The Ink Black Heart full Q&A with Robert Galbraith (J.K. Rowling) (September 22nd, 2022)

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 21 лис 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 184

  • @R0CK0Nbaby
    @R0CK0Nbaby 2 роки тому +127

    Here because I literally just finished IBH and I really didn't want it to end. Jo is such a mastermind, her books are pure magic, and I am so thrilled to hear how far along she is on the next one and that she already has ideas for the 2 after that! She's literally the only reason I read novels, and I'm so grateful for her! Long live JKR!!!

    • @Sam_Ardern_II
      @Sam_Ardern_II Рік тому +3

      Running Grave is even better ! Hope you have started reading it already as I have 😊

    • @R0CK0Nbaby
      @R0CK0Nbaby 10 місяців тому +3

      @@Sam_Ardern_II I actually just finished reading it right now, and omg it's definitely the best one so far! As usual, so addicting, really didn't want it to end, and I keep rereading the last chapter!

    • @deborahwylde1410
      @deborahwylde1410 10 місяців тому +1

      I've just been given IBH as a birthday present, so it's really encouraging to read your comments! 😊

  • @preddysun_official6913
    @preddysun_official6913 2 роки тому +140

    You're an amazing woman. Don't ever forget that

  • @jayque
    @jayque 2 роки тому +112

    You are LEGEND. All who do and say otherwise lack any intellectual capacity of basic IQ, moral, zero imagination, sensitivity, strength. You are a talented, courageous, amazing human being. You must be supported. #JKRowlingRise

    • @judithpriestess7781
      @judithpriestess7781 Рік тому +12

      Could not agree more! Most of her detractors likely haven't read her essay or anything else for that matter. They certainly wouldn't have the capacity to intelligently digest content or the courage/agility to shift their firmly held, half-baked, irrational, totalitarian "beliefs".

  • @SagarsDeck
    @SagarsDeck Рік тому +20

    What an incredible writer, she is. TIBH was such a complex plot to write. She did it seamlessly. Looking forward to the next book of the series. ❤❤

  • @elizeusoares7983
    @elizeusoares7983 2 роки тому +59

    Listening her explain these to characters it's so incredible. I could stay here for hours! Thanks again for posting it! Regards from Brazil.

  • @jlenardwang977
    @jlenardwang977 2 роки тому +34

    God I enjoy the way she speaks. Some magic thing going on.

  • @dudette7681
    @dudette7681 2 роки тому +28

    I missed those long witty creativity and craft centered type of interviews with her!!!

  • @denasherick6877
    @denasherick6877 2 роки тому +19

    I really enjoyed hearing her speak about the book. Having read the book twice, I am again impressed with the characterization, plotting, and completeness of the plot lines. I enjoy reading about Robin and Strike and look forward to the next installment. I love the world she has created.

  • @blueberry464
    @blueberry464 Рік тому +13

    I have a hard time even reading the books now because I listened to them all as audiobooks at this point and the narrator Robert Glenister is SO delightful with his voices. Probably why I haven't watched the show yet either.

    • @extramurous
      @extramurous Рік тому +1

      Mr. Glenister also plays Jasper Chiswell in the TV version of "Lethal White". He nailed the part.

    • @katemate7253
      @katemate7253 Рік тому +1

      You must watch the show. It is one of the best ones. They are slightly different for obvious reasons but Tom Burke and Holliday Granger are brilliant. I’ve watched the series several times. Can’t wait until TIBH is released 🌟🌟

  • @karenvanhook6748
    @karenvanhook6748 2 роки тому +18

    This is a wonderful interview. I just finished Ink Black Heart. I love seeing Strike and Robin size people up. Spending time in that world is so relaxing -- leaving real-world troubles behind and looking at all these people through the eyes of Strike and Robin -- that I wished it would never end. Can't wait for book 7.

  • @homidjohn
    @homidjohn 2 роки тому +36

    You know it is really exciting and comforting to see her be on a roll like that in terms of working on the content and putting these books at this rate. So pleased to know she's well into the next installment, gives me peace to know it (likely) isn't too far away. Not like the wait between *CAREER* and *LETHAL* anyway 🤞

    • @indedgames4359
      @indedgames4359 Рік тому

      Lethal simply had to be put aside nore

    • @imisstoronto3121
      @imisstoronto3121 9 місяців тому

      @@indedgames4359 Oh I loved it. And the TV version. The Silkworm was better than a sleeping pill

  • @jcbooks4684
    @jcbooks4684 2 роки тому +25

    I love the Strike novels and have bought them all. I'm a big fan now and always.

  • @mustuploadtoo7543
    @mustuploadtoo7543 2 роки тому +58

    JK Rowling is the greatest writer the UK has produced since William Shakespeare

    • @preddysun_official6913
      @preddysun_official6913 2 роки тому +8

      Facts

    • @yankandror5847
      @yankandror5847 2 роки тому +7

      With you there. Her and Kazuo are the absolute best

    • @ralfl.k.5636
      @ralfl.k.5636 2 роки тому +14

      J.K. Rowling for nobel price.

    • @yankandror5847
      @yankandror5847 2 роки тому +4

      She’s got my vote!

    • @trs8696
      @trs8696 2 роки тому +8

      the way she builds her characters and worlds actually reminds me of dickens. she's amazing.

  • @princepeterwolf
    @princepeterwolf 10 місяців тому +2

    Jo must have one of the most brilliant minds, I will forever be in awe of her talent and humility

  • @CS-pm8kc
    @CS-pm8kc 2 роки тому +38

    I love this series! I can’t wait for the next book!

    • @bazileia9222
      @bazileia9222 2 роки тому +2

      Same, just finished this one and already miss it and want the next one

  • @iR3vil4te
    @iR3vil4te Рік тому +21

    This was such a great book. I think I figured out the killer a little too early, but otherwise it was just magnificent. Really opened my eyes to how intellectually brilliant J K is.

    • @MOD_PODGE
      @MOD_PODGE 9 місяців тому +1

      How did you figure out the killer early? What clues led you there? Need specifics or I'm not buying it lol

    • @justink5000
      @justink5000 3 місяці тому

      Please give me specifics, I didn't figure it out at all!

  • @22Unlucky
    @22Unlucky Рік тому +9

    Thank you Jo. For everything.

  • @susanhulstine5915
    @susanhulstine5915 Рік тому +3

    Please keep writing this series! It’s the only series I follow and really look forward to. Thank you! ❤

  • @kevindouglas2060
    @kevindouglas2060 2 роки тому +11

    I just watched an extremely hateful video regarding your work and felt I needed to come here.
    I hope you see this. Please stay true to reality in regards to behavioral truths. Even in fantasy worlds, you have always done exactly that. Don't let the bullies intimidate you.
    I can relate to your experience writing something before it happens. I have a pretty good the first draft of a novel from 2018. I edit very slowly and during that process covid 19 came. What I wrote literally happened. I was worried it was too farfetched. Now it's too mundane. I won't give up, I'll try to find something else as the backdrop of the story.
    Thank you
    Stay strong

  • @NamasteBbooktube
    @NamasteBbooktube Рік тому +4

    'The Ink Black Heart' is extraordinary.

  • @LaxmiDevi-ey1rk
    @LaxmiDevi-ey1rk Рік тому +4

    I'm Indian respected madam respected madam you're a genius

  • @sambiscuits5768
    @sambiscuits5768 2 роки тому +22

    Just finished the book about an hour ago. Another fantastic book. I did think that the online World, the ideas, subjects and arguments e.g. ableist, cis, trans, are more reflective of 2022 than 2015. But loved it. Already looking forward to the next one.

    • @liabe18
      @liabe18 2 роки тому +2

      I thought so too-she even mentions someone having pronouns in their Twitter bio and that was not really a thing back in 2015. But honestly the rest of the Fandom and Twitter and tumblr stuff and the rhetoric of characters felt pretty spot on to my own experiences in fandoms in the early 2010s. What a weird and honestly scary time to have been a late teen.

  • @dracarys371
    @dracarys371 2 роки тому +7

    I’ve just finished it. Masterpiece!

  • @wyattfamily8997
    @wyattfamily8997 2 роки тому +17

    Support to J.K. from Australia, stand strong against the "woke wankers",......as George Carlin said "political correctness is just facism with manners."

  • @lower_than_furries9727
    @lower_than_furries9727 Місяць тому

    Just finished this book and currently on chapter 7 of The Running Grave, all I can say is this: the Ink Black Heart is the most intense, cathartic, and (in some ways) reflective creation of Robert Galbraith so far. It is exhausting at times, but the whole book has been an experience. Absolutely love it, Bwah!

  • @katemate7253
    @katemate7253 2 роки тому +8

    Lisa lee Morgan. I could have written that. I love all the books esp TB. I found Ink Black Heart a bit confusing esp the on line chats but I’ll read it again. Jo’s chat has helped. She is a genius- I love her 🎉❤

  • @joshuawilliams7734
    @joshuawilliams7734 Рік тому +6

    I know JK Rowling said she may never do a COVID-19 Strike Novel but listening to her explanation of Anomie and the concept of Sickness being a key theme and disconnection is pretty much part of what happened at the start of the pandemic so I feel like she's already tackled that monumental part of our lives at least thematically in this book Keep up the good work Jo can't wait for the next instalment 👍

  • @lizmcgrath7552
    @lizmcgrath7552 Рік тому +2

    They are my favourite books of all time! Thank you❤

  • @jools99caithness17
    @jools99caithness17 2 роки тому +4

    Thankyou for this- it’s good to know these strands. A little closer to home, Arbroath’s Western Cemetery and Mortuary Chapel have much in common with Highgate cemetery and Hospitalfields- Scotland’s earliest art school might be worth a visit ?

  • @stanislavabanova2
    @stanislavabanova2 2 роки тому +8

    Thank you for posting it!

  • @aslan9334
    @aslan9334 Рік тому +1

    No author has ever made me cry (twice)😭❤

  • @shylockwesker5530
    @shylockwesker5530 2 роки тому +11

    Great book, and the author is wonderfully on point about social phenomena that mainstream media only now become aware of, such as spoonies.

  • @barductube
    @barductube 2 роки тому +11

    I love that interview. Reading the kindle version drove me mad for some time though, until I found out you can ignore the pictures because the next pages will show the same in plain text, too. I loved the book but decided against the audible version because of the tweets. How could it be done there to be undecided or unclear about the sex of Anomie? Ive got every book of Jo's in at least two versions, some even in 4, like HP2 in American book, German book, English Illustrated book and Audibles in English and German. I like to live in her worlds. I am a 69 year old lesbian media designer, in politics for 30 years, having known many LGBT people and many of them as my best friends. I consider Jo as somebody who has done nothing against us, on the contrary. I can play a game where the headmaster is gay, my favourite teacher is short, my friends are very diverse and I can date girls and boys like in my real life. Where else can I do that? Still, I've had my controversial discussions with and about trans people back in the nineties and there were tears and agression and despair but lots of understanding and support, too. People who throw about hate and shitstorm online at anybody, who doesn't follow the mainstream, instead of exchanging views aren't really helpful to the cause. Live and let live is my motto and, I think, Jo's too. With love from Germany

  • @jools99caithness17
    @jools99caithness17 2 роки тому +5

    I’ve just finished reading and lived the book. Can you say what the significance is for the poetry quotes at the start of each chapter? Did you find these on tombstones in Highgate cemetery ?

  • @arcdecoeurlumos4289
    @arcdecoeurlumos4289 2 роки тому +8

    Bonjour jo ton nouveau livre a l'air trop bien j'ai hâte de le lire
    Courage jk je suis avec toi
    Je suis trop contente je te voire
    Bonne continuation et à bientôt j'espère
    Une fan de toi ❤️

  • @stephen9453
    @stephen9453 2 роки тому +11

    The formatting of the in-game private chats and the twitter threads were hard to follow in the Audible version. Enjoyed the book, more than Troubled Blood.
    Oh and Robert Glennister is fabulous but his Barclay could do with a bit of work :)

    • @stephen9453
      @stephen9453 2 роки тому +1

      @@PleadingMackerel I have a look in my head for Strike, kinda like Jo said in the interview. I don't think the chap in the TV series fits the bill. But Robert Glennister is superb with the voices, spot on. Well except for his Glaswegian, but then I'm local and have a critical ear.

    • @steppy3736
      @steppy3736 2 роки тому +2

      The formatting of the chats in e books was hell.

  • @gin.k
    @gin.k 2 роки тому +10

    I'm absolutely in love with the Cormorant Strike book series!🤗❤️ Literally read all of them. Now reading this one.🖤🖤🖤
    You're an amazing writer there Ms/Mrs Rowling. Absolutely appreciate you bringing all these wonderful stories to your readers.

  • @Mickmooreable
    @Mickmooreable 2 роки тому +10

    Best book yet. I avoid Twitter as it seems to be a horrible pit of hate. I know the book is fiction but it's not exactly a sales pitch for social media.

  • @sweetgumtree6093
    @sweetgumtree6093 Рік тому +1

    Loved this book!
    I'm a mystery fan and this series is my all-time favorite. I just can't wait for the book 7!
    I really hope there will be Japanese ver. of book 3 to 6 though, because lots of people would enjoy this series.
    Love from Japan!

  • @victoriapiace3479
    @victoriapiace3479 2 роки тому +5

    She’a incredible

  • @valkyraevixx5710
    @valkyraevixx5710 2 роки тому +9

    Thank you for posting this 💜

  • @helenedwards1468
    @helenedwards1468 Рік тому +1

    Really love all your books. I buy the audiobook the day it comes out and my daughter buys the book. I was so glad of that with IBH, I am old and not much into social media it was confusing listening too it. Once I was able to read the book itself, your amazing format made it all so much clearer. A trivial sideline, I live quite away from London and rarely visit, are the seemingly continual roadworks/ excavations which have been going on since Robin was wolf whistled in the first chapter of the first book, crossrail related?

  • @darmy713
    @darmy713 Рік тому

    She’s a wonderful writer. This one was a little harder to follow than previous books but my third time thru I finally got it.

  • @trs8696
    @trs8696 2 роки тому +14

    i heard that in book 9 robin and strike will finally hold hands

    • @gmvn19
      @gmvn19 2 роки тому +2

      Strike will be 50 & Robin will be 40 then .

    • @JDoe-gf5oz
      @JDoe-gf5oz Рік тому

      @@gmvn19 Yeah, she's too old for him.

  • @johannagavert5365
    @johannagavert5365 Рік тому +16

    I stand with jk - always

  • @stfnknbb
    @stfnknbb Рік тому +4

    Love you JKR! You're my hero!

  • @alicerose4332
    @alicerose4332 2 роки тому +8

    Love the books and the author ❤

  • @Ahmet_Koctar
    @Ahmet_Koctar 2 роки тому +6

    I don't think I will ever read the Strike novels, but I enjoy listening to Jo talk about her work.

    • @steppy3736
      @steppy3736 2 роки тому +4

      They are very good. Much better than Casual Vacancy imo.

    • @Ahmet_Koctar
      @Ahmet_Koctar 2 роки тому +1

      @@steppy3736 I do hope to read them one day. There are just so many other books that I want to read first. Casual Vacancy had some great parts but also a few boring sections. Overall, it's a good book.

    • @steppy3736
      @steppy3736 2 роки тому

      @@Ahmet_Koctar I completely understand! I've been slowly working on my tbr pile.

    • @cardejah
      @cardejah 2 роки тому +2

      You should! They're brilliant!

  • @vjekokolic9057
    @vjekokolic9057 Рік тому +1

    I just want to say that I love your books and adore your writing style. The Harry Potter books have influenced my childhood enormously and I still think that they are some of the best books ever written. But having grown older I don't mind more realistic plots and everyday life representation. I really enjoy the Strike novels because they depict the world we live in so perfectly and the charatcers are extremely relatable. Can't wait to get my hands on the next one in the series 😊

  • @kathryncainmadsen5850
    @kathryncainmadsen5850 7 місяців тому +1

    I am a fan of everything she writes. Just FYI, FORMATTING did get quite screwed up when I tried to read this book as a library ebook. It took me a while to figure out how to bypass the images and realize that the chat would appear in the text after the images. The image text was absurdly small in an eBook. I almost stopped reading until I figured out I could bypass the images.
    Then, it was very hard to track who said what and who was who in the chats without taking notes, especially as the revealing began as to who had what identities...so I started skimming those. That made this book a little bit less fun if I am honest. Skimming boring, repetitive chat actually meant I figured out who Anomie was without that, and maybe too early. It's still a fascinating plot. I recommend that the smallest device on which to read it is a tablet.

  • @lucagrochi7556
    @lucagrochi7556 2 роки тому +8

    Amazing woman

  • @margaretsmist7140
    @margaretsmist7140 Рік тому +1

    I never read past the first Harry Potter (yes I know - horrors! 😊) but absolutely adore this series. I always read the book (a min of) two times and listen to it about once a year--it’s like visiting with old friends. ☺️

  • @annab9994
    @annab9994 Рік тому +2

    I simple love this book series and TV show 😍

  • @Lucas-ug6zs
    @Lucas-ug6zs 2 роки тому +9

    I’m desperate to know what animation inspired IBH. I have my own idea’s including Rick and Morty or Family Guy

    • @shylockwesker5530
      @shylockwesker5530 2 роки тому +2

      I think it's Rick and Morty, considering the response of the uniquely toxic fandom

  • @5xcharlie
    @5xcharlie Рік тому

    Such a good book. I think I enjoyed this the most so far. What an amazing worldbuilder JK is, her mind must be a labyrinth.

  • @tracieh215
    @tracieh215 Рік тому +3

    I LOVE SHANKER!

  • @Ginge.1008
    @Ginge.1008 Рік тому +2

    I've asked for harry potter books for my birthday hopefully I get them but would love to read these books 😮 love jk she's an absolutely fantastic woman and so creative

  • @ramanboucher
    @ramanboucher Рік тому +1

    I can’t wait for book 7!! Now I know there’s 8 & 9!!! Very excited. Romance?!?! Please??!!

    • @AndrewNo6
      @AndrewNo6 24 дні тому

      Weird suggestion… these books comprise the most moving love story I’ve ever read. How much romance do you need?

  • @imisstoronto3121
    @imisstoronto3121 9 місяців тому +1

    I read the book when it came out, and while the plot was intricate and detailed, I can only remember being impatient with it. I felt some things were not adequately explained.
    For example, the online game. Games have a structure, a procedure, maybe even a strategy. If I recall correctly all the online characters did was hang around, literally. There seemed to be no purpose. Did you win points, collect streets like Monopoly, win pies like in Trivial Pursuit?
    If someone cares to explain, I'd happily listen.

  • @fleetstreet11
    @fleetstreet11 2 роки тому +8

    I wonder what the real-life cartoon that inspired her was.

    • @BigEyesSmallMouth
      @BigEyesSmallMouth 2 роки тому +6

      The consensus seems to be that it was "Rick and Morty."

    • @fleetstreet11
      @fleetstreet11 2 роки тому +4

      @@BigEyesSmallMouth She did say she found it funny, so that could be it

    • @liabe18
      @liabe18 2 роки тому +4

      The Gothic element of the ink black heart gave me homestuck vibes honestly - down to the crazy Fandom. I wasn't really in it but at least from the periphery this is what it felt like.
      Although clearly it wasn't the inspiration she was talking about.

    • @Shasha-jo5iv
      @Shasha-jo5iv 2 роки тому +3

      I think it's my little pony. Pony bros are insane

    • @fleetstreet11
      @fleetstreet11 2 роки тому +1

      @@Shasha-jo5iv But would she find that sort of cartoon funny?

  • @lisaleemorgan6274
    @lisaleemorgan6274 2 роки тому +4

    Thank you, JKR, for the Strike Series. ❤❤❤ Troubled Blood is my all time favorite detective novel, superseding all!
    I read Ink-Black Heart with excitement, loved the plot, the development w Strike and Robin. The formatting tripped me, though. I found it very difficult to dip into and out of the on-page ebook texts, and ended up frustrated, lost, and felt Interrupted flow. I kept reminding myself to imagine the pacing of a real text thread, which is drip drip drip over time among various texters. In the ebook, each text section was inside a photo, which had to be opened, enlarged, and read. The problem is even worse in the audible version w Glenister. There is no easier smoother way that I can think of to present long text threads, but it became a real block to my enjoyment. Maybe being an aging boomer is part of my problem! 😊 Meanwhile, I am waiting (very impatiently) for the Troubled Blood tv show to air. And how you are going to convey text threads on tv, I do not know! Hahaha😂 However difficult you make them, I will be following each of your creative offerings with admiration, pleasure, and deep gratitude!

    • @דליהכהן-כ8ש
      @דליהכהן-כ8ש 2 роки тому +1

      I also had problemms with the chats may be bevause my age but i love the plot and the characters. You are stil my favorit english writer. Im a jebrew spraker.

  • @steppy3736
    @steppy3736 2 роки тому +6

    This was a fantastic book! However, don't try to read it as an ebook. The formatting is awful.

    • @bazileia9222
      @bazileia9222 2 роки тому +4

      Absolutely agree, for the "in game chat" parts I had to use a magnifier 🤣
      On the bright side you feel like a true stereotypic dective

  • @mariaaparecidaribeiro2164
    @mariaaparecidaribeiro2164 4 місяці тому

    26:46 Amo Cormoran e Robin só quero que parem de correr sobre os sentimentos de um para com o outro, não vejo a hora que fiquem juntos

  • @kevinprudente
    @kevinprudente 2 роки тому

    jk rowling says thank you target us

  • @tracieh215
    @tracieh215 Рік тому

    I only hope she doesn’t kill off either Strike or Robin

  • @audreysmom
    @audreysmom 8 місяців тому

    Love you and your amazing work JK. ❤

  • @mifmana
    @mifmana Рік тому +1

    If in this new cancel culture, Gen Z, etc. In this new, fresh, and "optimistic world" someone so brilliant as J.K. Rolling becomes persona non grata...I have no hope. It's a waist! There is no future with acceptance of such stupidity! She did so much philanthropic work, gave so much love and ability to believe in magic, gave hope and ALL of this should never be forgotten! #JKRowlingRise

  • @math1mom
    @math1mom Рік тому

    9:00
    Thank you Ms. JK Rowling

  • @sapodilla25
    @sapodilla25 3 місяці тому

    I wonder what cartoon she's referring to that her kids told her about. Rick and Morty possibly?

  • @Javalipapere
    @Javalipapere 8 місяців тому

    Great book.

  • @ienekevanhouten4559
    @ienekevanhouten4559 2 роки тому +5

    I stayed with the book out of love for the characters, but I found the plot torturous, with the endless tweet threads a major irritation. It is especially bad in the audio version.

  • @mirosae7340
    @mirosae7340 Рік тому

    My fav so far.

  • @Miyako2610
    @Miyako2610 2 роки тому +2

    Auto subtitle 🙏

  • @ndmath
    @ndmath Рік тому

    8:00 They act a bit like animus/anima together, complimenting each other.

  • @wonderwoman5528
    @wonderwoman5528 2 роки тому +6

    I really like and warm to the real life Joanne I see in front of me. Seems like a rational, intelligent, and righteous woman. I find a disconnect between this and the online version. I wish she would debate her views face to face and not behind a screen… we would finally listen and respond in a healthy way, with some resolve.

    • @janeayres8772
      @janeayres8772 Рік тому +4

      Almost nobody responds to gender critical views in a healthy way offline, though. Most attempts at public conversations have been cut off at the knees. In any case, there are other women who are ready and very able to do that.

  • @АннаВербицкая-е4н
    @АннаВербицкая-е4н 8 місяців тому

    which cartoon are her children talking about?

  • @yorkietot5810
    @yorkietot5810 2 роки тому +1

    ❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️

  • @markkavanagh7377
    @markkavanagh7377 2 роки тому +3

    Ye have all realised haven't ye that Strike and Robin go on to be Harry's parents!
    😉

  • @extramurous
    @extramurous Рік тому +1

    I think IBH needed more editing. You could trim the book down by a third and it would be better for it. There were many characters, plot lines, and scenes that did nothing to move the story forward or explain anything that needed explaining.

  • @marcus_music
    @marcus_music 11 місяців тому

    What is the cartoon she's referring too, anyone know? Family guy? lol

    • @JohnDuraSSB
      @JohnDuraSSB 10 місяців тому

      probably rick and morty

  • @henrikandersson1393
    @henrikandersson1393 Рік тому

    😊

  • @teczowekotkilataja3983
    @teczowekotkilataja3983 2 роки тому

    Ask about Peter

  • @monkey6207
    @monkey6207 Рік тому +1

    The plot was so interesting I read it in 2 days, but the romance stuff kinda dragged it on too much.

  • @GiovanniDeCillis
    @GiovanniDeCillis Рік тому

    Can’t accept Anomie is stopped by two neighbours, I just can’t

  • @hajabdndjzu1700
    @hajabdndjzu1700 Рік тому

    They took my movie and made it mocking jay😢

  • @kevinprudente
    @kevinprudente 2 роки тому

    ems ems

  • @kevinprudente
    @kevinprudente 2 роки тому

    Kevin Prudente
    Kevin Prudente
    Kevin Prudente

  • @kevinprudente
    @kevinprudente 2 роки тому

    hey i have you today

  • @beverlylawrence131
    @beverlylawrence131 Рік тому

    So far have managed listening to half . 😮book and I .don’t like it at all. Have listened to all of her others books and really enjoyed them but this one I don’t like at all. Sorry.

  • @SkageXL5
    @SkageXL5 2 роки тому +5

    oh gross, why the heck would YT suggest this to me?
    Blefrgh.

    • @khots6501
      @khots6501 2 роки тому +11

      Maybe learn to read and you'll be able to enjoy her work

    • @monkey6207
      @monkey6207 Рік тому

      Help it's a self absorbed overgrown baby.

    • @SkageXL5
      @SkageXL5 Рік тому

      @@monkey6207 am I supposed to be the baby?

    • @monkey6207
      @monkey6207 Рік тому +1

      @@SkageXL5 The fact that you still read it though.

    • @SkageXL5
      @SkageXL5 Рік тому

      @@monkey6207 Why would you post your comment, but not want me to read it?
      I'm sorry, but I gotta ask, what do *you* think is happening?

  • @turtlemayhem39
    @turtlemayhem39 11 місяців тому +2

    She wrote a book to lionize her Twitter grievances. She can't stand being criticized for her lack of morals so she literally created a fictional universe where she's right. Jesus Christ.

    • @AndrewNo6
      @AndrewNo6 24 дні тому

      You are deeply ill-informed.

  • @yesterday1396
    @yesterday1396 2 роки тому +9

    Let trans people live their lives.

    • @trs8696
      @trs8696 2 роки тому +30

      let women speak

    • @Adam-vm8kp
      @Adam-vm8kp 2 роки тому +1

      When trans people let others live theirs.

    • @yesterday1396
      @yesterday1396 2 роки тому +3

      @@trs8696 agreed. Cis woman and trans woman should be able to speak.

    • @khots6501
      @khots6501 2 роки тому +10

      Stop gaslighting women.

    • @khots6501
      @khots6501 2 роки тому +1

      @@yesterday1396 Males can't be women. Cope.

  • @justinsingh221
    @justinsingh221 2 роки тому +6

    Booooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooo 👎👎👎👎👎👎👎👎👎👎👎👎👎👎👎👎👎👎👎👎👎👎👎👎👎👎👎👎👎👎👎👎👎👎👎👎👎👎👎

  • @Qu0thTheRaven
    @Qu0thTheRaven Рік тому +2

    for anyone curious about that word:
    en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Anomie

    • @AndrewNo6
      @AndrewNo6 24 дні тому +1

      Or if you can actually read, try Durkheim… 🙄

  • @teczowekotkilataja3983
    @teczowekotkilataja3983 2 роки тому

    Basingstoke RG21 4DS 12weysprings close