The Jews of Mumbai are still there?? | Endurance of a Jew Ep. 1
Вставка
- Опубліковано 26 лют 2022
- This is Ep. 1 in a new original series Meaningful Minute has produced starring Shloime Zionce.
This episode has been sponsored by raisethon.com
For more bonus footage from this trip, make sure to follow us on social media and download the Meaningful Minute app!
FREE APP
bit.ly/2MrRLv6
FOLLOW US ON INSTAGRAM
/ meaningfulminute
A monumental project undertaken by Nachi Gordon and Meaningful Minute. So glad this is finally out. I really hope and believe that this new series will inspire Jewish people to keep enduring! 💪🏻
All your content is just plain amazing 🤩!!!
Shloime, your contribution to peaceful co-existence and understanding is monumental - thank you!
@@davebloombeat Thank you Dave! 😃 Great to see you here again!
Lo
@@davebloombeat ? +
This has been such an incredible journey and I’m so excited to finally release these episodes! They are life changing!
77
Shloime, thank you for put this series out, this history deeply touched my soul.
CHABAD is an incredible movement. They have suffered so much to bring Judaism to Jews around the world
Thank you for this amazing video. Was very nice to also see the Iraqi synagogue. The Iraqi Jews have a very strong history in Mumbai and the Sasoon family was very prominent and had close ties to the Ben Ish Chai. It was under the direction of the Ben Ish Chai that the Sasoons opened Yeshivat Porat Yosef in Yerushalayim. Very nice to see that there is still Jewish life in Mumbai. Thank you for sharing this with us. Hatzlacha to Shloime and the rabbis of India and all of the Jews in India.
Atithi Devo Bhava! We Indians believe in togetherness, hence every religion and community is respectful and is leaving in peace along with us.
I am touched and moved by this courageous and faithful Rabbi. Thank you for sharing your life with us. I am in awe of you! 🇮🇱 also Thank you so much to the young man who conducted the interviews. Exceptional work!
Can’t wait for More!!!!
Thanks for sharing this amazing and emotional video ❤❤
Keep up the good work! I appreciated the photos being put in for context.
Was so powerful. Got me so emotional. Thank you so much
This is really amazing the production is
Such high quality
And so meaningful!!!
Thank you so much!
Thank you, Shloime. Again my time is well spent with you sharing your experiences.
What a beautiful and inspirational video. Much hatzlachah with the new channel! Keep em coming
Chazak Vamatz
Thank you Shloime for the beautiful first episode,
What an amazing episode, I pray for your success,
May you be מצליח בכל דרכיך,
I hope you work something out about Iran.
Great video. May you continue bringing us incredible stories.
Shloime! Todah Rabah, for the new program. I feel that HaShem is blessing you with insight wisdom to help heal the world and bring peace. I had been researching an ancestor of mine named Johannes Friend who died in New Jersey America in 1737, but was buried in Mumbai, Maharashtra, India. For me this didn't make any sense. But seeing your wonderful program on Mumbai, I now see that the Jewish impact on that part of the world is very old. Shalom, Shalom my Friend!
Very nice, respectful and I learned a great deal. I look forward to future videos and yes, I downloaded the app. That looks great also.
Great job ! Thank you for sharing
This was incredible! Shloime great job! The shluchim of the Rebbe keep strong you are amazing we love you
shalom, Shloime! :) this is a GREAT episode! great for the beginning of a series! i look forward to watching all the ones that come after!
Wow amazing video! This is going to be a great series!
Very interesting, looking forward to episode 2.
Wow! What a amazingggg video!
Again!
Thank you shloime!!
Thank you so much for this amazing and wonderful journey, I am touched and moved. All my best wishes and blessings to you and your family.💙🙏❤️
Hi to all my jew friends from India. I recently started reading your Torah in language (Old testament) . It's really amazing. You guys are awesome. Take care bye.
Absolutely amazing content enjoyed every second and got a big chizuk from it !!!
Wow. It's hard to explain the number of emotions that I got while watching this. It's amazing how you can find the light at the end of the tunnel in each situation if you look for it. Thank you for this amazing first episode.
It's incredible how much dedication and good vibes the shlihim of Habad has in each place that you find them.
Thanks Shloime. You brought back memories.
Oh wow! The legendary Mr. Sopher!! You sparked my first interest in India!!!
Shlomie keep up the amazing work 👏
HELP US TO HELP YOU...We Indians are very sentimental we respect everyone every community......love and peace ☮️ from India 🇮🇳 ....ladakh
Great video!
fascinating and inspiring...thank you!
Thank you for sharing the 😢 meaningful content Shloime and Nachi - only good news and peace…
Amen Eli! Thank you!
Love this video!
So amazing super inspiring
Woah the endurance of a Jew ! Really incredilbe
Thank you so much for the inspiring history! It is so good to see how light overcomes darkness! I very much look forward to future episodes in the series! So encouraging for those of us who are not able to travel. 💙🙏🏽🌻
For those that don't speak Hebrew maybe put little definitions of what certain words are. I understand a few that my great aunt taught me. Just a suggestion. Love the show so far.
just making sure you know the halacha that all kelim need to be inspected before use to make sure they are clean from previous non cholov yisroel milk.
Everyone should watch this.
Hazak Shloime beautiful video
Not even Jewish and I love all of Shloimes content. He's really doing good for the jewish community.
Yasher kochachem, holy brothers. Keep up the amazing work!
Who is the Rav who starts speaking at 1:00?
Rabbi Moshe Kotlarsky עמו״ש
@@ShloimeZionce thnx!
That was very, very interesting. I have to make a joke, though. Rabbis, at least around here, are notoriously bad drivers. I kept mentally telling the rabbi in the video to put on his seat belt, and put down the phone, because driving as a rabbi is dangerous enough. 😆 Oh, and he sounded Israeli, which adds another level of questionable driving. 🤣
I hope you go to Central America, and check out the Jewish communities there.
Very informative
I am hindu but can I visit a synagogues in mumbai ?
Yes, you can pls. Just visit an Orthodox one 🙏
Thank you
Good
A few live in Jew Street Kochin and they speak excellent Malayalam as well.
Nice mikvah
Hey shloime zionce 👋are you still here in mumbai?
I wanna meet you brother 💙
I'm also living here in mumbai
I will come to see you if you have time or you come to me
I'm a non jew. Can I attend shabbat service?
Yes pls
👏
The power of Lubavitch!
Bro, you have zero mentions of the Bene Israelis, the native Marathi jews of Mumbai and the Konkan region.
Did you ever get to visit them?
Baruch Hashem shalom Yisrael
I have a question:
In the beginning of the video, the rabbi gives a speech of how in the face of domestic terrorism, we shall not engage in war, and essentially sells this as the Jewish thing to do.
Yet in the story of Hanukkah and The Maccabees, the Jewish men DID fight the Greek army, in order to gain Freedom, despite having all the odds stacked against them.
So my question is, why is pacifism being sold as a good thing, and necessary as a Jew, when Jewish history has displayed that indeed sometimes fighting and engaging in war is necessary and later celebrated?
@Crystal Skulls In the Chanukah story, the Macabees were fighting active oppression.
Here, when the rabbi was speaking at the funeral, it was after the fact. He was saying that we would not seek revenge with violence, rather, we would respond with bringing more light into a world that often seems dark.
@@sdr5863 The rabbi specifically said, “In the face of domestic terrorism, we will not-“ do x, y, and z (engaging in war.)
Isn’t that saying, “We won’t defend ourselves,” ?
What phrase did you hear that he references being vengeful?
Because I can understand not being vengeful, I cannot understand advocating against self defense.
@@Crystal11Skulls The domestic terrorism was already experienced. They were gathered at the unfortunate aftermath. So by "in the face of domestic terrorism" he meant facing the results of domestic terrorism....
@@sdr5863It’s just an odd way to phrase things. He could have said, “Now that it’s over, we won’t-“ or “We will not be vengeful”, etc.
To say, “In the face of domestic terrorism,” well, “in the face” means current/present/as its happening now/etc.
I HOPE he meant “we will not be vengeful.” The way he phrased it though makes it sound otherwise. I just don’t like anyone advocating AGAINST self defense.
As I said, I hope you are correct. I hope my interpretation is incorrect.
@@sdr5863 Either way, thank you for responding and answering my question.
🥰
those chickens are funny! they do not sound like chickens . LOL
Hashems people
Watching this documentary during the Israel Palestine war I can see why India and Israel are the very same a group of people fighting Terrorism and Terrorists when we fight for our survival the world calls us extremist and so on
# solidarity with Israel 🇮🇱🇮🇳
It is only due to the greatness of Hinduism, Jews were and still are able to live in peace and harmony in India. Sadly it's not the same in the rest of the world. Shalom and Namaste 🙏
Sha 9.3
✡️
Ş
A few comments - I am only providing this as constructive criticism to help the channel improve, as I really think Shloime Zionce's content is great:
- The Chabad rabbi said that the Holtzbergs built the mikve in 2015, which is obviously not correct.
- Maybe a little less Yiddish, or at least provide subtitles. When ?Nachi Gordon? was talking about downloading the Meaningful Minute app, he threw in a couple of random Yiddish words, and I had no idea what he was trying to say. Shnell? Emshteh? Ashkenormative is not inclusive.
- You need to have a warning re shechita in the description. I have no idea if you filmed the shechita but I heard the squawking at @15:20, which is very disturbing, as I've been a vegetarian for 31 years. I had to jump ahead.
- Disappointed that you didn't interview any Indian Jews except for children attending a Chabad school. This episode was more about Chabad than the Indian Jewish community of Mumbai. There has been a complaint about Chabad for decades that they come into communities and try to displace their customs with Chabad customs. This video does not dispel that believe. Moreover, the Mumbai Jewish community goes back centuries and is vibrant and fascinating. This video did not provide any window into the Mumbai Jewish community. The terror attack in Mumbai was horrific, and I attended their funeral in Kfar Chabad, but there's so much more to the community in Mumbai. I think the Chabad Rabbi is a great speaker and I really got a lot out of listening him. Maybe the title and description just need to be changed to: "Nariman House: A story of tragedy and survival. 13 years later in Mumbai." Or something along those lines. And then you can make a separate video where you interview Indian Jews about the community in Mumbai, and call that video, "The Jews of Mumbai."
B'hatzlacha.
Chabad displaces Customs with Chabad customs? Lol!!! A real Chabad hater.
Shnel means fast, quick.
Der eybershter means Almighty, Most High, refers to God.
Hashem means The Name, refers to God.
@@stephenfisher3721 thank you. It's the Yiddish I don't know--not the Hebrew.
🇮🇱🇮🇱
🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸
🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱
🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇱🇮🇱