamthe6366
    @iamthe6366 5 годин тому

    The range boost from elite pd skill is really good for increasing dps of fighters

  • @Nahinalau
    @Nahinalau 7 годин тому

    Perfect vid for my carrier/converted hangar only run!

  • @wilsonspicher6690
    @wilsonspicher6690 6 годин тому +2

    Xyphos in converted hanger is really good on champion with tach and hvd

  • @valeralishko8125
    @valeralishko8125 7 годин тому +2

    Hell yeah, another great tutorial

  • @firekin5624
    @firekin5624 7 годин тому

    This man is unstopable!

  • @vorpal_void
    @vorpal_void 3 години тому

    I'm eagerly awaiting Meme tier.

  • @MrKibitt
    @MrKibitt 6 годин тому +1

    Hey, regarding Piranha and Flash Bombers, the best way to add reliability and flexibility to them is to fly a flagship Doom. Enemies will always run away from Doom mines so you can place 2-4 down to make any enemy turn around into the bomb wave. Failing that you can try strategies to inflict flameout with high mobility emp and kinetic damage, but the sheer amount of dmg these bombers deal makes it worth building around them. I have run double astral setups to good effect vs all manner of fleet using both piranha and flashes once I got enough of those. Highly recommend 2 afflictors for debuff and point capture as well.

    • @MrKibitt
      @MrKibitt 6 годин тому

      In general, because these bombers represent a huge amount of potential damage *and* ways exist to enable the application of that damage, I would rate them both maybe 1 category higher. Good ships and strategies make them way better, but they *do* restrict your strategies and aren't going to function on their own so rating them any higher is a bad indicator for people who want to just include "good" fighters.

  • @birbii8273
    @birbii8273 7 годин тому +2

    NO way we have Fighter tier list before Missle tier list. What is this personal beef with rockets that go boom :/ gimme PLEASE

  • @atomiccheddar
    @atomiccheddar 6 годин тому

    Nothing but Longbows on an Astral is perhaps not the most versatile, but OH MY is it fun to overflux anything it touches. And the PD laser does somewhat defend themselves from other fighters.

  • @Bernardo_tesch
    @Bernardo_tesch 6 годин тому

    "360 no scoping laser"

  • @94ionut
    @94ionut 2 години тому

    i had a save, where i used 8 pirate eradicators and 10 condors for the cheap 5 deployment points per fighter bay slot, had a lot of fun but i also experimented with different kind of wings, the worst that i noticed was when i used a bunch of fighters, like claws, wasps, sparks... i couldn't just figure it out why the hell do i ran out of fighters in a really short amount of time... as soon as switched those to talons, problem solved, all the enemy ships were constantly getting swarmed by fighters and i was confused as hell cause i thought they are one of the worst since they are literally available day 1 together with the broadswords... now i learned something from the video, as long as i stay below a total of 35 ish seconds replacement time per wing, i'm gucci even for prolonged battles, also learned that wasps are not that bad either... i just need to know what to throw them at... definitely not ships as i used to do, but other fighters

  • @zunwarshinn8193
    @zunwarshinn8193 7 годин тому +2

    Wings of liberty!! Let's Gooo!!

    • @zunwarshinn8193
      @zunwarshinn8193 7 годин тому +1

      Just the first 2 minutes already saving captain around the Sector. Only John Sextor can do this things

  • @sdoo-ou2ni
    @sdoo-ou2ni 7 годин тому

    on a carrier the first thing you should do is put fighters in the carrier before you do anything else with it before you add Sons before you add flux before you add weapons the fighters go on

  • @dmitrygolubev9398
    @dmitrygolubev9398 6 годин тому +1

    Can't say I agree with the placement of mining drones.
    Their purpose is to be projectile sponges that reduce DPS your enemies have against the ship that has them, as they are beefy, the hulls after their destruction are beefy, and the box formation makes all 4 of them be able to block Incoming damage on ships like Prometheus Mk. II and Invictus.
    Talons, even with defensive targeting array, will not do any of this, that's on top of the fact that a willingness to pay for targeting array means you can probably shove in a better defensive fighter instead.
    That's not to say that Talon isn't good at being an Interceptor, but I wouldn't use Talon's at all if only 1 ship in my fleet has fighter decks, and that ship is something like Sparrowhawk - so, a battlecarrier with way too few OP to spare on fighters. Because mining pods will just work, regardless of fleet comp, only restricted to specific ships. Talons need a critical mass, or they get eaten by PD before they get to do anything
    I think F was unwarranted. Mining pods could've gotten away with a D

  • @grievous6930
    @grievous6930 6 годин тому

    Man there was one loud lip smacking noise at the beginning of the video and now I can't help but hear it so loudly every time it happens aaaaaahhhhh.

    • @bigbrainenergyguy
      @bigbrainenergyguy  6 годин тому

      I don't notice when recording, but every time I listen to one of my videos I notice every single one... I didn't realize I did it so much.

  • @SuperZigbot
    @SuperZigbot 6 годин тому

    Broadswords stay winning rahhhhhh

  • @wbfscv331
    @wbfscv331 3 години тому

    About the 4x Khopesh and Gauss setup on the Legion, do you use Defensive Targeting Array or not. Khopesh's are one of the few fights with good enough engagement range that they can still fire at long range even with DTA.

  • @crumble1400
    @crumble1400 7 годин тому +1

    Just in case you make a ship tier list, could you group them up by ship size rather than low tech, midline and high tech?

    • @bigbrainenergyguy
      @bigbrainenergyguy  7 годин тому +7

      Yup! That makes the most sense. If anything, each ship size might get its own video.

  • @AltereggoLol1
    @AltereggoLol1 Годину тому

    I never liked the longbow, because the AI is _really_ good at flickering their shields to take sabots. I could never line up the torpedoes and sabots to hit at the same time.

  • @cultistofdarkness1661
    @cultistofdarkness1661 7 годин тому

    Wasnt the cobra bug patched out tho? Not sure which patch it would be, but i never seen this happen for quite a while. It was mostly a visual bug i guess, or low importance cuse the duplicated cobras ment that the orignals would just park themself and not actually go out in another attack run, that would be ridiculously overpowered

  • @HotDog14500
    @HotDog14500 7 годин тому

    Hell Yeah

  • @aisir3725
    @aisir3725 7 годин тому

    Alex has gotta make replacement rate's drain rate be proportional to replacement rate itself
    I might be crazy but i don't see reason why game needs RR death spiral

  • @KevetteofArethria
    @KevetteofArethria 20 хвилин тому

    Would a steady officer on a carrier with wasps be viable? Especially if you are capital heavy/cruiser heavy fleet composition? It would allow you to not put as much PD on your ships freeing up ordinance points for other things, right?

  • @phailupe2941
    @phailupe2941 3 години тому

    The best fighter is

  • @777CHEKIST777
    @777CHEKIST777 14 хвилин тому

    Oh no, where are the subtitles :(

  • @calvingall9685
    @calvingall9685 5 годин тому

    What about the fighters that come with the tempest and the shepherd ?

  • @kronox5109
    @kronox5109 7 годин тому

    Gaming

  • @filipgiczewski7738
    @filipgiczewski7738 7 годин тому +2

    1st! Love the videos!

  • @Hardwaregeekx
    @Hardwaregeekx 16 хвилин тому

    👍

  • @mllhild
    @mllhild 3 години тому

    How do you tell fighters to regroup? It took me months to figure out that I could press Z in combat view to attack something.

    • @bigbrainenergyguy
      @bigbrainenergyguy  3 години тому

      Z does both. There's a little text in the bottom left of the screen that tells you which mode they're on, and you use Z to toggle.

  • @johnx140
    @johnx140 7 годин тому

    Gamination?!

  • @romindous
    @romindous 2 години тому

    25:22 [Unsubscribed] xD