Best HFY story: Rage & Extrapolation Error | 2586 | r/HFY

Поділитися
Вставка

КОМЕНТАРІ • 31

  • @Koldankel
    @Koldankel 22 години тому +33

    Gotta say. Really like the idea of a paradise cage fight planet over the standart death world

    • @loganshaw4527
      @loganshaw4527 17 годин тому +4

      Mother nature too good at her job? Population control became a major issue.

  • @oli3645
    @oli3645 21 годину тому +16

    A planet can only be a death world if there is enough life fighting on it

  • @TheJMPD
    @TheJMPD 22 години тому +12

    Do NOT feck with Mama Bear!

  • @Shadow.Dragon
    @Shadow.Dragon 21 годину тому +4

    Great stories; Excellent narration! 1st story - Never, ever endanger a Human child. You WILL regret it! 2nd story - I bet the last word started with an "F"! LOL!!!

  • @dragongreek9059
    @dragongreek9059 22 години тому +7

    Earth is the death world and I considered paradise

  • @GenStallion
    @GenStallion 20 годин тому +5

    FIX BAYONETS!

    • @loganshaw4527
      @loganshaw4527 17 годин тому

      Lol wait till they see swords that can shot or guns that can slice.

  • @sleepycritical6950
    @sleepycritical6950 22 години тому +8

    Huh…that’s actually a novel idea. A garden planet breeding a more deadly threat. I personally don’t think humans are all that the stories make us out to be, but perhaps being human I am biased.
    There are surely more hellish places in the universe that the death world human stories just don’t make sense to me. This story however has given me pause. Perhaps garden planets are more hellish than death worlds.

    • @timfunnydragon
      @timfunnydragon 22 години тому +3

      While there are surely more hellish places, it could also be that we happen to be on the worst world that could support life. Anything more deadly and it's just beaten down every time it comes up no matter what evolution may try

    • @noppornwongrassamee8941
      @noppornwongrassamee8941 20 годин тому +2

      @@timfunnydragon Let's put it this way: the procedures and practices required to defeat a hostile environment are VERY DIFFERENT from the procedures and practices required to fight other life forms, especially thinking life forms that analyze what you've done and actively looking for weaknesses to exploit.

    • @timfunnydragon
      @timfunnydragon 18 годин тому

      @@noppornwongrassamee8941 you imply that this couldn't happen on a deathworld, and thus have a fatal flaw in your argument.
      A deadly environment with creatures that will actively learn from you while they try to kill you is the kind of death world Earth would be.

    • @Tiewaz
      @Tiewaz 18 годин тому

      Sure, Earth is a garden planet for the variety and numbers of living things on it, but that means there's more competition to survive to breed. And then the Earth itself likes to throw in a few challenges like earthquakes, mudslides, volcanoes, extreme temperature shifts globally and just extreme environments all over, tsunamis, hurricanes, floods, etc. There was even a giant space rock that killed a whole mess of critters and still the Earth came back, flourishing with life. Humans evolved to survive the planet, the other organisms, and each other.

    • @stevewhitten-p8m
      @stevewhitten-p8m 12 годин тому

      Star Trek TOS addressed this exact proposition - a paradise planet, no disease, no natural cause of death....and consequently, population density several hundred times the ideal.

  • @jeffreyharville1918
    @jeffreyharville1918 21 годину тому +1

    Oh the well known last words, "Well, Crap!"

  • @RealArcalian
    @RealArcalian 16 годин тому

    Greetings, Mentlegent!
    For the Rhyhtm that is Algo
    Story 1: Parental Wrath
    Story 2: So Earth still is a deathworld, only the HOW is different. A deadly garden. A garden of death.

  • @xessq1
    @xessq1 20 годин тому +2

    so NOT ONLY do the "strongest" survive and overcrowded paradise world, but also the " strongest most mentally unstable" ... Fack Ya!

  • @scotthinger6397
    @scotthinger6397 21 годину тому +1

    Liked both stories.

  • @Ibian666
    @Ibian666 22 години тому +3

    Paradise world? THIS planet?

    • @kain7759
      @kain7759 22 години тому +6

      Considering every planet we found untill now? Our moon stabilize the rotation and orbit therefore seasons, we are at the perfect distance from the sun, where radiations are shielded enought and water can both freeze and evaporate, our 2 gas giants "eat" most objects launched to the inner solar system and the core is almost 2 times the aaverage size of a planet erath size, wich allowed for stronger electromagnetic field and for the outer core to stay liquid. Yep, this planet is perfect for life development.

    • @Ibian666
      @Ibian666 21 годину тому +1

      @@kain7759 We eat eachother.
      Other planets might have developed ecosystems with no direct competition. Similar to what animals and plants have, but for all life on the planet. Compared to that? Hellworld.

    • @angrydragonslayer
      @angrydragonslayer 8 годин тому +1

      ​@@Ibian666it's a paradise world because of how easy life is here
      You can look literally anywhere on earth and you'll find entire ecosystems of life. This includes the mites and their ecosystem on your face.
      Sometimes, these mites can overpopulate the face and start eating it.

    • @Ibian666
      @Ibian666 6 годин тому +1

      @@angrydragonslayer Life is not easy. It is a constant battle for survival. That's how evolution works, by killing the weakest in any given species.

    • @angrydragonslayer
      @angrydragonslayer 6 годин тому

      @@Ibian666 and on other worlds in this setting, food and resources are so scarce that there's nobody else to fight
      You can't go "this town isn't big enough for both of us" if you're alone
      On most planets we have detailed scans of irl, 20 million total living organisms is unlikely to ever occur. Would you like to guess how many organisms live in a drop of water on earrh?

  • @merlinwizard1000
    @merlinwizard1000 День тому +1

    1st, 21 November 2024

    • @bluelake7669
      @bluelake7669 22 години тому

      Omg i can't believe it's already Nov 21.